Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 84-B, Issue SUPP_III November 2002

K. Mulpuri B.K. Foster E.P. Kirk J.M. Fletcher A. Hanieh

Aim: To determine that the aetiology of cord compression in mucopolysaccharidoses (MPS) type VI. To illustrate the variability of this complication of mucopolysaccharidoses even within families. To report the youngest MPS VI patient yet described with spinal cord compression and to present the technique and results of spinal stabilisation.

Method: The course, clinical findings and management of three patients with MPS VI and two with MPS IV were reviewed.

Results: The patients with MPS VI demonstrated that the pathogenesis of spinal cord compression in this condition is complex, with elements of joint instability, bony disease and soft tissue compression. Two of the patients with MPS VI are siblings: the younger sibling was 30 months old when she required surgery. She is the youngest reported patient with this complication of MPS VI. The patients with MPS IV are presented to illustrate similarities and differences in the pathogenesis of the same problem in the two disorders. Results of cervical spine stabilisation were found to be satisfactory.

Conclusions: In both MPS IV and MPS VI spinal cord compression may be multi-factorial. This complication of the mucopolysaccharidoses needs to be considered even when the patient is very young.


T. Wiesner M. Kuster MS. Kuster

Introduction: There is little data available about numerical analysis of polyethylene particles from regions with different degrees of osteolysis in aseptic loosening of total hip replacements. Hence, it was the purpose of the present study to investigate, whether particles from large ostolitic lesions are different in size or shape to particles from regions with little or no osteolysis.

Methods: during hip revision surgery tissue samples from regions with maximal and minimal osteolysis at the stem and acetabulum were collected in five patients. The samples were examined histologically and numerically for each region. The polyethylene particles were isolated from one gram soft tissue by papain digestion and analyzed with a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Size, elongation, area, form factor and perimeter were calculated for a total of 6526 particles.

Results: The histological examination showed significantly more lymphocytes (p < 0,001), histiocytes (p < 0,01) und giant cells (p < 0,001) in large osteolitic lesions. The numerical SEM analysis also revealed significantly larger particles (p< 0,001) in regions with maximal osteolysis (Median acetabulum 1,44mmm und femur 1,89mmm) than in regions with minimal osteolysis (acetabulum 1,21mmm und femur 0,76mmm).

Discussion: Presently only the small micro particles were thought of importance for aseptic loosening. The present paper showed, that regions with large osteolitic lesions have not only more but also larger particles than small osteolitic lesions. The question arises whether the larger particles and giant cells may have an influence on the progression of osteolysis or not. Furthermore, periprosthetic tissue for wear particle analysis in revision surgery must be harvested from the same region in order to obtain conclusive results.


G. Matheson S. Nicklin W. R. Walsh M. P. Gianoutsos

Introduction: New flexor tendon repair techniques have been proposed to withstand the increased loads of active mobilisation. Most reports on the biomechanics of tendon repair are based on static testing. Cyclic testing more closely replicates the clinical situation and leads to gap formation at lower loads than in static testing.

Aim: To examine three types of tendon repair using a new cyclic testing protocol.

Methods: Thirty fresh-frozen cadaveric tendons were randomly assigned to three groups; Kessler repair with simple or cross-stitch epitendinous suture or Savage repair with simple epitendinous suture. All repairs were performed in situ in Verdan’s zone 2. Samples underwent tensile cyclic testing in a saline bath at a rate of 0.1Hz. Each specimen was subjected to two phases of testing replicating passive and active motion. Gap formation, stiffness and the mode of failure were recorded for each.

Results: The Savage repairs were stiffer and more resistant to gap formation than the Kessler repairs. The simple epitendinous suture seemed to be more resistant to gap formation than the cross-stitch suture although there was no significant difference in ultimate strength.

Conclusions: Cyclic testing is a more rigorous testing protocol that more closely replicates the clinical situation. This study showed that some repairs formed significant gaps at lower loads than the reported ultimate load-to-failure seen with static testing. Although cyclic testing has its limitations, we believe it is essential to assess fully tendon repair techniques, especially those considered for active mobilisation post-operatively. This study suggests the Savage repair may be a better option for active mobilisation protocols.


S Okada H. Ohta K. Shiba T. Ueta Y. Takemitsu E. Mori K. Kaji I. Yugue

There are increasing opportunity of operative treatment for advanced aged patients with degenerative spinal disease aiming for better quality of life. We have studied such patients concerning operative result, complication and problem in pre- and peri- operative management, and achievement of their aims.

Patients and Results: 1) 26 patients were analyzed; 16 males and 10 females, av. aged 82.3, pts of 19 lumbar canal stenosis with marked intermittent claudication and 7 disc herniation. 2) Low back pain and neurogenic disabilities are evaluated on JOA scoring criteria excepting ADL points (full score:15).

Results: 1) 25 of 26 pts had following complications before operation; hypertension in 16, neurogenic bladder 7, arrhythmia 6, prostata hypertrophy 6, cardiac ischemic disease 4, DM 3, cerebral infarction 3, advanced OA of the knee joints 3. asthma 2, pulmonary emphysema 2, Parkinsonism 1, respectively. 2) All patients underwent laminectomy of av. 2.2 segments(1~4), and 3 pts had PL fusion. 3) One had postlaminectomy haematoma complicated with neurologic deterioration 3 hrs after operaion. He underwent immediate revision which resulted complete recovery of neurology. 4) One pt with pulmonary emphysema was operated successfully with lumbar anaesthesia as general anaesthesia was refused. 5) Improvement evaluated with modified JOA pain score accounted for as follows; av. preoperative score showed 7.16 improved to 10.73 (45.8%), objective symptoms 4.23–4.66, subjective symptome 3.0–6.08 (51.3%), ambulant ability improved from 0.35–2.0 (62.3%), and pain ± numbness of L/E 0.96–2.04 (52.9%) resp. 6) 2 patient


J.L. Williams V.A. Dickens M.S. Bhamra

Aim: To assess the value of physiotherapy in the treatment of patients with subacromial impingement syndrome.

Methods: Patients with subacromial impingement syndrome were identified. Those who had not previously had any physiotherapy and had failed to respond to other types of non-surgical management were selected and placed on the waiting list for subacromial decompression. These patients were randomised into two groups. One group was referred for physiotherapy while waiting for surgery. The control group had no intervention prior to surgery. The patients in the physiotherapy group underwent an assessment and treatment by a single physiotherapist. All patients were evaluated independently after each of three and six months. The Constant Score was used to assess all patients initially and at each visit.

Results: Physiotherapy group: All patients (n=42) increased their Constant score. Eleven of the 42 patients (26%) improved to an extent that surgery was no longer required. In patients not requiring surgery, the mean improvement in the Constant score was 25 (range: 12 to 45) In the patients requiring surgery, (n=31), the mean improvement was 21 (range: three to 34). Patients not requiring surgery had a higher initial Constant score, 65 (range: 30–84) than those requiring surgery 48 (range: 17 to 59). Patients not requiring surgery also tended to be younger 52 (range: 27 to 68) than those requiring surgery 59 (range: 48 to 68).

Control Group: All patients (n=23) went on to have surgery. The mean improvement in Constant score was two (Range: −16 to 12).

Conclusions: All patients with subacromial impingement syndrome improved with physiotherapy when compared with a control group that did not receive physiotherapy. Some patients in the physiotherapy group (26%) improved to the extent that surgery was no longer required.


P.N. Smith M. Maguire D. Smith

Introduction: We describe a new technique of using acetabular suction to improve cementing conditions in acetabular arthroplasty.

Aim: To analyse the effectiveness of a technique of applying suction to the acetabular cavity during cementing as a method of maximising the quality of the bone-cement interface.

Methods: In this study, a series of 100 cemented primary Exeter hip replacements performed by the senior author, using contemporary cementing techniques together with an acetabular suction technique were evaluated for the degree of cement penetration and the quality of the cement-bone interface so created. Radiographs were digitally scanned with high resolution and a CAD program was used to assess quantitatively the cement penetration in each of the Charnley-DeLee zones. The quality of the cement-bone interface was assessed using the grading system as described by Ranawat.

Results: An analysis showed significant cement penetration in each of the Charnley-Delee zones especially in zones 1b, 2a and 2b. The quality of the cement-bone penetration was excellent with most showing a Type I interface (perfect cement-bone interlock with gradual merging of cement into the cancellous bone with no radiolucency or rounding off of the cement front) in all zones.

Conclusions: These results indicated that application of acetabular suction significantly improved the cement penetration on the acetabular side in cemented total hip arthroplasty. We recommend this as a satisfactory method to ensure the best possible conditions for creation of an enduring cement- bone interface.


R.J.K. Khan A. MacDowell P. Crossman A. Datta N. Jallali G.S. Keene

Introduction: The best method of management of displaced intracapsular femoral neck fractures in elderly patients remains undecided. Most are treated by hemiarthroplasty.

Aim: To clarify the issue of whether or not to use cement in hemiarthroplasty for displaced, intracapsular, femoral neck fractures in the elderly.

Methods: Consecutive patients with displaced, intracapsular, femoral neck fractures treated by hemiarthroplasty between January 1997 and May 1998, in two hospitals within one region were reviewed. The same monoblock prosthesis was used; in Hospital A they were uncemented (121 patients), and in Hospital B they were cemented (123 patients). All surviving patients (50 and 56 respectively) were interviewed for assessments of pre-fracture and current pain, walking ability, use of walking aids and activities of daily living (ADL), using validated scoring systems. The average follow-up was 36 months.

Results: The patients’ demographical data were similar (the mean age was 82 and 84 years respectively). There was no greater incidence of intra-operative fall in diastolic blood pressure or oxygen saturation in the cemented group. Cemented procedures took, on average, 15 minutes longer. Fewer of the cemented group had been revised or were awaiting revision (p=0.036). There was no difference in complication or mortality rates at any time between surgery and follow-up (p=0.86). Prospective assessment revealed highly significant differences in favour of cement, in terms of pain (p=0.003), walking ability (p=0.002), use of walking aids (p=0.004) and ADL (p=0.009).

Conclusion: Our findings support the use of cemented hemiarthroplasty for the displaced intracapsular femoral neck fracture in the elderly patient.


L. Kandel R. Powell I.G. Woodgate R. Sekel

Background: A totally new double-threaded cone-shaped modular femoral stem has been designed, using rotational rather than percussive hammer insertion of the prosthesis. The vertical height, the neck length, the neck anteversion angle and the medial offset can all be adjusted after preparation of the femoral canal has been completed.

Methods: The new stem design and the technique of insertion are described. A consecutive series of the first 110 hip joints in 103 patients were followed clinically and radiographically for an average of 28 months.

Results: The Harris hip score average rose from 43.6 points preoperatively to 91 points postoperatively. The pain score average changed from 7.9 points to 42 points, respectively. Thirteen hips (11.8%) had mid-thigh pain, most of them mild. One hip (0.9%) showed clinical and radiographic signs of early loosening and was revised.

Conclusions: The short-term clinical and radiographic outcomes were encouraging. The double-threaded cone-shaped stem locking mechanism was shown to be able to withstand the torsional and vertical forces applied to a hip-replacement prosthesis.


AA. Haleem JS. Rana AR. Khan A Sarwari FN. Khan

Background: While generally aware about other infectious diseases, few realize the threats posed by Hepatitis C. We assessed if the Orthopedic surgery residents have adequate knowledge and wheather they take necessary precautions when exposed clinically to Hepatitis C.

Methods: A pre coded structured questionnaire was administered to Orthopedic surgery residents from three provinces and seven cities of Pakistan, who were participating in the Annual Orthopedic Review Course at the Aga Khan University hospital. Unprompted questions, focused on key knowledge issues, while beliefs and practices were assessed through knowledge and attitude towards Hepatitis C infectivity, complications, therapeutic modalities, actual precautions taken by them while handling body secretions of the patients. and their reading habbits about the literature of this disease.

Results: The median number of surgeries participated in, by the forty-three residents was 150 in the last one year. Though 83% knew that there was no vaccine for HCV, majority (66%) was unaware that it is a sexually transmitted disease and 82% did not know about its possibility of being transmitted perinatally. Eighty-eight percent knew about its transmission through a needle prick injury but 71% of the residents were unaware of the fact that in the case of the needle prick, highest risk of acquisition is of HCV when compared to HBV and HIV. In practices, 74% were vaccinated for HBV. When handling a known case of HCV, 87% used an extra pair of gloves while only 50% took extra care with needles. Median number of needle pricks was one in last one year. Only 16% knew the serostatus of the patients they received injury from. Only 28% of the residents knew their own serostatus for HCV compared to 60% for HBV. 60% of these residents were in habit of handling needles with their hands. Knowledge of HCV did not diff

Conclusion: Changing the attitude of the health care workers towards HCV has become increasingly important. We suggest that all new residents should be given a pretest, a lecture, a demonstration of the standard precautions and infection control procedures with post test, in the beginning of their carriers.


K. Yang

Congenital pseudarthrosis of the lower limb is not uncommon, with an incidence of approximately 1 in 150,000.

In contrast, isolated congenital pseudarthrosis of the fibula without tibial involvement is a very rare. There were only 11 cases of true isolated congenital pseudarthrosis of the fibula described in the English literature till 1999. We describe 3 patients diagnosed and treated in our institution. The current management is also discussed, highlighting the unique treatment options in this rare condition.


P.V. Madsen G.I. Bain R.J. Heptinstall

Purpose: To review a clinical series of patients who have had the SLAC (scapho-lunate advanced collapse) procedure.

Method: 50 patients with degenerative disorders of the wrist managed by a single surgeon using a single technique. The technique involved excision of the scaphoid and radial styloidectomy. Midcarpal arthrodesis was performed, and was stabilised with staples.

The patients were prospectively followed for two years.

Results: The majority of patients were satisfied with their outcome and their pain had decreased. Pre-operative flexion/extension was 39 degrees/38 degrees and post-operatively was 32 degrees/35 degrees. The average grip strength did not change.

Conclusion: The SLAC wrist procedure is a useful technique for patients who have localised degenerative arthritis of the wrist.


T W R Briggs S Mahroof L A David J Pringle M Bayliss

Background: The purpose of this prospective study is to analyse the histological results of the treatment of deep chondral defects with autologous chondrocyte transplantation in patients with articular cartilage defects of the knee joint.

Methods: Patients with articular cartilage defects of the knee joint were recruited prospectively and underwent autologous chondrocyte transplantation. Chondrocytes from a non-weight bearing area of the knee were harvested, isolated and cultured in vitro. Subsequent reimplantation involved injection of the chondrocytes into the defect which was then sealed with a porcine IIIII collagen membrane. Postoperatively, patients were evaluated at one year by clinical assessment, arthroscopy and histological examination. The presence of hyaline cartilage in the transplanted region was determined by staining with Erlich’s H & E, Safranin 0 and polarised light microscopy and by imimmohistochemical analysis with S100. Confirmation of the presence of hyaline cartilage was further assessed by examination of Type 11 collagen messenger RNA expression using PCR.

Results: Thirty four patients were recruited between July 1998 and November 2001, with a median age of 31 years (range 15–51 years). Of the 34 patients treated, 17 had right-sided lesions, 15 had left-sided lesions and two patients had bilateral lesions. Solitary lesions were treated in 36 knees with two defects being treated in one knee (37 defects in total). The defects were located on the medial femoral condyle in 22 cases, the lateral femoral condyle in eight, the trochlea in two and the patella in five cases. The defect size ranged from 1–7 cm2 (mean area 2.88cm2). The follow-up of the patients ranged from 1–39 months (mean 19 months). Twenty five patients had at least one-year follow-up. Of these patients, using the BritIberg Rating, six patients had excellent results, with 11 good, six fair and two poor. The mean Lysholin and GilIquist scores improved from 44.7 pre-op to 76.2 one-year post-op and the mean Verbal Numerical Pain Scores improved from 7.1 to 1.1. Arthroscopy revealed that the transplants were level with the surrounding surface in most cases. Biopsy at one year confirmed the presence of hyaline cartilage in 13 out of 19 cases (70%).

Conclusion: Although long-term follow-up is currently unavailable, autologous chondrocyte transplantation can provide, with careful patient selection and meticulous surgical technique, an effective treatment for cartilage defects of the knee. The histological results are extremely encouraging and chondrocyte transplantation may be the only procedure to allow regeneration of hyaline cartilage.


M. Clatworthy J. Balance G. Brick H. Chandler A. Gross

Introduction: To evaluate the medium-term outcome of patients undergoing revision knee arthroplasty with structural allograft for uncontained defects.

Methods: We followed prospectively 50 patients undergoing 52 revision knee replacements with 66 structural grafts in three institutions. An independent investigator reviewed twenty-nine knees in 27 patients after a mean of 96.9 months.

Results: Twelve knees were re-revised at a mean of 70.7 months. Two of these patients retained their allografts. Eleven patients died with their structural allograft and implants intact and were not awaiting revision at a mean of 93 months.

Failure was defined as an increase of less than 20 points in the modified HSS knee score at the time of the review or the need for an additional operation related to the allograft. Thirteen knees were deemed to be failures giving a 75% success rate. Graft resorption occurred in five patients resulting in implant loosening. Four failed due to infection and non-union between the host bone and allograft was present in two. One patient with both knees grafted failed to gain a 20-point improvement. Survival analysis showed a 72% survival at 10 years. Clinically, the modified HSS score improved from a mean of 32.5 pre-operatively to 75.6 at the time of the review. Radiographic analysis of the surviving grafts showed no severe resorption, one moderate and two mild cases of resorption. Evaluation for loosening revealed one patient with a loose tibial component, while three patients had non-progressive tibial radiolucent lines. All four patients were asymptomatic.

Conclusions: Our results demonstrated encouraging medium-term survival of allografts utilised for revision knee replacement in a group of difficult patients with massive bone loss.


O.T. Holubowycz T. Knight D.W. Howie M.A. McGee

Reported rates of dislocation after primary and revision total hip replacement (THR) vary widely, whereas subluxation after THR is not commonly reported. Importantly, it is now recognised that reported dislocation rates are likely to be an underestimate of the true dislocation rate. The primary aim of this study was to develop and validate a Patient Hip Instability Questionnaire and subsequently to use this questionnaire to determine the incidence of dislocation, subluxation and symptoms due to hip instability following primary and revision THR. In addition the associated costs, morbidity, disability and effects on health-related quality of life were examined.

A retrospective review of dislocation rates from 1996 to 1998 identified problems in determining the true dislocation rate from standard hospital and database records. Therefore, a patient-completed Hip Instability Questionnaire was developed and validated to monitor dislocation and subluxation rates. This was then mailed to patients three and 12 months following primary or revision THR. All dislocations were then confirmed by telephone interview and radiographs. Telephone interviews and patient completion of the SF-36 questionnaire were used to assess morbidity, disability and quality of life. Costs of treating patients with hip dislocation were also determined.

The response rate to the mailed questionnaire was greater than 95%. The questionnaire was shown to be a valid measure of the true rate of dislocation following THR and confirmed the inaccuracies in previous methods of determining dislocation rate based on hospital and database records. Using this questionnaire, the rate of subluxation was higher than previously reported and the significant morbidity and health care costs associated with with this complication were identified.

The use of this questionnaire will allow better assessment of morbidity and costs due to complications following THR.


K. Bose

Orthopaedics like all other branches of medicine is likely make tremendous scientific progress in the new millennium. The extent of this progress will depend on how we have done in last 1000 years. I feel it is important in a discussion of this nature to separate orthopaedic surgery from orthopaedic surgeons. Progress in orthopaedic surgery need not necessarily mean progress of the orthopaedic surgeon or for that matter the medical profession.

As an orthopaedic surgeon we have to deal with many issues such as taking care of all the patients who come our way; balancing our responsibilities to our patients and our families; fighting with the administration in the interest of good patient care and for our own economic well-being; and trying to keep up with advances in orthopaedics in order to stay, both competent as well as competitive. Unlike my generation you must deal with a host of health-care delivery systems, need to have a business acumen that rivals that of a corporate CEO and increasingly you require knowledge of coding that should qualify you as medical-records librarian. Before long you may become convinced unfortunately that medicine is really a business and not a profession. The essence of professionalism in medicine is the willingness of the physician to value the patient’s welfare above his or her own and to provide care when necessary without remuneration or at personal inconvenience. It is unselfish attention to the welfare of others and advancement of our patient interests that earns the public’s respect and trust. These in turn have caused the public to support the autonomy of medical practice, including the privilege of self-regulation. However, this trust has begun to erode. Financial return and economic security are important to all of us. But if and when the commercial ethic in medicine becomes so predominant that it is perceived by the society as greed replacing altruism, we will certainly face loss of autonomy and the ability to self-regulate. I believe that we are nearing that point when society will view medicine as a trade rather than as a profession and we will be treated accordingly.

Looking to the roots of western medicine, Hippocrates (466 to 370 BC) is recognized as the father of modern medicine. However the earliest mention seems to be in the Indian literature, the Rig Veda, the oldest book of Veda period (1500–99 BC) when the use of artificial leg as well as artificial eyes and teeth were recorded. Before the 20th Century, the practice of medicine employed little science and was mostly an art. Yet despite this its practitioners were held in the highest esteem. 100 years ago, a physician had few tools with which to work except those of compassion and caring. However, during this century a technological explosion has led to spectacular advances in medicine and as a consequence physicians are infinitely better equipped to bring good health-care to their patients. Our orthopaedic roots date back to 1743 when Nicholas Andre unveiled his splinted crooked tree. However, it was not until the use of plaster of Paris 100 years later that we moved out of the splint age. Modern fracture management rapidly accelerated during and after World War I with Sir Robert Jones espousing the principles of Hugh Owen Thomas. This was followed by the impact of World War II and subsequent war has led great advance in the management of musculoskeletal trauma.

Operative practice however came into its own with the introduction of modern anesthesia by William Morton a dentist in 1846, sterility by courtesy of Joseph Lister in 1876 and antibiotics from Alexander Fleming in 1945. These advances made the outcome of surgery more predictable and the practice of orthopaedics, in particular expanded exponentially as operative risks decreased substantially. New methodologies involving joint replacement, arthroscopy, spinal instrumentation and reconstruction following trauma were all developed in the latter part of this century. Last 30 years has sen the rapid changes in technology and it may be a good time to pause and think where all are going and take an account of our games and losses.

The Future: Developments in physics and engineering have rewarded our specialty with spectacular advances, but the changes in biotechnology by means of the DNA molecular genetic engineering and stem-cell transformation will be even more profound. This new area of biology has the potential to conquer cancer, grow new blood vessels in cardiac patients, create new organs from the stem-cells and possibly even reset the genetic code that causes our cartilage to age. Very soon we will be able to transplant virtually any tissue without fear of rejection. In the next century, when computer technology merges with biotechnology, we may be able to map the ten billion or so neurons in our brain and replace our minds with a machine.

Changes: Some of these changes in medical science and particularly in orthopaedics is already hear. It is important for orthopaedic surgeons to realise this and to prepare themselves so that they are not left behind.

Most important thing is “orthopaedic education” both at undergraduate and postgraduate level and continuing education. We must re emphasize that orthopaedic surgery means total care of the musculoskeletal system both conservative and operative. Most of us are interested in operative care because it is lucrative, and as Graham Apley use to say “Surgery in Fun” but 80% of our patients need conservative treatment. Scientific basis of our conservative treatment is appealing and is no better than the alternatives medicine providers. No wonders so many of our patients are now moving to “sinseh” and other providers, with dubious repetition.

Emphasizes in our residency is operative treatment and the residents enjoy it. Our continuation education if you may call it “Education” is sponsored one-way or other by multinational is mainly technology oriented to promote a particular product. This is not difficult to understand. These multinational are listed companies and it is not surprising that their motive is to make profit for their shareholders. Unfortunately I feel we are being caught and deviated from our goal of education and professionalism.

Type of education we are getting and type of education we need is quite different. What we need is an orthopaedic specialist with compassion but what we are becoming is a high-grade technician.

More emphasizes must be placed both at undergraduate and postgraduate level to have a better understanding of the biology of healing of the musculoskeletal system. We must emphasize on the conservative treatment and put it on a more scientific basis. We can no longer dismiss the alternatives as being substandard or even dangerous. We must therefore offer appropriate non-operative alternatives to our patients. If we do not adjust to this reality, we will be relegated to secondary status and will be called up only when operative intervention is a last resort. We are not just surgeons but we are physicians also lastly we may have gained in technology but may have lost in compassion. Medicine is both a science and art and even balance is necessary to provide good medical care. I am sure we will progress in the science of medicines but I hope we will not lose the art of medical practice. For future we must keep abreast with the new technological advances but should not forget the patient care is more than a technical achievement. As Ambre Pare said “we the physician treat the patient He cures them”.


Full Access
P. M. Brooks

The first decade of this century has been designated by the United Nations as the Decade of Bone and Joint Disease. The Decade was launched internationally in Geneva in January 2000, after almost two years of negotiations by health professionals, led principally by Orthopaedic Surgeons and Rheumatologists.

The Decade has four major aims:

To raise awareness of the growing burden of musculoskeletal disorders in society;

To promote prevention of musculoskeletal disorders and empower patients through education campaigns;

To advance research on prevention, diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal disorders;

To improve diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal disorders

The Decade offers the opportunity for all those involved in the management of musculoskeletal disorders, patient support organisations and, most importantly, patients themselves to join together to impress upon governments around the world the enormous burden of these conditions.

In Australia musculoskeletal diseases are the second most common cause of presentation to a general practitioner and the third leading cause of health system expenditure. In 1993–94, musculoskeletal diseases accounted for nearly 300,000 hospital admissions, nearly 15 million medical services and over 13 million prescriptions. Significant disability due to musculoskeletal diseases has been noted in more than half of those aged over 55 and is also commonly self-reported in population samples. Indeed osteoarthritis, the most important form of arthritis, accounts for over 5% of years lost due to disability in Australia.

Over 100 countries have now established national coordinators and governments of over 50 countries have endorsed the Decade. A National Coordinating Committee comprising representatives of the Australian Orthopaedic Association, the Australian and New Zealand Bone and Mineral Society and the Matrix Biology Society have been established. The national launch of the Decade will be held in Melbourne on April 27 with the Federal Minister for Health and Aged Care in attendance.

The decade promises to be enormously exciting for patients with rheumatic disorders with a range of new technologies that can address some of the problems posed by these conditions. The Decade offers the opportunity for all of us to work together to further the interests of our patients with musculoskeletal disorders.


M. Tsuru

Purpose: In this study, we evaluated AGEs(advanced glycation end products) based on the following points. In routine clinical practice, some patients with intervertebral disc hernia show or previously showed a high blood glucose level, similar to the state in cataract patients. This study is significant for hernia therapy in the near future in context of an approach from sugar(cause),not aging(result).

Materials and Methods: Herniated intervertebral discs were obtained during surgery. We obtained human fetal (aborted) tissue and immunohistologically stained.

Results: AGEs were already exposed during histogenesis, suggesting a relation to apoptosis.

Discussion: In this study, a relationship between programmed cell death and AGEs was suggested. During the early step of glycosylation, the reaction progresses in a manner dependent on saccharide concentration and reaction time. In patients in whom the blood glucose level had been high in the past, the incidence remained high even though the blood glucose level is currently controlled, suggesting that AGEs affect a gene and the effect is memorized.


K. Nagata

Purpose: Extruded tissue specimens excised during surgery on human intervertebral disc hernia and chondrocytes established and cultured from the excised tissue were observed via electron microscopy. Macrophages confirmed by CD68 immunostaining were added to the chondrocyte culture, and observed via electron microscopy. To observe, using an electron microscope, disc hernia degeneration at the cellular level as expressed in extruded tissue from a human intervertebral disc and cultured chondrocytes, and to investigate the mechanism of spontaneous regression and the effects of macrophages.

Materials and Methods: Tissues excised during surgery were fixed in various fixatives for electron microscopy and immune electron microscopy to avoid divided and treated with collagenase, and chondrocytes were then isolated and cultured. Human heparinized peripheral blood was separated using Ficoll and cultured. After culture, macrophages were collected and confirmed by CD68 immunostaining. These macrophages were added to the chondrocyte culture and observed under an electron microscope.

Results: Chondrocytes in the hernia is extruded region markedly differed from cultured chondrocytes. The tissue extruded from the intervertebral disc showed obvious degeneration such as changes in osmotic pressure. Macrophages were observed as the mechanism of spontaneous regression.

Discussion: In a previous study, we used ELISA to measure MMP-3 levels and TIMP-1 levels in both mRNA and serum in patients, and found a correlation between the two. In this study, we observed the pathological state of a disc hernia at the cellular level. When chondrocytes from the same tissue were cultured under conditions similar to those in the intervertebral disc, the extruded tissue showed a clear difference. It was considered that membrane osmotic pressure affects intervertebral disc hernia in humans and that protein transmission occurs in endoplasmic reticulum. It was also considered that spontaneous regression is due to the infiltration of macrophages.


L.H. Chen W.J. Chen C.C. Niu P.L. Lai G.P. Huang

Injection of PMMA bone cement into fractured vertebral bodies has been used clinically and proved to be effective. However, there are concerns about thermal injury to the cord and interferece of bone remodling .The purpose of this study is to use the biodegradable bone substitute as an alternative for augumentation of fractured vertebral bodies .

Material and Methods: From April 1998 to January 2000, 10 patients(Nine females and one male, age from 55 to 74 years) with osteoporotic compression fractures were retrospectively reviewed. The level of compression fracture mostly occurred at T12-L1 (Nine of ten cases). Eight of the ten cases were osteonecrosis of vertebral body with vaccum phenomenon. While other two cases had gross kyphotic deformity. Surgical indications for these ten patients include back pain, progressive kyphosis and failure of conservative medical treatment. (No neurological deficits were noted in all ten cases.) All ten cases underwent posterior instrumentation with vertebroplasty (Bipedicle impaction of osteoset and iliac bone autograft). The anterior body height and the kyphotic angle were measured preoperatively and postoperatively. The fusion mass was observed and followed up with T-L spine AP and Lateral X-ray regularly.

Result: The anterior body height increased over 50% in all cases in this series. The average correction of kyphosis angle is 10 degree. Stable arthrodesis with obvious fusion mass occurred in all patients under X-ray image. Postoperative pain relief were noted in all ten patients. No major complications were related to this procedure.

Conclusion: This preliminary study shows that vertebroplasty using osteoconductive biodegradable bone substitute and osteoinductive iliac bone autograft in osteoporotic compression fracture with osteonecrosis is feasable and effective. The technique might also provide an alternative for treatment of osteoporotic compression fractures instead of PMMA bone cement.


H. Yamamoto

Vertebroplasty is a radiologically guided therapeutic procedure that consists of percutaneous injection of surgical cement into unhealthy vertebra. Vertebroplasty originated from radiologists in Europe to stabilize malignant vertebral tumor by injecting PMMA cement (polymethyI methaerylate) percutaneously with a fluoroscopic guidance. With the achievement of an analgesic effect associated with vertebral reinforcement, Gangi (1996) and other radiologists (1998) extended the use of percutaneous injection of PMMA to the patients with spinal osteoporosis.

Since 1991, the authors have developed biomechanical augmentation of osteoporotic vertebral fractures by injecting self-hardening bioactive calcium phosphate paste, and reported in 1995 that the increased mechanical strength and osteoconductivity of the surrounding bone were achieved by the augmentation by bioactive calcium phosphate cement in the experimentally induced osteoporotic animals. In 1998, the authors reported clinical experiences of repair of osteoporotic vertebral fracture using transpedicular injection of calcium phosphate paste in 15 patients with fresh fracture or with vertebral pseudoarthrosis.

Various kinds of bone-substitutes including hydroxyapatite, calcium phosphate, carbonate and others have been currently utilized to stabilize the fractured osteoporotic vertebra. As the number of the patients with osteoporotic vertebral fracture is increasing with growing elderly population, the repairing of the spinal osteoporosis using biomaterials will be needed more and more. The current treatment and the future’s task will be discussed.


R.M. Lin S.H. Yen C.Y. Yang K. Lai

Since September 1999, a total of 45 senile patients with vertebral compression fractures have been randomly selected for this study. Three treatment modalities were performed including the medical treatment only(15; control group), PMMA cement(15; PMMA group) and HA cement(15; HA group) augmentation. The transpedicular injections of PMMA and HA cements were performed on the latter two groups respectively via posterior approach.

For all these patients, the subjective feeling and physical performance were evaluated by questionnaire (Modified Oswestry Questionnaire). The preop and postop X-rays, CT, bone density and bone markers were performed regularly for comparison and analysis.

In general, the subjective feeling and physical performance had at least one grade improvement. Even though the short-term results using questionnaire did not have significant differences among these three groups, many parameters did show the advantages of using cements. The back pain, self-esteem and quality of life resolved much earlier and persistent than that of control group. The non-progression in local kyphosis was also noted in the cement groups.

In addition, there were no significant differences between PMMA and HA cement groups. Both could be regarded as effective and reliable. However, due to the unique biological properties, HA cement is more promising in the future management of osteoporotic fractures.


Full Access
G. Sutherland

The human genome project is the largest focussed project ever undertaken in human biology. Its initial aims were to determine the sequence of the 3 billion organic bases which form the genetic code, and to identify all genes. The draft version of the sequence was published in February 2001. Perhaps the most surprising outcome of this was the finding that humans have only have around 35,000 genes, fewer than early estimates had suggested. Approximately 75% of the genome is ‘intergenic’ with 25% forming the components of genes. The advent of the sequence will allow the ready isolation of genes for rare diseases much more rapidly than in the past. The project will not be completed until the functions of all genes and their roles in human health and disease have been determined. The common variant forms of all genes should be known by about 2003. Arising from this will be knowledge of the interactions of an individual’s genome with the environment and this will reveal susceptibility to common diseases. Predictive medicine will be the ability to determine, from genetic testing, those diseases which an individual has increased risk of developing later in life. Knowledge of the genes involved in disease susceptibility will provide a range of new targets for the development of drugs to prevent and treat disease. Testing for susceptibility genes for common diseases will allow specific strategies to be developed to delay their onset, and new drugs will be developed to allow specific treatments.


J. Park

Introduction: The effect of facet tropism on the development of lumbar disc diseases has been investigated but is still controversy; moreover, there has been no study to be done on far lateral lumbar disc herniation (LDH). In the current study, the authors attempted to determine the differences of the degree of facet tropism and the degree of disc degeneration between far lateral and posterolateral LDHs. In addition, the effect of the difference of degree of facet tropism and the degree of disc degeneration on the development of far lateral LDH was investigated compared with posterolateral LDH.

Methods: 38 LDHs (far lateral, n = 19; posterolateral, n = 19) who underwent posterior open discectomy or paraspinal approach were included in this study. The mean age was 52.3 years in far lateral LDH and 45.3 years in posterolateral LDH. The degrees of facet tropism and disc degeneration were measured at herniated disc level using MRI, and compared for the two different types of LDHs. Mann-Whitney U test and Spearman test were used for analysis.

Results: There were significant statistical differences in the degree of facet tropism and the degree of disc degeneration. There was no significant correlation between the degree of facet tropism and the degree of disc degeneration in far lateral LDH.

Discussion: The current study suggests that the differences of the degree of facet tropism and the degree of disc degeneration might be considered as the key factors to determine the development of far lateral LDH compared with posterolateral LDH.


D. Hamblen

The Instructional Lecture will emphasise the advantages of multidisciplinary management for musculoskeletal tumours, which have produced marked improvement in survival rates in the past 10–15 years. The roles and contributions of individual team members in relation to the overall coordinated approach, which can be provided from a single Specialist Centre, or as a managed Clinical Network.

Clinical examples will be used to illustrate the advantages of this approach to the clinical management of these uncommon and challenging conditions. These will include aggressive benign giant cell tumour, malignant osteosarcoma, chondrosarcoma with pathological fracture, and a malignant fibrous histiocytoma of soft tissue.


M. Gross R. Mohan

Introduction: Good results have been reported with curettage and cementation in the treatment of giant cell tumours of bone. There is a fear of potential degenerative changes with the long-term presence of methyl methacrylate in a weight bearing subchondral location.

Purpose of the study: To prospectively study the effectiveness of treatment of giant cell tumours by curettage, high speed burring and cementation.

Patients and methods: A single surgeon treated 37 giant cell tumours with meticulous curettage and high speed burring followed by cementation of the resulting cavity. The tumours were graded radiologically after the method of Campanacci et al. All the patients were prospectively followed up clinically by MSTS scoring system and radiologically.

Results: There were 22 women and 15 men with a mean age at operation of 34 years (range 17–72). 26 of the tumors were around the knee. 4 patients were Campanacci grade I, 22 grade II and 11 grade III. In 8 patients with pathological fractures, cementation was supplemented by internal fixation. Mean follow-up was 3.3 years (1.7–14). There were 4 recurrences. All the recurrences occurred within the first year. There have been no degenerative changes in the adjacent joint. All the patients scored either excellent or good in the MSTS scoring system.

Conclusions: Curettage, high speed burring followed by cementation is a useful method in the treatment of giant cell tumours. The advantages include relatively low recurrence rate (10% in our series), immediate stability allowing early mobilization and easier and early radiological diagnosis of recurrence.


S. Osaka A. Kuwabara M. Toriyama Y. Yoshida H. Kawano J. Ryu

It is frequently difficult to diagnose and treat of malignant sacral bone tumors. This tumor is diagnosed with lumbar disc hernia, instability coccygitis, hemorrhoids. We reviewed the surgical treatment of primary malignant (14) and secondary (metastatic) sacral tumors (11) in 25 patients from 1983 to 2000. Primary tumors consisted of chordoma in 11 patients, chordoma with spindle cell sarcoma, malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor (MPNST), giant cell tumor of bone in 1 patient each. The secondary tumors consisted of invading carcinoma in 7 patients, metastatic carcinoma in 4 patients. Location of the sacral tumor was showed total sacrum in 2 patients, below S2 in 18, S3 in 2 and S4 in 3. Preserving nerves were L5 in 1 patient, S1 in 17, S2 in 2, S3 in 3, and 2 performed curettage. Posterior approach was used in 8 patients, and an anterior and posterior combined approach in 17. Sacrectomy only in 7 patients, and sacrectomy and colostomy in 8, including with rectum was performed in 8, and 2 patients had extensive curettage and bone graft or hydroxyapatite (HA) transplantation. Six tumor excisions were used modified T-saw which pass through the sacral canal preserving nerve roots. Surgical margin of chordoma in primary sacral tumors had wide in 10, wide excision with partial contamination in 2, except curettage in 1. MPNST had curettage and giant cell tumor of bone had marginal in 1 each. Secondary sacral tumors had wide in 9, marginal in 2.

Adjuvant therapy was used radiation therapy in 3 patients and chemotherapy in 2 and ethanol in 1. Musculocutaneous flap was reconstracted tensor fascia lata flap and gluteal muscle flap in 2 patients. Interval between initial chief complaints and diagnosis of chordoma detected from 6 months to 10 years, avarage 5 years 3 months by rectal examination, radiogram, genital ultra echo and MRI; invading carcinoma from 2 months to 3 years, avarage 8 months, and metastatic carcinoma from 2 months to 4 months, average 3 months. Six of 12 patients of chordoma in primary sacral tumors are alive from 6 months to 18 years, average 4 years 6 months; remaining patients were died 6 month to 8 years, average 3 years 2 months, except 2 patient died with infection. The patient with a MPNST died after 2 years 6 months, and a giant cell tumor of bone had no recurrence or lung metastases in 10 years.

One of 11 patients of secondary sacral tumor (initial surgery) is alive in 14 years 6 months, remaining 10 patients died 3 months to 4 years 6 months, average 1 year 10 months, except 2 patients died with infection. Complications were much bleeding, infection, skin slough, nerve injury. We recommend better surgical method that anterior and posterir approach use above S3, and posterior approach blow S4, A modified T-saw performed an osteotomy of the pars lateral of the sacrum, proved to be easier and faster than osteotomies performed using the old method.


J.J. Costi TC Hearn NL Fazzalari

Purpose: The aim of this study was to examine the intervertebral disc (IVD) biomechanics in a sheep model with concentric tears.

Methods: Fifty two adult merino wethers were randomly allocated into two groups with circumferential tears introduced by injection with saline (group 1) or needle stick with no saline (group 2). They were then sacrificed at 0, 1, 3, 6, 12 and 18 months for biomechanical testing. An additional ten sheep were used as an unoperated control at time 0 (Group 0). Biomechanical tests on each functional spinal unit (FSU) and IVD were performed.

Results: The effect of procedure overall was significant for torsion (P< 0.022), axial compression (P< 0.014), extension (P< 0.001) and left lateral bending (P< 0.004) for both the FSU and IVD. In almost every case, both groups 1 and 2 were significantly stiffer than group 0 but no different to each other. The effect of time overall was significant for flexion (P< 0.0028) and right lateral bending (P< 0.022) for both the FSU and IVD. In torsion, twisting to the left was significant for the intact FSU (P=0.008) and twisting to the right for the isolated IVD (P=0.009).

Discussion: The results of this study show that any intervention in the disc alters the biomechanics compared to an unoperated control group. To our knowledge this has not been shown before and these findings may have relevance to any intervention into the disc in the patient.


Y. Kasai D. Shi Atsumasa Uchida

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to speculate the process of degenerative changes in the lumbar spine.

Methods: The subjects were 80 (45 men and 35 women) patients aged 39–92 years (mean, 67.2 years) with degenerative change of the facet joints who had undergone surgery. These patients were divided between two groups using Gibson’s classification in T2-weighted MR images at L4-5 or L5-S1. The patients with 3 or 4 grade were regarded as D(+); otherwise as D(−). The number of patients, age, gender and the presence or absence of painful arthrosis in the limbs in each group were examined.

Results: There were 47 (20 men, 27 women) patients with a mean age of 67.5 years in the D(+) group, 33 patients (25 men, 8 women; mean age, 66.6) in the D(−) group. Painful arthrosis in the limbs was more often observed in the D(−) group than in the D(+) groups.

Conclusion: In the process of degenerative change of facet joints, some patients did not have severe disc degeneration. Most patients in the D(−) group were men and had painful arthrosis in the limbs.


C.K. How M.A. Mmh R.U. Rs H. Aams H. Singh

Lower limb injuries are the main cause of temporary and permanent disability among motorcyclists in the developing world of the Asia –Pacific region. They cause non-fatal but serious injuries requiring hospitalisation. This study presents computer simulation of the crash behaviour of the carry basket of a small-engined motorcycle with the lower limb using finite element (FE) methods. The results suggest that the extensive deformation of the motorcycle basket may reduce the risk of injury to the lower limb. The behaviour of the basket during collision is analogous to the crumple zone of automobiles. The use of these deformable baskets is recommended for all small engined motorcycles.


C. Oh J. Ihn B. Park

Introduction: This study was designed to investigate the feasibility and advantages of minimally invasive plate osteosynthesis of tibia fractures.

Methods: In a prospective study, 24 cases of unstable tibial fractures were stabilized with a narrow LC-DCP (Limited Contact-Dynamic Compression Plate) inserted using minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosyn-thesis technique. The technique consisted of 3 major steps: 1) reduction of fracture with or without distractor; 2) pre-contoured plate insertion percutaneously at the stab incision distant to fracture site; 3) plate fixation to the tibia percutaneously inserted screw. All the procedure was done under fluoroscopic guide. Between January 1998 and March 1999, we operated 16 proximal or distal periarticular fractures, 5 segmental fractures, and 3 mid-shaft fractures of adolescents that had still open physis. 18 fractures were closed, and 4 were open.

Results: 22 of 24 cases healed without second procedures such as bone graft or correction of angular deformity. There was no infection except 1 case of superficial infection that was healed with early removal of plate. There were 3 cases of screw breakage, but no procedure was required. At the follow-up, 2 patients were healed with > 5 degree varus alignment and > 10 degree internal rotation. All the patients had good knee or ankle function.

Conclusion: The authors feel confident that the minimally invasive technique for plate osteosynthesis of tibial fractures that would be inappropriate for intramedullary nailing will prove to a feasible and worthwhile method of stabilization, while avoiding the severe complications associated with the other methods.


I. S. Rikhraj

Introduction: Nailing of the femoral shaft fractures has almost exclusively been done through the antegrade approach. This involves the use of a traction table and location of the entry point piriform fossa can be difficult especially in the obese or well-built patient. The set-up and operative time and blood loss can be considerable. We conducted a prospective study of nailing of femoral fractures, using the retrograde approach (through the knee joint) to measure the operating time, blood loss and knee function. A purpose built retrograde system was used (ART Nail ® ACE Medical Company-El Segundo, California)

Materials & Methods: Seventeen patients who had a femoral shaft fracture, either as an isolated injury, or with associated with other injuries were nailed using the Art Nail, using the retrograde approach. The patients were placed on a radiolucent table, with a bolster place under the knee joint. A stienmann pin was inserted into the ipsilateral tibia 1” inferior and posterior to the tibial tubercle. This was used to apply traction manually by an assistant. The surgical approach was to split the patella tendon and the knee joint was entered. Using a light source, the nail entry point at the intercondylar notch, 7mm anterior to the PCL, is located. The rest of the operative procedure was done according to the operative manual. Blood loss was estimated by the anaesthesiologist. A drain was inserted into the knee joint after a through wash-out and continuos passive motion was started when the drain was removed on the 2nd postoperative day.

Results: Fourteen had a single fracture while 3 had other associated fractures. The age range of was 28 to 67 years. Operative time was 60–100 minutes with blood loss ranging from 50–600 mls,with the median at 200mls. Post-operative drainage was 10–335 mls with median at 100mls. One patient developed distal deep vein thrombosis. Two patients were lost to follow-up. Union occurred at 12–20 weeks in fourteen patients, Two patients had to undergo dynamisation of the nail, one of which required a bone grafting to achieve union at 24 weeks. Two patients had a 1cm shortening of the limb and there were no malrotations. Two patients had < 5 degree medial–lateral angulation, on X-ray. At six months follow-up, fourteen patients had full range of motion at the knee joint, while one patient who had chondrocalcinosis had range of motion from 0 to 90 degrees. . The follow-up period is from 10–26 months. No patient complained of pain or instability of the knee joint

Conclusion: The retrograde approach is a safe and quick method of nailing femoral shaft fractures with no medium term effects on the knee joint.


N. Blumberg M. Tauber N. Shaha S. Dekel

Purpose of the Study: To determine the efficacy of using the Fixion Intramedullary Nail System – an inflatable, unreamed, self locking nail in humeral pathologic fracture stabilization. To our knowledge no clinical reports regarding this subject have been published.

Patients and Methods: The medical record and radiographs, of 14 patients treated with the “Fixion” Nail, since October 1999, for pathological or impending humeral fractures, were reviewed. Patients included 6 male and 8 female with mean age of 58.8 years (35–83). Skeletal survey or routine radiograms made diagnosis. Patients harboring tumors were evaluated with isotope bone scan. Loss of approximately 33% of the bone substance was the criteria for nailing procedure consideration. Nine acute pathological fractures and 5 impending fractures were treated. The fracture’s site distribution per distal, medial and proximal humeral shaft were as following: 1, 11, 2, accordingly. Nine patients were operated on via antegrade and 5 via retrograde.

All surgeries were minimally invasive using a single 2–4 cm skin incision.

Results: Excellent humeral anatomical reduction and stabilization were achieved in all patients. Reaming was needed in 4 patients (28.5%). No interlocking screws were used. Significant relief of pain and regained functionality were demonstrated. Average surgical time was 32.7 minutes (20–55). Mean X-Ray radiation time was 4.07 minutes (0.5–6.15). No wound dehisces or other complications were reported.

Conclusion: The unreamed in most of the cases, no interlocking screws, minimal invasiveness and high stabilization capacities in addition to perfect torsion resistance confer to this nail the ideal qualities to be used with excellent results in pathological fractures. Oncological patients that might be immunosuppressive due to different administered therapies could benefit from reduced postoperative infection rate because of minimizing entry point for infection.


S.J. Griffin R.L. Williams

We aim to present an 18 Month Review of one Surgeons Practice Involving 16 Patients with 3 or 4 part Fractures or 3 part Fracture-Dislocations of the Proximal Humerus in patients under 60 years of age.

Management principles include anatomic reduction, internal fixation and early movement.

The implants used in this series include:

The PLANTAN PLATE from ATLANTECH

The STRATEC 4.5 mm ANGLE BLADE PLATE

The POLARUS NAIL and various small cannulated screw systems.

3 patients were treared with minimal fixation, 5 with the AO Bladeplate, 4 with the PLANTAN plate and 4 with the Polarus nail.

Surgical Treatment, Radiographic and Clinical Outcomes will be reviewed. Anatomic considerations, surgical technique and outcomes will be discussed.


A. Tassawipas S. Mokkhavesa

A cadaveric study was done to determine the relationship of intramedullary axis of femur and the anatomical landmarks of proximal femur. The sharp tipped intramedullary rod was placed in the medullary canal from the isthmus to the proximal femur in 20 adult femoral specimens. The point of exit was measured in relationship to the piriformis fossa, tip of greater tuberosity, and mid lesser tuberosity. The center of the femoral canal axis is 1.23 ± 0.92 cm superior and medial to the pirifomis fossa, and is located 1.55 ± 0.66 cm from greater tuberority and 5.21 ± 1.28 cm from mid lesser tuberosity. The clinical relevance of this study is that the starting point for closed antegrade intramedullary rod of the femur should be 1.2 cm superior and medial to piriformis fossa in order to avoid the difficulty and complications in intramedullary nailing.


K.H. Twe K.S. Lam E.H. Lee

86 children with 87 lateral condyle fractures were reviewed. Excellent clinical outcomes in 88.9% of Type 1 undisplaced or < 2mm displaced fractures treated by simple cast immobilisation.

In the Type 2 displaced fractures (2–3mm) treated by cast immobilisation, the risk of secondary displacement was 44%

Conclusion: Undisplaced or < 2mm displaced fracture can be treated conservatively in plaster immobilisation.

For 2–3mm displaced fracture, we recommend percutaneous pinning or open reduction and Kirschner wire fixation.

For displaced or rotated fractures, the fragment should be reduced anatomically and fixed with K wire until radiological union.


A. Anil S. Kumar P. Agarwal M.R. Rao N.C. Mathur R. Kalla V. Kathju J.C. Sharma

The lateral condylar fractures of the humerus are the second most common injury around the elbow in children. Treatment of patients presenting late is controversial. We report our experience of treatment of these fracture over last thirteen years in 78 children seen between 1987 and 2000. Average age- 5.2 years ; 53 patients presented early and 25 patients presented more than 3 weeks after injury . In latter, 11 patients were treated conservatively and rest by internal fixation. Pseudovarus was observed in 30% cases on long term followup. Of 25 patients presenting late, open reduction, internal fixation with bone grafting was carried out in eight cases (those who presented between 3–6 weeks) and rest of the 17 cases were kept under observation on regular follow up. At final follow up, the cases operated late (n= 8) had preservation of 70–80 % of Flexion Extension Arc. Of the 17 cases kept under observation, 8 (showing non union) developed cubitus valgus. 9 cases (showing malunion) continue to have stiff elbow . The elbow function was better in the former group. We suggest that every effort should be made to fix the lateral condylar fragment in patients presenting even more than 3 weeks especially if the metaphyseal chunk is large, the fragment is not widely displaced and rotated and the fracture is type II Milch in a very young child (as those patients rapidly develop very severe cubitus valgus deformity with translocation of ulna).


Full Access
M. J. Chehade A.R. Krstic M. Henneberg David Netherway Amanda Abbott Robert N Atkinson

Landmines continue to be a major cause of injury to both military and civilian personnel. This has lead to various strategies including the development of anti-landmine boots and vehicles. In an attempt to assess the efficacy of these strategies various physical and computer simulation models have been developed. International assessment technologies currently rely heavily on either live animal or human cadaver testing. Both these strategies are subject to wide individual variations and major practical and ethical problems. They are therefore not employed by the Australian Defence Organisation (ADO).

A multi-disciplinary team has been assembled by the ADO to develop both a “flesh and bone” human model and a computer simulation. The biomechanical human analogue is constructed from materials that have been developed to reflect the strength properties and performance of human tissues (biofidelity). The surrogates are also equipped with various sensory devices allowing analysis of the local and remote effects of load transmission throughout the body.

In the first stage of the program Frangible Synthetic Legs (FSL’s) were developed. These FSL’s have been blast tested in the presence of “protective” boots and vehicle platforms. These tests have yielded critical information on lower limb injury mechanisms and have highlighted the failings of some of these “protective” strategies.

These frangible surrogate humans can be reproduced with great consistency and, once sufficiently evolved, should remove the need for experimental assessment on either live animals or human cadavers. Whilst the Human Surrogate technology has application in the development of mine resistant boot technologies, it is also transferable to the various aeronautic and automotive crash test injury programs which are currently deficient in model biofidelity.


I. Ok J. Chae Y. Choi

There is still some controversy about the treatment of nonunion of the lateral humeral condyle in children. Twelve patients with symptomatic long standing nonunion of the lateral humeral condyle were treated by internal fixation with iliac bone graft. The age range of the patients 8 years to 25 years. There were 10 males and 2 females. The time from the original fracture to nonunion ranged from 2 years 6 months to 13 years averaging 6 years 3 months.

The indication for surgery was pain and deformity and weakness in elbow. Follow up ranged from 16 months to 6 years averaging 32 months. Bony union was achieved in all cases. Strength of the elbow were restored in all cases. All patients were painfree in the elbow strenuous activities. Postoperative elbow motion was decreased in four patients with an average loss of 10.5 degree of the motion present before surgery. The valgus deformity was improved. Surgical osteosynthesis for long standing nonunion of the lateral humeral condyle is recommendable method.


Armis

Background and Objectives. There are various classifications to assess the degree of open fracture and each has it’s own advantages and disadvantages. We proposed a new system since we couldn’t find any which was simple, objective, reliable, reproducible and applicable in an emergency setting. We set five variables namely, skin break, bone damage, muscle injury, neurovascular impairment and the degree of contamination to make scoring. We needed to know if the proposed classification had a better reliability, was simple, objective and applicable.

Design and Setting. A proposed diagnostic testing was set to better classifying the degree and severity open fractures. Every patient with open lower leg fracture was classified with the proposed Sardjito Scoring System. The residents on duty, medical students and nurse staffs were then asked to classify them with the proposed scoring Gustilo system . The debridement reports were used to be the standard as a comparison of the classification made by the residents, medical student and nurse staffs.

Main Outcome Measurements. The classifications made by the residents, medical students and nurses were compared with the finding during the debridement to measure their reliability with kappa coefficient, sensitivity, specivity and accuracy.

Results. We had 40 patients with open lower leg fracture. We found exelent reliability among the residents, medical students, and nurses (k: 0.86 p: 0.000).

Conclusion. The proposed Sardjito Scoring system of the open lower leg fracture was so far reliable, making it reproducible and applicable.


T.L. Lincoln P.W. Mack J.G. Birch

Introduction: Current classification schemes of fibular hemimelia concentrating on the radiographic appearance of the fibula do not adequately aid management of these patients. We reviewed our fibular hemimelia patient experience to devise a classification scheme which could serve as a better guideline for management decisions for this disorder.

Method: We reviewed the records/radiographs of all patients with the diagnosis of fibular hemimelia treated at our institution between 1957 & 1996. We excluded patients with PFFD, inadequate radiographs, or whose treatment was initiated elsewhere. We proposed a clinical management-oriented classification based on the presence/absence of a functional foot and overall limb shortening relative to the contralateral side (irrespective of the relative contributions of femoral & tibial shortening, or bilateral disease). The classification (with treatment guidelines) is:

Type I. Functional foot

Shortening 5% or less (none or epiphysiodesis)

Shortening 6–10% (epiphysiodesis or lengthening)

Shortening 11–30% (1–2 lengthenings)

Shortening > 30% (multiple lengthening or amputation)

Type II. Non-functional foot

Upper extremities functional (amputation)

Foot needed for prehension (no treatment)

A functional foot was defined as one which was or could be made plantigrade and stable with at least three rays.

Results: We identified 146 extremities in 122 patients with fibular hemimelia. 117 extremities were Type I (53 IA, 32 IB, 29 IC, and 1 ID), and 29 were Type II (28 IIA and 1 IIB). Limb length inequality remained proportional throughout growth, so that the distribution between groups did not change during growth.

Twenty-four patients had bilateral involvement. Twenty of 48 feet in these patients were Type II (nonfunctional). Nine patients with bilateral involvement had bilateral functional feet; these patients were short-statured, but were Type IA functionally.

The number of rays correlated directly with function: 100% of 5-rayed, 90% of 4-rayed, and 64% of 3-rayed feet were salvaged in this series. No feet less than 3-rayed were salvaged in this group; all such feet were associated with a completely absent fibula. Thirty-six of 63 limbs with completely absent fibula were classified as Type I. Eighty-two extremities in 65 patients have completed definitive management by virtue of skeletal maturity or amputation. A total of 39 extremities underwent Syme amputation, including 1 of 30 type IA, 1 of 11 type IB, 9 of 12 type IC, the single patient type ID, and all 27 type IIA deformities.

Conclusions: This classification system correlated well with the treatment required in our patients. While the amount of fibula present correlated with limb length inequality, 56% of patients in this series with absent fibula have been managed with limb salvage. The definition of a functional foot, and the boundary between multi-staged lengthening and amputation will remain an individual decision, but our classification scheme accurately predicted the amount of deformity present and the treatment required.


Full Access
L.P. Nolte

At present, multi-modality medical imaging including x-ray, fluoroscopy, ultrasound, CT, MRI, etc. allows to efficiently diagnose and plan for the majority of surgical interventions. So far, the resulting preoperative set of diagnostic and planning information could not be directly transformed to the real situation in the operating theatre. Additionally, there is a need to improve the accuracy and safety of surgical actions.

In the past few years a novel area of research and development – Computer Assisted Orthopaedic Surgery (CAOS) – has been established. Its primary goal is to provide a direct link between preoperative planning and intraoperative surgical action through advanced image-interactive surgical navigation. In addition, the use of computer hard- and software is promoted to enhance patient treatment and care pre- and postoperatively and to provide improved education and training of surgeons as well as advanced case documentation.

In this presentation an overview of the state of the art in CAOS research and development is given. Initial focus will be on image-interactive navigation based on preoperatively acquired three-dimensional tomographic image data sets. These techniques require intraoperatively a surgeon-generated transformation between the surgical object and the associated image based virtual object, the so-called registration procedure. Medical robots or free-hand navigation systems are then used to image-interactively perform various surgical actions. In addition, a novel approach to computer assisted orthopaedic surgery will be described, in which intraoperative images, such as ultrasound, endoscopy and fluoroscopy or ‘surgeon-defined anatomy’ complement or replace preoperatively acquired three-dimensional tomographic image data. Various applications for both strategies will be presented in different anatomical areas, such as spine, hip, shoulder, and knee. Surgical interventions ranging from joint reconstruction and replacement to trauma treatment will be covered.


O. Osti

Disc degeneration in the human spine is characterised by progressive fraying and dehydration of the nucleus pulposus associated with formation of clefts within the annulus fibrosus.

These have been classified on the basis of autopsy studies into radiating, circumferential and peripheral tears (rim lesions).

Outer tears allow neovascularisation of the outer third of the annulus fibrosus and ingrowth of nerve fibres.

Correlation with discographic findings had suggested the relevance of peripheral defects in the pathogenesis of discogenic pain.

Outer annular tears are likely to be linked to tensile strain onto the collagen fibres and, therefore, may have a mechanical aetiology.

In the animal model, peripheral tears of the outer annulus were proven to induce degenerative changes within the inner annulus and the nucleus pulposus.

The increased understanding of the role of discrete peripheral defects of the annulus in discogenic pain may support the potential therapeutic effects of thermal treatment using radiofrequency waves and specially designed probes.

At present, however, no in vivo studies have been able to demonstrate healing of outer annulus defects and reversibility of mechanical lesions to the intervertebral discs by thermal therapy.

While it is highly likely that discrete defects of the outer annulus may be responsible for acute episodes of self-limiting low back pain, it is unclear if annular pathology may be as relevant for chronic disabling back pain.

Recent studies using discography and other semi-invasive techniques have suggested that the main discriminating factors between benign, self limiting and chronic disabling back pain may not be anatomical but psycho-social.

The challenge remains, in the 21st Century as in the past, to devise appropriate strategies that may lessen the socio-economic burden of back pain.

Surgery, however, is highly unlikely to play a significant role in the future.


W.T. K. Lee J. Jiang P. Hu X. Hu J.C.Y. Cheng

In Northern China, Ca intake and serum vitamin-D level of adolescents are low due to non-dairy-based diets and insufficient sunshine exposure. Maximisation of bone mineral accretion in childhood and adolescence requires adequate dietary calcium (Ca) intake and body vitamin-D status. This study focused on nutritional adaptation in Chinese adolescents under these adversed conditions by determining Ca absorption (CaAbn) and urinary calcium excretion (CaEx).

16 healthy individuals (12 girls, 4 boys) aged 9–17-y were recruited from Beijing during December. CaAbn was determined by a dual stable-isotope technique (44Ca and 42Ca) coupled with a Thermal-Ionization -Mass-Spectrometer.

Mean ± sd Ca intake, 24-h CaEx, and serum 25-(OH) vitamin D3 were 603 ±158 mg/d, 87.5 ± 59.2 mg/24-h and 13.7 ± 4.8 ng/mL respectively. Mean serum 25-(OH) vitamin D3 reached the lower normal-limit of 11 ng/mL. 24-h-CaEx (< 100 mg/d) reflected a higher efficiency of Ca retention. CaAbn was found 57.4 ± 15.4% which was significantly higher than the U.S. counterparts (25–34%; Ca intake: 925 mg/d), P< 0.05. However, CaAbn in the current study was comparable to a group of healthy Hong Kong children aged 7-y (CaAbn: 54.8%, Ca intake: 862 mg/d, serum 25-(OH) vitamin D3:33.3 ng/mL).

The study showed that growing individuals with suboptimal vitamin D status are still capable of enhancing calcium absorption and reducing urinary calcium excretion to allow adequate bone Ca accretion.


M. Kawasumi N. Suzuki

We report a femoral shaft fracture that reduced spastic muscle hypertonus of the affected lower limb of a child with cerebral palsy. The child was a five years old boy. He was borne with spastic quadriplegia (total body involvement). He could not sit, stand and walk by himself. The femoral shaft fracture occurred during physiotherapy. The injury itself was iatrogenic although the bones were accompanied by roentgenological bone atrophy. Such bone atrophy comes from disuse or low physical activity.

The fracture was treated by a hip spica cast. The femoral bone was shortened at the time of immobilization. After removing the cast, the spastic muscle hypertonus was apparently reduced. This instructive case suggests osteotomy as a new effective treatment for spastic hypertonus. Osteotomies would make few scars in the muscles and tendons comparing to lengthening of multiple tendons and muscles. In this case, osteotomies are believed to be a non-invasive treatment rather than other available operative procedures.


M. T. Gillespie

Common cancer metastases in bone include those derived from the breast or prostate.

Associated with such metastases is considerable pain for the patient, a high incidence of pathological fractures (breast cancer metastases), and complications of spinal cord compression and paraplegia.

Attention has focussed on the properties of breast or prostate cancer cells that permit them to migrate from their primary site and to invade and grow in bone. Both breast and prostate cancer cell lines and primary cancers exhibit a number of phenotypic properties in common with bone cells, and it has been proposed that these properties may contribute to a breast cancer’s capacity to establish and grow in bone. Once established in bone, these cancers may induce an osteosceloritic or osteolytic lesion. Osteolysis is also noted in the establishment of an osteosclerotic lesion that is frequently associated with prostate cancers. Thus, paramount for a cancer to establish in bone is the requirement for limited bone destruction, and the magnitude of associated bone destruction is a function of the cancer cell.

Although it has been postulated that bone destruction by cancer cells is mediated directly by tumor cells, evidence indicates that breast cancer-induced bone destruction is mediated by the osteoclast. Support for the latter include: 1) breast cancers express cytokines [such as IL-1, IL-6, LIF, prostaglandin tumor necrosis factor and parathyroid hormone-related protein (PTHrP)] which can influence osteoclast formation; 2) histologic analyses of osteolytic lesions reveal tumor adjacent to osteoclasts resorbing bone; 3) and use of bisphosphonates, potent inhibitors of osteoclastic bone resorption, in women with breast cancer metastases to bone results in reduced skeletal morbidity.

The interaction of cytokines expressed by cancer cells in the bone microenvironment and their action on osteoblast/stromal cells to induce differentiation of haematopoietic cells of the macrophage / monocyte lineage into osteoclasts is now understood. The mechanisms involved in cancer metastasis, osteoclast formation, and ultimately bone destruction will be discussed, along with the potential new therapies to limit bone destruction.


P. F. M. Choong

Sarcoma is a malignancy of mesenchymal and neuroectodermal tissue, and as such, may arise in any location in the body. It is a rare tumour accounting for less than 1 in 1000 cancers and occurs with an incidence of 1.7–2 per 100000 head of population. Disease free survival following treatment of sarcoma has increased significantly over the last 20–30 years and five year survival for primary bone malignancies is approximately 75–80% and that for soft tissue sarcomas is approximately 70%.

Early attempts at limb sparing surgery was characterised by surgery with narrow margins, complicated incisions and substantial soft tissue bruising. Not surprisingly, the risk of local recurrence was high, but this was attributed to the nature of sarcoma rather than technique, and amputation became the treatment of choice for sarcoma.

In the mid 1970’s, the importance of surgical margins was recognised and guidelines were established for achieving oncologic surgical margins. Intralesional and marginal margins alone were regarded as inadequate, while wide and radical margins were acceptable for achieving local control of disease. The advent of magnetic resonance imaging improved the level of tumour delineation and allowed more accurate preoperative planning. This together with modern chemotherapy and radiotherapy increased the potential for limb sparing surgery.

Reconstruction following tumour resection is an exciting opportunity to protect the function of the limb and the mobility and independence of the patient. There have been a variety of techniques described and these involve either biological, prosthetic or a combination of these options. Reconstructions may be mobile or rigid. Mobile reconstructions frequently utilise prosthetic joints, but at other times pseudarthroses may function similarly, e.g. hip, shoulder. Osteoarticular allografts are also used to maintain joint function following tumour resection. Prosthetic joints incorporate advances in articulation and fixation to improve longevity as many of these devices are implanted into younger patients than normally anticipated for arthroplasty, and these joints are thus, exposed to an increased risk of wear and loosening. Osteoarticular allografts are prone to degenerative changes as well as graft disintegration and infection. Allograft prosthetic composites aim to reduce the articulation problems and may also assist in fixation of the construct. Biologic reconstructions using vascularised or non-vascularised bone are a useful technique for bridging defects and for replenishing bone stock. Adequate soft tissue coverage is vital following reconstruction.

The future of limb sparing surgery will depend on our ability to characterise the biological behaviour of the tumour because this will provide more information on the response of the tumour to treatment, the potential grade of the lesion and thus, its capacity to grown and spread. By understanding the process of tumour progression, we will be able to develop better strategies for treatment. Functional nuclear scanning using isotopes that are metabolised by tumours is a technique that is currently being evaluated as a complementary form of imaging. Chemotherapy has been the cornerstone in the treatment of bone sarcomas, but remains surprisingly disappointing when used for soft tissue sarcomas. Recent meta-analyses have demonstrated only a minimal improvement in disease–free survival with chemotherapy. Novel techniques or agents are required to improve the systemic role of chemotherapy. Patient selection is important and this may relate to their risk of developing systemic spread. Prognostic factors are therefore, important for identifying patients who may be candidates for novel or intensive chemotherapy. Molecular biology is providing an avenue for characterising these tumours but despite the identification of a multitude of distinctive chromosomal abnormalities with their associated gene products, only 2 abnormalities have been shown to be of prognostic significance (19p+ in MFH, and SSX/SYT in synovial sarcoma). Surgeon education is an area where significant advances may be made. Constant reiteration is required to ensure that the principles of proper diagnosis and referral are known. Successful treatment is dependent on knowledge of the criteria for and technique of biopsy, and the principle that the team that will be providing definitive treatment should perform the biopsy. Up to 30% of limbs are sacrificed each year because of inappropriate biopsy or surgery. This figure may be improved upon with greater understanding of the behaviour of sarcomas.

A regimented, multidisciplinary approach to the management of bone and soft tissue sarcomas is likely to improve the local and systemic control of this disease.


Full Access
R.M. Walters S. Smith M.J. Hutchinson A.M. Dolan B. Vernon-Roberts R.D. Fraser R.J. Moore

Primary disc space infections are thought to occur in children because of the abundant vascularity of the disc prior to skeletal maturity, and while they generally resolve with treatment, little is known about the long-term consequences on the spine.

An ovine model of discitis was used to investigate the effects of discitis on spinal development in the growing sheep. Six-week-old lambs underwent lumbar discography at multiple spinal levels using either radiographic contrast inoculated with Staphylococcus epidermidis (inoculated group) or radiographic contrast only (control group). Plain x-rays of the spines were taken at intervals up to 18 months before the animals were killed and the spines removed for histologic and morphometric analysis.

Discs from animals in the control group were radiologically and histologically normal at all time points, and as expected there was a steady increase in vertebral body and disc dimensions. Although not all inoculated animals showed histologic evidence of discitis, disc abnormalities were evident from an early stage. In particular disc height was significantly reduced from 2 weeks after inoculation and vertebral body dimensions were significantly reduced from one year.

Infection of discs at a young age, whether or not it progresses to discitis, has a significant effect on spinal development.


W. Morrison A Penington K Knight A Messina P Meagher K Cronin D. Brown

Tissue engineering in reconstructive surgery has many potential attractions, not the least to avoid donor site morbidity and reduce the potential need for allografts and prostheses. Currently there are only two products that have FDA approval in the United States, namely skin and cartilage. Other potential products being trialled are artificial blood vessels and heart valves. The common denominator of these is that they are essentially two dimensional and relatively avascular. Three dimensional tissue engineering has three essential components, (1) cells, (2) scaffold and (3) blood supply. Cells are most easily derived from an autologous source, by conventional tissue culture where they are expanded and implanted into the required site. They are committed cells and usually a large source of donor tissue is required to obtain an adequate source of cells for reconstruction. Stem cells have the potential to grow and differentiate, they may be embryonal which introduces ethical problems or adult stem cells. Cells can be genetically engineered to produce specific growth factors for the purpose of further cell proliferation, such as vascular endothelial growth factor for angiogenesis. The second essential is a scaffold for cells to adhere to and grow. This is particularly important for the development of the vascular network. Fibrin, PTFE (Dexon) Matrigel (a form of Laminen) or collagen are the most popular forms of matrix. The third and most essential component for three-dimensional tissue engineering is vascularization. To date, most tissue engineering research involves invitro studies of cell differentiation and growth but the invivo potential is limited because of inability to transfer a blood supply.

At the Bernard O’Brien Institute at St Vincent’s Hospital, Melbourne, we have developed a model of invivo tissue engineering which involves the initial creation of a vascular core inside a plastic chamber which can be moulded to any desired shape. This construct seems to be an ideal environment for seeding of cells, including stem cells which allows them to survive and differentiate into various mesenchymal tissues. To date we have been able to generate skin flaps, fat, tissue and skeletal muscle. Although our prime interest has not been bone or cartilage it is reasonable to assume that this can be relatively simply produced in the same model from either stem cell sources or by the use of differentiating factors.


Full Access
M.S. Moon S.S. Kim Y.W. Moon

Objectives: To assess the early diagnostic procedures and results of treatment for pyogenic discitis and to propose the ideal method of treatment for it.

Materal and Methods: 35 patients underwent open discectomies : 24 males and 11 females. 34 had single level and one had two-level discectomies. Blood were analysed on pre- and postop 3rd, 7th, 14th days, and 6 weeks. MRI exam in 6 patients and bone scintigraphy in 3 were done. Clinical symptoms of infection was observed on the postop 7 day on average. The characteristic features were back pain with muscle spasm, muscle cramping in legs, malaise, mild fever. 32 had conservative treatment and two had anterior radical surgery. Tobramycin, cloxacillin, and clindamycin were used for 4–6 weeks.

Results: WBC, ESR, CRP and body temperatures (BT) at postop 3rd, 7th and 14 days, and 6 weeks were checked; WBC were 11,500, 13,000, 9,300, 6,300 respectively: ESRs at one hour were 39, 50, 46, and 26mm : CRPs were 16.8, 23.5, 8.1 and 2.5. BT on average at postop 3rd, 7th and 14th days were 37.6, 37.4 and 37.2. Muscle spasm subsided together with cramping in legs 7–12 days after chemotherapy, but back pain persisted even after control of infection in most of the cases. MRI disclosed the infection in 5 of 6 cases, while in all 3 bone scans were positive. Infection was controlled in all. In 2 cases bony destruction advanced during chemotherapy, and in 2 other cases after anterior surgery infection exacerbated and spreaded to the neighbouring bone and joints.

Conclusion: Antibiotic therapy is found sufficient in controlling discitis, and surgery should be reserved for the patients without response to antibiotics.


Full Access
J. Wang K. Chang M. Wu C. Huang R. Su

Twenty-seven cases of baterial vertebral osteomyelitis during the period Dec. 1986 to Dec. 1995, were analyzed. The ages of the 13 men and 14 women ranged from 23 to 69 years. The main clinical symptoms were lower back pain and a knocking pain, with only 7 patients presenting with fever at the time of admission. Nineteen patients had white cell counts of more than 9000/cumm, and the sedimentation rate was significnatly elevated in 24 of 27 patients. Operation procedures were performed in 19 patients of which 15 patients underwent anterior fusion and bone graft and 4 patients had debridement only. One patient underwent posterior fusion 4 weeks after the anterior debridement with Harrington instrumentation. Other patients underwent bone biopsy under CT guidance and were treated by intravenous antibiotics and bed rest only. Bone union occurred after a period of between 2 months and eleven months. Surgery was indicated if an abscess was present, neurological complications occurred, instability

Pyogenic infection of the spine has been regarded as rare or uncommon. Kuloskil in 1936 reported the earliest large series of 102 cases. It may present diagnostic difficulties, as it often had an insiduous onset. Lower back pain is often ignored, and radiological changes may take weeks or months to develop. Neurological compromise can and does occur when treatment is delayed. Howerver, the increasing use of diagnostic instruments including CT scan and MR imaging has markedly improved the diagnostic rate. From 1986 to 1995 we reviewed 27 cases with proven osteomyelitis of the spine by pathology. This is a report of our experience with clinical presentation, diagnosis and surgical treatment of pyogenic osteomyelitis of the spine.


Dr. S. Rajasekaran

Introduction: The progress of post tubeculous kyphosis in children during ‘growth spurt’ is unpredictable and has not been clearly documented in literature.

Methods: The progression of deformity in 63 children treated conservatively and belonging to a controlled clinical trial was studied over 15 years.

Results: The average Kyphosis increased from 35.2 degrees to 41.3 degrees in the ‘Active Stage’ (Phase I), there was an increase in all patients. In the ‘Healed stage’ (Phase II), a variable progress continued which was more prominent during the ‘growth spurt’. In Type I, there was a worsening which occured either continuously (Type 1a; n=19.30%), or suddently after a gap of few years (Type 1b;n=6.9%). In Type II, an improvement occured either after an initial increase or a plateau (Type IIa; n=18.29%), or continuously after disease cure (Type IIb; n=9.15%). In Type III, the deformity was static (n=11.17%). The average increase in Type Ia was 24.2 degrees, Type IIb was 20;5 degrees, Type Ib was 58.4 degrees; the decrease in Type IIa was 4.9 degrees, Type IIb was 20.5 degrees and the decrease in Type III was 1.7 degrees. Overall, the growth spurt sresulted in an increase in deformity in 25 (39%) children, a decrease in 27 (44%) and no change in 11 (17%).

Conclusion:

Post-tuberculous kyphosis in children is a ‘Dynamic deformity’ which changes till skeletal maturity.

Children must not be discharged after disease cure and yearly follow up to monitor deformity is mandatory.

Surgical intervention to prevent late profress will be needed in one third of children.


M. Gross R. Mohan

Introduction: Osteochondral reconstruction following tumour resections has a high complication rate. We hypothesized that the vascularised fibular graft as a supplement to the allograft reconstruction following tumour resections would provide a biological solution.

Purpose of the study: A prospective study of the results of patients receiving large fragment allografts and vascularised fibular grafts following tumour resections around the hip and the knee.

Patients and methods: 18 patients underwent resection of primary malignant bone tumors followed by reconstruction with large fragment allograft and vascularised fibular graft. 8 patients underwent resection arthrodesis of the hip, six underwent resection arthrodesis of the knee and five underwent intercalary resections around the knee followed by a large fragment allograft and vascularised fibular graft reconstruction to span the gap left by resection. The patients were assessed clinically (MSTS scoring system) and radiologically at regular intervals.

Results: There were 14 males and 4 females, with a mean age of 26 years (12–70). Mean follow-up was 65 months (8–144). Five patients died of metastatic disease but without local recurrence. In six of the patients with resection arthrodesis of the hip, there was evidence of fracture of the allograft but without the failure of the construct. One fibula fractured but eventually healed uneventfully. There were no cases of non-union in cases of intercalary resections. All the patients scored good or excellent in the MSTS scoring system.

Discussion: Our experience clearly indicates that tumour resection followed by reconstruction with large fragment allograft and vascularised fibular graft is a useful limb salvage procedure providing a biological long-term solution with superior results when compared to prosthetic reconstruction.


M. Natsuyama K. Kumano

Lumbar disc herniations are quite common pathology in orthopedics. Percutaneous discectomy remains somewhat controvercial. It has limited indications and has not proven to be as effective as conventional or microscopic discectomy. Smith and Foley developed a new minimum invasive procedure for lumbar disc disease, Microendoscopic Discectomy (MED) in 1995.

We started MED from October 1998. Besides, we started the clinical application of MED for lumbar spinal canal stenosis from February 2000. The purpose of the presentations are to present operative technique, early clinical results and complications.

A) We operated upon 40 patients of MED from October 1998 to July 2000 for lumbar disc herniations. Male were 25, female were 15, and mean age was 38 years (15~64). In one patient, operated disc level was L2/3, in 21, L4/5, in 16, L5/S, and in two L4/5/S. Methods: We investigated: period of hospital stay, period of hospital stay postoperation, period to return to normal temperature, frequency of postop. NSAID, operation time, blood loss, period to begin to walk, JOA score, period to return to work or school, and complications. Results: The mean hospital stay was 17.9 days, the mean hospital stay postop. 9.7 days, period to return to normal temperature 1.3 days, frequency of postop. NSAID 1.1 times. The mean operation time was 105 ± 42 minutes, (65–180 min). The mean blood loss was 9.7 ± 18.5 Gm. (uncountable~ 120Gm.). All patients began to walk one day postoperatively. Mean JOA score was improved from 10.7 ± 3.8 preop. to 27.6 ± 0.9 4w. postop, to 28.1 ± 0.7 12w. postop., to 28.7 ± 0.6, 24w. postop. The mean period to return to work or school was 22.3 days. In one case, we had liquorrhea, and the damaged dura had to be repaired.

B)We operated upon five patients of decompression by MED for lumbar spinal canal stenosis from February 2000 to July 2000. Male were one, female were four, and mean age was 72 years (65–77). In four patient, operated disc level was L4/5, in one, L5/S. We will show the operative procedures by videotape. We investigated – operation time, blood loss, period to begin to walk, JOA score, and complications. Results: The mean operation time was 128+−31 minutes, (85m–170m.). The mean blood loss was 25 ± 29 Gm. (uncountable – 70Gm.). All patients began to walk one day postoperatively. Mean JOA score was improved from 15.7 ± 3.3preop. to 27.5 ± 0.5 4w. postop, to 28.0 ± 0.7 12w. postop.. There was no complication.

Discussion: The advantages of MED are small skin incision, less invasion to paravertebral muscles, short bed rest, and rapid return to work. The disadvantages are loss of deep perception and technical demands. To overcome the disadvantages, we are developping the 3D MED, and we are organizing live pig seminar biannually.

Conclusion: MED has several advantages i,e, small skin incision, less invasion to paravertebral muscles, short bed rest, and rapid return to work. We need proper knowledge and technique about endoscopic surgery, and laboratory training by live pig and cadaver. MED can be applied to the decompression surgery for lumbar spinal canal stenosis.


Full Access
S.H. Palmer C.L. Gibbons N.A. Athanasou

We analysed the histological findings in 1146 osteoarthritic femoral heads which would have been considered suitable for bone-bank donation to determine whether pathological lesions, other than osteoarthritis, were present. We found that 91 femoral heads (8%) showed evidence of disease. The most common conditions noted were chondrocalcinosis (63 cases), avascular necrosis (13), osteomas (6) and malignant tumours (one case of low-grade chondrosarcoma and two of well-differentiated lymphocytic lymphoma). There were two with metabolic bone disease (Paget’s disease and hyperparathyroid bone disease) and four with inflammatory (rheumatoid-like) arthritis. Our findings indicate that occult pathological conditions are common and it is recommended that histological examination of this regularly used source of bone allograft should be included as part of the screening protocol for bone-bank collection.


T. Briggs

Primary bone tumours are rare and account for only 1% of cancer deaths. The commonest area for tumour occurrence is around the knee. With the advent of chemotherapy and improved survivorship of patients with osteosarcoma and Ewings of the extremities, excision of the primary lesion and reconstruction has become both a viable and routine option in specialist centres.

The surgical options include; excision alone, or excision and reconstruction with Autograft or allograft, or using massive prostheses to fill the defect.

In the UK, we have developed and used massive endoprostheses to fill the defect made following tumour excision and I would like to report our experience.

The first report of the use of massive endoprostheses was by Seddon & Scales in 1949 at The Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital, Stanmore. Since then both the number primary and revision procedures has continued to grow on a yearly basis. In the year 2000 we carried out 95 primary massive endoprosthetic replacements and 27 revisions.

In terms of functional score (Musculoskeletal Tumour Soc), following excision of tumours of the lower limb including excision of the affected joint, results are superior in those patients who undergo reconstruction using an endoprostheses (87%), as opposed to reconstructions using either osteoarticular allograft (68%), or rotationplasty (85%).

The long term survivorship of prosthetic replacement varies enormously between the upper and lower limbs due to the different forces acting upon them, indeed revision for aseptic loosening in the upper limb is rare.

In the lower extremity the probability of survivor-ship of a cemented proximal femoral replacement at ten years is 93.8%, whilst those for the distal femur or proximal tibia using a fixed hinge (Stanmore Mk4) are 67.4% and 58% respectively. The two factors that have a huge bearing on this are; the age of the patient and the amount of the diaphysis of the long bone resected.

To try and improve the long-term fixation of implants we have used porous coated collars at the prosthesis bone interface. These were first used in 1988, however subsequent retrieval specimens showed only fibrous tissue ingrowth although initial x-rays were thought to be encouraging.

Hydroxyapatite coated collars were first used in 1989 and have become standard use in all endoprosthetic replacement since. Indeed, retrieval specimens have revealed good bone ingrowth and no delamination of the HA.

Another huge advance has been the introduction in 1991 of the rotating hinge for implants of the distal femur and proximal tibia.

Subsequent studies have shown a significant reduction in aseptic loosening in distal femoral replacements which have both an HA collar and incorporate a rotating hinge.

Since 191 we have also developed fully uncemented endoprosthetic replacements for our younger patients with a satisfactory outcome. These results will be discussed.

In the future we hope to make further developments in the area of the non-invasive growing prosthesis, and soft tissue attachment around prosthesis especially those of the proximal humerus and the proximal femur.


A.P. Pohl

1. The effect of removal of mechanical loads from bone. Lanyon and various co-workers studied functionally isolated avian bone preparations to which external loads could be applied in vivo through external fixation devices. They showed that the application of a rigid external fixator unloaded the bone, and that this stress shielding resulted in a substantial remodelling of the bone on three fronts: endosteal, cortical and, to a lesser extent, periosteal. The balance of remodelling was negative, resulting in a net loss of bone mass.

Similar results with rigid external fixation have been reported in other animals. These findings are consistent with what we know about disuse osteoporosis resulting from muscular inactivity and reduction in weight bearing. Clinically such bone atrophy commonly occurs: after a fracture necessitating various degrees of immobilisation; after muscle inactivity due to diseases of joints and muscle, or bed rest; after long-standing systemic debilitating disease; after muscle paralysis; and after periods of weightlessness in space.

The results are also consistent with what we know about bone that is unloaded by various fixation devices. Woo and his colleagues have shown that in intact bone, fixed with a stainless-steel plate, there is significant stress shielding and that this results in loss of bone mass. Similar results have been reported by other investigators.

Likewise, in fractures fixed by rigid plate fixation there is similar stress shielding, which again results in loss of bone substance, together with persistence of woven bone at the fracture site.

Bone remodelling is very sensitive to small changes in cyclic bone stresses and changes representing less than 1% of ultimate strength can cause measurable differences in bone atrophy after a period of months.

Experimental studies have shown that greater bone remodelling and bone loss is observed when the rigidity of fracture fixation is increased.

Progressive bone loss may occur after fixation of fractures with metal plates. This leads to an ubiquitous clinical dilemma: if the plate is removed too early, fracture may occur because of insufficient union, whereas if the plate is removed too late, re-fracture may occur because of structural weakening and loss of bone mass.

In summary, removal of mechanical loads from bone, whether it be physiological, by rigid plate fixation or by rigid external fixation, results in negative remodelling and a net loss of bone mass.

2. Effect of cyclic mechanical loads on intact bone. Rubin and Lanyon, again using isolated avian bone preparations, found that the application of a cyclic load of only four consecutive cycles a day prevented negative bone remodelling and resulted in no change in bone mass. This suggested that a suitable strain regimen prevented remodelling. Furthermore, they found that 36 consecutive cycles per day not only prevented cortical resorption, but also resulted in substantial periosteal and endosteal new bone formation over a six week period. An increase in the number of strain cycles to 360, or 1800 provided no increased benefit.

That mechanical loading of intact bone results in cortical thickening and increased bone deposition has been confirmed by other studies. Physiological loading of intact bone produces the same increased bone deposition in laboratory animals. Similar effects have been shown in humans, for example, in tennis players, baseball pitchers and cross country runners, as well as in other sportsmen.

Resection of the radius or ulna, thereby increasing the load of weight bearing in the remaining bone, has been shown to result in hypertrophy of that bone in dogs and in various animals.

Fixation of fractures with less-rigid fixation results in healing with external callus formation, and earlier weight bearing.

In summary, these studies have shown that, in animals or humans, the application of physiological levels of strain to bone, either physiologically or mechanically, causes remodelling which results in a net gain of bone mass.

3. Effect of static mechanical loads on intact bone and fractures. Using the same avian model, Lanyon and Rubin showed that static loads of similar physiological magnitudes of strain did not have a positive influence on the remodelling process. Hart, Wu, Chao and Kelly obtained similar results using external fixators. They concluded that static compression increased the rigidity of fixation but, of itself, provided no direct benefit for bone healing. Anderson studied compression plate fixation and the effect of different types of internal fixation and reported no evidence of stimulation of osteogenesis by compression. Other researchers have reported similar findings.

The effects of static compression produced at the fracture site by plate fixation have been reviewed extensively. Some investigators have claimed that compression promotes fracture healing, but there is no evidence of this from paired comparisons in the literature.

In summary, static compression does not directly stimulate fracture healing.

4. Effect of cyclic mechanical loads on fractures. Yamagishi and Yoshimura showed in 1955 that intermittent compression forces applied to healing fractures in rabbits caused proliferation of cartilaginous callus. In 1981 Wolf and co-workers reported that when long bone fractures were treated with cyclic loading, bone strength increased more rapidly than when fractures were treated by constant compression. In 1985 Goodship and Kenwright published their work on the influence of induced cyclic micromotion on the healing of experimental tibial fractures, using an Oxford External Fixator. When 500 cycles were applied per day, they found that the micromotion produced external callus sooner, namely at one week, compared with static external fixation where callus was just commencing at three weeks. The micromotion resulted in more callus formation, which extended over a wider portion of the diaphysis. Consequently, they found that fracture stiffness increased at a greater rate in the stimulated group than in the rigid group. When the animals were sacrificed at twelve weeks they found that there was increased torsional stiffness in the stimulated group, ie. 83% of the intact control stiffness, compared with 54% in the rigidly-fixed group.

These findings have been replicated by others. Yamagishi and Yoshimura, as well as Woo and co-workers, have shown that those models which allowed some fracture movement produced proliferative external callus formation. This callus was inhibited proportionally as the rigidity of the fixator was increased. Similar studies have been performed in humans. Kenwright, Goodship and co-workers showed that controlled axial cyclic micromotion decreased the time to full weight bearing, compared with rigid tibial fixation33, and further studies showed the same findings.

In summary, both animal and human studies have shown that the application of controlled cyclic micromotion to fractures promotes bone healing.

5. Summary and application. An understanding of the manner by which various loading regimes affect bone formation and fracture healing allows the treating physician to plan effective treatment of fractures. It forms a rationale for total perioperative management of patients, in terms of the choice of treatment, the choice of implant, the weight-bearing status and the timing of physical activity. It has also lead to the concept of ‘dynamisation’ of fractures and the development of second and third generation external fixators.


Full Access
B.K.S. Sanjay

Wide resection of bone tumour has become an accepted treatment in the limb salvage surgery. The reconstruction of the residual defect following wide resection is a major problem. Author had reviewed the results of five reconstruction methods. Osteoarticular graft is suitable for proximal tibial reconstruction and endoprosthesis for distal femoral reconstruction. Autograft is rarely used to reconstruct the large residual defect. Cement can reconstruct the larger defect, but it is not a suitable procedure on long term basis.

Health technology has been defined by WHO as the set of techniques, drugs, equipment and procedure used by health care professionals in delivering medical care to individuals and the system within which such care is delivered. Health technology assessment includes analyses of safety, efficacy and effectiveness, cost and cost effectiveness, infrastructure factors, social impact and fit, needs and capabilities of local health care delivery system.

The reimplanatation of resected autoclaved tumour bone graft is technically a simple, financially a cost saving and a biological solution for this difficult problem. This method of reconstruction fulfills all criteria of health technology. It is the suitable method of reconstruction in limb salvage surgery for all countries, but most suitable for the developing and poor countries where the resources for other methods are not available due to financial, technical or socio-cultural reasons.


K. Stoffel H. Engler W. Riesen A. Gächter M.S Kuster

Fracture healing results in increased markers of bone turnover and callus formation. The exact patterns of these changes after different type and locations of fractures as well as weight bearing are unknown.

Bone markers and the callus index were measured prospectively for 6 month following osteosynthesis of different fractures of the lower limb. Serum and urin samples were collected at day 0, 1, 3, 7 and after 2, 6, 12 and 24 weeks. X-rays were taken direct postoperatively and after 6 and 24 weeks. Labarotory parameters for bone formation were: bone-specific alkaline phosphatase (BnAP), Osteocalcin (OC), procollagen type I N- and type III C-terminal propeptide (PINP, PIIICP); markers for bone resorption were: free and peptid-bound forms of urinary pyridinium crosslinks (Dpd, Pyr,), N – terminal propeptides of type I collagen (NTx). All fractures healed within 6 month without complications.

Results: We present preliminary data obtained from 12 adults (10 male, 2 female, mean age 45±15 years). a great variability of bone formation and resorption markers was observed during the first two weeks, probably due to the type trauma and amount of soft tissue injury. Accelerated bone resorption, and a decrease of bone formation was observed during the first week. Thereafter, an increase in OC and BnAP was noted despite persistently elevated bone resorption markers. With increasing weigth bearing, a decrease of bone resorption markers with unchanged or slightly increasing levels of bone formation markers occured.

Conclusions: No fracture specific trends for changes in bone remodelling markers were observed. Accelerated bone resorption is followed by increased bone formation; the longer and steeper the increase on bone resorption, the later and more pronounced the increase in bone formation. For further evaluation of the relationship between changes in bone remodeling markers and fracture healing, more patients will be included into the ongoing study.


Y.S. Lee J. H.P. Hui K.Y. Loke E.H.J. Lee H.P. Hui

Objective: To determine the efficacy and safety of pamidronate combined with intramedullary rodding in improving bone mineralisation and reducing fracture incidence in children with osteogenesis imperfecta (O.I.).

Methods: A prospective pilot, open study was performed in which intravenous pamidronate was administered at 1.5 mg/kg bi-monthly to 12 children with O.I., over 18 – 28 months. The children were serially monitored for symptoms, anthropometric measurements, fracture incidence, biochemical assessments of calcium metabolism, bone mineral density (BMD), serum alkaline phosphatase (ALP), urinary N-telopeptides, and spine X-rays. Intra-medullary rodding of fractures were performed with when there was definite angulation of bones.

Results: The number of fractures decreased from 4 to 0.85 fractures/year during pamidronate therapy (p< 0.05). After 18 months of treatment, there was significant improvement in Areal BMD z scores of the lumbar spine from −2.38 to −1.76 (p < 0.05) and in the Volumetric BMD, which increased from 0.06 to 0.09 g/cm3 (p < 0.05). At 18 months, urine N-telopeptide levels (bone resorption marker), decreased from 439.7 to 222.3 BCE/Cr (p < 0.05), and serum ALP (bone formation marker) from 225.0 to 143.5 U/L (p < 0.05), reflecting reduced bone turnover. This may represent a net reduction in bone resorption, and provides a biochemical explanation for the increase in bone mineralisation. Height standard deviation scores were not affected, and there were no significant adverse effects.

Conclusion: 18 months cyclical pamidronate is effective in improving bone mineralisation, and reducing fracture incidence in O.I. Pamidronate therapy, which was safe, and when combined with intra-medullary rodding, can potentially improve the quality of life by improving mobility and preventing post-fracture deformities, thus offering new hope for children afflicted with OI.


K. Fujii T. Henmi Y. Kanematsu T. Mishiro T. Sakai T. Terai

Objective: To compare the functional results with the anatomical results of treatment for fractures of the distal end of radius in patients aged over 60 years.

Methods: The results of treatment for fractures of the distal end of radius in 25 elderly patients were evaluated retrospectively. The average age of the patients was 70 years and the average follow-up period was 24 months. Twenty-one fractures were treated by percutaneous pinning, two were treated with plates, and two were treated conservatively. All patients were right-handed. The functional results were evaluated according to the sum of demerit points (Saito, 1983), and the following three parameters were used for evaluation of anatomical results: radial tilt, ulnar variance, and palmar tilt.

Results: The latest follow-up functional end results were excellent in 52 % of the fractures and good in 48%. In the final radiographs, the average radial tilt was 20.5 degrees, ulnar variance was 3.7 mm, and palmar tilt was 2.5 degrees. The values of ulnar variance and palmar tilt were often found to be out of the normal range. Most of the patients had a satisfactory outcome, and the functional results were not correlated with the magnitude of residual deformities. Grip power was the most significant factor related to subjective evaluation. Grip power recovered 75.2 % of uninjured side grip power in patients fractured left hands and 103.4 per cent in patients fractured right hands. This difference was significant (p< 0.05).

Conclusions: A good functional outcome of treatment for fractures of the distal end of radius in elderly patients can be expected irrespective of radiographic evidence of minor deformities.


A.E.R. Wigg R. Walker J. Krishnan

Introduction: Current fixation methods for distal radial fractures usually involve immobilisation, which has been suggested to have adverse effects on wrist function. The aims of this study were to compare the clinical, functional and radiological outcomes of a bridging, and a non-bridging external fixator that did not cross the wrist joint, in the management of intra-articular fractures of the distal radius.

Methods: Sixty subjects were randomly allocated to receive a bridging Hoffman frame and limited wrist range of movement (ROM) exercises for 6 weeks, or a non-bridging Delta frame and full active wrist ROM exercises commencing at 2 weeks. All frames were removed at 6 weeks. Radiographic and clinical assessments were made at regular postoperative time intervals for 12 months with clinical outcomes including measures of pain, ROM, grip strength, function and quality of life.

Results: Preliminary clinical results analysing pain, grip strength and ROM including flexion, extension, pronation and supination at 1–6, 26 and 52 weeks postoperatively indicated that no statistically significant difference could be detected between the two groups at any time frame. Complication rates were similar for both groups. Preliminary radiographic analysis of dorsal angle, radial angle and radial length at 6, 26 and 52 weeks postoperatively also indicated that no statistically significant difference could be detected between the two groups.

Conclusion: Preliminary results of this trial suggest that no difference can be detected in the clinical and radiographic outcomes of subjects receiving a bridging external fixator with limited early wrist ROM exercises, or a non-bridging external fixator with early full active ROM exercises in the management of intra-articular fractures of the distal radius.


R. Pope

Clavicle fractures represent 45% of all shoulder girdle injuries. Although clavicle fractures are usually readily recognisable and unite uneventfully with treatment, they can be associated with difficult early and late complications. Fractures of the middle third of the clavicle represent 80% of all clavicular fractures. Traditionally clavicle fractures are treated conservatively, with surgical treatment reported as being associated with an increased rate of complications. Indications for primary open fixation include significant displacement, fracture comminution and tenting of the skin, threatening its integrity which fail to respond to closed reduction. What constitutes significant displacement, is usually not defined; nor is consideration for open reduction of displaced fractures, which are not comminuted and do not threaten the integrity of the overlying skin. This paper reports on the technique indications and use of the “Rockwood Intramedullary Clavicle Pin” and the results achieved using this technique.


Full Access
L. Chin

Clinical features and radiographic findings of three patients with dysplasia epiphysealis hemimelica (Trevor disease) are reviewed. In all patients the osteochondromatous lesions grow out from the epiphysis of the ankle joint with single lower extremity involved. The clinical symptoms, localization and roentgenogram are most important factors for confirming diagnosis. One patient presented with ankle varus deformity was found associated partial arrest of the distal tibial growth plate, surgical treatment including three arthrotomy with excision intraarthicular osteochondromatous lesions procedures, and one combined Langenskoid physeal bar excision procedure. Symptoms relieved and ankle function improvement were found in all three patients. MRI can provide further information such as: joint congruous, separation plane between the epiphysis and accessory osteochondromatous lesion; physeal plate growth disturbance conditions, and enabling precise localization and surgical treatment.


Full Access
E.H. Lee

In Clinical practice damage to the growth plate is usually caused by trauma. In neonates and infants, sepsis involving the growth plate may lead to very severe deformities as well as limb length discrepancy. The management for the child with physeal growth arrest depends on the age of the child, the site and the extent of involvement of the physis. The assessment of the extent of involvement of the physis can be made by plain x-rays, tomograms and magnetic resonance imaging. In younger children epiphysiolysis with or without an osteotomy is usually performed. In cases where is there is severe limb length discrepancy additional treatment with limb lengthening is carried out. Children towards the end of growth benefit from a corrective osteotomy. Hemichondrodiatasis is not recommended in younger children as there is a risk of physeal fracture leading to further growth arrest. However it can be used for selected cases towards the end of growth.

Epiphysiolysis with the use of interposition materials such as fat, silastic or cement has been shown to be successful for bony bars occupying less than 30 % of the entire physis. In cases where the physeal injury is more extensive recent experimental work has shown that the use of tissue engineering techniques involving the transfer of cultured chondrocytes or mesenchymal stem cells may produce better results than conventional methods.


Y. Nishijima

Posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF) enables us to perform posterior decompression and anterior reconstruction with single posterior midline approach. We designed trapezoid titanium mesh cage (TPM type N cage) to realign postoperative normal lordotic curve that prevents the progressive degeneration of the disc adjacent to the PLIF-D

Patients: We had 60 PLIFs by using TPM type N cage. There were 41 males and 19 females. The age was 52.6 year-old in average. The patients consisted of 19 degenerative spondylolisthesis, 12 multiply operated back syndromes (MOB), 16 intracanal ossifications, 5 spondylolytic spondylolisthesis, 7 unstable spines, 3 spinal canal stenosis.

Operation methods: Intracanal or extracanal approach was used. The reduction was achieved by restoring the disc heights with rotating disc shaver. The posterior 2/3 endplate were preserved to prevent the cage from sinking into the vertebral body. TPM type N cage with 13mm anterior, 11mm posterior height was used. The trapezoid shape reestablished the lordotic curvature.

Results: Mean follow-up period was 3.3 years (4.4–2.6 years). We evaluated the clinical results with Japanese Orthopedic Association score (JOA score). The preoperative 15.8 JOA score statistically improved to 25.0 in average. There was neither postoperative neurological deterioration nor contamination. Pre-operative 6.4 ± 3.2 mm disc height was statistically improved to 11.5 ± 1.8 mm. Pre-operative 6.4 ± 10.8° lumbar lordotic was statistically improved to 10.5 ± 3.9° The progressive degeneration of the disc adjacent to PLIF was identified in 7case (11%). They had no clinical symptoms.

Conclusion: Trapezoid titanium mesh cage reestablishes lumbar lordotic curvature and prevents progressive degeneration of the disc adjacent to PLIF.


O. Osti

Surgery for back pain remains highly controversial in view of the significant complication rate and the low likelihood of a successful clinical outcome.

Over the last few years, titanium and carbon fibre interbody implants have been used to stabilise spinal motion segments following sub-total removal of disc tissue. These implants offer the theoretical advantage of immediate stabilisation, avoidance of late collapse and prevention of loss of correction of pre-operative deformity in combination with other types of segmental instrumentation such as pedicle screws.

Recent long term studies have suggested the possibility of late loosening, implant migration and recurrence of segmental deformity.

A recent prospective long term study of titanium cylindrical implants for lumbar degenerative disc disease has indicated that in the presence of multi-level disease, pre-existing olisthesis and levels proximal to the lumbosacral segment, the use of supplementary pedicle screw fixation is required.

It appears, however, that despite improved radiological results, the use of interbody cages may not lead to superior functional outcomes when the surgery is carried out for non-specific low back pain.


W.J. Shen Y.S. Shen

Introduction: The nonunion rate is higher and loss of reduction is common after reduction and fusion for the higher grades of spondylolisthesis. This is due to fusion bone base deficiency and lack of anterior column support, and can be addressed by supplementing the posterolateral fusion with a posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF).

Materials: All patients had a single disc level degenerative or spondylolytic slip exceeding 25%. Laminectomy and instrumented reduction (VSP or TSRH) was performed. 86 patients underwent posterolateral fusion and 82 underwent the same procedure plus a PLIF (done by tightly impacting bone chips into the disc cavity after a very aggressive discectomy). No fusion cages were used.

Results: Presented as No-PLIF vs. PLIF. Age: 56 vs. 52 years. Male/Female: 14:72 vs. 15:67. Cases with pars fx: 44% vs. 56%. Level of slip (L3-4, L4-5, L5-S1): 9, 59, 18 vs. 4, 60, 18. Iatrogenic neurological injury: none vs. none. Deep infection: 1 vs. none. Nonunion: 9.3% vs. 2.4%. Broken screws: 6 vs. 2. Degree of slip (pre-op to post-op to 2 years): 34% to 11% to 20% vs. 38% to 4% to 8%. Patients that lost reduction: 67% vs. 18%. Disc height gained at 2 years: −0.2 mm vs. 2.3 mm. Subjective back pain score: 3.5 vs. 2.0. Greenough LBOS score: 54 vs. 62. Patients very satisfied: 43% vs. 60%. Cases with adjacent level slip: 4 vs. 4.

Discussion: Spondylolisthesis is commonly treated with a spinal fusion. The goal of surgery is to eliminate motion between the unstable segments, and mechanically it is preferable that the vertebrae fuse in as near anatomic position as possible. It has been shown that the fusion rate decreases with higher degrees of slip, with the spondylolytic types, and with severely degenerated discs. Pedicle screw instrumentation can increase the fusion rate. Reduction of the slip can often be achieved, but it is common to lose the reduction over the course of 1–2 years if only posterolateral fusion is done. Adding an interbody fusion cage can help restore the disc height and widen the intervertebral foramen, but increases complexity, cost, and may actually decrease bone contact area and compression forces. We have found that in grade II and worse slips, pedicle screw fixation alone is not strong enough to maintain reduction of either vertebral alignment or disc height. Adding a chip PLIF appears safe and effective in increasing the union rate and the disc height, and in maintaining reduction in grade II spondylolisthesis. Clinical results are better, the infection rate is not higher. In our hands, there have been no neurological injuries. This study also raises questions about the role and need for interbody fusion cages.


H. Serhan R. Ross G. Lowery R. Fraser

Introduction: The artificial disc consists of proprietary polyolefin rubber core bonded between two titanium endplates. It has been developed for the treatment of symptomatic disc degeneration with the aim of providing segmental stability and motion following wide disc space clearance. It was designed to have similar properties to a normal adult human intervertebral disc when working in conjunction with the retained anulo-vertebral tissues and the supporting musculoligamentous system.

Methods: Over 120 discs were used to biomechanically characterize the Device. Range of motion tests were designed and performed to measure the axial compression, torsional, and shear stiffness of the artificial disc and to compare this with the known values for the human lumbar disc. Pullout test was performed to evaluate the immediate and short-term stability of the inserted device by assessing the mechanical resistance to pullout or expulsion. To assess the ability of the implant to withstand average daily living loads throughout its predicted life, compression and compressive shear fatigue testing were performed.

Discussion: The device was found to replicate many of the physiologic characteristics of the in-vivo FSU. The quasi-static testing showed the device to have higher strength values than the highest in-vivo loads and displacements. Fatigue testing showed the smallest device endurance limit of 3,500N at ten million cycles.

The results demonstrate that the failure modes of the device contain sufficient safety margins to support the use of the device in a prospective clinical study.


A.A. Haleem M. Umer M. Umar

Introduction: Osteogenic Sarcoma is one of the most common malignant bone tumors in the younger population. The advances in chemotherapy in conjunction with surgery has improved the survival rates from less than 20% in 1970s to more than 70% in 1990s. Advanced imaging, better histopathological techniques, availability of bone banks and newer chemotherapeutic agents have made limb salvage surgery a viable option even in advanced stages of the disease. We reviewed the outcome and analysed the complications of patients with Osteogenic Sarcoma at our institution.

Materials and methods: The objective of our study was to evaluate our experience with the treatment of osteogenic sarcoma and to do a survival analysis. It was a retrospective study consisting of 20 patients who were treated between 1990–1998. Mean age was 17 years with equal distribution of males and females. Of all the patients, 18 had stage II b disease and 2 patients had stage III disease. The quetionnaire focused on the initial mode of presentation of the patients, their stage of disease, the type of neo-adjuvent chemotherapy used and the type of surgery they underwent

Results: Majority of the patients presented at least six months after the onset of symptoms with pain and swelling being the most common modes of presentation. Majority of our patients had open biopsies done outside our hospital and received non-uniform neo-adjuvant chemotherapy. Distal femur was involved in 60% of the cases followed by proximal and distal tibia. Limb salvage surgery was performed in 90% of the cases, while the rest had primary amputation due to the extent of the disease. Autoclaved bone, allografts, free fibular grafts and custom made prostheses were used to reconstruct the intercalary defects left by the resection of the tumor. Polyuria was our main early post operative complication followed by wound infection. Only one patient had a local recurrence and 7/20 had distant metastasis in our follow-up (mean 2.5 years). Mortality rate was 25% in our study.

Conclusion: Limb salvage surgery was performed quite successfully with only one local recurrence in all of our patients with stage II b disease. Most of our patients who developed late distant metastasis had a non-uniform and uncontrolled chemotherapy protocol which could have adversely affected our final outcome.


W.J. Chen C.C. Cheng L.H. Chen C.C. Niu P.L. Lai Tsai

Background Data: Postoperative spondylothesis had been noted for many years, first reported by White in 1977. Biomechanic effect of the facetectomy was reported by Abumi in 1992. There were few reports about the results of surgical treatment for postoperative spondylolisthesis.

Purpose: To assess the outcome of surgical treatment for postoperastive spondylolisthesis and examine the factors that might correlate with postoperative spondylolisthesis.

Materials and Methods: This study retrospectively reviewed twenty seven patients (eleven male and sixteen female), from 1979 to 1996, who received pedicle screws instrumentation and posterolateral fusion for postoperative spondylolisthesis. Average age was 57.3 years old (from 36.6 to 79.5 years old). Average follow-up time was 40.0 months (from 24 months to 72 months). The grade of fcetectomy, percentage of vertebral slipping, and disc narrowing was checked by plain X-ray. End results were assessed using the modified Stauffer-Coventry’s evaluation criteria.

Results: The mean period of postoperative instability was 49.3 months (from 6 months to 141 months) in whole group, 43.7 months (from 6 months to 129 months) in laminectomy group, 43.4 months (from 17months to 82 months) in laminectomy and disectomy groups, and 74.6 months (13 months to 141 months) in disectomy group. After an average follow-up period of 40 months, 29.6 % of patients had excellent results, 44.5% had good results, and 25.9 % had fair result. No complication was found in this study.

Conclusions: Pedicle screw instrumentation with posterolateral fusion can get satisfactory result for postoperative spondylolisthesis.


S.D. Boden T.A. Zdeblick H.S. Sandhu S.E. Heim d – Sofamor Danek

Purpose: Interbody fusion cages have met with great success as an adjunct in the treatment of painful degenerative disc disease. One of the limitations is the need for the use of autogenous cancellous bone graft. In preclinical studies recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) delivered in a variety of carriers has been shown to be an effective substitute for autogenous bone, resulting in more rapid and reliable healing than that seen in control groups. The goal of this study was to report the early results of the first human trial attempting to use rhBMP-2 in interbody fusion cages.

Methods: This study was an FDA approved IDE multicenter pilot study. From 1/97 to 4/97, 14 patients were entered into a prospective, randomized trial. All patients had single level lumbar degenerative disc disease that was refractory to prolonged nonoperative care and were candidates for anterior interbody fusion of L4-5 or L5-S1. After consent, patients were randomized to either the control group (N-3) and received autogenous bone inside tapered titanium fusion cages (NOVUS LT, Sofamor Danek Memphis, TN) or to the investigational group (N = 11) and received rhBMP-2 (1.5 mg/ml)(Genetics Institute, Cambridge MA) delivered in a collagen sponge (Helistat, Integra Life Sciences, Plainsboro, NJ) inside the fusion cages. Depending on the size, the sponge in each cage was soaked with from 1.3 to 2.6 ml of the rhBMP2 solution. Patients were followed at regular intervals with plain x-ray, CT scan with reconstruction, and a full panel of blood tests. Radiographs were reviewed by an independent blinded radiologist with fusion defined as < 5 degrees of sagittal motion, absence of radiolucent lines, and presence of continuous bone through the cages. Clinical results were assessed using an outcomes questionnaire including the SF-36 general health status and Oswestry low back specific instruments.

Results: All 14 patients were available for 1-year follow-up. No cages displaced and no further surgeries were required. Mean hospital stay was 2.0 days for the rhBMP-2 patients compared to 3.3 days for the autograft controls. Of the 11 rhBMP2 patients, 10 of 11 were judged to be fused at 3 months. At 6 months and 1-year all 11 rhBMP-2 patients were noted to have a solid arthrodesis. Of the 3 control patients, 2 had solid arthodesis and one had an apparent nonunion at 1 year. On sagittal CT scan reconstruction new bone growth was seen throughout and anterior to the cages that were filled with rhBMP-2. No patients had bone formation outside of the desired area. The control patient with the nonunion had a halo surrounding the cage on the sagittal CT reconstruction. This patient had persistence of low back pain. Compared to preop, the Oswestry scores at 3 months were decreased in the rhBMP-2 group (39 to 30) compared to controls which were increased (35 to 43) and both mean scores were similar at 6 months (28 and 27). Conclusion: The preliminary results from this clinical trial with rhBMP-2 inside interbody fusion cages were excellent and support a larger pivotal trial. The arthrodesis was found to occur more rapidly and reliably than in the controls, although the sample size was limited. In addition to faster bone healing, a major advantage was the elimination of bone graft donor site morbidity and realization of decreased hospital stay. No evidence of excessive bone formation or systemic complications occurred. Moreover, this study provides one of the first demonstrations of consistent and unequivocal osteoinduction by a recombinant growth factor in humans.


Full Access
G. Kinoshita T. Maruoka M. Matsumoto H. Futani S. Maruo

Between 1974 and 1998, 34 patients with primary bone tumors and 28 with soft tissue tumors, all located in the foot, were surgically treated at our institutions.

Of the 34 patients with a bone tumor, 27 (79%) had chondrogenic tumors: exostoses, 17; enchondromas, 7; benign chondroblastomas, 2 and chondrosarcoma, 1. This chondrosarcoma was misdiagnosed as a benign chondroblastoma at the initial biopsy. Five months after the initial curettage and bone grrafting, the tumor was recurred as a chondrosarcoma. This patient died with pulmonary metastasis another five months after the below the knee (BK) amputation. The differential diagnosis between benign chondrogenic tumors and low grade chondrosarcoma is very difficult as proposed by Mirra. Whereas the malignant tumor is very rare in the foot, the diagnosis of chondrogenic tumor should be made carefully.

Of the 28 soft tissue tumors, diagnoses were giant cell tumor of tendon sheath or pigmented villonodular synovitis, 8; angioleiomyoma, 4; ganglion, 4; hemangioma, 2; miscellaneous benign tumors, 7 and soft tissue sarcomas (STS), 3. All patients with a STS were treated by a BK amputation, a partial foot amputation or a marginal resection, and died with pulmonary metastasis. However the function of the operated limb and the emotional acceptance were better in a patient with the less abrasion surgery.

Conclusion: The majority of bone tumor in the foot was benign chondrogenic tumor. Even if the chondrosarcoma is very rare in the foot, it should be considered as a differential diagnosis to the benign chondrogenic tumors. Less abrasion surgeries for STS are recommended on the basis of functional evaluation and patient’s emotional acceptance, when the surgical margin is adequate wide.


Full Access
F. Kinoshita S. Osaka J. Ryu

Purpose: To analyze the cases with metastatic humeral tumors and to discuss treatment methods for humeral metastasis.

Methods: Forty-two cases (46 bones) with metastatic humeral tumors were reviewed. There were 23 males and 19 females and the average age was 57.4 (range 37 to 88). The common origins were lung, liver, and kidney(25/42 cases) and the common metastatic site was proximal one third of the humerus (28/46 bones). Seventeen cases were solitary humeral metastasis at the first examination and 21 cases sufferred from pathological fractures. All cases were treated for humeral lesions. The cases were divided into two groups :surgical treatment group (SG, 24 cases) and conservative treatment group (CG, 18 cases). The two group were compared.

Results: Surgical treatments included tumor resection with replacement of the endoprosthesis, tumor resection and internal fixation, and palliative medullary nailing. The plates and screws or medullary nails were used for internal fixation and the bone cement was also used. Conservative treatments included chemotherapy, radio-therapy, and brace or splint. One year survival rate of SG was 36.4% and CG was 6%. All cases of SG and 6/18 cases showed pain relief or decrease, and 22/24 cases of SG showed improvement of ADL, although only three cases of CG obtained improvement of ADL.

Discussion: The results showed surgical treatments for humeral metastasis obtained improvement of QOL. The survival rate of SG higher than CG, but the reason seemed that the surgeryies were performed for the cases with reratively good general conditions. Internal fixation with the bone cement seemed to be effective for rigid fixation.

Conclusion: Surgical treatment should be performed as possible for metastatic humeral tumors, and rigid fixation with or without tumor resection seemed important.


Full Access
T. Tokizaki S. Abe M. Hirose A. Tateishi t. Matsushita

Introduction: In the management of patients with bone neoplasm, we are confronted with various status which is difficult to treat. External fixation is useful for such status, and result in succes.

The purpose of this study is to report that patients of bone neoplasms were treated with external fixation.

Materials and methods: Fifteen patients with bone neoplasm who had treated by external fixation are an objective of this study, between 1989 and 2000. Clinical and pathological diagnosis is osteosarcoma in 7, giant cell tumor in 4, Ewing’s sarcoma in 1, chondrosarcoma in1, osteochondroma in 1, enchondroma in 1. Patients were divided into 4 groups depends on difference of indication of external fixation.

Result

Group 1. Immobilization of pathological fracture. Two patients with osteosarcoma of femur and one patient with GCT of humerus were treated by external fixation for their pathological fracture.

Group 2. Bone lengthening or correction for bone defect or deformity. We performed external fixation with Ilizarov fixator for bone lengthening following bone defect after tumor excision in 4 patients. Mean length of bone defect was 83.5 (22–150) mm. Two in 4 cases were stopped bone lengthening owing to local recurrence and progression of disease. And in 2 patients, we performed correction with external fixation for bone deformity arised by enchondroma of humerus and osteochondroma of ulna.

Group 3. Stabilization for vascularized bone graft. We performed vascularized fibular graft after wide resection and stabilized with external fixator in 2 patients with humeral sarcoma.

Group 4. Salvage of infected prosthesis. There were 4 patients with infected prosthesis. Three of them were treated by bone lengthening technique after removal of prosthesis. Mean length of bone defect was 264 (220–330) mm and mean term of fitting external fixator was 583.7 (442–726) days.

Discussion: Advantages of treatment with external fixation for bone defect, bone deformity and pathological fracture arise from bone neoplasm are mentioned as follows. It could immobilize pathological fracture that is difficult for plaster cast immobilization. It could compensate for bone defect following tumor resection. It is useful method for salvage of the infected prosthesis. Disadvantages of using of external fixation are mentioned as follows. In case of bone lengthening, it is need to perform a complete tumor control. Treatment term is longer. It is need pin site management. Treatment with external fixation is one of the useful method for pathological fracture, bone deformity, shortening, bone defect and infected prosthesis arise from bone neoplasm.


A.J. Bauze M. Clayer

The humerus is a common site for metastasis. Intramedullary nail fixation has been reported to be the best form of fixation for this disease but complications with this procedure have been reported. This study reports on the results of using a new humeral nail for the treatment of pathological fracture or impending fracture of the humerus. Twenty nine patients had 31 Austofix humeral nails, 25 for pathological fracture and 6 for impending fracture. Twenty-four nails were inserted anterograde and 7 retrograde. Cement augmentation was used in 4 patients. Adjuvant therapy was used in 26 patients. One patient was lost to follow-up. Fixation failed in six patients, two due to intra-operative fractures during retrograde insertion, one due to fracture through screw holes postoperatively, and three due to local progression of disease. Difficulties in locking the nail distally were encountered in an additional 3 patients. In conclusion, in the majority of patients, nailing of the humerus with metastatic disease resulted in a stable humerus. Retrograde nailing of the humerus was associated with an increased risk of intra-operative fracture. Adjuvant therapy cannot be relied upon to prevent loss of fixation due to local progression of disease. The longest possible nail should be inserted through the antegrade route and locked to minimise the risk of loss of fixation.


S. Abe H. Kawano T. Ishii Y. Nishimoto T. Goto

Background: For the treatment of osteosarcoma, the significance of the preoperative cisplatin (CDDP) as single agent has not been assessed in conjunction with prognostic value.

Purpose: To assess the effect of preoperative CDDP as single agent and its impact on the prognosis of the limb osteosarcoma in the multi-institutional group study.

Patients and methods: Forty-seven cases were entered for the study between December 1983 and June 1993 at cooperative institutions. Three cases were eliminated from the study because of presence of lung metastasis at diagnosis. Forty-four cases of stage IIB limb osteosarcoma treated with CDDP as initial preoperative chemotherapy were evaluated in this study. Mean age was 17.1 years old (7–29 yo.), and mean follow up periods of the living patients were 150 months (58–189 mo.). Two to four courses of CDDP (3 mg/kg, mean 2.4 courses) were administered intravenous and/or intraarterial rout as initial preoperative treatment. All the patients underwent postoperative multi-drug combination chemotherapy with CDDP, doxorubicin, with/without HD-MTX. We evaluated the effect of initial preoperative CDDP by synthesizing the results of clinical findings, radiological findings, serum alkaline phosphatase level, and histological findings. Each findings were evaluated into four grades, and final evaluation was done according to our criteria.

Results: Favorable response ((Complete response(CR) and Partial response (PR)) were obtained in 25 patients, and poor response (No change (NC) and Progression of the disease (PD)) were obtained in 19 patients. Survival rate of all patients in this study was 59.1%, and 64.0% in patients with CR and PR effects, and 52.6% in NC and PD groups. No statistical differences were found between the groups (p=0.3886). Necrotic ratios were examined in 20 patients, and average necrotic ratio was 74.5 %. Good histological response (%necrosis > 80%) was obtained in 11 patients and poor response was obtained in 9 patients. Survival rate of the patients with good histological response was 72.7%, and 44.4% in patients with poor histological response, with no statistical differences between the groups (p=0.14).

Discussion: CDDP has been postulated as one of the most effective chemotherapeutic agents for the treatment of osteosarcoma. In this study, we obtained 57% response rate (25/44) by initial preoperative CDDP administration. In this study, local response to single CDDP treatment is not significant prognostic factor. For treatment planning of neoadjuvant chemotherapy, local response should be evaluated after multi-drug combination preoperative regimen to predict patients¡Ç prognosis.


Y. Nakamura S. Ozeki K. Yasumura H. Koike M. Jinnai Y. Nohara

Introduction: The confocal laser-scanning microscope (CSLM) was recently introduced. We have invented a new transmission type of double pass CSLM. This study is the first report of valuable pathological information related to bone tumor being derived using such microscopy.

Methods: The most remarkable characteristic of this microscope is the use of two laser beams twice passing through the specimen. This laser microscope can detect signals from coloring sources such hematoxylin eosin (HE) stain and obtain clear images of the organelles. The images presented here were built up as electronic signals, processed by computer analysis, and stored in frame memory. Specimens of the giant cell tumor stained with HE were examined directly by the phase contrast mode of this microscope and computer analysis was performed. Double pass CSLM and conventional microscopic views were then compared.

Results: We successfully observed sharply and sensitively positive fine granules in our laser microscopes provided higher magnification, resolution and contrast than did conventional ones. CSLM provides high magnification, contrast, resolution and can be used to observe living cells in culture in real time. With the combination of double pass CSLM and computer analysis, clear images of the subcellular organelles of various cells were successfully visualized.

Conclusion: This study suggests that double pass CSLM is an important tool for analyzing the cellular ultrastructure, physiology, and function of bone tumor. Double pass CSLM is also a powerful new instrument for orthopedics, complementing light and electron microscopy.


A. Evdokiou M. Clayer D. Findlay

TRAIL/Apo2L is a member of the tumour necrosis factor (TNF) family of cytokines that induces death of cancer cells but not normal cells. Its potent apoptotic activity is mediated through its cell surface death domain containing receptors, DR4 and DR5. TRAIL binds also to three “decoy” receptors, DcR1, DcR2 and osteoprotegerin (OPG), which lack functional death domains, and do not induce apoptosis. The aim of this study was to investigate the cytotoxic activity of TRAIL as a single agent or in combination with clinically relevant anti-sarcoma drugs on human soft tissue sarcomas that are traditionally resistant to chemotherapy. Human soft tissue sarcomas known to be resistant to chemotherapy were taken at the time of biopsy and cultured to produce a cell line. This cell line was then tested against TRAIL, standard chemotherapeutic agents (including doxorubicin, cis platinum, etoposide, methotrexate and cyclophosphamide) and in combination. When used alone, TRAIL and/or the standard chemotherapeutic agents produced minimal tumour necrosis and this was mirrored in the clinical results. In combination, however, up to 60% necrosis was seen, with doxorubicin the most effective chemotherapeutic agent used. These results indicate that chemotherapy and TRAIL act synergistically to kill sarcoma cells and potentially opens up a new area of cytotoxic treatment for these difficult malignancies.


A. J. Andrade S. M. Lambert

Purpose of Study: In the UK locoregional soft tissue cover is more traditionally within the remit of Plastic Surgeons. Currently only seven hospitals in the UK have Plastic Surgical units within trauma hospitals so that soft tissue cover often requires patient transfer between hospitals, with associated significant delays to surgery. This study set out to identify whether the current practice of soft tissue cover by an orthopaedic surgeon was justified.

Methods: 21 patients with a mean age of 44 years (range 7–87 years) had locoregional soft tissue cover surgery since 1996.

Results: Of 15 patients with open tibial fractures 3 (16%) went on to require an amputation at a mean of 10 months after injury (range 2–21 months). The mean delay between injury and soft tissue cover was 9 days (range 0–51 days). 11 cases went on to union at a mean of 7 months (range 4–11 months). 4 cases are yet to achieve union.

Of 22 flaps carried out there were only two flap failures. One was revised successfully with a gastrocnemius flap, whilst the other required a free latissimus dorsi flap which also failed requiring an above knee amputation.

Conclusions: These results are comparable to those from Plastic Surgical units. Locoregional soft tissue cover in the lower limb is therefore still safely within the remit of the Orthopaedic Surgeon. In the present economic climate there are strong financial incentives for avoiding transfer of trauma patients to other centres for such surgery.


K. Anup

Retrograde Interlocking Nail Femur was used in 35 cases of complex femoral fractures with follow up of two yr. The cases included with gross comm. femoral frx. with ipsilateral frx. of neck femur and tibia. This technique of fixation is also used in management of pathalogical frx. of upper third of femur and also in very obeese patients with frx. shaft of the femur in which antigrade nailing is a problem because of obesity. This method of fixation is a simple closed technique to manage such complex frx. with good results. Knee movements regained in all cases accept one, malrotation were observed in two early cases of the series. Non union and implant failure was nil. Bone grafting was required in one case of highly comm. segmental frx. with delayed union.


S.H. Lin P.H. Wang S.C. Cheng M.Y. Kuo C.W. Lo L.S. Chin

Background: Reconstruction nail had developed since 1985. General indications reviewed from literatures are 1. Ipsilateral femoral neck-shaft fracture (nondisplaced), 2. Russell-Type IB subtrochanteric fracturtes (intact piriformis fossa, fractured less trochanter). Many authors did not recommend that application of reconstruction nail in displaced ipsilateral femoral neck-shaft fractures. The reason is that unpredictable femoral neck-shaft reduction and over-distraction of shaft fracture. We developed one new method for overcoming such technical puzzle to achieve one-step reduction for displaced ipsilateral femoral neck-shaft fractures.

Material: There are 24 consecutive cases were treated by reconstruction nail by the same operator in Chi-Mei Foundation Hospital from February, 1999 to June, 2000. Five of them were diagnosed as displaced ipsilateral femoral neck-shaft fractures and treating new surgical technique in reconstruction nailing. Initial radiographic assessment revealed displaced neck fracture can be classified as Garden III, the fracture morphology is vertical (Pauwell III). Average age of these five patients is 37.6 y/o. The sex distribution is M:F=3:2

Method: Provisional proximal fixation of femur is mandatory. First, we use two 5.0mm drillpit transfixed trochanter region after assure of femoral anteversion. Second, release of traction and distal locking for reduction and fixation of shaft fracture part. Third, remove application handle and use Internal rotation or other remote maneuver for restoration of neck-shaft angle. Finally, complete drilling through neck and sequent proximal cephalomedullary locking was performed by free-hand method.

Result: Initial reduction result was acceptable. There was no significant coxa-varus or coxa-brevis. Two of them had removed of implants and clinical result was satisfied. No avascular necrosis was noted in our following up.

Discussion: How to treat displaced ipsilateral femoral neck-shaft fractures in one-step was obstacle in our orthopedic practice. Abandonment of reconstruction nail just due to technique demanding purpose is very pity. We developed such technique to make patient with displaced ipsilateral femoral neck-shaft fractures treat by closed and one-step method and gained more satisfaction.


Tomoya Terai T. Henmi Y. Kanematsu K Fujii T Mishiro T Sakai K. Fujii T. Mishiro T. Sakai T. Mishiro T. Sakai

Objective: The objective was to evaluate mortality and ambulatory ability for elderly patients over 80 years with a femoral neck fracture treated surgically. A strategy for managing elderly patients with various problems is proposed.

Materials and Methods: From January 1, 1998 to March 31, 1999, 122 patients with femoral neck fractures were treated in our hospital. Sixty patients aged over 80 years were chosen from this series for the present study. The 60 patients included 50 women and 10 men with a mean age of 87.1years (range 80–97years). The fractures included 26 intracapsular and 34 extracapsular fractures. The mean follow-up period was 12.9 months. The patients were classified into three groups according to age: group A (80–84 years old), group B (85–89 years old) and group C (over 90 years old). The following parameters were evaluated: duration between injury and operative treatment, duration of hospital stay, senile dementia, prefracture and postoperative walking abilities, and mortality. Walking ability was graded on a scale of 0–4: 0, free gait; 1, gait with a walking stick; 2, gait with a wheelchair; 3, ability only to walk a few steps; and 4, bedridden.

Results: The rates of regained postoperative walking ability to better than grade 2 were 72.2% (13/18) in group A, 65.2% (15/23) in group B and 84.2% (16/19) in group C. These patients were followed until death or for at least one year. The overall mortality rates were 11.1% (2/18) in group A, 17.4% (4/23) in group B and 10.5% (2/19) in group C.

Conclusion: In cooperation with internists, medical staff and family members, we were able to overcome various problems and achieve good clinical outcomes. Cooperation of family members was needed for the elderly patients to return to where they had lived before the trauma and to improve their quality of life.


L.-P. Nolte

Orthopaedic surgeons are often found with critical procedures in trauma surgery that involve precise action on the underlying bony fragments without direct surgical access. This is exemplified by the intramedullary nailing technique, which is successfully used in many orthopaedic and trauma departments. Besides surgical actions on the surrounding soft tissues it involves fracture reduction as well as control of leg length and antetorsion angle. Distal locking of the inserted nail provides secure fixation to the bone fragments. To date accurate and safe performance of these steps remains a challenge in particular for the less experienced surgeon and can often only be achieved with extensive use of the image intensifier.

We have recently proposed a novel computer based technique, which was achieved combining intraoperative fluoroscopy based imaging using widely available C-arm technology with modern freehand surgical navigation. Modules were developed to automate digital X-ray image registration, which allows the real-time image interactive navigation of surgical tools based on one single registered X-ray image with no further image updates. Furthermore, the system allows the acquisition and real-time use of multiple registered images, which provides an advanced pseudo 3D control. Projection parameters were used effectively for intraoperative measurements on the patient’s anatomy, e.g. to determine bone axes, anatomic angles (e.g. femoral antetorsion), distances (e.g. leg length).

The system has been adapted to intramedullary nailing through the development of special stereotactic instruments and appropriate graphical user interfaces. A detailed validation of the prototype system was performed in laboratory settings and throughout early clinical trials. Currently the system is in routine use in various European clinics. Based on the resulting data the novel technique holds promises for improved accuracy and safety.


R.F. Kyle

Periprosthetic fractures are becoming an increasing problem because of the number of total joint replacements that are performed yearly as well as the increase in longevity of the patients that receive total joint replacement. the risk factors for intraoperative fracture are rheumatoid arthritis, cementless arthroplasty, metabolic bone disease, Paget’s Disease, complex deformities, and revisions. The risk factors for post-operative fracture are weakened bone secondary to stress risers, screw holes, cortical perforations and stem tip protrusion, loose implants, and osteolysis. As a general rule the surgeon should make sure that all stress risers such as cortical windows and holes in the diaphysis should be bypassed at least two times the shaft diameter with a longer stem which restores the strength of the shaft to approximately 80%. Areas of transition between stem tips and plates or stem tips and stem tips should be avoided. Cortical strut grafts over holes, windows, and in areas of transition are of value. Johannsen’s Classification with a Type I fracture being proxmial to the tip of the stem, Type II fracture being around the tip of the stem, and Type III fracture distal to the tip of the stem is of value. In a cementless implant the majority of fractures are type I with the minority being Type II and Type III. In periprosthetic fractures with a well fixed prosthesis, the surgeon should maintain the components, restore alignment, and restore function. In periprosthetic fractures with a loose prosthesis, the surgeon should revise the components,restore alignment,and restore function. Treatment options for an intact prosthesis include cerclage wiring in high fractures and the use of plating and allograft struts in lower fractures. With loose implants, treatment options include removal of the implant while maintaining as much bone stock as possible. A loose implant must then be replaced and longer stems and cortical strut grafts are options in the reconstruction. Weight bearing is delayed to allow fracture healing. With this knowledge in hand, the orthopaedic surgeon can anticipate problems and reconstruct bony lesions causing periprosthetic fracture with some confidence in his mechanical constructs.


L. Maini B.K. Dhaon

Thirty patients of infected nonunion of long bones were treated with radical resection of the necrotic bone and bone transport or compression/distraction osteosynthesis. Nonunion, infection, deformity, bone gap and shortening were all addressed simultaneously using the Ilizarov principles. There were 15 cases with bone loss ranging from 4 to 12cm (median bone gap of 7 cm), 10 cases of stiff non-union (6 of which had an associated deformity) and 5 cases of mobile non-union. The median time in Ilizarov frame was 150 days. Median follow up after frame removal was 33.5 months. Bone grafting at docking site was required in only 3 cases(10%). There were 3 cases of refracture(10%) and 3 cases of recurrence of infection (10%). The bone result was excellent in 21 patients (70%), good in 3(10%), fair in none (0%) and poor in 6 (20%). The functional results were excellent in 8 patients (26.7%), good in 12 (40%), fair in3 (10%) and poor in 7 (23.3%). It is difficult to precisely define the indications for preservation and reconstruction of severe injuries. The surgical team has to appreciate the length, disability, complications and cost of treatment. Patients must be aware of the limitations of functional results and the possible difficulty of return to work despite the reconstructive attempt.


J.S.C. Liu

A one-year-8-month-old girl who received radiotherapy and chemotheraphy after excision of embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma from left labium majus pudendi developed slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) over right hip when she was 9 years old. After mild limp had been noted for 6 months she was then referred to pediatric orthopedic surgeon and two Knowles pins were used to fix the slipping. The second case was a 17-year-old girl with Turner syndrome. SCFE developed during the growth hormone therapy and it was treated with percutaneous pinning with two cannnulated screws. The possibility of developing SCFE should always be kept in mind when treating and following these particular cases to avoid delay of diagnosis.


T. Kitano T. Komatsu T. Sakai Y. Yamano

Open reduction for developmental dislocation of the hip (DDH) is invasive and sometimes results in femoral head deformity while open reduction has been the first choice in case non-operative reduction is failed in.

We treated 3 patients with 3 affected hips using minimum invasive arthroscopic reduction method. Pre-operative MRIs represented these 3 hips had obstruction of interposed thick limbus. The average age of patients treated by this method was 23 months.

This method consists of arthrogram, arthroscopic limboplasty, and arthroscopic reduction. This series of maneuvers was able to lead unreducable hips to the reduction position.

Post-operative MRIs represented that the interposed thick limbus had been removed to the outside of acetabulum and the limbus covered the reduced femoral head. There were no signs of residual subluxation of the hips in radiographic examination.

This new minimum invasive arthroscopic reduction method have a possibility to take the place of the invasive open reduction in the treatment of DDHs with obstruction of interposed thick limbus.


M. Umer

Introduction: Developmental dysplasia of the hip is a congenital anomaly that is best treated immediately after birth. The deformity, if not treated early, usually progresses with time and becomes more complicated to treat. Its treatment in an older child requires a complete understanding of the primary disease process as well as correction of the secondary anatomical deformities which have matured at that time. In this study, we present our experience with the treatment of this complex problem in older children.

Materials & Methods: All patients who presented to us with idiopathic DDH beyond 18 months of age at the Aga Khan University Hospital were included in the study. We operated on 20 patients with 25 hips from 1990 to 1998. There were 13 females and five patients with bilateral disease. The mean age was 48 months and the average follow-up was 13 months. Patients were classified according to the Tonnis class and the acetabular index and the central edge angle were measured both pre- and post-operatively. Functional evaluation was then done using MacKay’s scoring system.

Results: There were 7 (28%) hips in the Tonnis class II, 10 (40%) hips in Tonnis class III, and 8 (32%) hips in the Tonnis class IV at the time of presentation. We were able to achieve closed reduction in five (20%) hips, and satisfactory open reduction without any bony procedure was performed in four (16%) hips. The triple procedure of open reduction, femoral and innominate osteotomy was performed in 16 hips in 13 patients. The acetabular index improved from an average of 350 pre-operatively to an average of 180 post-operatively. The MacKay score was good to excellent in 22(88%) hips and we had a failure in 1(4%) hip joint. The Severin class was good to excellent in 21 (82%) patients at the time of final evaluation. There were 3 cases of posterior subluxation and 1 case each of avascular necrosis and myositis ossificans.

Conclusions: Tonnis class and age of the patients are important determinants of the final outcome. The triple procedure of open reduction, femoral and innominate osteotomy gives the best results in an older child with DDH.


Full Access
P. Cundy R. Byron-Scott A. Chan R. Keane B. Foster

The MRC Working Party (United Kingdom) on CDH recently reported an ascertainment adjusted incidence of a first operative procedure for CDH of 0.78 per 1,000 live births, similar to the incidence before the commencement of the U.K. Screening programme. It also found that 70% of cases had not been detected before 3 months of age.

South Australia has had a similar clinical screening programme since 1964. This study determined the incidence of an operative procedure for CDH in the first 5 years of life among children born in South Australia between 1988 – 1993 (118,379 live births in total) and the proportion detected after 3 months of age.

Of 47 children identified as having non-teratologic DDH and operative procedures, 24 were diagnosed before one month of age. Some required operative intervention beyond 3 months of age despite early diagnosis. Only 22 (46.8%) had been diagnosed at or after 3 months of age 18 of the 47 had an open reduction and/or osteotomy while the remainder had arthrograms, closed reductions and/or tenotomy

The prevalence of non-teratologic DDH was 7.7 per 1,000 live births. The incidence of surgery in the first 5 years of life was 0.40 per 1,000 live births and only 0.19 per 1,000 for those late diagnosed at or after 3 months.

These results demonstrate that a screening programme can be successful, contrary to the findings of the UK MRC Working Party.


J.K. DeOrio A.W. Ware

Purpose: To determine if union could be achieved in peri-plafond tibial fractures by using a fibular plate with the screws brought all the way across to the medial tibial cortex.

Materials & Methods: Between September 1994 and March 2000, five patients were treated with this technique with autologous bone grafting with or without a tibial buttress plate. All of the fractures were within 2cm of the tibial plafond, thereby preventing adequate fixation with a tibial plate alone. The preoperative diagnoses included infected distal tibial nonunion (3 cases), a distal tibial nonunion (1 case), and distal tibial malunion (1 case). All had associated fibular involvement. The patients had undergone 12 prior operations. Their average age was 59 years. All patients healed without additional surgery and all were pleased with their procedure.

Conclusion: The difficulty in obtaining fixation of a periplafond tibial nonunion with fibular involvement was solved using rigid internal fixation via a fibular plate with the screws brought entirely across the tibia. All five patients achieved osseous union and stability and functionally were able to walk with minimal or no discomfort and required no ambulatory aides.


R. Atkinson

Over the centuries there has been a pattern of order developing from chaos in the behaviour of nations.

The 20th century has demonstrated major conflict between nations, and Defence Health has supported the core activity of the Australian Defence Force (ADF), which has been the aim of military medicine generally in all world defence forces. Preventative medicine and mass casualty treatment, as well as the maintenance of health and return to duty from minor injuries, has been a success for all traditional military medical structures.

It has been known that if the civilian population is supportive of the military effort, this is a significant advantage. The military medical assets directed in this manner to the local civilians builds bridges for lasting peace.

In 1989 the world changed, with the Cold War won and leaving the United States as the only super power. From that time, conflict has tended to be intrastate rather than between sovereign states, with a rise in communal or ethnic conflict. This situation is probably not going to change in the foreseeable future as there are no longer client states being controlled by super powers.

Since that time the Australian Defence Force has been involved in the treatment of indigenous Australian citizens, UN humanitarian missions and disaster relief. In fact the military medical assets of the ADF have been busier in the last 30 years in Military Operations Other Than War than in war itself.

The original concept of the Forward Surgical Teams developed in Adelaide was modular, encompassing a General surgeon, an Orthopaedic surgeon, an Intensive Care specialist and an Anaesthetist, and thus they were able to cover trauma sustained by most combat casualties. This module was man-liftable and able to be deployed by aircraft, by vehicle and also on board ship, augmenting existing medical facilities according to need.

This module in its varying forms has stood the Australian Forces well in Rwanda, Bougainville, East Timor, PNG, disaster relief and Aboriginal health missions.

It may be that further health modules can be developed, such as a Burns module, a Paediatric module and a Primary Care module, building on the increasing medical knowledge base, sub-specialisation and advancing technology. These building blocks can come together to form significant hospitals if necessary.

The ADF has provided first-world medicine and third-world medicine, producing a dichotomy in requirement for medical skills and technology, depending on circumstances. Being busy enhanced our logistical support systems and organisational skills. Medical experience was gained, and the foundation for lasting peace and building communities was established.

If war is considered the greatest social disease left then the pathology of war is in history. The diagnosis is easy but the treatment and prevention difficult.

Early in an emergency the military medical assets of any defence force are able to be deployed under difficult living conditions, and can provide health care for those who have survived the disaster whether it be man-made or natural.


R.F. Kyle

A new and very unstable intertrochanteric fracture complex is described. The intertrochanteric fracture with extension into the femoral neck is rare but results in an extremely high failure rate because of its instability. A ten-year retrospectic analysis of patients (246) with intertrochanteric fractures treated with a sliding compression hip screw at Hennepin County Medical center was performed. Of these 246 fractures, 20 were classified as fractures with a major intertrochanteric component with extension into the femoral neck. These fractures were similar to intertrochanteric fractures type I-IV described by Kyle and Gustilo in demographics, osteoporosis, and surgical treatment, but this new fracture fracture now described as Type V had a statistically higher rate of mechanical complications 0.0001, reoperation 0.0002, and failure of fixation 0.0001. The overall failure rate was 50%. The majority of these fractures were the result of complete collapse of the hip screw. We feel this higher complication and reoperation rate is secondary to inherent instability in the intertrochanteric fracture which extends into the femoral neck. This instability leads to cmplete collapse of a sliding hip screw result ing in a rigid device that leads to failure of fixation. This fracture complex also has a higher rate of nonunion and avascular necrosis. Although rare, this fracture must be recognized in the fracture classification of intertrochanteric fractures because of its poor prognosis. Other forms of treatment than a sliding hip screw may be considered with this fracture complex because of its high failure rate with standard treatment.


J.C.Y. Cheng S.H. Yung K.W. Ng T.P. Lam

“Subacute Synovities of the Hip”, which runs a more fluctuant clinical progress and slower response to treatment than those of acute transient synovitis, is always posing diagnostic and management challenge in children presented with acute hip pain. This study aims to identify the special features of this distinct entity, and the important diagnostic parameters in differentiation of acute transient synovitis, subacute arthritis and also septic arthritis in children presented with acute painful pain. From 1985–1999, 427 children have been admitted into our centre with subsequent diagnosis of acute transient synovitis, subacute synovitis & septic arthritis. 320 cases with full records are available for review, with 270 cases 85%) having acute transient synovitis, 35 cases (10%) of subacute arthritis and 15 cases (5%) of septic arthritis. Statistical results showed that patient having subacute arthritis different significantly from those with acute transient synovitis in terms of age of presentation & duration of symptoms before hospitalization. Moreover, patient having transient synovitis significantly different from those with septic arthritis in terms of temperature on admission, ESR and White Cell Count.


P.J. Ward G.R. Taylor N.M.P. Clarke J. Gardner

The ossific nucleus in Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip. A study of relative ossific nuceus size in hips treated in the Pavlik harness and its predictive value in treatment outcome.

Purpose

To assess the value of measuring relative ossific nucleus (ON) size difference in Developmental Dysplasia of the hip (DDH) as a potential predictor of outcome of hips treated in the Pavlik Harness.

Study Design

Prospective study of all unilateral cases (n=68) of DDH identified in Southampton by dynamic ultrasound and treated in a Pavlik harness studying changes in relative ON size and acetabular indices over a mean follow up period of 3.6 years.

Results

All cases responding to the Pavlik harness showed a progressive correction of ON size difference. Initial ON size difference was not associated with any difference in acetabular index at the date of last follow-up. Ultrasound grading of dysplasia did not affect the rate of normalisation of ON size difference.

Conclusion and clinical relevance

In patients responding to treatment of DDH in a Pavlik harness, ON size difference was not found to be a useful prognostic indicator of outcome.


K. Aoki H. Akazawa S. Mitani Y. Miyake H. Inoue

The authors added a classification of posterior pillars to Herring’s classification of lateral pillars in a retrospective study of 33 patients with Perthes disease. Anteroposterior and frog position lateral radiographs taken approximately two months later from first visit, were evaluated. All patients were treated by a non-weight-bearing method (continuous traction and wheel chair activity). The outcome was evaluated by the Stulberg method.

The mean age at follow-up was 18 years (range,14.2 to 26.9 years).

Thirteen hips were in Catterall group II, 18 were in group III, and two were in group IV. Twenty-five of the 33 hips were in Stulberg class I or II (with good results), and eight hips were class III. Nine hips were in Herring group A, 20 hips were in group B, and four were in group C. Eleven hips were in our group A with the posterior pillar classification, 16 were in group B, and six were in group C. Group A, with a lateral or posterior pillar had good results without exception. Concerning Herring’s classification, all four heads had become aspherical in group C, however, 16 hips were good results and four hips were poor in group B. The outcome was poorly related to the classification in 20 patients with 20 affected hips in Herring group B when only lateral pillars were used in classification. When both lateral and posterior pillars are considered in classification, results can be predicted more accurately than when only lateral pillars are considered. This more accurate prognosis at an early stage of Perthes disease can facilitate effective treatment selection.


Full Access
H.K.T. Raza

This paper is based on the experience gained from three recent earthquakes in India. Lature (Maharashtra 1993), Jabalpur (M.P. 1997),and Kutch (Gujarat 2001).

The importance of such studies and lessons learnt from the management of casualties cannot be under stated as we have had at least 6 major earthquakes in various parts of the world in the first two months of the New Millenium.

The uniqueness of an earthquake lies in its unpredictability. There is no warning & no time to take preventive measures. The event is sudden, takes a heavy toll of human life, leaves a huge injured population and very many trapped under the debris of fallen buildings. It also results in great fear psychosis in the injured/uninjured population as well.

Success of relief operations in earthquakes depends on:-

Preparedness for such eventualities by a clear established protocol of action before hand in earthquake prone areas.

Establishment of immediate communication links between affected area and controlling authorities.

Establishing a clear line of command from higher authorities to the rescue teams.

Immediate Co-ordination between government agencies and Non-Government Organisations flooding the area with man power and relief supplies. An effective control centre should be established for this.

Immediate mobilization of resources from nearby areas:-

Medical services.

Relief teams for removing debris to rescue trapped people.

Supply of food/water/shelters/Medical supplies.

Mobilization of Ambulance services/Helicopters for evacuation of injured patients after proper triage.

Monitoring services to keep updated statistics of injured/trapped /dead, and to constantly advise change of strategies for more effective rescue operations.

Minimize panic and boost morale of the affected population as well as rescue teams by preventing rumours of fresh quakes from circulating.

Early rescue operations to evecuate trapped people from debris/early evacuation of casualties by trained personnel in properly organised ambulance services help in drastically reducing the death toll.

Proper early management of polytraumatised victims on ATLS principles helps in saving a lot of lives in the first week after the earthquake. Systematic establishment of camps/mobile hospitals especially in remote areas further helps minimize mortality and morbidity in the second phase of relief services after the initial 2–4 days of emergency operations.

Psychotherapy of not only the injured but also the whole population is extremely important to minimize permanent mental scars which may take a lifetime to disappear.

It is important to conclude by stating that relief services require enormous manpower which should have a very high degree of motivation to perform under extreme physically and mentally stressful conditions.

Leadership is required at various levels to provide this motivation & is the key to success.

It must also be constantly kept in mind by medical personnel that the victims do not have only medical problems but far greater socio-economic and psychological problems from death in the family requiring completion of last rites, collapse of their houses & loss of all belongings & fear psychosis of further tremours.


D. Hamblen

The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery published in the A and B volumes remains the premier Orthopaedic Journal of the world. Like other specialist scientific journals it is coming under increasing pressure from the move to more electronic publication on the Internet and the wider availability of freely downloadable information. The need to move to the new technology must be balanced against the needs of the majority of our subscribers, who still require the paper journal, and with the financial requirements of a charitable based not-for-profit publication.

The paper will discuss how these pressures might be met and the plans for the redesign of our website to deliver a wider range of material, including the possibility of electronic pre-prints. The future of the Combined subscription CD-ROM will also be addressed together with the exciting future possibilities offered by the developments in digital information technology.


H. Junge T. Alfke T. Kettler J. T. Heverhagen L. Gotzen

Introduction: The role of transpedicular bone graft for the stability after dorsal instrumentation of fractures of the thoracolumbar spine is still not clear whereas the morbidity of harvesting the bone from the iliac crest is evident. In a clinical study we examined the clinical outcome, radiological signs of instability and the vitality of the bone by MRI.

Methods: We examined 45 patients who underwent posterior instrumention for fractures of the thoracolumbar spine between 1988 and 1997 and had removal of the implants more than 3 months ago. All patients had received a interspinal and interlaminar bone graft, 23 patients had received an additional transpedicular bone graft. We measured the clinical outcome by a standardized questionnaire and the stability of the spondylodesis by native and functional Xrays. The vitality of the transpedicular bone graft was examined by MRI.

Results: There were not significant differences in both study-groups concerning the clinical outcome. In both groups we saw one case with radiological signs of instability. In the MRI-examination 18 of the 23 patients with a transpedicular bone graft showed a vital graft. In 5 cases the transpedicular bone graft showed no increase of the signal intensity after contrast media which was interpreted as a avital graft.

Discussion: Although the support of the anterior column in the posterior instrumentation by a transpedicular bone graft is theoretically meaningful we saw no correlation to the clinical outcome. Considering our results and the donor site morbidity, the use of transpedicular bone graft must be discussed critically.


MS. Moon YS. Kim

Objectives: To assess the effectiveness of the two different types of C-D instrumentation constructs on the unstable thoracolumbar and lumbar spine fractures.

Material and Method: 45 fractures in 42 patients(age range, 18 to 57 years) were treated with C-D instrumentation and posterolateral fusion, and were followed up over 2 years(26±72 months). The level of injuries were T12 in 6 cases, L1 in 15, L2 in 12, L3 in 3, L3-4 in 6, and L4-5 in 3. The fracture types were bursting in 21, flexion-distraction in 15, fracture-dislocation in 9. Three had both L1 flexion-distraction and L3 bursting fractures. 9 had incomplete paralysis. Vertebral height and kyphosis angle were measured. All fractures were reduced by normally contoured rod handling without distraction or compression, and the vertebrae one above and one below the fractured spine were fused posterolaterally. 9 had posterior decompression surgery including reduction of retropulsed fragment. In 21 cases long rodding(group-I : over three level stabilization) and in 18 cases short rodding(group-II : one above and below) were performed.

Results: Fracture consolidation was achieved at 6.5 months (5±10 months). Overall fusion rate was 78.6%: 75% in Group-I and 83.3% in Group-II. In group-I average kyphosis at preop, immediate and fi nal postop follow-up were 20.3°, 7° and 11.4°, respectively, while in group-II those were 14.7°, 2.4° and 8.4°, respectively. The losses of correction in group-I and group-II were 4.4° and 5.7°. In group-I and group-II anterior body height losses at preop, immediate postop and fi nal follow-up were 45.6%, 14.6%, 17.1% and 40.3%, 15.8%, 23.7%, respecitvely. Complications were : screw breakage in group-I and II were 3 and 6 cases : plug dislodgement in 3 cases of group-I, and hook dislodgement in 3 of group-II.

Conclusion: Long rodding and posterior fusion is preferably recommended to minimize the loss of reduction.


K. Tateno S. Shimizu H. Edakuni H. Shimada H. Iizuka K. Fueki

Purpose: When we treat burst fractures, we try to preserve the movable vertebra as much as possible and see to it that the instrument can be extracted finally.

We have performed short-segment posterior spinal instrumentation and fusion (PSIF) for cases with no neurological symptoms, and combined short-segment posterior spinal instrumentation and fusion with anterior decompression and fusion (PSIF with AF) for cases with obvious neurological symptoms.

In this report, we review the postoperative results of our methods.

Methods: We have operated on 18 cases of burst fracture in the past seven years, eleven of them, who had been treated with PSIF (attachment of one level above the fracture to one level below the fracture), were selected for the subjects of the investigation. They consisted of 7 males and 4 females. The average age was 42 years and the mean follow-up of the postoperative image findings was one year and six months (range, eight months to two years and ten months). The number of the cases by traumatic ascensus was T11: 1, T12: 2, L1: 5, L2: 2. Among them, seven cases underwent PSIF. All the cases were operated on with a pedicle screw in combination with a hook. Four cases underwent PSIF with AF. In these cases, only a pedicle screw was used for the posterior, and only the bone transplantation after decompression was done for the anterior. For all cases, the angulation, alignment, and compliance were measured and examined before and after the operation using lateral radiographs, in addition to degree of improvement in the neurological symptoms.

Result: Preoperatively, the results of these cases showed that PSIF and PSIF with AF tend to cause larger damage to all of angulation, alignment, and compliance. Postoperatively, the difference in values between PSIF and PSIF with AF was small, and both groups maintained their respective values even with time. Based on the preoperative Frankel classification, the numbers of the cases undergoing PSIF were C: 1, D: 3, and E: 3. The numbers of the cases undergoing PSIF with AF were B: 1, C, 2, and E: 1. Improvement of one stage was seen in three cases undergoing PSIF. Improvement of two stages was seen in two cases undergoing PSIF with AF. No case showed postoperative deterioration of the neurological symptoms.

Conclusion: We perform PSIF with no neurological symptoms. In these cases, a pedicle screw and a hook are installed in the same vertebral body and arch to reduce the load on the pedicle screw and prevent the pedicle screw damage. AF is performed together with PSIF, and decompression is done surely for cases with obvious neurological symptoms. In these cases, a pedicle screw is used solely and no hook is used because there is a transplant bone as the prop in the anterior. At the moment, we cannot refer to the occurrence of kyphosis transformation in the future for lack of sufficient cases and length of the observation period. However, it was suggested that cases with no neurological symptoms could be treated with PSIF solely.


CH. Huang

Background: The osteolysis in revision total knee arthroplasty was observed. The purpose of this study was to compare the prevalence and characteristics of osteolysis recognized in revision total knee arthroplasties between the failed mobile bearing and fixed bearing knees.

Methods: Eighty revision total knee arthroplasties were done between 1995 and 1998. The primary prosthesis that failed included thirty-four mobile bearing (Low Contact Stress) knees and forty-six fixed bearing knees of vary prostheses. At the time of revision surgery, all the interfaces between bone and prosthesis or cement were routinely checked and recorded for evidence of osteolytic resorption of bone. Preoperative radiographs were assessed independently by two authors for evidence of focal or severe periprosthetic osteolysis. The presence of the lesion was recorded. The demographic data included age and body weight was reviewed. The interval between the primary and revision surgery was recorded. The revision technique was reviewed. A statistical technique of chi-square test was applied in this study.

Results: Osteolysis was recognized in sixteen of thirty-four mobile bearing knees (47 per cent) with thirteen knees involved distal femur and in six of forty- six fixed bearing knees (13 per cent) with four knees involved distal femur. The incidence of osteolysis was statistically significant difference between the mobile bearing and fixed bearing knees (p< 0.05). An overall 28 per cent (twenty-two knees) incidence of osteolysis was identified intraoperatively. The overall incidence of osteolysis in distal femur was 21 per cent (seventeen knees). The average time interval from the primary surgery to revision was 108 months. All the knees were affected by osteoarthritis. The most common site of osteolytic bone resorption was the posterior femoral condyle.

Conclusions: Comparing to the fixed bearing knees, the mobile bearing (Low Contact Stress) knees were at increased risk for osteolysis in our series. Osteolysis occurred predominantly on the femoral side, especially adjacent to the prostheses in posterior condyle. Radiographic evaluation of osteolysis in distal femur is unreliable.


R.W.W. Hsu

The bone mineral density (BMD) can be measured by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) accurately and precisely. BMD measurements of proximal tibia, where the structure is dominantly trabecular bone, were made on 45 normal women, aged 24–91 (52.0±14.2) years, and on 46 normal men, aged 20–71 (53.7±15.5) years. The precision of BMD measurements of proximal tibia, expressed as the coefficient of variation, was smaller than 4%.

Throughout this cross-sectional study, the following results were acquired. The mean BMD in male is higher than that in female. The BMD show a decrease with age at different rates in women and men. The BMD in both genders is found to increase with body weight. A positive correlation is found between the BMD and body height in women, not in men. In right proximal tibia, the BMD of medial regions are higher than that of lateral regions significantly. Our study also demonstrates that the excellent symmetry of the BMD of the bilateral proximal tibias in both genders, but not in men with age less than 50 years old.

Through the study of BMD in proximal tibias using the DEXA, it may reflect the bone reactions to many factors, such as age, sex, body weight & height, and weight bearing etc. Such a kind of study might be an useful adjuvant tool to assess the bone remodelling around the knee joint following the different surgical procedures such as total knee arthroplasty or high tibial osteotomy and might predict the future surgical outcomes.


Y. Takemitsu

In order to predict more detailed outcomes of paralysis in patients with acute cervical cord injury, we have compared degree of paralysis at the time of admission and the time after more than 6 months by using our modification of Frankel’s criteria.

Material and Method: The modified Frankel’s criteria comprises following items. Frankel B is divided into B1, B2, B3, C into C1, C2, D into D0, D1, D2, D3. B1; toutch sensation is preserved only in sacral segment, B2; it is preserved in more area, B3; pain sensation preserved. C1; MMT of the L/E has 1~2, C2; MMT of L/E 3. D1; ambulant but wheel chair is practically used. D2; crutch gait or central cord injury type, being liberated from wheel-chair. D3; completely independent. 2) 298 patients were included in this study, 259 males and 39 females, aged 48.1 yrs. in av. The time of admission from injury was within 7 days(average 1.7 days) and follow-up period was 28.6 months in av. Number of cases with bony injuries accounted for 154, those with no bony injury for 144. Patients with bony injury were treated operatively in acute stage; posterior reduction/fusion with wiring +or− anterior fusion . Patients with no bony injury were treated conservatively.

Result: Out of 151 pts with Frankel A, only 5 pts(3.3%) were restored to D, also B to D in 37%, C to D in 79%. Itemizing group B pts, B1 recovered to D in 20%, B2 to D in 32%, B3 to D in 80%. Itemizing group C pts, C1 improved to D in 61%, C2 to D in 97%. There were statistically differences between them. At the goal stage there were 111 Frankel D pts and they divited to D1(30%), D2(40%), D3(30%). D2 and D3 showed better abilities in whole ADLs than D1.

Conclusion: Comparing to the result reported by Frankel et al in 1969 we found that there were few neurologic improvement despite new technology. Using our modified Frankel’s classification we can estimate pts neurology more precisely and predict outcomes practically more in detail which have benefits to set the goal of treatment.


J. L. Pao

Between 1990 and 1998, twenty-nine patients with neurological deficits after acute unstable fracture of thoraco-lumbar spine were treatment by surgery at National Taiwan University Hospital. An attempt was made to contact all patients but 4 patients were unavailable for evaluation. The remaining 25 patients were followed for an average of 47.9 months (range 24 to 108 months). Postoperative improvement was observed in 56% and 60% of patients in Frankel grade and muscle power respectively. No patient had any neurological deterioration after surgery. None of these patients with initial Frankel grade A and B regained their ambulatory ability. However, 15 patients (60%) with initial Frankel grade C and D became independent ambulators after surgery (P = 0.0046). None of these patients with initial grade 0 muscle power regained his ambulation ability but all 15 patients (60%) with initial grade 1 to 4 muscle power became independent ambulators after surgery (P = 0.113). 10 patients with initial Frankel A or B had an average 0.4 grade of improvement and 25 patients with initial Frankel C or D had an average 0.9 grade of improvement (P = 0.11). However, those 10 patients with initial power 0 had an average 0.2 grade of improvement and the other 25 patients with initial muscle power 1 to 4 had an average 1.5 grades of improvement (P = 0.003). According to this study, we conclude that Frankel grade and muscle power are good predictors for the clinical outcome of surgical treatment for unstable thoraco-lumbar spine fracture. Patients with such injuries should be managed aggressively especially when residual muscle power could be elicited after the period of spinal shock has passed.


