Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 94-B, Issue SUPP_IV March 2012 British Orthopaedic Association (BOA) 2007

S Bahari M El Dahab M Cleary J Sparkes

Introduction

This study was performed to investigate the efficacy of steroid and local anaesthesia (LA) in reducing post-operative pain in lumbar discectomy.

Materials and methods

The study was ethically approved. Patients undergoing primary single level lumbar discectomy were randomised by a closed envelope system into 4 groups, which were (Group 1) 10mg of adcortyl in 1ml and 1ml of 0.5% marcaine, (Group 2) 10mg of adcortyl and 1ml of normal saline, (Group 3) 1ml of 0.5% marcaine and 1ml of normal saline and (Group 4) 2mls of normal saline as control. Combinations of the above were applied topically over the nerve root prior to closure. Pre-operative, day 1 and eight weeks post-operative pain scores were recorded. 24 hours post-operative opiate analgesia requirements and duration of inpatient stay were recorded. Data were analysed using student t-test for statistical significance.


S Tafazal L Ng N Chaudhary P Sell

Objectives

The main objective of our study was to determine the treatment effect of corticosteroids in peri-radicular infiltration for radicular pain. We also examined whether there was any effect on the need for subsequent interventions such as additional root blocks and/or surgery.

Subjects and Method

In a randomised, double blind controlled trial, 150 eligible patients with radicular pain and unilateral symptoms who failed conservative management were randomised for a single injection with bupivacaine and methylprednisolone (b+s) or bupivacaine (b) alone. The outcome measures used included the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), Low Back Outcome Score (LBOS), Visual Analogue Score (VAS) for leg pain and back pain and patient's subjective level of satisfaction of the outcome.


G Higgins J Philips S Iqbal H Kwong M Grainger

We reported the first single surgeon series comparing outcome of microscopic and open primary single level unilateral lumbar decompression or discectomy. We aimed to determine any difference in outcomes between the two techniques.

Forty-six decompressions were performed with use of an operating microscope (microscopic), and forty without (open) at two different hospitals. All procedures were performed by the senior author. Information was obtained by analysis of the patients' notes. The average age of the patients in both groups was comparable. Operating time was shorter in the microscopic group (68min, range 30-130) compared to the open group (83 mins, range 30-180). Dural tear rate was 4.3% with use of a microscope (0% symptomatic dural tear rate) and 7.5% without (2.5% symptomatic dural tear rate). Nerve damage incidence was 0% with use of a microscope and 5% (two patients) without. One of these was a neurapraxia and the patient made a full recovery. Wound infection rates, diagnosed on grounds of clinical suspicion, were 4.3% and 2.5% for microscopic and open respectively. There were no incidences of deep infection or post-operative discitis. Average inpatient stay was under 48 hours in both groups.

Using the modified Macnab criteria, results using the microscope were 0% poor, 14% fair, 32% good, and 55% excellent. The results for the open group were 0% poor, 10% fair, 37% good and 53% excellent. Average follow-up was six months (1-19) for the microscope group, and seven months (2-16) for the open group.

We conclude that primary single level unilateral lumbar decompressive surgery, performed without the use of a microscope, has a higher dural tear rate than the same surgery performed with the benefit of an operating microscope. Surgical time and incidence of nerve damage are also reduced by use of the microscope.


F Chinwalla M Shafafy J Nagaria M Grevitt

Aim

To evaluate morbidity and outcome associated with lumbar spine decompression for central spinal stenosis in the elderly compared with younger age groups.

Patients & methods

Case notes review of patients with symptomatic and MRI proven central lumber canal stenosis, under the care of a single surgeon. The study population was 3 age groups: patients < 60 year of age (Group 1, n=21), patients between 60 and 79 years (Group 2, n=54), and > age of 80 years (Group 3, n=15).

Data with regard to intra- and post-operative complications and subjective outcome variables were collected. These included pain (VAS), walking distance, Oswestry Disability score (ODI) and patient satisfaction scores.


AA Cole R Newsome N Chiverton LM Breakwell

Objective

To investigate, through a randomised, single blind, Quasi-experimental trial, whether immediate physiotherapy after lumbar micro-discectomy enables patients to become independently mobile more rapidly with no increase in risk of complications.

Background data

Although studies have demonstrated the efficacy of rehabilitation after lumbar discectomy, nos have looked at physiotherapy commencing immediately post-operatively.


HW Amarasekera P Roberts DR Griffin SJ Krikler U Prakash P Foguet N Williams ML Costa

We investigated the blood flow to the femoral head during and after Resurfacing Arthroplasty of the hip.

In a previous study, we recorded the intra-operative blood flow in 12 patients who had a posterior approach to the hip and 12 who had a trochanteric flip approach. Using a LASER Doppler flowmeter, we found a 40% drop in blood flow in the posterior group and an 11% drop in the trochanteric flip group (p<0.001). The aim of this current study was to find out whether the intra-operative fall in blood flow persists during the post-operative period.

We therefore conducted a Single Positron Emission Tomography (SPECT) scan on 14 of the same group of patients. The proximal femur was divided into four regions of interest. These were the mid-shaft, proximal shaft, inter-trochanteric and head-neck regions. The data was analysed for bone activity and comparisons made between the two groups for each region of the femur. We found that the bone activity in the mid-shaft, upper-shaft, and head-neck regions was the same eleven months after the surgery irrespective of the approach to the hip. However there was higher activity in the trochanteric flip group in the inter-trochanteric region.

We conclude that the intra-operative deficit in blood flow to the head-neck region of the hip associated with the posterior approach does not seem to persist in the late post-operative period. We believe the reason for increased bone activity in inter-trochanteric region to be due to the healing of the trochanteric flip osteotomy.


J Daniel C Pradhan H Ziaee D McMinn

Introduction

The results of the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR) device in several series reveal that the predominant mode of failure is femoral neck fracture or femoral head collapse and that careful patient selection and precise operative technique are vital to the success of this procedure. In this report we consider the results of BHR in patients with severe arthritis secondary to femoral head AVN.

Methods

This was a single-surgeon consecutive series of BHRs with a minimum follow-up of 5 years. Fifty-nine patients with Ficat-Arlet grade III or IV femoral head AVN (66 hips) and treated with BHRs at a mean age of 43.9 years (range 19 to 67.7 years) were followed up for 5.4 to 9.6 years (mean 7.1 years). No patient died and none was lost to follow-up. Revision for any reason was the end-point and unrevised patients were assessed with Oxford hip scores. They were also reviewed clinically and with AP and lateral radiographs.


A Cobb G Isaac R McLennan-Smith R Oakeshott T Siebel

Introduction

A metal ion study was undertaken in patients who had received an articular surface replacement. The design of these components is optimised in line with lubrication theory and produces low levels of wear in hip joint simulators.

Methods

Patients were recruited in four centres. Whole blood samples were analysed for metal ion levels using high resolution ICP-MS (inductively coupled plasma mass spectrophotometry). A total of 75 patients was enrolled into the study and 65 and 47 patients were assessed after 12 and 24 months implantation respectively. Results are included irrespective of clinical outcome.


Y Joshi M Ali N Pradhan O Wainwright

Introduction

We conducted a study of 312 patients undergoing primary hip and knee arthroplasty in 2005. The aim was to identify the correlation between length of stay, ASA (American society of Anaesthesiologist) grade and BMI (Body Mass Index).

Method and materials

312 patients underwent hip and knee arthroplasty in 2005. ASA grade for surgery was documented by the anaesthetist and BMI by the nurses. 67 patients had inadequate documentation. SPSS software was used for analysis.


VS Dachepalli A Shah L Jeys B Purbach

Introduction

The aim of the study was to whether the bone grafting techniques used affected the long term stability of the acetabular implant.

Methods

41 patients treated with a cemented total hip replacement with pre-operative protrusio or central acetabular defects at surgery were identified. The severity of initial protrusio was determined on plain AP pelvis radiographs by measuring the distance of the medial acetabular wall from the ilio-ischial line. The post-operative and last follow-up x-rays were reviewed, the thickness of the medial wall and the centre-edge angle of the cup was measured.


R Kotwal M Ganapathi A John M Maheson S Jones

Aim

To determine the outcome, the need for revision surgery, quality of life (QOL) of patients and the financial implications of instability following successful closed reduction of dislocation after primary total hip arthroplasty (THA).

Methods

Retrospective study. Parameters studied include indications for primary hip replacement, femoral head size, outcome in terms of the rate of recurrent dislocation, time to second dislocation and the need for revision surgery. QOL assessment was made cross-sectionally at a minimum follow-up of 1 year using the Oxford Hip Score (OHS) and the EuroQol-5 Dimension (EQ-5D) questionnaire.


PJ Wraighte P Howard

Femoral impaction grafting with cancellous bone and cement is an important technique in reconstituting deficient bone stock in revision hip arthroplasty. We report the medium to long term results of 75 consecutive patients using a collarless, polished, tapered femoral stem with an average age of 68 (±11.4) years and a mean follow up of 10.5 (±2.4) years (range 6.3 to 14.1 years).

The median Endoklinik pre-operative bone defect score was 3 (IQR: 2–3) with a median subsidence at 1 year of 2mm (IQR: 1–3mm). At the most recent follow-up (mean 10.5±2.4 years), the median Harris Hip Score (HHS) was 80.6 (IQR: 67.6–88.9) and median subsidence 2mm (IQR: 1–4mm). Ten-year survivorship with any further femoral operation as an endpoint was 92%. Four prostheses required further revision.

Subsidence of the Exeter stem continued, albeit at a slower rate after the first year and was related to the Endoklinik pre-operative bone loss (p=0.037). The degree of subsidence at 1 year was a strong predictor of long term subsidence (p<0.001). Neither subsidence nor bone stock were related to long term outcome (HHS). There was a correlation between previous revision surgery and a poor Harris Hip Score (p=0.028) and those who had undergone previous revision surgery for infection had a higher risk of complications (p=0.048).

The good long term results of this technique commend its use in revision hip arthroplasty for patients with poor femoral bone stock.


S Garrett B Bolland P Yates J Latham

Introduction and aim

One of the suggested advantages of hip resurfacing arthroplasty is that it offers the possibility of straightforward revision. As the femoral canal is not violated during the resurfacing procedure, it is postulated that the outcome of revision surgery should be equivalent to that of a primary hip arthroplasty. The purpose of this study was to investigate whether revision was as straightforward and as successful as has been suggested.

Method

14 patients underwent revision surgery due to the failure of the femoral component of their Birmingham hip resurfacing. The femoral component was revised to a cemented Zimmer CPT stem, with a large modular metal head (MMT). The acetabular component was found to be well fixed and was left in situ. Radiographs were studied to review any change in offset. These patients were matched with a group who had undergone a hybrid total hip arthroplasty as a primary procedure, using the same bearing. The Oxford and Harris Hip scores were used to measure outcome.


WY Kim YX Hu K Duan R Wang D Garbuz B Masri C Duncan

Introduction

Achieving durable implant–host bone fixation is the major challenge in uncemented revision hip arthroplasty when significant bone stock deficiencies are encountered. The purpose of this study was to develop an experimental model which would simulate the clinical revision hip scenario and to determine the effects of alendronate coating on porous tantalum on gap filling and bone ingrowth in the experimental model.

Methods

Thirty-six porous tantalum plugs were implanted into the distal femur, bilaterally of 18 rabbits for four weeks. There were 3 groups of plugs inserted; control groups of porous tantalum plugs (Ta) with no coating, a 2nd control group of porous tantalum plugs with micro-porous calcium phosphate coating, (Ta-CaP) and porous tantalum plugs coated with alendronate (Ta-CaP-ALN). Subcutaneous fluorochrome labelling was used to track new bone formation. Bone formation was analysed by backscattered electron microscopy and fluorescence microscopy on undecalcified histological sections.


R Metcalf S Thambapillay V Veysi M Stone

Our aim was to highlight that there is a sub-group of patients with disabling symptoms after leg lengthening at primary hip replacement who benefit from revision surgery.

Most patients with an over lengthened limb after total hip arthroplasty are either asymptomatic or find it an inconvenience which can often be treated with a shoe raise. A minority, however, find this severely debilitating, patients describing that the leg “feels long”, with pain felt around the hip, difficulty sitting and limited function. It is this sub-group of patients that we feel benefit from revision surgery to equalise leg lengths.

We report on 8 cases (6 female; 2 male) that underwent revision surgery for leg lengthening over a 7 year period . The mean leg length difference was 14.3mm (range 10-20mm). Five patients had revision of the stem only and the remaining 3 both cup and stem. Time to revision varied from 8 months to 3 years. We outline our method of radiological measurement of leg length after total hip arthroplasty, using the centre of hip rotation as the reference point. Individual cases are discussed with radiographs highlighting the typical clinical features and this radiological technique.

All patients reported an immediate improvement in their symptoms following revision surgery and have remained pleased with the outcome at their latest follow up.

Leg lengthening as a result of total hip arthroplasty is well recognised but its treatment remains controversial. There is a sub-group of patients who are particularly sensitive to over lengthening, often of short stature. We reiterate that this revision surgery is beneficial to the patient with a lengthened leg ONLY if they have significant symptoms and limitation of function. Our small series emphasises the need to recognise this group of patients who can achieve a successful outcome after revision surgery.


D Sharma A Agarwal AJ Hammer

The hook screw method is a direct repair technique that permits ‘restitutio ad integrum’ for a functional segment. The surgical method of treating spondylolysis and grade 1 spondylolisthesis by spondylytic hook screw reduction and bone grafting in 34 patients is reported. Of these patients, 32 showed good to excellent results.

Surgical technique

The bone on either side of the defect is roughened. Then the screws are inserted after pre-drilling into the base of the articular process inclined at 400 to the vertebral endplate and diverging 15 to 20 degrees from each side. Then the special hooks, hooked under the lamina, are fixed to the screws by nuts over a spring so as to obtain compression over the defect. Autologous cancellous bone graft is placed in the defect.

Materials and methods

A total of 34 patients were included in this study from 1998 to 2006, 32 male and 2 female patients. Pre-operative and post-operative Oswestry Lumbar Disability Index score (OLDI) and SF 36 scores recorded.


M Bapat

Introduction

Pedicle Subtraction osteotomy (PRO) in correction of severe spinal deformities is well established. Prospective analysis of its efficacy in complex spinal deformities is sparse in literature.

Aims and objectives

To assess the role of PRO in correction of uniplanar and multiplanar spinal deformity and to assess the role of revision PRO in failed corrections.


N Steele B Freeman T Sach J Hegarty R Soegaard

Study design

Economic evaluation alongside a prospective, randomised, controlled trial from a two-year National Health Service (NHS) perspective.

Objective

To determine the cost-effectiveness of Titanium Cages (TC) compared to Femoral Ring Allografts (FRA) in circumferential lumbar spinal fusion.


J Van Meirhaeghe D Wardlaw L Bastian S Cummings S Boonen

Background

Vertebral body compression fractures (VCFs) impair quality of life (QOL) and increase patient morbidity and mortality. The international, multicentre, randomised, controlled Fracture Reduction Evaluation (FREE) trial was initiated to compare effectiveness and safety of Balloon kyphoplasty (BKP) to non-surgical management (NSM) for the treatment of acute painful VCFs. We describe the primary endpoint of the ongoing 2-year study.

Methods

Patients with 1-3 non-traumatic VCFs (< 3 months old) were randomised to either BKP or NSM. The primary endpoint was the change in QOL as measured by the SF-36 Health Survey Physical Component Summary (PCS) at one month, and device/procedure-related safety. Secondary endpoints included SF-36 subscales, the EQ-5D, self-reported back pain and function using the Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire (RMDQ). All patients were given osteoporosis medical therapy.


M Bapat

Introduction

Anterior reconstruction has the advantage of conferring immediate stability to the cervico-thoracic junction

Aims and objectives

Assess clinical and radiological outcome in cervico-thoracic kyphosis treated with anterior reconstruction.


F Alvi JB Williamson H Dashti S Mohammad ERS Ross NJ Oxborrow

Introduction

Many journals require outcome data at 2 years post-operative for the assessment of operative procedures in spinal surgery. This study seeks to clarify the timescale of improvement after surgery to see if a shorter period of assessment will indicate the final outcome.

Methods

Outcome data for 185 consecutive patients who underwent spinal surgery was analysed. All were given a global outcome assessment questionnaire (as used in the Swedish Spinal Fusion study) at 6 months, 1 year and 2 years following surgery. Results were analysed according to the type of spinal surgery undertaken.


KNR Srikanth S Anand T Asumu K Buch

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of a single per operative injection of sodium hyaluronate (HA, Viscoseal¯) into the knee following arthroscopy.

This was a prospective, randomised controlled study. Knee arthroscopy patients were randomised into two groups: one receiving bupivicaine and the other sodium hyaluronate. Pre and post operative VAS scores for pain and Western Ontario and MacMaster Universities (WOMAC) scores for knee function were obtained. Forty eight patients of a single surgeon were randomised into two groups of 24. Both groups were similar as regards to age, sex, etc. Three patients withdrew from the study after randomisation. There was significant drop in pain scores for the Viscoseal¯ group compared to Bupivicaine group particularly between three-six weeks period (p< 0.05) and a significant improvement in WOMAC scores in the study group compared to control at 3 and 6 weeks (p=0.01). Viscosupplementation after arthroscopic knee surgery offers significantly improved function and pain relief over the medium term period (three-six weeks).


S Sivananthan H Colaco E Sherry P Warnke

Introduction

Bisphosphonates are among the most commonly prescribed drugs in Osteoporotic Patients. Their mode of action is anti-resorptive. Since remodeling is a key step in fracture healing, there has been concern regarding the effect of bisphosphonates on fracture healing.

Objectives

To assess the effect of alendronate on fracture healing in the rabbit ulna osteotomy model.


Z Dahabreh M Howard P Campbell P Giannoudis

Aim

To compare a variety of commercially available bone graft substitutes (BGS) in terms of promoting adherence, proliferation and differentiation of osteoprogenitor cells.

Materials and methods

A fixed number of porcine mononuclear cells obtained from cancellous bone of the proximal femur was mixed with a standard volume of BGS and then cultured for one week in media followed by two weeks in osteogenic media. BGS included commercially available β-Tricalcium Phosphate (□-TCP), highly porous β-TCP, Hydroxyapatite/Tricalcium phosphate composite, calcium sulphate (CS), Hydroxyapatite (HA), Demineralised bone matrix (DBM), polygraft, and polymers (PGA, PLGA).

Staining for live/dead cells as well as scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were carried out on all samples to determine viability and cellular binding. Further outcome measures included alkaline phosphatase assays with normalisation for DNA content to quantify osteogenic potential. Negative (BGS without cells) and positive (culture expanded osteoprogenitors) control experiments were carried out in parallel to validate the results.


G Altman R Horan P Weitzel D Horan E Mortarino N DeAngelis I Toponarski J Huang H Boepple J Prudom J Richmond

Objectives

We hypothesise that a long-term bioresorbable hydrophilic silkworm silk device, the SeriACL(tm) scaffold, can support the development and remodelling of native functional ligament tissue if designed to anticipate the remodelling curve of an ACL graft. This study evaluated the SeriACL scaffold for ACL replacement in a goat model at 3, 6 and 12 months.

Methods

The ACL of 43 goats was replaced in an arthroscopically assisted procedure. The ACL was excised, a guide pin driven into the femur and 6mm diameter antegrade drilling performed. The tibial tunnel was drilled under direct visualisation. The graft was anchored around a post on the femur, tensioned to 50N and cycled 30x before tibial fixation with a staple and sutures around a post. Animals were clinically, mechanically and histologically evaluated.


R-T Steffen K O'Rourke DW Murray HS Gill

In 12 patients, we measured the oxygen concentration in the femoral head-neck junction during hip resurfacing through the anterolateral approach. This was compared with previous measurements made for the posterior approach. For the anterolateral approach, the oxygen concentration was found to be highly dependent upon the position of the leg, which was adjusted during surgery to provide exposure to the acetabulum and femoral head. Gross external rotation of the hip gave a significant decrease in oxygenation of the femoral head. Straightening the limb led to recovery in oxygen concentration, indicating that the blood supply was maintained. The oxygen concentration at the end of the procedure was not significantly different from that at the start.

The anterolateral approach appears to produce less disruption to the blood flow in the femoral head-neck junction than the posterior approach for patients undergoing hip resurfacing. This may be reflected subsequently in a lower incidence of fracture of the femoral neck and avascular necrosis.


