Knee joint distraction (KJD) has been associated with clinical and structural improvement and synovial fluid (SF) marker changes. However, structural changes have not yet been shown satisfactorily in regular care, since radiographic acquisition was not fully standardized. AI-based modules have shown great potential to reduce reading time, increase inter-reader agreement and therefore function as a tool for treatment outcome assessment. The objective was to analyse structural changes after KJD in patients using this AI-based measurement method, and relate these changes to clinical outcome and SF markers. 20 knee OA patients (<65 years old) were included in this study. KJD treatment was performed using an external fixation device, providing 5 mm distraction for 6 weeks. SF was aspirated before, during and immediately after treatment. Weight-bearing antero-posterior knee radiographs and WOMAC questionnaires were collected before and ~one year after treatment. Radiographs were analysed with the Knee Osteoarthritis Labelling Assistant (KOALA, IB Lab GmbH, Vienna, Austria), and 10 pre-defined biomarker levels in SF were measured by immunoassay. Radiographic one-year changes were analysed and linear regression was used to calculate associations between changes in standardized joint space width (JSW) and WOMAC, and changes in JSW and SF markers. After treatment, radiographs showed an improvement in Kellgren-Lawrence grade in 7 of 16 patients that could be evaluated; 3 showed a worsening. Joint space narrowing scores and continuous JSW measures improved especially medially. A greater improvement in JSW was significantly associated with a greater improvement in WOMAC pain (β=0.64;p=0.020). A greater increase in MCP1 (β=0.67;p=0.033) and lower increase in TGFβ1 (β=-0.787;p=0.007) were associated with JSW improvement. Despite the small number of patients, also in regular care KJD treatment shows joint repair as measured automatically on radiographs, significantly associated with certain SF marker change and even with clinical outcome.
Knee joint distraction (KJD) is a joint-preserving treatment strategy for severe osteoarthritis (OA) that provides long-term clinical and structural improvement. Data from both human trials and animal models indicate clear cartilage regeneration from 6 months and onwards post-KJD. However, recent work showed that during distraction, the balance between catabolic and anabolic indicators is directed towards catabolism, as indicated by collagen type 2 markers, proteoglycan (PG) turnover and a catabolic transcription profile [unpublished data]. The focus of this study was to investigate the cartilage directly and 10 weeks after joint distraction in order to elucidate the shift from a catabolic to an anabolic cartilage state. Knee OA was induced bilaterally in 8 dogs according to the groove model. After 10 weeks of OA induction, all 8 animals received right knee joint distraction, employing the left knee as an OA control. After 8 weeks of distraction, 4 dogs were euthanized and after 10 weeks of follow-up the 4 other dogs. Macroscopic cartilage degeneration and synovial tissue inflammation was assessed using the OARSI canine scoring system. PG content was determined spectrometrically using Alcian Blue dye solution and the synthesis of newly formed PGs was determined using 35SO42- as a tracer, as was described before. Directly after KJD, macroscopic cartilage damage of the right tibial plateau was higher compared to the left OA control (OARSI score: 1.7±0.2 vs 0.6±0.3; p < 0.001). 10 weeks post-KJD this difference persisted (OARSI score: 1.4± 0.6 vs 0.6±0.3; p = 0.05). Directly after KJD, there was no difference in synovial inflammation between KJD and OA control (OARSI score: 1.4±0.5). At 10 weeks synovial inflammation increased significantly in the distracted knee (OARSI score: 2.1±0.3 vs 1.4±0.5; p < 0.05). Biochemical analysis of the tibia cartilage directly after KJD revealed a lower PG content (20.1±10.3 mg/g vs 23.7±11.7 mg/g). At 10 weeks post-KJD this difference in PG content was less (24.8±6.8 mg/g vs 25.4±7.8 mg/g). The PG synthesis rate directly after KJD appeared significantly lower vs. OA (1.4±0.6 nmol/h.g vs 5.9±4.4 nmol/h.g; p < 0.001)). However, 10 weeks post-KJD this difference was not detected (3.7±1.2 nmol/h.g vs 2.9±0.8 nmol/h.g), and the synthesis rate in the distracted knee was increased compared to directly after distraction (p < 0.01). Further in-depth investigation of the material is ongoing; these first results suggest that the shift from a catabolic to an anabolic state occurs within the first weeks after joint distraction, mostly reflected in the biochemical changes. As such, the post-distraction period seems to be essential in identifying key-players that support intrinsic cartilage repair.
Osteoarthritis (OA) is one of the most prevalent diseases of the elderly, affecting greater than 50% of the population over 60 years of age. Many factors are implicated in the development of OA but currently no mechanism has been described that provides an explanation for age as the major risk factor for OA. The present studies were designed to investigate the hypothesis that age-related accumulation of advanced glycation endproducts (AGEs) provides a molecular mechanism that explains (at least in part) the age-related increase in the incidence of OA. To gain insight in the diversity of AGEs present in articular cartilage, several AGE measures were determined in a wide age-range of normal human articular cartilage samples: all demonstrated increased AGE levels with increasing age. The level of these AGEs was high in cartilage compared to other tissues such as skin, which is mainly caused by the very low turnover of the cartilage matrix proteins. The t1/2 of collagen in articular cartilage is ~117 years (compared to t1/2 of skin collagen of ~15 years). Accumulation of AGEs in cartilage affected biomechanical, biochemical and cellular characteristics of the tissue. At the biomechanical level, increased AGE levels were accompanied by increased stiffness and brittleness, indicating that AGE accumulation leads to increased susceptibility of articular cartilage to mechanical damage. On the cellular level, accumulation of AGEs decreased the synthesis and degradation (= turnover) of the cartilage matrix. Such decreased cartilage turnover is likely to result in decreased repair capacity of the tissue. In combination, the AGE-related increase in tissue brittleness and decrease in extracellular matrix turnover, results in articular cartilage that is more prone to damage. This concept, that AGE accumulation predisposes to the development of OA was tested in the canine anterior cruciate ligament transection (ACLT) model for osteoarthritis. Selectively enhancing AGE levels in articular cartilage of young animals (in the absence of other age-related changes) resulted in more severe OA. Altogether, AGE accumulation in articular cartilage presents a molecular mechanism by which ageing predisposes to the development of OA, and it provides new possibilities for prevention and/or therapy via the inhibition and/or reversal of cartilage AGE formation.
