Pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS) is a rare proliferative process of the synovium which most commonly affects the knee and occurs in either a localised (LPVNS) or a diffuse form (DPVNS). The effect of different methods of surgical synovectomy and adjuvant radiotherapy on the rate of recurrence is unclear. We conducted a systematic review and identified 35 observational studies in English which reported the use of surgical synovectomy to treat PVNS of the knee. A meta-analysis included 630 patients, 137 (21.8%) of whom had a recurrence after synovectomy. For patients with DPVNS, low-quality evidence found that the rate of recurrence was reduced by both open synovectomy (odds ration (OR) = 0.47; 95% CI 0.25 to 0.90; p = 0.024) and combined open and arthroscopic synovectomy (OR = 0.19, 95% CI = 0.06 to 0.58; p = 0.003) compared with arthroscopic surgery. Very low-quality evidence found that the rate of recurrence of DPVNS was reduced by peri-operative radiotherapy (OR = 0.31, 95% CI 0.14 to 0.70; p = 0.01). Very low-quality evidence suggested that the rate of recurrence of LPVNS was not related to the surgical approach. . This meta-analysis suggests that open synovectomy or synovectomy combined with peri-operative radiotherapy for DPVNS is associated with a reduced rate of recurrence. Large long-term prospective multicentre observational studies, with a focus on both rate of recurrence and function, are required to confirm these findings. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2015;97-B:550–7

We examined the effects of previous resection of the radial head and synovectomy on the outcome of subsequent total elbow arthroplasty in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Fifteen elbows with a history of resection and synovectomy were compared with a control group of patients who had elbow arthroplasty with an implant of the same design. The mean age in both groups was 63 years. In the study group, resection of the radial head and synovectomy had been undertaken at a mean of 8.9 years before arthroplasty. The mean radiological follow-up for the 13 available patients in the study group was 5.89 years (0.3 to 11.0) and in the control group was 6.6 years (2.2 to 12.6). There were no revisions in either group. The mean Mayo elbow performance score improved from 29 to 96 in the study group, with similar improvement in the control group (28 to 87). The study group had excellent results in 13 elbows and good results in two. The control group had excellent results in seven and good results in six. Our experience indicates that previous resection of the radial head and synovectomy are not associated with an increased rate of revision following subsequent arthroplasty of the elbow. However, there was a higher rate of complication in the study group compared with the control group

A total of 187 patients with primary osteoarthritis (OA) of the knee undergoing total knee replacement (TKR) were randomly divided into two groups, one of which underwent synovectomy. The patients and assessors were blinded to the randomisation both before and after surgery. The duration of surgery, hospitalisation period, concealed bleeding, drainage volume, blood transfusion rate and range of movement of the knee at three days after the operation were analysed. Patients were followed up at four weeks and 12 months after their operation, and a visual analogue score (VAS) for pain, Knee Society score (KSS) and a patellar ballottement test were compared between the groups. The mean amount of concealed bleeding was higher in the synovectomy group compared with the control group (1.24 l (0.08 to 3.28) vs 1.03 l (0.16 to 2.94); p = 0.042), as was the mean drainage volume (0.90 l (0.35 to 1.81) vs 0.81 (0.25 to 1.65); p = 0.030). The mean operating time was also higher in the synovectomy group compared with the controls (1.50 hours (1.34 to 1.75) vs 1.41 hours (1.21 to 1.79); p = 0.006). There were no significant differences in blood transfusion rate (p = 0.882), hospital stay (p = 0.805) or range of movement of the knee (p = 0.413) between the two groups. At four weeks and 12 months post-operatively there were no statistically significant differences in any of the measured parameters. We concluded that synovectomy confers no clinical advantages in TKR for primary OA while subjecting patients to higher levels of bleeding and longer operating times. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2013;95-B:1197–200

