The outcome of idiopathic chondrolysis in South Africa has been reported as a progressive downhill course resulting in a painful, stiff hip (Jones 1971, Sparks&Dall 1982). The cause of the disease remains unknown. Theories suggested are mechanical (decreased movement with loss of synovial nutrition; increased joint pressure) and an auto-immune response in genetically predisposed individuals. Our experience with continuous passive motion (CPM) and anti-inflammatory treatment has been disappointing. In order to improve our understanding of the disease and our results, we prospectively studied 5 consecutive patients. All the patients had a subtotal capsulectomy (Roy&Crawford 1988) to relieve intra-articular pressure and correction of the flexion and abduction deformities. Post-operative treatment was with anti-inflammatories and CPMPurpose
Method
Physeal bar resection for partial growth plate arrest was first described by Langenskjold in 1967. The initial enthusiasm by Peterson (1989) who found that 83% of patients resumed physeal growth was tempered by Birch (1992) who only had 33% success. Poor results were due to failure to resume growth or premature growth arrest. We retrospectively reviewed 21 physeal bar resections performed in 19 children from 1987 to 2003. The average age at surgery was 8.2 years (range 3–12 years). The aetiology of the physeal arrest was : growth plate fracture (8), meningococcal septicaemia (5), osteitis (3; 2 neonatal), dysplasia (3), gunshot (1) and idiopathic (1). The commonest site was the distal femur (12; 5 due to growth plate fracture), followed by the proximal tibia (5; 3 due to meningococcal septicaemia), and the distal tibia (4; 2 due to growth plate fractures). Assessment of the size and location of the bar was with biplanar tomography in 7, MRI in 5 and both in 7. We found equal accuracy with both modalities, but currently prefer MRI. The bar was plotted on an anterior-posterior and lateral map of the growth plate. The average size of the bar was 25% (range 15 to 50%) of the area of the growth plate. Only 3 bars were larger than 30%. Fifteen of the bars were peripheral, 5 linear and 1 central. Results were classified poor if there was no resumption of growth or if premature growth plate arrest occurred, good if there was resumption of growth which continued to maturity or to follow-up, and excellent if the growth exceeded the expected growth. There were 5 (24%) poor results; all failed to resume growth. Three bars exceeded 30% and 2 were due to meningococcal septicaemia. The remaining 16 bars were followed up for a range of 2 to 12 years; 10 to maturity. Four (19%) had an excellent and 12 (57%) had a good result. The authors conclude that physeal bar resection is a worthwhile procedure if the size of the bar is equal to or less than 30% of the area of the growth plate. In growth arrest due to meningococcal septicaemia we only had a 60% success rate.
Tarsal coalition has been well recognized as the commonest cause of peroneal spastic flat feet in children and adolescents (Mosier and Asher 1984). Other rare causes are tuberculosis and rheumatoid arthritis. If no etiology can be found the term idiopathic peroneal spastic flat foot has been coined by Schoenecker (2000). We prospectively assessed all children and adolescents with peroneal spastic flat feet seen at our clinic in the period 2002 to 2004. Twelve patients (17 feet) were assessed. The average age was 11,9 years (range10 to15years). Seventy five percent of the patients were above the 95th percentile weight for age. Screening for tuberculosis (ESR, Mantoux and chest radiograph) was negative in all patients. Rheumatoid factor was positive in one patient with juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA). Radiology was standardized. Plain radiographs were standing lateral and 45 degree oblique views. CT and MRI:
axial: parallel to plantar surface; coronal oblique: gantry perpendicular to the plane of the subtalar joint. This latter view best illustrates a talocalcaneal coalition (Newman 2000). Two patients (four feet) had a calcaneonavicular coalition on the 45 degree oblique plane radiographs. This was also shown on the axial CT and MRI views. No talocalcaneal coalition was visualized on the coronal oblique CT and MRI views. In order to find a diagnosis and to confirm the accuracy of the MRI and CT, the middle facet of the talocalcaneal joint was explored in eight feet and a synovial biopsy done. No talocalcaneal coalition was found. JIA was histologically confirmed in one patient. The authors concluded that the idiopathic type is by far the commonest peroneal spastic flat foot seen in our clinic. The 45 degree oblique plain radiograph is as accurate as axial CT and MRI to diagnose calcaneonavicular coalition. The coronal oblique CT and MRI views are equally accurate to exclude a talocalcaneal coalition.
