Abstract
Introduction Plantar fasciitis is a common presenting problem and there are multiple treatments available. There is little scientific data to assist in the selection of the most efficacious or cost-effective treatment. This study compared the efficacy of corticosteroid injection and low-dose ESWT for the treatment of chronic proximal plantar fasciitis.
Methods One hundred and thirty-two cases of plantar fasciitis were enrolled into this prospective study over five years. Eligible patients performed a stretching program for the gastrocsoleus. In addition, patients randomized to group A received an intralesional corticosteroid injection, while group B received low dose ESWT (3 x 1000 pulses, energy flux density 0.08/mm2). Nineteen patients were not randomized and comprised a control group C. Patients were assessed before, and then three and 12 months post treatment using a VAS, and algometer (tenderness threshold, TT). The groups were compared using generalized linear models for repeated measures of VAS and TT scores, with orthogonal contrasts.
Results The three groups were significantly different in their VAS scores post treatment. Over the 12 months, pain levels reduced for all groups, but the trends between them differed significantly. The corticosteroid (CSI) group, had significantly lower levels of pain than the ESWT or controls. At 12 months, the CSI and ESWT had similar levels of pain, both significantly lower than that in the controls. Similar trends were found for TT. Threshold levels increased for all three groups post treatment but the trends between the groups were significantly different. At three months, the CSI group had significantly higher TTs than both the ESWT and control groups. By 12 months, all groups had higher TTs but they were similar. The TT of the CSI group had plateaued by three months. Of the 64 heels that received CSI, there were no infections and no cases of rupture of the plantar fascia. There were eight cases of post-injection pain. All patients found the injection unpleasant. Of the 61 heels treated with ESWT, six reported throbbing pain and erythema. Four reported a severe headache. All patients found the procedure unpleasant.
Conclusions Intralesional corticosteroid injection is more efficacious, and much more cost-effective, than ESWT, in the treatment of plantar fasciitis present for at least six weeks. The injection achieves a significant and lasting reduction in pain and tenderness within three months. Correctly used, this treatment has a low incidence of complications.
The abstracts were prepared by Mr Jerzy Sikorski. Correspondence should be addressed to him at the Australian Orthopaedic Association, Ground Floor, William Bland Centre, 229 Macquarie Street, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia.
None of the authors have received any payment or consideration from any source for the conduct of this study.