We compared inflammation in the knee after total knee replacement (TKR) for primary osteoarthritis between two groups of patients undergoing joint replacement with and without synovectomy. A total of 67 patients who underwent unilateral TKR were randomly divided into group I, TKR without synovectomy, and group II, TKR with synovectomy. Clinical outcomes, serial serum inflammatory markers (including interleukin-6 (IL-6), CRP and ESR) and the difference in temperature of the skin of the knee, compared with the contralateral side, were sequentially evaluated until 26 weeks after surgery. Pre-operatively, there were no statistically different clinical parameters between groups I and II. At the 26-week follow-up, both groups had a similarly significantly improved American Knee Society clinical score (p < 0.001) and functional score (p < 0.001) with no differences between the groups. Similar changes in serial inflammatory markers were found in both groups, including mean peak levels of IL-6 (189 pg/ml (. sd. 53.4) versus 201 pg/ml (. sd. 49.4) for groups I and II, respectively) and CRP (91 mg/L (. sd. 24.1) versus 88 mg/L (. sd. 23.4), respectively) on the first post-operative day, returning to pre-operative values at two and six weeks, respectively. The mean peak level of ESR for the respective two groups was 46 mm/hr versus 48 mm/hr at two weeks, which had still not returned to its pre-operative mean value at 26 weeks. The elevation in the skin temperature appeared to mirror the peak elevation of the ESR, with a range of 2.5° C to 4.5° C with some reduction at 26 weeks but still exceeding the pre-operative value. We concluded that synovectomy at the time of TKR does not provide any benefit to the clinical outcome or shorten the duration of the inflammatory response after surgery

We describe a case of highly refractory synovial chondromatosis, which recurred despite four arthroscopic synovectomies, a chemical synovectomy, two open synovectomies and an arthrodesis. A review of the literature revealed one similar case. Both presented with marked joint stiffness suggesting a poor prognosis. Although arthrodesis may relieve short-term symptoms it does not prevent further recurrence of disease

1. Synovectomy was carried out in thirty-four knees, of which thirty-one were certainly or probably afflicted by rheumatoid arthritis. 2. Synovectomy was considered only when adequate medical and physical treatment had failed to afford relief. Its purpose is to preserve useful function, and one of the principal factors influencing the decision to operate was the retention of a normal or good radiographic joint space in a persistently painful, warm and swollen knee. 3. Radiographic appearances constituted a useful but not infallible guide to the true state of the articular surfaces. 4. The method of operation, findings and subsequent care are described. 5. Up to two years after operation it appeared that improvement might be related to the state of the articular surfaces, but after two years this relationship was not evident and an attempt to explain this difference has been made. 6. It seems clear that the longer-term results are determined mainly by the course taken by the rheumatoid process. An unfavourable course was associated with considerably less satisfactory results than was a favourable course. 7. It is concluded that in rheumatoid arthritis which has resisted rest and medical treatment synovectomy of the knee is most likely to be successful when the radiographic joint space is good or normal, and when the rheumatoid process follows a favourable course. To undertake the operation at an early stage in the disease is to leave in doubt the outcome, as this is dependent upon the as yet undeclared general course of the disease. Even so, early synovectomy is worth considering when nothing else has given relief. The fact that arthrodesis has only once been necessary after synovectomy appears to justify the policy of salvage described

The short-term assessment of 14 arthroscopic synovectomies of the elbow in 11 patients with rheumatoid arthritis showed that 93% achieved a short-term rating of excellent or good on the Mayo Elbow Performance Score. At the most recent assessment at an average of 42 months, however, only 57% maintained excellent or good results; four had required total elbow replacement. Although rehabilitation is facilitated by an arthroscopic procedure the results deteriorate more rapidly than after open synovectomy. This may be due to the limitations of the arthroscopic technique and is consistent with experience of the similar procedure in the knee. Recognition of the short-term gain and the potential for serious nerve injury should be considered when offering arthroscopic synovectomy

1. Opinion is divided as to the value of synovectomy of the knee in juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. 2. Between 1964 and 1970 thirty synovectomies of the knee were performed in twenty-seven children, who have now been kept under review for one to eight years. Three have required a second operation. 3. The operative findings at various stages are presented and discussed, with special reference to the effect on growth of the limb. 4. Synovectomy is a useful procedure which should be reserved for cases where effusion persists despite nine months of conservative treatment and performed before signs of bone erosion appear

