Abstract
To determine whether resection of osteophyte at TKR improves movement, 139 TKRs were performed on knees with pre-operative posterior osteophyte. Randomisation was to have either resection of distal femoral osteophyte guided by a custom made ruler or no resection. After preparation of the femoral bone cuts the ruler measuring 19 mm was placed just proximal to the posterior chamfer cut. The proximal end of this ruler marked the bone to be resected and this was performed using an osteotome at 45 degrees. Knees randomised to no resection had no further femoral bony cuts. Three months after implantation the patients had range of motion assessed.
One hundred and fourteen suitable knees were assessed, with 59 knees (57 patients) in the resection group and 55 knees (54 patients) in the no resection group. Full extension was more likely in the resection group (62%) than the group without resection (41%)(p=0.08). Flexion to at least 110 degrees was, however, less in the resection group (37%) than the no resection group (54%) (p=0.09).
Our study failed to show a statistically significant difference if the bony osteophyte is removed. There were however sharp trends, with statistically a one in ten chance these results would be different if the trial was repeated. Although there is no indication as to the cause of improved extension this could be explained by the release of the posterior capsular structures allowing full extension. The reduction in flexion is harder to explain and this may be due to increase in perioperative trauma and resultant swelling, possibly with fibrosis. Range of movement, particularly flexion, is known to improve up to 1 year post-operatively and assessment of these groups at that stage would be beneficial.
The abstracts were prepared by Mr Richard Buxton. Correspondence should be addressed to him at Bankton Cottage, 21 Bankton Park, Kingskettle, Cupar, Fife KY15 7PY, United Kingdom
