Our previous research has demonstrated that minor adjustments to in vitro cellular aggregation parameters, i.e. alterations to aggregate size, can influence temporal and spatial mineral depositions within maturing bone cell nodules. What remains unclear, however, is how aggregate size might affect mineralisation within said nodules over long-term in vivo culture.

In this study, we used an osteoblast cell line, MLO-A5, and a primary cell culture, mesenchymal stem cells (MSC), to compare small (approximately 80 µm) with large (approximately 220 µm) cellular aggregates for potential bone nodule development after 8 weeks of culturing in a mouse model (n = 4 each group). In total, 30 chambers were implanted into the intra-peritoneal cavity of 20 male, immunocompromised mice (MF1-Nu/Nu, 4 – 5 weeks old). Nine small or three large aggregates were used per chamber. Neoveil mesh was seeded directly with 2 × 10³ cells for monolayer control. At 8 weeks, the animals were euthanised and chambers fixed with formalin. Aggregate integrity and extracellular material growth were assessed via light microscopy and the potential mineralisation was assessed via micro-CT.

Many large aggregates appeared to disintegrate, whilst the small aggregates maintained their form and produced additional extracellular material with increased sizes. Both MLO-A5 cells and MSC cells saw similar results. Interestingly, however, the MSCs were also seen to produce a significantly higher volume of dense material compared to the MLO-A5 cells from micro-CT analysis.

Overall, a critical cell aggregate size appeared to exist balancing optimal tissue growth with oxygen diffusion, and cell source may influence differentiation pathway despite similar experimental parameters. The MSCs, for example, were likely producing bone via the endochondral ossification pathway, whilst the matured bone cells, MLO-A5 cells, were likely producing bone via the intramembranous ossification pathway.