Decellularised porcine superflexor tendon (pSFT) has been demonstrated to be a suitable scaffold for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction[1]. While the role of collagen in tendons is well known, the mechanical role of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) is less clear and may be altered by the decellularisation process.

To determine the effects of decellularisation on pSFT GAG content and mechanical function and to investigate the consequences of GAG loss in tensile and compressive loading.

pSFTs were decellularised following previous techniques [2]. For GAG removal, native pSFTs were treated with chondroitinase ABC (ChABC; 0.1U/mL, 72h). Cell and GAG removal was validated using histology and quantitative assays. Native, decellularised and ChABC treated groups (n=6) were biomechanically characterised. In tension, specimens underwent stress relaxation and strength testing using previous protocols [1]. Stress relaxation data was fitted to a modified Maxwell-Weichert model to determine time-dependent (E1 & E2) and time-independent moduli (E0). The toe and linear region moduli (Etoe, Elinear), in addition to tensile strength (UTS) and failure strain were determined from strength testing. In compression, specimens underwent confined loading conditions (ramp at 10 s-1 to 10% strain and hold). The aggregate modulus (HA) and zero-strain permeability (k0) were determined using previous techniques [3]. Data was analysed by one-way ANOVA with Tukey post-hoc test to determine significant differences between test groups (p<0.05).

Quantitative assays showed no GAG reduction post-decellularisation, but a significant reduction after ChABC treatment. HA was only significantly reduced in the ChABC group. k0 was significantly higher for the ChABC group compared to decellularised. E0 was significantly reduced in the decellularised group compared to native and ChABC groups, while E1 and E2 were not different between groups. Etoe, Elinear, UTS and failure strain were not different between groups.

Decellularisation does not affect GAG content or impair mechanical function in pSFT. GAG loss adversely affects pSFT compressive properties, revealing major mechanical contribution under compression, but no significant role under tension.

Abstract

Decellularised porcine superflexor tendon (pSFT) provides an off-the-shelf, cost-efficient option for ACL reconstruction (ACLR). During decellularisation, phosphate buffered saline (PBS) is used for washing out cytotoxic solutes and reagents, maintaining tissue hydration. It has been shown to increase water content in tendon, swelling the tissue reducing mechanical properties. End stage PBS washes in the standard protocol were substituted with alternative solutions to study tissue swelling and its impact on the mechanical behaviour and matrix composition of pSFTs. 25%, 100% Ringers and physiological saline test groups were used (n=6 for all groups). pSFTs were subject to tensile and confined compression testing. Relative hydroxyproline (HYP), glycosaminoglycan (GAG) and denatured collagen content (DNC) were quantified. Modified decellularised tendon groups were compared to tendons decellularised using the standard protocol and native tendons. Specimen dimensions reduced (p=0.004) post-decellularisation only in 25% Ringers group. In all other modified groups, less swelling was apparent but not statistically different from standard group. Only 25% Ringers group had higher linear modulus (p=0.0035) and UTS (p=0.013) compared to standard group. All decellularised groups properties were reduced compared to native pSFTs. Stress relaxation properties showed a significant reduction in decellularised groups compared to native. Compression testing showed no significant differences in peak stress for modified decellularised groups compared to native. A reduction (p=0.036) was observed in standard group. Quantification of GAGs and DNC showed no significant differences between groups. HYP content was higher (p<0.0001) for saline group. A significant reduction in tissue swelling could be related to improved mechanical properties of decellularised pSFTs. Alternative solutions in end stage washes had no significant effect on quantities of matrix components, but altered structure/function could explain the differences in tensile and compressive behaviour, and should be further studied. In all decellularised groups, pSFTs retained suitable mechanical properties for ACLR.

Abstract

Abstract

Decellularised extracellular matrix scaffolds show great promise for the regeneration of damaged musculoskeletal tissues (cartilage, ligament, meniscus), however, adequate fixation into the joint remains a challenge. Here, we assess the osseo-integration of decellularised porcine bone in a sheep model. This proof-of-concept study supports the overall objective to create composite decellularised tissue scaffolds with bony attachment sites to enable superior fixation and regeneration.

Porcine trabecular bone plugs (6mm diameter, 10mm long) were decellularised using a novel bioprocess incorporating low-concentration sodium dodecyl sulphate with protease inhibitors. Decellularised bone scaffolds (n=6) and ovine allograft controls (n=6) were implanted into the condyle of skeletally mature sheep for 4 and 12 weeks. New bone growth was visualised by oxytetracycline fluorescence and standard resin semi-quantitative histopathology.

