Background

While posterior cruciate retaining (PCR) implants are a more common total knee arthroplasty (TKA) design, newer bi-cruciate retaining (BCR) TKAs are now being considered as an option for many patients, especially those that are younger. While PCR TKAs remove the ACL, the BCR TKA designs keep both cruciate ligaments intact, as it is believed that the resection of the ACL greatly affects the overall kinematic patterns of TKA designs. Various fluoroscopic studies have focused on determination of kinematics but haven't defined differentiators that affect motion patterns. This research study assesses the importance of the cruciate ligaments and femoral geometry for Bi-Cruciate Retaining (BCR) and Posterior Cruciate Retaining (PCR) TKAs having the same femoral component, compared to the normal knee.

The extension facet angle (EFA) of the medial compartment of the knee has been implicated as a potential mechanical cause for anteromedial knee osteoarthritis.

We developed a novel sagittal plane flexion osteotomy of the medial tibiofemoral compartment. We then performed a cadaveric study to study the effect of the osteotomy on the intra-articular knee pressures under axial load mimicking the stance phase of gait. A Tekscan K400 pressure sensor was inserted submeniscally into the joint and 700N applied using an Instron machine. A topographical map of the pressure areas was then assessed pre- and post-osteotomy for the 10 cadaveric knees specimens.

We found that the intra-articular pressures are greatest in the anteromedial compartment in the native knee and after the osteotomy the area of highest pressure moves posterolaterally spread over a greater surface area.

We conclude that a flexion osteotomy of the medial compartment reduces intra-articular knee pressures concentrated anteromedially in full extension and may be beneficial in patients with an elevated EFA with anteromedial symptoms.

Introduction

Femorotibial malalignment exceeding ±3° is a recognised contributor of early mechanical failure after total knee replacement (TKR). The angle between the mechanical and anatomical axes of the femur remains the best guide to restore alignment. We investigated where the femoral head lies relative to the pelvis and how its position varies with respect to recognised demographic and anatomic parameters. We have tested the hypothesis of the senior author that the position of the centre of the femoral head varies very little, and if its location can be identified, it could serve to outline the mechanical axis of the femur without the need for sophisticated imaging.

Introduction: The medial tibial plateau is composed of two relatively flat facets. An anterior upward sloping “extension facet” (EF) articulates with the medial femoral condyle from 0 to 20–the stance phase of gait (in Man but not in other mammals). Anatomical variation in this area might be responsible for antero-medial osteoarthritis (AMOA).

This paper reports the angle between the EF and the horizontal (the extension facet angle- EFA) in normal knees and in knees with early AMOA.

Method: MRI reports were searched to identify patients with acute rupture of the ACL on the assumption that they had anatomically normal tibiae (46 males and 18 females) and patients with MRI evidence of early AMOA without bone loss (11 males and 9 females).

A sagittal image at the midpoint of the femoral condyle was used to determine the EFA.

Results: The EFA in normal tibiae is 14 +/− 5 (range 3–25). The angle is unrelated to age. The EFA in individuals with early AMOA is 19 +/− 4 (range 13–26). The difference is significant (p< 0.001).

Discussion: There is a wide variation in the EFA in normal knees which is unrelated to age.

There is an association between an increased EFA (ie a steeper EF) and MRI evidence of AMOA. Although a causal link is not proven, we speculate that a steeper angle increases the duration of loading on the EF in stance and tibio-femoral interface shear. This may initiate cartilage breakdown.

Introduction: The medial tibial plateau is composed of two relatively flat facets. An anterior upward sloping “extension facet” (EF) articulates with the medial femoral condyle from 0 to 20° – the stance phase of gait (in Man but not in other mammals). A horizontal “flexion facet” contacts the femur from 20° to full flexion. Anatomical variation in this area might be responsible for the initiation of antero-medial osteoarthritis (AMOA).

This paper reports the angle between the EF and the horizontal (the extension facet angle - EFA) in normal knees and in knees with early AMOA.

Method: MRI reports were searched to identify patients with acute rupture of the ACL on the assumption that they had anatomically normal tibiae (46 males and 18 females) and patients with MRI evidence of early AMOA without bone loss (11 males and 9 females).

A sagittal image at the midpoint of the femoral condyle was used to determine the EFA. Repeat measurements were taken by two observers.

Results: The EFA in normal tibiae is 14 +/− 5° (range 3 – 25°). The angle is unrelated to age. The EFA in individuals with early AMOA is 19 +/− 4° (range 13 – 26°). The difference is highly significant (p< 0.001).

Discussion: There is a wide variation in the EFA in normal knees that is unrelated to age.

There is an association between an increased EFA (ie a steeper EF) and MRI evidence of AMOA. Although a causal link is not proven, we speculate that a steeper angle increases the duration of loading on the EF in stance and tibio-femoral interface shear. This may initiate cartilage breakdown.

