REPAIR OF SUBSCAPULARIS TEARS ASSOCIATED OR NOT WITH SUPRASPINATUS TEARS AND AN INTACT INFRASPINATUS: FUNCTIONAL AND RADIOLOGICAL RESULTS AT MEAN 9 YEARS (6–15 YEARS)

Abstract

Purpose: Short-term results of surgical repair of subscapularis tears are well known. The purpose of this study was to assess long-term outcome after surgical repair of 21 full-thickness tears of the subscapularis.

Material and methods: Inclusion criteria were subscapularis tear (n=21) which were isolated (n=9) or associated with a supraspinatus tear (n=11) without intraspinatus tears. The subscapularis was reinserted by transosseous fixation in fifteen cases and with a trapezeal flap in six. The supraspinatus was repaired by transosseous suture. Function (Constant score) was assessed preoperatively, at one and three years, and at last follow-up (nine years, range six to fifteen years). We also noted radiographic changes (subacromial height, osteoarthritis using the Samilson classification, anterior dislocation of the humeral head). Fatty degeneration (FD) of the cuff was assessed on pre-operative scans and at last follow-up. Arthroscan, performed at one year and ultrasonography performed at last follow-up were used to assess cuff continuity.

Results: The rough Constant score was 45.2 (12–93.5) preoperatively, 67.5 (20–95) at one and three years and 59.45 (20–95) at last follow-up. At last follow-up, the Constant score was significantly better than preoperatively (improved pain score). There was only one case of repeated tear (repaired supraspinatus). At last follow-up we noted six anterior dislocations. The subacromial space remained unchanged (9.5 mm). Glenohumeral osteoarthritis developed in fourteen cases (2 Samilson class 3) including eight de novo degenerations. FD of repaired subscapularis tendons was 0.8 (0–4) preoperatively and 1.64 (1–4) at last follow-up. FD of unrepaired subscapularis tendons treated with a trapezeal flap worsened (2.2 to 2.7). FD of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus (0.5 preoperatively) worsened one stage. At last follow-up, the Constant score was lower in the presence of anterior dislocation of the humeral head (p=0.013). Development of anterior dislocation of the humeral head was correlated with major preoperative FD of the subscapularis (cut-off between 1.5 and 2, p=0.01). There was a correlation between more FD of the infraspinatus and the presence of anterior dislocation of the humeral head. Among the trapezeal flaps, there were only two good results (Constant scores 74 and 75) in patients with FD of the subscapularis scored 1.5 preoperatively.

Conclusion: Functional and radiographic outcome after cuff repair or palliation with a trapezeal flap for subscapularis tears associated or not with supraspinatus tears is not satisfactory unless the fatty degeneration of the subscapularis is low preoperatively (δ 1.5).