Our aim in this paper was to investigate the guidelines and laws governing informed consent in the English-speaking world. We noted a recent divergence from medical paternalism within the United Kingdom, highlighted by the Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board ruling of 2015. We investigated the situation in the United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and the United States of America. We read the national guidance regarding obtaining consent for surgical intervention for each country. We used the references from this guidance to identify the laws that helped inform the guidance, and reviewed the court documents for each case.

There has been a trend towards a more patient-focused approach in consent in each country. Surgeons should be aware of the guidance and legal cases so that they can inform patients fully, and prevent legal problems if outdated practices are followed.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2018;100-B:687–92.

Whilst a few studies have associated various symptoms with the presence of a peroneus quartus muscle in the peroneal compartment of the leg, little is known of the clinical relevance of this muscle. We dissected 102 cadaver legs and reviewed the magnetic resonance images of 80 patients with symptoms from the ankle. The peroneus quartus, with a number of different attachments, was present in 6.6% of the legs. It most commonly arose from the peroneus brevis muscle and inserted into the retrotrochlear eminence of the calcaneum. Associated pathology included a longitudinal tear in the tendon of peroneus brevis, possible peroneal tendon subluxation or dislocation, and a prominent retrotrochlear eminence. On the MR scans its presence was associated with pain and weakness of the ankle. Orthopaedic surgeons and radiologists should be aware of the possible presence of the peroneus quartus muscle, not only because of possible associated pathology, but also for its potential use for surgical reconstruction

Instability of the knee is frequently found in association with congenital leg-length discrepancy. We have studied six such patients clinically, radiologically and arthroscopically. Clinical signs of knee instability and significant radiological changes were present in all, and at arthroscopy the anterior cruciate ligament was completely absent in four patients and functionless in the other two. This deficiency appears to be a congenital condition which may predispose to meniscus injury or retropatellar pain; it may also lead to subluxation or dislocation of the knee during leg-lengthening procedures

We describe a patient with a Mason type-III fracture of the head of the radius associated with traumatic dislocation of the elbow. The radial head was intact throughout its circumference despite being completely detached from the shaft and devoid of any soft-tissue attachments. Severe comminution of the radial neck prevented reconstruction by internal fixation and precluded prosthetic replacement of the head. The head was fixed to the shaft with a tricortical iliac-crest bone graft which replaced the neck. Two years later, the patient had a stable elbow with flexion from 10° to 130°. Radiologically, the head of the radius appeared to be viable and the bone graft had incorporated

Six different conditions of non-infective bone and joint pathology have been seen amongst 67 patients with diabetic neuropathy. The characteristics of each are described. Not all the conditions require treatment but they should be differentiated from osteomyelitis. Charcot osteoarthropathy is the most common condition seen but spontaneous fractures and dislocations generally present greater therapeutic problems. The aim of treatment should be to obtain a stable foot in which there is no undue pressure on the skin from a bony prominence

1. A review of intra-articular and peri-articular fractures of the phalanges has been carried out, and the late results of such injuries have been examined. 2. These fractures usually unite by bone. 3. The results of conservative treatment by immobilisation are satisfactory in the case of mallet fractures, hyperextension sprain fractures and collateral avulsion fractures of the proximal phalanges. 4. The less satisfactory results after collateral avulsion fractures of the interphalangeal joints and avulsion fractures complicating dislocations are discussed

Internal fixation with a trifin nail after displacement osteotomy of the femur permits reduction of external splintage to a degree that any patient can tolerate with ease; it also eliminates the problem of the stiff knee. The method has been used successfully for recent and old fractures of the femoral neck, for post-irradiation fractures, for failed nailing operations or arthroplastics, for osteoarthritis, for rheumatoid arthritis, for old congenital dislocations and subluxations, and to stabilise the hip after excision of the head and neck to create a pseudarthrosis

We have carried out a retrospective review of 11 Souter-Strathclyde primary total elbow arthroplasties in ten patients with osteoarthritis, over a period of nine years. The diagnosis was primary osteoarthritis in nine elbows and post-traumatic arthritis in two. The mean follow-up was 68 months (15 to 117). Although no patient was symptomatic, radiological review revealed evidence of loosening affecting three humeral and two ulnar components, one of which subsequently failed and was revised at 97 months. There were no dislocations, deep infections or mechanical failures. Complications included two superficial wound infections and two neurapraxias of the ulnar nerve which resolved. This study shows that the unlinked Souter-Strathclyde total elbow arthroplasty can be considered for patients with osteoarthritis and gives good symptomatic relief and improvement in function

