Abstract
Polyethylene wear debris in TKA arises from several sources, including the tibiofemoral articulation and the interface between the backside surface of the tibial insert and the metal tibial tray. In this study we identify a new source of abrasive damage to the polyethylene bearing surface: impingement of resected bony surfaces, osteophytes and overhanging acrylic cement on the tibial bearing surface during joint motion.
One hundred forty-eight tibial components of 24 different designs in a retrieval collection were examined. A digital image of the articular surface of each insert was recorded. The presence, location and projected area of abrasive wear to the non-articulating edges of the insert were assessed using image analysis software.
Significant abrasive wear was observed in 24% of the retrievals with cemented femoral components and 9% from non-cemented components. Of the retrievals exhibiting this abrasive wear mode, 46% experienced multiple site damage. The average damage area for each individual abrasive scar was 78±11mm^2. Within the group of worn inserts, the abrasive scars were seen with a frequency of 69% on the extreme medial edge, 19% on the extreme lateral edge, 38% on the posterior-medial edge and 23% on the posterior-lateral edge. In posterior stabilized components with an open femoral box design, scarring of the superior surface of the tibial post was also observed. This proposed mode of damage was confirmed with several retrieved femoral components containing either fixed cement protruding from the posterior condyles, from the medial and lateral edges or osteophytes embedded in the posterior capsule. The corresponding inserts exhibited significant abrasive scarring at those locations.
We have observed a previously unrecognized source of polyethylene damage resulting in gouging, abrasion and severe localized damage in cemented and uncemented total knee replacement. Clearly, acrylic cement, in bulk or particulate form, often contributes to severe damage of the tibial surface and improvements to instruments and techniques for cementing are needed to prevent this wear mechanism.
The abstracts were prepared by Nico Verdonschot. Correspondence should be addressed to him at Orthopaedic Research Laboratory, University Medical Centre, PO Box 9101, 6500 HB Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
