Abstract
Introduction The purpose of this study was to identify issues of importance to Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis (JIA) patients before and after total hip arthroplasty (THA) and to determine if these issues are included in widely utilized, standardized outcome measures for THA (Western-Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index – WOMAC; Patient Specific Index – PASI).
Methods JIA patients who underwent THA between 1986 and 1999 in our institution participated in the study (n=31). An independent observer was asked to gather data forms including patient demographics, a postoperative WOMAC questionnaire, postoperative patient-generated items from the PASI, a retrospectively completed preoperative PASI form, and changes in items from pre-operative to postoperative PASI. Descriptive analysis was completed on demographic information and clinical outcomes as well as for the WOMAC and PASI scores. Spearmans rank correlation coefficients were calculated to describe the association between WOMAC and PASI scores
Results Issues deemed important by JIA patients included four symptom areas (pain, joint motion, strength, discomfort) and five activity areas (light household, leisure, clothing, sports, sex); some indicated they had no symptoms or difficulties. Issues relevant to patients shifted from predominantly symptoms before surgery, to recreational and social activities at follow-up. Comparison of postoperative WOMAC questionnaires with preoperative and postoperative PASI questionnaires revealed fundamental differences between items found in the standardized WOMAC and items deemed important by the patient. The WOMAC included less than 10% of the unweighted content deemed important by these patients at follow-up.The shift in the PASI towards more physically demanding activities after surgery indicates that patients improved, which is not reflected in the WOMAC. Correlations between postoperative WOMAC and PASI scores for pain sub-scales were low to moderate (Spearman‘s coefficient rs=0.53) and 63% of JRA patients had higher PASI than WOMAC normalized scores.
Conclusion The self-generated, self-reported portion of the PASI questionnaire provided a different perspective on the impact of THA in JIA patients. The WOMAC did not include content deemed to be important by JRA patients and did not correlate well with the patient specific instrument.
Theses abstracts were prepared by Professor Roger Lemaire. Correspondence should be addressed to EFORT Central Office, Freihofstrasse 22, CH-8700 Küsnacht, Switzerland.
