Abstract
We report our experience of four initial cases of mosaicplasty using large plugs in four cases and subsequently fourteen cases using the OATS technique and large grafts.
The average size of the articular lesion was 1.7 sq cm with a range of 1–3 sq cm. The average number of grafts used was 2.3 with a range of 1.5. The average size was 9 mm with a range of 4–10 mm. Including a poor result due to infection, pain was only found in three patients on activity (17%). The Tegner score and the IKDC score improved significantly. The initial four cases of mosaicplasty resulted in two cases having donor site pain and crepitus which required a lateral release. Using the OATS technique reconstructing the donor site no further cases of pain and crepitus occurred.
On MRI imaging, the recipient site was congruous, intact and appeared functional and only one patient demonstrated protuberance of the articular cartilage (1mm). Recipient site marrow oedema, fluid accumulation or kissing tibial signals were not significant features. The donor site articular cartilage was congruent in 5 patients and homogeneously isointense in 6 out of 7 patients.
We have modified the technique and used osteochondral transplantation to treat isolated articular cartilage defects of 1–3 sq cm in area, using a mini open technique and multiple large grafts, avoiding graft impaction and with reconstruction of the donor site. This technique has resulted in an 89% success rate at an average of 2.5 years post operatively. Eighty three per cent of patients were able to return to recreational sports. MRI follow up has shown no cause for concern and demonstrates incorporation of all the grafts. The success reported in this study is higher than reported elsewhere but this may reflect the use of the modified technique.
The abstracts were prepared by Mr Richard Buxton. Correspondence should be addressed to him at Bankton Cottage, 21 Bankton Park, Kingskettle, Cupar, Fife KY15 7PY, United Kingdom
