Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 1 of 1
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_3 | Pages 101 - 101
1 Feb 2017
Clarke I Donaldson T Grijalva R Maul C
Full Access

Despite 46 years clinical experience with ceramic-on-ceramic (COC) hip bearings, there is no data on what constitutes a successful long-term wear performance. There have been many studies of short-term failures (Dorlot, 1992; Nevelos, 2001, Walters, 2004). One retrieval study using optical-CMM technology (OCM) documented volumetric wear-rates ranging up to 7mm3/year on femoral heads (Esposito 2012). It was noted that 83% of these revisions showed stripe damage within 3–4 years. The supposition would appear to be that these were bearing-related failures.

Our selected COC case for this study was particularly interesting, a female patient having her index surgery performed at age 17 and revised at age 49 (following onset of hip pain). This patient led an active lifestyle, went dancing multiple times per week, and was mother to three children. The 38mm AutophorTM THA (left hip) was eventually revised due to the cup painful migrating (Fig. 1: 32-years follow-up). Radiographs showed cup inclination at approximately 19°. Impingement marks were noted on the CoCr neck and collared stem (Fig. 2). Implant geometry and form factors were analyzed by standard contour measurement (CMM) while SEM and EDS imaging provided wear topography and evidence of metal contaminants. Linear and volumetric wear in head and cup were studied by OCM at Redlux (Southampton, UK).

The head's main wear-pattern consisted of two overlapping circular areas (Fig. 3). The narrowest margin made by the wear-pattern was used to define the superior aspect of the head. By light microscopy, the superior main-wear zone covered 1490–1680mm2 area while the total bi-lobed area covered larger 2170mm2 area. OCM analysis delineated the same bi-lobed appearance of head wear with the superior worn area assessed at 1365mm2. The cup revealed a more extensive wear pattern that circumnavigated its surface. The black staining identified by EDS imaging in the cup revealed Co and Cr elements. By OCM technique the head volumetric wear was 179 mm³ and the cup was 214mm3 (Fig. 4), i.e. 20% greater than head. Volumetric wear-rate averaged 12.3mm3 per year for this pioneering alumina ceramic.

This first demonstration of long-term, COC volumetric wear provides the foundation for retrieval and simulator studies alike. Our patient represented a “worst-case” scenario for hip-replacement surgery, due to extreme youth and long-term sporting life. While the superior wear pattern was not totally contained within the cup (Fig. 3), her implant positioning was clearly adequate. Nevertheless both cup edge-wear and CoCr contamination indicated this patient experienced habitual impingement, i.e. alumina cup rim wearing against CoCr femoral neck (Fig. 2). The head wear-pattern was distinctly bi-lobed but OCM images showed the majority of wear was in the superior hemisphere as noted in MOM retrievals (Clarke, 2013). The head wear-rate in this pioneering “Mittelmeier” THA averaged 5.6mm³/year over 32-years of follow-up. This appeared directly comparable to ceramic head wear measured with the same OCM-technique in modern ceramic THA (Esposito, 2012: 0.1 to 7mm3/year). This indicated to us that COC wear rates of the order 10–14mm3/year represented an acceptable “normal” level of performance in young and active individuals.