O Flannery P O'Reilly J Britton N Mahony P Prendergast P Kenny

The process of femoral impaction grafting requires vigorous impaction to obtain adequate stability but the force of impaction has not been determined. This process has been reported to result in femoral fractures with rates reaching 16%. The aims of this study were to determine the threshold force required for femoral impaction grafting, to determine the affect cortical thickness, canal diameter and bone mineral density (BMD) have on this threshold force and to measure subsidence of an Exeter prosthesis following impaction at the threshold force.

Adult sow femurs were prepared and placed through a DEXA scanner and the BMD and canal diameter measured. Thirty five femurs were impacted with morsellised bone chips and an increasing force of 0.5kN was applied until the femur fractured. Using callipers the cortical thickness of the bone was measured along the fracture line. Once the threshold force was determined 5 femurs were impacted to this threshold force and an Exeter stem was cemented into the neomedullary canal and a 28mm Exeter head attached. Axial cyclic loading was performed between 440N (swing phase of gait) and 1320N (stance phase of gait) for 150,000 cycles at a frequency of 3Hz. The position sensor of the hydraulic testing machine measured the subsidence.

29 tests were successfully completed. The threshold force was found to be 4kN. There was no significant correlation between the load at fracture and the cortex: canal ratio or the bone mineral density. Following impaction with the maximum force of 4kN the average subsidence for the 5 femurs was 0.276mm (range 0.235 – 0.325mm). In this animal study the threshold force was 4kN. Minimal axial subsidence of the implant occurred when impacting the graft with this threshold force. We therefore achieved a stable construct without fracture which is the ultimate goal for the revision hip surgeon.


H Ziaee J Daniel C Pradhan DJW McMinn

Introduction

Large diameter metal-metal total hip replacements (MM THRs) offer the advantages of low wear and low dislocation risk and are being increasingly used in high-demand patients whose bone quality rules out the possibility of a hip resurfacing. However suggests that large headed MM devices may result in greater systemic metal exposure compared to small diameter bearings. This raises fresh concerns of elevated systemic metal levels.

Methods

Whole blood concentrations and daily output of cobalt and chromium in 28 patients with unilateral large diameter MM THRs (42 to 54mm bearings) were studied at 1-year follow-up. These were compared with the whole blood levels in 20 patients at 1 year and daily output of metal ions in 28 patients with 28mm MM THRs at 1 to 3 years. Both bearings are made of high carbon cobalt-chrome alloy, the larger bearing is as-cast alloy and the smaller is wrought alloy. High resolution inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry was used for analysis. None of the patients had other metal devices or compromised renal function. They had either a cemented polished tapered stainless steel stem or a cementless porous ingrowth titanium alloy stem.


D van der Jagt S Williams A Brekon A Schepers G Isaac J Fisher

The search for the ideal bearing surface in Total Hip Replacements continues. The current ‘best’ materials are felt to be combinations of metal, ceramics and cross-linked polyethylene. Laboratory studies suggest that ceramic-on-metal articulations may provide distinct advantages. This study aims to identify the best bearing surface combination with the lowest adverse side effect profile.

Between February 2004 and September 2007, 164 hips were replaced in 142 patients. 39% were male and 69% were female. The average age at surgery was 53 years (17-72 years). Follow-up assessment included radiographs, the Harris Hip Score and whole blood samples for metal ion levels. Complications to date included 3 hips which needed femoral revision because of surgery related factors, and 3 cases of sepsis of which 1 settled and 2 needed revision. One hip needed revision of head and liner to a larger bearing size for recurrent dislocations, and is no longer being followed up for blood metal ions.

Post-operative whole blood metal ion levels were compared to pre-operative levels to determine the increase or decrease in metal ion levels. There were no changes in those patients with ceramic-on-ceramic and ceramic-on-polyethylene articulations. Moderately raised whole blood metal ion levels were noted at 3 months in the ceramic-on-metal group, while the metal-on-metal group show the greatest increase.

This study agrees with laboratory bearing surface wear studies demonstrating lower wear rates in the ceramic-on-metal group compared to the metal-on-metal group. With concerns related to high blood metal ion levels in metal-on-metal articulations, ceramic-on-metal bearing surfaces may well become a bearing surface of choice in the future, but progress needs to be monitored in the longer term.


Full Access
V Khanduja R Villar

Aim

The aim of this study was to assess the role of hip arthroscopy in the management of hip pain in elite athletes.

Patients and methods

It is a retrospective study of prospectively collected data. 31 hip arthroscopies were performed on 27 elite athletes. All the patients were assessed pre-operatively with a thorough clinical examination, radiographs and MRI scans. The modified HHS was also recorded for all the patients' pre and post-operatively. All operations were performed by the senior author, and the patients were assessed at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months and a year following the operation.


D Griffin S Karthikeyan

Background

Femoro-acetabular impingement (FAI) is increasingly recognised as a cause of mechanical hip symptoms in sportspersons. In femoro-acetabular impingement abnormal contact occurs between the proximal femur and the acetabular rim during terminal motion of the hip as a result of abnormal morphologic features involving the proximal femur (CAM) or the acetabulum (Pincer) or both (Mixed) leading to lesions of acetabular labrum and the adjacent acetabular cartilage. It is likely that it is a cause of early hip degeneration. Ganz developed a therapeutic procedure involving trochanteric flip osteotomy and dislocation of the hip, and have reported good results. We have developed an arthroscopic technique to reshape the proximal femur and remove prominent antero-superior acetabular rim thereby relieving impingement.

Methods

Twelve patients presented with mechanical hip symptoms and had demonstrable cam-type (eight patients) or mixed (four patients) FAI on radially-reconstructed MR arthrography, were treated by arthroscopic femoral osteochondroplasty and acetabular rim resection if indicated. All patients were competing at the highest level in their respective sport (football, rugby and athletics). All patients were followed up and post-operative Non-Arthritic Hip Scores (NAHS, maximum possible score 100) compared with pre-operative NAHS.


B Varghese N Patel B Hopton D Shutt C Groves SR Bollen

Hamstring tendons are commonly used for Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction. In our series of 100 consecutive Hamstring ACL reconstructions, a four-strand graft was less than 7.0 mm in 5 patients. The aim of this study was to develop a screening test to assess the size of the hamstring tendon and so aid in the pre operative planning and patient counselling especially if hamstring size was deemed to be inadequate. A retrospective study of 100 consecutive hamstring ACL reconstructions analysed the correlation of the tendon size to height, weight and body mass index. A prospective double blind study was also set up involving independent observations by a musculoskeletal radiologist and the lead Orthopaedic surgeon.

Result

There was no correlation between the anthropometric measures and hamstring size in the retrospective study. A total of 27 limbs were assessed sonographically, in 26 patients. Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was found to Pearson's r = 0.0786; p = 0.715.

Conclusion

Pre-operative anthropometric measures and Ultrasound could not be used as a screening test to detect inadequate hamstrings in the clinical setting.


N Ohly I Murray J Keating

We reviewed 87 patients who underwent revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. The incidence of meniscal tears and degenerative change was assessed and related to the timing from primary ACL graft failure to revision ACL reconstruction. Patients were divided into either an early group (revision surgery within 6 months of graft failure) or a delayed group. Degenerative change was scored using the French Society of Arthroscopy system. There was a significantly higher incidence of articular cartilage degeneration in the delayed group compared to the early group (53.2% vs 24%, p < 0.01, Mann- Whitney U test). No patients in the early group had advanced degenerative change (SFA grades 3 or 4), compared with 12.9% of patients in the delayed group. There was no significant difference in the incidence of meniscal tears between the two groups. In conclusion, the findings of the study support the view that patients with a failed ACL reconstruction and symptomatic instability should have an early revision reconstruction procedure carried out to minimise the risk of articular degenerative change.


S Konangamparambath F Haddad

Hamstring muscle strain is a common sports related injury. It has been reported in a variety of sports, following acceleration or deceleration while running or jumping. Injury may vary from simple muscle strains to partial or complete rupture of the hamstring origin. Avulsion fracture of the ischial tuberosity has also been described. Simple hamstring muscle strains are treated conservatively. Surgical exploration and repair is currently advocated for partial or complete rupture of the hamstring origin. A few case series exists in literature suggesting the benefits of early intervention.

We report a series of 8 athletes who presented between 2002 and 2006 with complete tear of their hamstring origin. Avulsion of the ischial tuberosity was excluded in these cases. After confirming the diagnosis, early surgical exploration and repair or reattachment was performed. The patients were braced for 8 weeks. This was followed by specialist physiotherapy and a supervised rehabilitation programme over 6 months. All patients were followed up to monitor return to normal activities and sports. The sciatic nerve was scarred to the avulsed tendon in three cases. Neurolysis led to a rapid relief of symptoms. Cases where the hamstring origin had retracted more than 3 cm required a figure 7 incision. There were no major complications including nerve palsies.

An excellent functional outcome was noted by 12 months in all 8 patients. 7 of them returned to their previous level within 6-9 months of injury. One person despite a very good recovery, opted out of sports. No other complications were seen as a result of the surgical procedure. In conclusion, a tear of the origin of hamstring muscles is a significant injury. Early surgical repair and physiotherapy is associated with a good outcome and enables an early return to high level sports.


J Walsh J Quinlan G Byrne R Stapleton D FitzPatrick D McCormack

Hypothesis

Athletes significantly alter their lumbar spinal motion when performing squat lifting at heavy weights. This altered motion effects a change in pressure in the posterior annulus of lumbar discs.

Methods

48 athletes performed 6 lifts at 40% maximum, 4 lifts at 60% maximum and 2 lifts at 80% maximum. Zebris 3-D motion analysis system used to measure lumbar spine motion. Exercise then repeated with weight lifting support belt.

4 cadaveric sheep spinal motion segments fixed to tension/compression loading frame, allowing compression replicating the forces seen in in vivo study. Pressure measurement achieved using a Flexiforce single element force sensor strip, positioned at posterior annulus. Posterior annulus pressure measured during axial compression and on compression with specimen fixed at 3° of extension.


G Smith G Johnson R Grimer

Objective

Sarcomas are a rare group of tumours, which pose numerous problems regarding correct diagnosis and appropriate management. This study aimed to examine whether symptom duration and tumour size at diagnosis have changed over time, using size and symptom duration as methods of comparison.

Methods

All patients diagnosed with sarcoma were identified retrospectively from a prospective database from 1963 to 2005. Demographic data concerning age at diagnosis, sex and diagnosis were recorded. Data were also collected on duration of symptoms and size of tumour at diagnosis. Symptom duration is defined as the length of time the patient was experiencing symptoms for until the date of diagnosis. Changes in size and symptom duration over time were compared by grouping date of diagnosis into time periods and comparing them against each other using non-parametric statistical analysis.


G Johnson G Smith R Grimer

Objectives

To assess the affects of a delay in diagnosis on the survival rates of Bone Sarcoma (BS) using size and symptom duration as measures of delay.

Methods

All patients diagnosed with a Primary BS from 1970 to 2005 were included. Demographic data concerning age, sex, diagnosis and tumour site were recorded. The data were collected retrospectively from a prospective database, with 2573 patients included. Symptom duration is defined as the length of time the patient was experiencing symptoms for until the date of diagnosis. Survival analysis was performed using Kaplan-Meier curves and Cox Regression was carried out to identify variables affecting outcome.


PK Jaiswal W Aston R Grimer A Abudu S Carter G Blunn T Briggs S Cannon

We performed a retrospective review of 98 patients with malignant tumours of the periacetabular region, treated by resection and endoprosthetic reconstruction between 1971 and 2005 at the Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital, Stanmore and The Royal Orthopaedic Hospital, Birmingham.

The mean age of the patients was 43.6 years (10 to 76). 53 patients (54%) were male. The age distribution demonstrated peaks in the 2nd and 6th decades. The mean follow up was 65 months (2 to 405. The overall 10-year survival rate was 56% (determined by the Kaplan-Meier method).

54 patients (58.1%) had one or more complications. Infection was the most common (30%) with the majority occurring in the first 2 years. Dislocation occurred in 19 (20%) of our patients all in the first year following surgery. All were recurrent with a mean of 2.9 (2 to 6) episodes. Operations performed before 1994 were associated with a dislocation rate of 40.5% and after 1996 the rate was only 3.9% (p < 0.001).

Function was assessed according the Toronto Extremity Salvage Sore (TESS). The overall TESS was 59.4. In patients that had a major complication the TESS was 37.1 but in the group that did not the TESS was 70.3 (p < 0.001).

Men experienced higher rates of death, infection and revision than women (p < 0.05). The local recurrence rate was 31% with high grade tumours associated with higher recurrence rates (p < 0.05). Tumour resection in the ilium is associated with higher rates of infection than tumours located in the periacetabular region alone (p < 0.05).

This method of reconstruction is still associated with high complication rates. Function is good if a major complication can be avoided. The lower dislocation rate more recently is probably the result of improved surgical technique and the use of larger femoral heads.


P Shanmugam L Banks M Lovell

Cementoplasty, like vertebroplasty, is a technique whereby Polymetylmethacrylate is placed into a bone lesion either percutaneouly or by surgery under image intensifier guidance.

Although there have been few studies with regard to cementoplasty percutaneously, there is no series in the literature to support the open surgical technique as a palliative procedure. In our series we describe four patients (1male and 3 females, age range 63-83) with metastatic bone cancer who have benefited from an open surgical procedure. The four patients presented to our hospital between January 2004 and December 2006. They all had gradually worsening hip pain at the time of presentation and pelvic radiographs revealed osteolytic lesions in the acetabulum. A 5 centimetre longitudinal incision proximal to the greater trochanter was made and the malignant lesion identified using the image intensifier. The malignant tissue was curetted and sent for microscopy, culture, sensitivity and histopathology and the remaining void filled with bone cement (via a gun or by hand) under x-ray control. Radiographs were taken in all patients post-operatively and were referred for adjuvant radiotherapy. All patients had immediate relief of pain and were able to mobilise within 48 hours. Two patients died within 6 weeks post-operatively due to complications from their primary malignancy (lung). One patient died at three months due to unknown primary. One patient remained pain free and fully ambulatory at one and a half years post surgery (breast primary).

This procedure can be recommended for patients with metastatic bone disease as it provides adequate pain control and improves the quality of life in this group of patients. These patients need a multi-disciplinary approach to their care, but as orthopaedic surgeons, we can make a significant impact to such patients and their families.


KNR Srikanth M Revell A Abudu R Tillman RJ Grimer

Solitary plasmacytomas in the appendicular skeleton are rare monoclonal expansions of plasmacytoid cells. They are two main hazards; local destruction of bone with resultant loss of function and possible fracture, and progression to Myeloma.

Between February 1988 and July 2005 seven patients (4 male, 3 female) were treated for solitary plasmacytoma with surgical resection and endoprosthetic reconstruction. The median age was 46.7 (35-75). The site was: distal humerus (2), proximal humerus (2) proximal femur (2) proximal tibia (1). Three patients had sustained a pathological fracture. Five patients had received pre-operative radiotherapy and three received post-operative radiotherapy. Mean follow-up is 8.6 years. Two cases became infected at 2 and 5 years post-operatively and have had revisions of their endoprosthesis. Both remain functional at 18 and 15 years. No patient has suffered a local recurrence. Two patients have progressed to multiple Myeloma but no patients have died. Literature review shows that the progression of solitary bone plasmacytoma to Myeloma is around 53% despite radiotherapy, in an average period of 2-4 years. With resection and endoprosthetic reconstruction, the progression in this series has been 28% despite an average follow up of 8.6 years.

Although the numbers are small, due to the rarity of the condition, surgical resection and endoprosthetic reconstruction reduces disease progression than radiotherapy alone. This produces far superior results compared to the intramedullary nailing of the long bones for this condition. Endoprosthetic reconstruction after resection should be given consideration in cases of solitary plasmacytoma of the appendicular skeleton when there is extensive bone destruction present. The optimal timing of local radiotherapy to be combined with surgery is still to be established.


L Jeys J Luscombe R Tillman S Carter S Abudu R Grimer

Between 1966 and 2001, 1254 patients underwent excision of a bone tumour with endoprosthetic replacement. All patients who had radiotherapy were identified. Their clinical details were retrieved from their records.

A total of 63 patients (5%) had received adjunctive radiotherapy, 29 pre-operatively and 34 post-operatively. The mean post-operative Musculoskeletal Tumor Society scores of irradiated patients were significantly lower (log-rank test, p = 0.009). The infection rate in the group who had not been irradiated was 9.8% (117 of 1191), compared with 20.7% (6 of 29) in those who had pre-operative radiotherapy and 35.3% (12 of 34) in those who radiotherapy post-operatively. The infection-free survival rate at ten years was 85.5% for patients without radiotherapy, 74.1% for those who had pre-operative radiotherapy and 44.8% for those who had post-operative radiotherapy (log-rank test, p < 0.001). The ten-year limb salvage rate was 89% for those who did not have radiotherapy and 76% for those who did (log-rank test, p = 0.02).

Radiotherapy increased the risk of revision (log-rank test, p = 0.015). A total of ten amputations were necessary to control infection, of which nine were successful. Radiotherapy may be necessary for the treatment of a bone sarcoma but increases the risk of deep infection for which amputation may be the only solution.


HG Harvey AJ Leroy N Garg EB Collin

The aim of this study is to assess the long-term results of Ethibloc (Ethnor Laboratories/ Ethicon, Norderstedt, Germany) injection in aneurysmal bone cysts (ABC).

33 patients with aneurysmal bone cysts were treated with computed tomographic (C.T) guided percutaneous injection of Ethibloc into the cyst cavity. 22 patients had Ethibloc injection as primary treatment and 11 patients had presented to us with recurrence following previous procedures including steroid injection, bone marrow injection, curettage bone grafting and various other surgical procedures. The mean follow-up was 54 (22-90) months.

Symptoms were relieved in all patients. 2 patients were lost to follow up. 18 (58%) of the 31 patients followed, had complete resolution of the lesion, 11 (35.5%) patients had partial healing (asymptomatic residual non progressive lytic areas). 2 (6.5%) patients showed recurrence in the proximal humerus during the follow-up. They are under follow-up but asymptomatic. 2 patients encountered more significant complications after the procedure.

Ethibloc injection is a relatively simple, minimally invasive alternative procedure for the treatment of ABC, and makes open operation unnecessary by stopping the expansion of the cyst and inducing endosteal new bone formation. This technique may be used as the primary management of ABCs excluding spinal lesions as shown by this long-term follow-up study.


S Chandrashekar K Hinduja A Paul J Jenkins

Haemangiomas are benign tumours with increased number of normal or abnormal appearing blood vessels. They are the commonest soft tissue tumours of infancy and childhood and comprise 7% of all soft tissue tumours.

Our study is a retrospective analysis of 120 referred cases of various vascular anomalies in the last 10 years. Eighty cases had confirmed haemangiomas. MRI scan and needle biopsy formed the basis of diagnosis. M:F = 42:38. Mean age at presentation was 34.8 years, with the youngest and eldest patient being 3.5 and 78 years respectively. 5 patients were lost to study. Sites of occurrence were upper limb(32), lower limb(32), axilla(3), foot(5), thumb(1), knee(4), spine(1), posterior chest wall(2). 55/80 patients were managed non-operatively by way of Sclerotherapy/Embolisation, watchful observation or symptomatic treatment. 4/55 cases were assessed to be unsuitable for sclerotherapy and 1 patient was subjected to surgery. 6/55 cases did not respond to sclerotherapy. 25/55 cases were managed with surgical excision. Complete excision was the primary goal of surgery. Intralesional margins were accepted if lesions were close to neurovascular structures. Indications for surgery were 1) Pain with functional and/or developmental disturbance, 2) Sudden increase in size, 3) Recurrent haemarthrosis, 4) Failure of sclerotherapy. There were 3 cases of incomplete excision among those operated. 6/25 cases had recurrence 1-8 years after surgery. Mean follow-up was 38.4 weeks (range6-12 months). We have had a success rate of 81.48% with non-operative management of symptomatic haemangiomas. Surgical excision of haemangiomas has borne 76% satisfactory results for pain relief/functional recovery.

We believe that extensive haemangiomata covering large surface areas are not suitable for surgical excision. Majority of cases can be successfully managed non-operatively by way of sclerotherapy/embolisation and watchful observation. MRI scan coupled with trucut needle biopsy has been most successful for diagnosis. Highly vascular sarcomata can mimic haemangiomas, hence histological diagnosis is crucial.