TC. Yu JT. Chien IH. Chen

Materials and Methods: This study included careful analysis of 24 knees with polyethylene wear in which revision surgery was performed. Preoperative evaluations included (1) single-leg standing AP, lateral and stress view, (2) dynamic weight-bearing lateral radiographs, and (3) manual test under anesthesia. Intraoperatively, (1) morphologic change of the worn inserts, (2) rotational alignment of tibia-femoral articulation (3) motion behavior of the joint following trial insertion was observed. Based on the above evaluation, 20 knees were revised with 3-component revision by constrained PS knees. The remaining 3 knees received isolated insert exchange.

Results: During the follow-up of 2–6 years, good and excellent results were obtained in all 21 patients who received three-component revision with Osteonics series IV constrained PS prosthesis. The mean HSS score was 92 and the mean ROM was 112 degrees. In the three patients receiving exchange of a thicker polyethylene only, two failed with the same mechanism 15 months and 23 months later and received re-revision. The X-ray of the remaining patient at 5-year F/U revealed impending failure.

Discussion: Based on our preoperative plain/dynamic radiographs and intraoperative findings, we postulate that tibial polyethylene wear is attributed to retained PCL in the absence of ACL, excessive posterior slope of tibial cut, rotational mismatch of tibia-femoral rotation and abnormal condylar lift-off in weight-bearing phase. With passage of time and progression of wear, secondary ligamentous decompensation and multidirectional instability may develop as a result of abnormal kinematics. Therefore, by isolated exchange of insert, the failure mechanism remains unchanged and secondary ligamentous instability persists. Eventually the new insert will fail again.

Conclusion: In revision surgery of tibial polyethelene wear, both the primary cause of failure and the secondary ligamentous instability must be addressed. The author strongly advocate that, in addition to reversal of the primary failure mechanism by 3-component revision, the use of a constrained PS prosthesis is mandatory to overcome the secondary soft tissue decompensation.


M. Takahashi S. Miyamoto S. Sakata A. Nagano

Aim: There have been increasingly publications about the complicated disease of patello-femoral joints after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We have treated soft tissue impingement under the patella after TKA by arthroscopic surgery and investigated the findings and efficacy of the treatment.

Materials and Methods: 6 patients and 8 knees which showed soft tissue impingement of patello-femoral joints after TKA. Surgical arthroscopy was performed and impinging soft tissues were classified and the efficacy of arthroscopic treatment were evaluated.

Results: We classified the patients with soft tissue impingement under the patella into three groups: (I) patellar clunk syndrome; the isolated fibrous nodule located suprapatellar lesion, without the other fibrous tissues causing the impingement, (II) impinging hypertrophic synovitis; generalized hypertrophic synovitis, no fibrous nodule, and (III) the combined type of (I)+(II), the suprapatellar fibrous nodule with generalized hypertrophic synovitis. Therapeutic efficacy was that in the category of type I two were good-excellent, in type II three were fair and one was poor, and in type III two were fair.

Conclusions: Better results were obtained in type I (a patellar clunk syndrome) than type II (impingement synovitis).


K. Uehara Y. Kadoya A. Kobayashi H. Ohashi Y. Yamano

The purpose of this study was to investigate the bone anatomy in determining the rotational alignment in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) using CT scan. Axial CT images of eighty-four varus osteoarthritic knees undergoing TKA were analysed. On the images of the distal femur and the proximal tibia, base line for anterior-posterior axis of each component was drawn based on the epicondylar axis for the femur and medial one-third of the tibial tuberosity for the tibia. Angle between these two lines was analysed as the rotational mismatch between the components when they were determined based on the anatomical landmark of each bone. Thirty-eight knees (45%) showed more than 5-degree mismatch and seven knees (8.3%) showed the mismatch more than 10-degree. There was a tendency to put the tibial component in external rotation relative to the femoral component when they were aligned to medial one-third of the tibial tuberosity. The results have indicated that the landmark of each bone was the intrinsic cause of the rotational mismatch between the components. The surgeons performing TKA surgery should aware of this fact and should align the tibial component in a compromised position, if necessary, to have overall satisfactory clinical outcome.


T Koshino Y. Mochida K Yamamoto K. Hirakawa T. Saito

Wear of UHMWPE and Clinical results of bioceramic total knee replacement have not been well reported yet. The ultra high molecular weight polyethylene surfaces of the tibial components were examined in 3 retrieved knees with non-infectious loosening, and were almost normal in appearance with only minor scratch lines 33 to 59 months after the initial arthroplasty. Bioceramic total knee arthroplasty was concluded to show satisfactory results except for the initial several cases done with rather poor surgical techniques. The wear of UHMWPE surface in ceramic knee was observed to be much less and milder than that of metal prosthesis.

Total knee arthroplasty (cementless) using Yokohama Medical Ceramic Knee was performed in 64 knees and, excluding 4 knees with the prostheses retrieved, was evaluated in 60 knees of 47 patients.

There ware 1 man (1 knee) and 31 women (44 knees) who had rheumatoid arthritis with a mean age of 56.8±11.9 years, and 2 men (2 knees) and 11 women (13 knees) with osteoarthritis with a mean age of 70.6±6.9 years. The mean follow-up duration was 48.1±9.2 months ranging from 33 to 60 months.

The maximum knee flexion was 115±24 degrees before and 104±20 degrees after arthroplasty in the rheumatoid group, and 107±40 degrees before and 101±26 degrees after arthroplasty in the osteoarthritis group.

Clinical evaluation using The Hospital for Special Surgery Knee Criteria showed 7 knees as Excellent, 34 as Good, 7 as Fair and 12 as Poor after surgery. Complications consisted of infection (1 case), tibial plateau fracture (1), avulsion fracture of the tibial tuberosity (1) and patellar dislocation (1)


FDA. Ghan TA. Savvoulidis

Between 1990–92, 59 Primary TKA’s were performed in 55 Patients with a mean follow-up of 9 years (8–10). Mean age at review was 75 years (61–87). Materials and Method: All cementless TKA’s (Whiteside Ortholoc Modular 3). One surgeon (operating or supervising). Intramedullary guides(tibia and femur). Lateral retinacular release. Clinical evaluation according to the Knee Society Scoring System & Knee Society TKA Roentgenographic Evaluation and Scoring System. Median Knee Score 93.5 (41–97). Median Functional Score 77.5 (35–100). Median flexion 100 degrees (80–120). All but one knee came to full extension. No effusions or swellings. Radiolucencies in one TKA only. Discussion: Long term success of TKA’s (cementless or cemented) depends on correct alignment of the implants. Rigidity of fixation is the second most important feature in achieving pain free function in an arthroplasty. Success in this series was due to good alignment of components. Good alignment minimises polyethelene wear. Rigid tibial fixation prevents motion, tilting and malalignment reducing wear.


CC. Lin PQ. Chen GL. Huang MC. Shin

There is quite a high incidence of musculoskeletal disorders in the hemophiliac patients because of their insufficiency in blood coagulation. Knee joint disability is the most troublesome problem among the all. Repeated bruise and intra-articular hemorrhage may activate hypertrophic synovitis and progress to advanced arthritis. The characteristic clinical presentation is their fusiform limbs with moderate degree of contracture and deformity. Treatments include administration of specific coagulation factors, aspiration of hemarthrosis and proper bracing. Synovectomy will treat and retard the progression of the disease, while some advanced cases may end up to spontaneous fusion or need surgical arthrodesis. Total knee arthroplasty is another option for such a knee problem in hemophiliac patients.

We have done 26 total knee arthroplasties in 19 hemophiliac patients since 1986. Male is predominant with sex-linked inheritance with only one exception. The timing for them to have surgery is from 22 to 47 years old with mean age of 30. Gross patholgies of the knee lesion are quite universal as hypertrophy of hemosiderin deposited synovium, destruction of articular catilage, subchondral bone loss, marginal osteophytes formation, fibrous contracture around the joints. Two cases were excluded for other systemic disease.

With the help of supplementary coagulation factor, the surgical courses were rather smooth with one exception of septic shock episode. There were no infections in total series but three revisions of prosthesis were done because of loosening or malposition. All the patients were satisfied with the improvement of function score and range of knee motion. Total knee arthroplasty did a great success for the relief of pain and function for such a knee disorder. The only remained troublesome problem is the extremely high cost of the coagulation factor therapy which may be an economic shock to the patients.


CC. Yew MV. Varaprasad D. Choon

Intramedullary devices have been used since 1989 for fractures around the trochanter. Standard PFN has been shown to be one of the stable and successful intramedullary devices for pertrochanteric fractures.

In order to minimise the intra-operative complications, small PFN has been designed to fit the Asian femora.

Before performing a clinical documentation series, the authors with the computer assisstance performed virtual templating of 60 asian femora.

After standardising the magnification of the radiograph with that of the template, best possible fit of the latter was achevied.

Various parameters such as:

Width of the remaining neck from the surface of femoral neck screw and hip pin.

Height of the proximal end of the nail from the tip of greater trochanter.

The distance between the actual and proposed take-off point of medio-lateral angulation.

Width of intramedullary canal at distal end of the nail were measured.

After analysis of the measurements, we propose to further modify the small PFN in order to get best fit and minimal intra-operative complications.


S. Waikakul

To improve the accuracy of pinning at the iliac crest during external fixation of the unstable pelvic fracture, an aiming device has been innovated. The device consists of 3 parts: a sleeve, a handle and guide points. The guide points were designed to grasp the iliac crest to allow proper pin fixation. The device has been used in 50 patients who had unstable fractures of their pelvises. All pins were in proper position with out loosening at the time the pins were removed. The use of this device has given encouraging results.


M. Krishnan R. Ramaiah

Objective: To analyze pattern of work related injuries sustained by patients admitted to The Orthopaedic Department of Hospital Ipoh. All patients admitted to Hospital Ipoh, Perak, Malaysia for acute injuries sustained during their work was analyzed prospectively. The period of this study was 1 year.

Parameters assessed were patients’ nationality, nature of occupation, duration of working experience, time of injury, adequacy of safely measures provided by the employer, whether normal duty or overtime, mechanism and type of injuries sustained and treatment given. Disability caused by the injury, outcome of the treatment and duration of sick leave were not analyzed. During this period, 386 patients were admitted (343 males and 43 females). Ages were ranging from 17 years to 78 years. Most of the patients were less than 25 years old (n=106) and only 3 patients were above 75 years of age. Malaysians were 80.8% (n=312) and foreigners were 19.2% (n=74). Among the foreigners, Bangladeshi were the highest 43.2% (n=32) and the least were from Pakistan, Nepal and Burma, 1.4% (n=1) each. Mostly were unskilled workers (labourer) comprising 50.8% (n=196). Largest group of patients have working experience of between 2 to 5 years 23.8% (n=92). On hourly analyses, highest number of accidents took place between 10am to 11am comprising 11.4% (n=44). 60.6% of patient (n=234) claims they were not provided with adequate safety gears.


JCY. Cheng SH. Yung N. Kw TP. Lam

Out of a total of 112 children with displaced forearm shaft fracture treated with Percutaneous Kirschner (K) wire fixation in the past 9 years, 84 cases with fracture of both the radius and ulna were reviewed. 64 (76%) had fixation of both the radius and ulna, 10 (12%) the radius only and the other 10 (12%) the ulna only. In 60 (71%) patients were successful with one stage close reduction and pinning, while in the remaining 24 (29%) a semi- open reduction through a small incision was required. The K-wire was inserted through the radial styloid or the Lister tubercle for the radius, and through the tip of the olecranon for the ulna. All the patients reviewed were found to have good functional results with no non-union, deep infection or premature physeal closure at a mean follow-up of 48 months. Initial pre-operative shortening or translation of the fracture were associated with significantly higher chance of open reduction. We concluded that percutaneous K-wiring for forearm diaphyseal fracture in children is a convenient, effective and safe operation, with minimal complications.


R. Penafort

All patients above 60 years of age who sustained a hip fracture following a trivial injury admitted to our institution between October 1995 and September 1996 were screened and treated according to a standard treatment protocol. They were followed up to a minimum of 4 years.

The 1 year mortality rate was 23% while that at 2 years was 50 percent. The mortality rate at the end of 4 years was 66%. The higher rate of death occurring in patients above 80 years of age. Analysis of results according to age, sex and fracture type was made. Definite correlation has been observed with the age, the increase being parallel to it, while age-specific mortality is higher in men. The mortality was also reviewed with relation to the associated medical conditions, and pre-morbid ASA grade, medical conditions and premorbid activity level index using the Barthel Index. There was no increase in mortality seen in trochanteric fractures.

The treatment of hip fractures in poses a challenge. Optimal anaesthesia, expeditious surgery and a co-ordinated multidisciplinary approach to care is essential in these patients.


P. Tabrizi A.P. Pohl O. Holubowycz G. Nisyrios

Introduction: Type C pelvic ring disruptions are commonly associated with significant patient morbidity. It is the senior author’s (APP) experience that the sacro-iliac alar cartilage is commonly damaged at the time of initial trauma. If left untreated, this may give rise to post-traumatic arthrosis of the joint, with resultant pain. The natural history of type C disruptions is one of late pain. In this paper, we review our results of acute arthrodesis of the SI joint simultaneously with fixation of the posterior pelvis.

Methods: From 1987–2000, a consecutive series of 28 patients who underwent primary surgical fusion and internal fixation of the sacro-iliac joint underwent clinical and radiographic review. All patients were examined at latest follow-up (79.8 months) in regards to pain, range of motion, walking tolerance and the incidence of significant complications. Evaluation of the pelvic ring reduction and success of arthrodesis of the SI joint were made through radiographs of the pelvic ring. In addition patients completed the SF-36 as a measure of general health status and the Musculoskeletal Function Assessment (MFA) and WOMAC scores as a measure of functional outcome. Work status was also examined.

Results: The majority of these injuries were sustained in either motor vehicle crashes or high energy falls. There was a high incidence of associated injuries and co-morbidities. The male to female ratio was approximately 2:1 with a mean age of 27 years. At initial surgery, all patients were noted to have severe fragmentation and disruption of the alar cartilage. The majority of patients had sacro-iliac screw fixation for their posterior injury and an external fixator for anterior stabilization. At follow-up there was a low incidence of late posterior complex pain. All patients were independently mobile and there were minimal complications. Only 1 patient had to change jobs secondary to pelvic or low back pain. The functional outcome at long term follow-up was good with regards to the SF-36, MFA and WOMAC scores.

Conclusions: Type C pelvic ring injuries have a high incidence of disruption of the alar cartilage. Treatment of these injuries by primary fusion and internal fixation leads to good long-term results.


J. van Essen J. Costi T.C. Hearn J. Krishnan

Purpose: A variety of second generation femoral interlocking intramedullary nails, in which the proximal lag screw is engaged in the femoral head, are now available for the treatment of complex comminuted pertrochanteric femoral fractures. Jamming of the lag screw results in a rigid device which is more likely to cut-out of the femoral head. The aim of this study was to determine the sliding characteristics and jamming potential of the lag screws of five different devices used to treat these fractures.

Method: The devices examined include; the single lag screw devices: the DHS, the Gamma nail and the Intramedullary hip screw (IMHS), and the double lag screw devices: the Russell-Taylor Reconstruction nail (RTN) and the Austofix Hip nail. The devices were mounted in a servo-hydraulic testing apparatus and examined by two different techniques. The first set-up looked at lag screw motion with respect to loads applied which were representative of the single limb stance phase of gait (SLSPOG). The second set-up which, was first described by Kyle in 1980, looked at the forces required to initiate sliding.

Results: For the first set up (SLSPOG), all single lag screw devices demonstrated sliding across the normal physiological range of applied load. The Russell Taylor Reconstruction nails demonstrated conflicting results with the lag screws of two nails sliding and one nail jamming. All the Austofix nails jammed at the higher angles of the normal physiological range (1590, 1640).

Using the Kyle set-up, the forces required to initiate sliding were found to be lowest with the Synthes DHS (42.33±5.77N), Zimmer CHS (52.67±26.56N), and the IMHS (45.33±10.97N). These were closely followed by the Gamma nail (79.33±8.39N) and the Richards Classic hip screw (82.00±16.37N). The highest forces were for the RTN (98.00±18.52N) and the Austofix hip nail (283.00±70.62N). These results were significantly different. (p< 0.001, ANOVA)

Conclusion: The results demonstrate that double lag screw implants require greater loads to initiate sliding and have a greater potential for jamming. Whilst all single lag screw nails slide, barrel length does alter the forces required to initiate sliding. Further testing using a lubricant is currently being undertaken.


F. Kasama

Purpose: Rogers’ wiring is the most generally used method as stabilization of the cervical distractive-flexion injuries. When there is fracture of the spinous process on the cranial side, it may be easily cut out during tightening of a wire or in the course of rehabilitation. Comparing to Rogers’ wiring, sublaminar-wiring methods reported by Watts in 1993 is useful for the cases of fracture of the spinous process. However, the method is not generally used. The purpose of this paper is to examine an usefulness of the sublaminar-wiring method and our modified technique.

Materials: Ten patients with cervical distractive-flexion injury were operated on using the modified Watts’ methods.

Operative techniques: We modified as follows. Firstly, we changed a wire system to a cable one. Secondly we make sublaminar wiring easier with a looped silk thread. Namely, the thread was passed under the cranial lamina using an aneurysm-needle. The looped portion of the thread was pulled out from the cranial interlaminar space. A looped cable was passed under the lamina using this loop. The loop of the cable was placed around the spinous process. After one side of the cable was caught again on the spinous process , both ends are bounded and tightened .

Result: A reduction of the dislocated cervical spine was well maintained at the follow-up in all cases.

Conclusion: Sublaminar wiring method for distractiveflexion injuries of the cervical spine is effective and useful. Our modified technique makes sublaminar wiring safer and easier.


A. Devadoss

The Surgery of resistant and relapsed club foot is always a great problem even for an experienced Orthopaedic Surgeon. Surgery on the bones in younger patient is contraindicated. The principle of differential fractional distraction technique invented by Prof. Joshi of Bombay is well accepted in many Countries. His technique using the JESS system (Joshi’s External Skeletal System) is used extensively for resistant and relapsed Club feet. In our Institute during this decade 57 feet in 45 children in the age group of one to five years were corrected using the above mentioned technique. Results were assessed as per SIMMON’S CRITERIA. 47 out of the 57 feet showed satisfactory results. Recurrence of the deformity observed in 10 feet. This study details the methodology of distraction, merits and pitfalls of the procedure.


S. Ozeki

Introduction: Most physicians agree that initial treatment for a newborn child with clubfoot should be nonoperative. Some children with rigid deformities, however, may need a soft tissue release operation at an early age. The optimal timing of such surgery and for whom remain controversial questions. We prospectively followed patients treated in our clinic under temporal protocol and analyzed results in order to answer these questions.

Methods: From 1979 to 1989, 132 infants with 185 club-feet visited the Hokkaido Univ. before they were three months old. Eighty eight patients with 124 feet were followed over a 10 year period. The averaged follow-up period was 15.2 years. Corrective casts were applied for no longer than 3 months. If the lateral tibio-calcaneal (TC) angle became less than 90°, a Denis Browne splint was used. If this angle was still larger than 90°, postero-lateral release was performed within a month after casting. Surgery was also performed for children whose deformities continued increasing after conservative treatment. McKay’s scoring system was used to evaluate the final clinical results. The results of patients needing major revision surgery were evaluated “failure”.

Results: Forty-nine feet were treated conservatively. Of these 35 were evaluated as good or excellent and seven were evaluated as poor or failure. Forty-three feet were underwent surgery before one year of age; an additional 32 feet underwent surgery after one year of age. Thirty-three feet were evaluated good or excellent and 19 feet were evaluated as poor or failure. At 6 months of age the lateral TC angle of the patients treated non-operatively and evaluated as good or excellent was 68.4 ± 14.3° (Mean ± S.D.), and the lateral TC angle of patients who underwent surgery after one year of age and patients who were treated non-operatively but evaluated as poor or failure was 80.0 ± 9.2°. There are statistically significant difference between these two groups. The age at surgery of patients evaluated as good or excellent was 12.6 ± 12.4 months old, and that of patients evaluated as poor or failure was 5.1 ± 3.0 months old.There are also statistically significant difference between these two groups.

Conclusion: Our results suggest that surgery is indicated for patients whose TC angle at 6 months of age is greater than 70°, and that the optimal timing for soft tissue release is later than 8 months of age.


B. Joseph

In reality, the diagnosis of idopathic clubfoot is never delayed, however, treatment is often delayed in developing countries on account of socio-economic factors. The experience gained from treating children who present late in these countries can be effectively used in more developed countries to treat relapsed clubfeet.

The author considers any treatment for clubfoot offered after a child has started walking as “late treatment”.

The treatment options vary depending on the age of the child and the extent of deformities. The aim of treatment is to obtain a plantigrade foot, retaining the mobility of as many of the tarsal joints as possible.

Accordingly, an outline of treatment is suggested. Soft tissue release operations are recommended for children between 1 and 3 years; soft tissue release operations with or without bony surgery for children between 3 and 5 years; soft tissue release combined with mid tarsal and calcaneal osteotomies and tendon transfers in children between 5 and 14 years. The role of external fixators and distraction techniques advocated by Ilizarov and Joshi, and finally, the role of salvage operations like triple fusion and talectomy are discussed.


I. Stratton

The author presents his experience over twenty three years as visiting orthopaedic specialist in the early management of neonatal and infantile clubfoot with annual visits to the Kingdom of Tonga, S.W. Pacific. This has involved three hundred and seventy two infants with five hundred and fifty eight feet.

The relative ease of assisting surgically those least able to afford treatment overseas in their own country where such treatment may not be available in their own country is discussed.

The equipment required; the surgical skills needed; the importance of safe anaesthesia; the importance in gaining the confidence of family, local medical, nursing and administration staff is emphasized.

The high incidence of clubfoot in Polynesians is noted. The incidence in Tonga approaches one per hundred live births ie. 1% so for Tonga where there are approximately 2500 live births per annum – this means an annual case load of 25 babies with upto 40 feet to correct on an annual basis: a formidable annual caseload.

Three orthopaedic visiting surgeons with one visiting anaesthetist plus another local anaesthetist utilizing two theatres can successfully complete this caseload in 3–4 days of operating.

In the absence of such visiting teams many of these babies would remain untreated or inadequately treated and would commence walking at 12–18 months on uncorrected feet with disastrous results. Early soft tissue correction in a baby under 12 months of age is highly desirable to ensure a corrected plantargrade foot before walking commences.

Clubfoot is therefore especially common in Tonga; Samoa; Tahiti; Hawaii and amongst Maoris in New Zealand yet it still occurs in Melanesians in Fiji; Papua New Guinea; Solomon Islands; Vanuatu; New Caledonia and in the Micronesian states in the Caroline Islands; Marshall and Mariana Islands.

There is a need for visiting orthopaedic teams to visit and surgically treat clubfoot on an annual basis.

The author in co-operation seeks to establish an Asian Pacific Foundation to ensure this important surgery is delivered annually to our near neighbours.


K. Mulpuri B. Joseph G. Varghese N Rao S. Nair

Background: Current treatment for Perthes disease aims at preventing deformation of the femoral head during the active stage of the disease by obtaining containment of the femoral head. To effectively pre-empt femoral head deformation, one needs to know, when during the disease irreparable femoral head deformation occurs. This study was undertaken to attempt to clarify this.

Methods: Records and 2634 pairs of radiographs (AP and lateral) of 610 patients with Perthes’ disease were reviewed. The evolution of the disease was divided into seven stages (Stages Ia, Ib, IIa, IIb, IIIa, IIIb & IV) based on plain radiographic appearances. Intra-observer and inter-observer reproducibility of this new classification system was assessed. The duration of each stage of the disease was noted. The stage at which epiphyseal extrusion and widening of the metaphysis occurred and the stage at which metaphyseal and acetabular changes appeared were identified. The shape and the size of the femoral head, the extent of trochanteric overgrowth and the radius of the acetabulum were assessed in hips that had healed.

Results: The reproducibility of the new classification system of the evolution Of Perthes’ disease was good. The median duration of each stage varied between 95 and 326 days. Epiphyseal extrusion and metaphyseal widening was modest in Stages Ia, Ib and IIa but increased dramatically after Stage IIb. > 20% extrusion occurred in 70% of the hips by Stage IIIa. Metaphyseal changes were most frequently encountered in Stage IIb, while acetabular changes were most prevalent in Stage IIIa. At healing, only 24% of untreated patients had spherical femoral heads, while 52% had irregular femoral heads.

Conclusions: The new classification of the stages of evolution of Perthes’ disease helps to identify when crucial events occur during the course of the disease. The timing of epiphyseal extrusion, metaphyseal widening and the appearance of adverse metaphyseal and acetabular changes suggest that femoral head deformation occurs by Stage IIIa in untreated hips. Hence, if containment were to succeed, it should be achieved before this stage.


N. Rao K.L.B. Joseph K. Mulpuri G. Varghese S. Nair

Background: Femoral varus osteotomy for Perthes’ disease aims at achieving Containment to prevent femoral head deformation. Theoretically, ontainment is most likely to succeed if it is achieved before the femoral head extrudes and is subjected to deforming stresses. It would follow that the timing of the procedure is an important factor in determining the outcome. This study was undertaken to verify this.

Methods: Records and radiographs of 610 patients with Perthes’ disease were analysed. The data of 302 patients who underwent femoral osteotomy were compared with those of non-operated patients. A new modification of the Elizabthtown classification of the stages of evolution of the disease with seven stages (Stages Ia, Ib, IIa, IIb, IIIa, IIIb & IV) was used to identify the timing of surgery and to monitor the progress of the disease following surgery. The results of treatment were assessed at healing by Mose’s criteria. Multivariate analysis was used to identify variables that influenced the shape and size of the femoral head at healing.

Results: 22 patients among 86 who were operated in Stage Ia or Ib by-passed the stage of fragmentation. The extent of metaphyseal widening was considerably less in operated children. At healing, spherical femoral heads were seen in 72% of operated hips as compared to 24% of non-operated hips. The variables that influenced the shape of the femoral head at healing were, metaphyseal width, sex, age at onset, epiphyseal extrusion and the stage at surgery. Patients who were operated before Stage IIb had significantly better results than those operated later.

Conclusions: The results of the study support the impression that the timing of containment is an important factor that influences the outcome in Perthes’ disease. The best results are obtained if containment is achieved before Stage IIb.


K. Yamazaki S. Kato T. Toba T. Shimamura

This study reports on postoperative changes of intra and epidural space of both degenerative lumbar spinal canal stenosis(DLSCS) and degenerative spondylolisthesis(DO)on MRI. 48cases(DLSCS:20cases, DO:28cases)were investigated in this study. All cases performed bilateral wide fenestration.

The average age of these patients was 65 years and average follow-up period was 60 months. The average improvement ratio(%) of JOA score was 68% at the last follow-up. Symptomes had deteriorated in 8 cases, according to an increase in the volume of the postlaminectomy membrane, at the last follow-up. There were 8 cases(29%)in DO. showing an increase of % slip on X-ray at the last follow-up, accompanied with both a slight decreasing of the cross-sectional area(CSA)of dural sac and a slight deterioration of clinical results.

Discussion: Symptomes in around 17% of the cases deteriorated, and there were three factors on MRI ; a poor expansion of the dural sac, a grouping of the cauda equina, and a decrease in the CSA of the dural sac.


S. Abe

Subjects and Methods: Surgical results of 12 patients aged 70 or older were compared with those of 15 younger controls with the same degree of cervical spondylotic myelopathy. All the patients were treated with the open-door laminoplasty in our institution from 1984 to 1999. The Japanese Orthopaedic Association Criteria (JOA score) was used for clinical evaluation. Perioperative complications were recorded.

Results: The maximum recovery of the JOA score was obtained approximately 1 year after the operation, and the recovery rate was slightly higher in the younger (53.3%) than the older (39.6%) subjects. Both groups exhibited gradual decrease in their JOA score, and the final score of 9.8 in the elderly had no significant difference with that of 11.2 in the control group. Despite the higher frequency of associated systemic disorders in the elderly, there was no major surgical complication in both groups.

Discussions: The lower JOA score in elderly subjects were partly due to their accompanied lumbar or knee symptoms. Major perioperative complications could be avoided even in the patient over 80 years old. The open-door laminoplasty demonstrated promising clinical outcomes and should be performed in the elderly patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy.


N. Tsunoda

To study the contribution of the special morphological features of lumbo-sacral spine as causes of the slipping in the spondylolisthesis, the roentgenographic measurements were performed in 47 cases of spondylolysis, 77 of spondylolisthesis and 597 of several low back pain as a control.

The transitional lumbo-sacral spine was more frequently seen in the spondylolisthesis group, but there was no d ifference between the spondylolysis and control.

The angle between the superior surface and the posterior border of the sacral vertebral body (posterior superior sacral angle) was apparently low in the spondylolisthesis, whereas no difference was noted between another groups.

In conclusion, special morphological features such as low prices of the posterior superior sacral angle is considered one of the risk factors for the cause of slipping.


K. Raveedran

The Graf technique of spinal stabilisation of the lumbar spine is a semi rigid pedicular screw system without spinal fusion. It is an unique system, which has both proponents and opponents. The mechanism of stabilisation is as yet not fully understood.

This retrospective study looks at the long term results of 35 patients with a minimum follow up of 4 years.

The age ranged from 35 years to 76 years with an average of 60 years of age.

89 percent of the patients improved considerably and no further surgery was performed on any of them. The complication rate was minimal. The Graf spinal system merits further study with prospective trials comparing it with pedicular screws and spinal fusion. The scientific basis should be established, as many surgeons are doubtful about this system.


T. Imai H. Ishii A. Konishi

In 141 patients with ossification of posterior longitudinal ligament, open-door expansive laminoplasty was done from 1980 to 1998. A follow-up study was made. 10 patients with cervical cord injury and cerebral diseases before or after operation were excluded. 121 of 131 patients were followd directly one to fifteen years(mean: 5 years and 3 months). Subjects included 93 male and 28 female. At the time of operation, their ages ranged from 40 to 80 years(mean:59.5). Operative results were evaluated using the Japanese Orthopaedic Association’s Score(JOA Score) and Hirabayashi’s improvement rate. X-ray was taken to measure the range of cervical spine motion, curvature of the cervical spine and progression of ossified masses.

Preoperative JOA scores ranged from 2 to 14 points(mean:9.1), postoperative JOA scores ranged 7 to 17 points(mean:14.1). The mean improvement rate was 62%. The range of cervical spine motion decreased from 26.6 degrees prior to operation to 10.8 degrees after operation. Lordotic curvature also fell from 11.8 degrees before operation to 6.6 degrees after operation. In 20 patients, the postoperative kyphotic curvature increased to 5 degrees of more, although no difference was seen in their improvement rates compared with patients whose lordosis remained unchanged. 80 of 121 patients experienced progression of ossified masses. Three patients underwent additional laminectomy due to progression of ossification or insufficient expansion.

Operation took an average 80 minutes and mean amount of blood loss was 215 ml. No patients had postoperative motor paralysis caused by C5 or C6 nerve damage and no serious complications were seen.


T. Sato Y. Tanaka K. Ozawa S. Kokubun

Purpose: There are a wide variety of operative procedures for lumbar spinal canal stenosis. Bilateral fenestration, preserving the continuity of the lamina and spinous processes, has widely been employed in our department and its affiliated hospitals. The following questions are raised: Are decompressive effects of fenestration and spinal stability maintained without spinal fusion or instrumentation? In order to answer the questions, we compared the rates of revision after fenestration with those after laminectomy alone and decompressive surgery with spinal fusion.

Materials and methods: The registry of spinal surgeries of our university and affiliated hospitals from 1988 to 1997 was consulted.

During the first 5-years period 1159 patients underwent decompressive surgery. 908 of them had spondylosis and 251 had degenerative spondylolisthesis (DO) as a contributing factors of neural compression. Fenestration was done in 740 (81%) of patients with spondylosis and in 176 (70%) of patients with DO.

Results: Regarding the whole series 31 out of 1159 patients had a revision. The revision rate was 2.7%. 15 out of 908 patients (1.7%) with spondylosis and 16 out of 251 patients (6.4%) with DO underwent revisions. 11 out of 740 (1.5%) with spondylosis and 11 out of 176 (6.3%) with DO underwent revisions after fenestration. No significant differences were found among the revision rate of fenestration, laminectomy and decompressive surgery with spinal fusion.

Conclusion: The decompressive effect of fenestration was maintained long enough, even for degenerative spondylolisthesis. As a first operation spinal fusion is not necessarily indicated for lumbar canal stenosis.


WM Tang PKY Chiu YH Zhu

Introduction: Normal axial alignment of the lower extremity is important to surgeons who perform reconstruction surgery of the knee. The data are, however, not available for Chinese adults.

Methods: The axial alignment of the lower extremity of twenty-five adult males and twenty-five adult females of southern Chinese origin was measured by using weight-bearing radiographs of the entire lower limb. The mean age of the male and female volunteers was twenty-four years and twenty-three years respectively. The axial alignment of the lower extremity was measured and the results were compared with two similar studies conducted in the United States.

Results: The medial inclination of the tibial plateau in the Chinese volunteers was greater than the commonly cited 3 degrees (with a mean of 5.4 ± 2.5 degrees for females and 4.9 ± 2.3 degrees for males). The extremities in Chinese volunteers were found to have a mean of 2.2 ± 2.5 degrees varus (females) and 2.2 ± 2.7 degrees varus (males).

Conclusions and Discussion: The medial inclination (knee joint obliquity) of the Chinese knee joint was significantly larger than Caucasian subjects. The higher knee joint obliquity exposes the cartilage of the Chinese knee to a higher shearing force and subsequently result in osteoarthritis. This may explain the racial difference in the ratio of knee to hip osteoarthritis. When performing total knee arthroplasty, a 5-degree, instead of the commonly cited 3-degree, external rotation of the femoral component may be required to obtain a rectangular flexion gap in total knee arthroplasty in Chinese patients.


R.F. Kyle

Unreamed, small diameter nails with interlocking capability have become the preferred treatment for most unstable tibial fractures, but have been shown to have a high rate of hardware breakage and frequently require secondary procedures to obtain union. Reamed nailing may offer advantages for fracture healing due to the use of larger implants and increased stability, but may cause higher rates of infection and compartment syndrome. In order to determine if there is a difference in healing or complications in open and closed tibial fractures treated with reamed or unreamed intramedullary nailing, we performed a prospective, surgeon-randomized comparative study. Ninety-four closed and open, unstable tibial shaft fractures (excluding Gustilo Types IIIB and C) treated with intramedullary nailing were studied. Our findings support the use of reamed nailing in closed tibial fractures, which led to earlier time to union without increased complications. In addition, reaming did not increase the risk of complications in open tibial fractures.


DTT. Lie A.M.J. Bull A.A. Amis

Objective: This study challenges the assumption that pivot shift is abolished once anterior stability is restored in the ACL reconstructed knee. Method: The kinematics of 7 cadaver knees were studied with the Flock-of-Birds, as pivot shift was repeated in intact, ACL deficient, then ACL reconstructed specimens with grafts tensioned at 0, 10, 20, 40 and 60N. All were BPTB grafts in similar positions. Results: Pivot shift is described as a sudden reduction from internal rotation of 8.57 +/− 2.3° at knee flexion of 24.2 +/− 11°; achieved with iliotibial loading of 56.2 +/− 11.5N, 2.26 +/− 0.6Nm valgus load and 1.5 +/− 0.4Nm internal torque. Internal rotation was significantly reduced at 40N (3.2°, p< 0.005) and 60N (2.9°, p=0.001). At maximum tension, all specimens felt stable and pivoted less. This reduction of internal rotation averaged 62%; ranging from 42% (subtle pivot) to 100% (complete abolition). At 90° knee flexion external rotation was reduced with graft tension of 60N, but not significantly (p=0.03). The range of knee flexion during reduction of the pivot shift was not significantly altered. Conclusions: Tensions of grafts that restored anterior stability (40N & 60N) did not always abolish the pivot shift, but significantly reduced it. This may account for complaints of subtle instability despite surgical reconstruction. Grants: DTT Lie was supported by a grant from the Singapore National Medical Research Council.


VA. Singh DSK. Choon

Postoperative leg swelling after a total knee replacement is common complaint amongst patients.

We studied leg swelling by constructing a novel, simple and cost water volumeter. A pilot study was conducted on 15 volunteers by two observers and each observer took a total of three readings.

The mean intraobserver variation was 0.2 percent and mean interobserver variation was 0.3 percent, indicating a highly acceptable level of accuracy.

The water volumeterwas then used in a randomized prospective study was conducted to determine the relationship between postoperative leg swelling and Fraxiparine, a low molecular weight heparin.

From the period of 1st January 2000 till 31th October 2000, a total of 36 patients were enrolled in the study. 18 patients in the study group received fraxiparine and 18 patients in the control group did not.

The leg volume was measured preoperatively and on postoperative days 5, 7 and 10.

We found that both groups developed maximum swelling at postoperative day 5 and this decreased to almost normal at day 10. However the fraxiparine group was statistically less swollen (4%) than the control group (10%) on day 5 and also on day 7 (−0.2% vs 7%). These findings were independent of whether the patient underwent bilateral or unilateral surgery. We conclude that low molecular weight heparins are effective in reducing postoperative leg swelling in total knee replacement.


CE Gibbons HS Gosal J Bartlett

Aim of study: To determine the long term outcome and complications associated with arthroscopic synovectomy in 22 knees with rheumatoid arthritis.

Methods: A consecutive series of 22 knees in 18 patients with seropositive RA underwent arthroscopic synovectomy for painful and swollen knees unresponsive to medical treatment. All operations were performed by the senior author. The mean age at operation was 44 years(22–64). All pre-operative Xrays showed Larsen grade 2 or less and no knees demonstrated marked joint laxity. Knee Society scores were recorded pre-operatively and at review, with a mean follow-up of 8 years (6–16).

Results: Two out of 22 knees(9%) have undergone TKR at 1 and 2 years post synovectomy. One patient underwent a further synovectomy for persistent swelling at 2 years and has since remained well. No per-operative complications were recorded but one large haemarthrosis and one stiff knee requiring manipulation were seen. The mean clinical and function scores increased by 22 and 15 points respectively at follow-up. The mean length of stay was 3 days and Xrays of the 20 knees not undergoing prosthetic replacement have all shown a small progression of degenerative radiological change.

Conclusion: This long-term study shows that arthroscopic synovectomy in appropriately selected patients with RA is a safe and reliable procedure with a low complication rate. The surgery is technically demanding but involves a shorter in-patient stay than with open synovectomy. The development of radiological degenerative changes were seen with all patients at review.


Tzai-Chiu Yu Jui-Teng Chien** Ing-Ho Chen

Materials and Methods: This study included careful analysis of 24 knees with polyethylene wear in which revision surgery was performed. Preoperative evaluations included (1) single-leg standing AP, lateral and stress view, (2) dynamic weight-bearing lateral radiographs, and (3) manual test under anesthesia. Intraoperatively, (1) morphologic change of the worn inserts, (2) rotational alignment of tibia-femoral articulation (3) motion behavior of the joint following trial insertion was observed. Based on the above evaluation, 20 knees were revised with 3-component revision by constrained PS knees. The remaining 3 knees received isolated insert exchange.

Results: During the follow-up of 2–6 years, good and excellent results were obtained in all 21 patients who received three-component revision with Osteonics series IV constrained PS prosthesis. The mean HSS score was 92 and the mean ROM was 112 degrees. In the three patients receiving exchange of a thicker polyethylene only, two failed with the same mechanism 15 months and 23 months later and received re-revision. The X-ray of the remaining patient at 5-year F/U revealed impending failure.

Discussion: Based on our preoperative plain/dynamic radiographs and intraoperative findings, we postulate that tibial polyethylene wear is attributed to retained PCL in the absence of ACL, excessive posterior slope of tibial cut, rotational mismatch of tibia-femoral rotation and abnormal condylar lift-off in weight-bearing phase. With passage of time and progression of wear, secondary ligamentous decompensation and multidirectional instability may develop as a result of abnormal kinematics. Therefore, by isolated exchange of insert, the failure mechanism remains unchanged and secondary ligamentous instability persists. Eventually the new insert will fail again.

Conclusion: In revision surgery of tibial polyethelene wear, both the primary cause of failure and the secondary ligamentous instability must be addressed. The author strongly advocate that, in addition to reversal of the primary failure mechanism by 3-component revision, the use of a constrained PS prosthesis is mandatory to overcome the secondary soft tissue decompensation.


JM. Sohn HK. Kim J. Jahng DH. Baek NK. Ha

Introduction: We have calculated the amount of antero-posterior diameter expansion by tibial intramedullary nails with distal anterior bend which were designed to prevent proximal posterior cortical fracture by the distal tip of a nail on insertion in the surgical treatment of tibial fracture.

Materials and Methods: Russell-Taylor® and AIM™ tibial nails were compared in respect to the amount of anteroposterior diameter expansion by the distal anterior bend of these nails. AIM™ tibial nails have shorter length but larger angle of distal anterior bend than Russell-Taylor® tibial nails. As Fig.1. shows, if we suppose that the length and angle of distal anterior bend of nail be L and _, respectively and the length of distal tapered portion be T, the amount of anteroposterior diameter expansion (E) by the distal anterior bend portion of the nail is [(L-T) _ sin_]. So, intramedullary nail with distal anterior bend passes down the medullary canal with an actual diameter (AD) of the sum of given diameter of the nail (D) and [(L-T) _ sin_] on anteroposterior plane.

Results: The amount of anteroposterior diameter expansion of Russell-Taylor® and AIM™ tibial nail was 2.81 mm and 3.26 mm more than the given nail diameter because the length and angle of distal anterior bend of Russell-Taylor® and AIM™ tibial nails were 64 mm, 3° and 47.5 mm, 5°, respectively and about 10 mm of distal tip of both nails are tapered to facilitate passage in the medullary canal.

Conclusion: On insertion of tibial nails with distal anterior bend, the anteroposterior diameter expansion effect by these nails should be carefully considered to prevent fracture of the isthmus. We think that the nail about 2 to 3 mm smaller than the final reamer used in diameter had better be used when you try to insert an intramedullary nail bent anteriorly at distal portion such as Russell-Taylor® and AIM™ tibial nails.


M.R. Rao

Purpose: The management of comminuted inter trochanteric fracture are a serious and difficult problem. The proper selection of fixation device is must to avoid significant complication in the management of this common fracture.

The use of contoured side plate screw attached to the sliding screw plate anchors the comminuted fragments thus gives better stability, compression, early mobility and bony union to this fracture where other implant fails.

Material and method: Since 1997 to 2000, 60 comminuted inter trochanteric fracture- age of 67yrs (46–91year) were treated by close/open reduction and internal fixation with 135 dynamic hip screw plate +side screw plate.

The side plate is a narrow D.C.P. (4/5 hole) which is contoured to the fl are of greater trochanter proximally and is attached to the sliding screw plate. The proximal holes of side plate hold the comminuted fragment of greater trochanter with cancellous screw above the sliding hip screw The patient were encouraged to walk on 2nd post operative day with support to start with partial weight bearing followed by weight bearing at 4 wk.

Result: On an average 12-week (8–16 wk) all the Tranzo grade II/ III fracture went into union . There was lengthening of 2.5cm (2–5 cm) in 15 cases due to valgus reduction which reduced to 1.5 cm (2–3cm) at end of 6 months. Backing up of the side plate screw and sliding hip screw was seen in 40% of case (24) (mainly in poor bone stock and valgus reduction case).

Conclusion: The side plate/ screw with sliding hip screw stables buttress for comminuted trochanter fragments gives compression, prevent rotation and better bony union the piece. This implant is an extended arm for holding fragment. The major trochanteric fracture fragment are held by side plate to sliding screw plate thus gives stability to the device, better bony contact thus early mobility and union. The sliding screw device with side plate is “forgiving” it allows subsequent displacement to achieve stability in comminuted fracture. The success of the implant assembly rest on the ability of slide and hold the fragment to give stability and bony union. This method gives an option of open reduction and bone grafting.


J.G. Birch M. L. Samchukov R.D. Welch P.W. Mack D.G. Bronson

Introduction: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications such as Ibuprofen are commonly used to aid in the management of chronic pain in both children and adults. These medications are known to retard fracture consolidation and inhibit the formation of heterotopic bone in susceptible patients. We wished to determine the deleterious effects, if any, of the administration of therapeutic doses of Ibuprofen on the strength of regenerate bone in a caprine model.

Method: Twelve skeletally immature cross-bred goats were divided into two groups. In both groups, a standard four-ring, 6-wire Ilizarov apparatus was fixed to the tibia of one hindlimb and mid-diaphyseal corticotomy performed. After a five-day latency period, the operated tibiae were lengthened to 20% of their original length at rate and rhythm of 0.25mm TID. Consolidation time was standardized at 80 days. Group I received Ibuprofen at a dose of 20mg/kg BID PO during the entire postoperative period. Group II received no additional medication, and served as the control group. The animals were monitored for gatrointestinal intolerance, blood dyscrasias, and blood levels of Ibuprofen throughout the experiment. At the end of consolidation, the twelve lengthened tibiae and the contralateral tibiae were harvested for mechanical testing.

Results: In the medicated group, no adverse affects on the gastrointestinal or hematopoietic organ systems were identified. Blood Ibuprofen levels remained in the low therapeutic range during the course of the experiment (average levels 28.9 ug/ml at 1.5 hrs, 15.1ug/ml at 4 hrs., and 2.6 ug/ml at 8 hrs., after oral administration of Ibuprofen) .

One nonunion developed in each of the two treatment groups, and was unsuitable for mechanical testing. The remaining 22 tibiae (10 lengthened, and 12 contralateral unoperated, tibiae) were torqued to failure on the MTS testing machine. There were no significant differences between the unoperated tibiae of the Ibu-profen group and the unmedicated group measuring torsional toughness, stiffness, and strength. Similarly, there were no differences detected using these parameters between the lengthened tibiae of the medicated and unmedicated groups.

No adverse systemic affects were noted during the course of this experiment, in which low therapeutic levels of Ibuprofen were maintained for an average of 120 days. No affect on the torsional strength of the unoperated tibia was detected. No adverse affect on the torsional strength, stiffness, or toughness of the regenerate of the medicated group was noted compared to the control group.

Conclusions: The chronic administration of Ibuprofen was well-tolerated and did not adversely affect the strength of untreated or lengthened tibiae in this model.


KI. Kim KH. Koo YC. Ha HB. Park SH. Cho

The purpose of current study was to describe the results of complex acetabular fractures treated with open reduction using transtrochanteric approach and arthrotomy of the hip joint. Fourteen consecutive patients with both column fractures of the acetabulum were treated with open reduction and internal fixation. All patients had various associated injuries. Among them, one patient had pelvic abscess associated with traumatic bowel perforation. The acetabulum was approached with Y-shaped triradiate incision, osteotomy of the greater trochanter, and arthrotomy of the hip joint. During the operation, the osteochondral fragments were removed and torn labrum was resected. In 6 patients the fracture was fixed with reconstruction plates and in 8 patients the fracture was fixed with plates and wires. All the patients were followed for an average of 4.6 years(range, 2–8 years). The clinical evaluation was done by the method of Merle d’Aubigne. All the fractures and all osteotomies united at the latest follow up. One patient had delayed hematogenous infection at 5.5 years after the operation. Although myositis ossificans developed in 3 patients it was neither progressive after 1 year nor associated with significant limitation of hip motion. Four patients had narrowing of the hip joint space. Three of them had osteophyte formation around the femoral head. No femoral head necrosis was observed. Eleven patients had excellent or good outcomes in clinical score. No patient underwent total hip arthroplasty. This extensile approach allowed a good exposure of the fracture site, more accurate reduction, and easier fixation of fracture fragments. It also allowed the removal of osteochondral fragments and the resection of torn labrum. However, 3 patients showed osteophyte formation around the femoral head. We are concerned about the further progression of the osteophyte and its clinical implication.


A.P. Pohl

Aim: To establish a method of emergency and definitive stabilisation of Type C pelvic ring injuries.

Methods: Patients with pelvic ring disruption were treated acutely, using instrumentation developed by Dr. Charles Reinert. Patients were positioned supine on a radiolucent operating table configured to allow the C-arm of an image intensifier to swing through an arc sufficient to allow pelvic inlet and outlet views of the pelvis. The unstable hemipelvis was reduced by means of longitudinal traction on the leg and lateral compression with a spiked, long handled, cannulated guide. Guide wires could be positioned accurately through the guide, allowing accurate placement of AO 7.3 mm cannulated iliosacral screws, by minimally invasive percutaneous techniques.

Results: Successful acute biomechanical pelvic stabilisation was achieved in all cases. After a short learning curve, the procedure could be completed in 20 minutes.

Discussion: Previously, pelvic stabilisation was often achieved by initial, tentative stabilisation using pelvic slings, traction and external fixation, with or without later definitive fixation. Using minimally invasive techniques, rapid, emergency stabilisation can be achieved, with sufficient stability to equally suffice for definitive fixation. The minimally invasive, percutaneous technique provides greater safety for treatment of patients with early coagulopathy.

Conclusions: Acute, rapid and definitive stabilisation of type C pelvic ring disruption can be achieved by minimally invasive, percutaneous techniques using the Reinert instrumentation.


MS. Kuster TN. Forster H. Ploeg KR. Grob

Introduction: For plate osteosynthesis (OS) many surgeons use a rigid fixation which prevents callus formation. The present paper applies biomechanical laws and a FE analysis for optimal screw placement to turn a rigid plate OS into a dynamic and biological OS.

Methods: A Finite Element Analysis was performed. The bone was modeled as a cylinder with an outer diameter of 30 mm and an inner diameter of 22 mm. An E-modul of 18 GPa was assumed for cortical bone. A DC steel plate was modeled with a preload of 300 N for each screw. Fracture motion and stress on the screw head was calculated for different screw placements and a load of 300 N angulated at 30 deg.

Results: The number of screws did not influence fracture motion. This could only be controlled by the distance of the first screw to the fracture site, the use of a lag screw and the material of the plate. When one screw hole was omitted close to the fracture site, motion doubled. Using A lag screw reduced fracture motion dramatically. The stress was greatest at the screw closest to the fracture site.

Conclusions: In order to achieve a dynamic plate OS with callus formation a long plate with a minimal amount of screws and no lag screws should be used. To adjust the flexibility of the OS, the distance of the first screw to the fracture site is the most crucial parameter. Additional screws do not influence the stiffness. The stress is highest at the screw head close to the fracture site. This screw is endangered for fatigue failure. To reduce the stress on this screw it must not be placed oblique and also not eccentric. However, the last screw has little stress and should be placed oblique to increase the pull out strength.


K. Yasumura

The Os subfibulare, or round ossicles at the tip of the lateral malleolus, are often regarded as accessory bone. Some patients with such fragments, however, complain of ankle pain and repeated sprain. This study addresses whether these fragments are unnecessary and ignorable?

Materials and method: From 1986 to 1998, we treated 54 ankles in 52 patients surgically. The average age at surgery was 18 years; the mean follow up period was 4.7 years. The whole the fragment was fixed to the lateral malleolus using a tension band.

Results: Each fragment was attached to at least one ligament. We classified these attachments as follows:

Type I a: only ATFL was attached to one fragment

Type I b: ATFL and CF were attached to one fragment

Type I c: ATFL, CF, and PTFL were attached to one fragment

Type II : ATFL and CF were attached to two individual fragments

There were 7 Type I a, 37 Type I b, 6 Type I c, and 4 Type II. Fifty-one ankles (94%) developed bony union and three united fibrously. The talar tilt was restored from 9.8 to 4.7 degrees after surgery. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Societyñs clinical rating system for the ankle-hindfoot improved from 77 to 98 and ankle pain decreased dramatically.

Conclusion: The fragment at the tip of the lateral malleolus is the origin site of the lateral ligaments. This fragment can be united with the lateral malleolus. We believe that the fragments are keystones of the lateral ankle ligament complex.


Full Access
R. Paterson

Ankle sprains are very common, and usually tear or partly tear one or more of the ligaments on the outer side of the ankle. The ankle joint is only designed to move up and down, whereas there is another joint immediately below the ankle joint, called the subtalar joint, which is designed to do the tilting in and out movement. If the foot tilts over too far, the subtalar joint reaches the end of its movement and then the ankle ligaments stretch and tear.

It is possible that variations of subtalar range of movement may contribute to ankle sprains or symptoms of weakness or instability. In particular, if the subtalar joint is unusually restricted in its movement, then the foot does not have to tilt far before the lateral ligaments tear.

If on the other hand the subtalar joint is particularly mobile and has excessive movement, then the foot may go right over without actually tearing ligaments and feel insecure or unstable simply as a result of abnormal excessive movement.

Recent studies have demonstrated what we have always suspected, that clinical examination and assessment of subtalar range of movement is highly unreliable. In order to accurately assess whether your subtalar range of movement is unusually restricted or excessive, the only standard and accurate method to date has been to obtain a CT scan.

We are now undertaking a study to establish whether plain xrays with a small metal clamp applied to the heel might not be a simpler, cheaper, quicker and equally reliable method of assessment of subtalar movement.

If you would like to know if your subtalar movement might be a contributing factor to either stiffness or insecurity of your ankle, we invite you to be examined clinically, by plain xrays at SPORTSMED•SA, and by a CT scan at Jones & Partners Radiology at Burnside. The xray and CT investigations would be bulk billed under Medicare so that you would not incur any personal cost and the information could well be helpful in assessing your ankle problem, or at least be reassuring that the subtalar joint has a normal range of movement.

The investigations can be arranged through your treating doctor, physiotherapist or podiatrist or by contacting Dr Roger Paterson, Foot and Ankle Surgeon, or Mr Stephen Landers, his Research Assistant, on Ph: 8362 7788.

The CT scan would be a very limited investigation resulting in minimum radiation exposure, comparable to the normal xrays. Further information on what is involved in having a CT scan is attached.

Neither the CT scan nor the plain xrays should cause any more than minor discomfort as the foot is tilted through its full range of movement, or from the padded pressure of the G clamp.

SPORTSMED•SA remains committed to excellence in treating active people of all ages, and through these investigations, we plan to further enhance the quality of assessment and care of people who suffer ankle problems.


DG. Little

Introduction: Distraction osteogenesis is a widely utilised orthopaedic procedure; however prolonged treatment time and considerable disuse osteoporosis remain problematic, with decreases of 44% to 61% in bone mineral density reported in adjacent bone. Refracture rates of 10–20% are reported after frame removal.

We set out to examine the role of bisphosphonates in protecting the bone against stress-shielding related osteopaenia during distraction osteogenesis. We used a NZW rabbit model with 2 weeks distraction to 10.5 mm then 4 weeks consolidation. We achieved positive results in the initial trial using the bisphosphonate pamidronate (Novartis). Not only were we able to abolish the decrease in BMD in the surrounding bone, we noted an increase in the mineral properties and strength of the new bone.

Moving on to zoledronic acid (Novartis), a third generation bisphosphonate designed for use in malignant hypercalcaemia and bone metastases, we achieved even more promising results. In a study of thirty rabbits, we gave saline to 10 controls, 0.1 mg/kg zoledronic acid to 10 rabbits at surgery and 10 further rabbits received 0.1 mg/kg zoledronic acid at surgery and at two weeks. The animals were scanned by DXA at 2, 4 and 6 weeks, and by QCT after culling. Mechanical testing was performed by destructive 4-point bend tests.

Second-weekly DXA scans documented faster mineral accrual after distraction between 2 and 4 weeks in both treatment groups (ANOVA p< 0.01). In the control group, the BMD in the segments around the lengthening fell by 0.16 g/cm2 between the 2nd and 6th week. The BMD showed a net increase over the same time period in all treated animals (ANOVA p< 0.01).

The cross sectional area of the regenerate at six weeks as measured by QCT was increased by 49% in the zoledronate group versus controls and by 59% in the re-dosed zoledronate group. (ANOVA p< 0.01). The final (6 week) BMC of the regenerate was increased by 92% in the zoledronate group versus controls and by 111% in the re-dosed zoledronate group (ANOVA p< 0.01). Bone mineral density was increased by a lesser but significant degree to normal values (28% and 34% respectively, ANOVA p< 0.01).

Four point bend testing revealed increases in peak load of 29% in the single dose and 89% in the re-dosed group (ANOVA p< 0.01).

Two patients are presented, one with congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia, and one who had not united a distraction gap of 5 cm at six months, who were treated with pamidronate. Both showed successful responses in line with our research findings.

A clinical trial is being set up to establish a scientific case for bisphosphonate use in patients undergoing distraction osteogenesis with the aim of possible earlier frame removal and less refractures. Further research in other areas of bone healing is also planned.


N. Usami S. Inokuchi E. Hiraishi A. Waseda C. Shimamura

Purpose: Pain occasionally develops in the posterior tibial tendon after chronic sprains, whose pathology is not known yet. We inserted an endoscope (tendoscope) into the tendon sheath of the tibialis posterior and treated based on the observation of its pathology.

Subjects and methods: Subjects were patients who had complained pain in the posterior tibial tendon after ankle sprain. The interval from the injury to the tendo-scope ranged from one month to one year and 8 months with an average of 9 months. There were 18 patients (11males, 7females). The age ranged from 18 to 33 years with an average of 24 years. For initial treatment, cast fixation, and orthoses were employed in 10 patients. Other 8 patients were left with bandage alone. For these patients, a 2.4mm-diameter endoscope was inserted into the tendon sheath.

Results: Synovia proliferation was found in all the cases, and vicula in the tendon sheath disappeared. Synovia proliferation was found in all patients and erosion of the tendon was observed in 8 patients. In other 3 patients, injured sliding floor of the posterior tibial tendon was found. For treatment, synovectomy and smoothing of the sliding floor were performed. All the patients had improvement of pain and returned to sports with the former level.

Discussion: It has been known that, in some cases, pain emerges in the posterior tibial tendon after ankle sprain. Its pathology has remained unknown. It is suggested that injuries in the tendon sheath of the tibialis posterior, sliding floor of the tendon, and deltoid ligament associated with the sprain may have caused inflammations, which has developed synovia proliferation. It is thought posterior tibial tendon is often injured after ankle sprain.


L.B. Solomon L. Ferris J. Taylor R. Pope M. Henneberg

The incidence of tarsal coalitions (TC) is not known. Most of the clinical studies report it as less then 1% but they disregard the asymptomatic coalitions. Two main theories have been elaborated regarding their etiology: 1) they result by incorporation of accessory bones into the nearby tarsals; 2) they occur as a result of the failure of differentiation and segmentation of the foetalmes-enchyme. Tarsal coalitions have been associated with degenerative arthritic changes. Computer tomography is the most commonly used diagnostic test in the detection of TC. The aims of our study were to establish the incidence of TC; the association between TC and accessory tarsal bones and between TC and tarsal arthritis; and to assess the sensitivity of CT as a diagnostic tool in TC. For this purpose we have undertaken coronal and sagittal CTs of 114 cadaveric feet which were subsequently dissected. The dissections identified 10 non-osseous tarsal coalitions, two talocalcaneal and eight calcaneonavicular. In nine cases we identified a synovial joint between the calcaneus and the navicular. We identified eight os trigonum, one accessory lateral malleolus bone, 38 sesamoid bones in the tendon of tibialis posterior and 19 sesamoid bones in the tendon of fibularis longus. Tarsal arthritis was identified in 37 cases. Both talocalcaneal coalitions were associated with talocal-caneal arthritis while none of the calcaneonavicular coalitions were associated with tarsal arthritis. The CT examination of five of the cases of calcaneonavicular coalitions showed one coalition and was suspicious of a coalition in another two instances. In conclusion our study demonstrated that the incidence of tarsal coalition is higher than previously thought (8.8%). The calcaneonavicular coalitions are more common (7%) but they do not seem to be associated with arthritic changes in the tarsal bones. The 7.9% of the calcaneonavicular synovial joint demonstrate that the “abnormality” of the calcaneonavicular space can take any form. Our preliminary CT results demonstrate a low sensitivity in the detection of nonosseous coalitions.


K.H. Mak T.K. Kwok

Thoracolumbar junction of the spinal column is the common site of spinal trauma and is often complicated by neurological dysfunction. From 1997 to 2000, there were 12 patients surgically stabilized. 8 of them were victims of major trauma while the rest was after a trivial fall in osteoporotic spine. Lengthen of follow-up ranged from 6 to 42 months.

Ages of the patients in the major trauma group were from 22 to 65. Except the one who had anterior approach because of multiple level lesions, all fractures after major trauma were initially relocated and stabilized posteriorly. Subsequent anterior procedures were necessary in three of them because of significant residual spinal canal stenosis. All except one had satisfactory lower limb function on follow up. Two patients who were paralysed on admission were able to walk independently and 4 others had improved by at least one Frankel grade. Return of neurological function was usually observed within the first week after the procedure. Residual sphincter dysfunction was however, a common problem.

The management of four osteoporotic spinal fractures in thoracolumbar junction was more unpredictable. Patients were from 66 to 92 years old. Anterior decompression was often performed because of the presence of retropulsed fragment. Although some improvement of lower limb function could be achieved, rehabilitation in three of them was complicated by loss of reduction or failure of the implant.

Recovery of the neurological function in the lower limbs was found to have no correlation with the amount of stenosis of the spinal canal. Most of the damage occurred probably at the time of injury. The sphincter control was most difficult to rehabilitate after an insult to the conus medullaris.


S. Okada S Ito H. Furuno T. Ueta K. Shiba Y. Takemitsu H. Ohta E. Mori I. Yugue T. Kitamura

In cases above C4 cervical cord injury a respiratory distress and serious pulmonary complications occur with frequent obstruction of air way by increased excretion and difficult evacuation. Long term tracheal intubation often provides many general complications. We analized advantage and demerit of early tracheotomy in such cases of cervical cord injury patients.

Material and Methods: 1) We proposed early tracheotomy to prevent complications and ease respiration when pts showed low vital capacity (v.c.) less than 500cc showing deltoid/biceps palsy and respiratory distress with much excretion and difficult evacuation. 2) We have analysed 91 patients who needed ventilator out of 845 cervical cord injury patients who admitted in our hospital. 2) 25 pts were treated by tracheotomy from the beginning of treatment, and others were switched over from management of tracheal intubation. 3) We used a double cuff tracheotomy tube to prevent continuous pressure to the tracheal wall. 4) Weaning from ventilator was done when Fi02< 0.3, PEEP< 5cmH2O and PaO2> 80mmHg in room air.

Results: 1) 4 (16%) out of 25 pts who had been treated with tracheotomy from the beginning had atelectasis, whereas 15 (23%) out of 66 pts treated with intubation occurred that symtome, and 20% of the pts suffered pneumonia. 2) Out of 46 pts treated with intratracheal intubation in the beginning and then changed to tracheotomy within 4 days 7(15%) had atelectasis, whereas 20 (29%) of the pts who underwent tracheotomy after 5 days occurred the complication. 3) As complication of tracheotomy? Infection and? tracheal stenosis were observed but all uneventful healed.

Discussion/Conclusion: 1) Acutecervical cord injury pts showing deltoid/biceps palsy have impending respiratory distress. Examination of spirometer is essential. In such cases low v.c. < 500 tracheotomy should be indicated. 2) Continuing respiratory distress > 4days of intubation it is advised tracheotomy in order to prevent genera l complications. 3) Combination with frequent position changing and chest tapping is also essential for evacuation.


T. Furukawa M. Hayashi T. Itoh T. Ogino

Introduction: The efficacy and complications of the transarticular screw procedure have been reported by many authors. However, few have reported this procedure for child younger than 10 years old. We have treated two children for atlantoaxial subluxation with transarticular screws, using a soft collar without a halo-vest, and have achieved bone union in good reduced position.

Methods/results

Case 1: a 5-year-old boy with mental retardation and cerebellar infarction due to an insufficiency of the vertebral artery resulting in severe atlantoaxial instability. He presented with a high degree of congenital atlantoaxial subluxation complicated by Os odontoideum. He has been treated with transarticular screw and iliac bone graft by Brooks procedure.

Case 2: an 8-year-old boy with congenital spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia and a right valgus knee. He, too, presented with a high degree of congenital atlantoaxial subluxation complicated by Os odontoideum, and has been treated with transarticular screw and iliac bone graft by Brooks procedure.

In both cases, we used two half-thread cortical screws with a diameter of 2.7mm and a length of 30mm for the transarticular screw procedure.

Discussion/conclusion: Rigid external fixation was obtained by Halo-vest. This method, however, would be expected to cause mental stress for the child patient and the family. More rigid internal fixation would be required to resolve this problem. More rigid internal fixation can be obtained with the transarticular screw, and postoperative orthosis can be performed easily, without the need for a Halo-vest.


Full Access
N. Usami S. Inokuchi E. Hiraishi A. Waseda C. Shimamura

Purpose: Severe trauma in the mid-foot induces various foot deformities, causing pain. The mechanism and treatment of foot deformities following mid-foot trauma were evaluated.

Materials: We evaluated feet showing dislocation and/or fracture of 2 or more joints or 2 or more tarsal bones encountered at our department between 1983 and 1996. The subjects were 24 males (26 feet) and 8 females (8 feet) aged 21–58 years (mean, 37 years). The injury that caused foot deformities was navicular bone fracture in 1 case, Chopart dislocation in 3, Lisfranc dislocation in 23, and fracture dislocation of the cuneiform in 5, The follow-up period was 2 years and 4 months _ 8 years (mean, 4 years and 9 months). Deformities occurred in these cases and associated factors were evaluated.

Results: Flat foot deformity occurred in the 1 case of navicular bone dislocation and 2 of fracture dislocation of the cuneiform. Cavovarus deformity occurred in the 6 cases of Lisfranc fracture dislocation. Other deformities were observed in 3 feet. All patients complained of pain and fatigability during walking and were treated by corrective osteotomy and arthrodesis. Though the pain reduced, discomfort in the foot persisted, making heavy labor impossible in 3 cases.

Discussion: In the mid-foot, there are many small tarsal bones, to which many tendons and ligaments are attached, forming the foot arch. Even though injury of one joint or one ligament (tendon), foot deformity can be induced. It is also possible that intraarticular injury was already severe at the time of injury, inducing secondary deformity. In trauma of the mid-foot involving multiple joints, the injured area should be adequately evaluated by preoperative stress X-P or MRI.


T. Yamamoto A. Miyauchi M. Iwasaki S. Suzuki

Purposes: To evaluate the validity of pedicle screw fixation in 20 patients with toracolumbar spine infections.

Methods and Materials: There were seven tuberculous and thirteen pyogenic infection, eight had thoracic and 12 had lumbar lesion. The indications for surgical treatment were; progressive bone destruction, mal-alignment or neurological deficit. On nine cases, we did two-step operation, which was bone graft from anterior and pedicle screw fixation from posterior. On 11 cases, we did debridement, interbody graft and the pedicle screw fixation from posterior simultaneously. We examined the outcomes of the infection, symptoms including neurological deficit and the graft bones postoperatively with follow-up period of 25 months in the average. We also examined changes of alignment after surgery and surgical complications as well to evaluate the validity of the surgery.

Results: Fusion of graft were confirmed in all cases within seven and half months in the average. Clinically, all of 14 patients who had had paraparesis gained neurological recovery of one or two steps of Frankel’s criteria after the surgery. Complications were, fracture of graft, fracture of vertebral body, screw loosening with alignment deterioration and recurrence of infection in one case each.

Summary: Pedicle screw fixation revealed a usefulness in surgical treatment of spine infection.


WC. Chen

There have been many reports on fracture-dislocation of the lumbar spine in recent years. Hyperextension as a mechanism for fracture-dislocation in the thoracolumbar spine was first described by Holdsworth accounting for only less than 3 percent of all fractures of the spine. De Oliverira reported an unusual pattern of sagittal shear fracture-dislocation secondary to posterior impact injuries. Hyperextension injuries result in the disruption of all ligaments & supporting elements of the spine starting with the anterior column. Sagittal translation and comminution of the posterior elements are the most common radiographic findings. Computed Tomography can accurately demonstrate the destruction of the posterior elements, and MRI is able to demonstrate the anterior ligamentous disruption. Nearly all cases suffered from paraplegia known as lumberjack paraplegia or severe neurological deficit.

A case of complete fracture-dislocation of the L4-5 resulting from hyperextensive injury without lumberjack paraplegia or neurological deficit is presented.

The diagnosis & treatment will be discussed.


H. Ohta T. Ueta K. Shiba Y. Takemitsu E. Mori K. Kaji I. Yugue Y. Kitamura

We have reported that most of lower cervical cord injury patients had either improved or remained the same neurology following early operative stabilization done in our hospital. However, a few patients deteriorated with ascending paralysis in acute stage. Purpose of this paper is to present such cases and discuss the outcomes.

Methods: 1) We have analyzed 10 pts of acute lower cervical cord injury who had deteriorated neurologic symptom ascending above C4 and complicated with respiratory quadriplegia. They accounted for 3.7 % out of 271 patients with bony injury. 2) They were 8 males and 2 females, aged 17~76, injury type C5/6 fracture-dislocation (Fx/Dx) in 4, C6/7 Fx/Dx in 4, C7/T1 in 1, and one C5 flexion tear drop Fx. 3) 2 patients were treated conservatively and 8 had operative reduction and fusion with careful technique.

Results: 1) All patients had complete quadriplegia. 2) 3 pts could not wean out of ventilator and other 2 of them eventually died. 3) Paralysis started to ascend in 3 days after injury needed ventilator in 24 hours thereafter. 4) 2 out of 10 patients underwent an excessive distraction being treated conservatively. 8 patients had operative fixation for bony injuries, 7 of them obtained solid spine with single operation, but one had redislocated in a few days after the operation and received restabilisation surgery.

Conclusion: 1) There are a few patients of acute lower cervical injury with complete quadriplegia deteriorated neurology ascending paralysis with respiratory distress. 2) Comparing to other cases an operative treatment would not a cause of such neurologic deterioration. 3) In most cases paralysis of diaphragm was passing symptom, but quite a few patients(1%) could not wean off ventilator. 4) Cause of ascending paralysis in such injury could not be identified definitely, therefore careful observation and prompt treatment such as tracheotomy should be recommended.


H Ohta T. Ueta K. Shiba Y. Takemitsu E. Mori K. Kaji I. Yugue

Charcot spondyloarthropathy is one of the late complications of traumatic spinal cord injury that produces further disability. Purpose of this paper is to introduce 5 patients who developed Charcot spine after traumatic spinal cord injury treated surgically in our hospital (SIC) and discuss the result.

Methods: 1) We experienced 7 pts who presented characteristic clinical and radiographic findings of Charcot spine treated in SIC for 20 years (an incidence < 1%). 2) 5 out of 7 pts underwent surgical fusion. They were 4 males, 1 female, aged: 39~66, previous injury comprises of: C6 Fracture-dislocation(Fx/Dx) in 1, T11 Fx/Dx in 2, T12 Fx/Dx in 2. respectively, 3) 4 pts had complete paraplegia, 0ne incomplete(Frankel B) and the Charcot spine occurred below fusion mass under the injured level. 4) Posterior spinal fusions combined with kyphosis correction were performed in 3, the same with posterior shortening osteotomy using TSRH instruments in 2. Fusions were extended to L4 in 1, L5 in 2, S1 in 2 respectively.

Results: 1) 4 pts who had been followed-up over one year showed ultimate osseous union. Another one showed loosening of screws resulted in non-union at 5 months postoperatively. 2) Cobb angle of kyphosis were improved from 67.7 degrs. in av.(58~82) to 13.7 degrs in av. (15~36) by the operation. 3) All pts could have restored a good sitting balance tolerated a long time wheelchair sitting without any localized back pain.

Conclusion: It is important for physicians who treat spinal cord injury patients to be aware of posttraumatic Charcot spine. As longevity of the people with paralysis is increasing, this phenomenon may occur more apparently. Special attention should be given to the spinal segments just below the fused level in patients with previous spinal fusion. For the unstable and symptomatic Charcot spine, a surgical correction and fusion should be considered. The correction of kyphosis is essential, but too much correction should be avoided, because it may worsen a sitting balance of the patient. We now recommend a posterior shortening osteotomy and rigid fusion using a solid pedicle screw instrumentation like TSRH.


CTJ Servant* JL Pozo

Objective: To assess the early results of the TC3 knee prosthesis, a modular system with stems and augments, in difficult primary and revision knee arthroplasties.

Method: 13 index procedures were undertaken for gross varus or valgus deformities with severe ligamentous incompetence and/or major bone defects. 18 procedures were revision arthroplasties, 7 being undertaken for sepsis.

28 knees underwent full clinical and radiological review at a mean of 25.8 months post-operatively, using the Hospital for Special Surgery Score and the Knee Society Score. 2 patients were interviewed by phone with recent radiological follow-up. One patient had died from unrelated causes.

Results: All patients were very pleased with the outcome of surgery.

The mean pre-operative alignment for the primary arthroplasties was 28° for the varus and 32° for the valgus knees. The mean postoperative alignment was 7°. The mean Hospital for Special Surgery score was 72.4 for primary arthroplasties and 72.7 for revision surgery. The mean Knee Society Knee Score was 79.8 and 75.1 respectively, and the mean Functional Score was 60.8 and 49.4 respectively. The latter reflects the elderly age, multiple joint involvement and constitutional status (including rheumatoid arthritis) of many of these patients. 4 patients experienced retropatellar pain. One patient with severe rheumatoid developed sepsis of the revision implant.

Difficulties with tibial tray lateralisation and stem fixation will be discussed.

Conclusion: The TC3 knee system affords an excellent modular option to compensate for bone defects and ligamentous incompetence, achieving restoration of the joint line and satisfactory function.


P McEwen M Kitchener G Keene R Paterson R Oakshot

Between December 1998 and December 1999 twenty-one patients with painful knee arthroplasties underwent assessment by radionuclide arthrography. There were eleven female and ten male patients, with an average age of 60 years at the time of the index procedure. The index procedure was a primary total knee arthroplasty, primary medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty and revision medial UKA in seventeen, three and one patients respectively. Nineteen arthroplasties were uncemented and two were hybrids. All patients had previously been investigated by clinical examination, serological testing, fluoroscopic AP and lateral radiographs, and Tc99 bone scan with equivocal results. The presence of radionuclide about the tibial stem was considered diagnostic of tibial loosening. Nine patients underwent revision knee arthroplasty. The presence of radionuclide about the tibial stem correctly predicted a loose tibial component in four of five cases. Similarly, the absence of radionuclide about the tibial stem correctly predicted a stable tibial component in four of four cases. In the single misdiagnosed case the tibial component did not have a large central stem, had focal osteolysis about several screws, but remained stable. Radionuclide arthrogram is a useful tool in the investigation of painful knee arthroplasty. Radionuclide about the tibial stem is the key predictor of tibial component loosening.


K.Y. Chiu T.P. Ng W.M. Tang P. Lam

Introduction: We compared the early results of mobile-bearing knee prosthesis with fixed-bearing knee prosthesis in 20 patients who had one-stage, sequential, bilateral replacements.

Patients and Methods: In each patient, a Low Contact Stress (LCS, Depuy) rotating-platform prosthesis was inserted in one side, and an Anatomic Modular Knee (AMK, Depuy) posterior-stabilised prosthesis was inserted in the other side. The same surgical routines were adopted for both sides in each patient. The LCS and AMK knees were comparable in Knee Society knee scores, knee flexion and flexion contracture before surgery.

Results: There were significant improvements in the Knee Society knee and functional scores after surgery (p < 0.001) for both LCS and AMK knees. Although the LCS knees had better Knee Society knee score, better knee flexion, and less residual flexion contracture at final follow-up, all these were not statistically significant when compared with the AMK knees.

Discussion and Conclusion: The results of mobile-bearing knee replacements were as good as those that followed fixed-bearing knee replacements.


N.W. Thompson A.L. Ruiz E. Breslin D.E. Beverland

Thirty-one patients (33 knees) with symptomatic patello-femoral osteoarthritis and minimal tibiofemoral changes underwent LCS total knee replacement without patellar resurfacing.

Average age was 73 years (range, 58–89 years) with a female to male ratio of 5:1. Average follow-up was 20 months (range, 12–40 months). All except four patients had grade 3 or 4 patello-femoral osteoarthritis.

Preoperatively all patients had significant knee pain. Sleep disturbance was reported in 21 patients. All but 10 patients required walking aids. Average range of motion was 1080 (80–125).

At latest review, 21 knees are pain-free, the remaining 12 knees describing only occasional knee pain. Two patients continue to have night pain. Average range of motion was 1040 (70–1350). Lateral patellar tilt improved in all but five knees by an average of 70 (1–260). Patellar congruency improved in all but three knees by an average of 18% (3–63%). None of the patients to date have required revision surgery.

We suggest that knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing is an effective option in older patients with isolated patello-femoral osteoarthritis.


H.K.T. Raza

The problem of chronic, haematogenous osteomyelitis is still a major one in developing countries. There are several patients who report with multiple discharging sinuses and a history of several operative procedures. The persistence of sepsis and repeated operations takes its physical, mental and financial toll.

The use of local muscle pedicle for filling saucerized cavities in chronic osteomyelitis was described by Starr and later by Ger. However, it has somehow not caught the fancy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.

The paper is a report of 55 cases of chronic osteomyelitis of long bones treated by use of the method. Anterior 1/3rd of Deltoid was used for proximal end of Humerus & lateral _ of brachialis for lower 1/3rd by a double breasting technique. The femoral shaft was filled by vastus lateralis by the author’s double breasting technique. The Medial Head of Gastrocnemius, soleus and Flexor Hallucis longus were used separately or in combinations for proximal 2/3rd of Tibia. The Abductor Hallucis was used for medial malleolus and calcaneum. A thorough debridement of necrotic and infected tissues preceded the application of muscle pedicle which was done as a single stage procedure.

The age of patients ranged from 8 yrs to 54 yrs with male preponderance. The followup of cases ranges between 18 months to 13 years with an average of 5.8 years.

All cases except 2 in femur showed no recurrence of sepsis. Two patients in femur had fracture through saucerized area.

It is concluded that filling of saucerized cavities with muscle graft obliterates the dead space as well as improves local vascularity. It adds only 20 minutes of operative time on an average and the technique is simple. It gives uniformly good results.


F.Y. Ho

Between 1995 and 1998, eighty revision total knee arthroplasties were done for the primary reason of advanced polyethylene wear. The primary arthroplasties prosthesis that failed included thirty-four mobile bearing knees and forty-six fixed bearing knees. In thirty-four Low Contact Stress (LCS) mobile bearing knees, osteolysis was identified intraoperatively in sixteen knees (forty-seven per cent). There were varying of fixation methods included nine cemented, four cementless and three hybrids. In forty-six fixed bearing knees, osteolysis was identified intraoperatively in six knees (thirteen per cent). The fixation methods of prostheses included two cemented and four cementless. The incidence of osteolysis was statistically significant difference between the mobile bearing and fixed bearing knees (p< 0.02).

Both scattering electron microscope (SEM) and light scattering analysis were used to examine the UHMWPE wear debris collected from tissue sample. The particle size analyzed by light-scattering is coincident with the measurement by SEM. The major type of wear debris extracted from failed knee prostheses is granular shape. There are more granular wear debris appear in the mobile bearing knees than in the fixed bearing knees. The particle size of UHMWPE wear debris with osteolysis was significantly smaller than that without osteolysis. The high rate of osteolytic lesions in mobile bearing knee (LCS) is well illustrated in our result that a lot of fine UHMWPE wear debris generated in the Low Contact Stress knee. The result also illustrates that there is no relationship between fixation methods and the third body wear that associate with osteolysis.


D. McMinn

Most total knee replacement designs incorporate the views of the designer relating to the function of the normal knee. A video of the normal cadaverie knee will be shown and depending on the loading regime the following movements can be clearly demonstrated: femoral roll-back, femoro-tibial rotation, medial pivot and lateral pivot. Knee replacement designs which do not allow all of the above movements risk Kinematic conflict. A knee replacement design will be shown which permits all of the normal knee movements.


M Bowditch R Paterson

Eighteen porous coated posterior stabilized prostheses, inserted without cement or screws have been reviewed. Six were revised within two years. One was infected. The remaining five were revised for persistent symptoms considered to be due to tibial component loosening. Three of the four improved after revision with cementing of the tibial component, the other has remained symptomatic. One patient was lost to follow-up. Clinical review of the remaining eleven was good or excellent at two years. Radiographs at two years, available in eight, revealed that all had a non progressive I mm radio-lucent line at the bone- tibial prosthesis interface. The lack of bony ingrowth and apparent symptomatic early loosening in the four revised, suggests that posterior stabilised tibial prostheses may require additional initial fixation. From our experience in this short series, it is recommend that the tibial component of this prosthesis and perhaps any other posterior stabilized design, be cemented or fixed with screws.


A Sudo M Komeno M Seto K Kato A Uchida

Antibiotic-impregnated polymethylmethacrylate beads, which are used to deliver antibiotic directly to infected sites in the musculoskeletal system has been evaluated most widely. The disadvantages include reduced biocompatibility with bone, short duration of drug release, very low release rate and thermal damage to the antibiotics. For solving this problem, we developed the antibiotic-impregnated calcium hydroxyapatite ceramic implant (HA) as a new drug delivery system. This study is to evaluate the clinical results of the antibiotic-impregnated HA used for the treatment of infected total hip and knee arthroplasty. Twenty-two patients with infected arthroplasty treated antibiotic-impregnated HA were evaluated. There were 5 men and 17 women with a median age of 65 (range, 54–86 years). The study included 14 hips and 8 knees. The duration from the initial arthroplasty to the detection of the infection was 16 years at the longest (median of 2 years and 2 months). The most common microorganism was Staphylococcus aureus, presented in 13 patients. Antibiotic most frequently impregnated was Vancomycin. In five patients, debridement without removal of the prosthesis was performed with antibiotic-impregnated HA implanted in surrounding bone. In another three patients, one-stage revision was performed with antibiotic-impregnated HA. In fourteen patients, antibiotic-impregnated HA was used to fill the dead space after removal of the prosthesis (two-stage revision was performed in 9 patients). No patients developed evidence of recurrent infection at an average follow-up of 18.7 months. Antibiotic-impregnated HA is an excellent drug delivery system for the infected total hip and knee arthroplasty.


S Gitelis P Piasecki

Text: Chronic osteomyelitis is a serious condition. The infection can be difficult to eradicate and destroy significant bone. Usual therapy includes debridement, systemic antibiotics and local antibiotic delivery with polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA). PMMA needs to be removed and does not aid in bone repair.

Purpose: To review the use of calcium sulfate (OSTE-OSET® loaded with Vancomycin 3.2% or Tobramycin 3.8%) as an antibiotic delivery and bone repair implant.

Methods: Six consecutive patients were reviewed. Clinical records, radiographs, bone repair, sedimentation rate, functional outcome (Enneking MSTS system) were evaluated. All patients were treated with a surgical debridement, degradable implants and six weeks of systemic antibiotics.

Results: Six patients (3M/3F), mean age 50 years. Site; tibia 3, femur 3. Organism: Staph Aureus 5, mixed 1. Defect size; 40 cubic centimeters (12–60). Pre op sed rate; 54 (22–105). Local antibiotic; tobramycin 5, tobra+vancomycin 1. Follow-up; 22 months (12–31). Follow up sed rate; 8, Follow-up defect size; 2.5 cubic centimeters. Bone repair, 91%. Follow-up functional score; 27.5/30. No fractures, infection relapses or additional surgery to date.

Discussion: Local antibiotic delivery with calcium sulfate (OSTEOSET®) proved to be effective for bone repair. This implant does not need to be removed and may be an adjunct to systemic antibiotics for chronic osteomyelitis.


A Anil S Kumar I Dhami K Verma B Nadkarni

Tuberculosis of short tubular bones is uncommon after childhood. “Spina Ventosa” is considered the classical radiological presentation and hallmark of this disease. The short tubular bones are uncommon loci for the manifestation of adult skeletal TB. We report our experience with 31 cases of tuberculosis of hand (excluding wrist) with the intention to call attention to its occurrence in infrequently documented areas, to stress upon its morphologic variability and to illustrate little emphasized radiological signs.

Material & Methods: (n=31) Age range 1–68 years; M:F – 11:20; duration of symptoms-3 weeks to 2 years; history of Incision and Drainage before presentation −12 (38%) cases; Epitrochlear lymph node enlargement seen in 22 (71%) cases. Radiologically-classical spina ventosa seen in 5 cases; primarily diaphyseal involvement of metacarpal in 9, lesion in metacarpal head in 4, juxtraarticular metacarpal head erosion in 3, metacarpal base lesion in 3, phalangeal involvement in 2, carpometacarpal joint involvement in 2 and primarily small joint involvement in 3 cases. Majority of them were treated conservatively. Follow up is 1–5 years.

Discussion: Tuberculosis of hand might mimic several other inflammatory or neoplastic diseases. Disease might be initially painless and constitutional symptoms may be absent. Rapid collection because of lax skin on the dorsum of hand might tempt the surgeon for incision and drainage. FNAC of Epitrochlear lymph nodes may be diagnostic which may be enlarged in 60–70% cases. The clinicoradiological presentation, differential diagnosis and treatment with special reference to dynamic finger traction will be discussed.


E. Sherry H. Boeck P.H. Warnke

Introduction: Over 75% of hospital-acquired infections are methicillin-resistant staphyloccoal (MRSA) infections. There is an urgent need to find alternatives to treat such infections. We report our experience with the use of a topical antibacterial agent, Polytoxinol, PT (TM), combined with debridement, for the treatment of wound and bone infections where antibiotics had failed. PT is a complex formulation of eucalyptic plant extracts, shown to be strongly bactericidal in vitro against a broad range of aerobic bacteria.

Methods: Staphylococcal infections were diagnosed in 6 cases by culture; 4 of these were confirmed as involving MRSA. In 8/9 patients, infection was localised at the site of ligament and/or bone surgery for repair of traumatic injury, or for prosthetic joint replacement.

Results: Prior to this series, PT was applied as a biological wound sealant to 180 orthoapedic patients with two instances of localised sensitivity.

Eight of the current 9 cases of wound infection, included 4 verified cases involving methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, were successfully treated by topical application of Polytoxinol, either without (6 patients), or in combination with systemic antibiotics (3 patients). In 8 patients, Polytoxinol application was followed by reduced inflammation, rapid granulation and healing even where infection was of > 2 years standing. Adverse local tissue reaction shown by 1 patient quickly subsided on withdrawal of Polytoxinol.

Conclusions: Polytoxinol antimicrobial liquid applied topically to infected wounds and bone is an effective broad spectrum bactericide. It has the potential to supplement, or in many instances replace, antibiotics in the treatment of such infections.


SH Cho KI Kim HB Park

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the result of treatment of the infected total knee arthroplasty by two-stage revision using antibiotics-impregnated cement spacer and beads.

Materials and methods: Out of 56 total knee arthroplasty revisions, 26 revisions were performed for infected total knee arthroplasties between 1985 and 1996. Two cases of infected total knee arthroplasties were treated by immediate replacement and four cases by arthrodesis. Twenty infected total knee arthroplasties had been revised by two-stage revision and followed-up for 38.6 months in average (range, 18–105 months). They were nine male and eleven female patients of 61.6 years old in average. The primary cause of arthroplasty was osteoarthritis in all. Infection was diagnosed by physical finding, radiography, preoperative aspiration, culture of the pus from draining sinus and culture of surgical specimen. Twelve cases revealed positive growth of causative bacteria, while eight were not identified. The protocol for two-stage revision began with the removal of infected implants and cement. The surrounding bony and soft tissue were thoroughly debrided and cleaned. The dead space between femur and t

Results: Two-stage revision was successful in nineteen cases. One case revealed the recurrence of infection eleven months after reimplantation and underwent the repetition of the same two-stage procedure. At the final follow-up, the average Hospital for Special Surgery score was 81.1 points, the average Knee Society knee score was 78.6 points and the average function score was 76.7 points. Patients could regain average 105 degrees of knee flexion.

Conclusion: The result of two-stage revision for infected total knee arthroplasty is satisfactory, showing that this can be the method of choice for infection treatment and functional restoration. This procedure using antibiotics-impregnated cement spacer and beads can control infection and improve functional results.


A Anil I Dhami S Kumar B Nadkarni G Arora NC Mathur

The diagnosis of painful heel syndrome is quite common in any busy orthopaedics OPD. Though neoplasm and infections are not uncommon in calcaneum, the surgeon does not suspect infection unless there is an obvious history of punctured wound or constitutional symptoms. As such till date there is no series of large number of cases of calcaneal tuberculosis. We present our experience with 39 cases of calcaneal tuberculosis which include 2 cases of simultaneous bilateral symmetric involvement and 13 cases of tubercular lesion at the site of the attachment of Tendoachilles and Plantar Fascia. A classification of calcaneal tuberculosis is proposed.

Material & Methods: (n=39) age 6–60 years; male: female – 20:19; duration of symptoms – 2 weeks to 8 years; “Heel up” sign present in 19 cases; X-ray showed erosive lesion at the site of Tendoachilles attachment (enthesitic type lesion) – 8 cases; erosive lesion at the site of Plantar Fascia attachment – 5 cases; Intraosseous lytic lesion(s) without subtalar joint involvment – 23 cases; subtalar joint involvemnet – 3 cases. FNAC was positive in 17 cases and core biopsy revealed tubercular material in 12 cases. All cases except one were treated conservatively.

Discussion: The diagnosis and treatment of calcaneal tuberculosis are often delayed because the surgeon is unaware and signs and symptoms of calcaneal osteomyelitis are less dramatic than seen in osteomyelitis of long bones. The diagnostic and radiological features will be discussed.


TN Crotti M Loric GJ Atkins DM Findlay DW Howie G Bain DR Haynes

Wear particles are thought to be a major factor causing osteolysis that leads to aseptic loosening. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of primary regulators of osteoclast development, RANKL (also known as osteoclast differentiation factor), its receptor RANK and natural inhibitor osteoprotegerin (OPG) in aseptic loosening. Cells were isolated from periprosthetic tissues taken at revision from more than 30 patients and the expression of these mediators in vivo was assessed using semi-quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). These cells were also cultured on dentine to determine their ability to become mature osteoclasts. In situ hybridisation using DIG labelled riboprobes specific for RANK mRNA was used to identify cells likely to become osteoclasts. We were able to compare revison tissues containing several different types of prosthetic wear particles.

RANKL, RANK and OPG mRNA were found in samples of periprosthetic revision tissues. Cells derived from this tissue developed into mature osteoclasts capable of resorbing dentine. Cells that rapidly formed osteoblasts expressed a fifteen fold higher ratio of RANKL:OPG mRNA. In situ hybridisation showed RANK expression by macrophages and giant cells, many of which contained wear particles. Significantly, cells from tissues containing silastic wear particles expressed higher levels of RANKL relative to OPG and more produced large numbers of osteoclasts in vitro. This study shows that different bio materials in a particulate form may differ in their ability to form osteoclasts and that the relative levels of RANKL and OPG are likely to be important in determining if osteolysis will occur. In the future molecules that inhibit RANKL binding, such as OPG, may be considered for therapy of periprosthetic osteolysis.


TN Crotti M Loric GJ Atkins DM Findlay MD Smith DR Haynes

There is growing evidence that RANKL (also known as osteoclast differentiation factor), its receptor RANK and its natural inhibitor osteoprotegerin (OPG) are involved in bone loss in a number of pathologies. The aim of this study was to determine if these factors are expressed in a number of bone loss pathologies and what cell types were producing these factors in the tissues using reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), in situ hybridisation and immunostaining techniques. Periarticular tissue was obtained from 15 patients undergoing revision of aseptic loose implants. Rheumatoid joint tissue was obtained from the pannus region of 12 patients diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis undergoing joint replacement or joint fusion. Inflamed gingival tissue from sites near bone erosion were obtained from 11 patients with periodontal disease. 6 normal periodontal and periarticular tissue from 6 osteoarthritic patients was used as controls.

RANK, RANKL, OPG and M-CSF mRNA were expressed in tissues obtained from all the pathologies. Higher ratio’s of RANKL to OPG were observed in the pathological tissues compared to their respective controls. In revision tissues many multinucleated giant cell containing particles expressed RANK mRNA. The pattern of staining of RANK mRNA was markedly different in the rheumatoid and periodontal tissues. Differences were also seen in the pattern of expression for RANKL using both in situ and immunostaining. Overall our results indicate that although similar osteoclastogenic factors are fundamentally involved in these bone loss pathologies, different cell types may be producing and/or responding to these factors. Identifying fundamental mechanisms such as these may indicate that similar treatments, such as using OPG or related compounds, may be used for a diverse range of bone loss diseases.


E.T. Mah

This paper will focus on the use and including a demonstration of Digital photography for the purpose of clinical documentation, audit, teaching and research. Digital photography is particularly suitable in upper & lower limb surgery because of the discrete regional anatomy and radiology. Digital images once created and stored do not deteriorate, unlike pictures or slides. Digital camera that uses a single floppy disc has an added advantage of simplicity and ease of storage. Pre-op, intra-op, and post-op images of patients undergoing hand surgery and treatment are easily documented with the camera. The information can be archived using commercially available filing software such as File MakerPro. The information can be retrieved at a later stage to be used in audit, teaching and research, with the images retained in their original, unmodified condition. Existing clinical, historical and teaching library slides, pictures or images can be archived to ensure the quality of the images do not deteriorate further, and for ease of retrieval and subsequent application. Archiving in this manner would require a slide scanner. The ease of file retrieval, reliability and accuracy of this imaging system has been tested using a minimum of 2000 patient files, using both PC and Macintosh systems, with no computer error and minimal operator errors found. The software used has “auto save” feature built in, hence computer “crash resistance.” The only limitation of the technology is the set up costs, and the resolution of the images. Fortunately, both these limitations are improving rapidly.


Full Access
MH. Zheng R. Laird J. Xu D. Wood

Successful reconstructive surgery with allografts is severely limited by a failure rate of 30 – 40%. Allograft failure is due to nonunion of the graft-host junction. The molecular mechanism by which this occurs is not yet fully elucidated. Using a sheep femoral allograft model, we have investigated the cellular and molecular mechanisms associated with nonunion of bone allografts. Five, from a total of twelve operations, resulted in the development of graft-host nonunion, reflecting a failure rate of 42%. Histological assessment revealed that allograft failure was due to the excessive accumulation of and resorption by, osteoclasts (Ocs) on the surface of the bone allograft. Three distinct layers, lying adjacent to the allograft bone surface, in the nonunion groups, were identified. The outer fibroblastic layer contained abundant fibroblasts and connective tissue. Underlying this layer were synovial-like cells and some multinuclear giant cells. The third layer, opposing the bone surface, consisted of Ocs and round mononuclear cells. Histomorphometric analysis showed that allograft unions, featured a large amount of newly formed bone on the surface, (OS/BS = 47.81%) with a small proportion of eroded surface (ES/BS = 20.59%). The number of osteoclasts associated with the allograft bone surface were few (Oc/B.Pm = 1.7190/mm) and activity (ES/BS = 46.68%) of Ocs with a reduced amount of new bone formation (OS = 6.35%). Both calcitonin receptor and H+ATPase mRNA, characteristically expressed by Ocs, were localised to the multinuclear giant cells, indicating that they were Ocs. Synovial-like cells in the histological layer above the Ocs, expressed gene transcript for the Osteoprotegrin Ligand (OPGL), a membrane bound factor that is critical for the induction of Oc activity and osteoclastogenesis. In conclusion, these findings suggest that failure of bone allografts is partially due to excessive resorption by host Ocs, accompanied by reduced bone formation. The production of OPGL by synovial-like cells, may be responsible for the recruitment and generation of Ocs.


NL Fazzalari JS Kuliwaba B Manthey MR Forwood

The presence of microdamage in bone and its targeted repair by activating bone remodelling has been controversial partly because it is difficult to locate and difficult to quantify. A number of studies have now validated techniques to locate and quantify microdamage and microdamage repair in human cortical and trabecular bone samples. The purpose of this study is to determine if microcracks accumulate in the cancellous bone of the intertrochanteric region of the proximal femoral shaft and influence the strength of bone. We have used en bloc basic fuchsin staining to identify in vivo microcracks in 70 micron sections. Trabecular bone was sampled in 33 patients undergoing total hip replacement for primary osteoarthritis. The study sample had a median age of 73 years and included 18 women (aged 49 to 84 years) and 15 men (aged 45 to 85 years). Histomorphometry was used to quantify the number of cracks in each case. In a selection of 12 cases the bone sample was also biomechanically tested to determine the cancellous bone strength. We found that microcracks accumulate with age, particularly after the age of about 60 years. This indicates that the bone from the elderly is more susceptible to fatigue damage than bone from the young. In addition, an increased number of microcracks in the cancellous bone significantly reduced the ultimate failure stress of the bone. Bone screws or pins placed in cortical or trabecular bone create microdamage adjacent to an implant, and the area in which this microdamage occurs is the same as that which subsequently remodels. Microdamage may be the result primarily of procedures during prosthetic implantation, but bone screws or pins can create stress concentrations that can be sites for initiation of new cracks. Therefore, if bone remodelling targets bone microdamage for repair then accumulation of microdamage around prosthetic implants may be responsible for the biologic responses which lead to implant loosening. This phenomenon is understudied in orthopaedic research and is an area requiring further investigation.


SD. Cook

Growth factors hold great promise for the treatment of various musculoskeletal conditions. Growth factors are small proteins that serve as signaling agents for cells. The discovery of these substances revolutionized the field of cell biology by revealing the mechanism of regulation of cell activities. Growth factors are present in plasma or tissues at concentrations measured in billionths of a gram yet they are the principal effector of such critical cellular functions such as cell division, matrix synthesis and tissue differentiation.

Several growth promoting substances have been identified in bone matrix and at the site of healing fractures. Among these are the transforming growth factor beta’s, bone morphogenetic proteins, fibroblast growth factors, insulin like growth factors and platelet derived growth factor. These growth factors are mainly produced by osteoblasts and incorporated into the extracellular matrix during bone formation. Small amounts of the growth factors can also be trapped systemically from serum and be incorporated into matrix. The present hypothesis is that growth factors are located within the matrix until remodeling or trauma causes solubilization and release of the proteins.

The discovery of growth factors and their study in in vitro cultures has allowed an understanding of the mechanism of the regulation of a broad range of cell activities. However, their presence in plasma and tissues in minute quantities limited their evaluation in vivo and precluded clinical application of the natural purified products. Advances in recombinant DNA methodology have allowed sufficient quantities of these materials to be produced and many are in various stage of in vivo pre-clinical and clinical evaluation.

Extensive efforts have been made to find methods by which growth factors can be used to stimulate local bone healing and bone formation in a variety of clinical models. The growth factors TGF-α, BMP and basic FGF are the only growth factors that have been demonstrated to possess substantial in vivo bone stimulatory capacity. The growth factors BMP-2 and BMP-7, also known as osteogenic protein-1, are in the final stages of pivotal human trials.

There are many challenges to the clinical application of growth factors. It is unlikely that cell signaling molecules act independently of each other or are present in isolation from each other at their sites of action. The therapeutic application of growth factors must also accommodate the fact that most factors have a widespread and varied distribution of target cells. A growth factor administered to elicit a desired response from one cell type may also influence other cell types possible in unintended or undesirable ways. Finally, in the current era of cost consciousness in health care, a growth factor treatment must demonstrate cost effectiveness along with clinical efficacy.


J.S. Kuliwaba DM Findlay GJ Atkins MR Forwood NL Fazzalari

The cellular and molecular mechanisms that lead to particular trabecular structures in healthy bone and in skeletal disease, such as osteoarthritis (OA), are poorly understood. Osteoclast differentiation factor (ODF) is a newly described regulator of osteoclast formation and function, whose activity appears to be a balance between interaction with its receptor, RANK, and with an antagonist binding protein, osteoprotegerin (OPG). We have examined the relationship between the expression of ODF, RANK and OPG mRNA, and parameters of bone structure and turnover, in human trabecular bone. Intertrochanteric trabecular bone was sampled from patients with primary hip OA (n=13; median age 66 years) and controls taken at autopsy (n=12; median age 68.5 years), processed for histomorphometric analysis and RNA isolated for RT-PCR analysis of ODF, RANK and OPG mRNA expression. The ratios of ODF/OPG and ODF/RANK mRNA are significantly lower in OA (1.78±0.98; 0.59±0.31) compared to the controls (3.41±1.94, p< 0.02; 2.53±1.5, p< 0.001). This suggests that in OA there is less ODF mRNA available per unit RANK mRNA, and that osteoclast formation may be reduced. Furthermore, eroded bone surface (ES/BS[%]) was significantly lower (p< 0.05) in the OA group (6.37±3.17) compared to controls (9.74±4.53). Stong associations were found between the ratio of ODF/OPG mRNA and bone volume (ODF/OPG vs BV/TV[%], r=−0.67; p0.05) and bone turnover (ODF/OPG vs ES/BS, r=0.93; p< 0.001; ODF/OPG vs osteoid surgace (OS/BS[%], r=0.80; p< 0.001) in controls. In contrast to controls, these relationships were not evident in the OA group, suggesting that bone turnover maybe regulated differently in this disease.


G.J. Atkins D R Haynes A.C.W. Zannettino M Capone T Crotti D.M. Findlay

We have used a culture system of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC)as a source of osteoclast (OC) precursors and murine stromal cells to define the cytokine environment in which human OC form, and to determine the separate contributions of the stromal and haemopoietic elements. We designed a panel of reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) primers that specifically amplify the respective murine or human mRNA species that correspond to cytokines and their receptors previously shown to promote or inhibit OC formation. Murine ST-2 cells and human PBMC were cocultured for up to 21 days in the presence of 1,25(OH) 2vitD3, dexamethasone and human macrophage-colony stimulating factor (M-CSF). OC formation was monitored by the appearance of cells that were positive for tartrate resistant acid phosphatase and able to form resorption lacunae on slices of dentine. We found that the ST-2 cells in these cultures expressed mRNA encoding a repertoire of many of the reported osteoclastogenic factors, as well as the recently described OC differentiation factor (ODF/RANKL). The stromal cells also expressed mRNA encoding osteoprotegerin (OPG), a potent inhibitor of OC formation. We found that agonists and antagonists of OC formation were expressed by both the stromal cells and the PBMC. RANK, the receptor for ODF/RANKL, was expressed only by the PBMC as were IL-1R2 and c-FMS. We identified three features of the cytokine environment that may be a characteristic of normal OC formation. Firstly, the ratio of mouse ODF:OPG mRNA was found to increase during the cocultures, consistent with a key role for ODF in the promotion by stromal cells of OC formation. Secondly, we found that mRNA encoding IL-1 and IL-17, as well as IL-6 and sIL-6R, were coordinately expressed by the PBMC. Thirdly, analysis of the culture medium showed that the PBMC secreted IL-1, IL-6 and TNF-alpha protein only in coculture with ST-2 cells during the first few days of osteoclast development. Similarly, prostaglandin E2, shown to synergise with ODF during OC development, was secreted only in cocultures. Together, these data show OC develop in a complex cytokine environment and suggest that haemopoietic cells provide signals to stromal cells during OC development. Work is in progress to extend these studies to human PBMC interacting with normal human osteoblasts.


F Koentgen

Ozgene is a commercial venture established to produce genetically modified mice (GM-mice). GM-mice are the most sophisticated tools in functional genomics and drug target validation. Our Directors, CEO and COO provide internationally recognized expertise to produce GM-mice for the biotechnology & pharmaceutical industry and academic institutions.

Ozgene’s service includes the identification, isolation, sequencing and mapping of murine genes followed by the generation of classical or conditional knock-outs, knock-ins and transgenics.

We also offer phenotypic analysis of GM-mice; providing a complete service from gene discovery to gene function.

We are able to produce, supply, maintain and cryopreserve GM-mice in alliance with the Animal Resources Centre, Australia’s premier supplier of specific pathogen free (SPF) laboratory animals.

Ozgene’s senior management team has an established track record in the generation and analysis of GM-mice as published in leading scientific journals including Nature, Science, EMBO, PNAS. Our CEO and COO were amongst the first to produce C57BL/6 knock-out mice and NOD transgenic mice.


Y. Mochida

Introduction: Alendronate is a pyrophosphate analogue of bisphosphonate that has been shown to inhibit osteoclastic bone resorption. Bone formation and remodeling are necessary to establish initial fixation of uncemented implants, especially those coated with bioactive surfaces, such as HA. Because the process of bone remodeling that culminates in new bone formation is thought to be initiated by osteoclastic bone resorption, it is appropriate to test the influence of osteoclast inhibiting medications on bone apposition to hydroxyapatite (HA)-coated implants. The purpose of this study was to determine the influence of alendronate on early bone apposition and remodeling around HA-coated canine total hip implants.

Methods: Twelve canines underwent staged bilateral total hip arthroplasty with surgeries 20 weeks apart. The femoral component was a titanium alloy stem with a proximal macro-textured surface and a plasma-sprayed HA coating. Modular cobalt-chromium alloy heads were used with cemented, all-polyethylene acetabular components. Six of the dogs received oral alendronate therapy from surgery to sacrifice; the other 6 dogs were untreated controls. The animals were sacrificed 4 weeks after the second surgery. Sections from matched implant sites (proximal, middle, and distal) were histologically analyzed. The linear extent of bone apposition, HA coating thickness, and the total amount of cortical and cancellous bone were measured with the use of an interactive image analysis system.

Results: There were no significant differences in radiographic or histologic findings between the two groups at either 4 or 24 weeks. Although the extent of HA coating decreased with time in both groups, no significant influence of alendronate was identified on either the extent of bone apposition, the extent or thickness of the HA coating, or the average cortical or trabecular bone area around the implants.

Conclusions: Many patients who are receiving alendronate for osteoporosis or other disorders may also qualify for uncemented total joint arthroplasty. Although bone formation is generally thought to be initiated by, and coupled with bone resorption, our results suggest that alendronate has no significant influence on attaining immediate fixation or in short term bone remodeling around HA-coated total joint implants.


W.Y. Ip S. Gogolewski

Background: Healing of segmental diaphyseal bone defects in animals can be enhanced by covering the defects with resorbable polylactide membranes. Based on the results of bone healing in defects 10 mm long in the rabbit radii, it was suggested that the membrane prevents muscle and soft tissue from invading the defect and maintains osteogenic cells and osteogenic substances within the space covered with membrane, thus promoting new bone formation. However, for bone defects larger than a critical size, bone healing did not occur when covered with polylactide membrane.

Objectives: To investigate and compare bone regeneration with resorbable polylactide membrane and polylactide sponge in a 20 mm bone defect in rabbit radii. The material used was polylactide (L/DL) 80/20/1.

To determine and compare the biomechanical strength of the bone fixation construct with reinforcement by membrane and sponge of such bone defect which were rendered unstable by ulnar osteotomy.

Material & method: 20 mm long diaphyseal segmental defects were made in the left radii of adult New Zealand rabbits. Transverse ulnar osteotomies were made at mid-shaft to make the forearm unstable. The rabbits were divided into 4 groups. In group 1, no fixation of the bone were performed and the limbs were immobilized in a plaster for 8 weeks. In group 2, the bone defects were fixed with 1.5 AO miniplate, with 2 screws on each side of the defect. In group 3, the bone defects were fixed similarly and polylactide membranes were used to cover up the bony defect. In group 4, the bone defects were fixed similarly to group 2 and the defects were bridged by sponge of 20 mm long, 3.5 mm in diameter. In group 5, the bone defects were bridged by sponge similar to group 4 and were also covered by polylactide membrane and similar internal fixation were performed.

Results: In group 1, there was bone healing bridging the bone ends. However, there was marked shortening of the limbs and all the limbs were deformed.

In group 2, there were bone formation at the ends of both proximal bone stumps and distal bone stumps. There was no bone bridging the defect.

In group 3,4, there were bone formation across the defect. There was more bone formation in group 4, i.e. the defects were bridged by sponge.

Conclusion: Polylactide membrane and sponge promote bone regeneration in 20 mm both defects in the rabbit radii model. There was more bone formation when sponged were employed.


J. Field T. Hearn J. Costi M. McGee K Costi N. Adachi M. Ochi

Introduction: Accelerated rehabilitation programs following ACL reconstruction require adequate fixation strength. Staple fixation of grafts outside the tibial tunnel has been shown to have fixation strength comparable to interference screws. The use of bioresorbable polymer implants has potentially significant advantages especially if revision is required. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a new bioresorbable fixation staple using an ovine model.

Materials and Methods: Forty-eight mature sheep underwent unilateral cranial cruciate ligament (CrCl) reconstruction. The reconstruction comprised a loop of superficial digital flexor tendon (autograft) joined to a prosthetic ligament (LK-15). Femoral fixation was by endobutton. Tibial fixation of the LK-15 was with either a new Poly-L-lactic acid (PLLA) staple (Zimmer Japan/Gunze Ltd.) or a Cobalt-chrome (CoCr) staple. Biomechanical and histological responses were evaluated at 0, 6, 12 and 24 weeks.

Results: At all times post-reconstruction there were no significant differences between staple types for construct strength or stiffness (p> 0.05). The staple was not the site of reconstruction failure, and there were no adverse tissue reactions, for either staple type. Fibrous tissue was more often found at the interface of the CoCr staple.

Conclusions: The PLLA staple performed biomechanically as well as the metal staple for tibial fixation of cruciate ligament reconstructions. There were no significant observable adverse histological responses over the time intervals examined.


Full Access
W. Walsh M. Svehla R.M. Gillies

Introduction: The biomechanical properties of tendon and ligament have long been the subject of intense research. The understanding of the ultrastructure as it relates to the biomechanical function and clinical demands have often considered the ultimate properties at failure alone. Tendons and ligaments are predominately loaded in-vivo at subfailure loads and often in the initial toe region. To date, little work has focussed on the viscoelastic properties of the tendon in the initial toe region. The biomechanical behaviour at these low loads may reflect the unique mechanical interactions between the fasciles and collagen fibrils. This study examined stress relaxation of ligaments in the initial non-linear portion of the load vs. displacement curve.

Methods: Six flexor tendons (2.5 mm wide x 1mm thick) were harvested from 18 month cross bred whethers and stored in 0.145 M NaCl until testing. Tensile testing was performed on a MACH 1 Micromechanical Testing Machine (BIOSYNTECH, Laval, Quebec, Canada) in 0.145M phosphate buffered saline at room temperature. Tendons (gauge length 30mm) were displaced to 0.5, 1 and 5% strain at a loading rate of 50 microns/sec and stress relaxation measured over a period of 300 seconds and repeated for 4 sequences. Data was analysed using an analysis of variance.

Results and Discussion: Peak loads at 0.5 % strain ranged from 50 g (sequence 1) to 130 g (sequence 4) while at 5 % strain peak loads reached upwards to 1600 g. These loads are well within the initial toe region of the load-displacement behaviour of the ligament. The MACH 1 testing system provide a reliable and highly accurate system to control micron level displacements and mg load resolution. Recently, Yamamoto and coworkers reported the stress relaxation behavior and strain rate effects of collagen fascicles differed greatly from those of bulk tendons. The differences in tensile and viscoelastic properties between fascicles and bulk tendons may be attributable, in part, to ground substances, mechanical interaction between fascicles, and the difference of crimp structure of collagen fibrils. The present study supports an important role of tissue ultra-structure at low loads with regard to stress relaxation. Subtle changes in ground susbtance, water content or biochemical consituents not evident in testin


Full Access
I Bastian R Stapledon

As in other high-income countries, tuberculosis (TB), including musculoskeletal TB, occurs infrequently in Australia. Only 954 new TB cases (i.e. 5.15 per 105 population) were reported in 1997 with 44 cases of musculoskeletal TB. Hence, most Australian physicians and surgeons are unfamiliar with musculoskeletal TB, which can often present as a chronic slowly-progressive destructive disease. Consequently delays in diagnosis are common resulting in significant morbidity. In contrast, TB rates are more than 100 per 105 population in many countries in SE Asia and the Pacific. Medical staff are therefore familiar with the manifestations of TB but often lack the laboratory facilities to confirm the diagnosis or perform drug susceptibility tests (DSTs).

This presentation will provide research findings of interest to medical staff from both Australia and neighbouring countries. A review of musculoskeletal TB cases reported in South Australia over the last decade will be presented highlighting the delays in diagnosis and the resulting morbidity. Recent advances in TB diagnostics (i.e., novel agar media, Alamar blue, and Mycobacterium Growth Indicator Tubes) that represent appropriate technologies for low-resource countries will also be described.


S. Ichinohe M. Yoshida G. Tajima T. Akasaka T. Honda T. Shimamura

Purpose: To evaluate repair of articular cartilage.

Methods: Ten cases of ten knees (6 males and 4 females) were evaluated in the current study. Seven knees treated by osteochondral graft including six receiving mosaic plasty and one receiving Pasteurization. Four knees treated by periosteal graft. One knee received both mosaicplasty and periosteal graft. Mean patient age at surgery was 31 years old. Eight knees underwent follow-up MRI, 6 knees underwent follow-up arthroscopy, and 4 knees underwent needle biopsy after informed consent was obtained. The mean period from the surgery to final follow-up was 21 months. The mean period from surgery to follow-up arthroscopy was 10 months.

Results: Seven cases of osteochondral graft presented good regeneration of articular surface by MRI and arthroscopic examination. Two knees receiving mosaic plasty demonstrated regeneration of hyaline cartilage even between the gaps in mosaicplasty. However, the structure of hyaline cartilage differed from that of normal cartilage. Pasteurization in one case also demonstrated good regeneration of hyaline cartilage. One knee treated by periosteal graft demonstrated regeneration of hyaline cartilage. However, the graft area in another such knee was covered by fibrous tissue. One periosteal graft became detached 14 days after surgery. There were no cases showing ossification after periosteal graft.

Conclusion: Periosteal graft could cover a wide defect of articular surface. However, induction of cartilage was not good. Osteochondral graft is a sure method of repairing hyaline cartilage where there is a small defect in the articular surface. Our results from needle biopsy demonstrated hyaline cartilage in the gaps among mosaicplasty areas, but the structure of hyaline cartilage was not good. There is a risk of re-degeneration due to the poor structure of hyaline cartilage. Careful observation is needed in both periosteal graft and mosaic plasty cases.


C. Y. Yang Y. C. Yang

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to investigate the biological responses of human osteoblstes on plasma sprayed HA coating (HAC), and the effects of surface roughness. In addition, the biological responses of human osteoblstes on HACs that pre-treated in the similar body fluid (SBF) were also investigated.

Methods: In this study, the HACs with 50mm thickness were made by atmosphere plasma spray (APS). The human osteoblasts derived from loose bone during the hip surgery were cultured in D-MEM with 4% FBS on polished HA coating (HACp), plasma sprayed HA coating (HAC) and polystyrene (PS) (as control). Part 1: The three specimens mentioned before were dipped in the SBF three days for pre-treatment (named t-PS, t-HACp, t-HAC). The cell adhesion and growth of pre-treated specimens were compared with non-treated specimens at the early phase (3, 12, 24 hours). Part 2: The cell growths (1, 3, 5, 10, 15 days) were evaluated by counting the cell number on the surface of PS, HAC and HACp. The biological functions of human osteoblasts were evaluated by the alkaline phosphatase activity (3, 5, 10, 15 days) and TGF-b concentration (5–15 days).

Results: Part 1: At the early phase of cell culture (< 1day), osteoblasts on pre-treated specimens surface showed the better attachment and growth than those culture on non-treated specimens. This result was due to the protein in the SBF provided the nutrient to cell, therefore, shortened the time of cell attachment and promoted the cell growth. Part 2: The cell morphology under SEM showed that cells on smooth PS and HACp surfaces had the better attachment than those on rough HAC surface. On cell growth and cell number (1, 3, 5, 10, 15 days), the PS was the best and HACp was better than HAC. It is due to the easy attachment and better growth on smooth surface than rough one. On alkaline phosphatase activity (APA), HAC showed better APA than HACp, the PS was the worst. On TGF-b concentration, the TGF-b secreted from human osteoblasts on rough HAC had higher concentration than smooth HACp and PS. The results mentioned above showed that the rough surface material promote the biological activity of human osteoblasts in late phase (5–15 days).

Conclusion: 1. The HACs after pre-treatment in the SBF would promote the cell attachment on coating surface and speed the cell growth. 2. The results from this study showed that rough HAC expressed better biocompatibility than the smooth one and smooth HAC show early superiority of cell growth than rough one.


S.D. Cook

Osteogenic proteins (OPs), also referred to as bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs), are a family of bone-matrix polypeptides isolated from a variety of mammalian species. These proteins are members of the transforming growth factors-beta superfamily of molecules that contain a highly conserved 7 cysteine transforming growth factor domain in their C-termini. Implantation of osteogenic proteins induce a sequence of cellular events that leads to the formation of new bone.

In preclinical studies, the implantation of recombinantly produced human osteogenic protein-1 (OP-1, also referred to as BMP-7) in conjunction with bovine bone derived Type 1 collagen or various nonproteinaceous biodegradable carriers into surgically created, critical size diaphyseal segmental defects resulted in the regeneration of new bone that was fully functional biologically and biomechanically. Injection of an OP-1 solution into a fresh fracture model accelerated the bone repair process compared with control fracture healing. Significantly increased biomechanical strength was the result of greater and earlier new bone formation. Further study has demonstrated that OP-1 can be used as a bone graft substitute to promote spinal fusion, aid in the incorporation of metal implants, and improve the performance of autograft and allograft bone. OP-1 has also shown promise as an agent for the repair of osteochondral defects.

Clinical study of the OP-1 device for the treatment of tibial nonunion fractures has shown healing characteristics similar to that obtained with autogenous iliac crest bone graft. The randomized, prospective clinical evaluation included 30 patients with 31 tibal nonunion fractures. The mean time from injury was 27.2 months (minimum 9 months). All patients were treated with reamed intramedullary rods. At the 9 month evaluation 14 of 16 OP-1 and 14 of 15 autograft treated fractures were clinically and radiographically healed. Advantages of OP-1 included no donor site complications, less blood loss, an a shorter operative time.


J. A. L. Hart J. Paddle-Ledinek

Purpose: To define the role of ACI in treatment of cartilage defects in the knee joint.

Method: 106 articular cartilage defects in 79 knees of 77 patients were treated by ACI as described by Brittberg et al, 1994. 43.5% of the lesions involved the patella, 35.2% the femoral condyles, 16.7% the trochlea, and 4.6% the tibial condyles. 20% of knees had more than one defect. Associated biomechanical procedures were carried out in 88.7%.

Results: 70 lesions in 58 knees and 56 patients were assessed arthroscopically 9 months after implantation; 4 eligible patients were not assessed. The average ICRS repair score (maximum 12) was as follows: tibial condyle 11.5, (4 defects); patella 11.3, (32 defects); femoral condyle 11.0, (23 defects) and trochlea 10.7, (11 defects). Synovitis was markedly reduced in all knees with well healed defects. Contraindications to ACI in this series were:

Non-contained defects,

Bi-polar lesions,

Patients greater than 45 years,

Uncorrected biomechanics,

Regional pain syndrome type 1,

Limited joint movement,

Defective subchondral bone plate.

Conclusion: ACI effectively repairs articular cartilage defects in the knee joint, provided that the contraindications are recognised. Unlike other series, the results for the patella, patellofemoral joint have matched those for the femoral condyle. This is attributed to the simultaneous biomechanical correction of the patellofemoral joint. Stabilisation of the articular surface results in resolution of synovitis.


B.J. Spring H.M. Staudacher I.J.P. Henderson

Articular cartilage has compressive stiffness determined primarily by the matrix which is quite characteristic and distinct from that of degenerative articular cartilage or regenerative fibrocartilage. Alterations evident when articular cartilage begins to degenerate include a decrease in proteoglycan content and water content and resultant reduction in stiffness. Regenerative fibro-cartilage has greatly reduced stiffness with functional implications. Identification of cartilaginous stiffness for various sites of normal articular cartilage in the knee is important to enable comparison measures of suspected degenerative cartilage and regenerative articular cartilage either hyaline, fibrocartilage or mixed. The aim of this study was to map the in vivo biomechanical properties of normal human articular knee cartilage using the Artscan 1000 arthroscopic cartilage stiffness tester (Artscan Oy, Finland). It has been shown that the Artscan 1000 is reliable when measuring the stiffness of thin articular cartilage (Lyra et al., 1999). Over a period of 12 months, 94 patients (age 15–69 yr) undergoing a knee arthroscopy consented to having their normal articular surfaces biomechanically evaluated for stiffness. Cartilage stiffness (N) was defined by the mean indenter force at each site where the applied force on the measurement rod equalled 10 ±1.5 N. Medial femoral condyle stiffness (M ±SD; 3.71 ±1.28 N) was greater than all other sites and was significantly greater than mean values obtained for proximal, distal and lateral trochlea (1.87 ±0.91, 2.44 ±1.02 and 2.69 ±1.52 N, respectively); medial (1.71 ±0.70 N) and lateral patella (2.18 ±1.03 N); and medial and lateral tibial plateau for all subjects (2.33 ±.1.26 and 2.27 ±1.19 N, respectively; p < 0.05). There were no significant differences between sexes for each site. There was no trend for cartilage stiffness to be lower in patients over forty compared to younger patients for both sexes for all sites. There was, however, statistically significant less stiffness of the distal trochlea for females under 40 years when compared to that of females older than 40 years. The clinical significance of this is under review. Further research involving the characterisation of cartilage stiffness in pathological situations and evaluation of stiffness following articular cartilage repair is now possible.


S. R. Lyu K. Ogata I. Hoshiko

In comparative studies of various gait patterns of 20 healthy subjects who used a cane, the vertical reaction forces and the passages of the center of force on the foot were measured and recorded by a force recording and analyzing device (Foot-scan system). The results indicated that when a cane was used in the ipsilateral hand, the center of force did not shift significantly compared with normal gait. When a cane was used in the contralateral hand, the center of force shifted medially compared with normal gait. In analysis of the vertical floor reaction force acting on the foot, the most efficient way to use a cane was to control the pacing so that the tip of the cane and the foot touched the ground simultaneously. By doing so, the cane could share as much as 34.3% of force at heel strike, 25.3% at midstance, and 29.7% at toe off of the stance phase of the gait cycle. When prescribing use of a cane for a patient with varus gonarthritis, the patient should be instructed to use the cane in the ipsilateral hand so as not to shift the center of force medially; for a patient with valgus gonarthritis, the cane should be used in the contralateral hand to shift the center of force medially. Patients should be taught to control pacing so that the tip of the cane and the foot touch the ground simultaneously.


E.H. Lee

In recent years numerous growth factors acting on musculoskeletal tissues have been identified. This presentation summarizes our experience with IGF1 in the stimulation of growth of the physis and TGF beta in the formation of bone and cartilage.

IGF1 in a carrier, agarose, was instilled in a paraphsyeal region in rabbit tibias. The physeal height was measured over a period of time and was found to have increased in the group treated with IGF1 when compared to the control group. In addition there was delayed closure of the physeal plate.

These findings may have clinical applications in stimulation of physeal growth in small by length discrepancies

A polycaprolactone scaffold impregnated with TGF beta was implanted under the skin, in the muscle and under the periosteum in rabbits. Over a period of time the scaffolds were harvested and subjected to histological analysis with a variety to stains. Formation of bone and cartilage was found in these scaffolds implanted under the periosteum. Subdermal and intramuscular implantation of the scaffolds did not produce the same results. It is postulated that apart from TGF Beta local and environmental factors may play a part in bone and cartilage formation. This model may be useful in creating complex scaffolds in-vivo for subsequent transplantations.


D.S. Lu K.D.K. Luk K.M.C. Cheung Y.W. Wong J.C.Y. Leong

The FBCI has been shown to be a better method for describing scoliosis correction because it takes spinal flexibility into consideration. 1

Objective: To use FBCI prospectively to compare the efficacy of four different posterior instrumentations in the correction of thoracic scoliosis.

Method: 123 idiopathic scoliosis patients with thoracic curves were surgically treated prospectively using 4 different posterior instrumentations: TSRH (n=35); ISOLA (n=33); CD-Horizon (CD-H: n=32); and Moss-Miami (MM: n=23). All the operations were performed by the same team of surgeons using standard techniques. The curve was measured using the Cobb’s method on the pre-operative PA standing, fulcrum bending and 1-week post-operative PA standing radiographs. The conventional correction rate and the FBCI were calculated. One-way ANOVA and independent sample t-test were used for statistical analysis.

Results: (1) There were no significant differences between any of the 4 instrumentations when assessed using the FBCI, however, the correction rate was better in CD-H than in ISOLA and TSRH (Table 1). (2) Higher FBCIs were observed in the stiff curve group (fulcrum flexibility £ 50%) compared with those in the flexible group (fulcrum flexibility > 50%), while the correction rates were lower in the former than in the latter (Table 2).

Discussion: Better correction rate obtained in the CD-H group was attributed to the more flexible curves rather than the instrumentation itself. In the flexible curve group, the instrumentations have been able to take up all the flexibility revealed by the fulcrum-bending radiograph. Although the correction rate was less in the stiff curve group, the FBCI showed that the deformity correction was actually more than that indicated by the fulcrum bending radiographs. One possible explanation of this phenomenon may be that the fulcrum-bending radiograph is less effective in eliciting all the flexibility in the stiff curves.

Conclusion: All 4 instrumentations were EQUALLY effective in correction of thoracic scoliosis when the curve flexibility was taken into consideration.


A. Chong J. Hui D. Wong H. K. Wong

Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) has been in use since the 1980s for surgery of the spine. Initially it was used for anterior release of the thoracic spine in order to facilitate posterior instrumentation. With increasing experience, it has been applied to perform definitive correction and instrumentation. Video-assisted thoracoscopic spine surgery allows the surgeon to perform anterior thoracic spine operations with fewer levels of instrumentation, reducing the crankshaft effect and removing the morbidity associated with thoracotomy. From 1996 to November 2000, our center performed 19 such operations. 18 of them were completed successfully endoscopically and one was converted to an open procedure. An initial group of 10 patients underwent thoracoscopic anterior release and fusion followed by same day posterior instrumentation and fusion. Subsequently, 6 patients underwent anterior discectomies, fusion with instrumentation via thoracoscopic approach.

For the initial 10 patients, the average operative time was 190 minutes. The average post-operative correction was 62 % and blood loss was 350 mLs. For the 6 patients who underwent anterior discectomies, fusion and instrumentation via the thoracoscopic approach, the average operative time was 360 minutes; average post-operative correction was 70% and blood loss was 400 mLs.

Complications encountered were minor and included one case ofcontralateral pneumothorax, one patient complained of transient limb numbness which resolved within 6 weeks. It is our conclusion that thoracoscopic anterior spinal surgery, though with learning curve, a safe and effective procedure.


A. Nabavi-Tabrizi A. Turnbull Q. Dao R. Appleyard

Introduction: Osteochondral mosaic plasty is gaining popularity as a treatment for isolated chondral defects in femoral condyles. Most systems use a metal punch to impact the osteochondral grafts in pre-drilled defects. Damage to the chondrocytes during impaction grafting is of concern and new methods are being sort to minimise this deleterious effect.

This study was designed to see if using a plastic punch instead of a metal punch reduces the extent of chondrocyte damage in osteochondral mosaic plasty.

Method: Ten fresh sheep knees were used to harvest thirty osteochondral plugs using the COR system. The opposite condyles were then prepared to receive the osteochondral grafts. Ten plugs were impacted using a metal punch and ten using a plastic punch. The ten remaining plugs were used as controls. The plugs were then recovered and incubated for 24 hours prior to being stained with MTT. The stained cartilage was then photographed using a digital macroscope.

Images were interpreted using a graphics analysis programme.

Results: There was no significant difference in the extent of chondrocyte damage between the two groups. However, the extent of chondrocyte damage in the impacted groups was significantly greater than the control group.

Conclusion: Impaction grafting clearly damages chondrocytes of the osteochondral plug. In our study using a plastic punch did not reduce the extent of chondrocyte damage during mosaic plasty.


K.M.C. Cheung J.G. Zhang D.S. Lu Y.W. Wong K.D.K. Luk J.C.Y. Leong

Introduction: Anterior convex epiphysiodesis and posterior concave distraction has not been previously described in the literature for the treatment of thoracolumbar hemivertebrae. We describe our experience with long-term follow-up.

Method: Six consecutive patients with a mean age of 3.4 years were operated on with this technique. Levels of fusion extended two levels above and below the hemi-vertebra, while the instrumentation span the full length of the curve. Further concave distraction was carried out when there was evidence of loosening of the hooks.

Results: The average follow-up was 10.8 years (range 8 to 14). The mean Cobb angle before surgery was 49°, and at the latest follow-up was 26°. There was a mean 41% improvement in the scoliosis. In 5 of these cases, this correction was achieved immediately after surgery and did not significantly change despite repeated distraction.

Conclusion: The addition of concave distraction provided better correction than convex epiphysiodesis alone. It is technically easier and safer than hemivertebra excision in the correction of such deformities. This method of treatment is recommended for patients with single fully segmented hemivertebrae located at the thoracolumbar junction that has a significant deformity.


D.S. Lu K.D.K. Luk C.C. Wong K.M.C. Cheung Y.W. Wong J.C.Y. Leong

In scoliosis, it is well known that lateral deformity is coupled with vertebral axial rotation. Coupled motion in the sagittal plane, however, has not been investigated.

Objective: To investigate the behavior of the sagittal alignment changes when coronal deformity was corrected in idiopathic thoracic scoliosis.

Method: 36 idiopathic scoliosis patients with thoracic curves were examined before surgery. Coronal deformity was corrected using the Fulcrum Bending technique1, and biplane radiographs were taken to monitor the correction of the deformity, as well as the coupled sagittal alignment changes. Sagittal alignment was measured from T4/T5 to T12 using Cobb’s method. Difference of less or equal to 3 degrees between two measurements was treated as no change. Results were compared with those measured from standing lateral radiographs prior to and at 1 week after surgery (Posterior correction and fusion with ISOLA: n=15; CD-Horizon: n=8; Moss-Miami: n=11, USS: n=2). Pearson correlation was used for statistical analysis.

Results: (A) When scoliosis was corrected under fulcrum bending, the coupled changes in the thoracic kyphosis were decreased if it was greater than 20 degrees (n= 18), increased if less than 20 degrees (n= 2), and kept no change if it was around 20 degrees (n= 16). These changes were not related to the amount of deformity or flexibility in the coronal plane (Table I). (B) There was strong relationship between the sagittal alignment measured on the pre-operative fulcrum bending and postoperative lateral radiographs (P< 0.01). However, the final sagittal alignment was neither correlated with the magnitude or flexibility of the coronal deformity, nor the instrumentation applied (P> 0.05)

Discussion: A coupling exists between the coronal lateral deformity and the sagittal alignment in thoracic scoliosis. It seems that the sagittal alignment in a scoliotic spine tends to “normalize” with correction of the deformity: a “hyper-kyphotic” spine tends to reduce, and a “hypo-kyphotic” one tends to increase the kyphosis. Post-operative sagittal alignment seems to be decided by the coupling motion and the amount of curvature of the pre-bent rod, as neither the nature (degree or flexibility or curve pattern) of the coronal deformity nor the choice of instrumentation were related to the post-operative sagittal alignment.


N. Matsui

Objective: When performing total hip arthroplasty for osteoarthrosis secondary to hip dysplasia, we usually aim to fix the acetabular component in the area of the original acetabulum before deformation has occured resulting from superior migration of the femoral head. In cases where intraoperative bony coverage of the socket is less than three-fourths of the surface area of the cup, we construct block bone grafts from the resected femoral head and fix these to the acetabulum using metal screws. In this study we report the middle-term results of cementless sockets implanted using block bone grafts.

Materials and methods: 25 hip joints of 20 patients with follow-up of over 5 years were included in this study. The mean age at surgery was 50 years (range: 36 to 67). The femoral components were fixed with cement in 9 joints and without cement in 16 joints. Follow-up periods ranged from 5.0 years to 10.5 years (mean 7.5 years). X-rays were obtained and studied concerning incorporation and collapse of the bone graft, migration of the socket and peripheral osteolysis.

Results: Incorporation of the grafted bone was obtained in all cases. No socket migration and no collapse of the bone graft were observed. A localized absorption of grafted bone was seen in two asymptomatic cases.

Conclusion: Very good results were obtained with cementless sockets implanted with block bone grafts at a mean follow-up of 7.5 years.


M. Thacker J.H.P Hui H.K Wong E.H. Lee

Introduction: Surgery in patients with neuromuscular scoliosis is aimed at improving truncal balance, facilitating sitting, prevention of progression of the curve and preservation of respiratory function.

Patients and Methods: This was a retrospective study of surgical results in a group of 24 patients with minimum follow up of 2 years an average post-operative follow up of 5 years (2–9 years) with neuromuscular scoliosis due to varying aetiologies. The aetiologies included SMA (7), CP (6), Duchenne (5), Congenital Myopathies (3), Spina Bifida (2) and Paraspinal Neuroblastoma (1).

Results: The average age at surgery was 10.6 years, the average duration was 4hrs 25mins with an average blood loss pf 1.1 liters. An average ICU stay was 1–2 days and stay in hospital is 11 days. The curves ranged from 25–103° (average 75.6°) pre-operative and we were able to obtain a correction of 56%. In all but 2 of our patients we were successful in preventing deterioration of respiratory function and all our patients could at least sit without support post-operatively. Our complications included only one deep infection (necessitating implant removal), 1 rod breakage and 2 patients with UTI. There were no significant respiratory complications in post-operation.

Conclusion: Spinal surgery in patients with neuromuscular scoliosis is safe and prevents deterioration of respiratory and improve truncal balance and hence quality of life.


M.C. Yoo Y.J. Cho Y.S. Chun N.S. Pyo S.K. Kim D.J. Shin

We report the long-term radiographic results of the total hip arthroplasty with use of the cementless porous coated Harris-Galante (H-G) stem. Seventy-five consecutive patients, eighty-eight hips formed the basis of this study. Fifty patients were male, twenty-five patients were female, and thirteen patients were bilateral. The mean age of patients at operation was 42 years. They were followed up for an average of thirteen years four months (ten years two months to fourteen years four months). The diagnosis was avascular necrosis of the femoral head in 49 cases, degenerative osteoarthritis in 32 cases. Clinical results were estimated by modified Harris hip score and thigh pain, and radiographic results by periodically checked plain X-ray film. The average Harris hip score increased from 60 points preoperatively to 83 points at the most recent follow-up examination. The hip pain score increased from 31 points to 41 points. Clinically severe thigh pain was observed in 3 cases (4%). In radiographic evaluation, subsidence more than 5mm was seen in 2 cases (2%). Periprosthetic osteolytic lesion was observed in 15 cases (17%), but the lesions do not influence stability of the stem. Femoral stem stability by Engh was stable in 72 cases, fibrous stable in 12 cases, unstable in 4 cases. Pedestal formation, cortical hypertrophy of the distal femur, and stress shielding was observed more than 40%. Subcollar resorption was identified in 29% and ectopic ossification in 15%. Revision of the femoral stem was needed in 4 cases for aseptic loosening. At 10 years probability of survival of the stem using Kaplan-Meyer method was 95.5%. Use of the cementless H-G stem yielded the excellent long-term outcome, but osteolysis and stress shielding would be the main problems to solve.


P. Q. Chen C. Yen S.H. Yang

AIS is the most popular spinal deformity to search for surgical correction. Between 1988 to 1995, there were totally 146 patients who undergone CDI for the correction. Among them 63, were due to thoracic scoliosis. In the begining, only hooks were placed in the laminar region according under the teaching of CD group. Later pedicle screws were inserted in the upper lumbar and the lower thoracic region. Fusion was mostly done using iliac bone chip. there was no external jacket or PP cast to protect the trunk. The average Cobb angle at coronal plane before surgery was 51.7 deg. After surgery, the angle became 17.3 deg. At final follow, there was 4.2 deg. loss. Thus the correction rate was 66.5%, and the correction loss was 7.7%. The Sagittal curve still could be maintain in the normal range. The axial correction rate was 31.5% for the initial 50 cases.

Complication was minimal. Four cases had mild numbness in the r’t thigh, and two of them had sl. weakness of knee extension. All resolved within one month. “Crankshaft” was detected in 4 cases. Ten cases had hardware problems. These included 2 pedicle screw breakage, and two screw back-out. Six patients had lower upward hook dislodgement. Two patients had late deep wound infection, which needed debridement and delayed removal. In summary, CDI was effective to correct the deformity in the adolescent patients.


W.T. Wu T.C. Yu J.T. Chien I.-H. Chen

Materials & method: From July 1990 to July 1997, we reviewed 58 hips in 47 patients receiving primary cemented hip arthroplasty with porous-coated prosthesis. There were 31men and 16 women. The diagnoses included AVN of femoral head in 18, OA in 4, femoral neck fracture in 33 and RA in 3 patients. The prosthesis included PCA 17, Osteonics in 18, United in 21 and Richard in 1.

Initially, all the femoral canals were prepared with the routine cementless fixation technique modified by the author (rasp-ream-rasp technique). With insertion of the final-size rasp, reliable fixation was not obtained possibly due to poor bone quality or inherent canal geometry. To avoid fracture with insertion of the next-sized stem, bone cement was added as gap-filler to augment fixation of the final-sized stems.

Result: The average age of the patients at operation was 51.1 years old (range, 34 to 88). The mean follow-up was 5.8 years (range, 2 to 10). No patients were lost to follow-up. The mean Harris hip score at final F/U was 92 points. The X-rays taken postoperatively, 3months, 6months, 1 year, 2 years and the last F/U were checked carefully. Radiographically, there was no stem loosening, no measurable subsidence or demarcation line both in bone-cement and implant–cement interfaces. Even in the thinnest area of cement layer, no breakage or fracture was detected. Load transfer predominantly occurred at proximal 1/3 in 38 stems, at middle 1/3 in 20 stems (i.e. junction of porous coating and uncoated surface of the stem). No load transfer was noted at distal 1/3.

Conclusion: When reliable cementless stem fixation is not obtained intraoperatively, cement can be added to function as “gap-filler” for augmenting the initial fixation. The clinical and radiological result is quite favorable. Thin (< 2mm) cement mantle between bone and porous-coated stem will not result in early cement mantle break and implant failure.


G. Horne W. Bruce P. Devane H. Teoh

Purpose: To examine the histology of the bone cement interface in a canine total hip model comparing two different cementing techniques.

Methods: Seven adult mongrel dogs underwent staged bilateral total hip replacement, on one side cement was finger packed into the femur, on the opposite side the femoral canal was washed, brushed, distally plugged and pressure injected with cement prior to inserting the femoral component. Sequential flurochrome bone labelling was performed. The dogs were sacrificed up to six months post surgery. Under-calcified sections of the femur were examined by fluorescent microscopy.

Results: Post-operative radiographs showed complete filling of the proximal femur with cement in the pressure injected group, and a relatively thin mantle in the finger packed group. Histology of the finger packed group showed minimal intrusion of cement into the cancellous bed, direct opposition of cement and bone with small areas of fibrous tissue interposition. In the pressure injected group the cement extended to the endosteal cortex, there was no bone necrosis, and the intruded bone underwent remodelling similar to that at the margins.

Conclusions: This study suggests that “third generation” cementing techniques result in greater contact between bone and cement, and may explain the claim that femoral stems in humans inserted using third generation techniques are more durable than those inserted using “first generation” techniques.


Y.H. Kim J.S. Kim

To evaluate the results critically of cemented total hip arthroplasty using a fourth generation cement technique and polished femoral stem, a prospective study was performed in patients under 50 years of age who underwent primary total hip arthroplasty. 55 patients (64 hips) were enrolled in the study (43 were male and 12 were female). Average age of patients was 43.4 years (21–50 years). Elite plus stems (DePuy, Leeds, UK) were cemented and cementless Duraloc cups (DePuy, Warsaw, IN.) were implanted in all hips. 22 mm zirconia femoral head (DePuy, Leeds UK) was used in all hips. All surgeries were performed by one surgeon (YHK). The diagnosis was osteonecrosis (43 hips or 67%), osteoarthritis (5 hips or 4%), O.A. 2° to childhood T.B. or pyogenic arthritis (4 hips or 6%), R.A, (3 hips or 5%), DDH (2 hips or 3%) and others (7 hips or 11%). The average F.U. was 7.2 years (6–8 years). The 4th generation cement technique was utilized including: medullary plug, pulsatile lavage, vaccum mixing of Simplex P cement; cement gun, distal centralizer and proximal rubber seal to pressurize cement. Thigh pain was evaluated using a visual analog scale (10 points). Clinical (Harris hip score) and x-ray follow-up was performed at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 1 year and then annually. Cementing technique was graded. Abductor moment arm, femoral offset, neck and limb length, center of rotation of hips, cup angle and anteversion were measured in all hips. Linear and volumetric wear were measured by software program. Osteolysis was identified. There was no aseptic loosening or subsidence of components. One hip was revised due to late infection. Incidence of thigh pain was 11% (7 hips). All thigh pain disappeared at 1 year postoperatively. Preoperative Harris hip score was 47.2 (7–67) points and 92.2 (81–100) points at the final F.U. Femoral cementing was classified as grade A in 50 hips (78%), grade B in 6 hips (9%), and grade C1 in 8 hips (13%). There was no cases in grades C2 and D. All bones had type A femoral bone. The average linear wear and annual rate were 1.25 and 0.21 mm, respectively. The average volumetric wear was 473.48 mm3. There was statistically significant relationship between the liner wear, age (under 40), male patient, and the cup angle. Yet there was no statistical relationship between the wear and Dx., wt., hip score, R-O-M, anteversion, anbductor moment arm, femoral offset, neck and limb length and center of rotation of hip. Osteolysis was identified in zone 7A in 6 hips (9%). No hip had distal osteolysis. Advanced cementing technique, polished improved stem design, strong trabecular bone, and utilizing a smaller head and thick polys greatly improved the mid-term survival of the implants in these young patients. Good cementing technique eliminated distal osteolysis and markedly reduced the proximal osteolysis. Yet high linear and volumetric wear of polyethylene liner remains to be a challenging problem.


Y.H. Kim J.S. Kim

To determine the results critically of cementless third generation prosthesis (proximal fit, porous coated, and tapered distal stem), a prospective study was performed only in Charnley class A patients under 50 years of age who underwent primary total hip arthroplasty. 50 patients (50 hips) were included in study (37 were male and 13 were female). Average age of patients was 45.4 years (26–50 years). IPS(Immediate Postoperative Stability) stems (DePuy, Leeds, UK) were implanted in all hips. Cementless Duraloc cups (DePuy, warsaw, IN.) were used in all hips. 22 mm zirconia femoral head was used in all hips. All surgeries were performed by one surgeon (YHK). The redominant Dx. was osteonecrosis (30 hips or 60%), O.A. 2° to childhood T.B. or pyogenic arthritis (8 hips or 16%) and others (12 hips or 24%). The average F.U. was 6.3 years (5–7 years). Thigh pain was evaluated using a visual analog scale (10 points). Clinical (Harris hip score) and x-ray follow-up was performed at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 1 year and then annually. Linear and volumetric wear were measured by software program. Abductor moment arm, femoral offset, neck and limb length, center of rotation of hips, cup angle and anteversion were measured and the results were compared between normal and operated hips. All hips had satisfactory fit in A-P and lateral planes. There was no aseptic loosening or subsidence of components. Incidence of thigh pain was 14% (7 of 50 hips). All thigh pain disappeared at 3 years postoperatively. Preoperative Harris hip score was 52.3 (7–64) points and 92.9 (80–100) points at the final F.U. The values of abductor moment arm, femoral offset, neck and limb length, center of rotation of hips, cup angle and anteversion of operated hips were comparable to normal unoperated hips. The average linear wear and annual wear rate were 1.25 and 0.21 mm, respectively. The average volumetric wear was 473.48 mm3. There was statistically significant relationship between the liner wear, age (under 40), male patient, and the cup angle. Yet there was no statistical relationship between the wear and Dx., wt., hip score, R-O-M, anteversion, abductor moment arm, femoral offset, neck and limb length and center of rotation of hip. Osteolysis was identified in zones 1A and 7A in 4 hips (8%). No hip had distal osteolysis. Close fit cementless stem in coronal and saggital planes without having distal stem fixation were proved to have an excellent mechanical fixation and provided favorable mechanical loading. Close fit in the proximal canal with a circumferential porous coating reduced the incidence of osteolysis. Factors contributing to good results in this young patient group are improved design of the prosthesis, improved surgical technique, strong trabecular bone and the use of smaller femoral head and thick polys. Although there was no aseptic loosening of the hip, high incidence of linear and volumetric wear of polyethylene liner in these young patients remains to be a challenging problem.


R. Sekel L. Kandel I.G. Woodgate

Introduction: The double threaded Cone Modular Hip Replacement System has been used in 114 patients as a primary prosthesis in over three years. No patient has been lost to follow up and all patients have been assessed postoperatively for the Harris Hip Score, Pain Score, Dexa analysis as well as plain X-rays.

Method: 114 patients requiring primary hip replacement were entered into a prospective clinical trial over a three year period. The Harris Hip Score, Pain Score and Dexa analysis (Luna 2000 program) and X-rays were assessed at six weeks, three months, six months, twelve months, two years and three years and results were compared with the preoperative figures. Length of hospital stay, discharge details (home or rehabilitation unit) and physiotherapy assessment of time to independent stair climbing was prospectively assessed.

Results: The Dexa analysis indicates a loss of bone at two years at Gruen’s zones one and seven of 25% and at zones two and six of approximately 20% with no increase or loss of bone in zones three, four and five.

The Harris Hip Scores and Pain Scores show a significant improvement comparing preoperative with postoperative results in this series.

One patient required revision of the femoral neck component for recurrent dislocation and three patients have significant rotational thigh pain due to varus implantation of the stem (the pilot has since been shortened and the diameter reduced by 1mm).

Conclusion: The double threaded cone shaped modular hip prosthesis stem allows immediate full weight bearing postoperatively. No prosthesis has loosened or subsided and the locking mechanism has been shown to gain immediate and long term fixation as a primary prosthesis stem.

Clinical assessment, X-rays and Dexa analysis indicate satisfactory results with good incorporation of the prosthesis by the bone.


DUPLICATED THUMB Pages 241 - 241
Full Access
P. P. Kotwal

In radial polydactyly, the Wassel’s classification is most commonly employed. This classification depends upon the bifurcation site of the thumb. In this paper the author discusses his experience in the treatment of duplicated thumb at various levels.

In duplicated thumbs, the supernumery digit (thumb) is excised in patients in whom one of the two thumbs is extremely hypoplastic. When both of the digits have an equal amount of tissue, some reconstructive surgical procedure is employed to centralize the thumb to improve the cosmesis and/or function. If thumb excision is done in such a case, the thumb may develop instability, axial deviation and may require secondary procedures for stabilization. The thumb may develop vascular compromise, though rarely, due to anomalous vascular supply. The author has employed the Bilhautcloquet procedure or its modification in the treatment of 12 cases of duplicated thumb.

This paper discusses the entity, the surgical technique and the results in 12 cases of duplicated thumb. The mean follow up is 3 years.


P.M. Hashmi

Reconstruction of large composite tissue defects with expose tendons, neurovascular structures, joints and bones is difficult and challenging problem. Such difficult situations can be handled in a single stage with free tissue transfer provided microsurgical expertise is available.

A review of 12 cases of free scapular flap is being presented, performed over period of 20 months from December 97 to July 1999. Free scapular flap is based on transverse branch of circumflex scapular artery, which is branch of subscapular artery. All the patients in this series were male, with average age of 29 years. The mechanism of injury leading to tissue defects was, RTA 7 cases, industrial accidents 3 cases and bomb blast injury 2 cases. The various sites requiring free scapular flaps were, plantar aspect of foot, heel and leg in 5 cases, dorsum of hand, first web space and forearm in 3 cases, axilla and upper arm in 2 cases and one each for popliteal fossa and dorsum of foot. Only 4 cases presented to AKUH within 6 hours of injury while remaining 8 cases had prior treatment somewhere else and subsequent polymicrobial infection. In three cases, 2-3 debridements were done before coverage with free flap. Average defect size was 18cm long and 11cm wide. All of these cases had associated fracture

Free scapular flap is very robust flap with long vascular pedicle and large lumen artery, which can be anastomosed very easily. Donor site is closed primarily without any morbidity and scar is hidden. Scapular flap can be considered as workhorse for extremity defects.


M. O’Sullivan W. Walter B. Zicat

Introduction: Osteolysis is a recognised complication in both cemented and cementless arthroplasty. This may be caused by macrophage mediated reaction to small particulate polyethylene debris. The effective joint space describes the area where polyethylene particles may travel, such as through holes in the cup, to cause a local osteolytic process.

Methods: Twenty four cases of osteolysis (in twenty three patients) requiring revision were identified from patients on whom we had performed the primary arthroplasty. These cases were compared to an overall group of 560 primary hip arthroplasty cases performed during the same time and with the same implants.

Results: The 24 index cases were revised for osteolysis. This represents 4.3% of the total group in this series of implants. Secondary loosening of the acetabular component was present in 7/24 with 13/24 cups being well fixed at the time of revision. All the cups with secondary loosening had evidence of bone ingrowth & had been undermined by the osteolytic process. In 4 cases, either a pelvic fracture or pelvic dissociation had occurred through an osteolytic lesion. In 21 cases femoral stems were revised, but none of these were loose, and none had significant osteolysis around the stems.

The average time from primary procedure to revision was 72 months. The osteolytic group was younger than the overall group at the time of index surgery (53 years vs 63 years, p< 0.0001). There were 16 females and 7 males (p = 0.06). The osteolytic group were also less likely to have an initial diagnosis of primary osteoarthritis than the control group (p=0.05). Other diagnoses in the osteolytic group included dysplasia, previous trauma and inflammatory arthropathy.

Acetabular liner thickness was assessed for all patients. The osteolytic group had a significantly higher proportion of cases with polyethylene thickness of less than 7mm (p < 0.005), and less than 6mm (p < 0.0001). There was no difference in the mean height and weight of the two groups.

Conclusion: Osteolysis is multifactorial and facilitated by screw holes in the acetabular shell that increase the “effective joint space.” Younger females with small ace-tabular components and thin polyethylene are most at risk. Alternate bearing surfaces or acetabular components without holes may alleviate this problem. These cases represent our experience with osteolytic lesions within the acetabulum requiring revision. There were no cases of cup loosening in our overall group other than the 7/24 that had been undermined by the osteolytic process. Revision to ceramic on ceramic bearing implants is our preferred method of treating this problem.


M. Hayes

Athletes are more prone to injury because of their prolonged training, dedication and body contact, and the injuries they sustain, with some unusual exceptions, are the same as those occurring in the general population but there is more pressure to return the athlete to their chosen sport with some times, little concern for the future. Australia, and South Australia in particular, enjoys a wonderful climate that allows year round outdoor activities with a consequent potential increase in the risk of injury.

The history and clinical examination remain the mainstay of diagnosis and coupled with the knowledge of the type and extent of injury, sport involved and level of competition, appropriate investigation can be arranged leading to a conclusive diagnosis and a positive therapeutic approach.

Injuries to the wrist and hand vary from overuse type tenosynovitis through to major carpal injuries with possible neurological and vascular compromise. and as well as helping the athlete return to sport as effectively and quickly as possible, it is also important to consider the implications for the patient in the future, once he or she has retired from competitive involvement. This aspect is further accentuated by monetary gain which may influence the athlete, coaches, etc.

As well as discussing management of selected injuries to the wrist and hand, several more unusual “sporting injuries” will be addressed.


K.S. Lee J.W. Park W.K. Chung

In 1980, Morrison and O’Brien reported their experiences with the reconstruction of an amputated thumb using a wrap-around neurovascular free flap from the great toe, but its indication has been limited distal to the metacarpophalangeal joint.

We have performed 37 wrap-around free flaps from the great toe for the reconstruction of thumbs amputated at distal or proximal to the MP joint. The amputation was distal and proximal to the MP joint in 25 and 12 cases respectively.

The opposition of reconstructed thumb to the other fingers was completely possible in all cases amputated distal to the MP joint. In the 12 cases amputated proximal to the MP joint of the thumb, opposition was completely possible in 6 cases in which the lilac bone block was fixated in the position of 30° flexion and 45° internal rotation. However, in the other six cases in the fixation of 30° flexion and 30° internal rotation, the opposition of the reconstructed thumb to the ring and little fingers was impossible in five cases and only to the little finger in one case.

We concluded that amputation proximal to the MP joint is not an absolute contraindication to the wraparound free flap procedure for thumb reconstruction. However, for a better functional outcome we recommend iliac bone block fixation in the position of 30° flexion and 45° internal rotation.


Full Access
P. M. Hashmi

Introduction: Amputation of digits/thumb is quite common in industrial areas of Karachi. Loss of digits/ thumb can lead to physical and functional disability and subsequent loss of job of a worker. Amputated digits/ thumbs can be re-implanted with adequate functional outcome provided microsurgical expertise, are available.

Materials and Method: A retrospective study was done to determine the outcome of reimplanted digits/thumb performed at AKUH from 1997 to 1999. All the patients with primary reimplantation of digits/thumb were include in the study while patients with primary stump formation, were excluded. The data was collected through a questionnaire after reviewing clinical records of patients. The important variables being demographic data, mechanism of injury, type of amputation, duration of amputation, digit involved and site of amputation, procedure performed (reimplantation / revascularization) complication, revision surgery, follow up and outcome. The functional outcome was measured using Chen’s criteria. The analysis was done using EPI info statistical package.

Results: Reimplantation was performed in 20 patients and revascularization was done in 4 patient from 1997 to 1999. The age ranged from _ year to 55 year with average age of 20 years. There were 22 male and 2 female patients. There were 8 cases of thumb, 14 cases of digits (index finger5, middle finger 4, ring finger 3 and little finger 2) and 2 cases of toe reimplantation.

The mechanism of amputation was industrial accidents in 18 cases and domestic injuries in 6 cases. The various types of amputations were a avulsion type in 3 cases, guillotine in 7 and amputation with localized crush in 14 cases. These patients presented to us with average duration of 7 hours after injury ranging from 4–10 hours. Ten cases were operated under L/A and 14 cases under G/A. Four of 24 cases required revision surgery due to venous block. The average follow up was 16 months ranging from 3 months–3 years.

The results were graded according to Chen’s criteria. Four cases had grade I, 9 had grade II and 1 grade III functional outcome according to Chen’s criteria.

Discussion: Although reimplantation of digits/thumb is successful procedure with refined microsurgical techniques. These procedures are long, tedious and demanding. Patient with re-implanted digits return to their job early but still have few complications like fingertip atrophy and diminished two point discrimination. Benefits and draw backs of reimplantation should be weighed before under taking reimplantation procedure.


FLEXOR TENDON REPAIR Pages 242 - 242
Full Access
R.H. Gelberman

Two views of tendon healing’s capability have prevailed since the early 1940’s. This presentation will outline the change in perspective regarding the primary tendon repair potential of intrasynovial flexor tendons and the clinical innovations that have been devised to reduce the inflammatory response and to improve the functional and structural characteristics of repair. Specifically, advanced suture, rehabilitation, and salvage techniques for tendon injuries will be discussed.


P. Cherubino

During the last decade there has been an increasing interest in the management of cartilage lesions, owing to the introduction of new therapeutic options. Beside the improvement of the classical vascular techniques (mosaicplasty, microfractures, etc.), cell therapy and tissue engineering have opened new perspectives in this field. One of the most recent tissue engineering techniques is represented by the MACI‚ (Matrix-induced Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation). This method requires seeding of autologous chondrocytes on a type I-III collagene membrane, after their arthroscopy harvesting from the knee and subsequent in vitro expansion of the cellular population using autologous serum. The seeded membrane is implanted in the chondral defect using exclusively fibrin glue, through a limited exposure joint approach.

Membrane structure and its cellular population were investigated by light microscopy, SEM and electrophoresis (SDS PAGE 7%) before implantation. There was evidence of chondroblasts and type II collagen inside the seeded membrane.

Clinical series. At the Institute of Orthopaedics and Traumatology of the University of Insubria in Varese (Italy), the MACI‚ technique was used for the treatment of 13 patients, affected by chondral defects, between December 1999 and January 2001. There were 9 males and 4 females with an average age of 35 years (range, 18 to 49 years). The sites of the defects were the following: 8 medial femoral condyle, 2 lateral femoral condyle, 1 femoral trochlea, 2 talar dome. The average size of the defects was 3.5 cm2 (range, 2 to 4.5 cm2).

The clinical and functional evaluation was performed using the ICRS (International Cartilage Repair Society) rating scale, the modified Cincinnati rating system, Lysholm II and Tegner scores for the knee, while the AOFAS (American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society) score was used for the ankle. MRIs were taken before the operation as well as at 6 and 12 months postoperatively.

The average follow-up was 6.5 months (range, 2 to 15 months). No complications were observed in the postoperative period. The six patients with a minimum follow-up of 6 months showed an improvement in the clinical and functional status after the operation, as testified by the scores reached with the different rating systems used. MRIs showed the presence of hyaline-like cartilage at the site of implantation.

Conclusions. According to our preliminary experience, the MACI‚ technique offers several advantages (technical simplicity, short operating times, minimal invasivity and easier access to difficult sites) and appears a reliable method for the repair of deep cartilage defects.


L. Peterson

Lesions to articular cartilage have a poor capability of regeneration and by mechanical wear and enzymatic digestion they may progress to osteoarthritis. In Sweden more than 900 patients with chondral or osteochondral lesions have been treated with autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT) since 1987. Cartilage is harvested arthroscopically and the chondrocytes are isolated. After two weeks of culturing the chondrocytes are deposited in the cartilage lesion in a cell suspension. The chondrocytes start to produce matrix and gradually form new hyaline cartilage able to withstand the forces of the knee.

Lesions to the femoral condyles have shown the most promising results when treated with ACT (90% Good/Excellent, n=57), osteochonditis dissecans showed 84% Good/Excellent results (n=32), multiple knee joint lesions 75% Good/Excellent (n=53) and femoral condyle lesions with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction 74% Good/Excellent (n=−27) at a long term follow up (2–11 years). The outcome after patella lesions treated with ACT were initially not as good (2 of 7 patients were graded Good or Excellent at a mean follow-up of 36 months) but better understanding of the nature of patellar lesions and development of the surgical technique have improved the result (65% Good or Excellent, n=32). Patients treated with ACT for cartilage lesion to the femoral trochlea showed Good/Excellent results in 58% (n=12).

At a second look arthroscopy biopsies were taken in 37 patients. In 80% of the biopsies the repair tissue was classified as hyaline like cartilage. Immunohistochemical analysis of collagen II, aggrecan and comp showed ++ to +++ for the hyaline like repair tissue compared to +++ for normal cartilage. There were also a strong correlation (0.73) between hyaline like repair and Good/ Excellent results.

Other areas have been transplanted as well such as the tibial plateau, the talus and the head of the humerus, but due to the small numbers of patients and short follow-up ACT to these areas is not yet recommended.

The clinical outcome after treating chondral and osteochondral lesions in the knee is good at a long term follow-up and the repair tissue is histological similar to normal articular cartilage.


T W R Briggs L A David J Pringle M Bayliss

Introduction: Articular cartilage defects within the knee joint have poor capacity for repair. The purpose of this study is to analyse the short-term clinical and histological results of the treatment of deep chondral defects with autologous chondrocyte transplantation.

