After anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction one of the risk factors for graft (re-)rupture is an increased posterior tibial slope (PTS). The current treatment for PTS is a high tibial osteotomy (HTO). This is a free-hand method, with 1 degree of tibial slope correction considered to be equal to 1 or even 1.67 mm of the anterior wedge resection. Error rates in the frontal plane reported in literature vary from 1 – 8.6 degrees, and in the sagittal plane outcomes in a range of 2 – 8 degrees are reported when planned on PTSs of 3 – 5 degrees. Therefore, the free-hand method is considered to have limited accuracy. It is expected that HTO becomes more accurate with patient specific saw guides (PSGs), with an accuracy margin reported in literature of 2 degrees. This proof of concept porcine cadaver case study aimed to investigate whether the use of PSGs improves the accuracy of HTO to less than 2 degrees. Secondly, the reproducibility of tibial slope measurement was evaluated. Preoperative MRI images of porcine cadaver knees (n = 3) were used to create 3D anatomical bone models (Mimics, Materialise, Belgium). These 3D models were subsequently used to develop PSGs (3-Matic, Materialise, Belgium) to correct all tibias for 3 degrees PTS and 4 degrees varus. The PSG mediated HTOs were performed by an experienced orthopaedic surgeon, after which postoperative MRI images were obtained. 3D anatomical models of postoperative tibias were created, and tibial slopes were assessed on both pre- and postoperative tibias. The tibial slope was defined as the angle between the mechanical axis and 3D tibial reference plane in the frontal and sagittal plane. The accuracy of the PSG mediated HTO (median and range) was defined as the difference in all possible combinations of the preoperatively planned and postoperatively obtained tibial slopes. To ensure reproducibility, the pre- and postoperative tibial slopes were measured thrice by one observer. The intra-class correlation coefficients (ICCs) were subsequently calculated to assess the intra-rater reliability (SPSS, IBM Corp., Armonk, N.Y., USA).Introduction and Objective
Materials and Methods