A Molloy R Dwyer M Kerin

Over 80% of patients with advanced breast cancer will develop bone metastases for which there is no cure. Although thought to involve a complex cascade of cell-cell interactions, the factors controlling the development of bone metastases are still poorly understood. Osteoblasts may have an important role in mediating homing and proliferation of breast cancer cells to the bony environment.

This study aimed to examine the potential role osteoblasts have in the migration of circulating tumour cells to bone and the factors involved in this attraction.

Culture of osteoblasts and MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells was performed. Breast cancer cell migration in response to osteoblasts was measured using Transwell Migration Inserts. Potential mediators of cell migration were detected using ChemiArray & ELISA assays. A luminometer based Vialight assay was used to measure breast cancer cell proliferation in response to factors secreted by osteoblasts.

There was a 3-4 fold increase of MDA-MB-231 migration in response to osteoblasts. ChemiArray analysis of osteoblast-conditioned medium revealed a range of secreted chemokines including IL-6 & 8, TIMP 1 & 2 and MCP-1. Initially, MCP-1 was quantified at 282 pg/ml, but rose to over 9000 pg/ml when osteoprogenitor cells were differentiated into mature osteoblasts. Inclusion of a monoclonal antibody to MCP-1 in osteoblast-conditioned medium resulted in a significant decrease in breast cancer cell migration to osteoblasts. There was no significant change in proliferation of MDA-MB 231 cells when exposed to osteoblast-conditioned medium.

Osteoblasts are capable of inducing breast cancer cell migration mediated at least in part by chemokine secretion. MCP-1 produced by the osteoblasts was shown to play a central role in mediating homing of the breast cancer cells. Increased understanding of the pathways involved in the development of bone metastases may provide new targets for therapeutic intervention.


BJ O'Daly SF Morris SK O'Rourke

Background

There is minimal published data regarding the long-term functional outcome in pyogenic spinal infection. Previous studies have used heterogeneous, unreliable and non-validated measure instruments, or neurological outcome alone, yielding data that is difficult to interpret. We aim to assess long-term adverse outcome using standardised measures, Oswestry disability index (ODI) and MOS short form-36 (SF-36).

Methods

All cases of pyogenic spinal infection presenting to a single institution managed operatively and non-operatively from 1994-2004 were retrospectively identified. Follow-up was by clinical review and standardised questionnaires. Inclusion in each case was on the basis of consistent clinical, imaging and microbiology criteria.


M Shafafy P Singh JCT Fairbank J Wilson-MacDonald

Aim

We report our ten year experience of primary haematogenous non-tuberculous spinal infection.

Method

Retrospective case note review of 42 patients presented to our institution with primary spinal infection during 1995-2005 was carried out. Demographic data, timing and modes of presentation, investigations, and methods of treatment were analysed. The cost benefit of Home Intravenous Antibiotics Service (HIAS) was also investigated.


S Judd B Freeman A Perkins C Adams SM Mehdian

Study Design

Prospective cohort study.

Objective

To assess the safety and efficacy of an intra-operative gamma probe in the surgical treatment of osteoid osteomas and osteoblastomas arising from the spine.


D Cumming C Scrase J Powell D Sharp

Previous studies have shown improved outcome following surgery for spinal cord compression due to metastatic disease. Further papers have shown that many patients with metastatic disease are not referred for orthopaedic opinion. The aims of this paper are to study the survival and morbidity of patients with spinal metastatic disease who receive radiotherapy. Do patients develop instability and progressive neurological compromise? Can we predict which patients will benefit from surgery?

Retrospective review of patients receiving radiotherapy for pain relief or cord compression as a result of metastatic disease. Patients were scored with regards to Tomita and Tokuhashi, survival and for deterioration in neurology or spinal instability.

94 patients reviewed. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 1 year or until deceased. Majority of patients had a primary diagnosis of lung, prostate or breast carcinoma.

Mean Tomita score of 6, Tokuhashi score 7, and mean survival following radiotherapy of 8 months. 11:94 patients referred for surgical opinion. Poor correlation with Tomita scores (-0.25) & Tokuhashi scores (0.24) to predict survival. Four patients developed progressive neurology on follow-up. One patient developed spinal instability. The remainder of the patients did not deteriorate in neurology and did not develop spinal instability. All patients with normal neurology at time of radiotherapy did not develop spinal cord compression or cauda equina at a later date.

This study suggests that the vast majority of patients with spinal metastatic disease do not progress to spinal instability or cord compression, and that prophylactic surgery would not be of benefit. The predictive scoring systems remain unreliable making it difficult to select those patients who would benefit. The referral rate to spinal surgeons remains low as few patients under the care of the oncologists develop spinal complications.


S Ghosh M Sayana E-N Ahmed C Wynn Jones

Introduction

We propose that Total Hip Replacement with correction of fixed flexion deformity of the hip and exaggerated lumbar lordosis will result in relief of symptoms from spinal stenosis, possibly avoiding a spinal surgery. A sequence of patients with this dual pathology has been assessed to examine this and suggest a possible management algorithm.

Materials and methods

A retrospective study of 19 patients who presented with dual pathology was performed and the patients were assessed with regards to pre and post-operative symptoms, walking distance, and neurological status.


D Hay M Izatt C Adam R Labrom G Askin

Purpose

1. To evaluate how radiological parameters change during the first 3 years following anterior endoscopic surgery. 2. To report complications encountered in this period.

Methods

Between April 2000 and June 2006,106 patients underwent an anterior endoscopic instrumented fusion. There were 95 females and 11 males. Average age was 16.1 years (range 10-46). 103 (97%) had right-sided idiopathic curves. The majority were Lenke type 1 (79%). Patients were assessed at 3, 6, 12, 24, and 36 months. 83 patients had 1 year follow-up, 69 had 2 years or more.

The following were investigated; the structural curve, instrumented curve, non-structural curves, skeletal age at operation and sagittal profile (T5-T12).


D Hay M Izatt C Adam R Labrom G Askin

Introduction

Luk (Luk et al. Spine vol 23(21) 2303-2307 1998) has shown that in posterior surgery, the correction achieved can be predicted by fulcrum bending films. The relevance to anterior correction has been disputed, as this commonly involves shortening the spine by the removal of intervertebral discs. The aim of the study was to see whether the pre-operative bending angle reflected the degree of correction achieved.

Method

91 patients with a structural thoracic curve had an anterior endoscopic correction using a single rod. The mean age was 16.1 years. (range 10-46) The majority of curves were Lenke type 1 (79%) or Type 2 (8%). In all cases disc clearance and bone grafting were performed. All had pre-operative fulcrum bending films.

The mean Cobb angle achieved at the pre-operative bending film was compared with the post-operative correction at 2 months. The FBCI (Fulcrum Bending Correction Index) and correction rates were also calculated. The FBCI is calculated by dividing the correction rate by the fulcrum flexibility and expressed as a percentage. It takes into account the pre-operative flexibility of the curve.


M Kokkinakis K Kafchitsas A Rajeev J Mortier M Engelhardt

The autologous osteochondral grafting represents a treatment option for osteochondral lesions of the weight bearing articular surfaces of femoral condyles and talus. The aim of our study was to evaluate the MRI findings and to determine the correlation between the radiological and the functional outcome in the early follow up.

We performed a retrospective study and followed up 33 patients 1 to 4 years after osteochondral auto-grafting. The grafts were harvested from the anterolateral region on the lateral femoral condyle of the ipsilateral knee using an insider rinsing diamond bone-cutting instrument (DBCS). The grafts were implanted using press fit technique and mosaic plasty.

Sixteen (48%) women and 17 men were included in our follow up with an average age of 38.4 years (age range-16 to 58 yrs). The Lysholm and Foot and Ankle Osteoarthritis Scores were used for the assessment of the functional outcome. MRI scans were performed by all patients.

While the MRI results illustrated graft incorporation, the cartilage contour interruption, irregularity of the subchondral lamina, inhomogeneity and subchondral oedema are typical findings between host and graft tissues. The clinical outcome demonstrated pain relief and improved function. There was no statistically significant correlation between radiological and functional outcome (p>0.05).

The MRI is a well-recognised non-invasive diagnostic tool to assess the integration of osteochondral grafts and to evaluate the articular surface but it has a reduced clinical significance on the early post operative stages. The long-term prognostic value of the unsatisfying MRI results is unknown.


B Holroyd D Dawe R Kincaid

We carried out a comparison of the analgesic requirements, length of stay in hospital, complications and cost effectiveness of patients who had either a continuous disposable infusion pump or standard treatment for unicompartmental knee replacement.

This study began as an audit. We completed the audit loop with a prospective study after implementing our recommendations. The device is a single use disposable elastometric pump, set immediately after surgery to deliver a continuous flow of 0.5% bupivacaine at a rate of 2mls per hour for 48 hrs into the knee joint via a fine catheter with a fenestrated tip.

The case notes of all patients in the study were analysed to establish their total analgesic requirements for 48hrs following surgery. Complications and length of stay in hospital were recorded This has changed our clinical practice. Results of our study of 50 patients, 25 in each group (age and sex matched) confirmed that there was a significant reduction in opiate requirements after introduction of the pain pump. Length of stay in hospital was reduced from 5.7 to 3.9 days. Patients' requirements for NSAIDs were reduced. There were no significant complications in the pain pump group. The costs of the pump (£40) were offset by the reduction in analgesic requirements and shortened length of stay in hospital.

We conclude this form of analgesia is safe, effective and cost effective. Our department has now changed to using the pump for all unicompartmental knee replacements.


K Willett T Lambert M Goldacre

We summarise findings from surveys of graduates from UK medical schools over 31 years. Serial surveys have been undertaken in 1974, 1977, 1980, 1983, 1993, 1996, 1999, 2000 and 2002. Questionnaires were sent to 33,151 doctors; 24,621 (74.3%) replied. Three years after qualification, 70.8% replied to a second survey; 5-years after qualification, seven cohorts were re-surveyed.

Trauma and orthopaedic surgery was the first choice career for 5.0% (men) and 1.0% (women) 1 year after qualification, and 5.2% (men) and 0.8% (women) at 5 years. Of those with T&O as first choice, 35% who chose it in year one, 56% in year three, and 84% in year five were working in it eventually. Experience as a student or junior, self-appraisal of skills, a particular teacher and enthusiasm for the specialty were the most important influences.

There has been an increase in the percentage of women choosing surgical careers. However, the much higher percentage of men who choose T&O surgery remains striking. The specialty needs to consider whether this matters. Women currently comprise about 60% of the medical school intake in the UK.

This study shows that doctors who ultimately pursued a surgical career made that choice by year 3 (equivalent to ST1) and between 84-92% had settled on the specialty by year 5 (ST3). Career progression for this historical cohort did not require an early commitment and a greater decisiveness may be anticipated in the more expectant system of Modernising Medical Careers.

It is unknown whether recent working time directives will influence career choice. This study defines T&O doctors to be highly motivated by work and not influenced by long working hours or competing domestic demands. This low priority places the specialty at the bottom of comparative tables. A change in work-life balance may directly impact future specialty recruitment.


MR Edwards D Hartwright WA Scott

Parallel operating lists are a contentious subject. Many people feel that supervision, training and quality of patient care is negatively affected and consider this an outdated model in modern practice. Dual and parallel lists have been largely abandoned due to training committees' opinions that standards of orthopaedic training were being negatively affected.

A new model of dual lists was implemented in a district general hospital as part of an arthroplasty service. The training impact was evaluated. Adjacent theatres were utilised for a single session. Two joint replacement surgeries were undertaken in each theatre. The sequential timing of the lists allowed the consultant to perform or supervise all of the operations in a consecutive manor. Staggering the start times allowed the consultant to approach and implant the first joint replacement, leaving the junior doctor or nurse practitioner to close the first operation and get the patient off the table while the consultant transferred to the adjoining theatre where the registrar had positioned, painted and draped the second patient, allowing the consultant to perform or supervise the second surgery. The process was then repeated until all four cases were performed.

Evaluation of two registrar's elogbooks was undertaken and compared to the national average.

During a twelve month period the trainees was involved in a mean of 72 joint replacement surgeries compared to a national average of 49. The trainees were the primary surgeon in a significantly higher number of operations compared to the national average.

This model of sequential operating lists facilitated a service of high volume arthroplasty surgeries and significantly increased the exposure of the training registrar to joint replacements. Supervision of trainees was not significantly impacted. The model requires effective support services and a dedicated team of theatre staff, but can be very rewarding for consultant surgeon and trainee alike.


N Howells A Price AJ Carr JL Rees

Objective

To investigate the effect of lab-based simulator training, on the ability of surgical trainees to perform diagnostic knee arthroscopy.

Method

20 orthopaedic SHOs with minimal arthroscopic experience were randomised to 2 groups. 10 received a fixed protocol of simulator based arthroscopic skills training using a bench-top knee model. Learning curves were clearly demonstrated using motion analysis equipment to monitor performance. All 20 then spent an operating list with a blinded consultant trainer. They received instruction and demonstration of diagnostic knee arthroscopy before performing the procedure independently. Their performance was assessed using the intra-operative section of the Orthopaedic Competence Assessment Project (OCAP) procedure based assessment (PBA) protocol for diagnostic arthroscopy. Performance was further quantified with a ten point global rating assessment scale.


R Gudena J Mehta KR Male C Evans R-M Jones

Introduction

Review the results of modified Lautenbach procedure (new method) to treat chronic osteomyelitis of the long bones.

Patients and methods

Retrospective analysis of sixty-seven patients with osteomyelitis of the long bones treated over 5-year period with modified Lautenbach procedure. Four patients were excluded from this study, as we were unable to retrieve the case notes. 48 men and 16 women were included and the average age was 33 years. All these patients had prior operative intervention including plating, intramedullary nailing or external fixator. Forty-seven patients had discharging sinuses and deformed leg. We noted the pre-operative inflammatory markers, bacteriology and pain score. We also recorded the duration of the hospital stay, post-operative recovery, deformity and the ability of the patient to resume his prior occupation.


E Ashby MJ Davies APR Wilson FS Haddad

There is mixed evidence in the literature regarding increasing age, ASA and BMI as risk factors for surgical site infection in orthopaedic surgery. To investigate the matter further, we examined 1055 wounds in 1008 patients in the Department of Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery at University College London Hospital between 2000 and 2006. All patients with a minimum two-night stay were included. Data was collected by four designated research nurses. The age, height, weight and ASA status of each patient was recorded. All wounds were classified using ASEPSIS. This is a quantitative wound scoring method which is a summation of scores calculated from visual wound characteristics and the clinical consequences of infection.

Our results showed a strong linear association between age and ASEPSIS scores. Single variable regression analysis showed a t value of 3.32 and p value of 0.001. A similar linear association was seen between ASA grading and ASEPSIS scores. Single variable regression analysis showed a t value of 2.75 and p value of 0.006. The association between BMI and ASEPSIS scores was markedly different from that seen with age and ASA. The graph was U-shaped with patients with a BMI of 25-30 having the lowest average ASEPSIS scores. Patients with a lower and a higher BMI had higher average ASEPSIS scores. Single variable regression analysis was not significant since the relationship between BMI and ASEPSIS scores is not linear.

In conclusion, there are clearly defined patient groups who are at increased risk of developing a surgical site infection: older patients, patients with a higher ASA, and patients with both a low and high BMI. These patients should be targeted to reduce overall infection rates. This can be achieved by ensuring adequate antibiotic prophylaxis, having a low threshold to treat suspected infection and arranging regular follow-up.


C Moser A Baltzer R Krauspe P Wehling

Aims

A new therapy, based on the intra-articular injection of autologous conditioned serum (ACS), is used in several European countries for osteoarthritis (OA) treatment. ACS is generated by incubating venous blood with medical grade glass beads. Peripheral blood leukocytes produce elevated amounts of endogenous anti-inflammatory cytokines such as interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) and growth factors that are recovered in the serum(1). ACS has been shown to improve the clinical lameness in horses significantly to enhance the healing of muscle injuries in animal models, and in human athletes. In the present study, the efficacy and safety of ACS was compared to intra-articular hyaluronan (HA), and saline in patients with confirmed knee OA.

Methods

In a prospective, randomised, patient- and observer-blind trial with three parallel groups, 376 patients with knee OA were included in an intention to treat (ITT-) analysis. Efficacy was assessed by patient-administered outcome instruments (WOMAC, VAS, SF-8, GPA) after 7, 13 and 26 weeks (blinded) and Two-years (non-blinded). The frequency and severity of adverse events were used as safety parameters.


M Zenios M Ramachandran B Milne D Little N Smith

The aims of this study were (1) to assess whether rotational stability testing in Gartland III supracondylar fractures can be used intra-operatively in order to assess fracture stability following fixation with lateral-entry wires and (2) to quantify the incidence of rotational instability following lateral-entry wire fixation in Gartland type III supracondylar humeral fractures in children.

Twenty-one consecutive patients admitted with Grade III supracondylar fractures at the Children's Hospital at Westmead were surgically treated according to a predetermined protocol. Following closed fracture reduction, 2 lateral-entry wires were inserted under radiographic control. Stability was then assessed by comparing lateral x-ray images in internal and external rotation. If the fracture was found to be rotationally unstable by the operating surgeon, a third lateral-entry wire was inserted and images repeated. A medial wire was used only if instability was demonstrated after the insertion of three lateral wires.

Rotational stability was achieved with two lateral-entry wires in 6 cases, three lateral-entry wires in 10 cases and with an additional medial wire in 5 cases. Our results were compared to a control group of 24 patients treated at our hospital prior to introduction of this protocol. No patients returned to theatre following introduction of our protocol as opposed to 6 patients in the control group. On analysis of radiographs, the protocol resulted in significantly less fracture position loss as evidenced by change in Baumann's angle (p<0.05) and lateral rotational percentage (p<0.05).

We conclude that the introduction of rotational stability testing allows intra-operative assessment of fracture fixation. Supracondylar fractures that are rotationally stable intra-operatively following wire fixation are unlikely to displace post-operatively. Only a small proportion (26%) of these fractures were rotationally stable with 2 lateral-entry wires. This may be a reflection of either the fracture configuration or inability to adequately engage the medial column.


A Bhaskar

Ten cases of missed Monteggia lesions were reviewed following treatment. Four cases were treated with an ulnar osteotomy, open reduction of radial head and annular ligament reconstruction (Group A). In six cases only an open reduction of the radial head was performed with an ulnar osteotomy (Group B). No annular ligament reconstruction was done in Group B. The mean age seven in both groups (range 4-12 years). The children presented three months to 24 months after the initial injury. Nine patients were classified as Bado type I, and one with Bado type III injury. The mean follow-up was 20 months (8-26 months) after surgery.

In both groups the ulnar osteotomy healed uneventfully. In group A, there was one superficial infection, the mean loss of pronation was 12 degrees and in one case the radial head re-subluxed.

In group B, the mean loss of pronation was 10 degrees. Elbow flexion was comparable to Group A. No radial head subluxation was seen in this group. No child in either group had any functional limitation in activities.

Thus, in chronic Monteggia lesion, annular ligament reconstruction is not always required to restore radio-capitellar alignment. Open reduction of radial head with an ulnar osteotomy and stable fixation will suffice. Ligament reconstruction will not stabilise an inadequately reduced radial head.


S Auplish D Wilson

Aim

This study aims to determine the value of MRI in children with hip pain which remained unexplained following routine investigations including ultrasound examination.

Materials and methods

Retrospective review of clinical notes and MRI findings in all children who received and MRI scan for undiagnosed hip pain over three years.


R Kanwar K George K Johnson H Prem

To assess healing pattern of Achilles tendons across the gap created by a percutaneous tenotomy and maintained by cast in club feet.

Twenty-one tenotomies in 16 patients (Age range 12 weeks-36 months) were monitored with dynamic and static ultrasonographic studies. Ultrasounds were performed before and immediately after tenotomy and at approximately 3, 6 and 12 weeks post tenotomy. Cast removal was done at three weeks. Two patients above age of two were casted for 6 weeks.

The healing pattern went through different phases although they were not distinctively exclusive from each other and did show considerable overlap. First phase showed formation of a bulbous mass with some continuity of scar tissue across tendon gap. The transition zone between new fibre and the original tend quite distinct. However dynamic ultrasound showed the Achilles tendon moved as a single unit. Second phase showed fibres resembling normal tendon crossing the gap and reduction of bulbous mass. The transition zone was still discernible. Final stage demonstrated more homogenous fibres of Achilles tendon with an indistinct transition zone.