Methods: This is a prospective study involving twenty-two consecutive patients receiving autologous chondrocyte transplantation. Chondrocytes from a non weight bearing area of the knee are harvested, then isolated and cultured in vitro. Re-implantation involves injection of the chondrocytes into the defect which is then sealed with a porcine I/III collagen membrane. Evaluation consists of clinical assessment, arthroscopy and histological examination. Histological evaluation consists of examination of a biopsy of the transplanted area one-year post-op. Staining techniques include the use of Erlich’s H & E, Safranin O and S100. Using polarised light, the absence of the fibrillar nature of fibrocartilage confirms the presence of hyaline cartilage. Further confirmation can be gained by the examination of messenger RNA content, confirming the presence of type II collagen.

Results: The patients were treated between July 1998 and December 2000. The age range of the patients was 15–51 years (mean age 31 years). Of the 22 patients treated, 13 had right-sided lesions, 11 had left-sided lesions with two patients receiving bilateral procedures. Solitary lesions were treated in 23 knees with two defects being treated in one knee (25 defects in total). The defects were located on the medial femoral condyle in 17 cases, the lateral femoral condyle in five, the trochlea in two and the patella in one case. The defect size ranged from 1–5.4cm2 (mean area 2.65cm2). The follow-up of the patients ranges from 3-30 months (mean 16 months). Thirteen patients have at least one-year follow-up. Of these patients, using the Brittberg Rating, two patients have excellent results, with six good, four fair and one poor. The mean Lysholm and Gillquist scores improved from 50 pre-op to 72 one-year post-op and the mean Verbal Numerical Pain Scores improved from 7.2 to 2.6. Arthroscopy revealed that the transplants were level with the surrounding surface in most cases. Biopsy at one year confirmed the presence of hyaline cartilage in 10 out of 13 cases.

Conclusion: Although the results are short-term, autologous chondrocyte transplantation can provide, with careful patient selection and meticulous surgical technique, an effective treatment for cartilage defects of the knee. The histological results are extremely encouraging and chondrocyte transplantation may be the only procedure to allow regeneration of hyaline cartilage.


G. Bentley A. Goldberg L. Biant M. Hunter R. Carrington

Many methods have been described over the past 5 years for repair of articular cartilage defects. The best reported results have been from the use of autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT)(1) and mosaicplasty.(2) There have, however, been no prospective clinical trials of these two methods. In this trial 70 patients were prospectively randomized to receive either autologous chondrocyte transplantation (37) or mosaicplasty (33) in the knee. 37 patients were female and 33 male. The average age was 32 years (16 – 44). The indications for surgery were persistent pain and mechanical symptoms in the knee with an isolated defect of the articular cartilage. 38 (56%) were post-traumatic, 12 (16%) due to osteochondritis dissecans, 10 (14%) due to previous meniscectomy, and 10 (14%) due to chondromalacia patellae. The size of the defects ranged from 2cm2 to 12cm2 (mean 4.8cm2). There were 35 defects on the medial femoral condyle, 13 on the lateral femoral condyle, 17 on the patella and 5 on the trochlear. 31 patients were undergoing primary surgery and 39 secondary surgery. All were independently reviewed using the Visual Analogue Pain Score, the Cincinatti Pain Score and the Stanmore Score. Patients were arthroscoped at one year with MRI scan and biopsies where possible.

Results: The visual analogue pain score improved overall from a mean of 5.4 (range 3.4 – 7.4) pre-operatively to 3.9 (1.8 – 5.1) at one year review. Similarly the Cincinatti pain score improved from 6.5 pre-operatively to 10.2 post-operatively and the Cincinatti function score improved from 46 to 62 at one year before sport commenced. Overall 71% (49) patients were excellent or good on the clinical scoring scales, 15% (11) were fair, and 14% (10) were poor. The 10 poor results were no different from the main group with regard to age, sex, pain level or site or size of lesion. However, 5 were secondary procedures, 2 had multiple lesions, and 3 had had previous ruptured anterior cruciate ligaments. Arthroscopy and biopsy of 21 lesions so far after one year has shown mature articular cartilage in 2, and immature cartilage in 19. In all cases there was bonding of the repair tissue to the underlying bone. This study is already clarifying the role of ACT and mosaicplasty in the management of cartilage defects in the knee and also the necessity for the use of periosteal covering membrane.


K. Chaipinyo B.W. Oakes M.P. Van Damme

Introduction: Human autologous chondrocyte transfer requires a small biopsy of articular cartilage (300–500 mg wet weight) obtained by arthroscopy from the patient’s knee joint. Chondrocytes are isolated and seeded at low density in monolayer culture to increase cell number. A common problem with this technique is that chondrocytes lose their phenotype by reverting to a fibroblast phenotype and synthesize a different matrix. Collagen type II and aggrecans are unique to hyaline cartilage-matrix. They form an extensive three-dimensional network of extracellular matrix in which other cell adhesion and growth factor molecules are integrated. It has been shown that a three dimension environment coupled with growth factors are important for the maintenance of the chondrocyte phenotype. Although cells cultured in alginate beads maintain their phenotype they do not proliferate well.

Aim of study: To develop and optimise a bovine chondrocyte culture system as a model for optimising human chondrocyte proliferation without dedifferentiation and their future transplantation. The optimum cell density determined for bovine chondrocyte cultures was used for human chondrocyte cultures. Cell proliferation and matrix synthesis of cultured human chondrocytes from normal as well as damaged knee joint articular cartilage obtained from debridement arthroscopy was investigated.

Methods: Bovine chondrocytes were seeded in collagen type I gels at various densities ranging from 104 to 106 cells/ml to obtain the minimal cell density required in a collagen gel culture system in which chondrocytes can proliferate and yet retain their unique phenotype. The media were supplemented with either bovine foetal calf serum (FCS) or a combination of three growth factors (3GFs), TGF-b1 + IGF-I + b-FGF. Cells and matrix were analysed on day 7, 14, and 21 of culture. Cell proliferation was determined by the trypan blue exclusion test. Cell morphology and matrix present were evaluated with both light and electron microscopy. A collagen type II specific antibody coupled with FITC conjugate was used to detect type II collagen neo-deposit in relation to the seeded type I collagen gels. The newly synthesised matrix was monitored after labelling cells with 35S-sulphate and 3H-proline. The collagen type was determined by SDS-PAGE Fluorography. Analysis of morphology and matrix synthesis was performed as

Results: Cell proliferation: Bovine chondrocytes cultured in collagen type I gels at low density proliferated up to 40 fold after 3 weeks while high density cultures proliferated only about 3 fold. There was no significant difference in cell numbers at day 21 in cultures supplemented with FCS or 3GFs. Therefore all human chondrocyte cultures were cultured at low density. Preliminary results from human chondrocyte cultures were obtained from 4 patients aged 59+19. After 4 weeks, human chondrocytes cultured at low density supplemented with FCS proliferated up to 10 fold in monolayer culture and up to 4 fold in collagen type I gels. Morphology: At all cell densities, the majority of bovine chondrocytes in the gels remained rounded while some cells near the surface of the gels were elongated. Human chondrocytes cultured at low density also demonstrated similar morphology. Matrix synthesis: For bovine chondrocyte culture, after 2 weeks in culture more than 70% of 35S-sulphate and 3H-proline incorporated matrix

Conclusions: This study has shown that bovine chondrocytes cultured at low density in collagen type I gels proliferated better than at high density and retained their phenotype. This low-density bovine chondrocyte culture model is applicable to human chondrocyte culture in vitro. Preliminary results shows that human chondrocytes obtained from patients aged 39–72 can proliferate both in gels and monolayer. Age of chondrocytes and growth factors may affect the growth of cells. This model system needs to be further investigated in normal human chondrocytes.


Full Access
R.H. Gelberman

The ligamentous anatomy of the carpus has been well described in recent years. This presentation will review the most important fundamental aspects of carpal anatomy, the presentation and clinical evaluation of the injured wrist, and the management of the most common carpal abnormalities. Specifically, acute and chronic scapholunate instability, dynamic scapholunate instability, and perilunate dislocations will be reviewed. In addition, the characteristic sequence of scapholunate advanced collapse arthritis and its recommended treatment will be described.


T.L. Dela Rosa A. Wang M.H. Zheng

Introduction: Rotator cuff tears are a common injury which affects both the young athlete and the sedentary elderly alike. This condition is commonly treated with glucocorticoid injections as part of initial management. The effects, however, of these injections on the histology of collagen and the metabolism of tendon fibroblasts are still controversial.

Materials and methods: In this study, samples from 19 patients with rotator cuff tears were taken during definitive surgery to manage these tears. There was a history of glucocorticoid injections in all of the patients. The samples were examined in terms of histopathology using light microscopy, in situ hybridization to detect the presence of glucocorticoid receptor mRNA and TUNEL assay to determine the incidence of apoptosis.

Results: Light microscopy of hematoxylin-eosin stained samples from the study group showed marked cellularity although there were no signs of inflammation. The nuclei were noted to be rounded and a significant number showed pyknosis. Angiogenesis was also noted in the sections, consistent with previous finding of angio-fibroblastic hyperplasia as a characteristic of tendinosis. Collagen structure was noted to be abnormal, with longitudinal clefts and focal areas of marked disorganization of fibers. In situ hybridization showed a strong signal for glucocorticoid receptor mRNA in all of the samples. TUNEL assay also showed a strong signal for apoptosis of the tendon fibroblasts in the study group as compared to the control group which showed almost no signal.

Conclusion: Our results suggest that although an overall picture of hypercellularity is seen in cases of tendinosis and tendon tears, a high percentage of these cells are undergoing apoptosis. This may reflect a natural high rate of turnover of cells during the process of repair or may be due to exogenous factors. Glucocorticoids almost certainly affect metabolism of tendon fibroblasts and subsequently collagen structure as seen by the abundant expression of the receptor mRNA. However, a causal relationship between glucocorticoids and apoptosis of tenocytes is yet to be established.


K.M.C. Cheung T.K.P.K. Kaluarachchi W.W. Lu J.G. Andrew K.M. Kwan K.S.E. Cheah

Introduction: Collagen type X is secreted by hypertrophic chondrocytes during fracture repair. Its precise role is uncertain. This study uses a knockout mouse model in which the collagen X gene is removed to examine its function.

Method: Bilateral femoral fractures were created in type X collagen knockout mice (mutant) and normal mice (wild type), and were stabilized using an external fixator. The mice were sacrificed 7, 10, 14, 21, 28 and 60 days after fracture. Fracture healing was followed by x-rays, histology, gene expression studies, immuno-histochemistry and mechanical testing.

Results: In the mutant mice, bony union was delayed, there was abnormal persistence of aggrecan up to 60 days after fracture. Histology reviewed amorphous acellular areas surrounded by osteoclasts at 21 and 28 days, while mechanical testing revealed that at 14 days after fracture, mutant callus was stiffer than the wild type, but the trend is reversed at 28 and 60 days.

Discussion: This study contributes to the understanding of the basic mechanisms involved in fracture repair. The data suggest that collagen type X plays a significant role in bone remodeling during fracture healing. Its absence results in delayed union and abnormalities within the fracture callus.


D.W. Murray

Unicompartmental knee replacements (UKR) have many advantages over total replacements (TKR), including better function and less morbidity. However, in general, they have a higher failure rate. To minimise the UKR failure rate it is essential that the implant should not wear out, and that the appropriate indications and surgical techniques are used. The Oxford UKR has a fully congruent mobile bearing and has been shown in a retrieval study to have minimal wear.

The indications for the use of Oxford UKR are clearly defined. It is recommended for medial compartment osteoarthritis, with a functionally intact Anterior Cruciate Ligament. The Varus deformity should be correctable and there should be full thickness cartilage in the lateral compartment, which is best demonstrated on a valgus stress radiograph. It is appropriate for about one in four osteoarthritic knees needing replacement.

The designer, Mr Goodfellow, achieved a 98% (CI 93% to 100%) survival at 10 years, using the appropriate indications. However, data from the designer is open to bias. An independent series of 420 Oxford UKR from Dr Svard achieved a 94% (CI 86% to 100%) survival at 15 years, with no loss to follow-up. In the Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register, in centres implanting at least 2 UKR per month, the survival rate of the Oxford UKR was 93% at 8 years. In centres doing very few UKR the failure rate was higher. These poor results were probably because of inappropriate indications or technique. To address the problem of inconsistent results new simplified instrumentation (Phase 3) has recently been introduced. This instrumentation has been specifically designed for a minimally invasive approach.

Patients recover three times quicker after minimally invasive UKR than after TKR. A Radiographic comparison demonstrated the Oxford UKR can be implanted as precisely through a short incision as through a standard incision. A fluoroscopic study demonstrated that knee kinematics after minimally invasive UKR are virtually normal and are substantially better than after TKR. At one year the first 58 minimally invasive Oxford (Phase 3) UKR implanted by a single surgeon had an average flexion of 135°, Knee Society knee score of 97 and function score of 92.

We conclude that UKR is the treatment of choice for medial compartment osteoarthritis provided appropriate implants, indications and surgical techniques are used.


Giles R. Scuderi

Few controversies in total knee arthroplasty have persisted for as long as the debate over the appropriate role of the posterior cruciate ligament. Excellent long-term results have been obtained with a posterior cruciate substituting design in which the tibial post and femoral cam function as a mechanical PCL. The constraint created by conforming surfaces and the spine-cam mechanism has not lead to increased loosening or polyethylene wear. Important new information in the area of biomechanics, histology, gait analysis, kinematics and clinical results have strengthened the belief that a posterior cruciate substituting design is the implant of choice for most primary and revision total knee arthroplasties.


D. K. Bae

Introduction: There has been a lack of general agreement on how successful unicompartmental knee arthroplasty has been. The purpose of this study is to report the results of revision total knee arthroplasties performed for failure of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty and to determine the factors that led to failure of the unicompartmental knee arthroplasty.

Materials and method: Between September 1992 and June 1999, 12 knees(10 patients) among 106 primary unicompartmental knee arthroplasties, had revision of a failed unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. The average age of the patients was 61 years(range, 43 to 73 years). The average follow-up period was 3.6 years. Diagnosis before initial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty included osteoarthritis in eight patients and osteonecrosis in two patients. The medial compartment was involved in all knees. The type of prosthesis used in the 12 knees before revision was one Modular II, seven Microlocs and four Allegrettoes. The initial unicompartmental knee prosthetic components had been in place for an average of 4.3 years(range, 1, 2 to 7.5 years). The clinical findings were assessed using the Hospital for Special Surgery scoring system. Radiographic measurements were done with Bauer’s method. ANOVA test was used for statistical analysis.

Results: The cause of revision was wear in six, loosening in five and one deep infection. The implant type used for revison was posterior stabilized type of Press Fit Condylar prosthesis. Eight knees had a bone defect at revision. Bone defects were filled with autogenous bone graft in six knees and metal wedges were used in two knees. At the last follow-up after revision, the average HSS knee score significantly improved from 58 to 83. And the Bauer’s angle was corrected from preoperative varus 6.3 degrees to valgus 6 degrees after revision. Radiographically, three knees had partial radiolucency. There was no complication such as postoperative hematoma, deep or superficial infection and peroneal nerve palsy.

Conclusion: Good or excellent results were achieved in all of the knees after revision. Successful salvage of the failed UKA could be achieved by revision arthroplasty. The design of prosthesis, proper selection of patients, and surgical technique were important factors for succes of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty.


M. Ahmed

Introduction: A number of clinical and experimental studies suggest that an intact nervous system is essential for normal fracture healing. In the present study, we analysed the occurrence of regenerating and mature nerve fibres over time in fracture callus. Using antibodies against neuronal proteins specific for nerve regeneration (growth associated protein – GAP-43) and nerve maturity (protein gene product – PGP 9.5) it is possible to demonstrate regeneration and end differentiation of nerves by immunohistochemistry.

Methods: Twelve male Sprague Dawley rats, weighing 230–290 g were used. The right tibias were fractured under HypnormÒ anaesthesia and fixed with a 17-G cannula needle in the medullary canal. The left un-fractured tibia served as an internal control. X-rays was used to monitor progress of fracture healing. Three rats were killed at 3 days, 1, 2 and 3 weeks post-fracture and right and left tibia were prepared for immunohistochemistry. The tissue sections (15 mm thick) were incubated with antiserum to GAP-43 and then with biotinylated antibodies. Cy2-conjugated avidin was used for the fluorescent staining. For double staining, after the staining with first antibody, the sections were incubated with avidin blocking solution followed by biotin blocking solution. Incubation with the second antiserum to PGP 9.5 was performed in the same manner as for the first peptide. For fluorescent staining of PGP 9.5, the sections were incubated with Cy3-conjugated avidin. A Nikon epifluorescence microscope was used for photog

Results: In the un-fractured tibia. PGP 9.5-positive nerve fibres were consistently identified in periosteum, muscles and connective tissues. A number of nerve fibres also expressed GAP-43, although there were no signs of nerve sprouting, i.e. regeneration. In the fractured tibia, many GAP-43-positive nerves were identified already at 3 days post-fracture in the hematoma and periosteum. At 1 week, abundant sprouting of these nerves was seen in cartilaginous callus and hyperplastic periosteum. A number of nerve terminals were observed very close to the chondroid cells in the fibrocartilage of the fracture gap. At 2 and 3 weeks, GAP 43-positive fibres gradually shifted from the fibrocartilage area towards the outlying hyperplastic periosteum. Double staining studies showed that an increased expression of GAP-43 as compared to PGP 9.5 occurred in the early period of fracture healing. This relationship changed at 3 weeks when enhanced PGP 9.5 and less GAP 43 expression was found.

Discussion: Our study suggests that there was an intense nerve regeneration in the early phase of fracture healing. Thus, a prominent expression of GAP-43 was seen in sprouting nerves in the hyperplastic periosteum and the callus fibrocartilage as early as 1 week post-fracture. This expression remained high in the fractures up to 3 weeks, when healing was essentially completed. Possibly, this persistent occurrence of GAP-43 is necessary for the ensuing ossification and bone remodeling. PGP 9.5 expression was markedly low at one week, but became pronounced at 3 weeks, probably reflecting functional maturation of the regenerated nerve in the healing fracture. It may prove that strong regenerative capability of nerves seen in the fractures is a prerequisite for normal fracture healing. Our results point to the possibility that regenerating nerves provide the delivery system for GAP-43 and other neuronal mediators required for normal callus formation and/or neovascularization.


M. Kim C. Niyibizi

TGF-β1 and BMP-2 are abundant proteins in bone matrix, their interaction in controlling osteoblastic differentiation is, however, not clearly understood. To gain more insight into the role of TGF-β1 in the control of osteoblastic differentiation, murine and human bone marrow stromal cells were transduced with an adenovirus carrying the human TGF-β1 cDNA or LacZ gene. The transduced cells assessed for alkaline phosphatase(ALP) activity, cell proliferation and matrix synthesis. The murine TGF-β1 transduced cells synthesized and secreted about 25 ng/ml of TGF-β1, while the human cells secreted about 120 ng/ml of TGF-β1 over 24h. Both the murine and human TGF-β1 transduced cells failed to respond to rhBMP-2 as indicated by non-expression of ALP activity, while the LacZ transduced cells expressed ALP activity under similar conditions. Treatment of the bone stromal cells with the human TGF-β1 protein in presence of BMP-2 demonstrated that the inhibition of the ALP activity expression is dose dependent.


G. Keene P. McEwen

This paper reports the authors’ experience of over 850 unicompartmental knee replacements beginning in 1985 with the MG2 uni and then the LCS uni in 1995, and more recently with the Allegretto, Oxford and PFC minimally invasive uni.

Minimally invasive unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (MIU) offers the knee arthritis patient significant benefits compared with total knee arthroplasty. Some of these are especially important for Asian patients, in particular range of movement and ability to squat.

The ideal indications for the MIU are not yet fully established but are becoming clearer. Contraindications are also clearer.

These issues will be discussed in detail. The results in 100 cases of unicompartmental arthroplasty will be presented and discussed along with the complications in these patients. Special considerations and recommendations for the commencement of MIU will also be discussed.

This recent and popular procedure also presents the knee surgeon with significant challenges. However, there are also disadvantages which will be outlined.

The surgical technique of the MIU will be shown in detail. The paper closes on a brief discussion into recent developments by an 8 member international group of knee surgeons of a new MIU offering a choice of fixed or mobile bearing MIU, with precise instrumentation of both the femoral and tibial sides, and the early result of the first 18 procedures in 15 patients (3 bilateral).


S. Sivananthan K.S. Sivananthan

With clearly defined indications, high tibial osteotomy offers a good outcome, provided the correction is performed as accurately and as early as possible. Ideally, in a varus osteoarthritis knee, there should be an over correction of the leg’s axis by a minimum of 2 degrees but not greater than 4 degrees.

The Balansys high tibial osteotomy instrumentation provides the surgeon with the means to determine the extent of the correction intraoperatively, with reference to clearly identifiable skeletal points. This intraoperative determination improves the accuracy of the osteotomy over conventional methods based on x-ray planning. The instrumentation controls the fulcrum of the wedge to be removed during the procedure as well as controlling the width of the residual bone bridge. The precise nature of the saw cuts offer the best conditions for fast, reliable consolidation.

For stabilization an 8 or 9 hole pre-contoured semi-tubular AO plate is used.

The cost of the plate is RM 72.80 (US$19.15). No external immobilization is done. The patient is mobilized non-weight bearing with crutches on the 1st postoperative day and discharged from hospital on the 2nd post-operative day.

From 1.6.1998 to 30.6.1998 we performed 20 consecutive cases of high tibial osteotomy using the Balansys system. The average follow up is 24 months. The indication for operation was painful varus knee with or without medial unicompartmental osteoarthritis.

The results were analysed and showed early union with excellent knee flexion and good cosmesis.

The only complication that was encountered was transient lateral popliteal nerve palsy. This complication can be avoided if attention is paid to the lateral popliteal nerve when the fibular head is osteotomised.


P. Smith R. Gillies W. Quo W. Walsh

Introduction: A tibial tubercle osteotomy can be used in the exposure of severe articular deformity and the tight knee in total knee arthroplasty, especially revision surgery. This osteotomy has been popularised by Dr. L. Whiteside [1] who described transosseous wiring to secure the osteotomy following joint reconstruction. Other fixation techniques including the use of cables and screws may provide options for this technique. The current study exmained 3 different fixation methods for tibial tubercle osteotomy using an in-vitro sheep model.

Materials and Methods: Tibial tubercle osteotomies (5 cm in length) were performed in ten adult sheep tibias. The osteotomies were fixed sequentially using circumferential Dall-Miles cables (Howmedica, Ritherford, NJ) (Fig. 1), transosseous wires and lastly 2 AO screws. Testing of each fixation configuration was performed using an MTS 858 Mini Bionix servo hydraulic testing machine (MTS Systems Corporation, USA). The loading regime used a cyclic 200 N load applied along the line of the patellar tendon with micromotion measured at the osteotomy and adjacent bone using optical sensors (MEL, Bahnhofstr, Germany). Data was analyzed using ANOVA. Micromotion at the end of the osteotomy fragment was recorded for 150 cycles for each tibia following reconstruction with cables, wires, and screws in succession.

Results: Cable fixation provided the most stable construct followed by screws and wires respectively. Wire fixation had the greatest variation in micromotion (370 microns). The ovine tibia model provides a reproducible bone bed to evaluate different fixation strategies for tibial tubercle osteotomy. Clinically, differences may even be marked considering anatomic and bone quality issues as well as magnitude of the load that have not been addressed in this in-vitro study.

Discussion: Fixation of the osteotmoy is an important surgical technique. Wolff et al. found that major complications related to the surgical technique occurred in 23% of the knees performed in 26 cases [2]. Reis et al. [3] observed fixation with 3 or 4 titanium screws was sufficient after a follow-up period of 18 months. Twenty-nine of the osteotomies healed primarily. One patient developed postoperative displacement of the tibial tubercle requiring additional screw and suture fixation. This study has shown that micromotion of a tibial tubercle osteotomy fixation in sheep is dependent upon fixation technique. Cables provided the most stable fixation compared to screws and wires in an ovine tibial model.


Y. Tanaka S. Kokubun T. Sato K. Ozawa

Diagnostic indices for the determination of involved nerve root in cervical radiculopathy have been described by Yoss (1957), Murphey (1973) and Hoppenfeld (1976). However, there has been criticism that their indices are inappropriate for the diagnosis, because involved nerve root can not necessarily be determined using them. Difficulties in diagnosis have been attributed to the variable patterns of symptoms and signs caused by nerve root compression.

Purpose: To develop the new diagnostic indices for determination of involved nerve root in cervical radiculopathy.

Methods: Forty-five cases operated on through posterior foraminotomy were reviewed. The sites of neck pain(s) (in nape, in suprascapular, superior angle of scapula, interscapular, or scapular regions), and arm pain (anterior, lateral, posterior or medial) in anatomical position were preoperatively recorded. The finger(s) with subjective paraesthesia or objective sensory change, and the finger(s) of the most severe involvement were recorded. Affected muscle(s) (deltoid, biceps, wrist extensor, wrist flexor, triceps, finger extensor, or intrinsic), and the muscle(s) of the weakest were recorded. All of 45 cases were decompressed unilaterally at only 1 level, and showed improvements just after operation. Involved nerve roots and number of their cases were as follows: C5, 7; C6, 12; C7, 13; C8, 13.

Results: Pain in the suprascapular region frequently (82%) indicated C5 or C6 radiculopathy. Interscapular or scapular pain always (100%) indicated C7 or C8 radiculopathy. Lateral, posterior, or medial arm pain frequently indicated C6, C7 or C8 radiculopathy, respectively. Involved nerve roots and number of patterns of finger paraesthesia [or sensory change] were as follows: C5, 0 [0]; C6, 4 [5]; C7, 8 [10]; C8, 4 [5]. However, when the most severe involvement was that of the thumb, the index or long finger, or the little finger, the indication was C6, C7 or C8 radiculopathy, respectively. Although patterns in affection of muscles were also variable, when the weakest muscle was deltoid, biceps or wrist extensor, wrist flexor or triceps, or intrinsic, the indication was C5, C6, C7 or C8 radiculopathy, respectively.

Conclusion: The sites of the neck and arm pain are important for the diagnosis of the involved nerve root. Not the fingers with paraesthesia but the fingers with the most severe involvement lead to the diagnosis.


S.H. Cho

Introduction: To compare the effect of complete and incomplete osteotomy of the medial cortex of proximal tibia in closing wedge high tibial osteotomy

Materials and methods: Total 153 cases of high tibial osteotomy (average age: 59.7 years) were divided into two groups: Group I; 57 cases of incomplete osteotomy of medial cortex and Group II; 96 cases of complete osteotomy. All osteotomies were fixed with 90¨¬angled blade plate. Two groups were evaluated to verify the difference of complete and incomplete osteotomies regarding the radiological changes of the mechanical axes.

Results: After average 3.5 years of follow-up (minimum 2.4 years), Group I showed recurrence of varus in 21 cases (36.8%) with average 10¨¬ correction loss, while Group II showed recurrence of varus in 11 cases (11.5%) with average 3¨¬ correction loss(P< 0.05). The blade plate fixation of high tibial osteotomy was not rigid enough to prevent loss of correction in case of osteoporosis of the proximal tibia as far as the medial cortex was left intact.

Conclusion: Authors recommend complete osteotomy of the medial cortex in closing wedge high tibial osteotomy in order to maintain the valgus correction by avoiding the spring effect of medial cortex. Blade plate fixation also provides more physiological tibiofemoral axis for future total knee surgery by lateral translation of the distal tibia after complete osteotomy of medial cortex.


R. Gillies P. Chapman-Sheath W. Chung W. Walsh

Introduction: Unicomparmental knee replacements have a long clinical history of success as well as failure. Recently, in Australia some 40% of knee surgery performed consists of unicompartmental knees for the treatment of medial compartment OA. This increased use of unicompartmental knees is in part due to advances in surgical technique through a minimally invasive approach. Loading conditions at the tibia-implant interface will play an important role in the stress/strain distributions at the proximal tibia. The use of an all PE tibial insert versus a metal backed component may provide a different strain disribution to the proximal tibia. This study examined the influence of metal backed and polyethylene tibial components in unicompartmental knee replacements with and without cement fixation on the initial strain distributions under various loading conditions.

Materials and Methods: Three cadaveric tibias (mean age 47 years old) were cleaned of all soft tissue and strain gauged. Rosette strain gauges (TML Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) were placed at 2 levels on the tibial cortex. The intact tibia were embedded in a low melting point alloy at a standard height and tested using an MTS 858 Bionix testing machine (MTS Systems, Min., MI). The tibia were tested in nuetral, varus and valgus positions at zero and sixty degrees of flexion. A 1500N was applied for 15 seconds and the strains measured. A K-Scan sensor (Tekscan, Boston, MA) was used to confirm the varus and valgus loading positions and to obtain a contact footprint and pressure for the intact and reconstructed tibias under the loading conditions (Fig. 1). Following intact testing, the tibias were templated and reconstructed by a surgeon familiar with the technigue. The implants were investigated with and without cement fixation and compared to their respective all polyethylene component if it was available using the same loading regime as the intact tibias. Principal strains were calculated.

Results: Tibial cortical strain distributions were significantly different at the proximal and distal sites under the loading conditions examined. The strain distribution for metal backed components was greater than the all PE design. Increasing flexion angle shifted the peak strains posteriorly. Metal backing and all PE tibial inserts presented different strain distributions on the medial side under nuetral and varus loading. Lateral compartment strains did not differ between designs, were higher proximal and decreased dramatically at the distal gauges. Cementless fixation tended to overload compared to the intact condition. Figure 2 presents the strain distribution for a typical metal backed and all poly unicompartmental knee in the nuetral position.

Discussion: Metal backed unicompartmental components overloaded the proximal cortex of the tibia. All polyethylene tibial inserts did not overload the proximal cortex and had similar strain distribution to the intact tibia. Cemented fixation allows the transfer of load to the distal tibial cortex via the proximal cortex and subchondral bone, provided that the bone cement has inter-digitised the subchondral bone.


W. Laohacharoensombat S. Suppaphol S. Jaovisidha

Background: It’s has been recently accepted that the posterior segmental spinal system is one of the best instruments in scoliosis correction. Since Cotrel introduced the CD system the use of this system is widely performed. Most reports verify moderate to good correction of coronal deformity with the Cobb’s angle correction range from 60 to 70%. However, many authors reported little degrees of vertebral derotation ranging from 0 to 20%. Wood found that actually the derotation occurred outside the segment of instrumentation and many authors demonstrated no or minimal apical derotation in the CD system. Recently the development of posterior pedicular screws system especially on vertebral derotation. This study reported the efficacy of RSS which is one of the pedicular screw system designed specifically for 3D idiopathic scoliosis correction.

Objective: To study the efficacy of RSS in idiopathic scoliosis correction

Methodology: We prospectively collected the data from April 1998 to March 1999. There were 25 patients who had the diagnosis of idiopathic scoliosis and underwent the posterior spinal correction and fusion with RSS. Inclusion criteria: all patients who had the Dx of AIS and underwent posterior spinal correction and fusion with RSS. Exclusion criteria: Juvenile scoliosis and in patient who had the indication for combined anterior and posterior approach.

We recorded the data both preoperatively and postoperatively as follow: Standing height, Cobb’s angle, Kyphotic angle (T5 to T12), coronal trunk balance (plumb line), shoulder height difference, Rib hump difference, vertebral rotation, alignment index, coronal hump difference.

Regarding vertebral rotation, we use the CT scan measurement by the method introduced by Aaro and Dahlborn and the angle we use was called RaMI which is defined by the angle formed between 2 lines, one line drawn from the sternum to the most posterior corner of the spinal canal and the other drawn from the most posterior aspect of the spinal canal and extending anteriorly to equally bisect the vertebral body. The alignment index is calculated by the equation as follow: -AI=|apex-(T+B)/2| where AI = alignment index, apex = average apical RaMI rotation angle, T= average upper end vertebral Raml rotational angle and B = average lower end vertebral Raml rotation. This represented the overall segmental vertebral rotational alignment, the closer the value to zero, the better the alignment. Coronal hump difference is used to evaluate the rib cage deformity and is measured from CT-scan film by first create the Raml line and the second line was made perpendicular to Raml line and touch the posterior aspect of the more prominent rib cage as shown in figure. We measure the distance from point B to rib cage on the less prominent hump in mm and this is the virtual coronal hump difference which can converted back to coronal hump difference by magnificating factor.


S.C. Chen P.W. Shen

The lumbar or sacral root compression is frequently associated with degenerative spinal diseases. It may be caused by the hypertrophic facets, hypertrophic ligamentum flavum, or protruding disc. Canal stenosis, epidural hematoma, the cyst of pseudo-joint from degenerative or lytic-type spondylolisthesis, or tumors are less common. We present one unusual case with the severe progressive symptom of bilateral S2-4 root compression. The 80-year-old active male suffered the intermittent claudication for 4 months and got the worse symptom including bilateral painful buttocks in recent one month. The bilateral radiation pain cannot be changed at any position and taking a rest. Plain x-ray showed the degenerative spondylolisthesis over L4-5 level. The magnetic resonance imaging showed the cyst-like mass indented the dura posteriorly. During the operation, one huge psudo-joint capsule created from the interspinous ligament compressed the dorsal side of the cauda equina. We performed the posterior decompression and removal of the pseudo-joint capsule and ligamentum flavum with posterolateral fusion. The patient was completely resolved from all the symptoms after surgery. Therefore we present the unusual case and discuss the differentiation from synovial or ganglion cysts of the spine.


R. Kosaka

Thirteen patients with symptomatic disc herniation in the cervical spine were treated with percutaneous laser disc decompression (PLDD). Patients included 10 males and 3 females with a mean age of 41.4 (range, 24–60) years old. Preoperative symptom was divided into 2 types; myelopathy in 8 and radiculopathy in 5 patients. The level of the treated disc, which was diagnosed from the provoked cervicobrachial neuralgia during discography, distributed to C4/5 in 1, C5/6 in 8, C6/7 in 4 patients. The Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm) was percutaneously irradiated to the involved disc through a needle of 1.5 mm with a mean energy of 600 joules. Clinical evaluations were assessed with modified Macnab`s criteria at a mean follow-up period of 3 years (range, 0.5–5.7 years) excluding one patient who received open surgery 3 weeks after PLDD. Six patients (46.2%) showed good to excellent results without any significant complications. Four patients of 7 with unsuccessful results received a subsequent open surgery. There was no significant difference between successful and unsuccessful group in gender, disc level, preoperative duration of symptoms, positive provocation during discography, and the total amount of irradiated energy. Patients with successful results tended to be younger with a mean age of 35.7 years compared to those with unsuccessful results with a mean of 46.3 (p=0.053). Clinical outcome in two patients with radiculopathy were judged as excellent. Although postoperative MRI revealed few morphological changes on the disc in 2–3 weeks after PLDD, MRI at the final follow-up showed remarkable decrease of signal intensity in the disc. On postoperative radiographs, the disc height and the range of motion during flexion to extension in the treated discs significantly decreased, indicating the acceleration of disc degeneration and the resultant stabilization of the segment.


K. Sasaki J. Arimizu K. Goshi

There exists two important pathologies in degenerative lumbosacral kyphosis (flat back), such as loss of lumbar lordosis and posterior rotation of the pelvis. Patients with this deformity complaint marked fatigue in lumbosacral region and disturbances on standing and walking.

Conservative treatment is seemed to be difficult, and surgical treatment may be selected for this deformity. Our surgical strategy is posterior shortening and anterior rotation of pelvis. Surgical procedure is tranvertebral decancellation closed wedge osteotomy, correction by shortening and lumbosacral fixation by intrasacral method. Radiographic assessment around the hip axis was performed by Jackson method on standing entire spine film.

5 females and 2 males were operated on by this method. Mean age at the operation was 67 yrs (57–82). Mean follow-up was 24 months (12–36). Mean operative time was 480 minutes (320–600). Mean estimated blood loss was 1440ml (985–2415). Mean pelvic angle was 41 degrees before the operation. At follow-up, mean value was 33 degrees. Preoperative mean local kyphosis was 4.7 degrees. Postoperative mean local lordosis was 24.1 degrees, average correction was 30 degrees. No loss of correction occurred in fused area. Clinical symptoms were remarkably improved after the operation. There was no major complication in this series.


N. Toda H. Iizuka A. Shimegi K. Takagishi T. Shimizu K. Tateno

Purpose: In recent years, many reports have described spontaneous resorption of lumbar disc herniation evaluated with Gd-enhanced MRI. We also found retrospectively that sequestrated lumbar disc herniation with Gd-enhanced MRI would disappear, and that patient with this type of lumbar disc herniation would improve clinically. But there is a question that Gd-enhanced MRI is really needed to speculate the prognosis of sequestrated lumbar disc herniation. The purpose of this study is to clarify the prognostic value of Gd-enhanced MRI for sequestrated lumber disc herniation.

Materials and methods: Since Nov. 1995, 22 patients of sequestrated lumber disc herniation were treated non-operatively under the speculation of getting good clinical result prospectively. From Nov. 1995 to Oct. 1997, 9 patients with sequestrated lumbar disc herniation with ring-enhancement on Gd-enhanced MRI were treated non-operatively (Group A). From Nov. 1997 to July 2000, 13 patients with sequestrated lumbar disc herniation were treated non-operatively without Gd-enhanced MRI examination (Group B). Clinical results and the last MRI findings of Group A were compared with that of Group B.

Results: In Group A, all cases were treated non-operatively and all of them improved clinically within a month of the first MRI examinations. Mean period of NSAID administration was 37 days (range 14–67 days), and the last MRI examinations revealed that the herniated masses disappeared in 5 cases and that the size of herniations diminished in 4 cases. All of 9 cases obtained good clinical results. In Group B, all cases were treated non-operatively but one, whose clinical symptoms were not improved within a month of the first MRI examination. Mean period of NSAID administration was 38 days (range 7–110 days), and the last MRI examinations revealed that the herniated masses disappeared in 5 cases and that the size of herniations diminished in 5 cases. Remaining 2 cases, the second MRI was not examined for some reasons. All of 12 cases obtained good clinical results. There were no differences between Group A and Group B by means of clinical results.

Conclusions: Gd-enhanced MRI is not needed to speculate the prognosis of sequestrated lumbar disc herniation. In the case of sequestrated lumbar disc herniation, good clinical result could be obtained without Gd-enhanced MRI examination at the first MRI examination.


V.M. Wells K.A. McCaul S.E. Graves A.E.R. Wigg T.C. Hearn

Introduction: THR and TKR have been shown to be successful treatments for moderate to severe osteoarthritis of the hip and knee. The requirement for total joint replacement will increase as the population ages. This study reports on the incidence of THR and TKR in an Australian population.

Method: Age and gender specific numbers of THR and TKR for the Australian population, 1994–1998 were obtained from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. The same data for South Australia, 1988–1998 were obtained from the Department of Human Services Epidemiology Branch. The incidences were calculated and tested for changes over time.

Results: For the Australian population in 1994 there were 9,120 THR and by 1998 this had increased by 25.9% to 11,488 THR. There were 10,132 TKR in 1994 and by 1998 this had increased by 42.8% to 14,472 TKR. Stratified by age group changes in incidence rate with respect to time was statistically tested using regression analysis. For the eleven year data from South Australia there was a significant increase in the overall incidence of THR (p=0.012). There were significant increases in TKR incidence, although this increase was not uniform across all age groups (p< 0.001). The increase in TKR incidence was greater than that for THR. For both THR and TKR there were no significant differences on the basis of gender.

Conclusion: The incidence of THR is increasing in Australia and TKR incidence is increasing at a greater rate. Future projections must take into account these changing incidences as well as changes in population demographics.


D.A.F. Morgan

There has been significant advancement in the principles and practices of Tissue Banking in Australia over the last two years. Those advances relate to scientific development, regulatory modulation and inter-relationships between both Federal and State governments. Licencing issues

The Therapeutic Goods Administration of the Federal Department of Health and Aged Care

Prior to 1997, Code of Ethics

Formal government regulations

Code for Good Manufacturing Practice Freeze dried materials

First national licence

Synthetic osteogenic proteins Centralisation of processing

Number of Tissue Banks in Australia

Considerable variation amongst Tissue Banks

Financial statistics

Difficulty in attaining and maintaining TGA licence

Inherent inefficiencies

Core activities

Nonstandardisation of processing regimen

International precedence

Further potential benefits

Consideration by Federal Government through Health Minister’s Advisory Council

Probable end point


N. Tanaka

Objective: In Total Hip Arthroplasty, 2D template on Plain X-ray is usually used for preoperative planning. But deformity and contracture can cause malpositionning and measurement error. To reduce those problems, a 3D preoperative simulation system was developed.

Materials and methods: 30 hip joints of 25 patients were included in this study. Very accurate AP and ML images of the femur was created based on 3-DCT Images. 3-DCT images were compared with 2-D template sheet and determined the size of the stem. Another way, fully 3D model of the femur was created. 3-D geometry data of the femur and the data of the stem were compared. Plastic skull models of the 10 patients were fabricated by stereolithography from three-dimensional data based on computed tomography bone images.

Results: The preoperative measurement of the stem size was accorded with the postoperative results in 85% cases.

Conclusion: The 3-D simulation method is particularly useful for the simulation planning of the severe deformed femur such as post osteotomy.


W.M. Tang P.K.Y. Chiu M.F.Y. Kwan M.C.M. Wong W. Lu W. Pehh

Background and Literature Research: Fixed sagittal mal-rotation of pelvis is commonly encountered in patients with ankylosing spondylitis. The pelvis positioning for total hip arthroplasty in these patients can be a pitfall to an oblivious surgeon, and gives rise to mal-positioning of the acetabular component and subsequently leads to dislocation of the arthroplasty.

Objective: To quantify the effect of sagittal pelvic rotation on the positioning of acetabular component using three dimensional computer model.

Materials and Methods: Ten embalmed cadaveric pelvis with intact ligaments were scanned in 1 mm slices using computed tomogram (CT). The image reconstruction was done by the software “MIMICS” in microcomputer. The resulting three dimensional models can be rotated freely using “MIMICS.” Insertion of acetabular component was stimulated in different sagittal rotation of the pelvis. The ratio of the longitudinal to the transverse dimension of the obturator foramen was noted, and the uncovered area of the acetabular components was calculated.

Discussion: Pelvic rotation on the sagittal plane cannot be easily measured by radiographs. The shape of the obturator foramen on plane pelvic radiographs centered at pubic symphysis varies with the pelvic rotation on the sagittal plane and thereby serves as an indirect way to measure pelvic rotation. The shape of obturator foramen on plain radiographs therefore provided a guideline for patient positioning and the alignment of insertion of acetabular component during surgery.


C.Y. Lung T. H. Chen W.H. Lo C.K. Cheng

The size selection of the outer metal shell to fit the acetabulum is a dilemma to the surgeons for the bipolar hemiarthroplasty. However, no body ever mentioned the final results of motion behaviour of bipolar hip endoprostheses by different size selections of outer metal shell. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the motion behaviour of bipolar hip endoprostheses under different sizes of outer metal shell.

A fresh cadaver of size of 50 mm and three different sizes of bipolar hip endoprostheses were used to evaluate the motion behaviour of bipolar hip endoprostheses under the MTS machine. Each size had six sets of bipolar hip endoprostheses to get statistical data. The single axial load scaled from 300 N to 3000 N with increment of 300 N was applied on both the inner bearing and outer bearing to obtain the frictional torque of two bearings randomly. The axis was rotated from 0° to 90° under the speed of 1 deg/sec. The motion behaviour of bipolar hip endoprostheses was predicted and verified by the comparison of the frictional torque of both bearings and repeat the experiments again.

The dynamic frictional torque of 48mm was larger than the dynamic frictional torque of the 50mm at the inner bearing. The size of 52mm had the largest value of dynamic frictional torque for the outer bearing under any load condition. The prosthesis that had larger outer metal shell than the acetabulum had the same relative motion behaviour as the design hypotheses, because the difference of frictional torque was much higher.

In conclusion, the motion of the bipolar hip endoprostheses is influenced by the frictional behaviour of the both bearings. The relative motion of bipolar hip endoprostheses with a larger outer shell size will have an idea relative motion behaviour, because the larger difference of frictional torque. The thickness of the UHMWPE has a positive effect to reduce the friction between the UHMWPE liner and metal head.


J.J. Costi D.G. Dunlop D.S. Barker C.R. Howie J.R. Field T.C. Hearn D.W. Howie

Introduction: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the micromotion of a femoral prosthesis relative to the femur in a revision hip replacement model.

Methods: A series of Ovine hip hemiarthroplasties were mechanically tested to detect micromotion of the femoral prosthesis relative to the femur 12 weeks following implantation. A mechanical testing device utilising muscle simulation of the major groups around the femur was designed. A 3D targeting system was developed using non-contact LASER transducers on the implant referenced to a second target on the overlying femur. Movement of this second target was measured with three LVDT’s (linear variable differential transformers).

Results: The system error was quantified in each femur to a resolution of the order of 15 microns. The mean micromotion, in 3D at two points assuming rigid body mechanics, was less than 50 microns for clinically stable implants. One stem was determined to be clinically loose and had a corresponding mean micromotion of 150 microns.

Conclusion: The method enabled measurement of 3Dmicromotion of a femoral prosthesis within the femur, during a laboratory approximation of normal physiological load cycles. The micromotion values corresponded to clinical outcomes, in a manner consistent with other reports in the literature. This system can be modified to allow targeting of different implants within a variety of bone types.


M. C. Yoo Y.J. Cho Y.S. Chun D.W. Hwang

The congenital or acquired contracture of gluteus maximus is relatively rare, and its clinical feature of chronic lower back pain and extension contracture of the hip joint had been confused with herniations of lumbar disc disease or sequelae of cerebral palsy. The authors successfully treated these contracture of gluteus maximus, so report these cases and results. 9 patients suffering from Difficulty in squatting position or gait disturbance were surgically treated in our department from 1979 to 2000. There were eight men and a woman, mean age was 17.3 years old, and seven patients were bilateral. Four patients revealed past medical history of multiple intramuscular injection at gluteal region, but five patients revealed unremarkable history. Preoperative mean further flexion, internal rotation and external rotation of hip joint were 42°, 15°, and −5°. These patients revealed specific features of frog leg position in squatting position. Intraoperatively, the authors released the fibrotic band of the gluteus maximus, the short external rotators, the gluteal attachment of the iliotibial band and the joint capsule. After anesthesiologic recovery, active and passive joint motion exercise of flexion and rotation was started to prevent recurrence of contracture. Postoperatively, mean further flexion of hip joint were increased to 105°, and no Difficulty in sitting or squatting position, but slight limitation in rotation was remained. In follow up visit, no decrease of articular motion were observed. Conclusively, severe limitation of joint motion due to contracture of gluteus maximus can be successfully treated with surgical maneuver accompanied with postoperative aggressive physical therapy.


R. de Steiger

Aim: Failed primary hip arthroplasty often results in significant loss of host bone. Revision surgery may require bone grafting to restore bone stock prior to insertion of a new cup. A two to five year follow up of one method of acetabular revision for severe bone stock loss is presented

Materials and Methods: Seventeen patients had acetabular revision with the use of impacted morcellised bone and a cage reconstruction with a cemented cup. The average age at the time of revision was 62. All patients were followed prospectively with regular X-rays. A variety of cages were employed and bone graft was hand morcellised from femoral heads or cadaver distal femurs.


Full Access
R.H. Gelberman

This presentation will provide an update of peripheral nerve anatomy and the classification of injury with pertinent clinical examples of each type. Recommendations for primary and secondary nerve suture and repair techniques for nerve injuries with and without segmental loss will be described.


T.K. Ho

This technique consists of making of two small incisions, one at the distal wrist crease and a second one on the mid-palm 2.5 cm from the first incision. Through these two incisions, the proximal and distal extent of the transverse carpal ligament (TCL) was identified and two specially designed dissector-retractors are introduced. One is isolating the deep surface of the TCL protecting the median nerve. One is isolating the superior surface of the ligament. The TCL is then divided under direct vision.

179 cases were studied from 1996 to 1999 with a minimal follow-up of 3 months. The patients were assessed using the scoring system put forward by Levine et al 1993.

Result: The overall improvement of symptoms is 1.62 points. The average return to activities of daily living was 5.6 days and the average return to work was 4.2 weeks. The complications include 8 pillar pain; 1 transient superficial palmar branch numbness; 1 transient digital branch paraesthesia; 1 retained suture and 2 superficial wound infection.

Conclusions: This new technique shows benefits of small incision surgery similar to endoscopic techniques. It gives direct visualisation of the relevant anatomy. It uses simple and re-useable instruments, and was shown to be safe.


M. Rajeev Rao E. Kader V.C. Sujith V. Thomas

Introduction: The surgical management for carpal tunnel syndrome is the release of pressure on the median nerve by dividing the transverse carpal ligament. There are different ways to release median nerve viz.extensive lazy ‘S’ incision from palm to forearm and the advanced arthroscopic release at wrist. We describe a simple, effective and minimally invasive surgery for C.T.S. to divide transverse carpal ligament.

Material & method: We present 38cases of C.T.S. after clinical and Electro diagnosis confirmation underwent the minimal invasive surgery. A 1” transverse incision over the center of distal wrist crease placed exposing the palmeris longus (retracted/divided) and exposing transverse carpal ligament. These transverse fibers are cut in the line of skin incision and exposing the median nerve. With blunt curved scissors the transverse ligament is cut distally in the palm and proximally in the wrist separating from the median nerve thus relieving the compression. The wound is closed in layers over the drain and compression bandage applied. Post operatively hand elevated for 24hours, drain removed after 48hours and suture removed at 7th day.

Results: In all the 38cases there was pain relief immediately after the surgery. There was progressive neurological recovery (sensory/motor) took place from 6months to 1year. One case developed a pulsatile swelling at the wrist (false A-V aneurysm). The false aneurysm was due to accidental nicking of superficial palmar branch of radial artery, which was ligated on second day. There was superficial marginal necrosis was observed in 6 cases, which healed in 12–16 days.

Discussion: The technique is simple, short, safe, economic, effective and easily reproducible. The transverse incision gives better visualization of transverse carpal ligament; easy resection of the ligament and better exposion of median nerve at the wrist makes this procedure to have good results. This tiny incision is in the langhans line at wrist has early wound healing, a cosmetic scar and least morbidity.


R. Crawford

Introduction: Octacol F15 is a fibrin sealant, derived from human cryoprecipitate, which can be delivered as a spray that seals on contact. Pre-clinical studies have established its safety. The aim of this study was to determine the impact of Octacol F15 on blood loss in patients undergoing THR

Materials and Methods: The effect of Octacol F15 on 81 patients undergoing THR was studied in a randomised, prospective, multi-centres study. 38 patients received Octacol F15 delivered to the soft tissues around the hip at 3 predetermined times throughout the operation. 43 patients received a routine THR. Surgeons were constrained to use their predetermined approach, fixation method, and DVT prophylaxis. Blood loss was measured and transfusion needs recorded along with all adverse events.

Results: Mean blood loss in treatment patients was 699ml v 837ml in controls. Log transformed means adjusted for weight, surgeon and pre-operative haemoglobin showed a significant reduction in blood loss of 197ml or 23.5% (95% CI 5.4% to 38.1%) as an effect of treatment (p=0.014). Intra-operative blood loss was not significantly less in the treatment group (p=0.13) but post-operative blood loss was significantly reduced (p=0.0005). 11 treatment patients received blood transfusions (29%) against 18 controls (42%). This difference in transfusion needs was not significant (p=0.11). There was only one minor complication ‘possibly’ related to the use of Octacol F15.

Conclusion: Octacol F15 significantly reduces blood loss in THR without any increase in the complication rate. Its use in THR, particularly in procedures in which increased bleeding may be encountered, offers important clinical benefits.


V.S. Reddy

The shape of the femoral canal is variable, infact more variable than most contemporary designs of femoral components would suggest or accommodate. Clinical and experimental studies of total hip replacement have demonstrated the need for a close geometric fit between the femoral component and the supporting bone for a durable implant fixation. In order to provide a basis for design and selection of femoral components in future, we undertook an anthropometric study of proximal femoral geometry on Indian specimens.

74 cadaveric femorae were studied to analyze the difference in the endosteal and periosteal geometry between Indian and Western population. Standard extra-cortical and endosteal dimensions were determined by direct measurements of radiographs. To enable comparison standard horizontal and vertical axis were established using the geometric center of lesser trochanter and the bisecting axis of the medullary canal at the level of the isthmus. Statistically significant differences were found for the following measurements: Femoral head offset, Width at lesser trochanter, Width at lesser trochanter-20mm, Proximal border of isthmus, Neck shaft angle.


F.X. Huber

Introduction: Open lower leg fractures are frequently associated with severe soft tissue damage. Cortical bone tissue is thus denudated. Osteomyelitis and impaired circulation with loss of bone tissue with subsequent defects are among the main complications, arising from the condition. Surfacing bone is judged on its perfusional conditione solely by the surgeon. Minor bleedings with decortication of the respective cortical bone serve as parameter for the clinical assessment and subsequent therapeutic decisions.

Methods: 80 inbred white New Zealand rabbits with two groups of 40 animals each were employed. Each animal had a tibial fracture induced in a standardized fashion, stabilized by screw osteosynthesis. The fracture area was freed from soft tissue and periost and the medullary space reamed. After 3 or 7 days (group one or two, respectively), the tissue defect was covered by a local fascia-free gastrocnemius muscle flap. In increasing intervalls from one to 16 weeks, the implants were removed and the animals euthanized. At all three interventions, cortical microcirculation was measured by two-channel laser doppler flowmetry (LDF), counting erythrocyte flux as product of erythrocyte velocity with number of erthrocytes observed. Observed were cortical bone of the fragment created and of the adjacent cortical bone with and without periostal linig. The bone was removed after euthanisation and analysed histo-morphologically. All animals were kept in accordance with the procedures outlined in the “Guide for the Care a

Results: A muscle flap after three days led to significantly better perfusion as compared to 7 days with 24 vs 10 flux (mean +/− SEM; p < 0,05, paired t-test; baseline 1,4 flux ), resembling almost healthy values. Simultaneously, flap covering after three days displayed a lower rate of necroses with 23 vs. 40 % (p < 0,05, paired t-test). Incidence of osteomyelitis was as well higher in the 7-days-group (24%). Improved microcirculation as well as lower rate of infection were associated with the induction of neoperiost from the muscle flap.

Discussion: Delayed plastic covering of open lower leg fractures led to delayed healing as well as infection in our experimental setting. Two-channel doppler was a reliable and little invasive means for the objective evaluation of conditions, associated with experimental open fractures. Identification of less vital tissue could lead to reduction in the loss of vital bone tissue in clinical settings without the hazard of active decortication. Again, a vital periost has been proved to be the one central aspect of bone healing.


K. Shinomiya S. Itoh T. Kawauchi M. Kikuchi J. Tanaka

A hydroxyapatite/type I collagen(HAp/Col) composite, in which the hydroxyapatite nanocrystals align along the collagen molecules, has been prepared. The bio-compatibility, osteoconductive activity and efficacy as a carrier of rhBMP-2 of this novel biomaterial were examined. Following three studies were performed – (1) The composite materials (4×4×1mm3) were implanted in the back of Wistar rats, and specimens collected for histological observations until week 24. (2) The composite materials (5×5×10mm3) containing rhBMP-2(0, 200, 400μg/ml) were grafted in radii and ulnae in beagle dogs. X-ray images were prepared, and specimens collected for histological observation at week 8 and 12. (3) The implants(15mm in diameter and 20mm in length) containing rhBMP-2 (0, 400 mg/ml) were implanted in tibiae in beagle dogs and fixed with Ilizarov method. Soft x-ray images were prepared each week. The bone mineral density was measured and the implants were harvested at 12, 18 and 24 weeks after surgery. The period until bone union after implantation of the HAp/Col implant was between 10 and 12 weeks after operation, and approximately the same as that of autogenous bone graft. Histological analysis revealed that osteoclasts appeared in a Howship’s lacunae-like structure formed on the composite and osteoblasts arranged on the newly formed bone. These findings suggest that the HAp/Col composite has a character similar to that of natural bone. X-ray images and histological findings for the composites support the idea that HAp/Col has a high osteoconductive activity and is able to induce bone-remodeling units. In cases where the implants are grafted at weight bearing sites, treatment with rhBMP(400μg/ml) may be useful to shorten the time until bone union.


M.J.L. Bertol A.A. Rivera R.B. Gustilo

Introduction: The balance between achieving stable fixation and maintaining hand and wrist function during the treatment of distal radius fractures has continuously plagued the orthopaedic surgeon. A radio-radial external fixation system was developed by Dr. Guillermo Bruchmann to address these concerns. This study was designed to evaluate the immediate functional and anatomical results of the fixation system on intra-articular and extra-articular fractures. This is the first study documenting the use of this technique in Asia.

Materials and methods: Fifty-four consecutive patients, 18 male and 36 female, with 56 distal radius fractures were treated with closed reduction and application of the COBRA radio-radial external fixator. The operative procedure is described in detail. Immediate use of the affected hand for activities of daily living (ADL’s) was encouraged. Each patient was evaluated regarding functional and anatomical recovery at 2, 4 and 6 weeks postoperatively. Using the modified system of Green and O’Brien, functional recovery was based on the presence of pain, ability to do ADL’s, and range of motion. The grading system of Sarmiento was used to evaluate the overall maintenance of anatomic reduction by comparing the post-operative radiographs with those taken at 2, 4 and 6 weeks and on removal of the fixator.

Results: Assessment of functional status showed that patients had occasional to no pain at the pin sites at 2 weeks; improving on biweekly follow-up. Those with extra-articular fractures were able to do restricted ADL’s wearing the device within the 1st 2 weeks; with wrist motion arc between 50–75°. Patients with intra-articular fractures were functionally delayed by 2 weeks but with a dramatic improvement at 3–4 weeks, doing light ADL’s with wrist motion between 20–60°; progressively improving on follow-up. Biweekly radiographic evaluation showed good to excellent maintenance of reduction for both intra- and extra-articular fractures up to time of fixator removal. Average time of fixation was 7 weeks (range, 6 – 9 weeks) with removal depending on radiographic evidence of fracture union.

Summary: The COBRA external fixator is a versatile tool in the treatment of intra-articular and extra-articular fractures that any general orthopaedic surgeon can use. The overall functional and anatomical outcome is good to excellent during the time of fixation up to the time of fixator removal. Hand and wrist function is initiated immediately markedly limiting the usual complications of stiffness and disability commonly associated with these fractures.


I.H. Parkinson N.L. Fazzalari

The cancellous bone adjacent to major load-bearing joints such as the hip and knee has complex architecture. The loading patterns across these joints influence the architecture of the cancellous bone, which varies according to the magnitude and direction of these forces. Articular lesions are associated with alterations in the loading patterns and hence change to the cancellous architecture. The fractal dimension, as a numerical descriptor of complex shapes, enables these changes to be quantitated.

The fractal analysis was performed by a box counting method. The perimeter of binary profiles of cancellous bone samples was measured for different box sizes. The fractal dimension is 1-D (where D is the slope of the straight-line segments from the plot of log of perimeter versus of log box size). Samples of cancellous bone were taken at autopsy from three subchondral regions, superior to the fovea in the femoral head (n=56) and the tibial (n=25) and femoral (n=25) condyles of the knee. There were three straight-line segments identified on the log-log plot, for each subject, indicating a fractal dimension over three different ranges of scale. Fractal 1 describes the complexity of bone surface detail influenced by osteoclast and osteoblast activity, fractal 2 describes the shape or form of individual trabeculae and fractal 3 describes the overall spatial complexity of the cancellous structure.

The results show that for fractal 1, all three regions are the same. For fractal 2, the femoral head is greater than the condyles (1.40±0.07 versus 1.36±0.05 and 1.36±0.05) and for fractal 3, the femoral head is significantly greater than the condyles (1.76±0.06 versus 1.73±0.04 and 1.70±0.05).

These data show that cancellous bone architecture differs between skeletal sites. In particular, the fine surface detail influenced by bone cell activity and described by fractal 1 is the same in each region, while the shape of individual trabeculae as described by fractal 2 is more complex in the femoral head. The overall spatial complexity of the cancellous structure as described by fractal 3 is the same in each condyle of the knee while in the femoral head it is significantly greater. The fractal dimension, as a descriptor of complexity, enables the effect of differences in the mechanical micro-environment on cancellous bone architecture to be quantified so that pathology affecting these regions can be studied.


S.J. Lin

In femoral locked nailing, the distal locking screws is vulnerable to mechanical failure. The stress on these screws is substantially affected by fitness of the nail in the medullary canal. In this study a closed form mathematical model based on elastic column-beam theory is developed to investigate how the nail-cortical contact which is simulated by a linear elastic foundation affects the stress of the distal locking screws. The model is comprised of a construct of a fractured femur with an intramedullay locked nail loaded by an eccentric vertical load. The stress of the locking screw is analysed as a function of the depth of the locking screw in the distal fragment under two situations: with or without nail-cortical contact in the distal fragment. In situation with nail-cortical contact, the screw stress is decreased as the length of nail-cortical contact and the depth of the screw in the distal fragment increases, but this stress contrarily increased when the nail is inserted beyond a certa


K. Yagishita T. Muneta K. Shinomiya

Introduction: The importance of soft tissue balance in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has been documented, and several authors have documented operative procedure of soft tissue release for soft tissue balancing. However, the quantity of change of soft tissue balance in each procedure has not been reported in detail, and the importance of each procedure of soft tissue release has not been well argued. This study is a quantitative evaluation of the effect of soft tissue release on soft tissue balance in TKA.

Materials and methods: Forty-five varus knees in 42 patients with a preoperative femorotibial angle (FTA) of more than 180°underwent TKAs from 1996 to 2000, and these knees were evaluated in this study. The mean age of the subject was 70.1 years (from 33 to 87 years), including 5 knees in male and 40 knees in female. The extension and flexion gap of the knee joint was measured by the instrument applying the force of the moment of 50kg& #65381;cm to each medial and lateral joints. We decided the procedure of soft tissue balancing as follows and the extension and flexion gap were measured in each steps. The procedure were 1) exposure of posterior medial aspects of the tibia with release of the attachment of semimembranosis, 2) removal of osteophytes from the medial distal femur and proximal tibia, 3) resection of the posterior cruciate ligament (if necessary), 4) release of the superficial medial collateral ligament (MCL), 5) resection of the superficial MCL (if necessary).

Results: The results of the change of the extension and flexion gap in each procedure were shown as below. Final gap was calculated as the difference against medial extension gaps.

Procedure: The change of extension gap The change of flexion gap medial lateral medial lateral 1) (n=45) 1.2 ± 1.4 1.2 ± 1.2 1.9 ± 2.2 1.7 ± 2.6 2) (n=36) 1.9 ± 2.5 0.7 ± 1.2 1.7 ± 1.6 1.3 ± 2.0 3) (n=19) 1.8 ± 1.5 1.9 ± 1.8 2.7 ± 2.0 2.9 ± 2.2 4) (n=18) 2.0 ± 1.9 0.3 ± 0.5 2.4 ± 1.7 0.9 ± 1.1 5) (n=4) 2.8 ± 2.3 0.4 ± 0.8 4.1 ± 1.5 1.5 ± 1.4 Final gap 0 3.4 ± 2.6 0.5 ± 3.1 3.1 ± 3.4

Discussion: The change of soft tissue balance in each soft tissue procedure in TKA was evaluated quantitatively in this study. The amount of the changes in each steps were few and differed with cases. The procedure for medial osteophytes and MCL had a tendency of efficacy to medial tightness against lateral in knees with varus deformity.


S.G. Reddy

Osteoporosis, the disease of aging, is a major health problem and its clinical end point: – Fracture is a major cause of mortality and morbidity. Osteoporosis is a silent, relentlessly progressive disease that is best treated by early diagnosis and prevention. To elucidate the predictors of fracture proneness in patients with osteoporosis the following study was undertaken.

32 patients with fractures of the hip and spine due to osteoporosis were studied with a control group of 30 patients with osteoporosis but no fractures. Osteoporosis was established by using the gold standard: Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry. Of the biochemical parameters studied lower values of, hemoglobin, total serum proteins & albumin, and alkaline phosphatase were found along with higher values for serum tartarate resistant acid phosphatase, urinary hydroxy proline and acid phosphatase, in the fracture group when compared with the non fracture group. It was inferred that biochemical parameters are reliable indicators of fracture proneness in patients suffering with osteoporosis and also that in the treatment of osteoporosis, anemia and hypoproteinemia must also be considered and corrected.


D.K. Pal

Introduction: Patella maltracking is dependent on multifactorial reasons. We have been able to identify one of major and important factor being the rotational alignment of the femoral component. The other subtle variable factors that have a cumulative effect on the tracking of the patella is recognized, which is not the major thrust this study.

Methods and Materials: This is a prospective study on a total of 200 TKR. The first subset of 100 done by the same surgeon and same type of prosthesis and the same sequence of all femoral cuts followed by the tibial cut.

Thus, the rotation of the femoral component was referenced from the posterior condyles.

The second subset of 100 cases, the distal femoral cut was followed by the tibial resection. The susequent femoral resection was referenced from the tibial cut. Thus the rotation of the femoral component was dependent on the tibial axis, and not on the posterior femoral condyles, which in deficient condyles can lead to a significant rotational error.

Conclusion: In the first subset the incidence of lateral release were 3% and 10% asymptomatic patellar tilt.

In the second subset, where the femoral rotation was referenced from the tibial axis, excluding the severe valgus knees, the incidence of lateral release was 0% with asymptomatic patellar tilt of 6%. since all other factors were unchanged i.e. patella replacement, rotation of the tibial prosthesis, same prosthesis, the single variable factor being the femoral rotation leads us to conclude that femoral rotation is a major in appropriate patellar tracking. As a corollary ‘Patellar tracking is the index of orientation, sizing of all components of the prosthesis and soft tissue balance’.


C.Y. Yang T.M. Tsai K.A. Lai

This retrospective study compared the perioperative morbidity of two consecutive groups of patients having primary total knee arthroplasty thru subvastus approach and conventional medial parapatellar approach.

The arthroplasties were performed in consecutive cases of the subvastus group(SV) (21 TKAs in 21 patients) from Dec. 1999 to May 2000 using a subvastus approach and in the control group(CY) of same operator(Y) (26 TKAs in 26 patients) from May 1999 to Nov. 1999 using medial parapatellar approach, and in the second control group(CB) (24 TKAs in 24 patients) from May 1999 to May 2000 using medial parapatellar approach by another operator (L).

The patient perioperative morbidities were evaluated including blood loss, blood transfusion, lateral release, pain condition, time to ROM 90 degrees, skin complication, admission days.

The subvastus group showed less time to gain 90-ROM(6.09, 6.8, 7.85), and less hospitalization days(10.43, 11.3, 12.15). But the SV group also showed higher rate of lateral release(13%, 8%, 12%) and skin complication(9%). Although the difference is not statistically significant.

The authors concluded that the subvastus approach led to early ROM rehabilitation and discharge.


S. Tapasvi

The subvastus approach to the knee has been described as early as 1929. This approach for primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) maintains the integrity of the quadriceps mechanism and maintains the vascularity of the patella.

We have conducted a prospective, double blind, randomised trial to evaluate the quadriceps function in TKA after the paramedian and the subvatus approaches in 40 patients with osteoarthitis. Patients were randomised to the two groups and were evaluated by an independent observer blinded to the approach used. The two groups were compared as regards function (range of motion, quadriceps lag, quadriceps power); functional outcomes (Hospital for Special Surgery scores); patellofemoral alignment (Patellar tilt); and operative time, blood loss and hospital stay.

There was a statistically significance difference between the two groups as regards quadriceps power and lag in the first post-operative week. The subvastus group performed better than the paramedian group. The range of motion was also better in the subvastus group, though this difference was not statistically significant. The subvastus approach avoids the painful inhibitory arc of the quadriceps and allows for better and rapid rehabilitation in the early post-opertaive phase.

There were fewer lateral retinacular releases in the subvastus group. The presence of an intact extensor mechanism allows for more accurate assesment of the patellofemoral alignment intraoperatively. The patello-femoral alignment readings were better in the subvastus group. The subvastus approach does not interfere with the vascular supply of the patella.

The patients operated by the subvatus group were discarged from hospitals early.


S.H. Palmer S. Machan M. Cross

Introduction: Dysfunction of the patellofemoral mechanism presents as patella dislocation or subluxation with or without anterior knee pain. Causes are numerous and include ligamentous deficiency, muscular deficiency, anomlies of bony alignment and patellofemoral joint abnormalities. The 130 different procedures described to treat this condition reflect the multiple pathologies responsible. No single procedure has gained widespread acceptance. We present a surgical technique that attempts to correct as many of these deficiencies of the patellofemoral mechanism as possible.

Method: The procedure consists of a lateral release, a vastus medialis tendon advancement and a tibial tubercle osteotomy. The ‘Q’ angle is corrected by medialisation of the tubercle, patella alta is corrected by a distalisation technique and joint reaction forces through the patellofemoral joint are reduced by placing the tibial tuberosity in a more anterior position.

100 patients who have undergone this procedure have been identified. 81 percent initially presented with patella subluxation or dislocation. The remainder complained of anterior knee pain with evidence of abnormal patella tracking on examination. 52 percent of our patients had undergone at least one previous patellofemoral realignment procedure which had failed. 43 percent of the patients had generalised ligamentous laxity.

Results: The mean follow-up was 2.6 years from the index operation. 81 percent of the patients stated the operation had improved or abolished their symptoms. Generalised ligamentous laxity was present in the remaining 19 percent and seemed to correlate with a poor outcome. 66 percent of patients stated they were satisfied with the outcome of the surgery. Two patients developed recurrent subluxation after surgery and one of these has undergone a revision distal realignment procedure.

Using the functional category described by Crosby and Insall for patellofemoral symptoms 66 percent had a good-to-excellent outcome, 23 percent had a fair outcome and 10 percent of the patients stated they were worse following the procedure with increased anterior knee pain. 100 percent of these patients had grade 3 or 4 cartilage defects on retropatella surface. 57% of patients returned to sporting activity. 14% of the remainder had not returned to sporting activity because of persisting symptoms in the knee.

57 percent of patients had lost a mean 12.5 degrees of flexion of the knee at follow-up [range 5–30]. 5 percent of patients developed minor complications following surgery. No radiological deterioration was seen in any patients although coexistent patellofemoral osteoarthritis was seen in 25 percent of patients. There was no loss of fixation in any of the patients.

Discussion: A multifaceted approach to the complex problem of patellofemoral dysfunction appears to achieve satisfactory functional results in patients even when previous surgical realignment has failed. The procedure appears to be associated with low morbidity although a loss of flexion of the knee is to be expected. Generalised ligamentous laxity and cartilage defects on the retropatella surface appear to be associated with poor results and anterior knee pain in the absence of instability may be a cause for persisting symptoms.


P. Tse K. H. Mak T. K. Wong

The aim of this study is to review the relation of polyethylene wear in patients underwent Anatomic Medullary Locking total hip replacement with respect to the types of acetabulum used.

85 cementless primary AML joint replacements were performed in the 10 years period from 1988 to 1998. The average age at operation was 46.6 with a range from 22 to 63. Two different types of acetabulum design namely the Acetabulum Cup System (ACS) and Duraloc were used. 39 of them were followed up from 2 to 10 years with an average of 69 months. Xrays were performed at the review visit and the thickness of the insert was calculated. The cup abduction angle was measured and the size of the cup and initial insert thickness was also recorded. The findings were correlated and subjected to statistical analysis.

Our findings suggested that the wear of the ACS cup was significantly higher than that of the Duraloc cup. The size of the cup but not the age of the patient at the time of operation also affects the wear rate. It appears that wear rate started to accelerate from year 8 onwards. The risk is higher with cups of less than 50mm diameter

We conclude that it is advisable to review closely those patients with the ACS cup implanted. Revision surgery should be considered if eccentric wear started to be seen on Xray to avoid complicated procedure.


J.H. Chung I.S. Park

Seventy-four mobile bearing total knee arthroplasties (LCS) without patellar resurfacing were analysed in 54 patients who were followed for a minimum of one year. We examined the congruence angle on Merchant’s view, the component rotation to the epicondylar line of the femur on computed tomography(CT), the femorotibial angle on weight-bearing anteroposterior radiograph to assess the contributing factors for the patellofemoral malalignment. The statistical analysis was performed by ANOVA test, student t test, and chi sguare test.

The patellofemoral pain was noted in 17 knees(23%). The incidence of patellofemoral pain was significantly increased in the knee when its congruence angle was more than 16 degrees (p=0.034). But the pain did not correlate with the status of the articular cartilage of the patella on operation. The average congrunce angle was 4¢ªdegrees preoperatively and 24.2 degrees postoperatively. The congruence angle in 29 knees with lateral release was significantly lower than that in 45 knees without lateral release (p=0.037). All femoral components were internally rotated on CT scan with average of 6.7 degrees. More significant increase of the congruence angle was observed in 42 knees with femoral or tibial component rotation than in 15 knees with normal or minimal rotation of both components(p=0.017). Pre-operative congruence angle and postoperative femorotibial angle also affected the patellofemoral alignment, which increased postoperative congruence angle respectively.

Based on our findings, it seems that the excessive internal rotation of one component and excessive valgus of the femorotibial angle should be avoided to prevent the patellofemoral maltracking. We believe that “no thumb test” should be done carefully and the lateral release performed without hesitation if patellar tracking is a concern.


D. Shi A. Sudo

Objectives: Post-operative deep vein thrombosis (DVT) is considered uncommon in Japanese. Numerous reports of pulmonary embolism (PE) have been reported in the last few decades, and although thrombo-embolic diseases appear to be increasing, the incidence of DVT and PE in Japan have not been investigated thoroughly. We studied the incidence of proximal DVT and PE in Japanese patients who had total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total knee arthroplasty (TKA).

Patients and Methods: Between October 1996 and November 2000, we performed THA on 99 patients and TKA on 75 patients at Mie University Hospital. All were included in this study. They were routinely examined for proximal DVT by ultrasonography before and after their operation. Those patients who had ultrasonographic findings of DVT were also investigated for PE by ventilation-perfusion lung scan.

Results and Discussion: No patient had a DVT before surgery. Fourteen patients had post-operative DVT, detected by ultrasonography, and confirmed by venography. 12 cases were females and 2 cases were males. There were 5 cases of PE among the fourteen cases of DVT, The symptomayic PE were 2 cases, and non-incidence of PE were 3 cases. The incidence of DVT was 5.2% on the left side and 4.0% on the right side.The incidence of DVT was 11.2% in THA, and 4.0% in TKA, while that of PE was 5.0% in THA and 0% in TKA. These results suggest that DVT and PE in Japan are lower than those of white races.


V.C. Bose

Modern Metal on Metal hip resurfacing originated from Birmingham in the early 1990’s and is now well estabilished in the U.K. This procdure is gaining acceptance in other parts of the world and is now being performed in many countries in the Asia Pacific region including Australia and India.The demographics of the patient population with hip arthritis in south Asia and western europe is very contrasting. Primary osteoarthritis of the hip is virtually non-existent in the Indian subcontinent wheras it is by far the commonest hip disorder in Europe.Sixty nine percent of patients had primary osteoarthritis as the presenting pathology in the pilot series of metal on metal hip resurfacings from Birmingham. Most patiens in India with hip arthritis are very young and have developed secondary degenerative in the joint due to other specific causes. Thus procedures like the Birminham hip resurfacing which addresses the difficult problem of hip arthritis in the young active adult have a greater role to play in this.


L. Walter A. Bhimani

Thirty nine Birmingham Resurfacing Hip Replacements were inserted between March 1999 and December 2000. The very early results are very satisfactory in a high demand group of patients.

Because of the relative ease of revision the implants have a role as a “pre” total hip replacement. The also have an important role in cases such as osteopetrosis and previous femoral osteotomy were an intra medullary stem is difficult. The series includes two cases of arthrodesis take down.

Complications have included one dislocation in a patient with cerebral palsy and one intra operative fractured neck of femur.

However, the early studies suggest that the large metal on metal bearing does produce serum chrome and cobalt levels which may be elevated in comparison with Metasul bearings at one year. The clinical significance of this is unknown.


I. Nusem D.A.F. Morgan

Aseptic loosening which may lead to osteolysis and massive loss of bone, remains the major cause of failure after total hip arthroplasty. Reconstruction of acetabular bone stock defects by means of bone grafting is mandatory to create a stable construct to support the cup, recreate anatomy, and restore lower limb length. Numerous classification systems for acetabular bone stock deficiencies have been recommended to date. The one proposed by the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons (AAOS) is the most comprehensive and most consistent. This system classifies acetabular defects into segmental (type 1), cavitary (type 2), combined segmental and cavitary (type 3), pelvic dissociation (type 4), and hip fusion (type 5).

The aim of this study is to present a long term review of our experience with reconstruction of acetabular bone stock deficiencies in conjugation with revision hip arthroplasties using bone grafting, based on the AAOS classification system.

Between 1987 and 1998, 88 revisions using bone grafting to reconstruct acetabular bone stock defects were performed. Of them 4 patients were classified as type 1, 47 as type 2, 29 – type 3, and 8 as type 4. The mean follow-up period was 8 years (range: 2–3 years).

The mean Haris Hip Score improved from 35 points preoperatively to 75 postoperatively. All patients improved.

The complications included nonunion in 5 cases, joint instability in 6 cases, graft lysis in one case, and neurologic injury in one case. Five cups were considered radiographicaly loose. One case was infected.


J.G. Sappiatzer G. Bain

The optimal wrist position between extension and flexion to achieve the highest grip strength, was assessed on the dominant hand of 20 normal female subjects aged 18–25. Seven fixed wrist positions between 60 degrees flexion and 60 degrees extension were assessed as well as a “self selected” position which was chosen by the subjects. Other variables were recorded and analyzed such as hand length, wrist circumference, height and weight of the subjects. Grip strength was recorded using an electrodynamometer. The mean self selected angle was 28 degrees wrist extension, and this position had the highest mean strength of all angles tested. The self selected angle was positively correlated with hand length. Grip strength decreased dramatically in marked wrist flexion compared to extension. The self selected wrist position increased with hand length, height, and weight.


P.G. Murphy W. Walter B. Zicat

Introduction: Hip arthroplasty for dysplasia of the hip provides a challenge to all hip surgeons. The choice of prosthesis used depends on the severity of the deformity, and the challenge of acetabular reconstruction. We report a review of 105 of our cases operated since 1992 with a minimum two-year follow-up.

Methods: The data in this study has been collected and entered prospectively since 1992 on an arthroplasty database. A total of 105 cases were identified and reviewed. The indication for surgery was painful hip osteoarthritis secondary to dysplasia. All patients were reconstructed with some attempt at restoration of the hip centre, and without femoral osteotomy.

Results: There were 96 patients (10 bilateral), 66 females and 29 males whose mean age at surgery was 53 years (23 to 97 years). The mean follow-up period was 59 months (27 to 107 months). The hip was exposed via a posterior approach in 98% of cases. The majority (94%) of cases had no previous surgery. Depending on the degree of dysplasia either an ABG or S-ROM prosthesis was used.

There were 78 Crowe I & II, and 18 Crowe III & IV hips. The more dysplastic hips required the versatility of the SROM stems to avoid excessive lengthening or femoral osteotomy. These cases also had significantly more inferior reconstruction of the hip centre, and medialisation of the hip centre.

Complications occurred in 8/106 (8%) of cases, the mean time to occurrence being 25 months. The majority were dislocations 7 (7%). There were no sciatic nerve palsies. Revision was required for 5 cups and 1 stem. Clinical evaluation showed all patients were living at home and 85% had no activity restrictions. Mean Harris Hip Score was 92/100. None or mild thigh pain only was reported in 90% of cases. In 98% of cases patients were satisfied with their outcome. Radiographic evaluation showed stem ingrowth occurred in all cases. Minor osteolysis was apparent in 6% of cases. Spot welds were identified in 76% of cases. One case demonstrated pedestal formation.

Conclusion: Reconstructing hip joint mechanics is a challenge in the dysplastic hip. The use of different prostheses for the varying severity in dysplasia has been an effective approach to optimise hip mechanics. Our results using this approach with cementless implants has given excellent short term clinical and radiographic results.


M. Rajeev Rao E. Kader S. V. Sujith V. Thomas

Introduction: Fractures of the forearm bones are not uncommon and every orthopedic surgeon has his share in treating these cases. The general consensus in the treatment of fractures of both bones forearm in adults is operative and there are various modes of internal fixations available, the choice of which rests on the treating surgeon. No matter what the implants are used the goal is to obtain sound union with excellent functional outcome and early mobilization. The aim of this paper is to demonstrate the combination of ulnar nailing and radial plating in the management of fractures both bones of forearm.

Materials and method: We are presenting our series of 237patients with fractures of both bones forearm during the period 1995 to 2000 treated ulna with Talwarkar’s square nail and radius -AO narrow DCP. Under G.A / brachial block first retrograde ulnar nailing with minimal exposure and minimal periosteal stripping followed by radial plating through Thompson’s approach… We followed a uniform operating technique and the post-operative protocol of A. E.pop slab/cast for 4 weeks and functional cast for next 4 weeks and radiological review after 3,12 months The implants are removed at average of 15 months

Result: 98.2% cases had bony union in our series, 2 cases had ulna hypertrophy non-union, 2 delayed union, which were managed with immobilization in cast for 3 months. There was nail breakage in 2 cases due to fall, olecranon bursa in 10 due to irritation by the nail and superficial infection in 7 cases was managed with antibiotics.The fixation with ulna nailing and radial plating has average operating time of 35 minutes. We have removed implants from 125 cases after bony union.

Conclusion: There is a recent emphasis on the concept of undreamed solid nailing, which preserves the biology enhances fractures healing and reduces wound infection.

The reduced operation time, economic implant, least periosteal stripping, least blood loss and subsequent easy implant removal are the advantage of this procedure.


M. Sandow S. Papas M. Kerylidis D. Pugh

Aim: The carpus is an intricate series of intercalated segments that are controlled by specific ligamentous constraints. During radial deviation (RD), the lateral carpal column shortens but the apparent differential rotation between the scaphoid, lunate and trapezium is not well explained by current theories. This project aims to demonstrate the 3D excursion of the various wrist components and identify those rules that guide and control such motions.

Materials and Methods: By animating 3D CT scans of the normal and abnormal wrist in various positions of coronal and sagittal deviation, the dynamic intercarpal relationships can be demonstrated, ligamentous constraints inferred, and reconstructive options identified and assessed. This involved the development of specific surface rendering software that created a true 3D model (within a graphics animation environment) of the carpus in various positions of sagittal as well as coronal deviation. The intercarpal isometric points that correspond to known ligaments were identified, and motion of the bones plotted through space.

Results: During ulnar to RD, the trapezium, which is firmly attached to the scaphoid, supinates around the foreshortening lateral column. Further, the axial rotation of the scaphoid in combination with its “scaphoid” shape produces an increase in the apparent scaphoid flexion in the sagittal plane. The scaphoid acts as a rotating link between the lunate and trapezium, and lunate stability is explained by the obligate translation combined with the obliquity of the (volar) radio-lunate ligament. “Virtual” scapho-trapezial, radio-capitate and radio-lunate ligaments are evident, however, the scapho-lunate connection is less rigid.

Discussion: An understanding of the fixed constraints (isometric points) and motion rules and patterns within the carpus allows for injury characterisation and the development of more logical reconstructive interventions that attempt to replicate normal kinetics. Specific motion rules of the carpus have been established allowing virtual reconstructive surgery on normal and pathological wrists.

Ref: www.madacademy.com.au/tla, www.truelifeanatomy.com


M.S. Moon Y.W. Moon

Objectives: To assess the stabilizing effect of Ender nails on humeral shaft fracture and to assess proper nail length.

Materials and Method: Ender nailing was performed in 67 patients. Age ranged from 22 to 79 years. 9 were open fractures, and the 58 were closed ones; 13 comminuted, 28 spiral, 23 transverse, and 3 segmental fractures. 19 had associated injuries in other parts. One nail was used in 18 cases, two nails in 46 cases, and three nails in 3 cases. In 16 cases long nails were used. In the 12 elderly patients nail was inserted under local anesthesia, In all cases the sling and swathe was applied postoperatively to avoid rotatory shear.

Results: Radiologically visible bridging callus was observed at 6.8 weeks on average: the earlist one was at postop 5 weeks, and the latest was at postop 15 weeks. The average clinical union time was 9.3 weeks. In the 6 cases the long nail distracted the fracture gap, and resulted in delayed union. In the 10 remainders the distracted gap was spontaneously reduced when the nails migrated proximally through an entry hole. In cases of proximal nail migration, shoulder pain and partial stiffness were complicated, which disappeared after nail removal.

Conclusion: It is found that intramedullary Ender nailing is a simple and less invasive surgical procedure in humerus which brings the successful fracture union with least complications.


B. Kelkar

Fracture or periosteal elevation near epiphysis induces inflammatory vascularity which is reported in early bone lengthening literature. In this study, corticotomy and periosteal elevation were put to use to induce new inflammatory vessels as collaterals in an ischaemic limb. In this prospective investigation between May 1990 and May 2000, seventy-two patients suffering from severe occlusive arterial disease (44 TAO, 13 atherosclerosis, 11 Raynaud’s disease, and 4 diabetics), who had not responded to previous non-surgical or failed surgical treatment, and had progressively deteriorating ischemic limbs, were subjected to corticotomy near major neurovascular bundles and the periosteal elevation along the whole length of the bone. There was complete relief from rest pain and an indefinite postponement of amputation in sixty-one out of seventy two patients. Longest follow up is ten years and shortest is six months. This new approach is based on principle of inflammation which is the universal reparative biological process. Digital Subtraction Angiography (DSA) studies before and after operation convincingly showed the continuance of a new vascular collateral network across the affected arteries, a process, which saved the ischemic limbs from certain amputation. This new Inflammatory vascular leash acts as a biological ‘bypass’ and appears to be an answer to small and diffuse artery disease, where vascular reconstruction is otherwise impossible.


K.F Fan M. Oudega M. B. Bunge

In the Bunge repair strategy, a tube containing a Schwann cell cable bridges the cord lesion. Regenerating axons penetrate the proximal cord-graft interface and grow through the Schwann cell cable but the axons do not grow across distal cord-graft interface and into distal cord stump. Regeneration of axons can be promoted by applying neurotrophic factors in graft. Adding a matrix containing genes encoding for neurotrophic factors in the SC bridge between the proximal and distal cord-graft interfaces may promote axonal regeneration into the graft and the distal cord stump.

Methods: There were 22 female fisher rats. One segment of 5-mm spinal cord was removed at T9 level. 6 of them (group1) received Schwann cell grafts positioned between transected stumps to test their efficacy to serve as bridges for axonal regeneration. 16 of them (group 2) received gene-treated Schwann cell grafts. All animals survived 4 weeks. Functional result was assessed by BBB behavior test everyweek after surgery. Fast-Blue injection into SC cable one week before perfusion. Immunocytochemistry to detect labeled neurons in cord, brain stem, and cortex. Toluidine blue stain for myelinated axons.

Results: A bridge between the severed stumps had been formed in all animals, as determined by the gross and histological appearance and the ingrowth of propriospinal axons from both stumps. In group 1, near the bridge midpoint there was a mean of 1800 myelinated axons and eight times as many nonmyelinated, ensheathed axons. In group 2, more fibrous tissue surrounding grafted cords were noted. Myelinated axons can hardly find in group 2 animals excepted some unmyelinated axons. Histological examination shows vigorous inflammatory reaction with Macrophage dominant in the bridges.

Conclusions: This study demonstrates that Schwann cell grafts serve as bridges that support regrowth of both ascending and descending axons across a gap in the adult rat spinal cord. The ground substance of gene-treated graft induced foreign body reaction that inhibits axon regeneration. Additional intervention will be required to eliminate this adverse reaction of the ground substance of gene-treated SC graft.


K. Kawana M. Takahashi H. Hoshino K. Kushida A. Nagano

Aim: Urinary C-terminal telopeptide of type I collagen (u-CTx) has been reported to be a sensitive biochemical marker of bone turnover. There have been two assays for urinary CTx, which are u-aCTx and u-BCTx. A newly developed immunoassay for serum CTx (s-CTx) is now available for assessment of bone resorption. We have both evaluated the effects of menopause, and osteoporosis on the measurements of serum CTx and compared them to urinary CTx assays.

Subjects: 79 premenopausal healthy women, 80 post-menopausal healthy women, 61 osteoporotic patients with vertebral fractures and 34 osteoporotic patients with hip fractures

Results: Bone resorption markers were increased after menopause. There was no significant difference among s-CTx, u-aCTx and u-BCTx in the T-scores of post-menopausal group over premenopausal group (T -score; s-CTx:2.3, u-aCTx:1.8, u-BCTx:2.1). Patients with vertebral fractures and patients with hip fracture had elevated levels of bone resorption markers compared to age-matched healthy postmenopousal women. There was no significant difference among s-CTx, u-aCTx and u-BCTx in the T-scores against postmenopausal group in vertebral fracture group (T -score; s-CTx:0.8, u-aCTx:0.9, u-BCTx:0.7) and in hip fracture group women (T-score; s-CTx:1.1, u-aCTx: 1.3 u-BCTx: 1.3).

Conclusions: These findings indicate that s-CTx reflects the increase of bone resorption associated with menopause and osteoporosis with vertebral fractures and hip fractures.


N. Aebli J. Krebs G. Davis M. Walton M. Williams J.C. Theis

Vertebroplasty (VP) is a new prophylactic treatment for preventing osteoporotic compression fractures of vertebral bodies. During this procedure polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) is injected into several vertebral bodies. However, there is the concern, that fat embolism (FE) and acute hypotension could occur as in a variety of other orthopaedic procedures.

This study was undertaken to investigate whether FE and acute hypotension are potential complications of VP using an animal model.

In six sheep 6.0 ml PMMA were injected unilaterally into L1. Transesophageal echocardiography was used to monitor the pulmonary artery for bone marrow and fat particles until 30 minutes postoperatively. Pulse, arterial and venous pressure were also recorded. Post mortem the lumbar spine and the lungs were harvested. The lungs were subjected to histological evaluation.

The first showers of echogenic material were visible approximately 7.0 seconds after the beginning of the cement injection and lasted for about 2.5 minutes.

Injection of bone cement elicited a very rapid decrease in heart rate after 2.0 seconds followed by a fall in mean arterial pressure after 6.0 seconds. A maximum fall in heart rate was accompanied by a delayed fall in mean arterial pressure of 33.0 mmHg (P=0.0003) at 36.0 seconds. Heat rate had returned to baseline by 89.0 seconds and had increased by 10.0 beats/min (P=0.02) at 25 minutes. Mean arterial pressure had recovered by 209.0 seconds and was not different to the baseline at 25 minutes.

The post mortem inspection revealed disseminated haemorrhages on the lung surface and throughout the parenchyma mainly in the caudal lobes of all six animals. No leakage of cement into the spinal cord was detected. In histology fat globules and bone marrow cells were observed in both the smaller and larger vessels throughout the lung.

This study clearly shows that VP resulted in a two-phase decrease in heart rate and arterial blood pressure. The first phase was probably due to an autonomic reflex and the second phase was due to the passage of fat emboli through the right heart and obstructing the lungs.


J. Buchholz L. Herzog F.X. Huber P.J. Meeder

Introduction: Open lower leg fractures are frequently associated with severe soft tissue damage. Cortical bone tissue is thus denudated. Osteomyelitis and impaired circulation with loss of bone tissue and subsequent defects are among the main complications. Necrosis vs. revascularisation are supposed to be reflected by local tissue contents of high energy phosphates.

Methods: 80 inbred white New Zealand rabbits with two groups of 40 animals each were employed. Each animal had a tibial fracture induced in a standardized fashion, stabilized by screw osteosynthesis. The fracture area was freed from soft tissue and periost and the medullary space reamed. After 3 or 7 days (group one or two, respectively), the tissue defect was covered by a local fascia-free gastrocnemius muscle flap. In increasing intervalls from one to 16 weeks, the implants were removed and the animals euthanized. Cortical bone of the fragment created and of the adjacent cortical bone with and without periostal linig was analysed. The bone was removed after euthanisation and analysed histomorphologically. Simultaneously, fragments were deep frozen in liquid nitrogen at −190°C, a two by one centimeter fragment from the unaffected contralateral tibia harvested as control. Analysis of high energy phosphates (ATP) was performed by high pressure liquid chromatography as described by NEES (HPLC). All animals were kept i

Results: The average ATP contents in healthy cortical bone was 0,092 +/− 0,009 nmol/mg dry weight. A muscle flap after three days led to significantly higher concentrations as compared to 7 days with 0,081 +/− 0,011 vs 0,03 +/− 0,008 nml/mg dry weight (mean +/− SEM; p < 0,05, paired t-test), the latter resembling sequestration. Simultaneously, flap covering after three days displayed a lower rate of necroses with 23 vs. 40 % (p < 0,05, paired t-test). Incidence of osteomyelitis was as well higher in the 7-days-group (24%).

Discussion: Delayed plastic covering of open lower leg fractures led to decreased ATP levels, delayed healing and infection in our experimental setting. For the first time, we could determine the contents of ATP by HPLC in cortical bone. Increase in ATP contents reflected the biological quality of the bone investigated, ranging from reconstituted healthy bone to sequesters.


C.H. Shih P.H. Hsieh W.E. Yang Z.L. Lee

The periacetabular osteotomies are effective but technically demanding surgical procedures in the treatment of adult dysplastic hips. We developed a modified technique which combines the two most popular surgeries: the rotational acetabular osteotomy (RAO), and the Bernese osteotomy. Transtrochanteric approach was used in our new spherical osteotomy and provided a good surgical exposure for redirecting the acetabulum with minimal complications. This article describes the surgical procedures in detail and reports the preliminary results in the first 32 hips. As the experiences are encouraging in terms of technical ease and reproducibility, the authors feel that this new osteotomy with transtrochanteric exposure is an ideal choice of surgery in treating residual hip dysplasia in the adult. Key words: osteotomy, periacetabular, hip dysplasia, adult.


N.S. Laud S. Warrier H. Bhende H. Patankar

The external fixation has been an established method in management of musculoskeletal disorders. Various prototypes are available Majority of these have specific application in trauma specially soft tissue injuries, infections and non unions. The Illizarov fixator is probably the most versatile of these with application in majority of congenital and acquired musculoskeltal disorders. However, very few of these devices are useful in management of disorders of writ, hand, foot and ankle mainly because of their size, weight, complexities of technique and patient acceptance. This paper deals with innovative mini external fixator device which is a modular system. The device is light weight, simple to use and is modular. The technique offers static and dynamic distraction, has short learning curve, light in weight and patient friendly. The device is useful in congenital conditions like CTEV, radial club hand, ulnar club hand and lengthening of meta carpals and meta tarsals. It is also useful in acute and neglected trauma including infections in forearm, wrist, hand, ankle and foot. Its special indication extends to its application in upper tibial plateau fractures as neutralization device. The basic unit with a small clamp which off loads the deforming forces in the bone by purchase of a simple K wire 1.2 to 2.5 mm and is connected to outer rod which knurled. The device has been mechanically tested and is found to be strong ad safe for use in clinical practice. The stability of device has been tested on Instrom 6556 testing machine for pull out and crush strength proving its safety in clinical use. We have used this device in clinical practice on about 3000 patients and have found t be very useful, simple and cost effective. The paper presents the basic design, biomechanics, basic special techniques and its clinical application. The paper includes example case presentation and its application.


D.W. Howie C.M. Steele-Scott K. Costi M.A. McGee

There is a lack of properly undertaken comparative studies of total hip replacement (THR). A randomised trial was established to examine the hypothesis that there are no important differences in clinical outcome at 2 years and at long-term follow-up between cemented and uncemented primary THR in middle aged patients.Eighty-three patients with 90 osteoarthritic hips were randomised to a cemented Exeter THR involving a matte or polished tapered stem (n=47, median age 68yrs) or an uncemented PCA proximally porous-coated cobalt-chrome stem and porous coated press fit cup (n=43, median age 66yrs). Patients underwent immediate full weight bearing post-operatively. The follow-up period is 8 to 16 years. The median Harris hip scores for the cemented and uncemented groups respectively were 92 and 95 at 2 years and 89 and 96 at long-term follow-up. Four cemented hips have been revised for aseptic loosening. There have been no failures of the polished stems. An analysis of a larger series of matt versus polished cemented stems also found that the results of the polished stems were superior. Four uncemented hips have been revised, two more recently for acetabular wear and osteolysis. There was a high rate of radiographic demarcation of the cemented cups. There were no important differences in the clinical scores between cemented and uncemented THR. Some matte surfaced femoral stems failed and this trend was confirmed by analysis of a larger series. Osteolysis around the uncemented acetabular components is a concern. Importantly immediate weight bearing was associated with good results of uncemented stems.


D.S.K. Choon P.F.M. Choon

Pre-operative and postoperative radiographs of both hips and pelvis of 160 Malaysian and Australian patients who had undergone Total Hip Replacement (THR) were reviewed.

The purpose of the study was to determine morphometric differences in each group that could influence sizing and positioning of cemented total hip implants.

In order to measure distances and diameters, we used OSIRIS, a digital radiographic analysis tool provided on the internet by the Department of Medical Imaging, University of Geneva.

The known head sizes of the implants were used to calibrate OSIRIS.

The patient groups were subdivided into three. We discovered that in general the sizes of the Malaysian population began 1 size below that of the Australian patients.

The dimensionally larger 2 groups of the Malaysian patients were similar to the smaller 2 groups of the Australian population leaving a group of small Malaysian femora for whom there were fewer suitable implants

We conclude that more work needs to be done to provide suitable implants for South East Asian patients.


M.A. McGee D. Howie O.T. Holubowycz K. Costi

The purpose of health outcomes monitoring is to assess the benefits and risks of health care processes, to enable benchmarking and to allow comparative studies of new technologies and variations in clinical practice. This paper critically reviews the discipline of health outcomes monitoring in joint replacement surgery. We reviewed over 250 papers published over the last 20 years in the major English speaking journals were reviewed. We conclude that there are considerable shortcomings of clinical studies which make it difficult to determine the results of different joint replacement designs. The shortcomings include inadequate study design and the lack of comparative data. Despite repeated calls for standardisation of outcome measures, this has yet to be achieved. Considerable resources are often invested in outcomes monitoring programs.It is therefore important that instruments are selected based on them meeting strict psychometric criteria, that adequate follow-up is achieved and that appropriate data analysis techniques are utilised, otherwise interpretation of results is difficult. We have found that patients’ reporting of symptoms and outcomes after hip arthroplasty were found to be consistent with those reported by their reviewing doctor. We therefore suggest that for uncomplicated joint arthroplasty cases, the marginal costs of their regular review in outpatients probably outweighs the marginal benefits and important resources and doctors time would be made available for other patient care activity if these patients were reviewed by patient self-administered questionnaires. Our studies have shown that SF-36 health survey and the WOMAC instruments are useful when administered by mailed survey, however, the cost-benefits of using these outcomes instruments is an important consideration. The lack of comparable outcomes data should encourage greater orthopaedic participation in multi-centre outcomes studies including randomised trials.


K.Y. Chiu T.P. Ng W.M. Tang

Objective: To compare the outcomes of two cementless total hip arthroplasty systems in young patients.

Methods: Between 1987 and 1995, 68 cementless total hip replacements were performed in 50 patients younger than 40 years (range 22–40). Five patients were excluded, and 61 hips in 45 patients were available for evaluation after 7.6 years (range 3.1–11.4). There were 27 Anatomic Medullary Locking (AML, Depuy, Warsaw, Indiana) and 34 Porous Coated Anatomic (PCA, Howmedica, Rutherford, New Jersey) prostheses. The two groups were comparable in gender, age, pre-operative diagnoses, activity levels, sizes of components used and the follow-up periods.

Results: Seven PCA (20.6%) and one AML acetabular components (3.7%) were radiologically loose (p = 0.02). Osteolysis was seen in five AML (18.5%) and 24 PCA hips (70.6%) (p = 0.001). Harris hip scores, revision rates, cumulative survival rates, femoral loosening rates, extent of stress shielding and the average linear penetration rates did not show significant differences between AML and PCA hips.

Discussion and conclusion: the PCA acetabular components had a higher loosening rate; the latter was comparable to the reported rates with this design. Osteolysis was more frequently seen in the PCA hips. Since the two groups were otherwise comparable, it was possible that either the polyethylene particles generated at the articulation could be different, or there could be increased backside wear in PCA acetabular components.


J.C. Theis G. Beadel

Purpose: The ABG Total Hip Joint Replacement is a cementless, hydroxyapatite coated prosthesis designed to be metaphyseal loading. The aim of our study was to analyze the changes in proximal femoral bone mineral density (BMD) following implantation of this prosthesis.

Method: Dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scanning has been shown to be an accurate and reliable method of assessing BMD following total hip arthroplasty. 14 patients undergoing primary ABG Total Hip Joint Replacement were recruited into the study following informed consent. BMD was determined for each of the seven periprosthetic zones of Gruen from DEXA scans, which were performed serially at preoperative,, 3 months, 6 months, 1 year and 2 years.

Results: 8 patients have now completed their scans. The most dramatic change in BMD was found in zone 7 which is the femoral calcar. In this region there was a progressive decrease in average BMD to 75% of the preoperative value at 2 years. In zones 2 and 3 representing the femoral cortex lateral to the prosthesis there was an increase in BMD to approximately 114.5% at 3 months and this was maintained at 2 years. In the remaining zones BMD was reasonably stable between 97.5 and 101%.

Conclusion: We have found that in the 2 years following ABG hip arthroplasty there is a dramatic decrease in BMD to 75% within the region of the femoral calcar. Further scans are required to determine if this is progressive. In the remaining regions BMD is either increased or relatively well preserved.


H. Malchau J. Kärrholm J. Thanner P. Herberts

Introduction: In a pioneer study Oonishi et al (1988) found reduced socket wear with the use of polyethylene subjected to high radiation doses. This observation has stimulated the development of a new generation polyethylene. In addition to high radiation doses the plastic is also subjected to various types of heat treatment to reduce the amount of free radicals. The purpose of the present study is to evaluate one of the new highly cross-linked polyethylenes in a randomized controlled study of cemented THA. The hypothesis is that the improved wear resistance will reduce the prevalence of osteolytic lesions with long-term follow-up.

Methods and materials: Patients in clinical and radiographic need of a THR with non-inflammatory osteoarthritis of the hip were randomized in two groups. Group 1 received a cemented Weber cup (Sulzer®, Switzerland) made of highly cross-linked (WIAM) polyethylene, group 2 got a conventional cup. All patients received a cemented Spectron (Smith & Nephew, USA) with a 28mm cobalt-chromium head.

So far 15 patients, (6 male and 9 females) with a median age of 55 years (range 42–62) have been evaluated in group 1 and 14 (9 male and 5 females) with a median age of 55 years (range 45–70) in group 2. The penetration of the femoral heads has so far been measured postoperatively (all hips supine), after 3 month (17 hips supine and standing) and after 6 month (11 hips supine and standing) using radiostereometry.

Results: The median proximal and three-dimensional (3-D) penetration (total wear) 0–6 month (supine position) was almost equal in the two groups. Group 1 had a proximal penetration of 0.08 mm (range 0.00–0.17) and a total penetration of 0.11 mm (range 0.06–0.14). The corresponding values for group 2 were 0,10 mm (0.05–0.21) for proximal penetration and 0.13 mm (0.10–0.16) for total penetration. Between 3 and 6 month the penetration (median values) was 0.04 mm/0.10 mm (proximal/3-D) for group 1 and 0.07 mm/0.12 mm for group 2. With the patients standing we found a proximally migration of the socket (0–6 month) in group 1 of 0,08 mm (−0.07 – 0.21) and 0.12 mm (0.1–0.13) in group 2.

Discussion: Use of a highly cross-linked polyethylene in the socket did not influence the early penetration rate after THR. Early creep of the material is possible explanation.

1-year follow-up on approximately 50% of the patients will be presented at the meeting.


M. Haber D. Biggs A. McDonald

Introduction: Acromioclavicular (AC) joint injuries are common in both the sporting and working populations. Most injuries are grade I in severity and settle with an appropriate non-operative treatment program.

Arthroscopic soft tissue debridement of the AC Joint without excising the distal clavicle, is a bone sparing procedure that, to our knowledge, has never been reported in the literature.

This paper is a retrospective review of patients with chronic recalcitrant AC joint injuries, who underwent arthroscopic soft tissue debridement of the AC joint.

Materials and Methods: Fourteen patients underwent arthroscopic AC joint soft tissue debridement. All patients had failed a non-operative treatment program including physiotherapy, anti-inflammatory tablets and corticosteroid injections. All patients had been symptomatic for a minimum of four months prior to surgery.

The surgery involves a glenohumeral joint arthroscopy, subacromial bursoscopy and AC joint arthroscopy. Excision of the torn AC joint meniscus, AC joint synovectomy and soft tissue clearance were performed in all cases. Surgery was performed as a day-only procedure.

Results: Ten out of fourteen patients obtained good pain relief and a corresponding increase in function. One patient was lost to follow-up. One patient subsequently underwent an open AC joint reconstruction for chronic instability.

Five patients had previously undiagnosed SLAP tears.

Conclusion

Arthroscopic soft tissue debridement for recalcitrant AC joint injuries gave good results in 77% of cases.

Arthroscopy of the glenohumeral joint in patients with presumed isolated AC joint disease is important as there is a significant proportion of patients who have associated significant superior labral tears.

Soft tissue arthroscopic AC joint debridement allows quick post-operative rehabilitation, an early return to sport and work and avoids having to excise bone from the distal clavicle.

Arthroscopic AC joint debridement is contraindicated in patients who have grade II or grade III AC joint instability.


S. Kumar S.M. Tuli A. Arora

We present a surgical technique through an axillary incision to perform scapular neck osteotomy and insertion of bone graft for recurrent anterior dislocation of shoulder. Fifty patients in the age group 09–40 years with the history of anterior dislocation of shoulder more than three times were operated during 1988–1998. The dominant shoulder was involved in all cases and there was no history of epilepsy, addiction to drugs and psychosomatic ailments. The surgery was performed through an axillary incision. The lateral border of the scapula was palpated and infraglenoid tubercle identified. The scapular neck was osteotomised parallel to the glenoid margin, from infraglenoid tubercle to the lateral border of the base of coracoid leaving the superior cortex intact. The osteotomy was prised open and a 3 cmx1.5 cmx1 cm corticocancellous bone graft was wedgedwhich projected 10 mm anteriorly and 6 mm inferiorly. The graft remained secure and compressed in the osteotomy without any need of metallic fixation.The shoulder was immobilised in arm chest bandage for 4 weeks followed by mobilisation aimed to regain full movements in 12 weeks. The bone graft got incorporated in all patients in 6 months.There were no recurrence at follow up of 2–10 years. All the patients returned to their previous occupation. Rowes shoulder evaluation revealed excellent result (85–100 units). This surgical technique is extra-capsular, requires no muscle cutting, blood transfusion or metallic fixation. The projecting bone block anteriorly increased the depth of glenoid resulting in glenohumeral stability in larger arc of shoulder movements.


BRT Love

At this time the majority of acetabular replacements in total hip replacement rely on bone ingrowth or bone ongrowth. Long term success has been well established but is this success the result of good luck or good management? Numerous systems exist with the simplest perhaps being that of the placement of a hemispherical cup in a hemispherically reamed acetabulum. Beyond this, a wide variety of added complexity exists with the presumption that these increased complexities provide improved stability and hence more secure primary and secondary fixation.

The computer model that has been established demonstrates the geometry of fixation of hemispherical cups as compared to rim fit cups and looks at the requirements of acetabular distortion before secure fixation can be achieved. The model attempts to explain why on some occasions an apparently ideally reamed acetabulum is not secure without some form of augmentation of fixation.

The model provides a basis for considering the various options of acetabular fixation.


B. Nivbrant S. Röhrl

Post operative stability is of paramount importance to obtain bone in growth and a tight interface in uncemented implants. Although hemispherical press fit cups are widely used different opinions exists according optimal fixation and a variety of principles are preferred. Lab studies show better stability if a cup is augmented by screws or pegs. However, cups with screws and holes increases penetration of joint fluid, pressure and particles to the interface with a risk for osteolyses. HA coating is in many studies favourable to obtain a quick in growth but is by many regarded unnecessary or even a risk for increased wear. This RSA studie was done to investigate stability and wear in cups with different fixation.

Material: 80 hips in 75 patients with a mean age of 58 years (36–70) were operated with a cemented Spectron stem and a porous coated Reflection cup of titanium (Smith a Nephew) All cups were oversized 1–2 mm and fixed with press fit by experienced surgeons. Great care was taken to achieve a good rim fit. They hips were by randomisation allocated to one of four groups with different fixation methods. One group was done with only press fit technique, one with additional screws, one additional pegs and another with HA coating on the porous surface. Migration and wear was investigated with RSA at 2, 12 and 24 months and standard radiography was done post op and at 2 years.

Mann-Whitneys U-test was used on signed values for evaluation of group differencies.

Results: At 2 years the mean cup migration for the whole group was 0.2 mm longitudinally, 0.3 mm horizontally and 0.3 mm anterior-posteriorly. (SEM 0.03–0.05) The inclination changed 0.4 dgr and anteversion 0.4 dgr as well. Most cups moved laterally, proximally and anteriorly with increased anteversion and decreased inclination. No major differences in mean values were found between the groups according translations or rotations and no significant differences. Nor did we find differences between the press fit only and the augmented cups.

Wear was 0.45 mm proximally and in total 0. 6 mm without any sign of differences between the HA and porous coated groups. HA coated cups had less radiolucent lines after 2 years. (p=0.01)

Discussion: The Reflection cups were stable fixed ad we found no indication of inferior stability for cups without augmentation as might have been anticipated. The reason is probably the firm press fit fixation obtained with a stable cup, good bone and forceful impaction. Many use screws for safety but such cups are not sealed for leakage of joint fluid and pressure gradients and the risk for backside osteolyses is higher… Pegs are easier and safer to insert and tighten the holes better. A tight, no hole cup with HA is preferred by us in normal younger patients since HA gave a better interface. Such a solution should minimise the risk for penetration of particles and pressure gradients with less risk for lyses.


G. Portland M. Hayes

Introduction: The Copeland Shoulder prosthesis was developed as an alternative to the more traditional prostheses. This cementless design differs in that it resurfaces, rather than replaces, the native humeral head. The obvious advantage of this design is only a minimum of bone is removed thus preserving bone stock for future revisions if needed. There exists little in the orthopaedic literature concerning the clinical results of patients with a Copeland shoulder prosthesis.

Materials and methods: Twenty-four patients receiving a Copeland hemiarthroplasty were identified at our institution between 1997 and 1999. All operations were performed by the senior author. A minimum of one-year follow-up was essential. Nineteen patients with twenty shoulders were available for follow-up at a mean of 2.2 years. Patients’ charts and operative reports were examined, and patients’ received retrospective pre-operative and prospective post-operative application of the constant score. AP and axillary lateral radiographs were examined for component position, evidence of osteolysis, and glenoid wear.

Results: The average Constant scores showed improvement in all subgroups: pain relief increased from 0.4 pre-operatively to 8.4 post-operatively; function rose from 9.3 to 14.3; and range of motion from 14.4 to 29.3. Two of twenty components required revision: one for loosening and the other for head collapse. One prosthesis showed some evidence of osteolysis, and five glenoids showed evidence of further wear.

Conclusion: Copeland hemiarthroplasty of the shoulder is effective in providing improved pain relief and function in short-term follow-up. The ability to preserve bone stock for future procedures may be ideal especially for the young, active patient. Complications are similar to those seen in more traditional hemiarthroplasties—loosening, osteolysis, and progressive glenoid wear. The 10% revision rate is slightly higher than reported in most total shoulder and hemiarthroplasty series. Longer follow-up will be essential to make any definitive conclusions.


S. Fukuta A. Kuge M. Nakamura

Objective: To investigate the clinical outcome of debridement arthroplasty using medial approach for the osteoarthritis of the elbows.

Methods: 40 elbows in 36 patients with osteoarthritis of the elbow were reviewed retrospectively. All of the patients were men and the mean age at the time of surgery was 60.0 years. The mean duration of follow-up was 35 months. All elbows were managed operatively with debridement arthroplasty. This procedure consisted of removal of free bodies, resection of inflammatory synovia, and resection of osteophytes. Medial approach with medial epicondylectomy was applied for all cases. In 10 elbows, posterior approach was used additionally for the debridement of posterior compartment.

Results: 23 elbows (57.5 %) had an excellent result, 11 elbows (27.5 %) had a good result, and six (15 %) had a fair result. 10 elbows (25%) had complete relief of pain while the other 30 elbows (75 %) had partial relief. Remaining pain was mostly located at the lateral aspect in patients with severe radiohumral arthritis. Flexion was improved from 106.5 degrees to 121.5 degrees.

Conclusion: This procedure is effective for patients with osteoarthritis of the elbow which is localized in ulnohumeral joint. Total elbow arthroplasty must be considered for the severe radiohumeral arthritis. Careful selection of patients is essential for successful outcome.


A. Tsujino N. Ochiai Y. Itoh T. Tanaka Y. Nishiura

We performed a new operation for ulnar neuropathy caused by recurrent dislocation at the medial epicondyle.

There were eleven patients, eight men and three women, with an average age of 52 years (24–74 years) at the time of surgery. The mean duration of symptoms was 23 months. The severity of the symptoms was McGowan grade 1 in five patients, grade 2 in five patients, and grade 3 in one patient. The operation consisted of ulnar groove plasty proximal to the cubital tunnel. The ulnar nerve was replaced into this reconstructed groove. The nerve was confirmed to be stable throughout the full range of elbow motion.

The cubital tunnel retinaculum of all patients was hypoplastic and the dislocated portion of the ulnar nerves was hard. One nerve showed severe adhesion around the dislocation site. One patient had a pseudo-neuroma. All patients were relieved of discomfort, and motor and sensory function were recovered. The ulnar nerve in the groove showed neither irritation nor adhesion. In patients with grade 1, symptoms or numbness of the fingers was relieved within three months of the operation. Sensory disturbances in patients with grade 2 symptoms also improved within six months. Grade 2 patients with intrinsic muscle weakness regained normal muscular power, and these with patients with intrinsic muscle atrophy had showed increasing muscular power. The patient with grade 3 symptomes recovered normal sensation after 1 year; clawing of the ring and little fin-gers recovered, and the muscle volume was increased.

Friction ulnar neuropathy has been treated traditionally by anterior transpositon or medial epicondylectomy. The ulnar nerve may become entrapped in scar tissue after these operations. We believe that this anatomical position is optimum for the nerve and that this procedure is essential for treatment of friction neuropathy.


G. Bain

Purpose: To review the clinical outcome of patients who have had complex radial head fractures managed with titanium radial head replacement.

Methods: There were 17 patients who had insertion of the radial head replacement. The indications for the prosthesis included acute Mason type III fracture which could not be stabilised satisfactorily with internal fixation. Other indications included delayed presentation including previously failed treatment.

Patients were managed with radial head excision and insertion of the Wright Medical titanium radial head replacement. The lateral ligamentous complex was stabilised. A back slab was applied for a period of one week and then the elbow mobilised.

The patients were followed up for a minimum of one year. The Mayo elbow performance index was used.

Results: There were 7 patients with acute injuries of which 6 had associated injuries such as dislocation or coronoid process fracture. 6 of these patients had an excellent result and 1 had a good result.

There were 9 patients with a delayed insertion of the radial head replacement. There were 3 patients who had an isolated radial head fracture and 6 patients with associated injuries, there were 2 excellent, 3 fair and 4 poor.

Three of the 4 poor results had associated capitellar chondral injury. Two patients with fair results had other significant pathology in the upper limb.

In the delayed presentation group the average flexion arc improved from 78 degrees to 102 degrees and the pro-supination improved from 117 degrees to 142 degrees. The average level of satisfaction on a visual analog score was 92 per cent.

Conclusion: Patients who present with acute complex radial head fractures (including associated injuries), the results of radial head replacement are generally excellent. If there are significant associated injuries and a delay in presentation, then the outcome is often only fair. However, this group of patients have improvement in their pain, level of satisfaction and range of motion. Associated capitellar damage is a poor prognostic indicator.


M. Sandow G. Gartsman S. Kirkley

The recommended surgical treatment of osteoarthritis (OA) of the shoulder remains controversial.

Recent published and presented trials evaluating hemiarthroplasty (HA) vs total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) have been underpowered to detect a clinically relevant difference between the treatments.

A meta-analysis was carried out using methodology as described by the Cochrane Collaboration. Comprehensive search strategy was used including Medline, Science Citation Index, a review of references of relevant papers and abstracts of recent orthopaedic meetings. All articles were reviewed in a blinded fashion to select qualified articles based on population, intervention, outcome and methodological rigor. 4 RCT’s were identified. One was excluded due to selection bias introduced by the timing of randomization. The data of the 3 remaining trials was combined for analysis.

In each trial multiple tools were used to assess patient outcome however, the UCLA score was the only one consistent to all 3 studies.

The results demonstrated a statistically significant difference in change scores from baseline to 1 year (TSA 15.6; HA 11.2, p=0.012) in favour of the total shoulder arthroplasty group. This meta analysis demonstrated that in this selected group of patients, (primary osteoarthritis with intact rotator cuff and without excessive glenoid erosion), total shoulder arthroplasty provided a more predictable improvement in pain and function than hemiarthroplasty at 2 years.


A. Rivera M. Pecson

Introduction: Transient posterolateral subluxation of the lateral femoral condyle has been postulated as a non-contact mechanism of ACL rupture. The consistent location of MRI bone bruises on the anterior half of the lateral femoral condyle and the posterior rim of the lateral tibial plateau in ACL injuries suggest this mechanism of injury. Previous studies utilizing radiographs have investigated and eliminated the possibility of an increase in posterior tibial slope angle as a risk factor for ACL injury. None, however, have specifically measured the slope angle of the lateral tibial plateau. This study was designed to utilize MRI images for specific measurement of the lateral tibial slope angle and investigate this as a risk factor for ACL injuries.

Materials & methods: The MRI images of 30 knees with complete ACL ruptures (Group I) and those of 30 knees with an intact ACL were studied. Both groups were age-matched (range 15 to 50 years) and predominantly male. The slope angles of the medial plateau and the lateral tibial plateau were measured separately. Statistical comparison was made between the slope angles of the medial and lateral tibial plateaus within both groups, and between the lateral tibial slope angles of Group I and Group II., using a Student’s t-Test.

Results: The mean slope angle of the medial plateau was 3.43 degrees in Group I and 3.67 in Group II. The mean slope angle of the lateral tibial plateau was 6.40 degrees in Group I, and 5.43 in Group II. The difference between medial and lateral slope angles was statistically significant, as well as that between the lateral tibial slopes of Group I and Group II. There was no statistical difference between the mean slope angles of the medial plateau of both groups.

Conclusion: There is a significant difference in slope angles of the medial and lateral tibial plateaus, and thus the need to specify the lateral tibial slope angle in determining slope angles as a risk for ACL injuries. While there is a statistically significant difference in lateral tibial slope angles of patients with ACL tears, the actual measured difference of one degree is not clinically useful as a predictor of ACL injury risk.


T. Nguyen R. Hau J. Bartlett

Driving is an important part of a modern life style. ACL injury is the most common ligamentous injury of the knee. However, there is a paucity of information about the pre and post-operative ability of an ACL injured knee to respond to stimuli for specific situation such as braking reaction in an emergency. Does an ACL unstable knee affect braking reaction time? If it does, is there a difference between left and right injured knee? When is it safe to resume driving after an ACL reconstructive surgery? Is there any simple clinical test to assess patient’s recovery after surgery?

Braking reaction time of 73 patients who underwent arthroscopic ACL reconstruction and 25 normal controls was prospectively studied using a computer-link automobile simulator. Majority of these patients had autologous hamstring tendon graft. Every patients and controls were tested pre-operatively, and every 2 weeks after surgery up to 8 weeks. At each time point, two clinical tests namely stepping and standing test were also performed.

The pre-operative results did not differ significantly between controls, left ACL group and right ACL group for the braking reaction time and the two clinical tests. Post-operatively, it took 6 weeks for braking reaction time of the right ACL group to be equivalent to that of the controls, compared to 2 weeks for the left ACL group. There were a strong corelation between the stepping and standing test and the braking reaction time at each time point.

Conclusion: an ACL unstable knee does not affect patient’s braking reaction time. After a right ACL reconstruction, patient should delay at least 6 weeks before resuming driving. However, patient may resume driving as early as 2 weeks after a left ACL reconstruction. The stepping and standing test can be used at follow-up to assess patient’s recovery after surgery and to suggest appropriate time to resume driving.


CAN THE ACL HEAL? Pages 257 - 257
Full Access
P. Parmar D. Johnson

Purpose: To document healing of the anterior cruciate ligament

Introduction: Conventional wisdom holds that the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) does not heal. In an athlete the ACL deficient knee is likely to be symptomatic and lead to functional instability. This has led to the belief that all ACL tears in the active athlete require reconstruction. Some ACL tears in recreational athletes are successfully treated conservatively with activity modification and bracing. A literature search was performed which found three articles on ACL healing. These articles felt that complete ACL tears could heal if patients were properly braced and rehabilitated.

Materials and Methods: At the Carleton University Sports Medicine Clinic we retrospectively reviewed ACL tears diagnosed by the Lachman, pivot shift, and KT-1000 arthrometer testing. We then examined those whose clinical exam became stable by the same three tests. The latest follow up exam was performed by the same examiner (P.P). At the follow up exam, knee function was evaluated with the expanded IKDC form.

Results: Nine patients were found to be asymptomatic and stable after an initial diagnosis of an ACL tear. In follow up the Lachman test had a good endpoint, the pivot shift was normal and the KT – 1000 manual max was less than 3mm. The IKDC results showed 3/9 were grade A, 5/9 were grade B and 1/9 was grade C.

The clinical implication: ACL tears should be treated initially conservatively since in a small percentage of patients, the ACL tear can heal.


P.F. Indelli. M. Dillingham D.J. Schurman

Objective: The treatment of Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) instability resulting from incomplete tears or elongation in continuity has been historically treated either conservatively or by graft replacement. The literature is sparce with regard to alternative reparative surgical treatment of this condition. We report our early experience using a thermal shrinkage treatment on 11 consecutive knees suffering from this condition in patients experiencing continuing instability.

Methods: Eleven patients underwent ACL electrothermal monopolar treatment at our institution between 1998 and 1999. All of these patients presented a difference of 6 mm or more when comparing the involved to the uninvolved side using KT-1000 evaluation. They showed ACL incomplete tears or elongation in continuity at the time of the arthroscopic evaluation. A single electrothermal device (Oratec, Oratec Interventions, Menlo Park, CA) was used in all of the cases. Rehabilitation protocol included immobilization and non-weight-bearing for 6 weeks. A one-year minimum follow-up study was conducted in all of the patients following the IKDC rating system.

Results: The overall outcome at a one-year minimum F.U. was normal or nearly normal in all of the patients. They also showed a 30 pound side to side difference less than 5 mm. They were allowed to return to running 3 months after ACL shrinkage and to full unrestricted sports after 6 months.

Conclusions: The thermal repair of ACL-insufficient knees represents an emerging alternative treatment to standard techniques. The primary controindication for this technique is discontinuity of the ligament. Particular attention must be paid to patient compliance during ligament healing in its early stages.


Y. Matsuda Y. Ishii

Yachting is dangerous sport due to weather conditions. But, before this study, no data was available in the medical literature on yachting injuries. We undertook this study to analyze the yachting injury mechanism and to make inquires about this prevention. The players were asked about the details of yachting injuries they had experienced, in a questionnaire. 114 players (40.6%) out of 281 responded to the questionnaire. 35 players had experienced at least one injury (30.7%). Injury incidence of 470 class (66.7%) was significantly higher of other class; snipe38%, sea hopper 23%, FJ 22% (P< 0.05). Heads and faces were involved in 30.8% of the injuries, and upper and lower extremities in 26.8%. 44% of injury mechanism is attributed to free running injuries, which occurred during a Gybing or wild Gybing predominantly. The boom was part of the yacht which most commonly caused injury, followed by the sheet, side stay, spinnaker pole. We concluded that advancement of performance level, protection equipment, and proper judgement about weather conditions were necessary to prevent these yachting injuries.


H. Morris

Current issues being debated in ACL reconstruction include injury prevention, graft choice, graft positioning, graft fixation, graft remodelling and rehabilitation. Tissue engineering, the alteration of biological mechanisms by application of novel proteins, enzymes and hormones, is rapidly changing the way we approach all aspects of surgery. Tissue engineering techniques in ACL/PCL reconstruction focus on new biosynthetic ACL material, fixation of soft tissue grafts to bony tunnels and graft remodelling

OP-1 is recombinant human Osteogenic Protein 1 (BMP-7). It is a member of the Transforming Growth Factor β (TGFβ) super family. OP-1 promotes the recruitment, attachment, proliferation and differentiation of pluripotential mesenchymal stem cells. It promotes both osteogenesis and chondrogenesis. The carrier is highly purified bovine bone type 1 collagen, which provides an osteoconductive matrix.

We have completed a study assessing the use of OP-1 as a means of enhancing early biological fixation of soft tissue grafts within bone tunnels in a sheep ACL model.

We have commenced a clinical trial using OP-1 in adult ACL reconstruction, believing that OP-1 will enhance early biological graft fixation, and hence, improve clinical results, speed up rehabilitation and prevent tunnel widening.

Other studies have shown the beneficial effects of BMP-2 on an extraarticular bone tendon fixation model, the use of TGF-B to enhance graft remodelling and the application of gene therapy to deliver BMP’s for enhanced graft fixation.

Several projects are underway looking at creating biosynthetic ACL grafts using tissue engineering techniques. As opposed to purely synthhetic grafts, bioACL grafts are made of a collagen scaffold, allowing for remodelling and revascularisation.

ACL reconstructive surgery is constantly evolving. Tissue engineering may provide us with a means of minimising morbidity, accelerating rehabilitation and improving the clinical outcome following this common surgery.


A.J. Andrade D. Stock J.J. Costi R. Stanley N. Kelly T.C. Hearn R.D. Oakeshott A.J. Spriggins

Aim: To determine the intra operative biomechanical properties of a semitendinosus graft used in ACL reconstruction.

Introduction: ACL reconstruction has become a commonly performed operation with 1,139 of these procedures being performed in South Australia in 1997 (SA Health Commission)

The majority of the scientific literature is based on data obtained from elderly cadaveric material. Little is known about the biomechanical properties of the soft tissue grafts currently used prior to implantation. The correct preconditioning and intraoperative tensioning of the soft tissue grafts has also not been investigated.

The initial graft biomechanical properties are important. Inadequate tension will lead to continuing instability whilst excessive tension may cause accelerated joint arthrosis. The tension in the graft may decrease by 30% if it has not been cyclically pretensioned.

Methods: A machine has been designed that will allow the intraoperative biomechanical testing of soft tissue grafts immediately prior to their implantation into the patient during ACL reconstruction. Data will be available on creep, stress relaxation, and tensile testing.

This device will also allow the accurate preconditioning of the graft, providing objective data that can then be compared to the subsequent clinical progress of the patient.

All testing will be accomplished during the time it takes to prepare the tunnels for insertion of the graft, and as such will not prolong unnecessarily the operative time.

Procedure: Once the graft has been prepared prior to fixation, it will be placed between two clamps. One is fixed to a load cell whilst the other is coupled to a linear actuator. The linear actuator will be driven by a computer controlled stepper motor under close-loop control. Custom software will cyclically load the autograft between two definable load points. A linear variable differential transformer (LVDT) will be used to monitor displacement of the autograft and load will be monitored with a load cell of capacity 125Kg.

This set-up will be immersed in a saline water bath maintained at body temperature during testing. The load cell will be hermetically sealed, with clamps and water bath being autoclavable. With the facilities for draping, the test area will remain sterile. The auto graft clamps will be designed to allow fixation of various graft materials (eg semitendinosus, gracilis, bone-patella tendon-bone) and adjustable for graft lengths. The water bath will house a thermocouple, heating mat and controller to maintain the saline temperature to within 1°C.

The testing system will be mounted on a stainless steel trolley for mobility in the operating room with an underlying shelf to house the associated electronics and a retractable side draw for storage of the laptop computer.

The autograft will be preconditioned between two known loads for 20 cycles recording load and displacement simultaneously on a laptop computer. Once preconditioned, the autograft will then be used for the ACL reconstruction in the standard way.

Summary: Objective data on preconditioning of ACL grafts, has never before been available intra-operatively. We outline the experimental set-up which has been designed and is undergoing testing prior to its use in a prospective study.


O.K. Muratoglu

Increasing crosslinking has been shown in vitro and in vivo to markedly improve the wear resistance of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE). However, the reduction in the mechanical properties of polyethylene under certain methods used to produce crosslinking has been a concern. These reductions are known to result from the processes used to increase the crosslink density and could affect the device performance in vivo. We present a novel method of increasing the crosslink density of UHMWPE in which UHMWPE is irradiated in air at an elevated temperature with a high dose rate electron beam and is subsequently melt-annealed. This treatment markedly improves the wear resistance of the polymer as tested in a hip simulator while maintaining the mechanical properties of the material within national and international standards. This method also leads to the absence of detectable free radicals in the polymer and, as a result, excellent resistance to oxidation of the polymer.


R. Norton

The Pulmonary Embolism Prevention (PEP) Trial was designed to assess the effects of a 35 day course of aspirin (160 mg daily) on the risks of thromboembolic events, other cardiovascular outcomes and bleeding among individuals undergoing surgery for hip fracture or joint replacement. From 1992 to 1998, 148 hospitals in Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Sweden and the United Kingdom randomised 13,356 hip fracture patients, and 22 hospitals in New Zealand randomised 4,088 elective arthroplasty patients. Among hip fracture patients, aspirin produced proportional reductions in PE of 43% (95% confidence interval [CI] 18% to 60%; 2P=0.002) and symptomatic DVT of 29% (95% CI 3% to 48%; 2P=0.03). PE or DVT was confirmed in 105 (1.6%) of 6679 patients allocated aspirin versus 165 (2.5%) of 6677 allocated placebo, representing an absolute reduction of 9±2 per 1000 and a proportional reduction of 36% (95% CI 19% to 50%; 2P=0.0003). Aspirin prevented 4±1 fatal pulmonary emboli per 1000 treated (18 aspirin vs 43 placebo deaths), representing a proportional reduction of 58% (95% CI 27% to 76%; 2P=0.002), with no apparent effect on deaths from other vascular (hazard ratio 1.04; 95% CI 0.86 to 1.26) or non-vascular cause (1.01; 95% CI 0.84 to 1.23). Deaths due to bleeding were rare (13 aspirin vs 15 placebo), but there was an excess of 6±3 post-operative transfused bleeds per 1000 allocated aspirin (2P=0.04). Among elective arthroplasty patients, venous thromboembolism rates were lower but the proportional effects of aspirin appeared similar to those among hip fracture patients.


Full Access
M. Ries

UHMWPE implants are made from small powders which are formed by one of three methods. The powders are either compression molded into sheets and then implants machined from the compression molded material, ram extruded into rods and then machined into implants, or molded directly into the final shape. With each method the powders are exposed to variable temperatures and pressures to consolidate the material. It may not be possible to directly mold some implants such as those with complex geometries or modular locking mechanisms.

Clinical and implant retrieval studies of UHMWPE sterilized by gamma irradiation in air have demonstrated that wear behavior may be influenced by resin type and manufacturing method or both. Directly molded Hi-fax 1900 total knee tibial components were found to have more surface wear (scratching and embedded metallic debris) and less fatigue wear (delamination) than similar components which were machined from ram extruded GUR 415 resin (1). The molded Hi-fax 1900 components also demonstrated less oxidation than the machined GUR 415 components. Both groups of implants were sterilized by gamma irradiation in air suggesting that the resin type and manufacturing method or both may influence resistance to oxidative degradation and associated wear behavior. However, most currently available UHMWPE implants have not been sterilized by gamma irradiation in air and it is not clear if wear behavior of these implants will be affected by resin type or manufacturing method.

During the past five years, much research has focused on the effects of sterilization on UHMWPE wear and mechanical properties. Gamma irradiation sterilization of UHMWPE causes polymer chain scission and oxidation which adversely affects both wear and mechanical properties. However, gamma irradiation can also produce cross linking of the polymer chains which improves wear resistance. Enhanced polyethylenes or highly cross linked polyethylenes have been developed to further improve the wear resistance of the material. Highly cross linked polyethylenes demonstrate markedly improved wear behavior in hip simulator studies, but they also have a decrease in mechanical properties (yield strength, ultimate tensile strength, and fatigue strength). In a highly conforming joint such as the hip where contact stresses are relatively low due to the large surface area of contact, surface wear mechanisms (abrasion and adhesion) predominate while in a less conforming joint such as a fixed bearing knee replacement, where contact stresses are high, fatigue wear mechanisms occur more typically (delamination and pitting). Modifications to improve the wear resistance of UHMWPE such as the highly cross linked materials may therefore be more appropriate for hip replacements than for fixed bearing knee replacements.

Previous efforts to improve the wear behavior of polyethylene such as the addition of carbon fibers (carbon reinforced polyethylene), hot isostatic pressing (Hylamer), and heat pressing have not demonstrated improvements in-vivo. While current joint simulator studies may accurately predict in-vivo wear behavior, clinical studies will ultimately be necessary to determine if highly cross linked polyethylenes enhance the longevity of total joint arthroplasty.


M. Ries

Metal-metal total hip replacements were commonly used in the 1960’s and early 1970’s. Failures usually occurred as a result of aseptic loosening although many of these implants provided long term function similar to metal-UHMWPE bearings.

Metal-metal bearings used in total hip arthroplasty are made of cobalt chrome. The volume of wear generated from a metal-metal bearing is considerably less than that from a metal-UHMWPE bearing. Factors which may affect the metal-metal wear rates include the clearance (difference in radius between the femoral head and acetabular bearing surface), surface roughness, and carbon content of the cobalt chrome alloy. A small clearance provides more contact area between the two surfaces which decreases contact stress while a large clearance permits more fluid flow into the joint. If the clearance is too small, and exceeds manufacturing tolerances, the joint articulation may become excessively tight and equatorial rather than polar contact occurs between the bearing surfaces which can increase frictional torque and cause loosening. This has been implicated as a cause of failure of the McKee-Fararr metal-metal hip replacements. Wear is also increased with increased surface roughness but the effect of other material variables such as cast vs. forged and carbon content are less clear.

Early clinical results with modern metal-metal hip replacements demonstrate clinical results which are comparable to metal-UHMWPE bearings and less aseptic loosening than metal-metal designs used in the 1960’s and 1970’s. However, concerns with metal-metal hip replacements include the generation of metal particulate debris which may travel to the distal sites as well as local osteolysis.

In patients with metal-polyethylene total joint replacements, metal as well as polyethylene particles can be found at distant sites. Urban et al. (1) reported that in a study of postmortem specimens from patients with metal-polyethylene total joint replacements, metallic wear particles were identified in the para-aortic lymph nodes in 68 percent and in the liver or spleen in 38 percent of the patients. The serum and urine levels of cobalt and chromium are elevated in patients with metal-metal articulations. Metals can travel to distant sites in ionic form and little is known about the long term clinical effects of elevated serum and urine metal levels. Cancer risk has not been shown to be increased in patients who have received metal-metal hip replacements. However, long term studies with large numbers of patients are needed to accurately asses this risk.


M.S. Kuster

The main problem of modern total hip replacement is the reduction of wear debris. Hence, new tribological partners such as ceramic on ceramic, metal on highly crosslinked polyethylene and metal on metal have evolved. Of these new combinations metal on metal has the longest history. The early problems of high friction using a “micro-fit” between acetabulum and femoral head have been solved by introducing an optimal clearance between the head and the cup to allow for small deformations of the acetabulum during activities without locking. The annual wear rate of metal on metal combinations has been shown to be extremely low ranging from 2 to 5 micrometers/year only. A further advantage of Metasul may be the “wearing in of small scratches” as well as forgiving slight malpositions of the acetabulum, which is not the case in ceramic – ceramic combinations. However, Metasul should not be implanted in patients with renal failure or severe allergies. Metal-metail pairing has proven a valuable alternative in young and active patients over the last 10 years.


J. Fisher

Traditional hip prostheses, which involve metal on poly-ethylene articulations, have shown good survivorship at ten years, but in the long term, wear debris induced osteolysis has been found to cause loosening and failure. Specifically, micron and submicron size polyethylene wear particles generated at the articulating surfaces enter the periprosthetic tissues, activate the macrophages causing adverse cellular reactions and bone resorption. Recent laboratory, retrieval and clinical studies have shown that oxidation of the traditional polyethylene irradiated in air, causes wear to increase by a factor of three following either storage on the shelf for five years or following implantation in vivo for 15 years. Furthermore, damage or scratching of metallic femoral heads has been shown to increase wear by a factor of two. In vitro cell culture studies with real polyethylene wear particles, have shown that the intensity of the adverse cellular reactions is critically dependent on the size of the polyethylene wear particle with the smallest particles 0.1 to 1 mm being the most active. A novel model has been developed to predict functional biological activity and osteolytic potential, by integrating wear rates, particle analysis and cell culture studies.

Stabilised and crosslinked polyethylenes have been investigated and been found to reduce wear rates by a factor of three compared to oxidised and aged materials. A moderate level of crosslinking reduced wear from 50 to 35 mm3 per million cycles compared to non crosslinked materials. However, against scratched femoral heads, the wear rate of both stabilised and cross-linked polyethylene was elevated to levels where the functional biological activity remains a concern in the long term. Alternative bearing surfaces, metal on metal, and alumina ceramic on ceramic provide potential to substantially reduce wear. Metal on metal bearings have shown mean wear rates of 1.5 mm3/year in the hip joint simulator, with very small, 30 nm size particles. Alumina ceramic ceramic have also shown very low wear rates of approximately 1 mm3/year, even in the presence of microseparation and rim contact, with small 10 nm size wear particles and larger particles up to 1 mm in size caused by grain boundary fracture. The functional biological activity and osteolytic potential of the alumina ceramic couple is predicted to be at least ten times lower than crosslinked polyethylene.

New ceramic materials (zirconia toughened alumina) have been shown to further reduce ceramic ceramic wear. Furthermore, novel differential hardness ceramic on metal bearings have shown even lower wear rates. The currently available hard on hard bearings and the recent further improvements of these bearing couples, indicate that osteolysis free lifetimes well beyond 20 years are now possible.


Full Access
R.M. Streicher

Late aseptic loosening of total hip arthroplasty (THA) components due to wear debris especially sub-micron Polyethylene induced osteolysis has been identified to be the major cause for revision. Therefore, the use of wear resistant designs and materials is imperative for the long-term success of articulating implants. One of the most promising articulations for THA regarding extremely low wear is the hard-on-hard Alumina/Alumina combination with a long history in orthopaedics accumulating to now 30 years of experience.

Alumina Ceramic: Aluminum-Oxide Ceramic (Alumina, Al2O3, ISO 6474) is an extremely hard material that can only be scratched and also machined and polished by diamond. It has excellent mechanical properties but is brittle as are most ceramic materials and can, therefore, not be used for highly stressed implants like an artificial hip joint stem. Due to its ionic structure it is hydrophilic allowing liquids to bound to and lubricate its surface. Alumina’s hardness allows a polishing to a low roughness, which is entirely inverse and therefore able to create lubricating “pools.”

Density, purity and grain size in combination with an optimised manufacturing process are crucial for the final properties of Alumina and have been sub-optimal at the early pioneering times. Also the design has to be adapted to the critical properties of this ceramic.

The biological activity of Alumina is graded as bio-inert and no direct osteointegration is to be expected, also proven by clinical experience. Alpha Alumina is bio-stable and practically insoluble in the body environment. Therefore, ageing or any systemic reaction in the human body with this ceramic is of no concern.

First Generation Alumina Ceramic: Boutin has introduced Alumina ceramic components for articulation with itself for THA in 1970, followed by Mittelmeier and other surgeons. First reports of its combination with UHMWPE cups date back to 1972. More than one million Alumina heads have been worldwide implanted since then. Problems regarding fracture of the head were mostly encountered with collared heads of one design and the cup (especially if placed at > 50 deg abduction position). Run-away wear in case of edge contact have been reported with these first generation implants.

A comprehensive retrieval study using a systematic analysis of two different designs confirmed that Alumina/ Alumina couples have a low clinical wear rate and identified the main risk factors that can lead to early failure of such devices. The wear rate of those historic Alumina / Alumina articulations is in the range of less than 5 microns per year. This is one to two orders of magnitude less than for any articulation with Polyethylene cups. Reaction to Alumina wear particles, mostly encountered on catastrophic failure of the historic implant designs is sparse and mostly benign.

Third Generation Alumina Ceramic: Significant improvements in material properties and quality have been made since its introduction. The third generation of Alumina has been introduced in 1994 and was a further evolution regarding material properties, manufacturing, quality control and design. Refinement of purity, grain size and manufacturing results in improved fracture and also wear resistance, which decreased from low to almost immeasurable values. With the evolution of this new generation ceramic the problems of the past have been successfully addressed. Following improvements are characteristic for a third generation Alumina:

Improved purity and reduced grain size (Figure 1) for better properties

Improved density, HIP for enhanced toughness and bending strength

Less stress raisers due to laser marking instead of mechanical engraving

Optimised head internal geometry

Rounded and polished rim for risk reduction of runaway wear on sub-luxation

Improved safety due to 100% proof test on heads and inserts

These improvements result in a significant increase in mechanical properties. The risk of head fracture has been reduced for this 3rd generation Alumina ceramic heads from 1 per 500 (0.2%) to 1 per 25 000 (0.025%).

The wear resistance of the couple Alumina/Alumina has also been enhanced which was measured in simulator tests to be around 1 micron per year. Tribological investigation involved a series of screening, pendulum and anatomical hip simulator tests with actual Alumina/ Alumina components in respect to the effect of clearance and cup angle (45° & 60°) in a series of tests for up to 5 million cycles. Adverse testing conditions for Alumina e.g. dilution of lubricant, dry and water, high load in swing phase, stop-start, etc in ascending aggressiveness (each at 1 million cycles) have also been investigated. No significant difference in wear volume was found comparing clearance or cup angle for all components tested. A new simulator test set up using a microseparation mode during every single cycle was also run for 5 million cycles combining Alumina from one single manufacturer and also mixing Alumina’s from different manufacturers. The wear in all cases was low and lower than for the first generation Alumina’s.

A series of implantations with Alumina/Alumina articulation has been performed since November 1996 according to a prospective multicentric FDA IDE protocol comparing the same implant with CoCr metal heads/PE combinations. Short-term results demonstrate no early complications with this third generation Alumina/Alumina articulation if implanted correctly. The benefit of the dramatically reduced wear rate will show only after longer-term follow-up.

Conclusion: Alumina/Alumina articulation demonstrates the lowest wear rate of all available material combinations for THA in the laboratory as well as in clinical praxis. The bulk material as well as its particles is bio-inert, therefore, giving no concern for adverse biological reactions.

Problems with earlier designs of Alumina/Alumina articulation have been successfully addressed by taking the identified risk parameters into consideration. Components of the third generation Alumina ceramic and design have been extensively tested. All components pass the mechanical tests. Alumina heads and liners of the third generation in the size and under the conditions tested are safe and efficient. Their wear rate even under the influence of adverse condition is minimal.

Further clinical trials parallel the application of this superior articulation couple in an innovative and modern design.Alumina/Alumina is, therefore, the material combination of choice for the active patient with high life expectancy.


P.H. Hsieh C.H. Shih W.E. Yang Z.L. Le

Two-stage reconstructive technique has been proved to be a safe and effective method in the treatment of deep infection of hip joint implants. Between stages, however, the patients may be uncomfortable with limited mobility and activity because the joint function is severely restricted by the removal of the infected prosthesis and a thorough debridement. Furthermore, the delayed reimplantation procedure after a Girdlestone-like surgery is often complicated by shortening, bone loss, and dislocation due to scar formation, disuse osteoporosis, and distorted tissue planes.

We reported the technical details of a new method to make a cement-on-cement prosthesis as a temporary spacer for the period between resection and reimplantion. The doughy cement, mixed with antibiotics, was introduced into a metal mold made with the shape of a unipolar prosthesis to form the femoral component. Several large K-wires were placed in the mold in advance to act as strut support in order to prevent late fracture of the cement prosthesis. The remained cement was put into the acetabular cavity and molded into a hemispherical shape with a retrieved unipolar prosthesis of identical femoral head size. After consolidation of the cement, the femoral component was taken out from the metal mold and implanted into the femoral canal with fixation by antibiotic-loaded cement on the proximal portion.

Between the year 1999 and 2000, we have treated 42 infected hip implants by this technique with few complications. This new molding method has been a routine procedure in our practice. We believe it to be a simple, safe, and inexpensive way to eradicate local infection and provide comfort and mobility for the patient and an easier reimplantation procedure for the surgeon.


R. Mohan M. Gross

Introduction: The main object of acetabular revisions in the presence of bone loss is to restore bone stock to provide adequate support for the cup. Allograft bone has been used to reconstruct the acetabulum with variable results.

Purpose of the study: Prospective assessment of the performance of the uncemented cups with morsellized allograft bone in revision acetabular reconstruction.

Patients and methods: A single surgeon using the lateral approach performed 98 acetabular revisions. An uncemented cup with multiple screw holes and morsellized allograft bone was used in all the patients. Acetabular defects were classified using both AAOS and Paprosky classification systems on standard AP x-rays and clinical assessment was by Harris hip scores.

Results: 93 patients had complete clinical and radiological follow-up. Mean age was 65.3 years (24–87) and majority was female. Mean number of prior operations was 1.7 (1–5). Majority of the acetabular defects belonged to group III (AAOS). The mean follow-up was 98 months (36–145). 13 patients have undergone repeat revisions, 5 for aseptic loosening and 3 each for infection, recurrent dislocation and early technical failures. Bone incorporation was complete within 3 months in all the cases

Discussion: The use of uncemented cups with screws provides the primary stability that is supplemented later by the incorporated allograft bone. The rate of re-operations for aseptic loosening of the cup in our series is low at 6% after 8 years. Even in these cases the repeat revisions were significantly easier due to restoration of the bone stock.


R. Mohan M. Gross

Introduction: The Gemini stem (DePuy) is a titanium femoral stem with a modular cobalt chrome femoral head. It has a roughened proximal surface finish to enhance cement bonding and a distal centraliser.

Purpose of the study: A retrospective assessment of the performance of the titanium cemented Gemini femoral component

Patients and Methods: 196 patients underwent a 204 total hip replacements using a titanium cemented Gemini stem and an uncemented cup. All the operations were performed by a lateral approach using modern cementing technique. Patients were assessed clinically (Harris hip score) and radiologically (standard AP and lateral x-rays)

Results: 11 patients with incomplete clinical and radiological follow-up were excluded from the study, leaving 185 patients (193 hips). 36 patients died with their total hip prosthesis in situ. The average age was 71 years and primary diagnosis was OA in the majority. The average follow-up was 70 months (range 35– 121). 29 of the hips have been revised. A further 11 were recognized as radiological failures. In 24, aseptic loosening or a broken stem was an indication for the revision. Mean time to revision was 3.1 years (range 1.5 to 7).

Discussion: Our results indicate that there is a high incidence of early failure associated with these titanium cemented stems, a cumulative failure of approximately 20%. The rough surface finish, titanium alloy and a fixed distal centraliser may all contribute to the early failure by increasing the stresses in the cement. Based on our experience, the continued use of this cemented stem is no longer justified.


R.J. Beaver E. Swarts

The concept of two-stage revision of infected total hip arthroplasties is well established in the literature. What has been lacking has been a user friendly, simple, safe, cost-effective interim prosthesis which can achieve hip stability, maintain ambulatory status and still deliver antibiotics at high local concentrations. Other commercially available products are expensive, difficult to implant and prone to dislocation. We have developed a modular, antibiotic-laden spacer hemiarthroplasty of the hip which has been fully bench tested. The prosthesis consists of a head/neck module utilising antibiotic impregnated bone cement (PMMA) as the bearing surface and a stainless steel neck. This can be assembled onto a polyacetal (Delrin) stem of varying lengths and diameters. Bone defects are accommodated with hand moulded PMMA at the time of implantation.

We have inserted 47 of these implants in the period 9/97 to 5/2000. 28 of these have been retrieved and submitted for biomechanical analysis at the Royal Perth Hospital Implant Retrieval Laboratory.

This paper presents the concept of the implant, the clinical results, the results of retrieval analysis and elutional studies on antibiotic release from the implant.

We have analysed the retrieved implants and there have been no implant failures. Two implants have been fractured during extraction and one has dislocated secondary to subsidence. Wear analysis has shown polishing of the PMMA in the weightbearing area of the head.

Elution studies are ongoing but suggest that antibiotic release is continuing for up to 8 weeks post implantation providing ambulation is encouraged. Clinical results indicate success rates comparable to other published reports of infected total hip arthroplasties.

This implant in the hands of a variety of orthopaedic surgeons has proven itself simple to use and to maintain ambulatory status to patients whilst maximising antibiotic delivery to the infected hip.


W. Walter B. Zicat

Purpose: We have been using the ABG cementless femoral stem since 1992 for the majority of our primary hip arthroplasty cases. This paper presents a review of our experience and results with the first 1000 ABG stems.

Method: A consecutive series of primary hip arthroplasty cases was followed prospectively beginning in 1992, with a total of 1000 cases performed before October 1996. A variety of degenerative conditions were included, and all cases were assessed using standard clinical and radiographic scoring systems, and recorded on an arthroplasty database.

Results: There were 1000 arthroplasties performed in 905 patients. Mean age at surgery was 64 years (22 to 94 years). There was a predominance of females (53%), and of right hips (58%). Mean height was 170 cms, and mean weight was 75 kgs. Diagnoses included primary or secondary osteoarthritis (93%), inflammatory arthropathy (5%), and fracture neck of femur (2%). Posterior approach was used in all but one case. A femoral fracture or stress riser was incurred in 3 cases (0.3%). A variety of acetabular components were mated with the stem, including ABG (58%), Implex one piece (20%), and ABG II no hole (20%). There were 1 deep infection, occurring acutely. There were 16 (1.6%) femoral periprosthetic fractures occurring between 2 days and 86 months after surgery, most requiring internal fixation or revision. There were 17 dislocations (1.7%) occurring between 2 weeks and 97 months after surgery. Only 1 stem has been revised for aseptic loosening, 3 for dislocation and 8 for periprosthetic fracture. At mean follow up of 60 months (24 to 108 months), average Harris Hip Score was 90/100, with 86% of patients having a good or excellent result. No additional stems were found to be loose on radiographic evaluation.

Conclusion: The design features of this anatomic, hydroxyapatite coated femoral stem provide for excellent initial stability, reliable bone ingrowth, and low intraoperative fracture rate. A small number of periprosthetic fractures occurred, most related to trauma. The proximal geometry of the implant results in low dislocation rates, despite use of the posterior approach.


H. Takeda K. Watarai K. Oguro Y. Samejima T. Saito

The purpose of this study is to describe a surgical procedure for unstable osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) of the capitellum and its results.

Between 1992 and 1997, 11 elbows of 11 patients with OCD of the capitellum were treated in our institution. The average age at surgery was 14.7 years and the ages ranged from 12 to 16 years. All patients were male baseball players affected in the throwing side. The follow-up period was from 31 to 95 months (average: 57 months). All patients underwent internal fixation using the pull out wiring method and bone graft (this procedure was established by Kondo in 1989). All lesions of OCD were not only softening or cracked but also unstable with early separation or partially detached fragment. After surgery, a long arm cast was applied for 3 weeks. After confirming bony union of OCD by X-ray, the wires were removed ranged from 15 to 21 weeks (average 17 weeks) postoperatively. Throwing activity was allowed 6 months after surgery.

At the follow-up, all patients were relieved pain and all except one returned to previous throwing levels. Radiographs showed good healing of OCD and minimum degenerative changes were found in only a few joints.

We concluded that this surgical procedure was an effective treatment for adolescent baseball players with unstable OCD of the capitellum.


A.S. Comley R.N. Atkinson

Repair of large rotator cuff tears can be a demanding technical exercise, particularly when patients are elderly and tissue quality for repair is poor. In 25 patients we have used a method of tying rotator cuff sutures over a screw fixation post at the level of the surgical neck to secure the torn cuff to the greater tuberosity while healing occured. This study reports the results of these patients. 25 patients (27 shoulders) of average age 68.5 years were reviewed at an average of 22 months post surgery (range 3– 52 months). 4 patients (6 shoulders) were workers compensation injuries. The Constant method of shoulder assessment and visual analogue pain scores were used. Constant scores improved from an average of 30.6 pre-operatively to 75.2 post operatively. Pain scores improved from an average of 7.2 pre-operatively to 2.2 post operatively.

Over 80 % of patients reported being very satisfied with the results of their procedure. 2 patients reported being unsatisfied with their procedure. Workers compensation patients had poorer results for pain and function than the group average but still reported good satisfaction with the procedure. 4 complications occurred. 2 patients had re- tears of their cuff after falls. One was repaired with side to side suturing and the other was re-repaired to the post. 1 wound infection occurred requiring arthroscopic shoulder lavage and final removal of the implant.

This shoulder subsequently healed with good function. One patient had significant shoulder pain requiring surgery and removal of the fixation post. There were no other cases of screw irritation and no axillary nerve palsy or deltoid avulsions were found.

Conclusions: This method of fixation is simple, strong, safe and gives results at least equivalent to if not better than other reported methods. The technique is a useful one to have in the surgical repertoire when dealing with large rotator cuff tears in older patients.


T.S. Park

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the role of a biodegradable fixation device (Suretac, Acufex Microsurgical, Inc, Mansfield, Massachusetts) in the treatment of the shoulder instability.

Materials & methods: From January 1995 to December 1996, fifteen patients diagnosed as the shoulder instability were treated arthroscopically by using a biodegradable fixation device. All the patients were found to have Bankart lesions, and had the definite histories of trauma. 6 of fifteen patients had suffered from shoulder pain before the trauma, and all of them showed generalized ligamentous laxity sign and grade 2 or 3 positive sulcus sign in examination under the anesthesia, as well as positive apprehension sign, positive fulcrum and relocation test. So they were diagnosed as concomitant TUBS and AMBRI group shoulder instability. The rest of 9 out of fifteen patients were diagnosed as TUBS group shoulder instability. There were twelve males and three females, and their mean age was twenty five years (range: 16 to 47).

In all the patients, the Bankart lesions were repaired or reconstructed by using at least 2 Suretac devices after extensive, sufficient superior-medial shift of the anterior-inferior glenohumeral capsuloligamentous complexes(GHLC) down to the 6 o¡Çclock positions of the glenoid rim. As for the patients with concomitant TUBS and AMBRI group shoulder instability, we did not only the plication of the anterior capsule for AMBRI component, but also the repair of Bankart lesion for TUBS component. Follow-up time averaged five years and six months (range: 4 years 5 months to 6 years 3 months).

Results: One patient (one shoulder) demonstracted persistent apprehension associated with popping sensation because of injury with fracture of the anterior glenoid rim two year and six months after the operation. A subsequent reconstruction was performed. The recurrence rate was 6.7%. But there were no other complications including any pain, and stiffness.

Conclusion: It is my impression that an arthroscopic Bankart repair or reconstruction by using Suretac devices after extensive, sufficient superior-medial shift of the anterior-inferior GHLC and if needed, plication of the anterior capsule played a role on the treatment of the shoulder instability.


B. Nivbrant

In clinical Orthopaedic research we often need better tools for follow up investigations and evaluation of new methods. One alternative is Radiostereometric analyses (RSA) which can be used for high precision measurements of migration, micro movements and wear. Since developed 25 years ago it has now been used in a few thousand patients and made into a comprehensible computerized, PC based system. Recent development has made it much faster, more accurate and user friendly enough for more common use.

RSA can basically measure 3D movements between rigid bodies as bone or implants and is used for many sorts of applications as bone growth, fracture healing, joint kinematics, bone elasticity, spinal fusion etc where a high accuracy is needed. It has, however, mostly been used for research in hip and knee arthroplasty since early migration has been found a good predictor for later implant failure. As also wear in artificial joints can be accurately measured the technique is definitely a useful tool for implant research.

Method: A minimum of 3 tantalum markers is inserted in bone and preferably also the implant. Two X-rays are taken with a 40° angle between them and with a RSA calibration cage beneath the X-ray table. The films are then digitized and measured with dedicated software, UMRSA ®. The same procedure is repeated at another occasion and the change in positioning calculated.

With modern digital x-ray technique we obtain an in vivo precision of about 50 microns longitudinally, 80 horizontally and 200 sagittaly, for rotations 0.1°–0.3°depending on direction, (95% confidence limit).

Studies: We have done around 30 different hip and knee studies since 1986 in Umea and this actual speech will give an overview of what is achievable in terms of outcome and some clinical implications found. In short and generally spoken we have also in Umea found early RSA measurements to very accurately predict coming clinical loosening or high wear rates in implants.

Some general findings are: In cemented stems the loosening starts at the stem-cement interface and the cement mantles are very well fixed to bone, loosening being a secondary phenomenon.

A low temperature curing, non-vacuum mixed cement had equal fixation to bone and stem as a standard vacuum mixed.

Some stem designs move a lot inside the cement, possibly with a big risk for cement fractures and abrasion. Especially subsidence and retro version seems ominous.

Repeatedly HA coating has shown excellent implant stability, in the same range as cemented components and better than porous coated ones.

We have found good and reproducible stability with impaction grafting in both acetabulum and femur using both cemented and uncemented non tapered implants. Structural grafts seem to imply increased migration.

Wear has been increased with non irradiated plastic components, in younger patients, if cement contains ZrO as opacifier and together with unstable cemented stems. No correlation has been found between wear and HA coating, head or stem material or weight but decreased wear found for high cross-linked plastics.

RSA has been a big asset for Implant research over the years. With the more stable implants and modern bearings of today a high accuracy method is even more needed for to measure fixation and wear, or the actual results will be lost in a lot of noise. The new focus and interest in synergistic effects of implant micro movements, interface stress, hydrostatic pressure and particles for the development of osteolyses is a new area were RSA should be a useful tool to study inducible implant movements and fixation quality in vivo.


Full Access
G. Bain

This will be a review of the various surgical approaches which are available for approaching the elbow and will include details of the global approach which can allow exposure of the medial and or lateral sides of the elbow via a common posterior midline incision.


G. Stubbs C. Gordiev I. Lyle

Distal biceps tendon avulsion requires surgical treatment but is uncommon. The average orthopedic surgeon will come across a case only occasionally. The two-incision technique of Boyd is technically difficult. One-incision methods are easier for the occasional surgeon. Methods using Mitek Bone Anchors and Endobuttons have been described in the literature. This presentation compares those techniques and a technique using anterior cruciate interference screws against the Two Incision Technique in a model consisting of sheep bone and sash cord.

The models were then tested on a dynamometer to failure to assess the ultimate strength of the various methods of fixation. In this model Mitek Anchors and Endobuttons gave comparable fail points to the two Incision Technique. The Interference Screw Technique was stronger.