Introduction and Aims: To assess the tibiofemoral kinematics of the PCL deficient knee using vertical open-access ‘dynamic’ MRI.

Method: Tibiofemoral motion was assessed using open-access MRI, weight-bearing in a squat, through the arc of flexion from zero to 90 degrees in six patients with isolated rupture of the PCL in one knee [diagnosed from conventional MRI scanning and clinical assessment] and a normal contralateral knee. Mid-medial and mid-lateral sagittal images were analysed in all chosen positions of flexion in both knees to assess the relative tibiofemoral relationships. Passive sagittal laxity was assessed by performing the posterior and anterior drawer tests, while the knees were scanned, again using the same MRI scanner. The tibiofemoral positions during this stress MRI examination was measured from mid-medial and mid-lateral sagittal images of the knees.

Results: Rupture of the PCL leads to an increase in passive sagittal laxity in the medial compartment of the knee [P< 0.006]. In the weight-bearing scans, PCL rupture alters the kinematics of the knee with persistent posterior subluxation of the medial tibia so that the femoral condyle rides up the anterior upslope of the medial tibial plateau. This ‘fixed’ subluxation was observed throughout the extension-flexion arc being statistically significant at all flexion angles (P< 0.018 at 0°, P< 0.013 at 20°, P< 0.014 at 45°, P< 0.004 at 90°). The kinematics of the lateral compartment were not altered by PCL rupture to a statistically significant degree. The posterior drawer test showed increased laxity in the medial compartment.

Conclusion: PCL rupture alters the kinematics of the medial compartment of the knee resulting in ‘fixed’ anterior subluxation of the medial femoral condyle [posterior subluxation of the medial tibial condyle]. This study helps to explain the observation of increased incidence of osteoarthritis in the medial compartment and specifically femoral condyle, in PCL deficient knees.

Purpose: To assess if ACL reconstruction restores normal knee kinematics.

Methods: Tibiofemoral motion was assessed weight-bearing through the arc of flexion from 0 to 90° in ten patients who were at least 6 months following successful hamstring graft ACL reconstruction. Lachman’s test was also performed using dynamic MRI. Mid-medial and mid-lateral images were analysed in all positions to assess the tibiofemoral relationship.

Results: The laxity of the reconstructed knees was reduced to within normal limits. However the normal tibiofemoral relationship was not restored after ACL reconstruction with persistent anterior subluxation of the lateral tibial plateau throughout the arc of flexion 0–90°(p< 0.001).

Conclusion: Successful ACL reconstruction reduces joint laxity and improves stability but it does not restore normal knee kinematics.

We have reviewed 29 patients (30 hips) who had undergone revision total hip arthroplasty using a Freeman metal-backed acetabular component and acetabular impaction allografting. The mean follow-up was for 15.3 years (12 to 17).

Five patients (5 hips) died with the prosthesis in situ and four (4 hips) were lost to follow-up. Twelve hips had failed and in the remaining nine there were minor symptoms. The mean time to failure requiring further surgery was nine years. Excluding patients who were lost to follow-up or had died, 72% of the hips were radiologically loose at the last review. The commonest pattern in those requiring revision was failure of the reinforcement ring in adduction with remodelling of the medial wall.

Of the nine patients who had not undergone revision, one with bilateral replacements had no current radiographs and only three of the remaining seven replacements had no radiological signs of loosening.

The short-term results for this technique have been reported to be satisfactory, but in the long term they are not. The factors associated with failure include the design of the prosthesis, which has been implicated in disappointing long-term results when used in primary arthroplasty, but not with the frequency of failure found in this series. It seems that the reliance on peripheral screw fixation over a bed of allograft without bridging the graft does not provide sufficient stability to allow incorporation of the graft.

We measured the proximal migration of 265 acetabular cups over seven years and correlated the findings with clinical outcome and acetabular revision for aseptic loosening. Cups which eventually became aseptically loose were shown to migrate more rapidly than successful cups. The average proximal migration at two years postoperatively for four groups of cups showed a monotonic relationship to the acetabular revision rate for aseptic loosening at 6.5 years. We conclude that acetabular cups which develop aseptic loosening as evidenced by pain, revision or screw fracture show increased proximal migration by one year, and that the 'migration rate' at two years can be used to predict the acetabular revision rate from aseptic loosening at 6.5 years.

We studied the wear generated by motion between polished and shot-blasted titanium-alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) or cobalt-chrome alloy (Co-Cr) surfaces and cortical bone in vitro. Semicircular sections of human proximal femoral cortex were reamed to fit metal cylinders of each alloy. The cylinders were then fitted in the bone, loaded and rotated in physiological saline. Ti-alloy resulted in more wear both of the bone and of the metal than did Co-Cr alloy. Metal wear was reduced and bone wear was increased by shot-blasting, a procedure which introduces surface residual stresses and roughens the metal surface. We conclude that when there is gross motion between a metal implant and bone, Ti-alloy is likely to generate more wear debris than Co-Cr alloy. The least wear both of bone and of metal was produced by polished Co-Cr.