Two older children showed a distinctly longer process of healing.

One child showed an irregular mass of fluid and soft tissue structures in the gap at six weeks.

The other child demonstrated a relative reduction in the proportion of tendon fibres across the gap.

At 12 weeks there was evidence of continuation of tendon fibres, but transition zone partly visible.

Conclusion

Young Child (<1 Year): when cast immobilisation is discontinued, the tendon is in mid phase of healing. There may be a positive effect on continued improvement in dorsiflexion while using boots and bars. Older Child: safe to consider percutaneous tenotomy in children up to 3 years of ages provided the period of immobilisation is extended.


V Peter Y Joshi H George A Bass

Introduction

Some patients with Cerebral Palsy who had a de-rotation osteotomy performed for correction of excessive anteversion had persistence of internal foot progression even after surgery. Potential causes which have been implicated include: weak hip abductors, spasticity of the anterior fibres of the gluteus medius, hip adductor spasm and persistent femoral anterversion. The aim of this study was to see if there is any relationship between significant abductor weakness [less than Grade III: MRC] and persistence of internal foot progression.

Methods

We included all ambulatory patients with cerebral palsy who had had a derotation osteotomy between the periods of 2000-2005, who had also had a pre and post operative gait analysis, assessment of anteversion [Gage Test], hip range of motion and muscle charting.

There were 12 patients [17 hips, 5 bilateral] with an average age of 13. Seven were diplegic, two hemiplegic and three had asymmetric diplegia. Data was assessed using SPSS13.0. The Spearman Co-relation Coefficient was used to test if there was any correlation.


S Symons J Robin F Dobson P Selber HK Graham

Proximal femoral deformity is common in children with cerebral palsy (CP), contributing to hip instability and ambulation difficulties. This population-based cohort study investigates the prevalence and significance of these deformities in relation to Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) level.

Children with a confirmed diagnosis of CP born within a three-year period were identified from a statewide register.

Motor type, topographical distribution and GMFCS level were obtained from clinical notes. Neck Shaft Angle (NSA) and Migration Percentage (MP) were measured from an anteroposterior pelvis x-ray with the hips internally rotated. Measurement of FNA was by the Trochanteric Palpation Test (TPAT) or during fluoroscopic screening of the hip with a guide wire in the centre of the femoral neck.

Linear regression analysis was performed for FNA, NSA and MP according to GMFCS level.

292 children were eligible. FNA was increased in all GMFCS levels. The lowest measurements were at GMFCS levels I and II p<0.001. GMFCS levels III, IV, and V were uniformly high p<0.001. Neck shaft angle increased sequentially from GMFCS levels I to V (p<0.001). This study confirms a very high prevalence of increased FNA in children with CP in all GMFCS levels. In contrast, NSA and MP progressed step-wise with GMFCS level.

We propose that increased FNA in children with CP represents failure to remodel normal fetal alignment because of delay in ambulation and muscle imbalance across the hip joint. In contrast, coxa valga is an acquired deformity and is largely related to lack of weight bearing and functional ambulation.

The high prevalence of both deformities at GMFCS levels IV and V explain the high rate of displacement in these hips and the need for proximal femoral realignment surgery in the prevention and management of hip displacement.


S Badhe R Morton R Rajan A Henry

Aim

To assess the risk of hip dislocations in children with cerebral palsy (CP) attending special schools, and the effects of preventative soft tissue surgery (psoas and adductor tenotomy).

Method

110 children were reviewed from 1985-2000. Severity of CP was graded according to the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS). Hemiplegics - grade 1, Diplegics grades 2 & 3, Quadriplegics grades 4 & 5. Patients were grouped into age groups 5, 10 and 15 years and the number of hip dislocations in each group were noted. Numbers of patients who had preventative soft tissue surgery was also noted. Indication for surgery, >35% femoral head uncovering.


HC Pape D Rixen J Morley CI Ellingson C Dumont C Garving B Vaske M Mueller C Krettek PV Giannoudis

Purpose

The timing of definitive fixation for major fractures in polytrauma patients is controversial. To clarify this aspect of trauma management, we randomised patients with blunt multiple injuries to either initial definitive stabilisation of the femur shaft with an intramedullary nail or an external fixator which was converted to an intramedullary nail at a secondary procedure and documented the post-operative clinical condition.

Methods

Multiply injured patients with femoral shaft fractures were randomised to either initial (<24 hours) intramedullary femoral nailing or to initial external fixation and conversion to an intramedullary nail at a later phase. Inclusion criteria: New Injury Severity Score >16 points, or 3 fractures and Abbreviated Injury Scale score >2 points and another injury (Abbreviated Injury Scale score >2 points), and age 18 to 65 years. Exclusion criteria: unstable or patients in extremis. Patients were graded as stable or borderline (increased risk of systemic complications). OUTCOMES: Incidence of acute lung injuries.


K Willett H Al-Khateeb R Kotnis O Bouamra F Lecky

Background

To determine the relative contributions of bilateral versus unilateral femoral shaft fracture plus injuries in other body regions to mortality after injury.

Study design

A retrospective analysis of the prospectively recorded Trauma Registry data (TARN) from 1989 to 2003.


PV Giannoudis NK Kanakaris O Bouamra E Tsiridis F Lecky

Introduction

The aim of this study was to investigate the differences between open vs closed femoral fractures with regard to the epidemiology, classification and outcome.

Patients & methods

Data collected prospectively from MTOS and TARN-UK. Between 2001 and 2005, 67,665 trauma patients found and 8,591 were identified having sustained femoral shaft fractures. Demographics, pre and in-hospital data were recorded. The AIS and ISS were calculated. Outcomes and mortality rates were recorded. Four groups of patients were identified namely isolated/open (IO), polytrauma/open (PO), isolated /closed (IC), polytrauma/closed (PC). ANOVA analysis was contacted to determine the effect of fracture classification and severity of trauma to mortality using SPSS 11.0 software.


G Higgins M Nayeemuddin E Bache J O'Hara P Glitheroe

Introduction

Paediatric hip fracture accounts for less than one percent of paediatric fractures. Previous studies report complication rates between 20 and 92%.

Method

We retrospectively identified patients with fixation for neck of femur fractures at Birmingham Children's Hospital. All patients were under age sixteen. Data were reviewed over a 10 year period (1997-2006). Fractures were classified by Delbet's classification and Ratliff's system to grade avascular necrosis (AVN). Function was assessed using Ratcliff's criteria, incorporating clinical examination and radiographic findings.


PV Giannoudis I Pountos J Morley S Perry HC Pape

Purpose

The aim of this study was to investigate whether growth factors essential for fracture healing are released in the immediate aftermath following fracture and whether reaming of IM cavity causes increased liberation of these autocoids.

Methods

Consecutive adult patients with femoral shaft fractures forming two groups (a group who received unreamed nail (n=10) and a second group who received reamed nail (n=10) were recruited for this study. Peripheral blood samples and samples from the femoral canal before and after reaming and before and after the solid nail insertion were collected. Serum was extracted and using Elisa colorimetric assays the concentration of Platelet Derived Growth Factor (PDGF), Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF), Insulin-like Growth Factor I (IGF-I) Transforming Growth Factor beta 1 (TGF-21) and BMP-2 levels was measured.


M Bhatia S Parihar G Talwadekar A Smith

Introduction

There are no specific and clear guidelines regarding management of trauma patients who are on Warfarin. The objective of this study was to compare two methods of anticoagulation management in the pre-operative period for this group.

Methods

This study was conducted in two phases. In the first half (October 2005 to April 2006) the trauma patients on Warfarin were managed by the traditional method. The second group of patients who were admitted during May to December 2006 was given a single stat dose of Vitamin K (1 mg IV) in addition to stopping Warfarin and starting low molecular weight Heparin. There were 90 patients in this study, 45 in each group. There was no statistically significant difference in age distribution, INR on admission and medical co-morbidities in the two groups. Majority of patients were admitted with fracture neck of femur (43 in each group). All the patients had INR more than 1.5 on admission.


PV Giannoudis E Tsiridis P Richards R Dimitriou S Chaudry

To evaluate efficacy and outcome of embolisation following pelvic ring injuries in patients presented with ongoing hypovolaemic shock.

Between 2000 and 2003, 200 poly-trauma patients presented in our institutions following pelvic ring injuries. Those with ongoing hypovolaemic shock who were treated within 24h of admission with embolisation were included in this study. Demographics, mechanism of injury, ISS, type of pelvic ring fracture, arterial source of bleeding, hours from injury to embolisation, and outcome were all recorded prospectively. Out of the 200 treated in our institutions 17 (8.5%) underwent angio-embolisation. The mean age of the patients was 37 (14-70) and the mean ISS was 29. Distribution of pelvic ring injuries included: 3LC, 7APC, 7VS. The mean time from injury to embolisation was 15 hours. 8/17 patients were initially treated with an external fixator.

The distribution of arterial injuries was: 7 superior gluteal arteries, 8 internal iliac arteries, 1 obturator artery and 1 internal pudental artery. The mean number of units transfused prior to embolisation was 22 (range 6-50). Mortality rate was 4 (23%) out of 17 embolised patients. Angio-embolisation for pelvic ring injuries occurred in 8.5% of our study population.

This study indicates that only a small proportion of patients required embolisation secondary to arterial bleeding. The overall survival rate was in accordance to published international experience. Embolisation should be considered as a valid adjunct in some selected group of patients with pelvic fractures where ongoing bleeding refractory to other treatment modalities is present.


F Sadek M Halawa

Different factors associated with an adverse functional outcome of acetabular fractures involving the posterior wall have been well documented. Among these is marginal impaction.

From 1998 until mid-2006, 105 cases were prospectively reviewed to assess the functional and radiological results of simple and complex acetabular fractures associated with a posterior wall component, with special reference to the marginal impaction. Associated posterior wall components associated with marginal impaction were compared to the pattern of fractures without marginal impaction. The exclusion criteria were non-anatomic reductions i.e. > 2 mm displacement, avascular necrosis, deep infection, heterotropic ossification grade III, IV, chondrolysis and nerve injuries. All marginal impaction fractures were identified on the pre-operative CT scan. They were openly reduced, elevated and autografted from the greater trochanter, followed by rigid internal fixation for early post-operative mobilisation i.e. CPM use.

Results were assessed clinically by the modified Merle d'Aubigné and Postel score and radiologically by Kellgren and Laurence method of grading of osteoarthritis. 40 cases were excluded for the reasons above. This left 27 cases of marginal impaction and 38 cases of control. The average period of follow-up was 35.7 months. The functional results of the marginal impaction grafting group revealed 13 (48.1%) excellent, 7 (25.9%) very good, 6 (22.2%) good and one (3.8%) fair, while the control group showed 18 (47.4%) excellent, 10 (26.3) very good, 8 (21%) good, one (2.6%) fair and one (2.6%) poor result.

The functional and radiological outcome of the posterior wall component fractures associated with marginal impaction showed very satisfactory results in comparison with a control group in the short and mid-term period. An integral part of this is careful recognition of this injury pattern and its management as part of the open reduction and fixation.


J Mutimer M Ockenden T Chesser A Ward

The purpose of this study was to assess the clinical and radiological outcome following spring plate fixation of posterior wall fractures.

Spring plates are fashioned from a one third tubular plate cutting through one of the holes in the plate and bending the sharp edges through 90 degrees allowing screw fixation of small acetabular margin fragments well away from the joint reducing the risk of joint penetration.

From July 1993 to August 2004, 89 patients with displaced posterior wall fractures underwent posterior wall fixation with one or more spring plates. Patients were assessed post-operatively with a CT scan and annually for up to 5 years for a clinical and radiological assessment. Clinically patients were graded according to the Epstein modification of Merle d'Aubigné/Postel Hip Score. The radiographs were graded using the Roentographic Grade criteria used by Matta.

Patients were reviewed at a mean 55 month follow-up. There were 12 post-operative complications. Clinically excellent or good results were seen in 70% and radiologically in 70%. There were 15 revisions for osteonecrosis, infection and osteoarthritis. 91% (20/22) of fractures had excellent/good clinical results if reduced anatomically compared with 66% (24/36) of those reduced to within 2mm as assessed by the post-operative CT scan. Only 44% (8/18) of those reduced leaving a gap of greater than 2mm had an excellent/good clinical result.

Posterior wall fractures can be treated successfully by the use of spring plates. Clinical results correspond closely with radiological appearance. The accuracy of reduction correlates highly with the subsequent prognosis and we recommend routine post-operative CT scanning to identify misplaced metalwork and the accuracy of reduction to help predict prognosis.


E Tsiridis Z Gamie N Upadhyay M George D Hamilton-Baillie PV Giannoudis

Surgery for pelvic or acetabular fractures carries a high risk of deep-vein thrombosis (DVT). Reports indicate that fondaparinux is a more effective thromboprophylactic agent than low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) after major orthopaedic surgery. We prospectively evaluated a new protocol for DVT prophylaxis using fondaparinux.

Patients and methods

One hundred and eight patients with pelvic or acetabular fractures were randomised to receive either fondaparinux or enoxaparin. Specific review points included the primary end-point of clinical deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary embolism (PE) and any evidence of adverse effects such as bleeding or allergic reactions.

Results

Two patients that received enoxaparin were found to have a DVT (3%) and one patient died from a PE (1%). There was no documented DVT or PE in patients that received fondaparinux. The mean number of units of blood transfused was significantly higher in the enoxaparin group and this was significant post-operatively (p<0.05). The current study supports that post-operative fondaparinux, in patients with pelvic and acetabular fractures, is more effective and equally safe to enoxaparin.


JP Vidalain

Introduction

Bio-active fixation has increasingly gained acceptance over the last two decades. However extent of the coating is still a subject of debate. We introduced in 1986, the concept of total osteointegration of a tapered stem with the hope that we could achieve durable biological fixation while preserving normal periprosthetic bone trophicity.

Material and methods

Patients from our first clinical series using this stem are now eligible for 18-year follow up. Between July 1986 and December 1990, we performed 615 THA using the Corail stem (DePuy). Corail is a straight tapered stem totally coated with a 150 μ thick layer of HA following an atmospheric plasma-spray process. The mean age at surgery was 64.5 (range 16 to 95). 242 patients are now deceased (39%), 62 patients (10%) are lost to follow-up. The mean follow-up for 243 living patients on file is 17.7 years.


M Kandasami W Hadden

Introduction

Despite being from different manufacturers, Exeter stem and Ogee cup are commonly used together as cemented ‘cross breed’ combination in United Kingdom. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the long-term outcome of this combination.

Materials and methods

The ten years outcome of 131 primary hip replacements using an Exeter stem and an Ogee cup combination were studied retrospectively from clinical audit data and radiographs.


JM Buchanan P Lindsley

Cemented Total Hip Arthroplasty gives good results for 10 or more years, but is too often complicated by a combination of mechanical loosening, wear debris and osteolysis.

Patients require an implant which will last the rest of their life. Cemented hips may not survive and a better alternative is needed.

Furlong hydroxyapatite ceramic coated (HAC) implants have been used for more than 19 years and to date there are 2248 primary hip arthroplasties.

Fixation of the implants with HA ceramic is entirely satisfactory; histological studies from post-mortem specimens have confirmed that there is good cancellous bone fixation to the HA. The hydroxyapatite behaves like bone and is replaced by creeping substitution. This results in a Perfect Fit with no intervening fibrous tissue. Fixation is therefore maintained.

Aseptic loosening is rare; eleven components. Polythene wear is a problem. Those patients with ceramic/polythene couples who have now reached about 15 years since surgery are showing wear of the liner evidenced by eccentricity of the ceramic head in the liner. Three of these have completely destroyed the liner and the titanium shell.

Ceramic/ceramic bearings do not seem to wear, although there have been occasional fractures of alumina. For the last two years Biolox Delta, a stronger compound ceramic material, has been available from Ceramtec. There are no reports of any fractures.

Patients who have a life expectancy of more than 10 or 15 years should be fitted with an HA coated implant with ceramic bearing surfaces. This may provide the answer for the long-lasting hip prosthesis.


R Raman V Eswaramoorthy D Dickson T Madhu P Angus

Introduction

We aim to report the clinical and radiological outcome of consecutive primary hip arthroplasties using the JRI-Furlong HAC coated femoral and acetabular components.

Methods

We reviewed 586 consecutive cementless primary THA in 542 patients, with a minimum 12-year follow-up to 18 years, performed at one institution between 1986 and 1994. Twenty eight (32 THA) were lost to follow-up. Clinical outcome was measured using Harris, Charnley and Oxford scores. Quality of life using EuroQol EQ-5D. Radiographs were systematically analysed.


D Griffin S Karthikeyan

Background

Cam-type femoro-acetabular impingement (FAI) is increasingly recognised as a cause of mechanical hip symptoms in young adults. It is likely that it is a cause of early hip degeneration. Ganz et al have developed a therapeutic procedure involving trochanteric flip osteotomy and dislocation of the hip, and have reported good results. We have developed an arthroscopic osteochondroplasty to reshape the proximal femur and relieve impingement.

Methods

Fifty patients who presented with mechanical hip symptoms and had demonstrable cam-type FAI on radially-reconstructed MR arthrography, were treated by arthroscopic osteochondroplasty. Ten patients had a post-operative CT; from these images flexion and internal rotation range was tested in a virtual reality (VR) model to determine adequacy of resection. All patients were followed up for a minimum of one year, and post-operative Non-Arthritic Hip Scores (NAHS, maximum possible score 100) compared with pre-operative NAHS.


A Kadakia VG Langkamer

The treatment of undisplaced femoral neck fracture in the elderly population is still controversial. We analysed the outcome of cancellous screw fixation for undisplaced femoral neck fracture in patients over 70 years.

Materials and methods

From 1998 to 2003, ninety-seven patients with undisplaced femoral neck fracture, aged over 70 and treated with cancellous screw fixation were retrospectively identified. Full clinical data was available for 79 of the 97 patients identified. All patients had in situ fracture fixation.

Results

Of the 79 patients, M:F was 22:57, average age was 81.3 years. The average inpatient stay was 13.2 days. The mean follow-up was 12 months. 24 patients had Garden type I and 55 type II fractures. 26 (32.9%) patients did not return to their pre-morbid mobility status, 5 (6.3%) did not return to their preadmission dwelling (2 went to residential homes and 3 to nursing homes). We had documented radiographic details in 46 patients: 41 patients had a healed fracture on radiographs (89.1%), 5 patients had AVN, 4 patients had non-union and 1 patient had AVN with non-union. The radiographic failure rate was 22%. 15 patients had evidence of screw back out with healed fracture.

12 of the 46 complained of pain post-operatively of which 9 (19.6%) patients had re-operation; 6 (13%) underwent revision surgery and 3 (6.5%) required screw removal. 30-day mortality was 3.7%. 1-year mortality was 23.2% of which 16 died within the first 6 months (19.5%).


Full Access
C Kerin C Barton P Shaylor

Introduction

Trochanteric bursitis is described as pain over the lateral side of the hip and thigh. The usual treatment is rest, administration of NSAIDs and injection of local anaesthetic and corticosteroid. Occasionally it is resistant to these measures.

Background

Whilst performing an ablation of the trochanteric bursa we noticed that the fascia lata looked particularly tight. Therefore a z-plasty of the fascia lata was performed.


E Rizal D Mok

Aim

Review causes of anchor fixation failures in patients who underwent arthroscopic rotator cuff repair.

Methods

Between 2003 and 2006, 650 arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs were performed by the senior author. Of these, anchor fixation failure occurred in fifteen patients. A retrospective review was undertaken to find out the reasons for their failure.


S Sharma O Levy

Objective

Arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs now yield a similar footprint as open procedures with several advantages, including reduced tissue trauma, post-operative pain, swelling, and concern about the deltoid attachment. We present a new simple and reproducible technique for arthroscopic rotator cuff repair.

Methods

Sutures are placed through the full thickness of the rotator cuff. The suture is tied in the following manner:

Traction is released, the assistant maintaining the arm in abduction and applying tension on the anterior cuff sutures while the posterior cuff sutures are tied. The procedure is repeated for the anterior cuff suture; and

One suture strand from the anterior cuff and one suture strand from the posterior cuff are tied. The procedure is then repeated using the second strand from the anterior cuff and second suture strand from the posterior cuff. This suture and knot tying technique snugs the cuff down to the prepared tuberosity and restores the articular footprint of the cuff. This study retrospectively evaluated the clinical outcome of 170 patients who underwent arthroscopic cuff repair using this technique.


