HIP HEMIARTHROPLASTY – CEMENTED OR UNCEMENTED?

Abstract

The best management of displaced intracapsular femoral neck fractures in the elderly remains undecided. Most are treated by hemiarthroplasty. The aim of this study was to establish whether the advantages of cement outweigh the disadvantages.

All patients with displaced intracapsular femoral neck fractures treated with herniarthroplasty between January 1997 and May 1998, in 2 hospitals within the same Deanery, were reviewed. The same prosthesis was used, but in hospital A they were uncemented, and in B cemented. There were 122 patients in hospital A and 123 in B. We conducted a detailed retrospective analysis of hospital notes. All surviving patients (50 and 56 respectively) were interviewed to obtain pre-fracture and current scores of pain, walking ability, use of walking aids, activities of daily living (ADL) and accommodation status, using validated scoring systems. The relative deterioration over the follow-up period (32–36 months) was determined and the groups compared.

Patient demographics confirmed comparability of groups. There was no greater incidence of intra-operative fall in diastolic blood pressure, or oxygen saturation in the cemented group. Cemented procedures were on average 15 minutes longer. Median in-patient stay was the same. Significantly fewer of the cemented group had been revised or were awaiting revision (p=0. 036). There was no difference in mortality rates at any point between surgery and follow-up. Prospective assessment of surviving patients revealed highly statistically significant greater deterioration in pain (p=0. 003), walking ability (p=0. 002), use of walking aids (p=0. 003) and ADL (p=0. 009) in the uncemented group. The trend for more dependent accommodation in the uncemented group failed to reach statistical significance (p=0. 14).

In conclusion, the cemented group faired significantly better than the uncemented group. Our findings suggest the advantages of cement outweigh the disadvantages, and we support the use of cemented hemiarthroplasty for the displaced intracapsular femoral neck fracture in the elderly patient.