Purpose of study: To investigate and compare the characteristics of the reconstructed articular surface microscopically and histologically after a time period of 6 weeks following the treatment of a focal defect of the right femoral head with subchondral drilling and autologous osteochondral transplantation in rabbits
Material and method: A 2,5 mm diameter and 3 mm depth iatrogenic osteochondral defect in the anterolateral weight bearing area of the right femoral head was created in 12 rabbits. In a group of 6 rabbits the lesion was treated with autologous osteochondral transplantation. The donor site for the transplant was the lateral condyle of the ipsilateral knee joint. The other group of 6 rabbits was treated with subchondral drilling. Both groups were sacrificed after a time period of 6 weeks and specimens were evaluated histologically under the classification system of the ICRS. For statistical analysis we used the Mann – Wittney test
Results: According to the ICRS score statistical significance was found for all variables between the 2 groups (subchondral drilling 6 weeks vs autologous osteochondral transplantation 6 weeks).: articular surface (p=0,049), matrix (p=0,003), cell distribution (p<
0,0005), subchondral bone (p=0,010), cartilage mineralization (p=0,0) except cell population viability.
Discussion: In comparison to subchondral drilling, autologous osteochondral transplantation provided better results concerning the smoothness and continuity of the articular surface, the consistency of the matrix with dominance of the hyaline and mixed hyaline – fibrocartilage type of tissue, the normality of subchondral bone and the columna r distribution of cells. The viability of the cell populations was the same for both methods. The incorporation of the osseous part of the graft was successful in all cases and the surgical procedure did not produce any necrosis of the femoral head.
Conclusion: In cases of focal osteochondral defect of the femoral head in rabbits, reconstruction of the articular surface through autologous osteochondral graft transplantation gives superior macroscopical and histological results in comparison to subchondral drilling