AK Bhadra R Abraham A Malkani

Aim

To assess clinical outcome of massive rotator cuff tear repair using triceps myotendinous flap.

Method

This is a prospective cohort of 43 patients (24 male, 19 female) with average age of 62 years. The primary indication of surgery was pain. Patients with massive rotator cuff tear involving supraspinatus and infraspinatus, showing retraction and fatty infiltration in MRI were selected. Few (8/43) were with failed surgical treatment and rest had conservative treatment failed. They underwent rotator cuff repair during Feb 1999 to Jan 2004.

The long head of the triceps was detached from the olecranon, rotated 180 degrees from its pivot point with its major vascular pedicle under the deltoid and acromion through the posterior capsule and attached to the greater tuberosity and any remnant of remaining cuff.

All patients were assessed pre-operatively, at 3, 6 and 12 months post-operatively clinically and also using UCLA pain and functional score for shoulder. Shoulder range of motion was assessed before and after the surgery. 24 patients had minimum of 1 year and 19 had 2 year minimum follow-up.


V Goel H Dabke S Gajjar A Jones R Kulkarni

Aims

To assess the accuracy of posterior and anterolateral methods of injection into the subacromial space (SAS) of the shoulder.

Patients and methods

Ethical approval was obtained and 50 patients (23 women and 27 men) with mean age of 64.5 years (42-87 years) and clinical diagnosis of subacromial impingement were recruited. Patients with old or recent shoulder fracture, bleeding disorders, and allergy to iodine were excluded. All injections were given by the consultant or an experienced registrar after obtaining informed consent. Patients were randomised into posterior and anterolateral groups and the method of injection was revealed by opening sealed envelopes just before the injection. A combination of 3mls 0.5% bupivacaine and 2mls of radiographic dye (Niopam) was injected in the subacromial space (SAS) using either anterolateral (n-22) and posterior approaches (28).

AP and lateral radiographs of shoulder were taken after injection and were reported by a Consultant Radiologist blinded to the method of injection. Visual analogue scale (VAS) and Constant-Murley shoulder score was used to assess pain and function respectively. Both scores were determined before and 30 minutes after the injection.


ZCJ Higgs B Danks M Sibinski LA Rymaszewski

Aim

Over the last 15 years there has been a series of publications reporting the beneficial effects of elbow arthrolysis, with considerable variation in operative technique and post-operative management. Many advocate the use of passive stretching techniques in the early post-operative period if range of motion fails to improve satisfactorily. The purpose of this study was to assess our results of open elbow arthrolysis in patients who did not receive any passive stretching after discharge from hospital.

Methods

Prospectively collected data of 55 patients with a minimum follow-up of 1 year after arthrolysis were analysed. All procedures were performed by the same surgeon (LR), achieving as much improvement in elbow motion as possible at operation. All patients had continuous brachial plexus blocks and continual passive motion for 2-3 days post-operatively but none received any passive stretching after discharge. At review, a senior physiotherapist (BD) formally assessed all the patients.


H Gakhar K Prasad SS Gill MS Dhillon SS Gill MS Dhillon H Sharma

Management of open tibial fractures remains controversial. We hypothesised that unreamed intramedullary nail offers inherent advantages of nail as well as external fixation. We undertook a prospective randomised study to compare the results of management of open tibial fractures with either an external fixator or an undreamed intramedullary nail until fracture union or failure.

Our study included 30 consecutive open tibial fractures (Gustilo I, II & IIIA) between 4 cm distal to knee and 4 cm proximal to ankle in skeletally mature adults, who presented to a level-1 trauma centre. Alternate patients were treated by either external fixation and unreamed nailing i.e. 15 in each group. Standard protocol for debridement and fixation was followed in all cases. All external fixators were removed at 6 weeks. All cases were followed up until fracture union, the main outcome measurement. 26 (87%) were males and 4 (13%) females; age range was 20-60 years (average 33.8).

All fractures in both groups united. Time to union averaged 7.9 months for both groups. Incidence of wound problems, infection, hardware failure and delayed union were comparable. However, there was higher incidence of angular deformities and stiffness of knee and ankle in external fixation group, although not statistically significant.

We found no statistically significant difference between unreamed intramedullary nailing and external fixation for the management of open tibial diaphyseal fractures, although ease of weight bearing as well as absence of angular deformities and joint stiffness were distinct advantages in the nail group. Therefore we recommend unreamed nail for Gustilo I, II and IIIA open tibial fractures.


J Webb I McMurtry A Port R Liow

Unstable fractures of the distal tibia are being increasingly treated by open reduction and internal fixation using pre-contoured locking plates. Functional outcome following this type of fixation has not been reported previously.

The aim of this study was to functionally assess patients following MIPO fixation of distal tibial fractures.

Case notes of 26 patients treated at a single centre were reviewed. The fracture type, fixation technique, complications, time to union and subsequent treatment were documented. All patients returned for functional scoring using the validated American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons (AAOS) foot and ankle core score.

Twenty-six consecutive patients were treated between 2002-2005. The majority were male, and 5 were open fractures. There were 13 AO type A, 4 type B and 9 type C fractures. Mean follow up was 20 months. Average time from injury to surgery was 2.5 days. All fractures were treated by a MIPO technique. A pre-contoured distal locking plate was used for the distal tibial reconstruction. Secondary surgical procedures e.g. 2nd look, delayed primary closure, or skin grafting were necessary in 3 cases. The fibula was plated in 60% of cases. Four patients developed wound infections requiring antibiotics, and all resolved. The commonest rehabilitation regime was 6 weeks non weight bearing in plaster. Mean time to union was 18 weeks. There were 3 cases of delayed union, requiring bone grafting. One patient required removal of the plate due to local irritation, and one required a broken screw to be removed. Mean range of movement was 10 degrees dorsiflexion, 30 plantarflexion. The mean normalised AAOS foot and ankle core score was 41 (SD +/− 8).

We conclude that MIPO fixation of distal tibial fractures is a safe and effective method of treatment. Functional outcome does not significantly differ from that of the general population.


S Dhage C Burke K Willett

Introduction

Around the knee high-energy fractures/dislocation may present with vascular injuries. Ischaemia time i.e. the time interval from injury to reperfusion surgery is the only variable that the surgeon can influence. It has been traditionally taught that 6-8 hours is revascularisation acceptable. There are only limited case series that have documented the time-dependent lower limb salvage rate (LSR) or the lower limb amputation rate (LAR). We have conducted a meta-analysis to look at LSR and LAR to inform clinical standard setting and for medicolegal purposes.

Methods

Two authors conducted an independent literature search using PubMed, Ovid, and Embase. In addition the past 5 years issues of Journal of Trauma, Injury and Journal of Vascular surgery were manually scrutinised. Papers included those in the English language that discussed limb injuries around the knee, and time to limb salvage or amputation surgery. The Oxman and Guyatt index was used to score each paper.


AM Alva NK Kanakaris B Chalidis PV Giannoudis

Introduction

Grade IIIa/b open tibial fractures (OTF) result mostly following high energy trauma and may be accompanied by significant associated injuries. Aim of this study was to compare the characteristics and the outcome of OTF between patients of different injury severities.

Materials and methods

Retrospective analysis of the records of patients admitted to a level I centre in a 4 year period with an OTF. Epidemiologic data, AO-ASIF classification, method of treatment, complication rates and time to fracture-union have been statistically analysed. An AIS98-ISS threshold (ISS 16) was used to separate OTF in 2 groups (A<16, B>16).


I Gill V Kolimarala R Montgomery

Aim

To analyse the results of the use of Recombinant Bone Morphogenic Protein (BMP-7) for treatment of fracture nonunions at our institution.

Material and methods

From 2001 to 2006, 23 patients with fracture nonunion were treated with BMP-7 for bone healing. There were 14 male and 9 females. The mean age of patients was 45 years (Range 21-76 yrs). There were 11 femoral, 9 tibial and 3 humerus fractures. There were 4 open injuries. The average number of operations before BMP-7 insertion was 2.66 (Range 0-6). The mean time between the injury and BMP insertion was 54 months (Range 5-312). 9 patients had previous autologous bone graft inserted without union.


Z Dahabreh P Giannoudis

Aim of the study

To estimate and compare the cost implications of the first attempt of treatment of tibial fracture non-unions treated with either autologous bone grafting or BMP-7.

Materials and methods

Patients who were successfully treated for fracture non-unions between 2001 and 2005 were included. Exclusion criteria included infected non-union, children, malignancy, or chronic debilitating disease. The decision to use BMP-7 or autogenous bone graft was guided by the defect size and the surgeon's preferred method of treatment. Group 1 (n = 12) received iliac crest bone grafting (ICBG) and group 2 (n=15) received recombinant human Bone Morphogenetic Protein-7 (BMP-7).

The total costs incurred during treatment including hospital stay, implants, theatre costs, drains, antibiotics, investigations and outpatient appointments were documented and analysed.


A Sahu N Harshavardena S Maret A Dhir H Taylor

Introduction

The aim of the study was to analyze the outcome of AO cannulated screws for fractures neck of femur at our institute.

Methods

412 patients (101 males/311 females) who underwent AO screws for fracture neck of femur over 5 years (2000 -2004) and followed-up for a minimum of 2 yrs formed the study population. A retrospective review of data from electronic patient record (EPR), clinical coding, clinic and GP letters was made. Age, residential placement, Garden's classification, mode of injury, associated comorbidities, pre-admission mobilisation status, allergies, addictions and anticoagulation status details were collected. Reasons for re-admissions, re-operations and comorbidities developing as a result of these interventions were critically analysed. Post-op physiotherapy, proportion of patients sustaining contra-lateral fracture NOF and its management and mortality statistics were reviewed.


C Edwards C Boulton A Counsell C Moran

The aim of this study was to investigate the risk factors, financial costs and outcomes associated with infection after hip fracture surgery.

Prospective hip fracture data from the University Hospital, Nottingham, was analysed, assessing patients with either deep or superficial wound infections admitted over a five year period.

3605 patients underwent hip fracture surgery. 2.3% of these patients developed a wound infection of which 1.2% were deep wound infections. 75% of infections were due to Staphylococcus aureus and 50% of all infections were caused by methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus.

No statistically significant risk factors for the development of infection were identified in this study.

Length of stay, cost of treatment and pre-discharge mortality were all increased with deep infection. Deep wound infection increased the average length of stay from 28 days to 100 days. This quadrupled the ward costs. The mean overall hospital cost of treating a hip fracture complicated by deep wound infection was £34903 compared to £8979 fro those who did not develop infection. Pre-discharge mortality increased from 24.2% in the control group to 30% in the infected group (p<0.006).

MRSA significantly increased costs, LOS, and pre-discharge mortality compared with non-MRSA infection.

These results show the huge impact that infection after hip fracture surgery has both on mortality and hospital costs.


J Chantrey S Blanckley C Boulton C Moran

The aim of the study was to assess the mortality associated with a hip fracture at 5 years in a geriatric population, and to evaluate the influence of age, cognitive state, mobility and residential status on long term survival after hip fracture.

This study forms part of a prospective audit of all patients with a hip fracture admitted to Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham. Every patient has a detailed admission questionnaire completed including details of the injury, medical history, residence and mobility. All data is collected by independent audit personnel using a detailed proforma. Integration with the database of the Office for National Statistics ensured accurate mortality data for every patient in the study for at least 5 years. All patients admitted in a 2 year period were included and divided into two groups: group B (<80 yrs age, Abbreviated Mental Test score 7/10, admitted from own home, independently mobile) and group A (any patient who did not fulfil all of group B criteria). A multivariate analysis indicated these as important variables that predicted mortality. Exclusion criteria: pathological hip fracture or bilateral hip fractures.

1319 patients fitted the inclusion criteria. 1068 patients fulfilled criteria for group A, 251 patients for group B. Overall mortality was 71% at 5 years. The excess mortality for the first year was 43%. 151 patients (60%) of group B were still alive at 5 years in comparison with only 231 (22%) of group A. Increased survival was shown for each variable: independent mobility RR 2.34 (p<0.05), admitted from home RR 3.81 (p<0.05), age<80 years RR 3.95 (p<0.05) and AMT 7/10 RR 5.45 (p<0.05).

These results facilitate early recognition of those patients with an increased chance of long-term survival that may be suitable for surgical treatment, such as total hip replacement, which have a good long-term outcome.


M Kassim A Rafee Y Rjakulendra S Nathan

Aim

To investigate any intra-operative alteration in management in those patients who had a pre-operative echocardiogram, a retrospective study for one year (March 2004 to February 2005) was carried out at West Middlesex University Hospital.

Results

Total number of 176 hip fractures, echocardiogram was done pre-operatively in 22 patients (12.5%). The request for echo was given by the anaesthetic team in 18/22 patients, the commonest reason for request being a cardiac murmur detected clinically in 20/22 patients.

There was a delay in surgery more than 24 hours in 17/22 patients who had an echocardiogram (77%) compared to a 38% delay in patients who did not.

The echocardiogram findings showed significant aortic stenosis in 4/22 (18%). There was no cancellation of surgery due to echocardiogram findings Five had general anaesthetic.

There was alteration in intra-operative management in two out of the 22 patients (8%) Invasive arterial monitoring was used in those two patients. None had intra-operative complications or ITU/HDU care post-operatively. Post-operatively 6/22 developed complications. 15/22 patients had a delay in discharge (68%) of more than 21 days compared to the 41% delay in patients who did not have an echocardiogram. We had a mortality rate of 22.7% (5/22) in these patients at 1 month compared to a mortality rate of 12% in patients without echocardiogram.


U Rethnam R Yesupalan B Ramesh T Muthukumar S Bastawrous

Background

One of the basic principles in the primary survey of a trauma patient is immobilisation of the cervical spine till cleared of any injury. Lateral cervical spine radiograph is the gold standard initial radiographic assessment. More than often additional radiographs like the Swimmer's view are necessary for adequate visualisation of the cervical spine. How good is the Swimmer's view in visualisation of the cervical spine after an inadequate lateral cervical spine radiograph?

Materials & methods

100 Swimmer's view radiographs randomly selected over a 2 year period in trauma patients were included for the study. All the patients had inadequate lateral cervical spine radiographs. The radiographs were assessed with regards to their adequacy by a single observer. The criteria for adequacy were adequate visualisation of the C7 body, C7/T1 junction and the soft tissue shadow.


U Rethnam R Yesupalan G Gandham

Background

A cautious outlook towards neck injuries is the norm to avoid missing cervical spine injuries. Consequently there has been an increased use of cervical spine radiography. The Canadian Cervical Spine rule was proposed to reduce the unnecessary use of cervical spine radiography in alert and stable patients. Our aim was to see whether applying the Canadian Cervical Spine rule reduced the need for cervical spine radiography without missing significant cervical spine injuries.

Methods

This was a retrospective study conducted in 2 hospitals. 114 alert and stable patients who had cervical spine radiographs done for suspected neck injuries were included in the study. Data on patient demographics, Canadian Cervical Spine rule, cervical spine radiography results and further visits after discharge were recorded.


Full Access
A Manoj-Thomas P Rao S Kutty R Evans

Osteotomy through the bare area of olecranon minimises the damage to articular cartilage in the trans-olecranon approach to the distal humerus. In this study we have identified a reliable and easily reproducible anatomical land mark to make sure that the osteotomy passes through the bare area.

Two methods were used to determine the line for the osteotomy, in the first a line from the lateral epicondyle perpendicular to the olecranon and in the second an intra-articular marker was used to determine the osteotomy. In 5 cadavers the osteotomy with lateral epicondylar line as a marker went 2 mm proximal to the bare area. Of the 5 cadavers dissected with a marker passed to the angle of olecranon the osteotomy went through the bare area of olecranon in three specimens and just proximal in the other two.

In conclusion a cheveron osteotomy with the base of the chevron on the lateral epicondylar line will be the ideal site to make sure that the osteotomy passes through the bare area of the olecranon.


Z Sivardeen A Ali S Thiagarajah H Kato D Stanley

Total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) has been shown to be a treatment option for elderly patients with complex distal humeral fractures and osteoporotic bone. The published results have often included rheumatoid patients who traditionally would be expected to do well from elbow arthroplasty. Only short-term results have been published using this technique in non-rheumatoid patients.

The current study contains the largest number and longest follow-up of non-rheumatoid patients whose fractures have been treated with a non-custom TEA. In total there were 26 patients, mean age 72 years, 22 female and 4 male, 25% dominant arm. The mean follow-up was of 5 years. There was 1 case of loosening, 1 radial nerve palsy and 2 cases of heterotrophic ossification. At final review the mean range of flexion/extension was 97.5 degrees and the mean range of pronation/supination was 151.75 degrees. The mean Mayo Elbow Performance score was 92.

We would suggest that TEA provides a very satisfactory outcome in elderly patients with complex distal humeral fractures, the benefit of which can be observed at a mean of 5 years.


I McFadyen C Curwen J Field

The aim of this study is to compare functional, clinical and radiological outcomes in K-wire fixation versus volar fixed-angle plate fixation in unstable, dorsally angulated distal radius fractures.

Fifty-four adult patients with an isolated closed, unilateral, unstable, distal radius fracture were recruited to participate in the study. Only dorsally displaced fractures with no articular comminution were included. Patients were randomised to have their fracture treated with either closed reduction and K-wire fixation (3 wires) or fixed-angle volar plating. Both groups were immobilised in a below elbow cast for six weeks. The wires removed in the outpatients at six weeks and both groups were referred for physiotherapy. Independent clinical review was performed at three and six months post injury. Functional scoring was performed using the DASH and Gartland and Werley scoring systems. Radiographs were evaluated by an independent orthopaedic surgeon.

Twenty-five patients were treated with a plate and twenty-nine with wires. There were no complications in the plate group. There were 9 complications in the K-wire group with 3 patients requiring a second operation (1 corrective osteotomy for malunion, 1 median nerve decompression and 1 retrieval of a migrated wire). The remaining complications included: 5 pin site infections (3 treated with early pin removal and 2 with oral antibiotics only), and 1 superficial radial nerve palsy. There were no tendon ruptures.

Both groups scored satisfactory functional results with no statistical difference. There was a statistically significant difference in the radiological outcomes with the plate group achieving better results.

We conclude that in unstable dorsally angulated distal radius fractures volar fixed-angle plate fixation is able to achieve comparable functional results to K-wire fixation with better radiological results and fewer complications. This has resulted in a change in our clinical practice.


F Ali A Kocialkowski M Rana A Malik

Aim

To demonstrate the effect of location of the split of the plaster on the raised intercompartmental pressure in the volar and dorsal compartments.

Methods

Artificial forearm skeleton was used along with two half litre saline bags on ether side representing volar and dorsal forearm compartment. A single layer of cotton wool with half width overlap was applied followed by three rolls of 10cm x 2.5 m plaster of paris. This was then left to dry for four hours. Both the saline bags had an eighteen gauge catheter inserted that was connected to the central venous pressure monitoring line on the anaesthetic machine. Baseline pressure in mmHg was recorded. Normal saline was then injected in both the bags so as to raise the pressure to 50 mmHg in each compartment. POP cast was then split, spread and then the wool was cut down to the saline bags while continually monitoring the pressures. The respective change in the pressure at the end of each step was recorded. Six simulated forearm models had dorsal splits and an equal number had volar splits. The effect of the site and various steps of splitting on the drop in respective compartment pressures was compared.


A Guha S Das U Debnath R Shah K Lewis

Introduction

Displaced distal radius fractures in children have been treated in above elbow plaster casts since the last century. Cast index has been calculated previously, which is a measure of the sagittal cast width divided by the coronal cast width measurement at the fracture site. This indicates how well the cast was moulded to the contours of the forearm. We retrospectively analysed the cast index in post manipulation radiographs to evaluate its relevance in redisplacement or reangulation of distal forearm fractures.

Study Design

Consecutive radiographic analysis.


P Ellanti M Ashraf R Thakaral T McCarthy K O'Sulllivan JP McElwain

Introduction

It is recommended that the ankle be held in dorsiflexion at the time of placement of syndesmosis screw. We assessed the validity of this recommendation.

Materials and methods

A two-part roentgenographic and computerised analysis of distal tibiofibular syndesmosis. The first part involved recruitment of 30 healthy adult volunteers. The second part involved 15 ankle fractures with syndesmotic injury requiring syndesmosis screw placement. In the first part individuals maximally dorsiflexed and plantarflexed their ankles in a specialised jig for standardisation. Mortice views were taken and intermalleolar distance measured. In the second part mortice views were taken in plantarflexion and dorsiflexion before and after the placement of syndesmosis screw in theatre. The intermalleolar distance was then measured.