The vertical migration of four configurations of a proximal femoral prosthesis, followed for up to nine years, was measured on standard radiographs. The same implant was used without cement (group 1) and with cement (group 2). The migration of both groups was linear from six months onwards. The mean migration rate and the incidence of late aseptic loosening were both greater in group 1. Survival analysis of the two groups, however, showed no statistically significant difference. In both groups, hips later destined for revision migrated more rapidly from the initial postoperative period onwards, than did the remainder. A threshold migration of 1.2 mm/year during the first two years after implantation detected hips likely to fail with a specificity of 86% and a sensitivity of 78%. This 'migration test' was applied to the results in two further groups of patients in which a modified femoral prosthesis had been implanted without hydroxyapatite coating (group 3) and with hydroxyapatite coating (group 4). The test distinguished between the four groups and suggested that at least two fixation procedures should be abandoned. We conclude that vertical migration measured on standard radiographs in the first two years after implantation can be used to predict late aseptic loosening. New prosthetic configurations should be evaluated by migration measurements before their general release. Our observations support the view that one cause of late aseptic loosening is imperfect initial fixation.

We have studied 27 tibial prostheses retrieved from knee replacements after 1 to 9 years. In 22 the femoral components were of cobalt-chrome, in five polyacetal. The design of the components gave a nominal contact area of 320 mm2 on each condyle. The tibial component was of high-density polyethylene (HDP) at least 6 mm thick, and not heat-treated. In the metal/HDP prostheses the average wear rate was 0.025 mm/year. The relative wear on the medial and lateral sides was related to the leg axis. None of the retrieved prostheses showed any severe disruption of their surface. The polyacetal/HDP prostheses showed similar wear with a statistically insignificant trend towards slower penetration. We conclude that the rate of wear of HDP in a conforming tibiofemoral bearing with a fixed tibial component at least 6 mm thick and not heat-treated is slow enough to be safe in clinical practice.

We studied two groups of femoral hip prostheses: 43 TiAlV ridged press-fit stems, and 26 with similar stems coated with hydroxyapatite on the proximal half. At one year, radiological measurement showed a mean downward migration of 0.99 mm for the TialV prostheses and 0.12 mm for the HA-coated prostheses (p = 0.0002). Hydroxyapatite coating appeared to provide effective bio-active supplementary fixation.

We studied the effect of a layer of cement placed under the tibial component of Freeman-Samuelson total knee prostheses with a metal back and an 80 mm intramedullary stem, using roentgen stereophotogrammetry to measure the migration of the tibial component during one year in 13 uncemented and 16 cemented knees. The addition of cement produced a significant reduction in migration at one year, from a mean of 1.5 mm to one of 0.5 mm (p less than 0.01), including a significant reduction in pure subsidence. One year postoperatively the clinical results were similar between the groups, but, at three years, one uncemented knee had required revision.

We determined the cumulative survival rates, in arthroplasty of the knee, of three designs of tibial component, using a change of position on standard radiographs or revision for aseptic loosening as criteria of failure. The average migration of each of the three designs in the first postoperative year is known from roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis reported by other authors. The ranking order of the components as judged by cumulative survival is the same as that determined by early migration. This finding supports the view that the measurement of early migration can predict late aseptic loosening and therefore that such measurements are clinically of value.

One-stage reimplantation for the salvage of infected total knee arthroplasty in 18 patients was reviewed at an average follow-up of five years. There had been one recurrence and one new infection, both in rheumatoid patients with another focus of infection. In four other patients the clinical result was impaired by pain after walking (2) and limited flexion (2). Our results suggest that one-stage reimplantation is a reasonably reliable procedure for the management of a loose infected prosthesis.

Tissues from five patients who underwent revision operations for failed total hip replacements were found to contain large quantities of particulate titanium. In four cases this metal must have come from titanium alloy screws used to fix the acetabular component; in the fifth case it may also have originated from a titanium alloy femoral head. Monoclonal antibody labelling showed abundant macrophages and T-lymphocytes, in the absence of B-lymphocytes, suggesting sensitisation to titanium. Skin patch testing with dilute solutions of titanium salts gave negative results in all five patients. However, two of them had a positive skin test to a titanium-containing ointment.

We studied the effect of a metal tray with an intramedullary stem on the micromotion of the tibial component in total knee arthroplasty. Of 32 uncemented Freeman-Samuelson knee arthroplasties performed in London and Gothenburg, nine had a metal backing and stem added to the tibial component. Micromotion of the tibial components, expressed as migration and inducible displacement, was analysed using roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis up to two years follow-up. The addition of a metal back and a 110 mm stem to the standard polyethylene component significantly reduced both migration over two years and inducible displacement.