N. Pourgiezis

The aim of this prospective, randomised study is to compare outcomes within three groups of patients undergoing either open, one-portal or two-portal endoscopic carpal tunnel release. The study population consisted of 90 hands in 59 patients presenting with idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome and symptom duration greater than 6 months, or those patients who had not gained satisfactory symptomatic relief from conservative treatments. Only patients with positive nerve conduction studies were included in the study. All patients were assessed using a standardised protocol which included a questionnaire on activities of daily living and symptoms experienced rated using a visual analogue scale. An examination followed which included; provocative tests; grip, pinch and abduction strengths; light touch; moving two-point discrimination; and vibration testing. Each patient was subsequently randomly allocated to one of the three surgical groups. All patients were assessed postoperatively, using a standa

We found no significant differences between the three surgical groups with regard to postoperative pain, level of satisfaction and objective return of grip and pinch strengths. The ability to perform activities of daily living postoperatively, however, was significantly reduced in the open technique group compared with patients treated with either endoscopic technique. There was also a significant difference in the time taken to return to work in the open group compared with both the endoscopic groups.

No neurovascular complications occurred in our series. The only complications that occurred were in the open group and included; prolonged scar tenderness, severe post-operative bruising of the forearm, and infection.


P. Stavrou J. Slavotinek J. Krishnan

The concept of bipolar hemiarthroplasty has been described in the hip for over twenty years, its role being to decrease acetabular wear. Shoulder bipolar hemiarthroplasty is a more recent concept. The purpose of this study was to determine if the prostheses acted as a bipolar device, moving primarily at the inner metal on polyethylene bearing as intended or as a unipolar hemiarthroplasty moving at the outer metal on cartilage surface.

Eleven bipolar shoulder hemiarthroplasties with a minimum follow up of twenty two months were examined fluoroscopically. The proportion of arm abduction occurring in the scapulothoracic plane as well as that between the two components of the bipolar hemiarthroplasty was assessed and compared to that of normal patients and those with total shoulder replacements, previously reported in the literature.

The results of this study show that the majority of movement occurring in active arm abduction occurred in the scapulothoracic plane and that the bipolar hemiarthroplasty acted predominantly as a unipolar device.


T. Negishi S. Ozeki H. Yao Y. Nohara

Introduction: Functional knee braces are commonly used after ACL reconstruction surgery. However, the study to evaluate the contributions of the knee brace is a few. We investigated the effects of knee brace prospectively.

Methods: From 1993 to 1996, forty eight patients with 48 knees were treated with autogenous ACL reconstruction. The patients were randomly divided to two groups; twenty five patients (group B) used knee brace for one year and the other 23 patients (group NB) were free from bracing. Forty two patients were followed over two years. The averaged follow-up period was 27 mouths and the averaged age at surgery was 24.5 years. The semitendinosus and the gracilis tendon in the contralateral side were used to make triple looped (six strands) substitute. Bone tunnels were made at the appropriate site using inside-out technique under arthroscopy assistance. Polyester meshes were connected to the substitute and fixed to the tibia and femur with staples after grafting through the bone tunnels. The same rehabilitation protocol was used for both patients group. Functional outcomes were evaluated with IKDC score.

Results: The rate of category A, B ,C and D in the group B were 52%, 44%, 4% and 0%. Those in the group NB were 65%, 26%, 9% and 0% respectively. There is not any Statistically significant difference between the two groups.

The joint stability were measured with stress x-p using TELOS device. The anterior displacement ratio improved from 73±4.9%(mean ±sd) to 64±4.6% in group B, and it also improved from 72±4.0% to 62±2.9% in group NB. Statistically significant improvements were obtained after surgery in both the two groups, however, no statistically significant difference of stability were found between the two groups.

Conclusion: These results suggest that the functional knee brace is not indispensable when the hamstring substitute is used for ACL reconstruction with secure fixation methods.


S. Sakata M. Takahashi K. Kushida M. Oikawa A. Nagano

Introduction: Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) occurs as one of clinical features of Dialysis Related Amyloidosis (DRA). Recently, it has been suggested that advanced glycation endproducts (AGEs) and bate 2 microglobulin (b2m) modified with AGEs are related to DRA. In our previous cross-sectional study, the fact that serum pentosidine, which is an AGE, was higher in DRA than in non-DRA indicates that it has potential as an indicator for the occurrence of DRA in HD patients.

Aim: In this prospective study we examined to elucidate whether serum levels of pentosidine relate to the occurrence of CTS in patients with HD in 4 years longitudinal follow up.

Material and Methods: The subjects are 106 end-stage renal failure patients undergoing HD, who had never operated for CTS. Serum pentosidine was measured by the HPLC method with column switching. b2m and intact PTH were also measured. During follow up period we operated 15 patients for CTS.

Results: Pentosidine levels were significantly elevated in the operated group than the non-operated group, whereas there were not significant differences in b2m and intact-PTH.

Conclusion: These results indicate that serum pentosidine has the potential as an indicator for the occurrence of CTS in long-term hemodialysis patients.


J. Bartlett

31 consecutive patients (mean 54.7 years) were examined mean follow-up time of 47 months. Patients were evaluated clinically; using Lysholm, Cincinnati, IKDC and Tegner Activities Scores. Objective assessments were made with KT1000 Arthrometer and Isokinetic strength testing.

Lysholm scores improved from 62 preoperatively to 93 at review; Cincinnati 48 to 89; Tegner 3.6 to 5.2. 81 percent of knees were considered normal or nearly normal to IKDC, 6 abnormal, none severely abnormal. KT1000 manual max difference 2.9mm; Isokinetic flexion strength 102 percent; extension strength 95 percent. Poor results were mainly associated with advanced articular cartilage degenerative changes at time of surgery. This also correlated with increased time from injury to surgery, and increased preoperative injury rates.

This study demonstrates that the anterior cruciate ligament can be reliably reconstructed in patients over the age of 50 years with good symptomatic relief, restoration of function and return to activity.


P.F. Indelli M. Dillingham

Objective: Bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and Achilles tendon allografts have been widely used in primary and revision ACL reconstructions showing good results comparable to those with autografts. The literature is sparce with regard to treatment and results of primary ACL reconstruction using Achilles tendon alone. The objective of this study was to present the clinical outcome of 50 consecutive primary ACL reconstructions with Achilles allograft utilizing interference screws fixation. Particular attention was dedicated to the incidence of tunnel widening and graft rejection phenomenon.

Methods: Fifty consecutive patients had primary ACL reconstruction using fresh frozen Achilles tendon allografts from 1997 to 1998 at our institution. All grafts were sterilely harvested and none of them were subjected to secondary sterilization. All procedures were performed using interference screws fixation. A two-year minimum follow-up study was conducted in all of the patients: clinical and functional evaluation was performed according to the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) by an independent examiner. All patients were evaluated using the KT-1000 arthrometer at 30 pounds of force: data was reported as an injured-to-uninjured difference. Lateral and 45° posteroanterior weightbearing radiographs were performed in each patient. The sclerotic margins of the tibial tunnel were measured at the widest dimension by a single observer and were compared with the initially drilled tunnel size.

Results: According to the IKDC rating system, the overall outcome was normal or nearly normal in 96% of the patients. Forty-eight patients had a 30 pound side to side difference £ 5 mm. None of the patients had greater than a 10 mm difference. There was no evidence of graft rejection from an immune response or disease transmission. On the femoral side, all bone plugs appeared to be incorporated radiographically. The average allograft tibial tunnel enlargement at the widest level was 1.9 mm (0 to 5 mm) in the posteroanterior view and 1.7 mm (−0.2 to 5 mm) in the lateral view.

Conclusion: Our results suggest that fresh frozen Achilles tendon allografts represent a good alternative in primary ACL reconstructions. No significant difference was seen in KT-1000 arthrometer measurements and clinical outcomes between patients with different tibial tunnel widening. We believe that fixation with interference screws could reduce the incidence of this undesirable phenomenon.


Y.B. Jung S.K. Tae D.L. Yang J.S. Lee

Purpose: To introduce modified tibial inlay technique for autogenous bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) reconstruction and evaluate the outcomes of PCL reconstruction by this method.

Methods: Fifty patients who underwent autogenous BPTB PCL reconstruction using modified tibial inlay technique were evaluated at average 30.9 months (range 12–52).

The outcomes were assessed by stress radiographs, maximal manual test with KT-2000 arthrometer, IKDC grading and OAK knee score.

Results: Average side to side difference in push view with Telos stress device decreased from 11.7mm to 3.2mm. Difference in maximal manual test with KT-2000 arthrometer also decreased from 11.5mm to 3.1mm. Final IKDC grading was A in six patients, B in thirty four, C in nine and D in one.

Average OAK score improved from 64.3 to 86.4

Conclusion: We consider that the modified tibial inlay technique is a method to reduce technical effort and contribute to satisfactory clinical results in autogenous BPTB PCL reconstruction.


W.M. Tang T.P. Ng K.Y. Chiu W.H. Szeto P. Ching

From 1992 to 1999, 713 total joint arthroplasties were performed in The Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The University of Hong Kong. Since January 1993, a uniform prophylactic antibiotic regime was employed: one dose of first generation cephalosporin (one gram cephazonlin) on induction and every 4-hourly. In case of sequential bilateral total knee arthroplasty, one gram of cephazolin will be given on induction for the first knee and one hour before the operation on the opposite knee. Antibiotic will be discontinued post-operatively. No significant difference was identified between the infection rate before (1.4%) and after (1.2%) the adoption of the prophylactic antibiotic guidelines (p > 0.4). The study had shown that one dose of first generation cephalosporin is as effective as multiple dose of prophylactic antibiotic, either first or second generation cephalosporin, in preventing infection in total joint arthroplasty.


L. Osti J. Bartlett

The isolated arthroscopic lateral release has been already presented in the literature as an effective alternative for surgical treatment of different degrees of patellofemoral instability. This paper is to evaluate the long term results of this procedure in patients with recurrent dislocation of the patella (RDP).

Material of this study is a group of patients who underwent isolated arthroscopic lateral release for RDP with a minimum 10 years follow-up. All the patients included presented 1) clear clinical history of RDP 2) positive apprehension test 3) patella able to be dislocated under anesthesia. Were excluded from this study patients who presented 1) generalised ligamentous laxity 2) habitual dislocations of the patella 3) avulsion fracture of the patella 4) marked malalignment 5) age over 40 years. 42 patients met these criteria and 27 (28 knees) were available for follow-up. There were 13 females and 14 males with an average age of 20, 1 years and an average follow-up of 13, 4 years.

All the patients were evaluated for patellar stability and functional outcomes with both Miller and Bartlett and Crosby and Insall scores. According to the evaluation scores above mentioned 16 knees (57%) were rated as excellent /good results.

The isolated lateral release can be considered as the first approach for the treatment of RDP. The outcomes are adversely affected by long term-follow-up, however, it does not compromise any further treatment.


R. Norton

A recent systematic overview of 213 studies of more than 50,000 patients showed that ectopic bone formation (EBF) is present on the radiographs of about 40% of all patients who have undergone elective hip arthroplasty and in at least half of these, EBF is rated moderate to severe and is associated with an increased risk of an impaired functional outcome. A recent meta-analysis of more than a dozen trials of NSAIDs in patients at risk of EBF has demonstrated that perioperative treatment reduces the risk of EBF by about 50%. However, prophylaxis is rarely given in clinical practice due to concerns about perioperative bleeding, gastrointestinal events and implant loosening, combined with a lack of data on the clinical importance of EBF. The HIPAID study involves the conduct of a randomized double blind clinical trial, designed to assess the effects of a 15 day peri-operative course of ibuprofen (1200mg daily) on the clinical consequences of EBF in individuals undergoing total hip replacement surgery. The trial will be conducted in 20 orthopaedic centers throughout Australia and New Zealand, and will involve 1,000 patients aged 60 to 80 years, scheduled for elective total hip replacement surgery. The primary study outcomes are self-reported pain and physical function, assessed by the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC), six months after surgery. Secondary outcomes include EBF, health-related quality of life (SF-36v2), patient’s global assessment, hip flexion and the 50ft walk time. Peri- and early postoperative events will be assessed including bleeding and gastro-intestinal complaints.


S. Graves P. Ryan D. Davidson L. Ingerson B. McDermott N. Pratt E. Griffith

With increasing primary joint replacement procedures and an ageing population surviving longer, the rate of revision surgery will increase. Revision surgery, however, is associated with increased morbidity and mortality and has a far less successful outcome than primary joint replacement. The mid- to long-term survival rate of the large variety of replacement prostheses remains unknown. Inadequate outcomes data for the majority of prostheses, as well as variability related to different surgical techniques and diagnostic groups, have made it difficult for surgeons to identify the relative effectiveness of different prostheses and treatments. The Federal Government provided funding to the Australian Orthopaedic Association (AOA) to establish the National Joint Replacement Registry (NJRR) in March 1998. The AOA has appointed a committee to manage the Registry and has contracted with the Data Management and Analysis Centre at the University of Adelaide to establish and manage the data systems for the Registry.

The primary aim of the AOA NJRR is to evaluate the effectiveness of different types of joint replacement prostheses and surgical techniques at a national level.

Implementation methods, aspects of database design and early progress in data collection are presented.


Y.B. Jung S.K. Tae D.L. Yang J.N. Han

Purpose: The aim of this study was to elucidate the continiuty of ligament in chronic injury of the posterior cruciate ligament(PCL).

Method: Magnetic resonance imaging(MRI) of twenty-six PCL injury patients with grade II or III laxity and more than 5mm side to side difference on stress radiographs were reviewed in terms of ligamentous continuity and thickness of the ligament at average 7.2 months(range:1–36) after injury. The results were compared with arthroscopic findings in fifteen patients.

Results: Eighteen PCLs(69%) showed continuity of PCL, in which average thickness of the injured portion was 61% of the intact portion. When thickness of the ligament in cases without continuity was rated as zero, the average thickness of the PCLs as compared to intact portion of the ligament increased as the time from injury elapsed; 16.4% in 0–2 months group (7 cases), 30.0% in 3–5 months group (6 cases), 53.8% in 6–8 months group (9 cases) and 80.0% in over 9 months group (4 cases). Of the fifteen cases with confirmed continuity of PCL in arthroscopic examination, nine cases showed continuity on MRI, while the remaining six cases didn’t.

Conclusion: More than two thirds of PCLs in symptomatic chronic injury showed ligamentous continuity on MRI. The longer the interval from injury was, the thicker the PCL was. In cases over 6 months after injury, the PCLs were of more than 50% thickness of the intact portion.


Y. Matsui Y. Oishi

Introduction: Instability of the anterior horn of the medial meniscus (MM) has been described as dislocating, subluxating or hypermobile, but it is still controversial whether segments of the MM of the knee were surgically treated by arthroscopic stabilization. The average age of the patients was 28.7 (range 12 to 56). There were 9 men and 4 women. All patients complained of medial knee pain and felt tenderness in the medial joint space, most of them on the anterior side. None showed an apparent tear of the meniscus by arthroscopy or on MRI images, but all arthroscopically showed hypermobility (or easy dislocation from the edge of the tibial plateau) of the anterior to middle segment of the MM. No other apparent pathological changes were found. Six knees had marked limitations in the range of knee motion before operation. Arthroscopic stabilization of the hypermobility was performed in order to restrain the movement of the MM by fixing it to the tibial edge, using staples (2 cases), Kirschner wires (2 cases) or suture anchors (9 cases). Using the Japanese Orthopaedic Association meniscus injury score (maximum 100 points), the result was evaluated. The average follow up period was 20.1 months (range 9 to 49 months)

Results: The result of arthroscopic fixation was satisfactory (excellent in 8 cases good in 1, fair in 1, and poor in 1). The average meniscus score at follow up was 87.8, while that of before operation was 41.9. It is suggested that instability of the anterior segment of the MM can be effectively treated by arthroscopic fixation of this site.

Discussion: Since all of the knees in this study had an isolated lesion of instability in the anterior segment of the MM, the marked improvement in medial knee pain that resulted from fixation of this site does show that this lesion can be symptomatic. After excluding other possible pathological lesions, stabilization of this lesion by arthroscopic fixation is a good choice of treatment.


Full Access
R. Atkinson

Introduction: This is a report of a new anatomical feature in the knee. This finding to our knowledge has never been described before. The feature consists of a shallow oval impression in the synovium on the femoral surface of the floor of the suprapatellar pouch over the lateral side just before the trochlear entry to the lateral femoral condyle. Clinical correlation was considered to be a separate study and not part of this anatomic description.

Methods: During arthroscopy of the knee the presence or absence of the “entry feature” was noted, entered on a database consecutively and prospectively. All arthroscopies were carried out by the senior author. 21 cadaveric knees (formalin preserved) were dissected.

Results: Out of 457 consecutive knee arthroscopies carried out by the senior author the “entry feature” was present in 294 and not noticed in 163. Histology of the synovium in this region was normal. 21 formalin preserved cadaveric knees demonstrated the “entry feature” in 17 and absent in 4.

Conclusion: We propose the “entry feature” as a new anatomical landmark for the arthroscopic knee surgeon. It gives an initial impression of the patellar position on the synovial floor just before commencing its excursion towards the trochlear.


Full Access
P. Berton

A review of 100 consecutive patients who underwent knee arthroscopy within 1 month of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of the knee took place to assess the role of Magnetic Resonance Imaging in regard to assessment of intra articular pathology. The study period was from 15th April 1998 to 19th September 2000. The study compared the MRI report with the operative findings of one surgeon documented with average of 20 photos per patient.

The enclosed tables document the sensitivity and specificity in regard to articular cartilage of the patella, trochlearand medial femoral condyle. Medial meniscal and lateral meniscal pathology was reviewed as was anterior cruciate ligament.

The study would suggest that whilst MRI is useful for assessment of meniscal pathology it is not highly accurate for assessment of articular surface lesions and anterior cruciate ligament pathology.


G. Horne J. Fielden P. Gander B. Lewer P. Devane

Purpose: To measure quality and quantity of sleep in patients before and after hip arthroplasty.

Methods: A prospective survey where 50 participants were sent a sleep diary, an acti-watch motion-logger, and a 32 item sleep questionnaire. These data were collected at least four weeks prior to and three months after surgery. Data analyses included descriptive statistics and within-subject pre and post surgery comparisons. For the subjective data, comparison was by the McNamar Test for the significance of changes. For the acti-graphy variables, comparison was by mixed model analysis of variance.

Results: Preliminary results indicate that subjective measures of sleep quality improve significantly three months after hip arthroplasty, e.g. patients rated their sleep disturbance due to hip-pain on a scale from 1=never to 4=always. 75% of patients reported an improvement, and 25% reported no change in this variable, post surgery. Acti-graphy measures confirm the overall improvement in sleep quality (for sleep efficiency, (p(f)=0.05) and fragmentation index, (p(f)=0.05), and a reduction in mean activity during sleep (p(f)=0.04). Ongoing analyses are addressing the reliability of subjective measures compared to acti-graphy and why some patients show greater improvement in sleep than others, after hip arthroplasty.

Conclusions: Findings suggest that sleep disturbance occurs as a result of painful osteoarthritis in the hip, and that this can be significantly ameliorated by hip arthroplasty surgery. The expected improvement in quality of life and level of day to day functioning that accompany improved sleep are perhaps an under-rated benefit of this procedure.


A.J. Andrade A. J. Spriggins

Purpose of Study: The role of surgery in the treatment of acute patella dislocation has always been controversial with procedures falling in and out of popularity.

Since the Medial Patellofemoral ligament was first described in 1979, its importance as a prime patella stabiliser has been defined, and procedures for its repair and reconstruction have been described.

We believe that the MPFL has a pivotal role in the stability of the patella, and is disrupted in all patients with acute patella dislocation. Failure to address this will inevitably lead to ongoing patellofemoral symptoms.

Methods: We summarise the current literature detailing the anatomy and biomechanical properties of the native as well repaired MPFL.

We present our own experience of treating acute patella dislocations by repair of the Medial Patellofemoral Ligament, in acute cases.

A lesion can occur anywhere along its length from the superomedial patella to a point superoposterior to the adductor tubercle. The technique of repair has to address the site of primary disruption, as well as any associated intraarticular knee injuries.

Results: In one series we have shown that of 13 patients who presented with acute patella dislocation, 10 had an MRI proven lesion of the MPFL and went on to have an open repair which reconstituted patella stability.

Conclusion: A lesion of the MPFL is the primary pathology in acute patella dislocation, and we believe that this lesion warrants surgical intervention to avoid progressive symptoms.


P. Verner Madsen K. Dissing G. Kristensen

Introduction: The technique of endoscopic bursectomy is described. Results are evaluated and compared to “open” surgery.

Patients and methods: Data were registered from case records of all relevant patients operated on in the period 1/1/1994–30/6/97. Patients were interviewed by telephone at follow up.

Results: Ten female and 60 male patients had been operated on, 19 patients endoscopically (EN), 19 with excision and primary suture (EPS), and 32 with incision (IN). In the EN group 14/19 of the bursites were infected, in the EPS and IN groups figures were 5/19 and 26/32 respectively. Operation time was shorter and hospitalization time longer in the IN group. Healing was fastest in the EN group, no patients were readmitted or reoperated. One patient in the EPS and 6 in the IN group were readmitted. Twenty two patients in the IN group were reoperated between one and seven times.

Conclusion: Endoscopic resection is safe and effective.


I. Mclean

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is a common procedure; HIC figures for 1999 in Australia include 4652 primary reconstructions, and 279 revisions (6%). We all see many good results, with some being excellent; but I also see a lot of ‘ordinary’ knees, and large group of unhappy patients following this type of surgery. Second opinions are frequently sought, because the patients feel that they have not progressed as expected. I looked prospectively at 50 patients in this category. The most common symptoms were pain, crepitus, catching, and functional insecurity or instability - and subsequent failure-to-progress. They presented four months to 15 years following ACL surgery, many having unrealistic expectations, often brought about because of media reports. Many patients complained of ‘failure of communication’ with their surgeon, and were prompted to seek a second opinion by a vocal third party. Their problems were generally complex combinations of:

Ligamentous laxity.

Meniscal, chondral, or other internal derangements of the knee.

An inflammatory response.

‘Neuromotor dysfunction’ (this group struggles from the start, often develops patellofemoral symptoms with persisting quadriceps wasting and insecurity).

Those with significant degenerative arthritis. Failure to distinguish instability of patellofemoral and neuro-motor origin; from that of ACL deficiency; can lead to inappropriate revision surgery.

Reviewing these patients who sought second opinions, emphasises the importance of a surgeon’s being an excellent technician, (as 60% of those reviewed had anterior placement of the drill holes); but equally being a team leader; understanding tissue responses, psycho-emotional factors and having good communication skills, time to listen to patients and offer adequate follow up.


L.A. Pinczewski D.J. Deehan L.J. Salmon V.J. Russell

Aim: To compare, in a longitudinal study, the clinical outcomes of endoscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction with either a four-strand hamstring tendon (HT) or a patellar tendon (PT) autograft over a five-year period, when a similar operative procedure is followed for both groups.

Method: Ninety patients with isolated ACL ruptures who had received PT autografts and another 90 who had received HT autografts were studied annually for five years. Fifty patients were randomised as a subgroup. The assessments included the IKDC Knee Ligament Evaluation, KT1000, Lysholm Knee Score, thigh atrophy, kneeling pain, hamstring pain and radiographs.

Results: The median Lysholm Knee Score was 96 for the PT group and 95 for the HT group. No significant difference was found for subjective knee function, overall IKDC assessment, X-ray findings, manual ligament KT1000 instrumented testing, graft rupture or contra-lateral ACL rupture. There was an increasing incidence of fixed flexion deformity seen in the PT group. There was no difference in the requirement for subsequent surgery. The incidence of kneeling pain at five years was significantly higher in the PT group. The results of the randomised patients were identical to the sequential patients.

Conclusions: Endoscopic reconstruction of the ACL utilizing either type of autograft restored knee stability and was protective of the meniscus despite a high level of sporting activity. We found a worrying trend towards an increasing incidence of fixed flexion deformity with time in the PT group. Pain when kneeling also remained a persistent problem in this subgroup. PT grafts appeared tighter clinically and, with the KT 1000, when assessed up to three years post operatively, compared with HT grafts. Thereafter the results were similar.


J. Feller K. Webster

Aim: To determine the short to mid-term outcome differences between patellar tendon (PT) and hamstring (HS) autograft in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructions.

Methods: Sixty-five patients undergoing primary ACL reconstruction were randomised to receive either a PT or a quadruple HS autograft. Post operatively patients undertook a standard “accelerated” rehabilitation protocol. Patients were reviewed at four and eight months and then after one, two and three years.

Results: Anterior knee pain was significantly more common in the PT group at eight months, and again at two years, but not at other times. Pain on kneeling was significantly greater in the PT group at four months and this difference persisted at three years. There was a significantly greater incidence of effusion in the PT group at eight months. Extension deficits were significantly greater in the PT group at eight months and this continued unchanged at three years. Active flexion deficits were significantly greater in the hamstring group at one and two years but not at three years.

KT-1000 side to side differences in anterior knee laxity were significantly greater in the HS group from four months through to three years. There were significantly greater peak quadriceps torque deficits in the PT group at four months and at eight months. Sports activity levels were significantly higher in the PT group at four months but this difference had resolved by eight months. Cincinnati scores were significantly higher in the HS group at one year but not thereafter. There was no difference in IKDC ratings between the two groups. Radiographic femoral tunnel widening was significantly more prevalent and greater in the HS but did not correlate with any clinical differences. Radiographic tunnel widening was present at four months and did not change significantly thereafter.

Conclusions: Overall, HS autografts were associated with less morbidity but increased anterior knee laxity and radiographic femoral tunnel widening compared with PT autografts. From a functional point of view, there was no significant difference between the two graft types at three years.


R. Stange VJ. Russell L.J. Salmon L.A. Pinczewski

Aim: To confirm previous studies and reports of tunnel widening following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. To report the medium term behaviour and the effect of tunnel widening on the clinical results.

Methods: A retrospective analysis of the ACL database comparing BPTB autograft versus HT autograft and interference screw fixation was carried out. All procedures were performed by the same surgeon using an identical endoscopic, single-incision, surgical technique and a single method of fixation (7 x 25mm Titanium RCI screws). Patients who had a radiographic series at two and five years were included in the study. All patients had an isolated ACL injury.

Patients underwent a continuous follow up evaluation including clinical examination IKDC, Lysholm knee score and KT-1000 man max testing. Tibial tunnel widening was calculated from lateral radiographs digitalised and corrected for magnification. The tunnel shape was classified according to Peyrache.

Results: The median HT tunnel area increased significantly for the first two years (p = 0.00) and was unchanged from two to five years. The median PT tunnel area decreased significantly during the first two years (p = 0.03), and decreased again from two to five years (p = 0.02). A significant difference in tunnel shape existed between HT and PT groups (p = 0.00).

Conclusion: Tibial tunnel widening was confirmed in 79% of HT and 24% of PT ACL reconstructions utilising a single Titanium RCI screw fixation in each. Graft choice was shown to influence tibial tunnel shape; 21% of HT developed a cavity shape and 29% of PT exhibited tunnel disappearance. All patients with a decrease in tunnel area had a negative pivot shift. This was significantly different from the tunnel-widening group.


D. Wood

A paper was presented two years ago reviewing evidence of absorption of the Bio Interference screw and tunnel widening at three, six and 12 months following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using double-stranded hamstrings. The femoral fixation was with an Endobutton with a double loop of Mercylene tape with a Bio Interference screw and an extra small staple for the distal fixation. This paper presents further magnet resonance imaging (MRI) studies at least two years after surgery on 10 of those patients to assess if there was any MRI evidence of absorption of the Bio Interference screw or tunnel widening (in particular ganglion formation) in the femoral or tibial tunnels.

The results showed that at least two years after surgery there was little evidence of Bio Interference screw absorption. There was no evidence of tunnel widening.


L.A. Pinczewski T.P. Musgrove C. Burt L.J. Salmon

Aim: To determine if a side-to-side difference in laxity occurs with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction utilizing a hamstring tendon and standard RCI (Smith and Nephew) interference screw fixation, and if this can be affected by the use of a reverse thread RCI screw in right-sided knees.

Methods: This was a prospective study of 80 patients undergoing right-sided ACL reconstruction with hamstring tendon autograft. Females were excluded in case of there being a sex difference in postoperative laxity with HT graft. The study group comprised of 36 males utilising standard RCI screws (STD) and 44 males utilising reverse-thread RCI screws (REV). The same technique was used on all patients and all procedures were carried out by the same surgeon. The patients were evaluated at six and 12 months following the surgery with KT1000, IKDC assessment, and Lysholm Knee Score.

Results: At the follow-up after 12 months, the average side-to-side differences using KT1000 testing were 2.0 mm (STD) and 1.0 mm (REV) using manual maximum, and 1.7 (STD) and 1.0 (REV) using KT20. Both results were statistically significant. In addition, 33% of the STD group had a manual maximum of ≥3mm compared with 11% of the REV group (p< 0.01). Accordingly, there was a higher incidence of grade I instability (Lachman) in the STD group (23% of STD group; 8% of REV group, p=0.04).

Conclusion: The use of a reverse-thread interference (RCI) screw for femoral fixation in right-sided hamstring tendon ACL reconstructions in males significantly decreased side-to-side laxity at the 12 month review when compared with standard RCI fixation.


L.A. Pinczewski J.T. Kartus V.J. Russell L. Magnusson L.J. Salmon S. Brandsson

Aim: To determine the influence of concomitant partial meniscal resection on the medium-term clinical results after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

Method: Four hundred and sixty patients fulfilled the criteria for inclusion in this multi-center study. Four hundred and twelve of the 460 (90%) patients were re-examined by independent observers after a median 41 months (range: 24 months to 60 months). At the initial operation resection of a minimum of one third of the medial or lateral menisci was performed in 137 patients. The remaining 275 patients had stable, intact menisci. Patients who had undergone previous or subsequent meniscal surgery, a re-rupture of the ACL graft, or had an abnormal contralateral limb were excluded from the study.

Results: The patients who underwent concomitant meniscal resection at the ACL reconstruction had significantly more pain (p=0.012), a greater incidence of loss of motion (p=0.0006), increased laxity (p=0.001) and lower IKDC (p< 0.0001) and Lysholm (p< 0.0001) evaluation scores than patients who had intact menisci.

Conclusion: At the medium-term clinical follow-up the patients who underwent partial meniscal resection in conjunction with the ACL reconstruction revealed significantly worse subjective and objective measurements than the patients who had intact menisci. These findings demonstrated the effect of meniscectomy on the surgical outcome of ACL reconstruction and emphasised the importance of intact menisci for the function of the knee joint.


L.A. Pinczewski V.J. Russell D.J. Deehan L.J. Salmon

Aim: To study the influence of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency upon functional outcome after Coventry high tibial osteotomy, four to seven years after the surgery.

Method: One hundred and thirty-five patients (142 knees) each underwent a Coventry high-tibial osteotomy with staple fixation, performed by a single surgeon for medial arthrosis of the knee. During the study period, six patients (seven knees) proceeded to total knee arthroplasty and three patients died from unrelated causes. Nine patients were lost to follow-up. Comparisons were drawn between those patients with an intact ACL (ACLi) and those with ACL deficiency (ACLd).

Results: One hundred and seventeen patients (122 procedures) were available for review (100 males, median age 49 years, range: 29years to 70 years). The median follow up period was 64 months (range 37 to 80 months). The ACLd group was significantly younger (median age was 44 versus 51, p< 0.05) and reported significantly less pain and difficulty with stairs, shopping and rising to stand than the ACLi group. Seventy-eight percent of ACLd patients underwent previous surgical procedures on the affected knee. Ninety-six percent of the ACLd group and 89% of the ACLi group were either enthusiastic or satisfied with the outcome of the surgery. The mean Knee Society Score was 83 and 79 (respectively). All six revisions of the knee arthroplasties were in the ACLi group.

Conclusions: High tibial osteotomy was performed at a younger age for those patients with an absent anterior cruciate ligament. These patients had a subjectively better functional medium-term outcome, despite having had a greater number of surgical procedures prior to the osteotomy and having an ACL-deficient joint.


A. MacDiarmid I. Anderson

Aim: To evaluate the technique of percutaneously harvested bone graft mixed with morphogenic bone protein and endoscopically delivered to ununited long bone fractures.

Methods: Thirty-eight patients with established delayed union of long bone fractures were bone-grafted endoscopically. Morphogenic bone protein (OP1) was used in 12 cases and the graft was supplemented with calcium sulphate pellets (Osteoset). The minimum follow-up was eight months. The study group included eight femoral shaft fractures, two humeral shaft fractures and the remainder were tibial shaft fractures.

Results: Four fractures failed to unite with this technique. Two femoral shaft non-unions required repeat surgery, one humeral shaft non-union and one tibial shaft non-union required supplementary grafting and fixation. The technique requires radiological imaging to supplement endoscopic preparation and graft delivery. For tibial fractures this can be used as a day-stay technique but most patients required one night in hospital.

Conclusions: Endoscopic bone grafting can be supplemented with graft substitute (Osteoset) and morphogenic protein (OP1). It is as effective as standard open ‘onlay’ grafting but good fixation of the fracture is necessary before graft and supplements are effective.


K. Tetsworth C. Sen D. Paley J. Herzenberg

Introduction: The management of post-traumatic, tibial, segmental, skeletal defects is a difficult problem that often requires complex approaches for successful limb salvage. Bone transport and acute shortening with subsequent relengthening are two techniques that have been made possible using Ilizarov’s methods.

Aim: To determine whether either technique offers any intrinsic advantage relative to the other.

Methods: We carried out a retrospective review of charts and radiographs of 42 patients with post-traumatic tibial defects that had been managed using Ilizarov’s methods. The follow-up period averaged 26 months. We selected patients with defects between 3 cm and 10 cm to provide a suitable comparison. The patients were divided into two groups of 21 each, treated either by bone transport or acute shortening.

Results: The defects averaged 7.0 cm in the transport group and 5.8 cm in the acute shortening group. The transport group averaged 12.5 months in the fixator; the acute shortening group averaged 10.1 months. However, the external fixation index was virtually identical in the two groups (mean 1.8 months/cm in the transport group and 1.7 months/cm in the acute shortening group). The complication rate, radiographic results, and functional results were slightly better in the acute shortening group.

Conclusions: Both techniques demonstrated excellent results overall and the external fixation index was nearly identical for these related methods. The final results after treatment by acute shortening were found to be slightly better than the final results following bone transport. There may be a slight advantage to the use of this technique for smaller defects in properly selected patients.


G. Horne N. Lash J. Fielden P. Devane

Introduction: Ankle fractures are the third most common fracture presenting at public hospitals in New Zealand. There have been few outcome studies following treatment of ankle fractures.

Aim: To identify the relationship between three types of ankle fractures and the functional and quality of life outcomes for patients two years after the injuries.

Methods: Seventy-four patients seen at Wellington Hospital with ankle fractures during 1998 were contacted for the study. Patients had been treated by open reduction and internal fixation, or by the application of a plaster cast with manipulation of the fracture being performed where necessary. Each patient completed an ankle specific Olerud and Molander questionnaire and an EQ5D Quality of Life Outcome measure. All x-rays were analysed and the fractures were classified using the Weber classification.

Results: There were 22 males and 52 females, 11% had Weber type A fractures, 67% had Weber type B, 18% Weber type C and 4% an isolated posterior malleolar fracture. Fifty-one patients underwent surgery. Patients who sustained Weber type A fractures generally recorded good to excellent OMA scores, while those with Weber Band C fractures produced significantly poor results. An analysis of the ankle visual analogue score versus the method of treatment showed that patients who underwent surgery judged their ankle to be less functional than the patients who had non-surgical interventions. The mechanism of injury also correlated with the end result, patients who had injured their ankles during sporting activities scored lower scores than those who had injured their ankles in simple falls. Patients requiring removal of an internal fixation device had a lower OMA score when compared with those who retained their fixation devices in situ.

Conclusions: This long-term out come study indicated that there was significant dysfunction following ankle fractures, with a surprising level of disability following Weber B and C fractures. The results of this study do not indicate better results in those patients who underwent surgery.


A.B. Vincent S.H. Sims J.F. Kellam M.J. Bosse R.D. Peindl R.D. Zura

Introduction: Unstable, extra-articular, proximal, tibia fractures are difficult clinical problems often complicated by mal-alignment and soft-tissue breakdown.

Aim: To evaluate the biomechanical properties of a traditional double plating (DP) technique, the Less Invasive Stabilization System (LISS) and hybrid external fixation. Secondarily, the clinical outcomes of an initial series of 20 fractures treated with the LISS system were to be evaluated.

Methods: The axial stiffness and biaxial tilt (varus/valgus and anterior/posterior) of the three systems were tested. Five synthetic tibiae per system were loaded in sequence under the following conditions of instability:

1)Intact.

2)1 cm medial wedge osteotomy (proximal metaphysis).

3)1 cm gap osteotomy.

Twenty proximal tibial fractures treated with the LISS system were reviewed to assess union rates, complications, knee motion and secondary procedures.

Results: There were no significant differences between the different systems when they were used on the intact specimens. The DP system was significantly stiffer axially and in varus tilt than the LISS and the hybrid systems for the wedge osteotomy for all loads. The LISS was significantly stiffer in varus tilt than the hybrid with the wedge at maximal loading. With the gap osteotomy, all three systems were significantly different from each other in both stiffness aspects (DP> LISS> hybrid). The hybrid exhibited axial gap closure at approximately one third of the force of the other systems. No implant failed or exhibited plastic deformation. In the clinical review all fractures united and only three required bone grafting. No fixation failed but there were three deep infections. Over 80% of the cases had knee motion of 90 degrees or better.

Conclusions: The DP was significantly stiffer than both the LISS and the hybrid system for axial displacement and varus tilt at comparable loads for the wedge and gap models. The LISS was significantly stiffer than the hybrid in the completely unstable gap model. The tibial LISS system gave encouraging initial clinical results.


K.T. Boyd R.J. Tippett C.G. Moran

Aim: To assess the prevalence of anterior knee pain after intramedullary nailing of the tibia and its socioeconomic impact.

Methods: A retrospective, study of 251 consecutive tibial intramedullary nailings in 248 patients, aged less than 60 years at the time of injury. The minimum follow-up period was five years and the patients were assessed using a questionnaire and the Lysholm knee score.

Results: The mean follow-up was 7.9 years. Anterior knee sensory disturbance was reported by 58% of patients. Anterior knee pain (AKP) was reported by 47%. This interfered with activities of daily living in 37%, work in 36% and sport in 57%. Pain on kneeling was mild in 54%, moderate in 34% and severe 12%. AKP improved with time in 73% patients and became worse in 4%. The Lysholm score rated 41% knees as excellent, 19% as good, 26% as fair and 14% as poor. Eighty-six percent of the patients returned to work. The presence of anterior knee pain prevented return to previous work in 10%. The type of work performed before and after injury respectively were; sedentary 26%/29%, walking-based 20%/27%, manual 38%/37%, heavy manual 16%/7%.

Conclusions: Anterior knee pain persisted in 47% of patients after intramedullary nailing of the tibia. There was some decrease in symptoms with time and the majority of patients were able to return to work. However, anterior knee pain caused a significant disability in a small number and all patients should be warned of this problem before this type of surgery.


M Damiani R.S. Kuo

Introduction: Unstable Lisfranc (tarsometatarsal) joint injuries are increasingly being treated by open reduction and internal fixation.

Hypothesis: A good outcome is achievable by anatomical reduction and internal fixation of these injuries.

Methods: This was a retrospective outcome-analysis involving 21 patients. Six were treated non-operatively. There sere eight ligamentous and seven ligamentous/osseous injuries.

The patients’ outcomes were assessed with the use of the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) midfoot score and the long-form Musculoskeletal Function Assessment (MFA) score.

Results: The average follow-up was11 months. One patient developed a post-operative infection, and another developed a deep-vein thrombosis. The average AOFAS score was 71 and the average MFA score was 32. The study group as a whole sustained their injuries through low-energy trauma, therefore comparison with other studies should take this into account.

Conclusions: Follow-up in this study was short an this was reflected in the scoring. Longer follow-up will allow a greater evaluation of final outcome.


A. Rothwell T. Hobbs J. Rietveld S. Sinclair

Aim: To measure the percentage increase in length of the donor graft during rehabilitation from 0 degrees to 120 degrees of elbow flexion and to compare this with the end range strength.

Method: During the troids procedure four metal skin-clips were inserted at the proximal and distal margins of the proximal and distal tibialis posterior tendon weaves creating three intervals for measurement. Lateral x-rays of the humerus with the tube distance at 100cms were taken after five weeks of plaster immobilisation before elbow flexion commenced at a maximum rate of 15 degrees per week. X-rays were repeated when 60 degrees and 120 degrees of flexion obtained and when possible six months post surgery. Elbow torque was measured by the Troidometer throughout the range of motion at similar time intervals. Interval measurement was by a Vidar VRX 12 digital scanner. The Paired T test was used for statistical analysis.

Results: Sixteen arms (nine patients) were entered into the study but complete rehabilitation data were available from only 12 arms and late data from only four. There was a 12.3% average increase between 0 degrees and 60 degrees (range six to 20.6 degrees) and a further 3% increase from 60 degrees to 120 degrees (range −6 degrees to 21 degrees). The most stretch occurred in the distal segment and in bilateral arms the percentage of stretch was similar for each arm. There was no correlation between the percentage of stretch and end range torque or lag.

Conclusions: The Troids transfer restores elbow extension for tetraplegics but an extensor lag often develops which is thought to be from stretching of the donor tendon graft. This study confirmed that tendon stretch occurs but there was wide variation among individuals although similar for each arm in bilateral procedures. An average of 75% of stretch occurred during the 0 degrees to 60 degrees mobilisation. We concluded that tendon stretch is inevitable but is not a major contributor to end range weakness or lag.


K.D. Mohammed B.L.H. Campbell K. Dalzell A.G. Rothwell A.F. Hobbs

Introduction: The patterns of forearm and hand paralysis in traumatic tetraplegia are recognised and classified by an international classification system. Although weakness and wasting are common around the shoulder in tetraplegia, it is harder to discern individual muscle function.

Aim: To determine the activity of shoulder girdle muscles in patients with traumatic tetraplegia and to relate these results to the subjects’ international forearm classifications.

Methods: Twenty-five male tetraplegic subjects (50 upper limbs) were examined. Forearm muscle strengths were recorded according to the international classification system. The strengths of nine shoulder movements were recorded according to the Medical Research Council (MRC) grading system. The presence of wasting and the electromyographic (EMG) activity of nine shoulder muscle regions were noted. Using surface electromyography we noted whether voluntary EMG patterns were present or absent and whether lower motor denervation signs were present or absent.

Results: Absence of voluntary EMG activity was only seen in latissimus dorsi, and only in patients with very high-level lesions (either no MRC grade IV forearm muscles, or brachioradialis only, i.e. international forearm grade I or less). Lower motor neuron signs were observed in latissimus dorsi in most patients without ipsilateral MRC grade IV finger extension (international forearm grade VI or less). Lower motor neuron signs were observed in infraspinatus in most patients without MRC grade IV forearm pronation (international forearm grade IV or less).

Conclusions: Only patients with very high level lesions showed paralysis of any shoulder girdle muscles and, then, only latissimus dorsi. In most cases of traumatic tetraplegia shoulder girdle muscles have the capacity to be strengthened by use and rehabilitation.


C.J. O’Meeghan V. Mamo J.K Stanley I.A. Trail

The natural history of scapholunate ligament injury is unknown. In fact, as far as we can tell, there has been no study examining the long-term natural history of this condition. It has, however, been assumed that the long-term progression of this injury leads to secondary osteoarthritis – scapholunate advanced collapse (the so-called SLAC wrist). In this study, we evaluated the clinical condition of 11 patients with proven scapholunate ligament injuries that had declined further treatment in an attempt to quantify any long-term disability. Whilst there was on-going pain and functional limitation in the injured wrist, there was no rapid progression of the osteoarthritis or SLAC wrist deformity.


Full Access
C.J. O’Meeghan

An anatomical cadaver dissection was used to compare two approaches to the volar aspect of the distal radius. The traditional approach between flexor carpi radialis and the radial artery limits the exposure of the ulnar aspect distal radius. In the trauma setting, it is difficult to perform a carpal tunnel release whilst protecting the palmar branch of the median nerve and gain sufficient exposure of the volar ulnar fragments and the DRUJ. An extensile ulnar sided approach to the distal radius is described which permits wide exposure of the volar aspect of the distal radius including the DRUJ and radial styloid. This exposure utilises the plane between flexor carpi ulnaris/ulnar neurovascular bundle and flexor digitorum profundus. It permits easy and safe release of the carpal tunnel and Guyon’s canal.

Its use in the trauma and post traumatic setting will be shown with intra-operative pictures.


N. Emslie A. Rothwell T. Hobbs

Aim: To develop a database of the force generated by brachioradialis muscle (BR) using IEMG.

Methods: The 32 BR muscles of 12 young male and four young female adults were studied using the MedTronic functional diagnostics key point EMG machine. Two self adhesive surface electrodes were placed 3mm apart over the BR belly and a third earth electrode over the radial styloid process. The subject’s arm was at the side of the trunk, the elbow flexed to 90 degrees and the forearm strapped in neutral rotation. Recordings were taken over a five-second voluntary maximum isometric elbow flexion and the force of the contraction measured from the rectified and integrated tracing (mv.ms). Four recordings were taken for each arm; wrist in neutral and at maximum passive flexion, with a two-minute rest between recordings. Recordings were repeated after minimum of 24 hours later.

Results: There was large inter-subject variability with a range of values recorded between 14 685 and 278 533 mv.ms with an average of 99 472 for the wrist in neutral and 93 038 with the wrist flexed in males and 53 292 and 57 224 respectively for females. However, intra-subject variability was low (co-efficient of variation, CV 8 to 11%) and good repeatability (CV 6 to13%). There was no significant statistical difference with the wrist either in neutral or fully flexed.

Conclusions: BR is the key muscle for hand reconstruction in tetraplegia but it has not been possible until now to test its force objectively in isolation from other elbow flexors. Although the results from the study demonstrated a wide range of values for the BR muscle the consistent repeatability probably reflected different involvement of the BR muscle in elbow flexion. If verified, it would indicate that tetraplegics who have low IEMG values should benefit from specific strengthening exercises prior to transfer surgery.


S. Nicklin S. Ingram M. P. Gianoutsos W. R. Walsh

Introduction: Although a variety of fixation techniques have been reported for fixation of oblique or spiral metacarpal fractures, lag screw fixation has been reported to be the most biomechanically stable method. Lag screws are inserted following over-drilling of the proximal cortex, which provides compression at the fracture site. We believe the compression provided by the Leibinger Bow system makes over-drilling unnecessary.

Methods: Twenty fresh-frozen human cadaveric metacarpal bones (index, ring and middle) were utilised. Bones were cleared of soft tissue and the proximal ends were embedded in Wood’s metal using a Teflon mould. Long oblique osteotomies were performed with a fine oscillating saw. Bones were randomly allocated to lagged and non-lagged groups. All bones were held in the Leibinger Bow and fixed with two screws at right-angles across the fracture site. The proximal cortex of the lagged specimens was over-drilled and the non-lagged specimens were not. The bones were subjected to cantilevered bending to failure in a mechanical testing machine. The axial stress was calculated from results for load to failure and the moment of inertia for each specimen.

Results: All specimens failed through the proximal screw. Analysis of variance statistical analysis revealed no significant difference in axial stress between the two groups.

Conclusions: Minute errors during over-drilling of the proximal cortex can easily lead to inadequate fixation. These data suggest that the use of the Leibinger Bow System may eliminate the need for this over-drilling. This not only shortens the procedure, but also reduces the chance of errors leading to poor fixation.


D. Horman S. Bell R. Bryce

Aim: To determine the effectiveness of arthroscopic surgery, without excision of the radial head, in elbows with end stage arthritis of the radiocapitellar joint.

Methods: Twenty-three elbows with bone-on-bone degeneration of the radio-capitellar joint, but with only minor degeneration of the humeroulnar joint, had arthroscopic surgery, with synovectomy, removal of loose bodies and excision of impinging tissues and bone. The average age was 51 years (range: 16 years to 59 years). Evaluation was by a questionnaire and the follow-up was after a minimum of one year.

Results: The average follow up was 41 months (range 12 months to 83 months). Twenty-one of 22 patients reported improvements. Six patients were pain free, 12 had mild residual pain and six had significant, continuing pain. Only three patients reported residual lateral elbow pain. The average visual analogue pain score was 3.4. According to the Mayo elbow function score, there were eight excellent, seven good, six fair, and three poor outcomes.

Conclusions: Satisfactory improvements in symptoms and function were obtained in arthritic elbows with arthroscopic surgery, even in the presence of severe radiocapitellar arthritis.


B. S. Miller W. P. Harper J. S. Hughes D. H. Sonnabend W. R. Walsh

Introduction: The delivery of regional antibiotic prophylaxis has been described in reconstructive knee surgery as well as in the management of hand injuries. In this study, we describe a technique for the delivery of regional antibiotic prophylaxis to the upper extremity in patients undergoing elbow surgery, and compare tissue antibiotic concentrations achieved with this technique to those achieved with standard systemic intravenous antibiotic prophylaxis.

Methods: We collected bone and fat samples from eight patients undergoing elective elbow surgery who had received regional antibiotic prophylaxis, and measured tissue antibiotic concentration by high performance liquid chromatography. In these patients, prior to the surgical incision, we exsanguinated the arm, inflated the tourniquet, and delivered a standard dose of Cephazolin into a dorsal hand vein. For comparison, we measured antibiotic concentrations in bone and fat samples taken from eight patients undergoing elective shoulder surgery who had received standard systemic antibiotic prophylaxis.

Results: Mean tissue antibiotic concentrations were significantly higher in the patients who received regional antibiotic prophylaxis compared with those who received standard systemic prophylaxis (Bone: 1060 mcg/gm versus 41 mcg/gm; Fat: 649 mcg/gm versus 10 mcg/gm; p < 0.05.)

Discussion/conclusions: The delivery of regional antibiotic prophylaxis in elbow surgery achieved higher tissue antibiotic concentrations than those achieved with standard systemic delivery. This technique may help reduce the risk of acute infection in elbow surgery, and may be especially valuable in elective surgery in predisposed patients (e.g. rheumatoid arthritis), in the management of open fractures, as well as in protection against particularly virulent organisms.


S. Nicklin M. Chircop M.P. Gianoutsos W.R. Walsh

Introduction: The classic teaching in flexor tendon repair suggests that a 10mm bite is important for the integrity of the repair regardless of the other features of the technique. Although this has been widely accepted since Bunnell’s first descriptions of accurate flexor tendon repair there appear to be little data to support it. An extensive review of the literature showed no biomechanical data relating specifically to size of bite in flexor tendon repair. We hypothesised that decreased bite may cause less damage to the tendon during repair while still offering adequate mechanical strength.

Aim: To investigate the effect of different bite sizes on the mechanical properties of flexor tendon repairs.

Methods: Twenty fresh-frozen cadaveric flexor tendons were divided at their centres. One side of a modified Kessler repair was used on each side taking a 6mm bite on one side and a 10mm bite on the other. The tendons underwent tensile testing on a mechanical testing frame by pulling on the ends of the suture with the tendon secured in pneumatic grips. Data for stiffness and ultimate load to failure were recorded.

Results: An increased bite size made no significant difference to stiffness of the repairs. There was a difference in load to failure noted but this was not significant. The ultimate load to failure was noted after the specimens had been distracted over 2mm, which would result in clinical failure.

Conclusions: These results suggested that a 10mm bite may be excessive in flexor tendon repair and could cause more tissue damage than lesser bites. Further study of in vivo effects of decreased bite size is required.


N. Aebli J. Krebs U. Wehrli

Introduction: The aim of introducing mobile-bearing knee replacements was to improve long term survival by maintaining large areas of surface contact, while allowing motion to occur at the bearing-metal interface on the tibial and patellar components. Despite wide use of these implants, there are only a few intermediate or long-term follow-up studies.

Aims: To present the intermediate follow-up results of a cementless, posterior cruciate ligament retaining, low contact-stress, knee replacement system (LCS).

Methods: Between 1987 and 1991 the senior author (U.W.) performed 134 cementless LCS total knee arthroplasties in 121 patients. Twenty of the patients were male, 101 female, with an average age of 70 years (range: 49 years to 91years). In 40% of the cases the patella was resurfaced. The patients were evaluated with clinical knee rating (Insall score) and radiographic analysis, between six and nine years postoperatively.

Results: At the time of the follow-up 94 patients were alive. Twelve patients (10%; 14 prostheses) were contacted by phone after an average of 77 months. Evaluation was possible in 82 patients (68%; 91 prostheses) after an average of 74 months. Ninety percent of these patients had an Insall score of > 80 (good to very good). One patient had a score of < 70 (insufficient). Average flexion was 114 degrees (range: of 70 to 135 degrees). Two patients had flexion of < 90 degrees. There were no radiographic signs of aseptic loosening. The meniscal bearing of four prostheses and one patellar component were replaced. Complications like haematoma, fibrotic arthritis and infection due to endocarditis lenta lead to three revisions.

Conclusion: Our study has shown that the non-cemented posterior cruciate ligament retaining LCS knee replacement system produced very satisfactory results with few complications in the medium term.


D.P. Gwynne Jones J. Lane C.R. Howie P.J. Abernethy

Aim: To report our experience of revision knee arthroplasty with respect to surgical technique, joint line restoration and clinical outcome.

Methods: A clinical and radiological review was made of 45 knee revisions performed between 1996 to1998 using the Kinemax system. The reasons for revisions were infection (19), wear (11), loosening (seven), base-plate fracture (four) and instability (five). A primary prosthesis was used in 10 (22%), a posterior stabiliser in 24 (53%) and a superstabiliser in 11 (24%). WOMAC pain and function scores, arc of motion and measurements of joint line and patellar height were made.

Results: Three patients had died. Three knees had been revised a second time for instability and one had been arthrodesed for infection. The mean joint line elevation was 1.3mm compared with the primary and depressed 1.6mm when compared with the natural knee. Twenty-seven percent had patella infera and 13% had patella alta. A significant correlation was found between the change in patellar tendon length and the change in the joint line. The flexion arc was significantly improved from 83 degrees to 95 degrees. No relationship was found between the clinical outcomes and the changes in the joint-line. There were two deep infections (4.4%) and five knees were unstable. The three cases of flexion instability were due to failure to reconstruct adequately the antero-posterior (AP) diameter of the femur.

Conclusions: By restoring the level of the joint-line, a less constrained prostheses can be used in revision surgery with good functional results. The AP diameter of the femur must also be reconstructed to avoid flexion instability.


F. Phillips J. Balance

Introduction: The Oxford Unicompartmental Knee Hemiarthroplasty has been used in the Nelson region by three surgeons for over 10 years. This prosthesis has had favourable reports from the designers, with a 98% surviving 10-years or more. Other series have reported less successful results.

Aim: To evaluate the performance of this prosthesis in a provincial area.

Methods: Using the established audit system all patients were retrieved and their notes were reviewed. The patients were reviewed as outpatients according to the Oxford 12-item knee score and basic data were collected. Standardised radiographs were taken. Patients living out of the area were interviewed by telephone.

Sixty-three prostheses were implanted in 54 patients. Follow-up was from 55 to 144 months. Eighteen patients had died. Eight prostheses had been revised between four to 82months after the initial surgery. Of the patients who were reviewed, the average Oxford Knee score was 20. Two patients were not satisfied with the prosthesis.

Conclusions: These results are comparable with other non-designer series for the Oxford Knee. Patients who had successful replacements scored well and were very happy with their surgery, but there was a significant failure rate that must be taken into account when selecting patients for this prosthesis.


M.J. Cross G.S. Roger R.L. Morgan-Jones S. Machan E.N. Parish

Introduction: The Motus (Osteo) total knee replacement design is an uncemented, stemless, hydroxyapatite-coated prosthesis designed as a low profile resurfacing implant.

Aim: To review the results after five to eight years of the use of this prosthesis by one surgeon and to discuss the perceived advantages of its design.

Methods: Between 1992 and 1996 the Motus (Osteo) prosthesis was used in 606 primary total knee replacements in 409 patients. The evaluation was undertaken using a clinical knee score based on the Knee Society Score and the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) score, which produces a maximum score of 200/200.

Results: The mean age was 69 years (range: 31 to 88 years) with 53% of the patients being female. Osteoarthritis was the underlying pathology in the majority of the cases. The minimum time to follow up was 60 months (mean: 79, range: 60 to 104 months). The mean pre-operative knee score was 98/200 with a range of movement from six degrees to 122 degrees. After five years, the mean knee score was 180/200 with a range of movement from one degree to 113 degrees. To date only two patients have required a revision procedure, both for deep infection. Twenty-six patients have died and six have been lost to follow-up as they are overseas.

Conclusion: At a minimum five-year review, the Motus (Osteo) total knee replacement prosthesis produced excellent functional and clinical results with a low rate of complications.


L. Kohan S. Stanners

Aim: To assess the survival rate of implants and the effect of UKR on knee pain, function, stiffness and quality of life in a prospective study.

Methods: All of the knee replacements were performed using minimally invasive techniques. SF36 and WOMAC were evaluated pre-operatively and at six-monthly intervals post-operatively.

Results: There were 506 knees. The mean post-operative evaluation time was two years and six months and the maximum time was three years and nine months. The status of all knees was established. There were nine failures as determined by the need for revision procedures. Six patients died with their implants functioning.

Survival analysis: 99% at 12 months 98% at 24 months 98% at 36 months.

The scores on SF36 and WOMAC were adjusted to the Australian Population Norm. The WOMAC score showed an increase in function, and a decrease in the pain and stiffness scores. The physical and mental component summaries of the SF-36 both indicated an increased quality of life post-operatively. Implant failure was due to loosening of tibial and femoral components and progression of arthritic changes in the lateral compartments.

Conclusion: The results from the health assessment forms indicated a high patient satisfaction with the operation and a sustained improvement in quality of life, flexibility and function.


R.N. De Steiger C. Mills M. Immerz S. Graves

Introduction: There has been significant development in computer technology in recent years and this has led to applications in orthopaedic surgery. Of particular interest is computer assisted joint arthroplasty to enable accurate insertion of the components based on CT generated images of the patient’s bones.

Methods: Twenty-five patients have undergone computer assisted total knee arthroplasty using a computer guidance system (Vector Vision, Brain Lab, Munich) implanting a PFC cruciate retaining total knee replacement (TKR) (Depuy, Leeds). Pre-operative CT scans were obtained from each patient and alignment and sizing were calculated before surgery. Intra-operatively, an infrared camera tracked the instruments and the patient’s limb was accurately mapped in space by surface matching the bone and comparing it with the CT scan. For the purpose of the study the computer generated alignments and sizing were evaluated along with the use of traditional instruments and stored in a database.

Results: These have been evaluated comparing computer assisted and instrumented knee arthroplasty. Variables measured include the AP femoral cuts, rotational femoral alignment, and tibial axis alignment in AP and lateral planes.

Conclusions: Computer assisted orthopaedic surgery has undergone a rapid development in the last 18 months to enable real-time intra-operative images to be viewed in a moving limb with a degree of accuracy previously not possible. The use of this technology may lead to more accurate alignment of hip and knee prostheses and therefor help to reduce wear in the long-term.


S. Bell I. Mcnabb D. Horman

Aim: To determine the long-term outcome of surgery for rotator cuff disorders.

Methods: Ninety-two patients were followed up, after a minimum of nine years following rotator cuff surgery, including arthroscopic and open subacromial decompression, and repair of a rotator cuff tear. The results were assessed with the UCLA rating score. These results were compared with another group with a two-year follow-up.

Results: The follow-up periods for the 92 patients were from nine to 14 years. There were 58% of patients in the good or excellent group, 23% in the fair, and 19% in the poor. The results in cases with rotator cuff repairs were similar to those with only subacromial decompressions. The long-term results were a little worse than the results in the two-year follow-up group.

Conclusions: In some cases there was a gradual deterioration over time in shoulder symptoms following rotator cuff surgery. After 10 years, 19% had a poor result.


D.A. Parker D. Naudie D. Maymen R.B. Bourne C.H. Rorabeck

Aim: unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty (UKA) is experiencing a resurgence in popularity. In order to provide accurate indications for UKA it is essential to evaluate the long-term results and to determine which patients are appropriate candidates.

Methods: One hundred and seventeen cemented UKA were performed between 1988 and 1995 in 90 patients with osteoarthrosis. The cohort comprised 25 Brigham (BG) and 92 Miller-Galante (MG) implants performed in a sequential fashion in well-matched groups. The average age at the time of the surgery was 66.4 years (range: 39.5 years to 87.1 years). There were 72 males and 45 females. The surgery was performed by either one of two surgeons. The minimum follow-up period was five years and the maximum was 13.2 years. Data, including KSCRS scores and radiographic results, were collected prospectively for all patients.

Results: Six Patients died during the study period and two were lost to follow-up. The average time of death was eight years post-operatively, with average latest KSCRS prior to death of 184 points compared with 134.7 pre-operatively. Twelve knees were revised at an average of 4.25 years (range 1.0 – 11.8 years) after the initial surgery, with polyethylene wear and progression of arthrosis being the most common reasons. The surviving 97 implants had an average follow-up of 9.6 years, with an average KSCRS improving from 100 points pre-operatively to 172 points at latest follow-up. There was no radiographic evidence of prosthetic loosening. A survival analysis using revision as the end-point (Kaplan-Meier, 95% confidence interval) showed a 10 year survival of 89% for all prostheses, 85% for BG, and 90% for MG prostheses.

Conclusions: Relatively few reports of the long-term results of UKA are available. The results of this study are slightly inferior but still comparable to TKA after the same follow-up period, suggesting that, with proper patient selection, UKA can offer reliable relief of pain and restoration of function for patients with unicompartmental knee osteoarthrosis.


M.C. Ferguson

Introduction: The advantages of arthroscopically assisted mini-open rotator cuff repairs have supported the evolution of all arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs. Careful analysis of these complex techniques is required to ensure that excellent or good surgical outcomes are achieved.

Methods: In each case a diagnostic arthroscopy preceded the repair. The configuration of the tear was noted and an assessment of the ease of repair was made. An arthroscopic acromioplasty was performed in all cases. Soft tissue releases were carried out. Bone and cuff preparation was required. The principles of margin convergence and balancing of force couples of the rotator cuff without tension mismatch were followed. Knot and loop security was required for cuff fixation. All patients who underwent arthroscopic rotator cuff repair from 1997 to 2001 were reviewed. Outcome scores were evaluated for pain, levels of activity, range of motion and strength.

Conclusions: Results comparable to mini-open repairs can be achieved. Complex arthroscopic skills must be mastered and the attraction of cosmesis and lower perioperative morbidity and stiffness must not compromise the long-term outcomes of the surgery.


J. Ashwell D. Liu

Aim: To compare two approaches to the knee joint for total knee arthroplasty with regard to patient comfort and return of knee function.

Methods: Sixty-six consecutive patients were randomised prospectively to undergo either a medial parapatellar or midvastus approach for total knee arthroplasty. All patients received the same type of prosthesis under the guidance of the same surgeon. A comparison was made of operative time, number of soft tissue releases required, the number of days to reach 60 and 80 degrees of flexion, the time to achieve a straight-leg raise, and the time to discharge from hospital. A subgroup of 34 patients who received the same type of anaesthetic (spinal and femoral nerve blocks) and who also received the same type of post-operative analgesia, were compared for pain and analgesic requirements in the first 48 hours following surgery.

Results: The two groups were similar for number, age, weight, gender and diagnosis. A statistical analysis showed that the midvastus approach was significantly better, with an earlier straight-leg raise and shorter operative time. There was a trend towards improvement in early range of motion but no difference in post-operative pain, number of soft tissue releases or difficulty with surgery.

Conclusions: This trial has shown that the midvastus approach was an effective alternative to the medial parapatellar approach for knee arthroplasty. It produced less tissue damage to the quadriceps mechanism and medial patellar blood supply. It allowed an earlier recovery of knee function and shorter surgery time with no increase in the difficulty of the surgery.


L. Kohan S. Stanners

Introduction: Medial unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) is a successful procedure in the management of early osteoarthrosis. This procedure is not usually indicated in patients who have insufficiency of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). However, a problem arises when, after a UKR, an ACL rupture occurs, and instability develops. A technique is described to stabilise the knee and possibly avoid conversion to total knee replacement.

Methods: Three patients underwent arthroscopic ACL reconstruction. Only semitendinosus tendon was used. The proximal fixation was with a Mulch screw (Biomet) and the distal fixation was with two screws and washers. A post-operative, standard, accelerated rehabilitation programme was used in all three.

Results: After two years, two patients continued playing doubles tennis, and one continued as a dancing instructor.

Conclusions: While an ACL-related instability is a contraindication to undertaking a UKR, the disruption of an ACL in a well functioning UKR and the development of instability need not necessarily force the conversion to TKR. Using a modified hamstring reconstruction it was possible to stabilise the knee and maintain the UKR function.


K.T. Boyd D.R. Simpson

Aim: To quantify the effect of overhead sports on static scapular position.

Method: Three cohorts of young adults were evaluated: Swimmers (n=35), Tennis players (n=32) and Controls (n=33). Scapular position was determined using the method described by DiVita. Details of overhead activities, hand dominance and history of shoulder injuries were obtained by questionnaire. All measurements were performed by a single observer.

Results: DiVita’s normalised ratios in dominant shoulders were 1.57±0.09 for swimmers, 1.61±0.11 for tennis players and 1.57±0.12 for controls. For non-dominant shoulders, the ratios were 1.58±0.1.5, 1.59±0.13 and 1.63±0.13 respectively. There were no significant differences between groups. Within male subjects, there were no differences in scapular size between athletes and controls on either dominant or non-dominant sides. However, scapular distance was significantly greater in swimmers in both shoulders (dominant p=0.009, non-dominant p=0.028) and in the dominant shoulder in tennis players (p=0.037) when compared with controls. Female athletes showed no differences in scapular size when compared with controls but female swimmers had greater scapular sizes on their non-dominant sides when compared with controls (p=0.016).

Conclusions: There were measurable anthropometric differences between athletes and controls that supported our hypothesis of greater scapular distances in both shoulders in swimmers and in the dominant shoulder in tennis players when compared with controls. However, these were not borne out using a normalised ratio. DiVita’s method of assessing static scapula position is readily applicable to clinical and sporting settings and proved reproducible with minimal equipment. It may be worthy of further investigation.


M.G. Sharland J.S. Hughes D.H. Sonnabend

Aim: To review the experience of a tertiary referral shoulder practice in managing a group of patients each of whom presented with disabling pain and loss of function following excision of the distal end of the clavicle.

Methods: A retrospective analysis was performed of eight male patients (average age 46) who underwent this procedure between August 1998 and December 1999. All patients were assessed using a standard protocol pre and post-operatively.

The surgical technique involved an arthrodesis at the acromio-clavicular joint and coraco-clavicular space using autogenous iliac crest bone graft and fixation with both tension band wires and a cancellous screw.

Results: The minimum follow-up was six months and clinical assessments demonstrated painful instability of the residual clavicle predominantly in the antero-posterior plane presumably because of disruption of the posterior acromio-clavicular joint capsule which is the major restraint to posterior translation of the clavicle. The patients had undergone on average 3.1 operations and had had symptoms for an average of 79 months before the fusion.

The fusion rate was 75% (six out of eight). Pain, measured using a Visual Analogue Scale (0 to 10), was reduced from 8.5 pre-operatively to 3.1 post-operatively. The patient’s perception of instability reduced from an average of 9.0 to an average of 1.0. The range of motion increased in five patients, decreased in two and remained the same in one. All of the patients would have the operation again and seven out of eight were very satisfied. The complications included the two non-unions, mild sterno-clavicular pain in two cases and a need to remove K-wires in seven instances.

Conclusions: Acromio-clavicular and coraco-clavicular fusions are worthwhile salvage techniques in the difficult situation of painful instability of the distal clavicle after multiple previous procedures. This complication can be avoided primarily by preservation of the posterior acromio-clavicular joint capsule.


S.A. Qaimkhani M.S. Bhamra

Aim: To study the outcome of the modified Bosworth technique for Tossy III acromio-clavicular joint (ACJ) dislocations

Methods: Thirty-six patients were treated surgically for Tossy III ACJ dislocations over a period of five years.

A modified Bosworth technique was used in all patients. The shoulders were immobilised in collar and cuff slings for six weeks. The screws were removed after six to eight weeks. The patients were assessed using the modified Constant Score. The average follow up was 35.2 months (range: seven to 60 months).

Results: Thirty-five patients were available for follow-up. The average age was 35.5 years (range: 25 to 62 years).

Using the modified Constant score:

– Twenty-six patients (74%) scored 100;

– Five patients (14%) scored between 90 and 99 and

– One patient (3%) scored 87 (against a score of 96 on the other side)

– Three patients scored poorly.

Conclusions: In our experience the modified Bosworth technique has proven to be a reliable method for treating Tossy III dislocations of the ACJ. This has applied to all ages and for both acute and chronic dislocations.

We concluded that this technique produced good to excellent functional results and we would recommend its use for Tossy III ACJ dislocations. The technique is not obsolete!


D. Horman A. Pavlic S. Bell

Aim: To evaluate the results of arthroscopic resection of the superomedial corner of the scapula, using a new superior portal, in patients with painful snapping scapulæ.

Methods: An analysis was made of 10 patients who had each undergone arthroscopic resection of the superomedial corner of the scapula. The patients were evaluated by questionnaire and clinical examination, and the results assessed by the UCLA rating score.

Results: There were four women and six men with a mean age 26.9 years (range: 16 to 40 years). The average duration of symptoms was 53.2 months (range: 12 to 154 months). Their x-rays and CT scans were normal. The average follow-up period was 11.3 months (range: three to 23 months). There were no post-operative complications. The scapulothoracic crepitus disappeared in two patients, decreased in seven patients, and remained the same in one patient. The mean postoperative visual analog pain scale was 2.7. All felt the procedure to be worthwhile. On the UCLA score there were four excellent, four good and two fair results.

Conclusions: Scapulothoracic arthroscopy using medial and superior portals is a safe procedure. Resection of the superomedial corner of the scapula reliably improved symptoms from the painful snapping scapula.


B.S. Miller W.P. Harper J.A. Goldberg D.H. Sonnabend W.R. Walsh

Aim: To define the contact force and contact area at the glenoid labrum-bone interface between suture sites in an open transosseous Bankart repair, and to assess how these contact parameters are altered by tying adjacent sutures to each other.

Methods: Twelve capsulolabral avulsion lesions were created in fresh-frozen human shoulder specimens and were repaired using a standard transosseous suture technique. The contact forces and contact areas were measured at the labrum-bone interface between sutures before and after repair. Using the free suture ends, either a single or double strand knot was then tied between adjacent suture sites and the contact parameters were measured again.

Results: The contact forces and contact areas under the soft tissue bridges between transosseous sutures were mildly increased during repair (before repair: average force=5.53g, area=2.25mm2; after repair: force=11.7g, area=3.13mm2). However, both the contact forces and areas increased significantly when a single or double strand of suture was tied over the soft tissue bridge. The double strand technique resulted in a significantly greater increase in contact forces and areas than the single strand technique (single strand average force=70.1g, area=6.75mm2; double strand average force=95.15g, area=8.0mm2 p< 0.05).

Conclusions: The contact parameters between labrum and bone in a Bankart repair were increased when the suture strands from adjacent transosseous repair sites were linked. Increasing contact force or contact area may improve healing at the bone-soft tissue interface, and may reduce the risk of “spot welding” repairs. This, in turn, may reduce the failure rate of Bankart repairs.


D. Pitchford I. B. Mcphee C. E. Swanson

Aim: To review the effect of school screening on the referral pattern and management at a provincial scoliosis clinic.

Methods: Records of all females aged 10 to 17 years with scoliosis seen in Mackay (North Queensland) were reviewed. The age, date of presentation, magnitude of the curve, Risser sign, menarche and previous treatments were noted. Patients wearing scoliosis braces were reviewed to determine compliance. School Health, Mackay, provided data on number of females who were in grade seven at school and these were screened. The number having a possible deformity, and the number of confirmed cases per year were recorded.

Results: Notification rates for potential scoliosis cases ranged from 29.5% in 1993 to1.8% in 1998. The annual prevalence of confirmed scoliosis ranged from 3.3% in 1992 to 1% in 1997. Twenty-four of 57 cases seen in the clinic were initially detected by school screening. Those in the group detected by screening were significantly younger than other referrals, but no significant differences were noted in curve size, Risser sign or the menarche. The proportion treated with a brace was significantly greater in the screened group (p=.03), but the proportion coming to surgery was not significantly different (p=.07) between groups.

Conclusions: Although school screening for scoliosis resulted in referral at an earlier age, it did not translate to detection of smaller curves at an earlier stage of development, nor to a trend to brace treatment. The efficacy of bracing depended on compliance.


D. Paterson J.A.I. Ferguson B.F. Hodgson

Aim: To examine the effect of the anterior and posterior approaches for the surgical correction of scoliosis on pulmonary function, curve correction and patient satisfaction.

Methods: Thirty-five patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis undergoing surgical treatment were evaluated with spirometry, assessing volume (FVC) and flow (FEV1) pre and post-operatively . They were followed for a minimum of two years and their results were compared with the normalised data for their age group. The patients were divided into three groups based on the surgical approach and the amount of correction. The patients in group one underwent posterior spinal fusions and had greater than 60% correction of pre-operative Cobb angles. Those in group two underwent posterior spinal fusions and had less than 60% correction of their pre-operative Cobb angles. A combined anterior and posterior spinal fusion was used for the patients in group three with greater than 60% correction in their pre-operative Cobb angles.

Results: The patients in group one had significantly improved pulmonary function values at follow-up. The patients in group two all returned to pre-operative pulmonary function values and the patients in group three had improved pulmonary function values but this was not significant.

Conclusions: Patients with purely posterior surgery and large Cobb angle corrections demonstrated a statistically significant increase in lung function values. Large corrections greater than 60 degrees in combined anterior/posterior procedures increased lung function values but not significantly. We suggest that large corrections can be achieved with posterior surgery alone using pedicle screws for caudal fixation and question the need for a thoracotomy.


C. Birks M. Barnes H. Crawford

Aim: To determine the length of stay after adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) surgery in Starship and Mercy Hospitals to ascertain whether there is a difference in the length of stay of patients having AIS surgery in a private hospital compared with a public hospital. To determine the variables having significant influence on the length of stay.

Methods: Patients between the ages of 10 and 20 who had surgery for AIS during the period 1/1/96 to 31/12/2000 were identified from theatre logbooks. Patients who had anterior and posterior surgery were excluded. A retrospective analysis of case notes was carried out. Fisher’s Exact Test was used to analyse categorical data while Student T Test was used for continuous variables.

Results: Thirty-three patients fulfilled the entry criteria. Sixteen male patients were operated on in Starship Hospital. Seventeen patients had operations at Mercy Hospital but only one of these was male. The groups were not significantly different in terms of age, sex, weight, ASA, number of levels, or curve pattern. The Mercy Hospital patients had a significantly lower Cobb angle (by 12 degrees). The Starship Hospital patients tended to retain their PCA pumps longer and tended to use more PCA morphine, however, this result was not significant. The Mercy Hospital patients had their intravenous access removed and were mobilised significantly earlier (1.7 and 1.9 days earlier respectively). The Mercy Hospital patients had a significantly shorter length of stay (6.4 and 8.4 days respectively, p= 0.0002).

Conclusions: Patients at the Mercy Hospital had a significantly shorter post-operative length of stay after AIS surgery. This was not completely explained by the lower Cobb angle seen in the Mercy Hospital patients. The Mercy Hospital patients had their drips removed and were mobilised significantly earlier. This may be the key to early discharge.


K.T. Boyd R. Jari L. Neumann W.A. Wallace

Aim: To assess shoulder proprioception before and after a new surgical treatment for multi-directional instability.

Methods: A pilot study assessing shoulder proprioception in asymptomatic controls (n=6), pre-operative patients (n=7) awaiting surgery for multidirectional instability (having failed rehabilitation) and post-operative patients (n=7) having undergone thermo-capsular shrinkage and rehabilitation. Data were obtained using the Proprioception Assessment System developed at our centre following a standardised protocol to record threshold to detection of passive movement (TTDPM) and reproduction of passive position (RPP) in three positions of rotation.

Results: For controls, TTDPM at 0 degrees, +30 degrees and −30 degrees was 1.08 degrees ± 1.05 degrees, 1.75 degrees ± 1.80 degrees and 1.61 degrees ± 1.68 degrees respectively. In the pre-operative group the asymptomatic shoulders had values of 2.48 degrees ± 2.22 degrees, 2.14 degrees ± 1.59 degrees and 1.51 degrees ± 0.87degrees and the symptomatic shoulders 8.59 degrees ± 12.96 degrees, 6.89 degrees ± 6.36 degrees and 4.4 degrees ± 3.45 degrees respectively. In the post-operative group, asymptomatic shoulders had values of 2.09 degrees ± 1.25 degrees, 2.31 degrees ± 1.30 degrees and 2.30 degrees ± 1.31 degrees and symptomatic shoulders 2.15 degrees ± 1.30 degrees, 2.54 degrees ± 1.43 degrees and 2.89 degrees ± 2.12 degrees respectively. With respect to RPP, controls had values at 0 degrees, +30 degrees and –30 degrees of 2.49 degrees ± 1.02 degrees, 2.58 degrees ± 1.13degrees and 2.72 degrees ± 2.11 degrees. In the pre-operative group, the results for asymptomatic shoulders were 2.48 degrees ± 0.68 degrees, 0.87 degrees ± 0.51 degrees and 3.44 degrees ± 2.41 degrees and for symptomatic shoulders 5.63 degrees ± 2.05 degrees, 3.17 degrees ± 2.05 degrees and 7.56 degrees ± 6.10 degrees respectively. In the post-operative group, the results for asymptomatic shoulders were 2.85 degrees ± 1.13 degrees, 3.78 degrees ± 1.94 degrees and 2.55 degrees ± 2.11 degrees and for symptomatic shoulders 2.28 degrees ± 0.81 degrees, 5.40 degrees ± 5.91 degrees and 3.62 degrees ± 1.63 degrees respectively.

Conclusions: There were no differences between shoulders in controls and post-operative patients. Despite the small numbers, the pre-operative patients showed significant differences (p< 0.05) between shoulders in two of the six test protocols. Post-operative shoulders had means similar to controls suggesting thermo-capsular shrinkage may help regain shoulder proprioception after injuries.


M. Zacharias B. Hodgson J. Faed

Introduction: The intra-operative blood-loss data on scoliosis surgery patients at Dunedin Hospital during 1992–2000 were analysed retrospectively. Various measures had been tried to reduce the intra-operative blood loss and included use of fibrinogen, DDAVP and antifibrinolytic agents. Patients with medical abnormalities, particularly those with muscular dystrophies/myopathies appeared to have a high incidence of intra-operative blood loss.

Aim: To evaluate the amount of bleeding. any pre-operative factors identifiable as contributing to the bleeding and any preventive measures which have been identified.

Methods: An audit of intra-operative blood loss on all cases presented for corrective surgery for scoliosis in Dunedin Hospital during the period 1992–2000 was undertaken.

Results: A total of 160 operations were performed during the eight years. The mean age of the cohort was 14.8 years (SD 6.8) and the mean weight of the cohort was 44kg (SD 18.9). Fifty-six percent of the patients were idiopathic cases with no medical abnormalities, where as 44% had congenital/medical abnormalities.

The mean blood loss as a percentage of calculated blood volume was 38% (SD 35). There was a strong suggestion that patients with medical abnormalities, particularly those with muscular dystrophies, had much higher blood losses (63%, SD 59). There were no differences between the different patient groups in the pre-operative haematological investigations.

Conclusions: We have noted a definite overall improvement in the amount of blood loss since 1995. The reasons included intra-operative monitoring of coagulation factors, early use of fibrinogen, use of DDAVP and antifibrinolytic agents.


M. Howard N. Hartnell D. Duckworth

Aim: To evaluate the usefulness of the apical oblique projection of the shoulder in determining radiographic signs of instability.

Methods: Radiographs from 50 consecutive patients who presented for surgery for treatment of symptomatic unilateral shoulder instability were evaluated. Standard radiographic views had been obtained (anteroposterior [AP], lateral and axillary view) pre-operatively along with an apical oblique. The apical oblique view is obtained by placing the patient in a 45 degrees posterior-oblique position and angling the beam 45 degrees caudad. The radiographs were reviewed independently by two radiologists. Each radiograph was evaluated for evidence of any Hill-Sachs or bony Bankart lesions that were accepted as radiographic signs of anterior instability. Comparison of the diagnostic yield of the standard views and the apical oblique were made.

Results: The radiographs of 32 males and 18 females with an average age of 27 years (range: 17 to 41 years) were included in the series. Pathology (Hill-Sachs, Bankart lesions or both) was seen on an apical oblique in 93% of cases compared with AP (48%), lateral(17%) and axillary(32%) views. Taken collectively the standard views showed pathology in only 72% of cases.

Conclusions: The apical oblique view is easy for the radiographer to obtain, can be performed using standard imaging equipment and can be obtained pain-free in the acute setting. The diagnostic yield was significantly higher than the standard trauma series. The apical oblique view should be added to these in cases of suspected shoulder instability.


K.M.C. Cheung J.G. Zhang D.S. Lu K.D.K. Luk J.C.Y. Leong

Introduction: Anterior convex epiphysiodesis and posterior concave distraction has not been previously described in the literature for the treatment of thoracolumbar hemivertebrae. We describe our experience with long-term follow-up.

Methods: Six consecutive patients with a mean age of 3.4 years were operated on using this technique. The levels of fusion extended two levels above and below the hemivertebra, while the instrumentation spanned the full length of the curve. Further concave distraction was carried out when there was evidence of loosening of the hooks.

Results: The average follow-up was 10.8 years (range: eight to 14 years). The mean Cobb angle before surgery was 49 degrees, and at the latest follow-up was 26 degrees. There mean improvement in the scoliosis was 41%. In five of these cases, this correction was achieved immediately after surgery and did not significantly change despite repeated distraction.

Conclusions: The addition of concave distraction provided better correction than convex epiphysiodesis alone. This method of treatment is recommended for patients with single fully segmented hemivertebrae located at the thoracolumbar junction associated with a significant deformity. This method is technically easier and safer than excision of the hemivertebra in the correction of such deformities.


Y-M. Kwon W. Bruce H. van der Wall J. Stephen

Introduction: Spondylolysis is amongst the commonest causes of low back pain in the athletic child. We observed increased uptake in the pedicles of the affected segment and a triangular pattern of uptake in the sagittal projection of tomographic studies of fractures of the pars interarticularis. The hypothesis that these observations were specific for fractures of the pars interarticularis was tested in a variety of spinal disorders.

Methods:. A retrospective study of 25 young athletes with a variety of spinal disorders was undertaken (17males, 8 females; average age 13.5 years [range: nine to16 years]). The patients were referred from a specialised sports clinic. Back pain was present for an average of four months (Range six weeks to 11 months). All children had planar and tomographic scintigraphic bone scans with special reconstruction. The diagnosis was confirmed by radiological studies and/or response to treatment.

Results:. All 15 children with spondylolysis had evidence of increased uptake in the ipsilateral (12/15) or contra-lateral pedicle (3/15). None of the cases of muscle insertion injury, facet joint or disc disease demonstrated this pattern. A triangular shaped pattern of uptake was only seen in the sagittal view of the tomographic studies in patients with fractures of the pars interarticularis.

Conclusion:. We have described two unique features of spondylolysis that add to the confidence with which the scintigraphic diagnosis may be made.


G.R.C. Howie

This was a retrospective review with minimum two-year follow-up of 52 patients treated between 1989 and 1998 with a variety of fixation methods. All patients had posterolateral fusions (after McNab). In addition, 27 patients had interbody fusions (23 with Brantigan or Harms cages). Fixation was by interlaminar screws in 13 (modified Nagerl technique), 18 with Roy Camille or AO notched spinal plates and in 21 with rigid fixation (6 VSP and 15 Diapason).

A good result was defined as a pain level of less than four out of 10 and an Oswestry Disability Score of less than 30%. Only 13 patients achieved a good result. The best results were seen in the patients with rigid fixation (8 out of 21). A fusion rate of 100% was achieved in patients who had an interbody cage and rigid fixation.

These results were compared with results from other papers in the literature. Social factors are important criteria for patient selection. No patient without a “significant partner” achieved a good result.


C.J. Mann M. Parikh J. O’Dowd

We compared magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans and plain antero-posterior (AP) and lateral radiographs of 100 randomly selected patients in order to detect segmental abnormalities of the lumbar spine. We started by identifying those who appeared to have a segmental defect of the lumbar spine on MRI scan. We then checked all 100 plain radiographs to detect the true rate of segmental abnormality. We detected 17 patients with a segmental abnormality that correlates well with other studies. We believe that MRI scanning alone is not sufficient to detect reliably all segmentation defects in the lumbar spine, and that a plain lateral and an AP x-ray is also required. Of those who do have a segmentation disorder we have identified a sub-group who are at risk of surgery at the wrong level, if the correct pre-operative work-up is not performed. The difficulty will occur when a segmental abnormality is present (as determined by plain radiographs) and it is missed by MRI scan, and plain films are not taken, and the correct level is determined by counting upwards from the lumbosacral take-off angle using the image intensifier in theatre. We believe that all patients undergoing nerve root decompression should have an AP and lateral plain film and an MRI scan as well as pre-operative image intensification in theatre. Although the number of patients that would be affected by this is small, the consequences of operating on the wrong level are well recognised and can be avoided by being aware of the potential problem and by adhering to the above recommendations.


I.B. McPhee C.E. Swanson

Introduction: The reduction of severe spondylolisthesis remains controversial and is not without risk. The reduction should aim, primarily, to restore the lumbosacral angle.

Aim: To review the principle author’s experience with reduction of severe lumbosacral spondylolisthesis with emphasis on the restoration of the lumbosacral alignment.

Methods: Thirty patients have undergone reductions of severe lumbosacral spondylolistheses. All were treated by two-staged operations with variation. The anterior operations involved subtotal disc clearances with leverage to distract the discs and restore the lumbosacral angulation. Posteriorly, ala-transverse fusions and L5 laminectomies were performed. More recently pedicle screws were used. Initially hyperextension traction was employed between operations, but this was subsequently abandoned.

Results: Significant reductions (p< 0.01) of displacements were achieved at each stage but significant improvements in slip-angles only occurred with the initial operations. Loss of sagittal and angular corrections were noted at the one-year follow-up. Loss of angular corrections were significantly less with internal fixation (p=0.03). The final alignments were significantly improved when compared with the initial positions.

Conclusions: Satisfactory restoration of the lumbosacral alignment was achieved in severe spondylolisthesis by staged anterior and posterior procedures. Leverage to restore lumbosacral angulation during the anterior procedure facilitated reduction. Post-operative loss of correction was limited by pedicle screw fixation.


I.B. McPhee C.E. Swanson

Introduction: Progression of lumbosacral spondylolisthesis during adolescence is not uncommon, but it is rare in adults. Structural changes in adolescent spondylolisthesis have been reported as possibly predictive and contributory to progression.

Aim: To review the structural changes that occur with and possibly contribute to slip progression in lumbosacral spondylolisthesis.

Methods: The radiographs of 42 patients with lumbosacral spondylolisthesis who had been followed for a mean period of six years were reviewed. The following radiological parameters were determined from the initial and latest radiographs:

Percentage slip

Slip angle

Rounding of the sacrum

Trapezoid index of L5 vertebral body

Progression of a lumbar lordosis was defined as an increase in slip of 5% or more.

Results: Strong correlations (p< 0.01) existed between all radiological parameters at the time of the initial examination and at follow-up. Changes in percentage slip over time correlated with changes in all radiological parameters (p< 0.01). Slip progression correlated with increased slip angle (p< 0.01), increased trapezoid index (p< 0.05), and increased lordosis (p< 0.01) but not with age (p=0.16), adolescence (p=0.10), gender or with spondylolysis. The risk of slip progression was greatest for adolescents with an initial slip of 30% or more (p=0.13, Odds Ratio=5.7).

Conclusions: Slip progression in lumbosacral spondylolisthesis was associated with corresponding proportional structural changes in the sacrum and the L5 vertebral body, possibly related to growth and remodelling. The tendency to progress was greatest in adolescents with slips of greater than 30%. This relationship was sufficiently strong to consider prophylactic fusion.


J.M. Fielden J.G. Horne P.A. Devane

Introduction: It is well documented that surgery following hip fractures (#NOF) has accepted failure rates of between four and 33%. An average of 120 patients are admitted to Wellington hospital for #NOF each year.

Aim: We aimed to identify the rate of and reasons for readmission for further surgery within a year of #NOF in patients admitted to Wellington hospital.

Methods: A list of all patients admitted for surgical treatment of hip fractures during 1998 and 1999 was obtained from the hospital database. Demographic data, type of fracture, surgical intervention, readmission for surgery on the same hip and subsequent surgical intervention for each patient were noted.

Results: Of the 209 patients who underwent surgery for 215 fractures, 55% (n=119) sustained subcapital, 43% (n=92) intertrochanteric and 2% (n=4) other fractures. Seven percent (n=15) were readmitted for a second hip operation within twelve months. Eighty percent (n=12) of those who were readmitted had sustained sub-capital fractures. Of those in the readmission group primary surgery comprised ORIF with cannulated screws (40%), compression screw with or without one cannulated screw and plate (40%), hemiarthroplasty (HA) (13%) and total hip arthroplasty (THA) (7%).

For patients who had sustained a subcapital fracture (n=117), 21% (P< 0.05) of those who had been treated with cannulated screws required further surgery compared with 2–14% who had the other types of surgery.

Conclusions: Rates of readmission for further hip surgery following hip fracture in Wellington hospital appear to be in the lower range of those reported elsewhere.


R. .K. Khan P. Crossman A. MacDowell N.S. Reddy A.C. Gardner G.S. Keene

Aim: To establish the surgical treatment of displaced intracapsular femoral neck fractures in hospitals across the United Kingdom.

Methods: The on-call registrars in all 223 hospitals receiving acute orthopaedic admissions in the UK, were interviewed by telephone. Their usual practices were recorded for two groups of patients, active and frail. The proportions of hospitals using the different surgical options were determined.

Results: Despite stereotyped clinical features, management varied between specialists within some hospitals: two or more different methods of treatment were in routine use for active patients in 22% of hospitals, and for frail patients in 27%. The management also varied between hospitals. Overall, for active patients, bipolar hemiarthroplasty was in use in 41%, internal fixation in 37%, unipolar hemiarthroplasty in 32% and total hip replacement in 16% of hospitals. For frail patients either Austin-Moore or Thompson prostheses or both were in use in 94% of hospitals. Where used, Austin-Moore prostheses were uncemented in 93% of hospitals, and Thompson prostheses cemented in 79%. Bipolar prostheses were in use in 8%, and the alternative of internal fixation undertaken for frail patients in 1% of hospitals.

Conclusions: The findings demonstrated a lack of consensus in several aspects of the treatment of displaced intracapsular fractures of the femoral neck, with implications for consideration of best practice, in the UK, and worldwide.


A.B. Vincent J.F. Kellam M.J. Bosse S.H. Sims

Introduction: Complex acetabular fractures often require an extensile exposure to visualise the fracture adequately. Such extensile exposures have been associated with increased morbidity. Simultaneous iliofemoral and Kocher-Langenbeck approaches offer an alternative to such exposures and do not involve sectioning of the abductor tendons or a trochanteric osteotomy. We have used simultaneous anterior and posterior exposures for complex fractures in which the transverse component is transtectal and for selected both-column fractures. This study reports on the technique and reviews 51 cases performed between 1990 and 1998.

Methods: Combined anterior and posterior surgical approaches were used in 51 of 397 acetabular fracture between 1990 and 1998. A retrospective review of the case notes of all 51 patients was performed and operative times, blood loss and complications were recorded. Pre-operative, post-operative and 12-month follow-up radiographs were assessed for fracture classification, adequacy of reduction and the development of heterotopic ossification. The presence of avascular necrosis and post-traumatic osteoarthritis were also noted.

Results: The average duration of surgery was 4 hours and 40 minutes and the average blood loss was 1735ml. A reduction within 1mm of the anatomic position was achieved in 71% of cases and within 3mm of the anatomic position in 92% of cases. There were two deep infections and two post-operative sciatic nerve palsies. There were two patients who developed Brooker grade IV heterotopic ossification.

Conclusions: Planned simultaneous iliofemoral and Kocher-Langenbeck exposures were performed with operation time, blood loss, fracture reduction and complications comparable with or better than other reported series using extensile exposures. We consider this approach a useful alternative particularly for complex fracture patterns of the acetabulum, which involve a displaced transtectal transverse component.


V.S. Pai D. Arden N. Wilson

Aim: To identify the significant risk factors that influence patient mortality and morbidity in the management of displaced subcapital neck of femur fractures in independent elderly patients (aged > 70 years) managed with total hip arthroplasty through a modified Hardinge approach.

Methods: Thirty-seven primary hip arthroplasties performed for displaced fractures of the neck of femur in “Healthcare Hawkes Bay” between 1998 and 2000 were reviewed. The surgery was carried out by one surgeon (VP), using a modified lateral approach. The patients’ records were screened for outcomes and complications. An independent review was made (DA, NW) using the modified Harris hip score.

Results: The average age of the patients was 85 years (range: 70 to 92 years). At an average of 1.8 years (12 months to 24 months), no patient had suffered a dislocation or had needed another operation on the hip. The majority of the patients were satisfied with the outcome. However, there were significant medical complications (total of 38 complication in 22 patients). There were two deaths in the first 12 months.

Conclusions: The incidence of dislocation and a reduced revision rate can be achieved with a modified lateral approach (Hardinge). However, aggressive treatment is necessary before and after the surgery, as there is high incidence of medical complications. The number of existing medical conditions at the date of admission to hospital was a significant factor influencing patient morbidity.


A.D. Shaw N. Ramamohan

Introduction: While recent guidelines for the treatment of such fractures do not recommend load-bearing devices, there is little evidence actually condemning them, and there is still a lack of literature on the reconstruction nails now generally used.

Aim: To evaluate the clinical outcome of pathological (metastatic) proximal femoral fractures treated by either a long Gamma nail, an AO nail with a spiral blade plate (AO-SBP), or a dynamic hip screw (DHS).

Method: Eighty-six operations in 80 patients with average age 63.9 years were followed for 18 months or until death. Thirty-one procedures were prophylactic.

Results: Thirty Gamma nails (three bilateral), 28 AO SBP rods (three bilateral) and 28 DHS were implanted. The DHS had complications in 10 cases (35%), all occurred in less than 14 months; three implants fractured, four cut out, and three failed to relieve symptoms. The Gamma nail group had two (7%) complications, both after 20 months; one nail fractured and the other lost fixation. The AO-SBP group had two (7%) complications, with one SBP misplacement, and one postoperative death after bilateral nailing. Pain relief and function were greatly improved by the nailing procedures in 57 out of 58 cases. Survival averaged 5.5 months, and was related to primary disease, and presence of visceral metastases.

Conclusion: Both the long Gamma and AO- SBP nails reliably treated metastatic proximal femoral fractures, but loss of fixation occurred with long-term survival. The DHS had a high complication rate when used in these cases, and we do not recommend its use.


Full Access
J.A.L. Hart K. Dom A. Trivett

Method: One hundred and twenty-eight knees treated by carbon fibre resurfacing pads and rods for grades III and IV articular cartilage lesions were assessed arthroscopically, with an average follow-up of 22.6 months. The mean age was 37.4 years. Results were scored by an independent observer, using the ICRS scale (1–12) as grade I, normal; grade II, nearly normal; grade III, abnormal; grade IV, severely abnormal.

Results: The mean scores were: medial femoral condyle, 10.5; lateral femoral condyle, 9.76; trochlea, 9.9; patella 9.4. Grades I & II scores for rods were: medial femoral condyle, 95.1%; lateral femoral condyle, 76.0%; trochlea, 86.1%; patella, 89.7%. The pads were used in significant numbers only on the patella. Of the total, 76.7% of the repairs were for grades I and II changes.

Patellar resurfacing was combined with realignment and an ‘anteriorisation’ procedure in 77 knees. We found that 96.7 % of repairs for grades I & II disease were seen with rods on the patella, when combined with a mechanical correction, compared with 66.0%, when used on the patella without a realignment procedure. However, when the use of pads was combined with mechanical corrections the score was 76% and a lower proportion were grade I repairs (13%) than with rods (30.0%).

The mean Waddell Score (0–4) was 2.9. From the survey 81.8% regarded the procedure as worthwhile and 9.1% were doubtful.

Conclusions: We concluded that carbon fibre resurfacing was an effective method of treating articular cartilage defects. Rods were more effective than pads and are recommended as the universal method. The results were improved by the correction of abnormal biomechanical alignment. Stabilisation of the cartilage defects resolved synovitis.


B.J. Spring H.M. Staudacher I.J.P. Henderson

Introduction: Articular cartilage has compressive stiffness determined primarily by the matrix and it is quite characteristic and distinct from that of degenerative articular cartilage or regenerative fibrocartilage.Alterations that are evident when articular cartilage begins to degenerate include a decrease in proteoglycan content and water content and resultant reduction in stiffness. Regenerative fibrocartilage has greatly reduced stiffness with functional implications. Identification of cartilaginous stiffness for various sites of normal articular cartilage in the knee is important to enable comparison measures of suspected degenerative cartilage and regenerative articular cartilage either hyaline, fibrocartilage or mixed.

Aim: To map the biomechanical properties of normal human articular cartilage in vivo using the Artscan 1000 arthroscopic cartilage stiffness tester (Artscan Oy, Finland).

Method: Over a period of 12 months, 94 patients (aged 15 to 69 years) undergoing a knee arthroscopy consented to having their normal articular surfaces evaluated biomechanically for stiffness. Cartilage stiffness (N) was defined by the mean indenter force at each site where the applied force on the measurement rod equalled 10 ±1.5N.

`Results: Medial femoral condyle stiffness (mean ± SD; 3.71 ± 1.28N) was greater than all other sites and was significantly greater than mean values obtained for proximal, distal and lateral trochlea (1.87 ± 0.91, 2.44 ±1.02 and 2.69 ±1.52N, respectively); medial (1.71 ± 0.70N) and lateral patella (2.18 ± 1.03N); and medial and lateral tibial plateaux for all subjects (2.33 ± 1.26 and 2.27 ± 1.19N, respectively; p < 0.05). There were no significant differences between sexes for each site. There was no trend for cartilage stiffness to be lower in patients over forty compared with younger patients for both sexes, for all sites. There was however, statistically significant less stiffness of the distal trochlea for females under 40 when compared with that of females older than 40 years. The clinical significance of this is under review.

Conclusion: Further research involving the characterisation of cartilage stiffness in pathological situations and evaluation of stiffness following articular cartilage repair is now possible.


D. Wood A. Brown R. Salleh B. Robertson M.H. Zheng

Articular cartilage defects of the knee occur commonly in sports injuries and trauma. Increasing evidence suggests that the only technique that enables the regeneration of articular hyaline cartilage in chondral defects is autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI). Here we have reported our clinical experience of autologous chondrocyte implantation using biodegradable type I/III collagen membrane (CACI). A total of 26 patients (age range from 19 to 60 years, average 37 years) was conducted with CACI. Pre-operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans were performed on all patients. Post-operative MRI scans were planned for approximately three and 12 months after the surgery to determine the success of integration of implanted chondrocytes.

The results demonstrated that the initial post-operative MRI scans at three months showed the presence of oedematous tissue at the defect sites in 23 patients, contrasting with the fluid filled defects seen preoperatively and with and MRI signal differing from that of the surrounding normal hyaline articular cartilage. MRI scans in nine patients at 12 months after their operations showed maturation of cartilage graft in all patients. Apopototic testing of the chondrocytes using Annexin IV before implantation showed that the viability of the chondrocytes was over 85% where the apopototic rate of chondrocytes was less than 2%. One patient with an apopototic rate of over 10% has a delayed repair in cartilage defects as shown by MRI.

In conclusion, early phase clinical studies showed that autologous chondrocyte implantation remains promising for the treatment of chondral defects with restoration of hyaline cartilage. Longer clinical follow-up of the patients and better assessment of cellular phenotype of chondrocytes before implantation are required.


M. Clatworthy G. di Bartolo

Introduction: Day-stay anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is commonly performed in North America. We report our experience in New Zealand.

Methods: One hundred and sixteen arthroscopic ACL reconstructions were performed by one surgeon with the same anaesthetist over a period of 14 months. One hundred and four were performed as day-stay procedures. Children and patients who had no social support stayed overnight. All patients underwent spinal anaesthesia with a femoral nerve block. Patients were discharged with oral analgesia, a brace and a cryocuff. One hundred and three patients were prospectively evaluated after two weeks by a visual analogue pain scores (0–10) and a self-administered patient satisfaction questionnaire.

Results: One hundred and two patients (99%) were happy to go home. One patient was admitted from the day-stay unit. One patient was re-admitted in the middle of the night. Ninety eight patients (93%) coped on the night of surgery and did not think they should have been in hospital. The mean visual analogue pain score at discharge was 1.0, in the middle of the first night was 1.8 and was 2.1 on the first day post op. Patients experienced significantly more pain the day after surgery than the night of surgery (p= 0.04).

Conclusion: Day-stay ACL reconstruction was well tolerated by most patients.


J.A.L Hart D. Bardana J. Paddle-Ledinik

Aim: To evaluate the repair of articular cartilage defects in the knee treated by autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI), using arthroscopic assessment.

Method: One hundred and six articular cartilage defects in 79 knees of 77 patients were treated by ACI. The chondrocytes were injected beneath a periosteal flap (Brittberg et al, 1994).

Arthroscopy and removal of the metal implants were performed nine months following implantation. The ICRS score was used to assess the repairs.

Results: Of the 79 knees 43.5% of the lesions involved the patella, 35.2% the femoral condyles, 16.7% the trochlea, and 4.6% the tibial condyles. The average defect size was 254.65mm2. It was found that 20% of knees had more than one defect. Associated biomechanical procedures were carried out in 88.7%.

Seventy lesions in 58 knees (56 patients) have been assessed; four eligible patients were not assessed arthroscopically. The ICRS scores (maximum 12) were: tibial condyle 11.5; patella 11.3; femoral condyle 11.0, and trochlea 10.7. Synovitis was markedly reduced in all knees with well-healed defects. Adhesions between the periosteal graft and the synovium caused a click in 11 patients, which was relieved by arthroscopic resection. Incomplete healing occurred in one patient with a wound dehiscence, in two following a fall in the post-operative period, and in one patient with a non-contained defect. Biopsies at arthroscopy showed predominantly hyaline cartilage.

Conclusions: We concluded that ACI was an effective method of repairing articular cartilage defects. In this series the results for the patella matched those for the femoral condyle, attributed to the simultaneous biomechanical correction of patellofemoral dysplasia. Stabilisation of the articular surface resulted in resolution of synovitis.


K. Mulpuri P. Cundy P.B. Sharpe A. Chan.

Aim: The neonatal screening procedure in South Australia has shown that the late diagnosis of developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) is rare with well conducted clinical screening. We studied the cases of late diagnosis of DDH to determine the epidemiological features and the out come of management with special reference to development of the femoral head and acetabulum.

Methods: Patients’ case records and radiographs with a delayed diagnosis of DDH, identified by the South Australian Birth Defects Register between 1988 and 1993, were reviewed. Epidemiological features, acetabular angles, size of femoral head, spherical index, CE angle and migration percentage were examined. The Severin’s grouping and Makey’s criteria were used to assess radiological and clinical outcomes. Late DDH was defined as DDH diagnosed after three months of age.

Results: The acetabular angles and percentage coverage improved rapidly -faster in younger children. The CE angle also improved rapidly. When treatment was started late (after one year) the improvement was slower and final out come was unpredictable. The femoral head continued to grow irrespective of age at reduction and became normal in most cases. In some patients Salter osteotomies stabilised the hips after open reductions and gave excellent results. The epidemiological features were compared with that of DDH diagnosed early in postnatal life.

Conclusions: Clinical screening and early detection is important in the outcome of DDH. Early treatment may give better results.


D.G. Little P. Williams N.C. Smith J. Briody C. Cowell L. Bilston

Aim: To examine the effect of the bisphosphonate zoledronic acid in doses of 0.1mg/kg on new bone formation and stress shielding in a distraction-osteogenesis model in New Zealand white rabbits.

Method: Thirty male rabbits underwent a right tibial osteotomy at eight weeks of age. Distraction of the osteotomy by 0.75mm/day was performed for two weeks followed by four weeks for consolidation. Group I was given saline infusions, Group II zoledronic acid at surgery, and Group III received zoledronic acid at surgery and again at two weeks. DXA scans evaluated BMC and BMD. Quantitative computerised tomography measured the cross-sectional areas. Four-point bend testing of both distracted and non-operated tibiae was performed in a standardised fashion.

Results: Bone mineral accretion between two and four weeks was significantly higher in treated versus saline groups, and was better maintained at six weeks (P< 0.01 ANOVA). Stress shielding osteopaenia that was seen in surrounding bone segments in Group I (controls) was abolished in the treated groups. By six weeks there was a 49% and 59% increase in cross sectional area of new bone in Groups II and III respectively (P< 0.01 ANOVA). Group II tibiae were 29% stronger in four-point bending, while Group III were 89% stronger than Group I (P< 0.01 ANOVA). There was little detectable effect on the non-operated tibiae.

Conclusions: Zoledronic acid administration significantly increased the rate and amount of new bone formation and its mineralisation. The increases in bone formation and retention translated to a significant, dose-dependent increase in strength. Further research into the role of zoledronic acid in orthopaedic surgery is indicated.


R. Rowan H.A. Crawford

Introduction: The management of idiopathic talipes equino varus remains controversial. Excellent long term results have been reported with non operative management using the Ponseti technique.

Aim: To assess prospectively the early radiologic and clinical results in idiopathic club feet treated in New Zealand by the Ponseti technique.

Method: We have reviewed prospectively 29 feet in 19 consecutive patients presenting with idiopathic club feet. The initial assessment consisted of a clinical examination, assessment of the Pirani score and clinical photographs. At follow-up the Pirani score, ankle range of motion, foot length and calf circumference were measured and radiographs were taken. Follow-up was at an average age of 7.3 months.

Results: The Pirani score improved from an average of 4.9 to 0.5. The range of motion averaged 32 degrees dorsiflexion and 42 degrees plantar flexion. Radiographs showed good correction of the hindfoot with a mean talocalcaneal index of 55 degrees, and a dorsiflexion tibiocalcaneal angle of 62 degrees. A normal mean AP talo-first metatarsal, AP calcaneo-fifth metatarsal angle, and lateral talo-first metatarsal angle showed good correction of midfoot adductus and cavus. Forced dorsiflexion radiographs showed that ⅗ ths of dorsiflexion motion occurred in the hindfoot and ⅖ ths in the midfoot. Complications were all minor. One non-compliant patient required bilateral posteromedial releases.

Conclusions: This is the largest reported series outside of Iowa City using this technique and the first to show the early radiographic findings. Excellent early clinical and radiographic results have been shown.


THE IRRITABLE HIP Pages 276 - 276
Full Access
D. Muir H. Crawford

The limping or non-weight bearing child can present a difficult diagnostic dilemma. It may be possible to avoid admission of a large proportion of these patients if septic arthritis or other serious pathology can be exclude d.

We have established a continuing, prospective study of all patients admitted for hip pain (with normal radiographs) to Starship Children’s’ Hospital between two and 13 years of age. Forty-two patients had a final diagnosis of transient synovitis. Only two patients during an eight month period had septic arthritis. Due to small numbers of patients with serious pathology we compared the transient synovitis group with a retrospective review of those with septic arthritis treated at Starship Hospital in the previous four years.

Following comparisons of these two groups, we found that there was a greater incidence of septic arthritis in Maori and Pacific Islanders and septic arthritis tended to occur in younger children. The patients’ initial history, temperature, white cell count and ESR were sensitive in discriminating between septic arthritis and irritable hip.

Once the diagnosis of “irritable hip” was made it was unlikely to be altered. We therefore would recommend that it is possible to avoid admission in a large number of these patients. We would however continue to recommend admission for those with a clear history of current illness, Maori or Pacific Islanders, children under the age of four, those with an elevated temperature, and any patient with an elevated white cell count especially neutrophil count or ESR.


S. Walsh F. Phillips

Deep vein thrombosis is uncommon in children but can occur given certain circumstances. Protein C deficiency has recently been described in a child with deep vein thrombosis complicating septic arthritis. We present four case reports of children who developed deep vein thrombosis in association with musculoskeletal sepsis. All had evidence of musculoskeletal sepsis and thrombosis. One child died. Prothrombotic screens were performed demonstrating normal haematological parameters in the three surviving children. The high mortality of deep vein thrombosis complicating musculoskeletal sepsis is emphasised, particularly the potential for septic embolic complications. Deep vein thrombosis should be considered in any child with musculoskeletal sepsis and generalised limb swelling. Early recognition and treatment can lead to favourable outcomes.


D.G. Little P. Williams J. Briody C. Cowell

The bisphosphonate, pamidronate, has been used successfully in our hospital for the management of osteogenesis imperfecta with an excellent safety profile in growing children. We have performed several research studies on distraction osteogenesis in New Zealand white rabbits showing significant increases in new bone formation and the abolition of stress shielding osteopaenia using both pamidronate and zoledronic acid. Recent studies have shown that bisphosphonates positively effect osteoblasts as well as inhibiting osteoclastic bone resorption.

We present a series of early cases where this research has been used in humans. Two cases of pamidronate assisted distraction osteogenesis are presented, one of which also had congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia, which united after pamidronate administration.

Two cases of post-traumatic avascular necrosis have been successfully treated such that osteolysis and collapse of the necrotic femoral head did not occur. Bisphosphonates may act to slow bone resorption while simultaneously increasing new bone formation, such that the mechanical integrity of the necrotic segment can be maintained during revascularisation.

A randomised controlled trial of bisphosphonates in distraction osteogenesis at our hospital has now received ethical approval. Newer bisphosphonates have proven their clinical value in osteogenesis imperfecta and adult osteoporosis, but other potential roles are emerging for these compounds, which have extremely potent effects on bone.


D.G. Little M. Hile M. Uglow J. Briody L. Bilston

Aim: To examine the effect of the low intensity ultrasound stimulation (SAFHS, Exogen) on new bone formation and stress shielding in a distraction osteogenesis model in New Zealand white rabbits.

Methods: Thirty male rabbits underwent a right tibial osteotomy at eight weeks of age. Distraction of the osteotomy by 0.75mm/day was performed for two weeks. Ultrasound stimulation commenced on the seventh day after wound healing. The ‘active’ group was stimulated for 20 minutes daily. The controls had identical dummy stimulators applied. Half of the animals were culled at four weeks and half at six weeks. Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry scans evaluated BMC and BMD. Quantitative computerised tomography measured the cross-sectional areas. Four-point bend testing of distracted and non-operated tibiae was performed in a standardised fashion.

Results: No differences were identified between the active and control groups at four or six weeks with respect to BMD, BMC or cross-sectional area of the regenerated bone. Stress shielding osteopaenia was unaffected by ultrasound stimulation. No significant improvement in strength of the regenerate was identified in either group – there was a trend towards improved strength at four weeks.

Discussion: Low intensity pulsed ultrasound accelerates fracture healing in humans when immobilised by plaster of Paris. One published study purporting to show improvement in distraction osteogenesis is fatally flawed. We believe the intensity of the ultrasound may need to be increased to stimulate mechanically a bone rigidly fixed by an external fixator. Other interventions such as the use of growth factors or bisphosphonates provide much greater improvements in experimental animals and are much more convenient to apply.


L. Kandel T. Diamond C. Bryant R. Sekel

Background: Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry has been validated as an accurate method for assessing periprosthetic bone loss around the femoral stem after uncemented total hip arthroplasty. A prospective longitudinal study was conducted to evaluate bone mineral density (BMD) changes around a series of double-threaded cone-shaped modular femoral stems.

Methods: Sixty-two hips with implanted double-threaded cone-shaped femoral stems were scanned in the antero-posterior femoral plane using a Lunar DPXL densitometer with special software. The initial BMD scan was performed between two and four weeks after the surgery and thereafter yearly for up to three years.

Results: Significant changes occurred during the first year after surgery. In the proximal femur the mean BMD decreased to 73%, by17% in the calcar area and to 91%, by13% in the greater trochanter region. In the middle part of the stem the mean BMD decreased to 86%, by 17% on the medial side and to 84%, 12% on the lateral side. No significant changes occurred around the distal part of the stem. During the second and third postoperative years, small progressive changes in BMD were noticed in all Gruen zones, in keeping with age-related bone loss.

Conclusions: Significant decreases in BMD around the prosthetic femoral stem in the proximal parts of the femur were recorded during the first postoperative year. These changes may be explained by the metaphyseal-diaphyseal gripping prosthesis design. No significant distal changes were found.


R.P. Pitto W. Kalender R. Schmidt

Introduction: Little is known about periacetabular bone remodelling and stress shielding after total hip arthroplasty.

Aim: To analyse prospectively the bone changes around an acetabular component using high resolution computerised tomography (CT).

Methods: A sequential CT scan mode was used (140kv and 206mA, table feed 10mm, slide thickness 2mm). Special software (IMPACT-HIP, VAMP, Germany) was used for bone density (BD) measurements. Parameters of the assessment were: BD of cancellous, cortical and full bone, bone-implant-contact area, bone-area. Twenty patients with degenerative osteoarthrosis (20 hips) were operated on using an uncemented, pressfit, acetabular component and alumina-alumina pairing (Cerafit, Ceraver Osteal, France). The average age of patients was 57 years. CT examinations were performed after two weeks and again one year after the operation. Measurement of BD of the contralateral hip was conducted as a control.

Results: Cancellous bone showed a decrease of BD ranging from 20% to 23% in the caudal portion of the periacetabular area and a decrease ranging from 8% to 12% in the cranial portion. The cortical BD increased 6% at the cranial portion of the periacetabular area. Only slight changes of cortical BD were observed at the caudal portion.

Conclusions: The study showed a significant atrophy of the cancellous bone around the cup, but limited changes of the cortical bone. Periacetabular stress shielding is a little recognised phenomenon which requires further investigations. The method used in the present study allowed analysis of bone changes by 3D-viewing of the acetabulum and by separation of cancellous and cortical bone.


N. Cleaver G. Gillett

Aim: To assess the impact of three different entry points of the femoral canal preparation with regard to cement mantle thickness in the saggital plane.

Methods: We reviewed the literature to find that little has been written on the cement mantle thickness in the saggital plane. We reviewed randomly 60 total hip replacements performed at our institution to discover a common error of a thin cement mantle anteriorly (proximally) and posteriorly (distally) in the saggital plane.

We used standard saw-bone preparations of two prosthetic hip systems: Friendly (Lima) and Exeter (Stryker). In each hip system we performed five preparations for each entry point (trochanteric fossa, posterolateral corner and mid point of the cut neck). The only variable was the entry point. Preparation was performed according to the manufacturers’ recommendations. The preparations were x-rayed and cement mantle alignment and thickness were measured on the x-rays. Saggital sections with digital imaging and radial measurements were also performed.

Results: The results showed a strong trend towards neutral alignment (antero-posterior (AP) and saggital) and a uniform cement mantle with trochanteric fossa preparation. There was an increasing trend to varus alignment (AP), angled anterior to posterior alignment (saggital) and incomplete cement mantles with postero-lateral corner and mid point of cut neck preparation.

Conclusions: We conclude that in cemented femoral replacement, the entry point for canal preparation should be as far lateral and posterior as possible and the trochanteric fossa is the best to achieve neutral alignment and the complete cement mantle.


G.G. Valdivia M.J. Dunbar D.A. Parker M.R. Woolfrey R.W. McCalden C.H. Rorabeck R.B. Bourne

Introduction: The cement mantle is a critical factor in the longevity of cemented total hip arthroplasty (THA). Concern has been raised about the reliability of plain radiographs for its assessment. A new high-definition, three-dimensional (3-D), in vitro method of cement mantle evaluation has been developed.

Aim: To compare cement mantle quality in six contemporary stem designs.

Methods: Exact resin replicas of six contemporary stem designs were implanted into cadaver femora using third generation techniques. The specimens were imaged with a high-speed, helical, computerised, tomographic scanner. Computer-assisted, 3-D analysis of the cement mantle thickness was made. Comparisons were made between different stem designs and also with plain film assessments of the mantles.

Results: Standard radiographs overestimated mantle thickness (p< 0.05) and underestimated the deficiencies. The percentage area of cement mantle that was thinner than 2mm ranged from 9% to 28%. Slight malrotation or malalignment of the stem with respect to the broach envelope produced deficient mantles. Characteristic patterns of deficiencies were seen for different stem designs.

Conclusions: Plain x-rays overestimated the cement thickness, frequently missed areas of substandard cement, and should, therefore, be interpreted cautiously. The cement mantle varies widely depending on the stem design and surgical technique, and commonly used designs have significant deficiencies in their mantles by standard criteria despite proper surgical technique. Surgeons should be familiar with the stem that they use and its instrumentation to maximise outcomes. This is a valuable technique for the study of the cement mantle as it relates to implant design, surgical technique and patient anatomy.


P.J. Papantoniou L. Kandel R. Sekel

Introduction: Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) measurement is a valuable and accurate method of assessing periprosthetic bone loss around femoral stems.

Method: The cohort was 21 patients who underwent total hip arthroplasties with double-threaded, cone-shaped, modular, femoral stems and who already had a prosthetic contralateral hip. The contralateral hip arthroplasties were Autophur fully porous coated, Exeter cemented and Charnley cemented stems. DEXA measurements were performed in the anteroposterior femoral plane using a Lunar DPXL densitometer and analysed using the Lunar Orthopaedic Software Package, Version 1.7, designed for periprosthetic measurements. The initial measurement was performed between two and four weeks after the surgery as a baseline and then repeated after three, six, 12 and 24 months. The DEXA scan results were analysed comparing the bone density of the double-threaded cone-shaped modular femoral stem side with the contralateral side in a longitudinal study.

Results: The contralateral hip bone quality remained fairly constant in keeping with the maturity of the hip arthroplasties. The insertion of the double-threaded cone-shaped modular femoral stem caused the expected initial bone loss in Gruen zones one and seven due to proximal stress-shielding. Only minor bone loss occurred distally, reflecting good fixation and load transfer of the prosthesis.


F.S. Santori N. Santori

Introduction: Stem alignment and cement mantle thickness influence stress distribution on the cement-bone and the bone-cement interfaces. Malposition of the implant and an incomplete cement mantle can lead to suboptimal long-term results. The proximal and distal centralisers that are currently available have shown severe limitations in their clinical application and do not centralise the stem in the lateral plane.

Aim: To evaluate a new stem-positioning system.

Method: One hundred Friendly (Lima LTO) stems implanted between October 1999 and October 2000 have been evaluated radiographically for stem centralisation and cement mantle thickness in both projections. One surgeon used the same technique in all patients and employed a newly designed set of proximal and distal centralisers.

Results: All cases had an acceptable and complete cement mantle. In only seven cases cement thickness was below 2mm in Gruen zone 14. Stem-bone contact was never observed. No patient had migration of the distal plug during pressurisation or complete cement defects. In eight cases mild (2 degrees to 4 degrees) valgus deviation of the stem was found. None of the distal centralisers failed whilst one of the proximal centralisers broke during insertion of the stem without influencing the final result.

Discussion: Cementing the stem is the most delicate phase of cemented total hip replacement. The use of proximal and distal centralisers is mandatory to prevent malposition which in turn results in incomplete cement mantle. The system employed in this series appears accurate and reproducible for stem alignment.


W.L Walter W.K. Walter W. Walsh M. O’Sullivan B. Zicat

Introduction: Acetabular osteolysis is common behind cups with holes (the reported incidence is 9% to 36%). Fluid pressure has been implicated in the pathogenesis of osteolysis.

Aim: To test the hypothesis that a polyethylene liner in a metal cup can act as a pump in vivo.

Methods: This study was performed during revision surgery in six cases. The components were from several manufacturers. All were ingrown uncemented cups that had osteolytic lesions associated with holes in the cup.

A cannula was placed through the capsule into the hip joint and another was placed through the periosteum and bone of the ilium into the osteolytic lesion above the ingrown cup. The continuity of these two spaces through the holes in the cup was confirmed by the injection of methylene blue. Pressure transducers were then connected to both cannulae. Measurements were taken while applying compression and distraction forces across the artificial hip joint.

Results: Compression and distraction loads produced a rise (48mmHg) and a fall (35mmHg) respectively in the pressure in the osteolytic lesion but no change in the hip joint pressure, thereby, demonstrating a pumping action. After exposing the prosthesis we were able to demonstrate 1mm to 2mm of in-out excursion of the polyethylene liner in the metal cup, which may explain the mechanism of the pumping effect.

Discussion: The polyethylene liner in the metal shell can act as a pump. Compression and distraction forces, such as occur in normal gait, produce changes in fluid pressure, which are transmitted through the holes and may cause osteolysis behind the cup.


Full Access
S.C. Parkinson G. Hooper

Hypotheses:

A subject’s response to commonly used knee assessment scores is variable, even in the presence of a normal knee.

The subjective response to a knee score is dependent on age and cultural expectations.

Methods: A group of 150 New Zealand subjects with normal knees were given three commonly used knee assessment questionnaires. There were three age groups with 50 subjects in each group: 20 to 40, 40 to 60 and above 60 years of age. All were examined to determine that each knee was objectively normal. This group was then compared with a similar group of Canadian subjects and the results were analysed.

Results: The results showed significant differences in expectation between the age groups, with the older age group less happy to score maximum points for their ‘normal’ knee. The Hospital for Special Surgery Knee Score scored the lowest followed by the Knee Society Knee Score. In the over 60 years group there was a significant difference between the New Zealand and Canadian subjects with the Canadians tending to score higher in all scores.

Conclusions: These results have implications when trying to compare results of total knee arthroplasty between different countries and age groups. This study has been expanded to include other countries in an attempt to find a mathematical formula to make future comparisons more relevant.


R.P. Pitto G. Willmann D. Schwämmlein

Aim: To provide information on treatment outcomes for patients who received an acetabular component inserted with a polyethylene liner and to compare the results with those of patients who received the same acetabular component inserted with an alumina liner.

Methods Sixty consecutive patients (60 hips) with osteoarthrosis were allocated to two matched-pair groups. The patients were matched for age, gender, body-mass-index, level of activity, and bone stock. The first group of 30 hips (control group) received a total hip arthroplasty with a press-fit acetabular component, a polyethylene liner and an alumina femoral head. The second group of 30 hips (alumina group) was operated on using the same prosthesis, but an alumina liner was inserted instead of polyethylene.

Results: At a mean follow-up of five years (4.5 to 5.5 years) the mean Harris hip score was 94.1 points in the control group, and 92.7 points in the alumina group. No hip required revision, and there was no radiographic evidence of aseptic loosening.

Discussion: Modular acetabular components with alumina liners are currently used in total hip arthroplasty, but concerns have emerged regarding their high stiffness, which could cause impairment of stability, stress-shielding phenomena, and early loosening. In the present study, the acetabular components with an alumina liner functioned well overall and patient satisfaction was high at an average of five years postoperatively. Clinical and radiological results did not contrast with those achieved using the same prosthesis with a polyethylene liner.


D.A. Parker M.J. Dunbar G.G. Valdivia R.B. Bourne C.H. Rorabeck

Introduction: Range of motion is an invariable outcome -measure in studies on total knee arthroplasty (TKA) and other knee surgery. Concluding that a certain change in motion equals a corresponding change in outcome may be invalid if true accuracy of current measuring techniques is unknown. This is integral to many studies. Surprisingly little has been done to validate these techniques.

Methods: Maximum extension and flexion were measured in 32 TKAs by four independent observers using three common techniques: visual estimate (VE), pocket and universal goniometers (PG and UG). Lateral radiographs in reproducible positions were measured using computer analysis, providing a gold standard for comparison with clinical measurements. The correlation coefficients and coefficients of reliability were calculated.

Results: There were no significant differences between observers using any method. Significant differences were found between each technique and radiographic measure (paired t-test, p< 0.001). Correlation coefficients were lower for extension estimates (0.76–0.80) than flexion (0.91–0.96). Coefficients of repeatability varied from 11.6 degrees to 12.1 degrees for extension measurements and from 13.8 degrees to 19.2 degrees for flexion measurements, with UG being the most accurate. The VE accuracy approached that of UG only at easily visualised angles such as 90 degrees. The coefficient of repeatability for radiographic measure was significantly lower at 2.9 degrees.

Conclusions: Clinical measurements of range of motion vary significantly from radiographic measurement, with the computer assisted radiographic measurement providing high reliability as the gold standard. UG is most accurate, followed by PG and VE. However, coefficients of repeatability were surprisingly large, indicating the degree of accuracy of each measurement technique and the necessary magnitude of difference for this to be outside measurement error. This has relevance for all outcome studies and everyday clinical practice.


P.J. Papantoniou

Introduction: Pre-operative templates for total knee arthroplasty are routinely provided by the manufacturers. These often provide a representation of the required size of prosthesis and of the bone cuts. A common deficiency is that the actual cuts made by the jigs are angulated to allow for factors such as distal femoral angulation and back-slope on the tibia. The templates that were provided do not take into account this built in angulation and can lead to bone cuts which appear different to the cuts determined by the template. This factor is taken into account by the surgeon intra-operatively but leaves a situation where estimation is replacing pre-operative planning.

Method and Results: New universal templates have been produced as an adjunct those provided to take into account this angulation. A mathematical proof of the exact difference between various angle templates and right-angle templates yield significant variation in thickness of bone cuts. Using an average of 80mm width of the femur, a difference of 7.0mm in bone cuts is obtained with a five degree template compared with a right-angle template. A tibial anterior-posterior distance of 50mm yields a 2.62mm difference in bone cuts with a back slope of three degrees when compared with that predicted by a right-angle template.

Conclusions: The use of right-angle templates in total knee arthroplasty for sizing should be supplemented with angled templates to allow an accurate assessment of bone cuts to be made.


L. Kohan L. Harris W. Walsh

Introduction: Whether or not to resurface the patella in total knee replacement (TKR) is controversial. One concern is the possibility of progression of the arthritis in the patellofemoral joint that has not been resurfaced when exposed to the stress of articulating with the femoral component.

Methods: The cohort comprised six knees for Trac TKA (Biomet). The assessment involved the use of an electronic sensor system(Iscan, Tekscan). The readings were taken on an anaesthetised patient, during surgery. A tourniquet was not used. A subvastus operative approach was used.

Results: The contact area and contact stress increased with flexion with and without the femoral component in place. We measured no increase in patellar stress when the patella that had not been resurfaced articulated with the femoral component.


P.M. Sutton N. Stewart B.R. Tietjens

Radial cleavage tears of the lateral meniscus are uncommon and may be associated with a meniscal cyst. There is a recognised association of these lesions with radiographically visible erosions of the lateral tibial plateau; however, this association is reported to be rare. We believe this radiographic feature is more common than previously reported and as most reports are limited to the radiology literature it is not widely appreciated by Orthopaedic Surgeons. The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of this valuable radiographic sign in patients with a proven radial cleavage tear and draw attention to it among Orthopaedic Surgeons.

We identified 20 patients from our prospectively collected database that had undergone an arthroscopic partial lateral meniscectomies for radial cleavage tears of the lateral menisci. A consultant radiologist (NS) independently assessed the pre-operative radiographs of these patients, specifically looking for the presence of erosions of the tibiae below the lateral joint line. Of 20 patients assessed 9(45%) had radiographically visible bone erosions.

Our study confirms our clinical experience that patients with symptoms and signs suggestive of a radial cleavage tear of the lateral meniscus frequently have an associated plain radiographic sign to support the clinical diagnosis.


K.D. Mohammed J. Sharr

Aim: To determine the accuracy of the posterior-to-anterior (PA) 15 degrees caudad view of the clavicle to assess amount of shortening of clavicular fractures. Method: The first stage of the study involved taking x-rays of an adult skeleton, centred on the clavicle. The projections included the standard anterior-to-posterior (AP) 15 degrees cephalad view, and the PA 15 degrees caudad view. Additional images were taken in the 15 degrees caudad view with a series of oblique rotational views, and oblique images in the vertical plane. Metal markers were placed on the clavicle at 10mm intervals. The clavicular length and the interval between markers were measured on the x rays.The second stage of the study involved obtaining the PA 15 degrees caudad x-ray on 50 patients with clavicular fractures. The non injured clavicle was also x-rayed. The lengths of the non injured clavicle and the lengths of the fragments of the fractured clavicle were recorded.

Results: The length of the clavicle of the skeleton in the AP standard image was 149mm. The length in the PA 15 degrees caudad image was 130mm, with a maximum of 4mm variation on the oblique views up to 30 degrees. The true length was 124mm.Forty-five fractures were diaphyseal, and five were outer third fractures. There was less than 5mm measured difference in the length of injured and non injured clavicle in 38 out of 45 patients with diaphyseal fractures (84%).

Conclusions: The PA 15 degrees caudad clavicular x-ray provided a more accurate assessment of clavicular shortening than the standard AP view, and was well tolerated by the patients.


C. Vasili D. Duckworth D. Bokor

Introduction: Mid-shaft clavicular fractures that are displaced and shortened are often treated surgically. The standard technique in the past has been to use plate fixation. However, in the last five years intramedullary fixation has been popularised. To our knowledge no recent study has compared the outcomes of intramedullary pinning and plating of displaced mid-shaft clavicular fractures.

Method: We retrospectively evaluated 40 patients with mid-shaft clavicular fractures. Twenty patients had plate fixation and twenty patients had intramedullary fixation for exactly the same fracture pattern. Each patient filled out a standardised questionnaire particular to clavicular fractures and was assessed using the Shoulder Score Index of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons and the Constant Score. A physical examination was performed and individual radiographs were assessed to determine the state of union.

Results: All fractures that were treated with intramedullary pin fixation went on to union within two to three months. There was one nonunion in the plate fixation group requiring revision surgery. The results revealed no significant difference in the functional outcome scores. There were however fewer complications, less scar related paraesthesia, shorter stay in hospital, and earlier mobilization in the group who underwent intramedullary pinning.

Conclusions: Our results suggested that both techniques of intramedullary pinning and plating resulted in good long-term functional outcomes for patients with acute mid-shaft clavicular fractures. Intramedullary pinning, however, resulted in fewer short-term complications. From this study the method of fixation for mid-shaft clavicle fractures should be determined by the surgeon’s preference and expertise.


J.M. Scarvell P.N. Smith D. Lane H. Galloway K.M. Reshauge

Aim: A method of analysing the kinematics of the knee has been developed using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at regular intervals of knee motion. This method was tested for reliability and applied to normal and injured knees.

Method: MRI scans were used to study knees of 11 healthy subjects and knees of eight patients ACL with injuries. Scans were taken at 15 degrees intervals from 0 degrees to 90 degrees flexion, using a positioning jig to enable scanning with the knees either loaded or unloaded. The tibiofemoral contact points were mapped for each knee position, loaded and unloaded, in the medial and lateral compartments. The data were analysed for repeatability by interclass correlation and compared with known data.

Results: High reliability was achieved using T1 weighted fast spin echo images, scanned into Adobe Photoshop, or gradient echo sequences, downloaded as Dicom files and analysed using Osiris. Gradient echo sequences have advantages in efficiency without loss of reliability. Analysis of ACL-deficient knees confirmed aberrant contact-point behaviour compared with the non-injured side. The results showed that right and left normal knees and loaded and unloaded uninjured knees did not demonstrate significant differences but that medial and lateral condyles did demonstrate significant differences reflecting the longitudinal rotation of the knee during flexion.

Conclusions: The technique of MR imaging of the knee for kinematic analysis has been demonstrated to be robust and reliable. This technique may be applied to assessments of the effect of knee injury on the biomechanics of the knee or the results of surgical and physiotherapy interventions.


G.W. Brick K. Chin P.J. Tsahakis

Introduction: Diffuse pigmented villo-nodular synovitis (DPVNS) of the knee remains a difficult tumor to eradicate. We report our experience with a combined posterior and open synovectomy technique.

Method: A single surgeon operated on 40 patients averaging 35 years old (14 to 68 years). The patients were placed into one of three groups: group I received surgery alone (five patients), group II had surgery and intra-articular radiation synovectomy using Dysprosium-165 (165Dy) (30 patients), and group III had surgery and external beam radiation (5 patients). The adjuvant radiation was performed three months postoperatively. MRI evaluation was used preoperatively and post-operatively.

Results: The average combined Knee Society Scores and range of motion improved. Thirty-seven patients (92.5%) had a good or excellent results; two (5%) had a fair result; and one (2.5%) had a poor result. There were seven recurrences (17.5%). None occurred in group I; five occurred in group II (12.5%); and two occurred in group III (5%).

Discussion & Conclusions: This technique allowed excellent visualisation and removal of intra- and extra-articular DPVNS tissue with excellent functional results and few recurrences documented by MRI. Adjuvant intra-articular radiotherapy may be beneficial for small foci of residual disease but complete resection of all DPVNS tissue was the key to prevent recurrence. External beam radiation did not prevent recurrence and possibly predisposed patients to pain and less improvement in knee flexion. Extensive pre-operative degenerative joint disease predisposes patients to continued pain.


J. Rush J. Bartlett C. Gibbons

Aim: To test the hypothesis that open surgical synovectomy of the knee results in better long-term control of chronic inflammatory synovitis of the knee than arthroscopic synovectomy.

Method: To test this hypothesis a prospective clinical trial was carried out involving three groups of patients:- In Group I (22 cases in 18 patients) arthroscopic synovectomy was performed by a surgeon experienced in arthroscopy (Bartlett). In Group II (15 cases in 11 patients) open surgical synovectomy / debridement was performed (Rush). In Group III (10 cases in seven patients) arthroscopic lavage was carried without synovectomy (Rush) and this acted as a “control” group. The patients were followed up for some 10 years. At the final review the clinical and functional scores were recorded using the H.S.S. knee score system. There are obvious problems in comparing two or three groups of patients from two separate units and these are discussed.

Results: The results showed that in both groups (i.e. Groups I & II) there was a significant shift to the right in the clinical and functional scores. This did not occur in the “control” group. In Group I, two cases out of 22 came to total knee replacement. In Group II, four cases out of 15 and in Group III, five cases out of 10 came to knee replacement.

Conclusions: It was concluded that knee synovectomy was a worthwhile procedure and that arthroscopic synovectomy was just as good and probably better than open surgical synovectomy but it needs to be done early and by a surgeon with experience in carrying out this difficult procedure.


ACE HUMERAL PLATES Pages 280 - 280
Full Access
S.G. Doig G. Hoy C. Kondogiannis

Proximal humeral fractures may be treated by joint replacement or internal fixation. We have been concerned by the unpredictable results of hemiarthroplasty in the trauma situation. At The Alfred hospital, we have used the ACE proximal humeral plate over the last three years. This is a retrospective study of 55 cases, looking at the outcome of internal fixation, the incidence of avascular necrosis, and the functional results. The results were very favourable when compared with the results of other series that have been published in the literature. Our conclusion is that it is better to internally-fix these fractures whenever possible.


Full Access
J. Sinclair

This is a review of the literature detailing the causes, presentation and appropriate investigations of patients with suprascapular nerve compression. The choices of treatment are discussed in the context of the pathology found. The recommended surgical procedures are described. Suprascapular nerve compression is an uncommon cause of persisting and diffuse shoulder pain that arises from direct trauma to the shoulder or as a result of repetitive, overhead manoeuvres producing a traction type injury.

The presence of tenderness over the suprascapular notch, weakness in external rotation and especially the presence of infraspinatus or supraspinatus atrophy (either separately or in combination) with positive nerve conduction studies confirm the diagnosis of suprascapular nerve entrapment. MRI is recommended for identification of a cause of the nerve compression. Fibrous transverse ligaments have been seen causing stenosis and entrapment at the suprascapular and spinoglenoid notch. A variety of space-occupying lesions can be found in the notches including supraglenoid ganglia and tumours.

Initial conservative management of the shoulder is recommended when the neuropathy results from repetitive activity in the absence of a space-occupying lesion. Early decompression of the nerve using arthroscopic debridement of the labrum and open release of the ligaments at the suprascapular and spinoglenoid notch is advocated in the presence of a ganglion cyst.


B.S. Miller W.P. Harper J.V. Perez R.M. Gillies D.H. Sonnabend W.R. Walsh

Introduction: Arthrodesis of the shoulder joint is appropriate for several conditions, including paralysis, degenerative disease, infection, and salvage of failed arthroplasty. Two common complications of shoulder fusion, non-union and unacceptable arm position, may reflect failure to achieve rigid fixation during the surgical procedure. Numerous fixation techniques have been described, including plate fixation, external fixation, and screw fixation.

Aim: To compare the biomechanics of five fixation techniques of shoulder fusion in a human cadaveric model.

Methods: Twenty-five shoulder fusions were carried out in fresh-frozen human cadaveric specimens with the following five techniques: screw fixation alone (n=5), external fixation alone (n=5), external fixation supplemented with screw fixation (n=5), single plate fixation (n=5), and double plate fixation (n=5). Each specimen was tested on a servo-hydraulic machine under repeated physiologic loads to determine the bending and torsional stiffness.

Results: There was a statistically significant difference in bending and torsional stiffness between all five fixation techniques (ANOVA, p< 0.05). Normalised bending (B) and torsional (T) stiffness, in descending order, were: double plate (B=1.0, T=1.0), single plate (B=0.77, T=0.89), external-fixation with screws (B=0.68, T=0.74), external-fixation alone (B=0.40, T=0.53), and screws alone (B=0.13, T=0.26).

Discussion & Conclusion: Statistically significant differences in bending and torsional stiffness have been identified using five different techniques of shoulder fusion. The risk of the most common complications of this surgical procedure, non-union and unacceptable arm position, may be minimised if these biomechanical findings are applied to surgical decision-making.


R.L. Somerville R. Kyd

Aim: To review a single surgeon’s experience of EIG for femoral and acetabular revision arthroplasty.

Method: A retrospective review of EIG revisions from Waikato Hospital from May, 1995 to November, 2000. The notes and x-rays of patients from this time were reviewed. All x-rays were reviewed by the senior author.

Results: There were thirty-two revisions using the EIG system. The indication for revision in all cases was aseptic loosening of either or both of the acetabular or femoral components. There were 14 men and 12 women. Four patients had bilateral revisions. One required bilateral revisions to be repeated. The average age was 79 years and nine months (range: 53 to 90 years). The average time from initial hip replacement to revision was 10.4 years (range: 13 months to 24 years).

Sixteen revisions had EIG to femur and acetabulum. Four acetabular cups and 10 femoral stems were revised with EIG alone or in combination with a replacement component.The average period of follow-up was 34 months. One acetabulum was revised for recurrent dislocation. Three other hips dislocated in the post-operative period. Two femoral stems (one patient) were revised again with EIG for subsidence. One is now stable, the other has been exchanged for a Solution stem because of repeated subsidence. The histological specimens taken from these showed the grafted bone was necrotic. One other stem subsided 2mm. There were two intraoperative femoral shaft fractures.

Conclusions: EIG is one solution for complicated revision in the presence of proximal femoral bone stock loss. Subsidence requiring re-revision was been a problem with one patient.


H.D.H. Leslie D. Backstein P. Weiler W. Kraemer

Introduction: The Evan’s staple is an intramedullary device. It has two 20 cm tines connected by a horizontal bar with a hole mid-apex to facilitate insertion over a K-wire and enhance fixation to the humerus by means of a tension band.

Aim: To perform a retrospective review of the results of using the Evan’s staple as a means of fixation for displaced proximal humeral fractures.

Method: Between 1989 and 1997 at the Toronto East General Hospital, 56 patients with displaced proximal humeral fractures were treated with an Evans’ staple. This included 14 three-part and four four-part fractures and six fracture-dislocations. The age range at the time of operation was 18–94 years. The average duration of follow-up was 48.6 months, the range being 11–99 months. The study consisted of patient chart review, radiological review and use of the DASH (Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand) questionnaire.

Results: Complete radiological data were available for 26 patients and these showed a 100% union rate. The majority (77%) healed in neutral, the remainder in varying degrees of varus. Twenty-one patients returned the DASH questionnaire, with an average functional score of 37.8 (0= no disability, 100= severe disability). The complications included eight cases of impingement that required staple removal and one fracture distal to a staple caused by a subsequent fall.

Conclusion: The Evan’s staple is a viable means of fixation for displaced proximal humeral fractures.


F.S. Santori N. Santori

Introduction: Most diaphyseal humeral fractures can be successfully treated with conservative treatment. Nailing is indicated for transverse displaced fractures, pathological or impending fractures, non-unions, fractures with a radial nerve palsy and oblique fractures after failure of conservative treatment. Most surgeons prefer the distal retrograde approach to the humeral canal because of the high incidence of chronic shoulder pain after proximal nailing. However, when using such an approach targeting the holes for proximal static locking is demanding and time consuming. The EXP nail (LIMA LTO) is cannulated and has an original self-looking mechanism that is designed to match the advantages of the retrograde approach. These include rapid proximal locking and reduced radiation exposure.

The proximal locking is achieved by the protrusion of a wire into the medullary bone of the humeral head. Distally the EXP nail has two small wings shaped to sit on the medial and lateral columns of the olecranon fossa.

Cases: We implanted 56 EXP nails in 56 patients. The average surgical time was 40 minutes (min 30, max 110). The average radiation exposure was one minute and 40 seconds (20 seconds for proximal locking). In all cases we obtained fracture union and no patients suffered shoulder pain. In four cases elbow extension was reduced by less than 10. In one case the nail broke but the fracture united.

Conclusions: The EXP humeral nail provides satisfactory stability, it is cannulated and requires minimal radiation exposure.


Y. Yu W. Bruce D.S. Sonnabend W.R. Walsh

Methods: Sixty pseudo-capsular tissues from loose shoulder, hip and knee (20 each) arthroplasties and 30 capsular tissues from primary total joint arthroplasty (TJA) patients (10 each; 12 rheumatoid arthritis [RA], 18 osteo-arthrosis [OA]) were investigated for mRNA and protein expressions of IL-1ß (interleukin-1 b, IL-1Ra (interleukin-1 receptor antagonist), MMP 1 (matrix matalloproteinase-1)-, TIMP 2 (tissue inhibitor of MMPs-2) using in situ hybridisation and immunohistochemistry. Polyethylene and metal debris in the same sections were semi-quantified simultaneously.

Results: IL-1ß mRNA and proteins were expressed in most RA primary and revision tissues and were less expressed in OA primary tissues. In contrast, IL-1Ra mRNA was found in most primary OA tissues and less in RA primary and the revision tissues. The ratio of staining intensities of IL-1ß/IL-1Ra mRNA was higher in revision and primary RA tissues compared with the primary OA tissues. MMP-1 protein expression was correlated with the IL-1ß/IL-1Ra ratio. Polyethylene (PE) debris was found in 56 out of 60 of the revision tissues. Their sizes were different in the hip (mainly small, < 30 mm in diameter), the knee (mainly large, > 300 mm) and the shoulder (all sizes). The expressions of the detected factors were highly correlated with the concentration of the PE debris but with not their sizes.

Conclusions: The high ratio of IL-1ß/IL-1Ra in primary RA and revision tissues and its correlation with MMP-1 expression and PE debris concentration indicated that an over-expression of IL-1ß and/or regulation downwards of IL-1Ra is an important event in inflammatory disorders and the foreign body reaction in TJA. A therapeutic strategy with IL-1Ra, that has been considered in RA treatment may thus contribute to the longevity of prosthesis of a TJA.


D.W. Howie M.A. McGee D. Dunlop K. Costi A. Carbone C. Wildenauer C.R. Howie J. Field

Introduction: New biological approaches to reconstruction of major bone deficiency such as the use of bone substitutes and growth factors are being developed. This paper reports on the adverse response to the Bioglass in comparison to allograft alone.

Aim: To compare the biological response to femoral impaction grafting and a cemented femoral stem when using allograft bone versus allograft bone plus a synthetic bone graft substitute, Bioactive glass.

Methods: Eighteen merino wethers underwent a left cemented hemi-arthroplasty and were randomised to have impaction allografting of the femur using either allograft alone (allograft group) or a 50:50 mix of allograft and Bioactive glass (Bioglass group). After sacrifice at 12 weeks, histological analysis of the femora at the levels of the proximal, mid and distal femoral stem and distal to the stem was undertaken.

Results: In the allograft group, there was a consistent response with bone graft incorporation being greatest in the proximal femur and occurring progressively less, more distally. Mineralised bone apposition in the graft occurred post-operatively after eight weeks. In contrast, in the Bioglass group, the response was inconsistent. Bone graft incorporation was either minimal, or there was partial or complete resorption of the bone graft with replacement by particulate-laden fibrous tissue and resorption of endocortical bone. Inflammation of the capsule tissue was noted in some cases.

Conclusion: In comparison to allograft alone, the use of Bioglass to supplement allograft for use in impaction grafting in ovine hip arthroplasty gave inferior results.


K. Chin G.W. Brick

Introduction: The reconstruction of the severely deficient proximal femur is more commonly achieved with a large composite proximal femoral allograft and a prosthesis.

Aim: To review our experience with this technique in 19 revision total hip arthroplasties (18 patients) treated between December 1988 and January 1997.

Cases: There were 15 females and three males. The average age was 56 years (32 to 78 years). The primary diagnoses included osteoarthritis (seven), rheumatoid arthritis (six), congenital dislocation (two), avascular necrosis (one), septic arthritis (one), and ankylosing spondylitis (one). Each underwent an average of three (range: one to 9) previous hip operations. The average time from the previous operation was 10.65 years (0.25 to 25). All hips had significant periprosthetic osteopenia and bone loss on preoperative radiographs. Five had previous infections with two subsequent Girdlestone arthroplasties. Six presented with periprosthetic fractures and loose components.

The hips were approached posteriorly. A step cut was used to secure the host to allograft junction. The femoral component was cemented within the allograft and with a press-fit in the host bone. All but three cases had iliac crest bone graft and/or residual host bone chips added to the host-allograft site. The acetabulum was revised concurrently in 13 (two whole acetabular allografts).

Results: The average period of follow-up was 57.6 months(range: 25 to 127 months). The time taken to heal was estimated radiographically as less than 8.5 months (range: three to 18 months). The average Harris Hip Scores improved from 25.6 to 75.53. One patient complained of persistent pain post-operatively. The complications included proximal migration of the greater trochanter in five, one infection that was converted to a Girdlestone excisional arthroplasty 27 months later, and seven patients with dislocations.

Conclusions: Allograft prosthetic reconstruction of the proximal femur is a durable construct with up to ten years follow-up. This technique preserved host bone while providing additional bone for future reconstruction. There was substantial improvement in function with low complication rates.


J. Harvey

Aim: To evaluate the outcome of uncemented femoral revision after total hip arthroplasty using the CLS system at Southland Hospital, Invercargill, between 1995 and 2001.

Methods: A retrospective study of 28 hips, representing the total experience of Southland Hospital with the CLS femoral prosthesis for revision surgery. For evaluation we used the Harris Hip Score and reviewed the radiographs.

Results: Twenty-eight hips(23 male and five female),with an average age of 66 years(33 years to 82 years). The mean interval from the primary surgery to the revision was 7.6 years (range one day to 24 years). The majority (60%) of the revisions was for aseptic loosening, 10% for infection, 10% for periprosthetic fracture and the remainder for recurrent dislocation. There was one case of a mismatch of the femoral and acetabular components requiring revision on the same day. The majority of patients reported a favourable outcome, two experienced serious complications, neither requiring revision.

Conclusions: Our results suggested that the CLS stem was a very useful method of correction following failure of total hip arthroplasty, with a high level of patient satisfaction.


R.N. De Steiger

Introduction: Infected hip arthroplasties have usually been managed with either one or two stage revisions using antibiotic impregnated cement to fix the components. The use of cementless fixation has been less widely reported. The results on the femoral side have been less encouraging.

Aim: To present the short to medium term results of cementless revision for infected hip arthroplasty.

Methods: Ten patients who had undergone cementless revisions for infected hip arthroplasties have been followed prospectively. There were eight males and two females with an average age of 67 years. Nine of the 10 patients were treated with two-stage revisions with one female undergoing a one-stage revision for medical reasons. The diagnosis of sepsis was made on the basis of bacterial cultures and positive histology from all patients. Removal of the prosthesis was followed by the administration of intravenous antibiotics for six weeks and, in some, cases oral antibiotics for several months. The reconstructions were undertaken following the Girdlestone’s arthroplasties with a range from eight weeks to three years, (with the exception of the one stage exchange).

Results: The patients were examined from 18 to 64 months after the surgery with none lost to follow-up. All prostheses remained in situ with improvements in the Charnley and Oxford hip scores. There had been no recurrence of infection and no clinical or radiological evidence of loosening.

Discussion: Debate still exists about the merits of one-stage versus two-stage reconstruction for an infected hip arthroplasty. The use of antibiotic-impregnated cement has been recommended, especially for the femoral component. This series demonstrated that cementless reconstruction for infected hip arthroplasty was successful in providing an infection free, stable hip in the short to medium term.


R.M. Gillies M. Yamano M.J. Svehla A. Loefler A. Turner A. Butler W.R. Walsh

Introduction: Various plating devices and screw systems are available for single and multi-level cervical fusions. Recent reports regarding screw migration under torsional load and a “windshield wiper effect” has brought to light the importance of plate and screw design as well as the choice of graft.

Aim: This study examined the relative stability of cervical plating systems under pure bending and axial-torsional fatigue using the Cloward type graft.

Methods: Five fresh-frozen human cervical and 10 porcine spines assessed by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scanning and then reconstructed at the C2–3 and levels using the anterior Cloward technique. C4–5 Two different plating systems (a solid plate and a hollow plate) were used and alternated between the C2–3 and C4–5 levels. Strain gauges placed on the plates themselves. The systems were subjected to pure bending and torsional loading.. Five kilogram loads were used to apply bending moments to the spine and did not differ between the two systems evaluated. Bending moments and displacement angles were recorded for the pure bending loading regime and torque versus time was recorded for the torsional fatigue loading.

Results: Strain gauge analysis revealed minimal strains on the plates under the loading conditions. Torque versus time was measured, and the decay constant was calculated from the decay curves. The hollow plating system decayed quicker than the solid plating system. Angular displacement under pure bending was minimal. The hollow system plate system resisted greater torque compared with the solid system. The decay curves eventually reached an asymptote for the both systems. This implied that the systems become stable under fatigue loading. The X-rays illustrated no failure at the screw/ bone interface (i.e. No “wiper” effect) after torsional fatigue.


R.M. Gillies A. Turner M. Yamano W.J.M. Bruce D. Dennis W.R. Walsh

Introduction: Proximal bone resorption is a common problem after total hip arthroplasty. This has been attributed to stress shielding and has been reported to be more pronounced for cemented than for uncemented implants.

Aim: To investigate the cortical strain distribution of a new proximal “fit and fill” cementless, titanium, femoral, hip prosthesis based on the SROM design.

Methods: Strain gauges were mounted on five fresh-frozen cadaveric and five saw-bone femora and checked against a template for the prosthesis. The strain gauges were placed at four levels on the anterior, posterior, medial and lateral cortices corresponding to the Gruen zones. Two extra strain gauges were placed on the proximal posteromedial cortex. Loading was applied to the intact and reconstructed femora in the ISO 7206–4 orientation and single legged stance in an MTS servo-hydraulic testing machine. Data were analysed using analysis of variance.

Results: The strain distributions following reconstruction and multi-axis loading (ISO 7206–4 orientation) approximated the strains in an intact femur in the diaphysis. The proximal posteromedial cortical strains were approximately 50% of those of the intact femur.

Conclusions: The strains observed in the proximal femur following reconstruction in the present study are considerably higher than most others reported in the literature. A number of factors may contribute to the high proximal strains observed. This study has illustrated that geometric design and material selection along with surgical technique may allow for greater loading to proximal bone and enhance the long term integrity of this type of implant.


Y. Yu K.J. Gifford A.K. Low W.R. Walsh

Introduction: Abnormal fracture healing in aged, post-menopausal or ovariectomised patients remains a clinical problem. Understanding the distribution and regulation of biomolecular factors in fracture healing in oestrogen deficient rats may have clinical implications for developing novel therapeutic strategies for enhancing osteoporotic fracture healing. Our previous work demonstrated that bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs), transforming growth factor beta (TGF-ß) and their signal transducers, Smads, played important roles in normal fracture healing. Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) has been indicated playing a role in the maintenance of bone mass. Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) has been indicated to play a role in bone matrix degradation. Those factors in ovariectomised fracture healing have not yet been reported.

Aim: To investigate the expression of BMP-2, 7, TGF-ß, Smads1–7, IGF-I, IGF-I receptor 1a (IGF-IR1), MMPs and TIMPs by a quantitative immunohistochemistry in a fracture model in an ovariectomised rodent (OVX).

Methods: Age-matched, normal, female rats served as controls. The animals were sacrificed in groups of six at one, two, three, four and six weeks after the fracture.

Results: The highlights of our results were the lack of IGF-I in the early stage of fracture healing (up to two weeks) in OVX rats and the greater expression of MMP-1 in OVX rats at all groups when compared with the normal rats.

Conclusions: Our data suggested that the regulation downward of IGF-I in the OVX fractures resulted from estrogen deficiency and may have the function to stimulate MMP-1 activity. Over-expressed MMP-1 degraded collagen matrix in the cortex and inhibited the woven bone matrix formation during OVX fracture healing.


Full Access
J. Pennington D.P. Gwynne Jones

Aim: A care pathway was introduced into our institution in July 1997 for all patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The aim of this study was to review the effect of this pathway with respect to outcome, length of stay, re-admissions, and complications.

Methods: Using prospectively gathered data from the patient administration system, the department audit and the care pathway system, 443 consecutive patients undergoing unilateral primary TKA between January 1995 and December 1999 were identified. There were 181 patients in the pre-pathway group and 262 pathway patients. Demographic details, complications, length of stay, discharge destination and re-admissions within 90 days were compared between the two groups. Outcome at the time of discharge was assessed in the pathway group.

Results: The patients in the pathway group were older (71.1 vs 69.4 years), the female:male ratio was higher (1.5 vs 1.3). One patient died in hospital in each group. The mean length of stay reduced from 12.8 days to 10.4 days. Only 1.6% pre-pathway and 4% of pathway patients were admitted on the day of surgery. More pathway patients went to a rehabilitation unit (13% vs 7%). The overall complication rate fell (29% to 19%) while the re-admission rate was similar (11% pre, 12% post pathway).

Conclusions: By introducing a care pathway the length of hospital stay was reduced and the complication rate fell without any increase in the re-admission rate or of compromise in the early outcome. An increase in the use of in-patient rehabilitation facilities contributed to the decrease in length of stay. Admission on the day of surgery could decrease length of stay further.


J. C. Theis

Introduction: Waiting times for first specialist assessments (FSA’s) are excessively long and a significant number of patients have to wait for more than six months. Less than 30% of the patients referred to an orthopaedic clinic will require surgery. This means that some patients have to wait over six months to be told that there is no surgical solution to their problem.

Aim: To evaluate the role of ‘paper only’ assessments for FSA’s in orthopaedics.

Method: One hundred GP referrals were selected randomly and all available investigations (mostly x-rays) were retrieved. The referral letters were retyped and the x-rays processed in order to eliminate all identifying information. A pro forma was used to record data including quality of referral letter, clinical information, investigations and recommendation to the GP in the form of a mock letter.

Subsequently the patients were booked into routine orthopaedic clinics without prior knowledge of the investigator and after the face-to-face assessment a letter to the GP was generated. Correlation between the mock and real GP letter was carried out in all cases.

Results: The majority of referrals were for back pain and hip or knee problems. The quality of the referrals was satisfactory with only a small percentage of poor and excellent letters. Pain and physical disability information was more consistently available compared with data on social disability. The X-rays when appropriate were available in most cases.

The correlation between the mock and real letter was outstanding and in over 90% of the cases the face to face assessment did not alter the outcome of the paper assessment.

Conclusions: Paper assessments in orthopaedics are an effective and safe alternative to face-to-face assessments as long as the clinical information in the referral letter is appropriate. This allows for timely advice to the GP and a reduction in waiting times for specialist assessments. This new assessment method is particularly appropriate for conditions that do not benefit from surgery.


S. Faraj J. Cullen

Introduction: Criticism is often made of general practitioners’ referrals to an orthopaedic service in a public hospital. There is often inadequate information about any previous treatment and it is difficult to assess the levels of pain and disability in the individual patient.

Method: A review of 200 referral letters from general practitioners for patients to attend as orthopaedic out-patients has been carried out. One hundred of these patients were from the North Shore Hospital catchment area and the rest were from the Auckland Hospital catchment area. The letters were analysed according to history, previous treatment, results of previous treatment, and investigations including results of blood tests and x-rays.

Results: An analysis of the results showed that, in general, 50% of the patients’ referrals were inadequately documented and, in particular, it was difficult to assess the individual patient’s level of pain and disability relating to the primary orthopaedic problem.

Discussion: It is suggested that referral letters should contain adequate information to start the initial prioritisation of patients to allow those who have the greater need to have access to the limited resources of the public hospital service.


W.A.J Higgs P. Lucksana R.J.E. Somboon D. Higgs M.V. Swain

Introduction: The viscosity of bone cement used in total joint arthroplasty is an important for determining the proper handling characteristics of the cement and its interlock with bone. The degree of penetration and, therefore, the integrity of the arthroplasty are dependent on the viscosity of the bone cement system. As yet there is still no standard measurement of the efficacy of each bone/cement system with regard to the ability of the cement to penetrate the interstices of the bone.

Aim: To quantify the rheological properties of bone cement systems with the view to assisting in cement selection for orthopaedic purposes

Material & Methods: The rheological properties of a variety of current bone cements were determined using a novel apparatus developed at the CSIRO called the Micro Fourier Rheometer (MFR). This device measures the complex viscosity and complex modulus by subjecting a sample to small amplitude oscillatory squeezing between two parallel plates. The force transmitted through the sample is detected by a dynamic load cell and the complete signal spectrum is then analysed using Fourier Techniques. The bone cement is mixed according to manufacturers’ instructions and placed between the plates and is then subjected to a random displacement. Subsequent Fourier analysis lends itself to rheological parameters such as real and imaginary modulus, viscosity and phase (1–100 Hz).

Results: Consistent with earlier studies, it was found that the viscosity increased with time in an almost linear manner due to the progression of the polymerisation reaction of the cement. Thereupon the cement mass began its exothermic phase and the viscosity increased exponentially until fully set. The complex modulus at this time, when extrapolated to zero frequency, corresponded to the static modulus (as in conventional mechanical testing). The viscosity was highly dependent upon the shear rate (or frequency). As the cement was sheared the viscosity reduced, establishing the pseudo-plastic or shear-thinning nature of these materials. The phase provided an accurate measure of the setting and working time of the cement brands corresponding with studies by Krause (1982) and Ferracane (1981).

Conclusions: The results supported the conclusion that rapid insertion of the prosthesis is recommended, creating high shear stresses, thus decreasing the cement’s viscosity and allowing better cement penetration and mechanical interlock. The study highlights the differences between the major brands of bone cement.


D. Arden D. Atkinson

Introduction: Large numbers of women are taking hormone replacement therapy (HRT) or an oestrogen containing contraceptive pill. They are being advised that these medications can increase their risk of developing deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and there has been considerable recent publicity.

Aim: To determine the practice of New Zealand orthopaedic surgeons when women taking such medications present for major surgery.

Method: A postal survey was sent to all New Zealand orthopaedic surgeons. The current practice was compared with recently revised national guidelines and manufacturers advice.

