Multiligament knee injuries (MLKI) are rare and life-altering injuries that remain difficult to treat clinically due to a paucity of evidence guiding surgical management and timing. The purpose of this study was to compare injury specific functional outcomes following early versus delayed surgical reconstruction in MLKI patients to help inform timing decisions in clinical practice.

A retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data from patients with MLKIs at a single academic level 1-trauma center was conducted. Patients were eligible for inclusion if they had an MLKI, underwent reconstructive surgery either prior to 6wks from injury or between 12weeks and 2 years from injury, and had at least 12months of post-surgical follow-up. Patients with a vascular injury, open injuries or associated fractures were excluded. Study participants were stratified into early (<6wks from injury) and delayed surgical intervention (>12 weeks – 2 years from injury). The primary outcome was patient reported, injury specific, quality of life in the form of the Multiligament Quality of Life questionnaire (MLQOL) and its four domains (Physical Impairment, Emotional Impairment, Activity Limitations and Societal Involvement). We secondarily analyzed differences in the need for manipulation under anesthesia, and reoperation rates, as well as radiographic Kellgren Lawrence (KL) arthritis grades, knee laxity grading and range of motion at the most recent follow-up.

A total of 131 patients met our inclusion criteria, all having had surgery between 2006 and 2019. There were 75 patients in the early group and 56 in the delayed group. The mean time to surgery was 17.6 ± 8.0 days in the early group versus 279 ± 146.5 days in the delayed. Mean postoperative follow-up was 58 months. There were no significant differences between early and delayed groups with respect to age (34 vs. 32.8 years), sex (77% vs 63% male), BMI (28.3 vs 29.7 kg/m²), or injury mechanism (p>0.05). The early surgery group was found to include more patients with lateral sided injuries (n=49 [65%] vs. n=23 [41%]; p=0.012), a higher severity of Schenck Classification (p=0.024) as well as nerve injuries at initial presentation (n=35 [49%] vs n=8 [18%]; p<0.001). Multivariable linear regression analyses of the four domains of the MLQOL did not demonstrate an independent association with early versus delayed surgery status (p>0.05), when controlling for age, sex, Schenck classification, medial versus lateral injury, and nerve injury status. In terms of our secondary outcomes, we found that the early group underwent significantly more manipulations under anesthesia compare with the delayed group (n=24, [32%] vs n=8 [14%], p=0.024). We did not identify a significant difference in physical examination laxity grades, range of motion, KL grade or reoperation rates between groups (p>0.05).

We found no difference in patient reported outcomes between those who underwent early versus delayed surgery following MLKI reconstruction. In our secondary outcomes, we found significantly more patients in the early surgery group required a manipulation under anesthesia following surgery, which may indicate a propensity for arthrofibrosis after early MLKI reconstruction.

Quadriceps tendon ruptures are a rare but debilitating injury resulting in loss of knee extension necessitating surgical intervention. Currently, multiple different surgical techniques and rehabilitation programs are utilized by surgeons. Researchers have been unable to determine the best surgical technique with respect to function and complication rate; certain techniques are more cost-effective than others. Early vs. late motion rehabilitation programs are utilized; recent evidence suggests that less aggressive initial rehabilitation may lead to decreased extensor lag and fewer additional surgeries. The goal of our study is to determine the treatment practices of orthopaedic surgeons across Canada.

Our study was completed anonymously via SurveyMonkey.com (Palo Alto, California). Based on current literature, a 26-question survey was distributed. E-mail invitations were be sent to all members of the Canadian Orthopaedic Association. Participation is voluntary.

Currently, 104 surveys have been completed. 78% of respondents utilize transosseous drill holes, 13% utilize suture anchors and 9% utilize a combined surgical technique. The majority of surgeons begin range of motion (ROM) at 2 weeks (42%) or 6 weeks (24%); ROM is then commonly progressed in a step-wise fashion at 2-week intervals (58%). Approximately half of respondents have performed revision surgery for quadriceps re-rupture.

Surgical management of quadriceps tendon ruptures is fairly consistent amongst Canadian orthopaedic surgeons. However, wide variation exists regarding rehabilitation, favoring early initiation and progression of ROM despite some evidence recommending a longer period of immobilization.