We compared the results in two groups of patients with late reduction of posterior elbow dislocations, one of which had lengthening of the triceps (group A, n = 36) and the other did not (group B, n = 34). The elbows had all been dislocated for more than one month and less than three months. The patients in group B had better clinical results and significantly less postoperative flexion contracture (p < 0.05)

A study of the attachment of the joint capsule to the scapula, and of the shape of the humeral head, has been carried out in 52 fetal and embryonic shoulders. In 77% of cases the anterior capsule was attached to the labrum or close to it; in the remaining 23% it was inserted into the neck of the scapula, so creating a pouch. In all 52 specimens the humeral head was spherical. It was concluded that the pouched and redundant anterior capsule sometimes seen during surgery for recurrent dislocation of the shoulder, may not be traumatic in origin, but could be a developmental variant

Anterior subluxation of the cervical spine from flexion-rotational violence is often overlooked. Either radiography is omitted or the slight displacement visible on the films is not recognised. A method for recognising these injuries is suggested. Five cases are described showing that in these subluxations the soft-tissue damage is severe, that late increasing displacement can occur, with varying neurological sequelae, and that instability can persist indefinitely. Four of the patients required stabilisation by operation, in contrast with complete dislocations in which 80 to 90 per cent fuse spontaneously

We have reviewed 107 patients of 80 years or over who underwent primary total hip replacement. They had many more complications than younger patients. Thus, acute dislocation occurred in 15%, and became chronic in 9%; there were femoral shaft fractures in 4.6% and these, with shaft perforation gave universally poor results. Nevertheless, 75% of patients had a satisfactory outcome, with worthwhile relief of pain. It would seem sensible to warn elderly patients and their relatives of the increased risks in this age group

Aims

To determine the outcomes following revision surgery of metal-on-metal hip arthroplasties (MoMHA) performed for adverse reactions to metal debris (ARMD), and to identify factors predictive of re-revision.

We have reviewed 22 patients with scaphoid fractures treated by internal fixation with the Herbert screw. Three patients had trans-scaphoid perilunar dislocations, one had an oblique displaced fracture of the waist of the scaphoid and 18 had fractures with delayed or non-union. Corticocancellous bone grafts were added in nine of the cases of non-union. Results were excellent or good in 80% of cases after a mean duration of postoperative immobilisation of four weeks. The technical difficulties are analysed and the problems of applying the jig and of operative exposure are discussed

Aims

A clicky hip is a common referral for clinical and sonographic screening for developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH). There is controversy regarding whether it represents a true risk factor for pathological DDH. Therefore a 20-year prospective, longitudinal, observational study was undertaken to assess the relationship between the presence of a neonatal clicky hip and pathological DDH.

1. Eight patients are described in whom the patellae subluxated laterally on every extension of the knee. This is an unusual type of recurrent subluxation. It may recover completely, or remain symptom-free for many years, or increase in severity so that the patient seeks treatment for relief of pain and joint effusion, or progress to frank dislocation. 2. Each patient was examined and the probable causes were analysed. The bayonet deformity was present in twelve of the sixteen knees. A new observation is made on the relationship of tibial crest and tubercle in this condition

1. The condition of persistent foetal alignment is discussed both as an entity and in its relationship to the development of a normal hip, and also to the varying degrees of congenital dislocation of the hip. A possible connection with osteoarthritis is also mentioned. 2. The secondary deformities to which it may give rise are discussed, and the way in which both primary and secondary deformities may be corrected is described. 3. The importance of estimating rotation with the hip in full extension is emphasised. 4. The results in eight patients so treated are mentioned

We compared the success of the screening programmes for congenital dislocation of the hip in two hospitals in the same district, as applied to 68,861 live births over 11 years. Both used only clinical tests on new-born infants. Screening was less successful when the tests were done by junior paediatric physicians than by senior physiotherapists supervised by an orthopaedic surgeon. Clinical screening can be highly effective provided that all babies are screened at birth, and high-risk cases are followed up by a properly trained team with a well-designed protocol

We report two cases of surface deterioration of a zirconia ceramic femoral head associated with phase transformation after total hip arthroplasty. One head was retrieved at revision due to recurrent dislocation after six years and the other because of failure of the locking mechanism of the polyethylene liner after three years. The monoclinic content of the zirconia ceramics rose from 1% to about 30% on the surface of the heads. SEM revealed numerous craters indicating extraction of the zirconia ceramics at the surface. Surface roughness increased from an initial value of 0.006 3m up to 0.12 3m. This is the first report to show that phase transformation of zirconia ceramics causes deterioration of the surface roughness of the head in vivo after total hip arthroplasty