Results: The response rate was 80% (118/148). There was wide variation in the beliefs surrounding the peri-operative use of both of these medications. Of the surgeons who replied, 44% indicated that they would routinely advise discontinuing the combined oral contraceptive pill peri-operatively for major surgery, 24% indicated that they would routinely advise discontinuing HRT peri-operatively. The mean duration that surgeons would discontinue the medication pre-operatively was 13 days for the contraceptive pill and nine days for HRT. The mean time for re-starting medication post-operatively was 18 days for the contraceptive pill and 13 days for HRT.

Recently released New Zealand guidelines recommend that HRT should be stopped for at least 30 days prior to elective surgery and withheld for 90 days following surgery. Less than 3% of surgeons appeared to be routinely following this recommendation. Most manufacturers of combined oral contraceptive pills recommend stopping the medication for at least four weeks prior to elective surgery. Only 25% of surgeons routinely practice in accordance with these recommendations.

Discussion: This survey demonstrated substantial differences between actual clinical practice, recently revised national guidelines and manufacturers’ advice. These differences need to be brought to the attention of surgeons and guideline producers alike. A review of international literature and recommendations revealed that these guidelines are very conservative and that strong evidence for them is lacking. Issues to be considered include the practicalities of implementing such recommendations; the associated risks of discontinuing medication; the presence of other risk factors; the type of surgery; the use of thromboprophylaxis and not least the wishes of the patient. The possible medico-legal implications are uncertain and caution in this area is advised.


J.N. Trantalis A. Turnbull

Aim: To assess the clinical and radiological performance of metal-on-metal articulations in uncemented total hip arthroplasty.

Method: Between 1996 and 2000, 60 uncemented S-ROM (Johnson & Johnson) total hip arthroplasties were performed on 55 patients with arthritis. Fifty-one of the patients (56 hips) were available for follow-up. This involved clinical assessments including completion of a hip score for each patient, along with radiological examinations.

Results: Follow-up ranged from six months to four years, with an average of 18 months. The average hip score improved from an average of 32.3 to 75.3 (maximum 84, range 53 to 84) at the latest follow-up. The average pain score improved from an average of 9.9 to 41.7 (maximum 44). No patients required revision for loosening of either the femoral or acetabular components. Thus far, there has been no radiological evidence of acetabular loosening.

Conclusions: In the short-term, the clinical performance of metal-on-metal articulations is equivalent to metal-on-polyethylene. In this group of patients, there has been no radiological evidence of acetabular loosening thus far.


M. Damiani R.S. Kuo W.J. Mills S.T. Hansen

Although described by Gattelier and Chastang in 1924, the transfibular approach to the ankle has been slow to emerge as a conventional orthopaedic technique. To date, applications have been confined to the treatment of tibiotalar arthrodesis, ankle joint incongruity and exposure of the fractured talus, where the distal fibula is also fractured. While seemingly undocumented, it is also proving effective in mosaic-plasty of the talus. This paper outlines an innovative technique of segmental distal fibula osteotomy and its role in the treatment of osteochondritis dissecans of the postero-lateral talar dome.


B.R.T. Love

Various assumptions must be made during total hip replacement when placing the acetabular component within the reamed acetabulum with regards to its orientation. Various methods have been described for different acetabular components, some relying on knowledge of the existing anatomy and some relying on the use of jigs to align the component. Many of these assumptions are based on opinion rather than science and the current study was designed to define the position of the acetabulum in relation to a fixed position of the pelvis.

A neutral position of the pelvis must be defined and this is represented by having a line from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubis fixed in the coronal plane and taking measurements of the perpendicular axis of the pelvis taken from this.

A variety of measurements were made using measurement techniques and the conclusion was reached that the average angle for operative inclination is 43 degrees ± 5 degrees and the average angle for operative anteversion is 29 degrees ± 8 degrees. These figures should give a preliminary guide to the correct placement of the acetabular socket in total hip replacement although other factors may need to be taken into account.


D.C. Davidson

From July 1985 to April 1996, 394 PCA total hip replacements were performed using proximally, porous-coated, femoral components. A prospective study using a specifically designed database has been used to follow these patients. There have been 10 deaths and five patients were lost to follow-up (F/Up), leaving 379 for review.

Revision of 33 acetabular components has been performed for loosening; four acetabular liners were revised for recurrent dislocation; and three acetabular liners were revised because of wear. Only three femoral stems have been revised for loosening.

The fully proximally, porous-coated, cementless stem resulted in good survival in the mid-term.

The problems of the acetabular component of cement-less total hip replacement have been the cause of early failure, but close follow-up of patients has enabled the femoral components in these patients to be preserved.

Improved acetabular components, with lower wear characteristics, may prolong the survival of the femoral components of proximally porous –coated femoral components.


S. Qaimkhani M.S. Bhamra

We have performed 466 metal-on-metal total hip replacements (THR) in our hospital, since November 1993. Forty-seven of these have been the TPP (Thrust plate prosthesis - Sulzer Medica). We present here the results of our experience with this prosthesis when used for the “younger” patient. Forty-two patients received 47 THRs The age was 40 years (range: 21 – 53 years) There were 25 female patients.

At the latest review: one patient (with two THRs) had died from a pulmonary embolus one patient had a revision for an aseptic loosening (one hip) one patient was lost to follow-up (one hip). The remainder were satisfactory although two hips had subsided into a varus position. The early results were satisfactory in this high-demand group of patients.


D.W. Howie C.M. Steele-Scott M.A. McGee K. Costi

Aim: To compare the outcomes of cemented and uncemented primary total hip arthroplasty and to report the radiological features of 41 Exeter polished tapered stems which demonstrate good clinical scores at long-term review.

Methods: We set up a randomised trial, involving two surgeons, Twenty stems were modular and 21 were monoblock. The radiographic measurements, made using templates adjusted for magnification, included vertical subsidence of the stem, scoring of cement mantle thickness, analysis of the p-c and cement-bone (c-b) radiolucencies, and cement fracture in each of the Gruen zones on AP and lateral views.

Loosening was classified as possible if there was between 50 and 99 percent c-b radiolucency, probable when there was complete radiolucency, or definite when vertical subsidence was more than 5mm. The presence and type of radiological features analysed according to surgeon and whether a centraliser was utilised.

Results: There were no failures of the polished stems with 100% survival at 11 years. At the latest review, none of the polished cemented stems demonstrated definite or possible loosening. Osteolysis was found proximally in two cases and more distally in one case and each of these stems was implanted without a centraliser. Incomplete cement mantles and the presence of radiolucencies were more common around stems without centralisers, however the differences in results according to surgeon is a potential confounder and requires investigation in a larger series.

Conclusion: This study demonstrated excellent radiological results of the polished Exeter stem at mid to long-term follow-up.


P.A. Vendittoli

Introduction: The excellent results obtained with metal-polyethylene (M-P) bearing surfaces in total hip arthroplasty (THA) are still limited by the production of polyethylene wear debris, osteolysis and aseptic loosening. Because of its superior tribologic properties and biologically inert composition, alumina-alumina (AL-AL) bearing surfaces are proposed to improved survival of THA but previously reported early complications prevented widespread use of this material.

Aim: To compare the early results and complications with Ceraver M-P and AL-AL THA.

Methods: One hundred and thirty-eight Ceraver hybrid THAs in patients less than 70 years old were randomised to M-P or AL-AL bearing surfaces. We present the clinical and radiological results for patients followed-up from six to 48 months.

Results: No significant difference was found on W.O.M.A.C. and Merle D’ Aubigné Postel scores. No specific complication associated with alumina components like fracture or malpositioning of the acetabular insert were observed in this study. Documented complications were: infection 3 AL-AL / 0 M-P; dislocation 1 AL-AL / 4 M-P; and heterotopic ossification 47% AL-AL / 24% M-P. No aseptic loosening was observed.

Discussion and Conclusion: Ceraver AL-AL bearing surfaces gave early clinical and radiological results similar to M-P. Our results were in accordance with studies suggesting that AL-AL has the potential to become the bearing surfaces of choice in THA in the young patients.


W.L. Walter J.J. Eckardt M. Kabo

Aim: To calculate the incidence and timing of metal failure in endoprostheses used for bone tumour reconstructions and to analyse the mode of failure.

Methods: A retrospective analysis was performed on 468 endoprostheses with an average follow-up of 50 months. The explanted prostheses were studied to determine the mode of failure and the design and material features that might have contributed to the failure.

Results: There were 18 mechanical failures of metal. A total of 19 cases were revised for loosening one of which was noted to have a metal fracture pending at the time of the revision. There were three cases of failure of the coupling between components of modular systems. All of the remaining cases (16) were in the lower limb and these failed by fracture of the metal. The fractures occurred at an average of 92 months. The majority of the fractures that were seen were simple fatigue fractures but in three cases other types of failure were also involved. There were no fatigue fractures in forged cobalt chrome components. Fatigue fracture of the cast cobalt chrome implants could always be attributed to a local stress riser or a local area of high stress due to features of the design. Fatigue fractures of titanium implants were often related to notching.

Discussion: The large skeletal defects left by resection of bone tumours can often be reconstructed with endo-prostheses. The mechanical demands on these implants are great resulting in a relatively high incidence of metal failure. Improvements in design and materials can minimise these failures.


W.L. Walter W.K. Walter B. Zicat

Aim: To review our experience and results of the use of the ABG cementless femoral stem in younger patients; less than 50 years at the time of surgery.

Methods: A series of 82 primary hip arthroplasty cases in patients under the age of 50 years were reviewed. All cases were assessed using standard clinical and radiographic scoring systems.

Results: There were 82 arthroplasties performed in 72 patients. The mean age at surgery was 41 years (22 to 49 years). Diagnoses included primary osteoarthritis (44%), secondary osteoarthritis (42%), and inflammatory arthropathy (13%). There was one femoral peri-prosthetic fracture occurring at 69 months after surgery, associated with a large trochanteric granuloma and ace-tabular wear. There were four dislocations (4.9%). One stem has been revised, for dislocation two weeks after surgery. One other ingrown stem was removed at the time of acetabular revision for osteolysis. A total of 10 patients (14%) has required revision for osteolysis and wear in this group. At mean follow up of 72 months (37 to 109 months), average Harris Hip Score was 91/100, with 90% of patients having a good or excellent result. No stems were found to be loose on radiographic evaluation.

Conclusions: This anatomic, hydroxyapatite coated femoral stem provided excellent initial stability and reliable bone in-growth. The fixation appeared to be durable over this follow-up period. This group of young patients had a high polyethylene wear rate, as expected in high demand individuals, and higher dislocation rate than our overall experience with this implant and surgical approach.


C.J. Mann E.J. Taylor S. McNally J.A.N. Shepperd

Introduction: Reports of the results of screw-cup arthroplasties have been disappointing with high revision rates.

Aim: To review our experience of 173 HA-coated screw- cups that have been implanted in 150 patients.

Methods: The patients were followed up at six weeks, three months, six months, again at one year and annually thereafter. The patients were assessed using the Merle D’ Aubigne (MDP) clinical scoring scale and by radiographic review.

Results: The average follow-up was 6.5 years (range 5–9 years). The follow-up rate was 93%. Two patients had revision surgery for recurrent dislocations (1.2%). Two patients were revised for aseptic loosening (1.2%). One patient underwent revision surgery for to deep prosthetic infection (0.6%) and two patients were revised for polyethylene wear without loosening (1.2%). This gave a total revision rate of 4.0%. The average post operative MDP scores were 5.7 for pain, 5.5 for range of movement and 5.4 for function. A radiological review revealed one patient with extensive granuloma formation and two patients with evidence of migration although no cups were revised for migration alone.

Discussion: We believe that the lower revision rate in this series is due to the double advantage of an HA coated cup (which leads to low revision rates for aseptic loosening), and the use of a ceramic head (which produces low polyethylene wear rates). We believe our results convey strong evidence for the advantage offered by HA coating for use with a screw-cup or other prosthesis.


D. Paterson W. Bruce H. van der Wall W. Kuo

Introduction: Labelled leukocyte scintigraphy has been shown to be a sensitive and specific technique for the detection of pedal osteomyelitis in patients with diabetes mellitus. There has however been little data relating the efficacy of the technique to outcomes.

Aim: To examine the prognostic value of sequential 99m Tc labelled leukocyte scans at diagnosis and after 3–4 weeks of appropriate antibiotic therapy.

Method: Twenty-three patients with proven pedal osteomyelitis or persistent uptake on the sequence of scans were studied.

Results: Five additional episodes of osteomyelitis developed in the group over the period of the study. Eleven patients demonstrated persistent uptake in the sequential scans. Nine progressed to amputation. The remaining two patients were biopsy negative for infection, did not have cutaneous ulceration and were thought to have rapidly progressive arthropathy.

Conclusion: Sequential leukocyte scintigraphy accurately predicted the need for amputation and circumvented ineffective prolonged antibiotic therapy.


A.R. Brown A.F. Vicca G.J.S. Taylor

Introduction: Deep infection remains a major complication of joint arthroplasty. Major randomised controlled trials to determine the most effective antibiotic prophylaxis are difficult to construct and interpret. In a conventional theatre most orthopaedic intraoperative wound contamination arrives by the airborne route.

Aim: To use a unique method to compare antibiotics against these airborne bacteria.

Method: Seven antibiotics were tested; Cephradine, Cefuroxime, Cefotaxime, Flucloxacillin, Amoxycillin, Co-amoxyclav and Imipenem. They were incorporated into blood agar at concentrations equivalent to serum levels. Plates were then inoculated with airborne theatre bacteria using a multiple synchronous collection technique. After incubation, the percentage kills were calculated for each antibiotic.

Results: At concentrations equivalent to serum levels one hour following an intravenous dose all of the antibiotics proved highly effective, with kill rates greater than 95%. Imipenem and Co-amoxiclav significantly outperformed the other antibiotics with kill rates of 99.6% and 99.4% respectively. At trough levels the antibiotics achieved kill rates from 61% to 97.6%.

Discussion: Future randomised controlled trials comparing antibiotics in the setting of an already low infection rate are inappropriate. This technique for comparing antibiotic prophylaxis is quick, inexpensive and repeatable. The superiority of Imipenem is not unexpected, given its broad spectrum against both gram positive and negative, aerobic and anaerobic bacteria. Of more interest is the effectiveness of Co-amoxiclav over the presently favoured Cefuroxime.


C.M. Muggeridge J. Mehta M. Sharland

Aim: To assess trends in acute pyogenic osteomyelitis (OM) over the last six years in the Top End catchment area of the Royal Darwin Hospital (RDH).

Methods: One hundred and seventy-five medical records were assessed to investigate the trends in acute pyogenic OM. The outcome was determined on the basis of resolution of symptoms and signs and lack of recurrence/ representation at RDH. The follow-up period for subjects varied between six years and six months and depended on the time of presentation within the six-year span of the study.

Results: One hundred and one cases of acute pyogenic OM were found to meet the inclusion criteria. An average yearly incidence of 1.3 +/−0.7(CI95%) cases per 1000 cases was noted. Of these, 79.2% of cases were male, 70.3% in the age group 0–30 years and 67.3% ATSI. The most common sites affected were the lower extremities (62.3%) and the hands (32.6%). The average delay in presentation after the onset of symptoms was 30.5 days +/−12.8 days (CI 95%). A microbe was identified in only 50% of cases. Staphylococcus aureas was the causative organism in 83.6% of cases. All patients were treated with antibiotics or surgery. The average time for treatment with IV antibiotics was 9.8 days +/− 1.5 (95% CI). The average time for oral antibiotic treatment was 5.4 weeks +/− 0.7 (95%CI). 52.4.% of patients required surgery, with 16% requiring more than one operation and 10.2% requiring terminalisation or amputation of digits. There was a recurrence rate of 3.9%.

Conclusions: OM in the Northern Territory occurs predominantly in males aged less than 30 years, and most commonly in the ATSI population. The most common organism is Staphylococcus aureas. Intravenous therapy for 10 days and oral therapy for six weeks has been shown to be adequate, giving a recurrence rate of 3.9%.


O.D. Williamson

Introduction: Spinal infections are uncommon, but if the diagnosis is delayed or missed, serious consequences may occur. Recently, there have been major advances in diagnosis and treatment of spinal infections.

Aim: To document the evolving clinical picture, diagnosis and treatment of spinal infection over 20 years.

Methods: Prospective and retrospective data were collected by the infectious diseases services of a metropolitan referral centre and a provincial region. The clinical features, investigations, treatment and outcomes were analysed and comparisons were made between two periods; 1980–1992 and 1993–1999, and between the separate centres.

Results: One hundred and fifteen patients presented, with an estimated incidence of 1.7 cases/100,000/yr. The median age increased from 55 to 63.5 years and median time to diagnosis decreased from 28 to 21 days. The most common symptom was local back pain [112/115 (97%)] and the most common sign was local tenderness [88/115 (77%)]. A fever was present in 73/115 [63%]. Forty-one patients had neurological signs [36%] and 50 [43%] had epidural masses. MRI scanning was the most accurate imaging method. All patients received antimicrobial therapy, 27 [23%] partly through an at-home programme. Forty-nine patients [43%] required surgery. At follow-up, 76% were considered cured without neurological deficits. The outcomes improved over time and the differences between services reflected referral patterns.

Conclusions: Over the last 20 years the management of spinal infection has evolved through new diagnostic technology, prolonged treatment with antimicrobials, appropriate surgical intervention and a multidisciplinary approach. Heightened awareness of the condition is required to minimise the potentially serious consequences.


Full Access
W.A.J. Higgs R.J.E.D. Higgs J.M. Higgs

In law, doctors owe “a duty of care” to their patients to ensure that they are properly informed of treatment risks and are not harmed by their doctor’s negligent acts. This term is well established, however, a recent case in the New South Wales Supreme Court has considered the proposition of whether a duty of care, of this type, extends to ancillary medical staff; in this case the receptionist.

The court in the case Alexander v Heise [2001] NSW SC 69 has found that ancillary non-medical staff can owe patients a duty of care, for which a medical practitioner can be vicariously liable, and furthermore that this duty of care can begin when a person books an appointment either for or as a prospective patient and even before the prospective patient has been seen by the doctor. It is clear from this decision that the duty of care has widened somewhat.

Many important issues arise from this case; ensure that your practice has adequate insurance to cover all staff. There is no excuse for lack of training. Training should be focused, regular and documented. Extra care needs to be exercised when a patient is disclosing symptoms on behalf of a third party.


DISCITIS Pages 285 - 285
Full Access
P.G. Mutch A.T. Hadlow

Aim: To effect a retrospective review of all patients who presented with discitis at Auckland Hospital between 1990 and 1998 for the purpose of delineating the indications for surgery and to establish guidelines for treatment of those patients where a pathogen was not isolated.

Method: The clinical, laboratory and radiological findings were reviewed. Where possible, patients underwent telephone interviews.

Results: Thirty-one patients were reviewed. Two patients had died. The clinical picture was characterised by back pain, point tenderness, spasm, radiculopathy, fevers and chills. The average time between clinical presentation and diagnosis was 11 weeks. The ESR was consistently elevated at the time of presentation and it was indicative of disease activity. A causative pathogen was isolated in 28 patients. Mixed pathogens were uncommon. Seven patients required operative debridement and five needed orthotic supports. A spectrum of imaging modalities was used. Particular attention to MRI in support of the diagnosis was critically reviewed.

Conclusions: Non operative management along with chemotherapy specific to the pathogen remains the main stay of treatment for patients with discitis. An algorithm for treatment is recommended including indications for surgery and guidelines for empirical treatment where a causative pathogen is not isolated.


A.R. Brown D.J. Wood

Introduction: Transmission of infection is always a concern in allograft bone banking and the surgical applications of such bone.

Aim: To review the microbiological results of the femoral head donor program at Perth Bone and Tissue Bank from March 1992 until April 2001.

Methods: There were 4515 femoral head donations. All were cultured by means of a swab and bone chip at time of retrieval, prior to storage at −75 degrees C. Once six month repeat serological testing of donors had been obtained, the heads were processed under sterile conditions. All soft tissues were removed, the bone was milled and washed with 1.5 litres warm saline as pulsed lavage. A microbiological swab was taken prior to packaging the graft ready for irradiation and freezer storage until use.

Results: Five hundred and seventy-nine femoral heads had a positive swab or chip at retrieval, with 31 cases having the same organism on both tests. In 516 cases only one of these tests was positive, with skin organisms being the dominant finding. In 10 cases the swab at the end of processing was positive on culture. Eight of these cases were negative on retrieval testing, and in only one case was the same organism, a coagulase negative staphylococcus, present on the processing swab and retrieval testing.

Conclusions: This work suggested that microbiological culture of femoral head swabs and bone chips at time of retrieval has little effect on the culture at the end of processing. After storage at −75 degrees C, mechanical cleaning and washing, less than 1% of femoral heads were positive prior to irradiation.


R. Powell M. Handel D. Zahra B. Courtenay

Aim: To determine the pattern of gene expression induced in cultured human chondrocytes in response to compressive mechanical loads.

Methods: Chondrocytes were obtained from tissue discarded at the time of a number of total knee replacements and where established in primary cell culture. The cultured chondrocytes were then subjected to compressive and tensile loads using a Flexcell machine. The RNA was subsequently extracted from these chondrocytes and the alterations in gene expression determined using the Affymetrix Gene Array machine.

Results: Intended as an in vitro model for Osteoarthritis, it was found that mechanical stimulation of human chondrocytes caused a significant alteration in the expression of a number of classes of compounds. These included enzymes, inflammatory mediators and structural proteins.

Conclusions: This study identified several interesting candidate genes whose expression was significantly altered after being exposed to a laboratory model for osteoarthrosis. Further study of these genes and their expression may lead to important clinical applications.


A. Nabavi-Tabrizi A. Turnbull Q. Dao R. Appleyard

Introduction: Osteochondral mosaicplasty is gaining popularity as a treatment for isolated chondral defects in femoral condyles. Most systems use a metal punch to impact the osteochondral grafts in pre-drilled defects. Damage to the chondrocytes during impaction grafting is of concern and new methods are being sort to minimise this deleterious effect. This study was designed to see if using a plastic punch instead of a metal punch reduces the extent of chondrocyte damage in osteochondral mosaic plasty.

Method: Ten fresh sheep knees were used to harvest 30 osteochondral plugs using the COR system. The opposite condyles were then prepared to receive the osteochondral grafts. Ten plugs were impacted using a metal punch and ten using a plastic punch. The ten remaining plugs were used as controls. The plugs were then recovered and incubated for 24 hours before being stained with MTT. The stained cartilage was then photographed using a digital macroscope. The images were interpreted using a graphics analysis programme.

Results: There was no significant difference in the extent of chondrocyte damage between the two groups. However the extent of chondrocyte damage in the impacted groups was significantly greater than the control group.

Conclusions: Impaction grafting clearly damaged the chondrocytes of the osteochondral plug. In our study using a plastic punch did not reduce the extent of chondrocyte damage during mosaicplasty.


A. Bayan T. Danesh-Clough J-C. Theis G. Veale

Aim: To demonstrate the pattern and mechanism of injury of alpine skiing and snowboarding, and to evaluate the potential risk factors.

Methods: We analysed prospectively all cases of orthopaedic injuries requiring hospital admission that were the result of snowboarding or skiing accidents in the winter of 2000. This included four popular skiing facilities in the South Island of New Zealand.

Results: Seventy-six patients were reviewed. Of those, 30 cases were the results of accidents from snowboarding and 44 cases were from skiing. In addition to appropriate medical evaluations and medical care, a detailed examination was performed on every patient to determine various factors, including demographics, their level of experience and the cause and mechanism of the accident. There were 47 males and 29 females, with an average age of 28 (range: seven to 62)years. Snowboarders tended to be younger men with an average age of 23 years compared with 31 years in skiers. Males constituted 77% of snowboarders and 54% of skiers.

There were 14 patients in the beginners’ group, 32 intermediate, 20 advanced and nine at an extreme-skill level. Thirty-eight patients sustained injuries of the lower extremities, 24 of the upper extremities, 13 of the spine, and one of the pelvis. Lower extremity injuries were more common in skiers (59% of lower limbs, versus 25% of upper limbs), while in snow boarding upper extremity injuries were more common (43% upper limbs versus 36% lower limbs). Ulnar collateral ligament injuries of the metacarpophalangeal joint of the thumb, were far more common in skiers (six in skiers versus one on snowboard). Sixteen patients (nine skiers and six snow-boarders) sustained diaphyseal fractures of their tibiae. In all nine patients in the skiing group, the mechanism of injury was failure of the binding to release resulting in a twisting force to the leg, while in the snowboarding group, three patients (50%) fractured their tibiae on landing badly from a jump and in the other three on colliding with another person or a fixed object.

Conclusions: Lower extremity, equipment-related injuries are common in alpine skiing. The data suggested that currently used bindings are insufficient. Research, technical developments and optimal adjustment of binding are required.


D.A. Stanton W.J. Bruce J.A. Goldberg W. Walsh

Introduction: Hip instability is a complex and challenging problem. In experienced units, up to 4% of patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty will require revision surgery to treat hip instability, with only 60% of these treatments being successful. Many authors reporting results with various constrained systems available have described dislocation rates post implantation of the constrained component of 4% to 29%.

Method: The thirteen patients who underwent placement of a constrained component as a revision procedure in our unit from 1989 to 2000 were reviewed.

Results: The indications for revision surgery included recurrent dislocation in eight and intraoperative instability in five revision hip arthroplasties. No patients were lost to follow up. The average follow-up was 43 months(range 14 to 121). The average age at time of surgery was 73 years(range: 52 to 84 years). No component has been revised. The average hip score after revision surgery was 72(range: 52 to 89). There have been no episodes of dislocation of the constrained arthroplasty. In seven cases the constrained arthroplasty was implanted into a previously placed well fixed shell.

Conclusion: Constrained acetabular components were a highly effective tool in the treatment of hip instability.


M.H. Zheng

Introduction: Autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT) has been shown to be a promising method for restoring hyaline cartilage defects. Since it was first reported by Brittberg et al nine years worth of clinical follow up studies indicate that ACT has provided an excellent outcome in the restoration of hyaline cartilage. As ACT relies on the use of cultured cells and the biosynthetic profile of cultured chondrocytes has been shown to be altered during in vitro expansion, cultivation of chondrocytes for ACT has presented many technical and quality control challenges.

Aim: To perform an assessment of the cellular phenotype of cultured chondrocytes, consistent with differentiation of articular hyaline cartilage, to ensure the delivery of ACT for restoration of hyaline cartilage.

Methods: Using RT-PCR and flow cytometry analyses, we characterised the cellular phenotype of culture chondrocytes used for ACT. We examined several transcriptional factors, cytokines and matrix proteins necessary for the differentiation of chondrocytes in a total of 15 cases of ACT. These included SOX9, Cbfa1, Indian Hedgehog (Ihh), TGF-b3, BMP-2, PTHrP, type I and type II collagen, aggrecan and alkaline phosphatase.

Results: The results demonstrated that there is a variety in the expression of these genetic makers but cultured cells used for ACT were within the programme of chondrocyte differentiation. Furthermore, there is variation in the level of apoptosis of chondrocytes between patients as evidenced by annexin V flow cytometry. As evidenced by MRI in two patient samples, apoptosis of chondrocytes greater than 8% was coincident with cases that could not restore hyaline cartilage three months after ACT.

Conclusions: Given that there is a medical need for ACT in the treatment of articular cartilage injury, a process for monitoring the quality of culture chondrocyte prior to implantation may provide a better clinical outcome of ACT.


J.N. Trantalis W.J.M. Bruce J. Goldberg B. Walsh

Introduction: The revision of a resection arthroplasty of the hip to total hip arthroplasty is a demanding procedure with higher complication rates than those of primary hip arthroplasty.

Aim: To evaluate the outcome of revising resection arthroplasties and thereby assist in deciding which patients would benefit from the procedure.

Methods: We reviewed the experience of an orthopaedic surgeon (WJMB) who performed revisions of resection arthroplasties to total hip arthroplasties for 10 patients from 1990 to 1999. The reason for resection arthroplasty was established or suspected infection in all patients.

Results: The time since the resection arthroplasty ranged from 12 to 36 months, with an average of 14.7 months. The Harris hip scores with the resection arthroplasties ranged from 21 to 44 with an average of 38.3. The follow-up ranged from one to eight years with an average of 4.2 years. Five patients had died from other causes at the time of the study. The Harris hip scores at the latest follow-up ranged from 46 to 89 with an average of 66.

The complications included instability requiring a constrained acetabular liner, an intra-operative femoral fracture requiring a long-stem prosthesis, the breaching of a femoral cortex by a prosthesis requiring a revision and recurrence of infection in a patient who was non-compliant with the prescribed antibiotics.

Conclusions: The revision of a resection arthroplasty to a total hip arthroplasty is a demanding procedure with a high complication rate and prolonged recovery. Revising only those patients with poorly functioning resection arthroplasties optimises the possibility of a positive surgical outcome, being an improvement in pain and function.


A.K. Jeffery M. Walton J. Rietveld

Introduction: The surface of articular cartilage is adapted to low-friction movement. It is important for lubrication, resists shear and compression, and allows transfer of fluid, nutrients and metabolites between synovial fluid, matrix and cells. Surface damage is common following trauma and in early osteoarthritis. The use of intra-articular hyaluronan (visco-supplementation), or oral glucosamine and chondroitin, is claimed to enhance surface protection and/or repair. To validate such treatment biologically, a better understanding of normal structure and function of the cartilage surface is required.

Methods: The surface of femoral condylar cartilage of sheep was examined using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), scanning electron microscopy and polarising microscopy. Fresh specimens were obtained before and after wiping the surface with lens tissue.

Results: TEM of un-wiped normal cartilage showed a thin surface coating of amorphous electron-dense material containing occasional microvesicles and bundles of detaching collagen fibrils. In wiped cartilage this coating was absent, suggesting the superficial layer described in previous studies (lamina splendens of MacConaill), is an adherent coating, probably aggregated proteoglycan, hyaluronate and matrix degradation products. The definitive cartilage surface was a smooth network of fine collagen fibres supported by a mesh of collagen containing microvesicles and particles. More deeply a denser layer of collagen ran parallel to the joint surface. The most superficial zone would allow rapid surface exchange of fluid and particles while the deeper collagen would protect the underlying cells and limit fluid moving deeper during joint loading.

Conclusions: The findings have implications for therapy aimed at cartilage surface protection and/or repair.


E.J. Nightingale R. Kameron J. Goldberg W.R. Walsh

Aim: Radio-frequency treatment is used clinically in unstable joints to reduce the length of the supporting soft tissues to help provide stability. The mechanical properties after treatment have not been adequately studied. Since there is a change in the tissues’ ultra-structure with treatment we hypothesised that different collagenous tissues may have varying responses to radio-frequency treatment.

Methods: Ovine extensor tendons and cadaveric gleno-humeral capsules were tested on a MTS machine to investigate the dynamic and failure properties before and after radio-frequency treatment. Three radio- frequency treatments of different power (5, 10 and 20W) were used and two different treatment times (10s and 30s) to investigate the effects of treatment power and time on changes in the mechanical properties.

Results: The tissue shortening that was produced in the tendons and capsules was progressive with increases in treatment wattage and time. The tendon failure-force and stiffness were significantly reduced by the radio-frequency treatment but no significant changes were found in the capsules. Considering the dynamic properties only, the tendons showed significant changes with treatment. The mechanical properties were significantly different between control and treated groups but not between the treatment settings.

Conclusions: The tissue type altered the effect of radio-frequency treatment on the mechanical properties. Varying the treatment wattage and time did not significantly alter the changes observed with the largest difference being between control and treated tissue at any treatment setting. Therefore, radio frequency was proven to shorten collagenous tissues in a predictable manner but changes to the mechanical properties depend on the tissue type.


B. Milne A.M. Ellis S.J. Ruff

Total hip arthroplasty (THA) using modular components offers many advantages such as a reduction in the implant inventory required and increased intra-operative flexibility with component sizing and selection. However, it also comes at the price of the additional complication of component dissociation, in particular at the non-fixed interface between the polyethylene cup and the acetabular metal backing.

A review of 110 patients requiring revision THA from June 1993 to December 2000 performed by the senior authors revealed seven patients presenting with the triad of signs suggestive of this complication – a previously successful, painless THA that had become acutely painful and with radiographic evidence of femoral head asymmetry in the acetabular cup. Each of these patients had Harris - Galante II porous acetabular cups. At the time of the revision, these patients were found to have dissociated polyethylene cup liners and several with broken locking mechanisms warranting replacement of the acetabular cups, the liners and the worn femoral heads.

This is an uncommon complication of THA, with characteristic presenting symptoms and signs. The importance of comparison of previous radiographs with those at presentation and the postulated mechanisms for dissociation is stressed. Certain precautions are imperative when using modular implants and the pitfalls of the Harris - Galante II porous acetabular component locking mechanism should be acknowledged.


G.J. Coldham H.E. Gruber E.N. Hanley

Introduction: Eighty percent of individuals experience low back pain in their lifetime. This is often due to disc injury or degeneration. Conservative treatment of discogenic pain is often unsuccessful whilst surgery with the use of spacers or fusion is non-physiological.

Aim: To develop an animal model to assess the viability of autologous disc cell therapy.

Methods: The fat sand rat (Psammomys obesus obesus) was chosen because of its predisposition to the early development of spondylosis. Using microsurgical techniques fragments of annulus and nucleus were harvested from a single disc in 50 sand rats. Vascular clips were placed on the adjacent psoas muscle to mark the harvested level. Disc material was initially cultured in a monolayer then transferred into a three-dimensional culture medium of agarose. This technique yields greater cellular proliferation and the development of cell growth in colonies. Cells were labelled with bromodeoxyuridine for later immunohistochemical identification. Twenty thousand cells in a carrier medium were then reimplanted at a second operation at an adjacent disc level in the same animal. The rat was subsequently sacrificed and the histology of the disc space was reviewed.

Results: To date, 50 primary disc harvests and 30 reimplantations have been performed. Two rats died prior to reimplantation. All histological specimens confirmed the presence of viable transplanted disc cells.

Conclusions: Autologous disc cell transplantation can be performed in the rat. Further modification of these techniques may lead to the development of autologous disc cell therapy comparable to that currently successfully used in hyaline cartilage defects of synovial joints in humans.


N. Aebli J. Krebs G. Davis M. Walton M. Williams J-C. Theis

Introduction: Vertebroplasty (VP) is a relatively new procedure to treat osteoporotic compression fractures of vertebral bodies. During this procedure polymethyl-methacrylate (PMMA) is injected into vertebral bodies. However there is the concern, that fat embolism (FE) and acute hypotension could occur as in a variety of other orthopaedic procedures.

Aim: To investigate whether FE and acute hypotension are potential complications of VP using an animal model.

Methods: In six sheep, 6.0 ml PMMA were injected unilaterally into the L1 vertebral body. Transœsophageal echocardiography was used to monitor the pulmonary artery for bone marrow and fat particles until 30 minutes post-operatively. Pulse, arterial and venous pressures were also recorded. The lumbar spine and the lungs were harvested post mortem. The histopathologic score, (percentage of lung fields occupied by intravascular fat globules as seen through the microscope), was calculated.

Results: The first showers of echogenic material were visible approximately seven seconds after the beginning of the cement injection and lasted for about 2.5 minutes. The injection of bone cement caused a very rapid decrease in the heart rate after two seconds followed by a fall in the mean arterial pressure after 6.0 seconds. A maximum fall in heart rate was accompanied by a delayed fall in mean arterial pressure of 33.0 mmHg (P=0.0003) at 36seconds. The heat rate had returned to the baseline by 89 seconds and had increased by 10 beats/min (P=0.02) at 25 minutes. Mean arterial pressure had recovered by 209 seconds and was not different from the baseline at 25 minutes. Post mortem examination showed that no leakage of cement into the spinal cord had occurred. The histology revealed fat globules and bone marrow cells in the smaller and larger vessels throughout the lungs. The histopathologic score was 5.2 ± 0.9%.

Conclusions: This study clearly showed that VP resulted in FE with a two-phase decrease in heart rate and arterial blood pressure. The first phase was probably due to an autonomic reflex and the second phase was due to the passage of fat emboli through the right heart and obstructing the lungs.


R.M. Gillies J. Lane W.R. Taylor W.R. Walsh

Introduction: The stress and strain in the proximal femur after total hip arthroplasty are influenced by the geometry of the implant in addition to its materials properties and applied loading. The addition of a third taper in the medio-lateral plane may provide additional stability and improved load transmission.

Aim: To examine the relative stability of double and triple tapered stems in two finite element (FE) models.

Methods: The geometry of a polished, double-tapered and a triple-tapered stem were scanned using a three dimensional technique. Two FE models of the stems were created using PATRAN. The models were analysed using the ABAQUS. Tied and sliding contact conditions were allowed between the implants and the cement mantle. The interface at the distal tip of the stem was removed to represent the scenario with a distal centraliser present.

Results: When tied contact was assumed, both stems displayed similar von Mises’ stress distributions. The peak stresses remained constant in the double tapered stem, with a marked translation of regions of high stress towards the distal tip with the introduction of sliding contact conditions. Peak stresses in the triple tapered stem decreased, but displayed a more continuous distribution along the implant with sliding contact. Torsional loading of the stems reduced the magnitude of the distal tip stresses.

Conclusions: The triple-tapered geometry displayed a more even distribution of stresses along the length of the implant. The double-tapered geometry displayed a high stress state at the distal tip of the implant.


A. Butler M. Svehla W.R. Walsh

Introduction: The transition from fixed bearing to mobile bearing total replacements represents a recent trend in Australia with the introduction of many new designs. The complex kinematics of mobile bearing designs coupled with the importance of proper surgical techniques including soft tissue balancing presents a number of factors that may influence the short and long-term success of these implants. There have been few reports in the literature on the performance of many of the new mobile bearing design with regards to initial wear of the polyethylene (PE) insert.

Aim: To investigate the patterns of wear on three mobile bearing knee PE inserts that had been retrieved soon after implantation.

Methods: Three mobile bearing knee PE inserts were retrieved at the time of revision surgery and submitted to our laboratory for examination. The proximal and distal articulating surfaces were examined by measuring surface roughness (Ra) using a Surfanalyzer (5400 (Federal Products Co., Providence, RI, USA) following ISO 97. Optical microscopy and scanning electron microscope (SEM) analyses were used to locate and identify patterns of wear.

Results: The average time in service for the PE inserts was 18.6 months. The maximum Ra values were noted on the anterior-lateral side for all implants. Optical and SEM analysis revealed wear mechanisms that included burnishing, scratches, pitting and cold flow. Damage to the distal surface was noted in all samples with extensive wear tracks noted in the LCS and TRAC knees.

Conclusion: The surface roughness analyses showed asymmetrical wear on the distal PE interfaces as well as wear on the proximal PE interfaces. The presence of embedded particles and debris suggests a third-body mechanism. Dislocation and general instability may have exacerbated the early signs of wear in these components.


C.J. Mann B.F. Shahgaldi F.W. Heatley

Introduction: We hypothesise that the fixation method of the acetabular component influences stress transmission to the host bone in vivo. We believe that the frequency of appearance of radiolucent lines at the prosthetic rim is directly related to the brake drum effect whereby compressive forces at the dome of a semi-rigid body leads to tensile forces at the rim.

Method: A series of miniature pressure transducers were manufactured and positioned at the prosthetic/ bone interface of an acetabular component of a total hip arthroplasty (THA) in a jig designed to replicated the loading conditions of a THA in vivo. The transducers were arranged in a series of five concentric rings spaced from the centre of the acetabular dome to the prosthetic rim. A total of six transducers was used. Three separate experiments were performed: 1. a polyethylene component alone to act as a control. 2. a polyethylene component surrounded by a cement mantle and 3. a polyethylene component surrounded by a metal-back. A separate jig was constructed to provide a cement mantle of the same thickness as the metal back. The stress transmitted to the host bone was measured in each case.

Results: The results indicated that successively less stress was transmitted when changing from controls to cemented then to metal-backed cups. Both cemented and uncemented cups demonstrated at the very least absence of compressive forces at the prosthetic rim and in some cases tensile forces, indicating that the brake drum effect is likely.


J. Krebs N. Aebli H. Stich M. Walton P. Schawalder J-C. Theis

Introduction: After more than 10 years of clinical experience, hydroxyapatite (HA) coated orthopaedic implants are now an established, viable alternative to porous coatings for achieving good implant fixation. However, developments are continuing to improve the nature and adhesion of the HA coating.

Aim: To investigate the biological attachment characteristics of titanium and highly crystalline HA implant coatings in the metaphysis of an animal model.

Method: Titanium alloy implants with a coating of commercially pure titanium (Ti) or highly crystalline HA were evaluated by light microscopy and pullout tests after one, two and four weeks of unloaded implantation in the tibial and femoral metaphyses of 18 sheep.

Results: The interface shear strength pullout increased from approximately 29N/cm2 at one week to approximately 326N/cm2 at two weeks. At four weeks the pull-out strength for Ti and HA coated implants was 1,004.87 ± 189.82N/cm2 and 1,043.26 ± 260.61N/cm2 respectively. The pullout strength increased significantly over time up to four weeks, but the difference between the coatings was not statistically significant at any time interval.

Histomorphometric analysis showed an increase of bone-implant contact between one and two weeks from 0 to 15% for Ti and 0 to 20% for HA coated implants. At four weeks Ti and HA implants showed 44% and 60% bone-implant contact respectively. There was a significant increase in bone-implant contact over time for both coatings. HA implants had significantly higher bone-implant contact at two and four weeks. Light microscopy revealed that bone grew into HA coated surfaces in the form of feet, spreading over the surface. Whereas for Ti the newly formed bone looked like a bridge linking the original bone with the implant surface.

Conclusion: The different growth patterns of bone into Ti and HA surfaces resulted in different bone-implant contact areas. Highly crystalline hydroxyapatite coatings enhanced the osseointegration in the early stages of bone healing. However there was a discrepancy between the mechanical and histological results. This may suggest that the mechanical failure does not occur at the implant-bone interface.


N. Aebli J. Krebs G. Davis M. Walton J-C. Theis

Introduction: Vertebroplasty (VP) is a new prophylactic treatment for preventing osteoporotic compression fractures of vertebral bodies. During this procedure polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) is injected into several vertebral bodies. It has been shown that fat embolism (FE) with acute cardiopulmonary deterioration occurs during VP as it does in a variety of other orthopaedic procedures (e.g. knee and hip replacements).

Aim: To investigate the cardiovascular changes during FE caused by multiple VP using an animal model.

Method: PMMA was injected unilaterally, into L1 – L6 in six sheep, with 10 minutes between injections. Arterial, venous and pulmonary arterial pressure, cardiac output and blood gas values were recorded before injection and again after the injection at one, three, five and 10 minutes. The lungs were harvested post mortem and the histopathologic score (percentage of lung fields occupied by intravascular fat globules as the field of the microscope) was calculated.

Results: The sequential injection of bone cement into six vertebral bodies from values before injection of L1 to 10 minutes after injection of L6 resulted in significant falls in arterial blood pressure (P< 0.0001), cardiac output (P=0.0049), pO2 (P< 0.0001) and pH (P< 0.0001). There were also significant rises in pulmonary arterial pressure (P=0.0005) and pCO2 (P< 0.0001), but no significant change in central venous pressure. The histopathological score was 19.1±1.94%,

Conclusions: This study clearly showed that multiple VP in sheep leads to FE with major cardiovascular reactions. Arterial blood pressure showed a stepwise, cumulative fall and was clearly the best parameter to demonstrate these reactions. This suggests that in human patients, particular attention should be paid to falls in arterial blood pressure during multiple VP.


R.M. Gillies C. Hatrick D.H. Sonnabend J. Goldberg W.R. Walsh

Introduction: Uncemented humeral components rely heavily on initial stability and fixation as a function of the design of the implant. Concerns over initial torsional stability of humeral components have motivated the development of a variety of design concepts.

Aim: To investigate the torsional stability of two types of cementless humeral shoulder prostheses.

Methods: Twelve fresh-frozen cadaveric humeri were cleaned of all soft tissues and prepared for reconstruction with the two types of cementless humeral shoulder prostheses. The humeri were embedded in a low melting point alloy and tested in a servohydraulic-testing machine. The loading applied to the humeri was a controlled angle loading regime at ± 1.5 degrees for 150 cycles. Torque versus time was measured, and the exponential time constant was calculated.

Results: The Z implant displayed overall a tightening effect, and a positive time constant. Whereas the G implant displayed a negative time constant, i.e. a loosening of the implant.

Discussion: These differences reflect the initial stability achieved immediately following surgery and may have important implications for bone in-growth and long-term stability.


A.D. Shaw A. Meighan E. Thomson P.D.R. Scott

Aim: To investigate the efficacy of the Insall tube realignment procedure when used to treat osteoarthrosis of the lateral facet of the patello-femoral joint. This procedure has not been reported before for this indication.

Methods: The operation is a quadricepsplasty that tilts the patella to enable it to articulate on its intact medial facet, decreasing the loading of the damaged lateral surface. An independent retrospective review was performed with clinical examinations and a score of pain and activity. The mean period of follow-up was 3.6 years with a minimum of one year.

Results: There were 43 operations in 30 patients (12 males), with a mean age of 54 years. The patients graded their overall pain relief and functional change as being good to excellent in 32 knees, unchanged in four knees and worse in seven knees. The overall pre- and postoperative pain scores for sitting, walking, running and stair climbing all showed improvements. Ten patients felt some quadriceps weakness on descending stairs, but only one was clinically weak. There was an increase in the number of patients with severe pain on kneeling. Three patients with unsuspected tibio-femoral degenerative change seen at surgery all had poor results.

Discussion: We recommend this relatively simple and effective operation for the surgical treatment of isolated lateral facet patello-femoral osteoarthritis.


M.J. Barnes H.A. Crawford I.A. Spika

Introduction: There is a paucity of published data concerning major thoracolumbar spine trauma in the paediatric population, reflecting the rarity of these injuries.

Aim: To review retrospectively 11 cases of thoracolumbar paediatric spinal fractures and dislocations requiring operative management by one surgeon from 1991 to 2001 at Starship Children’s Hospital.

Methods and results: The mean age was 10 years (range: four to 15). Four patients had a neurological deficit (three were incomplete, one was complete). All patients underwent surgery with internal fixation. Canal decompression was achieved by operative realignment in most patients although two patients underwent additional decompression by corpectomy. Seven patients had flexion-distraction injuries with facet joint dislocations. These patients were treated with posterior instrumentations in compression. A further two patients with fracture-dislocations were also treated by posterior instrumentation and the remaining two patients (one burst fracture and one fracture-dislocation) by anterior instrumentation. The general principles for surgical management of thoracolumbar spine trauma in adults were found to be applicable to the children in this series. Suitably sized internal fixation devices were available to allow stabilisation in all cases. The preponderance of dislocations presumably reflects differing biomechanics in the immature versus the adult spine and necessitated a posterior operative approach in most cases.


K.D. Mohammed K.G.B. Dalzell A. Quick A.G. Rothwell

Aim: To describe accurately the contributions of glenohumeral (GH) and scapulothoracic (ST) joints in shoulder movements in normal male adult subjects, aged 20–30 years.

Methods: We recorded data with a Polhemus magnetic tracking device (Kaiser Aerospace and Electronics Co., Vermont). Receivers were taped on landmarks, over the sternum, scapula and humerus. The movements that were studied were elevation in the sagittal plane, abduction in the scapular plane and lowering the arm from these positions. We collected data from 26 male subjects (52 shoulders), aged 20–30 years, with no history of shoulder problems. Repeatability data were obtained in 16 subjects.

The data can be expressed in a number of ways, including plotting the ratio of GH/ST movement versus overall shoulder movement. Polynomial equations to fit these curves describe movement patterns. We have developed software to calculate cumulative averaging of data.

Results: Both GH and ST movements contribute to shoulder movement throughout the ranges studied. Although the shapes of the movement curves were fairly consistent, there were some non-conforming curves and variations. As the arm is abducted the mean ratio of GH/ST movement increases to approximately 3/1. Adduction produces curves that nearly mirror image the abduction curves. Flexion and extension curves tend to be flatter with a mean GH/ST ratio of 2–3/1, throughout the range. The reproducibility data shows satisfactory fits to initial curves.

Conclusions: We have developed a method to describe shoulder movement that provides new information regarding normal shoulder movements. This method can be applied to study patients with shoulder disorders.


I. Anderson A. MacDiarmid D. Pang W. Walsh

Aim: To measure contact pressures in vivo in patients with unicompartmental arthritis fitted with osteoarthrosis (OA) braces to see if the arthritic side of the joint is unloaded.

Method: A thin flexible sensor (TekScan) was manoeuvered arthroscopically into the medial compartment of the knee joint under local anaesthesia in patients with unicompartmental OA of the knee undergoing either therapeutic or diagnostic arthroscopy. All 15 patients had been fitted with a brace before the arthroscopy. Measurements were made within the compartment of double leg stance and single leg stance. Ground reaction force using a load cell was measured for 14 patients and the knee sensor data were normalised relative to this. Recordings were then repeated with the patients with different commercially available braces.

Results: The first two groups of patients showed significant reductions in pressures. Normalised knee sensor forces were reduced to 68%(Sd 22%) and 61%(Sd31%). In the last group of patients, reductions in pressure recordings were less between no-brace and brace. Three patients produced low signals suggesting incorrect sensor replacement.

Conclusions:

Significant unloading of the osteoarthritic compartment could be observed by applying manually a valgus force to the knee.

Significant unloading of the arthritic compartment of the knee was not observed by applying a brace (up to 10%).

Measurement of pressures within the osteoarthritic knee is difficult and variable.


R. Nicol L. Piedrahita

Twelve patients ranging in age from 10 to 35 years have undergone 14 Ganz Osteotomies. The surgical approach used to define the anatomy is described and questions asked as to its safety with regard to the vascularity of the acetabular segment.

The complications encountered in the learning curve of this operation are described together with the early outcomes.


L. Kohan R.L. Cordingley S. Stanners

Introduction: Bone fragility is a result of the reduction in bone mineral density and mass. This reduction directly reduces the effectiveness of trabecular cross bracing. The problem of femoral neck fractures after hip resurfacing surgery is directly related to the mechanical load on the osteoporotic bone.

Aim: To determine any correlation between the degree of osteoporous and subsequent femoral neck fractures.

Methods: A comparison was made between both femoral necks in the same patient, to determine the degree of osteoporosis prior to surgery. These results were then compared with subsequent changes in osteoporosis 12 months post-operatively.

Bone mineral density values, were used to compare the non-operative femoral neck to the operative femoral neck before surgery. These values were then used as a predictive risk of subsequent femoral neck fracture in this patient group. Bone mineral density assessments were repeated 12 months after the surgery to compare the subsequent changes in the osteoporotic values. The bone mineral density evaluations were carried out on one hundred patients, both male and female between the ages of 28 and 87 years. The criterion for entry into this group was a bone mineral density value of no lower than 1.5 standard deviation points below the young reference value.

Results: We found an improvement in the bone mineral density values for each patient, therefore reducing the risks of subsequent femoral neck fracture.


A.D. Beischer A. Cornuio R.N. De Steiger J. Cohn S. Graves

Introduction: Patient education and informed consent are areas of clinical practice that are taking an ever-increasing proportion of a surgeon’s time and effort. The expectation is that this trend will continue, as medical malpractice litigation becomes more commonplace. Patients are also requiring increased access to medical information to help facilitate decisions about their healthcare. With the increasing use of computers and improvements in technology modules to aid patients’ understanding have become available and may prove useful in patient education.

Method: A computer-based multimedia module of total hip replacement (THR) has been developed. These involve three-dimensional (3D), animated computer graphics with text and spoken word. A questionnaire based on educational models was designed to test ease of use and patients’ comprehension after viewing the module.

Results: A pilot study involved 20 patients each awaiting elective surgery for THR. The results showed a good comprehension and understanding of the nature of the surgery and the possible complications.

Conclusions: We have shown that a 3D-multimedia patient education module improved patients’ understanding of THR surgery and its possible complications. The use of 3D multimedia modules has the potential to save the surgeon time whilst ensuring that his/her patients have given informed consent to their forthcoming surgery. It is hoped that better-informed consent may equate to a reduction in medical malpractice activity and thus insurance premiums.


S. Burch P. Devane G. Horne

Aim: To examine the effect that a modular, uncemented, fully coated titanium stem (PFM-R, Protek) has on the bone stock of revised femora.

Methods: Forty revision hip arthroplasties between 1997–2000 were performed by one surgeon using the PFM-R revision stem. The patients were assessed radiographically over a two-year follow-up period. The pre-operative radiographs were examined for bone defects according to Paprosky et al., 1987. Serial radiographs taken post-operatively after two days, six weeks, three months, six months, 12 months and 24 months were used to assess signs of fixation, stability and change in the cortices of 16 femoral zones according to criteria set out by Engh et al., 1987. The change in the density of the bone defects identified at the time of surgery was also examined.

Results: The average age of the patients was 65 years. Thirteen revision stems were followed for one year and 13 were followed for two years. Fourteen patients had an incomplete radiographic follow-up. Two type I defects, 23 type II defects and one type III defect were identified. Twenty-one of the 23 type II defects showed evidence of regeneration in the subtrochanteric metaphysis. One revision stem had radiographic evidence of bone resorption proximally though three stems subsided. No stress shielding was seen distally.

Conclusion: At early follow-up the PFM-R appears to be a viable revision femoral implant which facilitates the regeneration of metaphyseal bone stock.


Dres. Adolfo R. Grandal Jose Cifone Pedro F. Royo Nestor Vallejos Meana

We report our experience at the Pediatric Hospital “Ricardo Gutierrez” in Buenos Aires. 11 diplegic patients (8 male, 3 female) who presented severe neurological valgus feet were treated with the Dennyson Fulford technique between 1996 and 2000. 7 patients had a bilateral deformity and 4 unilateral deformity . Patients’ ages averaged 9.5 years (range, 7–12 years). The average follow up was 2 years and 3 months (range, 7 months–5 years).

We took into consideration the following parameters to evaluate the results: 1- hind foot position, 2- adaptation to the orthosis 3- pain. The results were excellent in 10 feet, good in 6 feet and poor in 2 feet.

The results obtained with the subtalar fusion using a screw for fixation coupled with bone graft were considered satisfactory on obtaining 88% of good and fair results and a good acceptance among patients. We consider that the Dennyson Fulford technique allows an proper reduction with few complications and we emphasize it as the best option among other current surgical techniques for this pathology.


Dr. Baroni Eduardo Dr Lòpez Vidal Dr Dortignac Mariano Dra. Pelozo Patricia Dr. Groiso Jorge

Our objective is to show the results of the unstable slipped capital femoral epiphysis treatment with reduction and threaded screw fixation.

A retrospective analysis of 21 patients (13 boys and 8 girls) with unstable slipped capital femoral epiphysis was performed between 1993 and 1998. The right hip was involved in 13 patients and the left hip in 8. The patients presented acute pain and functional difficulties. The diagnoses were based on the clinical presentation, neutral and Lowestein hip x-rays. The treatment consisted on gentle manipulative reduction of the unstable slip (flexion and internal rotation), threaded cannulated screw fixation on orthopaedic table and image intensifier control.

Results showed 2 avascular necrosis, 2 bone shortening, 3 limited range of motion. The rest showed satisfactory clinical results in the short term.


Dres. Ruben Maenza

The thoracoscopic technic is a minimal surgical approach that minimizes the skin, muscle and ribs trauma without altering the effectiveness of the treatment.

This type of surgery has been gaining importance due to its advantages: excellent lighting, visualization and magnification. It offers an acute visual control during manipulation and dissection of delicate structures. We aim to assess the anterior release and the thoracic spine arthrodesis through thoracoscopic approach and measure the effectiveness and security of anterior thoracoscopic instrumentation in an experimental study in pigs.

The study was performed on 18 pigs which weighed between 40 and 60 kg. The surgical procedures were conducted at the Hospital Italiano in Buenos Aires. A thoracoscopic surgery was performed as an access to the spine.

The quality of the anterior release ranged significantly from cases in which the incision of the common anterior vertebral ligament could not be finished to cases in which more than 75% of the anterolateral disk circumference was released. In the subjective thoracoscopic assessment of the surgeon the screws were placed successfully in all The radiographic assessment confirmed the surgeon’s presumption, all the screws had been placed correctly. The rod presented complications in several cases.

The radiographic assessment showed that 40.6% (13 patients) of the disc spaces were pseudoarthrosic or with a delayed union. The macroscopic examination confirmed this finding and raised the number of pseudoarthrosic spaces up to 46.8% (15 patients) revealing 4 discs that still had a nucleus pulposus. The data were reinforced by histologic examination.

This histologic cuts were performed using the E & O method. The fibrous ring was clearly identified in the pseudoarthrosic cases as well as the processes of the osteochondral bone formation in its different phases of maturation.

It is very important to highlight that in our experience we had found a direct relationship between the quality of the disectomy, the fusion technique and the experience of the surgeon.

The surgical technique, the rod placement on the screws needs proper positioning and depth. The radiographic and microscopic examination confirmed that the posterior longitudinal ligaments was not damaged.

The thoracoscopic instrumentations in pigs using a rod and screws of third generation is a secure technique. It is essential the development of instrumentation which allows effective thoracoscopic distraction and compression.


Dr. Adolfo Ricardo Grandal Dr. José Alberto Cifone Dr. Daniel Vison Dallapozza Dr. Néstor Vallejos Meana

We report 16 patients (18 hips) treated between 1997 and 1999. The average age was 5 years and 3 months (range, 2–9 years). Of all the hips evaluated, 13 (72%) corresponded to diplegic patients and 5 (28%) to tetra-plegic patients. The surgical plan consisted on femoral osteotomy combined with Dega pericetabular osteotomy coupled with adductor and psoas tenotomy using as a variable the reduction of the hip by the anterior approach depending on each case. We used the following criteria to evaluate results: 1 – pain, 2 – abduction range, 3 – Reimmers index, 4 – acetabular index.

Diplegic patients had good (78%), fair (12%) and poor (12%) results. Tetraplegic patients had good (25%), fair (50%) and poor (25%) results in this short follow up. On analyzing the cases, we observed an adequate development of the neurologic hips when using the acetabuloplasty with the Dega technique because it minimized the risk of coverage loss, as commonly seen in these kind of patients due to the progressive valgus during the postoperative period.


Dr. Lautaro Campos Torres Dr. Sergio Montenegro Mauras Dr. Mauricio Vergara

11 patients (7 girls and 4 boys) with multidirectional instability of the shoulder were treated between 1999 and 2000. The average age was 15 years 8 months (range, 14–17), with a follow-up of 1 year 6 months. In the examination under general anesthesia it was confirmed that the luxation had more than one direction. The surgery was performed with general anesthesia using a standard arthroscope with video camera and classic approach for the shoulder. In order to decrease the capsular volume, capsular plicature and retraction by heat were used The plicatures were anterior, inferior and posterior.

Patients were immobilized postoperatively in plaster splints or casts during 3 weeks and then they were placed in a rehabilitation program. The patients were followed up postoperatively, the UCLA Score was used during this period. Results were excellent and good in 90% of the patients, who were pain free and had full external rotation. Only one patients (10%) presented recurrence of the instability.

Patients showed the same pre surgical sport performance. Only one case presented capsule laxity and an open surgery was performed. This patient was reexamined and was labeled as a psychiatric case wrongly selected. Only 2 patients presented capsule inflammation with limited external rotation. They were treated with intensive rehabilitation.

The arthroscopic method allows for capsular volume reduction. Results were similar to the ones described with the open technique. The reduction of the capsular volume is done mixing capsular plicature and retraction by heat.

This arthroscopic techniques, previously described for adult patients with multidirectional instability, proved to be useful in adolescents.


Dres. Tello C. Bersusky E. Francheri A. Noel M. Barragán B.

Malignant hyperthermia (MH) is a pharmacogenetic disorder, potentially lethal, due to the exposure to anesthetic drugs that triggers, a high increase of corporal temperature, progressive muscular stiffness, severe rabdomiolisis and death due to cardiac dysfunction. Many research works relate Malignant Hyperthermia to muscular illnesses or to the King Syndrome. Through this study we present the incidence of MH in patients with congenital vertebrae malformations. (CVM)

The objective is to establish the incidence of the MH in patients who were operated on CVM and to alert about this association.

1029 patients with CVM were treated between 1972 and 2000. 390 with congenital vertebrae malformation were operated on. 3 patients (0.76%) (1 girl and 2 boys) developed MH while they underwent surgical treatment for the CVM. 1 patient presented an isolated congenital vertebrae malformation. 1 patient presented King Syndrome and the other presented Robert Syndrome. Only 1 elevated amount of preoperative CPK was found (the are no reports on the others).

No muscular biopsy was done to test sensitivity. Two of them were biopsied for a post episode study. At the surgical moment, any patients reported personal or familiar antecedents of MH. No deaths were reported, although it is considered as a potentially lethal disorder.

We found no reports in the literature in this subject. Most of the bibliographic data belonged to anesthesiologists or geneticists. Our approach as spine surgeons leaded us to the detailed analysis of this studies and the 0.76% (3 out of 390) incidence suggested us to have an alert attitude when facing patients with surgical MVC and take the necessary precautions.


G. Dres. Arendar E Samara M D’Elía E Levy

We evaluated 28 patients, 52 feet with flaccid paraparesis (27 MMC, 1 neonatal paraplegia) in which a posterior transference of the tibialis anterior was performed for talus deformities. Between 1987 and 2001 in two institutions.

Mean age at surgery 6+6 ( from 0+4 to 12+10) 16 males, 12 females,

Neurological last level functioning was 1 Toracic, 2 lower lumbar, 25 sacral

Technique: through minimal incisions the muscle is transferred posteriorly opening bluntly the interosseous membrane and weaved to the aquiles tendon if present and fixed to the top of the os calcis in 10° of equinus

There where 23 bilateral cases

Asociated surgeries 17 extension calcaneal osteotomies 5 peroneal z plasties, 4 short peroneal to posterior tibialis transfer, 2 vertcal talus correction, 2 Evans lenghtenings, 1 IF arthrodesis

Follow up in 25 patients (3 lost) was 3+11 (0+3 to 12+1)

Complications: 1 late calcaneal osteomielitis, ,2 severe valgus feet in a vertical talus

Results: we measured calcaneal pich in 26 feet in a lateral xray. Mean preop measure 34*(20 to 50 ) postp 21* (15 to 25).

All patients were independent walkers at follow up.

Conclusion: Posterior transfer of the tibialis anterior is an excellent operation that prevents talus progression in the absence of planta flexors alone or in conjuction with extension calcaneal osteotomy in older children, the better position lessens trhe chance for the habitual skin lesions in this patients


Dres. Goyeneche Rodolfo D’Elia Martín Lanfranchi Lucas Groiso Jorge

Nonsurgical treatment is gaining importance nowadays due to the complications that a surgery involves: over-correction, subcorrection and joint stiffness.

A comparative and prospective study of longitudinal cut was performed between May 2000 and July 2001 in 16 patients (26 feet) with varus equinus supination club-foot. It aimed to evaluate the results of the nonsurgical treatment. All the patients were younger than 1-year-old and virgin of treatment

The technique described by Ponseti was used and its rules were followed strictly. All the components where corrected simultaneously except the equinus which was treated with percutaneous Achilles tenotomy when the initial treatment proved no to be successful. 3 patients (11%) required subtalar released.

The study shows that if Ponseti indication are strictly followed in the clubfoot treatment, only 11% of the patients would require surgical treatment within the first year of life, in contrast with the 70% of surgical indications we have had upto now. Proper training in the use of the technique and a personalized follow up improves the possibility of a successful treatment.


Dres Tomás Vonder Walde Daniel Palombo Juan S. Cairo Claudia Singal Hugo Bordo Pablo Gutman Ernesto Bertoni

Taking into consideration that distal epiphysis of the tibia is responsible of the 45% of its longitudinal growth, we emphasize the importance of this pathology trying to clarify which cases should be treated nonsurgically and which should undergo a surgical treatment in order to obtain the best possible results.

Seventy-five patients with distal epiphyseal fractures of the tibia and/or tibia and fibula were reviewed from 1993 to 2001. Sixty-two of them were male and 13 female, age of the patients ranged from 10 to 15 years old. They were evaluated according to the Lauge Haunsen classification which was modified by Dias and Tachdjian.

The results depended directly on the type of lesion and on the opportunity to perform a surgical reduction. The more frequent complications were in type III and IV of Salter and Harris. We believe that the future of these lesions, frequently seen in the orthopaedic field, with a higher incidence during the last years due to the increase of sports demands on children, depend directly on the initial physeal damage and the articular congruence obtained through the chosen treatment.


Dr L. Solano Dr. de Coulon J.C. Couto

Due to the increasing rate of relapses and the morbidity degree that this implies, we report our experience and results in the treatment of clubfoot in patients with myelomeningocele.

Between February 1996 and February 2001 12 patients with myelomeningocele (16 feet with clubfoot deformity and 4 bilateral cases) underwent surgical treatment. 5 were boys and 7 were girls. 3 relapsed cases were referred to our institution, 1 of them had a bilateral involvement. The average age at time of surgery was 27 months (range 7 months–5.3 years).

Levels of functional involvement were recorded according to Caneo (Argentina Chapter of Neuroorthopaedics) classification: Caneo 0: 2 patients, Caneo 1: 4 patients, Caneo 2: 8 patients, Caneo 3: 1 patient.

Relapses occurred in 3 cases; 2 with tendon lengthening technique and 1 tibialis posterior transfer to lateral peroneus brevis, split tibialis anterior tendon transfer. The complications were postoperative infection in 3 cases with wound dehiscence, tibia fracture after cast removal in 1 case and residual tibia intrarotation in 1 case. AFO were used in patients older than 2 years old with Caneo type 2 and 3 and RGO in patients with Caneo type 0 and 1.

The final results after solving all the complications were: 6 plantigrade feet, 1 intrarotated plantigrade foot and 1 relapsed inverse foot undergoing release of filum terminale with tethered spinal cord.

In conclusion, we consider the most effective technique the one that presents the lower rate of relapses and with efficient functional outcomes. We agree with Luciano Dias opinion that regional resection of all the tendinous elements is the best option to fulfill our goals.

We strongly advice a tendon lengthening or transfer in patients belonging to Caneo classification type 3.


Dres. Susana Canelo Gregorio Arendar

The corticosteriods in the treatment of Duchenne’s or Becker’s muscular dystrophies causes muscular weakness and osteoporosis characteristic of these patients and result in different fractures which are of difficult resolution because prolonged immobilization increases morbidity. How can this problem be solved in highly risk patients? The diverse models of external fixators have given us the possibility of treating them without immobilization and in consequence obtain a quicker return to previous functional status including gait .

4 patients with Duchenne’s and Becker’s muscular dystrophies were treated. 1 patient recovered its ambulatory ability and the rest maintain their gait. 1 of them still has an external fixator but he is able to walk. Patients presented a diaphyseal fracture of the femur, a proximal fracture of the tibia, an introchanteric fracture of the hip and a supracondylar fracture of the femur.

We consider that external fixators open an endless range of options, not very much used until recently, that help our patients to extend their functional status and gait. Patients accept them easily because they give them independence and avoid the depression that stems from the loss of capabilities.


H Miscione C Primono L Lanfranchi

Femoral osteotomies of pelvic support was performed in patients with hip instability, axial malalignment and leg length-discrepancy. Possibly inspired by techniques previously described by Schanz, Milch. Ilizarov and Rozbruch, 5 patients had neonatal hip sepsis sequelae (2 cases and 3 hips), septic arthritis (2 cases) and proximal femoral focal deficiency (1 case) were reviewed.

X-Rays of both limbs in neutral position to measure the deviation degree of the mechanical axis and other with the limb in maximal adduction to measure the osteotomy level of the pelvic support were taken before surgery.

The technique consists of a proximal femoral osteotomy in the intersecting axis in maximal adduction and a second distal metaphyseal osteotomy which allows the compensation of the mechanical axis and the elongation of the limb. Both are fixed with an external fixator.

This technique gives a pelvic support improving the Trendelemburg gait and tighter abductors muscles due to simultaneous correction of LLD and knee alignment.


Dres. Luis Cassinelli Juan Domingo Parejas

Developmental dysplasia of the hip presents different presentations and its treatment depends on early detection. 2975 patients younger than 6-month-old with hip ultrasonographies were studied between March 1998 and March 2001. In 26 patients, 33 ultrosonographically pathologic hips were detected and treated. 81% of the treated hips (27 patients) returned to their normal position before the 3rd week, only 6 remained dislocated and underwent surgical resolution. Patients with dislocated hips required an average of 12 week to complete the treatment protocol. Hip instability and subluxed hips healed between the 6th and 8th weeks. Those patients who began their treatment at one month old (10 hips – 33%) obtained the best results. To conclude, we agree with others authors on the effectiveness of the ultrasonographic method for early diagnoses and its use along treatment.


C. Cadu L. Pidhorz

Introduction: The purpose of this retrospective study was to evaluate the results of retrograde pinning, according to Hacketal procedure, for unstable fractures of the humeral neck with particular attention to three and four part fractures.

Materials and Methods: Between 7/1990 and 4/2001, we treated 44 patients (26 females and 18 males) ranging in age from 16 to 92 years (mean: 59/5 years). 75% of the cases followed a domestic trauma. Using Neer classification there were 30 two part fractures, 12 three part and 2 four part fractures. After closed reduction was performed under biplane image intensification, a small incision was made to expose the distal humerus by blount dissection. A 5 mm hole was drilled. Three to five prebend Kirschner (25 cases) or Metaizeau pins (19 cases) were introduced retrograde achieving a ‘bouquet’-type fixation within the humeral head. Post operatively, the arm was immobilized in a Mayo-type sling for 2–3 weeks. Then mobilization was started in all directions except rotation, who was cautiously done later. The results were evaluated according to consolidation, pain and range of motion. Complications associated with the treatment were recorded. We considered as excellent results, asymptomatic shoulder with full motion, good results patients with slight pain or reduction of motion and bad results, those with any pain, valuable restriction of motion and functional handicap.

Results: The mean follow up was 21/7 months. Two patients died before callus formation. All patients were re-examined or contacted by phone. No patient was lost to follow-up. The mean hospitalization range was 6.4 days. Two patients had loss of fixation. Fractures united with callus formation in 4 to 8 week. Patients regained a full range of motion in 64% of the cases, 88% were free of pain. No avascular necrosis was noted in that series.

The functional outcome was excellent in 64% of the cases, good in 21.5% of the cases. Pins removal was almost necessary for proximal pins migration in 45% of the cases and distal migration in 7.5% of the cases.

Discussion: The overall finding of good results in this series compares favorably with results of other operative treatment. We believe that our technique offers distinct advantages: few displacement, no osteonecrosis but our follow-up can be considered as insufficient. Migrations of the pins remain a matter of concern.

Conclusion: Retrograde pinning by the olcranon fossea is a demanding technique which makes sense biologically from the stand point of respect of vascularity. It is a useful alternative to open reduction and internal fixation. In three or four part fractures, it has to be tested before primary hemiarthroplasty.


G. Edelson F. Vigder I. Kelly

Complex fracture patterns of the proximal humerus can be difficult to understand and to treat. Classification systems are inadequate and the exact mechanisms of injury are obscure. From inspection of 73 cases of proximal humeral fractures culled from a large number of museum specimens, we propose a hypothesis as to the nature and configuration of these injuries. It is suggested that the glenoid is the “anvil” upon which the humeral head is broken and that the particular fracture personality reflects the position of the head vis a vis the glenoid at the time of injury. From this perspective, proximal humeral fractures present in a comprehensible and progressive sequence. Five different fractures patterns are identified and account for the vast majority of these injuries. X-ray examination, especially CT 3-D reconstructions, in a small group of clinical cases (30 patients) substantiated the usefulness of looking at these fractures in this way. From a combination of the museum studies and patient material, we have constructed a “fracture wheel” diagram for the presentation of these injuries in a format which may be helpful in organizing a new and clinically useful classification system.


C. Zinman

Fractures of the proximal humerus account for 4 to 5% of all fractures. Most occur in elderly individuals caused in part by osteoporosis.

Conservative treatment frequently led to poor clinical results because of the inability to gain and maintain satisfactory reduction.

The preferred method for these fractures was open reduction and internal fixation especially in those fractures with displacement and in young patients.

In 18 patients the fracture was operatively reduced and was secured with a plate and screws.

Methods of plating: T plate, clover leaf plate or blade plate modified. Delayed union and non-union of humeral head fracture is also an indication for open reduction and internal fixation by plate and screws.

A consecutive series of 18 patients with displaced fracture and fracture dislocation, followed for a minimum period of one year were analyzed.

The age of the patient range from 16 to 62 years.

The fractures were classified according to Neer 91970).

The aim of treatment was accurate reduction and stable fixation of the fracture with plate and screw.

The most common technical error was a too high positioning of the plate caused implant impinged under the acromion during abduction. No aseptic necrosis of the humeral head was observed. There was no deep infection.

11 patients had an excellent or good result, 7 had a fair result, and 1 had a poor result.

Koval in a biomechanical cadaver study was to compare the mechanical stability of ten different fixation, techniques used of stabilize surgical neck fractures of the proximal humerus in both osteopenic and non osteopenic bone.

The AO five holes T plate provided significantly greater resistance to displacement than all other methods tested the fresh-frozen specimens. Their effectiveness diminished in the presence of osteopenia.


G. Volpin

Introduction: The treatment of fractures of the proximal humerus is still controversial. Conservative treatment may result in severe disability due to malunion and shoulder stiffness. Open reduction and rigid fixation requires extensive soft tissue exposure, which may result in a high incidence of avascular necrosis of the proximal humerus. Today, many authors are in the opinion that “minimal osteosynthesis” of such fractures is preferable to rigid fixation. It may be achieved by K.W. techniques, lag screws, rush pins, percutaneous pinning or percutaneous external fixation. This study reviews our experience with comminuted fractures of the proximal humerus treated by different minimal invasive techniques of fixation, using functional evaluation and radiological assessment.

Materials and methods: This study consists of 76 patients with comminuted fractures of the proximal humerus (33 M, 44 F, 18–89 year old, mean 52/5Y) with follow-up of 2–6 years (mean 3.5Y). They were treated by minimal invasive surgical techniques: 53 of them by closed reduction and percutaneous pinning and the remaining 23 by ORIF and minimal osteosynthesis. All patients were evaluated by Neer’s shoulder grading score and radiographs.

Results: Overall results were excellent and good in 85% of patients with 2, and 3 parts fractures of the proximal humerus, treated either by closed or open minimal osteosynthesis techniques, with some better results in less comminuted fractures.

9/13 (69%) of young patients with 4 part fractures treated by closed percutaneous minimal fixation had good functional results. In four other patients the clinical results were poor and two of them developed AVN of the humeral head. 5/8 (62.5%) of young patients with 4 part fractures treated by ORIF and minimal fixation had good functional results. In three other patients the clinical results were poor and one of them developed AVN of the humeral head.

Conclusions: Based on this study it seems that “minimal osteosynthesis” by K.W. techniques and by lag screws, by closed or open reduction, remains as the first optional treatment of complex fractures of the shoulder, even in young patients with a 4 part fracture.


S. Velkes I. Jakim

Fractures of the proximal humerus occur predominantly in the elderly patient population. There has been a tendency over the last 15 years to perform surgical procedures to reduce and hold these fractures while the bone and soft tissue heal. The osteoporotic nature of the bone does not allow adequate fixation of the bone and therefore fixation techniques are inadequate to allow optimal soft tissue rehabilitation.

A study was performed to observe the results of non-surgically treated displaced fractures of the proximal humerus in the elderly.

The encouraging results are presented and discussed.

Non-surgical management of displaced fractures of the proximal humerus achieves a good functional shoulder although not normal in this predominantly sedentary population. The question arises as to quality of function after surgical management of these difficult fractures compared to non surgical management and if surgical management is indicated in these elderly usually frail patients with low demand from their shoulders.


Ch. Cuny M. Irrazi P. Beau

Introduction: Complex humerus fractures is a frequent lesion with a greater incidence than hip fractures. The treatment is a challenge for orthopaedic surgeons. We present a new osteosynthesis technique based on a mini invasive nailing with a self stabilized screws interlocking.

Methods: We used a 15 cm intramedullary nail with a 7, 8, or 9 mm width. The proximal locking is carried out in the articular and tuberosity fragments with cancellous screws. Two or three small fragments long threaded screws are usually necessary to stabilize the fragments and the humeral head. Rigid fixation is obtained with an excellent stability due to the intra nail locking of the screws. Distal interlocking is carried out at the level of the deltoid tuberosity ensured by 1 or 2 frontal screws introduced away from the nerves and blood supply. Functional therapy is initiated on the first post-operative day.

Results: We present a series of the first 64 cases done in a prospective approach. The patients have been classified according to the Constant score. The mean balanced score is 88% at the two years follow-up. Among the advantages of the technique we point out the great comfort of the patients with a minimal pain and the possibility of an immediate rehabilitation after the surgery. Because of the use of the nail, we stop the use of the hemiarthroplasty even in the 4 fragments fractures.

Conclusion: Telegraph nailing of the complex proximal humeral fractures gives excellent results at the two years follow-up, sometimes unexpected even in the more complex cases and avoid the use of shoulder arthroplasty in the traumatic indication.


G. Morag E. Maman E. Steinberg G. Mozes

Introduction: Fractures of the proximal humerus account for 4–5% of all fractures. The number one cause of this type of fracture is age related osteoporosis associated with minimal trauma. Approximately 80% of these fractures are non or minimally-displaced, and can be treated conservatively with good results. However, treatment of displaced complex fractures is still controversial. The disadvantage of open procedures is the risk of damaging the blood supply to the humeral head, leading to a higher incidence of avascular necrosis.

Closed Reduction and Percutaneous Fixation (CRPF) is a minimal invasive procedure with a lower risk of damaging the blood supply. The main complication of this technique is loosening of the guide wires and displacement of the fragments requiring a second operation.

Purpose: The guide wire loosening leads us to improve the technique by adding an external fixator to stabilize the guide wires and secure fragment positioning. We report our experience of treating displaced fractures of the proximal humerus with Closed Reduction and External Fixation (CREF).

Materials and methods: Between the years 1996–2001 we operated on 37 patients for 38 complex fractures and fracture dislocations of the proximal humerus. We had 16 two part fractures, 13 three part fractures, 3 four part fractures, 5 two part fracture dislocation and 1 four part fracture dislocation according to the Neer’s classification.

The mean age was 60 years old ranging from 16–90 with a male to female ratio of 1:1. The patients were placed in a beach chair position using an image intensifier for AP and axillary views. Because the closed reduction was unsatisfactory, six patients underwent open reduction and external fixation. The remaining 32 shoulders underwent CREF.

Passive motion exercises were initiated on the first postoperative day. The external fixator was removed after four to six weeks (mean time for external fixator – 5.3 weeks). After removing the external fixator the patients began with active assisted mobilization of the shoulder and isometric strengthening exercises.

Results: The average follow up was 31.6 months (range 6–60 months). No loosening was observed upon removal of the external fixator, however the following complications were encountered: 5 patients had superficial pin tract infections, 1 patients developed an avascular necrosis of the humeral head, 1 patient had a non union of the fracture. Of the remaining patients, 13 patients had an excellent result, 15 patients had a good result and 5 patients had a fair result.

Conclusions: CREF is a minimal invasive technique for complex fractures of the proximal humerus, greatly reducing the damage to the blood supply when compared to open surgical procedures. It offers a better stabilization than CRPF, thus reducing the complication rate. The percutaneous technique causes less scaring and therefore a shorter rehabilitation program. Consequently, this procedure is recommended for complex fractures of the proximal humerus.


D. Hendel M. Weisbort A. Garti

Forty-two revision knee replacements were performed in our department between 1992–2000. We report our experience in 18 cases of stiff knees with a range of motion from −5° – 75° (average 50°) where an oblique incision through the quadriceps tendon combined with medial capsular incision (the “wandering resident” incision) was used for exposure. This exposure allowed us to expose the stiff knee with no hazard of avulsion of the patellar tendon and with easy removal of the old prosthesis and implantation of the new one. In 5 of these cases, this exposure was used twice in two stage revisions of a septic prosthesis.

Post-operative rehabilitation was slower, a knee brace was used in extension for 6 weeks and daily physiotherapy and CPM from 0°–70° only. Full range of motion was started after 6 weeks. Follow-up in 1–8 years (average 3.5 years).

All patients had good clinical results with range of motion from 0°–110° (average 86°). One patient had a lag of 10° in active extension. The knee score of the American Knee Society ranged from 35–52 (average 40) and improved to 72–89 (average 84).

In 3 cases, we used a non-constrained prosthesis (PCL) sacrificing condylar prosthesis), in 11 cases a constrained prosthesis (CCK type) and in 4 cases a rotating hinge prosthesis.


A. Oran M. Pritsch (Perry)

Introduction: Fracture of the proximal humerus are challenging for diagnosis and treatment. The vast majority of these fracture associated with osteoporosis in elderly. Decision making for the treatment must include all arguments of fracture type, physical demands and rehabilitation cooperation of patients. This is particularly crucial in proximal humerus fracture. Results of surgery including hemiarthroplasty are difficult to predict and many times type of surgical treatment can be determined intra-operative or at least after closed manipulation attempt.

Material and methods: Between September 1998 to September 2000, 68 patients underwent surgery for proximal humerus fracture. Patients who underwent hemiarthroplasty were not included in this study. Diagnosis of the fracture was based on Neer classification system and was aided by CT scan. Type of surgery was made finally after closed manipulation attempt under anesthesia. Patients were consented for closed manipulation, open reduction and internal fixation or hemiarthroplasty. Data was collected retrospectively from outpatients notes. 32 males and 36 females, age 40–88 (mean: 62), underwent closed manipulation and pinning (30), ORIF included pinning and PDS suture (32) and ORIF included PDS suture only (6). Fracture type distributed as follows: 2 parts surgical neck – 9, 2 parts GT – 6, 3 parts – 29, fracture dislocations – 6, 4 parts – 12, impacted valgus fracture 6.

Four threaded pins were inserted retrograde and trimmed under the skin. Two antegrade pins were left out of the skin and banded to prevent migration to the axilla. Patients were immobilized in shoulder immobilizer for 6 weeks when pins were removed in outpatient clinic. Control X-ray was taken at 2, 4, 6, 12 weeks. If fracture was noted to be unstable, X-ray was taken every week up to 4 weeks. In case of any deterioration after 12 weeks X-ray was taken to detect signs of AVN.

Rehabilitation program commenced after clinical union with passive and assisted active for 4 weeks followed by active mobilization. Follow-up ranged from 10–34 months (mean: 22) and range of motion with X-ray description were documented.

Results: All fractures but one were united, fracture position was noted in 31 patients as normal in 46 (68%), head-shaft in extension in 8 (11.7%), varus head – 7 (10%), valgus head – 1 (1.4%), prominent GT – 4 (6%), prominent LT – 3 (4.4%), complete displacement – 2 (2.8%), dislocated – 1 (1.4%).

Mean range of motion for all groups was: Elevation – 144 (60–180), External Rotation – 54.6 (−10–80), Internal Rotation – L1 (Throchanter – T8). Statistical analysis for fracture groups showed best results for impacted valgus and greater tuberosity fracture after open reduction and worst results were noted for 4 parts fractures and fracture dislocation. Although the study was not randomized there was no significant difference between the group of closed pinning and open surgery.

Complications: Six patients had revision surgery during the early follow up due to fixation failure. In one case repinning was performed, in 2 cases closed pinning transformed to open surgery and suture of GT, in one case osteotomy and re-insertion of LT was needed, one case complete lost of fixation ended in hemiarthroplasty and one case of fracture dislocation failed to closed and open surgery and need bone block (Laterget) to prevent re-dislocation. AVN was noted in 5 cases – 2 partial and 3 complete (3% and 4.4%, respectively). Pin tract infection occurred in the 6 of prominent antegrade pins and resolved after early removal of these pins without the retrograde pins. G-H arthrosis was noted in one case after 2 years.

Conclusions: Surgical treatment of proximal humerus fracture and attempt to preserve the humeral head is alternative to conservative treatment or hemiarthroplasty from the other hand. High surgical are demanded and fixation cannot be guaranteed due to minimal bone stock for fixation. Partial loss of fixation still leave better position and reasonable functional results. Further attention is needed to the lesser tuberosity which could be seen better under fluoroscopy under anesthesia.


Y. Mattan

We present our experience with 40 infected total knee arthroplasties that were treated in our department during the last 10 years. Three patients suffered from early postoperative infection and were treated by debridement and antibiotic therapy with complete cure.

25 patients had chronic infection with loosening. 17 patients were treated by two-stage revision, six were treated by arthrodesis and in three patients excision arthroplasty was performed due to general poor conditions. 12 patients had late acute hematogenous infection and nine of them underwent debridement, either open or arthroscopic, and antibiotic therapy. Overall, 90% of the patients had no clinical, radiological or laboratory evidence of infection.


M. Soudry A. Butbul S. Iordache A. Greental

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the results of revision surgery in the treatment failed TKR with the TCP III like prosthesis.

Materials & Methods: Between 1985 till May 2001, 116 failed knees were managed. 91 underwent complete revision, 18 were arthrodesed, 6 underwent patella revision only and 1 arthrolysis. Among the complete revisions: 45 were due to mechanical failure (loosening, wear or instability) 29 for infection and 17 for painful or stiff knee.

In 81 of them the implanted prosthesis was TCP III or CCK and were evaluated in this study. 33 were males and 58 females. The average age at revision was 72 years. Most of the cases were performed by the senior author. All cases were osteoarthritic except one which was rheumatoid. The distribution of TCP III like prosthesis was as follows: 47 were TCP III, 33 were CCK and 2 dual. The infected cases were treated whether by one stage or two stage surgery. Patella was not resurfaced but reshaped if patella bone stock was not adequate.

Results: Nine patients died and 14 patients could not be traced in the last follow-up. The average follow up was around 6 years (range of 6 months to 16 years). As compared to preoperative situation almost all of the patients were on the overall subjectively satisfied. The preop HSS score was poor for all the patients. The average postop HSS score was 82 for mechanical failure, 76 for infection and 77 for painful knee. One infected knee got reinfected after 3 years. Three cases had to be revised for the second time to a rotating hinge prosthesis: 2 due to instability and one due to loosening.

Discussion: The TCP III like prosthesis proved in our hands to be a relatively successful implant in revision knee surgery. The new modular CCK design is quite an improvement over the TCP III design and is more versatile in allowing restoration of previous anatomy and joint line. The obvious advantage of this implant are its immediate inherent stability combined with a reproducible normal valgus alignment. The results were best in the treatment of failed knee due to mechanical failure.


Full Access
C. Tauber A. Kaban M. Krushinsky

Between 1983 and 2001, 25 revision of total knee arthroplasties were performed in our department. 16 tibiofemoral, 9 tibial revisions and 9 operations on the patella were performed.

The original implants of the 16 tibio femoral revisions were 8 total condylar, 2-IB1, 2-IB2,

1 AGC, 1 cruciate retaining AGC and 2 porous coated J& J.

The revision prostheses were: One IB1, 1 kinematic II, 7 CCK, 4 dual articular, 1 sigma and 2 Guepar.

The results were: very good 2, good 9, failure 2 (sepsis, removal of implants and knee fusion), 3 patients died during the study period of unrelated causes to surgery. One of them was followed for 13 years, having a very good result (Kin II) until his death.

Tibial component revisions were performed on 9 knees.

The original implants were: 5 total condylar, 1 IB-1 and 3 IB-2.

The revision implants were: 5 total condylar, tibiae, 1 IB-1, 1 IB-2 and 2 IB-2 with augments and intramedul-lary rods.

The results for the tibial revisions were: good – 4, fair 1, failures – 2 (sepsis and eventually arthrodesis. Two patients died within the study period of unrelated causes.

The patella posed a special problem, of 9 patients, 7 were operated for patellar component loosening, and the component was removed. In one patient a patellec-tomy was performed because patellar osteomyelitis was suspected. In another patient a tibial tuberosity transfer for patellar dislocation was performed.

The results of patellar surgery were: 4 – fair, 1 – unknown, and 4 patients died during the study period of causes unrelated to surgery.

Our series reflects the gathered experience in our department. During the early years tibial and patellar loosening were the main problems. Special revision prostheses were not available and were not needed in most cases. Later, with increasing number of arthroplasties performed, and with longer follow up periods, the need for special revision prostheses became overt. The most commonly used implant was the constrained con-dylar knee and was later replaced by the dual articular prostheses. The latter appealed to us because of its partially mobile tibial articular surface.

Our failures were due to Staphylococcus aureus sepsis, which we were unable to eradicate, in spite of performing staged procedures, repeated joint debride-ments and the use of gentamycin impregnated bone cement.

In all but one of these cases the implants had to be removed and the knee had to be fused. In one of our 4 failures even after solid fusion, the infection was not eradicated. We succeeded to revise only one infected knee with Staph. Aureus with a good functional result. In one case of candida infection, we succeeded to eradicate the infection and replaced the loose implants with a CK achieving a good result now for 4 years.


S. Dekel

No doubt that revision TKR is a challenging procedure. This procedure may be divided into three steps. First, a careful clinical examination is needed to assess range of motion, stiffness and possible difficulty in exposing and extracting the prosthesis. Second, an examination of joint stability is needed. Finally, radiographs should be evaluated for any bone deficiency that may require bone grafting or special prosthesis.

Exposure approaches may change in cases when second stage implantation is performed when an infected total knee replacement exists and when a cement spacer is used. In the cases when the cement spacer is left in place for a longer period of time, stiffness is much more prominent and therefore exposure may be even more difficult.

Subvastus and midvastus approaches are not suitable for this kind of revision. Usually in revision of total knee replacement or after cement spacer procedures, a larger exposure with the use of either snip incision, or osteotomy of the tibial tuberosity, or VY exposure is required. There are some cases where one can perform revision total knee without the extra exposure mentioned.

In revising total knee replacement, it is imperative that the joint line be restored to its original position. There are a few techniques that can be used to achieve this task by using a few landmarks. They include:

The residue of the menisci.

The distance measured from the medial epicondyle to the joint surface.

The distance measured from the head of the fibula to the original joint surface.

This can be done by comparing the other non-operated knee too.

The decision to which kind of prosthesis to use depends on the amount of bone loss and the injury to the surrounding structures and ligaments. One should be prepared for all options during surgery, in other words, using constrain or unconstraint prosthesis in the same patients. This depends solely on the findings during surgery.

In our hospital, we have used all the exposure approaches of the knee in revision surgery. We prefer the snip excision in the first stage, and if this is not sufficient then a tibial tuberosity osteotomy is preferred to the VY incision of the quadriceps mechanism. We found that using the meniscal residue is a very useful landmark for the joint line and we use it constantly.


L. Pidhorz the Guepar

Introduction: Dislocation after primary total knee arthroplasty is a very uncommon complication. Some case reports referred to Total Condylar, Insall Burstein or more recently Mobile bearing prostheses.

Frequency is probably under evaluated and their treatment and consequences subject to discussion.

Dislocation has to be differentiated from knee instability, subluxation and expulsion of the PE tibial insert.

The purpose of this review was to study their mechanism, treatment and consequences.

A modification of the surgical technique and the insert design was deduced.

Materials and methods: From 9/1994 to 9/1998, 229 primary Wallaby 2 with an original modular PE tibial insert were performed by the Guepar in 11 centers. Eleven posterior dislocations occurred less than 2 years postoperatively.

A prospective analysis was performed to compare the following variables of these patients (study group) to 56 cases who did not experience that complication (control group): age, sex, weight, component size, surgical approach, importance of release, pre and post surgical scores, alignment, stability, patella and component thickness. Statistical analysis of these parameters was performed.

Results: There were no statistical differences between the two groups for any variable assessed except importance of the valgus knee deformity (11° vs 6°), Keblish approach, lateral release and postoperative flexion (119° vs 106°) p< 0.01.

Conservative treatment was successful in 10 cases, but 3 recurrent dislocations and a neglected dislocation were treated surgically after modification of the tibial insert.

Discussion: Possible factors contributing to these dislocations are discussed as surgical procedure, quality of knee stability, characteristics of the tibial post compared to other implant (placement, dislocation safety factor).

After modifications of the stabilizer concerning height and slight posterior displacement, in a personal series of 129 TKA, dislocations disappeared.


Y. Mirovsky Y. Anekstein N. Halperin

Study Design: Thirty-four patients who were operated for spinal deformities with the Spine System Evolution (SSE) were retrospectively reviewed.

Objectives: To evaluate the efficiency of SSE to correct spinal deformities.

Summary of Background Data: Since the end of the Harrington rods era, several instrumentation were introduced for correction of spinal deformities. Most of these instrumentations are evolution of he CD instrumentation and are based on combination of translation, distraction/compression and possible some rotation forces. Cord injuries were informed to be more frequent with the new instruments and are related both to ischemic injuries and to mechanical insults to the cord by the supralaminar and the infralaminar hooks. Correction by the SSE is based on pedicle screws and pedicular-transverse locks. No hook is inserted into the spinal canal.

Methods: All charts, radiographs, and images of the patients operated for spinal deformities with the SSE were reviewed. Thirty-four patients were found. For the purpose of this study they were evaluated for the amount of correction achieved, balance of the spine, subjective satisfaction of the cosmetic appearance and the surgical complications.

Results: The mean age of the operated patients was 19.5 years. Twenty-one were operated for idiopathic scoliosis and were found to have 61% correction of the major curves. Five patients were operated for neuromuscular scoliosis with 69% of correction in average, four were operated for thoracic hyperkyphosis with reduction of the curves to physiologic range in all of them and four were operated for adult scoliosis with 38% of correction. Twenty-eight patients were satisfied from the results and the same number of patients were found to be balanced in the range of up to one-centimeter shift from the mid-line. No patient was found to have any major neurologic complication and no deep wound infections was registered. One patient had postoperative bronchopneumonia, another one had pneumothorax, one had superficial wound infection and another girl was troubled with her body image.

Conclusions: SSE instrumentation was found friendly to use and relatively safe for correction of spinal deformities.


H. Bensahel (Paris) K. Kuo (Chicago) M. Duhaime (Montreal)

Purpose: In order to improve our understanding of club-foot, an international rating system of evaluation is proposed which is supported by the International Club Foot Study Group (ICFSG).

Method: All the parameters of the assessment shall be objective. They are clinical and radiographic. On the clinical side, the morphology of foot is assessed for the hindfoot, midfoot and the forefoot. Then, the global morphology of the foot and lower limb is assessed. But the function of the foot is the major criteria which enhances the value of the outcome. It is assessed on the passive motion of the different parts of the foot. Then, the active motion is evaluated. Arc added a clinical gait analysis and the occurrence of eventual pain. On the radiographic side, the various angles of bones axes are calculated on AP and lateral views.

Results: The score of Outcome Evaluation ranges from 0 up to 60 points, the latter expressing the worst result. Four groups of results are mentioned so as excellent, good, fair and poor. The Outcome Evaluation should be performed at 6 years old and at the end of the growth.

Conclusion: The Outcome Evaluation will allow us to be able to compare truly the forthcoming series of club-foot.


S.D. Iordache E. Mercado N. Ohana M. Soudry

With advances in surgical technique and instrumentation, the anterior approach to the thoracolumbar spine becomes more popular. Anterior approach is considered particularly when ventral decompression of neural structures is needed, providing optional stability by fusing the involved segment with instruments specially designated for that purpose. The usual approach is done through a 10th or 11th rib thoracotomy, opening of the pleural cavity and a semilunar cut at the periphery of the diaphragm, in order to expose the anterolateral aspect of the vertebral column. This technique involves the risk of phrenic nerve injury and diaphragmatic paralysis combined with morbidity of the chest tube. A variant of that technique is the retrodiaphragmatic approach, which provides the surgeon with the advantages of ventral exposure, potentially avoiding the morbidity of the standard transpleural thoracotomy.

Methods: During a three-year period, all patients with major anterior pathology at the T11, T12 or Ll level, were operated using the retrodiaphragmatic anterior approach. This involved an 10th or 11th rib thoracotomy with the patient in a lateral decubitus position. Following rib resection, blunt dissection of the diaphragm from the chest wall was performed without its surgical incision. The parietal pleural was mobilized medially and left intact and the thoracolumbar spine was exposed for the procedure. In case of a major pleural defect, a chest drain was inserted.

Results: Fifteen patients (10 males and 5 females, mean age: 32.6y) made up by study group. This included six patients who had a thoracolumbar fracture, five patients who were diagnosed as having idiopathic scoliosis and four patients who presented with metastatic disease in the thoracolumbar region. Adequate decompression was achieved in all patients as well as stable fixation of the involved segment. Mean operating time was 4.5 hours, average hospitalization length was six days. Three patients (20%) required a chest drain following the procedure. The drain was removed within three postoperative days of the operation. In five cases (40%) blood transfusion was required. Mainly for the underlying disease. The average decrease in the hemoglobin values, in the patient subgroup not requiring blood transfusion, was 3mg% at discharge comparing to the preoperative level. No intra-operative complications related to the surgical technique or instrumentation, were noted, nor any case of mortality. Complications such as respiratory distress, neurological damage, infection, hardware loosening or failure, pseudoarthrosis or hernia in scar were not observed during the post operative follow-up.

Conclusion: The retrodiaphragmatic approach to the thoracolumbar spine is safe and technically easy to apply in cases where ventral exposure of the spine is needed. This technique spares the need for diaphragmatic incision and in most cases, leaves the pleural cavity intact.


N. Ohana I. Klier D. Sheinis A. Sasson M. Soudry

Correction of spinal deformities such as those seen in idiopathic scoliosis, are one of the challenging aspects of the spine surgeon’s routine. A significant progress has been made in sense of the surgical approaches, implants design and methods of correction during the last two decades. Since the pioneer conception of Paul Harrington that a scoliotic curve can be corrected by distraction, other methods such as derotation and translation came out as an alternative ways to get a straight and balanced spine. Recently, a new concept of correction for spinal deformities named in-situ contouring, has brought to our attention. This method is based on a 6mm Titanium rod (SCS Eurosurgical Inc.) connected to the spine with a multiple hooks and screws system. The rod is bend according to the curve in the coronal plane and loosely secure with setscrews. Following primary application of the rod, the surgeon begins to bend it manually in situ, in a contrary direction to the curve’s shape. By applying a combination of a sagittal and coronal plane forces, the surgeon is able to achieve a final result of a straight and nicely balanced spine.

Methods: The medical records of patients with idiopathic scoliosis, who had surgery during the last three years, were reviewed. Patients, whose operation evolves using of the SCS system, enrolled into the study group. Clinical as well as radiographical data were retrieved from the hospital charts. Curves were classified according to King et al., measurements were taken using the Cobb’s method.

Results: There were 10 patients in the study group (7 females, 3 males, mean age: 16.6 years). All curves were primary thoracic from which 9 were type II and only one was type III. Mean pre-operative angle of the primary curve was 56°, mean post-operative angle was 22° with a 61% correction rate. Patients were followed for an average period of 12 months. No complications related to surgery, correction techniques, or neurological status was noted.

Conclusions: The in-situ contouring system has no drawbacks compare to other known methods. Our feeling is that this new technique gives the surgeon an ability to achieve the final position of the corrected spine, by a slow and gradual manipulation. This is taking a crucial advantage of the elastic property of the spine in order to get good correction and to avoid neurological complications or hooks pull out.


A. Hasharoni T.J. Errico

Combined anterior/posterior scoliosis surgery is the mainstay of scoliosis surgery in large curves with Cobb angle more than 65°, in stiff curves that correct to above 40° only on the pre-operative bending films and in Steersman’s kyphosis greater than 90°. The combined anterior/posterior scoliosis surgery allows better correction of the curve, saving motion segments in the spine and eliminating the occurrence of the crankshaft phenomenon. Video-assisted spinal surgery (VATS) and Mini open thoracotomy, thoracoscopically assisted (MOT-TA) allow for the performing of multi level discectomies and soft tissue release, as an anterior adjunct to posterior spine fusion, through minimal approach to the thoracic spine in scoliosis surgery. During the last year we have begun using the MOT-TA for anterior thoracic spine release and fusion, as the first step in releasing, reducing, and fusing large and stiff scoliotic curves, utilizing standard surgical instrumentation and techniques.

Materials and Methods: Mini-Thoracotomy Thoracoscopic Assisted was performed on 15 patients, age 4 to 48 (mean 20 years old) between January 2000 to present. There was a female predominance (12:3). In the group, 13 patients were scoliosis patients and 2 were kyphosis patients. All patients underwent anterior release and discectomy before performing posterior fusion. A mean of 4 discs (range 3 to 5 discs) was excised at surgery. The mean Cobb angle was 62°. No anterior instrumentation was placed in the first 14 cases. In case No. 15 an anterior crew-rod construct was placed through the mini thoracotomy incision.

Technique: MOT-TA is performed with the patient positioned in a lateral decubitus with the convex side of the scoliotic curve up through a 5–7 cm skin incision above the apical vertebra obliquely from the posterior to the middle axillary line.

Results: There was a short learning curve associated with the technique, which proved to be an easy and straight forward surgical technique. Pre-operative thoracic Cobb angle measured 50°–80° (average 62°) that bends to 30°–66° on the pre-operative thoracic bend films (average 45°). The pot-operative thoracic Cobb angle measured 15°–38° (average 28°). The overall curve correction was 59% on average. The anterior soft tissue releases and discectomies were a quick and relatively “dry” part of the surgery. Estimated blood loss ranged 50–800cc, less than a quarter of the total intra-operative blood loss averaging 220cc out of 1227cc of the total EBL. Anterior surgery time ranged 100 to 170 min averaging 147min for mean of 6.1 discs (range 4 to 9 discs). When compared to the total operative time, the anterior part of the surgery took about a 1/3 of the total surgery time.

Discussion: The results of the study show that the mini open thoracotomy, thoracoscopically assisted, for anterior thoracic spine release and discectomies is a fast, easy to learn technique with a short learning curve leading to complete anterior release, short operative time, allowing same day front and back surgery with no difficulty in performing internal thoracoplasty that results in structural and cosmetically superior outcome. In the hands of an experienced surgeon, the usage of VATS could be an effective and beneficial in scoliosis surgery; however, in the case of less experienced surgeon, who has no experience in thoracoscopic surgery, the MOT-TA could be an elegant and useful way to perform the technically demanding anterior discectomies and releases in severely deformed and rigid scoliotic spine. In our last case we have demonstrated the ability to instrument the anterior spine utilizing the same mini thoracotomy incision, this advance will be carried further to more extensive instrumentation in the future.

In conclusion: Mini open thoracotomy, thoracoscopically assisted, for anterior thoracic spine release and fusion is a faster, easier, cosmetically superior and surgically justified procedure.


Y. Bronstein Y. Barzilay L. Kaplan

Treatment of congenital kyphosis with severe angular dysplastic spine in children with myelomeningocele (MMC) is one of the most difficult spinal procedures. Most of the surgeons support kyphectomy with long segmental spinal instrumentation and postoperative immobilization by thoracolumbosacral orthosis.

Several spinal deformities are seen frequently in patients who have MMC. The deformity may be congenital or paralytic. Congenital lumbar kyphosis is less common, but most difficult in patients with MMC, occurring in 10–20% of patients. Most curves are congenital and rigid, often more than 80° at birth, and rapidly progresses.

With progression of kyphotic deformity, patients experience recurrent skin breakdown over the apex of the kyphos; impaired sitting balance; the necessity of using their hands for support; collapsing spine and decreasing of lumbar height reduce the capacity of the abdominal cavity and resulting in reduced respiratory capacity and malnutrition. The poor posture and short abdomen make it difficult to manage the patients’ urological needs. A severe deformity raises difficulties in social and psychological development.

Non-operative treatment with spinal orthoses may provide only temporary correction of a kyphotic deformity, but does not prevent progression and skin breakdown.

The goal of surgical treatment is correction of spinal deformity by long segmental instrumentation and achievement of a solid spine fusion in order to allow a balanced sitting position and to prevent complications.

From 1983 to 2001, 6 patients with thoracic level myelomeningocele and severe kyphotic deformity were referred for surgical correction. There were 5 males and 1 female patients with average age at the time of surgery of 8.3 years (range 4.3–13 years). All patients suffered from severe kyphosis, range 90° to 130°, average – 108°. All of them underwent posterior ligation of spinal cord during resection of lordotic segment of the kyphos, and segmental spinal fixation of the deformity from the thoracic spine to the sacrum. In all cases following the resection of the vertebrae it was possible to correct the deformity.

All patients were available for follow-up with range of 6–216 months, average 85 months. All of them were satisfied with the surgical outcome and presented in their final clinical examination with balanced and comfortable sitting, without soft tissue complications. In all cases a significant correction of the deformity was achieved (15°–30°) and enabled comfortable and stable sitting. Two patients suffered post-operative complications, one from surgical wound infection which required surgical debridement followed by soft tissue covering, and the other suffered from distal migration of the rod which was shortened later on.

Discussion: Kyphotic deformity in a patient who has MMC is a challenge for the orthopaedic surgeon and requires major surgical intervention. Resection of the kyphos with posterior instrumentation and fusion may solve patient’s functional problems.


R. Gepstein I. Pekarsky Y. Folman Y. Leitner R. David O. Nakai SH Lee

Study Design: We describe innovative minimally invasive Israeli made Expandable Spinal Fusion System for lumbar spinal fusion, in patients with all caused of mechanical back pain: Degenerative Disc Disease (DDD) at one or two levels from L2–S1, up to Grade l spondylolysthesis. The purpose of the study was to provide a preliminary evaluation of the safety and efficacy of the Expandable Spinal Fusion System in establishing vertebral stability and fusion, and in improving the quality of life of the patients.

The relatively large diameter of currently used cages dictates extensive manipulations, damaging structures that are crucial for spinal stability.

The Expandable Spinal Fusion System, is 5 mm in diameter in closed configuration, applied in a minimally invasive technique, through a 6mm entering opening by an open or percutaneous posterior procedures. Once in position, its dimensions are increased to a precut size in a controlled procedure. Thus, this system maintains the integrity of facet joints, with no or minimal laminectomy, and minimal damage to the surrounding tissues.

Methods: Data were collected in a series of 60 patients with DDD in levels L3–S1. The patients wee operated in the open posterior approach with or without Pedicle Screws and percutaneous posterolateral. Both end-plates faces were treated by special curettes and partially removed. Posterior iliac bone graft was used and 2 tubes device were introduced to the inter-somatic space under direct vision controlled by X-rays C-Arm intensifying magnification.

Data: The implantation approach was posterior in 52 patients, anterior in 2 and percutaneous in 6 patients. Maximal follow up period is 12 months. Patients follow up was completed according to investigational protocol mandate follow up visit at 1.5, 3, 6, 12 months postoperatively. The main at the time of the surgery was 52 years old. 57 underwent surgery at one level as follows: 3 at L3-L4, 32 at L4-L5, and 21 at L5-S1, and 3 underwent surgery at two levels.

Patient questionnaire pain and quality of life was evaluated using the Oswestry questionnaire and VAS measurement. The patient fill those pre-operatively and at each follow up visit.

Results: Although follow up period is short according to preliminary data, the Expandable Spinal Fusion System has proved to be safe, effective, as well as easy to handle for treating all cases of mechanical back pain: DDD. There was no neurological injury, no infection, no death and no worsening of clinical symptoms. There was no breakage or migration of the implant at the last follow-up. Flexion-Extension X-ray show good stability. VAS score for pain dropped from 8 pre op to 2.6 in average 3 months post-op.


D. Attia

Purpose: We report on the midterm clinical results in a retrospective series of 157 patients who have undergone PLIF with the Varilift expandable and lordotic cages, mostly stand alone.

Material & methods: 157 consecutive patients, 80 men and 76 women, with a mean age of 44 (19 to 72); Single level procedure in 123 patients, 2 levels in 34 patients. Preoperative symptoms included chronic low back pain and/or sciatica for more than 6 months with failure of conservative treatment including epidural steroids. Primary surgical indications were degenerative disc disease (n = 76), spondylolisthesis (n = 33), failed back syndromes (n = 43 patients). Posterior fixation was added in 21 of the spondylolisthesis, 2 multi-level fusions and 3 other patients due to a previous wide laminectomies and a resultant instability. Surgical technique consisted of minimal bilateral laminotomy preserving the midline ligamentous structures and the conservation of most of the facets.

Results: Follow ranged from 12 to 60 months. There were a 89.2% satisfactory results, 10 fair and 7 poor results, of which 2 required revision. Neither revision was due to implant failure. Fusion was deemed solid in 150 from the 157 patients, 7 showed an asymtomatic radiolucency around the cage, but without motion on bending films. 3 other patients needed a posterior fixation removal after one year. Of the 128 patients working pre-op, post-op 92 patients returned to their previous job, 18 returned to a less strenuous position and 18 patients did not return to work. No patient’s symptoms worsened. As major complications, we noted 3 cases of foot drop who had partial (1) or complete recovery (2), and one cases of unilateral thrombosis of the retinum central artery. there were no cage breakage or migration of the implants.

Segmental lordosis, measured on the fused discs at the last follow up showed a mean angle of lordosis of 6.9o (4.8° on L4–L5, 8° on L5–S1).

Conclusion: The VariLiftTM Cage confirms by its medium term result the stand alone feature in the appropriate indications. This PLIF technique resulted in a greater than 90% fusion rate, with a minimal of complications, good pain relief, and early recovery. No failure of the material was noted. The major advantages of this device are its intrinsic stability, the big inner volume for bone graft, the promoting of lordosis and the overall size saving that authorize a minimal invasive procedure.


R. David Z. Arinzon I. Pekarsky Y. Leitner Y. Pevzner R. Gepstein

Objective: To assess the safety and outcome of laminectomy in patients with spinal stenosis operated at the age of 65 years or older. The relation between the duration of the symptoms and results was investigated.

Study Design: A retrospective chart analysis with up to 10 years follow-up.

Setting: The Spinal Care Unit, Meir Medical Center, Kfar Saba, Israel.

Material and Methods: The medical records of all patients who had laminectomy for spinal stenosis at the age of 65 or more in a 10 years period were reviewed. Assessment of pain, ability to perform the basic activities of daily living, transferring dressing and basing before and after the operation was done by a telephone interview. Patient’s self-estimation of the final result of the surgery was also recorded.

Results: Two hundred eight-three patients were eligible to participate in the study.

They were allocated into 3 groups according to the duration of symptoms before surgery. Group A with symptoms lasting up to 24 months, B with 25–48 months and C with symptoms lasting for more than 48 months. The average age at the time of the operation was 68.9, 72.6 and 71.3 years, respectively. Forty-eight patients died and 18 refused or were not able to participate in the study. The average time of follow-up was 43.3 months, 42.2 in group A, 47.4 in B and 42.8 in C.

No significant differences were noticed in the demographic, anesthetic and surgical parameters among the 3 groups.

There were no mortality cases in the immediate postoperative period. The overall complication rate was 43.5%, nearly identical in all 3 groups. Two patients had cerebrovascular accident and 5 had myocardial ischemia but no one turned into infarction. Mild complications included 11 urinary retention, 24 urinary tract infections and 11 patients with superficial wound infection. Twenty-two patients were re-operated along the follow-up period.

There was remarkable improvement in the perception of pain, walking distances and in the ability to perform basic activities of daily living in all 3 groups. Self-assessment of the final results disclosed 70% satisfied patients in group A, 67% in B and 67% in C.

Conclusion: Surgery for spinal stenosis in elderly patients is safe and often lead to significant relief of pain and improvement in the quality of life. Delaying surgery had no deleterious effect on the operative results.


R.D. Zeller D. Ovadia S. Bette D. Petit G. Vanacker

Introduction: Hook displacement or pullout is a common complication compromising the stability of spinal instrumentation. The two most common causes are the loss of the optimal adjustment between hook and lamina during the connection of the implant to the rod and the displacement of the hook during correction maneuvers.

Therefore, a partially constrained rod-implant link was conceived allowing for free rotation in the sagittal plane while maintaining the possibility for transverse loading during correction maneuvers. One of the possible benefits of this system is the preservation of the adjustment between hook and lamina.

Purpose of Study: To compare the adjustment obtained between hook and lamina by using a partially constrained pivot link (PL), connecting the hook to the rod while allowing for rotation in the sagittal plane, versus the common fully constrained link (FCL) connecting the hook rigidly to the rod.

Methods: A plastic model of the lumbar spine was instrumented on one side with a L1 supralaminar hook and a L3 infralaminar hook. Seven lordotic configurations (range: −45° to −30°) were randomly assigned to the model. A prebent rod with a −41° lordosis between the fixation points was used for all tests. Compression was applied to the claw construct until the best fit between hooks and laminae was achieved. The PL hooks were secured to the rod by a top-loading clip system allowing for rotation in the sagittal plane until final fixation with an incorporated setscrew. The FCL hooks were secured to the rod with a top-loading plug screw. The length of the hook blade in contact with the lamina, the initial and final lordosis of the construct were measured.

Results: The mean length of the hook blade in contact with the lamina was 6.9 mm for the PL infralaminar hooks versus 4.2 mm for the FCL infralaminar hooks (p< 0.0005). There was no statistically significant correlation between the degree of initial lordosis and the amountof contact achieved by both the FCL and PL infralaminar hooks (FCL: r = −0.052; PL: r = −0.585).

Discussion: Using a partially constrained pivot link achieves a larger contact between hook and lamina than the common fully constrained link. This was statistically highly significant at the level of the strategically most important infralaminar hooks in a lordotic construct. Early clinical experience using a spinal instrumentation based on the pivot link principle in seventy patients seems to confirm the enhanced strength of fixation. Especially, the management of spinal deformities in patients with severe osteoporosis or dystrophic lesions of the spine is significantly improved. Significant implant volume reduction allows for the use of this system even in young children.


N. Ohana E. Mercado M. Soudry

Antibiotic polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) beads are known as an effective drug delivery system for local antibiotic therapy in bone and soft tissue infections. Over the years it has become an efficient method to treat osteomyelitis and other infections in orthopaedic surgery. Whilst this method has gained popularity primarily in infected arthroplasty, trauma and chronic osteomyelitis, its application in spine surgery is less known.

Methods: From 1997 to 2000 we have followed prospectively all patients who developed severe purulent wound infection following various types of instrumented spine fusion. Any patient, who had the typical presentation of surgical wound infection was enrolled into the study. Revision consisted of radical debridement of all necrotic tissue from the surgical wound, jet irrigation with saline and application of antibiotic contained PMMA beads. Primary closure over a suction drain was done in all cases and the patient was treated with parenteral antibiotic therapy. Following first revision, patients were treated with broad-spectrum parenteral antibiotic therapy, which was converted to culture-sensitive antibiotic. Suction drains were removed when the output was less than 50cc/24hr. Patients were returned for a second revision when local and systemic parameters showed no evidence of active infection.

This revision consisted of PMMA bead removal, debridement as necessary and irrigation. Primary closure over a suction drain was performed in all cases. No hardware removal was done in any of the cases. Follow up studies included radiographs and gallium bone scan.

Results: There were five patients in the study group. Of these, two had posterior spinal fusion for trauma; the remaining three had fusion for a various etiologies (tumor, corrective osteotomy in ankylosing spondylitis and lumbar instability). Causative organism was staphylococcus aureous (2 patients) and MRSA (3 patients). Mean interval from primary surgery to the first revision was 12 days and 19 days until the second revision. None of the patients had a third revision. There was no evidence for exacerbation of the infectious disease during follow up nor any pain or other signs which could mark the beginning of chronic osteomyelitis. No systemic or local complications related to the surgical technique or the PMMA beads were noted during the period between revisions. Galium scan was performed in only three of the five patients for a different reason. Scan results were negative in all three.

Conclusion: Two-stage revision surgery with PMMA antibiotic beads in a purulent surgical wound infection following spinal fusion, is a highly efficient method. This approach can assure proper healing of the surgical wound with no need for instrumentation removal or prolonged secondary healing of the surgical


M. Kligman E. Sprecher M. Roffman D. Yarnitsky

Background: Quantitative sensory testing (QST) conventionally identifies threshold elevation as reflecting sensory deficit. A major disadvantage of the technique is its inability to distinguish organic from feigned sensory deficit, as both are characterized by an elevated threshold.

Aim: To distinguish organic from feigned sensory deficit.

Method: Vibratory thresholds and their variances were measured, at foot L4, L5 and S1 sites, in 14 patients with low back pain (LBP) suspected of non-organic sensory loss by clinical criteria of Waddell, 14 patient controls with abnormal neurological examination and CT of the low back, and 20 healthy controls.

Results: Thresholds of non-organic patients and of patient controls were elevated to a similar extent compared to those of healthy controls. Variances, however, were higher for non-organic patients (6.7–10.5 for the various test sites) than for either patient controls (0.39–0.80, p: 0.001–0.05) or for healthy controls (0.20–0.54, p: 0.001–0.02). Of non-organic patients with high thresholds who would otherwise be identified as pathological, 30–67% were ‘spared’ the misdiagnosis and correctly identified as non-organic because of the inclusion of the variance criterion.

Conclusion: Variance evaluation is therefore suggested for inclusion into QST methodology, together with threshold itself, as a quality assurance parameter.


E. Pevzner A. Livshits I. Pekarsky Y. Leitner R. David R. Gepstein

Radiofrequency (RF) lesions have been used for over 25 years in the treatment of intractable pain of spinal origin. The conventional understanding of this technique is that the heat which is produced in the tissue surrounding the electrode tip causes destruction of nervous tissue, which in turn reduces the input of noxious nerve stimuli and alleviates pain. Neuropathic pain is usually a contra-indication to the use of RF nerve lesioning. For treatment of patients with severe radicular pain we use pulsed radiofrequency who has been recently described as a technique to apply a relatively high voltage near a nerve but without the usual effects of rise in temperature or subsequent nerve injury.

This study reports the effect of pulsed RF in 21 patients with severe radicular pain who had previously failed to respond to conventional therapy.

Patients and Methods: From December 2000 to August 2001, 18 patients underwent pulsed RF Rhizotomy of Dorsal Root Ganglion (DRG) of segmental N. Root of the painful dermatome. Out of them, 16 passed treatment in the lumbar area and 2 in the neck. The age of the patients ranged from 20 to 75 years (m=55.7 years). Male/female ratio was 1.4/1. 50% was previously operated (discectomy, laminectomy). No complications were seen either in the procedure or in the follow-up.

Results: Out of 21 patients, 3 (14.3%) did not respond to treatment. In the remaining 18 patients Rhizotomy was successful at 3 months follow-up. Mean VAS score before procedures was 8.85 (range 7–10), after treatment 3.8 (range 0–10).

Conclusion: Pulsed RF treatment is a safe, simple procedure to control radicular, neuropathic pain in the cervical, thoracic and lumbar regions. Advantages of this method:

It is non-destructive procedure and it can therefore be used for different indication which were not suitable for conventional RF.

Post-procedure discomfort does occur but it is less pronounced than following conventional RF.

Although permanent sensory loss is a rare complication of RF it does occur. Pulsed RF does not have this complication.


L. Sedel A.V. Picart

Introduction: Complex fracture of the acetabulum are difficult to treat. If an osteosynthesis is performed difficult surgery resulted in blood loss, long operating time, high risk of sepsis and failure. Even if the fracture is well operated and ideally stabilised there is a major risk of secondary osteoarthrosis. This can be related to bone necrosis , cartilage surface damage , bone loss.

There are also intraoperative risks of neural damage: sciatic nerve as well as gluteus medius nerve. On the other hand , modern surgical technique including an alumina against alumina bearing could allow very long term survival without any activity limitation and this even in very young patients.

Secondary procedure after a failed osteosynthesis provides statistically worse functional results than primary total hip. The surgery is more difficult because of hardware retrieval, nerve dissection, bone reconstruction and remaining muscular dysfunction.

Materials and Methods: To address these issues we reviewed our results of total hip for acetabular fractures. 80 patients received a total hip for acetabular fracture. From 1980 to 1998: 58 acetabular fractures in 57 patients sustained a total hip: 39 males and 18 females. Mean age: 50 years (from 21 to 80). 35 had had a conservative treatment, 22 had had an osteosynthesis. Delay between fracture and total hip: operated: 10 years, non-operated: 6 years. All prosthesis had an alumina against alumina couple. The stem was always made of titanium alloy, it was smooth, collared and cemented. The socket was plain alumina cemented 8, cement less : 3, metal back alumlina insert: 29, screw in cup with alumina liner: 10, plain polyethylene cemented: 8.

Results: Follow-up: from 6 months to 20 years (mean 5,5years). Last Postel Merle d’Aubigne rating: 16,1(8–18) 9 revisions : 1 bipolar aseptic loosening, 8 socket loosening : 2 septic , 6 aseptic. (2 screws in , 6 cemented).

There were 22 neural disorder; 19 sciatic palsies; 13 post trauma; 4 post osteosynthesis; 2 post THR; 3 gluteus medius palsy. 7 sepsis: 4 post osteosynthesis, 3 post THR (including 2 post osteosynthesis).

Discussion: The results presented were inferior to a regular total hip if an osteosynthesis have been performed previously. Reasons for these inferior results were limp due to previous palsy of gluteus medius nerve, sciatic sequellae, complications of previous sepsis and so on. In contrast cases who had at first orthopaedic treatment followed some weeks later by a total hip experienced very good results. It is difficult to conclude from this limited series. But we are actually on the way to modify our perspectives.

Many weak results could have been avoided by doing fine primary surgery. We could expect better functional results with less complications regarding sepsis, nerve damage, muscle preservation if we perform a primary total hip in conjunctions with acetabular reconstruction. Osteosynthesis is still recommended for simple acetabular fracture with large displacement involvement of the posterior wall or one column not comminuted.


I. Jakim S Velkes

Introduction: Historically Surface Replacement of the Hip exhibited a high failure rate due to femoral head loosening attributed to polyethylene wear debri, originating from the acetabulum. A metal on metal bearing resurfacing prosthesis has been developed to address this problem.

The authors’ early experience using this prosthesis is presented.

Material and methods: 48 patients underwent metal on metal hip Resurfacing Arthrolplasty (Cormet 2000R Corin U.K.) of the hip between 1999–2001. 43 patients suffered from osteoarthritis and 3 from avascular necrosis.

29 males and 19 females underwent the procedure with a mean age of 60 years (45–74).

In 20 hips a posterior approach was used and in 28 our saggital trochenteric osteotomy.

A cementless prosthesis was implanted in 30 patients and the femoral prosthesis was cemented in 18 patients.

Results: All but two patients had an improved hip score with 95 % of the patients reporting a good to excellent result. There were 2 femoral neck fractures one early and one late. One patient had severe heterotrophic ossification and one a transient partial sciatic nerve palsy.

Discussion: Conservative Hip Arthroplasty with Femoral Head and acetabular resurfacing is an attractive concept. Violation of the upper femoral canal is prevented and bone stock is preserved. Improved applications of metallurgical and tribological principles increases the predictability of metal on metal bearing surface function and prevents the catastrophic polyethylene wear previously observed in hip resurfacing procedures.

The principles of metal on metal bearing surfaces, Resurfacing Arthroplasty of the hip and the early clinical results and complications are discussed.


M. Vigler Y. Tytiun L. Shauer A. Greental M. Soudry

The need for better durability and longevity in total hip arthroplasty in high demand patients is a constant challenge. For this purpose a metal-on-metal prosthesis with improved tribology was developed. Our early results of using this system are presented.

Materials and Methods: From 1997 till present 68 Meta-sul hip arthroplasties were performed on 64 patients. 16 cases performed during 2001 were not included in the study due to short follow-up period. Of the remaining 52 cases, 39 were fully followed up (18 male and 21 female) and five were telephonically contacted. Six were lost to follow up and two died for reason not related to the THR. The average age at operation was 57y (27–77y), average height 163cm and average weight 79kg (50–180kg). 18 cases were left and 21 right sides.

4 patients had bilateral THR. There were 3 revision cases due to loosening of cemented cup and 3 post surgical hip procedures. The etiology of the hip pathology was OA in 23, AVN in 10, CDH in 3, two post surgical procedures and one Paget’s disease. The THR prosthesis system consisted of a Wagner type uncemented cup with a factory-assembled Metasul inlay. An uncemented collarless hydroxypaptite coated, Spotorno stem, with a modular 28mm head was used. Long stem was used in 3 cases and reinforcement cage in one. Additional screws (average of 3,4) were used for primary cup fixation. The anterolateral approach, laying either supine or on the side was performed. Average hospitalization time was 12 days. Full weight bearing was allowed as tolerated.

Results: The average follow-up was 30 months. Average Harris Hip Score pre-operatively was 45 (15-74) and post-operatively 75 (15–99). Subjectively, 87% of the primary cases with various etiologies were satisfied with the outcome. The majority of patients had pain-free range of motion and returned to improved daily function. One technical intra-operative complication (false route) was resolved with immediate revision. Two patients required cerclage wiring due to a femoral crack. Immediate post-operative complications included 2 cases of persistent distal peroneal nerve palsy. Three cases of anterior dislocations were reduced and did not recur. A case of positive intra-operative culture was treated successfully with 6 weeks of intravenous antibiotic therapy. Late complications included one case of cup loosening and one of a painful hip with suspected infection that required revision with a cemented prosthesis. Radiographic examination included measuring of radiolucent lines around the femoral stem according to the zones described by Gruen et al. and acetabulum as described by DeLee and Charnley. No femoral radiolucent lines were found. Seven cases revealed partial ace-tabular radiolucent lines.

Discussion: The Metasul metal-on-metal THR system was used so far with relatively satisfactory results in the early follow-up period despite the leaning curve. It is early to draw conclusions as to the superiority of this system over conventional metal-polyethylene bearing prosthesis. Long term follow-up studies are needed.


Y. Weil O. Elishoov M. Liebergall M. Mattan

Introduction: Cementless hydroxyapatite coated prosthesis are mainly selected for a relatively young and active patient population. Most clinical studies demonstrate excellent osseous integration of the HA coating and good outcome. The clinical follow-up reports of the ABG group suggest excellent results, however we observed an alarming rate of acetabular osteolysis and polyethylene wear which required revision surgery. Thus a comprehensive retrospective evaluation of all operated patients had been conducted.

Patients and Methods: 162 ABG hips were replaced in 148 patients, of them 75 patients were studied and followed-up. Mean age was 56 (range 33–71). 48 patients were women and 27 were men. 8 patients had bilateral hip replacement. Etiology of hip disease varied and included primary osteoarthritis (27 patients – 36%), congenital hip dysplasia (24 patients – 32%), osteonecrosis (12 patients – 16%), ankylosing spondylitis (5 patients – 6.6%), post traumatic arthritis (5 patients – 6.6%) and post-infectious arthrosis (2 patients – 2.6%). Postoperative follow-up period averaged 4 years (range 15–80 months).

Results: The mean postoperative Harris hip score was 89 (range 52–100). 23 patients (30%) reported of modified life activity after surgery, and the majority had resumed their previous occupations.

Complications included 3 early and one late dislocations – one patient required an early cup revision, one patient suffered a fracture of the femur during stem insertion, and 3 patients (4%) had deep vein thrombosis. There was one case of a femoral vein injury and one resolving superficial infection. No deep infections were noted.

13 patients had undergone cup revision due to severe polyethylene wear and periacetabular osteolysis. Of them 5 were diagnosed during this retrospective study and 8 were referred for revision due to clinical symptoms. Thus the revision rate of the entire operated population is 13/162 = 8.0% and 13/75 = 17.3% of the studied patients. The true loosening rate should be between these 2 figures.

In 2 patients the entire cups were removed and revised due to loosening. In 11 patients following the removal of the polyethylene inserts the metal back proved to be stable. In these cases the bone defects were filled-up with bone graft substitute, and a highly cross-linked polyethylene (22 mm head) were cemented into the metal shell. No stems needed revision.

Conclusion: In spite of a relatively high Harris Hip Score and generally good long-term follow-up a high rate of acetbular lysis and polyethylene wear were observed. This observation warrants avoiding the use of the ABG cups until further investigation is performed. A continued clinical and radiographic analysis is required for the entire operated patients. In all cases of polyethylene wear or significant osteolysis revision is indicated.


M. Salai I. Dudkiewicz A. Israeli Y. Amit A. Chechik

Background: The few reported results of total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients younger than 30 years of age involve mostly patients suffering from juvenile rheumatoid arthritis (JRA), indicate a high complication rate, and questionable durability.

Aim: We report our results of treatment of 56 patients who underwent total hip arthroplasty (71 THA operations) < 30 years of age at the time of surgery.

Methods: 56 patients who underwent total hip arthroplasty (71 THA operations) < 30 years of age at the time of surgery (mean 23.23 ± 4.31) were followed-up for a mean of 7.4 ± 3.79 years after surgery. Multivariant regression analysis indicated that although there was a variability of indications for surgery, only patient age at surgery, hospitalization time, and type of hip prosthesis (cementless vs. cemented) had a statistically valid influence on the final result, namely: Harris Hip Score (HHS) and complication rate.

Results: The final average HHS was 90.59 ± 9.36. Loosening of the cup in 11 of 71 and early traumatic dislocation of 5 of 71, accounted for the majority of complications.

Conclusions: These results indicated that THA is a durable, good treatment modality for young patients with disabling diseases that affect the hip joint.


M. Kligman M. Roffman G. Kirsh

Aim: To evaluate the clinical and radiological results of hydroxyapatite stem in primary total hip replacement.

Method: A prospective review was performed on 22 osteoporotic patients (Singh index 1–3) with hydroxyapatite-coated total hip replacements. These results were compared with a control group (Singh index 4–6) of 45 patients (48 hips) with respect to clinical and radiographic data. Surgery was performed over a six year period (1991–1996) and the time to follow-up evaluation averaged 5 years (range 2–7 years). Clinical evaluation was based on the Harris Hip score and radiographic evaluations using Engh’s criteria.

Results: There was no significant difference between the final average Harris hip score in the osteoporotic bone group which was 87 points and that for the control group which was 91 points (p> 0.05). Radiographic evaluation demonstrated confirmed bone ingrowths in all patients except for one patient in each group, each with suspected bone ingrowth. There were no stems revised for aseptic loosening and no endosteal lysis was found. Progressive bone formation was seen around the femoral stem proximally. The acetabular components demonstrated no sign of mechanical loosening or osteolysis. Bone formation was found in most patients in zone I, and less in zone III.

Conclusion: The basis of the results of this study, it is believed that osteoporotic bone as a factor by itself should not compromise the early results of hydroxyapatite total hip arthroplasty and hopefully give as good results n the long term.


Y. Khatib O. Schwartz D.G. Mendes M. Said

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to present our imaging results of Corail stem implant after 11 years of follow-up.

Material and Methods: 31 patients that underwent total hip arthroplasty between 1990–1996 in which Corail stem was implanted were included in this study.

The imaging parameters that were collected from patient X-rays were: radiolucent line, osteolysis, subsidence, cortical hypertrophy, cortical thinning, undersizing, distal pod, rounded calcar, cupping and sagging.

Results: Our of 31 patients, 21 were man and 10 were women, the mean age was 60.5 years (range 32–77y), 6 were bilateral, 3 patients had trochanteric osteotomy before surgery. The mean follow-up period was 8.2 years (range 5–11y).

No sign of loosening were observed in any patient, 23 stems were implanted in neutral position, 2 stems in valgus and 6 in varus position. In 15 patients stem was undersized. In 23 patients distal pod was observed, 19 patients had trochanteric osteopenia, in 10 patients cupping was noticed and in 6 patients cortical thinning was observed. Five patients showed proximal osteopenia and in 5 patients sagging of few millimeters was noticed during the first years after surgery. No radiolucent line, osteolysis, subsidence and cortical hypertrophy were observed up to 11 years follow-up.

Discussion: No signs of loosening were observed in all stems after 11 years of follow-up.

Conclusion: In our opinion Corail stem for THA is a very reliable implant.


L. Kandel R. Powell I.G. Woodgate R. Sekel

Background: A total new double-threaded cone-shaped modular femoral stem has been designed, using rotational rather than percussive hammer insertion of the prosthesis. The vertical height, the neck length, the neck anteversion angle and the medial offset can all be adjusted after preparation of the femoral canal has been completed.

Methods: A consecutive series of the first 110 hip joints in 103 patients were followed clinically and radiographically for an average of 28 months.

Results: The mean Harris hip score rose from 43.6 points preoperatively to 91 points postoperatively. The mean pain score changed from 7.9 points to 42 points, respectively.

13 hips (11.8%) had mid-thigh pain, most of them mild. One hip (0.9%) showed clinical and radiographic signs of early loosening and was revised.

Conclusion: The short-term clinical and radiographic outcomes are encouraging. The double-threaded cone-shaped stem locking mechanism has been shown to be able to withstand the torsional and vertical forces applied to hip replacement prosthesis.


L. Kandel T. Diamond C. Bryant R. Sekel

Background: Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry has been validated as an accurate method for assessing periprosthetic bone loss around the femoral stem after uncemented total hip arthroplasty. A prospective longitudinal study was conducted to evaluate bone mineral density (BMD) changes around a series of double-threaded cone-shaped modular femoral stems.

Materials: 64 hips with implanted double-threaded cone-shaped femoral stem were scanned in the anteroposterior femoral plane using a Lunar DPXL densitometer with special software. The initial MBD scan was performed 2–4 weeks after the surgery and thereafter yearly for up to three years.

Results: Significant changes occurred during the first year after surgery. In the proximal femur the mean BMD decreased to 73%±17% (p< 0.001) in the calcar area and to 91%±13% (p< 0.001) in the greater trochanter region. In the middle part of the stem the mean BMD decreased to 86%±17% (p< 0.001) on the medial side and to 84%±12% (p< 0.001) on the lateral side. No significant changes occurred around the distal part of the stem. During the second and third postoperative years, small progressive changes in BMD were noticed in all Gruen zones, in keeping with age-related bone loss.

Conclusion: Significant decreases in BMD around the femoral stem prosthesis in the proximal parts of the femur were recorded during the first postoperative year. These changes may be explained by the metaphyseal-diaphyseal gripping prosthesis design. No significant distal changes were found.


R.A. Imberg M. Said D.G. Mendes

Objective: To point out the strict rules of surgical technique required for the success of newly applied advanced technology.

Materials: 73 hips in 70 patients, aged 23 to 71 years old, underwent total hip arthroplasty using ceramic bearing surfaces implants. 62 were a primary procedure, and 11 were revision surgery.

Results: One complication of fracture of posterior ace-tabular wall was registered in a patient with ankylosing spondylitis, four early dislocations that were reduced closed, and one case of late postoperative death in a cardiac high-risk patient. No other complications were recorded since the first operation in May 1999. All patients had remarkable pain relief, improved range of motion and improved function.

Discussion: The tribological properties of the ceramic articulating surfaces favors them as the preferred technology for future orthopaedic implants. By reducing wear to a minimum the choice of ceramics seems to be justified. The main concern is fragility versus toughness. We have formulated ten rules of proper surgical technique concerning: accurate fit of the components, accurate orientation of the components, stability of the joints, adequate tissue tension, caring for debris and prevention of metal transfer due to ceramic-metal touch.

Conclusions: While our clinical experience is still short term, it appears that applying a rigorous and uncompromising surgical technique with ceramic bearing surfaces is essential for the clinical success of this potent bio-material.

Based on our experience, our recommendations are that:

Ceramic bearing surfaces T.H.A.-s should be performed in specialized centers.

The use of 32 mm. heads should be considered in order to avoid dislocations.

With 28 mm. heads, full profile cups should be considered.

Conservative physical therapy and range of motion exercises for 6–12 weeks.


T. Hovav D. Alk D. Robinson N. Halperin

Objectives: Assessment of the need for bolt removal in long stem distally interlocked revision stems.

Introduction: Proximal stress shielding might prove in the long run detrimental to the success of distally fixed revision stems. In our department during the last 4 years a proximally fixed stem combined with distal interlocking has been used. The manufacturer recommends bolt removal 18 months after surgery. The current investigation was conducted in order to assess the need for bolt removal.

Methods: 22 consecutive stems inserted from 1997 to the present were included. In all these cases femoral bone loss was graded according to Paprosky. A locked long stem is indicated in bony deficiencies of Grade 2B, 2C or 3 (i.e. loss of at least the metaphysis shell with or without major diaphyseal bone loss). Volkmann’s trans-femoral approach was used in 19 cases and sliding trochanteric osteotomy in the rest. Impaction grafting or structural allografts were not used to stabilize the prosthesis. In all cases grade II fixation (according to D’Antonio) was achieved at the end of the procedure.

Results: Median follow-up is 14 months. There were no septic complications. In two cases bolts slippage allowed prosthesis subsidence. One stem had to be revised due to aseptic failure. During surgery the prosthesis was markedly smaller than the regenerated medullary canal, and proximal bony fixation was not achieved. One patient’s bolts broke and in another case screw migration into soft tissue occurred. All patients attained ambulatory status. In none of the patients were the screws removed.

Discussion: Our results seem not to support the manufacturer’s recommendation for elective screw removal. Osteotomy healing appears to occur in all cases, however, time to healing varies greatly. The range of complete healing is from 3 months to 24 months. It does not appear that bolt retention leads to an interference with bone healing and bone regeneration of the proximal femur at the osteotomy site. Bolt breakage is rare and does not appear to adversely affect the results at least in the short term.


I. Dudkiewicz M. Salai A. Chechik A. Ganel

Background: Childhood septic hip should usually be treated immediately by arthrotomy and antibiotic. Even if treated correctly, the affected hip may become osteoarthritic and functionally disabling.

Usually the literature is not in favor of THA in young patients, and the reports are on patients older than 32 years of age.

Aims: We present here a unique group of very young patients who suffered from early coxarthrosis due to septic hip in childhood, with an average age of 19.14 years at the time of the arthroplasty.

Methods: Seven patients who suffered from early coxarthrosis due to septic hip in childhood underwent total hip arthroplasty, with an average age of 19.14 years (range between 14 and 25 years) at the time of the arthroplasty.

Results: The Harris Hip Score (HHS) improved from a pre-operative mean of 58.43 to a post-operative mean of 94.14. The follow-up period ranged between 2 and 25 years, with an average of 8.14 years.

Conclusion: We conclude that THA in young people with early coxarthrosis due to septic hip in childhood provides good functional results.


Y. Weil G. Rahav Y. Mattan M. Liebergall

Background: Osteoarticular disease is the most common complication of brucellosis and has been described in 10–85% of patients. Spondylitis is the most prevalent clinical form, also arthritis, bursitis, tenosynovitis, sacroileitis and osteomyelitis have been also described.

Method: We describe our experience concerning three patients with brucellar prosthetic joint infection in Israel.

Results

Case 1: A 38 year old artist was admitted for revision of total hip replacement due to increased pain accompanied by loosening of the prosthesis. Four years prior admission total hip arthroplasty was performed due to psoriatic arthritis treated by methotrexate. Revision surgery demonstrated necrotic tissue which grew Brucella melitensis. Doxycycline and rifampicin were administered for 12 weeks. Second stage revision was performed on the 6th week of antibiotic therapy with favorable results.

Case 2: A 62 year old Arab male underwent right total knee arthroplasty 4 years prior admission due to osteoarthritis. Past medical history included hip arthritis. A second TKA was performed due to septic arthritis caused by Staphylococcus epidermidis and Acinetobacter baumanii. The first stage of the arthroplasty grew Brucella melitensis.

Antibiotic treatment and second stage revision surgery were followed successfully.

Case 3: A 67 year old Arab male was admitted due to fever, right pelvic and back pain lasting for 6 weeks. Five years prior admission the patient underwent left total knee arthroplasty. Computerized tomography was normal. Following admission severe left knee pain developed. Joint aspirate grew Brucella melitensis. Antibiotic treatment and two stages revision surgery were performed successfully.

In all three cases consumption of unpasteurized dairy products was documented. All three patients had serum brucella antibody titer of 1:1600.

Conclusion: Brucella melitensis should be added to the differential diagnosis of prosthetic joint infection, mainly in the Mediterranean basin and the Arabian Gulf. Only two other cases of brucella prosthetic joint infections were reported involving prosthetic knees.


D. Robinson A. Peer Y. Mirovsky

Vertebral fracture due to a metabolic bone disease or a neoplastic disease is a common and debilitating condition. It most often is associated with either osteoporosis or metastatic bone disease. Some of the patients suffering from such fractures continue to complain of back pain and deformity despite optimal medical therapy, including radiotherapy and biphosphonates.

Vertebroplasty, i.e. transcutaneous injection of bone cement into the vertebral body can serve as an internal fixation device and allows restoration of mechanical strength and partial restoration of the vertebral height.

During the year 2000, 17 vertebrae in 12 patients were injected. These were either lumbar or thoracic vertebrae. All patients reported decrease in pain and improved ambulation capacity.

Two minor complications were encountered including headache lasting for 72 hours prior to spontaneously resolving. This possibly indicates a transarachnoidal approach, the other complication has been cement leak below the posterior longitudinal ligament. The patient reported pain amelioration. No emergency surgical interventions were necessary to date.

Treatment of metastatic bone disease should be staged, with only a few vertebrae injected in each session, to prevent pulmonary embolization.

Vertebroplasty appears to allow excellent palliative treatment in patients suffering from unresectable primary tumors of the vertebrae, or more commonly, metastatic bone tumors as well as osteoporotic fractures.


D. Robinson E. Sucher

Vertebroplasty has been developed during the last decade in France as a method to relieve pain in patients suffering from a metastatic disease of the spine, that are poor surgical candidates. The indications include: mechanical pain, compression fractures, lytic bone metastasis.

Contra-indications include neurological compromise, breaching of the posterior wall, complete pedicle destruction or a large anterior soft-tissue mass. Relative contra-indications include a single resectable metastasis and a radiation sensitive tumor.

The method has been refined during the last few years by the introduction of specialized delivery systems and tailor-made bone cements.

The state of the art of this emerging technique will be discusses as well as some exciting future developments such as cements that can actively destroy tumors by physical or chemical modifications.


V. Benkovich E. Rath Y. Gortchak A. Vindzberg D. Atar

Introduction: The increasing utilization of total hip arthroplasty and the increasing life expectancy have brought an increasing incidence of revision hip arthroplasty. With severe acetabular, revision surgery with the use of standard cemented or press-fitted components is inadequate for fixation. In these cases the use of proximal femoral allograft can restore the deficiency.

Purpose: To present a new technique and preliminary results of revision total hip arthroplasty using proximal femoral allograft prosthetic composites for massive ace-tabular bone loss. The technique uses the natural vector of forces in the intertrochanteric region in an opposite direction at the acetabular defect.

Methods: From June 2000 to July 2001, seven patients underwent reconstruction of massive acetabular defects with proximal femoral allograft bone. The etiologies for bone loss were infection in 2 patients, aseptic loosening in 4 and acetabular protrusion in 2 patients. In 4 hips there were also femoral defects that was reconstructed with allograft. The average age of the patients was 69.8 years. All patients were wheel chair bound prior to surgery. Harris Hip Score was used to assess preoperative and follow-up function level.

Results: Harris Hip Score improved significantly in all patients. All patients are ambulatory at follow-up. Complications included 2 dislocation and 2 deep-vein thrombosis. No allograft resorbtion was noted at follow-up.

Conclusions: The proximal femoral allograft provides a solid construct for the acetabular cup in large acetabular bone defects. Although failure and complication rates might be higher than revision procedures with lesser bone defects, this reconstructive option for massive ace-tabular defects dramatically improves a patient’s function level.


Y. Kollender J. Bickels J. Issakov M. Ben-Harush I. Cohen Y. Neuman G. Glusser I. Meller

Introduction: Soft-tissue sarcomas (STS) in children and young adults are rare. This is a heterogeneous group of tumors, which is traditionally divided to rhabdomyo-sarcomas and non-rhabdomyosarcoma soft-tissue sarcomas (NRSTS). These tumors are further classified to high- and low-grade tumors.

Material and Methods: Between 1988 and 1999, the authors treated 50 patients (25 males, 25 females) under the age of 20 who were diagnosed with a soft-tissue sarcoma.

Histopathological Diagnoses: rhabdomyosarcoma – 11, synovial sarcoma – 6, other high-grade STS (extraskeletal Ewing’s sarcoma, epitheloid sarcoma, neurofibrosarcoma, hemangiopericytoma, fibrosarcoma, and unclassified sarcoma) – 17. Seven patients were diagnosed with low-grade STS and 9 patients with an aggressive desmoid tumor.

Anatomic Location: Lower extremities – 30, upper extremities – 9, shoulder girdle – 2, trunk – 4, pelvic girdle – 5.

Preoperative Treatment: Thirty patients received neo-adjuvant chemotherapy, four patients underwent isolated limb perfusion with TNF and melphalan, and one patient received preoperative radiation therapy. Surgery: Forty-seven underwent limb-sparing resections and 3 underwent primary amputation. Wide margins were achieved in 37 patients and marginal margins in 10. Intralesional resection was performed in 3 patients.

Postoperative Treatment: Thirty-seven patients received adjuvant chemotherapy and 34 received radiation therapy.

Oncological Status: At the most recent follow-up, 24 patients of the 37 patients with high-grade STS have no evidence of disease, three are alive with disease, and seven are dead. Fourteen of the 16 patients with low-grade tumors have no evidence of disease and 2 are alive with disease. There were 4 secondary amputations due to local tumor recurrence.

Conclusions: Management of soft-tissue sarcomas in children and young adults requires the judgmental use of pre- and postoperative treatment modalities. Local tumor control can be achieved in the majority of the patients. A longer follow-up is required to determine the overall survival of these patients.


J. Bickels J. Wittig Y. Kollender K. Kellar M. Malawer I. Meller

Introduction: Total scapular resection causes a significant functional loss because of the sacrifice of the glenoid, which serves as a stable base for shoulder motion. The authors analyze their experience with two types of reconstructions following total scapular resection; suspension of the humeral head from the clavicle without endoprosthetic reconstruction of the scapula and endoprosthetic scapular reconstruction.

Materials and Methods: Between 1979 and 1997, the authors treated 23 patients with scapular tumors that required total scapular resection. Patients were diagnosed with 14 bone and 9 soft-tissue tumors. Resection included total scapulectomy in 12 patients and enbloc resection of the scapula and humeral head in 11 patients.

Reconstruction: All eleven patients who had resection of their humeral head underwent reconstruction of the humerus with endoprosthesis. Scapular endoprosthesis was further installed in 7 patients and suspension of the humeral head from the clavicle with a Dacron tape was performed in 16 patients (Suspension of the prosthetic humeral head from the clavicle – 4 patients; suspension of the native humeral head from the clavicle – 12 patients). Endoprosthetic reconstruction of the scapula was feasible only when the periscapular musculature was sufficient for endoprosthetic attachment and coverage. The scapular prosthesis was attached to the prosthetic humeral head with a Goretex® sleeve, which served as an artificial joint capsule. All patients were followed for a minimum of 2 years; follow-up included physical examination, radiological evaluation and functional evaluation according to the American Musculoskeletal Tumor Society system.

Results: Elbow range-of-motion and hand dexterity were similar in the two groups of patients. However, compared with patients who undergone humeral suspension, those who had scapular endoprosthesis had better abduction (60°–90° vs. 10°–20°) of the shoulder joint. Moreover, these patients had better cosmetic appearance of the shoulder girdle. There were no deep wound infections, prosthetic failures, or secondary amputations. Overall, 6 patients who had scapular prosthesis (86%) and 10 patients who had humeral suspension (62%) had a good-to-excellent functional outcome.

Conclusions: The number of patients who underwent a scapular endoprosthetic reconstruction is small and does not allow a valid statistical analysis; however, the authors feel that scapular endoprosthesis reconstruction is associated with better functional and cosmetic outcomes, when compared to humeral suspension. The authors recommend reconstruction of the scapula with endoprosthesis when periscapular musculature, remaining after tumor resection allows attachment and coverage of the prosthesis.


S. Shabat Y. Kollender O. Merimsky J. Issakov G. Glusser M. Nyska I. Meller

Background: The surgical treatment of extensive diffuse Pigmented Villonodular Synovitis (PVNS) of large joints alone, is unsatisfactory, with high rates of local recurrence. Postsynovectomy adjuvant treatment with external beam radiation therapy or intraarticular injection of Yttrium90 (Y90) yielded better results.

Aims: Experience with 10 cases treated with debulking surgery followed by intraarticular injection of Y90 is reported.

Methods: Between January 1989 and June 1998, 10 patients (8 males and 2 females aged 15049 years) with extensive diffuse PVNS were treated. In 6 patients the knee joint, in 3 patients the ankle joint, and in 1 patient the hip joint were involved. The 10 patients underwent 15 operations, 1 patient had 3 surgical procedures, and 3 patients underwent 2 surgeries (interval between re-operations for local recurrence were 2–4 years). All patients had an intraarticular injection of 15–25 mCi of Y90, 6–8 weeks after the last surgery.

Results: Follow up time was 2.5–12 years (mean 6 years). All patients were followed by repeated computerized tomography (CT) scans, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), plain X-ray films and bone scans semi-annually. In 9 patients no evidence of disease and no progression of bone or articular destruction have been noted. In 1 patient stabilization of disease was achieved with no further evidence of bony or articular damage. No complications were noticed after surgery, nor after the intraarticular Y90 injection.

Conclusions: A combination of debulking surgery with intraarticular injection of Y90 for extensive diffuse PVNS of major joints is a reliable way of treatment with good results.


A. Peer D. Robinson J. Sandbank

Objectives: Description of early results using a new modality in musculoskeletal oncology.

Introduction: Radiofrequency as a malignant tumor ablative modality has been employed during the last decade in liver tumors. Extra-hepatic application in malignancies is new and its indications are not precisely defined. It has been used for more than ten years for osteoid osteoma ablation. Radiofrequency allows destruction of a precise sphere around the application tip. Ablation efficiency is monitored by the change in tissue conductance following tissue necrosis.

Methods: 10 patients scheduled to undergo limb sparing surgery were included. During the pre-operative angiography and embolization, tumors were treated by radio-frequency ablation. The precise location of the needle electrode was defined by real-time ultrasonography. The relation of the needle tip to large blood vessels was monitored by comparison of ultrasonography to angiography. Thus, precise ablation of the tumor tissue was possible without risk to the neurovascular bundle.

Results: Tumor necrosis was uniform in the center of the ablative sphere and declined to 60 percent in the periphery. No complications were encountered.

Discussion: This method appears to allow further shrinkage of the tumors prior to limb sparing surgery. This technique is rapid and does not require delay of surgery, as does isolated limb perfusion or neo-adjuvant chemotherapy. The procedure can be performed in sedated patients, thus obviating the need for general anesthesia prior to limb sparing surgery. It can be employed in areas were isolated limb perfusion is not anatomically feasible such as the pelvis. Further studies are required in order to better define the role of this technique as compared to intra-arterial chemotherapy or isolated limb perfusion.


O. Merimsky Y. Kollender J. Issakov J. Bickels G. Flusser I. Meller

Introduction: Modern cancer treatment has substantially increased the survival of patients with various malignancies. One of the late sequelae of a successful treatment is the development of a second malignant tumor. However, in many cases of second primary cancers, exposure to chemotherapy or radiation therapy is not evident, and it should be postulated that the putative mechanism for the development of the second cancer is different.

Material and Methods: Retrospective search of data files of 610 patients with soft-tissue or bone sarcomas that were treated by the authors from January 1995 through December 1999 were performed.

Results: Out of 375 patients with soft-tissue sarcoma (STS), 28 (7.5%) developed other malignant neoplasm either before or after its diagnosis. The second tumor types included mainly STS and renal cell carcinoma. The time interval between the diagnosis of STS and the second malignancy was o to 21 years. Three patients developed a third primary tumor within 0–3 years after the diagnosis of the second tumor. The median overall survival was > 78 months.

Conclusions: The phenomenon of two or three primary neoplasms in patients in whom one of the tumors was STS occurs in a rate of 7.5% – a significantly higher rate than the occurrence of STS among the general cancer population (1%). Most cases are detected incidentally. The clinical implications are the need to search for an occult second primary in patients with STS as an integral part of their follow-up. It is especially true in patients with primary MFH who show increased risk for developing a renal cell carcinoma.


N. Blumgerg M. Tauber S. Dekel E. Steinberg

Between the years 1999 and 2001, approximately 3000 expandable intramedullary nails were used worldwide in various surgical procedures. From this number, 250 of these nails were used for traumatic fractures and are the focus of the study presented here. The subjects consisted of 160 males and 90 females with a mean age of 41 years. Initial radiographs were obtained for all subjects. Additional X-rays and follow-up data were reported for only 75 patients (30%) with follow-up time averaging 18 weeks. Most of the fractures occurred in the midshaft (64%), followed by distal thirds (22%), and then proximal (14%). The group was then divided according to fracture location: humerus, tibial and femur.

The nail was used in 92 humerus fractures. Follow-up data was available for 35 patients with a follow-up time averaging 16 weeks. The nail was inserted retrograde in 61% of the patients and antigrade in 39% of the patients. Partial reaming was done in 42% of the cases. Mean operating time was 52 minutes and fluoroscopy time was 3.8 minutes. Anatomical reduction was achieved in 96% of the cases and in 4% of the cases, acceptable reduction was achieved with a varus < 10°. Surgical outcomes included 28 complete bone union, and 7 partial union. Eight nails were removed after complete union was achieved.

In addition, the inflatable nail was used for treatment of 114 tibial fractures. In 39% of the cases a partial reaming was done. Average operating time was 39 minutes and fluoroscopy time was 3.4 minutes. All the fractures were reduced anatomically. In 25 patients with mean follow-up of 18 weeks, 14 united completely and 11 united partially. Nine nails were removed after completion of the union.

Data on 44 patients with femoral fractures treated by the inflatable nail were also reported. Only 15 patients were available for follow-up with an average of 21 weeks follow-up time.

Nail insertion by the antegrade approach was used in 89% of the patients and the retrograde approach was used in 11% of the patients. Partial reaming was done in 44% of the cases.

Mean operating time was 60 minutes and fluoroscopy time 7.5 minutes. Anatomical reduction was achieved in all with the exception of two patients with mild valgus deformity (< 10°). By the end of the study period, 8 had complete union, 7 had partial union.

In summary, the nail was found to be very effective and safe. The surgeons who performed the surgery reported that surgical and fluoroscopy time were both reduced by half. Reaming was not mandatory and this contributed to the shortened operating time. No complications were encountered during extraction of all the nails after completion of union, even in those patients in whom the nail developed an hour glass configuration according to the size of the medullary canal.

It is still too early to conclude if this nail will produce better or equal results to the conventional interlocking nails. Nevertheless, the lack of reaming, locking, and the low contact area of the nail with the medullary canal, may explain the rapid healing observed in some cases.


D. Robinson A. Dotan Z. Nevo

Objectives: Development a giant cell tumor model arising from the mutated mesenchymal cells present in its stroma. This establishes the pathogenic mechanism of giant cell tumor, and allows the evaluation of the possible role of biphosphonates and retinoic acid in medical therapy of giant cell tumor of bone.

Introduction: In previous studies our group has shown that mesenchymal stroma contains mesenchymal cells capable of recruiting osteoclasts, and lacking capacity to undergo osteoblastic differentiation. These cells represent the actual neoplastic component of the tumor. In the current study, an attempt was made to establish a giant cell tumor in an animal model by injection of these cells.

Methods: 6 Balb/C named mice were used. The mice were kept in a laminar flow hood and injected when they were 4 weeks old. The injection was in an intra-osseous location into the distal femur. The cell inoculum consisted of 1 million stromal cells. The cells were derived from a grade III giant cell tumor occurring in the hip joint of a 30 years old woman. The mice were kept for 2 months and than sacrificed.

Results: A lytic lesion similar to that occurring in humans developed. The tumor consisted of stromal cells with interspersed osteoclasts. These were identified as being of host origin by mice-specific monoclonal antibodies. The tumor penetrated the cortex but did not infiltrate the articular cartilage. Metastases were not observed.

Discussion: Giant cell tumor of bone is typified by osteolytic bone destruction mediated by osteoclasts. In previous studies, our group has shown that the proliferation rate of the stromal component correlates closely with prognosis and grade of the tumor. The stromal component was shown to consist of pre-osteoblasts that fail to differentiate into osteoblasts, but instead recruit giant cells (osteoclasts), mediating bone destruction. Addition of retinoic acid in culture induces osteoblastogenesis cells by blocking AP-1. The current study confirms in an animal model that indeed the stromal cells are capable of osteoclast recruitment and bone destruction. This animal model might allow development of medical remedies to this tumor.


I. Meller J. Bickels J. Wittig Y. Kollender M. Malawer I. Meller

Introduction: Despite advances in limb-sparing techniques, the proximal tibia remains a difficult area in which to perform a wide resection of extensive bone tumors due to the intimate relationship to the nerves and blood vessels, inadequate soft-tissue coverage, and the need to reconstruct the extensor mechanism. The current long-term follow-up study, based on the experience with 55 patients who underwent proximal tibia endoprosthetic reconstruction emphasizes reconstruction of the extensor mechanism.

Materials and Methods: Between 1980 and 1997, 55 patients underwent proximal tibia resection with endoprosthetic reconstruction. There were 34 males and 21 females whose age ranged from 8 to 56 years (median, 27 years. Diagnoses were: primary bone sarcomas – 48, benign aggressive lesions – 6, and failure of previous osteoarticular allograft reconstruction – 1. Intra-articular resection with en bloc removal of the tibial tuberosity was performed in all cases. Endoprosthetic reconstruction was performed with 39 modular, 16 custom-made prostheses. Reconstruction of the extensor mechanism included reattachment of the patellar tendon to the prosthesis with a Dacron tape and reinforcement with a gastrocnemius flap and bone grafting of the patellar tendon-prosthesis interface. Rehabilitation emphasized prolonged immobilization of knee joint in full extension.

Results: All patients were followed for a minimum of 2 years (range 24–235 months, median – 75.5 months). Full extension to extension lag of 20° was achieved in 44 patients (78%), extension lag of 20° to 30° was found in 10 patients (19%), and extension lag of 40° was found in 1 patient (3%). Eight patients required an additional procedure which involved reinforcement of the patellar tendon with either combined quadriceps tendon and Goretex graft construct (seven patients) or simple plication of the tendon (one patient). Seven of these patients gained an extension lag of less than 20°. Overall, function was estimated to be good to excellent in 48 patients, fair in 6, and poor in one patient.

Discussion: Extension lag of up to 20° is considered compatible with activities of daily living. Emphasis on reattachment of the patellar tendon to the prosthesis and its reinforcement with a gastrocnemius flap and bone graft achieved that goal in the majority of the patients.

Secondary reinforcement of the patellar tendon is recommended for extension lag of more than 20°.


Y. Kollender J. Bickels R. Shomrat Y. Yaron M. Goldstein D. Junig J. Issakov I. Bar-Am A. Orr-Urtreger I. Meller

Introduction: Chromosomal analysis is becoming increasingly useful in the diagnosis and management of bone and soft-tissue sarcomas. The identification of chromosomal aberrations such as translations, deletions, additions of a part or whole chromosome, and other markers are associated with specific tumor subtypes.

Material and Methods: Between 1998 and 2000, 78 bone and soft-tissue tumors were analyzed. Cytogenetic analysis was carried on a short-term cultured tissues by G-banding FISH and SKY procedures, as needed. Histopathological diagnoses included osteosarcoma – 16, Ewing’s sarcoma – 13, synovial sarcoma – 4, rhabdomyosarcoma – 4 (alveolar – 3, embryonal – 1), liposarcoma – 3, extra-abdominal fibromatosis – 3, alveolar soft part sarcoma – 12, and other soft-tissue sarcoma – 12. Other diagnoses included 8 hematological malignancies and 13 benign tumors.