S Patil J Gandhi I Curzon A Hui

Stable ankle fractures can be successfully treated non-operatively with a below knee plaster cast. In some European centres it is standard practice to administer thromboprophylaxis, in the form of low molecular weight heparin, to these patients in order to reduce the risk of deep venous thrombosis (DVT).

The aim of our study was to assess the incidence of DVT in such patients in the absence of any thromboprophylaxis. We designed a prospective study, which was approved by the local ethics committee. We included 100 consecutive patients with ankle fractures treated in a below knee plaster cast. At the time of plaster removal (6 weeks), patients were examined for signs of DVT. A colour doppler duplex ultrasound scan was then performed by one of the two experienced musculoskeletal ultrasound technicians.

We found that 5 patients developed a DVT. Two of these were above knee, involving the superficial femoral vein and popliteal vein respectively. The other three were below knee. None of the patients had any clinical symptoms or signs of DVT. None of the patients developed pulmonary embolism. Of these five patients, four had some predisposing factors for DVT.

The annual incidence of DVT in the normal population is about 0.1%. This can increase to about 4.5% by the age of 75. DVT following hip and knee replacement can occur in 40-80% of cases. Routine thromboprophylaxis may be justified in these patients. However, with a low incidence of 5% following ankle fractures treated in a cast, we believe that routine thromboprophylaxis is not justified.


CA White S Bil M Lacy M Costa

Fractures of the Proximal Femur are a common and disabling injury requiring hospital admission and surgical treatment leading to approximately 86,000 inpatient episodes annually in the UK, with such patients occupying more than 20% of NHS orthopaedic beds. Based on current trends the number of hip fractures may rise to 120,000 per annum by 2015.

As the age of the population increases, so does the prevalence of concomitant medical conditions. Atrial Fibrillation is rising in the general population. Recently, the benefit of treating these patients with warfarin to prevent stroke has been shown; as a consequence, the number of patients being treated with warfarin is on the increase.

We have performed a retrospective study of all patients admitted to our unit with Fractures of the neck of the femur between 2001 and 2006, from the Accident and Emergency department with a primary diagnosis of Proximal Femoral Fracture (1987 patients). 138 patients were on long term warfarin at the time of their admission (6.9% of admissions). 90.4% were being warfarinised for AF, 7.6% for DVT and the rest for other indications. Of these Patients only 12 (8.7%) received active reversal to their warfarin. (All received vitamin K either orally or Intravenously). The average delay to theatre attributable to warfarin therapy was 41.1 hours (p-0.001). Active reversal allowed this delay to be negated (p-0.01), and did not delay the reloading of warfarin post-operatively (p-0.012). It also allowed an average of 10.2 days earlier discharge from the orthopaedic unit (p-0.001).

This study shows that significant delays occur because of Warfarinisation of these patients and that active reversal seems to be beneficial in expediting surgical treatment and discharge from the orthopaedic unit.


P Baker M Khaw L Kirk P Gregg

Introduction

We have carried out a 15 year survival analysis of a prospective, randomised trial comparing cemented with cementless fixation of press-fit condylar primary total knee replacements.

Methods

A consecutive series of 501 PFC knee replacements received either cemented (219 patients, 277 implants) or cementless (177 patients, 224 implants) fixation. No patients were lost to follow up. Revision was defined as further surgery, irrespective of indication, that involved replacement of any of the three originally inserted components (Femur, Tibia, Patella).


P Baker J van der Meulen J Lewsey P Gregg

Purpose

To examine how patients viewed the outcome of their joint replacement at least one year post surgery. Emphasis was placed on investigating the relative influence of ongoing pain and functional limitation on patient satisfaction.

Method

Questionnaire based assessment of the Oxford Knee Score (OKS), patient satisfaction, and need for reoperation in a group of 10,000 patients who had undergone primary unilateral knee replacement between April and December 2003. Questionnaires were linked to the NJR database to provide data on background demographics, clinical parameters and intraoperative surgical information for each patient.

Data was analysed to investigate the relationship between the OKS, satisfaction rate and the background factors. Multivariable logistic regression was performed to establish which factors influenced patient satisfaction.


R Pydisetty JH Newman

Between 1989 and 1992 102 knees adjudged suitable for Unicompartmental replacement (UKR) were randomised to receive either a St Georg Sled UKR or a Kinematic modular total knee replacement (TKR). The early results demonstrated that the UKR group had less complications, and more rapid rehabilitation. At 5 years there were equal failures but the UKR group had more excellent results and a greater range of movement.

Despite this doubt persisted about whether these advantages would be maintained these cases have been followed regularly by a research nurse at 8, 10, 12 years. We now report the final outcome at 15 years. 43 patients (45 knees) have died with all their knees intact. Throughout the review period the Bristol Knee Scores (BKS) of the UKR group have been better and at 15 years 77% and 53% of the surviving UKRs and TKRs achieve an excellent score. 6 TKRs and 4 UKRs have failed during the 15 years of the review.

Conclusion

The better early results with UKR are maintained at 15 years with no greater failure rate. The median BKS scores of the UKR group was 91.1 at five years and 92 at 15 years suggesting little functional deterioration in either the prosthesis or remainder of the joint. These results would seem to justify the increased use of UKR.


LC Biant WJM Bruce PM Walker S Herrmann WR Walsh

‘High flexion’ polyethylene tibial tray inserts are available from total knee replacement (TKR) manufacturers. There is currently no published data available that examines how much extra knee flexion these new implants give or if there are any wear consequences for the change in design. The high flexion inserts are narrower posteriorly than standard inserts and have chamfers anteriorly and on the post in cruciate sacrificing designs.

This prospective randomised controlled trial of 100 patients undergoing posterior stabilised TKR compared knee flexion, measured intra-operatively by a computer navigation system, of the standard and high flexion trial inserts in the same knee. Patients were then randomised to receive either a standard or ‘high flexion’ definitive component and the stability assessed. The post-operative knee flexion of all patients was measured at six months.

High flexion inserts did not give significantly more knee flexion than standard inserts either per-operatively at the trial insert stage, or at six months post-op and resulted in marginally more anterior draw. The average per-operative difference in flexion between standard and high flex inserts measured in the same knee was 3.2° (range -4-18°) The average knee flexion at 6 months post op was 106° for both groups. The average change in knee flexion comparing pre and post op was 2.3° for the high flex group and 0.6° for the standard insert group.

Laboratory Tek scan contact pressure analysis at the surface of the standard and high flexion designs was not significantly different, but the thinner polyethylene of the high flexion design raises questions about wear characteristics. High flexion polyethylene inserts are probably not justified in terms of improved knee flexion, but may be a useful option in certain technical circumstances during TKR such as patella baja or if the patella impinges on the post in deep flexion.


PLR Wood

The Mobility (DePuy International) is a three-component, cobalt chrome, uncemented design.

Patients

Over an 18-month period 100 ankles, with end-stage arthritis and less than 20 degree valgus or varus deformity, were replaced. There were 95 patients (70 OA, 25 RA) with average age of 65 years (41-95). Five had bilateral replacements. Follow-up was 30 months (24 to 48).

Results

Average score on VAS pain line improved from 8.8 to 1.8. The average AOFAS pain score improved from 3 to 33. Average AOFAS function score improved from 31 to 48. Four patients were disappointed because pain relief was poor. Four ankles have undergone further surgery. One ankle was converted to fusion for recurrent deformity. One ankle required repeated washout for infection at six months but remains clinically and radiologically satisfactory 2 years later. One ankle required exchange of UHMWP insert at 4 weeks because of a technical error. One ankle required fixation of an ununited intraoperative medial malleolar fracture and subsequently developed ‘edge loading’, namely radiographs showed that a gap had opened up between the articular surfaces on the lateral side of the joint. The radiographs of 3 other ankles also showed ‘edge loading’. Two of these patients were symptom free but one wore a brace to control symptoms of instability. Radiographs showed bony incorporation in all surviving ankles. This was always complete around the tibial stem and under the talar component. However in 15 ankles there was a small non-progressive area of lucency adjacent to the tibial plate.


P Culpan V Le Strat T Judet

We present a series of 16 patients who have had a failed ankle arthroplasty converted to an ankle arthrodesis using a surgical technique of bone grafting with internal fixation. We describe our technique using tricortical autograft from the iliac crest to preserve length and an emphasis is placed on maintaining the malleoli and subtalar joint.

A successful fusion was achieved in all cases with few complications. Our post operative AOFAS improved to a mean of 70 with good patient satisfaction and compares well to other published series. From this series and an extensive review of the literature we have found fusion rates following failed arthroplasty in patients with degenerative arthritis to be very high. In this group of patients a high fusion rate and good clinical result can be achieved when the principles of this surgical technique are adhered to.

It would appear that a distinction should be made between treating patients with poor quality bone and more extensive bone loss, as is often the case with rheumatoid patients; and the patients with a non inflammatory arthropathy and better bone quality. The intramedullary nail would appear to be the preferred option in patients with inflammatory polyarthropathy where preservation of the subtalar joint is probably not of relevance as it is usually extensively involved in the disease process, and a higher rate of complications can be anticipated with internal fixation.


A Sahu M Singh R Bharadwaj N Harshavardana R Hartley

Introduction

The aim of this study was to compare the results and length of stay of patients of early (within 12 hours) versus conventional (after 48 hours) ankle fixation our hospital.

Methods of study

It was a retrospective study over 18 month period (July 2004 - Dec 2005) including 200 Patients (aged 16 or more). We looked into age, place of living, Weber classification, mechanism of injury, comorbidities especially diabetes, addictions mainly smoking, etc. Overlying skin condition, the amount of swelling at presentation, associated ankle dislocation or talar shift, acute medical comorbidities, injury types-open or closed were classified accordingly.


P Darcy S Albert S Srinivasan K Le Doare G Hill P Ramesh

Scarf osteotomy for correction of painful hallux valgus is an effective technique, giving a predictable correction of the deformity. However, some patients remain less than fully satisfied, despite normalisation of the usual radiographic parameters. This study examines whether lateral soft tissue release can cause late splaying of the forefoot.

A series of 32 feet in 29 consecutive patients in a single centre, operated on by a single surgeon, over a 12 month period were studied. After pre-operative weight-bearing x-rays and consenting, a standardised ‘Barouk-technique’ Scarf procedure was undertaken with on-table assessment for lateral soft tissue release and phalangeal varisation. Post-operatively, patients were kept heel weight-bearing without cast for 6 weeks, with use of a fabric splint after removal of bandages at 2 weeks.

HVA and IMA were measured pre-operatively, at 6 weeks, and at 6-12 month follow-up. Distance from the mid-points of the 1st to the 5th metatarsal heads and distance from lateral sesamoid to 2nd metatarsal shaft were also recorded by blinded observers. AOFAS Foot Scores were collected prospectively. Student's t-test for single-tailed paired data was applied and p-values calculated. There were 22 female and 10 male feet; in patients aged 27 to 74 (mean 58).

Average HVA improved from 34° to 17° and was maintained at 16°. IMA improved from 14° to 7°, but then increased significantly to 10°. Overall inter-metatarsal width reduced from 76mm to 65mm but then significantly increased to 71mm. Sesamoid distance was also reduced and later increased, but not significantly. Mean foot scores improved from 52 to 85 at late follow-up. Complication rate was low.

Late widening occurred more in those feet with bigger original HVA, which were likely to have had more extensive soft tissue release (deep inter-metatarsal ligament). We recommend cautious release; and pre-operatively counselling specifically regarding eventual overall foot-width.


SK Bajaj V Tadevosyan V Satish

Aim

To investigate the effect of Tranexamic acid on blood loss associated with Total Knee Replacement Surgery.

Methods

A prospective double blind randomised controlled trial was conducted on 48 patients undergoing unilateral primary cemented total knee replacement. The mean age of the patients was 68 years. Recruitment was based on specific inclusion and exclusion criteria. Patients were randomised to receive either 10 mg/kg of tranexamic acid or a similar volume of normal saline at the time of cementing the prosthesis before deflation of the tourniquet. Both the patient and the surgeon were blinded to the type of injection. The post-operative blood loss was calculated in each case.


P Moonot G Railton S Mu RE Field SA Banks

The performance of total knee arthroplasty in deeply flexed postures is of increasing concern as the procedure is performed on younger, more physically active and more culturally diverse populations. Several implant design factors, including tibiofemoral conformity, tibial slope and posterior condylar geometry have been shown directly to affect deep flexion performance.

The goal of this study was to evaluate the performance of a fixed-bearing, asymmetric, medial rotation arthroplasty design during kneeling activities.

Thirteen study participants (15 knees) with primary total knee arthroplasty (Medial Rotation Knee, Finsbury, Surrey, UK) were observed while doing a step activity and kneeling on a padded bench from 90° to maximum comfortable flexion using lateral fluoroscopy. Subjects averaged 74 years of age and nine were female. Subjects were an average of 17 months post-operative, and scored 94 points on the International Knee Score and 99 on the Functional Score. Digitised fluoroscopic images were corrected for geometric distortion and 3D models of the implant components were registered to determine the 3D position and orientation of the implants in each image.

During the step activity, the medial and the lateral femoral contact point stayed fairly constant with no axial rotation from 0 to 100° of flexion. At maximum kneeling flexion, the knees exhibited 119° of implant flexion (101°-139°), 7° (-7° to 17°) tibial internal rotation, and the lateral condyle translated backwards by 11 mm.

Patients with medial rotation knee arthroplasty exhibited medial pivot action with no paradoxical translation. The knees exhibited excellent kneeling flexion and posterior translation of the femur with respect to the tibia. The axial rotation in MRK was within the range of normal knee kinematics from -10 to 120 (perhaps 140).


J Murray M Sherlock N Hogan S Palmer C Servant M Cross

The anterior femoral cortical line (AFCL) is an anatomical landmark which has been used by the senior author for 20 years to assess femoral rotation in over 4000 TKR's. The AFCL describes the alignment of the anterior cortex of the distal femur proximal to the trochlear articular cartilage.

The AFCL was compared with the surgical epicondylar (SEA), anteroposterior (Whiteside's line) and posterior condylar (PC) axes using 50 dry-bone cadaveric femora, 16 wet cadaveric specimens, 50 axial MRI's and 58 TKR patients intra-operatively.

In the dry-bone/cadaveric femora (measuring relative to the SEA the AFCL and Whiteside's AP axis were 1° externally rotated and the PC axis was 1° internally rotated. By MRI (relative to the SEA) the AFCL was 8° internally rotated, Whiteside's was 2° externally rotated and the PC axis was 3° internally rotated. In the clinical study (measuring relative to a perpendicular to Whiteside's line alone) the AFCL was 4° degrees internally rotated, which equates to 2-3° of internal rotation relative to the SEA.

The AFCL is another axis, completing the ‘compass points’ around the knee. It may prove particularly useful when one or all of the other reference axes are disturbed such as in revision TKR, lateral condylar hypoplasia or where there has been previous epicondylar trauma. We suggest building in 5° external rotation with respect to the anterior femoral cortical line for femoral component rotation.


S Jain P Mohanlal B Dhinsa

To analyse the intra-operative variation in mechanical axes of the lower limb at various stages during navigated total knee replacement.

A prospective study was performed to analyse the intra-operative variation in the mechanical axes of the lower limb during navigated total knee replacement. All consecutive patients who underwent navigated total knee replacement were included and patients with inadequate data were excluded from the study. The intra-operative initial, trial and the final mechanical hip-knee-ankle axes were recorded from the navigation system. The differences between these axes were calculated and analysed. There were forty patients, of which 24 were females and 16 males with the age ranging from 37-89 (average 68.4) years. The right knee was replaced in 27 and the left knee in 13 patients. The average initial mechanical axes alignment was 0.03° valgus (3° varus to 3° valgus), trial alignment 0.64° varus (3° varus to 1.5° valgus) and final alignment 0.25° varus (4° varus to 4° valgus). Average deviation from initial to trial axes was 0.97°, trial to final axes was 0.74° and initial to final axes was 1.08°. The correlation co-efficient between the initial and the trial axes was 0.25, trial and final axes was 0.43 & initial and final axes was 0.09.

This study highlights a significant variation in mechanical axes between the different stages of navigated total knee replacement. The potential sources of intra-operative errors causing these changes could be soft tissue imbalance, variations in implant placement and possible tracker micro motion. Execution of bony cuts in near normal neutral alignment does not guarantee achievement of near normal final alignment. We advocate surgeons to be vigilant to avoid potential malalignment during navigated total knee replacement.


SA Hanna J Saksena S Legge HE Ware

In 2002 the UK government in its attempt to reduce long total joint arthroplasty waiting lists, arranged for local councils via NHS trusts to send patients abroad for their surgery. In theory it was a win-win situation where pressures upon surgeons were reduced, trusts could reach government targets and of course, patients got their operation with a bonus holiday! Unfortunately, it was not until patients had returned from their surgery that problems with this method of waiting list reduction were realised. The majority of patients were discharged after only one check up and often had very little in the way of post operative physiotherapy. A few presented to our clinic with more serious complaints with two cases eventually requiring revision surgery.

We undertook a case-control study looking at an age and sex matched group of patients who underwent total knee arthroplasty, Group A (Belgium) and Group B (Local Institution) during the same time period from November 2003 to November 2004. We compared their Oxford knee score (OKS), Knee society score (KSS) and SF12 physical and mental component scores.

Results

Follow up was a minimum of 28 months. No significant difference was noted with the OKS and KSS (Group A-average OKS 24.68, average KSS 72.72, Group B-average OKS 25.04, average KSS 79). However, SF12 figures revealed a statistically significant difference between the two groups in both the physical (PCS) and mental components (MCS) (Group A - mean PCS 40, mean MCS 48, Group B – mean PCS 47, mean MCS 57, P<0.05).

Conclusion

Our results show that although the majority of patients operated upon abroad had got comparable functional results as patients operated locally, they often felt dissatisfied with the overall experience of going abroad for their operation, especially in terms of post operative care received including physiotherapy and follow up.


K Hawkins B Gooding J Rowles

Purpose

A comparison of patient satisfaction of service provided by independent sector treatment centres versus an index NHS hospital in total knee replacement surgery.

Methods

Patients were all initially listed for total knee replacement (TKR) by a single consultant from the index NHS hospital, Derbyshire Royal Infirmary (DRI).

Patients were sent a postal questionnaire and asked to rate the TKR service provided by a given hospital, based on recent inpatient experience. Questions covered quality of care delivered by hospital staff and quality of ward environment. Overall satisfaction was rated. Patients electing surgery under Patient Choice at an independent sector treatment centre (ISTC) were asked about factors that influenced their hospital choice. 100 consecutive patients undergoing TKR at DRI and 100 patients choosing ISTC hospitals were identified. All surgery occurred between April 2003 and September 2006.


E Reay JJ Wu G Sarah D Deehan J Holland

During a retrospective case note analysis, a significant difference was found in prosthesis survival, between two cohorts of patients who underwent different total knee replacements. The first cohort included 70 patients who underwent Kinemax Plus total knee replacement, the second cohort included 58 patients who underwent PFC Total Knee replacement. All patients were under the care of one Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon. Interestingly, the Kinemax Plus cohort was found to have a higher rate of revision compared to the PFC cohort. A detailed comparison was carried out between the two groups to identify any obvious cause for the disparity.

The two cohorts were found to be well matched with respect to age, sex, ASA grade, underlying pathology and operative technique. Median follow up being 6 years and 5 years for the Kinemax Plus and PFC groups respectively.

There were 11 failed prostheses in the Kinemax Plus cohort, 7 undergoing revision with the remaining 4 patients offered revision but unwilling to have surgery. Wear of the polyethylene tibial insert was the most obvious finding at revision, present in six of the seven revisions. 97% of the Kinemax Plus Prostheses were intact at 5 years but by 8 years only 87% were intact. There were no revisions performed in the PFC cohort.

Post-operative x-ray analysis was undertaken to rule out prosthesis malalignment as a cause for the increased failure rate. The coronal alignment of the prostheses (CAK) was calculated and all post operative x-rays were within the normal limits of 4-10 degrees.

Analysis of the explanted Kinemax Plus polyethylene liners was undertaken. In six cases, the polyethylene bearing surfaces displayed severe surface and subsurface delamination. This suggests massive fatigue and fatigue wear. Only one implant showed localised delamination.

