THE CLINICAL OUTCOME FOLLOWING DIRECT REPAIR OF SPONDYLOLYSIS IN PROFESSIONAL ATHLETES

Abstract

The incidence of symptomatic pars defect varies between 15% and 47% in the young athletic population. We have analysed the outcome of direct repair spondylolysis on young professional athletes.

We have prospectively studied 22 young athletes with lumbar spondylolysis in whom conservative treatment has failed. Fifteen male and 7 female patients with a mean age of 20.2 years (range 15–34 years) were surgically treated for radiographically confirmed spondylolysis between 1994 and 1999. Eleven patients were professional footballers and four were professional cricketers. Pre-operative assessment included plain X rays, SPECT imaging with planar bone scan and reverse gantry CT scans. All patients had the Oswestry disability index (ODI) and 19 patients had Short Form 36 (SF-36) scores recorded pre-operatively and two years post operatively. Nineteen patients underwent Buck’s fusion and 3 underwent Scott’s fusion. At two-year follow-up nineteen patients had ODI and SF36 scores recorded. Return to the sporting activity at the previous level was regarded as a successful outcome.

The average duration of back pain prior to surgery was 8.9 months (range 1-36 months). The mean lysis defect determined by CT was 3.5 mm (range 1–8 mm). The mean pre-operative ODI was 39.5 (SD=8.7) and the mean post-operative ODI was 10.7 (SD=12.9). The mean scores of the physical health component of SF-36 improved from 27.1 (SD=5.1) to 47.8 (SD=7.7). The mean scores of the mental health component of SF-36 improved from 39.0 (SD=3.9) to 55.4 (SD=6.3) [P < 0.001].

The surgical repair of bilateral spondylolysis with modified Buck’s fusion in professional sportsmen and women results in a significant improvement in Oswestry Disability scores (p< 0.001) and in all domains of SF36 health questionnaire (p< 0.001). Ninety five percent of patients in this group return to active sport within seven months of surgery.