Results: Eight of the 16 osteosarcomas studies demonstrated complex hyperploid karyotypes compatible with the diagnosis of high-grade osteosarcoma. In most Ewing’s sarcoma, including three cases with a typical t(11;22) translocation, other chromosomal abnormalities such as trisomies of chromosomes 5,6,8, and 14 were observed. Three of the four synovial sarcomas had the typical t(X;18)(p11.2;q11.2) translocation. One of the synovial sarcomas was initially diagnosed on a histopathological basis as Ewing’s sarcoma but the cytogenetic analysis showed a complex X;18 translocation and led to change in diagnosis and related treatment. Only one of the alveolar rhabdomyosarcomas demonstrated the typical t(2;13)(q35;q14) translocation, while hypertetraploid set with double minutes (dmin) was detected in the other two cases. By using SKY, chromosome 1 was determined as the origin of one of the dmins, suggesting that PAX7 amplification could be involved in the pathogenesis of this tumor.

Conclusions: Cytogenetic analysis of bone and soft-tissue tumors are of important clinical value for accurate diagnosis of tumor type. It can also provide information suggesting the pathogenesis of these tumors.


D. Ben-David R. Mosheiff S. Beyth O. Suraki M. Liebergall

Introduction: Fluoroscopy is routinely used for real-time intra-operative localization of patient anatomy and surgical instrument positioning. Using this radiographic information the orthopedic surgeon inserts different implants into bone. Despite its utility, however, fluoroscopy does have disadvantages. The most notable is potential occupational radiation exposure. Conventional fluoroscopy usually provides only one plane at a time, whereas at least two planes are needed for optimal placement of an implant. By combining a standard C-arm fluoroscopy with computer aided surgical technology, radiation exposure can be eliminated and four different planes can be visualized simultaneously. This study presents data of preliminary clinical experience using this new technology.

Material and methods: The Stealth Station Treatment Guidance Platform System by Medtronic was used. The calibration target was attached to a C-arm fluoroscope. The static reference arc which was attached to the patient and various surgical tools. All with affixed light emitting diodes (LEDs) which were seen by the Infra Red camera. After a short registration process in which the relevant anatomy images were acquired, the C-arm was withdrawn and the entry point to the operated anatomy was determined using the navigation capabilities of the system.

During a period of six months, 31 patients underwent different surgical procedures in which a guided wire was used for: percutaneous fixation of unstable pelvis and hip fractures (13 patients), inserting and locking of an intrameduallry nail (12 patients), inserting pedicular screws (2 patients), or removing foreign-bodies or internal fixations (4 patients). In all cases the placement of the hardware was approved by conventional fluoroscopy as well.

Results: Excellent correlation between the virtual fluoroscopic imaging and live fluoroscopy was observed, thus the placement of the wire in all cases was satisfactory and there was no need to change the position of the wire following the live fluoroscopic confirmation. The number of fluoroscopic buttoning was smaller than the average number in similar surgery using conventional fluoroscopy.

Discussion: According to our preliminary clinical experience it seems that virtual fluoroscopy offers several advantages over conventional fluoroscopy while providing acceptable targeting accuracy. Our impression is that its saves fluoroscopic radiation exposure and improves exactness of the procedure. However, since currently only one reference arc can be detected at a time by the guidance system it can be used only in a stable anatomical situations (such as non-displaced fractures or pedicular screw placements). The use of better-oriented surgical instrumentation and more than one reference point detection will significantly improve the clinical potential of this method.


C. Pidhorz Y. Ben Asher

Upper limb salvage involves treatment of traumatic amputations or devascularization proximal to wrist level. Their management differs from that of more distal lesions because of the muscles involved.

We want to report our experience of 25 upper limbs salvage (23 revascularizations and 2 replantations). Four times the lesions were situated at shoulder level, 7 times at arm level, and 12 times at forearm level. Even though several patients were referred for completion of the amputation, all the limbs but two were finally saved.

The quality of the functional recovery bore no relationship to patient’s age or duration of the ischemia at the time of the accident.


H. Sahtarker S.C. Gillson J. Stolero A. Kaushansky G. Volpin

Introduction: The accepted treatment for unstable displaced tibial shaft fractures in adults is primary closed reduction and intramedullary nailing. However, this method poses a problem when treating young adolescents whose epiphyseal plates have not yet closed. We used the Ilizarov external fixation as an alternative method of treatment for these patients.

Patients and Methods: 13 patients with displaced unstable tibial shaft fractures (11 boys, 2 girls; age 13 to 16 yrs), of which 5 were open (Gustilo I–II), were treated by this method from 1995–2000. The Ilizarov frame was applied to 3 patients within the first 2 days of injury, a further 6 during the 1st week and 4 on the 2nd week or later.

All patients were allowed to weight bear from the first postoperative week. Physiotherapy was started immediately after operation and continued until normal knee and ankle function was regained. Dynamization was done in all cases 2 weeks before removal of frame. Following removal, the patients were advised to use crutches for an additional two weeks.

Results: A good or excellent alignment with full ROM in the ankle and knee joints was obtained in all patients. There were no cases of delayed or non-union. No cases of contractures or nerve injuries were reported. Superficial pin tract infection was seen in 6 patients, treated by antibiotics and local care. No cases of osteomyelitis or deep infection occurred. Length of fixation was 8–15 weeks (mean 11 weeks).

Conclusions: This method permits fixation without danger of injury to the epiphysis in growing adolescents. The stability of the fixator allows early weight bearing and leaves the adjacent joints mobile. There is no necessity for POP after removal of frame. Due to early weight bearing and an unrestricted joint movement less muscle wasting occurs. The healing time is relatively shorter than in other methods of the treatment and the complications rate was low in the presented series.


O. Schwartz S. Goldemberg M. Butnariu-Efrat D.G. Mendes

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to present an alternative method of treatment for periprosthetic fractures of the femur.

Materials and methods: 8 patients, 4 of them after total hip arthroplasty and 4 after Austin Moore hemi-arthroplasty had periprosthetic fracture of the femur. By the classification of Beals and Towers, patients with fractures types IIIa, IIIb and IV were included in this study.

All were treated by retrograde intramedullary nailing.

The surgical procedure was done closed or open by insertion of a retrograde intramedullary nail. Distal interlocking was achieved by two transversal screws.

Clinical and radiological follow-up was performed during the first year after operation.

Results: One patient died in the postoperative period from cardiac complication and 2 failed to attend to follow-up. In 5 patients, complete healing of the fracture was noticed and return to daily activities.

Conclusions: Retrograde intramedullary nailing of the femur may be a good solution of treatment for periprosthetic fractures of the femur.


Z. Horesh M. Levy M. Soudry

Introduction: Treating tibial plateau fractures extreme care should be given to restore articular surface height preserving knee joint stability to be able to obtain maximal range of movement and to prevent future joint degenerative changes. Preoperative evaluation with CT and 3-D reconstruction is mandatory to understand the topography of the fracture for surgical planning. Traditional bone grafting techniques together with newer bone substitutes should be utilized in addition to ligamentotaxis when necessary. Fixation with smooth or olive wires (in occasions with washers for wider contact), sometimes augmented by screws is used with the Ilizarov external frame for stabilization avoiding extended incisions. In unstable fractures, bridging of the knee with slight distraction of the joint is provided by including the distal femur to the frame with an additional ring. Guided by these principles, complex tibial plateau fractures were treated in our department and the results are reported.

Materials and Methods: Ten patients 40.6 years old on average (30–70) with Schatzker type V–VI fractures (all closed) were treated by hybrid 3 ring Ilizarov external frames alone or in combination with another procedure. Six were treated by ligamentotaxis and Ilizarov fixation alone and minimal opening for joint surface elevation when needed. The remaining 4 needed 6.5 mm canulated cancellous screw augmentation and 2 of them additional bone graft supplementation. Two patients needed extension of the frame to the femur with hinges on the center of joint rotation. All patients remain non-WB for 6 weeks and partial WB for another 6 weeks. Within 3 months the frame was removed and replaced by a brace or a cast-brace with full WB. Physiotherapy started early after the operation.

Results: The results were analyzed over an average follow-up period of 22.6 months (range 3–53). All fractures healed in an average of 12 weeks. Range of motion in all patients included full extension with 90° of flexion or more. No postoperative infections, septic arthritis or neurovascular complications were reported. Pin site infection was resolved locally. One case resulted in mild valgus alignment due to osteoporotic bone (70 years old patient).

Discussion: Ilizarov external fixation for complex tibial plateau fractures offers the advantage of minimal invasive interventions with a high level of functionality since the early post operative period. The combination with minimal invasive opening for joint surface elevation and additional screws or bone graft extends even more the scope of the treatment. Functional results were similar to previous reported series. The good observance of traditional tibial plateau surgery principles should guide the surgeons when using this modality of treatment for optimal results.


Y. Salameh N. Bor B. Kaufman

Background: The Ilizarov external fixation is considered to be a unique technique in limb surgery for mal-nonunion and limb deformities with or without length discrepancy. The theory suggests that the tension stress and the subsequent distraction osteogenesis, “opens a window” over hypervascularized- hypertrophic non-union for consolidation, and stimulates vascularization and osteogenesis in the avascular nonunion. Also, post traumatic bone deformities and axial deviations can be corrected by using special hinges incorporated in the device for uniplanar or multiplanar deformities. Recently, there are encouraging reports of high rate of consolidation using a non-bone grafting technique even in atrophic nonunions. However, the bifocal treatment is still preferable.

In our study we will review 28 patients suffering from mal- nonunion, whom were treated by an Ilizarov external fixation, and the results of the treatment concerning radiological alignment and consolidation rate.

Methods: Twenty-eight patients have been operated in our department during the last eight years due to mal-union (19 patients), mal- nonunion (3 patients) and non-union (6 patients) of fractures.

Malunions were treated either with acute or gradual correction of the deformity, following low energy osteotomy. For hypertrophic nonunion and mal-nonunion in general only distraction compression technique (mono-focal) was used. Atrophic and infected nonunion were treated with a bifocal technique (so-called bone transport), except for one case treated with monofocal technique only.

Results: The average age of the patients at operation was 31 years old (12–71), six female and 22 males. The average time in the device was 4 months (2–8) and average rate of consolidation was 3.6 mo. (2–7.5). All fractures and osteotomies healed thoroughly. Still, three cases of the mal unions remained suffering from residual deformity. Two patients had fracture of the regenerate after minimal trauma just after removal of device and treated with IMN. The most prevalent complication was pin tract infection, 24 out of 28 patients, all managed with P.O. antibiotics besides two patients who needed to be admitted for intravenous antibiotics. Two cases of lateral compartment muscle herniation of the leg appeared after fibular osteotomies, treated later by large fasciotomy.

Conclusions: The treatment of the different types of nonunion and malunion following fractures is a real challenge for the orthopedic surgeon. Many times the nonunions are the result of poor vascular supply to the involved limb. While the surgeon is facing old scars and poor nourishment of the entire limb, the Ilizarov external fixation, in most of the cases, enables us to deal with these difficult cases with minimal surgical exposure. In case of malunions, Ilizarov technique enables to achieve accurate angular correction of the deformities.


Full Access
S. Luria R. Mosheiff Y. Mattan M. Liebergall

Background: Osteoporotic tibial fractures may be a challenge both in diagnosis and treatment. The aim of treatment is obtaining joint congruity and normal alignment, joint stability, adequate soft tissue healing and functional range of motion. The goal is prevention of degenerative osteoarthritis. In the majority of cases the treatment of tibial plateau fractures consists of open reduction and internal fixation.

Objectives: The presentation of two aspects of the osteoporotic fracture – the insufficiency fracture and fixation of the fractures by a more appropriate method.

Patients: We present our experience with 7 cases treated during the past 2 years. Two of these cases presented with no story of trauma, normal X-rays and were diagnosed clinically and on CT and bone scanning. The other 5 cases resulted of minor trauma and operative treatment was in order, using a modified fixation technique – a small fragment plate.

Results: The patients suffering from fractures with normal X-rays suffered from insufficiency fractures and were treated conservatively. The patients suffering from depressed, split or comminuted fractures were treated by open reduction and internal fixation with a small fragment plate.

Discussion and Conclusion: Insufficiency fractures often are misdiagnosed as exacerbation of chronic metabolic or inflammatory diseases and a fracture is not suspected until intense augmentation of radionuclide is seen on bone scan. Screening of patients presenting wit non-traumatic knee pain has shown a prevalence insufficiency fractures of the tibial plateau between 3 to 8% of the cases. These cases may be much more common than we commonly presume.

The fractures in need of reduction and fixation of the plateau fracture involve raising the depressed articular fragment, the possible addition of bone graft augmentation and buttressing of the osteochondral fragment with a plate. These buttress plates may hold the cortical rim of the plateau but many times fail in maintaining the reduction of the intra-articular surface of the plateau. This again results in degenerative changes in the joint and pain.

Internal fixation of these fractures with small fragment plates may be a solution to this problem, as demonstrated by the 5 presented cases treated operatively. The plates are smaller in size and are held by more screws, which are more proximal to the articular surface. This way they allow better control and maintenance of the anatomic reduction and in combination with an a-traumatic dissection and less stress shielding effect, result in a low rate of local complications.


A. Khoury R. Mosheiff M. Liebergall

With obesity on the rise in Israel, most of the medical staff will probably encounter the unique challenges that result from the pathophysiological changes in this population. Morbid obesity is a chronic disease manifesting itself in a steady and slow-progressive increase in body weight. Currently, BMI is considered the best score for morbid obesity definition and it is calculated by dividing the body weight (kgs) in body surface area (m2). The score for morbid obesity is above 40 kg/m2 and has many systemic implications such as hypertension, diabetes, cardiovascular changes, especially it effects the musculoskeletal system. Complex multiple trauma in morbid obesity patients present a challenge throughout all stages of treatment: assessment of injury, preliminary care, and definitive surgical approach.

In the last two years five morbid obese patients (all weighted more than 150 kgs) sustained various degrees of high-energy multiple-trauma and were operated on in our institution. The patient presented with the following injuries:

Femoral fracture.

Femoral fractures and contralateral tibial fracture.

Neck of femur fracture, comminuted forearm fracture and ARDS.

Pelvic fracture and ARDS.

Pelvic fracture and bilateral segmental fractures of femora, bilateral patellar fractures and ARDS.

The preoperative, operative and post-operative care presented special curative dilemma and pitfalls which required modifications in regular treatment modalities such as improvisation in special equipment and surgical techniques. The operating tables had to be changed so they could sustain the increased patient’s weight and allow, in the same time, modified percutaneous surgical approaches to overcome the anatomical problems. In all patients we were able to achieve the main goal of trauma treatment, i.e. stable fixation of fractures and mobilization.

The experience we have gained in managing and overcoming these obstacles may serve as a basis for devising guidelines for the comprehensive treatment of these patients.


E.N. Segev N. Yaniv E. Ezra S. Wientroub

We believe that soft tissue release and articulated hip distraction distinguishes itself in the short term as a good salvage procedure for late onset severe Perthes disease of the hip.

Our series is made of 10 patients with late onset Perthes disease. All 10 patients were above 9 years of age at diagnosis (average = 11 years). There were 7 boys and 3 girls in the series. All patients had significant limp and pain with positive Trendelenburg sign. All patients used crutches or wheelchairs and had symptoms for a period of 0.5 to 3 years before the operation; all hips had limited ROM. Two patients had previous soft tissue release. There were 2 children with Down syndrome and 1 child had Gleophysic Dysplasia. On preoperative radiographs, 8 patients had a saddle shape subluxating femoral head with hinge abduction and 2 subluxations only. Nine hips were graded Catterall IV and Herring C and 1 hip Catterall III Herring B. There were at least 3 and mostly 4 Catterall prognostic risk signs for these hips. All patients had a broken Shenton line, increased medial joint distance and low Epiphyseal index before surgery.

After adductor and ileopsoas release an orthofix hinged apparatus for distraction is applied to the hip. The distraction continues until overcorrecting of Shenton line achieved. The external fixator is left in place for 4–5 months while in the apparatus flexion and extension of the hip is possible and encouraged. The follow-up ranged from 0.5 to 3 years. At last follow-up all patients were walking freely with improved hip ROM. All patients resumed daily ambulatory status and 2 were involved in regular sports. Latest radiographs showed that the saddle shape disappeared in 7 of 8 hips, in all patients hip subluxation decreased as measured by medial joint distance and Shenton line was corrected to between 0.6 mm. The Epiphysis index and joint congruency improved in most cases.

The level of satisfaction from the operation was very high for all patients and their parents.

Drawing of final conclusion will be possible only after assessing the long-term results.


A. Cziger M. Paranjaphe K. Katz

Purpose: The aim of the study was to establish normal reference standards for the appearance of the femoral head ossification center according to age, sex and gestational age.

Material and Methods: Sonographic examination of the hip was performed in 1800 healthy Indian and Israeli infants (900 each) aged 2 to 24 weeks. There was an equal number of males and females. A single physician performed all examinations in each country. For each infant, we recorded sex, date of birth, gestational age at birth (weeks), date of ultrasound examination, age at examination (weeks), and presence or absence of the femoral head ossification center on sonographic examination. All data were collected in a Microsoft Excell file and submitted for independent statistical analysis using paired Fisher exact test, chi-square test, and a NOVA test.

Results: The ossification center was noted in the second week of life in the Israeli infants and at 8 weeks in the Indian infants. By 20 weeks, however, it was noted in 81% or more of the Indian infants but only 22–74% of the Israeli ones. In both groups between 20 to 24 weeks of age the ossification center was noted in more than 90% of the infants.

Conclusions: Knowledge of the normal sonographic appearance of the femoral head ossification center by age and ethnicity will help clinicians in the diagnosis and treatment of hip disorders.


SPRENGEL DEFORMITY Pages 307 - 307
Full Access
H. Bensahel A. Khairouni Y. Desgrippes Ph. Souchet

Introduction: Sprengel deformity is also named High Congenital Scapula (HCS).

It is a rare abnormality in children of which consequences are cosmetic and functional too.

Purpose: It is to assess those anatomic findings which have a prognostic value and to focus on the main stages of the treatment.

Material and Methods: We reviewed a series of 23 cases of HCS in 19 children, 4 of whom having had a bilateral involvement. In all the cases, the elevation of the scapula was accompanied by a rotation and a varus position of the glena.

The age of our patients ranged from 6 months to 13 years old. 50% of them were younger than 9 at the first visit. Functional consequences consisted in a modification of the plan of the movements of shoulder. Besides the omovertebral bone, many important abnormalities – mainly of the spine – have been noticed in our series.

The cases were classified using the degree of elevation of the superomedial angle of scapula. Three grades could be set up.

Concerning the treatment, 2 children have not been operated on. In the other cases, we used a modification of the Woodward procedure.

Results: Two cases were judged to have a poor result. One case had a fair result.

79% were considered as good on both aspects, cosmetically and functionally, with no complication.

The age at which surgery has been performed seems to have no influence on the result. On the opposite, the number and the severity of the anatomic anomalies have to be taken into consideration for the prognostic assessment.

Discussion: As comparing our results with those of the other series, we could notice that our procedure is less aggressive. Indeed, the majority of the surgical procedures mention a resection of a part of the scapula. In such a way, the cosmetic result can be easily improved, even if the scapula has not been really lowered. On the other hand, the anti-varus stage of our procedure improves the plan of movements of the shoulder.

Conclusion: The Sprengel deformity could need surgical correction in the moderate and major deformities. Surgery shall lower the scapula as much as possible, but it shall avoid neurologic or vascular complications. At last, surgery is first indicated for improving the biomechanics of the scapular girdle.


Full Access
E. Bar-On D. Weigl R. Parvari J. Katz T. Steinberg

Purpose: Congenital insensitivity to Pain (CIP) is a rare peripheral neuropathy which may affect various sensory pathways and often affects the autonomic nervous system. Musculoskeletal manifestations include infections, fractures, growth disturbances, avascular necrosis, Charcot arthropathy, joint dislocations and heterotopic ossification. The purpose of the study was to review the orthopaedic problems in patients with Congenital Insensitivity to Pain and make treatment recommendations.

Methods: Thirteen patients from eight families were examined and all charts and radiographs were reviewed. A quantitative sweat test was performed in five patients and an intradermal histamine test in ten.

DNA was prepared in all patients and examined for specific mutations.

Results: Three clinical presentations were found:

Type A – Five patients presented with multiple infections requiring many surgical procedures ranging from local debridement to below knee amputation.

Type B – Three patients presented with fractures and growth disturbances of the lower limbs as well as avascular necrosis of the talus or femoral condyle. Two patients underwent corrective osteotomies due to deformities. Type C – Five patients presented with Charcot arthropathies, joint dislocations, fractures and infections. Four of them were mentally retarded.

Patients underwent multiple surgical procedure to control infections.

Attempts surgical stabilization of joints were unsuccessful.

Mutations were found in four patients.

Conclusions

Patient education, shoe ware and periods of non weight bearing are important in prevention and early treatment of decubitus ulcers.

Differentiation between fractures and infections is difficult and should be based on aspiration and cultures in order to prevent unnecessary surgery.

Established infections should be treated by wide surgical debridement.

Deformities should be treated by corrective osteotomies and shortening should be treated with shoe lifts or epiphysiodesis.

Joint dislocations should be treated non-operatively as attempts at surgical stabilization gave poor results.


W.B. Lehman D.S. Feldman D.M. Scher D. Atar J. Bazzi A. Mohaideen

Purpose: To describe a simple method for performing pelvic osteotomies in children that will obtain appropriate femoral head coverage.

Method: The necessary femoral head coverage was preoperatively predicted by assessing the acetabular, Wiberg, and Lequesne angles, and by 3-D CAT scan evaluations of each hip. Postoperative results were evaluated in a similar manner and compared with the preoperative findings. An “almost” percutaneous triple pelvic osteotomy was performed using an adductor incision and a transverse incision.

Results: In spite of the theoretical restrictions in this age group to acetabular movement, i.e. rigid triradiate cartilage, stiff symphysis pubis and rigid sacrospinous and sacrotuberous ligaments, adequate coverage of the femoral head was attained with the described technique.

Conclusion: If a pelvic osteotomy is being considered to better stabilize a child’s hip due to a condition such as Legg-Calve-Perthes disease, hip dysplasia, a deformed femoral neck secondary to slipped capital femoral epiphysis or femoral head necrosis, the “almost” percutaneous triple osteotomy has a decided advantage over other well described pelvic osteotomies since it is simpler to perform and sufficiently covers the femoral head.


F. Lokiec S. Rochkind M. Yaniv S. Wientroub

Despite the impressive advancements in prenatal planning and assessment, obstetrical brachial plexus palsy remains an unfortunate consequence of difficult childbirth.

Although the majority of infants with plexopathy recover with minor or no residual functional deficits, a number of children do not regain sufficient limb function and develop significant functional limitations, bony deformities and joint contractures.

Recent developments in the technique of microsurgical reconstruction of peripheral nerve injuries proved to be effective in selected cases of children with obstetrical brachial plexus injury.

Many of these children and those who were defined as having minor injury will remain with considerable functional limitation and deserve late orthopaedic reconstruction.

Based on that, we developed a multidisciplinary Brachial Plexus clinic gathering a microsurgeon, a pediatric orthopaedic surgeon, an electrophysiologist clinician, physiotherapists and occupational therapist in order to assess and evaluate these children.

A total of 105 children were seen and followed up in our clinic during the last 2 years.

Most of these children were referred to our clinic from other centers and from physiotherapists treating these children on an out-patient basis.

We report the orthopaedic reconstruction operations performed in 9 cases of residual functional disabilities in children born with obstetric palsy.

4 patients had latissimmus dorsi and teres major transfer.

2 patients had derotation osteotomy of the humerus.

1 patient had Steindler flexorplasty of the elbow.

2 patients had open reduction and capsulorrhapy for a dislocated shoulder.

Video assessment of these children was performed before and after the operation. Function was also analyzed before and after operation by a physiotherapist and an occupational therapist.

Significant functional improvement was achieved, to the satisfaction of patients and parents.


E. Cohen

Study Design: The lumbar spine of children an adolescents with suspected spondylolysis was assessed by magneting resonance imaging.

Objectives: To evaluate the value of MRI in diagnosis and after nonoperative treatment of incipient spondylolysis in children and adolescents.

Summary of Background Data: The diagnosis of incipient spondylolysis in children and adolescents is difficult. Radiographs have a low sensitivity and the use of bone scans, computer tomography and MRI controversial.

Methods: The study is prospective. The lumbar spine was assessed by MR imaging in children (n=14, mean age 12.4 years) with unspecific low back pain for more than 3 weeks and normal plain radiographs at presentation. Six of the seven children were involved in moderate to severe sport activities.

Incipient spondylolysis was diagnosed when on T1 sequences a hypointense area was found within the pars interarticularis of any lumbar vertebra while on T2 sequences a corresponding hyperintense zone was detected. Brace and activity restriction was recommended. Follow-up MRI studies were performed after treatment at 3 months interval.

Results: Seven of 14 patients presented with pars edema (T1 hypointense, T2 hyperintense), six at L5 vertebra, one at L4 and L5 vertebra, respectively. After 3 months healing was demonstrated both clinically and by imaging in six children in another child healing was observed after 6 months.

Conclusions: MRI showed promising results in detecting and monitoring the early onset of spondylolysis. In our cases early treatment prevented pars defects.


Y. Odeski

Introduction: Congenital pseudoarthrosis is one of the greatest challenges of pediatric orthopedic practice. Treatment measures and literature addressing this condition are numerous reflecting the difficulty in management. The aim of successful treatment is to achieve length, union and normal axis of the involved leg.

A method of treatment is described whereby the affected tibia is united and lengthened.

Material and methods: Ten patients between six and thirty years of age were treated.

All patients suffered from Boyd 1 or 2 Psuedoarthrosis of the Tibia. All patients had had previous surgery (three to thirteen operations) and three to ten centimeter of shortening. All patients were treated by lengthening of the tibia and open debridement and compression of the pseudoarthrosis till union using Ilizarov techniques.

Results: All patients had eventual successful outcome.

Eight patients achieved union length and normalization of the tibial axis with the first operation and two patients had recurrence of the pseudoarthrosis and had re-operation with success.

Conclusion: Successful surgical treatment of pseudoarthrosis of the tibia is possible.

To achieve this success a number of basic principles need to be followed.

These principles are:

Correction of the axis of the limb.

Debridement of the pseudoarthrosis and opening of the intra medullary canal with insertion of one of the ends of the tibia into the other.

Lengthening of the tibia with proximal osteotomy and concurrent compression of the fracture site.

Absolute correction of the tibial axis.

This treatment regime has shown success in the failed management of the pseudoarthrosis and if these principles are adhered to this regime will have success in the management of this pathology and prevent re-operation.


O. Levy S.N. Massoud S.A. Copeland

Introduction: Thermal shrinkage has been used to reduce the volume of redundant capsule in patients with multidirectional instability. Concerns have been expressed that thermal shrinkage may char or burn the capsule compromising future attempts at surgical stabilization. The purpose of the current study was to assess whether laser assisted capsular shrinkage adversely affects the result of a subsequent open inferior capsular shift.

Patients: A prospective study of ten consecutive patients treated by open inferior capsular shift following a failed laser assisted capsular shrinkage. They were five men and five women with an average age of 29 years. Six patients had true multidirectional instability, two had antero-inferior instability with multidirectional laxity and two had postero-inferior instability with multidirectional laxity. An anterior approach was used and a humeral side capsular shift performed. The mean period of follow-up was 33 months (range, 18–47 months).

Results: According to the system of Rowe et al., nine patients had an excellent rating and one poor at final follow-up. The mean score improved from 37.5 to 94 points on the Rowe scale, from 73 to 90.0 points on the Constant score and from 1.6 to 7.6 points on a numerical satisfaction scale. The one poor result was in the only patient who had multiple attempts at open stabilization prior to laser assisted capsular shrinkage. There were no complications.

Conclusion: The results of an inferior capsular shift following failed laser assisted capsula-shrinkage are comparable with the results of a primary capsular shift for multidirectional instability.


A. Oran M. Pritsch (Perry)

Introduction: Thermal shrinkage represents a major innovation in the evolving field of surgery for shoulder instability. The basic science of collagen fiber change has been studied in detailed and set the physical basis for mechanical properties change of the capsule. Animal models and clinical studies has been published for the last decade with short and mid-term results. A clinical application has proceeded basic knowledge in many respects and there is concern about the safety and efficacy of the procedure.

Materials and Methods: Between February 1999 and January 2001, 25 patients, mean age 21.5 (range 16–28) were operated (single shoulder) for radiofrequency capsular shrinkage with VAPR device. In this group 2 high performance sportsmen (basketball and judo), 4 leisure sports activities (mainly basketball), 6 combat soldiers and 13 non related to sporting activities. In 5 of these patients arthroscopic Bankart repair was performed. In one case the procedure was performed after failure of capsular shift in an extreme hyperlax multidirectional instability and this patients was excluded from the study.

Indication for surgery were: 1. Multidirectional instability with less than 3 frank dislocation. 2. Symptomatic subluxators with positive apprehension test after failed non-operative rehabilitation program. 3. High demands first dislocators sportsman with failure of non operative rehabilitation program.

The arthroscopy was performed in sitting position with posterior and anterior portals as a day surgery or overnight hospitalization. Anterior portal was used for VAPR probe first and portals were switched if needed.

All patients were immobilized in shoulder immobilizer for 6 weeks. Rehabilitation program was planed on individual basis and patients were instructed not to return to full contact sport or activities at least 6 months post operatively. Patients were checked at 2 and 6 weeks before commence rehabilitation and than at 3, 6, 24 months. Mean follow up was 17.6 months (range 6–27 m.).

Results: Operation and postoperative course was uneventful and no complications were detected. All patients had normal axillary nerve sensation and normal deltoid function. 21 of 24 (87.5%) regain pre dislocation activity between 6 to 12 months and had no dislocation or instability symptoms. Range of motion after 6 months was fully functional and comparable with the opposite side in 22 of these 23 patients. One patient had postoperative stiffness up to 12 months from operation and recover completely then. All but two followed rehabilitation instructions One of these two regains basketball activities 4 weeks postoperatively and dislocated his shoulder immediately. These patients underwent inferior capsular shift operation later on.

The second patient, a 16 years female elite judoka, commenced judo matches after 3 months and was asymptomatic with 24 months follow-up time.

Conclusion: In selective indications with multidirectional instability, individual rehabilitation program and good cooperation success rate of 91% could be achieved among mixed activities group. We think that this procedure is a good alternative in selected cases. Longer follow-up for selected groups is still needed.


O. Levy G. Tytherleiah-Strong G. Sforza L. Funk S. Copeland

Introduction: Shoulder arthroplasty is generally a successful procedure. However, in a small percentage excessive pain or limitation of motion, does occur. We examine the role of arthroscopy in the diagnosis and treatment of these patients.

Methods and Results: Between 1995–2000, 29 patients who had excessive pain or limitation of motion following arthroplasty underwent arthroscopy. Time between procedures was 37.3 months (range 4–95).

Impingement syndrome confirmed and successfully treated by ASD in 10, a rotator cuff tear in 3. Loose bodies removed in 1. Arthroscopic washout was performed in 1 patient for acute septic joint. 6 of 7 with capsular fibrosis underwent a successful arthroscopic capsular release. Loose or worn components were found in 4, a florid synovitis in 1, loose cement in another and in 1 no abnormality could be found.

Discussion: Arthroscopy is a useful tool for diagnosis and treatment of painful or stiff shoulder arthroplasty. However, it leads to a number of technical difficulties. Orientation within the joint is often hindered as the reflection from the prosthesis makes it difficult to differentiate between the real and mirror images of the tissues and arthroscopic instruments. Access is often compromised in stiff shoulders.

Conclusion: Arthroscopy following shoulder arthroplasty is useful for the diagnosis and treatment of pain and loss of motion in selected patients, but can be technically difficult. Diagnostic arthroscopy following shoulder arthroplasty should be considered for patients suffering from pain in whom no cause could be found using less invasive investigations.


V. Barchilon J. Verney-Carron T. Hallel D.F. Gazielly

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to analyze the anatomo-radiological results, the clinical results, and complications of minimally displaced fractures of the proximal humerus, treated by immediate, ambulatory self-passive mobilization, followed by a strengthening and propioceptive training program.

Materials and Methods: 12 patients, 7 females and 5 males, mean age 56.91 (SD: 15.76) were reviewed retrospectively at a mean of 28.33 months follow-up. All the patients were mobilized the day after the first visit, i.e. the day after the fracture in 7 patients (58.3%), up to 7 days after the fracture in 4 patients and 3 weeks after the fracture in one late referral. Over an average period of 5.8 months, an average 45.41 (SD: 20.83) sessions of rehabilitation, with a therapist, for each patient, were recorded. The patients were recommended to perform four sessions of self rehabilitation a day. Clinical evaluation included a questionnaire covering subjective evaluation, Activities of Daily Living (ADL) by means of the ASA index and the Constant’s score, and type and duration of rehabilitation. The radiological evaluation included review of the X-rays, from the initial traumatic event to the last follow up X-ray. An AP view with three rotations, outlet view and axillary view were performed for each patient. The fracture type, displacement, interval for union, glenohumeral osteoarthritis (according to the Samilson classification), type of acromion and osteoporosis, were recorded. Special attention was paid in detecting joint stiffness, algodystrophy, neurological impairment, malunion, further displacement, signs of avascular necrosis and post-traumatic osteoarthritis.

Results: The mean non adjusted Constant’s score at last follow up was 88.33 over 100 (SD: 11.45) an average of 96.01% compared to the contralateral side. 83% of patients were pain free, and 17% reported mild pain. Active motion was very satisfactory averaging 96.23% in forward flexion, 89.86% in external rotation with the hand at the side, and 90.22% in external rotation at 90° abduction, and a difference of 1.46 vertebral levels in active internal rotation, as compared to the contralateral shoulder. Passive motion was also analyzed in the same way. Power of the affected shoulder in forward elevation was on average 90.19% of the contralateral side. Impingement was tested by the Neer, Hawkins and Yocum signs: 4 patients (33.3%) reported at least one positive sign of impingement. The Jobe and Palm up tests were negative in 100% of patients. 11 patients were very satisfied and 1 patient satisfied. Joint stiffness developed in one case (8.3%), with 100° of forward elevation, 50° external rotation with the hand at the side, 50° external rotation at 90° abduction. No algodystrophy, no neurological impairment, no further displacement, no signs of avascular necrosis, no post-traumatic progression of osteoarthritis, were observed in any case. Union was achieved in all the 12 patients, in 2 cases with some degree of angulation.

Conclusions: Very good functional and radiological results were obtained with immediate passive mobilization of minimally displaced fractures of the proximal humerus. It is a safe method as all the fractures united and the rate of complication was very low especially without joint stiffness or RSD and with very good patient satisfaction.


A. Regev P. Sagiv E. Glaser

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS) is the most common peripheral neuropathy. The pathology is due to pressure on the median nerve at the wrist.

Ultrasonography shows the soft tissues as well as other pathological conditions as edema, synovitis, soft tissue tumors or bonny pathology of the carpal tunnel and its contents. The test can be dynamic and can provide the clinician with important information regarding the flexor tendons/muscles movement into the canal.

The present study aimed to find sonographic criteria for the diagnosis of CTS. Pressure on the median nerve under the carpal ligament causes narrowing of the nerve (hourglass deformity). The ratio between nerve width proximal to the canal and the width of the most compressed part of the nerve under the ligament was selected as our indicator. Our assumption was that in healthy individuals the ratio would be 1 or close to 1. Standardization was based on values taken from a group of healthy volunteers (47 hands). Mean value of this ratio in the healthy group was x-=0.95, standard deviation 0-=0.13. 79% (37/47) of the control group were in the range of ±1 and 97% (44/47) were in the range of ±2 standard deviations from mean value.

Based on these figures, we defined a probable diagnosis of CTS as a ratio under two standard deviations from the mean value.

Our database included 450 patients operated for CTS at our department between 1998 and 2000. Out of this group, 99 patients had met our inclusion criteria (positive anamnesis, positive clinical examination, complete Ultrasound and EMG studies).

We could define an indicator and analysis of the results of our study show a significant and positive statistical correlation between this indicator and a positive motor latency electrodiagnostic finding.

Conclusion: EMG is the current Gold Standard for the diagnosis of CTS. Based on our findings concerning the indicator we have defined Ultra Sonography is a reliable, readily available, low cost auxiliary test to help diagnose CTS.

A larger scale study of this indicator is in progress.


S. Romano F. De Schrijver I. Pigeau P. Saffar

Although articular chondrocalcinosis is a frequently seen disorder, the broad clinical variations of forms affecting the wrist are more recently and more rarely described. Chondrocalcinosis of the wrist is an evolutionary disorder, which can initially be well treated medically. Further in the natural evolution, scaphoradial joint destruction occurs followed by midcarpal wear. Until now one form of chondrocalcinosis, developing scapholunate dissociation and tending towards a SLAC (Scapho-Lunate Advanced Collapse) wrist, has been well documented.

We state that there exists a pathway which does not lead to any scapholunate gap and is less often associated with a ST (Scapho-Trapezium) osteoarthritis. This isolated form of chondrocalcinosis of the wrist has been mistaken for SLAC or SNAC (Scaphoid Non-union Advanced Collapse) wrists, because its clinical and radiological resemblance. We propose to call this form the SCAC (Scaphoid Chondrocalcinosis Advanced Collapse) wrist. It is seen in elderly patients. There is a long evolution for several years, and most patients have an extensive medical history before the correct diagnosis is being made.

We describe the typical clinical and radiological evolution on five patients. According to the amount and pattern of cartilage destruction we propose a radiological classification in four grades. The five cases presented were all seen in grade III.

Two of them underwent previous surgery; a styloidectomy in one and a scaphoid replacement by a titanium prosthesis in the other. Three patients had previous carpal tunnel release. All five have been treated by a hamatoluno-capitate arthrodesis, with resection of the scaphoid and triquetrum (according to Delattre’s technique). Results are described and discussed.


J. Bickels J. Wittig Y. Kollender M. Malawer I. Meller

Introduction: Surgical removal by means of curettage is the mainstay of treatment of enchondromas of the hand. Methods of reconstruction after tumor removal usually entail no reconstruction or filling of the tumor cavity with a bone graft. These techniques necessitate a prolonged period of protected activity until bone healing of the tumor cavity occurs. The authors have utilized hardware and bone cement for the purpose of reconstruction of the tumor cavity. This technique provides immediate mechanical stability and allows early mobilization.

Methods: Between 1986 and 1999 the authors treated 13 patients (8 females, 4 males) who ranged in age from 23 to 58 years (median, 32 years) and diagnosed with enchondroma of the hand. Eight patients presented with a pathological fracture. Anatomic locations included: metacarpal bones – 5, proximal phalanx – 4, and middle phalanx – 4. Tumors were approached through the retained thinned or destroyed cortex to minimize additional bone loss. Surgery included removal of all gross tumor with hand curettes; this was followed by high speed burr drilling of the inner reactive bone shell. Reconstruction included intramedullary metal wire along the longitudinal axis of the cavity and polyme-hylmethacrylate (PMMA). Full activity as tolerated was allowed immediately after surgery. All patients were followed for more than 2 years.

Follow-up included physical and radiological evaluation and functional evaluation.

Results: Following surgery, all patients returned to their presurgical functional capability within two weeks. At the last follow-up, none of the patients had local tumor recurrence and although three patients had 15° to 20° decrease in flexion of the metacarpophalangeal joint, none reported a functional limitation. There were no postoperative infections or fractures.

Conclusions: Reconstruction of the tumor cavity, remaining after curettage of enchondroma of the hand, with intramedullary hardware and PMMA provides immediate mechanical stability and allows early mobilization. This technique is associated with good short- and long-term functional outcomes.


L. Sedel P. Bizot L. Banallec R. Nizard

In order to avoid the consequences of polyethylene wear in a high-risk population, 128 alumina-alumina total hip arthroplasty were implanted in 116 consecutive patients of 40 years old or less. Osteonecrosis and sequellae of congenital hip dislocation were the main etiologies representing 71% of the hips. The same titanium alloy cemented stem was implanted in all hips. Four alumina acetabular component fixations were used: cemented plain alumina socket (41 hips), screw-in ring with an alumina insert (22 hips), a press-fit plain alumina socket (32 hips) and a press-fit titanium metal back with an alumina insert (33 hips).

Eight patients (11 hips) died during the follow-up period. Sixteen revisions were documented, 12 for ace-tabular aseptic loosening, 3 for bipolar loosening (2 were septic), and 1 for unexplained pain. Eighty-nine hips were followed radiologically for two to twenty years. No femoral nor acetabular osteolysis were observed with an average follow-up of 8.4 years. Wear was unmeasurable. Four additional sockets showed definite migration. The respective survival rate at 7 years were 91.4% for the cemented cup, 88.8% for the screw-in ring, 95.1% for cementless press-fit plain alumina socket and 94.3% for the metal-back press-fit component.

The ten-year survival rate was 88.0% for the cemented socket and 88.8% for the screw-in ring. The fifteen-year survival rate was 76.7% for the cemented socket. The occurrence of a graft was the only prognostic factor with a 62.6% survival rate at ten years for the grafted hips and a 90.1% for the non-grafted hips (p=0.004).

The alumina-alumina bearing surfaces for young patients appeared as a valuable alternative to standard metal-polyethylene system. There is a need to improve socket fixation if we want to have a survival of the arthroplasty as long as the life expectancy of this increasing and demanding population. The last design with a fully coated HA titanium shell and an alumina liner seems to fulfill the requirements.


A. Maroudas

Cartilaginous tissues such as articular cartilage and the intervertebral disc are called upon to function under very high pressures which they can do, thanks to the very special properties of their two major components, viz., the proteoglycans (PG) and collagen. The PG, a flexible polyelectrolyte of high fixed charge density has a high osmotic pressure and therefore a tendency to imbibe water and maintain tissue turgor while the collagen mesh, with its good tensile properties, prevents undue swelling, thus enabling the proteoglycan-water mixture to exist as a concentrated solution. Moreover, by resisting instantaneous deformation, the collagen network ensures the dimensional stability of cartilage. The combination of the two components enables a cartilaginous tissue to exhibit flexibility and to withstand tensile stresses as well as high compressive loads.

Moreover, cartilage is an avascular tissue, hence the transport of nutrients and different substrates is controlled by the properties of the matrix. In addition to common nutrients, various regulatory substances, such as growth hormones and cytokines, also have to reach the cell. These substances are often required in extremely small amounts which, however, need to be rigorously controlled. This again, depends on transport through the extracellular space. At the same time, metabolic waste products are secreted by the cells into the matrix and have to pass through the latter in order to reach the synovial fluid for removal from the joint space. The same must happen to matrix macromolecules degraded in the course of normal turnover, whether the degradation happens intra- or extracellularly. Finally, macromolecules, newly synthesized by the cells, are secreted into the matrix and must move through it before being assembled at some distance from the cell.

The concentration of a solute within the matrix, apart from being an important factor in determining the rate of transport, is also able to modify the properties of the matrix itself. Thus, ionic concentrations are largely responsible for determining the level of the osmotic pressure within the cartilage matrix in general, and in the immediate environment of the cell in particular. The osmotic pressure of the matrix, in turn, is responsible for the resistance of cartilage to fluid loss and hence to compressive stresses. Together with the hydraulic permeability of the pore space, it is also an important determinant of the rate of fluid movement out of and into the tissue. In addition, the high ionic concentration and osmotic pressure in the immediate environment of the chondrocyte have been shown to affect their synthetic processes.


S. Itzchak M. Eichenblat

Endoscopic surgery has evolved tremendously in the past decades, especially the use of arthroscopy in orthopedics.

The knee is the joint most commonly treated, followed by the shoulder.

The arthroscopy of the elbow has developed slower than in the other joints mostly due to the close anatomic relationship to vital structures, that is, the risk of injuring the main blood vessels and nerves, as there are reports of as much as 10% of complications.

The purpose of our study is to summarize our experience of elbow arthroscopy in Kaplan Medical Center in the past years, and to show that sound technique, precision with details and expert use of this method may lead the elbow arthroscopy to be an excellent tool in the solution and treatment of many problems in clinical practice.

We present 18 subjects with the age ranging from 17 to 68. Our results were good in most of the cases. We had no major complications in long term follow up.

Our conclusion is that meticulous use of elbow arthroscopy has few complications and with good results, and may avoid open surgery.


R. Nizard

Introduction: The achievement of a well aligned limb is one of the main factor that probably affect the long term survival of total knee arthroplasty. Despite many improvements in ancillary device design, a significant number of total knee arthroplasty remain in excessive varus or valgus. Computer assisted systems may improve the control on implant positioning. The goal of this paper is to present the rationale and the early experience with a recently developed system (Navitrack®).

Material and methods: A CT-scan allows acquisition of patient anatomy. The 3D reconstruction is obtained with specially developed software. Location of the instruments and bone during surgery is obtained either with a magnetic or an optical system. After captor placement, navigation allows real-time control of the ancillary device in order to perform the necessary cuts. The main landmarks given by the system during surgery are the femoral and tibial mechanical axis, cuts location, rotational positioning of the femoral implant can also be controlled using the transepicondylar axis, the posterior aspects of the femoral condyles, or the patellar groove. Rotational positioning of the tibial component can also be evaluated in order to allow a adequate orientation of the tibial slope.

Results: Four implantations failed for technical reasons including failure of captor fixation on bone during surgery, and failure of the electronic control of the captors. However, most attempted implantations were successful with an accurate placement of the implants evaluated on long leg radiographs.

Discussion: Implantation of a TKA with an anatomic-based system is possible. But, this first encouraging experience needs to be confirmed and improvements are in progress.


Ch. Msika J. Zahlaoui K. Hansraj

Valgus High Tibial Osteotomy (H.T.O.) in a recent past has unfairly been compared to Total Knee Replacement (T.K.R.); H.T.O. was unduly discarded as n unreliable procedure due to its supposed high rate of failures and/or complication; the clinical material which led to these conclusions was, in fact, predominantly poorly done H.T.O.’s. If, however, Valgus H.T.O.

Is performed (and achieves union) with the same technical predictable accuracy as T.K.R.

Is evaluated with comparable statistical methods as T.K.R. (on the basis of survivorship analysis of postoperative knee function).

T.O. remains a very valuable procedure to treat knee osteoarthritis, especially in still very active patients.

Material and methods

Since 1989, 49 “A.C.C.W.I.F.” H.T.O. were performed and followed up for at least three years (Automatic Correction through Closing wedge Internal Fixation).

Using full-length radiographs and pre-operative planning, the technical accuracy was assessed immediately after surgery, at the time of union and at the last follow-up.

Negative marks were given either in case of inadequate correction (more than 3° degrees of error to the pre-op planning) or in case of complication.

The knee function was rated according to the I.K.S. scoring system.

Excellent results were observed in more than 90% of the operated knees, with very little deterioration of the results with time.

Survivorship of knee function was assessed using revision by T.K.R> or repeat H.T.O. as its end point.


O. Schwartz R.A. Imberg D.G. Mendes M. Said

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the efficacy of radiographic and computed tomography pre-operative planning and postoperative results of total knee arthroplasty.

Material and methods: 110 procedures of Corin MTK total knee arthroplasty were performed since July 1998.

A strict radiological and CT evaluation was done prior to and following the surgery and accompanied the clinical evaluation and follow up. A cohort of 32 patients is presented in details regarding the imaging pre-operative planning and the post-operative results.

The radiological data included: 1. Angle of frontal deformity; 2. Angle of instability; 3. Fi-Fc – distance from the tip of the fibular head to the distal part of the lateral femoral condyle; 4. Frontal inclination angle of tibial component; 5. Frontal inclination angle of femoral component; 6. Sagital posterior inclination of tibial component; 7. Sagital posterior inclination angle of the femoral component; 8. The distance from the patella to the knee center of motion.

The computed tomography data included: 1. The actual dimensions of the patella, tibia and femur; 2. The preoperative angle between the posterior condylar line and anterior condylar line; 3. The angle between the posterior condylar line and the trans-epicondylar line; 4. The angle of external rotation of the femoral component; 5. The angle of external rotation of the tibial component; 6. The distance of lateralization of the femoral and tibial components.

Results: The desired value of external rotation of the femoral component was 6–8°. Measuring the pre-operative angle between the posterior condylar line and the trans-epicondylar line helped to determine the degree of external rotation intraoperatively. The mean external rotation of the femoral component in our cohort was 6.73.

Measuring the angle of external rotation of the tibial component preop helped to determine the extent of external rotation of the tibial component intraoperatively.

A significant decrease of the postop Q angle was noticed in all patients.

Conclusion: Radiographic and computed tomography postoperative data reflects the value of the preoperative planning of total knee arthroplasty.


S. Velkes M. Livshitz I. Jakim

Introduction: Polyethylene wear of the prosthetic knee tibial component is currently the main cause of medium and long term failure of total knee arthroplasty. The use of a mobile bearing knee prosthesis is intended to decrease the rate polyethylene wear and therefore delay medium and long term failure. We present our five year clinical results of a mobile bearing knee prosthesis.

Material and methods: 150 mobile bearing knee arthroplasties implanted between 1993 and 1996 in our institution were followed. 15 knees were lost to follow up. All knees followed up were operated on for osteoarthritis.

The British Orthopaedic Association knee function score was used to access the clinical results and the Knee Society Radiographic evaluation was used for radiological evaluation.

Results: 33% of patients achieved an excellent result, 52% a good result, and only 3% were not satisfied with the end result.

Flexion was greater than 90 degrees in 97% of the patients.

Three knees required re-surgery, 1 for deep sepsis, 1 for patello femoral problems and 1 for a fractured polyethylene component.

No knee required revision for polyethylene were or loosening.

Conclusions: Our mid term results are comparable to those of other prosthesis both mobile and fixed bearing knees as far as revision and radiological and functional scores are concerned. We noted that patient satisfaction in the face of good radiological and functional scores is less than would be expected.


M. Yasin M. Weisbort E.U. Eskenazi D. Hendel

Approximately 700 TKRs (Total Knee Arthroplasty) were performed in our department from 1992–2000. In 13 cases, patellar dislocation occurred post-operation - 12 with no trauma and one following a fall and trauma to the medial aspect of the knee. Dislocation occurred from 2 months following the operation until 1 year postoperative (average 4.5 months). None of the patients had malalignment of the components. The average femorotibial angle was 5° (range 8° valgus to 3° varus). No patient had preoperative valgus deformity. Postoperative range of motion was 105° (range 90–125°). All dislocations were treated by operative lateral relapse and medial capsular implication followed by 6 weeks of immobilization with a brace in full extension and then physiotherapy, range of motion, patellar taping and Vastus medialis strengthening.

The patella stabilized in 11 cases following the operation. In 2 cases, dislocation recurred following the operation and they were operated on again where medialization of the tibial tubercle was performed. Both cases stabilized following the second operation. One case developed a stress fracture of the tibia at the end of the tubercle osteotomy which healed conservatively. All dislocations occurred in the IBII prosthesis.

During the past 3 years since using the PFC Sigma and Legacy prosthesis, we have had no dislocations of the patella, probably for the following reasons:

Use of the mid vastus exposure.

Geometry of the prosthesis.

In only 10% of the replacements, patellar resurfacing was performed.


R.A. Imberg O. Schwartz M. Said D.G. Mendes

Objective: To present our innovative surgical technique that simultaneously provides optimal femorotibial tracking and patellofemoral tracking in total knee arthroplasty.

Material and methods: A total of 127 patients underwent total knee arthroplasty using new criteria for femoral, tibial and patellar preparation and placement of their respective components. The technique consisted of intraoperative determination of the rotation of the femoral and tibial components, lateralization of the femoral and tibial components and medialization of the patellar component, thus reducing the Q-angle. It provided excellent tracking of the tibiofemoral and patellofemoral joints without retinacular release.

Results: At a follow up of up to 3 years, 90% of patients gained up to 120 degrees of motion within first 6 months. Rest pain score [10-0] improved from 5.2 to 0.8. Activity pain score [10-0] improved from 9.0 to 2.0. Stair climbing [0–10] improved from 2.8 to 7.1. Walking score improved from 3.2 to 7.3. ADL function improved from 4.3 to 7.1. Our complications included 1 case of postoperative traumatic fracture of the patella, that healed spontaneously, 1 deep infection which responded well to open lavage, and 6 cases of delayed wound healing that required secondary closure. One patient died of unrelated cause. No fracture, loosening, component failure or instability was recorded. None of the implants required removal.

Conclusion: Implementation of our 10 rules concept of surgical technique gave early excellent results, and we recommend it as a technique universally applicable in total knee arthroplasty.


G. Kirsh L. Kandel C. Vasili

We studied the influence of different femoral alignment systems on blood loss and the need for blood transfusion after total knee arthroplasty. We retrospectively recorded the blood loss in two groups of consecutive patients. The first group consisted of 46 patients in whom the total knee arthroplasty was performed using an intramedullary femoral alignment system and the second group consisted of 45 patients in whom the procedure was performed with the extramedullary system.

In the first group, the mean volume of drained blood was 758 milliliters, while in the second group it was 613 milliliters (p< 0.05). More patients in the first group required blood transfusions, but there was no significant difference in the number of blood units transfused per patient.

In conclusion, extramedullary femoral alignment instrumentation reduces the blood loss after the cementless total knee arthroplasty.


R. Thein A. Kidron

Between April 1999 and April 2001 we operated 233 ACL reconstructions. In 24 cases we used Bone Patellar Bone allografts for ACL reconstruction. All allografts came from the same tissue bank and prepared in the same manner. There were 10 Right knees and 14 Left knees. The average age of the patients was 46.8 years with the range between 26 and 55.

There were 6 females and 18 males. The average follow up was 8.2 months with the range between 3 and 24 months. All reconstructive surgery was done in the same technique by both authors. All graft donors were younger than 35 years.

The indications for using allografts were revision cases and patients over 40 years of age.

The width of the graft was increased by 20% to compensate for the decreased strength due to the preparation process. The outcome was assessed by clinical evaluation form, detailed physical examination of the knee by the examiners and structured interview. 21 had excellent and good results (full return to previous activity, no pain, stable knee with good range of motion). There were 19 primary cases and 5 revision cases. There was one poor result – spontaneous tear of the allograft (a revision case). One case had a partial tear of the graft falling from stairs (a revision case, that was treated with thermal shrinkage). One case who went for Genzyme treatment, had a stable knee, the arthroscopic examination showed a partial tear of the graft. We had no cases of infection or synovitis.

According to our short follow up data collected from the study, our conclusion is that using allografts for reconstruction of torn cruciate ligaments in the knee is a good method in the right indication. We find it suitable for the group of elderly patients and revision surgery. A larger study is recommended.


O. Schwartz J. Aunalla M. Levitin D.G. Mendes

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the patterns of wear of patella implants in total knee arthroplasty.

Material and methods: The pattern of polyethylene wear of 17 patella components, 5 kinematic and 12 total condylar, retrieved after an average of 80 month in situ, was studied. The primary diagnosis was osteoarthritis in all cases. The implants were retrieved from 6 men and 11 women with an average age of 64 years at the time of arthroplasty. Their average height was 168 cm and average weight was 68.5 kg.

In all cases, revision was performed for mechanical loosening of one or several components. Using light microscopy, the articulating surface of each patella component was analyzed for six modes of damage: polishing, delaminating, surface deformation due to cold flow, scratching, pitting and abrasion.

To describe the damage, the surface of the patella component was divided into four sections. The contact stresses between the patellar and femoral components were calculated in relation to the areas of wear. Volumetric wear could not be accurately established.

Results: The “Papion” pattern indicated higher rate of wear at the periphery of the patellar implants.

Four modes of damage were observed: polishing in 13, delimitation in 12, cold flow in 6 and scratching in 3. The median total area of polyethylene damage was for polishing 76.5%, delimitation 70.6%, cold flow 35.3% and scratching 17.6%. The average contact stress on the nonconforming Total Condylar patella component was 12.9 Kgf/mm2. It was significantly higher (p< 0.002) than the average contact stress on the conforming Kinematic patellar component – 2.9 Kgf/mm2. The area of wear was smaller, 357.2 mm2 for the nonconforming Total Condylar, than for the conforming Kinematic patella 439.2 mm2. However, this difference was not statistically significant. The average weight of the patients with the Kinematic knee (74.5 kg) was higher as compared to the patients with Total Condylar knee (66 kg) but the difference was not significant.

Conclusions: The high incidence and pattern of wear of the patella components indicates a basic fault in the design of the patellar implants. In our opinion there is insufficient thickness of the polyethylene in most points of contact, specifically at the periphery. We suggest improving two mechanical properties: adequate thickness of the entire polyethylene implant including the periphery and conforming articulating surfaces of the periphery of the dome.


M. Yanko D. Daby W. Rosenblatt S. Dekel

Osteonecrosis (ON) around the knee joint can be spontaneous (primary), without comorbid medical conditions, or secondary. ON is characterized by sudden pain, usually self resolving after six months to a year, night pain, and involving mainly women older than 55 years of age.

Twenty seven patients with primary ON were retrospectively reviewed. The patients were evaluated clinically (physical examination and H.S.S. scoring) and radiographically (plain radiographs were done at the beginning and at the end of follow-up and MRI studies). The MRI study included calculations of the area and the volume of the lesion, osteoarthritic changes, bone collapse and meniscal pathologic findings.

The majority of the patients, 96% (26/27), complained of sudden pain. Night pain was observed in 46% of the patients. Osteoarthritic changes observed in 60% of the patients and further deterioration (37%) was noted at follow up radiographs. Osteoarthritic changes were more predominant in patients with tibial condyle involvement rather than those with femoral involvement, 61% vs. 43% (p=0.04), respectively. Diagnosis of osteonecrosis by the initial radiographs was more common in patients with femoral involvement (7 femurs vs. 1 tibia).

All ON lesions were diagnosed by MRI, from these, 17 meniscal tears (63%) were detected.

Several observations were noted in the volumetric analysis: Tibial lesions were larger than femoral lesions (8.1cm3 vs. 3.1cm3, respectively, p=0.026). Women had significantly larger lesions in volume and area than men (area – 5.09cm2 vs 2.05cm2, p=0.01; and volume – 6.6cm3 vs. 1.2cm3, p=0.001). Significant correlation was found between bone collapse and the need for total knee replacement (TKR): 40% collapse in the TKR patients versus 13.6% collapse without TKR (p=0.028). Patients that were diagnosed with collapse at the end of the follow up had a larger area (5.8cm2 vs 3.7cm2) and a lower HSS score (68.5 points vs. 83 points, p=0.02) than those without. A significant correlation was noted between a larger lesion area and lower HSS scoring (p=0.037) at the end of the follow-up. Patients with tibial lesions had more meniscal pathologies involvement, 56.3% vs. 43.8%, however it was not statistically significant (p=0.68).

We conclude that MRI study for patients with ON and calculating the area and the volumetric data particularly, is an accurate predictive tool for the natural history of knee ON. The findings presented here may guide us in determining the best possible treatment.


N. Rosenberg H. Koufman H. Stein

Topical treatment of infected wounds has a crucial role as an adjuvant to surgical debridement. Solutions currently used for local would treatment have either low antiseptic properties with low irritating effect, such as physiologically balanced solutions acting mostly by a mechanical irrigating effect, or antiseptic solutions which cause chemical irritation of the surrounding tissues. The use of topical substance with effective antiseptic properties, which is also not irritating to surrounding healthy tissues, should improve significantly the effectiveness of infected wound treatment.

Previous reports on the use of Hexamethylenebiguanide solution for local antiseptic treatment in infected wounds indicated on a good curative effect without any local or systemic side effects. Unfortunately none of these reports is based on well designed statistical data which is essential for the safe and skilled use of any pharmaceutical agent.

We present the results of controlled prospective double-blind study comparing the topical use of 0.1% Hexamethylenbiguanide solution with non lactated Ringer solution as agents for a topical treatment of infected wounds in extremities. The group of 104 patients with ischemic, combat, post surgical or due to open fracture wounds treated by either of these solutions following surgical debridement without additional systemic antibiotic use. According to the strict follow-up protocol, wounds’ healing was evaluated on a weekly basis. In the group of patients treated by the 0.1% Hexamethylenbiguanide solution, 75% rate of a complete wound healing was observed. In the control group the rate of healing was 52% [p=0.026, Chi square test, Figure 1]. These results indicate the high effectiveness of the Hexamethylenbiguanide as a topical agent for infected wound treatment.


Y. Litwin

A new fixating device was developed for fixation of the anterior cruciate ligament using hamstrings and allowing immediate full weight bearing and full range of movements as pain subsides. The surgical technique is simple, similar to the one described by L. Johnson: a femoral tunnel of 25 mm depth without exit on the lateral wall of the femur. The tibial tunnel is drilled in the usual manner. In order to achieve a straight line drill of the tibia and the femur an aimer is used. The hamstrings are harvested in the usual manner and used as free graft.

The new anchor is composed of 2 parts: a self tapping screw and an oval eyelet.

The harvested hamstrings are passed through the eyelet and doubled. The assembled system is passed through the tibia directly into the femur and screwed in place. For distal fixation 2 square staples are used.

The patients are discharged on the same operative day, and followed.

On follow up the clinical exam included assessment of range of movements, stability (Lachman, Pivot shift). The results of a subjective rating of patients’ satisfaction was also taken into consideration.

The anchor was used in 50 cases: 46 males and 4 females. In 4 cases semitendinosus alone was used as graft. Full range of movements and weight bearing were allowed as pain subsided. Short term follow-up (3 years) showed excellent results. No complication of any type (infection, loosening or vascular) were encountered. 48 of the 50 cases returned to their previous activity without any limitation. However, in 2 cases meniscal tears occurred:

1 medial meniscus and 1 lateral meniscus and were considered as failures because the stability achieved was insufficient for their activity. It has to be pointed out that none of our patients were professional athletes.


E. Adar R. Levi H. Oz B. Bender S. Shabat G. Mann

The importance of meniscal tears repair is discussed widely in the literature. The repair should be performed if the conditions promise some chance for healing. Due to technical difficulties many orthopaedic surgeons still prefer partial meniscectomy to meniscal repair.

We describe our techniques for meniscal repair. The described techniques could be used by any surgeon with basic skills in arthroscopic surgery. No special equipment is needed.

The basic equipment for this technique is a standard 18 gouge needle. The plastic cup of the needle is cut away in order to overcome the ridge between the plastic and the metal part of the needle, thus making the suture passage easier.

Following the arthroscopic identification of the meniscal tear and preparing the torn parts for repair, the place for the first suture is identified.

A 2–3 mm long skin incision is made. The subcutaneous tissue is bluntly developed to the capsule. The 18 gouge needle is past from outside-in in the desired point through the torn margins of the meniscus. The tip of the needle is emerged above or under the meniscal surface, depends on our decision of suture position.

1st step – Producing a loop outside the joint: Two ends of a nylon 2/0 suture are inserted through the needle into the joint cavity, and pulled out through one of the arthroscopic portals. The needle is removed. The result of this step is a nylon 2/0 suture passing through the torn parts of the meniscus with a loop outside the joint.

2nd step – Producing a double-loop inside the joint cavity: A second nylon 2/0 suture is passed through the first loop. The first suture is pulled into the joint. At this stage, both loops are inside the joint, holding each other. The free ends of the first loop are emerged through one of the arthroscopic portals, while the free ends of the second loop pass through the torn parts of the meniscus and emerge through the capsule.

3rd step – Producing the meniscal suture: A second 19 gouge needle is inserted close to the point of insertion of the first one, directed into the joint. The emerging point of this needle, on the meniscus, should be positioned according to the desired suture direction (transverse, vertical, or oblique). The tip of the needle is then directed into the “2nd” nylon loop (the “1st” nylon loop can assist at this stage). The loop is wrapped over the needle, and the 1st suture is removed.

PDS suture (1/0 or 2/0) is inserted through the needle until a 5 cm free end is positioned intra articular. The needle is removed with caution without pulling the PDS suture, leaving the

PDS free end inside the nylon loop. The nylon loop is used as a pooling tool for the PDS suture. Pulling the free end of the PDS suture out of the joint results in a PDS loop for the meniscal suture (in order to avoid iatrogenic tear of the meniscal tissue while pulling the sutures, a probe should be positioned under the PDS suture during the process). The PDS is tightened over the capsule. The technique is repeated as much as necessary for perfect repair of the meniscus.

The advantage of this method is that it does not necessitates unique equipment, but rather uses the ordinary arthroscopic tools and sutures. This method was used successfully upon large number of meniscal tears. We recommend its use routinely.


D. Ben-David R. Mosheiff S. Beyth O. Suraki M. Liebergall

Introduction: Fluoroscopy is routinely used for real-time intra-operative localization of patient anatomy and surgical instrument positioning. Using this radiographic information the orthopedic surgeon inserts different implants into bone. Despite its utility, however, fluoroscopy does have disadvantages. The most notable is potential occupational radiation exposure. Conventional fluoroscopy usually provides only one plane at a time, whereas at least two planes are needed for optimal placement of an implant. By combining a standard C-arm fluoroscopy with computer aided surgical technology, radiation exposure can be eliminated and four different planes can be visualized simultaneously. This study presents data of preliminary clinical experience using this new technology.

Material and methods: The Stealth Station Treatment Guidance Platform System by Medtronic was used. The calibration target was attached to a C-arm fluoroscope. The static reference arc which was attached to the patient and various surgical tools. All with affixed light emitting diodes (LEDs) which were seen by the Infra Red camera. After a short registration process in which the relevant anatomy images were acquired, the C-arm was withdrawn and the entry point to the operated anatomy was determined using the navigation capabilities of the system.

During a period of six months, 31 patients underwent different surgical procedures in which a guided wire was used for: percutaneous fixation of unstable pelvis and hip fractures (13 patients), inserting and locking of an intrameduallry nail (12 patients), inserting pedicular screws (2 patients), or removing foreign-bodies or internal fixations (4 patients). In all cases the placement of the hardware was approved by conventional fluoroscopy as well.

Results: Excellent correlation between the virtual fluoroscopic imaging and live fluoroscopy was observed, thus the placement of the wire in all cases was satisfactory and there was no need to change the position of the wire following the live fluoroscopic confirmation. The number of fluoroscopic buttoning was smaller than the average number in similar surgery using conventional fluoroscopy.

Discussion: According to our preliminary clinical experience it seems that virtual fluoroscopy offers several advantages over conventional fluoroscopy while providing acceptable targeting accuracy. Our impression is that its saves fluoroscopic radiation exposure and improves exactness of the procedure. However, since currently only one reference arc can be detected at a time by the guidance system it can be used only in a stable anatomical situations (such as non-displaced fractures or pedicular screw placements). The use of better-oriented surgical instrumentation and more than one reference point detection will significantly improve the clinical potential of this method.


O. Schwartz O. Arnon D.G. Mendes H. Solomon A. Liberson

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to clinically evaluate the efficiency of extracorporal shockwave therapy for enthesopathies.

Materials, Methods and Results: 26 patients with mean age of 51 (range: 18–73) which suffered from enthesopathies in different regions were included in this study. Prior to treatment pain and function were assessed subjectively by using a visual analog scale ranging from 1 (maximum pain/minimum function) to 10 (no pain, full function).

The follow-up period was 6–18 months with an average follow-up period of 13 months.

All patients were treated with ESWT. One to three treatment sessions were provided to each patient with an interval of one week between the sessions. After all sessions were finished, pain and function were reassessed in the same method that was used before the beginning of the treatment.

The overall mean pain value was 1.96 before the treatment and 5.92 after the treatment.

8 patients (30.7%) reported no pain at all after the treatment and in 6 patients (23%) a significant improvement in pain was achieved. 7 patients (19%) reported of only slight relief of pain and 4 patients (15.4%) reported no change in pain level. Only in one patient (3.9%) worsening of the pain was observed.

The overall mean function capacity was 5.76 before the treatment and 8.65 after the treatment. 11 patients (42%) returned to full functional capacity and in 7 patients (27%) a significant improvement in functional capacity was observed. In 8 patients (30.7%) no change in the functional capacity was noticed.

Good results of improvement in pain severity and functional capacity were observed in cases of plantar fasciitis and tennis elbow.

Conclusion: We think the EWST is helpful for treatment of enthesopathies, especially plantar fasciitis and tennis elbow, and suggest to include it in treatment algorithms.


Y. Gelfer A. Peer N. Halperin D. Robinson

Study design: In order to evaluate a new CECT (Continuous Enhanced Circulation Therapy) based on protocol for DVT prevention a prospective, randomize, single-blind study was designed to compare the effect of the new protocol to the current standard of care in DCT prophylaxis (LMWH).

Objectives: To evaluate and compare the incidence and severity of DVT between the two groups.

Background: Total hip and knee replacements are operations particularly prone to thromboembolic complications. Recommendations regarding prophylaxis have changed over the years. A treatment protocol was proposed, based upon the CECT system as the primary DVT prophylaxis method with the addition of low dose aspirin. This protocol is using two very safe treatment modalities with very low risk for adverse effects. The CECT system applies continuous mechanical enhancement of venous blood flow through a miniature, mobile, battery operated system.

Methods: 39 patients, who underwent total hip or knee replacement, were prospectively randomized into two groups. In the study group the patients received CECT system starting immediately after the induction of anesthesia and covering the operation and the first 5 postoperative days, within 12 hours after surgery aspirin 100 mg per day was added. In the control group the patients received Enoxaparin 40 mg per day for 5 postoperative days. A venography was performed at the 5th to 8th post-operative day and the DVT prevalence was compared.

Results: In the study group 3 patients out of 21 (14.3%) were found to have DVT (1 of them proximal), compared to 8 patients out of 18 (44.4%) in the control group (5 of them proximal). The differences between the two groups are statistically significant for both total and proximal DVT rates (p=0.037).

In the study group only 1 patient needed prolonged high dose anticoagulant treatment while 6 patients in the enoxaparin group were treated (p=0.020).

The cumulative incidence of adverse events in the study group was significantly lower than that observed in the control group (p=0.000). Average postoperative hospital stay was 8.4 days in the study group and 11.7 days in the control group (p=0.002).

The CECT device was very well tolerated by the patients and facilitated early mobilization.

Conclusions: The protocol combining CECT and Aspirin was found to be both safe the effective. Comparison to the standard prophylaxis with enoxaparin revealed significant advantage of the proposed protocol with: better DVT prevention, less adverse events and shorter hospital stay. Further research is needed in order to establish the place of this prophylaxis protocol as the treatment of choice in orthopaedic patients.


S.C. Gillson H. Shtarker J. Stolero G. Volpin

Introduction: During the last decade the Ilizarov method of limb lengthening has provided a solution for many patients with short stature, suffering not just from cosmetic problems, but having functional disability as well. The aim of this presentation is to discuss our experience of physiotherapy at all stages of treatment, from pre-operative evaluation to the final adaptation of the patient to his new limb condition and the problems that evolved and our solution to them.

Patients and Methods: Over the past six years, five patients underwent limb lengthening. Two had achrondoplasia, one had proximal focal femoral dysplasia and two had metaphysical dysplasia. Physiotherapy was given to prevent pulmonary complications, maintain joint mobility and muscle strength, stretch the soft tissue, encourage weight bearing and improve gait. The main complications that occurred were short quadriceps tendon, short Achilles tendon causing equines, excessive anterior pelvic tilt, restriction of the knee joint due to tightness of the iliotibial band and non-compliance of the patient.

Results: After the completion of treatment all patients walked independently and returned at least to their pre-operative functional level. Their posture and self-confidence were improved. Average lengthening of the lower limb was 28 cm.

Discussion: Careful selection of patients, maintenance of maximal range of motion of all joints involved at every stage of the treatment and long term physiotherapy after the removal of the external fixators are essential for success. It may be important to halt the lengthening process if adequate joint motion is not achieved. It can be concluded that despite the fact that this is a lengthy and painful procedure, the end results make it worthwhile.


S. Shabat G. Mann N. Constantini Y. Foldes M. Nyska

Background: Female recruits are known to have a relatively high incidence of stress fractures (SF). This has been apparent also when female recruits entered the Israel Border Police training program.

Aims: To examine the influence of various interventions including shoe modification, nutrition, controlled training program and pre-recruit course on the incidence of SF.

Methods: Between February 1996 and February 1998, five courses of female recruits were held with a total of 229 participants. The four later courses were controlled and strictly documented. These included 203 recruits. The total number of SF was recorded using bone scintigraphy. “Dangerous SFX” was described as those SF including the long bones of the lower limb and the navicular bone. Due to high number of SF the organic medical team introduced various interventions: 1. Shoes were replaced with lither and flexible shoes with soft absorbing soles (course I onward). 2. Nutrition was modified (course II onward). 3. A training scale was programmed and introduced (course III onward). 4. Selecting candidates six months before recruitment and running a three-month preparation course (course IV onward).

Results: 1) 55 recruits (of 203) or 27.1% suffered SF grade I or more (2.9 SF for injured recruit or 0.78 SF for each recruit in the course. 2) 36 recruits (of 203) or 17.7% suffered SF grade II or more (2.1 SF for injured recruit or 0.37 SF for each recruit in the course. 3) The data concerning 229 recruits along the 5 courses was recorded and found that the incidence of number of recruits suffering dangerous SF in all grades, or grade II or higher, and the number of dangerous SF per recruit was reduced gradually from course to course.

Conclusions: The incidence of stress fractures in female recruits during basic training is high, ranging in the series for the various courses from 23% to 35% for all grades and from 8.3% to 19% for “dangerous” SF (basically of the long bones) graded II onward. Various interventions including shoe modification, nutrition, controlled training program and pre-recruit course seems to have a possible combined effect in reducing the incidence and severity of stress fractures, especially those termed “dangerous stress fractures”.


G.J. Velan E. Rath D. Sheinis A. Sasson D. Atar

Low back pain is not a frequent complaint in adolescents and usually is a self-limited affliction without signs or significant findings in pertinent imaging studies. Adolescent athletes are in an increased risk of overuse injuries to the spine due to their relative ligamentous laxity and lack of proper technique in their chosen sport.

This is a prospective study of adolescent athletes referred to the spine clinic due to low back pain and significant findings on physical examination and/or the imaging studies.

Between 01.08.1998 and 31.03.2001 we have treated 7 athletes, 2 girls and 5 boys, average age 15.67 years (range 13–17). Sports involved were golf in 2, body building in 1, volleyball in 1, handball in 1, track and field in 1, and ballet in 1. Five were eventually diagnosed with L5 pars defects (2 unilateral and 3 with bilateral lesions); L2 spondylolysis was diagnosed in 1 and L5-S1 central disc protrusion in 1. All complained of pain located to the lower back, the patient with disc protrusion complained of pain radiating to her lower extremities. Plain films were diagnostic in 1 patient only with a unilateral L5 pars defect. Technetium bone scan showed increased uptake at the level of the lesion in all 6 patients with spondylolysis and was normal in the patient with L5-S1 disc protrusion. CT scans were performed in 4 patients and were diagnostic 2, MRI was performed in 2 patients and was diagnostic in both.

The six patients with spondylolysis were treated by analgesics, rest for 3 months and then gradual supervised return to sports with modification of the swing in both golfers, decrease of training volume in the body builder and limiting the track and field athlete to running only. Both volleyball and handball players withdrew from athletic activities. The volleyball player with L5-S1 herniation refused surgical treatment.

The evaluation of adolescent athletes with low back pain longer than few weeks, should be by bone scan first and CT and/or MRI later. MRI should be preferred to limit radiation exposure. After proper rest and supervised training they can safely resume their athletic interests.


B. Kish S. Shabat S. Masrawa A. Stern M. Nyska

Background: Osteoarthritis (OA) may affect large and small joints and is common final pathway of large array of conditions. OA of the large joints includes mainly hip, knee, shoulder and ankle. The treatment of OA of the ankle is limited and the surgical treatment is usually salvage procedure as fusion. Therefore there is a need for an efficient conservative treatment of the ankle OA.

Aims: The objective of this clinical trial was to evaluate the symptomatic efficacy of intraarticular preparation containing Sodium Hyaluronate, in the treatment of OA of the ankle.

Methods: The study was conducted on patients who visited our out-patients clinic under the direct supervision of the principle investigator. The male or female patient aged between 30 and 80 suffering from osteoarthritis of the ankle joint of radiographic severity II or III or IV according to Kellgren and Lawrance, suffering from one or more of the following conditions of the ankle joint: swelling, tenderness or pressure, and/or pain on motion or at rest, who have clinical history of ankle pain for over 6 months.

Intraarticular injections of 25 mg Sodium-hyaluronate in 5 following weeks were administrated to 16 patients, 31–79 years old (average 43 years) suffering from pain in the ankle, 9 months to 27 years. 12 patients after operation, 4 with no trauma history.

Follow-up visits were performed 1,2,3,4,7 months post treatment and included clinical evaluation and score scale.

Results: Global assessment showed in 13 out of 16 patients improvement in the motion range (20%) and significantly reduction of the OA symptoms according to the score: 2–3 points improvement on each scale and according to the osteoarthritis ankle hindfoot score scale (100 points total): up to 20 points improvement. Seven months after the treatment, no decrease in the treatment efficacy has been shown.

Global assessment of 2 patients did not show any significant improvement after the treatment. One patient dropped off the study due to other operation.

Conclusions: Symptomatic relief of OA of the ankle can be achieved by admission of intraarticular preparation containing Sodium Hyaluronate.


E. Peled J. Mizrahi E. Isakov O. Verbitsky C. Zinman

Introduction: The regulation of balance during upright standing involves continuous muscular activity, associated with body sway. In single stance standing, the base of support is narrower compared to double stance, resulting in an increased body sway and emphasizing the role of individual muscles in regulating the sway motion. In this study, we investigated the effect of Tibialis Anterior (TA) fatigue on body sway during standing on one leg on ten able-bodied subjects.

Methods: Foot ground reaction forces, goniometry of the ankle joint, and EMG of the TA were all measured simultaneously in two tests. Each test lasted 30 sec. During which the subjects were required to stand as still as possible with their dominant leg on a forceplate and the contralateral knee flexed upward at 90 deg approximately, and their hands resting on their waists. The tests were separated by a 4 min isotonic fatiguing effort of the TA, indicated by a significant decrease of the mean power frequency (MPF).

Results: The EGM root mean square (RMS) started off at 45% MVC but, towards the end of the effort, significantly increased to 52% MVC, the latter determined in non-fatigue condition. Compared to the non-fatigue state, the following significant (p< 0.05) sway changes took place in the fatigue state: force RMS increased from 2.61 to 3.90 N and from 3.77 to 5.01 N in the mediolateral (ML) and vertical directions, respectively. The center of pressure (CoP)

RMS in the ML direction increased from 0.57 to 0.68 cm. The EMG RMS in the TA increased from 4.15 to 5.58 and the MPF decreased from 107.6 to 96.7 Hz in the fatigued state.

Discussion: An interesting finding was revealed by comparing the variations of the ankle angle to those of the center of pressure in the anterior-posterior direction taking place during standing. During the non-fatigue test the CoP moved gradually posteriorly, while the goniometer indicated an ankle change towards dorsiflexion. These obviously two opposing trends necessitate compensatory angular adjustments at the knee and/or hip joints. However, during the fatigue test, the posterior excursion of the CoP was accompanied by a consistent change in the ankle, towards plantar flexion. This seems to suggest that in the fatigue state the redundancy of the musculoskeletal system is reduced, increasing the degree of correction between ankle angle and CoP.


S. Shabat J.W. Brodsky M. Nyska

Background: Seven cases of osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) of the tarsal navicular bone have been described mainly radiologically.

Aims: We report our experience with additional 6 patients which represent the largest series described, and conclude about the treatment modalities in this unique type of OCD.

Methods: All patients who had OCD of the tarsal navicular bone during the years 1993 and 1998 were evaluated. The parameters which were examined were the age and sex of the patients, the location of pain, duration of symptoms, and any trigger mechanism if this was noted. The various treatments used for these patients as well as their outcome were recorded.

Results: Six patients were treated by us between 1993 and 1998 (follow up 3–7 years). There were 4 males and 2 females aged between 14 and 35 years (mean 21 years). All patients had pain in the dorsal aspect of the midfoot, and painful limitation in midfoot movements. Duration of symptoms varied between 4 months and 1 year. In 3 patients basic training in army service and in one running short distances triggered the pain. In 3 patients an accompanying stress fracture of the navicular bone was developed. Three patients were managed conservatively. Two patients underwent excision, curettage and drilling, and one patient underwent excision and fusion. All patients, whether treated conservatively or surgically, still suffer form pain in activities and painful limitation of midfoot motion.

Conclusions: OCD of tarsal navicular bone affects mainly young patients. Physical efforts are the trigger mechanism for the symptoms. The clinical presentation includes painful limitation in midfoot motion. The outcome is reserved both for conservative or operative treatment.


S. Eylon R.A. Bloom A. Peyser Y. Barzilay M. Liebergall

Background: The Achilles tendon is the strongest and thickest tendon in the human body, it is very commonly injured with significant clinical implications. The treatment of Achilles tendon rupture is a matter of controversy in orthopedics and sports medicine. Surgical repair compared with conservative treatment is debated constantly in the literature, without a conclusive decision. The diagnosis of Achilles tendon rupture is based usually on clinical examination, and may be reinforced by ultrasound or magnetic resonance imaging. The present study has been conducted in order to determine whether an ultrasound examination performed at the time of injury could be useful in deciding how to treat the patient.

Patients: Over a period of 5 years we treated 26 patients who had a clinical presentation of ruptured Achilles tendon with ultrasound diagnosis of either a partial tear or a full tear. Patients who were diagnosed by ultrasound as having a full tendon tear were operated on, and were not included in this study. Eight patients had partial tear of the tendon, six had a tear of the musculotendinous region, and twelve had a proximal tear. All patients were treated by means of a cast or a dressing, with limitation of weight bearing. The follow-up period ranged between six months to three years after the injury, and included up-to-date functional evaluation.

Results: Eighteen patients were available for evaluation. Excellent functional results were reported by five patients, twelve patients reported good results, and one patient complained of a bad result. None of our patients needed delayed surgery, and only one suffered from re-rupture of the tendon during his rehabilitation, and was treated conservatively with good results. No correlation was found between the location of the tear and the functional results.

Conclusions: 1. Ultrasound is an important and accurate tool in the diagnosis of Achilles tendon tear and is helpful in choosing the appropriate treatment. 2. Partial tear of Achilles tendon is not an indication for operative treatment, even when the clinical examination (Thompson test) is positive. The outcome of conservative treatment in this situation is as good or even better than surgical treatment.


E. Glaser C. Lidor

Purpose: To describe sonographic evaluation of Morton’s neuroma and to demonstrate the advantage of the ultrasound technique.

Material and methods: Between the years 1999–2001, eight patients were operated upon because of Morton’s neuroma in the 3rd interspace, using dorsal approach at the Basel Height Medical Center. Five patients were female and three were male, mean age 35 years (range, 17–51 years). All the patients suffered from metatarsalgia at the 3rd web while walking with shoes. No pain was noted when they walked barefoot. All the patients underwent sonographic evaluation by using high frequency transducers of 10 and 12 MHz. Plantar and dorsal scanning was performed with and without digital pressure of the metatarsal space.

Results: In all the operated cases ultrasound examination prior to surgery revealed an ovoid, well defined hypoecogenic mass of a mean diameter of 8 mm (range 7–15 mm), located in the third interdigital space, proximal to the metatarsal heads. Plantar scanning and dorsal digital pressure, by the examiner, disclosed the best sonographic images. All cases were confirmed by histological examination. No surgical complications were noted.

Conclusion: We present the sonographic appearance of Morton’s neuroma in eight cases that underwent surgical excision of the neuromas. We describe manual maneuvers in order to bring up the best images of the mass.


D. Plotquin A. Bunin R. Vago

Osteochondral lesions are frequent as a result of sport and daily activities.

The healing processes of these defects are prolonged and complicated and often leading to irreversible ostheo-arthritic changes. In this study, biotechanical and bioChemical approaches are being combined in an attempt to identify potential uses of biofabricated marine carbonate materials in biomedical applications, particularly as for remodeling cartilage and bone tissue. Biofabricated material was grafted into osteochondral induced defects in animals’ models during knee arthrotomy. Using histological sections, SEM, EDS studies it was revealed that the biofabricated, porous material is highly biocompatible. The graft was incorporated into the osteochondral defect area and followed by surface remodeling. After 4 months the interface and subchondral areas were been replaced by new cartilage and bone.

We believe that it is the first time that such biofabricated materials have been used for biomedical purposes. In face of the obvious environmental disadvantages of harvesting from limited natural resources, we propose the use of bio-engineered coralline and other materials such as those cultured by our group under field and laboratory conditions as a possible biomatrix for hard tissue remodeling.


S. Shabat H. Mahhamid S. Lev T. Hallel M. Nyska

Background: Osteoarthritis (OA) is a common phenomena in the population. About 80% of the patients more than 55 years of age have reontgenographic signs of OA, while 25% have clinical signs. Eventually OA leads to joint destruction, which may necessitate joint replacement.

Aims: Our goal was to evaluate the synovial reaction in 10 patients who suffered from arthritis and thus underwent total knee replacement operation.

Methods: Ten patients with arthritis of the knee joint (8 with OA and 2 with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) who underwent total knee replacement were evaluated.

Age ranged between 66 and 79 years (mean 71 years). A control group consisted of 6 cadaver knees (mean age 31 years) with no previous history of knee problems.

All the patients in the research group were graded functionally for their knee score by the system of Hospital for Special Surgery Functional Score.

Additional plain X-ray score on a three point scale was performed. During surgery macroscopic changes on the articular surface of all three compartments were recorded on a four point scale. Synovial specimens were taken from each compartment for microscopic examination.

Results: In the research group the average knee score was 54. The macroscopic changes were found predominantly in the medial compartment. No correlation was found between microscopic and histological changes in the synovia. However, a statistically significant correlation between radiological changes in the medial and lateral compartments and macroscopic changes was noted. In the OA patients the ratio of T to B cells was 60% in favor of the B cells, in contrast to RA which was 75% in favor of T cells. In the control group the common find-ing was a thickened sub-synovial fat layer in the patello-femoral (PF) compartment.

Conclusions: Inflammatory reaction in the synovia is graded by the lymphocytic infiltration into the synovia. In OA this is usually mild. However, the predominant reaction is fibrosis. There is no correlation between this fibrotic reaction and overt radiological or macroscopic findings. The thick subsynovial fat layer found in the PF compartment in the control group has not been described previously in the literature and should be the focus of further investigations.


D. Robinson M. Guetsky R. Halperin D. Schneider N. Halperin Z. Nevo

Methods of study: Prospective Controlled Animal Study.

Objectives: Evaluation of the feasibility of embryonal epiphyses transplantation in a xenogeneic model for reconstruction of adult articular cartilage in a rabbit model.

Introduction: Articular cartilage reconstruction has been the goal for many years of orthopaedic research. Current acceptable techniques include the use of allografts, autologous chondrocytes transplantation and osteochondral cylinder grafting. Reconstruction of articular cartilage defects using adult osteochondral allografts is an established clinical procedure, whose principal drawback is lack of lateral integration of the grafts to the surrounding tissue. Autologous chondrocytes transplantation is a sophisticated technique requiring cell culture and a staged operation. Its main draw back is the lack of mechanical strength early on and the prolonged rehabilitation period. This study was conducted in order to evaluate the possibility of using embryonal epiphyses as a cartilage reconstruction tissue.

Methods: A xenogeneic human to rabbit sub-acute osteochondral defect model was designed to evaluate the possibility of allogeneic implantation in humans. The following procedures were performed (n=5): transplantation of: 1. live epiphyses, 2. live epiphyses with autogeneic periosteum, 3. devitalized epiphyses, and 4. devitalized epiphyses with autogeneic articular chondrocytes.

A fifth control group did not receive any implant. Animals were followed for 3 months after transplantation and than sacrificed. The histological specimens were evaluated by image analysis after immuno-histochemical stains were performed (including the following antigens – collagen type II, collagen type I, collagen type III, collagen type X, S-100, alkaline phosphatase, osteocalcin, osteopontin, nitric oxide synthase).

Results: Animals in groups 1 and 2 had a viable reconstruction of the articular surface with little evidence of rejection and without pannus formation. Animals in groups 3 and 4 became severely arthrotic and the graft was resorbed. Nitric oxide synthase accumulation was reduced in group 1 and 2 as compared to groups 3, 4, and 5, indicating a joint preserving function of the epiphyseal grafts.

Discussion: Epiphyseal grafts appear to be a feasible procedure for reconstruction of articular cartilage defects even in a xenogeneic model. The restoration of articular cartilage even with a xenogeneic graft appears to prevent nitric oxide synthesis and the resulting destruction of unafflicted articular cartilage. This is a major pathway leading to secondary osteoarthritis after joint injury. Blocking this pathway might prevent degenerative changes.


N. Blumberg E. Steinberg M. Tauber S. Dekel

The incidence of comminuted proximal femur fractures is increasing, due to the growing proportion of elderly people in the general population. Severely depleted cancellous bone in the femoral head and neck prevent stable proximal purchase, mandatory for intertrochanteric and subtrochanteric fractures. Osteoporotic bones are associated with high implant failure rates, evidenced by cutout and upward screw penetration of the hip joint.

A new method for femoral head fixation is described. The peg consists of a distal end that can expand in diameter from 7.8mm to 10.5mm by using pressurized saline, allowing good abutment into the femoral head. The peg may be connected to a side plate or an intramedullary device for inter or subtrochanteric fractures.

Materials and Methods: Ten femoral heads were retrieved from patients who underwent hip hemiarthroplasty due to subcapital fracture. The heads were covered with a transparent epoxy resin until full solidification was obtained. An 8mm drill-hole was used to drill from the distal femoral neck along the femoral head axis, not penetrating the subchondral bone and cartilage. Afterwards, 1.4mm drill was used to penetrate the cartilage and subchondral bone of the femoral head for insertion of a pressure gage. Intraosseous pressure measurements were then recorded. The peri-prosthetic bone density was evaluated by Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DEXA) and Microradiography Computer Analysis in two stages: 1) with the peg unexpanded, and 2) with the peg expanded. In addition, Instron 8871 tested axial load, pullout and rotatory strengths of the peg.

Results: Increased periprosthetic bone density following peg expansion was demonstrated on DEXA and microradiography with no increase in the intraosseous pressure. The friction coefficient of the bone implant interface, calculated by axial load measurements, was less than the coefficient of steel to steel. Pullout and rotatory strengths were as good as those reported for the Dynamic Hip Screw (DHS).

Conclusions: Bone stock preservation due to compression of the depleted cancellous bone (rather than removed bone by drilling) may improve the mechanical properties of the periprosthetic bone and the stability of the fixation. Due to the strong abutment of the peg, hardware failure, mainly bone cutout can be reduced. Due to its lower friction coefficient, the hip peg will begin to slide following axial load through the plate or the intramedullary device, rather than penetrating the femoral head.

Preliminary positive results indicate that this new method may be suitable for inter or subtrochanteric femoral fracture fixation.


O. Safran I. Ilsar I. Leichter V. Neeman M. Liebergall

Introduction: Bone strength is determined by several factors including bone mineral density and the geometrical structure of bone tissue. Plain X-ray is not used regularly for bone mineral density measurements due to different x-ray exposure used for each patient. The different radiation energies have major effects on the optical density of the obtained films. Therefore dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) is the golden standard for bone density estimation. However it is relatively expensive and relatively inaccessible.

Objective: To evaluate a new computerized analysis of digitized plain radiographs of the proximal femur to allow the evaluation of bone mineral density in human subjects.

Material and Methods: 14 people hospitalized for proximal femoral fracture had their uninvolved proximal femur BMD estimated with a DEXA in the 5 typical regions defined by the DEXA test. Plain proximal femur radiographs of these patients were taken with a standard wedge and digitized into the computer to generate a digital image. The gray levels in the digital image were analyzed and normalized to yield the mineral content at the 5 regions defined by DEXA. The data obtained were correlated with the DEXA results.

Results: The correlation between BMD (DEXA) and gray level measurement of the proximal femur (R=0.261) was not significant. This correlation was significantly improved after modification of the gray levels to 0.549 (P< 0.032).

Conclusion: This computerized analysis and modification of gray levels in digitized radiographs improved significantly the possibility to evaluate bone mineral density of the proximal femur from plain X-rays.


G. Turgeman M. Liebergall Y. Zilberman G. Pelled H. Aslan A. Peyser Z. Gazit A. Domb D. Gazit

Mesenchymal Stem Cells (MSCs) are key regulators in senile osteoporosis and in bone formation and regeneration. MSCs are therefore suitable candidates for stem cells mediated gene therapy of bone. Recombinant human Bone Morphogenetic Protein-2 (rhBMP-2) is a highly osteoinductive cytokine, promoting osteogenic differentiation of MSCs.

We hypothesized that genetically engineered MSCs, expressing rhBMP2, can be utilized for targeted cell mediated gene therapy for local and systemic bone disorders and for bone/cartilage tissue engineering. Engineered MSCs expressing rhBMP-2 have both autocrine and paracrine effects enabling the engineered cells to actively participate in bone formation.

We conditionally expressed rhBMP2 (tet-controlled gene expression, tet-off system) in mouse and human mesenchymal stem cells. RhBMP2 expressing clones (tet-off and adeno-BMP2 infected MSCs), spontaneously differentiated into osteogenic cells in vitro and in vivo.

Engineered MSCs were transplanted locally and tracked in vivo in radial segmental defects (regenerating site) and in ectopic muscular and subcutaneous sites (non-regenerating sites). In vitro and in vivo analysis revealed rhBMP2 expression and function, confirmed by RT-PCR, ELISA, western blot, immunohistochemistry and bioassays. Secretion of rhBMP2 in vitro was controlled by tetracycline and resulted in secretion of 1231 ng/24 hours/106 cells.

Quantitative Micro-CT 3-Dimentional reconstruction revealed complete bone regeneration regulated by tetracycline in vivo, indicating the potential of this platform for bone and cartilage tissue engineering. Angiogenesis, a crucial element in tissue engineering, was increased by 10-folds in transplants of rhBMP2 expressing MSCs (tet-off), shown by histomorphometry and MRI analysis (p< 0.05). In order to establish a gene therapy platform for systemic bone disorders, MSCs with tet-controlled rhBMP-2 expression, were injected systemically (iv).

These engineered MSCs were genetically modified in order to achieve homing to the bone marrow. Systemic non invasive tracking of engineered MSCs was achieved by recording topographical bioluminescence derived from luciferase expression detected by a coupled charged CCD imaging camera. For clinical situations that require immuno-isolation of transplanted cells, we developed an additional platform utilizing cell encapsulation technique. Immuno-isolated engineered MSCs, with tet-controlled rhBMP-2 expression, encapsulated with sodium alginate induced bone formation by paracrine effect of secreted rhBMP-2. Finally, we have characterized a novel tissue-engineering platform composed of engineered MSCs and biodegradable polymeric scaffolds, creating a 3D bone tissue in rotating Bioreactors. Our results indicate that engineered MSCs and polymeric scaffolds can be utilized for ex vivo bone tissue engineering. We therefore conclude that genetically engineered MSCs expressing rhBMP-2 under tetracycline control are applicable for: a) local and systemic gene therapy to bone, and b) bone tissue engineering. Our studies should lead to the creation of gene therapy platforms for systemic and local bone diseases in humans and bone/cartilage tissue engineering.


S. Tsurel S. Pradhan J. Berilla J.F. Welter

Osteoblastic cells response to mechanical forces by activating signal transduction cascades and altering gene expression patterns. We examined the responses of MC3T3E1 mouse osteoblasts to short term, low level (1000 microstrain, 1Hz) loads applied by cyclic deformation of the growth surface. At these load levels, daily short-term loading significantly retards the ascorbate induced differentiation of the cells as measured by alkaline phosphatase and osteopontin expression. This effect peaked at 5 minutes of loading per day; loads of 1 or more hours per day accelerated the differentiation process slightly as measured by the same criteria. C-fos is known to respond to mechanical loading of bones in vivo, we therefore examined the effect of brief loading bouts on c-fos promoter activity.

Stable lines of MC3T3E1 cells carrying the fos promoter driving a luciferase reporter gene were loaded for 0, 5 or 60 minutes. For these experiments cells were grown in MEM without ascorbate and were then either supplemented or not with 37.5mM ascorbate-2-phosphate at confluence. In cells which had not been pre-treated with ascorbate the c-fos promoter was essentially unresponsive to loads. Following 24 hours of ascorbate treatment (placing these cells at the earliest stages differentiation) a 5 minute loading bout resulted in a marked (~ 50%) decrease in luciferase activity with a trough at 6–8 hours. Loading for 60 minutes caused a similar, but accelerated inhibition of luciferase activity with a trough at 2–4 hours after loading. 24 hours after loading, fos promoter activity had returned to baseline in cells loaded for 60 minutes but remained depressed at 75% of baseline in cells loaded for 5 minutes.

Ets family transcription factors have been implicated in gene regulation in response to mechanical stimulation in several systems. The c-fos promoter contains a Serum Response Element which contains both a CarG motif responsible for binding the Serum Response Factor and an ets core motif CAGGT which can bind ets factors. We therefore repeated these experiments using a mutant c-fos promoter in which the ets binding site is destroyed. The response of this mutant to loading for 60 minutes was indistinguishable from that of the wt-promoter. However, in contrast to the wt-promoter, the ets-mutated promoter responded to a 5 minute loading with a rapid increase in activity (~150%) which peaked at 10 hours before returning to baseline at 24 hours.

These results suggest that although similar in magnitude, the inhibition of the c-fos promoter by 5 and 60 minute loading bouts are regulated by different mechanisms, and implicate the ets family of transcription factors in the response to the briefer loading events.


M. Salai I. Dudkiewicz E. Segal I. Cohen A. Chechik N. Savyon N. Farazone S. Strasburg P. Longevitz A. Livneh

Background: Heterotopic ossification is a common feature that follows total hip arthroplasty, and affects up to 70% of patients with clinical implications, such as pain and restricted hip movements. Previous clinical observation showed negligible heterotopic ossification in our patients who underwent total hip arthroplasty due to familial Mediterranean fever, and received colchicines on a daily basis.

Aims: To evaluate in vitro, in vivo and during clinical studies whether colchicines, given on a prophylactic daily basis to all total hip arthroplasty patients, was responsible for the negligible heterotopic ossification.

Methods: In vitro: cell lines of fibroblasts and osteoblasts were cultured with increasing concentrations of colchicines. Direct cell counts [3H]thymidine uptake, and mineralization were measure. In vivo: heterotopic ossification was induced in the thigh muscle of rabbits by injecting bone marrow. Animals were given colchicines, and X-ray radiographs, ultrasound the histological studies measured its effect on heterotopic ossification. Clinical study: Fifty-two patients admitted for total hip arthroplasty were randomly selected to receive colchicines on a daily basis, starting 10 days pre-operatively, and 6 weeks postoperatively. Clinical evaluation was made according to Harris Hip Score and heterotopic ossification according to Brooker classification.

Results: In vitro: colchicines was found to be a strong, nonselective inhibitor of cell proliferation, and an even greater inhibitor of tissue mineralization. In vivo: statistically significant reduction in the amount of hetero-topic ossification induced in the thigh muscle of rabbits was measured in the groups that received colchicines. Clinical study: Patients who received colchicines pre-operatively developed a negligible amount of hetero-topic ossification after total hip arthroplasty at 1-year follow-up without adversely affecting the Harris Hip Score.

Conclusions: Colchicine is a strong inhibitor of cell proliferation and tissue mineralization, and an effective means of reducing heterotopic ossification after total hip arthroplasty. These effects may be used in other bone-forming processes: after hip/pelvic trauma, head injury, and possibly in other bone-forming conditions.


R. Mosheiff A. Friedman M. Friedman M. Goldvirt M. Liebergall

Severe bone loss in weight bearing bones is one of the main causes for morbidity in trauma victims. The use of guided bone regeneration in the treatment of such large defects has not yet been studied extensively. The aim of this study was to establish an accurate evaluation system, which will enable quantifying the compatibility of membranes to provide bone regeneration in a large middiaphyseal bone defect. In our longitudinal study on 16 rabbits we examined the new bone formation obtained in the vicinity of critical segmental defects (2.5 times the diameter of the bone) covered with tubular ethyl cellulose membranes. The contralateral limbs with the same bone defect served as the control group which was not treated by membranes. The healing process was followed up for eight weeks.

Bone analysis of the implanted and non-implanted bone defects and adjacent tissues was performed in order to evaluate the total area and the density of the regenerated new bone at the gap area. Computerized X-ray study showed newly formed bone as early as 14 days after membrane implantation within and around the radial defect compared with a typical creation of non-union in the contra-lateral non-implanted defects. The bone formation across the gap progressed until reconstruction of the defect occurred after 6–8 weeks. A slowdown in new bone formation was evident after 6 weeks according to the measurements of area size and density of the formed bone.

A parallel longitudinal histomorphological assessment of the process in the treated and non-treated bone defects was conducted. A characteristic process of osteogenic activity and new bone formation takes place inside the confined space and within the tissues around it. A typical modeling process with lytic changes in the different osteogenic fronts takes place from the second week post-implantation. These histological findings, corresponding with the radiological assessment, were summarized according to a scoring system which was constructed by the authors. The scoring was related to eight different zones which were defined within and around the osteotomy site.

This rabbit model clarifies the mechanism and provides quantification of guided bone regeneration. It can serve as a means to study the accelerated bone formation using different membranes in large segmental weight bearing bone defects.


D. Robinson Y. Gelfer Y. Mirovsky Z. Nevo

Study design: An experimental human study of retrieval material.

Objectives: Assessment and evaluation of the involvement of TNFα and Nitric oxide in sciatic pain.

Summary and background data: It appears that the inflammation produced by the herniated fragment is at least partially related to the sciatic pain. TNFα was found to be expressed by herniated nucleus polposus of rats and exogenous TNFα applied in vivo to rat nerve root produced neuropathologic changes and behavior deficit that mimicked experimental studies with herniated nucleus polposus (HNP) applied to nerve roots. Nitric oxide was shown to be involved in the mechanism that produce mechanical and thermal hyperalgesia in rats. Nitric oxide synthesis can be induced by different cytokines among them TNFα and is mediated by the enzyme Nitric oxide synthase. The current study was performed in order to evaluate the possible mechanism of action of TNFα in human herniated discs and define the relationship between nitric oxide and TNFα production by human discs.

Methods: Six herniated fragments of lumbar discs were compared to a similar number of normal intervertebral discs removed during spinal fusion procedures of the lumbar and thoracic spine for the presence of TNFα and the expression of Nitric oxide synthase.

Results: TNFα was expressed by chondrocytes of the herniated fragments but not by the same cells in normal discs. Similar expression pattern was noted for nitric oxide synthase. Both materials were not expressed in the healthy discs.

Conclusions: TNFα appears to be related to pain mechanism of disc herniation. It’s effect is mediated through Nitric oxide. It is well known that NSAIDs are relatively inefficient in modulating TNF-related pain. This might explain the lack of efficacy of currently used medications.


I. Solar I. Meller Y. Kollender J. Bickels O. Merimsky G. Flusser B. Lifschitz-Mercer A. Eisenthal I. Schwartz J. Issakov

Introduction: Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein that adds TTA GGG nucleotide repeated into the ends of eukaryotic chromosomes to maintain their integrity. Most of the normal somatic cells do not express telomerase while telomerase is expressed in the vast majority of malignant tumor cells. Contradictory and limited data have been reported concerning the telomerase expression in soft-tissue sarcomas. The current study evaluates telomerase expression in a single histologic type of a high-grade soft-tissue sarcoma.

Materials and Methods: A non-radioactive in situ hybridization (ISH) method was used to study the expression of the RNA component of human telomerase in 55 paraffin embedded archives tissue samples of patients who were diagnosed with synovial sarcoma, the diagnosis of which was based on morphologic, immunohistochemical, and cytogenetic characteristics. The intensity and distribution of telomerase RNA was scored by two different investigators. Intensity was graded as weak, moderate, or intensive. These parameters were further correlated to the oncologic status of the patient.

Results: The majority of the investigated specimens demonstrated moderate to intensive telomerase RNA intensity with a diffuse distribution throughout the specimen. A positive correlation was found between telomerase intensity and progression of the underlying disease.

Conclusions: Results of the current series suggest that upregulating of telomerase expression may play a role in the pathogenesis and biological activity of synovial sarcoma. This upregulation as detected by ISH assay may be a useful prognostic tool in the evaluation of these patients.


O. Merimsky J. Issakov S. Dadia Y. Kollender I. Schwartz J. Bickels G. Flusser M. Inbar I. Meller

Background: The c-ebB-2 gene and its products (also designated HER-2 and c-neu) encode for a 185-kd transmembrane glycoprotein with intracellular tyrosine kinase activity. C-erbB-2 belongs to the epidermal growth factor receptor family, of which there are four known members, and has molecular homology to the epidermal growth factor receptor. It seems that this family is critical in control of growth, differentiation, and mobility of many normal and transformed epithelial cell types.

Materials and Methods: We have looked for over expression of c-erbB-2 gene product in 230 cases of soft tissue sarcoma, in order to establish a possible new prognostic marker, and a potentially new treatment option.

Results: In all the cases, irrespective of the sarcoma histological type, the immunostaining for erbB-2 was negative.

Conclusions: Applications of erbB-2 for prognostication as well as the option of receptor targeting by trastuzumab monoclonal antibodies were aborted.


O. Merimsky J. Issakov Y. Kollender M. Inbar J. Bickels I. Meller

Background: We have recently observed that many of our sarcoma patients presented also with thyroid disorders. Literature data are almost unavailable on this topic.

Materials and Methods: Retrospective analysis of files of patients with sarcoma and clinically overt thyroid disorders.

Results: Out of 375 patients with soft tissue sarcomas (STS) and 235 with bone sarcoma (BS) including small blue round cell tumors (SBRC), 28 patients (4.6%) had an associated significant thyroid disorder. The types of sarcoma were mainly liposarcoma followed by malignant fibrous histiocytoma, leiomyosarcoma and bone sarcoma. The primary sites were mainly limb and trunk. The interval between the diagnosis of the thyroid disorder and the sarcoma varied between {−14} years (thyroid first) and {+16.5} years (thyroid later) with a median of {−0.2} years. Thyroid disorders included goiter, thyroiditis and carcinoma.

Conclusions: There are basic-science and clinical evidences to a possible common pathway that leads to the association between overt thyroid disorders and sarcomas of bone or soft tissues. Oncogene erbA activity is related to thyroid receptors to T3 and to development of sarcoma. Cross talk of the sarcoma oncogene and the erbA might contribute to the development of sarcoma. The thyroid hormone receptor and the highly related viral oncoprotein v-erbA are found exclusively in the nucleus as stable constituents of chromatin. It has been shown that v-erbA can block the spontaneous differentiation in erythroid cells transformed by various retroviral oncogenes. V-erbA can alter the spectrum of neoplasia induced by the v-src oncogene, which causes predominantly sarcomas and erythroblastosis in chicks. The erbA can cooperate with other oncogenes such as v-erbB or with v-fms, v-ras, and c-kit. Cooperation with v-myc may play a role in the development of rhabdomyosarcoma especially in thyroid hormone deficiency state. The possible clinical implications are the need to screen patients with sarcoma to thyroid disorders, and patients with thyroid disorders for malignant diseases.


V. Goldman A. Peyser Y. Bronstein G. Golomb S. Shushan M. Liebergall

Objective: The objective of this study was to compare the influence of different hyperthemic processes (autoclave and microwave oven) on the morphologic and thermodynamic properties of collagen.

Summary and Background Data: The current thinking regarding the treatment of human bone tumors is a radical excision, attempting to preserve the function of the limb. An acceptable method for limb preservation is reimplantation of the affected bone after the debridement of gross tumor tissue and sterilization by means of autoclave. This hyperthermic processing technique provides a perfectly sized graft, but it is associated with a decline in the mechanical and biological properties of the bone. A previous study demonstrated that sterilization using a microwave kills all viable cells with a minimal decrease in the mechanical and biological properties of the bone. Possible explanation of this phenomenon is preservation of matrix protein such as collagen. The current study’s goal was to investigate the effect of different hyperthermic treatments on native collagen.

Materials and Methods: In this study we used Heilistat-absorbable collagen sponge (American biomaterials corporation, Plainsboro, NJ 08536). This collagen was divided into three study groups. The first group was processed in the autoclave, the second in a microwave oven and the third which served as the control group received no thermal treatment. The thermodynamic properties of these three groups were checked by Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) and Thermo-Gravimetric Analysis (TGA). The morphological structure was examined by Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM), Phillips. Accelerating Voltage 30 KV.

Results: Thermodynamic properties: The peak temperature and the amount of energy invested showed similar results in the control group and in the microwave group, and differed from the results of the group treated by autoclave. The graphs of TGA, which represent the weight decrease as a function of heating, were also similar in the microwave group and the control group.

The morphological structure of the collagen, namely, the architectural structure of the material and single fibers, as shown by the SEM in various magnifications (100, 1200, 2500 and 5000), was much more similar when comparing between the control group and the microwave group than in the autoclave processed group.

Conclusion: Hyperthermic treatment using a microwave oven has minimal effect, if any, on the native collagen of bone, causing only minimal damage to the morphological and thermodynamic properties of bone. This observation may explain the biological superiority of the microwave treatment over autoclave treatment of bone.


M C Rao M S Siddique I M Pinder

Purpose: To study the functional outcome and survivorship of custom designed knee implants for revision and primary total knee replacement surgery where off-the-shelf prosthesis were unsuitable.

Methods: We prospectively reviewed the clinical and radiological results of 20 patients with 23 custom designed total knee prosthesis from 1991 to 2000. The indications were bone loss due to multiple revisions of total knee prosthesis and debridement for infection; peri-prosthetic fractures; bone deformity with rickets and small bones of patients with juvenile chronic arthritis. All the patients had their knee designed and manufactured in the Centre for Biomedical Engineering, University College London Medical School, Stanmore, UK. There were 4 different designs of knee prosthesis used: Condylar knee of miniature size, CAD-CAM knee, Superstabiliser and Rotating Hinges. Patients were operated upon by one senior surgeon and the Hospital for Special Surgery score taken pre-operatively, at three months, and yearly by an independent research physiotherapist.

Results: Clinical and radiological results after an average of 62.5 months (range 22 to 118 months) showed that the average Hospital for Special Surgery Score improved significantly (p=0.025) from 13.5 points (range 0–48) pre-operatively to 86.5 points (range 62–96 points). Average maximum flexion post operatively measured 86.4 degrees (range 60–122 degrees). 16 knees had excellent, 5 good and 2 poor results. Three patients had an extension lag ranging from 15–25 degrees. Only one patient with juvenile chronic arthritis needed revision at five years after the index arthroplasty.

Conclusion: The clinical and radiological results compare favorably with those who had standard knee prosthesis with similar indications. Our results support the use of a custom designed knee implant as a salvage prosthesis and an alternative to arthrodesis or amputation.


C E Ackroyd S L Whitehouse J H Newman C C Joslin

Purpose: To compare the ten-year survivorship results of an established total and medial compartment knee replacement performed in a single centre over an eighteen year period.

Method: Since 1978 knee replacements have been prospectively recorded in Bristol on a database. Regular clinical and radiological review has been undertaken every two or three years up to twenty years. 408 medial St Georg Unicompartmental replacements and 531 Kinematic total knee replacements have been subject to survivorship analysis using three failure end points. One - revision or removal of the implant. Two – revision or removal and moderate or severe pain. Three – the worst case including all patients lost to follow-up.

Results: The follow-up rate was 97% in both groups. 212 patients (562 knees) died and 31 patients (35 knees) were lost to follow-up. At ten years 25 medial Sled and 20 Kinematic knee arthroplasties had been revised. There was no significant difference (p > 0.05) in the number of good and excellent results. The mean range of movement at the last follow-up was 109 degrees for the medial Sled and 100 degrees for the Kinematic (p< 0.01). 94% of the medial Sled patients obtained a range of movement equal to or greater than 90 degrees whereas only 84% of Kinematic patients obtained this range (p < 0.05).

The ten-year survivorship figures were similar for both groups. Revision as the end point was 87.5% for the medial Sled and 89.6% for the Kinematic knees. When moderate and severe pain was considered in addition to revision ten-year survivorship was 79.4% in both groups. The worst case survivorship was also 74% in both groups.

Conclusion: The ten-year survivorship results of a fixed bearing, non-congruous, Unicompartmental arthroplasty are as good as those of a total knee replacement when performed in a single centre by two consultant surgeons and a variety of trainees. The advantages of a more rapid recovery and better quality result are offset by an easier though slightly higher revision rate.


R C Hartley N G Barton-Hanson R Finley R W Parkinson

There has been speculation as to whether the outcome of revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is as successful as primary TKA, this study was designed to compare the outcomes of primary and revision TKA in order to address this question.

The study collected data prospectively from patients operated upon by one surgeon using one prosthesis design in each group. All patients undergoing revision TKA between 1997 and 2000 were included in the study. 100 consecutive patients undergoing primary TKA between 1997 and 1999 were included in the study. All surgery was performed by the senior author.

Patients completed SF-12 and WOMAC questionnaires pre-operatively and at six and twelve months post-operatively. Mean scores were calculated for the different areas within both outcome measures (WOMAC pain, stiffness and function; SF-12 – physical constant score [PCS] and mental constant score [MCS])

The results were entered into a database and analysed using a combination of two way and simple repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) and t-tests. Only if the result of the ANOVA was significant were post-hoc adjusted t-tests performed on the data values.

WOMAC scores did not differ between the two groups pre-operatively. Both patient groups showed a significant improvement in WOMAC scores at six months (P< 0.0005). In the primary group the pain and function scores improved significantly between six and twelve months (P=0.0258 and P=0.0019 respectively). This was not the case in revision patients.

SF-12 PCS scores were significantly better in the primary patients pre-operatively (P< 0.0005). Both groups showed a significant improvement at six months assessment (P< 0.0005). Neither group demonstrated an improvement between six and twelve months. SF-12 MCS scores did not show any difference between the two groups pre-operatively. No significant change in MCS score occurred during the study in either the primary or revision patients.

The SF-12 and WOMAC health questionnaires are valid, reliable and responsive outcome measures. The study has collected data prospectively from patients operated upon by one surgeon using one prosthesis design in each group. These findings support the concept that revision TKA leads to a comparable improvement in patient perceived outcomes of physical parameters as does primary TKA in both generic health outcome measures and disease specific outcome measures.


J J Candal-Couto D J Deehan

Introduction: Arthroscopic A.C.L. reconstruction using Semitendinosus (S.T.) and Gracilis (Gr.) tendons is a popular technique for the treatment of ACL deficient knees. It is common to find accessory tendinous bands (vinculae) arising from these two tendons when harvesting them. The implications are that extra care must be taken with the use of the tendon stripper if one is to avoid cutting the main tendon. Our clinical experience reveals that these connections are highly variable and, contrary to popular thinking, may be present beyond 10cm. proximally.

Aim: Our aim was to map these intertendinous connections and assess their variability using a cadaveric model. In particular we were interested to identify the presence of vinculae arising proximally beyond 10cm.

Procedure: We dissected the tendons of Gr. and S.T. of ten embalmed adult human cadaveric legs. Various vinculae from both tendons were identified and their origin and insertion mapped. All measurements were done using the tibial crest as a reference.

Results: We found that vinculae have a high variability. Bands were seen between tendons, connecting them to the popliteal fascia, sartorius, gastrognemis, pretibial and superficial fascia. Vinculae originated more than 10cm proximally from Semitendinosus and Gracilis in eight and two occasions respectively. There was a constant connection band between S.T. and the grastrocriernius fascia.

Conclusion: Our results confirm that vincular anatomy is more variable than previously reported. Surgeons should be aware of our new finding of vinculae commonly originating beyond 10cm. proximally. This work has prompted us to investigate the role of MRI for pre-operatively templating vinculae.


V Bhalaik V Sahni R Hartley P Carter R Finley R W Parkinson

Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of the Co-ordinate revision knee prosthesis (Depuy Ltd, Johnson and Johnson, Warsaw, In) between 1995–2001.

Methods: One hundred and thirty-three knees (126 patients) undergoing revision total knee replacement between 1995–2001 were followed up prospectively. Surgery was performed by one surgeon (senior author). The patients were scored pre-operatively and postoperatively with SF-12 and WOMAC score. Surgery was performed for aseptic loosening (92%) and infection (8%). The changes in SF-12 physical score and the WOMAC score between pre and post operation were significant (SF-12 p < 0.0018, WOMAC pain p< 0.0001, WOMAC stiffness p< 0.0001, WOMAC Function p< 0.0001)). The prosthesis produced reliable relief of pain and improved range of movement with minimal complications.

Conclusion: This modular knee revision system produced satisfactory results in dealing with bone loss and instability in the medium term.


N Pradhan J Borrill J Blan M Porter

The aim of this study was to ascertain if a correlation exists between the indication for revision and the clinical outcome in revision total knee replacement.

Methods: We analysed the data of 81 revision knee arthroplasty patients performed at Wrightington Hospital with an average follow-up of 31 months (1yr – 6yrs). All patients had semi-constrained prosthesis implanted (PS-PFC or TC3, Depuy). The indications for revising the total knee arthroplasty in each patient were noted and the clinical outcome was determined using a patient satisfaction questionnaire.

Results: Of the 81 patients, 18 were enthusiastic with the clinical outcome, 38 were satisfied, eight were non-committal and 17 were disappointed. Indications for revision in our series were aseptic loosening (31 patients), implant failure (21 patients), instability (14 patients), pain (eight patients) and infection (seven patients). Correlation between the indication for revision and the clinical outcome are detailed in the table below.

Sixteen per cent of patients revised for aseptic loosening were non-committal or disappointed with the outcome in comparison with 33.3% revised for implant failure, 21.4% revised for instability, 62.5% revised for pain and 71.4% revised for infection.

Conclusion: The indication for revision does affect the clinical outcome in revision knee arthroplasty. Patients undergoing revision knee arthroplasty for infection and pain are less likely to be satisfied with the clinical outcome of revision surgery.


N Pradhan J Borrill J Blan M Porter

It is usually assumed that there is a correlation between the number of previous operations and the clinical outcome of revision knee arthroplasty though it has not been studied and published. We reviewed our series of 81 revision knee arthroplasty patients to ascertain if a correlation exists. All patients had a semi-constrained prosthesis implanted.

Methods: We analysed the data of 81 revision knee arthroplasty patients performed at Wrightington Hospital with an average follow-up of 31 months (1yr – 6yrs). The number of previous operations on each knee were noted and the clinical outcome was determined using a patient satisfaction questionnaire.

Results: Of the 81 patients; 18 were enthusiastic with the clinical outcome; 38 were satisfied; eight were non-committal; 17 were disappointed. Seventy four per cent of patients with one previous operation were enthusiastic or satisfied with the revision surgery outcome in comparison to 55.5% and 0% of patients with two and three previous surgery respectively.

Conclusion: The trend from the above figures suggests that as the number of previous operations increases the likelihood of satisfactory clinical outcome decreases, in revision total knee replacement using semi-constrained prosthesis.


I D McDermott S Richards P Hallam S Tavares J R Lavelle A A Amis

Aims: To determine load to failure for four different meniscal repair techniques, and to assess gapping across repairs under cyclical loading.

Background: Studies comparing the biomechanical properties of different meniscal repair systems are limited, and most have simply investigated load to failure. Meniscal tissue is highly anisotropic, and far weaker under tension in the radial direction. Load to failure using high loads may, therefore, not be the most physiologically relevant in-vitro test for repair of circumferential tears, and measuring increases in gapping across repair sites under cyclical loading at lower loads may be of greater importance.

Methods: Bovine menisci were divided vertically, 5mm from the peripheral edge to simulate a circumferential tear, and then repaired using one to four techniques: vertical loop sutures using 1 -PDS, bioabsorbable Meniscal Arrows (Atlantech), Meniscal Fasteners (Mitek) or T-Fix Suture Bars (Acufex). Nine specimens were tested in each group using an Instron 5500 materials testing machine to determine load to failure. A further nine specimens in each group were tested by cyclic loading between 5N and 10N at 20mm/min for 25 cycles, using a digital micrometer to measure initial gapping, and a Differential Variable Reluctance Transducer to measure the progressive increase in gapping across the repair site during the cyclical loading. Data was analysed by ANOVA and Tukey’s multiple comparison post test using Prism (GraphPad) software.

Results: The mean loads to failure (with s.d.) in Newtons were: Sutures 72.7 (22.0), Arrows 34.2 (15.4), Fasteners 40.8 (13.4), and T-Fix 49.1 (13.8). The load to failure was significantly greater with the Sutures compared to the Arrows (p< 0.001), the Fasteners (p< 0.001) or the T-Fix (p< 0.05).

The mean gapping across the repairs after 25 load cycles (with s.d.) in millimetres was: Sutures 3.3 (1.0), Arrows 2.2 (0.9), Fasteners 4.0 (0.6) and TFix 3.5 (0.7). The mean gapping was significantly less for the Arrows compared to the Sutures (p< 0.05), the Fasteners (p< 0.01), or the T-Fix (p< 0.05).

Conclusions: These results confirm that meniscal repair by suturing gives the highest load to failure, but show that Arrows give superior hold with the least increase in gapping across a repair under cyclical loading by this test protocol.


T A Sudhahar M M S Glasgow S T Donnell

This is a prospective study analysing the accuracy of expected tunnel position (graft site) for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and to decide whether or not confirmation of the tunnel site using intraoperative imaging is required. 35 cases of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using bone patella bone tendon performed by three surgeons are studied. The surgeons use three different techniques. Immediately after the surgery, the surgeon marks the expected tunnel site (graft site) in a diagram (AP and LAT of femur and tibia) without seeing the x rays and a separate observer studies the actual position in the x-ray. Significance of the difference is studied using statistical tests. Best surgical outcome can be obtained using radiological confirmation of tunnel position intraoperatively with the guide wires.


M Hassaballa A Porteous J H Newman

Aim: To assess the functional results of revision TKR with the PFC/TC3 system, and to correlate this with the reasons for revision and restoration of joint height.

Method: One hundred and fifty three patients underwent revision TKR using the PFC/TC3 system. Data was prospectively collected (using the Bristol Knee Score) pre-operatively and at a mean of 4.2 years post-revision. Forty three revisions were for infection and 81 revisions were for aseptic loosening. Measurements of the joint height were made pre and post-operatively using Figgie’s method and were divided into three groups: lower by more than 5mm, restored and elevated more than 5mm. Use of distal augments and polyethylene thickness were recorded.

Results: The mean pre-op function score was 12 and post-operatively was 19 for the infection group and 20 for the aseptic loosening group. Revision after initial UKR gave a mean score of 21, while revision after TKR gave a mean score of 18 (max 27). Knees in which the joint line was elevated by more than 5 mm had a mean score of 17 while those where the joint line was restored had a mean score of 1 9. Recent increasing use of distal augments improved the joint line and results.

Conclusion: Revision using the PFC/TC3 system produced acceptable medium term functional results and good survival. Better restoration of joint line and functional results were achieved by distal femoral rather than proximal tibial augmentation.


I Hijazi A Amis

In this experiment we induced posterolateral knee instability to cadaveric knees in vitro. We observed the changes in these knees to posterior displacement (PD), varus-valgus (V-V) rotation, external rotation (ER) and coupled external rotation (CER) and compared the effect of reconstructing, the popliteo-fibular ligament and the popliteus muscle in correcting posterolateral rotatory instability.

Method: Fourteen intact freshly frozen cadaveric knees were damaged using a specially constructed jig that pivoted at two points simulating the hip and ankle joints while an anteromedial force was applied to the proximal tibia causing combined varus, and hyperextension. Eight of these knees were suitable for reconstruction and the modified Larson popliteo-fibular and the Muller popliteal reconstruction were tested on each knee. A hamstring graft was used for the popliteo-fibular Larson techniques and the biceps tendon for Muller technique. Pd and CER were measured at 0, 30, 60 and 90o, ER was measured at 0, 30 and 90o and Varus rotation measured at 0 and 20o. Measurements were recorded for intact, damaged and reconstructed knees.

Discussion: Both reconstructions repaired Pd at 0 flexion with no significant difference between intact and reconstructed states. However both failed to do so at 30o of flexion (P< 0.05). Both significantly over constraint the knees at 90o of flexion (P< 0.05). Varus displacement was significantly corrected by both procedures at 0o flexion, at 200 of flexion the popliteal reconstruction failed to significantly restore varus displacement while the P-F reconstruction significantly did so P< 0.002. At 0,300 flexion ER & CER was significantly corrected by both reconstructions and over-constraint at 90o of flexion.

Conclusions: Both reconstructions failed to correct posterior displacement at 300 of flexion, this will manifest clinically in giving way in low angles of knee flexion e.g. negotiating staircases. Of clinical significance is the ability of the P-F reconstruction to correct varus rotation at low angles of flexion. Surprisingly there was no significant difference between both reconstructions in correcting external rotation and coupled external rotation. The popliteal reconstruction fails to correct both posterior displacement and varus rotation at low angles of flexion.


D L Isaac D J Beard A J Price D Murray

Aim: This study was designed to investigate the nature and extent of tibial translation (TT) during open kinetic chain (OKC) and closed kinetic chain (CKC) activity; recent reports have suggested that the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) may be strained to an equal amount during CKC and OKC exercise.

Method: Fifteen unilaterally ACL deficient (ACLD) patients and six control subjects underwent fluoroscopic assessment while performing a passive extension exercise, an OKC resisted extension exercise, and a weight-bearing CKC exercise designed to reflect knee motion experienced during dynamic daily activity. Measurements of the patella tendon angle (the angle between the long axis of the tibia and the patella tendon) were obtained to calculate relative TT.

Results: The results show that in ACL intact (ACLI) knees the CKC exercise caused greater anterior TT than the OKC exercise from 0 to 60° of knee flexion (p< 0.05). No difference between ACLI and ACLD knees was detected during the CKC exercise. Maximum weight-bearing (CKC) TT was 8±3 mm. The ACLD tibia during the OKC exercise translated more than the ACLI tibia, and to the same extent as the CKC exercise at 10 to 200 of knee flexion. The ACLI tibia during OKC exercise translated to a maximum of 3±4 mm at 1 0° knee flexion.

Summary: This study has demonstrated that fluoroscopic analysis may be used to detect differences in the kinematics of ACLI and ACLD limbs during activity. It validates recent data demonstrating that the ACL may be strained during CKC exercise to an equal or greater amount than during OKC exercise, and shows that the ACLD knee kinematics are similar to the ACLI knee during CKC exercise. Factors other than the ACL may control the extent of maximal TT during weightbearing activity. This has important consequences for the development of rehabilitation regimes after ACL reconstruction. The commonly held assumption that CKC exercise will protect an ACL graft may not be valid.


A J Bing C N A Esler

Purpose: To determine current practice in knee Arthroplasty surgery for osteoarthritis in young patients for the population registered on the Trent and Wales Arthroplasty Database. Is there a ‘gold standard’? If there is what is it?

Method: The Trent Arthroplasty Audit Group collects prospective data on all knee Arthroplasty surgery performed in Trent Region and North and West Wales (population 6.2 million). In 2000/2001 7% of knee arthroplasties were performed on osteoarthritic patients aged 55 years or less. We analysed the database to reach the following results.

Results: In 2000/01 208 arthroplasties were performed in this group of patients. The youngest patient was 36 yrs. Seventy per cent of the patients were aged between 50 and 55 years. 114 were female. 27 had a unicompartmental knee replacement, mobile bearing in 25. Where the patient had a condylar knee replacent a mobile bearing design was implanted in 10 knees. A PCL sacrificing implant was used in 36% of cases. The patella was resurfaced in 31%. An uncemented prosthesis was used in 19 knees. An 8mm tibial insert was implanted in 32 cases and an insert of less than 10mm in a further eight cases. The surgery was performed by a Consultant in 65% of cases. A Consultant assisted in a further 14% of cases. The arthroplasty was the first surgical procedure to the knee in 38% of cases. The arthroplasty followed arthroscopic procedures in a further 41% of cases.

Conclusions: The surgeons of the Trent Arthroplasty Audit Group are offering knee Arthroplasty to their patients at an earlier stage. Surgeons don’t appear to change their surgical practice or choice of implant when operating on young osteoarthritic patients. Given that we have previously shown that 20% of these patients are disappointed by the pain relief and 38% by their level of function what should we recommend?


T S Waters G Bentley

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of trochlear design in total knee replacement with and without patellar resurfacing.

Methods and Results: In 1992 a trial was set up, including all patients undergoing primary PFC (Johnson & Johnson) total knee replacement. Patients were randomised to either patellar resurfacing or retention. The patients were assessed using the American Knee Society rating, a clinical anterior knee pain score and BOA patient satisfaction score. Assessment was performed without knowing whether the patella had been resurfaced.

In July 1998 we began using the PFC Sigma. This incorporates a deeper trochlear groove with a 5° valgus angle.

We compared the results for the two types of prosthesis. In the PFC group there were 474 knees in 390 patients. Follow-up was from 2 to 9 years (mean 5.5 years). The overall prevalence of anterior knee pain) was 25.1% (58 knees) and 5.3% (13 knees) in the non-resurfaced group (n=231) versus the resurfaced group (n=243) respectively. Anterior knee pain became apparent in all cases within 18 months.

In the PFC sigma group there were 67 knees in 62 patients. Follow-up was from 18 months to 3 years (mean 2 years). The incidence of anterior knee pain was 0 in the resurfaced group (n=30) versus 37.8% (14 knees) in the non-resurfaced group (n=37). Knee scores were lower in the non-resurfaced groups for each prosthesis.

Conclusion: The prevalence of anterior knee pain was significantly higher in knees with non-resurfacing of the patella. The asymmetrical, deeper femoral groove improves anterior knee pain with the resurfaced patella but may contribute to it if not resurfaced. We recommend patellar resurfacing in all cases where technically possible.


S J Scott J D Moorehead S C Montgomery

Purpose: Femoral roll causes the sagittal plane axis of the knee to move posteriorly and anteriorly with flexion and extension. The aim of this study was to measure this movement with a surface marker imaging system and assess the effect of Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) deficiency on the Sagittal Axis Pathway (SAP) of the knee.

Method: Twelve normal and fourteen unilateral ACL deficient subjects were video recorded as they flexed and extended their knees in the sagittal plane. Video stills were captured at 150 intervals from 90o flexion to full extension. An imaging system was then used to extract the co-ordinates of leg markers from each still. These co-ordinates were then processed to derive the SAP for each knee throughout its range of movement.

Results: Pooling all the normal results together (24 bilateral + 14 unilateral = 38 knees), it was found that a 90° knee extension caused the sagittal axis to displace anteriorly with a mean value of 20.0mm (SD=7.8). In comparison the 14 ACL deficient knees were found to have a mean anterior displacement of 9.2 mm (SD=8.0). A bilateral comparison of the 12 pairs of normal knees showed no significant difference between left and right sides (paired-t, p=0.99). However, a bilateral comparison of the 14 unilateral ACL deficient patients showed a significant difference between normal and injured sides (paired-t, p=0.00025). In this group, the normal knees axis at full extension had a mean location 28.9mm (SD=8.8) posterior to the front of the tibial plateau. In comparison the injured knees axis has a mean location 37.8 mm (SD=8.5) posterior to the front of the tibial plateau. Again, this was highly significant (paired-t, p=0.0001).

Conclusion: These results indicate that normal knees have a mean forward roll of 20 mm for a 90° knee extension. In comparison ACL deficient knees have a reduced roll of 9.2 mm which occurs at the rear of the joint. This reduction in roll is consistent with the abnormal ligament biomechanics.


C M Gupte A Smith I D McDermott A M J Bull R D Thomas A A Amis

Aim: To accurately identify the meniscofemoral ligaments in cadaveric human specimens, and to determine anatomical variations in the posterior cruciate ligament that may lead to mis-identification of these structures.

Methods: A total of 79 fresh frozen knees were examined from 45 cadavers Combined anterior and posterior approaches were used to inspect the vicinity of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) for the presence of the anterior and posterior meniscofemoral ligaments. The anterior approach utilised a medial parapatellar incision followed by division of the anterior cruciate ligament, whilst a midline posterior arthrotomy was used for the posterior approach. Further dissection facilitated inspection of the meniscal and femoral attachments of the MFLs, and measurement of their lengths. Videos of MFL and PCL motion during passive flexion of the cadaveric were also performed.

Results: In total, 74 (94%) of the 79 specimens contained at least one meniscofemoral ligament. The posterior meniscofemoral ligament (pMFL) was present in 56 (71%) specimens, whilst the anterior meniscofemoral ligament (aMFL) was present in 58 specimens (73%). Both ligaments coexisted in 40 (51%) of knees. In 15 specimens the PCL was seen to have oblique fibres, which attached proximal to the tibial attachment of the main part of the PCL. We termed this “the false pMFL”, as it could be easily mis-identified as the posterior meniscofemoral ligament. Several other anatomical variations were also identified. The mean length of the aMFL was 20.7±3.9mm, whilst that of the pMFL was 23±4.2mm. Although the lengths of the MFLs were relatively constant, there was a wide variation in thickness.

Discussion: This study confirms the high incidence of at least one MFL in humans, which suggests a functional role for these structures. The oblique fibres of the PCL can be readily mis-identfied as the pMFL. These caveats should be borne in mind, during both arthroscopic examination and in the interpretation of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans of the knee. Although some variations of the MFLs have been reported on MRI imaging2, there has been no note of the oblique fibres of the PCL reported in the present study. As this variation was present in almost one in five of our specimens, its appearance on MRI scanning requires investigation.

The function of the meniscofemoral ligaments is undetermined, although many hypotheses comment on a role in guiding the motion of the lateral meniscus during knee flexion. Other possibilities include a function as a secondary restraint supplementing the posterior cruciate ligament.


N P Thomas R K Kankate

Chronic medial collateral ligament (MCL) instability is an unusual clinical problem. Due to the unsatisfactory results of advancement procedures or reconstruction using autologous techniques we have devised a new technique using a non-irradiated tendo achilles allograft construct.

Three patients are presented who had symptomatic MCL insufficiency. The laxity was demonstrated clinically (all grade 3) and radiologically using valgus stress views.

The tendo achilles was fashioned into a triangular composite graft consisting of a bone plug (30 x 10 mm) and the tendon. The bone plug was attached to the femur at the anatomical insertion of the MCL using an interference screw and the tendon on the tibia using a multiple suture anchor technique.

The rehabilitation programme consisted of immediate mobilisation and the use of a brace for twelve weeks.

At follow-up (average 12 months) all patients were asymptomatic, had a full range of movements, no increased clinical laxity and no increased radiological laxity to a valgus force at 25 degrees of flexion when compared to the other side.

We conclude that this is an effective technique in the treatment of chronic symptomatic MCL laxity.


J R Robinson J Sanchez-Ballester R deW Thomas A M J Bull A A Amis

Objective: To provide a functional, anatomical description of the posteromedial structures, allowing future biomechanical studies to evaluate how they act to restrain tibio-femoral joint motion and contribute to joint stability.

Methods: Twenty fresh cadaveric knee joints were dissected. The appearance of the medial ligament complex was recorded using still and video digital photography as the specimens were flexed, extended, internally and externally rotated.

Results: We divided the medial structures into thirds, from anterior to posterior, and into three layers from superficial to deep: Layer 1: Fascia. Layer 2: Superficial MCL. Layer 3: Deep MCL and capsule. In the Posteromedial Corner (posterior third) it is not possible to separate Layers 2 and 3. The posteromedial corner (PMC) envelops the posterior medial femoral condyle. A discrete posterior oblique ligament (POL) is not identifiable. The PMC appears to be a functional unit with a role in passively restraining tibio-femoral valgus and internal rotation with the knee extended. The semimembranosus, through its tendon sheath attachments, may act as a dynamic stabiliser.

Conclusion: The MCL appears to have three functional units:Superficial MCL, Deep MCL and PMC. We believe that this description allows a logical approach to understanding the biomechanics and surgical reconstruction of the posteromedial structures. We plan to use this anatomical study as the basis for further work to evaluate the how these functional units act.


Full Access
T Ashraf R Evans J H Newman C E Ackroyd

Objective: To report the survivorship rate and clinical outcome of a large series of lateral unicompartmental replacements.

Method: 88 lateral St Georg Sled LTKRS were performed between 1978 and 1999. Clinical and radiological data was prospectively recorded at regular follow up and only 5 knees were lost during the 22 year period.

Results: 15 knees were revised after an average of 8 years. (eight for progressive arthritis, six for loosening and four for femoral fracture) 29 patients (30 knees) died during the course of the study. At final follow up (average 9 years) 50 of the 63 remaining knees were rated as good or excellent, nine as fair and nine poor. The mean range of flexion was 110°.

At 10 years the cumulative survival rate was 83% and at 15 years 78% (10 knees at risk). The “worst case scenario” where knees with pain or lost to follow up are added to revisions shows a 10 year survivorship of 74%.

Conclusion: Although the results are not as good as medial UKR. These clinical outcomes suggest that the conservative surgical procedure of lateral UKR with the fixed bearing St George Sled prosthesis can give acceptable results in the uncommon situation of severely symptomatic isolated lateral tibio femoral arthritis.


C M Gupte A Smith N Jamieson A M J Bull R D Thomas A A Amis

Aim: To accurately assess cross-sectional areas of the MFLs and distinguish between the mechanical properties of the anterior and posterior meniscofemoral ligaments.

Methods: Twenty-eight fresh frozen cadaveric knees were dissected to isolate the lateral meniscus and MFLs, which remained attached to the femur. The cross-sectional areas of MFLs were determined using the Race-Amis1 casting method for measurement. The ligaments were then tensile tested in an Instron materials testing machine. The stress and strain in each sample was calculated from measurements of cross sectional area, load applied, and increase in length,.

Results: The mean cross sectional area for the anterior MFL (aMFL) was 14.7 mm2 (±14.8mm2) whilst that of the posterior MFL (pMFL) was 20.9mm2 (±11.6mm2). The mean loads to failure were 300.5N (±155.0N) for the aMFL and 302.5N (±157.9N) for the pMFL, with elastic moduli of 281MPa (±239MPa) and 227MPa (±128MPa) respectively. There were no significant differences in structural or material properties between the two MFLs. When compared with the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), the mean ultimate loads of the MFLs were similar to those of the posterior bundle of the PCL (pPC), and their elastic moduli were analogous to the anterior bundle (aPC).

Discussion: This is the first study to distinguish between the properties of the aMFL and pMFL, and indicates that both ligaments must be given equal consideration when formulating hypotheses on function. The aMFL and pMFL may also serve mutually distinct functions in the human knee. Previous authors2 have commented that the reciprocal tightening and slackening of the aPC (taut in flexion) and pPC (taut in extension) indicates a difference in function of these two components of the PCL. Others3 have similarly commented on the reciprocal tightening and slackening of the two MFLs. This may also indicate differing functions for these ligaments. It is proposed that the aMFL supplements the function of the aPC, whilst the pMFL supplements the function of the pPC. This hypothesis stimulates debate on preservation of these structures during PCL reconstruction.

Race A., Amis A.A., 1996. Cross-sectional area measurement of soft tissue. A new casting method. Journal of Biomechanics 29(9), 1207–1212.

RaceA., Amis A.A., 1994a. The mechanical properties of the two bundles of the human posterior cruciate ligament. Journal of Biomechanics 27(1), (13–24).

Friederich N F., O’Brien W., 1990. Functional anatomy of the meniscofemoral ligaments. Fourth Congress of the European Society of Sports Traumatology Knee Surgery and Arthroscopy (ESSKA)


R Sethi T K Bagga

Introduction: Total Knee Replacement is a commonly done planned operative procedure frequently requiring blood transfusion. Fear of adverse reactions, transmission of viral illnesses like AIDS, Hepatitis B, C and Non A Non B has led to interest in alternatives to allogenic blood transfusion.

Predonation of autologous blood, administration of erythropoeitin alpha, postoperative blood recovery using cell saver or suction devices for reinfusion of whole blood have all been suggested to overcome this problem.

Aim: Our study was aimed to assess the efficacy of reinfusion of autologous blood transfusion from the blood collected after completion of the surgical procedure using Constavac reinfusion drain system.

Method: A prospective analysis of 54 patients undergoing primary total knee replacement was done. All patients with preoperative Hb of 12.5gm/dl or more were included. Postoperative drop in Hb below 9 gm/dl was an indication of supplemental transfusion. Probability of sepsis or malignancy were criterion for exclusion.

Results: In all patients undergoing Total knee replacement , average amount of blood reinfused was 480 mls. 50 of the 54 (92.6%) patients did not need any homologous blood transfusion. Average drop in Hb was 2.3 gm/dl. In nine patients (16.7%) there was drop in Hb of more than 3 gm% but only three of them needed blood transfusion. Patients with valgus deformity and needing lateral release were more at risk of needing homologous blood transfusion. No complications or adverse effects were noticed.

Discussion: Our study shows that reinfusion alone may be sufficient in most cases needing Total knee replacement. It is a reliable, safe, simple and cost effective way to overcome the need of allogenic blood transfusion in patients undergoing Total Knee Replacement. This may reduce the load on blood banks for cross matching all patients undergoing knee replacement except in valgus knees .


M Salman Ali S R Mangaleshkar

Aims: To assess the medium term results of uncemented meniscal bearing total knee replacement.

Methods: Fifty one knees in 40 patients with posterior cruciate ligament retaining meniscal bearing total knee replacement were reviewed 5 to 12 years after the arthroplasty. Forty nine knees had uncemented metal backed rotating patella. They were followed up annually with subjective questionnaires and radiological assessment.

Results: Forty eight out of the 51 knees were available at the time of final review. Three knees were lost due to the death of patients. They were reviewed after an average follow-up of 8 years 7 months. There was no loss to follow-up. There were three revisions due to excessive wear of the meniscal bearing. Defective polyethylene bearing was the reason for failure in one knee. The mal-rotation resulting from the posterior cruciate ligament deficiency could have been reason for the increased wear of the meniscal bearing and early failure in the other two knees. The ten-year survival rate was 93.08% (95% CI - 81.74-98.22). The objective assessment of the knee replacement was done with The Knee Society scoring system. The average knee score was 87.64 and the average functional score was 74.4.

Conclusion: The long-term survival of PCL sparing meniscal bearing knee replacement seems to be affected by increased polyethylene wear.


S J Parsons A T Helm D S Johnson R B Smith

Aim: We conducted a prospective, randomised study of 50 patients, 40 (80%) male and 10 (20%) female, with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture to compare the results of ligament reconstruction by middle third patellar tendon graft (M) or synthetic Leeds-Keio (LK) ligament.

Method: The patients were randomised into two groups. 26 (52%) underwent PTG repair and 24 (48%) LK repair. Subjective knee function was classified using the Lysholm score, Tegner activity score and IKDC grading. Laxity was tested by clinical examination including anterior draw, pivot shift and arthrometric measurements using the Stryker Laxometer (Stryker Corporation, Kalamazoo, Michigan, USA).

Results: We present the early (two to five-year follow-up) results of this on-going trial. There was no statistical difference between the two groups in activity levels, both pre-injury and current. However, both pivot shift and anterior laxity were significantly greater in the LK group at two years and greater.

Discussion: While the LK group did develop significantly greater laxity, it is demonstrated that the functional outcome is not affected. We conclude therefore that if the results of surgery were to be based on a functional outcome rather than objective measurements of laxity, it would seem logical that the LK is an acceptable alternative to autogenous PTG.

However whilst function appears to be as good the less successful objective criteria do suggest reservations for the long term results of the Leeds-keio graft.


A Khan J Emberson G S E Dowd

Aim: To determine retrospectively the post-operative mortality and fatal pulmonary embolism (PE) rates in 936 consecutive primary total knee replacements (TKR) in the three month period after surgery where chemical thromboprophylaxis was not routinely used.

Methods: Operations were performed over a period of eleven years by eight different senior orthopaedic surgeons on 248 men and 525 women. One hundred and sixty three patients had bilateral TKRs and the mean age at the time of operation was similar (69.4 and 72.2 years respectively). Patients were traced by out-patient appointments, telephone and through their general practitioners (GPs). Post-mortem examinations were used to verify cause of death in all save three of the cases. All but one of the patients were followed up.

Results: There were no deaths from PE confirmed by post-mortem examinations. As three patients were certified dead without post-mortem examination and one patient could not be traced this meant that, at worst, our fatal PE rate was 0.43% (4/936; CI 0.14%–1.17%). The all-cause mortality rate was 0.64% (6/936; CI 0.26%–0.46%) (Table 1). The patient mortality was compared with the population mortality of England and Wales using standardised mortality ratios (SMRs). The SMR for both sexes combined was 0.74 (CI 0.29–1.52). We observed a lower mortality in females SMR = 0.67 and males SMR = 0.84 during the first three post-operative months than compared to the general population.

Conclusion: Fatal pulmonary embolism after total knee replacement without routine chemical thromboprophylaxis is uncommon. The overall death rate in this series of patients undergoing total knee replacement appears to be lower than that in the general population.


M D Waites B L Smith A J Unwin A J Taylor R L Allum

Aim: This prospective study set out to establish whether a 10 mg dose of intra-articular morphine in combination with 0.5% Bupivicaine was more efficacious than a 5mg dose following therapeutic knee arthroscopy.

Methods: Sixty patients were randomised to receive either 5mg or 10mg intra-articular morphine in combination with Bupivicaine at the end of a therapeutic arthroscopy. Patients completed pain scores at regular intervals over 5 post operative days.

Results: There was no significant difference in both analgesic effect and side effect profile between the two different doses of intra-articular morphine.

Conclusion: 5mg intra-articular morphine in combination with 0.5% Bupivicaine provides effective post operative analgesia in patients having had a therapeutic knee arthroscopy. A 10 mg dose provides no added benefit.


M Salman Ali S R Mangaleshkar

Aims: To assess the medium term results of uncemented Low Contact Stress Rotating platform total knee replacement.

Methods: One hundred and nine primary uncemented Low Contact Stress rotating platform total knee replacements in 85 patients were reviewed 4 to 12 years after the operation as a prospective study on consecutive cases. 106 knees received uncemented metal backed rotating patella. All patients were followed up annually with subjective questionnaires and radiological assessment.

Results: At the time of final review, 69 patients with 87 rotating platform total knee replacement were alive. There was no loss to follow-up. The American Knee society score was used for objective assessment. The average knee score was 86.42 and the average functional score was 65.1. No evidence of radiological loosening was observed in any patient. One knee was revised because of medial collateral ligament laxity. The ten-year survival rate was 99.08% (95% CI - 91.9-99.9).

Conclusion: The uncemented LCS rotating platform knee replacement seems to be reliable at medium-term follow-up.


O Aiyenuro O O A Oni

Introduction: Following osteochondral transplantation for articular surface defects, union between graft and recipient bed cartilage may occur via two mechanisms. Healing could occur as a result of ingrowths of mesen-chymal cells derived from the subchondral bone. Direct cartilage-to-cartilage healing could occur as a result of chondrocyte proliferation and migration from the margins of graft and recipient bed. This latter mechanism depends upon the marginal chondrocytes surviving the transplantation process, remaining viable and then being capable of cell division as well as normal matrix production.

Aim: The purpose of this study was to investigate the viability of chondrocytes at the graft-recipient bed boundary using the Trypan Blue exclusion technique.

Method: Under general anaesthesia, the medial femoral condyle (MFC) of the right knee of 12 adult male New Zealand White rabbits was exposed via a midline incision and medial arthrotomy. A cylindrical 4mm diameter and 4mm long osteochondral graft was obtained using the T- handle harvester (MITEK COR System) and then it was reinserted into the same site. A groin-to-toe plaster of Paris cast was applied and the animals were allowed to recover. At weekly intervals, 3 animals were killed and the femoral artery of the operated leg was perfused with 10ml Trypan blue. The MFC was excised and fixed in 10% buffered formalin for 1 week. Thereafter, the specimens were decalcified in 10% Kristensen’s solution for 1 week, processed and then paraffin embedded. Sections ‘6u thick were obtained and examined with a light microscope. For each specimen, one section was counterstained with eosin before microscopy.

Results: The animals survived for the duration of the study and the wounds were well healed with no signs of infection. Joint effusion and synovitis were observed in the operated knees at weeks 1, 2 and 3. All grafts were in place and all had faint demarcating borders separating the graft from the surrounding recipient bed. In all cases, there was a zone of positively staining chondrocytes on the periphery of the graft and in the adjoining recipient bed. The zone of positively staining cells extended some considerable distance into the cartilage and affected all its layers. Chondrocytes at the periphery of osteochondral grafts and the adjoining recipient bed may not survive transplantation.

Discussion: This calls into question the ability to achieve direct union between the graft and the recipient bed cartilages. The likely causes of cell death are physical perturbation and direct contact between chondrocytes and blood or synovial fluid. The long-term survival of an osteochondral graft may be determined by whether or not boundary healing has occurred. In the absence of boundary healing, a graft could become bathed in synovial fluid. A pseudarthrosis of sorts could then form which may erode the graft, cause graft subsidence and/or ultimately result in graft death.


M C Rao M S Siddique D J Deehan I M Pinder

Purpose: To study the effect of retaining an abraded femoral component on the outcome of primary revision of uncemented total knee prosthesis.

Method: 66 revision procedures for failed uncemented porous coated anatomic (PCA) total knee replacement were performed in 60 patients. At review, four patients had died while two were lost to follow up, therefore 60 knees in 54 patients were included in this prospective study. The principal indications for primary revision were polyethylene wear and loosening of the tibial base plate. 14 patients had a well fixed femoral component and hence were retained while 46 patients had both the components revised. All patients were prospectively assessed prior to surgery, at three months, six months and yearly thereafter. Review comprised clinical and radiological assessment. The mean follow up was 8.4 yrs (7–12 yrs)

Summary of results: The mean pre-operative Hospital for Special Surgery knee score after the first revision improved at a follow up of 8.4yr (7–12yr) giving 39 (65%) excellent, 17 (28.4%) good and four (6.6%) poor results. 13 out of 60 knees needed a further revision. Six of these second revisions which had only the tibial component changed failed very early (mean of 2.1 yr) when compared to the rest (6.8yr), probably due to wear between the abraded retained femoral component and polyethylene insert. The estimated odds ratio (relative risk) of second revision in patients with retained femoral component compared to those with revision of both the components was 4.17 (95% C.I. 1.07 – 15.4).

Conclusion: We recommend exchange of all the components at the time of revision of PCA knee prostheses. Significance: To our knowledge, this is the only study involving such a large number of PCA revisions and looking into the effect of retaining the femoral component compared to changing both the components on the outcome of revision.


O Aiyenuro O O A Oni

Purpose: Osteochondral grafts are being commonly used to repair articular surface defects. The purpose is to achieve the normal architecture of hyaline cartilage with secure and seamless incorporation into recipient sites. However the details of the incorporation of these grafts have not yet been completely elucidated. The expectation is that graft union would involve the proliferation and/or migration of cells and the secretion of matrix and fibres into the graft-host cleft. The aim of this study was to determine the composition of the graft-to-host repair tissue and the integrity of the surfaces of the transplanted graft.

Method: The medial femoral condyle (WC) of the right knee of 12 adult male New Zealand White rabbits was exposed via a midline incision and medial arthrotomy under a general anaesthetic. A cylindrical 4mm diameter and 4mm long osteochondral graft was obtained using the T- handle harvester (MITEK COR System) and then it was reinserted into the same site. A groin-to-toe plaster of Paris cast was applied and the animals were allowed to recover. At weekly intervals, 3 animals were killed and the MFC was excised, fixed in 10% buffered formalin for a week and decalcified in Kristensen’s solution for another week. The specimens were dehydrated through graded ethanol and amyl acetate. Next, they were critical point dried in Blazers Critical Point Drier CPD 030 giving four 15-minute exchanges through liquid C02 before critical point drying. Finally, the specimens were mounted on aluminium stubs and sputter coated in a Polaron SC7640 Sputter coater for 90 seconds resulting in a layer of Gold/Palladium with an approximate thickness of 673 Ao. The samples were then viewed in the Hitachi S-300H scanning electron microscope.

Results: Cartilage-to-cartilage union was not observed at any time interval. Where cartilage union appeared to have occurred, this was due primarily to press fit or ‘surface weld’. In some cases, the adjoining graft and host surfaces revealed superficial fractures presumably caused, as grafts were malleted into place. There was bony union at the base in all cases. In the later time intervals this union had crept up towards the joint surface. The materials in the cleft between the graft and the recipient bed ranged from fibrous to bony elements. The graft surfaces were smooth like the surrounding normal articular cartilage at 1 and 2 weeks but fibrillated at 3 and 4 weeks.

Conclusions: These results appear to suggest that direct cartilage-to-cartilage healing may not occur following osteochondral grafting. Bone-to-bone healing appears to be universal and rapid and, materials ftom this source may be responsible for gap healing. The results also raise the possibility that the articular surfaces of grafts may deteriorate with time but the reasons are not apparent from this study.


P J Fules R T Madhav R K Goddard M A S Mowbray

Aim: The aim of our study was to evaluate the results of the Soffix Mark 1 and Mark 11 hamstring fixation device, placed transtibially with an “over the top” femoral route when applied to revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery.

Method and results: Twenty nine ACL revisions performed between 1992 – 2000 were evaluated. Twenty six failed prosthetic ligaments, two failed semitendinosus/ gracilis (STG) and one BTB autografts were revised using hamstring grafts in 26, quadriceps in two, and patella bone tendon bone (BTB) in one patient. Mark 1 and 11 fixation devices were employed. Follow up included clinical examination, KT 2000 arthrometric assessment, Lysholm, Tegner and IKDC scoring. The average follow up time was 50 months ±22.4.

Arthrometric examination showed a mean side to side difference (SSD) of 1.66 mm ±1.5. The mean Lysholm score was 87.2 ±12.5 and 22 patients had a B rating (nearly normal) on IKDC scoring.

The Mark II Soffix group had a mean SSD of 1.23 mm ±1.3, a mean Lysholm score of 85.8 ±14.6 and IKDC B rating in 11/15. The lowest clinical scores were in 4 multiply operated knees but the SSDs were comparable with other groups. The Mark 1 Soffix group had a mean SSD of 2.0 mm ±1.6, Lysholm score of 84.6 ±14.3 and 13/16 had a B rating (IKDC). The smaller SSD in the Mark I Soffix was statistically significant (p< 0.05) when compared with the Mark I device. Multiply operated knees had worse IKDC and Lysholm scores (not statistically significant).

Conclusions: We concluded that a revision technique using the STG Soffix fixation device can restore stability with good functional outcomes following failed primary ACL reconstruction. Multiply re-operated knees had the worst functional results despite restoration of stability.


C J Wilson G Tait

Purpose: In this study we intend to evaluate the outcomes of patients with the Rotaglide prosthesis implanted for osteoarthritis.

Method: All patients reviewed had this prosthesis implanted for primary total knee arthroplasty in Cross-house hospital. The minimum follow up period was 5 years (range 5–8). Patients were assessed clinically and results were standardised using the Hospital for Specialist Surgery (HSS) knee score. Standard radiographs were taken in AP and lateral planes to assess for loosening. Case notes were then examined for evidence of complications in the peri and postoperative complications.

Results: Sixty seven patients (73 knees) were reviewed with the Rotaglide total knee replacement implanted for osteoarthritis. 94% of patients had an excellent clinical outcome with HSS scores of 85 or more. The average HSS score was 90.2. Two patients were revised, one for meniscal fracture and one for meniscal dislocation. Two patients were treated with anti-biotics for superficial wound infection.

Conclusions: We feel this prosthesis offers a safe and effective treatment for osteoarthritis with a good clinical outcome at 5 years with a low level of complications.


S Roy C Wilson R Williams A J Sharma C Holt P O’Callaghan

Purpose: In this ongoing trial we are analysing the performance of both a fixed bearing total knee replacement and a mobile bearing total knee replacement using gait analysis and a patient-based questionnaire. We aim to find out if there is a difference in the functional performance of the two types of prosthesis.

Method: Patients are taken from the in-patient waiting list of three consultants and introduced to the trial if deemed suitable. Each patient is analysed once pre-operatively and on three occasions post-operatively (6 weeks, 3 months and 1 year) at the university gait analysis laboratory. At each visit various anthropological measurements are recorded and the patient fills in an “Activities of Daily Living” questionnaire. After calibration and measurement of the passive range of motion of both knees each patient has their gait analysed over a series of six walks using a standard 5 camera system with skin marker clusters, the kinematic data from this is supplemented with force-plate recordings and video analysis of each set of walks. Data is recorded for both of the patient’s knees. The staff in the gait analysis laboratory are blinded as to which prosthesis has been used for each patient in an effort to eliminate bias.

We present our methodology and some preliminary results.


C. L. Le Maitre A. Rajpura A. Watkins W. Watkins W. Staley R. Ross M. Knight A. J. Freemont J. A. Hoyland.

Background: Current treatments for Low back pain (LBP) are often empirical and few directed at the underlying disorder, altered discal cell metabolism, which precipitates the problem. The use of gene therapy to manipulate discal metabolism to treat LBP is an interesting possibility. The Intervertebral disc (IVD) is a therapeutic target in LBP, and one approach to gene therapy would be to isolate IVD chondrocytes (IVDC) and transfer genes Ex Vivo into these cells. Subsequent reinjection of these genetically altered cells into the lumbar IVD, would permit the expression of the trans-gene in vivo, generating the therapeutic protein within the IVD.

Methods: To test the viability of this approach, we isolated human IVDC from patients undergoing surgery, grew them Ex vivo and transfected them with the marker gene LacZ, using an adenovirus vector and the CMV promoter. Expression of the gene was then measured using X-gal staining for the gene product ~-galactosidase.

Results: IVDC infected with adenovirus/CMV-LacZ showed maximal LacZ expression 2 days post infection, with almost 50% of cells displaying X-gal positivity within monolayer cultures and 100% infection within alginate culture, gene expression was maintained up to 4 weeks and control cultures showed no LacZ expression.

Conclusion: This study shows that human IVDC can be transfected with a foreign gene using the adenovirus vector. The gene transduction of a therapeutic gene into IVDC, could provide long lasting effect. In addition the use of inducible promoters could allow for the autoregulation of gene expression.


W. E. B. Johnson S. M. Eisenstein S. Roberts.

Objective: The shape of articular chondrocytes regulates their function, changes in response to mechanical load and is altered in osteoarthritis. We aimed to identify the shape of intervertebral disc cells in pathological and normal tissue.

Design: Immunohistology of human intervertebral discs using cytoskeletal markers to examine disc cell shape.

Subjects: Intervertebral discs from patients with degeneration (n=3), scoliosis (n=3), spondylolisthesis (n=3) and from non-pathological cadaveric spines (n=3).

Outcome measures: (i). Cell shape and (ii). Organisation/ content of cytoskeleton.

Results: In degenerate and normal discs, cells of the anulus fibrosus were generally elongated and bipolar, whilst those of the nucleus pulposus were rounded/oval. However, in localised areas, cells were observed with multiple cytoplasmic processes that extended into the discal matrix. In central regions of scoliotic and, most markedly, spondylolisthetic discs, such cells were more frequent. Their processes were vimentin positive (but F-actin negative) and reached up to 80μm in length. F-actin was clearly present in endothelial cells of blood vessels but absent in disc cells. In contrast, vimentin was expressed by disc cells within the discs’ inner regions, but not towards the outer anulus fibrosus.

Conclusions: The altered shape of disc cells in pathological tissue may reflect areas of abnormal loading. These changes are also likely to affect/reflect altered cell function and therefore have a role to play in the pathological process.


K. Crossman M. Mahon P. Watson J. A. Oldham R. G. Cooper

Background: Prospective population studies demonstrate that poor paraspinal muscle endurance increases the risk of developing first-time LBP and many CLBP studies also document excessive paraspinal muscle fatigability. The question arises as to whether this could have predisposed to chronic symptoms, through impaired spinal instability, especially in light of the wide inter-individual variation observed in the constitutionally determined paraspinal muscle fibre-type composition, which governs contractile performance.

