We have compared the results and complications after closed and open reduction with internal fixation in young adults with displaced intracapsular fractures (Garden grades III and IV) of the neck of the femur. We also studied the risk factors which influenced nonunion and the development of avascular necrosis (AVN). A total of 102 patients aged between 15 and 50 years was randomised to receive either closed or open reduction. Both groups were compared for age, gender, time to surgery and posterior comminution as well as for union and complications. Using univariate and multivariate analysis the factors influencing nonunion and AVN were assessed.

Of the 102 patients, 92 were available for review. There was no significant difference between the groups in terms of union (p = 0.93) and AVN at two years (p = 0.85). Posterior comminution, poor reduction and improper placement of the screws were the major factors contributing to nonunion. The overall incidence of AVN was 16.3% (15 of 92 patients) and it was not influenced by these factors. A delay of more than 48 hours before surgery did not influence the rate of union or the development of AVN when compared with operation within 48 hours of injury.