Abstract
Introduction The accuracy of ultrasonography has been reported to be high in diagnosing full thickness rotator cuff tears if measurements are made in both in the coronal and sagital planes. The purpose of this study is to determine how well pre-operative shoulder ultrasound rotator tear measurements when performed only in the coronal plane, the common practice in Israel, predicts the intra-operative surgical findings.
Materials and Methods Fifty consecutive patients who underwent open rotator cuff repairs were included in the study. All patients underwent a pre-operative ultrasound by the same experienced musculoskeletal ultrasoundist. Rotator cuff tears were measured in the coronal plane only. This was compared with the tear size measured intra-operatively. Regression analysis was done between the two variables.
Results The mean size of rotator cuff tears as determined by ultrasonography was 15.56±8.07mm and the measure size of the tears intraoperatively was 27.94±9.8 mm. The result of the regression analysis of the two variables was R2= 0.268405 for the first 25 patients and R2= 0.310309 for the second 25 patients.
Discussion Using ultrasound it is easy to visualize the extent of rotator tears in the coronal plane, but more time consuming to measure the extent in the sagital plane, where the tear may have its greatest extension. Ultrasound measurements tear measurements in this study, made only in the coronal plane correlated poorly with intraoperative findings and only minimally improved over the time course of the study.
Conclusion Proper assessment of a possible candidate for a rotator cuff repair should include an ultrasound with the tear size measured specifically in both the coronal and sagital planes.
The abstracts were prepared by Ms Orah Naor. Correspondence should be addressed to Israel Orthopaedic Association at PO Box 7845, Haifa 31074, Israel.