Objective: To determine whether CLBP-associated excessive paraspinal fatigue results from a paucity in the type I fibre content.

Design: Control comparison using male subjects.

Subjects: Thirty-five CLBP patients with Von-Korff Chronic Pain Scores of ≤ III (high level of residual function, despite pain, to negate effects of disuse atrophy), and 32 controls of similar age.

Outcome measures: Fatigue-induced median frequency (MF) declines in the surface EMG signal, monitored bilaterally at L4 level during Biering-Sorensen- and 60%MVC- isometric fatigue tests. Percutaneous para-spinal muscle biopsies permitted histomorphometric comparisons.

Results: Between-group differences were assessed using independent t-tests (p < 0.05). There were no differences for MF decline during the Biering-Sorensen -0.37(0.16) vs. -0.36(0.12), and the 60% MVC test −0.42(0.31) vs −0.51(0.29), and in the percentage number of type I fibres, 63.6% vs 64.3%, or percentage area occupied by type I fibres, 69.4% vs 67.2%, in the paraspinal muscles for patients and controls respectively (p> 0.05).

Conclusion: Impaired CLBP-associated endurance is not the result of a constitutionally ‘adverse’ fibre-type composition.


D Siddall A. M. M. A. Mohsen P Gillespie M. J. Fagan.

Objective: A patient-specific finite element model of the spine is being developed to aid the surgeon in the diagnosis and clinical management of spinal conditions1. To validate the application of the computer model, a laboratory validation spine is being developed. This study is concerned with the development and basic characteristics of the intervertebral disc component of the laboratory spine.

Method: The external profile of the laboratory disc was determined from CT images of a cadaveric spine. A two-part silicon rubber was used to form the annulus part of the disc. Prior to sealing it was possible to fill the cavity with an appropriate medium (such as grease or oil) to represent the nucleus pulposus with the further option of applying external pressurisation through a small pressure inlet in the wall of the disc. The laboratory disc was then tested in denucleated form, and grease-filled with initial intradiscal pressures of 0, 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 MPa. A finite element model of the disc was also developed and used to investigate the characteristics of the laboratory disc.

Results: The agreement between the finite element results and experimental test results was excellent and the compressive and flexural load-deflection characteristics of both intact and denucleated laboratory discs were found to lie within the range of values reported in the literature for cadaveric discs. Disc bulge characteristics of the intact and denucleated silicon discs were also similar to that observed with natural discs in vitro.

Conclusions: An artificial disc for a laboratory validation spine has been developed and shown to have representative characteristic properties in compression loading. The disc is now being modelled and tested in torsion.


P. Pollintine S. J. Garbutt J. Tobias P. Dolan M. A. Adams.

Introduction. : Measurements of overall vertebral bone mineral density (BMDv) do not adequately explain the observed patterns of osteoporotic vertebral fracture. Perhaps bone loss from specific regions of the vertebra has a more important effect on vertebral strength, and risk of fracture, than overall bone loss? We hypothesise that ‘stress shielding’ of the anterior vertebral body by the neural arch in erect standing postures can reduce BMDv in the anterior vertebral body and thereby reduce vertebral compressive strength.

Materials and Methods: A compressive force of 1.5kN was applied to lumbar ‘motion segments’. positioned to simulate erect standing posture. Compressive stresses within the intervertebral disc were measured by pulling a miniature pressure transducer through it. ‘Stress profiles’ were integrated over area to calculate the total compressive force on the disc1. This was subtracted from the 1.5kN to calculate the force resisted by the neural arch. Motion segments were then compressed to failure in moderate flexion (to simulate heavy lifting) and their compressive strength obtained. After disarticulation, the BMDv, of the whole and the anterior half of each vertebral body was measured by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA). We report preliminary results from 9 specimens, aged 72–92 yrs.

Results: Vertebral strength (in flexion) was inversely related to load-bearing by the neural arch in erect posture (r2=0.42, p=0.05). Strength was directly related to the BMDv of the whole (r2=0.65, p=0.06) and the anterior (r2=0.8, p=0.005) vertebral body.

Conclusions: These results suggest that habitual load-bearing by the neural arch in erect postures can lead to stress shielding of the anterior vertebral body so that the latter losesBMDv, and the vertebra is weakened in the anterior vertebral body appears to be a BMDv better predictor of vertebral strength than BMDv, of the whole vertebra.


V. Jasani D. Jaffray

Objective: To establish the anatomy of the iliolumbar vein.

Design: Prosections of human cadavers were examined.

Subjects: Sixteen iliolumbar veins in eight cadavers. Outcome measures: Width, length, pattern of drainage, tributaries, distance from IVC to the iho lumbar vein, structures drained and immediate relations. The risk of avulsion on great vessel retraction to expose the L4/L5 disc.

Results: Two variants encountered; a single vein an average 3.74cms from the IVC (11/16), or two stems, an average of 2.98cms to the proximal and 6.04cms to the distal (5/16). All 16 veins tore on great vessel retraction. In all veins the obturator nerve was found to cross superficially an average 2.76cms lateral to the mouth, in four cases, the actual distance was less than 1.5cms. In 15 veins the lumbosacral trunk crossed deep, in one superficial. The average distance from the mouth was 2.5 cms, in three veins the actual distance was 1cm or less.

Conclusion: This study confirms variability in the vein with vulnerability to avulsion on retraction of the great vessels. The close relationship with the obturator nerve and lumbosacral trunk further emphasise the need for proper exposure of the vein prior to ligature and safe surgical exposure of the anterior lumbar spine. Other findings are also presented.


A. K. D. Goswami M. T. N. Knight A. J. Freemont

Objectives: To examine and correlate the presence of neovascularisation, crystalline pyrophosphate deposits and other hisotological features in the disc and discogenic pain established by spinal probing and discography under aware state endoscopic visualisation.

Design: Tissue removed from intervertebral discs of 224 patients during surgery were examined by direct and polarised microscopy to identify the presence of calcium pyrophosphate and neovascularisation.

Material and Methods: Histology was correlated to the diagnostic provocative findings of spinal probing and discography, discal palpation during aware state endoscopy.

Results: Calcium Pyrophosphate: 20/224 (9%) patients demonstrated calcium pyrophosphate in the discs. Fourteen had pain reproduced on probing or discography; 13/20 (65%) of patients had either an annular collection or leak at the index level; 6/20 had an extradiscal cause of pain.

Neovascularisation: Thirty-seven out of 224 (16.5%) patients showed neovascularisation in the disc; four discs had crystalline pyrophosphate deposits; 33/37 (90%) had pain on probing and/or discography.

Conclusion: The presence of pyrophosphate in a disc without a tear or leak is not associated with annular tenderness. The presence of pyrophosphates in radial tears or leaks is associated with annular tenderness. Annular tears or leaks are not directly correlated to the presence of pyrophosphates. There is a high correlation between pain provocation and neovascularisation.


S. Roberts I. W. McCall J. P. G. Urban J. Menage E. H. Evans C. Evans S. M. Eisenstein.

Objective: To determine if (a) inflammatory mediators are present in herniated intervertebral discs and (b) if their presence correlates with inflammation of nerve roots or symptoms.

Design: Inflammation was assessed with gadolinium enhancement of MRI. Neurological compromise was measured. Disc tissue was examined for inflammatory mediators IL-1α and β, IL-6, MCP-1, TSG-6, iNOS, TNFα and thromboxane.

Patients: Sixty-five discs were removed from 64 patients undergoing surgery for disc prolapse.

Outcome measures: We developed (i) an MRI score to assess inflammation radiologically prior to surgery (n=28, mean 4.9±6.8 days), (ii) a Surgical Score to assess inflammation of the nerve roots at surgery (n=44), (iii) a Clinical Score to determine pain, disability and neurological compromise (n=17) and (iv) a Mediator Score to reflect the number and amount of inflammatory mediators present (n=20).

Results: Thirty percent of the prolapses in this study were extrusions, 19% sequestrations and 51% protrusions. Sixteen of the 28 patients with gadolinium had nerve root enhancement (86% of the extrusions, 57% of sequestrations, and 43% of protrusions), whilst 19 had enhancement of or around the disc herniation itself (71% of the extrusions, 86% of sequestrations and 57% of protrusions). The Mediator Scores were highest for the sequestrations (as was the Surgical Score) and lowest for the protrusions, but extruded discs had most IL-1α and β, IL-6, TNFα and thromboxane. Extruded discs had the highest Clinical Score and sequestrated the lowest.

Conclusions: Mediators produced in prolapsed disc appear to play an important role in inflammation of adjacent tissue and nerve roots. The type of mediator present and proximity of the prolapse to the nerve root may be the important factors in determining which pro-lapses are the most painful.


S. R. S. Bibby D. A. Jones J. P. G. Urban.

Objective: To develop and use a closed chamber to study the metabolism of isolated disc cells under controlled conditions such as reduced pH.

Design: Disc cells were incubated in the chamber for four hours, while embedded electrodes measured pH and pO2. A port allowed sampling.

Subjects: Nucleus pulposus cells were isolated from the coccygeal discs of 33 steers (18–24 months old), within three hours of slaughter.

Outcome measures: Metabolic rates were calculated from concentration changes. Cell viability was assesed on completion.

Results: At pH 7.4, metabolic rates were similar to those measured in tissue [1, 2] with lactic acid production and oxygen consumption rates of 157 and 12 nmol/million cells/hour respectively, and a 1: 2 ratio of glucose consumption: lactic acid production. Lactic acid production and oxygen consumption fell with extracellular pH, to 89 and 65 nmol/million cells/hour (lactate) and 8 and 5 nmol/million cells/hour (oxygen), at pH 6.7 and pH 6.2 respectively.

Conclusions: These results show a fall in lactic acid production and oxygen consumption with extracellular acid-ification. There is a complex interplay between different components of the nutritional environment. Investigating these in combination should give valuable information about disc cell metabolism, as changes can affect nutrient availability and hence cellular activity, viability, and matrix production rates.


I. D. Beith J. O’Dowd P. J. Harrison

Objective: To investigate the reflex control of the internal oblique (IO) muscles

Design: Reflex activity in the IO muscles was evoked by (i) tapping each IO muscle in turn and (ii) tapping the abdomen in the midline to produce a stretch of equal magnitude in both muscles. Muscle activity was recorded using surface EMG.

Subjects: Seventeen asymptomatic subjects and one subject with scoliosis.

Outcome measures: Onset latency and normalised amplitude of reflexes

Results: Tapping the IO muscle on one side evoked large reflex responses in both ipsilateral and contralateral IO muscles. Across all subjects the reflexes in these two muscles were of equal amplitude (p=0.12). Measurements of onset latency suggest that both reflexes are monosynaptic in origin. Tapping in the midline also produced large amplitude responses. In two subjects, the response in one IO muscle was always larger than the other, irrespective of which of the three points was tapped, and this was repeatable. One of these subjects has a scoliosis.

Conclusions: The IO muscle is usually controlled from ipsilateral and contralateral muscle afferents. In a scoliotic subject this afferent activity was biased to the IO muscle on one side, and may therefore be associated with this condition


M. Krishna

Objective: Assess outcomes following a three-month multi-disciplinary spinal rehabilitation program for chronic low back pain, based in the community in a £10 million sports centre.

Design: This was a prospective study with data being collected before and at the completion of the programme. The programme team consists of an orthopaedic surgeon, physiotherapists, fitness instructor, nurse counsellor and a secretary. The programme included a graded aerobic fitness programme, spinal stabilisation programme, cognitive behavioural therapy, hydrotherapy and occupational therapy.

Subjects: 112 patients with chronic mechanical back pain. Mean duration of symptoms 9.1 years. Mean age was 46 years: 52 women and 60 men.

Outcome Measures: Included visual analogue score, Oswestry Disability Score (OSW), lumbar motion velocity, shuttle walking test, lifting endurance, isometric strength of spinal extension and flexion and the return to work rate.

Results: Mean VAS back pain and leg pain scores reduced from 6.6 to 4.1 and 3.7 to 2.2 respectively (p< 0.001). Mean OSW decreased from 34.6% to 21.7% (p< 0.001). Back pain improved by 37% and the Oswestry score by 42%. Only three of the 112 patients went on to have surgery. Mean lumbar motion velocity improved from 114 to 161 degrees/second (P< 0.001). Shuttle walking test improved from 458 to 644 metres (p< 0.001). Mean lifting maximum improved from 16.1 to 19.3Kg (p=0.005). Lifting endurance improved from 51 to 38 seconds. Mean Isometric spinal extensor strength improved from 24.2Kg to 48.6Kg and flexion from 25.7 to 49.4Kg (p< 0.001 in all cases). Thirty-eight percent of patients were unemployed before the program and 10% after the program. Patients also reported needing less analgesia, having more confidence, feeling happier and their flare-ups settling more quickly.

Conclusions: This three-month programme delivered significant improvements in back pain, disability, strength and endurance capacity and a return to work rate, in this cohort of chronic back pain patients.


A. Khot M. G. Bowditch J. M. Powell D. J. Sharp.

Objective: To report a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of the therapeutic efficacy of intradiscal steroid injection for the treatment of discogenic back pain after two years.

Introduction: Discography remains the main method to assess whether a degenerate disc is the source of back pain. The treatment of such discogenic pain is difficult. There is only one previous RCT of the use intradiscal steroids, but with a short follow-up.

Patients and Methods: 120 consecutive patients with positive discography were randomised intra-operatively to receive an intradiscal injection of saline or 40mgs Depomedrone. Outcome was assessed using a back pain questionnaire at six weeks, three and six months, and at two years. Pain (using a visual analogue score), disability (the Oswestry Disability Index), and psychological status (DRAM score) were measured. The results were correlated with Modic changes and high intensity zones on MRI scan.

Results: An initial improvement of back pain in the steroid group is not maintained at two years, with no statistical difference between the two groups. Correlation of the results with the MRI findings will be presented.

Conclusion: This study demonstrates the need for long-term follow-up of such intradiscal therapeutic methods of treating discogenic pain.


S. Brealey

Objective: The UK BEAM trial was designed to evaluate treatments for back pain in primary care. The objective is to briefly describe the different treatments and to present the frequency with which trial participants attended for manipulation, exercise or both.

Design: The UK BEAM trial is a national randomised factorial trial in primary care. Participants were randomised to receive one of GP management, exercise classes, manipulation (in either private or NHS premises) or both exercise classes and manipulation. Participants randomised to manipulation alone could receive up to eight sessions delivered by a chiropractor, an osteopath, or a physiotherapist. Those randomised to exercise alone could attend up to nine sessions led by a physiotherapist in a local community facility. Subsequently, those randomised to manipulation followed by exercise could attend up to 17 sessions.

Subjects: Participants were recruited from 150 GP practices in 14 centres distributed across the United Kingdom. The target population was patients between 18 and 65 years who present in general practice with non-specific back pain with or without leg pain.

Outcome Measures: The frequency that participants attended for manipulation, exercise, or both.

Results: The trial recruited 1334 participants. The current analysis shows the mean number of sessions attended by participants for manipulation alone is 6.6. The mean number of sessions attended for exercise alone is 4.4. In contrast, those participants randomised to manipulation followed by exercise attended 5.2 and 3.4 sessions respectively.

Conclusions: Those participants who were randomised to manipulation followed by exercise attended fewer sessions on average than those randomised to manipulation or exercise alone.


J. A. Alonso D. C. Bancroft A. J. Barrett J. Doyle.

Objective: To assess the effect of the Active Spinal Rehabilitation Programme (ASRP) at four years after completion and its impact upon re-referral rates to General Practitioners and Orthopaedic Consultants.

Design: Patients included in the previous twelve-month follow-up study were sent a further explanatory letter and questionnaire including functional goal, exercise, analgesia intake, GP visit, consultant referral, employment status, revised Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Index and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS)

Subjects: The first 140 patients completing the programme between April 1997–1998 were included in this study. An overall response rate of 85% (119 out of 140) was achieved with the aid of a follow-up telephone call (to those who did not respond to the postal questionnaire)

Results: The results obtained were comparable to those at one-year follow up. There was an improved VAS in 46% of the patients at four years post ASRP compared with VAS immediately after completion. The Oswestry Score was improved (decrease in patient perceived disability) in 55% of the patients. 56% of the patients achieved their functional goal and 83% felt in control of their pain. 57% of the patients did not visit their GP in the 12 months prior to the four-year follow up and 76% did not require Consultant referral after completing ASRP.

Conclusion: This study shows that the multiple benefits of an active spinal rehabilitation programme can be maintained for a four-year period, with a significant reduction in the demands on NHS resources.


S. Coulton

Objective: Systematic reviews show beneficial effects of spinal manipulation, general exercise and ‘active management’ on the part of general practitioners in the treatment of back pain. The objective of UK BEAM is to evaluate the effectiveness of these treatments for back pain.

Design: The UK BEAM trial is a national randomised factorial trial in primary care. Participants were randomised to receive GP active management, exercise classes, manipulation (in either private or NHS premises) or both exercise classes and manipulation.

Subjects: Participants were recruited from 150 GP practices in 14 centres distributed across the United Kingdom. The target population was patients between 18 and 65 years who present in general practice with non-specific back pain with or without leg pain. To avoid carry over effects participants would not have had physical therapy in he previous three months. To avoid participants who recover without specific treatment, participants were included in the trial only if their current episode had lasted at least four weeks. There was no upper limit to the duration of pain.

Outcome Measures: At baseline, one month, three months and twelve months participants completed questionnaires which included questions about general health, experience of back pain, beliefs about back pain, functional disability and costs to both the NHS and participants themselves.

Results: The trial recruited 1334 participants, of which 84% and 77% completed the one and three month questionnaires. At randomisation, the mean Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) score was 9.0 points (sd = 4.0). This improved to 6.8 points (sd = 4.8) at one month and to 5.5 points (sd = 5.0) at three months.

Conclusions: Preliminary blinded results show an improvement in RDQ scores across all participants. The primary analysis, available late 2002, will estimate he main effects of exercise and manipulation, each compared to GP care.


S. R. Woby P. J. Watson N. K. Roach K. M. Birch M. Urmston.

Objective: To determine the extent to which coping strategies mediate chronic low back pain (CLBP) disability in patients presenting for physiotherapy.

Subjects: CLBP patients presenting for their first assessment at an outpatient physiotherapy department were used (N = 90; 60% male; M age = 41 yrs; SD ± 10).

Design: The mediating role of coping strategies was investigated after controlling for the influence of recorded demographics, healthcare variables and pain. Hierarchical multiple regression was employed with disability1 as the dependent variable. Independent variables were entered in three separate steps. Demographics (sex, age and socioeconomic status) were entered in Step one. Healthcare and Pain variables (leg pain, previous surgery, history of back pain and current pain intensity [VAS]) were entered in Step two. Three coping dimensions (Adaptive Coping, Maladaptive Coping and Efficacy of Pain Management), derived from a factor analysis of the Coping Strategies Questionnaire2, were entered in the final Step.

Results: Demographics accounted for 14% of the variance in disability [F (3, 86) = 4.81, P =. 004]. Healthcare and Pain variables accounted for an additional 17% of the variance [F (4, 82) = 5.11, P =. 001]. The three coping dimensions accounted for a further 6% of the variance [F (3, 79) = 2.71, P =. 05]. The model accounted for 38% of the variance in disability [F (10, 79) = 4.81, P =. 000].

Conclusion: Coping did mediate levels of CLBP disability. Moreover, disability is influenced more by Adaptive (Standardised β = −. 26, P =. 02) and Maladaptive (Standardised β =. 27, P =. 02) coping strategies than Efficacy of Pain Management (Standardised β =. 07, P > . 05).


S. Bartys A. K. Burton P. J. Watson I. Wright C. Mackay C. J. Main.

Objective: To implement an early occupational intervention which tackles the psychosocial factors (yellow and blue flags) that influence recovery from occupational back pain.

Design: An early, psychosocial, occupational health nurse-led intervention using a basic ‘counselling’ technique that reinforces evidence-based messages and advice, along with availability of modified work.

Subjects: 206 workers from a sample of Glaxosmithkline sites who took absence due to back pain.

Outcome measures: Duration of presenting absence.

Results: The target for contacting the worker was achieved at Site 1 (mean 3 days), but not Site 2 (mean 12 days). Results showed that late contact of absent workers (> 1 week) was significantly associated with both longer presenting absence and fewer recipients of the psychosocial intervention, compared with early contact. Preliminary results show that the psychosocial intervention (irrespective of early or late contact) reduces the length of presenting absence by half.

Conclusions: The lack of early contact at Site 2 was due to local sickness absence management differences. This study reveals a third class of obstacles to recovery – organisational policies (black flags) – that can negate the effect of occupational rehabilitation programs.


P. Silva M. L. Newey

Objective: To evaluate the use of standard outcome measures in assessing individuals attending a functional restoration programme with chronic back pain.

Design: Prospective collection of data from standard outcome measures used to assess patients attending a functional restoration programme. Data was collected before the start of the programme and six weeks, six months and one year after completion of the programme.

Subjects: There were 69 individuals (33 males and 36 females) with an average age of 41 years, who attended the programme from February 1999 to February 2001.

Outcome measures: Visual Analogue Score (VAS) for pain, Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), Short Form 36 (SF36), the Distress Risk Assessment Measures (MSP and MZDI)

Results: During the follow-up period, outcome scores showed only modest improvement compared to pre-programme scores. This was not necessarily reflected in the clinical and functional progress of patients.

Conclusions: Standard outcome measure may not necessarily reflect patient response to rehabilitation programmes.


S. Ahuja I. D. Russell J. Howes P. R. Davies

Purpose: The purpose of this prospective study is to evaluate the benefits of this treatment for discogenic back pain.

Method: Thirty-four patients with chronic discogenic back pain underwent this therapy. All the patients had a failed trial of conservative treatment. Patients with a positive provocative discogram were selected for intra-discal electrothermal therapy (IDET). The outcome is assessed using a SF 36 questionnaire filled in pre-procedure and then at three, six, twelve and eighteen months and two years post-operatively.

Results: The mean age group of the patients was 37 years (range 15–58 years). All the patients had a minimum follow up of 12 months (range 6–2 years). Out of the 34 patients 5(14%) had no improvement and had to undergo an interbody fusion following IDET. No patient developed any neurological complications. At a minimum of one year follow-up 56% patients had improvement in physical function scores and 52% had improvement in pain scores as per the SF 36.

Conclusion: Thus IDET appears to be an effective procedure in the short-term relief of discogenic back pain in patients who otherwise might be candidates for fusion.


A. Singh H. A. Crockard.

Introduction: To examine if an individual’s timed walk in sufficiently reproducible to correlate with the degree of spondylitic myelopathy and if surgical decompression has measurement effect on performance.

Methods: A 30mm timed walk, including a turn. The number of paces counted.

Forty-one non-myelopathic individuals were obtained. There was good inter-and intra-observer reliability.

Age matched with 41 patients referred to five neurosurgeons with spondylitic myelopathy were measured prior to surgery and at three, six, twelve, and twenty-four months postoperatively.

Results: The mean control walking time and steps was 64.7 ± 8.4 seconds 46.9 ± 1.2 steps. The mean patients preoperative walking time and steps was 85.4 ± 11.2 seconds; 74.8 ± 5.3 steps and postoperative 64.7 ± 8.4 seconds; 63.5 ± 4.2 steps.

Significant improvement following surgery (p = 0.0018 and p = 5.87 x 10−6 respectively) and improvement maintained for at least two years after surgery.

Discussion and Conclusions:

The test is reproducible and reliable with good sensitivity and specificity.

It shows validity and relevance when compared to other functional scales such as Myelopathy Disability and Nurick.

Changes following surgery can be measured.

A multi-centered trial is recommended.


M. Krishna J. M. Bradburn D. Poles J. Feary C. K. Bhatia

Objective : To share our experience developing an integrated spinal service, including a Spinal Assessment Clinic (SAC), Data Collection Centre, self-help Spinal Fitness Programme, three month Multi-disciplinary Spinal Rehabilitation Programme surgical service and Spinal Support Group. The Service was commended in the National Nye Bevan Awards and won the Millennium Nurse of the Year award surgical category.

Design: The SAC has operated for three and a half years and includes two nurse practitioners and an extended scope physiotherapist. Over 1000 patients per year are assessed, investigated, educated and commenced on a management plan by the practitioners, including data collection pre and post treatment. The three-month Rehabilitation programme is based in a sports complex and runs in collaboration with the private sector. The patients seen by MK are fully investigated and have failed conservative measures. The patient-led Spinal Support Group counsels all patients prior to treatment, feeding back related problems. The sole consultant (MK) has developed formal links with another spinal surgeon combining operating, clinical and audit sessions.

Outcome measures: Reduced out-patient waiting times, patient satisfaction survey, discharge rate following self-help Spinal Fitness Programme, number of complaints.

Results: Waiting time reduced from 89 to 16 weeks, urgent cases are seen within twenty-four hours. One hundred patients polled by questionnaire: 70% regarded their experience through SAC as excellent, 28% good and 2% fair. 70% were discharged six months following the self- help Spinal Fitness Programme. SAC had three complaints in three years, none for a missed diagnosis.

Conclusion: We would commend this service model for consideration by our colleagues.


C. V. J. Morgan-Hough P. W. Jones S. M. Eisenstein

Objective: To identify risk factors associated with patients that required revision surgery for sciatica.

Design: A retrospective study of 580 patients who underwent surgery for intractable sciatica attributable to pro-lapsed lumbar intervertebral disc from 1986 to 2000 inclusive.

Subjects: The study included a total of 580 patients. Of these seven patients had an operation at two levels, 25 patients had had a primary operation elsewhere and were therefore excluded; four sets of notes remain missing. The total number of primary operations analysed was therefore 558.

Outcome measures: Parameters such as gender, age, level and side of discectomy were entered into a database for analysis. Diagnostic and clinical parameters were also entered; these included the value of the angle of the straight leg raise recorded and absence or presence of neurological deficit (altered sensation, reduced motor power, and absent or diminished reflexes). Operative findings recorded and entered were the type of disc at operation (i. e. protrusion, extrusion and sequestration) and the presence of free cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), however minor, indicating a dural tear.

Results: The total number of primary discectomies was 558 of which 43 went on to require a second operation, giving a revision rate of 7.71%. Of the primary discectomies, 356 were protrusions, 92 extrusions and 110 sequestration. Of the 43 that went onto revision surgery, 35 were protrusions, two extrusion and six sequestration. A significant association was found with primary disc protrusions, this type of disc prolapse was almost three times more likely to go on to need revision surgery compared to extruded or sequestrated discs. Data analysed on primary protrusions showed these patients had a significantly greater straight leg raise angle and reduced incidence of positive neurological findings and so could be identified clinically.

Conclusions: This lead us to conclude that the group of patients with primary protrusions could be selected out and treated conservatively since they are three times more likely to require revision surgery.


S. R. Woby N. K. Roach P. J. Watson K. M. Birch M. Urmston.

Objective: To assess the psychometric properties of the Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia (TSK)1.

Subjects: Eighty-four chronic low back pain (CLBP) patients presenting for their first assessment at an outpatient physiotherapy department were used (57% female; M age = 45 yrs; SD ± 10 yrs).

Design: Eighty-four patients completed the TSK. Internal consistency, item-total correlations, distribution of scores on each item, three-day test-retest reliability and responsiveness were then calculated. To determine responsiveness, patients were categorised into two groups, namely meaningful change in pain-related fear (Group 1) and non-meaningful change in pain-related fear (Group 2). Patients were categorised based on their response to a thirteen-point global rating scale (GRS). Standardised Response Means (SRMs)2 were computed for each group.

Results: Internal consistency was excellent (Cronbach α = 0.82). With the exception of items 8 and 16 all item-total correlations exceeded the level of 0.20. Scores were normally distributed for most items, however, items 4, 12 and 14 were positively skewed (Z-scores > 1.96). Test-retest coefficients were high (ICC = 0.91). SRMs were −0.96 and −0.44 for Groups 1 and 2, respectively, thus indicating good discriminatory power. An adapted version of the TSK (MTSK-12), constructed from the twelve most psychometrically robust items, had comparable reliability and validity (Cronbach α = 0.82; ICC = 0.91; SRM [Group 1] = 0.89; SRM [Group 2] = 0.39).

Conclusion: Overall the TSK has excellent psychometric properties. The MTSK-12 is a valid and reliable measure of pain-related fear and warrants further investigation.


S. R. Woby N. K. Roach P. J. Watson K. M. Birch M. Urmston

Objective: To determine the factor structure of the Coping Strategies Questionnaire (CSQ)1 in chronic low back pain patients (CLBP) presenting for physiotherapy.

Subjects: CLBP patients presenting for their first assessment at an outpatient physiotherapy department were used (N = 105; 60% male; M age = 41 yrs; SD ± 10).

Design: A factor analysis, using varimax rotation, was performed on patients’ responses to the CSQ. Factors emerging with eigenvalues of ≥1 were considered. A coping strategy was included in a factor if it correlated with the factor at a level greater than 0.6.

Results: Three factors accounted for 70% of the variance in questionnaire responses. Factor 1, labeled Adaptive Coping, accounted for 35% of the variance and comprised the subscales for reinterpreting pain sensations, ignoring pain sensations, and coping self-statements. Factor 2, labeled Maladaptive Coping, accounted for 23% of the variance and comprised the subscales for diverting attention, catastrophizing, praying or hoping, and behavioural coping styles. The final factor, labeled Efficacy of Pain Management, accounted for 12% of the variance and comprised the two single-item scales. Adaptive Coping was positively correlated with Maladaptive Coping (r = 0.37, P < 0.01). Efficacy of Pain Management was positively correlated with Adaptive Coping (r = 0.28, P < 0.01). A non-significant negative correlation was found between Maladaptive Coping and Efficacy of Pain Management (r = −0.03, P > 0.05).

Conclusion: Three underlying factors, labelled Adaptive Coping, Maladaptive Coping, and Efficacy of Pain Management accounted for 70% of the variance in questionnaire responses.


S. Disney J. C. T Fairbank P. B. Pynsent

The Oswestry Disability Index has become one of the major condition specific outcome measures for spinal problems. The original version has been in use since the late 1970’s. It was modified in 1985 by a MRC Working Group. Innumerable papers have cited the ODI and many of these have used the ODI as an outcome. It has been translated into at least five other languages.

The understanding of the validation and behaviour of outcome measures has expanded considerably in the 22 years since the ODI was first published. Many studies have been done on the ODI in conjunction with other spinal outcome measures. This material has now been brought together on a new website (www.merc.wlv.ac.uk/ODI/index.htm). This includes an interactive version of the ODI for self-assessment (which can be downloaded), a large bibliography and frequently asked questions. The site also contains some of the translations and other English versions.


S. Fahy P. T. Diep J. Doyle V. Gadyar Z. Mollah.

Objective: To assess the clinical effectiveness of dexamethasone wound infiltration post lumbar discectomy.

Design: A prospective, double blind, randomised study comparing morphine consumption in two groups of patients in elective lumbar spine surgery via the posterior approach.

Subjects: There were forty patients divided into two randomly selected groups, one received postoperative wound infiltration with dexamethasone, the other with saline. Their morphine usage was measured.

Outcome measures: These included levels of morphine use postoperatively, pain scores and length of hospital stay.

Results: There was no statistically significant difference between postoperative morphine consumption in the two groups or in the length of hospital stay. There appeared to be improvement in pain scores with dexamethasone. There were no complications.

Conclusion: Postoperative wound infiltration with dexamethasone may result in some subjective improvement in pain, but none in analgesic consumption. Despite the lack of complications the subjective benefits do not outweigh the risks in the absence of objective improvement in pain.


D. Dillon S. Ahuja S. Evans C. Holt J. Howes P. R. Davies.

Objective: Controversy exists as to whether the biomechanical properties of a 360° lumbar fusion are influenced by the order in which the anterior and posterior components of the procedure are performed.

Methods: The fusion technique used Mager screws to effect the posterior fusion and a Syncage implant (Stratec) to effect the anterior component of the fusion. Isolated motion segments from five calf spines were tested in each of two groups. In the first group the posterior fusion was performed first and in the second group the anterior fusion was performed first. Loads were applied as a dead weight of 2Nm in each range of movement of the spine (flexion/extension, lateral flexion and rotation). The range of movement was measured using the Qualisys motion analysis system, using external marker clusters attached to the vertebral bodies. Each motion segment was tested prior to instrumentation, post anterior or posterior instrumentation and with both anterior and posterior instrumentation.

Results: Ranges of movement following 360° instrumentation were decreased in all planes. When posterior fixation was performed first; flexion/extension reduced to 55% compared to 26% with anterior fixation first (p=0.020), in lateral flexion 34% v 18% (p=0.382), and in rotation 73% v 18%(p=0.034).

Conclusions: The 360° fusion construct has reduced range of movement if the anterior first approach is used as compared to posterior first approach. Posterior fixation should not be performed prior to anterior fixation as this results in a significant loss of stability in both flexion/extension and rotation.


Y. L. Leung M. P. Grevitt L. M. Henderson.

Objective: Determine the incidence of abnormal somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEP) in patients with ‘at risk’ spinal cords undergoing anterior spinal deformity surgery.

Design: A retrospective chart and SSEP trace review of cases between 1982–2001.

Subjects: Patients undergoing elective anterior spinal deformity surgery were included. Excluded were those with inadequate SSEP monitoring or no pre-operative MRI scan.

Outcome measures: Paraparesis due to cord ischaemia based on an abnormal SSEP trace, i. e. > 50% decrease in SSEP baseline amplitude +/− > 10% increase in latency1.

Results: Partial data was available for 1982–1990, thus analysis was based on cases between 1990–2001.871 patients underwent elective anterior spinal deformity surgery, 11% were ‘at risk cords’; 2% demonstrated intraoperative SSEP changes. Post operative paraparesis ws found in 0.6%. Intra-operative changes were significantly more common in ‘at risk cords’ (chi-squared test = 30.3, df = 2; p< 0.005). No statistical difference in the incidence of paraparesis in normal cords vs ‘at risk’ cords.

Conclusions: Post operative neurological deficit is rare in anterior spinal deformity surgery. Significant SSEP changes do occur with ligation of segmental vessels, implying cord ischaemia. Therefore, for the ‘at risk cord’, these patients should be considered for spinal cord monitoring and temporary clamping of segmental vessels prior to their division


R. Nannapaneni N. V. Todd.

Objective: To reassess whether the Ranawat IIIB (quadriparetic, non-ambulant) rheumatoid arthritis (RA) with cervical myelopathy patients should be surgically treated.

Study Design: Retrospective study

Subjects: Over a 12-year period (1988–1999), 51 patients [15 M: 36F; mean age 64 years] in Ranawat IIIB with RA were diagnosed to have cervical myelopathy. These included 47 patients with atlantoaxial subluxation (AAS) [15 with AAS alone, 10 with basilar invagination (BI), 18 with associated subaxial subluxation (SAS) and four patients with BI and SAS] and four patients with SAS alone.

Results: Thirty-two patients considered fit for surgery successfully underwent operative treatment (Group 1). All underwent posterior instrumented fixation with or without transoral odontoid peg excision. Postoperatively 22/27 patients were pain free and 21/32 patients initially non-ambulant were able to walk. 3/26 patients died within six months of surgery. 13/19 patients managed conservatively (Group 2) because of medical complications died within six months of presentation.

Conclusions: Even in advanced stages of cervical myelopathy in RA, surgical intervention is beneficial with significantly higher morbidity/mortality in conservatively managed patients.


J. R. McConnell B. J. C. Freeman E. Bevan-Davies G. Ampat U. Debnath J. K. Webb.

Objective: To determine if a porous, coralline-derived hydroxyapatite block (ProOsteon 500TM, Interpore, Irvine, CA) is a suitable substitute for tricortical iliac crest autograft in cervical interbody fusion.

Design: A prospective randomised trial with two-year follow-up comparing clinical and radiographic outcomes in patients receiving either iliac crest or hydroxyapatite grafts in cervical interbody fusion.

Subjects: Twenty-nine patients undergoing cervical fusion and anterior plating were randomised to receive either iliac crest (Group I) or hydroxyapatite (Group II) interbody grafts. Fourteen patients (19 grafts) in Group I and twelve patients (18 grafts) in Group II were available for final analysis. Both groups were similar with respect to age, sex, diagnosis and levels fused.

Outcome Measures: The SF-36 and Oswestry Disability Index were used to measure clinical outcome. Post-op and final follow-up radiographs were analysed for graft fragmentation, loss of height, loss of angular alignment and hardware failure to assess structural integrity of the graft. Computed or plain tomography was used to evaluate fusion.

Results: Groups I and II demonstrated improvement in preoperative scores for bodily pain (p=. 016 and. 016 respectively) and physical functioning (p=. 050 and. 016 respectively) at final follow-up. There was no significant difference in SF-36 and Oswestry scores between the two groups. Successful radiographic fusion was similar in both groups (79% in Group I and 76% in Group II). Graft fragmentation occurred in 89% of the hydroxyapatite grafts and 11% of the autografts (p=. 001). Greater than 2mm of graft height and 3° of segmental lordosis were lost in 55% of hydroxyapatite grafts vs. 11% of autografts (p=. 009). One patient in Group II and none in Group I required revision surgery for graft failure. The high rate of early radiographic failure in the hydroxyapatite grafts prompted suspension of further enrolment in the clinical trial.

Conclusions: ProOsteon 500 coralline hydroxyapatite blocks do not possess adequate structural integrity to resist axial loading and maintain disc height or segmental lordosis during cervical interbody fusion.


J. D. Lafuente A. T. H. Casey A. Singh.

Objective: To assess the safety and efficacy of a novel Artificial Cervical Disc.

Design: Compare the Bryan prosthesis to Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion (ACDF), by using the pre-defined objective performance criteria (OPC) derived from a literature meta-analysis of ACDF in which a success rate of 73% was established. The Null hypothesis is that the success rate for the Bryan prosthesis is greater or equal to the OPC (Objective Performance Criteria) of 85%. Secondary Objectives studied included the range of motion after implantation; adverse events from implantation onwards; maintenance of the disc space height; amount of subsidence. Radiology was assessed by an independent radiologist. Improvement in the quality of life for the patient (SF-36) was also recorded at six weeks, six months and one year. Data was collected by an independent research practitioner.

Subjects: Multicentre study seven European centres: 107 patients Male 51, Female 66. Age ranged from 27 to 71. Mean age was 42 years with a clinical diagnosis of cervical radiculopathy or myelopathy, and single level disc disease on MRI.

Outcome Measures: Odom Criteria, SF-36, radiological range of movement.

Results: The Bryan Cervical Disc was associated with a clinical success according to Odom’s criteria of 87%. Radiological success occurred in 97%. SF-36 analysis revealed a statistically significant improvement in all domains.

Conclusion: The Bryan Disc has been successfully implanted in 107 patients with good clinical results and at one-year follow-up there is radiological evidence of preserved motion.


R. W. Kulkarni J. A. N. Shepperd.

Objective: This is a prospective study by an independent observer in which outcomes of 118 anterior lumbar interbody fusions (ALIF), done for discogram-concordant axial low back pain, were evaluated. Aims of the study were to assess overall functional and comprehensive outcomes, predictors of outcome, and whether ALIF alone can be recommended for low back pain.

Design: The functional and patient perception assessment was based on a self-evaluation back pain questionnaire, which consisted of Oswestry Disability Index, Pain Chart, Numerical Rating Scales (NRS) for back pain and leg pain and SF-36-Version II. The comprehensive outcomes were categorised as satisfactory (excellent, good or improved) and unsatisfactory (fair, poor, unimproved or worse).

Results: Overall, we had 61% satisfactory outcomes. Average percentage change in ODI, NRS and SF-36 PCS scores was statistically quite significant. However, patients who had previous posterolateral fusion at the same level had satisfactory outcome in 81%. Incidence of non-union was higher in two-level fusions than one-level fusions, and cases that developed non-unions had unsatisfactory outcome.

Conclusions: ALIF alone can be recommended for discogram-concordant axial low back pain. Radiographic evidence of spondylosis, lysis or listhesis, level of fusion, number of levels fused, floating/non-floating type of fusion, and previous back surgery did not affect the outcome. Cases in which the middle column was stabilised (such as those with (a) intervertebral cages extending up to the posterior longitudinal ligament and (b) previous posterolateral fusion at the same level), and hence biomechanically stable, showed better outcomes. Placement of intervertebral implants mainly in the anterior column lead to distraction of the disc anteriorly, resulting in compression of back wall of the disc and facet joints, and narrowing of intervertebral foramina and spinal canal at that level, thus compromising the outcome.


D.K. Sengupta M.P. Grevitt B.J. Freeman S.H. Mehdian R.C. Mulholland J.K. Webb

Objective: This study investigates whether the sequence of anterior and posterior procedure has any effect on the lordosis, disc height and stability in combined A-P fusion of the lumbar spine.

Design: A biomechanical study on cadaver lumbar spine.

Materials and Methods: Twelve motion segments (between L2–L5) from four cadaver lumbar spines were studied. Anterior and posterior stabilization were performed using a Syncage (Synthes, Switzerland) of appropriate sizes, and translaminar screws respectively. Load-deformation characteristics in flexion-extension, lateral bending, and torsion were tested in a material-testing machine (Dartec, Stourbridge, UK) with 7.5Nm cyclical load. Angular deformation of each motion segment was determined simultaneously, by 2-D optical reflex camera system (Pro-reflex, Qualysis, Sweden). Disc height, and angle of lordosis between the adjacent endplates were determined from lateral radiographs. These parameters were measured in the intact spine, after A-P fixation with front first, and after back procedure first.

Results: Compared to the intact spine, the disc height was significantly increased (p< 0.05) when Syncages were introduced before posterior fixation, but not when posterior fixation was done first (p = 0.12). The angle of lordosis was increased significantly with posterior stabilization first, but only marginally, with anterior stabilization first. The stability of the motion segments increased significantly with combined A-P fusion, compared to either anterior or posterior fixation alone. With posterior stabilization first, the stability in all directions were greater but not statistically significant, compared to anterior stabilization first (p> 0.05).

Conclusion: In combined A-P fusion of lumbar spine, the lordosis is better restored when posterior stabilization is done first, but disc height is better restored when the anterior stabilization is performed first. Stability of fixation is not significantly affected by altering the sequence.


U. K. Debnath B. J. C. Freeman G. Ampat G. de la Harpe. R. W. Kerslake J. K. Webb.

Objective: To assess the clinical outcome and return to sport following surgical treatment of spondylolysis in young sporting individuals.

Design: A prospective outcome analysis of consecutive surgically treated cases of lumbar spondylolysis in young sporting individuals.

Subjects: Twenty-two young sports persons (15M: 7F) with a mean age of 20.2 years (range 15–34 years) were surgically treated for radiographically confirmed spondylolysis between 1994 and 1999. Eleven patients were professional footballers and four were professional cricketers. Pre operative assessment included plain X-rays, SPECT imaging with planar bone scan and reverse gantry CT scans. All subjects had pre-operative Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and SF36 scores recorded. Eighteen patients underwent Buck’s fusion and four patients underwent Scott’s fusion. A graduated exercise regime was commenced at 12 weeks. At two year follow-up nineteen patients had ODI and SF36 scores recorded.

Outcome Measures: The clinical outcome in individual patients supported by statistical analysis of the pre operative and post-operative data was performed using SPSS (ver 10). Return to the sporting activity at the previous level was regarded as a successful outcome.

Results: Eleven patients had bilateral spondylolysis at L5. Twenty patients had positive uptake on SPECT imaging and the remaining two were diagnosed to have lysis on CT scans alone. The average duration of back pain before the patients underwent surgery were 8.4 months (range 3–36 months). The mean lysis defect determined by CT was 3.5 mm (range 1–8 mm). The mean pre-operative and post-operative ODIs were 40.5 and 12.4 respectively (SEpreop = 2.06 and SEpostop = 3.05). The mean scores of physical health component of SF36 improved from 27.1 to 47.8 (SEmean = 1.1 and 1.7 respectively). The mean scores of mental health component of SF36 improved from 39.1 to 55.3 (SEmean = 0.9 and 1.4 respectively) [P < 0.001]. Eighteen patients returned to their previous active sporting career following an average of seven months of rehabilitation (range 4–10 months).

Conclusions: The surgical repair of bilateral spondylolysis with Buck’s fusion in professional sportsmen and women results in a significant improvement in Oswestry Disability scores (P< . 001) and in all domains of SF36 health questionnaire (P< . 001). 90% return to active sport seven months following surgery.


A. A. Siddiqui A. Jackowski.

Objective: To compare fusion time, Neck Disability scores, Pain scores, interbody height ratio and angulation, in cervical interbody fusion performed using tricortical graft or Ostapek cage, and a comparison between smokers and non smokers in fusion times.

Design: A prospective randomised study.

Subjects: Forty-two patients aged between 30 and 71years. Eighteen tricortical graft fusions, and 24 Ostapek cage fusions.

Outcome measures: Grading of fusion from plain radiographs, Neck Disability Scores, Pain scores, interbody height ratio, and interbody angulation.

Results: Mean time to good quality fusion was 4.66 months in the cage group and 5.97 months in the tri-cortical graft group with p< 0.5 and 5.00 months in the smoking population and 5.6 months in the non-smoking population with p< 0.5. At six months: mean percent NDI was 66.75 in the cage group and 50.67 in the tri-cortical graft group 0.1< p< 0.5;mean percent pain scores were 70.33 in the cage group and 34.50 in the tricortical graft group 0.02< p< 0.05; mean percent interbody height ratio was 98.68 in the cage group and 95.22 in the tricortical graft group 0.1< p< 0.5; mean change in interbody angle was 1.36° kyphosis in the cage group and 3.8° of kyphosis in the tricortical graft group 0.05< p< 0.1.

Conclusions: Tricortical graft fusion gives equal results to cage fusion and is much cheaper.


A. H. McGregor S. P. F. Hughes.

The majority of studies investigating the outcome of lumbar decompression surgery have been retrospective in nature and have not used validated measures of outcome. They have rarely gathered any information regarding patient rated expectations of surgery and measures of satisfaction with surgery. The aim of this study was to prospectively investigate the short and long term outcome of lumbar decompression surgery in terms of function, disability, general health and psychological well being and to examine patient expectations of surgery and short and long term satisfaction with the outcome of decompressive surgery.

Eighty-four patients undergoing lumbar spinal stenosis surgery were recruited into this study. Patients were assessed using validated measures of outcome pre-operatively, and at six weeks, six months and one year postoperatively. On recruitment into the study patients were also asked to rate their expectations of improvement in pain, general health, function etc. In addition at each review stage patients were asked to rate their satisfaction in improvement of these key outcome measures.

A significant reduction in pain (p< 0.001) was observed at the six week post-operative stage, this did not change at the subsequent assessment stages. Only some of the SF~36 categories were sensitive to change. The sub-categories that were sensitive to change were; physical function (p< 0.05); bodily pain (p< 0.001); and social function (p< 0.05). Improvements were observed in these categories at the six week and six month reviews. A gradual reduction in the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) was observed with time, with changes principally being observed between the six week and six month review, and six week and one year review stages (p< 0.05). Minimal changes were observed in the psychological assessments with time. The outcome of surgery could not be predicted reliably from psychological, functional or pain measures.

The results also demonstrated that patients had very high expectations of recovery particularly in terms of pain and function and that patients were confident of achieving this recovery (76.8%) confident of a good result. Levels of satisfaction however, varied considerably. 41% of subjects were 50% satisfied with the outcome, whilst 30% were dissatisfied. Most patients felt that they had made the right decision to have surgery although the surgery had only achieved 43.4% ± 37.8 of the outcome they had expected.

In conclusion, lumbar decompression surgery leads to a reduction in pain and some improvements in function. Examination of patient’s expectations of and satisfaction with surgery revealed that frequently patients had unrealistic expectations of their surgery and as a consequence tended to have lower levels of satisfaction.


N. Farooq G. Ampat U. K. Debnath M. P. Grevitt.

Objectives: Comparison of peri and intraoperative parameters between mini-ALIF (using balloon assisted dissector and Synframe retractor) and open midline approach for single and double level ALIF.

Methods: Independent, retrospective evaluation of 35 patients split between those undergoing the mini-ALIF or the conventional approach via larger midline incision. Groups matched for age, sex and number of levels. Operations performed at University Hospital, Nottingham between 1997 and 2000.

Outcome measures: Data collated for operative time, intraoperative blood loss, complications, PCA requirements, time to mobilisation and hospital stay.

Results: Statistically significant (p=0.01) reduction in operative time (175 vs 265mins) and time to mobilization (2.1 vs 3.9 days) found for single level mini-ALIF. Complications namely vascular injuries were almost equal in both groups. No difference was found between the two groups for double level procedures.

Conclusion: The immediate advantages of a less invasive approach both to the patient and the hospital do not appear to be borne out by this study. Cosmesis was not assessed and long term functional outcome awaits later review.


D. K. Sengupta M. P. Grevitt B. J. Freeman S. H. Mehdian J. K. Webb J. Lamb

Objective: To demonstrate possible advantages of combined (motor and sensory) versus single modality (either motor or sensory) intraoperative spinal cord monitoring

Design: Retrospective and prospective clinical study

Materials and Methods: One hundred and twenty-six consecutive operations in 97 patients had peroperative monitoring the lower limb motor evoked potentials (MEPs) to multi- pulse transcranial electrical stimulation (TES), and tibial nerve somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs). Seventy-nine patients had spinal deformity surgery, and eighteen had surgery for trauma, tumor or disc herniation

Results: Combined motor and sensory monitoring was successfully achieved in 104 of 126 (82%) operations. Monitoring was limited to MEPs alone in two, and SEPs alone in eighteen cases. Neither MEPs nor SEPs were obtainable in two cases with Friedreich’s ataxia. Significant evoked potentials (EP) changes occurred in one or both modalities in 16 patients, in association with instrumentation (10) or systemic changes (6). After appropriate remedial measures, SEPs recovered either fully or partially in all cases (8/8) and MEPs in 10/15. New neurodeficits developed post-operatively in six of the sixteen patients with abnormal EPs, including two in whom SEPs had either not changed or recovered fully after remedial measures. One patient developed S3–5 sensory loss despite full recovery of both SEPs and MEPs. Two patients without neurological consequences had persistent MEP changes. Normal MEPs (but not SEPs) at the end of the operation correctly predicted the absence of new motor deficits. There were no false negative MEP changes.

Conclusion: MEPs are more sensitive than SEPs, but may rarely raise false positive alarm. SEPs are unaffected by anaesthetics and can be monitored more frequently. Combined monitoring is safe, complimentary to each other, and increases sensitivity and predictivity of adverse neorological consequences. True incidence of false positive MEP or SEP changes are difficult to define. Remedial measures after monitoring changes may help cord ischaemia to recover and absence of neurological deficit, therefore, may not indicate a false positive monitoring change.


A. K. D. Goswami S. Rao R. Rao

Objective: To determine the in vitro difference in stability in a functional spinal unit (FSU) following bilateral laminotomy, and compare it to the instability resulting from laminectomy.

Design: The normal and injured spines were subjected to flexion, extension, lateral bending and torsional moments.

Subjects: Six fresh human cadaver lumbar spines were injured sequentially at the L4–5 level: bilateral laminotomy and laminectomy.

Outcome measures: The three-dimensional motion behaviour of each spine before and after the two injuries was recorded using a magnetic motion sensor. The data from all five spines was pooled for statistical analysis.

Results: With flexion and extension loading, bilateral laminotomy induced significantly less sagittal angulation and translation in the FSU than did laminectomy. Significant increase in coronal translation occurred with laminectomy in spines subjected to lateral bending loads. There were no significant differences between the two techniques in coronal plane angulation with lateral bending loads and torsional loads.

Conclusion: The increase in motion seen with laminectomy in sagittal angulation/translation, and coronal translation in this in vitro model may represent clinical instability, and may be responsible for continued symptomatology in these patients. Preservation of the lamina, spinous processes, and the posterior ligamentous structures significantly enhances the biomechanical stability of the FSU.


R. J. Laing N. Haden M. Latimer H. M. Seeley.

Objective: Anterior cervical discectomy (ACD) has been established for 40 years. Most surgeons introduce an interbody spacer despite randomised evidence, which suggests this is unnecessary. Surgeons are concerned about the effects of discectomy on cervical spine alignment causing neck pain and accelerated degenerative changes at adjacent levels. In this study we have investigated the relationships between pre-operative disc height, post-operative radiological changes and clinical outcome following ACD.

Design: Prospective cohort study of patients undergoing ACD

Subjects: Seventy-three patients undergoing ACD for the treatment of cervical myelopathy or radiculopathy. Minimum follow up one year.

Outcome measures: SF 36, Neck Disability Index, visual analogue scores for neck and arm pain, cervical spine alignment, segmental kyphosis, and disc height.

Results: Greater pre-op disc height predicts greater post op percentage loss of disc height but does not correlate with poor outcome (p> 0.05 all measures). Post- op X-rays revealed disturbed alignment in 54% of patients. Analysis of clinical outcome showed no statistical differences in any of the clinical outcome measures between patients with and without radiological abnormalities (p> 0.05) SF 36 scores were significantly worse than population controls in patients with and without radiological abnormalities.

Conclusions: Large discs collapse more than small discs but this does not compromise outcome. Radiological changes occurred in a significant number of patients in this cohort. These abnormalities do not appear to influence clinical outcome at 12–24 months. The study continues and will report outcomes at five years.


P. Gaston R. W. Marshall.

Background: Publications concerning recurrent disc disease quote percentage recurrence without regard to the times of recurrence and the influence of longer follow-up.

Objective: To assess the use of survival analysis to measure revision rate after lumbar microdiscectomy.

Design: A retrospective analysis of the hospital records of all patients undergoing lumbar microdiscectomy over a nine-year period was undertaken. Patients who had a repeat microdiscectomy at the same level as the index procedure were designated ‘revisions’. The overall revision rate was calculated for the average length of follow-up. A survival analysis was then carried out using the life table method, as described by Murray et al for follow-up of hip arthroplasty.

Subjects: Seven hundred and twenty-nine patients underwent primary microdiscectomy during this time period, average age 40 years.

Results: Twenty-seven patients had a revision microdiscectomy during the study period. This gave an overall revision rate of 3.7% at average follow up of five years, one month. Using survival analysis the revision rate was 5.5% at eight years of follow up, number at risk 51.

Conclusions: Survival analysis gives a more accurate estimation of the true recurrence rate for patients undergoing lumbar microdiscectomy. The method would allow better comparison between different interventions for intervertebral disc herniation.


G. Ampat N. Farooq N. Buxton M. P. Grevitt.

Objective: A clear definition of cauda equina syndrome (CES) following herniated discs was not available from the literature. Some define CES as a total paralysis of the pelvic viscera1 while others consider any dysfunction as sufficient evidence of CES2. An extensive search of the literature also demonstrated a lack of a disease specific outcome measure for CES. We aimed to classify CES in the above spectrum and validate a new outcome score for CES.

Design and subjects: We present a retrospective study of 38 patients with a minimum of one-year follow up who presented with an acute cauda equina syndrome. We categorized the patients as complete or incomplete and further sub-classified them as acute or chronic. A total paralysis of the pelvic viscera was considered as complete. Presence of only dysfunction of the pelvic viscera was considered as incomplete. If the presenting episode plateaued within 24 hours or less of onset it was classified as acute and if it plateaued later than 24 hours it was considered as chronic.

Outcome measures: The new 17-item disease specific questionnaire was compared with the Oswestry Disability Index, SF36 and Urodynamic studies.

Results and conclusion: Of the patients studied, 44.7% were complete with acute onset, 21.1% were complete with chronic onset, 10.5% were incomplete with acute onset and 23.7% were incomplete with chronic onset. Outcome score matched the spectrum of our suggested classification.


Full Access
P Sell

Clinical governance encompasses audit. Audit is a requirement of our professional bodies and our hospital trusts. It is not usually resourced adequately and the ability to audit spinal surgical outcomes is haphazard nationally. This presentation describes the results that can be achieved in the absence of formal audit support.

A surgical database was started in 1993; its evolution involved the use of standard outcome measures in 1995. Between 1995 and 1999, four hundred and one major spine procedures were undertaken by a single surgeon. The outcome measures were the Oswestry disability index, the low back outcome, MSP MZD and a visual analogue pain scale.

Pre-operative data was collected on all 233 elective cases. Follow up was 59% at 6 months, 51% at one year and 57% at 2 years. At two years a Macnab score was available in 106 cases and the results were excellent/ good 81%, fair/poor 19%.

There were 56 recorded perioperative complications. 21 occurred in the 77 instrumented procedures and 35 in the 156 non instrumented procedures.

The results of this type of audit can only be cautiously compared to published data because of poor follow up. Quality outcome measures and audit probably require a funded resource to be of value.


H. Mullett J. King K. O’Rourke D. Fitzpatrick

Introduction: Five occipitocervical implant systems were compared biomechanically in vitro using nondestructive testing.

Methods: A composite material model of the occiput and upper cervical spine was developed and validated. The specimens were tested using an in-vitro purpose build test rig. Instrumentation was from the occiput to C5 and included five constructs in current clinical use. Biomechanical testing parameters included axial rotation, flexion/extension and lateral bending. Nondestructive pure moments were applied to C5 using a system of cables and pulleys loaded by a materials testing machine (Hounsfield Ltd. UK) Angular displacement of the specimen under load was measured using the Zebris System (Zebris Medizintechnik, GMBH, Germany) which collects and stores three-dimensional space co-ordinates by means of attached ultrasonic markers. Mean maximum angular displacement was calculated from a series of five test cycles for each construct. Statistical significance was determined using a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) combined with a LDS test at 95% confidence.

Results: Statistically significant differences were shown in the initial stiffness of current implant constructs used for stabilization of the occipitocervical junction. The Zebris system was also validated as an accurate and efficient 3-D motion analysis for cervical spine biomechanical research.


M. T. N. Knight A. K. D. Goswami A. Hothersall

Objectives: The view that patients low back pain presenting with ‘abnormal’ psychometric and poor DRAM scores predict an unsatisfactory surgical outcome is considered controversial. This prospective study was designed to identify if DRAM Scores (Scores of Distress Risk Assessment Method) is a predictive determinant or a reactive instrument in regard to the outcome of Endoscopic Foraminoplasty.

Design: Pre- and postoperative assessment of disability and DRAM at two years.

Subjects: One hundred and eighty-five patients (86 males and 99 females) underwent an Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty between April 1997 and November 1998.

Outcome measures: Oswestry Disability Scale, and the Visual Analogue Pain Scale and the DRAM scores. Patients were categorised by their pre-op DRAM score. Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance and a regression analysis were performed.

Results: There was significant improvement in disability and pain scores at two years. (p< 0.05). A significant difference in median DRAM between the preoperative and postoperative score at two years was noted.

Conclusion: The DRAM score highlights individuals in distress who may need psychological support and physical treatment for optimum benefit from endoscopic spinal intervention. While the DRAM score predicted the patients’ disability and pain it failed to predict percentage benefit gain in outcome.


P. Pollintine M. A. Adams G. Findlay

Introduction: Intradiscal electrothermal therapy (IDET) is a novel treatment for discogenic back pain. A heating element is inserted percutaneously into a disc in order to denature the collagen of the posterior annulus. Clinical success is claimed, although laboratory studies indicate that temperature increases may be insufficient to cause widespread collagen denaturation, or denervation, and that IDET has little effect on gross mechanical properties. We report on changes in internal disc mechanics following IDET.

Methods: Ten cadaveric lumbar ‘motion segments’ (aged 72–79 yrs) were stored at −17°C. Subsequently, each was equilibrated at 37°C. A miniature pressure transducer was used to measure the distribution of compressive stress along the mid-sagittal diameter of each disc while it was compressed at 1.5kN. IDET was performed, using bi-planar radiography to confirm placement of the heating element, and an independent thermocouple to measure temperature in the inner lateral annulus. Stress profilometry was repeated irnmediately after IDET.

Results: Before IDET, all discs exhibited stress concentrations typical of mild degeneration. Accurate placement of the element was confirmed in all discs. Temperatures in the inner lateral annulus during IDET reached only 40.9°C (STD 2.3°C). Differences between stress measurements repeated before IDET never exceeded 8% (NS). After IDET, peak stresses (above nucleus pressure) were reduced by more than 8% in 6/10 specimens (mean reduction 55%), increased in 2/10, and were unchanged in 2/10. Nucleus pressure fell by 13% (n=10 0, P=0.05).

Discussion: IDET had a variable effect on these 10 degenerated discs. In six of them, stress concentrations in the annulus were reduced, suggesting that IDET can cause disc material to resist compression in a more coherent fashion, possibly by ‘bonding’ fragmented tissue together, and thereby distributing load more evenly across the endplate. Reduction in nucleus pressure following IDET suggests load transfer to the neural arch, although this could not be confirmed. Reducing annulus stress concentrations could conceivably reduce pain in some individuals.


M. T. N. Knight D. R Ellison A. K. D. Goswami V. F. Hillier

Objective: To analyse the incidence and gravity of reported complications that arise in spinal surgery and assess the comparative safety, or otherwise, of Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty.

Design: Prospective independently analysed study of complications arising during the six weeks following Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty was correlated and compared to a meta-analysis of reported data on complications in conventional spinal surgery.

Subjects: Nine hundred and fifty-eight procedures performed on 716 patients

Outcome measures: Occurrence of complications.

Results: The cohort integrity of operative and review records at six weeks after surgery was 100%. Twenty four complications occurred in 23 patients: nine cases of discitis (one infective) (0.9%), one dural tear (0.1%), one deep wound infection (0.1%), two patients suffered a foot drop (one transient) (0.2%), one myocardial infarction (0.1%), one erectile dysfunction (0.1%) and one post operative panic attacks (0.1%). MRI later demonstrated eight residual disc herniations (0.8%). The overall surgical complication rate was 1.6%. Meta-analysis of conventional spinal surgery reported overall complication rates for fusion (11.8%), decompression (7.6%), discectomy (6.0%) and chemonucleolysis (9.6%).

Conclusions: The complication rate of Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty is significantly lower than that reported following conventional spinal surgery (P < 0.01).


C. Assuma H. Norris C. Hutchinson R. Ross

Objective: Movement in an artificial disc would be assumed to be a necessary function of the disc. The purpose of this study was to establish whether, if any, relationship existed between movement in the artificial disc and outcome.

Subjects: 25 patients who had received an artificial disc prosthesis were assessed using radiological methods. Despite many vagaries in the measurement of X-rays, fluoroscopy was used to assess gross movement and end of flexion/extension views used to measure degrees of motion.

Outcome measures: Oswestry disability score.

Results: A very clear relationship has been established between motion in the artificial disc and outcome.

Conclusions: It is likely that spinal fusion will ultimately give way to disc replacement. Although spinal fusion has been shown in the Swedish spine series to produce good outcomes for significant numbers of patients, it remains to be seen whether the retention of motion will enhance outcome in low back pain patients. This series suggests that the retention of motion is an important component in the outcome of surgery in back pain sufferers.


S. Ahuja A. Maury A. Gibbs J. Howes P. R. Davies

Aim: To determine the histological changes in discs retrieved at the time of fusion following failed Intra-Discal Electrothermal Therapy (IDET).

Method: Three patients who had failed IDET treatment underwent lumbar interbody fusion. At the time of the operation the disc material and the endplate were sent for histopathology. The histological changes were compared to a degenerate disc and endplate. The staining techniques used were Haematoxylin Eosin stain, Elastic Van Geison and Alcian stains.

Results: In the post IDET specimens there was stromal disorganisation, paucity of chondrocytes and chondrocyte degeneration. These changes were seen in the nucleus pulposus, annulus fibrosis and the endplate as well. Comparatively cadaveric studies using intra-discal radiofrequency thermocoagulation showed histological change only in the nucleus pulposus.

Conclusion: The endplate changes at the cellular level can be widespread following IDET therapy, which can potentially cause alteration of its mechanical properties.


M. Krishna C. Bhatia

Object: To study the incidence, etiology and management of patients with neuralgia following Posterior Lumbar Interbody Fusion (PLIF).

Design: A prospective study of 85 patients undergoing PLIF surgery from March 1996 to March 2001.

Subjects: Seven of the 85 patients undergoing PLIF surgery developed new leg pain between three days and five months following surgery.

Results: The incidence of neuralgia was 8%. In all the patients the post-surgical neuralgia was in a new distribution. MRI examination ruled out misplaced pedicle screws in all cases, but was otherwise unhelpful. One patient developed neuralgia five months post-operatively due to collapse of the cortico-cancellous graft and secondary foraminal narrowing. This was not relieved following surgical decompression. Four patients had neuralgia caused by relative stenosis of the exiting nerve (3) or the traversing nerve (1) which started between three days and two weeks after surgery. The pain was relieved in all four following surgical decompression. One patient had leg pain when lying down; standing and sitting relieved this. A loose lamina was found on exploring the wound. Her pain settled after surgery. One patient developed a spondylolisthesis at the level below a L4/5 PLIF four months after surgery. Her pain was eased by stabilization of the lower segment.

Conclusions: MRI scans are not very helpful in these cases. Early exploration is recommended and gave good results in six of our seven cases.


S. Ahuja M. Lewis J. Howes P. R. Davies

Purpose: To assess the results of this technique for stabilisation of severe spondylolisthesis.

Method: Twelve patients with symptomatic severe spondylolisthesis were treated with this technique. All the patients had significant symptoms, inspite of conservative measures. The mean duration of symptoms was 3.5 years. The fixation technique was purely done through a posterior approach, with extensive posterior decompression. Stabilisation of the slipped L5 vertebra was achieved with a trans sacral screw. The point of entry of the screw being the posterior part of the body of S1 and it traverses the L5-S1 disc space into the L5 body. A hollow medullary screw passed over a guide wire helps achieve the fixation. This fixation is supplemented with pedicle screws into L5 and S1 and posterolateral bone grafting. Thus an anterior and posterior fusion was achieved and the severe slip fixed in-situ.

Results: The mean follow-up was 1 year. All but one (8%) patient had improvement in leg pain. 2(16%) patients were aware of the prominent metalwork (pedicle screws). Good 360° fusion was achieved using this technique in all the patients. There was no progression of spondylolisthesis.

Conclusion: Thus, anterior and posterior in-situ fusion for severe L5-S1 spondylolisthesis can be achieved effectively using a single incision via a transsacral approach.


N. Ahad C. Lee A. Noorani J. Lehovsky T. Morley

Fourteen patients with neurofibromatosis presented with symptoms or radiological evidence of cervical spine involvement over a period of 27 years. The symptoms included neurological deficit in five, neck mass in two, deformity in eight, decrease in neck movement in two and two with neck pain. Patients’ age ranged from five to forty-two years. Twelve patients have had surgical procedures. Two patients have been followed up and treated non-operatively despite osteolysis of vertebral bodies with kyphosis of more than 100°.

Current literature presents few cases of neurofibromatosis of the cervical spine. The largest World Series is of eight cases (Craig and Govender et al 1992). At present there is no coherent strategy of management for these conditions. The authors of this series recommend that correcting spinal deformity or to stabilise an unstable spine requires combined anterior and posterior fusion. Posterior fusion alone has a higher failure rate. Surgery for severe kyphotic deformity is questionable especially with no neurological deficit.


S Bojanic A Shad C Adams.

Objective: To demonstrate the safety, surgical efficacy and advantages of the Posterior Lumbar Interbody Fusion (PLIF) technique using posterior elements as graft material when combined with pedicle screw fixation.

Design: Retrospective study assessing the Oswestry Score and Pain Intensity Score pre and post-operatively in patients undergoing disc excision and PLIF with the above technique.

Subjects: Eighteen patients (6 male), mean age 44 years (range 24 – 59) with a mean follow-up of 11 months (range 9 – 14). Four subjects had undergone previous lumbar surgery. All subjects had a history of back pain with or without sciatica.

Outcome measures: Pre and post-operative assessment of functional ability and pain using the Oswestry Score and Pain Intensity Score.

Results: Following surgery there was marked improvement in the Oswestry Score from a mean score of 36 (+/−12) to 19 (+/−9), P< 0.0001. Likewise there was an improvement in the Pain Intensity Score from a pre-operative mean score of 4 (+/−1) to a post-operative score of 1 (+/−1), P< 0.0001. Seventeen of the eighteen patients indicated that they would have the operation again.

Conclusion: Our technique is safe, effective and the results are comparable with published data. This technique provides the added benefit of utilisation of posterior elements of the spine as bone graft and hence avoids donor site problems and the risks associated with insertion of block grafts.


S. S. Rajaratnam G. P. F. Selmon M. Mueller J. A. N. Shepperd R. C. Mulholland

Objective: To present early results of a new technique of dynamic stabilisation of the lumbo-sacral spine.

Design: Prospective study

Subjects: Between September 2000 and December 2001, 43 patients underwent posterior spinal stabilisation using the Dynamic Neutralisation System (DYNESYS) (Sulzer Medica).

Outcome Measures: Oswestry Disability indices, complications, visual analogue pain scores, patient satisfaction.

Results: The perceived indications were isolated degenerative disc disease (26), spondylolisthesis (8), degenerate adult scoliosis (4), failed Graf stabilisation (1), lumbar canal stenosis (3) and traumatic compression fracture (1).

Fixation was at one level in 14, two levels in 23, and three or four levels in 6 patients. Thirty-seven had Dyne-sys fixation alone and six had additional procedures at the same operation.

Complications included facet fracture (1), broken pedicle screw (1), apparent screw loosening (1) and discitis (1). At average follow-up of eight months (range 2–14 months), the average Oswestry disability score had fallen from 52 to 32 and the visual analogue pain score from 7.5 to 1.7. 65% of patients were pleased or better with their result.

Conclusions: The Dynesys system seems to be a safe alternative to conventional operative treatment for degenerative disorders of the lumbar spine without the need for rigid fusion. The anatomic re-stabilisation may allow the spinal segment to recover. The early results are encouraging. It is hoped that longer term follow-up will clarify the groups of patients who will benefit most from this procedure.


M. Murphy E. Wheeler F. Johnston.

Objective: Radicular symptoms of the cervical spine are usually effectively managed by cervical decompressive surgery when the symptomatic nerve root corresponds to the level of maximal radiological compression. The response is less predictable when the symptomatic level and the level of radiological compression are mismatched. The aim of this study was to retrospectively assess the efficacy of surgery in cases where symptom level and the level of radiological compression were mismatched.

Design: We conducted a casenote review of patients who underwent cervical decompressive surgery for radicular symptoms over a five year period with an average follow-up period of 3.5 years.

Subjects’ outcome: Three hundred and thirty-nine patients underwent cervical decompression during this period. Of these, 76 had surgery for isolated radicular symptoms. Nineteen of these patients had radiological and symptomatic mismatch.

Results: Seventy-five percent of those with mismatch initially had a good response to surgery, but 31% subsequently required a further operation. Comparable figures for those whose symptoms and radiology matched are 63% and 6%.

Conclusions: Patients who have radicular symptoms, which do not correspond to the level of radiological compression, do benefit from surgical decompression, but have an increased likelihood of requiring a second operation.


W. El-Assuity H. Norris D. Hughes C. Persilege R. Ross

Introduction: The Charite Mark 3 disc prosthesis has been used by the senior author for ten years. There has always been a question mark over the wear properties of the high density polyethylene spacer used in this prosthesis.

Methods: Ten patients who have received Charite implants, eight, nine and ten years ago were subjected to helical CT scanning. Slices at 3 mm. intervals were taken across the prosthetic levels. Fifteen prostheses were studied. Four clinicians, two of whom were radiologists and one a spinal fellow, assessed the CT scans against a standard protocol. Since the original heights of the prostheses were known, it was possible to measure prosthetic height and therefore get an estimate of wear. In addition, areas of osteolysis around the prostheses were estimated, again as a sign of wear.

Results: Remarkably little wear or wear debris was noted around the 15 prostheses.

Conclusions: Although this is a small series, it confirms that the medium-term performance of this prosthesis as far as wear is concerned is good.


U. K. Debnath D. K. Sengupta M. J. Hutchinson S. M. H. Mehdian J. K. Webb.

Objective: To asses the outcome of hermivertebrectomy and fusion for symptomatic thoracic disc herniation.

Design: A retrospective case analysis

Subjects: Between 1993 and 1999, ten patients (M5, F5) were treated surgically for thoracic disc herniation by the two senior authors (JKW & SHM). The average age of patients at presentation was 5Oyears (range 32–77years). Two patients had two level disc herniations (total 12 disc herniation). The most common sites of disc herniation were at T10/11(4 patients). Duration of diffuse mid thoracic hock pain in eight patients varied from one week to six months. The initial neurological evaluation demonstrated weakness and spasticity of varying grades in eight patients, of which five had paraplegia and three had monoparesis. Sensory changes below the level of the lesion were found in eight patients. Sphincter dysfunction was noted in seven patients. Hemivertebrectomy followed by discectomy and fusion was carried out in all patients. Instrumentation with cages was performed in eight patients and only bone grafting in two patients. Spinal cord monitoring was used in all cases.

Outcome Measures: The average follow up was 24 months (range 13–36 months). Pre-operative and postoperative neurological grading was done using MRC grading for motor and sensory deficit. Asymptomatic patients with full activity were regarded as a successful outcome.

Results: Three patients had excellent, three had good, three had fair and one had poor outcome. Seven out of eight patients with cages had radiological fusion. The cage stabilises the segment and maintains the spinal height till bony fusion takes place. One patient with hone graft alone had recurrence of symptoms and had a re-surgery with a poor outcome. Six patients had residual back pain of varying degrees. One patient had atelectasis, which recovered within two days of surgery. One patient had suffered from complete paraplegia immediately after surgery detected by SSEPs. She underwent a MRI scan within the hour and was reoperated. She had complete corpectomy and instrumented fusion. At two years she was walking with a support.

Conclusion: Exposure of the norrnal tissue above and below herniated disc by hemivertebrectomy facilitates the safe removal of the disc and reduces the risk of further neurological damage. Cages were found to have advantages over autogenous strut only grafts. However, persistent back pain in some cases remains an unsolved problem.


C. Wigfield S. Gill R. Nelson N. Metcalf J. Robertson

Objective: To assess the safety, clinical stability and capacity to preserve motion in the cervical spine of a newly designed cervical intervertebral disc replacement for patients with degenerative disc disease.

Design: A prospective cohort pilot study.

Subjects: Fifteen patients considered to be at risk of developing adjacent level degenerative changes received the artificial joint. Patients had either radiculopathy and/or myelopathy with radiological evidence of compression.

Outcome Measures: Radiological evidence of stability of the device and preservation of motion at the operated level and adverse events associated with the procedure. Secondary outcome measures were changes in scores on SF-36, Neck Disability Index, European Myelopathy Score and Visual Analogue Pain Scale assessments.

Results: The artificial joint maintained motion at the operated in all patients. The procedure was considered safe to be performed by experienced spine surgeons. The device was stable with no dislocation of components or backing out of screws. Improvements were noted in all of the assessment scores though statistical significance was not achieved.

Conclusions: Cervical intervertebral motion can be maintained with this device which at two years is clinically stable. The long-term influence of this device remains unknown.


S. C. Burn O. M. B. Austin G. Towns A. G. Batchelor

Patients requiring posterior fixation of the cervical spine are often elderly and frequently suffer from concurrent connective tissue disease together with steroid therapy. These patients are at increased risk of wound infection and breakdown. The extensive tissue dissection required, and the bulk of the posterior spinal devices may lead to difficult wound closure and delayed wound healing.

Over a four-year period, 1997 – 2001, 54 patients underwent posterior cervical spine fixation. Of these, eleven patients required muscle cover, four at the time of initial surgery and seven as a delayed procedure for wound breakdown. All these patients underwent trapezius muscle flap reconstruction (ten unilateral, one bilateral) which resulted in successful wound healing.

We make several recommendations for prevention of wound breakdown in this patient population. These include modification of the screw and rod fixation system to reduce the bulk, and assessment of the wound at the end of the primary procedure with a view to primary trapezius muscle flap transposition in those patients who are at risk of wound breakdown.


A. K. D. Goswami M. T. N. Knight

Objectives: To assess the efficacy and outcome of endoscopic aware state pain source definition combined with endoscopic decompression of the foramen, mobilisation and neurolysis of the exiting and transiting nerves and ablation of osteophytes in patients with spondylolytic spondylolisthesis followed for a minimum of two years.

Design: This prospective study determined the outcome of endoscopic foraminal decompression in symptomatic spondylolytic-spondylolisthesis.

Subjects: Sixteen males, and fourteen females with an average age of 46 years

Outcome measures: Results were analysed using the percentage change in Oswestry Disability Index, and percentage change in visual analogue pain (VAP) scores.

Results: One hundred percent cohort integrity was maintained at the final follow up. Using a percentage change in Oswestry Disability Index of 50 or more to determine good and excellent outcomes, 75% (22 out of 30) exceeded this value with five (17%) having 100% benefit for the procedure.

Conclusion: These results indicate that Endoscopic Laser Foraminoplasty provides a minimalist means of exploring the extraforaminal zone, the lytic defect, the foramen, its contents, and the epidural space and performing decompression, discectomy, osteophytectomy, perineural neurolysis in patients with spondylolytic spondylolisthes. Done in an aware state, it serves to identify and localise the source of pain generation.


D. J. Sharp

Aim: To investigate the use of the Graf Dynamic Stabilisation System for the treatment of multi-level discogenic pain associated with symptoms of ‘instability’.

Introduction: Indications for the use of the Graf Ligament system remain controversial. There is a small group of patients who present with severely disabling pain with failed conservative treatment, of discogenic origin at more than one level, and associated with symptoms of so-called ‘instability’ (acute pain related to position and movement), for whom treatment is extremely difficult.

Methods: Twenty-two consecutive adult patients of working age with this clinical picture, with discogenic pain at two or three levels confirmed by discography, were treated with the Graf Ligament System. They were prospectively studied, and reviewed by an independent assessor.

Results: At an average of three year follow up, 50% had good or excellent results including return to work, 18% fair, and 32% were no better. None were worse. Correlation with pre-operative MRI findings and complications will be discussed.

Conclusions: Whilst such dynamic systems may have a role in the treatment of discogenic pain, the success rate in this series does not justify its continued use for this indication without further research into the theoretical basis of the action of such dynamic stabilisation systems and the entry of all cases into prospective controlled trials.


C. J. Goldberg D. P. Moore E. E. Fogarty F. E. Dowling.

Objective: Examination of treatment outcome in a mixed group with early onset scoliosis.

Design: Retrospective review of patient data in order to plan a meaningful prospective study of treatment protocols.

Background: Scoliosis presenting before age 10 years, whatever the classification, has potentially significant consequences for morbidity and mortality, yet is discussed less than the more benign adolescent form.

Subjects: Patients with early onset idiopathic or syndromic scoliosis who were at least 15 years old at last review.

Outcome measures: Cobb angle change and the incidence of non-operative treatment and of surgery.

Results: There were 44 male and 74 female patients (19 IIS, 44 JIS and 55 syndromic) with follow-up 12.3 years SD 4.35 and mean Cobb angle progression from 26.6° to 47.21°. Non-operative treatment did not reduce the incidence of surgery either over-all (66.1%) or in individual groups (84.2% IIS, 63.6% JIS and 61.8% syndromic). Surgery in conservatively treated patients was at a later age (11.8 years SD 3.72) in comparison to those without (9.1 years SD 4.53), suggesting some advantage.

Conclusion: While orthotic treatment cannot be shown to prevent surgery in this series, achievement of the more modest aim of delay until nearer the pubertal growth spurt would be an undoubted benefit. Further study is necessary to determine whether this is a therapeutic effect or artefact.


M. A. Fazal S. J. Drew M. A. Edgar.

Objective: Senior author conducted two studies focusing on the age of presentation, Cobb angle at presentation and means of detection of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis in 1976 and 1985 respectively. We conducted another similar study in 1999 to compare the present situation with the previous two studies.

Design: Data was collected for 100 consecutive cases of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis which presented to the scoliosis clinic at The Middlesex Hospital, London from 1997 to 1999. the age of presentation, Cobb angle at presentation and the person who detected the deformity first were recorded. The patients were divided in following groups.

Group1 detected by family and friends.

Group2 detected by GP or by another doctor incidentally.

Group3 detected at school.

Group 4 detected by teachers.

Subjects: There were 81 female and 19 male patients with a mean age of 13.8 years.

Results: Group 1 consisted of 63% of the patients. Group 2 had 26% of the patients. Group 3 compromised of 8% of the patients and group 4 had 3% of the patients. Group 1 was the largest group and had increased since 1985 and 70% of the patients in this group had a Cobb angle greater than 40 degrees at presentation. It was also noted that group 3 had significantly dropped to 8% while in 1985 and in 1976 it was 10% and 32% respectively.

Conclusions: Our results represent a small sample from one center but it clearly shows that detection of scoliosis at school has dropped and majority of the cases are detected by family and friends often at a later stage with larger Cobb angles in excess of 40 degrees. Non-operative methods are ineffective with Cobb angles of this magnitude thus highlighting the importance of some means of early detection of scoliosis and producing greater awareness in the community.


A. Foster J. B. Spilsbury J. B. Williamson.

Objective: This study evaluates the use of the Isola Growing Rod System for scoliosis in a group of skeletally immature patients with predominantly neuromuscular disorders. Our series of patients was unsuitable for definitive anterior and posterior fusion due to poor respiratory function.

Design: We reviewed the case notes and x-rays of eighteen patients who had undergone instrumentation with the Isola Growing Rod System. The Cobb angles on the pre-operative and subsequent post-operative X-rays were measured. Complications were noted.

Subjects: Eighteen children with scoliosis.

Outcome measures: Curve correction and complications.

Results: Two patients had idiopathic scoliosis, four patients had spinal muscular atrophy with the remainder having varied diagnoses. Eight patients were fully ambulant, the remainder being wheelchair bound pre-operatively. The average age at rod insertion was eight years, three months. The average number of lengthenings was four. The mean pre-operative Cobb angle was 76 degrees, the mean most recent Cobb angle 28 degrees. One patient required definitive fusion. Two patients required revision procedures due to implant failure.

Conclusion: Our study shows that progressive scoliosis associated with neuromuscular disorder can be controlled with the growing rod system, thus avoiding both anterior release and the ‘crankshaft’ phenomenon, until the optimal time for definitive spinal fusion.


R. Bertagnoli C. D. Ray R. J. Vazquez

Objective: To determine the success of the Anterior Lateral transPsoatic Approach (ALPA) for implanting the PDN disc nucleus prosthesis.

Design: Eight patients were implanted with the PDN device via the ALPA technique. After making a 4cm incision in the lateral-abdominal area, the peritoneum was accessed and followed medially towards the lumbar spine, where a blunt-dissection technique through the psoas muscle was used to reach the disc. The anulus was then incised, and the nucleus material was removed before inserting the PDN device into the vacated disc cavity.

Subjects: Five female and three male patients, all with moderate degenerative disc disease, were implanted. Average age was 44.5 years (+/− 8.3). Seven patients were implanted at L4–L5 and one at L2–L3. These eight subjects were followed for twelve months.

Outcome measures: Improvements in Oswestry scores and disc-height measurements were considered indicative of implant success.

Results: Oswestry scores improved from a preoperative mean of 33.8 (+/− 15.1) to a postoperative mean of 10.0 (+/− 11.1), and disc height increased from a preoperative mean of 8.6mm (+/−2.4) to 9.4mm (+/− 2.3) postoperatively.

Conclusion: The ALPA technique facilitates implantation of the PDN device, with excellent clinical results.


D. K. Sengupta M. P. Grevitt B. J. Freeman S. H. Mehdian J. K. Webb S. Eisenstein.

Objective: This study investigates whether fixation down to lumbar spine only can prevent pelvic tilt compared to pelvic fixation, in the surgical treatment of Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD).

Design: Retrospective and prospective clinical outcome study, with long-term follow up.

Materials and Methods: Nineteen cases of DMD with scoliosis had early stabilisation (mean age 11.5 years, range 9–16) with sublaminar wires and rods, and pedicle screws up to the lumbar spine. This cohort was followed up for a mean 4.2 years (3–10 years). 31 cases in another centre had late stabilisation (mean age 14.5 years, range 10–17), with Luque rod and sublaminar wire fixation, and pelvic fixation using L-rod (22 cases) configuration or Galveston technique (9 cases) and were followed up for 4.6 years (0.5–11.5 years). Post-op morbidity, Cobb angle correction and pelvic obliquity data were collected retrospectively and prospectively for comparison.

Results: In the lumbar fixation group FVC was 58%, the mean Cobb angle and pelvic obliquity were 19.8° and 9° preoperative, 3.2° and 2.2° direct postoperative, and 5.2° and 2.9° at final follow up respectively. The mean estimated blood loss was 3.3 litres and average hospital stay 7.7 days. In the pelvic fixation group FVC was 44%, the mean Cobb angle and pelvic obliquity were 48° and 19.8° preoperative, 16.7° and 7.2° direct postoperative, and 22° and 11.6° at final follow up respectively. The mean blood loss (4.1 litres) and the average hospital stay (17 days) were significantly higher (p< 0.05) compared to the lumbar fixation group. The pelvic fixation group had higher complication rate at the lower end of fixation. No progression of the pelvic obliquity was noted in the lumbar fixation group during follow up

Conclusion: Lumbar fixation may be adequate for scoliosis in DMD, if the stabilisation is performed early, before the pelvis becomes tilted, and scoliosis becomes significant. The caudal pedicular fixation in the lumbar spine stops rotation of the spine around the rods, and prevent pelvic tilt to occur. Pelvic fixation may be necessary in presence of established pelvic obliquity and larger scoliosis, but is associated with higher morbidity and complications.


K. O’Shea H. Mullett C. Goldberg D. Moore E. Fogarty F. Dowling.

Surgical correction of spinal deformity in patients with neural axis abnormalities has established risks of causing further neurological injury. It is necessary to identify individuals with a predisposition for such abnormalities before treatment is instituted.

Objective: Examination of the association between idiopathic scoliosis and underlying neural axis abnormalities in the infantile and juvenile age groups.

Design: Retrospective chart and radiographic review.

Subjects: Ninety-four (36 infantile, 58 juvenile) consecutive patients with non-congenital scoliosis under the age of eleven years.

Outcome measures: These consisted of the MRI findings, neurological examination, associated curve morphology and necessity for neurosurgical intervention or surgical curve correction.

Results: Approximately 25% of patients presenting as idiopathic juvenile scoliosis had underlying neural axis abnormalities. No patient with apparent infantile idiopathic scoliosis had an abnormal spinal MRI scan. Using the Z score for independent proportions, there was a statistically significant difference between infantile and juvenile scoliosis and the presence of an underlying neural axis abnormality (Z score of 2.089, equivalent to p< 0.02).

Conclusions: We advocate routine MR spinal imaging in all patients with juvenile idiopathic scoliosis. In infantile idiopathic scoliosis, to avoid unnecessary general anaesthetics, one should image the spinal canal only when clinically indicated


C. J. Goldberg D. P. Moore E. E Fogarty F. E. Dowling.

Objective: Assessment of the outcome for spinal surgery in early onset deformity.

Design: Prospectively collected data on surface topography and respiratory function was analysed.

Subjects: Patients who underwent anterior and posterior spinal surgery before the age of 10 years for non-congenital deformity with special regard to cosmesis and respiratory function.

Outcome measures: Surface topography and respiratory function.

Results: In 10 children with pre-operative surface topography, surgery produced only an apparent reduction in the spinal angle. In the larger group, N=25, who have serial topography post-operatively (mean topographic follow-up 3.5 yrs, SD 1.55), the Suzuki hump sum (a measure of rib hump and back asymmetry) had increased significantly by a mean of 6.9 (SD 14.3, t=2.424, P=0.023). Respiratory function declined. Cobb angles varied in stability but usually increased initially. Trunk balance was maintained.

Conclusion: Surgery in early onset spinal deformity offers mechanical correction of deformity and a promise of no further progression, while also intending to preserve respiratory function into adult life, thus reducing morbidity and early mortality. Initial findings suggest that this is not so: while Cobb angle and trunk balance may be stabilised, the rib hump continues to increase and respiratory function to decline.


C. J. Goldberg D. P. Moore E. E. Fogarty F. E. Dowling.

Objective: Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) has been intensively studied for many years but conclusions on prognosis and best treatment are hampered by the shortage of untreated controls.

Design: Analysis of patient data in a prospectively maintained database.

Subjects: Patients with AIS (42 male, 458 female), at least 15 years old at last review.

Outcome Measures: Cobb angle change, growth, and the incidence of surgical treatment.

Results: Of 500 patients, 36 (7.2%) were braced and 138 (27.6%) had surgery. At diagnosis mean age was 13.8 yrs. SD 1.55, Cobb angle 30°, SD 17.85. Change over a mean of 3.5 years averaged 5.94°, SD 11.61, range −23° to +55°. There was no association between brace treatment and outcome. Below 50° at presentation, there was a significant association between age at diagnosis and curve progression. The change in Cobb angle correlated significantly with both absolute increase in height and in growth rate.

Conclusion: These results can be repeated in any scoliosis centre in the world, regardless of treatment policy. About one quarter will develop a significant cosmetic deformity. The remainder will stabilise their scoliosis without treatment. Deformity progresses with growth and correlates with growth rate, so is intrinsic to the growth process.


K. M. Venu J. K. O’Dowd.

Objective: To assess if a minithoracotomy gives sufficient access to undertake satisfactory anterior release and fusion of the thoracic spine.

Design: A prospective collection of data in patients undergoing anterior spinal surgery.

Subjects and Methods: Ten patients, nine with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) and one with congenital thoracolumbar kyphosis underwent anterior release and fusion through a minithoracotomy. A minithoracotomy being defined as a thoracotomy through an incision of ≤ 6cm. The female to male ratio was 3: 2 with an average age at the time of surgery of 13.5 years (10–15) in the scoliosis group. The patient with congenital kyphosis was operated on at 24 years of age. The mean standing pre-operative Cobb’s angle in the AIS group was 78.4° (60–110°), and this was reduced to a mean of 64° (45–85°) on bending films, with a flexibility of 18.4% (2.7–40%). The pre-operative kyphosis angle in the kyphosis patient was 60°. The thoracotomy incisions were measured with a sterile measuring tape on the completion of closure.

Results: All anterior surgery was satisfactorily achieved through a minithoracotomy with mean incision length of 6.5 cm (5.5–7). The average time taken for thoracotomy and procedure was 99 minutes (40–120) and an estimated blood loss of 116mls (50–250). Satisfactory correction was achieved in all patients with the mean improvement of the Cobb’s angle of 56% and post-operative Cobb’s angle of 34° (18–52). The post-operative kyphosis angle in the thoracolumbar kyphosis patient was 45°. The mean post-operative stay in the intensive care unit was 1.2 days (1–2); the duration of chest drain 1.5 days (1–2); blood transfusion requirement 2.9 units (1–6) and the post-operative stay on the ward 7 days (6–8). Two complications were seen comprising of minor chest infection and superficial infection of the chest drain wound requiring a course of oral antibiotics.

Conclusion: A minithoracotomy provides satisfactory access to achieve anterior release as demonstrated by satisfactory correction achieved with improved cosmesis, acceptable operation time and blood loss and with minimal complications.


B. J. C. Freeman A. Trezies P. Twining J. K. Webb.

Objective: To assess the clinical and radiological outcome of isolated hemivertebrae and multiple vertebral anomalies in the very young.

Design: A cohort of patients with congenital scoliosis were identified on antenatal ultrasound and followed prospectively from twenty weeks in-utero (IU) for a mean of two years (range IU – five years).

Subjects: Twenty fetuses with congenital hemivertebrae were identified from 16, 000 routine antenatal scans over a five-year period. Each was X-rayed at six weeks and investigated for renal and cardiac abnormalities.

Outcome Measures: Clinical assessment included trunk balance, neurological abnormality and associated congenital abnormalities. Radiological assessment of curve magnitude and curve progression was performed using the Cobb method. The potential for progression (based on site, degree of incarceration, growth potential and presence of a congenital bar) was assessed. In all cases a clinical and radiological assessment was made at maximal follow-up.

Results: One of the twenty fetuses aborted spontaneously at 23 weeks, three remain in-utero, leaving 16 live births. Thirteen of 20 had an isolated hemivertebra, and seven of twenty had multiple vertebral abnormalities. Two fetuses had renal agenesis, two had VATER’s syndrome and one had rib and abdominal wall abnormalities. The mean antenatal Cobb angle was 30°. IU curve progression was noted in three. Seven of the 16 live births required surgery based on curve magnitude, curve progression, truncal imbalance and the potential for progression. Surgery included anterior and posterior convex hemi-epiphyseodesis in two, and hemivertebra excision with fusion in five. The mean pre-operative Cobb angle was 36° (range 25–42) reducing to a mean of 21° (range 0–45) at maximal follow-up.

Conclusions: Multiple vertebral abnormalities were more commonly associated with renal and cardiac abnormalities. If associated with the oligohyramnios sequence the fetus appeared to be at high risk. In general US detected isolated fetal hemivertebrae carry a good prognosis, nevertheless 38% of these cases at our institution underwent surgery within the first two years of life.


C. I. Adams M. McMaster M. J. McMaster.

Objective: Surgical correction of late-onset idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) has been shown to be effective in obtaining correction in the frontal and sagittal planes, but is of questionable benefit in reducing the rib hump in the transverse plane The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of double rod and pedicle screw (AO USS) instrumentation on transverse plane asymmetry (on the convex and concave side of the scoliosis) in a single thoracic curve type (King III).

Design: A consecutive, prospectively studied cohort treated by a single surgeon with either a single-stage or two-stage procedure.

Subjects: Sixty-five patients with a King III adolescent idiopathic scoliosis were studied. There were 53 females and 12 males whose mean age at surgery was 14.5 years (range 11.1 to 17.9). A single-stage posterior fusion with instrumentation was performed in 46 patients whose mean Cobb angle at surgery was 56° (range 35 to 84). A two-stage procedure with thoracotomy and anterior spine release by multiple disc excisions (mean 6 levels) combined with internal costoplasty (mean 6 ribs), followed one week later by posterior spinal fusion with instrumentation, was performed in 15 patients whose mean Cobb angle was 78° (range 40 to 92).

Outcome measures: All patients were assessed both radiographically and by Integrated Shape Imaging System (ISIS) surface topography pre-operatively, postoperatively (mean of 14 weeks) and at follow-up visits for a mean 2.7 years (range 1.5–6.1).

Results: There were no non-unions or instrument failures in either group.

Single-stage group: Post-operative improvement in the Cobb angle was a mean 54% with a mean 2° loss in correction at final follow-up. ISIS showed the angle of rib hump elevation (convexity side) was improved by a mean of 2.1° and the angle of rib depression (concavity side) was unchanged. At final follow-up the angle of rib hump elevation had recurred by a mean of 3.6° beyond the original pre-operative value. The angle of rib depression remained unchanged.

Two-stage group: Post-operative improvement in the Cobb angle was a mean 64% with a mean 1° loss in correction at final follow-up. ISIS showed the angle of rib hump elevation (convexity side) was improved by a mean of 6.2° and the angle of rib depression (concavity side) was improved by a mean of 3.5°, producing a more balanced transverse plane. At final follow-up the angle of rib hump elevation only recurred by a mean 2.2°. This was compensated by a further improvement in the angle of rib depression by a mean of 2.5°, producing a further correction to balance the transverse plane.

Conclusions: Single-stage surgery is not effective in improving the transverse plane deformity. Two-stage surgery improves the transverse plane deformity on both the convexity and concavity producing a more balanced spine with further improvement due to an improvement of the rib depression (concave side) during follow-up (growth).


A. R. Meir D. A. Jones D. S. McNally J. P. G. Urban J. C. T. Fairbank.

Objective: To measure intradiscal pressures in scoliotic spines to further understand the role of mechanical forces in the development of scoliosis.

Design: Pressure readings were obtained in consented patients with ethical approval. A needle mounted pressure transducer was introduced into the disc during routine anterior scoliosis surgery.

Subjects: Ten human scoliotic discs from three patients.

Outcome measures: Intradiscal pressure profiles.

Results: Nuclear hydrostatic pressures varied from 0.2 to 0.6 MPa. The mean nuclear pressures for the three spines were 0.27+0.12, 0.35+0.06 and 0.47+0.12 MPa.

High stress, non- hydrostatic regions were consistently recorded in the concave annulus.

Conclusions: Nuclear pressures in these scoliotic patients were significantly higher than the 0.12 and 0.15 MPa recorded previously in non-scoliotic recumbent individuals1;2 suggesting that spinal loading is abnormal in scoliosis.


G. H. Prosser M. Jiggins A. Abudu A. Jackowski.

Objective: We present our recent experience in the management of tumours of the cervical spine and in particular comparing patterns of presentation of benign and malignant tumours and highlighting any delays of treatment.

Design: A retrospective study of 40 patients treated operatively at a regional spinal centre between 1995 and 2001.

Results: Twenty-five patients had metastastic disease and fifteen had primary tumours, five of which were malignant. Patients with malignant disease were older at diagnosis (55 vs 40) and had a shorter duration of symptoms (3m vs 19m). All patients with metastases reported good pain relief and improvement in neurological function where myelopathy or radiculopathy was present. Eight of these twenty-five patients have died at a mean of eleven months postoperatively. The longest survivor is now 31 months surgery. There were some excessive delays in treatment in benign and malignant cases. There were five cases of missed or wrong diagnosis and three patients waited more than six months for investigations.

Conclusions: Surgery for metastatic disease in the cervical spine has been successful in improving the quality of life in all of the patients although it should be stressed that each case must be dealt with on an individual basis with a multidisciplinary approach. It was noteworthy that some patients were subjected to extraordinary delays in diagnosis.


Full Access
M. Radford J. Loveridge J. Wilson-MacDonald.

Objective: To assess early results with the KASS system for scoliosis correction. To assess lateral curvature, rotational correction and complications.

Design: The first 22 patients requiring anterior correction of scoliotic curves were retrospectively reviewed. Pre- and post-operative curve measurements were made with a Cobbometer. Topographical assessment (ISIS) scan was used to assess rotation and correction of the rib hump. The notes were reviewed to determine complications and time to discharge.

Subjects: Twenty-two patients: 18 idiopathic scoliosis (4 others); average age 15.4 years; 5 King One, 10 King Two, 6 King Three and one non-definable; 5 thoracic curves

Results: Average pre-op scoliosis 54.85 degrees

Average post-op scoliosis 19.4 degrees. Average correction 65%. One patient required second operation for long screws. Four self limiting rninor complications. Average time to discharge eight days

Conclusion: KASS instrurnentation is a safe, effective and reliable method to correct scoliotic curves including rotational deformities. It was not possible to correct the Cobb angle of purely thoracic curves as much as thoracolumbar curves. Cosmetic correction however has been excellent as demonstrated with ISIS. Long term review will be necessary to confirm that correction is maintained.


C. J. Goldberg D. P. Moore E. E. Fogarty F. E. Dowling.

Objective: Determination of the height at maturity of patients with congenital vertebral anomalies and analysis of the effect of spinal surgery.

Design: Review of clinical measurements collected prospectively.

Subjects: Patients with congenital vertebral anomaly who had passed their sixteenth birthdays.

Outcome measures: Stature compared to normal centiles for age and gender, with consideration of the type of abnormality, age at surgery and co-existing abnormalities.

Results: Thirty-eight boys, mean age 16.41 years, SD 0.31, and 79 girls, mean age 16.76 yrs, SD 1.3 were identified. Growth rate over two years after age16 years was slow (boys: 1.0 cm, SD 3.05; girls: 0.33 cms, SD 1.98). At maturity, mean height for boys was just above the third centile while girls were on theirs. Height was significantly lower for patients with prior spinal surgery and with a diagnosis of VACTERL association. In boys, there was no correlation between age at surgery and final height, but in girls final height correlated significantly with age at diagnosis and at surgery and negatively with age at menarche.

Conclusion: Stature at maturity is reduced and this is exacerbated by associated abnormalities and by spinal surgery. However, those with more severe abnormalities are more likely to have had surgery, and these two effects were not differentiated in this study.


M. F. Grainger A. J. Stirling D. S. Marks A. G. Thompson A. Jackowski

Objective: To assess the validity of the Tokuhashi and Tomita scoring systems in the prediction of prognosis following spinal surgery for skeletal metastases.

Design: A retrospective cohort study of patients treated in a specialist spinal unit

Subjects: All patients undergoing definitive surgery for metastastes of the spine were considered eligible. Time to death or current length of survival was available in 147* of these which was confirmed by the Cancer Registry. Medical and nursing case notes were reviewed and prognostic scores using the methods of Tokuhashi et al, and Tomita et al. were calculated for each patient.

death data for further patients currently awaited from Cancer Registry.

Outcome measures: Mean survival period with 95% confidence intervals for patients grouped according to prognostic score.

Results: Thirty-two patients were still alive and 113 had confirmed death dates. Forty-three patients had Tokuhashi scores of 9 or greater with a mean survival of 20.1 months (95% confidence interval 5.8 months) compared to 9.5 months (2.9 months) for scores 6–8 and 3.5 months (1.8 months) for scores below this. Tomita scoring showed a similar trend with those with better prognostic profiles but without the same degree of statistical significance. The overall 30-day mortality was 8.2% with no significant difference between any other groups.

Conclusion: In patients presenting with metastatic disease involving the spine, published prognostic profiles offer some guidance to likely survival of the patient and so the appropriateness of surgical treatment.


M. H. Kassem S. Cutts E. K. Alpar W. El-Masry V. V. Killampalli.

Objective: To assess the correlation between the Denis classification and clinical outcomes.

Subjects and Design: We performed a retrospective study of 87 patients with spinal injuries in the thoracolumbar region. All patients were admitted to the Oswestry Spinal injuries unit between Jan 1990 and December 1998. Following a review of their notes, CT scans and radiographs, we attempted to classify their injuries according to the Denis (3 column) Classification of spinal injuries.

Outcome Measures: The patients were assessed both at the time of presentation and on subsequent follow up. Neurological function was assessed using the Frankel classification.

Results: The results of the study show that the correlation between Denis classification and clinical outcome is poor. In addition, the relative proportions of the two most common Major Injury types described by Denis were reversed in our study with Burst fractures forming the majority of injuries. This difference in out come was attributed primarily to the increased use of CT scanning in our study. It appears that Denis misdiagnosed a significant number of burst (two column) fractures as compression (anterior column) fractures.

Conclusions: Our findings showed no correlation between the degree of instability and the number of columns disrupted. We believe that only 3 column fracture dislocations are fundamentally unstable. In addition, our results support the practise of treating vertebral fractures by conservative means with no apparent correlation between treatment modality and neurological outcome at long term follow up.


A. K. Burton T. D. M. McClune G. Waddell.

Objective: A review of scientific literature on whiplash associated disorders was conducted to inform appropriate messages for an evidenced-based patient educational booklet – The Whiplash Book. The booklet has been developed for use as both a clinical tool and general health intervention.

Design and Results: A systematic literature search was conducted, using MEDLINE and psychINFO, together with hand searches, reference tracking, and the Internet. The Quebec Task Force report and the British Columbia Whiplash Initiative were taken as the starting point. The new evidence covered the period May 1994 through March 2001 (163 articles). All relevant articles were included, with a particular focus on management and treatment of whiplash associated disorders. The quantity, consistency and relevance of all retrieved articles was evaluated, and rated as:

*** consistent findings in multiple reports

** consensus based on balance of various findings

* limited information (single report)

Conclusions: The main messages from the literature suggest: serious physical injury is rare, reassurance about good prognosis is important, over-medication is detrimental, fastest recovery occurs with early return to normal pre-accident activities; self-exercise/manual therapy and positive attitudes/beliefs are helpful to regain activity levels; collars/rest and negative attitudes/beliefs delay recovery and contribute to chronicity.


L. Breakwell M. Deas A. Patel S. Patel S. Harland A. J. Stirling

Objective: To compare the presentation, diagnosis and treatment of spinal tuberculosis in two cities, one in the UK, and one in Malaysia

Design: Retrospective comparison over a five-year period from June 1995. The Centres studied were the Royal Orthopaedic and Queen Elizabeth Hospitals, Birmingham (UK), and the Kuala Lumpur General Hospital (KL), Malaysia.

Subjects: There were 80 patients (29 females, mean age 42) in the KL group, and 19 patients (8 females, mean age 45) in the UK group.

Outcome measures: Frankel grading before and after treatment were measured for both groups.

Results: KL patients had higher rates of immunocompromise, and had fewer spinal levels involved, 2.1 compared with 2.6 (p-−0.04). There were 65 procedures, 58 positive ZN stains, and 65 positive cultures as compared with 24, 2 and 9 in Birmingham respectively. Improvement in Frankel grading was seen in four patients in UK (5 grades), and in 17 patients in KL (29 grades).

Conclusions: Although the two groups exhibited similar demographics, the rate of immunocompromise-related tuberculosis, severity of neurological deficit, and type of surgery undertaken differed significantly. Reasons for the difficulty in identifying the tubercle bacillus in Birmingham are discussed.


Y. C. Gan S. Chapman S. Sgouros A. R. Walsh A. D. Hockley.

Objective: To investigate the incidence, treatment and outcome of spinal injuries in paediatric patients with head injuries admitted ventilated to the paediatric ICU.

Design: Retrospective review of all head injury patients admitted ventilated to Birmingham Children’s Hospital from September 1995 to March 2001.

Outcome Measures: Severe head injury is defined as an initial GCS of 8 or less; moderate head injury as GCS between 9 – 12 and minor head injury – GCS above 12. Spine injuries detected on plain trauma radiographs and/or CT. Outcome is described by Glasgow Outcome Scale and Frankel grade.

Subjects: Two hundred and two consecutive patients were admitted during period: 141 (70%) patients had severe head injury; 44 (22%) patients had moderate head injury; 17 (8%) had minor head injuries. There were 131 males (65%) and 49 females (35%). Age ranged from nine months to sixteen years (mean eight years). The head injuries were: 35 extradural haematoma, 47 acute subdural haematoma, 41 contusions and 79 diffuse axonal injury (DAI).

Results: All 202 patients had cervical radiographs done. Forty-eight patients (24%) had further cervical spine CT mainly for inadequate cervical radiographs. Seven patients (3.5%) had CT of the thoracic or lumbar spine. Nineteen patients (9.5%) had MRI of the spine performed. In total, eight of the 202 (4%) patients had spinal injuries (aged two to ten years): 6/8 (75%) were cervical and 2/8 (25%) thoracic and lumbar spine. They were: C3 lamina fracture, C2/3 subluxation, C1/2 sub-luxation, C2 fracture with C6/7 dislocation and cord transection, C6/7 dislocation with cord transection, distraction of atlanto-axial junction, T12 crush fracture and L3/4 fracture dislocation. The cause was road traffic accidents (n=5) and falls from windows (n=3). All had the spinal injury diagnosed on radiographs with no false negative radiographs. All were treated conservatively: one halo vest, one thoracolumbar corset and five hard collars. There were three deaths due to the head injury (C6/7 dislocation with cord transection, L3/4 fracture dislocation and distraction of atlanto-axial junction) at day one, day five and day ten of injury respectively, one patient (C2 fracture) remained quadraplegic (Frankel A), four patients (C3 lamina fracture, C2/3 subluxation, C1/2 subluxation, T12 crush fracture) had good outcomes (Frankel D). Four patients had a GOS of 5 and one patient had GOS of 3 at six months.

Conclusion: The incidence of spinal injuries especially cervical injuries was higher than expected, probably reflecting the severity of the injury in this group of patients. Plain cervical and thoracolumbar radiographs detected all patients with spinal injuries suggesting that this investigation alone is sensitive enough for this purpose. Non-operative treatment resulted in good outcome for most of the patients.


J. F. Quinlan R. W. G. Watson P. M. Kelly J. M. O’Byrne J. M. Fitzpatrick

Patients with spinal cord injuries have been seen to have increased healing of attendant fractures. This for the main has been a clinical observation with laboratory work confined to rats. While the benefits in relation to quicker fracture healing are obvious, this excessive bone growth (heterotopic ossification) also causes unwanted side effects, such as decreased movement around joints, joint fusion and renal tract calculi. However, the cause for this phenomenon remains unclear.

This paper evaluates two groups with spinal column fractures – those with neurological compromise (n=10) and those without (n=11), and compares them with a control group with isolated long bone fractures (n=10). Serum was taken from these patients at five specific time intervals post injury (24hrs, 120hrs, 10 days, 6 weeks and 12 weeks). The time period most closely related to the end of the acute inflammatory reaction and the laying down of callus was the 10-day post injury time period.

Serum samples taken at this time period were analysed for IGF-1 and TGF-β levels, both known to initiate osteoblastic activity, using ELISA kits. They were also exposed to an osteoblast cell culture line and cell proliferation was measured.

Results show that the group with neurology has increased levels of IGF-1 compared to the other groups (p< 0.14, p< 0.18 respectively, Student’s t-test) but had lower TGF- (p< 0.05, p< 0.006) and osteoblast proliferation levels (p< 0.002, p< 0.001), despite having a significantly higher cell proliferation than a control group (p< 0.0001). When the neurology group is subdivided into complete (n=5) and incomplete (n=5), it was shown that the complete group had higher levels of both IGF-1 and TGF-. This trend is reversed in the osteoblast proliferation assay.

This work, for the first time in human subjects, identifies a factor which may be regulating this complication of acute spinal cord injuries, namely IGF-1. Furthermore, the observed trend in the two cytokines seen in the complete neurology group may suggest a role for TGF-β. However, the results do show that a direct mediation of this unwanted side effect of spinal cord injuries is unlikely as seen in the proliferation assay. Further work remains to be done to fully understand the complexities of the excessive bone growth recognised in this patient group.


Full Access
P. Basu C. G. Greenough

Objective: To assess the result of surgical stabilisation of spine in Spinal cord injured patients.

Design: Retrospective review of patients managed and followed at a spinal injury centre.

Subjects: Sixty-six patients with spinal cord injury, treated with surgical stabilisation of their spinal fracture and followed for a minimum of two years.

Outcome Measures: Delay in starting ambulation from injury/surgery, sagittal balance, metalwork failure and surgical complications.

Results: The mean age was 29.5 years (17–67), and five patients were female. The median follow up was 7.9 years (2–24). There were 19 cervical, 21 thoracic and 28 thoracolumbar and lumbar fractures. A total of 36 patients had over six weeks delay in starting ambulation. Of these 11 were due to inadequate fixation. Ten patients (50%) with cervical fracture and seven patients (25%) with lumbar fractures had normal lordosis. Significantly more patients with anterior cervical fixation had normal lordosis compared to those with posterior fixation. Nineteen with thoracic fracture had thoracic kyphosis within 40°. Nine patients had failure of metalwork. Surgical complications occurred in 21 (33%) patients.

Conclusion: Early ambulation was not achieved in the majority. The maintenance of lordosis was successful in cervical but not in lumbar spine. Posterior fixation of thoracic spine was successful in maintaining normal sagittal balance.


A. M. McGee P. Armstrong A. Jackowski

The Synex cage is an expanding titanium implant designed for reconstruction of the anterior column in injury, post-traumatic kyphosis or tumour of the thoracolumbar spine. It is supplemented by a stabilizing implant. As it is expandable in situ it therefore can be inserted via a relatively small exposure. The design enables good purchase of the endplates and reduces the possibility of secondary displacement.

Surgery for anterior reconstruction is usually performed via an anterior approach, however, there are incidences were a posterolateral approach is indicated. The Synex cage is useful in these circumstances, as being expandable, posterolateral insertion with preservation of the nerve roots is possible. The Synex cage is then supplemented with a posterior construct. The cage can be inserted via a left or right posterolateral approach. A specially designed angled screwdriver is now available to release the ratchet mechanism and if necessary collapse the cage.

We present, what is, to the best of our knowledge and that of the manufacturer, the first two patients where a Synex cage has been inserted using the posterolateral approach.

Conclusion: Synex cage has the advantage of being expandable and it is therefore possible to insert this via a potentially small exposure, between the nerve roots, using a posterolateral approach


R. R. Shah S. Mohammed A. Saifuddin B. A. Taylor.

Objectives: To determine if high quality, thin slice (1–3)mm CT scan images would allow proper evaluation of interbody fusion through titanium cages in view of the fact that there are no universally accepted radiological criteria. 1

Design: Patients undergoing interbody lumbar fusion were prospectively evaluated with a CT scan and plain radiographs six months following surgery. These were blindly and independently evaluated by a consultant radiologist and a research fellow. They were assessed for bridging bony trabeculation both through and surrounding the cages as well as for changes at the cage endplate interface.

Subjects: Fifty-three patients (156 cages) undergoing posterior lumbar interbody fusion using titanium inter-body cages were evaluated. Posterior elements were used to pack the cages and no graft was packed outside the cages.

Outcome Measures: Kappa co-efficient and chi-squared analysis.

Results: On the CT scan both observers noted bridging trabeculation in 95%of the cages-Kappa 0.85, while on radiographs they were present in only 4%-Kappa 0.74. Both observers also identified bridging trabeculation surrounding the cages on the CT scans in 90%-Kappa 0.82, while on the radiographs this was 8%-Kappa 0.86. Radiographs also did not identify all the loose cages.

Conclusions: High quality CT scan images can demonstrate bridging bony trabeculation following the use of titanium interbody cages. It also demonstrated consistent bone growth outside the cages inspite of not using any bone graft.


R. Turner S. Kumar G. Vidalis M. Paterson.

Objective: NHS Patients can wait up to 18 months for non-urgent spine surgery. The intended procedure is determined by the outpatient MRI scan. Do changes occur within the spine during the wait for surgery? Would the changes affect the operative decision?

Design: A Prospective study.

Subjects: 105 patients listed for elective lumbar spine surgery at a district general hospital

Outcome Measures: If the MRI scan is over six months old, a second scan is performed prior to surgery. Changes that alter the operative decision are noted.

Results: Forty-four percent discectomy, 17% decompression, and 19% fusion plus decompression patients cancelled surgery due to improvement in symptoms. None of the spinal fusion patients cancelled. Fourteen percent discectomy; 12.5% decompression; 25% fusion; 19% fusion plus decompression and 65% fusion plus discectomy patients had different procedures after the second MRI. Changes seen include disc resolution, pro-lapse at a new level, progressive modic changes and compression at different levels.

Conclusions: We do not support the fact that patients may have to wait up to 18 months before having elective spinal surgery. However, a significant numbers of discectomy and decompression patients found that their symptoms improved enough to decline surgery. No patient who had been listed for fusion alone got better. Due to changes seen on the second MRI scan, one in six operations were different to the initial planned procedure. Could a surgeon failing to request a further up to date scan prior to surgery therefore be considered negligent?


R. R. Shah S. Mohammed A. Saifuddin B. A. Taylor.

Objective: To document the incidence of adjacent superior segment facet joint violation following transpedicular instrumentation in the lumbar spine as it has been postulated that this can lead to long term deterioration There has been no study so far determining this incidence.

Design: Patients undergoing lumbar fusion were prospectively evaluated with a CT scan and plain radiographs six months following surgery. These were blindly and independantly evaluated by a consultant radiologist and a research fellow.

Subjects: 106 patients (212 top level facet screws) between 1996 and 1999 were evaluated. All patients had their screws and instrumentation inserted through a Wiltse muscle splitting approach and a lateral entry point in the pedicle so as to reduce the risk of facetal impingement. 1

Outcome Measures: Kappa co-efficient and chi-squared analysis.

Results: The Kappa co-efficient for the CT scan and plain radiographs were 0.88 and 0.39 respectively. On the CT scan both observers noted facet joint impingement in just over 20% of the screws and just over 30% of the patients. The impingement was independent of the level and diagnosis (p> 0.05) and it occurred with uniform incidence in each of the year.

Conclusion: This study raises the theoretical possibility of long term deterioration in the clinical results following the use of transpedicular instrumentaion.


J. A. Harty J. F. Quinlan K. E. Soffe S. Hassan M. G. Walsh J. O. Byrne

Objective: To date the principal focus of the mechanism of cervical spine fracture has been directed at head/ neck circumference and spinal canal dimensions. However the role of other measurements, including chest diameter and head/neck/chest proportional ratios, in a standard cervical fracture population has not yet been studied in detail. Cervical fractures often involve flexion/ extension type mechanisms of injury, with the head and cervical spine flexing/extending, using the thorax as a fulcrum.

Study design: We prospectively studied all patients with cervical spine fractures who were admitted to the spinal injuries unit from 1st July, 2000 to 1st March 2001. Anthropometrical measurement of head circumference, neck circumference, chest circumference, and neck length were analysed. Ages ranged from 18 – 55yrs, and all patients with concomitant cervical pathology were excluded from the study. Mechanism of injury involved flexion/extension type injuries in all cases; those with direct axial loading were excluded. A control group of 30 patients (age 18–55yrs) involved in high velocity trauma with associated long bone fractures, in whom cervical injury was suspected but without any cervical fracture, or associated pathology, were measured.

Results: Our analysis revealed a statistically significant increase in chest size in the male control group versus the fracture group 98.89cm v. 94.19cm (P< 0.05, t-test). There was a correspondingly significant increase in chest circumference between the female control versus the fracture group 94.33cm v. 88.88cm(P< 0.05, t-test). Our results revealed no statistical difference in either head circumference, neck circumference, or neck length between each of the groupings. However we found a statistically significant increase in head/neck/chest ratios between each of the groups. These results indicate a proportionately larger chest may be protective in cervical spine fractures.


N. Farooq G. Zaveri B. J. C. Freeman J. K. Webb

Objective: To evaluate the efficacy and safety of an expandable titanium cage for anterior column replacement after partial or total corpectomy in the thoracolumbar spine.

Design: A retrospective study evaluating the clinical and radiographic outcome following insertion of a novel implant.

Subjects: Twenty-three patients with anterior column insufficiency secondary to tumour, fracture, and infection were treated with a vertebral replacement capable of rapid and controlled in-situ expansion. Follow up consisted of a clinical and radiological review at a mean of 15.2 months (range 6–20 months).

Outcome Measures: The clinical outcome was measured by the degree of pain relief post-operatively, the ability to ambulate and the reliance on walking aids. Neurological deficit was measured using the Frankel Grade. Radiological follow-up compared preoperative radiographs with those taken at maximal follow-up. The degree of kyphosis and the degree of subsidence was measured.

Results: Twenty-three patients with a mean age of 43.6 years (range 20–72) underwent surgery. Indications included metastatic tumour in eight, acute fractures in five, infection in four, degenerative conditions in three, post-traumatic kyphosis in two and pseudathrosis in one. Nineteen patients underwent a single-level corpectomy and four patients a two-level corpectomy. Fourteen patients had a significant neurological deficit preoperatively. Supplementary instrumentation was used in 20 of 23 cases (anterior in nine, posterior in eleven). Excellent pain relief was observed in 19. Ten of 14 patients showed neurological improvement. Eleven patients improved their ambulatory status. There was no hardware failure. An average correction of 110 of kyphosis was observed. The average subsidence was 1.3 mm (range 0.2–2.3).

Conclusions: The use of an expandable vertebral body replacement with supplementary instrumentation following corpectomy appears to be safe and efficacious in correcting kyphosis. This implant appears to have a high resistance to subsidence.


M. Torrens S. Kalos G. Asithianakis A. Kelekis.

Introduction: Two example case reports are presented of symptomatic vertebral haemangiomas. These were managed by percutaneous acrylic vertebroplasty in preference to total vertebrectomy and trivertebral fusion.

Subjects: Both patients were female and presented with severe thoracolumbar pain. One, aged 23, had an implosion fracture of L2 with kyphosis. The other, aged 73, had continuous back pain made worse by lying down. MRI revealed haemangiomas in both cases replacing the vertebral bodies of L2 and L4 respectively. There was no neurological deficit.

Technique: Percutaneous vertebroplasty was performed in both cases under general anaesthetic by bilateral synchronous transpedicular injection of polymethyl-methacrylate, using continuous biplanar image intensifier control to monitor the distribution of the acrylic.

Results: Both cases were relieved of all symptoms from the moment of waking from the anaesthetic. The total number of haemangioma cases treated in Athens and Geneva is 11, and these current results are typical of the series1 where all cases have been effectively treated without significant complications. Follow up one to seventy-two months.

Conclusion: Percutaneous acrylic vertebroplasty should be the treatment of choice for symptomatic vertebral haemangiomas without neurological involvement. The reason for this presentation is to emphasise not only the relative simplicity of the technique but also the impressive immediate resolution of symptoms.


P. G. Sorelli H. J. Foale J. O’Dowd

Objective: To evaluate a new system of prescribing and administering IV morphine introduced by our Paediatric Pain Service for paediatric patients undergoing corrective spinal surgery.

Design: An audit of post-operative pain management was conducted retrospectively on patients who had undergone scoliosis correction between November 1999 and September 2001.

Subjects: Sixteen patients between the ages of nine and seventeen years who had undergone spinal scoliosis correction during the study period were evaluated.

Outcome measures: The average post-operative IV morphine consumption, the pain and sedation scores, the incidence of side effects, and the use of adjuvant analgesics were analysed. Statistical evaluation was carried out using the Student’s T test and the Mann-Whitney U test.

Results: Morphine consumption was significantly higher in the first post-operative twenty-four hour period, as well as in the over 13 year-old age group. There was no significant difference in morphine consumption between genders or ASA physical status. The pain scores were significantly higher in males compared to females on day one post-operatively. There was no statistical difference in sedation scores.

Conclusions: An audit of the post-operative pain regimen for patients undergoing spinal scoliosis correction provided by the Paediatric Pain Management Service has shown that it is both efficient and safe. We recommend an anticipated pain management pathway of recovery following spinal fusion for idiopathic adolescent scoliosis.


N. Buxton Y. L. Leung G. Ampat J. K. Webb J. L. Firth

Objective: To study the long term operative and non-operative outcome in patients with diastematomyelia (DM).

Design: A prospectively acquired database of all spinal patients seen jointly by the senior authors (JKW, JLF), was searched for patients with DM. Their notes and the database were then reviewed.

Subjects: Thirty-six patients were identified; twenty-one (58%) had associated scoliosis. There were 60 associated abnormalities in the 36 patients, most common being ten (27%) with leg length inequality. Twelve patients (33%) had no radiological bony abnormality. Twenty-four (66%) had neurosurgery, eleven (31%) untethering of filum alone and eleven (31%) with removal of a spur and closure of the DM as well. Nineteen (53%) underwent some sort of neuraxial shortening scoliosis correction/surgery. Twenty-eight (78%) were deemed to have a normal/independent neurological outcome, seventeen (61%) having neurosurgery and twelve (43%) scoliosis surgery.

Conclusions: Patients with DM have been followed up for many years. Good neurological outcomes can be anticipated in cases with untethering and with scoliosis correction alone. This series raises the question as to whether any unthethering procedure is necessary in these cases when neuraxial shortening is carried out for scoliosis cases.


J. F. Quinlan H. Mullett L. Coffey D. FitzPatrick D. McCormack.

Cervical orthoses are currently used in the pre-hospital stabilization of trauma patients and also as part of the definitive non-operative treatment of injuries of the cervical spine. The construct stability of orthoses is compromised by virtue of the fact that the cervical spine exhibits the greatest range of movement amongst the spinal segments and also because of the complex composite nature of neck movements.

To date, data has been difficult to attain comparing the various orthoses, in the various planes of movement of the cervical spine. Various methods including the use of inclinometers, goniometers, radiography, computerized tomography and cineroentgenography have been used in an attempt to measure these movements but none have provided satisfactory triplanar data.

This paper uses the Zebris ultrasonic 3-D motion analysis system to measure flexion, extension, range of lateral bending and range of axial rotation in five similar male and five similar female subjects with no history of neck injuries. The subjects were tested in a soft and hard collar, Philadelphia, Miami J and Minerva.

Results show that the Minerva is significantly the most stable construct for restriction of movement in all planes in both groups (p< 0.002 vs. all groups, Student’s t-test), but more impressively in the female group. In the male group, the standard hard collar performs second best in flexion, lateral bending and axial rotation. In the female group, the second most stable orthosis is the Philadelphia in flexion/extension and the hard collar in lateral bending and axial rotation (p< 0.05 vs. next most stable in all cases, Student’s t-test). The soft collar in both groups offered only minimal resistance to movement in any plane, e. g. 45.07° vs. 46.45° extension vs. normal in males and 40.15° vs. 41.8° extension vs. normal in females.

Looking at these results together allows the ranking of the measured orthoses in order of the three-dimensional stability they offer. Furthermore, they validate the Zebris as a reliable and safe method of measurement of the complex movements of the cervical spine with low intersubject variability.

In conclusion, this paper, for the first time presents reproducible data incorporating the composite triplanar movements of the cervical spine thus allowing comparative analysis of the three-dimensional construct stability of the studied orthoses.


R. Kumar C. M. Bolger C. P. Little J Nagaria N Patel

Objective: Spontaneous spinal subdural haematoma is a rare cause of spinal cord compression usually confined to a few vertebral levels. When the haematoma extends over several spinal segments, surgical decompression is a major undertaking. A minimally invasive technique of decompression, using topical recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA), is presented in two patients with extensive spinal intradural haematoma.

Clinical Presentation: Two patients, receiving long-term anticoagulation therapy, presented with acute-onset back pain progressing to paraparesis. MRI of the spine demonstrated spinal subdural haematomas extending over fifteen vertebral levels in one and twelve in the other patient.

Intervention: An angiography catheter was introduced into the subdural space through a limited laminectomy. Thrombolysis and evacuation of haematoma was then achieved by intermittent irrigation of the subdural space with recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA), followed by saline lavage. Post-operative imaging demonstrated satisfactory decompression in both patients. There was significant improvement of neurological function in one patient.

Conclusion: Topical application of rt-PA for spinal sub-dural haematoma allows evacuation of the haematoma through a limited surgical exposure. Decompression of the subdural space by this minimally invasive technique may be advantageous over extensive surgery by minimizing surgical exposure, reducing postoperative pain and risk of neuronal injury. This technique may be useful in patients presenting with compression extending over several vertebral levels or poor surgical candidates.


U. K. Debnath S. M. H. Mebdian.

Objective: To report a complete neurological recovery following cervical laminectomy and drainage of an extradural panspinal abscess in a patient with quadriplegia~

Design: A retrospective case analysis

Subject: Case report – A 63 year-old male was admitted to the hospital fever of 102.5F and four days old neck and back pain. On admission he was drowsy and short of breath. He was treated successfully with intravenous Penicillin for proven Pneumococcal meningitis three weeks prior to this admissjon On examination he had respiratory distress and quadripegia and upgoing plantar reflex with a sensory level below T2. He had urinary incontinence but his anal tone was preserved with intact bulbocavernosus reflex. He was ventilated for five days. The CSF culture grew Streptococcus pneumoniae. Once his breathing became normal i. e. seven day later a MRI scan revealed a diffuse extradural abscess extending from the cranio-cervical junction to the lower thoracic region posteriorly There were associated oedema and ischemic changes in the cord. He underwent a cervical lamitomy and decompression from C3–7. The intra-operative findings were pus and granulation tissue in the epidural space. The pus was drained and the infected granulation tissue was removed. He was continued postoperatively on intravenous Benzyl Penicillin The patient showed signs of neurological recovery from the third day onwards.

Outcome measures: Ravicovitch and Spallone (1982)1 suggested a grading system to indicate the post-operative neurological outcome: 0-only signs of infection, 1-Root involvement, 2-Mild Spinal cord synptoms, 3-Severe spinal cord involvement, 4- Functional tresection.

Result: The patient was discharged three weeks following the surgery and was under a rehabilitation team. At six months follow-up he was walking without support and had MRC grade 5/5 power in both his upper and lower limbs. It has been recorded in literature that the duration of neurological symptoms has been shown to influence the functional outcome. If the neurologic grade 4 is present for more than 36 hours, little or no return of function could be expected. 2,3

Conclusion: This case is unique. The reasons are: 1) Pneumococcal extradural abscess are extremely rare, 2) Ahscess posterior to the cord is also very rare, 3) A full neurological recovery even though the decompression was performed seven days following the episode.


D. Kucharzyk G. Alavanja

A study was undertaken to see the efficacy of backfilling the iliac crest post harvesting on postoperative pain levels and overall functional outcomes.

A randomized study was undertaken in which twenty patients were divided into two groups: one received backfilling of the iliac crest with corralline hydroxyapatite and the other did not.

All patients underwent posterior instrumented lumbar fusion’s with all evaluated for diagnosis, age, levels fused, and risk factors. Comparisions were made evaluating: postoperative pain, time to mobilization, rehabilitation levels, and incorporation of the corralline. Follow-up was a minimum of two years with patients still being followed.

Results revealed a reduction of pain on the analog pain scale in the corralline group compared to the non-backfilled group. This was seen at three days, two weeks, one month, three months, six months, one and two years. Pain levels were reported at one at three months and zero at six months, one and two years in the corralline group compared to five at three months and four at six months and three at one and two years. Time to mobilization was one day sooner in the corralline group. Functional outcomes were seen to be better in the corralline group as well. Incorporation of the corralline hydroxyapatite was seen in all patients.

Back-filling the iliac crest has shown to decrease pain, increase functional outcomes and produce a sooner time to mobilization and physical therapy than the non-filled iliac crest.


K. S. Conn A. D. H. Gardner D. J. Sharp.

Objectives: To surgery the UK Specialist Orthopaedic Registrars (SpRs) to assess their perceptions of and attitudes towards spinal surgery, and to identify factors discouraging interest in spinal surgery.

Introduction: In order to improve the provision of spinal surgery in the UK, the existing 175 Orthopaedic Surgeons with an interest in Spinal Surgery needs to increase by 25%. There is a predicted shortfall in the number of orthopaedic trainees intending to practise spinal surgery.

Methods: A postal questionnaire was sent to all 578 SpRs

Results: Three hundred and seventy-four replied (71%). Sixty-nine percent intend to avoid spinal surgery. Thirtyfive (9%) intend becoming either Specialist Spinal Surgeons or Surgeons with a Spinal interest. Their perceptions will be discussed; the intellectual challenge and opportunities for research are widely recognised but are outweighed by poor perceptions of outcomes of surgery, psychological complications, and of badly organised clinics. There is also inadequate exposure to spinal surgery during training.

Conclusions: Training in spinal surgery could be improved by exposure to spinal surgery at an earlier stage of training, and the development of more specialised units with properly structured spinal clinics to include triage systems to assess referrals and close liaison between the specialities required to treat these patients.


P. McCombe

Introduction: posterior lumbar interbody fusion can theoretically allow neural decompression directly and by restoration of disc height and appropriate lumbar lordosis. The technique of insertion of a trapezoidal lordotic wedge spacer (ramp) into the disc space before rotating it into position theoretically will obtain both an increase in disc height and allow correction of lordosis. However observations suggest that incongruity between a flat implant and a curved end plate, and possible settling of the implant into the vertebral body may limit the ability of the technique to achieve its full theoretical potential. This paper attempts to establish the capacity of this technique to (1) restore disc height, and (2) alter segmental lordosis.

Methods: pre- and post-operative lateral radiographs were obtained from 34 patients who had undergone posterior lumbar interbody fusion using carbon fibre spacers with a lordotic angle of five degrees. Supplemental pedicle screws were used in all cases. The procedure was performed at l2/3 in one case, at l3/4 in two cases, at l4/5 16 cases and l5/1 in 15 cases. Measurements of pre- and post-operative lordosis, anterior and posterior disc height, slip percentage and anterior and posterior positioning of the prosthesis were made. To allow for comparison of length measurements the raw data were normalised by dividing by the inferior end plate length.

Results: stepwise multiple linear regression showed the only variable to be related to final post-operative lordosis was pre-operative lordosis (p = 0.026). There was no relationship between final lordosis and implant placement or slip percentage. The regression line suggested that small pre-operative segmental angles (less than 7.5 degrees) were increased post-operatively while large pre-operative angles (greater than 7.5 degrees) were reduced. This suggests that the segment is attempting to accommodate to the five-degree implant. The regression equation only explains 14% of the total variance (r2 = 0.144). The mean normalised posterior disc height increased significantly by 55% (0.1195 to 0.1844) (paired t test p < 0.0001) and the mean normalised anterior disc height increased by 18% (0.27151 to 0.32251) (paired t test p < 0.007). Changes in both anterior and posterior disc height were highly correlated with pre-operative disc height (r = −0.6729 p < 0.0001, r = −0.7402 p < 0.0001).

Discussion: posterior lumbar interbody fusion using a five degree wedged spacer can lead to significant improvements in anterior and posterior disc height when the disc space is narrowed and maintain disc height when the disc height is normal. The insertion of a wedged implant causes the segment to approximate the lordosis of the implant. The variation is however large. Possible causes for this variation are a mismatch between the flat implant and a curved end plate and end plate subsidence. Having a curved implant end plate and a selection of lordotic angles may possibly reduce the former effect.


E.R.G. Santos D.G. Goss R.K. Morcom R.D. Fraser

Introduction: The radiographic criteria for successful lumbar arthrodesis remains controversial. Plain radiographs including flexion-extension views are commonly used to assess fusion, but there is disagreement on the degree of apparent motion that is significant. Helical CT assessment of bridging bone between vertebrae is considered to be the most accurate method currently available. This study compared the use of plain radiographs including flexion-extension views with helical CT scans in the assessment of lumbar interbody fusion.

Methods: Plain radiographs (including flexion-extension views) and helical CT scans were performed on 32 patients (47 levels) five years after ALIF using carbon fibre cages and autologous bone. A radiologist assessed fusion utilising the Hutter method to detect movement, whilst a spinal surgeon measured movement in degrees using the Simmons method. Helical CT scans (with sagittal and coronal reformatting) were assessed for the presence of bridging trabecular bone.

Results: The radiographic fusion rate was 85% based on the presence of bridging bone, and also 85% with the Hutter method. The fusion rate was 74% when movement of at least two degrees was considered significant, but was 98% with the five degrees cut off adopted by the FDA. Fusion as determined by the presence of bridging trabeculae on helical CT Scans occurred in 67%. Concordance rates were as follows: between plain films and helical CT, 69.5%; between Hutter method and plain films, 76%; between Simmon’s method (two degrees) and helical CT, 67%; and between Simmon’s method with the FDA cut-off of five degrees and CT, 65%.

Discussion: The assessment of fusion with radiographs appears to be unreliable. The use of plain films and flexion-extension radiographs clearly overestimated the actual fusion rates. Furthermore, there was low concordance between these methods and the more reliable helical CT. This disparity between fusion rates from radiographs and with helical CT supports the view that plain radiographs, including flexion-extension films are of limited value in the assessment of spinal arthrodesis.


W. Sears

Introduction: Since Briggs and Milligan1 first described posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF) in 1944, posterior lumbar interbody fusion has been a controversial fusion technique. Reports regarding the safety, efficacy and fusion rates have varied greatly over the years. Modern pedicle screw instrumentation and the use of intervertebral spreaders / implants have provided a powerful technique for the restoration of spinal balance in degenerative deformity.

Since 1993, the author has performed over 400 posterior interbody fusions for a wide variety of degenerative, traumatic and neoplastic conditions. A review was undertaken of 362 consecutive patients who were managed with this technique between October 1993 and July 2001. The purpose of this review was to determine the efficacy and safety of the technique and in particular, to attempt to identify those factors, which have contributed to patient outcomes.

Methods: The first 86 patients underwent wide posterior decompression with resection of facet joints and interbody grafting using morcellised posterior elements and pedicle screw stabilisation. From February 1995, the interbody graft was supplemented with Carbon wedge shaped spacers bearing serrated upper and lower surfaces (Ramps). From July of 1996 (patient 170), the interbody graft was supplemented with posterior grafting, and from December 2000 with Autologous Growth Factor (AGF) treated graft.

Patient pre-operative, operative and post-operative data and complications and follow-up Surgeon Subjective Outcome Assessments (SSOA’s) were acquired prospectively. Questionnaires were administered seeking patient generated follow-up data, including Patient Subjective Outcome Assessment (PSOA).

Results: Follow-up data (SSOA ± PSOA) was available on 327 or 91% of patients. The data was for periods greater than 6 months in 64% of patients. PSOA data was available on 31% – mean follow-up time for these patients was 27.7 months (± 25.8). Average age at surgery was 56 years (± 16). Average number of levels operated was 1.5 (± 0.9). Average number of previous surgeries was 0.7 (± 1.0). 286 patients were private and 76 were compensation. 88 patients had no deformity while the remainder had some form of deformity, the most common of which were spondylolisthesis – 156 and scoliosis – 94.

Overall, private patients did much better (very good or excellent outcomes) than compensation ones: 76% vs. 57% (p < 0.002). Patients who underwent surgery for conditions associated with deformity did significantly better than those without: 80% vs. 57% (p < 0.01). The outcomes since the introduction of interbody serrated spacers and additional posterior grafting have been significantly improved: for private patients, 86% now vs. 62% (p < 0.002).

The introduction of ramps improved the non-union rate from 16.3% in the first 86 patients to 8.3% in the next 84. The addition of posterior grafting improved the non-union rate to 1.0% in the next 198 patients. There have been no non-unions since the introduction of AGF.

Serious complications included three deaths, five deep infections, eight early returns to theatre for radiculopathy, four partial and one complete foot drop, four CSF leaks and one pulmonary embolus. Of the patients surveyed, 123/131 or 94% considered the surgery worthwhile and 88% said that they would have it again, if necessary.

Discussion: Refinements in technique and improved patient selection have resulted in a significant improvement in clinical outcomes over the last eight years. While technically demanding, this PLIF technique now yields a high fusion rate, the ability to fully correct sagittal and coronal deformity and a high rate of good or excellent clinical outcomes: 86% in private patients.


S.L. Blumenthal R.D. Guyer S.H. Hochschuler D.D. Ohnmeiss

Introduction: There is a great deal of interest in intervertebral disc arthroplasty. These devices have been used in Europe for more than 10 years. There have been several reports published on the European results when using the SB Charité III (link) prosthesis and good results have been reported in 63% to 79% of patients1,2,3. The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate surgical outcome following implantation of an artificial disc.

Methods: The SB Charité III device has two cobalt chromium plates with a polyethylene core between them. Motion occurs through articulation between the concave/convex surfaces of the plates and core. The disc prosthesis is implanted using the same approach as used for anterior lumbar interbody fusion procedures. It comes in multiple sizes to accommodate variations in individual patient size.

The disc has been implanted in 39 patients in our clinic. This group includes 19 males and 20 females (mean age 39.8 years, range 26 to 54 years). The primary study inclusion criteria were single-level symptomatic disc degeneration, failure of at least six months of non-operative treatment, and no previous surgery at the operated segment. Outcome measures included neurological examination, radiographic assessment, Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Questionnaire, visual analog scale (VAS) assessing pain, SF-36, and work status. Data were collected pre-operatively, and at six weeks, three, six, and 12 months post-operatively. To date, 22 patients have reached the 12 months follow-up point.

Results: Overall, patients demonstrated improvement in the self-reported outcome measures. The mean VAS score improved approximately 50% at the six weeks follow-up and this improvement was maintained during subsequent follow-up. The Oswestry scores improved 37% at six weeks follow-up and had improved by 50% at subsequent follow-ups. Radiographic assessment revealed no cases of device displacement or migration. Complications were comparable to those reported for anterior lumbar interbody fusion. There have been no cases of device failure.

Discussion: The results of this prospective study, using patient self-report questionnaires, demonstrated good clinical outcome. There was a significant improvement noted six weeks post-operatively that was maintained during the follow-up visits. The disc prosthesis can be implanted safely, with complications similar to those encountered with anterior lumbar interbody fusion. As with any surgical procedure, long-term prospective follow-up is needed and data will be collected as these patients reach 24 months follow-up.


R. Hitchcock W. Sears M. Gillies B. Milthorpe W. Walsh

Introduction: The lordosis of the lumbar spine, flexion angle and body weight result in significant shear forces through the lumbar and lumbosacral disc spaces. These shear forces result in translational motion across the disc space, which is resisted but not completely abolished by pedicle screw stabilisation. Failure of lumbar interbody fusions through non-union may be related to translational micromotion at the vertebral endplate / bone graft interface. A porcine in vitro model was established to test whether variations in the design of inter-body implants and in particular, the presence of surface serrations would assist in resisting shear forces – especially those causing anterior translation.

Methods: Measurements of anterior vertebral translation were recorded on porcine cervical spine segments, subjected to 25 N antero-posterior shear load while under a 300 N compressive pre-load. Baseline testing was firstly performed on the intact specimens and following removal of the facet joints. The annulus, disc nucleus and cartilaginous endplates were then removed and the specimens were divided into two groups for testing using interbody implants. Four stainless steel blocks measuring 15 mm (length) × 5 mm (height) × 4 mm (width) were manufactured to act as intervertebral disc spacers. Two were made with smooth surfaces and two were made with 1 mm deep serrations on the upper and lower surfaces. One group was tested with two smooth and one with two serrated implants.

Results: Under 25 N shear load, the specimens tested with the serrated implants showed anterior vertebral translation of 0.046 ± 0.013 mm while those tested with the smooth surfaced implants measured 0.152 ± 0.075 mm (p < 0.01). A significant difference was also found between the stiffness of the specimens implanted with smooth surfaced (432.8 N/mm) and serrated (1088.4 N/mm) implants (p < 0.01). The value for peak load at failure for the specimens with smooth surfaced implants (150.43N) was less than those implanted with serrated implants (175.48 N), but not significantly different.

Discussion: The presence of surface serrations on the interbody implants significantly increased the resistance to shear forces in this model. In the clinical setting, we postulate that the degree of micromotion generated by anterior shear forces at interbody fusion sites should be substantially less when serrated implants are used and reduce the incidence of non-union. This may explain the improved fusion rates reported by contemporary authors when using some interbody implants. Further research is needed to clarify the combined effects of pedicle screw stabilisation and interbody implants upon shear displacement and variations in implant design.


M. Scott-Young L. Tan

Introduction: This is a prospective study to determine the effectiveness of artificial disc replacements in the treatment of discogenic low back pain. There has been increasing interest in the possibility of preserving the motion of a diseased vertebral motion segment by various biomechanical designs. Preserving the motion of the segment, rather than opting for arthrodesis seems intuitively to be a more favourable treatment for several spine disorders.

Up until now most spine surgery has been salvage (correcting the effects of trauma, stabilising correcting deformity, fusing degenerative segments) not restoration of normal function. As new alternatives to fusion come to fruition, we now have the ability to truly restore the spine to normal function. Spinal arthroplasty is a new concept and includes total disc replacement, nuclear replacement and there are efforts by investigators looking at posterior element reconstruction or facet replacement.

Methods: The data have been collected from the surgical experience of one surgeon since commencement of this procedure in 1996. Data were collected from pre-operative, post-operative clinical and patient questionnaires (both pre- and post-operative) and radiological assessment.Patient questionnaires include Roland-Morris Questionnaire, Oswestry Questionnaire, Visual Analogue Scores, and SF36 Data.

Results: 86 Patients have had implantation of the Charite artificial disc prosthesis “Link”; 113 levels have been instrumented; 42 males, 44 females; follow-up two months to five years, average follow-up 20 months.

The results so far indicate good to excellent in 84% of cases. Complications have the potential to be catastrophic but attention to surgical detail results in minimal complications which will be discussed in the body of the presentation.

Discussion: This paper is a prospective study. It also represents a personal surgical evolution and understanding of the role disc replacement plays in the treatment of discogenic low back pain. Disc replacement should be used as part of the armamentarium a spine surgeon can utilise in his practice. There are strict guidelines and criteria that need to be adhered to if optimal results are to be obtained. The artificial disc which has been most extensively used in the world is the Link SB Intervertebral Prosthesis. To date, over 2000 cases have been performed worldwide. The study is not intended to suggest that routine or indiscriminate use of the artificial disc replacement is warranted, but rather serves to provide a framework for further investigation to the utility of spinal arthroplasty with function intervertebral replacements.


R.F. Davis D. Long J. Yingling

Introduction: Anterior lumbar interbody fusion has become a frequently utilised procedure. The trend has been towards less invasive techniques including laparascopic and mini-open techniques. This report examines the results of one procedure and suggests appropriate tools to decrease the learning curve.

Methods: Twenty-two patients with a mean age of 41 (17–78) underwent mini-open ALIF with threaded cortical bone dowels. The same senior surgeon performed all procedures (RFD). Indication for the procedure was discogenic pain verified by concordant discography after a failure of a minimum of six months non-operative treatment. Patients were followed at standard intervals. Complications as well as the evolution of surgical technique were recorded prospectively for all patients.

Results: Twenty-one of 22 patients had the successful implantation of two dowels at each level. Intraoperative fluoroscopy and auditory EMG monitoring was used in all cases. Thirty-two levels were fused from L2–S1 (Average =1.39 levels). Average length of stay was 2.96 days (1–14). Follow-up averaged 24.93 months (2–36). Fusion was achieved in 15/16(93%) of the one level cases but only 3/6 (50%) of the two level cases. Posterior reoperation with posterolateral fusion and pedicle screws was performed in 2/3 of these patients. Use of a dedicated pin-based anterior lumbar retractor enabled a 45% reduction in incision length with a 40% decrease in operative time. Complications included: massive bleeding (1), post-operative dysesthetic leg pain (2), postoperative kyphosis (2), lateral graft displacement (1).

Discussion and conclusion: ALIF remains a formidable surgical procedure. Precise identification of the midline and use of fluoroscopy assures good placement of the devices. Preoperative osteopenia should be recognised and treated with posterior stabilisation. Posterior stenosis should be a relative contraindication. We have abandoned multilevel standalone procedures given the poor fusion rate. A pin-based retractor allows a smaller incision with less operative time. Attention to myriad technical details remains paramount.


M. Scott-Young L. Tan

Introduction: Anterior cervical discectomy and inter-body fusion (ACDF) is recognised as an effective surgical treatment for cervical degenerative disc disease. The goals of anterior discectomy, interbody graft placement, and subsequent fusion, are to improve and maintain intervertebral height, establish and maintain physiological cervical lordosis, and achieve arthrodesis so as to eliminate pathological motion. Establishing the most clinically effective and cost effective operative approach to achieve these goals while, at the same time, minimising post-operative complications, is currently an evolving process. One view is that the use of anterior cervical plates reduces graft-related complications, maintains the cervical alignment, and leads to a higher incidence of fusion. In addition, there is evidence to suggest that there is a direct cost benefit of earlier return to pre-operative function and employment.

Bone graft: Iliac crest autograft would be regarded as the gold standard source of bone for ACDF. However, donor site complications (due to harvesting autograft) are not insignificant and range from 1% to a sizeable 29%. These complications include iliac crest fracture, infection, persisting pain, neural injury, bowel injury, etc. With the advent of bone banks, allograft has become available and eliminates the problem of graft-harvest related complications. There is a theoretical risk of disease transmission and a corresponding difficulty with patients accepting donated tissue. To date, no HIV cases transmission has occurred from ACDF allograft. There are several studies that demonstrate a significant difference in fusion rates when comparing allograft and autograft. The preponderance of data from the literature supports the conclusion that the use of allograft in ACDF can lead to a higher incidence of graft collapse, pseudarthrosis, and possible subsequent revision surgery. Bishop et al., (Spine 1991 16:726–9): have documented a higher increase in pseudarthrosis rate, graft collapse, and interspace angulation in the allograft group compared to the autograft group. Therefore, the dilemma of allograft being preferred as a basis of eliminating graft harvesting complications, while at the same time being associated with a higher incidence of fusion failure and deformity, have led some surgeons to trial the combination of allograft with anterior plate fixation. Shapiro (J Neurosurg 1966 84:161–5) has reported no incidences of fusion failure, graft collapse, progressive kyphosis, or plate-related complications in 82 consecutive single and multiple level ACDF’s using allograft and anterior plating.

Treatment failure: The incidence of the following complications have been reported in the literature. (Graham JJ. Spine 1989 14:1046–50).

Pseudarthrosis – 3%–36%

Graft collapse – 3%–14%

Graft extrusion – 0.5%–4%

These figures are regardless of the graft source and are significant. Recent studies show that the combination of graft and anterior plate fixation virtually eliminates the complication of graft extrusion, and also decreases the risk of graft collapse and development of pseudarthrosis. There are also studies that contend that plate fixation can maintain proper lordotic alignment of the spine more effectively than can ACDF without plating. I contend that the use of contemporary cervical plates significantly decreases the rate of fusion failure and graft-related complications without imparting significant implant-related complications.

As a result, there is decreased overall risk to the patient.

The current type of plates which are available are unicortical with locking systems that substantially decrease the risk of screw loosening or hardware migration.


A.B. Fagan G.N. Askin J.W.S. Earwaker

Introduction: This is a prospective study of a series of consecutive cases of Os Odontoideum focussing on CT and MRI data. Both congenital and post-traumatic aetiologies have been proposed in the literature. This can lead to confusion in a medico-legal and clinical setting.

Methods: Radiological, CT and MRI data from 26 consecutive cases of cranio-cervical anomalies were collected prospectively. Demographic details, the presence of any recent or remote traumatic aetiology and the clinical presentation were obtained from the medical record. A reconstructed mid-sagittal CT was examined for the thickness of the arch of C1, the size and location of the Os and the morphology of the atlantodens joint. The presence of any cord impression or signal change was obtained from the MRI.

Results: 18 cases of Os Odontoideum were identified. Only one had a history of significant trauma remote from presentation. All adults had an abnormal archdens joint configuration (the ‘Jigsaw’ sign) with one exception. The atlantodens ratio was significantly greater in all cases of Os odontoideum indicating a relatively thickened anterior arch of the atlas. One case of non-union of a dens fracture presenting five or more years after the injury was identified in this series. Neither in this case nor two cases of transverse ligament rupture and two cases of Ossiculum terminale, was a thickened arch or an abnormal atlantodens joint observed. 12 of the cases presented after traumatic injury to the neck. In only three of these was there any abnormal neurological signs.

Conclusions: Os Odontoideum has a characteristic appearance of the anterior C1 arch and the atlantodens joint as viewed on CT. These radiological signs are not observed after dens fractures. They may be taken to indicate a congenital aetiology for the condition. Patients with Os odontoideum are able to tolerate moderate to severe levels of injury without sustaining significant acute cord damage.


R.E. Thompson T.M. Barker M.J. Pearcy

Introduction: the neutral zone is defined as a region of no or little resistance to motion in the middle of an intervertebral joint’s range of movement. Previous studies have used quasistatic loading regimes that do not model physiological activity1. The aim of the present study was to assess experimentally the existence of the neutral zone of intervertebral joints during spinal motion in flexion/extension, lateral bending and axial rotation during physiological movements simulated using a robotic testing facility. Sheep intervertebral joints were used as they have been shown to exhibit similar mechanical behaviour to human joints2.

Methods: five spines from mature sheep were used. Three specimens were tested from each spine to simulate human l1/2, l3/4 and l4/5 intervertebral joints. The robotic facility enabled the testing regime to be defined for each individual joint based on its geometry. The joints were tested by cycling through the full range of physiological movement in flexion/extension, lateral bending and axial rotation.

Results: a neutral zone was found to exist during dynamic movements only in flexion/extension. The results were equivocal for lateral bending and suggested that a neutral zone does not exist in axial rotation. The zygapophysial joints were shown to be significant in determining the mechanics of the intervertebral joints as their removal increased the neutral zone in all cases. A criterion for defining the size of the neutral zone was proposed.

Conclusions: a neutral zone exists in flexion/extension during dynamic movements of intervertebral joints. This has important implications for the muscular control of the spine consisting of several intrinsically lax joints stacked on one another.


N. Bogduk M. Karasek

Introduction: On the basis of observational data, intradiscal electrothermal anuloplasty (IDETA) has been implemented as a treatment for back pain due to internal disc disruption. In order to assess the efficacy of IDETA, a prospective cohort study with comparison group was commenced in 1998. The present study provides the two-year results of that study.

Methods: Of 53 patients who satisfied the diagnostic criteria for internal disc disruption 36 were allocated to a treatment group and 17 to a comparison group, according to whether or not their insurer approved treatment with IDETA. Outcomes were assessed in terms of relief of pain, return to work, and use of opioids to treat persisting pain, at three months, twelve months, and two years after treatment.

Results: As a group, the comparison patients exhibited no significant improvement in their pain at any time. One was partially relieved, but no patient was completely relieved at either 12 or 24 months. The patients treated with IDETA exhibited significant improvements in their median pain scores, which were sustained at 12 and 24 months. At 24 months, 54% of these patients had achieved at least 50% relief of their pain, no longer used opioids, and were at work. Seven patients (20%) were totally free of pain and at work at 24 months.

Discussion: Despite the small sample size, the study had 90% power to detect the differences encountered at three months, 78% power at two years. The long-term results of IDETA are stable and enduring. It is not universally successful, but 54% of patients can reduce their pain by half, and one in five patients can expect to achieve complete relief of their pain. The results encountered in the present study are better than those reported in the literature, but may be attributed to more stringent selection of patients and closer attention to the accuracy of operative technique. Given the benchmark established by this study, consumers should beware of observational and controlled studies that achieve lesser results, lest these be used to impugn the procedure rather than the operator.


R.F. Davis

Pain management has remained a challenge for surgeons since the dawn of organised medicine. A massive influx of unproven techniques and alternative therapies has descended upon us with little regard to true efficacy and even safety. It is incumbent upon us as practitioners of medicine to finally begin to pay more attention to the tenets of evidenced based medicine while making therapeutic choices.

Johns Hopkins has had a long history of dealing with pain in many of its chameleon forms ranging from the management of acute post-operative pain to the more difficult management of chronic pain. To effectively manage pain in a surgical practice requires attention to first establishing the type of pain (ie. nociceptive or neuropathic). Once the type of pain is clear, specific algorithms can be worked out based on the principles of evidenced based medicine which can be carried out by a variety of paramedical personnel (ie. Physician Assistants or Nurses) without specific surgeon input. This maximises benefit to the patient and minimises problems for the surgeon. Specific algorithms for the management of acute LBP, chronic LBP, acute postoperative pain, chronic postoperative pain, cancer pain and sociopathic pain will be discussed.


R.F. Davis D.F. Antezana A.W. Poetscher J. Yingling J. Awad M. Schlosser D.M. Long

Introduction: Although anterior cervical discectomy and fusion is a well-established technique for arthrodesis of the cervical spine, there are limited data on the use of allograft with plate in large series. There are even fewer such studies that incorporate three and four level fusions. We report our experience with 252 patients (530 levels).

Methods: 252 patients underwent anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) with plate and allograft (91-one level, 74-two levels, 57-three levels, 30-four levels; 530 total levels) via a modified Smith-Robinson technique. Radiographic fusion was determined with plain X-rays at predetermined intervals. Fusion was defined as no lucent line and no hardware failure. Average follow-up was 22.5 months. Average age was 50 years (M 26, F 19). Comorbidities included 58 smokers and 16 diabetics. Patients wore an external orthosis for six weeks.

Results: There were six reoperations for junctional disease outside the original fusion construct. 16 patient developed junctional disease. 28 levels had residual radiographic lucent lines and/or hardware failure at most recent follow-up for a fusion rate of 94.7% (502/530). Complications occurred in 32 patients (6.0%). There included 16 instances of hardware failure and/or pseudoarthrosis, nine of which occurred in the three and four level group, dysphagia (9), vocal cord dysfunction (2), respiratory distress (2), wound hematoma (2), wound infection (1).

Conclusion/discussion: Extremely high fusion rates were recorded in this series, including three and four level constructs, with an acceptable complication rate. We believe that outstanding results are obtainable with allograft and plate, even at three or four levels. The principles of precise fit and fill of the interspace with a contoured graft and fixation with compression and instrumentation must be employed.


W. Sears

Introduction: The management of patients with thoracolumbar burst fractures has evolved over the last 60 years from the days of conservative management through to the current era of anterior decompression combined with either anterior or posterior stabilisation. There is no doubt that surgical outcomes have improved markedly with the more modern techniques. Nevertheless, there are still technical and other difficulties, which the surgeon may encounter. Based upon his experience with posterior vertebrectomy and reconstruction for thoracolumbar tumours, the author has used this technique for the management of acute burst fractures in this region.

This paper presents a review of 10 patients with severe thoracolumbar burst fracture or fracture dislocation managed since 1997, using a single stage posterior decompression, realignment and stabilisation/interbody fusion.

Methods: Data were acquired prospectively on consecutive patients between June 1997 and October 2000. All patients underwent single stage posterior decompression via laminectomy and then a subtotal eggshell vertebrectomy with removal of any herniated bone fragment(s) or partial vertebrectomy/ pedicle subtraction osteotomy. Pedicle screw stabilisation was performed to include one or two vertebrae above and below the involved vertebra(e). The intervertebral discs adjacent to the fractured vertebra were removed prior to realigning the vertebral column and performing inter-body fusion using carbon fibre spacers and autograft (4 patients) or vertebral body reconstruction with Titanium mesh cages and autograft (6 patients).

Results: The mean age was 37 years (21–52 years). There were six males and four females. Three patients had no neurological deficit. Seven had incomplete paraplegia, three of which were severe with no or only a flicker of leg movement. The principal fracture involved L1 in 6 patients, L2 in 2, L4 in 1 and L5 in 1. Seven had herniated bone fragments occupying 90+% of the spinal canal. Of the seven patients with incomplete paraplegia, all recovered the ability to walk. Two with conus lesions still self catheterize. There were no serious early complications. A serious late complication was the development at three months of a severe deep wound infection, which required debridement and subsequent anterior/ posterior revision surgery. One patient with severe polytrauma and an L4 burst fracture/dislocation has developed a chronic pain syndrome.

Discussion: The decompression, realignment, interbody reconstruction and stabilisation of thoracolumbar burst fractures/dislocations using a single stage posterior technique is technically demanding but the neurological outcome and restoration of spinal balance in these 10 patients was gratifying. The procedure appears to have two advantages over an anterior decompression and reconstruction combined with anterior or posterior stabilisation: first, it appears to provide easier access and improved visualisation for lumbar burst fractures where the psoas muscle may be swollen and contused, and second, it allows for easier realignment of any coronal or sagittal deformity.


W. Findlay T. Coyne F. Tomlinson

Introduction: The management of cervical spine fracture, subluxation or dislocation in the elderly may present difficulties in decision-making. Frequently, the elderly suffer from medical comorbidity and a limited physiological reserve, which need to be considered in deciding on surgical versus conservative management of fractures and dislocations. Debate exists regarding the merits of surgical versus nonsurgical management of these injuries.1,2,4

Methods: Retrospective analysis of 16 patients with traumatic cervical spine fractures with or without dislocation or subluxation in patients greater than 65 years of age, spanning 1994 to the present were carried out. Success of spine stabilisation, time in hospital, ability to return to pre-injury function and medical or surgical complications were measured.

Results: The average age of the patients was 76 years with a range of 67–86 years of age. A variety of cervical injuries and fixation methods were identified, the most common injury being odontoid fracture requiring transarticular screw fixation. One patient died eight days post-operatively of cardiac arrest and a second patient died of pneumonia. One other complication of wound hematoma while the patient was taking anticoagulation therapy occurred. All other patients were discharged independent in activities of daily living. There were no cases of failure of surgery to restore stability. No post-operative neurological deterioration in any of the patients occurred.

Discussion: This study shows that surgical fixation of cervical fractures in the elderly can be performed as a safe and efficient form of management. Surgery decreases the period of both immobility and hospitalisation with subsequent decrease in the risk of complications such as deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism and pneumonia3.Complications from immobilisation devices such as the halo-thoracic brace may also be avoided.