These findings suggest the hypothesis of weak polyethylene particle interface strength.


L David D Back S Hanna S Cannon T Briggs

Introduction

We discuss the use of the SMILES (Stanmore Modular Individualised Lower Extremity System) in salvage revision knee surgery and review the medium-long term results of 42 cases.

Methods

This is a prospective, single-centre study. The SMILES prosthesis is a custom-made implant incorporating a rotating hinge knee joint. 42 prostheses were used in 40 patients as salvage revision procedures between September 1991 and September 1999. Patients undergoing surgery for tumours were excluded. The minimum follow-up was seven years with a mean follow-up of ten years and six months. Patients were independently assessed using the Knee Society Rating Score. The age of the patients ranged from 36-85 years (mean 68 years and 6 months). 23 of the patients were male. The original pathology was osteoarthritis in 32 patients and rheumatoid arthritis in 8 patients. The number of previous arthroplasties ranged from 1-4. The main indications for a SMILES prosthesis were aseptic loosening, periprosthetic fracture and infection in the presence of bone loss and ligamentous laxity.


SK Godey JS Watson

TKA (Total Knee Arthroplasty) is a successful operation. Soft tissue problems with TKA are difficult to treat. Flap surgery is successful in treating this problem and salvaging the prostheses. We present results of flap surgery for complicated TKAs over a ten year period, performed by a single surgeon.

Between 1996 and 2005, 31 patients (32 knees) underwent flap surgeries for TKAs. Four of these procedures were done prophylactically in patients with previous knee surgeries. Gastrocnemius, medial fasciocutaneous and anterior compartment flaps were used either solely or in combination based on the size of the defect. The data was collected retrospectively from case-notes and correspondence from the treating orthopaedic surgeons. All the knees included in the study had a minimum follow up of 6 months.

The patients were aged between 50 and 94 years. Indication for primary TKA was osteoarthritis in 26 patients and rheumatoid arthritis in 5. The index orthopaedic surgery was a primary knee arthroplasty in 14 and revision in 13. The average duration between the TKA and flap surgery was 11 weeks (range 1 – 52). Gastrocnemius was the most commonly used local flap (17 cases). Anterior compartment flap was used in 5 cases and in the rest combination of flaps was used. Coagulase -ve Staph. aureus was the most commonly isolated organism from the perioperative wound swabs. Successful soft tissue cover was achieved in 29 of 32 knees (92%). Overall, TKA was salvaged in 23 of 32 knees (72%) and 3 knees (9.7%) underwent arthrodesis. Three (9.7%) patients had above knee amputation, two of these had post op MRSA infection. We could not use a functional knee scoring system due to inadequate information available.

We conclude local flap surgery is a viable and successful procedure for providing soft tissue cover for complicated TKAs with good results.


P Moonot Y Kamat YE Kalairajah M Bhattacharyya A Adhikari RE Field

The Oxford Knee Score (OKS) is a valid and reliable self-administered patient questionnaire that enables assessment of the outcome following total knee replacement (TKR). There is as yet no literature on the behavioral trends of the OKS over time. Our aim is to present a retrospective audit of the OKS for patients who have undergone TKR during the past ten years.

We retrospectively analysed 3276 OKS of patients who had a primary TKR and had been registered as part of a multi-surgeon, outcome-monitoring program at St. Helier hospital. The OKS was gathered pre-operatively and post-operatively by means of postal questionnaires at annual intervals. Patients were grouped as per their age at operation into four groups: 60, 61-70, 71- 80 and >80. A cross-sectional analysis of OKS at different time points was performed.

The numbers of OKS available for analysis were 504 pre-operatively, 589 at one-year, 512 at two-year and gradually decreasing numbers with 87 knees ten-year post-operatively. There was as expected a significant decrease (improvement) of the OKS between pre-operative and one-year post-operative period and then reached a plateau. Beyond eight years, there is a gradual rise in the score (deterioration). The younger patients (60) showed a significant increase in their average OKS between one and five-years post-operatively. However beyond five years, they followed the trend of their older counterparts. When the twelve questions in the OKS were analysed, certain components revealed greater improvement (e.g. description of knee pain and limping) than others (e.g. night pain).

The OKS is seen to plateau a year after TKR. According to the OKS the outcome of the TKR is not as good in the younger age group as compared to the older age group. Further investigation is required to ascertain the cause of this observed difference.


MR Utting JS Mulford JD Eldridge

Trochlear dysplasia is a developmental condition characterised by an abnormally flat or dome shaped trochlea and is an important contributing factor to patellofemoral instability and recurrent patellar dislocation. We prospectively studied a cohort of 54 consecutive patients (59 knees) with patellofemoral instability secondary to trochlear dysplasia, treated with a trochleoplasty by a single surgeon over a 5 year period.

Patients were recruited from the senior author's specialist knee clinic and pre-operatively, multiple patient-centred scores were recorded. After the trochleoplasty, these were repeated along with a patient satisfaction questionnaire. Of the 54 patients and 59 knees operated, 39 of the patients (44 knees) were female and 15 (15 knees) male and 40 patients (42 knees) had follow-up of 12 months or more. Their mean age at surgery was 21 years and 6 months and mean length of follow up 2 years. One patient was unable to attend for follow up due to the development of a pelvic Ewings sarcoma. A statistically significant improvement in outcomes was demonstrated when the pre and post-operative scores were compared (mean scores of Oxford 26 to 19, WOMAC 23 to 17, IKDC 54 to 72, Kujala 62 to 76, Lysholm 57 to 78, p values <0.001 for all scores). 93% (50 patients) were satisfied with the outcome of their procedure.

We conclude that in the short and medium term, the results of trochleoplasty are encouraging in this challenging group of patients.


D Loveday S Donell

Patella instability is a common problem with many surgical options. We prospectively evaluated the results of medial patella femoral ligament (MPFL) reconstruction with an autogenous gracilis or semitendinous graft. With a minimum follow up of one year patients were reviewed using the Kujala scoring system.

Twenty MPFL reconstructions were performed on seventeen patients over a two year period, from January 2004 to December 2005. There were 13 females and 4 males. Three patients had bilateral involvement. Thirteen patients had a lateral release with their MPFL reconstruction and three had a distal realignment procedure as well to correct their patella instability.

The mean follow up was 17 months (range 12 to 26 months). The average age was 25 years old at operation (range 13 to 47) and the average age of their first dislocation was 16 (range 0-35). Nine patients had previous surgical treatment for patella instability. The average hypermobility score in the patients was 5/9 and six patients scored 9/9.

At follow up 18 out of 20 patients (90%) had stable tracking with no further subluxations/dislocations. Of the two with unstable tracking, one had a stable patella before falling several times onto her knee. An MRI confirmed the ligament was intact but a type 2 trochlear dysplasia was present and a Bereiter trochleoplasty was subsequently performed. The other patient described no frank dislocation but instead subluxations.

Eighteen of the twenty reconstructions (90%) achieved a stable patella. Overall Kujala scores increased by a third.


CO Nnene V Spiteri CN Esler

Only 0.8% of arthroplasties registered on the National Joint Registry in 2006 are patello-femoral. The Leicester patello-femoral replacement (Corin) has been in use for over 10 years with satisfactory initial results. The indication for use is isolated patello-femoral osteoarthritis with the theoretical benefits of bone preservation, maintenance of normal knee mechanics and easy revision. The implant was only available in one size and the femoral component was uncemented.

We reviewed 49 patients managed with this prosthesis with a median follow up of 10 years (range 4-16). The mean age of the patients at time of surgery was 64. 62 arthroplasties were performed.51 were in females and 11 in males giving a 5:1 ratio. Thirteen patients had bilateral procedures. Thirty-nine revisions (62.9%) were performed for progressive tibio-femoral arthritis or prosthetic failure. Mean time to revision was 5 years 3 months. The knees were revised to total knee replacements without the need for stems, wedges or constraint. The unrevised knees had a mean survivorship of 8 years 6 months with a range of 4-14 years. The mean Oxford score for these surviving implants was 22.5.

Results of other implants from the literature included the Avon prosthesis with 80% satisfaction rate at 5 years and the Lubinus with 45% satisfaction rate at 7.5 years. The Leicester device showed a pattern of progressive failure with up to 40% revision at 5 years. However those with surviving implants were reasonably happy as shown by the Oxford scores.

We concluded that patello-femoral replacement has a role though this is not as well defined as TKR or even UKR. We posed the question as to whether these results were due to poor patient selection or design failings of the Leicester prosthesis. This prosthesis has been successful at reducing pain and improving function and may have been more successful with more sizes of implant, better instrumentation and more rigid patient selection.


KR Thirumalesh H Munyira R Fletcher M Parikh PR Allen

We report the early results of a patello-femoral prosthesis with a more anatomical trochlear component than previously reported designs, and with a patella component, geometry and instrumentation that allows optimum tracking and coverage of the patella, prior to final fixation of the patella component.

The first 115 patello-femoral prostheses were implanted between April 2000 and October 2005, and were followed up in a Special Clinic by one observer, who was not the operating surgeon, using the Bristol Knee Score (BKS), and the Oxford Knee Score (OKS). 115 patello-femoral arthroplasties were performed in 86 patients, 28 bilateral procedures (24.3%). 20 (71%) of which were performed as a single procedure. There were 100 females and 15 males, a ratio of 6.6:1, with a mean age of 70.05 years. (range 57 – 79). There were 9 patients lost to follow up, giving a follow up rate of 89%. The mean period follow up was 36 months (range 12 – 78 months). The median OKS (maximum 12/60) was 40/60 pre-operatively (range 22-46) and 22/60 Post-operatively (range 12 – 38), and the BKS was 45 pre-operatively (range 35 – 65) and 85 post-operatively (range 55 – 100). The mean range of movement was 110° pre-operatively (range 90 – 120°), and 125° (range 90 – 130°) post-operatively.

There was 1 superficial wound infection. 2 knees were revised to total knee replacement for progression of arthritis. Four other patients had re-operations, 1 for bilateral subluxing patellae, 2 for soft tissue problems, 1 patient had a locked knee with displacement of the patella prosthesis, which was revised successfully.

Early results of the FPV prosthesis demonstrate, like other more recent designs, that there are fewer problems with mal alignment and mal tracking than with earlier prosthesis, giving 90% good or excellent results.


PK Jaiswal D Park R Carrington J Skinner T Briggs A Flanagan G Bentley

Introduction

We report the initial 2 and 3 year follow-up results of this randomised controlled trial of autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) using porcine-derived collagen membrane as a cover (ACI-C) versus matrix-carried autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI) for the treatment of osteochondral defects of the knee.

Methods

217 patients were randomised to have either ACI (92 patients) or MACI (125 patients). The mean age in each group was 35.1 and 33 years respectively. There were equal proportion of males and females and there was no difference in the size of lesions in each of the treatment groups. One year following surgery, patients underwent check arthroscopy (with or without biopsy) to assess the graft. Functional assessment was performed yearly by using the Modified Cincinatti Knee score, the SF-36 score, the Bentley Functional Rating Score and the Visual Analogue Score.


J Wimmer N-O Wendler M Russlies P Behrens

Autologous matrix-induced chondrogenesis (AMIC) is a new treatment option for full-thickness cartilage defect repair using the well-known microfracturing technique combined with a porcine collagen type I/III matrix implant and partially autologous fibrin sealant.

A retrospective study has being carried out to investigate the objective and subjective clinical outcome of this procedure over a period of up to 2 years after the operation. 18 patients (10 male, 8 female) with localised cartilage defects were treated with AMIC.

The mean age was 37 13 years. Defects treated were localised retropatellar (6), on the medial femoral condyle (7), on the lateral femoral condyle (2) and multiple lesions (3). During the clinical follow-up these patients were evaluated with the help of 3 different scores (IKDC score, Cincinnati score, Lysholm-Gillquist score).

For the collective of 18 patients, one or more years had elapsed since the operation at the time this study was completed. 10 patients were included into the 2-year evaluation. The IKDC Score showed a mean improvement from 28 to 58 out of 100 at 1-year and from 25.5 to 69 out of 100 at 2-years post-operative. The Cincinnati and Lysholm-Gillquist scores showed the same tendency with an improvement of about 40 pecent at 1 year and about 55 percent at 2 years compared to pre-operative value. The improvement in the IKDC Score as well as the Cincinnati and Lysholm-Gillquist suggest that AMIC is a promising alternative in the treatment of local cartilage defects in the knee with good short and possibly mid-term results.

Further follow up will reveal, if the good results are durable and AMIC, as matrix enhanced microfracturing technique can become a valuable, recognised cartilage repair technique.


CG Murphy G Chen DC Winter D Bouchier-Hayes

Introduction

Long bone surgery and marrow instrumentation represent significant surgical insults, and may cause severe local and systemic sequelae following both planned and emergent surgery. Preconditioning is a highly conserved evolutionary endogenous protective mechanism, but finding a clinically safe and acceptable method of induction has proven difficult. Glutamine, a known inducer of the heat shock protein (HSP) response, offers pharmacological modulation of injury through clinically acceptable preconditioning. This effect has not been previously demonstrated in an orthopaedic model.

Aims

The aim of the study was to test the hypothesis that glutamine preconditioning protects against the local and systemic effects of long bone trauma in a rodent model.


N Gogi A Perera M Vishwanath S Gella BK Singh

Aim

To assess the influence of posterior slope on Knee flexion and function in Asian and Caucasian populations.

Material & methods

We have conducted a prospective comparative study of 109 Asian and Caucasian posterior tibial slopes. All data has been collected prospectively and includes personal data (height, weight, tibial measurements), ASA grading, knees scores and range of movement. Analysis was performed for the whole group and comparisons were made between the two sets of patients. Minimum follow-up was two years.


ID McDermott DTT Lie A Edwards AMJ Bull AA Amis

This paper reports a series of comparative tests in-vitro that examined how lateral meniscectomy and meniscal allografting affected tibio-femoral joint contact pressures. 8 Cadaver knees (age range 81 – 98 years) were loaded in axial compression in an Instron materials testing machine up to 700N for 10 seconds and pressure maps obtained from the lateral compartment using Fuji Prescale film inserted below the meniscus. This was repeated after meniscectomy, then after meniscal allografting with fixation by a bone plug for the insertional ligaments, plus peripheral sutures. Finally, the pressure when the allograft was secured by peripheral sutures alone was measured.

Meniscectomy caused a significant increase in peak contact pressures (p=0.0002). Both of the reconstructive methods reduced the peak contact pressures significantly below that of the meniscectomised knee (p=0.0029 with bone block; p=0.0199 with sutures alone). A significant difference was not found between the peak contact pressures after the reconstructions and that of the intact knee (p=0.1721 with bone block; p=0.0910 with sutures alone). The peak pressures increased slightly when the allografts were converted from bone block to suture-only fixation (p=0.0349).

The principal finding was that both of the meniscal allograft insertion techniques reduced the peak contact pressure significantly below that of the meniscectomised knee, so that it did not then differ significantly from the peak contact pressure in the intact knee. When the two fixation methods were compared, the loss of the bone plug attachment caused a small increase in peak pressure.

This study suggests that meniscal allografting should have a chondroprotective effect and that there is a small advantage from adding bony fixation to suture fixation.


Z Sivardeen I Bisbinas U De Silva M Green R Grimer D Learmonth

Pigmented villonodular synovitis is a monoarticular proliferative process most commonly involving the synovium of the knee joint. There is considerable debate with regards to diagnosis and effective treatment.

We present our experience of managing PVNS of the knee joint over a 12 year period. Twenty-eight patients were reviewed. MRI was used to establish recurrence in symptomatic patients rather than routine screening and to identify posterior disease prior to surgery.

Eight patients had localised disease and were all treated with open synovectomy and excision of the lesion, with no evidence of recurrence. Twenty patients had diffuse disease, eight treated arthroscopically and twelve with open total synovectomy. Nineteen patients (95%) had recurrence on MRI, however, only five (25%) had evidence of clinical recurrence.

There were no significant complications following arthroscopic synovectomy. Open synovectomy, in contrast, was associated with three wound infections and two thrombo-embolisms. Three patients had Complex regional pain syndrome.

We believe diffuse disease should be treated with arthroscopic synovectomy which is associated with minimal morbidity and can be repeated to maintain disease control. Radiotherapy is helpful in very aggressive cases. TKR was used when there was associated articular erosion.


S-C Cheng WA Wallace D Buchanan Z Sivardeen D Hulse KJ Fairbairn S Kemp J Brooks

Objective

Shoulder instability is a common cause of morbidity amongst Professional Rugby Union players. This study explores whether the risk of shoulder dislocation is associated with innate shoulder laxity.

Methods

A randomised controlled study was completed in which all the Premiership Rugby Clubs in England were visited in 2006. 169 professional rugby players (mean age 25.1 years) with no history of instability in either shoulder were assessed and 46 injured players with one shoulder with a history of Bankart lesion or dislocation (mean age 27.5 years) also took part in this study. Shoulder laxity was measured by dynamic ultrasound. Anterior, posterior and inferior translations were measured in both shoulders for healthy players and the uninjured shoulder only for injured players.


R Boden E Burgess D Enion M Srinivasan

Background

Successful use of bioabsorbable anchors for capsulolabral and rotator cuff repair is well documented. The bioknotless anchor (DePuy mitek) has demonstrated reliable fixation of these pathologies. However, this poly (L-lactide) polymer has recently demonstrated some similar complications to those documented for the earlier polyglycolic acid implants; namely synovitis and chondral damage with osteolysis. We report three cases with osteolysis and chondral damage associated with bioknotless anchors.

Methods

A prospective record of shoulder arthroscopy is maintained by the senior author. From this, three patients with post-operative complications of arthropathy and osteolysis, following bioabsorbable anchor repair of capsulolabral lesions were identified. A retrospective review of case notes, radiographs, operative records and intraoperative video and photographic material was undertaken.


Full Access
A Richards T Knight S Belkoff

Avulsion fractures of the tip of the olecranon are a common traumatic injury. Kirshner-wire fixation (1.6mm) with a figure of eight tension band wire (1.25mm) remains the most popular technique. Hardware removal mat be required in up to 80% of cases. Modern suture materials have very high tensile strength coupled with excellent usability. In this study we compare a repair using 1.6mm k-wires with a 1.25mm surgical steel, against a repair that uses two strands of 2 fibrewire.

Twelve Pairs of cadaveric arms were harvested. A standard olecranon osteotomy was performed to mimic an avulsion fracture. In each pair one was fixed using standard technique, 2 × 1.6mm transcortical ?-wire plus figure of 8 loop of 1.25mm wire. The other fixed with the same ?-wires with a tension band suture of 2.0 fibrewire (two loops, one figure of 8 and one simple loop). The triceps tendon was cyclically loaded (10-120 Newtons) to simulate full active motion 2200 cycles. Fracture gap was measured with the ‘Smart Capture’ motion analysis system. The arm was fixed at 90 degrees and triceps tendon was loaded until fixation failure, ultimate load to failure and mode of failure was noted.

The average gap formation at the fracture site for the suture group was 0.91mm, in the wire group 0.96mm, no specimen in either group produced a significant gap after cyclical loading. Mean load to failure for the suture group was 1069 Newtons (SD=120N) and in the wire group 820 Newtons (SD=235N).

Both types of fixation allow full early mobilisation without gap formation. The Suture group has a significantly higher load to failure (p=0.002, t-test). Tension Band suture allows a lower profile fixation, potentially reducing the frequency of wound complications and hardware removal.


V Dhukaram J Brewer S Tafazal P Lee J Dias M Jones A Gaur

Introduction

Brachial plexus blocks are used widely to provide intra-operative and post-operative analgesia. Their efficacy is well established, but little is known about discharging patients with a numb or weak arm. We need to quantify the risk of complications for improved informed consent.

Objectives

To assess whether patients can be safely discharged from hospital before the brachial plexus block has worn off and record any complications and concerns.


JE Farmer A Aladin S Earnshaw C Boulton CG Moran

Developments in plate technology have increased interest in the operative fixation of Colles' fracture. The vast majority of patients are treated non-operatively, yet there are few medium or long-term outcome studies.