1. The follow-up reports of ninety-one joints affected by rheumatoid arthritis and treated by synovectomy showed that seventy-three joints remained free of pain. Forty-nine out of ninety-one joints retained useful function after a period averaging three and a half years. 2. The average duration of the disease before admission was eight and a half years. 3. The joints causing most distress were selected for operation. Better results might have been obtained if these patients had received constitutional treatment, splintage and synovectomy earlier. Many of these patients had advanced disease which was continuing to advance at the time of their admission, in spite of previous treatment. Many accepted a trial of treatment in a long stay hospital as a last hope. 4. The return of forty-eight out of sixty-two patients to unassisted or nearly unassisted activity and the maintenance of this state in thirty-nine out of fifty-four shows that the success of the pilot scheme conducted in cooperation with Dr W. S. Tegner and Dr R. M. Mason of the London Hospital has been confirmed by further experience

Our experience of five children with chronic thorn synovitis indicates that removal of free thorn fragments and all the macroscopically abnormal synovium is required in order to achieve a complete cure. Four children required total synovectomy for diffuse proliferative synovitis and one needed partial synovectomy of the area immediately around the embedded thorn. Joint washouts and partial synovectomy were unsuccessful in children with diffuse synovitis. Careful review is required following removal of a thorn as fragments may be retained within the joint

The results of thirty synovectomies of the elbow for rheumatoid arthritis are reported. Satisfactory relief of pain was obtained in twenty-seven elbows and the range of movement was improved in twenty-one. The classical operation includes excision of the radial head but in this series approximately half the radial heads were conserved with comparable results. The results of synovectomy do not significantly deteriorate with time up to ten years and the operation can be done with good results, especially in respect of relief of pain, even in elbows with relatively advanced rheumatoid disease. Radiographic assessment is not of much help in evaluating the results of the operation, but is essential in selection of elbows for synovectomy

We analysed the results of arthroscopic synovectomy of the wrist in 18 patients (19 wrists) with rheumatoid arthritis who had not responded to conservative treatment. The patients’ symptoms were assessed using visual analogue scales for pain and satisfaction. Standard posteroanterior radiographs which were taken pre-operatively and at final follow-up were analysed using a modified Larsen scoring system (normal, 0; total destruction, 40). The mean follow-up period was 29.2 months (24 to 45). The mean pre-operative pain score was 8.58 which decreased to 3.58 one year after surgery and increased again to 4.42 at final follow-up. This suggested a gradual increase in pain with time. The mean satisfaction score was 6.26. The mean modified Larsen’s score was 9.8 pre-operatively and 13.9 at final follow-up, which demonstrated the slow progression of degenerative changes. Arthroscopic synovectomy for rheumatoid arthritis of the wrist allows effective pain relief and high patient satisfaction, although any prolonged benefits will require long-term follow-up

1. One hundred and twenty-three patients with rheumatoid arthritis who had synovectomy and excision of the head of the radius performed on 154 elbows have been reviewed one to six years after operation. 2. The severity of the disease process at the time of operation was graded radiologically and an attempt made to relate this to the results. 3. Overall, the clinical results were most satisfactory; more than 70 per cent of the patients were pleased with the outcome. When radiographic deterioration of the joint was taken into account, however, only 54 per cent achieved a "satisfactory" result. 4. Clearance of the synovium through combined medial and lateral incisions gave better results than a lateral approach alone. 5. When the disease was far advanced by the time of operation any good results were likely to be short-lived. 6. The indications for synovectomy of the rheumatoid elbow are discussed in the light of these findings

Little is known of the effects of synovectomy on articular cartilage. In order to investigate this matter, anterior synovectomy of the knee was performed in thirty-five normal adult rabbits and in thirty-five which were given 25 milligrams of hydrocortisone intramuscularly each week afterwards. The animals were killed at intervals from four to 110 days after synovectomy. Histological examination of the regenerating synovium in both groups showed complete structural and functional regeneration by eighty days in the first group and a delay in regeneration in the steroid group. . 35. Sulphur autoradiographs of the articular cartilage of femoral and tibial condyles revealed surface fibrillation and chondrocyte death in 23 per cent of normal knees after eighty days but only 1·8 per cent of knees of animals receiving hydrocortisone. Thus synovectomy in a healthy joint may have an unfavourable effect on the physiology of cartilage by alteration of synovial composition and hyaluronate content in normal joints. Systemically-administered hydrocortisone may reduce this harmful effect in normal cartilage

