Abstract
Aim
Most orthopedic infections are due to the microbial colonization of abiotic surfaces, which evolves into biofilm formation. Within biofilms, persisters constitute a microbial subpopulation of cells characterized by a lower metabolic-activity, being phenotipically tolerant to high concentrations of antibiotics. Due to their extreme tolerance, persisters may cause relapses upon treatment discontinuation, leading to infection recalcitrance hindering the bony tissue regeneration. Using isothermal microcalorimetry (IMC), we aimed to evaluate in vitro the presence of persisters in a methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) biofilm after treatment with high concentrations of vancomycin (VAN) and their ability to revert to a normal-growing phenotype during incubation in fresh medium without antibiotic. Moreover, the ability of daptomycin to eradicate the infection by killing persisters was also investigated.
Method
A 24h-old MRSA ATCC 43300 biofilm was exposed to 1024 µg/ml VAN for 24h. Metabolism-related heat of biofilm-embedded cells, either during or after VAN-treatment, was monitored in real-time by IMC for 24 or 48h, respectively. To evaluate the presence of VAN-derived “persisters” after antibiotic treatment, beads were sonicated and detached free-floating bacteria were further challenged with 100xMIC VAN (100 µg/ml) in PBS+1% Cation Adjusted Mueller Hinton Broth (CAMHB).. Suspensions were plated for colony counting. The resumption of persister cells' normal growth was analysed by IMC on dislodged trated cells for 15h in CAMHB. Activity of 16 µg/ml daptomycin was assessed against persister cells by colony counting.
Results
When incubated with 1024 µg/ml VAN, MRSA biofilm produced undetectable heat, suggesting a strong reduction of cell viability and/or cellular metabolism. However, the same samples re-inoculated in fresh medium produced a detectable and delayed metabolism-related heat signal, similarly to that generated by persister cells. The following exposure to 100xMIC VAN resulted in neither complete killing nor bacterial growth, strongly supporting the hypothesis of a persistent phenotype. IMC analysis indicated that VAN-treated biofilm cells resumed normal growth with a ∼3h-delay, as compared to the untreated growth control. Daptomycin treatment yielded a complete eradication of persister cells selected after VAN treatment.
Conclusions
Hostile environmental conditions (e.g. high antibiotic bactericidal concentrations) select for persister cells in MRSA biofilm after 24h-treatment in vitro. A staggered treatment vancomycin/daptomycin allows complete biofilm eradication. These results support the use in clinical practice of a therapeutic regimen based on the combined use of antibiotics to kill persisters and eradicate MRSA biofilms. IMC represents a suitable technique to detect persisters and characterize in real-time their reversion to a metabolically-active phenotype.