The aim of this study was to evaluate medium-term outcome of a cohort of patients who previously received treatment in a plaster cast. 236 patients entered two previous prospective, randomised control studies comparing closed reduction techniques or plaster cast type. Both studies showed no difference in clinical or radiological outcome between groups. 43% of this cohort had a final dorsal tilt of > 10° and 44% had final radial shortening of >2mm. All patients now have a minimum follow-up of five years and 60 have died. The remaining 176 patients were contacted by post and asked to complete two validated patient-based questionnaires: a modified Patient Evaluation Measure and a quickDASH. 112 replies were received. The mean age of patients is 67 years (range 23 – 91 years). 31 patients are employed and 57 retired. 77% of patients had a quickDASH score of less than 20. 59% of patients never experience wrist pain whilst 8% of patients have daily pain.

All Patient Evaluation Measures have shown a median score of 12 or less (0=excellent, 100= terrible). The best score was for pain (median 4; IQR 2-12) and the worst for grip strength (median 12; IQR 4 – 41). No radiological outcome 5 weeks after injury correlated with any outcome score, except for dorsal tilt, which correlated with difficulty with fiddly tasks (p=0.04) and carpal malalignment which correlated with interference with work (p=0.04).

In conclusion, our results show a good functional outcome five years after non-operative management of Colles' fracture. A degree of malunion is acceptable and in the light of our results the economic impact of surgery must be evaluated.


I Ibrahim K Alsey SZ Naqui G Pendlebury JG Warner

Aims

To study the outcomes of DVR plating for distal radius fractures.

Methods

We prospectively studied all patients managed with a DVR plate, over a twelve-month period in 2006/07.

All patients were seen in our dedicated research clinic at 2, 6, 12 and 26 weeks post-operatively. Physiotherapy started at 2 weeks post-operatively. Active range of motion (ROM) of the injured wrist was recorded at 6, 12 and 26 weeks and compared with the normal side. Standardised radiographs were taken at 2 and 6 weeks and compared with pre- and post-operative films for radial and volar angulations, relative radial length, ulnar variance and implant position. Patient satisfaction was measured with the Patient Rated Wrist Evaluation score (PRWE) at 6, 12 and 26 weeks.


R Chidambaram D Mok

Introduction

Unstable dorsal fracture/dislocation of PIP joint is a complex injury and difficult to treat. Different treatment methods have been described with varying results. We describe a novel technique to combine fracture fixation with volar plate repair using micro anchor suture.

Material and methods

Between July and December 2005, 11 consecutive patients with unstable dorsal PIP joint dislocations underwent open reduction and volar plate repair using our technique. Nine patients had dorsal fracture dislocations and two had open dislocations. All patients were males and their average age was 26 years. All patients were reviewed with the minimum follow up of 12 months. The pain score, range of movements and grip strength were recorded and compared to the normal side.


N Davis E Powell-Smith S Phillips J Hobby I Lowdon

Introduction

PIPJ replacement has become increasingly popular however, there is very little clinical data available apart from small studies and those from the originators of the prostheses. We present a review of our initial experience with the Acension(c) Pyro-carbon PIP joint.

Results

Data was collected from 62 joints in 39 patients with one patient lost to follow-up. Mean age was 61.6 years. 29 patients were female and 10 male. Mean follow up was 22.3 months (range 11 to 54). 7 patients or 11% needed further surgery. The majority were for stiffness with 3 operations for dislocation or component malposition. The total complication rate was 32%, again the biggest problem was stiffness. 4 joints have subluxed or dislocated, 2 had superficial infections. There was no statistical difference in the rate of complications compared to the operated finger or the pre-operative diagnosis.

Post-operatively patients had a mean fixed flexion deformity of 19° and flexed to 76° (58° arc). However patients undergoing surgery following trauma do not do as well as the other groups with a decrease in ROM of 33°.


A Middleton L Irwin

The Mathys¯ finger joint replacement system offers a novel fixation method into the proximal and distal medullary canals and a semi-constrained articulation. This comprises a separable, form-fit joint with a distal/proximal play of 0.7 mm, a lateral excursion of 10°, and rotation of up to 6°. This has theoretical advantages of increased radio-ulnar stability, preventing ulnar drift in patients with rheumatoid disease, and enhanced osseointegration offering implant longevity. In our unit, however, high failure rates were noted, prompting a review of cases to quantify our suspicions.

Case notes of all patients who underwent finger joint replacement using the Mathys¯ implant between 1999 and 2005 were retrieved. Twenty-two devices were implanted by a single surgeon during this period. Four were in finger proximal interphalangeal joints, 17 in finger metacarpophalangeal joints and one in a thumb carpometacarpal joint (CMCJ).

Indications for joint replacement included sixteen for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and five for post-traumatic joint problems. The only thumb CMCJ was replaced for primary osteoarthritis. Patients were reviewed regularly and implant performance assessed critically along with survival of the implant to revision, infection or death of the patient. Mean follow up was 30 months.

Sixteen implants failed including the only thumb CMCJ. Modes of failure were rotation (11), poor range of motion (two), infection (two) and dislocation (the CMCJ). Similar ball and socket designs for uncemented thumb CMCJ replacement, such as the Ledoux prosthesis, have previously shown poor survival and have been withdrawn from the market. Of the finger implants in RA patients (n=16), 12 implants failed of which ten were due to rotation. Time to failure ranged from two to 48 months (mean 15 months).

The authors do not recommend the use of this implant, especially in cases of rheumatoid arthritis.


JS Butler CJ Hurson RT Moon PP Doran JM O'Byrne

Introduction

Osteoporosis is a common skeletal disorder characterised by a reduced bone mass and a progressive micro-architectural deterioration in bone tissue leading to bone fragility and susceptibility to fracture. With a progressively aging population, osteoporosis is becoming an increasingly important public health issue. The Wnt/β-catenin pathway is a major signalling cascade in bone biology, playing a key role in regulating bone development and remodelling, with aberrations in signalling resulting in disturbances in bone mass.

Objectives

To assess the effects of silencing the expression of the Wnt antagonist Dickkopf-1 (Dkk1) on the bone profile of primary human osteoblasts exposed in vitro to 10-8M dexamethasone.


M Costa AD Patel S Donell

Background

Shockwave therapy has been shown to induce osteoneogenesis in animal models. The mechanism of action is unclear, but experimental evidence suggests micro-fracture formation and increased blood flow as the most likely explanation. Several reports from Europe have suggested good results from the treatment of delayed fracture union with shock-waves. We present the results of a randomised double-blind placebo-controlled pilot study.

Method

Fourteen patients with clinically and radiologically confirmed delayed union of long-bones consented to enter the trial. The treatment group had a single application of 3000 high-energy shockwaves using the Stortz SLK unit with image intensifier control. The control group had the exactly the same treatment but with an ‘air-gap’ interposition to create a placebo-shockwave. Each patient was followed-up with serial radiographs as well as visual analogue pain scores and EuroQol assessments. All of the patients were reviewed for a minimum of three years post treatment.


B Morgan JA Livingstone I MacFadyen M Jackson RM Atkins

Introduction

The optimal management of intra-articular tibial plateau fractures with metaphyseal-diaphyseal dissociation remains challenging and controversial. We report results using the technique of limited open reduction with external fixation using a fine wire circular frame.

Method

Between 1994 –2006, 83 eligible patients were identified. Case notes were reviewed; X-Rays and CT scans were examined and used to rank-order the severity of injury. ‘Musculoskeletal Functional Assessment’ (MFA) and ‘Knee Outcome Survey’ (KOS) questionnaires were completed and axial alignment X-Rays were taken to assess functional and radiological outcome.


S Singh S Lo M Soldin

Traditional teaching, and indeed the impression from the BOA BAPS working party report on open tibial fractures, suggests that soft tissue cover of the distal third of the leg will often need a free flap.

However, more recently with the introduction of propeller flaps by Quaba, and the reintroduction of the concept of Ponten's nerve oriented flaps with the reverse sural artery flap, the role of free tissue transfer comes into question. The attraction of local flaps for distal third fractures is the reduced operating time, reduced morbidity of donor site, versatility and reliability. However, detractors would argue that muscle enhances bone union and reduces local infection. Previous reviews of lower limb soft tissue cover look at all areas of the leg. This series of 30 (14 free and 16 local flaps) cases looks exclusively at the distal third fractures, compares the complication rate of free versus local flaps and looks at the change in approach to distal third fractures with the more recently described fascio-cutaneous flaps. Our results challenge the conventional teaching and indicate that fasciocutaneous flaps can play a more active role in distal third fractures.

Our study shows that the local flaps are a valuable alternative to free flaps for managing soft tissue defects in distal third fractures of tibia especially in smaller wound size and low energy fractures. The advantages are lesser operating time, reliability, versatility, lesser wound complication and osteomyelitis incidence, earlier flap cover and lesser post op morbidity leading to shorter hospital stay. The free flaps on balance are probably better with larger soft tissue defects and with more severe limb injury. This supports the use of fascio-cutaneous flaps in distal third tibial fractures.


D Bhaskar S Vishwanath VV George R Jayakumar CC Kovoor

We did a retrospective comparative analysis of twenty five patients treated with Ilizarov bone transport [IBT] and twenty one patients treated with vascularised fibular graft [VFG] from 1994 to 2003 in one institution, for post traumatic tibial bone defects of more than six centimetres.

The aim of the study was to find out if there were any differences in achieving radiological end points, bone and functional score and return to work (final outcome), hospital stay and operating time (logistic factors) and complication rates. The mean defect size in the IBT group was 11.9 centimetres and in the VFG group 14.6 centimetres.

Twenty one and sixteen patients in the IBT and VFG group respectively achieved the radiological end point that is union of the defect and graft hypertrophy [p 0.5]. Nineteen patients in the IBT group and fifteen in the VFG group returned to productive work [p 0.72]. Bone and functional results were analyzed by Paley's evaluation system and there were no significant differences in the two groups of patients [bone result p 0.97 and functional result p 0.1]. The logistic factors were significantly less of IBT group [p < 0.05]. Two patients in the IBT group and one patient in the VFG group had amputation and one patient in VFG group died. Three cases in the VFG group had flap loss. Stress fracture of the graft occurred in eight patients in the VFG group [p 0.0007].

The final outcome was same in both groups. Hospital stay, operating time and refractures were significantly less in IBT group.


D Bhaskar CC Kovoor VV George

Distal tibial bone loss involving the ankle is a devastating injury with few options for reconstruction. The purpose of our study was to look at the long term results of ilizarov technique used to achieve lengthening of tibia and fusion at the ankle.

17 cases (16 post traumatic and one post tumor resection) admitted to one institution between 1994 and 2003. 13 cases were done in bifocal and four in trifocal mode.

The duration of follow up was 12 to 84 months The average age was 33 years (Range 7-71). The mean length of the defect was 4.5 cm (Range 1-12). Union of the fusion site occurred in 88 % (15/17) of the patients with mean duration to docking and union being 8 months. The mean time in fixator was 13 months (Range 5 to 29).

Average number of surgeries per patient was 3.2. Five patients required free vascularised grafts before the index procedure and 4 patients required realignment at the docking site. Functional results – Fourteen (77.5%) of the patients could walk without support or bracing and twelve patients (71%) returned to same or modified occupation.

Complications – Two non-union.

Deformity – Fusion site equinus deformity occurred with non union after re-fracture in one case. There were 2 cases of residual fore-foot equinus.

Residual low grade infection with discharging sinus was present in two patients. One patient needed change of wires for Pin tract infection. Our study showed 76% good and excellent scores on functional scoring but also demonstrates the high morbidity associated with this procedure. In spite of the steep learning curve and high complication rates the procedure can be undertaken in specialised centres for highly motivated patients to achieve good functional results.


L Ogonda M Laverick C Andrews

Introduction

Paediatric tibial fractures, unlike femoral fractures do not have much potential for overgrowth. In simple factures of the tibial shaft treated non-operatively the major problems are shortening and malunion.

In complex injuries with extensive soft tissue disruption and bone loss, the long-term aim of reconstruction is to achieve union with a fully functional limb without limb-length inequality.

Methods

Four children (Age range 6-12 years) who sustained high-energy grade III open fractures of the tibia were treated with acute shortening and bone transport. Any soft tissue reconstructive and secondary grafting procedures for delayed union were recorded. The children were prospectively followed up to fracture union. Distraction ostegenesis proceeded until limb length equality was achieved and the regenerate allowed to consolidate.


N Pradhan V Gupta V Clarke

Aim

To evaluate the costs of performing revision hip and knee surgery at a District General Hospital.

Methods

A retrospective review of all revision hip and knee surgery between October 2004 and October 2006 was performed. Information was obtained from the notes and theatre log books. Each case was fully costed. The breakdown costs included implant choice, theatre time, length of stay, allograft, blood products and post-operative physiotherapy/OT. The costs were obtained from the hospital financial department and theatre invoices. Payment to the hospital is based on a specific tariff which in turn is determined by coding each patient episode. We individually coded every case, using the OPCS 4.3 coding system, and applied the appropriate tariff. The tariffs that the financial department had applied to each case were also available. A comparison was made between actual costs incurred, the expected reimbursement (from our study coding) and the actual reimbursement received (from finance department).


J Millington R Pickard KS Conn ND Rossiter GJ Stranks NP Thomas JM Britton

It is established good practice that hip and knee replacements should have regular follow-up and for the past seven years at the North Hampshire Hospital a local joint register has been used for this purpose and we compare this with results of the Swedish and UK national and the Trent Regional registries.

Since March 1999, all primary and revision hip and knee arthroplasties performed at North Hampshire Hospital, Basingstoke have been prospectively recorded onto a database set up by one of the senior authors (JMB). Data from patients entered in the first five years of the register were analysed. All patients have at least one year clinical and radiological review then a minimum of yearly postal follow-up. 3266 operations (1524 hips and 1742 knees) were performed under the care of 13 consultants. Osteoarthritis was the most common primary diagnosis in over 75% of hips and knees. Our revision burden was 7.5% (10.2% hips and 3.5% knees). As of 31/12/2006 6.2% of patients had died and 5.5% were lost to follow-up.

Revision rates were 1.5% and 1.4% for primary total hip and knee replacements respectively.

Our data analysis of revisions and patello-femoral replacements has allowed us to change our practice following local audit which is ongoing. Oxford scores at 2 years had improved from a mean of 19 and 21 pre-operatively to 40 and 39 for primary hips and knees respectively. Our costs are estimated at approximately £35 per patient for their lifetime on the register.

Compared to other registries:

Our dataset is more complete and comprehensive

Our costs are less

All patients have a unique identifier (the UKNJR has at least 26% of data which is anonymous)

Our audit loops have been closed.


V Roberts CN Esler WM Harper

NICE published the guidelines ‘Selection of prostheses for primary hip replacement’ in 2000. Essentially these guidelines made two recommendations: firstly to use prostheses which had attained the ‘10 year benchmark’ of a revision rate of 10% or less at 10 years, or had a minimum of three years revision rate experience that was on target to reach this benchmark; and secondly to use cemented hip prostheses to the exclusion of uncemented and hybrid prostheses.

The information from the Trent Regional Arthroplasty Study (TRAS) has been used to retrospectively examine the types of hip prostheses used from 1990 – 2005, and assess the impact that the NICE guidelines have had on orthopaedic practice.

This study revealed that the percentage of prostheses used which attained the ‘ten year benchmark’ has increased since the guidelines were published. In 2001, of the ten cups, which constituted 80% of the acetabular components used, only three attained this NICE benchmark, but by 2005 this number had risen to eight. Similarly in 2001, of the eight stems, which constituted almost 80% of the femoral components used, only five attained this NICE benchmark. In 2005 seven out of these eight stems had attained the minimum standard.

However contrary to the recommendation made by NICE in 2000, to use cemented prostheses, the results indicate the use of uncemented prostheses has trebled (from 6.7% to 19.2%, n= 137 and 632 respectively), and the use of hybrid prostheses has more than doubled (from 8.8% to 22% of all prostheses, n= 181 and 722 respectively) since the guidelines were published.

Therefore the recommendations made by NICE are not being followed, which calls the value of NICE guidelines into question.


S Mulay A Wokhlu S Birtwistle R Power

We undertook a comparative audit of 171 consecutive Hip and Knee Arthroplasties performed by an overseas team at an Independent Hospital (Group 1) between August 2005 and December 2005 and compared them to a corresponding number performed by all grades of surgeons at the local NHS Trust (Group 2). We examined patient selection criteria such as BMI and ASA grade and compared the early radiological outcome, complication rate, length of hospital stay and the patient satisfaction rate between the two groups.

We found that patients in Group 1 had a lower average BMI (27.13) and a better ASA grade (95% grade 1 and 2) as compared to Group 2 (BMI - 29.69 and 80% ASA Grade 1 and 2). The average hospital stay was 6.1 days in Group 1 and 8 days in Group 2.

Only 74% of the patients in Group 1 were completely satisfied with their treatment outcome as compared to 91% in Group 2. (Trent Arthroplasty Questionnaire)

There were 7 early dislocations (9.1%) in Group 1 (76 THRs), two requiring revision, as compared to one in Group 2 (1.3%, 84 THRs). Three other patients from Group 1 (TKRs) required a revision procedure within the first year.

There was an increased incidence of adverse features (mal-alignment and mal-positioning of components) on the post operative X rays of patients in Group 1 as compared to Group 2 leading to adverse clinical events. 11 patients (95TKRs) showed substantial femoral notching in Group 1 as compared to 3 in Group 2.

This study shows that patients selected for surgery by the overseas team were the fitter of the two groups, but had a significantly higher complication rate and a much lower satisfaction rate. The study underlines the potential risks of commissioning work to overseas teams in order to reduce waiting times.


G Bannister M Ahmed M Bannister R Bray P Dillon S Eastaugh-Waring

We compared the early complication rates of total hip (THA) and total knee (TKA) arthroplasty carried out at a regional orthopaedic hospital (AOC) and two Independent Sector Treatment Units (ISTUs) (WGH and CNH). After THA, reoperation rates were higher at CNH (9%) than AOC (0.6%) or WGH (1.4%). After TKA, reoperation rates at CNH were (8%) higher than AOC (1%) and WGH (1.9%).

5% of patients undergoing TKR at CNH underwent 2 stage revision for deep infection.

After THA, dislocation rates at CNH (6%) were higher than AOC and WGH (1.8%). Readmission from CNH (13%) was higher than AOC (1.2%) and WGH (0.6%).

Major wound problems at CNH (20%) were higher than WGH (3.8%) and AOC (0.4%).

After TKA, major wound problems were higher at CNH (19%) compared to WGH (1.9%) and AOC (1.1%). Readmission rates not requiring surgery from CNH (13%) were higher than AOC. (1.1%) and WGH (1%). AOC and WGH audited their outcomes. None were available from CNH. WGH initially missed many of their complications because they presented at base hospitals elsewhere.

ISTUs performed approximately 2/3rds of procedures for which patients had been referred from base hospitals.

At CNH, 23% were rejected on grounds of potential co-morbidity. Audit from ISTUs is inferior to NHS hospitals and the results in one of those audited significantly worse.

Patients offered surgery at ISTUs should be told that the audited outcome of the surgeon who will be treating them is not known and that, in some, results are inferior to surgery in the NHS.


J Fagg A Morgan P Fagg K Phillips

Independent sector treatment centres (ISTCs) were introduced in October 2003 in the United Kingdom in order to reduce waiting times for elective operations and to improve patient choice and experience. Many concerns have been voiced from several authorities over a number of issues related to these centres. One of these concerns was regarding the practice of ‘cherry-picking’. Trusts are paid according to ‘payment by results’ at national tariffs. The national tariff is an average of costs occurring in an average mix of patients. The assumption is that the higher the co-morbidities of the patients the more likely they are to consume a higher amount of resource and to require a longer length of stay. Cherry-picking may also affect the quality of training available to trainees.

This audit was aimed at identifying if, and how much this practice occurs. It also identifies what affect this has on the case-load of patients left for the NHS hospitals.

We looked at the number of co-morbidities amongst 198 consecutive patients undergoing hip and knee primary total arthroplasty at an ISTC, a district general hospital whose PCTs provide patient to the ISTC (Doncaster Royal Infirmary - DRI), and a district general hospital in the same area whose PCT did not provide choice at that time and who therefore did not send patients to the ISTC (Bassetlaw District General Hospital - BDGH). We found a statistically significant difference in the number of co-morbidities per patient at the ISTC compared with the DRI (1.23 vs. 2.05) and the ISTC compared with the BDGH (1.23 vs. 1.76). We were unable to show a statistically significant difference between the DRI and the BDGH. We conclude that cherry-picking does take place, and further work should be done to assess the impact on training and finance.