The aim of this study was to determine whether patients with
metal-on-metal (MoM) arthroplasties of the hip have an increased
risk of cardiac failure compared with those with alternative types
of arthroplasties (non-MoM). A linkage study between the National Joint Registry, Hospital
Episodes Statistics and records of the Office for National Statistics
on deaths was undertaken. Patients who underwent elective total
hip arthroplasty between January 2003 and December 2014 with no
past history of cardiac failure were included and stratified as
having either a MoM (n = 53 529) or a non-MoM (n = 482 247) arthroplasty.
The primary outcome measure was the time to an admission to hospital
for cardiac failure or death. Analysis was carried out using data
from all patients and from those matched by propensity score.Aims
Patients and Methods
Circulating cobalt and chromium from metal-on-metal implants cause rare but fatal autopsy-diagnosed cardiotoxicity. Concern exists that milder cardiotoxicity may be common and under-recognized. Unacceptably high failure rates of metal-on-metal hip implants have prompted regulatory authorities to issue worldwide safety alerts. Despite this, approximately 1 million patients continue to live with metal-on-metal implants, putting them at risk of systemic toxicity. Although blood cobalt and chromium levels are easily measured and track local toxicity, no non-invasive tests for organ deposition exist. We recently demonstrated the utilisation of a T2* protocol (cardiovascular MRI) to detect cobalt and chromium deposition within the liver of a patient with elevated blood cobalt levels (confirmed by liver biopsy tissue analysis and X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy). We sought to detect and constrain the correlation between blood metal ions and a comprehensive panel of established markers of early cardiotoxicity. In addition we applied T2* protocols with the aim of detecting cardiac metal deposition. 90 patients were recruited through RNOH clinics into this prospective single centre blinded study. Patients were divided into 3 age and gender-matched groups according to type of implant and blood metal ion levels as follows: [Group A] Non-metal bearing hip implants; [Group B] Metal-on-metal implants, low blood metal ion levels (<7ppb); and [Group C] Metal-on-metal implants, high blood levels (>7ppb). All underwent detailed cardiovascular phenotyping using cardiac MRI (with T2*, T1 and ECV mapping, in addition to LV size and ejection fraction), advanced echocardiography (LV size and ejection fraction), and cardiac blood biomarker (Troponin and BNP) sampling in the same sitting at the Heart Hospital London. Primary outcomes were pre-specified. See study flow diagram – figure 1. (The study was registered with Blood cobalt levels were significantly different between groups (0.17ppb (range 0·10–0·47, SD 0·08) vs. 2·47 (0·72–6·9, SD 1·81) vs. 30·0 (7·54–118.0, SD 29·1) respectively for groups A, B and C). No significant between-group differences were found for LV size, ejection fraction (CMR or echocardiography), LA size, T1, T2*, ECV, BNP or troponin, with all results within normal ranges. There was no relationship between blood cobalt levels and either left ventricular ejection fraction or T2* (r=-0·022 and r=-0·108 respectively). Although small, the study was sufficiently powered to detect, as a minimum, a difference in ejection fraction of 4.8% (Cohen's d effect size 0·8). Using best available technologies, exposure of patients with metal-on-metal hip implants to high (but not extreme) blood cobalt and chromium levels has no detectable effect on the heart. We believe these findings will offer reassurance to one million patients worldwide living with a metal-on-metal hip implant and will support clinicians caring for such patients. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly by clicking on ‘Info & Metrics’ above to access author contact details.
