A prospective case control study analysed clinical and radiographic results in patients operated on with the periosteum autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) due to cartilage lesions on the femoral condyles over 10 years ago.

31 out of the 45 patients (3 failures, 9 non-responders, 2 others) were available for a continuous clinical (Lyshom/Tegner, IKDC, KOOS) and radiographic (Kellgren-Lawrence) follow-up at 0, 2, 5, and 10 years after the ACI procedure. The patients were sub-grouped into focal cartilage lesions (FL) – 10, osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) – 12, and cartilage lesions with simultaneous ACL reconstruction (ACL) – 9 subgroups.

Lysholm, Tegner, and IKCD subjective scores revealed stable results over the period from 2 to 10 years with a significant improvement toward the pre-operative levels, but the patients had not reached their pre-injury Tegner levels. KOOS profile at 10 years was: Pain 78.6, Symptoms 78.1, Activities of daily living 82.5, Sports 56.9, and Quality of life 55.1. A 10-year IKDC knee examination classified operated knees as: 14 normal, 10 nearly normal, 5 abnormal and 2 severely abnormal. Kellgren-Lawrence scores of 2 and above were found in 10 patients (FL 5, OCD 0, and ACL 5). Seven patients in the group required an arthroscopic re-intervention (3 ACI related, 4 ACI unrelated).

ACI provided safe and stable performance of operated knees over ten years. High incidence of knee osteoarthritis in FL and ACL subgroups, and low incidence in OCD patients indicate that best long performance is expected in localised low-impact cartilage lesions of young patients.