Scaffolds were found to be fully decellularised and maintained the native microarchitecture. Following 4-week implantation in sheep, both scaffold and allograft appeared well integrated. The trabecular spaces of the scaffold were filled with a fibro-mesenchymal infiltrate, but some areas showed a marked focal lymphocytic response, associated with reduced bone deposition. A lesser lymphocytic response was observed in the allograft control. After 12-weeks the lymphocytic reaction was minimised in the scaffold and absent in allografts. The scaffold showed a higher density of new mineralized bone deposition compared to allograft. New marrow had formed in both the scaffold and allografts.

Following the demonstration of osteointegration this bioprocess can now be transferred to develop decellularised composite musculoskeletal tissue scaffolds and decellularised bone scaffolds for clinical regeneration of musculoskeletal tissues.

Whilst lateral ankle sprain is often considered a benign injury it represents between 3–5% of all A&E visits in the UK. The mechanical characteristics of ankle ligaments under sprain-like conditions are scarcely reported.

The lateral collateral ankle ligaments were dissected from n=6 human cadaveric specimens to produce individual bone-ligament-bone specimens. An Instron Electropuls E10000 was used to uni-axially load the ankle ligaments in tension. The ligaments were first preconditioned between 2 N and a load value corresponding to 3.5% strain for 15 cycles and then strained to failure at a rate of 100%/s.

The mean ultimate failure loads and their standard deviations for the anterior talofibular (ATFL), calcaneofibular (CFL) and posterior talofibular (PTFL) ligaments are 351.4±105.6 N, 367.8±76.1 N and 263.6±156.6 N, respectively. Whilst the standard deviation values are high they align with those previously reported for ankle ligament characterisation. The large standard deviations are partly due to the inherent variability of human cadaveric tissue but could also be due to varying previous activity levels of participants or a prior unreported ankle sprain. Although the sample size is relatively small the results were stratified to identify any potential correlations of age, BMI and weight with ultimate load. A strong Pearson correlation (r=0.919) was found between BMI and ultimate load of the CFL but a larger sample size is required to confirm a link. The ligament failure modes were observed and categorised as avulsion or intra-ligamentous failure. The ATFL avulsed from the fibula in five instances and intra-ligamentous failure occurred once. The CFL avulsed from the fibula twice and failed four times through intra-ligamentous failure. Finally, the PTFL avulsed from the fibula once, avulsed from the talus once and failed through intra-ligamentous failure in four instances.

The results identify the forces required to severely sprain the lateral collateral ankle ligaments and their failure modes.

The concept of decellularised xenografts as a basis for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction was introduced to overcome limitations in alternative graft sources such as substantial remodelling delaying recovery and donor site morbidity. This study aimed to measure the biomechanical properties of decellularised porcine super flexor tendon (pSFT) processed to create ACL grafts of varying diameters, with a view to facilitating production of stratified ‘off the shelf’ products with specified functional properties for use in ACL reconstructive surgery.

Decellularisation was carried out using a previously established procedure, including antibiotic washes, low concentration detergent (0.1% sodium dodecyl sulphate) washes and nuclease treatments. Decellularised pSFTs were prepared to create double-bundle grafts of 7, 8 and 9mm diameter (n=6 in each group). Femoral and tibial fixations were simulated utilising Arthrex suspension devices (Tightrope®) and interference screws in bovine bone respectively.

Dynamic stiffness and creep were measured under cyclic loading between 50–250N for 1000 cycles at 1Hz. This was followed by ramp to failure at 200mm/min from which linear stiffness and load at failure were measured. Data were analysed using either 1- or 2-way ANOVA as appropriate with Tukey post-hoc analysis (p<0.05).

Significant differences were found between all groups for dynamic stiffness and between 7 & 9mm and 8 & 9mm groups for dynamic creep. Significant differences were also found between 7, 8 & 9mm groups for linear stiffness (167.8±4.9, 186.9±16.6 & 216.3±12.4N/mm respectively), but no significant differences were found between groups for load at failure (531.5±58.9, 604.1±183.3 & 627.9±72.4N respectively).

This study demonstrated that decellularised pSFTs possess comparable biomechanical properties to other ACL graft options (autografts and allografts). Furthermore, grafts can be stratified by their diameter to provide varying biomechanical profiles depending on the anatomy and individual needs of the recipient.