We reviewed 61 elbow synovectomies in 50 patients with rheumatoid arthritis, with follow-up varying from 4 to 10 years (mean 6.5 years). The results were graded as satisfactory in 70%, with no significant difference in the results between joints which were radiologically good before operation and those which had been destroyed. Longer term results were analysed of 27 elbow synovectomies in 22 patients followed up for over six years. The results were satisfactory in 67% of the patients in both 1981 and in 1987, with no deterioration over this period

We have compared the concentrations of stromal-cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1), matrix metalloproteinase-1 (MMP-1), MMP-9 and MMP-13 in serum before and after synovectomy or total knee replacement (TKR). We confirmed the presence of SDF-1 and its receptor CXCR4 in the synovium and articular cartilage by immunohistochemistry. We established chondrocytes by using mutant CXCR4 to block the release of MMPs. The level of SDF-1 was decreased 5.1- and 6.7-fold in the serum of patients with OA and RA respectively, after synovectomy compared with that before surgery. MMP-9 and MMP-13 were decreased in patients with OA and RA after synovectomy. We detected SDF-1 in the synovium and the bone marrow but not in cartilage. CXCR4 was detected in articular cartilage. SDF-1 increased the release of MMP-9 and MMP-13 from chondrocytes in a dose-dependent manner. The mutant CXCR4 blocked the release of MMP-9 and MMP-13 from chondrocytes by retrovirus vector. Synovectomy is effective in patients with OA or RA because SDF-1, which can regulate the release of MMP-9 and MMP-13 from articular chondrocytes for breakdown of cartilage, is removed by the operation

Subtotal synovectomy was performed in the knee joints of New Zealand white rabbits. The changes noted in the articular cartilage as manifest by decreased metachromatic staining of the matrix were considered to indicate matrix degradation caused by the altered joint environment. The documentation of the enzyme changes suggests that the histological alteration in the articular cartilage noted after synovectomy may be mediated through the activation of endogenous chondrocyte lysozomal enzymes, particularly cathepsin and acid hydrolases

1. . 133. Xe clearance rates as a measure of blood flow were determined in the knees oftwo groups of patients. 2. In the first group eight patients with rheumatoid arthritis were studied before, three months after and one year after synovectomy. Blood flow values were significantly lower three months after operation but the values recorded one year after operation did not differ significantly from those before operation. 3. In the second group (twenty-one patients with rheumatoid arthritis) blood flow values were determined two to three years after synovectomy. The values obtained differed from those obtained in normal joints and fell within the range of values obtained in forty-three patients with rheumatoid arthritis who did not have synovectomy

1. Synovectomy of the elbow affected by rheumatoid arthritis is a worthwhile procedure even in the presence of advanced radiological changes. 2. Relief of pain is good (93 per cent) and movement is retained (87 per cent). 3. Although the follow-up in this series was short, averaging nineteen months, the results seem to be maintained. 4. Good access to the joint may be had through medial and lateral incisions, and division of the olecranon is unnecessary. A lateral incision alone is not recommended. 5. The ulnar nerve should be preserved during dissection. Anterior transposition is needed only if there are neurological symptoms before operation

1. The results of synovectomy of the knee in eighty-five patients with rheumatoid arthritis are presented. 2. When reviewed between five and nine years after operation 55 per cent of 122 knees still had improvement in pain. 3. Only 31 per cent of knees lost movement. 4. Recurrence of symptoms in nearly all cases was related to the recurrence of active rheumatoid synovitis. 5. Recurrence of symptoms was a little less likely when the generalised disease improved, when the Rose-Waaler test was negative, when only one knee was involved and when the operation had been carried out within three years of the onset of disease in that knee