EARLY FAILURE OF A CEMENTED TITANIUM GEMINI STEM - 3 - 10 YEAR RESULTS

Abstract

This is a retrospective assessment of the performance of the titanium cemented Gemini femoral component. The Gemini stem (DePuy) is a modular titanium femoral stem with a cobalt chrome femoral head. It has a roughened proximal surface finish to enhance cement bonding and a fixed distal centraliser.

205 total hip replacements were performed using a titanium cemented Gemini stem and an uncemented cup. All the operations were performed by a lateral approach using modern cementing technique. Patients were assessed clinically (Harris hip score) and radiologically. Kaplan Meier Survivorship analysis was used to assess survival.

8 patients were lost and 36 patients died with their total hip prosthesis in situ. The average follow-up in the remaining 161 hips was 70 months (range 37–124 months). The average age was 70 years (range 35–91). Osteoarthritis was the commonest diagnosis and majority of the patients was female. Using the Barrack’s criteria for cementing quality, more than 85% of the hips belonged either to grade A or B with an adequate proximal cement mantle. 28 hips have been revised (26 of which for aseptic loosening) and a further ten have been recognized as radiological failures. A small sized stem was used in over 85% of the failures. Mean time to revision was 3.1 years. Survival according to Kaplan-Meier Survivor curves at 6 years was 72%.

There is a high incidence of early failure associated with these cemented titanium stems (28%). The possible mechanism of failure is as follows. The rough surface finish and the flexible titanium alloy are likely to produce large amounts of wear debris and the centraliser which is fixed to the stem probably acts as an area of stress concentration causing accelerated destruction of the distal cement mantle. Based on our experience, the continued use of this cemented stem is no longer justified.