The goal of the study was to describe the features of the aseptic loosening of the cup in CoC THR and to determine factors that affect the time to revision.

It is a retrospective study including all patients who had a revision of CoC THR for aseptic failure fixation of the cup, between 2007 and 2017. 55 patients (27 women, 28 men) (56 hips) were included in the study. Eight hips (13 %) had also a stem exchange. At the primary T HR, the mean age of the patients was 47.9 years (17–72), 28 press fit cups had screws, the mean diameter of the cup was 51.2 mm (46–62) and the mean inclination was 52° (37–67). Clinical and radiological data were retrospectively recorded by an observer different to the initial operators.

The mean age of the patients at the revision was 55.4 years (26–84). The mean time to revision was 90.1 months (14–240), and was significantly greater in patients aged less than 52 years, in cups without screws and with a 28mm head. The trend curve of the time to cup revision showed a bimodal distribution at three and ten years. 20 cups had migrated (33%). Bone loss was rated type 1 in 41 hips (73.0%), type 2 in 12 hips and type 3 in three hips). The mean diameter of the new cup was 52.3 mm (46–64). It was inferior to that of the initial cup in 26 hips (46.4%). 31 cups were impacted (55.5%) and 25 needed to be cemented (45.5%). No macroscopic wear was detected on the ceramic implant.

Aseptic loosening of the cup in CoC THA does not appear to increase over time, supporting the fact that the failure is unrelated to wear and is not due to a biological mechanism. The occurrence of two peaks of frequency over time may suggest that different mechanisms occur.

Recent studies about hip stability after total hip arthroplasties (THA) concerned differences regarding bearings: ceramic on ceramic (CoC) presenting less dislocations on the long term compared to metal or ceramic on polyethylene. The hypothesis is a difference in the healing process of periarticular tissues, with a stronger fibrous tissue for the first one, and more foreign body reaction, joint effusion with the others.

NMR Imaging of the pelvis showing both hips using novel MR MAVRIC program for metal artefacts suppression, were performed in 10 patients, 15 THA and 2 non-pathological contralateral hips. Eight hips had CoC bearings, 3 of which were impacted cementless bulky ceramic implant, and 5 had a metal back. 7 hips had CoP bearings, 4 of which were cemented.

Native capsules showed a mean thickness of 6.6mm. For CoC bearings, capsule thickness ranged from 7mm to 9.6 mm with a mean thickness of 8mm. For CoP bearings, capsule thickness ranged from 3mm to 8.4mm, with a mean thickness of 6.1mm. Neocapsule appeared clearly in all COC bearings observed, while for CoP, sometimes it was less dense with fatty aspect, 3 hips out of 7 having a very thin capsule under 4mm.

It is possible to observe and quantify new capsule after THR and measure differences although not significant regarding bearings on limited number of samples. More patients might be included, but the tendencies observed here might explain better long term stability in vivo observed with Coc.