Supercritical fluid (SCF) sterilization produces clean and osteoconductive allograft bone capable of healing a critical-sised bony defect. SCF treated graft induces an increased anabolic response and decreased catabolic reponse compared to gamma irradiated graft. Clinically, allogeneic bone graft is used extensively because it avoids the donor site morbidity associated with autograft. However, there are concerns over the optimal sterilization method to eliminate immunological risks whilst maintaining the biological efficacy of the graft. This study compared the effect of Supercritical fluid (SCF) sterilization and gamma irradiation on the osteoconductivity of allograft bone in a bilateral critical-sised defect rabbit model.Summary Statement
Introduction
Demineralised bone matrix augmented tendon-bone fixations in the animal model show less scar tissue and an enthesis morphology closer to the physiologic one which may lead to a more resistant repair construct. Rotator cuff repair is one of the most common operative procedures in the shoulder. Yet despite its prevalence recurrent tear rates of up to 94% have been reported in the literature. High failure rates have been associated with tendon detachment from bone at the tendon – bone interface. Exogenous agents as biological strategies to augment tendon – bone healing in the shoulder represent a new area of focus to improve patient outcomes. Demineralised bone matrix (DBM) contains matrix bound proteins, exposed through acid demineralization step of DBM manufacture, and has long been recognised for its osteoinductive and osteoconductive properties. We hypothesised that DBM administered to the bone bed prior to the reattachment of the tendon, will upregulate healing and result in enhanced tissue morphology that more closely resembles that of a normal enthesis. An established ovine transosseous equivalent rotator cuff model was used.Summary Statement
Introduction
Gamma Irradiation is often considered the gold standard for sterilizing bone allograft. However, a dose dependant decrease in the static mechanical properties of gamma irradiated bone has been well established. Supercritical Fluid Sterilization (SCF) using carbon dioxide represents a potential alternate method to sterilize allografts. This study aimed to evaluate the effect of SCF on the static and dynamic (fatigue) properties of cortical bone in 3-point bending. Eighty paired 18-month old rabbit humeri were randomized to 4 treatments: Gamma Irradiation at 10 kGy or 25 kGy, SCF Control and SCF with Peracetic Acid (Introduction
Methods
Cortical bone is a complex composite material composed of an inorganic mineral phase and organic matrix of type I collagen and various non-collagenous proteins. The hierarchical organisation of bone results in a transversely isotropic material with the mechanical properties in the long-axis (z) being superior to the radial and circumferential axes which are equivalent. This directional dependence of bone has been well reported, whilst the mechanisms/anisotropy are more difficult to study. This study examined the anistropic nature of cortical bone and the influence of different sterilisation procedures. Ninety cortical bone cubes were prepared using established techniques (Walsh and Guzelsu) and randomly allocated to three treatments; control, 15 KGy, Super Critical Fluid (SCF) (n=30 per group). The ultrasonic moduli was examined using longitudinal sound waves at 5 MHz using a pulse receive technique. Unconfined compression was performed non-destructively in longitudinal (z), circumferential (ï±) and radial orientations (r). Samples were tested to failure in the z axis. A two-way analysis of variance (treatment and time) followed by a Games Howell post hoc test and covariate analysis was performed using SPSS for Windows. Data from this study revealed some interesting and intriguing results with respect to the effects of gamma irradiation and dense gas technology on the properties of cortical bone and load transmission. A statistical decrease in the compressive stiffness and strength was noted with 15 KGy of whilst SCF treatment did not alter the properties in the r or ï orientations. Similar results were found with respect to the ultrasonic moduli (data not shown). The pilot data confirmed the adverse effects of bone in compression following gamma irradiation as we found in our recently presented ORS work. However, the study in compression demonstrated that the directional dependence that makes cortical bone a transversely isotropic material is removed following gamma irradiation with SCF did not appear to have this effect. The effects of gamma irradiation on the mechanical performance of allografts in the long bone axis may play a role in their in vivo performance. The removal of the anisotropy following gamma irradiation provides insight into the relationship(s) between the mineral and organic constituents, which requires further study.
This study aimed to compare the early clinical results and stem subsidence between three consecutive series of revision hip replacement cases with femoral impaction bone grafting to evaluate the effects of developments in technique. In the original series 1 (n=23), bone graft was irradiated at 25kG. I n series 2 (n=12) non-irradiated double washed graft and long stems were used as required. In series 3 (n=21) modular tamps were used. Sensitive radiographic analysis techniques, EBRA and RSA, were used to measure stem subsidence. Major stem re-revision was required in five hips in series one, one hip in series two and no hips in series three. Two periprosthetic fractures occurred in series one. There was a statistically significant reduction in stem subsidence at the cement-bone interface at 12 months between series one and series two and three (p<0.05). In series three there was negligible stem subsidence at the cement-bone interface. Technique developments in femoral impaction grafting, including the use of modular tamps designed to simply the procedure, yields excellent early clinical and radiographic results. Using RSA, we have shown that the fixation of the stems in bone is comparable to that achieved in primary hip replacement.