P.A. Robertson H.J. Rawlinson A.T. Hadlow

Introduction: Large anterior column defects of the thoracolumbar spine, after fracture decompression, tumour or other pathological resection, or spinal osteotomy present significant difficulties in respect to autograft procurement, donor site morbidity, graft instability and residual spinal instability. Titanium Mesh Cages for reconstruction thoracolumbar vertebral body defects (after corpectomy) offer an alternative to structural iliac crest autograft or allograft. The use of TMCs for inter-body reconstruction has been addressed yet the use of larger cages for corpectomy reconstruction has not. This study examines implant stability and deformity correction of TMCs following corpectomy reconstruction in the thoracolumbar spine.

Methods: Independent radiological review before, after and at follow-up (one year) was performed for 27 patients having implantation of TMCs. Measurement of thoracolumbar kyphosis was performed before surgery, immediately post operatively, and at one year follow-up. Correction of kyphosis was expressed both as angular improvement and percentage improvement. Cage settling into adjacent vertebral bodies, translational deformities and any evidence of implant failure was sought.

Results: Indications for reconstruction with TMC included burst fracture (13), post traumatic kyphosis (8), primary tumour resection (3), debridement of infection (1), and stabilisation of severe kyphotic deformity in achodroplasia with associated spinal stenosis requiring decompression (2). Desired resection and decompression was achieved as indicated. Correction of kyphosis was a mean of 12 deg / 61% (range 0 – 38 deg, 0–85%). No cage moved. One patient had kyphosis recurrence of > 5 deg (12 deg). Five patients demonstrated some settling of the cage within adjacent vertebral bodies (1–8%, mean 3.4% of height loss over construct length – the vertebral body above to the body below). Translational malposition of three cages occurred. One of these cases demonstrated the maximum settling and another was associated with the only case of instrumentation failure. Clinically significant spinal canal intrusion did not occur. One cage demonstrated buckling of the wall without evidence of other problem and the clinical result was excellent.

Discussion: Use of TMCs is safe when managing vertebral body reconstruction. Significant kyphosis or translational deformity has not occurred, however minor cage settling within adjacent vertebra may occur. Fusion rate is unknown as the cage mesh obscures graft maturation. Construct failure has only occurred after pre operative translational malalignment could not be corrected. This demanding procedure offers a reconstructive option with superior structural stability and reduced bone grafting morbidity.


G.M. Weisz

Introduction: Described by Jacques Forrestier at the beginning of the 20th century, the disease was named ankylosing hyperostosis of the spine1. Since that time various other names have been accorded to it, the most comprehensive being dish: diffuse, idiopathic, skeletal, hyperostosis2. The disease is often misdiagnosed by radiologists, unrecognised by surgeons and considered a silent condition. To diffuse this myth of ‘innocence ‘ I am presenting syndromes collected from over 80 patients, during some 20 years.

Methods: the clinical syndromes were recorded, with emphasis on general health and family history. The physical examination recorded the rigidity of spinal movements and neurological changes. All patients were exposed to plain films and CT scan of the spine, to barium meal and /or laryngoscopy.

Results: Only clinical assessment and radiological illustrations were the aim of this review: Cervical syndromes: – painful ankylosis; stenosis with myelopathy (3);

-Tracheal compression with laryngeal nerve palsy;

-Esophageal compression with endoscopic implications. (4).

Dorsal syndromes: painful ankylosis, spinal stenosis & myelopathy (5,6,);

Lumbar syndromes: painful hyperlordotic ankylosis, spinal stenosis (7);

Sacroiliac fusion (8); calcifications of iliosacral and iliolumbar ligaments.

Extra spinal calcifications: peri articular at elbow, hips and in operative scars: Achilles’ repair; Post-laparatomy abdominal wall ossification (9).

Particular features: early onset (age 40); incidence in families with two brothers and another with three brothers.

Discussion: Presentation of multilevel spinal syndromes and extra-spinal symptomatic calcification/ossification is intended to dispel the “innocence” of this disease. Except the ankylosis, often asymptomatic, the approximate symptomatic disease was found to be of 10%.


A. Fagan N. Eames G. Askin

Introduction: The purpose of this study is to present the current results of a series of 21 cases operated on over the past two years. This is the only series of this type in Australia to date. Although the technique was first reported four years ago, two year results have not been reported or published.

Methods: This study is a prospective single cohort study. The technique is applicable to approximately half of the adolescent idiopathic cases requiring surgery in a busy spinal deformity practice. Clinical radiological and patient derived outcome data are collected pre-operatively and at six weeks, three months, 12 months and 24 months post operatively.

Results: The series comprised 17 females and 1 male. Median age was 16 years (range 10–37). A median of four portals was used (range 3–5), six discs excised (range 4–8) and seven levels instrumented (range 5–9). Operating time was a median of 6 h (range 4.5–7). Median blood loss was 300 ml (range 20–2000). Mean intra-operative x-ray time was 160 s (range 130–190). Rib hump was corrected from a mean of 170 to 70. The Cobb angle was converted from a mean of 510 to a mean of 240, a correction rate of 52%. There has been no loss of correction in any case to date. Further to the minor complications outlined last year there has been one case of persistent postoperative deltoid pain from the dependant shoulder that resolved after several days.

Discussion: The thoracoscopic technique has proven safe and effective. A more cosmetic wound is achieved and one or two levels in the thoracolumbar spine are spared from fusion.


J-L. Clement E. Chau

Introduction: Some authors (Suk, Barr, Hamill ...) showed that lumbar and thoracic pedicle screws provided adequate reduction of scoliosis. Quality of reduction depends on primary stability of the vertebral anchors. If the anchor has a good primary stability, reduction forces are entirely transferred to the vertebra, which results in reduction of the deformity, whereas, if the anchor has a poor primary stability, it will move when subjected to reduction forces, and this will result in inadequate reduction. Lumbar screws which are advocated by many authors, are extensively used. Thoracic screws are only used by a limited number of surgeons, as most surgeons favour hooks. Polyaxiality facilitates rod positioning; it eliminates the orthogonal stresses that are generated during tightening and which are known to be responsible for screw fracture. The drawback manoeuvre consists in applying forces directly to the vertebra via the anchor; the deformity is reduced by gently translating the vertebra towards the rod. The polyaxial vertebral claw that we are presenting here is a self-stabilising implant that provides the same primary stability as the screw and allows application of multidirectional drawback forces.

Materials and methods: The system consists of self-stabilising vertebral anchors, either screws or claws. Each anchor is polyaxial and features a threaded extension that allows translation of the vertebra towards the rod. Connection of the screw or claw to the rod is provided by connecting clamps. The first operative step consists of inserting the vertebral anchors, favouring the apex of the deformity. The insertion technique is described in detail. The claw is locked independently, prior to securing the rod on to the claw. The second operative step consists of positioning the rods which are bent to the ideal sagittal curve. Polyaxiality and threaded extensions make rod positioning an easy step. Progressive tightening of the nuts results in correction of the deformity as it slowly moves the vertebrae towards the rods. The translation force is distributed over all the anchors, ensuring a gentle reduction manoeuvre with no risk of back out of the implants. Approaching vertebrae at the end of the reduction manoeuvre results in vertebral derotation. It is not necessary to use distraction which is considered hazardous.

Results: 35 such instrumentations have been used in patients with idiopathic scoliosis over the previous 12 months. We have used an average of nine screws and four claws per patient, mainly thoracic pedicle/transverse claws. Main curve correction was 71% (average curve was 59° preoperatively and 17° postoperatively). Average correction of the uninstrumented lumbar curve was 73%. The upper curve improved from 34° to 15°. The slope of the first uninstrumented vertebra was 14° pre-operatively and 6° postoperatively. In the sagittal plane, the average angle of thoracic kyphosis in hollow backs (kyphosis less than 15°) was 9°, increasing up to 27° postoperatively.

Discussion: This instrumentation is characterised by stable implants which provide a quality of reduction similar to that achieved with pedicle screws. Vertebral claws are easy to insert and have a better primary stability than screws.

Poly-axiality is a common feature to all the implants of this system; it greatly facilitates placement of the implants and allows to apply traction simultaneously to all the anchors, which results in progressive, gentle reduction. Simultaneous traction application ensures adequate correction of the thoracic kyphosis (gain of 18°). As a matter of fact, severe kyphosis can be bent into the rods, and translation of the vertebrae towards the rods is very easy. Adequate reduction of the main curve results in correction of the underlying lumbar curve and shifting of the first uninstrumented vertebra into a more horizontal position.

Conclusion: This instrumentation based on stable poly-axial implants, should allow to improve the quality of reduction of scoliosis.


S.V. Hadlow

Introduction: The purpose of this case report is to highlight an unusual presentation of a well-described but rare condition (idiopathic spinal epidural lipomatosis) in association with a commonly presenting problem (far-lateral disc herniation).

Methods: Retrospective case report and review of the literature.

Results: A 46-year-old Caucasian male presented with right L5 radiculopathy secondary to a far-lateral lumbosacral disc protrusion, confirmed on MRI scanning. Treatment consisted of a right L5 foraminal steroid injection with a 50% improvement in symptoms. This was soon followed by symptoms of spinal stenosis, and repeat MRI showed worsening of idiopathic spinal epidural lipomatosis seen on the initial scan. Over this period the patient had been unable to exercise regularly and had gained 10 kg of weight. Nonoperative treatment, including a supervised Xenical weight-reduction program (which was unsuccessful), failed to alleviate his symptoms so operative decompression was performed, with satisfactory resolution of the stenotic symptoms.

Discussion: Spinal epidural lipomatosis may be idiopathic or secondary to excess steroids (endogenous or exogenous). It affects either the thoracic or lumbar spine. Treatment options are withdrawal of exogenous steroids, weight reduction or decompressive surgery. In this case, disability associated with a far-lateral disc herniation resulted in weight gain, and subsequent stenotic symptoms from previously asymptomatic lumbar idiopathic spinal epidural lipomatosis.


G.M. Weisz M Houang

Introduction: Flat Back Syndrome resulting from decreased lumbar lordosis or increased thoracolumbar kyphosis was initially described by Doherty1 in post scoliotic surgery patients. This decompensation was later coined as fixed sagittal imbalance and was also detected in patients operated for ankylosing spondylitis or with fractured vertebrae. Various clinical symptoms were included in the syndrome such as stooped posture, knee/ hip flexion compensation, fatigue of para-spinal muscles, neck pain and upper spinal deformities, imbalanced gait. Surgical corrections were described by Kostuik2, Lagrone3, Farcy4 and others. The “normal” assessments were varying, but accepted according to Propst-Proctor5 and Bernhardt & Bidwell Segmental measurements6. The clinical diagnosis was supported by radiological evaluation using the Cobb technique and a plumbline alignment from odontoid to promontorium. This evaluation required multiple sets of x-ray films.

Methods: Our preliminary study is aiming at describing in detail the clinical syndrome in patients with lower dorsal and upper lumbar vertebral compressions. Scanogram CT- imaging of the spine is suggested for diagnosis, a rapid technique reported to be with at least 40% reduced radiation7,8. The scanogram is suggested to be functional as it is repeated in prone and in supine positions. The two films were superimposed and rigidity assessed, angles were measured (Cobb) at the T/L junction (two above and two levels below the fracture) and of the lumbar lordosis (from Inferior L1 to superior L5).

Results: This technique was applied to eight patients: the clinical syndrome is detailed with one additional, as yet unreported feature, namely the sleeping position. These were patients with two, three or four vertebral compressions, resulting in imbalance of the dorsolumbar junction and deformity of the lumbar lordosis. All patients had increased T/L kyphosis of varying degrees, all but one had parallel loss of lordotic curvature.

Discussion: A different imaging technique, functional and less irradiating is suggested for the diagnosis of fixed sagittal imbalance of the dorsolumbar spine and is applied to deformities resulting from fractured vertebrae. The clinical syndrome is enlarged with one feature, namely sleeping in prone position. These early impressions need a larger prospective study for confirmation.


G.J. Coldham H.E. Gruber E.N. Hanley

Purpose/introduction: 80% of individuals experience low back pain in their lifetime. This is often due to disc injury or degeneration. Conservative treatment of discogenic pain is often unsuccessful whilst surgery with the use of spacers of fusion is non-physiological. The aim of this study was to develop an animal model to assess the viability of autologous disc cell therapy.

Method: The Fat Sand Rat (Psammomys obesus obesus) was chosen due to its predisposition to the early development of spondylosis. Using microsurgical techniques fragments of annulus and nucleus were harvested from a single disc in 52 sand rats. Vascular clips were placed on the adjacent psoas muscle to mark the harvested level. Disc material was initially cultured in monolayer then transferred into a three dimensional culture media of agarose. This technique yields greater cellular proliferation and the development of cell growth in colonies. Cells were labelled with Bromodeoxyuridine for later immunohistochemical identification. 20 000 cells in a carrier media were then re-implanted at a second operation at an adjacent disc level in the same animal. The rat was subsequently euthanised and the histology of the disc space reviewed.

Results: To date 52 primary disc harvests and 20 reimplantations have been performed. 15 rats have been euthanised and sectioned. Average age at primary surgery was 6.8 months reimplantation eight months and euthanisation 11.2 months. Cell colony viability was inversely related to rat age at harvest. Immunohistochemical analysis of colony extracellular matrix revealed production of type 1 and 2 collagen, chondroitin and keratin sulphate Two rats died prior to reimplantation. All histological specimens confirm the presence of viable transplanted disc cells. Transplanted cells did not alter the progression of degenerative changes on x-ray.

Conclusion: Autologous disc cell transplantation can be performed in the rat. Further modification of these techniques may lead to the development of autologous disc cell therapy comparable to that currently successfully used in hyaline cartilage defects of synovial joints in humans.


B.F. Walker

Introduction: Estimates of low back pain prevalence show that low back pain is a common problem particularly in western countries. But the extent to which low back pain causes true disability and not just nuisance pain casts doubt of the utility of these estimates. No studies have been performed in Australia to study both the prevalence and disability associated with low back pain in the population. Accordingly, the objectives of this study were to determine the prevalence ranges and retrospective one year incidence of low back pain together with any related disability in Australian adults.

Methods: A survey was mailed to a stratified random sample of 3000 Australian adults selected from the Electoral Roll. There was a 69% response rate. Demographic variables of respondents were compared with those of the Australian population taken from Census data. Selective response bias was investigated using wave analysis. A range of prevalence data were derived as was a disability score using the Chronic Pain Grade Questionnaire1 (CPG). The CPG has demonstrated reliability and validity in measuring pain and disability in postal surveys2. Prevalence and disability estimates were variously standardised using gender, age and marital status.

Results: There was little variation between the sample and the Australian adult population. There was no significant selective response bias found. The sample point prevalence was estimated at 25.5% (95% CI, 23.6–27.5), six-months prevalence was 64.6% (95% CI, 62.6–66.8) and lifetime prevalence was 79.2%, (95% CI, 77.3–80.9). The retrospective one year incidence was 8.0% (95% CI, 6.9–9.3). In the previous six months period 42.6% (95% CI, 40.4–44.8) of the adult population had experienced low intensity pain and low disability from it. Another 10.9% (95% CI, 9.6–12.3) had experienced high intensity pain, but still low disability from this pain. However, 10.5% (95% CI, 9.2–11.9) had experienced high disability low back pain. The mean time-off from usual activities in the past six months for this group was 1.6 months (95% CI, 1.3–1.9), the median was 18 days. There was no gender difference for a high disability rating or time-off.

Conclusion: Low back pain is a very common problem in the Australian adult population, yet most of this is low intensity and low disability pain. Nevertheless, over 10% had been disabled by low back pain in the past six months and it required significant time off from usual activities.


D.M. Long R.F. Davis

Technology has grown at a logarithmic pace during the last century. The ability to accommodate these challenges in today’s operating theatre has become problematic. A specific task force has been established at Johns Hopkins to deal with these issues proactively.

The operating room of the future must be able to integrate technology with continuous attention to modern day economics. Contributions from surgical staff must be combined with input from administrators, architects, and industry. Physician surgical administrators are perhaps the best compromise to spearhead such projects.

I will introduce the concepts of interstitial space, imaging track systems and surgical workstations to stimulate thought and discussion.


Full Access
J. Czubak

There is a very long way from diagnosis to treatment of the developmental dysplasia of the hip. Everything is complex: clinical examination is subtle and requires a long training. Treatment is not as simple as could be thought. The risks include approximate examinations and of standard, ready-made ones. The discussion has not been settled as to whether all children with hip instability can be clinically detected at birth. The complexity of the problem arises from the fact that only 10% of children who have instability at birth develop long-term problems if they are left untreated. It is well known, affirmed by several different studies that at birth the incidence of hip instability in approximately 1–4% of patients, with figure being higher in girls. There is also a consensus that a large majority of these unstable hips will become stable during the first few days of life, even without treatment. What is not known, however, is how many of those hip that become stable will become completely normal as the child grows. These two fundamental issues are of the utmost importance. They emphasize the significance of early examination (first 48 hours) in order to detect instability and employ careful follow-up of any newborn in whom hip instability has been identified.

Some children are at particular risk of hip instability. Those infants are labeled as “high risk”. They include children born in families with hip instability, those presented by breech, first born children or products of oligohydramniotic pregnancies, particularly girls, those with the generalized joint laxity, those with torticollis and scoliosis, those with foot deformities and increased birth-weight over 4000g. Whilst all children should be screened at birth by a doctor experienced in clinical examination with particular attention directed to those children, who are considered high risk.

It must be emphasized that clinical examination is the most important for the detection of hip instability in newborns. Clinical examination should be very delicate, gentle, based on feelings rather than signs. Clinically, hip instability can be divided into: 1. irreducible dislocation, 2. reducible dislocation, 3. dislocatability, 4. subluxability. The clinical tests of instability were described by Ortolani and Barlow. Fully dislocated irreducible hip is a very rare condition and may be associated with neuromuscular abnormality. It represents dislocation well before delivery. In this form acetabulum is vacant, femoral head palpable posteriorly. There are no singns of Ortolani and Barlow tests. We can only find the sings of “pump”, which means there exists a movement along the long axis of the leg. This is the most severe pathology of the hip in DDH.The reducible dislocation is characterized by the Ortolani maneuver. With the hip flexed 90 degrees, we abduct the hip and than we feel and hear the click which is the sign of the reduction of the hip. Dislocatable and subluxatable are the most common types of pathology of the hip in DDH. This deformity arises at the end of pregnancy. This is characterized by positive Barlow test, which is the provoked-dislocation test. Using it we can dislocate or subluxate the hip. It is very rare to find restricted hip movements in newborns. The limited abduction of the affected hip is the sign typical for older children, more the 3 months of age. It is crucial to repeat the clinical examination even during the same office visit. Ultrasonography has changed our diagnostic ability for DDH. These direct examinations help us in hip evaluation in the first days of the newborn period. The exact Graf classification and methodology makes possible to classify all types of hip pathology irrespective of the examiner. Another important feature of ultrasonography is the ability to monitor the treatment not only in newborn period.

How to start with the prevention of DDH in newborn period? There is no any really good screening without collaboration of orthopedics surgeons and pediatricians. To achieve this, we must control our own environment, especially maternity hospitals and constantly keep pediatricians, pediatric nurses and obstetricians informed. There is no consensus in screening programs – general or limited. I personally recommend limited program. All newborns should be examined clinically after the delivery. The infants with positive or doubtful clinical signs and those with signs of high risk should be examined ultrasonographically immediately after delivery within first 2 weeks. The other children should be screened ultrasonographically at the time when most of the hips are mature enough. It is important, that if we live in the region with high percentage of late detected DDH (more than 3 months of age) the general clinical and ultasonographical screening program should be used.


Full Access
F. Cigala F.M. Lotito D. De Felice

The D.D.H screening programme until the second half of ’80 was based on the clinical Ortolani-Barlow’s manoeuvre at newborn age and by xray examination of the pelvis at three – four month old to discover hip joint anomalies that could be address at a future dislocation. Never less the so-called Dislocation of the Hip was a quite common pathology around Europe. The close reduction of a dislocated hip has been the treatment of choice in order to attempt to reduce a dislocated hip without surgical operation. Close reduction was preferred to be obtained after a period of skin traction on bed, at which a special frame were added, to perform a progressive gentle reduction gaining, in an average of three weeks time, complete abduction before applying a spica cast. Two main methods were used: reduction with the hips extended, abducted and internal rotated according to Sommerville- Petit and reduction in over head position with the hips flexed, abducted and external rotated. These two systems were designed to decrease the Avascular Necrosis of the femoral head that often occurs if the reduction was obtained during a sudden manoeuvre under general anaesthesia.

Generally the correct position of the femoral head into the acetabular socket, at the moment to apply the plaster, was assessed by an arthrogram, to avoid the bad surprise of further dislocation due to false reduction after the traction period.

The child so treated had to be followed during her/his growth to assess the development of acetabular roof and the position of the femoral head linked at the antiversion of the femoral neck. Any hip joint, in which acetabular index do not improve during growth, needs acetabular and femoral osteotomies to overcome these anatomical defects as cause of a persisting genetic defect.

At the end of ’80, a deep change of the natural history of D.D.H. in Italy is related to the introduction of screening programme based on accurate clinical examination of the hip of the babies at the nursery, selection of babies with risk signs of D:D.H. such as clinical anomalies, instability of the hip at Ortolani-Barlow’s, familiarity for D.D.H. and breech delivery. The hips of those babies are immediately assessed by ultrasonographic examination according to Graf’s method. The general population, on the contrary, is examined by US between the second and the third months of age. The National Health Service encourages the US screening paying its cost. In this way the incidence of late-D.D.H. and late-dislocation is enormously decreased and the outcome of the pathology has been improved. The conservative treatment of the hip affected by different grade of anomalies early discovered trough US examination, in fact, are treated by simple harness in abduction for mild dyspalsia to plaster spica cast in human position if the hip is severely unstable and Ortolani positive. There are same rare cases of true Congenital Dislocation at birth that can not be conservatively reduced and it will be necessary to perform a open reduction generally when the ossified nucleus of femoral head appeares.

Our experience:

From 1975, when our Children Orthopaedic Department was created in the Medical School of “Federico II” University of Naples and the first authors become the Chief, we admitted 374 patients affected by dislocation of the hip (F=308 – M= 66 F:M= 5:1) with a mean age of 7 and half months (min.4 mths.– max 20 mths). All these patients were put in traction on the Morel’s bed in order to attempt a close reduction in extended, abducted and internal rotated position according to Sommerville- Petit method.

Average time of traction was 25 days (min. 7 max 38). 120 patients were undergone at an arthrographic examination in general anaesthesia. 46 patients did not achieve the reduction and were operated on.

A spica cast were applied for 60 days followed by an harness in abduction. Total amount of time of treatment was a mean of 7 months (min 110 days max. 12 months). Residual dysplasia was observed in 48 patients that needed a further surgical procedure.

The number of inpatient affected by D.D.H. were an average of 21 per year until 1990 to drop dramatically at 3 per year in the last decade. On the other hand the D.D.H. outpatient clinic increased. The selected babies examined were 6930 at an average age of 4 months old. All the babies were undergone to clinical and Us examination and classified according to Graf. Hip anomalies were seen in 630 babies. The treatment was related to clinical and Us observation. Simple abduction pillow or simple harness in abduction were used in hip clinically negative at Ortolani-Barlow’s manoeuvre and 2c or 2b type according to Graf.’s classification. Milgram harness or Coxaflex harness (Thamert –Burgwedel –Germany) or plaster spica cast in “human position” were applied in instable hip type D or worse and clinically positive at Ortolani-Barlow manoeuvre. 25 patients were hospitalised because affected by irreducible hip.

Conclusion:

The experience that we have done over decades in treatment of D.D.H. confirms the assumption of Treadwell and Bell (1981) that claimed that D.D.H. screening deeply changed the natural history of D.D.H. The problem was to find a good screening test helpful to diagnose as soon as possible a pathological hip.

Graf’s method, after a decade of scientific criticism, can be elected at a worth method to screen an infant hip. Screening program based on ultrasound and clinical examination decreases hospitalisation, cost and sequels of D.D.H. in term of surgical operation and degenerative arthritis of hip joint at least at a medium follow up. The hip that need to be hospitalised are the true congenital dislocated hip for which early diagnosis probably should not effect their clinical history.

A danger is hidden in US screening. Ultrasonography has to be performed by a skill examiner and it has to be implemented by careful clinical examination with anamnestic recording of the data in order to obtain the best result of the D.D.H. screening program.


Full Access
P. Dungl

Introduction: The incidence of DDH has decreased dramatically during the last thirty years. The first reason was the introduction of targeted examination of all newborn babies (in the Czech Republic since 1977) and then our system was adopted by all of the other European countries. In the 1960s about 15% of all children were treated for different stages of hip dysplasia and there were 3% of true dislocations. These very high numbers of less serious grades of DDH are partially due to over-diagnosis and over-treatment. In the 1980s, the numbers had been reduced to 5% of dysplasias and 0.8% of dislocations. The introduction of ultrasound examination according to Graf within the first week of life has contributed to further reduction of DDH cases.

Material and Methods: Open reduction is indicated only for congenitally dislocated hip joints in which tender, conservative reduction cannot be done. As a tender reduction, this can only be made by continuous overhead traction with a gradual increase of hip abduction from 10 to 60 degrees. When reduction cannot be considered as harmless, the surgical procedure consisting of open reduction and derotational osteotomy should be performed before the age of one year. In children older than the age of eighteen months a pelvic osteotomy must be added

Results: From 1980 to the end of 2000 (a period of 21 years), 147 dislocated hip joints in 128 children were operatively treated. The average follow-up was 11 years (2 – 21). In the age group of up to 15 months of age, 68 hip joints (62 patients) had open reduction and a derotational osteotomy was added in 32 cases (47%).

An additional pelvic osteotomy in cases of simple open reduction was performed on 17 hips (47%) and on 10 hips (31%) in cases of open reduction and derotation.

Aseptic necrosis developed in 5 cases (7.3%), but it is difficult to distinguish between pre-existing necrosis after conservative treatment and postoperative necrosis.

In the age group of 15 months to 36 months, there were 47 hip joints in 42 children. The surgery consisted of open reduction, varus and derotational osteotomy plus Salter (exceptionally Pemberton) osteotomy. The rate of necrosis was 12.8% (6 cases).

The open reduction in children older than the age of 3 was performed in 24 children (32 hip joints). The open reduction, varus and derotational osteotomy of the femur were performed in all cases. The Salter osteotomy was performed in 12 hips, Pemberton in 5, triple pelvic osteotomy in 6 cases, and Chiari was used in primary reduction in 9 cases.

The necrosis rate was 6.2% (2 cases).

In the targeted study regarding the effectivity of overhead traction, we had 90 hip joints in 76 patients. In the group of primary treatment in our institution (57 hip joints), successful reduction was reached in 80.1% of cases, but in the group of 33 hip joints where primary treatment had failed, conservative treatment was successful in only 30% and open reduction was performed in 23 cases.

We used the radiological classification according to Severin and clinical score according to Merle D’Aubigne: Severin I - excellent results − 12%, Severin II – good – 63%, Severin III – fair – 15%, Severin IV – poor – 6%, Severin V – re-dislocation, 6 cases – 4%. The necrosis rate was 9%.

Conclusion: Conservative and operative treatment of DDH are not two competing methods. The treatment of each dislocation starts conservatively. Only when there is no chance for harmless, tender reduction of the femoral head into the acetabular socket, the open reduction should be indicated and performed by experienced specialists. Early open reduction with femoral derotation gives statistically significant better results in comparison with only open reduction. The percentage of excellent results seems to be low, but it must be kept in mind that a hip joint which was operated and had an open reduction heals, in the majority of cases, at least radiologically. Functional results do not correspond in childhood with the radiology. Despite that, the children in the time period of FU do not complain, and the patients with operated DDH in the natural history must be considered as a high risk for the development of secondary coxarthrosis.


D. Tönnis

In this paper operations are discussed that improve the dysplastic acetabular roof in developmental dislocation of the hip (DDH) of children up to 10 years. In the first year of life acetabular dysplasia can be treated successfully by flexion-abduction splints and plaster casts in „human position“. From the second year on, only slight dysplasias can heal spontaneously or be treated conservatively. Then the steep acetabular roof has to be osteotomized and levered down to a normal angle and coverage to avoid redislocation or residual dysplasia.

Different procedures have been described in the course of time. Two osteotomies are chiseling in the anterior to posterior direction. Salters innominate osteotomy levers the whole acetabulum with the lower part of the pelvis in an anterolateral direction around an axis passing through the pubic symphysis and the posterior part of the osteotomy. In Pembertons osteotomy the hinge for turning down the acetabular roof is the last, posterior, transverse cortical segment over the tri-radiate cartilage, short before the sciatic notch.

Osteotomies chiseling from lateral in medial direction have been described already by Albee (1915) and Jones (1920). Lance (1925) propagated this technique in Europe. Here the acetabular roof is partially osteotomized in a thickness of 5–7 mm. Only the lateral part of the acetabulum is brought into the horizontal position. Wiberg in 1939 used this technique, but in 1953 he was the first to publish a full osteotomy what Dega called 1973 a transiliac osteotomy. Dega had originally learned the technique of Lance, but in 1963 when he reduced high dislocations after the technique of Colonna, he performed also a full transiliac osteotomy. After the Symposium of Chapchal in Basel 1965 we started in Berlin also with the complete acetabular osteotomy. With the control of an image intensifier the blade of the osteotome is driven toward the posterior rim of the tri-radiate cartilage leaving only a small bony rim above. Anteriorly the blade passes through the ant. inf. iliac spine. Posteriorly it just enters the sciatic notch. Here we check the blade position by direct palpation. The acetabulum is bent down partly in the small rim of bone left and mainly in the triradiate cartilage. Angles up to 50° have been achieved, which you cannot reach by other techniques.

In the beginning we have combined after Mittelmeier and Witt this acetabuloplasty with a varus osteotomy of the femur. In our long-time follow-up (Brüning et al. 1988,1990) however, we found in almost 50% a subcapital coxa valga or a so-called head-in-neck-position of the femoral head. Then we avoided varusosteotomies and had good results without it (Pothmann).

To keep the acetabular roof in the new position we used first bone wedges from the varus osteotomy, then deproteinized bone wedges from animals, and today deep frozen wedges of human femoral heads of the bone bank, sterilized at 121 degrees C for 20 min. (Ekkernkamp, Katthagen). A firm layer of cortical bone laterally is necessary. Reinvestigations have proven the stability of this material too ( Pothmann). This type of acetabular osteotomy in our and other authors opinion is the best. Salters osteotomy is not as efficient in severe dysplasia. And in older children it produces a decrease in anteversion of the acetabulum, which may limit internal rotation of the hip and cause osteoarthritis if it does not improve. In Pembertons osteotomy one cannot use the image intensifier, which is of great help to perform the osteotomy exactly and also the levering of the acetabulum to the optimal coverage.

Our first long-time follow-up of children with additional varus-osteotomies (Brüning et al.) reviewed 90 hip joints in 67 children. The age at operation was in average 3.6 years, the age at follow-up 15 years.

Clinical results. 98% of the patients had no pain or only occasional, no limitation of movement and normal or almost normal gait. The Trendelenburg sign was negative in 71% of the cases, grade 1 in 15.5% and grade 3 in 13.5%.

Radiological evaluation. The mean value of the AC-angle (acetabular index) preoperatively was 33.8°, postoperatively normal with 16.3°. The acetabular angle of the weightbearing zone was at follow-up 9.7°, which is normal too. At the age of less than 18 years the CE angle of 25,9° was normal too, as well the instability (protrusion) index of Reimers of 12.3 % and the distance femoral head to teardrop figure with 8.8 mm.

In our study group of hip dysplasia we introduced a score of normal values of hip measurements and 3 grades of deviation from normal, slightly pathological, severely pathological and extremely. When we counted normal values and slightly pathological ones together as a good result, we found for the different measurements of the acetabulum percentages mainly between 82 and 93 %. Remarkable were two measurements of the femoral neck, the epiphyseal index with only 50 % of normal and slightly pathological angles and the head-neck index with 47.7% respectively. This was due to the head-in-neck position of the femoral neck after varus osteotomy as we have mentioned already.

Acetabular coverage is achieved best in transiliac osteotomies up to 10 years. Then, only by triple pelvic osteotomies the acetabulum in total can be redirected to a normal coverage. But this operation is more difficult. Residual dysplasias therefore should be treated as early as possible in the way demonstrated here.


Full Access
F. Langlais J.C. Lambotte

In early secondary arthritis due to femoral dysplasia, varus osteotomy achieves a control of arthritis for two decades in 80 % of cases : it is therefore a very reliable conservative treatment. Moreover, in carefully selected cases of severe arthritis in young active patients, a valgus osteotomy can achieve pain relief for a decade in 70 % of cases.

THE VARUS OSTEOTOMY is recommended when the arthritis is due to a coxa valga ≥ 140°. By reducing the inclination angle to 125° the abductors level of arm is optimized, and their contracture is decreased. Therefore, the osteotomy reduces the surface strains, but it does not improve the extent of articular surfaces.

A – INDICATIONS

1) Four factors are mandatory to achieve long term improvement:

The arthritis must be the consequence of the dysplasia, with degenerative changes localized at the supero lateral part of the head and of the acetabulum. This can be confirmed by isotope scanning. If the arthritic changes are not localised the desease is rather a primary arthritis, or an inflammatory or a metabolic disease, which are not an indication for a biomecanical treatment.

There must be a real coxa valga, evidenced by coxometry. Anteversion is mesured by CT scan, and the inclinaison is mesured on a X ray of the pelvis with the hips in internal rotation equal to the ante-version. If there is a shortened femoral neck (such as a post reduction osteonecrosis), the modification of the glutei lever of arm may not change significantly the articular strains, and therefore osteotomy is no indicated.

The articular congruency must not be impaired by the reduced inclination angle. Pre operative X rays with the hips in an abduction equal to the planned varisation must not reveal any lateral narrowing of the joint space, which would mean incongruity, and lead to failure.

The possibility of articular healing must be important : varus osteotomy is recommended before 45 years, and if the joint space remains ≥ 50 % of normal.

2) Therefore varus osteotomy is not recommended

in a non symptomatic dysplasia (as some of them may not lead to arthritis), or if the symptoms are those of a labrum syndrom, with suddent pain, instead of a progressive and mechanical arthritic pain.

if the dysplasia is only acetabular : then only the acetabulum has to be treated.

if the anatomic abnormality is not an increase of the inclinaison (neck-shaft) angle, but a modification of the head-neck angle, which causes impigement with the labrum, and which is not improved by inter-tro-chanteric osteotomy.

3) The assosciated dysplasia have to be taken into consideration

If there is a femoral hyperanteversion there are two different conditions in the adult :

if the patient walks with internal rotation of knees (convergent strabismus of patella), realising a dynamic correction of hyperanteversion, the association an external rotation of the femur to the varisation is recommended.

but if, despite hyperanteversion, walking is without abnormal rotations of the knees, this means that the optimum congruity of the hip is in that position. An ostotomy is no advocated as, instead of retroversing the femoral neck, it would rotate externally the femoral shaft.

If there are both an acetabular and a femoral dysplasia, they both have to be treated :

if an augmentation is recommended for an anterolateral defect, the shelf osteoplasty can be performed in the same operation that the varus osteotomy.

if a medialisation is necessary (Chiari), both osteotomies can be assosciated in one stage.

but if a complex reorientation osteotomy is necessary (either periacetabular –Giacometti-,

or pelvic –Ganz-), it could be hazardous to perform a varus osteotomy at the same time.

B – SURGICAL TECHNIC

The importance of the varisation depends on that of the coxa valga. The final inclinaison angle must be 125°, as the lever of arm of the abductors is impaired for a lower angle. Moreover there is a post operative limping due to the ajustement of the glutei length, the duration of which is function of the varisation (one year per 10°). To reduce this limping, only the necessary varisation has to be made.

The technic has several important points :

non union is avoided by non dissection of the medial metaphysis or removal of a wedge :

we use a subperiosteal osteotomy, leaving in contact the medial cortex, with a lateral opening, fixed by a nail plate as a tension band. This technique gives a minimum limb shortening (12 mm for 15° varisation).

respect of the articulation and soft tissues. There is no arthrotomy as the nail plate is inserted on a guide pin. Later implantation of the THR will not be complicated by the previous osteotomy.

precise, « automatic » correction, depends only on the nailplate angle.

the resistance of the osteosynthesis allows immediate rehabilitation (this extra articular operation does not reduce ROM), and 10 to 20 kilos weight bearing. Full weight bearing is authorized at three months.

C – RESULTS

There are less thant 5 % mechanical complications. An antalgic effect is obtained within some weeks. In 80 % of cases, painlessness and absence of radiological deterioration for two decades is achieved, a THR becoming necessary in the third decade. In 20 % of cases, only a temporary effect is obtained, leading to a THR after 5 to 10 years.

THE VALGUS OSTEOTOMY is at present used in only seldom cases of young patients with a severely damaged articulation, but who prefer an antalgic conservative surgery than a THR, because they wish to continue for a decade a strenuous activity not compatible with an arthroplasty. This can be made only when there are two large osteophytic drops of the acetabulum and of the femoral head, which can be put into contact by the valgisation, and facilitate healing of the superior lesions. In carefully selected cases, a relief of pain is achieved for a decade in 70 % of patients.

IN CONCLUSIONS

The femoral varus osteotomy remains one of the most reliable conservative operations in osteoarthritis due to DDH. However to achieve these good results, a clear understanding of the indications and biomechanical demands of this operation is required.

In seldom and selected cases of severe arthritis, a palliative valgus osteotomy can achieve a decade of pain relief.


U. Dorn D. Neumann

DDH with or without previous treatment is the most frequent source of early hip OA in adolescents. Others are hip joint deformation following Legg-Calve-Perthes disease, slipped capital epiphysis or trauma. Secondary OA after rheumatoid arthritis, bacterial infection or as result of an hemophilic hip joint are relatively infrequent.

The choice of treatment depends on the type of the deformity and the severity of osteoarthritic changes. Osteotomies are favorably performed in adolescents. Arthrodesis is rarely accepted in this age group. In selected individuals THR is the matter of choice.

Pain, limping gait, restricted joint motion and sometimes clicking phemomena are the usual complains. Pain is usually aggravated by running and other sports activities.

Residual dysplasia of the hip with a spherical femoral head is best treated by a triple periacetabular osteotomy. The Bernese ostetomy of Ganz (3) and the triple osteotomy of Tönnis (9) are popular procedures. They mobilise an acetabular fragment, then reorient and stabilise the fragment in an optimal position. Internal fixation with screws provides stability and allows early mobilisation with partial weight bearing.

Chiari’s osteotomy is a supracetabular rotatory displacement osteotomy. Femoral head and joint capsule are medialised and covered by the osteomised iliac bone. The joint capsule in the weight bearing zone is transformed into fibrous cartilage by time. Congruent remodelling of the acetabular roof and fibrous tissue transformation into cartilage are biased by inproper height and orientation of the osteotomy (5). There is still an indication in severe DDH with subluxation of the femoral head and those with a severely deformed femoral head.

In pathomorphologies with aspherical femoral heads femoral osteotomies, usually valgus osteotomies, are required additionally in order to optimize the joint congruency

A dysplastic hip in a high dislocation and moderate to severe OA are contraindications.

Radiographic work up includes pelvic ap view and faux profil view. Assessment of the anterior and posterior acetabular rim indicate orientation of the acetabulum in terms of anteversion / retroversion. Orientation of the subchondral sclerosis over the femoral head is an indicator of femoral head coverage as CE-angle and AC-angle. 20°–30° abduction view in neutral rotation mimikes the postoperative acetabulum / femoral head relation. From CT-scans acetabular orientation ( ante-version / retroversion ), degenerative bone cysts, posteroinferior joint space and femoral head deformities and femoral neck osteophytes are depicted. Labrum pathology is dedectable by MRT and MRT-arthrography.

After treatment of DDH deformation of the femoral head and neck due to ischaemic necrosis develop in an incidence up to 20 %, depending on the method. Premature closure of the epiphyseal plate can also follow trauma, septic arthritis and Legg-Calve-Perthes disease. Most often an combination of acetabular dysplasia and coxa magna with short femoral neck and a high-standing greater trochanter are typical deformities. Specchiulli’s classification (8) is very helpful for deformations after avascular necrosis in DDH. Limping gait due to femoral shortening and insufficient strength of the abductor muscels are the major complains of adolescents. Symptoms exacerbate during walking of longer distances and restrict sports activities. Valgus osteotomy, Y-osteotomy, transfer of the greater trochanter alone or in combination with valgus osteotomy are appropiate methods to restore a better function and improve alignment of the mechanical axis to the knee joint. Femoral neck lengthening osteotomies (1,4) with distal-lateral transfer of the greater trochanter are advocated by several authors. Restoration of almost normal anatomy muscle function of the hip joint are realistic aims of these methods.

If the abductor muscel deficit is dominant and only a minor leg length discrepancy is in slight deformities, e.g. some Specchiulli’s type B2, we do not always need such complex procedures. Isolated transfer of the greater trochanter also improves the lever arm of the abductor muscles and therefore joint function, but does not influence leg length discrepancy. Disappearance of the Tren-delenburg-type gait is the most visible improvement of this procedure (7).

Total hip replacement (=THR) is rarely indicated in adolescents, but sometimes necessary for restoration of a almost normal quality of life. Especially in severe symptomatic OA after septic arthritis or trauma in some individuals remain only two options : arthrodesis or arthroplasty. Arthrodesis is a permanent solution for many years or even life time. Gait function is compromised remarkable (6) and specific compensatory mechanisms are adopted when walking. Excessive motion in the lumbar spine and ipsilateral knee provokes back and knee pain as well as osteoarthritic changes on the long run.

THR in young patients includes the risk of several revisions over life time , due to wear problems particularly in physically active individuals. A deficient acetabular bone stock as usual in severe acetabular dysplasia or poor bone quality after trauma or septic arthritis may compromize primary stability and secondary osteointegration. Nevertheless functional results and outcome (2) in terms of life quality are superior compared with various non-substituting procedures.


Full Access
NF Friederich U König G Petsinis

Introduction

There are numerous arthroscopic techniques available for the treatment of femorotibial osteoarthritis. Advances in arthroscopic technology have made arthroscopic treatment a widespread accepted treatment. Short-term pain relief after arthroscopic treatment in degenerative conditions of the knee has been well established, however this this not the case for the long-term results.

One of the reasons why arthroscopic procedures are well accepted is the favorable risk–benefit ratio, when compared to more invasive procedures like realignment osteotomies, unicompartmental or even total knee arthroplasty (15,16,17,18,19,21,26) Very often the arthroscopic procedure is offered to the patient as a temporizing or “time gaining” measures (11,23,24). However their efficacy is often unequal. Almost no prospective controlled studies are yet available. Arthroscopic mosaicplasty techniques as well as arthroscopically assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantations are – in this context – not regarded upon as treatment options for the osteoarthritic knee and are therefore described elsewhere.

Arthroscopic techniques in knee osteoarthritis

- (Partial) Meniscectomy

- Chondral Shaving

- Removal of osteophytes

- Removal of loose bodies

- Synovectomy

- Subchondral drilling techniques (Pridie)

- Abrasive chondroplasty

- Microfracturing techniques

Results published in peer-reviewed journals

- (Partial) Meniscectomy: Results more dependent on the status of the knee joint, than on the age of the patient (15,17). For the treatment of chondrocalcinosis there are controversing results: Many authors found actually chondrocalcinosis to be an adverse prognostic factor (6,8,19). Meniscectomy is not always a benign procedure (5)

- Chondral Shaving: This technique of chondral debridement, removal of cartilaginous flaps etc. has become very accepted with the advent of motorized instruments. Positive short-term results have been published, on the long-term this treatment however still fails to have proven efficacy (1,2,3,9,10,11). In some studies simple needle lavage, as performed by many rheumatologists, proved as effective as the arthroscopic method (4,8,17).

- Removal of osteophytes: Several studies show a benefit, when mechanically disturbing osteophytes are removed (3,16)

- Removal of loose bodies: One of the most rewarding arthroscopic techniques. Only free bodies in the anterior compartment of the knee are responsible for blocking, catching and/or pain (6,9)

- Synovectomy: At the first moment making sense – removing inflamed synovia may be of benefit to the patient, we caution. Even when utilizing some of the newer radio-frequency ablation devices (Arthro-care® etc), important postoperative hemarthrosis may occur and may cause longstanding postoperative problems after knee arthroscopy (18,19)

- Subchondral drilling: Originally described by Pridie in 1959, this technique of “subchondral stimulation” creating and stimulating re-growth of type I collagen layers has been adapted to arthroscopic techniques (22)

- Abrasive chondroplasty: This rather aggressive technique, introduced by Lanny Johnson in 1986, has a decreased popularity, since almost nobody but the creator reported good mid- to long-.term results (7,12,13,25)

- Microfracturing: A similar technique to the Pridie drilling technique, however avoiding any heat damage due to the fact that the perforations of the subchondral plate are performed by “ice-picks”. Its advocates report good to excellent results on the short-term (20,27,28)


Prof. Klaus-Peter Günther

Knee osteoarthritis (OA) is a major cause of pain and disability in elder people. The prevalence of radiographic OA in a population aged 35–74 years is 5–15% and about one third of involved people complain of symptoms. In the „Ulm Osteoarthritis Study“ patients undergoing total knee replacement reported a mean duration of knee pain of 10 years prior to surgery.

Multiple genetic, constitutional and environmental factors contribute to the development of OA. Initial cartilage degradation leads to joint space narrowing and early osteophyte formation which can be observed radiographically. Whether elevated subchondral bone mineral density is contributing to manifestation of the disease or just a secondary reaction process is still under debate. OA finally involves not only cartilage and subchondral bone but also soft tissues in and around the joint (synovial membrane, ligaments and muscles), which often results in painful effusions, muscular shortening and stiffness.

Many conservative treatment options have been developed in the past to relief these symptoms and to slow down or even stop the cartilage degradation process. Evidence to support the effectiveness of individual treatments, however, is variable. Recently the EULAR Committee for Clinical Trials determined an approach for the development of evidence based guidelines for conservative treatment of knee OA (Pendleton et al, Ann Rheum Dis2000;59:936–944). Through a process of quality assessment of available publications and determination of expert consensus employing a Delphi approach propositions relating to a rationale conservative management could be made:

Treatment of knee OA must be tailored to individual patients, taking into account factors such as age, comorbidity and the presence of inflammation. Optimal management requires a combination of non-pharmacological treatment modalities (regular education, exercise, appliances and weight reduction) and pharmacological approaches. Paracetamol generally is the preferred analgesic and there is enough evidence to support its application, as the pain controlling effects are comparable to NSAIDS and long term application is safe enough. NSAIDS (oral or even topical) can be considered in patients with effusion. Although some studies found NSAIDS to have better efficacy than paracetamol in the treatment of painful knee OA, the gastrointestinal side effects limit their long-term application. Therefore most experts consider their application only in patients unresponsive to paracetamol and in major effusions. In such situations long-acting steroids can be injected intra-articularly as well. While the effects of steroids in knee OA have been assessed in a number of studies, the predictors of response are still somewhat unclear and further investigations are necessary.

Recent data seems to support the theory that some symptomatic slow acting drugs (glucosamine sulfate, chondroitin sulfate, diacerein and hyaluronic acid) may possess structure modifying properties. Further studies, however, are necessary to determine the pharmacoeconomic aspects of that treatment and to define the indications more precisely.

Education should be an integral part in the management of knee OA. Several large randomised controlled trials have shown benefits of different educational techniques in reducing pain and increasing coping skills. Function can reliably be improved by quadriceps strengthening exercises and there is enough evidence to show the positive effects of weight reduction on the progression of the disease process.

In conclusion, evidence based guidelines in the conservative management of knee OA exist. Orthopaedic Surgeons should have knowledge of the various approaches and be aware of the fact that certain clinical propositions are supported by substantial research based evidence, while others are not.


Lars Peterson

Osteoarthritis is the end stage of a gradual process of degradation of the cartilage and secondary responses in other tissues within a joint after many years of use. It is common in the knee joints in elderly. The surgical treatments for OA are often symptomatic, such as arthroplasty and HTO. Traumas to the knee, especially in combination with other injuries such as ACL rupture or meniscal tears, can lead to a speedy process and premature OA. The osteoarthritic patient often experiences a gradual on set of symptoms such as pain and swelling on weight bearing, catching and locking and in late stage nightly pains, leading to a very limited lifestyle. If it is possible to treat the OA at an early stage and thus hindering the destruction of the joint, much is won for the patient.

Autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT) is a treatment for focal chondral and osteochondral lesions in the knee joint. The technique has also been used on patients with early stages of OA in knee, including multiple lesions, kissing lesions, lesions in combination with malalignment, instability and total mensicectomy. When treating these patients it is important to not only focus on the cartilage lesions but also on other pathology. A high tibial osteotomy should be considered, especially if there is a malalignment, but also as an unloading procedure if the lesion is large or if there are bipolar kissing lesions. If the patient has had total or subtotal meniscectomy meniscal allograft transplantation may be indicated. Ligamentous instability from a ruptured ACL for example must also be treated. All these procedures can be done prior to or after the ACT, but mostly concomitant with the ACT. As the patients have often been symptomatic for a long time and the greater surgical trauma with a concomitant procedure, it is harder to regain knee function after the surgery. Close contact between the patient, the doctor and the physical therapist is imperative, so measures can be taken if the patient does not progress accordingly.

Young patients with early OA are hard cases. These patients often have a high demand on knee function and have had a high level of activity but are disabled by their symptoms. When treating these patients with ACT it is important to assess and treat all pathology that may jeopardize a good outcome.


R.P. Jakob Chr. Marti E. Gautier

Osteotomies around the knee are still utilized a lot in Europe and in Asia while in US unicompartmental and total arthroplasty for the same indications have more and more taken over, partially due to fear of complications. We think that with careful planning and technique the indications can be maintained. Furthermore with modern methods of cartilage repair it is of utmost importance to unload overloaded compartments. Also many young patients having suffered ligamentous tears of the knee and having been reconstructed are in need of OT’s later on.

Many of the poor results are due to absent or poor planning and to poor OT technique and fixation. Not every knee needs to be operated to an overcorrected position. While opening wedge OT has become trendy because of fewer neurological complications we think there are definite indications for closing wedge technique.

In this lecture we would like to summarize the principles and the steps which are very personal and that are based on 20 years of practice.

Indications for osteotomies around the knee

Varus Knee

Opening wedge osteotomy: Advantages: Rapid surgery, small incision, fast healing, precise correction. Indicated when:

Degree of OA moderate and angular correction of not > 8°

Useful in associated MCL Instability

Useful when open surgery on medial femoral condyle needed (Mosaicplasty)

In case of associated ACL instability when tibial slope is not > 10°

Patella alta

Has a tendency to increase the tibial slope.

We use tricortical grafts from the iliac crest where the base of the wedges in mm corresponds to the degrees of correction. A cervical spine AO plate with for screws is used for fixation.

Creates less deformity of the proximal tibia which is an advantage for a later total knee. Increases the intraarticular pressure even when the MCL is cut or detached distally, without us knowing the effect on the degree of OA, no long term studies being known to us.

Closing wedge osteotomy: Advantages: Allows higher degrees of correction

Degree of OA advanced, need for higher corrections

Useful when open surgery on lateral femoral condyle needed

In ACL instability when tibial slope must be corrected, because of need to break the medial cortical hinge a heavier implant is needed may be enforced by a sagital Ex.Fix.

Patella baja

Corrections over 5 degrees need an OT of the proximal or distal fibula. We perform the resecting OT in the fibular neck, the proximal cut is incomplete removing only the anterior and lateral cortex, the distal cut is complete. This allows to shift the distal fragment proximally and in front of the proximal cortical shelf allowing nerve protection.

For fixation of the tibial OT we use the 90° angled cannulated AO osteotomy plate, that is inserted over a 2,0 K wire using a specific “transporteur” in relation to the amount of correction. The OT is done using the precise AO osteotomy jig, cutting along 2,5 mm K wires inserted through the jig. The two cuts meet 5–10 mm short of the opposite cortex.

The closing wedge OT creates more deformity, carries a certain risk of peroneal nerve injury and of compartment syndrome. Surgery must therefore been done very skilfully and demands expertise.

All the studies about long term effect of HTO have been done one using closing wedge technique.

Double Osteotomy

Indications:

For deformities of over 12° to avoid obliquity of the joint line otherwise created by tibial or femoral OT alone.

When sagital deformity needs to be corrected together with frontal plane deformity, eg a flexum of 20° and a varus of 10°.

Valgus knee

Closing wedge Osteotomy of the distal femur: Advantages are the potent fixation using the same plate as on the tibia leading to rapid healing. Approach is rather extensive. Indicated:

When deformity of valgus and sagital plane ( flexion contracture) need to be addressed.

When valgus is marked ( in small deformities the OT can also be performed in the tibia).

Opening wedge Osteotomy of the distal femur. Indicated:

When the deformity is small.

When cartilage gestures need to be performed on the lateral femoral condyle.

Planning of Osteotomies:

We use one leg standing films in ap, pa 45° flexion, and lateral projection, varusvalgus stress films with 15 kp (Telos) and Orthoradiogramm (hip-ankle). A potential contralateral opening on the standing film is compensated on the drawing by a push orthoradiogram which virtually brings both compartments into contact.

For the varus knee the ideal crossing point of the mechanical xis sits at 30% in the lateral compartment, the centre between the tibial eminences being 0% the medial or lateral border of the tibia being 100%. This is the displacement corresponds to the classical 3° over-correction that is useful when the medial compartment is down to bone. This would be an overcorrection for the less damaged medial joint lines where however an OT may already be indicated.

We therefore have prospectively studied and validated a more balanced approach.

If the medial compartment in a varus knee has lost up to one third of his cartilage the axis is calculated to pass at 10% in the lateral compartment.

If is down by two thirds it is meant to pass at 20% laterally.

If it is totally worn it passes at 30%.

The drawing for the high tibial OT on the orthoradiogram is simple:

Connect the centre of the femoral head with the point at 10, rsp. 20, rsp. 30% in the lateral compartment and prolong this new axis of the leg distally to a point lateral of the ankle joint.

Now select the hinge joint for the opening or closing wedge OT 2–3 cm distal to the joint line and connect this point with the old and the new centre of the ankle. Measure the angle between the t line which corresponds to the amount of correction and the angle to open or resect.

The planning for the varus OT of the distal femur in valgus deformity is somewhat more complicated but should aim at a correction which leaves a femorotibial valgus of 1–2°.

Using these rules one is able to reach adequate correction.


Full Access
S. Odenbring

Introduction

Osteotomy for medial gonarthrosis is most often done as a proximal tibial valgus osteotomy, either as a closing wedge osteotomy (HTO) or as an opening wedge osteotomy including hemicallostasis (HCO).

In case of lateral gonarthrosis the osteotomy is done as a proximal tibial varus osteotomy, closing or opening wedge or as a distal femoral varus osteotomy depending on the anatomy of the knee.

The early period after osteotomy is influenced by complications to osteotomy. Complications depend on the operative method and localisation of surgery.

Short- and long-term results are presented as knee scores or survivorship of high tibial osteotomy. Most often used scores are the HSS-score, NHP-score and the knee scores according to Lysholm and Tegner. Scores from the patient’s perspective are NHP, SF-36. KOOS (Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score) was introduced recently, and only short-term results are available.

Results

Osteotomy for medial gonarthrosis

Immediate postoperative results

The closing wedge osteotomy is the golden standard and reported complications are peroneal palsy in 0 – 8%, infection in 1 – 3%, fracture of the tibial plateau and delayed union in 3 – 5% and thromboembolism in 2 – 4%.

When the opening wedge method including HCO is used peroneal palsy is extremely seldom, delayed union is reported in 2%, major pin-tract infection in 2 – 20 % and thromboembolism in 2 – 4%.

Short-term results

The short-term results are generally good and one to two years after osteotomy excellent and good results are reported in 85 – 97 %. All five partial scales in KOOS with the exception of sports/ recreation function were significantly improved 3 – 4 months postoperatively.

Long term results 5 – 20 years after surgery

Evaluations of osteotomies using survivorship of the osteotomy, with conversion to a total knee as the endpoint, show an expected rate of survival of 73–94% at 5 years, 51–85 % at ten years, 39–68 % at 15 years and 30% at 20 years. Analysis of risk factors show that age older than 50 years, presence of lateral tibial thrust and insufficient valgus correction were significantly associated with probability of early failure.

Evaluations using knee scores with a mean follow-up time of 5 – 10 years show excellent and good result in 64 – 80%. At follow-up 11– 15 years after surgery the fraction good and excellent knees is 55 – 60% and 16– 20 years after osteotomy a minority of the knees are good or excellent, at most 46%.

Stage of arthrosis: Good long-term results are reported for knees with early medial arthrosis with at most obliteration of the medial joint space or just minimal bone attrition. Results after HCO on knees with more advanced gonarthrosis are reported with a short follow-up and the change of osseous correction after osteotomy was less compared to HTO.

Only minimal progress of arthrosis after osteotomy is reported in most papers. The results of some studies indicate that the greater the surgical correction, the slower the progress of the medial joint arthrosis.

Alignment of the knee:

Most reports find better clinical results and less risk for failure when the osteotomy is corrected to a slight over-correction of the knee alignment. There is however no consensus on the smallest correction needed to change the load on the medial arthrotic compartment.

Osteotomy for lateral gonarthrosis

The condition is uncommon and a minority of the papers on osteotomy for gonarthrosis concern osteotomy for lateral gonarthrosis. The aim of osteotomy for lateral gonarthrosis is to achieve a varus alignment of the knee with a joint line obliquity, which after surgery is less than 10 degrees. That affects the method, which is either a proximal tibial osteotomy or a distal femoral osteotomy. Most often the aetiology of the deformity is posttraumatic.

Immediate postoperative results

When using the opening wedge osteotomy on tibia transient nerve palsy is reported in 9–50%. Infection is reported in 2% and thromboembolism in 2 – 4%. Pin tract infection when using HCO is reported in 2 – 20%.

In a multicenter follow-up distal femoral varus osteotomy 11 complications were recorded in 32 patients (five non unions, three deep infections and three cases with a stiff knee).

Short-term results

Short-term results one to two years after surgery are reported excellent and good in 85 – 95%.

Results 5 – 15 years

Five to ten years after surgery good and excellent results are reported in 75 − 77%, and in 11 – 15 years after surgery in 50 – 80%. Results are much better in recent reports because of better patient selection and operative technique. The tibial varus osteotomy can be used in knees with less than 12 degrees of valgus. Furthermore the tilting of the tibiofemoral joint line should postoperatively be less than 10 degrees. Otherwise a distal femoral osteotomy should be used. Persistent excessive obliquity of the tibiofemoral joint line predisposes instability with risk of compromising the result.

To summarize: Osteotomy is effective in a patient with a medial or a lateral gonarthrosis at most Stage II according to the classification of Ahlbäck, under the age of between 50 and 60 years and of high demands by reason of lifestyle and occupation.

Aim at an overcorrection so when the osteotomy is healed you should have a slight overcorrection in valgus in medial gonarthrosis and in varus when you have a lateral gonarthrosis. Furthermore the joint line obliquity should postoperatively be less than 10 degrees.

With this selection of patients and with a good surgical technique your patient can expect a probability of having a good knee in about 70 % after ten years. After ten years it is more difficult to make a prognosis for your patients knee.


Full Access
C Dodd

There are now a number of controlled prospective trials comparing the advantages of unicompartmental arthroplasty versus total knee replacement (Rougraff 1991, Lawrencin 1991, Newman 1998, and Price 2000). These studies all favour unicompartmental arthroplasty over total knee replacement in terms of the following. The kinematics of uncompartmental arthroplasty are better and more normal for the surgery retains both cruciate ligaments with proprioceptive input. The range of motion tends to be greater in the unicompartmental group and the function better. This is especially true of demanding activities such as ascending and descending stairs, and has been shown using gait study analysis (O’Connor 1986).

The pain relief is as good, or better, with unicompartmental arthroplasty in these studies when compared to total knee replacement, and in particular there is “a better feel” with unicompartmental arthroplasty. The complications with the smaller procedure tend to be less frequent and severe and the recovery more rapid, with a potential benefit allowing for a lower cost.

There are however certain disadvantages encountered in using unicompartmental arthroplasty when compared to total knee replacement. In general there is a higher revision rate with the unicompartmental arthroplasty and this is particularly borne out in the Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register. Using the strict criteria of Insal/Stern they suggest an incidence of 1:20 patients suitable for unicompartmental arthroplasty, and with such small numbers it is hardly surprising that there is a higher complication rate.

The advantages of unicompartmental arthroplasty in the young remains controversial. In particular there are few comparative studies (Broughton and Newman 1988).

In a small study from Oxford we have found that the pain relief and function in the unicompartmental arthroplasty group were substantially better with an age match comparison group using a patient based question score (The Oxford Knee Score 0–48). We sent the Oxford questionnaire to the HTO patients of the main proponent of osteotomy surgery in the UK, who has devoted a lifetime to perfecting the art of osteotomy surgery. These patients represent the “best case scenario” and his patients at five year follow up scored 27/48 on the Oxford Knee Score. Age match group of young uni-compartmental arthroplasty patients scored 38. Comparison of total knee replacement group would score 35, and it is of interest to note that those patients revised from a failed high tibial osteotomy to a total knee replacement raised their scores from 27 to 33. There are of course disadvantages comparing unicompartmental arthroplasty and high tibial osteotomy in the young. The main disadvantages that artificial material is implanted and there is the potential for infection. What remains debatable and controversial is the outcome of procedures when converting them to a total knee replacement. In terms of 10 year survivorship most of the published literature suggests that with high tibial osteotomy there is a two-thirds survivorship, one-third being converted to a total knee replacement by 10 years (range 51% to 80%) (Naudie 1999, Coventry 1993, Rudan 1991). The similar 10 year survivorship of unicompartmental arthroplasty in patients under 65 years is in the order of 80%. This is borne out in the Swedish Knee Registry.

In general the problem with unicompartmental arthroplasty seems to centre around a higher revision rate, and faced with this problem there are a number of solutions. One can accept this and abandon the procedure, which has happened until recently in the United States. One can suggest that a unicompartmental arthroplasty is used as a pre-knee replacement, which has been forwarded by Repicci in the States. Alternatively one can try to minimise the failure rate by employing an implant with very good wear characteristics, one can concentrate on appropriate indications and one can define an accurate reproducible technique. One can seek to achieve a survival rate that is similar to that of the best total knee replacement.

The Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement was deigned first by Goodfellow and O’Connor 25 years ago. It employs a spherical femoral component articulating on a flat tibial component. There is a fully mobile bearing, which is unconstrained. This bearing is fully congruent in all positions, which minimises wear.

In two published retrieval studies (Argenson and Psychoyios) 10 year wear rate was 0.03mm per year. In those cases with no impingement the rate was 0.01mm per year. There was no correlation with thickness and we now feel comfortable advising a 3.5mm bearing for long term survivorship.

The indications for unicompartmental arthroplasty in essence centre around medial compartment osteoarthritis with a functionally intact ACL. Some superficial damage to the ligament is acceptable, but in essence the structure needs to be intact to be functioning. There needs to be a correctable varus deformity with full thickness lateral compartment articular cartilage and this is best demonstrated on stress x-ray. A fixed flexion deformity of less than 15° is usual and employing the above indications we find that a unicompartmental arthroplasty is suitable for 1:4 knees presenting with osteoarthritis.

We do not feel that the state of the patellofemoral joint is a contraindication to unicompartmental arthroplasty. We have significant evidence to corroborate this statement. In Mr Goodfellow’s published series in 1998 the state of the patellofemoral joint and the clinical results did not correlate. The study by Weale (1999) there was no progression of patellofemoral osteoarthritis over 10 years. On the Swedish Registry there have been no cited revisions for progression of patellofemoral arthritis.

The age and the activity of the patient does not seem to be an obvious contraindication. In particular in the old and unfit using the minimal invasive approach there is a low morbidity, with all its attendant advantages. In the young patient (less than 50 years), the 10 year survivorship is 92% in two published series (Murray et al 1998 and Price 2000).

The published 10 year results of the designers patient (Murray et al 1998) details the follow up of 144 unicompartmental arthroplasties with a 10 year survivorship. At 10 years there were 34 knees at risk giving a 98% 10 year survivorship 95%, confidence levels 93–100%. There was one case lost to follow up giving a worse case scenario of 97%.

Of much more relevance concerns an independent series from Sweden (Svard et al 2001). These series is of 420 Oxford unicompartmental arthroplasties from a single centre performed by four surgeons. None lost to follow up. A 10+ year follow up involved 122 Oxford unis reviewed, with 92% good or excellent HSS scores.

The 15 year survivorship was 94% with confidence levels 86 to 100%, there were none lost to follow up so the 15 year worse case scenario was 94%. This is better than fixed bearing unis and as good as the best total.

The Swedish Knee Arthoplasty Register however gave a different picture, and was published in 1995 (Lewald et al), reported poor early results with no learning curve and advised that the difficult implant should not be used. We in fact have gained data from 944 rather than 699 from the register. It concluded that at these centres they had very reasonable results, but one or two centres had catastrophically poor results, in the order of 30% failure. We can only conclude that these poor results were due to inappropriate indications or technique. More recently in January 2001 Robertson et al have published an update of the Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register citing good to excellent results in those centres performing more than 23 Oxford unicompartmental arthroplasties a year. Good results were possible, but there is a definite learning curve.

The phase 3 tradition of the Oxford was introduced in 1998. The aim of this introduction was to make the operation simpler and more consistent. We have consistently employed a minimally invasive approach, but we have sought to keep the advantages of phase 2 Oxford unicompartmental arthroplasty. In effect there has been minor modifications to the instruments with an increased range of sizes.

Our early phase 3 results, published in 1999 (Price et al) have compared the early recovery. This is the time taken to functional recovery, by which time the patient is ready for discharge. We compared the first 40 minimals with the last 20 opens and used 40 knee replacements taken as controls performed at the same time. We have shown that the minimally invasive unis recover three times faster than the totals (p< 0.001) and twice as fast as the open unis (p< 0.001).

Finally our one year follow up of the first 58 phase 3 Oxford unicompartmental arthroplasties reveal increase in the mean flexion from pre-operative 123° to postoperative 135°. A high proportion of the patients gained at least 130° of flexion and 50% were 140+. A mean AKS score rose from a pre of 37 to one year of 98. The AKS function score raised from a pre 53 to one year 94, with a very high proportion of patients scoring 95+ score out of 100 on the AKS.

In summary unicompartmental arthroplasties offer many potential advantages over TKR in terms of:

- Recovery, function.

- The best long term results of uni (Oxford) are now as good as best TKR.

- Unis in general are technically demanding and there is a definite learning curve.


Full Access
J.Y. Nordin

Treatment by TKR of severe deformities : fixed varus or valgus knee, or flexion contracture, sometimes combined (valgus and flexed knee as for example in rheumatoid arthritis) is frequently a difficult challenge. Seldom a flessum, recurvatum or malrotation have also to be managed.

These deformations, articular, extra-articular or combined can be observed in knee arthritis associated with malalignement, malunion of diaphysis, malunion of lower part of the femur or upper tibia after fracture or osteotomy, chronic juvenile arthritis or rheumatoid arthritis, Paget’s or post-rachitism disease.

In 60′ and 70′ the most difficult cases have been frequently treated by hinge prosthesis with a high percentage of infection and loosening; many of the other cases treated with customary prosthesis had a poor follow-up because instability, luxation, patellar problems, pain or recurrence of the deformity.

Now to obtain the best prosthesis survival rate , the well trained orthopaedic surgeon has to make a good radiographical and clinical examination and the a good planification with the good choices:

- necessity or not to perform, as a first stage, an osteotomy of femur or tibia to correct a mal-union or a deformity in frontal, sagittal or horizontal plane

- type of prosthesis ( constrained or not, PCL sparing or sacrificing, mobile bearing ),

- medial or lateral approach, and then Keblish procedure or not; tibial tubercle osteotomy or quadricepsplasty in stiff knees;

- sequence and level of tibial and femoral cuts; always perpendicular, for us, to the mechanical axis ,

- different steps of release of lateral, or medial and sometimes posterior ligamenteous and capsular elements, with many controversies for lateral compartment (iliotibial band, collateral lateral ligament, popliteus, posterolateral capsule, biceps tendon )

- necessity of medial ligament advancement or thightening when distension in severe valgus knee,

- repair of bone loss by cement, or more usually by bone graft or metal wedge.

ARTICULAR OR PARA ARTICULAR DEFORMITIES

1) FIXED VARUS KNEE

Treatment of this deformation is usually not so difficult. In case of postero-stabilized prosthesis implantation, after removal of medial condylar and tibial plateau osteophytes resection of PCL and release of semi-membranosus tendon and postero- medial capsule are performed. Pes anserinus and collateral medial ligament release creating a subperiosteal elevation of the medial envelope is sometimes needed for good soft tissue balance; in such case a constrained plateau can be useful.

It is also possible to try PCL sparing but a good tightening of PCL is difficult and reconstruction by bone graft, metal wedge or cement or medial tibial plateau is in most cases necessary to protect tibial insertions of PCL.

2) FIXED VALGUS KNEE

We prefer the Keblish approach to have a direct look on the tightened formations (iliotibial band, lateral collateral ligament, popliteus.

We agree with the Krackow’s classification of valgus knee in 3 groups.

For group 1, according to Whiteside it is possible to spare the PCL in the majority of cases if we accept to use a bone graft or a metal wedge on the lateral femoral condyle or/and tibial plateau taking the medial compartment as a reference.This choice of arthroplasty with PCL retention maintains the right level of the knee joint and offers often a best stability than postero-stabilized prosthesis does; PCL well tightened is a “third ligament” giving frontal stability as proved in traumatology. In fact many surgeons prefer to use postero-stabilized arthroplasty to avoid difficulties in PCL managing, and they release in different controversed steps the lateral elements. If there is instability they implant a more constrained tibial insert than usually. As communicated by Burdin it is also possible to prevent instability by performing a sagittal osteotomy of the lateral condyle around the insertions of popliteus and collateral ligament, and screw it after obtaining a good balance of the knee with the displacement of the osteotomized bone downward and/or posteriorly.

For group 2, which is caracterized by medial collateral ligament instability, it is safer to treat these knees with a postero-stabilized more or less constrained prosthesis than using a PCL sparing one and advancement of the medial ligament.

For group 3, severe overcorrection in valgus after lateral closed osteotomy for tibia varus realizes an upper tibial malunion. Prosthesis implantation is difficult: difficulties of soft tissue balance, conflict between upper tibial lateral cortex and tibial metalback stem, and bad coverage or overlapping of the tibial metalback, unless using a twisted stem. Different options can be choosen:

postero-stabilized prosthesis needs a release of lateral side; the tibial cut perpendicular to mechanical axis resecting bone to the bottom of the lateral defect takes off a too big amount of bone on the medial tibial plateau to have a safe support for metal back. If bone graft of lateral plateau is done to avoid this fact a constrained insert is potentially necessary.

implantation of a PCL sparing prosthesis with also release of lateral soft tissue, and reconstruction of medial tibial plateau and eventually condylar bone loss. For stability of the knee PCL acts as a collateral ligament. correction of the deformity by a new tibial osteotomy and after its consolidation implantation of the prosthesis some months later.

tibial osteotomy and prosthesis can be performed during the same operation, using a long tibial stem, cemented or not to stabilize the osteotomy site.

3) FLEXION CONTRACTURE

Correction of the deformity can be difficult when flexion is more than 30 or 40 degrees; PCL is not always an obstacle for correction. Sometimes initialy anterior bony deformity of the upper tibia has to be resected , especially in rheumatoid arthritis. After regular cut of the distal femur and removing of posterior osteophytes and loose bodies, elevation of posterior capsule from the distal femur is less dangerous than transverse incision of its middle part. If needed proximal attachements of gastrocnemius can also be stripped from the femur. Then if knee extension is not possible with trial component the tightened PCL has to be sacrified, or released or lengthened for some surgeons wanting to spare it. Finally a choice between lengthening of hamstrings and pes anserinus or a new cut of distal femur is necessary with use in some cases of a more constrained tibial plateau. For good tracking of patella lateral retinacular release is also mandatory.

4) FLESSUM, RECURVATUM, MALROTATION

Small flessum or recurvatum in metaphyseal area can be managed with the femoral anterior and posterior distal femoral cuts or tibial cut with sometimes incidence on prosthesis choice and biomechanical consequences.

Malrotation around 15 degrees can also be corrected by implants positioning, and perhaps a little more than 15° using a mobile bearing prosthesis.

EXTRA ARTICULAR OR COMBINED DEFORMITIES

In this type of deformity it can be necessary to perform in the same or in two separate operations its correction by a diaphyseal osteotomy preferably at the site of the deformity.

It is mandatory to have a good fixation of the bone to allow a quick and strong rehabilitation of the knee after prosthesis implantation. Plating, nailing or stabilization by the stem of prosthesis can be used.

At the present time the trend is to reach good correction of the deformity and implantation of the prosthesis at the same time even if the deformity is extra-articular; this challenge can be difficult.


R. Lemaire

Condylar knee prostheses were designed over 25 years ago, as it became evident that the hinge prostheses previously developed were unsatisfactory because of their marked potential for loosening and femoropatellar problems.

There are currently several hundreds of different types and subtypes of condylar prostheses available and more are being introduced on the market place every year. Continuous technical development has become a familiar feature with high technology products; does this also apply to knee prostheses?

The basic designs of condylar knee prostheses already existed 25 to 30 years ago, with the Freeman-Samuelson knee implanted in 1970, the Total Condylar in 1974 and the Insall-Burstein posterior stabilized knee in 1978. Long term results are now available for these prostheses as well as for others that came next: overall, survival rates between 84% and 98% have been reported with follow-up from 10 to 25 years. Will newer implants do any better? It will take that long to know, as it has been repeatedly demonstrated that theoretical studies or tests on knee simulators are not really predictive of the in vivo behavior of an implant.

The wide variety of current implants evidently reflects commercial interests. Each of the current prosthetic knees represents a more or less unique combination of a number of features related to the geometry of the articulating surfaces, including the trochlea and patella, the resection, preservation or substitution of the posterior cruciate ligament, the type of fixation to bone; most have a modular fixed tibial bearing, with various types of fixation to the underlying metal baseplate, and an increasing number of others have a mobile bearing with restrained or unrestrained mobility in rotation and/or in AP translation. The introduction of new knee prosthesis should hopefully provide some improvement in terms of function, range of motion, and implant survival as compared with the existing knees. Such improvements have proved very difficult to demonstrate on an objective basis, all the more as the results achieved with a specific implant do not only reflect its design, but also a number of manufacturing and processing features, and also the way it has been implanted.

We have learned a number of lessons from past failures such as

- the importance of selecting adequate materials

- the importance of an optimal manufacturing of implants (surface macro- and microgeometry, rugosity,

- the importance of an adequate sterilization technique for polyethylene

- the importance of a good trochlear design

- the dangers of resurfacing the patella using a metal-backed component.

Surgical technique has substantially improved over the years, not only because better instrumentations have been developed, but also because we have come to a better understanding of the anatomy and physiology of the arthritic knee before and after arthroplasty.

The rotational positioning of the femoral component has been extensively studied, and is now a regular feature of the operative technique. This, together with other technical factors such as improved design of the prosthetic trochlea, has to a large extent cleared the femoro-patellar complications which marred the results of some early designs. Techniques for ligament balancing in the varus or valgus knee have become systematized.

The issue of preservation or substitution of the posterior cruciate ligament is still a matter for debate, but we now know that it is unrealistic to expect restoring normal knee kinematics with prosthesis when both cruciate ligaments are not intact. Posterior stabilized prostheses have been shown to provide more predictable kinematics than others intended to be closer to normal physiology.

To summarize, advances have been made over the past 30 years regarding a number of elements among which implant design was probably of lesser importance than better understanding of the anatomy and physiology of the knee, better understanding of ligament balancing and operative technique in general, as well as improved manufacturing and processing of implants.


INFECTED TKR Pages 356 - 357
Full Access
M. Hämäläinen

Despite of improved operative technique, ultra-clean air in the operating theater and systemically administered as well as in bone cement loaded antibiotics, septic complications after replacement arthroplasty of the knee still exist. Depending of the follow-up time in different reported series insidence vary from 0.5 to 5 per cent.

Classic clinical symptoms, painful, swollen knee joint, possibly fever, indicate to more accurate examinations.

Lesson to learn: No treatment before adequate diagnosis ! No “homeostatic” antibiotics before accurate examinations. If the very first contact with physician or surgeon happens in such conditions, that adequate diagnostic methods are not available, patient has to be referred to hospital or institution with capable facilities.

Prosthetic infection can be classified in many ways. The following classification is useful for the treatment purposes.

Classification of infection:

1. Early postoperative infection less than 4 weeks after surgery.

superficial

deep

extensive soft tissue defects due to skin necrosis

2. Originally patient is operated for aseptic loosening, but intraoperative cultures are positive.

3. Late chronic infection

4. Acute hematogenous infection

Diagnostic methods:

1. Clinical examination:

- symptoms can be suppressed by painkillers or immunomodulant drugs

- wound healing problems

- sinuses

- swelling, redness

- pain

- temperature increased

2. Blood chemistry:

ESR, C-reactive protein and blood white cell count/ differentiation are helpful.

Be ware if the patient has such a general disease, which increases fex CRP

3. Routine x-rays. In early cases no significant signs, in late cases might appear erosions or cysts.

4. Isotope scintigraphy. Technetium- or indium labeled leucosytes are given intravenously

The patient is scanned 24 hours. Extended scintigraphy seems to be more sensitive than routine 6 to 8 hours‘ scintigraphy.

5. Joint aspiration.

One has to sure, that the patient is not on antibiotics. If she/he is, antibiotics has to be stopped for two to four weeks, and aspiration performed after that, unless infection is not clinically obvious or situation is not life-threatening

White cell count/differentiation can be for some help. When the cell count is less than 2000/ml, and majority of cells are mononuclear, the result is indicative negative for infection. White cell count over 10000/ml, and majority polymorphonuclear, speaks for infection.

When the aspiration has been carried in aseptic condition, positive culture is strong evidence for infection.

Adequate handling of sample is important: as little as possible air in the syringe and as short as possible time used for transportation to lab.

Treatment protocols

Treatment protocols can rather straight forward: if any sample culture is positive,

Two-stage revision arthroplasty is carried out. But also more conservative opinions are reported.

1.a. Early postoperative, superficial infection:

Surgical débridement of the wound.

Careful examination of retinaculum layer. Lavage and wound closure if possible. Systemic antibiotics. Joint puncture and aspiration through healthy skin area, never through open wound.

b. Early postoperative, deep infection:

Open débridement and careful lavage with retention of prosthesis. Additional peroperative samples for culture in order to confirm earlier pathogene definition.

Systemic antibiotics regarding sensitivity estimation. Arthroscopic debridement and lavage has not proved to be better or neither as good as open. New aspiration 4–6 days after. If white cell count clearly over 10000/ml and possibly culture positive, new debridement and lavage. If third debridement comes necessary, even without bony changes, removal of prosthesis and antibiotics- loaded spacer has to be considered.

c. Dehiscense of wound or soft tissue defect due to the necrosis:

Wound débridenent, antibiotics and depending on the extend of defect either partial closure, skin grafting or pedicled gastrocnemius muscle flap is performed.

2. In some cases there is no signs of infection, and the is operated as an aseptic loosening. In all revision, routineously 4 to 5 tissue samples should be taken for culture. If preoperatively there is any doubts about infection, histological examination of frozen sections should be carried out. If there are high count of polymorphonuclear cells, results of culture has to be waited. If later on in minimum two samples same pathogen is growing, the case has to be considered as infected. Two-stage revision protocol is recommended.

One positive sample cannot be regarded as a concluding proof. Long term antibiotics is recommended.

3. Late chronic infection has insidious , slowly progressing onset. Symptoms can be confusing mild, and can lead to misdiagnosis. Method of choice is débridement, removal of the prosthesis and all bone cement, and placement of an antibiotics-loaded cement spacer. No dead space is left , but has to be filled with antibiotic-loaded collagen or antibiotic-cement beads. The patient is put on systemic antibiotics, preferably combination of two. Antibiotic therapy is continued six- to eight weeks. Healing process is controlled with ESR and CRP tests. If the blood test normal and clinical situation is normal, delayed revision arthroplasty is performed. Antibiotic loaded-cement is always used.

4. Acute hematogenous infection. Onset is usually acute and symptoms dramatic.

Sometimes distant focus can be found. If the history is rather short( less than 14 days) open débridement, retainment of prosthesis, antibiotics-loaded collagen filling of the joint as well systemic antibiotics is recommended. Recovering is monitored by blood chemistry and repeated joint aspiration and cultures. If in aspiration sample there is high polymorphonueclear count and culture possibly positive, new débridemand is carried out. If signs of infection still continue, two-stage exchange to be considered.

Pathogenes

Gram-positive

staphylococci are most frequent patogene in total knee replacement infections (95%).

Gram-negative

bacilli cover the rest (5%). Coagulase-negative staphylococci has grown up the most important bacteria, and it‘s resistance against antibiotics has turned frightening.

Spacers

In cases with short history retainment of prosthesis can be considered. Many authors change of polyethylene bearing.

In two-stage revisions static antibiotic-loaded cement spacer was used during

The six to eight weeks‘ interval. Static spacer is connected with extensive bone loss as well as stiff causing problems in secondary revision. Molded cement spacer is used in order to avoid complications and to achieve better functional results.

Failure

In some cases treatment of infection is unsuccessful. Arthodesis with method of Ilizarov or intramedullary nail or sometimes above-knee amputation comes necessary.


LATE OUTCOMES IN TKR Pages 356 - 356
Full Access
Quilis A. Navarro

The outcomes of any procedure in our clinical practice have to be looked upon in several ways:

a.The benefit the individual obtains from the procedure, in respect to the quality of life or well being.

b.All these gains, if they are produced, must have a cost inferior to the ones that had occurred if the operation had not been done: (medical and social costs).

c.The changes observed in pain, mobility and stability of the joint before and after the operation.

d.The changes in the individual functional state: what the patient can do in his normal life activities (walk, stairs, fasten shoes, personal wash-up, etc) and any needed help for a normal daily living.

e.Length of time the procedure will be holding the results, and the necessity of revision (survivorship), depending on the clinical state and the radiographic studies (migration, inclination, subsidence, lucent lines in the surfaces, etc).

The aspects on well-being and cost-benefit after the total knee replacement have changed for better in a parallel way to the improvement on the function of the knee joint and the function of the body as a whole. We have recently studied the first two (a and b) outcome measures with positive results, that compare well to the published ones.

In considering others aspects or measures of the outcomes, we agree with M. A. R. Freeman that the year 1980 could be the milestone for looking back and forth in the history of total knee replacement. Before 1980 the number of early failures was high, mainly due to sinkage and inclination of the tibial component, wear of the components, instability of the joint, and patelo-femoral pain.

We did work on the design of a new method of fixation for the tibial plateau from 1980 to 1988, because of the many publications on bad results due to tibial loosening; our method of fixation was based in an intramedullary elastic, press-fit, stem, trying to avoid the fixation on the tibial surface, mainly because the trabecular bone was weak to stand the weight pressures, and because it was very difficult to cover all the surface of the tibia cut (the tibial not only differs in size but also in shape).

Following the introduction of the ligament tensor by Freeman and the use of the “gaps” technique by Insall, in order obtain hte proper ligament tension and equal flexion and extension spaces and proper joint alignment, the short-term results published made us think that the tibial plateau problems were due more to bad surgical technique, that to other causes; we, therefore left aside our work.

The functional results since then have shown little changes; we have not obtained more flexion or stability, and the patello femoral problems have not improved much. The different new designs have more to do with early wear of the polyethylene and consequent osteolysis and instability, than with function.

The challenges of the future, in order to get better outcomes are:

To obtain better flexion.

To obtain a better patelar tracking.

To reduce the lucent lines around the prosthetic components.

1 and 2 should be addressed with a better geometry of the components. Practically every design and every technique change the geometric arrangement, specially, of the distal femur.

We change the troncoconical (medial bigger than lateral) shape of the condyles into a cylindrical one; we change the oblique hinge into a normal one; we do not allow space for the lateral condyle to run backwards and forwards on the lateral tibial plateau in flexion and extension. This last problem is made even worse by the tension of the lateral ligament in flexion of the knee.

If we had all this into consideration we could get more flexion and better patellar tracking. Actually, we are working on this subject.

The issue 3 on the radiolucent lines: the coating of Hydroxiapatite might finally give a better fixation than cement. Hydroxiapatite resists the micromovements better and its interface membrane dissapears in favour of bone.


del Prever EM Brach P Bracco L Costa

Introduction – Polyethylene (PE), or better Ultra High Molecular Weight Polyethylene (UHMWPE) wear was demonstrated to be the main cause of Total Knee Replacement failure during the ‘90ties years. Wear, that occurred during the in vivo service, was related to the implant biomechanics, both the prosthetic design (constrained - non constrained, PCL sacrifice…) and the implant technique with rotational and alignment defects. In all these studies, retrieved PE inserts and wear particles were supposed to be UHMWPE, with the same chemical and physical characteristics of the original certified polymer. Unfortunately, degradation of UHMWPE, that is the modification of the chemical and physical structure, may occur during the preparation of prosthetic components; in particular, gamma irradiation in air is responsible for superficial and deep, unpredictable, inhomogeneous oxidative degradation of the polymeric biomaterial (16). Therefore, new PE components sterilised by in air gamma irradiation and ready for implant can be supposed to be UHMWPE, but they could not be. Sterilisation with ethylene oxide (EtO) does not modify the chemical and physical properties of the original PE. Furthermore, during the service in vivo cholesterol and other components of the synovial fluid diffuse in the PE components and modify the mechanical properties of the polymer (7).

Aim of the study - To characterise new PE components (hereafter called PEs in this paper) ready for implants and retrieved PEs obtained from failed total knee replacements in order to evaluate the wear, oxidation level and, in the retrieved ones, the diffusion products after service in vivo. Only after this characterisation some mechanical considerations and therefore wear in vivo could be discussed.

Materials - 24 new and 75 retrieved PEs were analysed. New PEs were produced by 9 different firms, 18 were sterilised by gamma irradiation in air, 1 in inert atmosphere or in vacuum, 5 by EtO. Surgical revisions were performed after an average time of 5 years (min 3 months, max 15 years) because of aseptic loosening (51 cases), septic failure (16 cases), PE severe wear (4 cases), other causes (4 cases). The retrieved PEs had been produced by 15 different firms; 74 were sterilised by gamma irradiation, while only 1 by EtO. The mean age at revision was 70 years (range 57–82 years).

Methods – At the surgical revision, PEs were photographed; wear area score according to Collier and wear severity score according to Plante-Bordeneuve and Freeman were evaluated. Prior to the analyses, PEs were stored in the dark in formaldehyde 4%. New and retrieved PEs were cut perpendicularly to the articular surface. A series of slices of controlled thickness (from 100 to 300 microns) were recovered from the cross-section using a Poly Cuts Microtome (Reichert-Jung) at 20 mms−1 in air at room temperature. A FTIR Microscope (Perkin Elmer System 2000) equipped with a x-y motorised micropositioning stage was used to identify and map the distribution and level of oxidation. Identification of oxidised species was carried out by derivatisation and IR analysis. Soxhlet extraction in boiling cyclohexane for 20 hours was performed to extract low molecular weight substances which diffused into PEs.

Results – All new PEs sterilised by gamma irradiation in air presented surface and bulk oxidation, variable in severity and distribution. Wear of retrieved PEs sterilised by gamma irradiation in air was extended for more than 50% of the articular surface (score 3) in 60% of cases and was severe (score 5–8) in 47% of them. In most of the gamma irradiated in air retrieved plateaux a “crown zone” at a depth of 1–2 mm from the surface was observed. This zone has been found to correspond to the maximum of the oxidation profile, measured by FTIR mapping. Diffusion of cholesterol and its esters with fatty acids has been observed in many of the samples, in variable amount depending both on the clinical situation of the patient and on the implant time.

Conclusions – These results show that significant modifications of the physical properties of UHMWPE can be introduced by the sterilisation treatment. The chain reactions that follow gamma ray sterilisation and lead to oxidation tends to decrease the molecular weight of UHMWPE. The presence of the subsurface “crown zone” is the macroscopic evidence of an extremely high level of oxidation, responsible for delamination and wear of the tibial plateaux. Critical mechanical phenomena can be related with oxidation due to gamma irradiation and in vivo degradation. Diffusion in the PEs of cholesterol and other synovial fluid components may affect the mechanical resistance in vivo. All these results emphasise that discussion about mechanical behaviour in vivo of different prostheses, particularly for total knee replacement where the biomechanics is complicate, must be proceeded by accurate control of physicochemical properties of the ready-to-implant prosthesis and of the retrieved components. New tests must be introduced to control the integrity of the ready-to-implant components, besides that of the row material. Furthermore, suitable in vitro tests might give a prediction on the effects of diffusion on the material performances.


Full Access
K. Knahr

Total knee arthroplasty is a predictable operation. Unfortunately, there is a subset of patients who do not well and require revision surgery. The surgical objective of revision total knee arthroplasty is the same as primary total knee arthroplasty: restore the original anatomy, restore function and provide a stable joint. The operation technique itself is a decisive for the success of arthroplasty as any type of malalignment may result in pain, instability or loosening of the implant.

1. REASONS OF FAILURE

The most important reason for revision total knee arthroplasty include aseptic loosening of one or both components. Early loosenings occur frequently as failures of ingrowth of a porous coated implant, while late loosenings mainly concentrate on cemented components, predominantly the tibial part. Another major reason for knee arthroplasties to fail is instability between the femur and tibia, caused by incorrect alignment or laxacity of the ligaments. Wear and osteolysis are the result of abnormally increased abrasion and plastic deformation of the polyethylene inlay. Usually this is a sequela of overloading through subluxation or deformity. It generally happens when the weight-bearing contact surfaces are small.

Pain around the patella may occur due to anterior displacmenet of the patellofemoral joint and is not related whether the patella remains natural or is totally replaced.

Rare complications are fatigue fractures of metallic components, femoral or tibial fractures around the implant, extreme limitation of motion or hyperextension of the joint.

The most severe complication is periprosthetic infection, which in most of the cases requires a one or two-stage revision procedure to replace the implant.

2. GOALS OF REVISION SURGERY

Correct axial and rotational alignment including the restoration of the right joint line is mandatory for the success of a revision total knee arthroplasty. Especially joint line elevation can result in functional disorders, therefore the use of distal femoral augmentation in revision has given more attention.

Balance of soft tissues to create equal flexion and extension spaces is another mandatory goal for revisions. Soft tissue releases can usually correct fixed angular deformities. Concerning balance by additional cuts of femoral or tibial bone one has to remember that adjustments on the femoral side can effect the knee in flexion or extension, whereas any adjustment on the tibial side will effect both. Minimize bone resection and achieving stability by stable fixation of all components of the implant are further prerequisits for the success of revision surgery.

Another criteria for success is correct patella tracking, which can on the one hand be solved by soft tissue procedures or by revising the implant. Even one has to change the femoral and tibial component, retaining a well fixed patella component appears to be a suitable option.

One of the most important criteria in revision total knee arthroplasty is implant selection. Recent publications have demonstrated that the implant-related failure rate was 25% when using implants designed for primary total knee arthroplasty, the failure rate of modified primary components was 14% and if components were used specially designed for revision the implant-related failure rate dropped to 6%. It was evident that revision implants exhibited superior performance and durability despite their use in more difficult reconstructions.

Concerning wear and osteolysis one should consider that an isolated revision of an polyethylene insert should not be performed when there is accelerated wear of the insert with severe delamination and radiographically under surface osteolysis.

The major objectives of bone grafting or augmentation blocks are filling in bony defects with biomechanically stable components to allow weight bearing and functional motion, to create an equal flexion and extension space for ligamentous stability and to restore a nearly anatomic joint line.

The use of intramedullary stems at revision surgery provides fixation of components into diaphyseal bone leading to increased stability for reconstruction. It produces axial alignment, the stems also partially relieve stresses on the deficient metaphyseal bone or allograft.

3. TREATMENT OF INFECTION

The incidence of periprosthetic infections is rather low. In early infections antibiotic treatment combined with open arthrotomy including debridement and exchange of inlay are the treatments of choice.

Late infections are best treated combining antibiotics and two stage exchange arthroplasty. Arthrodeses or amputations are extremely rare to indicate.

4. REVISIONS WITHOUT REPLACING THE IMPLANT

Many of these procedures belong to the patella including the removal of osteophytes, secondary release of the lateral patella retinaculum, secondary replacing the patella with an implant, or patellectomy.

The replacement of a worn tibial inlay is often combined with secondary synovectomy, sometimes heterotopic ossifications need to be removed for the improvement of mobility. In infected knees the placement of an inflow/outflow drain in an attempt to manage an acute periprosthetic infection or to provide relief of pain in the presence of sepsis.


Alexa Ovidiou

Complications of distal radius fractures range from 20 to 30% and are consequence of injury or of treatment. Management of these complications must be individualised and the multitude of proposal treatments prove that this problem is controversial. Complications may involve soft tissue (tendon, nerve, arterial or fascial complication, reflex symphatetic distrophy) or bone and joint (malunion, nonunion, osteoarthritis).

Tendon complications following distal radius fractures, range from minor adhesions to complete rupture. Peritendinous adhesions will become apparent after cast removal. Diagnosis is based on the limitation of the range of movement for individual fingers.This complication can be avoided with a proper cast technique allowing full range of motion to the digits. Treatment consists of rehabilitation techniques and only rarely, in severe cases, operative tenolysis may be a treatment of choice. Tendons may be entrapped either in the fracture site or in the distal radioulnar joint. Most common tendon entrapment are for extensor carpi ulnaris and extensor digiti minimi. If early recognition is made, open reduction with freeing the tendon must be the choice. Late diagnosis will require more complex tenolysis procedures. Tendon rupture may occur at the time of injury due to sharp fracture fragments. Diagnosis is based on identification of functional loss and, whenever possible, primary tendon suture is recommended. If the diagnosis is late the treatment is free tendon graft or tendon transfer. The late rupture of extensor pollicis longus is the most common possibility. Since it is not related with comminution or displacement of fracture it is possible that an ischemic mechanism is involved. Solutions are free tendon graft or the transfer of extensor indicis proprius. Direct tendon repair is not recommended after few weeks.

Nerve complications. Careful neurological investigations demonstrated that nerve injuries associated with distal radius fractures are more common than it is believed. Median nerve is most frequently involved. Primary mechanisms of injury are: direct lesions due to fracture fragments, lesions related to forced manipulation and nonanatomical position of immobilization. Late injuries, occurring a long time after the fracture are more frequent and are related to carpal tunnel syndrome or paraneural adhesions. Carpal tunnel pressure could be measured and ethiologic factors must be identificated in order to establish the proper treatment, usually based on relise of carpal tunnel. Ulnar and radial neuropathy are less common and treatment may vary from cast removal to relise of Guyon’s canal.

Vascular complications are uncommon, arise usually in relation with high energy trauma and the treatment is complex, involving different speciality surgeons. Some authors presented rare cases of entrapment of vasculare structures or radial artery pseudoaneurism after the use a volar plate.

Compartment syndrome after distal radius fracture is rare and is likely to occur in young adults suffering a high energy trauma. Clinical diagnosis is based on the classical 5 “P’s” (pain, pallor, paresthesias, paralysis, and pulselessness) but treatment must start before all symptoms are present. Anytime when compartment syndrome is suspected, intracompartimental pressure must be measured. The treatment must start immediately and consist in removal of constrictive devices (bandage, cast) and fasciotomy. Indications for fasciotomy are intracompartmental pressure of 15–25mmHg in presence of clinical signs or over 25mmHg in absence of clinical signs. If there is doubt, it is better to perform an unnecessary fasciotomy than to wait until lesions becomes irreversible.

Reflex sympathetic distrophy is described with many terms such as algodistrophy, cauzalgia, Sûdeck’s atrophy, shoulder-hand syndrome. Recently, the term complex regional pain syndrome was proposed to replace all the exiting synonyms. Despite many theories, the pathogeny of this disease is uncertain. The diagnosis is mainly clinical, based on presence of pain, trophic changes (atrophy, stiffness, edema) and functional impairment but plain x-ray demonstrating osteopenia and bone scintigraphy showing abnormal bone turnover may be helpful. Since the patogeny is unclear, the treatment is targeting the symptoms rather then the disease. Treatment must be individualized and may consist of: physical therapy of the hand, pain control with general or local drugs, corticosteroids, and symphatectomy. Prevention of reflex symphatetic dystrophy in the first days of a distal radial fracture is very important and include: prevention of the edema (elevation of the hand, early mobilization of fingers), decrease of pain, cast removal to relive pression, non-traumatic surgery.

Malunion is the most common complication of distal radius fracture and it usually occurs after close treatment. The malalignament may be extraarticular or it may involve the joint (radiocarpal or distal radioulnar joint). Axial shortening and dorsal or radial malalignament are the most common. Clinical signs are wrist pain, loss of grip strength, limitation of wrist mobility. Osteoarthritis is likely to develop in both types of malunions. For extraarticular nonunions osteotomy is usually the treatment of choice. Many types of osteotomies have been proposed but the most commonly used are opening wedge osteotomy and Watson osteotomy. Intraarticular malunion is more difficult to treat and many surgical solutions have been proposed: intraarticular osteotomy, bone resections (styloid, anterior or posterior rim, radiolunate or radioscapholunate limited arthrodesis, proximal row carpectomy, wrist denervation, wrist arthroplasty, total wrist arthrodesis). Salvage procedures on the distal radioulnar joint may be resection of distal cubitus (Darrach) or Sauve-Kapandji technique.

Nonunion is an extremely rare complication and is likely to occur in patients with multiple comorbid conditions such as diabetes, peripheral vascular disease or alcoholism. In most cases the initial treatment was close reduction and cast immobilization or external fixation. Diagnosis is based on the absence of radiographic signs of union at 6 months. Treatment must be individualized but basic options are reconstructive procedures or wrist arthrodesis. Reconstructive procedures consist of debridement of nonunion site, realignment with distractor, plate and screw fixation and iliac crest bone grafting. Since the bone is of poor-quality, new implants providing fixation in orthogonal planes may be useful. Usually, malalignement is present, so some authors recommend to take in to consideration the possibility to associate reconstructive procedures with additional techniques such as: dividing brachioradialis tendon, incision of the dorsal or volar joint capsule or Darrach operation in presence of severe shortening of the radius. Wrist arthrodesis should be chosen when the distal fragment has less then 5 millimeters of subchondral bone supporting the articular surface.


Full Access
B.S. Goldie

My talk concentrates on the practical management of wrist fractures in adults. The management of complications of wrist fractures and the management of fractures in children are covered by other speakers.

Epidemiology

Fractures of the distal end of the radius have been estimated to account for upwards of 1/6 of all fractures seen and treated in emergency rooms. Distal radius fractures are more common in women. Above the age of 50 years, 86% of wrist fractures are in women. Fractures increase in incidence in both sexes with advancing age, and usually result from a fall from level ground rather than from high energy trauma. 10% of adults older than 35 years will suffer a distal radius fracture in a 30 year period.

Historical

Up until the early 18th century, it was thought that the injury that resulted from a fall on the outstretched hand was a dislocation and not a fracture. The first author to suggest that the injury was a fracture was probably JL Petit in 1783. Abraham Colles published his article in 1814 without having dissected a specimen showing a fractured wrist. Barton described the fracture associated with his name in 1838. RW Smith described extra-articular bending fractures of the distal end of the radius in 1847.

Classification

There are very many different classifications used to describe fractures of the distal radius. The Frykman classification (1967) has been widely used in the past. It concentrates on the involvement of the radioulnar joint. The classification system of AO is useful for documenting fractures that does produce 144 possible combinations. The classification by Fernandez (In: Fractures of the Distal Radius Fernandez and Jupiter, Springer 1995) concentrates on the mechanism of the fracture and enables correlation with the management of the fracture. It is the most useful classification when deciding exactly what to do.

Imaging

Plain radiographs are the mainstay of fracture management. Good quality AP and lateral views are essential. A lateral view with the forearm angled 20 degrees towards the tube gives a better view of the lunate fossa. Tomograms can be used to evaluate the joint surface in an intra-articular fracture but has been superseded by more sophisticated imaging. Uniplanar CT produced good images in 1 plain only. The reconstructed images in second plane were always of poor quality. Nowadays Spiral CT produces excellent images with rapid acquisition and low radiation dosage. MRI scanning has its use in evaluating soft tissue injuries and also injuries to the bone that have not caused a fracture, such as a “bone bruise”. Intraoperatively it is possible to arthroscope the wrist in order to guide fracture reduction. This should only be attempted by skilled wrist arthroscopists.

Anaesthesia

In the UK, haematoma blocks have become the standard method of anaesthesia in the emergency room when manipulating fractures of the wrist. The degree of anaesthesia is somewhat unpredictable and the failure to achieve a complete anaesthesia leads to poor reductions.

Intravenous regional anaesthetic (Biers block) used to being the main form of the anaesthesia in British emergency rooms. The technique requires two doctors and was going out of fashion even before the manufacturers of Prilocaine withdrew the preservative-free formulation generally used for Biers blocks.

Axillary block anaesthesia is commonly used in the operating room but is less so in the emergency room.

General Anaesthesia is my preference for patients undergoing more than just simple manipulation.

Operative techniques

Surgeons should not limit themselves to only performing one method of stabilisation. They should be able to perform all forms. They should plan surgery in advance and should have the facility to adopt an alternative technique intraoperatively should this prove necessary.

If a patient requires a manipulation in a proper operating theatre using anything other than a haematoma block anaesthetic, then K-wires should be inserted for most fractures. There are many ways of inserting K-wires but my preference is for Kapandji intrafocal pinning.

External fixation can be used for many types of intra-articular fractures using the principle of ligamentotaxis. Most fixators are applied bridging the joint. If not put on with excessive distraction, stiffness is not usually a problem. McQueen has published on the application of nonbridging fixators which certainly has some clinical indications. In the older patient, the use of bone graft should always be considered to fill the defect left the following elevation of a fracture. The alternative is to use synthetic bone graft substitutes such as Biobon®. Sometimes it is necessary to combine external fixation with supplementary K-wires.

Internal fixation

The volar approach through the terminal part of the Henry approach is relatively straightforward with low morbidity. This is used to apply volar buttress plates.

The distal radius is approached dorsally through incisions between the extensor compartments. The routine application of dorsal plates is favoured by some. However there is considerable morbidity associated with even the modern low profile plates such as the Pi plate. Tendon rupture is a particular problem. The plate usually has to be removed once the fracture has united. An approach between the fourth and fifth extensor compartment is useful in elevating the lunate facet prior to K-wire or screw fixation. Limited internal fixation using cannulated screws is useful in stabilising major fracture fragments such as the radial styloid.

As with any other fracture, the management of distal radius fractures is determined by the biology of the patient, the configuration of the fracture and the ability of the surgeon. The biggest errors come from considering all distal radius fractures as one, or applying one management protocol to all fractures.


Full Access
J.C. Skowroñski

The major aim of this presentation is to introduce the complex medical procedure concerning wrist fractures, luxations and wrist ligaments injuries based up-to date literature and author’s own experience. In scaphoid fractures the most common one – the diagnostic problems (proper X-ray projection, repete X-ray, CT, bone scan, e.t.c.) are presented as well as the right treatment based on the bone healing pathology (different vascular topography, fracture type e.t.c.). Also the medical procedure algorithm of the fresh scaphoid fractures (Herbert’s screw, Matti-Russe method), prolonged union or pseudoarthroses (bone transplant according to Matti-Russe or Fisk-Fernandes) is suggested.

The treatment ways concerning lunar fractures (blood supply disorders and Kienböck disease), capitatum fractures (unstable fractures - open reposition + bone graft), triquetrum fracture (a mirror Bennet or ridge fracture), trapezoideum fracture, hamatum fracture (most common one – the hook) and posiforme fracture (usually coexists with other fractures) one also discussed based on clinical examples.

Due to the wrist ligaments injuries author presents the most common luxations and instabilities; the treatment of perilunar luxations, either quicke hand reposition or open repositions with simultaneous tunnel decompression is described. The wrist instabilities are presented mainly due to diagnostic problems. According to static instabilities (dissociations) the author compares static X-ray and a healthy wrist X-ray (three arcs estimation, interbone space asymmetry) while dynamic instabilities require forced position X-ray scans. The most common instabilities – VISI and DISI – are also presented from wrist biomechanical point of view.


Full Access
Schatzker M.D. Joseph

Non operative treatment of supracondylar fractures of the humerus has almost always resulted in failure. Closed reduction followed by prolonged immobilization until union, may be associated with an acceptable X-ray but with unacceptable function because of marked stiffness. Traction and early motion preserves movement but the incongruity of the joint leads to instability, early post-traumatic arthritis and pain. Traction also requires prolonged hospital admission which is not possible in modern health care settings. Attempts at early motion without reduction, the so called “bag of bones treatment” leads to gross malunions, non-unions and poor function.

In order to function normally an elbow requires stability, a congruent articulation, freedom from pain, and a functional range of motion. After fracture one can achieve a normal elbow only after anatomic reduction fracture which is combined with absolutely stable fixation and early motion.

These fractures are classified according to the Comprehensive Classification into Types: A, B, and C, with their respective groups and subgroups, all arranged in an ascending order of severity. Once a surgeon classifies a fracture he gains insight into the associated problems in treating it. Classification thus helps in proper decision making.

In young patients these fractures are usually the result of a high energy trauma. Although multifragmentary and at times open, these are fractures of normal bone and are therefore often amenable to secure fixation.

In the elderly the commonest mechanism is a slip and fall on to the point of the elbow. The olecranon is driven into the trochlea and splits the osteoporotic condyle of the humerus into a multitude of fragments. The resultant fractures are multifragmentary, displaced and often defy attempts at reduction and fixation.

When one is deciding on treatment the factors which must be considered are patient factors, the fracture factors, and the treatment factors. The most important factors are: the patients age and the degree of osteoporosis, the comminution and displacement of the fractures, the association of neurovascular injuries, and whether the fracture is open or closed.

An open reduction and internal fixation is best performed with the patient on the side with the injured elbow uppermost, or with the patient prone. The best surgical approach is posterior. Once the skin is incised one must isolate and protect the ulnar nerve. The facture is exposed by carrying out an osteotomy of the olecranon. In elderly patients in whom a prostheses might become the salvage, one should consider using a triceps splitting approach or a triceps peal as for an elbow arthroplasty.

Commence fixation with an anatomic reduction of the trochlear fragment to the capitellar fragment. If bone is missing than instead of lag screws one uses fully threaded screws to prevent the narrowing of the distal articulation. Once securely fixed, the articular complex is fixed to the metaphysis and shaft. The fixation is carried out with two plates which should be positioned at 90 degrees to each other to achieve the strongest biomechanical construct. The plates commonly used are the 3.5mm LCDCP plates or the 3.5mm reconstruction plates. The choice of one or the other plate depends on the fracture pattern and on the necessary contouring of the plates. The usual choice are two reconstruction plates one medially and one posteriorly contoured to fit the posterior aspect of the capitellum which is devoid of articular cartilage. Such fixation is particularly useful in distal fractures. If there is metaphyseal bone loss one should use at least one LCDCP since these are stronger than the reconstruction plates.

Post-operatively the elbow is immobilized in 120–150 degrees of extension and is elevated for 24–48 hours. Early active motion should commence no later than day three in order to regain a range of motion.

Delay in internal fixation beyond day 5 often leads to the formation of heterotopic bone with marked stiffness. If surgery is delayed the patient should receive Indocid to prevent heterotopic bone formation. If heterotopic bone develops and blocks motion it should be resected early. One should not delay until the alkaline phosphatase and the bone scans return to normal.

Supracondular fractures in the elderly present special problems since they defy attempts at reduction and stable fixation. As a result many elderly patients, whether operated or not, end up with poor and painful elbow function. To prevent these therapeutic disasters recently primary total elbow arthroplasty has been used as a primary form of treatment. Bernard Morrey published encouraging early results of elderly patients with supracondylar fractures treated primarily with the semi-constrained Coonrad Morrey prosthesis. Since then this rationale has been adopted by a number of trauma centers and there are numerous multicenter trials underway to evaluate this form of treatment and place it in its proper perspective.

Open supracondylar fractures present a special problem. If they occur in young patients with good bone and if they are reconstructible, then after a thorough irrigation and debridement a primary open reduction and internal fixation should be carried out. If stable fixation is not possible one should carry out an open reduction and fixation of the articular component, and span the elbow with an external fixator. Once a stable and closed soft tissue envelope has been achieved one can carry out a delayed reconstruction of the metaphyseal component. This greatly reduced risks of infection. In elderly patients with osteoporotic bone this may not be possible as indicated. Every open fracture must be irrigated and debrided. Stable internal fixation greatly lessens the risk of infection. Because of poor bone mobilization of the joint in these patients must be delayed and the internal fixation often supplemented with external fixation to prevent fixation failure. A primary arthroplasty should not be considered because of the risk of sepsis.

In young patients with good bone with Type C1 and C2 fractures 80–90% of good functional results are to be expected. C3 fractures particularly if open and fractures in the elderly, except those treated with primary arthroplsty, lead to unsatisfactory outcomes.


Full Access
K. Zyto

Proximal humeral fractures account for approximately 4–5% of all fractures seen in the emergency departments. Of all shoulder injuries they account for aproximatelly 53%. In 1970 Neer published his classic study, in which he described a new method of classification, and gave recommendations for treatment. Neer recommended ORIF for three-part fractures, and prosthetic replacement for four-part fractures and fracture-dislocations. However there is still disagreement on the management of the displaced humeral fractures.

Diagnosis

Accurate radiographic evaluation, is essential in order to make a correct classification of the proximal humeral fractures. The radiographic examination consists of films from three different views. The anterio-posterior (AP), lateral (Y view of the scapula), and the axillary one. The AP view will assess the fracture position, and by centring it 30 degrees posteriorly and obliquely, clearly image the glenohumeral joint space. The lateral view is taken perpendicular to the scapular plain. The head overlaps the glenoid, and projects on the centre of a “Y“, formed by acromion, the coracoid superiorly, and the scapular body inferiorly. In this projection any large avulsed greater tuberosity fragments are usually easy to visualise posteriorly, and the lesser tuberosity is visualised medialy.

The axillary view is the most useful in assessing the relationship between the humeral head and the glenoid. Fracture dislocations, and true posterior dislocations can be easily distinguished in the axial view. Computer tomography, plain or with three dimensional reconstruction-views might also help the surgeon to make an accurate diagnosis and in preoperative planning.

Classification

A valid classification system can be useful as a tool to select the optimal treatment. The system should be comprehensive enough to reflect the complex fracture pattern, and specific enough to allow an accurate diagnosis. The classification should be useful as a tool for identifying those fractures which should be operated upon.

In 1935, Codman proposed a new classification system based on four different anatomical fragments of the proximal humerus. The anatomical head, the greater tuberosity, the lesser tuberosity and the humeral shaft. Codman stressed that the musculotendinous cuff attachment to each fragment was of major significance to the fracture pattern.

In 1970 Neer further developed Codmans classification, stressing the importance of the biomechanical forces, and the degree of displacement for more complex fractures. When any of the four major segments is displaced over 1 cm or angulated more than 45 degrees, the fracture is considered to be displaced: Group 1: all fractures regardless of the level or number of fracture lines, in wich NO segments are displaced. Group 2: a two-part fracture is one in which one fragment is displaced in reference to the other three fragments. Group 3: a three-part fracture is one in which two fragments are displaced in relationship to each other and the other two are undisplaced fragments, but the head remains in contact with the glenoid. Group 4: a four-part fracture is one in which all four fracture fragments are displaced; the articular surface of the head is out of contact with the glenoid and angulated either laterally, anteriorly, posteriorly, inferiorly, or superiorly. Furthermore it is detached from both tuberosities. Neer has also emphasised the term fracture dislocation. It exists when the head is displaced outside the joint space rather than subluxated or rotated and there is, in addition, a fracture. The degree of displacement is directly related to the clinical outcome and the choice of treatment.

In the 1970’s the AO group from Switzerland, emphasised the importance of the blood supply to the articular surface of the humeral head. Since the risk for avascular necrosis was high, they based their classification on the vascular anatomy of the proximal humerus. The system classified the fractures into three different categories:

Group A: Extra-articular, unifocal fracture.

Group B: Partially extra-articular, bi-focal fracture.

Group C: Articular fracture.

Each group is sub-divided into three categories, from less to more serious lesions. This gave us 27 different sub-groups to analyse and interpret. The AO system is easy to use for the diaphyseal segments of the femur, tibia and humeral shaft, but applying it to the proximal humerus is confusing, and makes it more difficult to use than the Neer system. Consequently the AO classification system has not gained general acceptance among shoulder surgeons.

The reliability and the reproducibility of these classifications have been questioned Unfortunately, we do not have a better classification system on hand and therefore the Neer system is still widely used.

Treatment

Many methods of treatment of proximal humeral fractures have been proposed during the past 50 years, creating a great deal of controversy and confusion. There are two main treatment options: Non-operative treatment and operative.

Conservative treatment

Approximately 80% of all proximal humeral fractures are non-displaced, or only minimally displaced, and the clinical outcome is satisfactory after conservative treatment. After some days of rest, early mobilisation with gentle physiotherapy is of great importance.

Operative treatment

Various types of osteosynthesis have been suggested. Semitubular straight or angulated plates, screws, Rush pins, external fixators, cerclage wires, tension band technique or K-wires with bone grafting have been used. The results reported range from excellent to poor. In cases of three- and four- part fractures, most authors have used open reduction with internal fixation. Because of poor bone quality, and a torn cuff, especially in elderly patients, osteosynthesis is not always the best choice. Hemiarthroplasty is reported to give an excellent outcome in many studies. In fracture dislocations, when closed reduction is not possible, the only way to restore the dislocated shoulder joint is to perform an open reduction and stabilise the fracture with an osteosynthesis implant, or replace the humeral head with a hemiarthroplasty.

Scoring systems for evaluation of the end results

There are two rating systems generally used. The Neer system from 1970 has been widely used in a number of studies, all over the world, and the Constant-Murley system from 1987 has been recommended for use in Europe. Neer’s rating system from 1970 is used to assess shoulder function, after fractures, arthroplasty and dislocations. It is based on a 100 units scale, with points for pain (35), function (30), range of motion (25), and anatomy (10). In 1987 Constant and Murley designed a European scoring system, claiming it to be applicable for measuring shoulder function regardless of diagnosis. This system is also based on a 100 point scale. The degree of pain, activities of daily living, strength, and active range of movement are assessed. The results are then related to gender, age and activity level of the patient.

Both systems has recently been questioned because of its low reliability. Confusion remains because different authors from the USA and Europe continue to use their own criteria for evaluation. Consequently, it is not unusual that the reported results after fracture treatment vary, depending on which rating system was used.


Full Access
U.E. Pazzaglia

This study is based on 286 consecutive fractures of the shaft of the humerus surgically treated in the Orthopaedic Department Spedali Civili, Brescia, from November 1996 to December 2001.

Fractures were classified accordingly to AO System.

A peculiar group was represented by 33 (11.5%) complex and multifragmental fractures, where the fracture involved either the shaft and the proximal metaphysis and epiphysis.

Fractures were always treated by plate and screws when a deficit of the radial nerve was present, in order to allow neurolysis or nervous graft.

Fractures without radial nerve lesion were treated either by plate or by endomedullary nail.

In the latter group two typed of nail were used:

rigid, reamed, Kuntscher nail inserted through the proximal epiphysis

elastic nail, type Marchetti-Vicenzi, inserted through a posterior, distal humeral approach.

Patients were evaluated with a follow-up of a least 1 year.

The rate of fracture consolidation, was similar in the group 1 rigid nail (96.5%) and plate (96.9%), while lower in the group of elastic nail (89.1%).

Also time of consolidation and functional recovery was similar in the first two groups.

Particular problems presented by the group of complex fractures required a differentiated post-surgical treatment, with plaster cast or orthopaedic devices used as adjuvant mode of immobilization. All except one of these cased consolidated in a larger lapse of time (mean 4.5 months) with the following functional results: 36.5% very good; 18.1% good; 9.1% fear; 36.3% poor. A selection of the technical solution adopted is presented.


Full Access
K. Parsch

Number one in frequency of all fractures in children is the distal forearm fracture. The most common green-stick fracture with minor or no dislocation is treated by short or long arm cast. Depending on the age 4 or six weeks of immobilization is sufficient.

Displaced fractures of the distal radius and ulna are treated by closed reduction under general anaesthesia or lighter forms of analgesia. Reduction is followed by fixation in the “Schede position” (flexion, ulnar abduction) with obligatory change of cast after 10–14 days. Healing can be expected after 6 weeks. As an alternative percutaneous pinning of the reduced fracture allows immobilization in a short arm cast and without the the unpleasant flexion and ulnar abduction (Voto et al 1990, Mani et al 1993, Gibbons et al 1994, Choi et al 1959).

There is currently a prospective randomised study running organized by Mr Clarke from Southampton, to the advantages and disadvantages after use of pins or abstaining from them apparent risks.

For midshaft forearm fractures closed reduction and long arm cast immobilisation had been treatment of choice in the past. Remanipulation under anaesthesia because of lack of retention of both bone fractures have been common. Concerns came up mainly in the age group above 10 years with a high rate of unsatisfactory results (Kay et al 1986). Plate fixation of both bones is a difficult procedure and causes damage to the interosseous membrane and can enhance rotatory deficits. In addition ugly scars are not unusual. Intramedullary nails seemed advantageous. (Amit et al 1985)

J.L. Morote and the Spanish school of Sevilla were the first to use a minimal invasive method of reduction and K-wire fixation of midshaft and proximal forearm fractures. (Perez-Sicilia et al 1977).

The French group in Nancy and Metz had the some years later and developed their elastic stable intramedullary system for forearm fractures Metaizeau 1988, Lascombes et al. 1990). A high rate of excellent outcomes and hardly any complications were observed.

Intramedullary fixation with elastic stable nails even permits immediate motion (Verstreken et al 1988).

The surgical technique of Morote using blunt-ended 1,6 to 1,8 mm K-wires is described in “Operative Technique in Orthopaedics and Trauma” (Parsch 1990) The results were confirmed by Kaye Wilkins (1996), Luhmann et al 1998, and Richter et al 1998

An unacceptable high rate of complications was seen in groups, who used pins, which were not buried, who removed pins to early and before consolidation or who had fixed only one bone (Cullen et al 1998, Shoemaker et al 1999).

We recommend the intramedullary system for all displaced forearm fractures of children above 6 years until closure of the growth plate.(Parsch 1990). The learning curve is short, the time of surgery an average of 40 minutes. The radiation exposure can be limited by the use of short impulse image intensifier. There is virtually no blood loss. With the learning curve more than 80 % can be fixed by closed means. Open reduction might be necessary in adolescents, or in delayed fracture care.

Postoperative immobilisation is a plaster shell or brace is used for 2 weeks, this is not obligatory. Postoperative infections have not been observed after this minimal invasive method. Skin irritations can be avoided by complete bending of the K-wire ends.

In unacceptable malunion after conservative treatment closed or open realignment of the fractures followed by intramedullary Morote pinning is the treatment of choice.

Refractures may happen with wires in place shortly or a long time after removal of the hardware. They are not associated to the system, but rather to the fact that some children are subject to repeated falls, liable to break an arm.

Acute Monteggia fractures have the radial head reduced conservatively, usually under general anaesthesia. (Bado 1967). The ulnar fracture is reduced and than fixed by intramedullary K-wires (Fowles et al 1983)

In late reconstruction of Monteggia lesions we prefer plate fixation of ulna osteotomy.


Full Access
C. Hasler

Introduction: Closed reduction and percutaneous pinning techniques for displaced supracondylar fractures of the humerus in children have overcome disastrous ischemic complications and long inpatient treatment. Closed reduction of those highly unstable fractures and the demanding pin placement itself are potential sources of failure for the inexperienced reflected by the rate of cubitus varus which is still about 5 to 15% in recent series. Rotational primary and residual displacement has to be appreciated to prevent permanent cosmetic deformity. Malrotation is the major source of instability since bicolumnar support is lost which allows the distal fragment to tilt.

Anatomy: The transverse section of the distal humerus is the key to all stability related problems faced in supra-condylar fractures of the humerus in children. In the supracondylar region the radial and ulnar column are only connected by a thin bony wafer which results from the presence of the cubital and olecranon fossa. In case of a fracture. In case of a fracture rotation leads to decrease of bony contact and hence to instability.

Epidemiology: Elbow fractures account for 7–10% of all pediatric fractures whereof 80–90% are located at the distal humerus with 80% involvement of the supracondylar region. Most of the supracondylar fractures occur between ages 5 and 10 years.

Mechanism of injury: Fall from a height, usually from a household object in the age group < 3 years or from a playground equipment in children > 4 years on the outstretched nondominant arm (indirect elbow trauma). 96% of all supracondylar fractures are extension type injuries. Open fractures, mostly grade 1, occur when the anterior spike of the proximal fragment pierces through the brachialis muscle and the skin of the cubital fossa. Their incidence is about 1–3% in major referral centers.

Differential diagnosis: Supracondylar fractures have to be differentiated from transcondylar fractures and dislocations of the elbow. In a supracondylar fracture the fracture line stays proximal to the distal humerus physis. If it runs across it, it is most likely a supracondylar fracture. Dislocations of the elbow typically after the age of 10 years.

Neurologic compromise: Fracture related peripheral neuropathies have an incidence of 10 to 17%. With rare exceptions concomitant nerve lesion recover spontaneously within a time range of 1 to 4 months. The rate of iatrogenic nerve injuries is 3%–16% with the ulnar nerve being the most susceptible due to inadvertent pinning. Despite a high recovery rate, they are a nuisance for the patients.

Vascular compromise: Early recognition of vascular compromise with subsequent reduction and fixation of the fracture and avoidance of extreme flexion at the elbow have decreased the incidence of ischemic complications. An initially absent radial pulse is found in up to 19% in displaced fractures. Closed reduction restores pulsation in about 80%. Patients with postreduction lack of pulse or poor capillary refill should undergo vascular revision. There is still controversy regarding the management of a post reduction pink, warm but pulse less hand with adequate capillary refill. Simple observation and conservative management leads to a favourable clinical outcome in most cases but cold intolerance or exercise induced ischemic symptoms is a potential sequel.

Treatment:

Undisplaced fractures: simple immobilisation e.g. collar and cuff

Incomplete displacement: in case of malrotation and/or age-related unacceptable extension (> 20° in patients older than 6 years) closed reduction and pinning otherwise conservative management

Complete displacement: Attempt for closed reduction and percutaneous pinning. Irreducibility is found in up to 22%. Open reduction is most widely as a last resort.

Complications:

Infection

Occasionally, superficial infection after pinning occurs despite all preventive measure (wires left protruding through the skin should not be covered by plaster to prevent rubbing; pin care instruction for the parents; regular follow-up for pin site inspection)

Cubitus varus

Most common complication with an overall incidence of about 20%. As a malunion in the coronal plane it has no capacity for remodelling. Although this deformity is mainly a cosmetic problem and does not interfere with the range of motion, it may be a functional problem in some activities e.g. in apparatus gymnastics.

Malunion/Stiffness

Even after perfect reduction, lack of full extension is common and usually takes over 6 months to improve. Impaired range of motion may be prolonged or even persistent due to an underlying pathology. Malunion is the most common one. In the sagittal plane, antecurvation leads to hyperextension and reduced flexion of the elbow. Significant remodelling with growth can only be expected below the age of 6 and in antecurvations of less than 20°. Rotatory malunion with an anterior spur restrains flexion. Complete remodelling of the spur usually takes place even in older children. Volkmann’s contracture represents the most severe complication after supracondylar fractures. Fortunately, it has become a rarity.

Conclusion:

The human factor, in view of the particular anatomy of the supracondylar region and the extreme fracture instability seems to be more decisive for the end result than any biomechanical differences of various pin configurations. Repeat instruction by an experienced surgeon for proper reduction technique, assessment of achieved reduction and technically correct pin placement is crucial to further improve the outcome of this challenging fracture.


Neves M. Cassiano Freitas R. Telles

Proximal Radius – Fractures of the proximal radius in children account for slightly more than 1% of all children’s fractures, represent 5 to 10% of all elbow fractures and accounts for 5% of all fractures involving the growth plate. The average age in the literature is 10 years (4 to 16 years) with no difference between boys and girls.

The anatomical aspects should be emphasized for the comprehension of this fracture: 1) the radial head of the child only starts to ossify at age 5 so it is very rare to have a fracture before this age since all the head is cartilaginous and therefore more resistant to trauma. At the same time it makes more difficult the diagnosis because of the absence of ossification of the epiphysis. 2) There is a valgus angulation of 12.5° between the radial head and the shaft of the radius in the AP plan and an anterior angulation of 3° on the lateral plane that should not be misinterpreted as fractures. 3) The radial head is intrarticular in a similar way like the femoral head and trauma to this region may lead to AVN as a result of damage to the vascular supply of the epiphysis. 4) The proximal radioulnar joint has a very intimate continuity contributing to exact congruence of the articular surfaces. The axis of rotation lies directly in the center of the radial neck. Any deviation of the epiphysis over the neck has a major reflect over the axis of rotation causing a “cam” effect when the radial head rotates with loss of pronosupination.

The mechanism of injury responsible for this injury result from a fall on the outstretched upper extremity in which the elbow is extended and a valgus force is applied to the elbow joint. In more rare cases it result from direct pressure to the radial head during dislocation of the elbow.

There are different classifications mostly based on the anatomical lesion or degree of deformity. Wilkins divides this fracture in two major groups: Group I (valgus fracture) subdivided in three types: type A – the Salter-Harris type I and II, type B – Salter-Harris type IV and type C – fractures involving only the proximal radial metaphysis and Group II (fractures associated with elbow dislocation) subdivided in two types: type D – reduction injuries and type E – dislocation injuries. O’Brien divides the common valgus injury in three types according to the degree of angulation between the radial head and the axis of the radius: Type I (0 to 30° angulation) Type II (between 30° and 60°) and Type III (more than 60°).

The clinical symptoms may vary according to the magnitude of the injury. The child will mostly complaint of pain and tenderness on the lateral side of the joint. In young children pain may first be referred to the wrist. The pain usually increases with pronosupination and extension of the elbow.

The diagnosis relies mostly on the x-ray view (AP and lateral) and the fracture will be easily visualized in either film. In the cases where the fracture line is superimposed over the ulna an oblique view will be necessary. In the young child, whereas the epiphysis is still not ossified, an ultrasound may be helpful differentiating the position of the radial head. An arthrogram may also be of benefit especially during the process of reduction to check the accuracy of the treatment.

The prognosis of this lesion depends on several factors. A poor result can be expected if the fracture is associated with other injuries such as elbow dislocation and ulna or medial epicondylar fractures. A residual tilt of the radial head, provided is not superior to 30°, is more tolerable than a translocation of the radial head superior to 4mm. Age is also an important factor since the older the child the less remodeling it will have. The treatment has also an important role in the prognosis of this injury since it is unanimous acceptable that an open reduction is associated with poor results.

Therefore the treatment of a young child with an isolated minimal displaced fracture-separation of the proximal radius (less than 30°) should be a simple long arm cast. In a more displaced fracture (more than 30° of tilt) a closed reduction should be performed under general anesthesia as suggested by Patterson. If the maneuver is not successful other attempts should be made with lateral pin compression applied directly to the radial head as suggested by Pesudo or an indirect reduction by an intramedullary kirschner wire as suggested by Metaizeau. Open reduction should be only reserved for dislocated Grade IV Salter-Harris type fractures, incarcerated radial head or in the presence of failure of closed treatment.

The incidence of complications especially if associated with a dislocation of the elbow or other fractures can be high. The most common are loss of motion, radial head overgrowth usually with no clinical significance, notching of the radial neck and premature physeal closure. Avascular necrosis of the radial head is most commonly associated with open reduction.

Distal Radius – It is the most common fracture separation in children and represent 46% of all fractures involving the growth plate. A fracture of the ulna is associated in 6 to 11% of the injuries. The average age is 12 years with a minimum of 7 and a maximum of 16 years. Although this high incidence it is very uncommon subsequent growth disturbance.

The usual mechanism of injury is similar to the proximal radius injury and result from a fall on the outstretched upper extremity with the wrist hyperextended.

This type of injury is classified by the Salter-Harris classification for physeal fractures and the most commons are the types I and II.

The clinical symptoms vary from mild tenderness over the fracture site to a noticeable deformity most often with the apex volar. Attention should be given to the possibility of vascular and neural injury associated, mostly from the time of the acute deformation, and the diagnosis is made by x-ray view (AP and lateral) with the fracture well visualized.

The prognosis is in general good since even in the presence of a markedly displaced fracture it can be expected a remarkably remodeling even in an older child.

Treatment in a nondisplaced fracture only requires a below elbow cast for 4 weeks. In a displaced fracture a closed reduction should be performed under hematoma block or general anesthesia (in a young child). The reduction is stable most of the times in a plaster with the wrist in slight flexion. The incidence of complications is very rare.


G.V. Kuropatkin O.N. Sedova U.P. Eltsev

The Acetabular Dysplasia creates serious technical problems for the insertion of acetabular socket. In first, cup must have a good primary stable fixation in a shallow acetabulum. In second, smaller cups are usually required in dysplasia hip, but small sockets must have thick polyethylene wall. And in third, cup design must ensuring easy reconstruction of the anterolateral bone defect. In our opinion, all these problems can be achieved by using of cementless acetabular Robert Mathys (RM) cups.

Materials and Methods

In the period from 1996 to 2000 168 patients with ace-tabular dysplasia were operated with titanium powder coated RM cups. The patients age was from 18 to 75 years old (average 43,5). In 77 patients with type I dysplasia (AAOS classification) a primary stable fixation of the acetabular component in a good position without of filling bone defect was achieved. In 53 patient with type II dysplasia stable fixation was supplemented by closing of a cup by filler bone grafts in a place of bone defect. In case of type III dysplasia (38 patients) with very shallow acetabulum and extensive bone defects initial stabilization was achieved by the press-fit one or two anchoring pegs and insertion cancellous screws. In type III dysplasia the massive bone transplant was fixed by additional screws. The features of a design of a cup allowed to stop on the small socket sizes without danger of use implant with critically thin polyethylene wall. It considerably improved a covering of a cup.

Results

In 166 patients (98,8 %) a good medium-term results (2–6 years) were obtained. The radiologic controls have shown that the prostheses underwent good osteointegration. 2 patients (1,2%) needed revision. Of them one patient had a infected complication, one other had an aceptic necrosis of acetabulum and secondary cup migration. In all other patients no osteolisis was observed. The good primary fixation of the RM cup decreased the risk of aseptic loosing of the autologous bone graft. The temporal partial (not more than 1/3) bone graft resorption was find in 33,9 % at the type II and 42,1 % at the type III dysplasia. After 2 years in all cases we observed improvement of the bone stock quality at the site of bone grafting.

Conclusions

The features of a design of RM cup allow to use implants of the small size. The application for cup fixation pegs and screws allows to receive its reliable primary stability even at expressed acetabular dysplasia. The good primary stability and ease of application of bone grafts allows to achieve with RM cup of an overall objective of operation - maximal restoration of anatomy and biomechanics of the dysplastic hip joint.


J.-Chr. Wolter G. Wolf H. Graßhoff

For the treatment of the acetabular dysplasia in the early childhood the spherical periacetabular osteotomy of the ilium is a well-recognized procedure.

52 hips of 35 patients treated with a periacetabular osteotomy between 1969 and 1985 we followed-up after 14 to 31 years. At the time of operation the average age was 2,8 years.

The measurement of the anterio-posterior radiographs showed a normalization of the acetabular roof obliquity in 79% of the cases. However, there were only 46% of the cases with a normal center-edge angle. 42% had a medium pathologic angle of 20 to 30 °. In 12 % we saw severe pathology with angles smaller than 20.

Fife cases (10%) presented radiologic signs of osteoarthritis and three a slight incongruence between head and acetabulum.

Rare cases of postoperative complications are presented.

The low incidence of radiographic osteoarthritis supports the view that the spherical periacetabular osteotomy is an appropriate surgical procedure to treat acetabular dysplasia in early childhood.


F. Makai I. Janèik P. Maresch

Aim of the study: In our work we firstly investigated severe, neglected cases of dysplastic coxarthroses, secondly trying to elucidate the best type of implant and operative procedure for severe, neglected cases and find out the outcome of these operations.

Material and methods: In the period 1987–2001 we operated more than 700 patients with dysplastic coxarthroses, in whom we implanted total hip prostheses (THP’s). The percentage of dysplastic coxarthroses among our hipoperated patients oscillated in the mentioned period between 40–50%, the average age of the mostly female patients was 38,8-42 years. In these mostly young patients we implanted following types of uncemented THP’s; in the order of most operations: Zweymuller’s cementless THP’s, Aldinger’s individual, custom made cementless THP’s, the Harris-Galante cup and Geradschaft femoral stem, mostly uncemented, the C-Fit THP, rarely other types (f.i. Charnley’s cemented THP’s).

Results: According to evaluation of Merle d’Aubigne and Postel we achieved best results with Aldinger’s custom made THP’s – nearly 88% very good and good results.

Conclusion: The best long-term results in THP’s for dysplastic coxarthroses were achieved by Aldinger’s THP’s, followed by Zweymuller’s cementless THP’s, which we consider as methods of choice in the mentioned cases.


M. Synder M. Domzalski A. Grzegorzewski

Introduction: Thanks to early ultrasound diagnosis of DDH the number of late diagnosed cases decreased in the last ten years. The surgical intervention because of dislocated hip is also reduced to the few cases a year. We still however have in our practice patients after operative treatment of DDH. One of the methods used for proper hip reduction is transiliacal pelvic osteotomy described by Dega.

The aim of this study is to evaluate the late results of one stage procedure with Dega transiliacal pelvic osteotomy in the treatment of DDH with dislocation.

Material and Methods: In our Institution 256 dislocated hips were treated surgically by means of open hip reduction, femoral directional osteotomy and Dega’s transiliacal osteotomy. From this group 102 patients (91 female and 11 male), presented 144 operated hips were seen for the final follow-up. The left hip was affected in 45 cases, right in 17, and bilateral in 41 patients. The mean age at the surgery was 23,5 months. Mean follow-up was 19.8 years (minimum 15 years after surgery). Patients were evaluated clinically (Barrett modification of McKay classification) and radiologically using Severin classification. All radiograms from whole period of treatment were collected and evaluated.

Results: In 90 hips the final result was classify as very good (57%), good in 36 hips (23%), satisfactory in 10 hips and poor in 8 hips. Radiologically very good result (group IA) was seen in 51 hips, good in 65 hips (group IB, IIA, IIB), satisfactory in 24 hips and poor in 4 hips. It was a good correlation between clinical and radiographic classification.

Conclusions : The late results after one stage hip reconstruction with Dega’s transiliacal osteotomy gives a long lasting good results and is recommended for operative treatment of DDH with dislocation.


K.S Stafilas P.B Kitsoulis Th.A Xenakis P.N Soucacos

INTRODUCTION: The treatment of “congenital hip disease” by total hip arthroplasty is now well established, but the indications for this type of surgery, the preoperative planning, the selection of the stem and the technique to be followed are still open to debate.

AIM OF THE STUDY: The purpose of this study is to analyse the long-term follow up after use of the cementless-system (CLS) femoral component designed by Spotorno in dysplastic or congenitally dislocated hips.

MATERIAL AND METHODS: Our study includes 70 hips in 59 patients, 49 females and 10 males, 36 left hips and 34 right hips that treated with total hip arthroplasty from 1987 to 2000. The mean age of the patients was 48.5 years (range 34–74 years). Forty-one hips were congenitally dislocated and twenty-nine were severe dysplastic. Preoperative planning with CT and CAD-CAE system were used for selection of the stem. 11 patients had bilateral total hip arthroplasties with Spotorno CLS stem.

RESULTS: The mean follow up was 8.1 years (range 2–14 years). No patients were lost during the follow-up period. Patients were evaluated clinically with Merle d’ Aubigne and Postel hip score. There was a significant postoperative clinical improvement of the mean pain score by 3.7 points, of walking ability by 2.2 points and of motion by 2,6 points. Thigh pain was not reported. There were no deep infections or mechanical loosenings that required revision of the femoral component.

CONCLUSIONS: Although, the femoral component Spotorno CLS is used to every kind of hip diseases, had excellent long-term clinical results in adults, with dysplasia or congenital hip dislocation. Spotorno CLS uncemented femoral component represents an attractive option for adults with “congenital hip disease”.


JM. Gutiérrez Carrera Valdivieso T. Ruiz Arce R. Sota Cespedosa A. Ginés Pérez A. Ganso

Knee arthrodesis is a useful procedure in difficult cases such as failed total knee arthroplasty, bone tumors and infected knee joints. A review of 27 cases treated using a modular locked intramedullary nail “Wichita” in 4 hospitals was performed. This fusion nail is a device designed to provide simultaneous compression and intramedullary fixation. The device is implanted through a single knee incision using three main components after femoral and tibial reaming. The femoral components inserts retrograde and has two holes in its proximal end to accept transverse locking screws. The tibial component inserts anterograde into the proximal tibia and has some holes for transverse screw placement. The compression screw component is used to lock the femoral and tibial components together and simultaneusly compression is generated across the joint line. Teorical advantages are single incision, inmediate and solid stability, posibility of compression, adjust of length, high fusion rates and less risk of infection than other procedures. An individual study protocol was made and it includes previous primary or revision failed total knee replacement, severe articular trauma and infection. No bone tumors were includes. Protocol includes aspects such as operative time and blood loss,intraoperative complications, radiographic evaluation (tibiofemoral alignement, contact tibiofemoral surface area...) shortenning of extremity, time to union, posoperative complications and patient subjective evaluation.10 patients are being studied prospectively in our institution since january 2000 and the mean follow-up is 16 months. 17 patients were retrospectively studied in 3 differents hospitals using the same protocol and the mean follow-up is 26 months. Global results show a solid fusion in 26 (96 per cent) of the 27 patients at an average time of 15 weeks (range 12 to 22 weeks) after the operation. There were one mechanical failure of the implant (thecnical mistake during assembly of the compression screw component). There were 2 non desplaced fractures in the end of the nail. There was 1 desplaced fracture and removed of implant was required, osteosynthesis was performed with a long intramedullary nail. No infections were detected. These results and others are related. Although good results observed, with high fusion rates and minimal complications, a potential disadvantage is the difficult to remove the nail if this is necesary.


M. Synder M. Marciniak M. Drobniewski

Introduction: The knee arthritis is a very common seen chronic disease in an orthopaedic practice. It is mostly seen in patients after 6 decade of life and connected with a severe knee pain. In most of the cases the surgical intervention is indicated because of unicondylar arthritis changes. Because of the costs of the hemiarthroplasty we choose a high tibial osteotomy for tibial axis correction to prevent further gonarthrosis.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the late results after high tibial osteotomy in patients with unicondylar gonarthrosis.

Material and Methods: In our Institution during last 20 years 94 high tibial osteotomy were performed because of unicondylar, medial gonarthrosis. The mean age of the patient at the time of surgery was 56 years (from 19 to 72 years). The mean follow-up was 16 years. Only patients with arthritic changes on the medial compartment of the knee with a “good” lateral part of the knee were scheduled for this type of surgery. In every case the dome type of osteotomy was performed followed by 1cm resection of fibula. After surgery the limb was stabilized with plate in 16 cases, K-wires in 4 cases, Ilizarov frame in 43 cases, orthofix device in 8 cases and other type of external fixator in remaining 23 cases. In patients where external fixator was used the full weight bearing was recommended as soon as patient tolerated the pain. The external fixator was removed after an average period of 6 weeks when bone callus was diagnosed. To assess of the clinical results based on HSS score and radiological results were evaluated using the modified Dihlmann classification.

Results: In 88,8% of all cases the final result was graded as excellent and good, in 1,9% the final results was satisfactory and in 7.8% the final results was poor. From analyzed patients 46% was scheduled for TKR at an average time of 12 years after initial surgical procedure. In 28% after average 16 years after high tibial osteotomy the good shape of the knee joint was observed with good clinical function and radiographic appearance. Pain was reduced in 82% of all cases, increased range of the knee motion was observed in 65% and improved walking ability in 64% of all cases. The poor results were connected with not adequate patients selection for this type of surgery (patients after 7 decade of life) and with advanced arthritic knee changes before the surgery.

Conclusions : The high tibial osteotomy is a good method for preventing gonarthrosis. When early performed gives good long-lasting result. In our opinion is recommended for unicondylar gonarthrosis as an alternative to the knee hemiarthroplasty.


R. Becker M. John W. Neumann

One of the advantage in using unicondylar prosthesis seems to be the preservation of the bone stock, which allows most often easily revision to a total knee replacement if required. The purpose of the study was to compare the patients outcome after revision of unicondylar prosthesis with a group of patients who have received total knee replacement primarily.

Material and Method: 28 patients after revision unicondylar prosthesis (group A) and 28 patients after primary total knee replacement (group B) were included in the study. The two groups were matched according to age, sex, weight, height, type of prosthesis and follow-up time. The patients’ evaluation was based on the Knee-Society-Score and the WOMAC-score. X-rays of the knee were taken in the AP weight bearing and lateral view.

Results: In group A the average follow-up time was 55±15 months and in group B 56±13 months. The knee-score showed 71.8±18 and 80.4±10.4 points and the function-score 56.1±15 and 62±19 points for group A and group B respectively without any statistical difference. The subjective assessment according to the WOMAC score showed difference in the functional outcome. A better range of motion of 110±11° was noticed for group B in comparison with group A 102±8° (p=0.004). The revised patients required a significantly higher poly-ethylene-inlay (12.9±3mm) compared to the primarily implanted ones (10.3±3mm) (p=0.004).

Discussion: Based on our findings revision of unicondylar to total knee replacement provides comparable results to primarily implanted total knee arthroplasty and should be considered for the treatment of unicompartmetal osteoarthritis even in younger patients, where a revision operation during lifetime is more likely. Despite the difference regarding the height of the inlay of 3mm, adequate bone stock was still found in order to implant an unconstraint type of knee prosthesis. The impaired functional outcome seems to be related to the fact of the reoperation and a significant longer history of osteoarthritis for group A in comparison with group B.


P Than Gy Szabò J Kránicz Á. Bellyei

Introduction: With the growing number of primary knee arthroplasties, the number of revision operations is also increasing. The large number of unicondylar replacements carried out in the 1980’s, due to lack of modern total condylar implants, grant the revision techniques an outstanding significance in Hungary. One of the main issues of modern revision techniques is the management of bone defects, which can be solved by different methods documented in literature.

Aim of study: The aim of our study was to investigate the success and feasibility of the various defect management techniques by evaluating the results of revision knee prosthetic surgeries carried out at our clinic.

Patients and methods: Femoral and tibial bone defects had to be solved with revision surgeries in 35 cases, all performed due to aseptic loosening of uni- and total condylar prostheses implanted earlier. For filling of bone defects, metal augmentation of the prostheses was applied in 9 cases, allografts from bone bank were used in 11 cases, own cancellous bone was applied in 20 cases. Results were prospectively analysed with the help of the knee society rating system, with an average follow-up of two and a half years.

Results: Revision interventions were successful in 34 cases, detailed results are revealed in the presentation, complemented with case presentations. In a single case, repeated intervention surgery is indicated due to disorganisation of the structural allograft and the resulting loosening of the tibial component.

Conclusion: The success of the various bone replacement techniques, completed with adequate indication could be proven in all cases. The unsuccessful case proved that allograft incorporation should be supported by appropriate stem augmentation of the tibial component. In order to perform successful revision knee arthroplasty, we consider it fundamentally important to have a wide variety of allografts from bone bank and a modern knee prostheses system application already during primary implantations.


H. Pandit A.J. Price J. Rees D.J. Beard H.S. Gill D.W. Murray C.A.F. Dodd

Introduction: The indications for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) can be contentious. Concerns exist about implanting a UKA in younger individuals and it has been reported that the procedure is contra-indicated in patients under the age of 60. The suggestion is that younger patients may compromise their outcome after surgery by their increased activity levels. However, the number of publications with data on UKA in young patients is minimal and the age/activity related criteria for UKA remains unknown.

Aim: The aim is twofold: 1) to confirm that younger UKA patients have higher activity levels than older patients, and 2) to test the hypothesis that younger, more active patients have inferior outcome when compared to older less active patients.

Materials and methods: Fifty consecutive patients undergoing UKA who were under 60 years old at the time of surgery (Group Y) and 50 patients over 60 years (Group O) were recruited. Indications were anteromedial arthritis with full thickness lateral compartment cartilage, a functioning ACL and a correctible varus deformity. All patients underwent Oxford UKA using the minimally invasive technique. This device employs an unconstrained fully congruous meniscal bearing. Outcome was evaluated using the American Knee Society Score (AKSS). Activity level was documented using the established Tegner Activity Score.

Results: The average age of patients for group Y and O was 55 years and 68 years respectively. Minimum follow up for both groups was 2 years. Pre-operative AKSS scores were comparable for each group (Group Y = 38.8, Group O = 35.8) and patients in both groups significantly improved after surgery. A significant difference in Tegner score was found between groups after surgery (Group Y = 3.9, Group O = 2.6). It was found that 40% of younger patients regularly participate in high demand activities like skiing, tennis, hard manual labour and swimming. No statistically significant difference in any other post operative knee scores or complication rate were found despite adequate study power.

Conclusions: Younger patients have increased activity levels after UKA when compared to an older age group. There is no evidence that the outcome of UKA in younger more active patients will be inferior to those who are older and more sedentary.


O.N. Paramasivan D. Younge P. Moreau S. Raja

Displaced supracondylar fracture in adults often require internal fixation. Plate fixation, requires soft tissue stripping resulting in devitalisation of bony fragments and this predisposes to risk of non union, infection and nerve injuries. This is the first report of a new technique, locked intramedullary transolecranon fossa nailing.

In this technique the fracture is exposed through a limited posterior triceps splitting incision, keeping the soft tissue stripping to the minimum. The medullary canal is entered proximally through an anterior shoulder incision. A guide wire is inserted in an antegrade manner to enter the fracture site. The distal fragment is predrilled to create a tract with 3.2mm drill from proximal to distal, in such a way that the drill enters the olecranon fossa and then the proximal part of trochlea avoiding penetration of the elbow joint. The guide wire is then advanced into the tract in the distal segment. The medullary canal is reamed over the guide wire in anti-grade fashion with flexireamer. Utilising the standard antegrade technique, the nail is inserted and advanced under direct vision until tip of the nail is firmly seated in the trochlea. The proximal and distal locking are done in standard fashion. Postoperatively active mobilisation is encouraged. Four patients underwent this procedure. All the fractures healed in 3 months and at one year follow up the average arc of elbow motion is 120 degrees. There are no complications.

Transolecranon fossa locked nailing is an available option to treat the displaced supracondylar fracture of humerus in adults.


M. Tyllianakis A. Karageorgos A. Karabasi D. Giannikas

Aim of the study

End results analysis of operative treatment in transcaphoid perilunate dislocations.

Material and method

From 1/1/91 to 1/1/01 twenty transcaphoid perilunate dislocations were operative treated. Ligamentous lesions were repaired through a dorsal approach, either by directly suturing the ligaments (10cases), or by using mini Mitek anchors (8 cases). Simple approximation and stabilization with K-wires was performed in 2cases. Scaphoid fractures were treated by open reduction and internal osteosynthesis with Herbert screw (12 cases), cortical AO 2.0 screw (2cases) or K-wires (6 cases). The wrist remained immobilized in a slight flexed position with short arm plaster for 8 weeks. Physiotherapy was necessary for all patients to regain full range of motion. Clinical and radiological evaluation was possible for all patients. The end results were estimated according to Cooney’s evaluation system. Kinematics of the injured wrists was also tested by cineradiography in order to estimate the dynamic behaviour of the wrist. The Average follow-up time was 52 months (range 11–76).

Results

Twelve patients had excellent result, 4 good, 1 fair, and 3 poor. Fourteen out of 16 cases returned to their previous work. Additional operations were required in two patients: 1) four corner arthrodesis because of aseptic necrosis of the proximal pole of the scaphoid with arthritic changes, 2) Scaphoid reoperation because of non-union by Matti-Russe procedure. The later was found in cineradiography to present a painless rotational instability.

Conclusions

Transcaphoid perilunate dislocation has a very good response to early operative treatment. Dorsal ligament repair with mite mini anchors seems to be a reliable easy made method. Scaphoid fracture stabilization requires a stable compressive fixation. Herbert screw is ideal and can be safely placed from proximal to distal via the dorsal incision. Cineradiography is the best way to evaluate normal wrist kinematics.


E. Czerwiñski R.T. Kukielka K. Nowak Z. Szygula

Varus deformity is found in 90% of patients with knee OA. Axis deviation of lower extremity influences joint biomechanics and produce alteration in bone mineral density. Structure and density of subchondral bone of the knee was previously examined by X-ray. Densitometry gives us a new method of bone mineral content measurement in the interesting regions of the skeleton.

The aim of this study was the assessment of effect of varus deformity on bone mineral density in tibial epiphysis.

Bone mineral densities (BMD) were estimated in 46 patients at a mean age of 62 years (15 to 78) who were operated on in Department of Orthopaedics. All of them represented osteoarthritis of the knee with varus deviation. BMD of the proximal tibia was evaluated on the Lunar DPX-IQ densitometer and analyzed in three regions of interest: medial, lateral and central. Lower extremity axis deviation was measured using the Metrecom devise (Faro). Results were compared to a control group of 20 patients without osteoarthritis of the knee and without deviation of lower extremity axis.

Increased BMD was found on the overweighed compartment of the knee in comparison to the underweight one. These differences were not observed in the control group. We developed a coefficient, which is the ratio of BMD in the overweighed compartment compared to BMD in underweight one. In our patients the mean value of this coefficient was 3.3, and it ranged from 1,2 to 24,5 (SD 5,7).

Significant correlation between varus axis deviation of the lower extremity and increased BMD coefficient was found.


P. Stavlas J. Gliatis K. Koukos T. Chatziargyropoulos S. Dangas D. Polyzois

Introduction. We present the results of the management of irreducible dislocation or fracture / dislocation of the elbow using the “Orthofix” external fixator in cases where the condition of the soft tissues was contraindicated for extensile surgical approaches or the internal fixation would not be stable enough to permit safe joint mobilization postoperatively.

Materials and methods. Twelve (12) patients were treated using elbow external fixation,5 with supracondylar fracture and severe osteoporosis and 7 with fracture / dislocation of the elbow and excessive soft tissue impairment (two of them with open fracture). For the patients with fracture, we performed minimal internal fixation using small incisions and minor soft tissue detachments and then we applied the elbow external fixator for the neutralization of the fixation. This permitted the immediate active assisted joint mobilization postoperatively without interfering with the stability of the joint and of the fixation. The same happened for the patients that their elbow remained unstable after reduction of traumatic dislocation, where the external fixation maintained the reduction of the joint. Prerequisite for the safe mobilization of the joint was the application of the external fixation at the center of rotation of the elbow which is the transepicondylar axis, in order to comply with the biomechanics of the joint.

Results. The fixator was applied for a mean of 10 weeks (6 – 16 weeks). All the fractures united and no instability of the joint was noted. The range of motion was between useful limits with lack of extension less than 30 degrees and flexion more than 130 degrees, pronation 60 degrees and supination 55 degrees (mean values). Pin track infection was presented in 3 patients and the treatment was local care and antibiotics. One patient had radial nerve palsy immediately after the operation, who recovered totally after four months without any treatment.

Conclusions. The external fixation of the elbow provides sufficient stability permitting the immediate mobilization of the joint postoperatively and in combination with the minimal soft tissue damage during the operation prevents the postoperative stiffness. It is a safe alternative solution when the condition of soft tissues around the elbow do not permit a thorough open procedure.


G.V. Kuropatkin U.P. Eltsev O.N. Sedova O.M. Semenkin

Introduction Distal radius fractures are the most common in the upper extremities and usually comminuted and unstable. The following techniques are usually used in treating these fractures: osteosynthesis with plates and screws (ORIF), Ilizarov device and the AO- external fixator, K – wires.

The main aim of the report is to study the results of surgical treatment of distal radius nonunion, malunion, and pseudarthrosis in cases when different techniques of fixation were used.

Material and methods. In 1998–2001 a clinical study of 48 patients (33 males and 15 females) with distal radius injury was conducted in orthopedics department. The mean age of the patients was 42 years (15–69). 28 patients had the injury of their right hand and 20 - of their left hand. 19 patients had distal radius non-union, 15 – malunion, and 14 – pseudarthrosis. The average time from injury to the surgical treatment was 5 months. The mean follow-up was 27,2 Months (12–36). The AO techniques (ORIF with titanium and stainless steel implants) were used in Group I (36 patients). Conventional techniques and fixators were used in 13 patients of Group II: home produced plates and screws, Ilizarov device, external fixator, K- wires. The indications for surgical treatment nonunion were: A3 type, B1 – B3 type, C1 – C3 type, accompanied by more than two criteria of instability. In 10 patients with extraar-ticular fractures we used osteosynthesis with dorsal or palmar T-plates (3.5 mm). Mini-«T» - and «Pi»-Plates (2,7 mm) were used in four patients who had comminuted fractures with tiny distal fragments (‘bursting’ mechanism).The Ilizarov device and K-wires were used in five patients. Radius reduction without rotational and angular deformity was considered to be an indication for shortening osteotomy of the ulna. Internal fixation with a 3.5 mm LC-DCP plate was used in six patients of Group I, and K- wires were used in two patients of Group II. The deformity of the radius required corrective osteotomy with a 3.5 mm T-plate fixation in five patients of Group I, in two patients of Group II we used home produced plates, screws, and bone autoplasty with a spongy graft from the iliac crest (14); in one patient a «Bio-oss» graft was used. In 7 patients we used Ilizarov device and K-wires.

Results. Pain relief was achieved in 87% of the reexamined patients from the Group I and in 72% - from the Group II. Bone fragments united in 31 patients of Group I (86%) and in 9 patients (75%). In one case a plate broke resulting in the relapse of pseudarthrosis. Application of the AO fixators allowed early mobilization, which helped to avoid post immobility contractures. Grasping power restoration in Group I was 76% (grip strength) and 82% (pinch strength) of the uninjured side. In Group II grip strength was 55% and pinch strength − 69% of the uninjured side. In Group II there was consolidation in two cases of nonunity, Sudeck’s syndrome developed in two patients. Contractures and progressive arthrosis in the wrist were also observed. Recovery of Group I patients was 2.5 times quicker than in Group II and the functional results were much better in Group I throughout the whole course of treatment.

Conclusion. In comparison with conventional fixators, AO-plates (ORIF) help to perform anatomically accurate and stable osteosynthesis, which, in its turn, helps to promote early mobilization, to reduce the complications. All this leads to a fall in the disability rate and invalidity of patients.


Ercilla J. Palencia Valdivieso T. Ruiz Aragòn F. Ardura

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

Classical treatment for supracondylar fractures of the femur has been osteosynthesis with plate and screws. This treatment is not free of complications as non-union, infection and material breakage. An alternative to this treatment is endomedullary osteosynthesis with retrograde interlocking nail.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We have reviewed 7 supracongylar fractures of the femur in 6 patients, treated with SCN retrograde interlocking nail. The average age of patients was 73 years. Traffic accidents were responsible of 3 of the cases, and the other 4 were due to low energy traumatisms. None of the fracture was opened.

The average follow up was 20 months (17–27), and clinical results were evaluated according to the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) knee evaluation scale modified by Leung et al.

OPERATION TECHNIQUE

Patients were placed in the supine position, without any longitudinal traction. We performed an anterior access with parapatellar arthrotomy. All nails were locked both proximally and distally. Functional recovering of the limb in discharge began during postoperative period for an average of 12 weeks (6–20).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

The results were fully satisfactory. The use of intramed-ullary locking nail in these fractures provides several advantages over standard treatment with opened reduction and internal fixation with plates and screws Endomedullar nails have become the elective choice in shaft fractures of the femur, and with the use of interlocking nails, their indications have expanded to distal fractures of the femur. However, their use in supra and intercondylar fractures is not very expanded yet.


G. Holnapy P. Nyíri P. Somogyi

INTRODUCTION: To determine the bone mineral density (BMD), the osteoporosis risk factors and the wrist function after distal radius fractures, treated by non-operative methods at the Orthopaedic Department of Semmelweis University Budapest.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: 55 patients, between January 1999 and December 2000 (47 to 90, mean age: 69.4 years) were treated non-operatively after distal radius fracture following minor trauma. The osteoporosis risk factors were detected by an interview format and the BMD was measured in the proximal femur, in level LII.-LIV. vertebras and in the contralateral radius. An adapted interview format was filled in six months following fracture healing to detect the wrist function.

RESULTS: Of the wrist-fractured patients 78% are osteoporotic, 20% are osteopenic in one of the examined region. 72.5% are osteoporotic and 17.5% are osteopenic at the contralateral radius. The T score is below −1 in LII–LIV. and the hip region in 80.36% and 67.92% respectively. Some of the patients had earlier fractures. Those, who had previous fracture before the age of 70, are all osteoporotic, and those who had no fracture previously are 64.5% osteoporotic, 22.5% osteopenic at the contralateral radius. At the LII–LIV vertebras, those who had previous fracture, 60% are osteoporotic and 33.3% osteopenic and those who had no fracture previously are 27.7% osteoporotic, 44.4% osteopenic. At the proximal femur region, those who had previous fracture, 23% are osteoporotic and 53.8% osteopenic and those who had no fracture previously are 16.2% osteoporotic, 48.6% osteopenic. Patients with body mass index (BMI) under 25 are more osteoporotic in all of the measured region, than those with BMI over 25. We did not find significal difference in wrist function of those who had a redislocation of 5° to 20° after the reposition and those who had fracture healing in an anatomical reposition.

CONCLUSIONS: The examined patients with a distal radius fracture are a high risk population because of their high percentage of lower BMD. A wrist fracture resulted by minor trauma must be a warning sign: there is a higher probability of a following fracture due to osteoporosis. This might have a negative effect on life quality too. Therefore after a distal radius fracture there is a major importance of detecting the risk factors for osteoporosis, measuring the BMD in high-risk cases and starting the antiporotic therapy at the same time, to decrease the proximal femur and vertebral fractures rate.


K.Ch. Westphal

The „Press Fit Condylar“ (P.F.C., DePuy Johnson& Johnson) knee implant was invented in 1984 as a cruciate-retaining endoprosthesis. 4 years later the cruciate substition was added. In 1991 this as „P.F.C. modular“ well known system was upgraded for extended revision surgery with stems and augmentations called „Total Condylar 3“(T.C.3). Last evolution was in 1997 the P.F.C. Sigma with improvement of contact areas in patellofemoral and tibiofemoral joint and improved PE. Instrumentation was also modified. Femoral implant is made from CoCr-alloy, tibial implant from TiAlV, PE inlays and onlay patellae complete the implant. Cemented or cementless versions are available.

Good result in condylar knee implantation depend strictly on using the techniques of planning/ templating, correct aligned bone cuts and especially on adequate soft-tissue-balancing. Different situations of ligament and/or capsule laxity or contracture associated with various deformities need stepwise release-procedures. The modularity helps also to manage the great variety of arthritic knees.

The P.F.C. is one of the worldwide most used implants, a lot of studies showed good results. Using revision due to loosening as an endpoint a 10years survivalrate from 97% or 15 until 21 years rate from 95-91% was published.

In future new technologies like navigation or robotics may help optimizing implants position and fit but a experienced surgeon will be absolutely necessary managing the operation and esp. the soft-tissue-part. Evolution of implantdesign and materials may in long term show new possibilities.