CERVICAL SPONDYLOTIC MYELOPATHY: COMPARISON OF OUTCOME FOLLOWING CIRCUMFERENTIAL VERSUS ANTERIOR DECOMPRESSION AND FUSION

Abstract

A retrospective review, comparing outcome following circumferential versus anterior decompression and fusion for patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy (CSM).

To assess the safety and efficacy of the circumferential operation for CSM.

Cervical spondylotic myelopathy has traditionally been managed by anterior or posterior decompression with/ without fusion. However, there is a considerable variation in neurological recovery and clinical outcome following these procedures. While circumferential decompression and fusion has been shown to provide superior neurological outcome in selected patients with cervical trauma and tumours, its role in the management of CSM has yet to be clearly defined.

Fifteen patients who underwent a 360° operation (Groupl) for CSM were matched (age, number of levels operated and follow-up duration) with patients (Group 2, n=15), that underwent anterior decompression and fusion for the same problem. All patients were operated by a single surgeon and reviewed independently. Charts, radiographs, patient interviews and MODEMS Cervical Spine Outcome questionnaires were the basis for assessment.

The operative time, blood loss, in-hospital stay and post-operative complications were higher in group l. The pseudoarthrosis rate was comparable though a trend towards increased graft and hardware problems was noted in group 2. Neurological improvement as measured by the mJOA Myelopathy Scale was significantly better (p = 0. 039) in group 1. 87% of those in group1 and 67% in group 2 showed improved function. Patients in group1 also performed better (p=0. 056) in the neurological domain and treatment expectation scales of the cervical spine questionnaire, though the incidence of post-op, neck pain was higher.

Single stage circumferential spinal decompression and fusion permits consistent neurological recovery in selected patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy and it can be performed with limited morbidity.