We have developed a decellularised porcine superflexor tendon (pSFT), which has shown promising regenerative capacity in an ovine model of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) repair. This study investigated the strain rate dependent and dynamic mechanical properties of native and decellularised pSFTs.

Decellularisation was carried out using a previously established procedure, including antibiotic washes, low concentration detergent (0.1% sodium dodecyl sulphate) washes and nuclease treatments.

Three different strain rates were employed: 1, 10 & 100%s-1 (n=6 for all groups). Toe-region modulus (E0), linear-region modulus (E1), transition coordinates (εT, σT), tensile strength (UTS) and failure strain were calculated. For DMA, specimens were loaded between 1 & 5MPa with increasing frequency up to 2Hz. Dynamic (E*), storage (E') and loss (E'') moduli, and tan delta were calculated for native and decellularised groups (n=6). Data was analysed by 2-way ANOVA and Tukey post-hoc test (p<0.05).

For decellularised tendons, altering the strain rate did not affect any of the static tensile properties. For native pSFTs, the UTS, failure strain and E1 were not affected by changing the strain rate. Increasing the strain rate significantly increased E0 (1% vs 10% and 1% vs 100%) and σT (1% vs 100%) and decreased εT (1% vs 10% and 1% vs 100%) for native pSFT. E*, E' and E'' were all significantly reduced in decellularised specimens compared to native controls across all frequencies investigated. No significant differences were found for tan delta.

Evidence of strain rate dependency was witnessed in the native pSFTs by increase of the toe region modulus and displacements of the transition point coordinates. This response was not seen in the tissue following decellularisation. DMA demonstrated a reduction in dynamic, storage and loss moduli. Tan delta (E''/E') remained unchanged, indicating reductions in solid and fluid components are interlinked.

The growth in the popularity of tissue engineering principles in the treatment of musculoskeletal disorders has been complemented greatly with research investment into tissue specific scaffolds. Biological scaffolds produced by means of decellularising native tissues have the advantage of providing the natural complex hierarchical matrix and, in doing so, replicating the specific biomechanical and biological functions of the tissue in question. Decellularisation treatments are multi-faceted, vary considerably between different processes and may involve many lengthy treatment steps. Some of these bio-processes may cause undesirable structural changes to the extracellular matrix of tissues and, by association, their mechanical properties. Thus, it is of paramount importance to ensure that the properties of the scaffolds are not affected to the extent of reducing their integration, biomechanical performance and longevity. This talk consists of a body of work detailing investigations into bio-process optimisation, sterilisation strategies and the regenerative and functional capacity of decellularised xenogeneic and allogeneic tendon, ligament and bone scaffolds. In addition, on-going work concerning advanced pre-clinical assessment, stratification of these products to particular patient populations and the importance of the manufacturing value chain in their translation will be discussed.

Acellular porcine super flexor tendon (pSFT) offers a promising solution to replacement of damaged anterior cruciate ligament [1]. It is desirable to package and terminally sterilise the acellular grafts to eliminate any possible harmful pathogens. However, irradiation techniques can damage the collagen ultra-structure and consequently reduce the mechanical properties [2]. The aims of this study were to investigate the effects of irradiation sterilisation of varying dosages on the biomechanical properties of the acellular pSFT.

Tendons were decellularised using a previously established protocol [1] and subjected to irradiation sterilisation using either 30 kGy gamma, 55 kGy gamma, 34 kGy E-beam, 15 kGy gamma, 15 kGy E-beam and (15+15) kGy E-beam (fractionated dose). Specimens then underwent stress relaxation and strength testing at 0 and 12 months post sterilisation to determine whether any effect on these properties was progressive. For stress relaxation testing, specimens were analysed using a Maxwell-Wiechert model. For strength testing, the ultimate tensile strength, Young's modulus and failure strain were assessed.

Significant differences were found which demonstrated that all irradiation treatments had an effect on the time-independent and time-dependent viscoelastic properties of irradiated tendons compared to per-acetic acid only treated controls. Interestingly, no significant differences were found between the irradiated groups. Similar trends were found for the strength testing properties. No significant differences were found between groups at 0 and 12 months.

Tendons retained sufficient biomechanical properties following sterilisation, however it was notable that there were no significant differences between the irradiated groups, as it was believed higher dosages would lead to a greater reduction in the mechanical properties. The changes observed were not altered further after 12 months storage, indicating the acellular pSFT graft has a stable shelf-life.