Osteoarthritis (OA) is a progressive and degenerative joint disease resulting in changes to articular cartilage. In focal early OA defects, autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) has a 2-fold failure rate due to poor graft integration and presence of inflammatory factors (e.g. Interleukin-1β). Bone marrow derived mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are an alternative cell source for cell-based treatments due to their chondrogenic capacity, though in vivo implantation leads to bone formation. In vivo, chondrocytes reside under an oxygen tension between 2–7% oxygen or physioxia. Physioxia enhances MSC chondrogenesis with reduced hypertrophic marker (collagen X and MMP13) expression compared to hyperoxic conditions (20% oxygen). This study sought to understand whether implantation of physioxic preconditioned MSCs improves cartilage regeneration in an early OA defect model compared to hyperoxic MSCs. Bone marrow extracted from New Zealand white rabbits (male: 5–6 months old; n = 6) was split equally for expansion under 2% (physioxia) or 20% (hyperoxia) oxygen. Chondrogenic pellets (2 × 105 cells/pellet) formed at passage 1 were cultured in the presence of TGF-β1 under their expansion conditions and measured for their wet weight and GAG content after 21 days. During bone marrow extraction, a dental drill (2.5mm diameter) was applied to medial femoral condyle on both the right and left knee and left untreated for 6 weeks. Following this period, physioxia and hyperoxia preconditioned MSCs were seeded into a hyaluronic acid (TETEC) hydrogel. Fibrous tissue was scraped and then MSC-hydrogel was injected into the right (hyperoxic MSCs) and left (physioxia MSCs) knee. Additional control rabbits with drilled defects had fibrous tissue scrapped and then left untreated without MSC-hydrogel treatment for the duration of the experiment. Rabbits were sacrificed at 6 (n = 3) and 12 (n = 3) weeks post-treatment, condyles harvested, decalcified in 10% EDTA and sectioned using a cryostat. Region of interest was identified; sections stained with Safranin-O/Fast green and evaluated for cartilage regeneration using the Sellers scoring system by three blinded observers. Physioxic culture of rabbit MSCs showed significantly shorter doubling time and greater cell numbers compared to hyperoxic culture (∗p < 0.05). Furthermore, physioxia enhanced MSC chondrogenesis via significant increases in pellet wet weight and GAG content (∗p < 0.05). Implantation of physioxic preconditioned MSCs showed significantly improved cartilage regeneration (Mean Sellers score = 7 ± 3; ∗p < 0.05) compared to hyperoxic MSCs (Sellers score = 12 ± 2) and empty defects (Sellers score = 17 ± 3). Physioxia enhances in vitro rabbit MSC chondrogenesis. Subsequent in vivo implantation of physioxia preconditioned MSCs improved cartilage regeneration in an early OA defect model compared to hyperoxic MSCs. Future studies will investigate the mechanisms for enhanced in vivo regeneration using physioxia preconditioned MSCs.
Osteoarthritis (OA) is one of the most prevalent joint diseases involving progressive and degenerative changes to cartilage resulting from a variety of etiologies including post-traumatic incident or aging. OA lesions can be treated at its early stages through cell-based tissue engineering therapies using Mesenchymal Stem Cells (MSCs). In vivo models for evaluating these strategies, have described both chondral (impaction) and osteochondral (biopsy punch) defects. The aim of the investigation was to develop a compact and reproducible defect inducing post-traumatic degenerative changes mimicking early OA. Additionally, a pilot study to evaluate the efficacy of MSC-hydrogel treatment was also assessed. Surgery was performed on New Zealand white rabbits (male, 5–8 months old) with defects created on medial femoral condyle. For developing an appropriate defect, three approaches were used for evaluation: a biopsy punch (n = three at six and twelve weeks), an impaction device1 (n = three at six and twelve weeks) and a dental drill model (n = six at six and twelve weeks). At stated time points, condyles were harvested and decalcified in 10% EDTA, then embedded in Tissue-Tek and sectioned using a cryostat. Upon identification of region of interest, sections were stained with Safranin-O/Fast green and scored using OARSI scoring system by two blinded observers2. For the pilot study, autologous bone marrow was harvested from rabbits and used to isolate and expand MSCs. The Dental drill model was applied to both knee condyles, left untreated for six weeks at which stage, PKH26 fluorescently labelled MSCs were seeded into a hyaluronic acid hydrogel (TETEC). Repair tissue was removed from both condyles and MSC-hydrogel was injected into the left knee, whilst right knee was left empty. Rabbits were sacrificed at one (n = 1), six (n = 3) and twelve (n = 3) weeks post-treatment, processed as previously described and cartilage regeneration evaluated using Sellers score3. Impacted condyles exhibited no observed changes histologically (Mean OARSI score = 1 + 1), whereas biopsy punched and dental drilled defects demonstrated equal signs of cartilage erosion (OARSI score = 3 + 1) at assessed time points. However, biopsy punched condyles formed a diffusive defect, whereas dental drilled condyles showed a more defined, compact and reproducible defect. In the pilot study, PKH-labelled MSCs were observed at one and six weeks post-implantation within the defect space where hydrogel was injected. Tissue regeneration assessment indicated no difference between empty (Mean Sellers score = 14 + 2) and MSC treated defects (Sellers score = 16 + 5) at six weeks post-injection. At twelve weeks, MSC treated defects showed improved tissue regeneration with substantial subchondral bone restoration and good integration of regenerative cartilage with surrounding intact tissue (Sellers score = 10 + 1), whereas untreated defects showed no change in regeneration compared to six weeks (Sellers score = 16 + 2). Dental drill model was found to be the appropriate strategy for investigating early OA progression and treatment. Application of MSCs in defects showed good cartilage regeneration after twelve weeks application, indicating their promise in the treatment of early OA defects.