A metal ion study was undertaken in patients who had received an articular surface replacement. The design of these components is optimised in line with lubrication theory and produces low levels of wear in hip joint simulators. Patients were recruited in four centres. Whole blood samples were analysed for metal ion levels using high resolution ICP-MS (inductively coupled plasma mass spectrophotometry). A total of 75 patients was enrolled into the study and 65 and 47 patients were assessed after 12 and 24 months implantation respectively. Results are included irrespective of clinical outcome.Introduction
Methods
The Harris Hip Score improved from a pre-operative mean of 56.99 to 97.12 at the latest follow up, and 60% of patients were scored at 100. At the latest follow up, 91% of patients scored 6 or above on the UCLA activity score; indicating at least regular participation in moderate exercise. There were no dislocations and no clinically evident DVT’s or PE’s There have been 11 revisions for fracture (1.06%). Five of these were intra-operative fractures, and six of these took place in patients aged over 50years. Fractures occurred in 3.1% of patients 65 years or more and in 0.5% of patients under 65 years(P<
0.05). In addition there were three revisions for cup loosening (0.29%) all in women over 60 years, three for unexplained pain (0.29%), one for impingement and subluxation, and one for infection(0.1%) Five patients have died with the resurfacing in situ (0.51%), for unrelated causes. The 3-year cumulative survival rate for all patients and all components was 97.4%. For 425 patients under 55 years the cumulative survival rate was 99.4%, aged under 65 years was 98.3%, and aged over 65 yrs was 94.8 %.
There have been 3 revisions for cup loosening (0.29%) and 3 for pain (0.29%). 5 patients have died (0.51%). There was one revision for infection and one for impingement. Average Harris Hip Score rose from 57.0 to 97.1, and 60% of patients scored 100. UCLA activity score was 6 or over in 91%, and the median score was 7.5. All failures were evident by 12 months The Cumulative Survival Rate at 3 years was 97.4%,, 99.5% for 55 years and under, 98.3% for under 65 years, and 94.2 % 65 years and over.
The average age of primary hip replacement patient was 70 years. (male patients 68 years and 71 years in females.) Over the 13 year period, the average age of male patients was noted to decline steadily from 71 in 1993 to 66 in 2003. But the average age of female patients remained constant at around 71 years. The number of patients below age 60 years undergoing hip replacement procedures was analysed. Only 8% of patients were under 60 years of age in 1993 rising to 23% in 2005. Between 2000 and 2005 this figure was at or above 20%. Surface hip replacement was started at our hospital in 1999. The number of patients treated with surface hip replacement as a proportion of all primary hip procedures has increased to 32% in 2005. The average age of these patients was 57 years. The sex difference was approximately 1:1 as compared to 1:2 in total hip replacement. The average age of primary knee replacement patients was 73 years, 72 yrs for males and 73 yrs for females. No change in average age was noted over the period. The proportion of patients under age of 60 years varied between 4 and 9%
The purpose of the study was to investigate the outcome of re-operations performed at this district general hospital on total knee replacements over a period of nine and a half years: we also compare the reasons for re-operation as well as their timing. Total knee replacements performed at this hospital and other centres requiring re-operation involving an open procedure were included in this study (total number =58). Patients were assessed both before and after re-operation using the knee society score. Data was recorded with respect to the type of original pros-thesis, reason for and time to re-operation as well as the nature of the re-operation procedure itself. Pre- and post-operative knee society scores showed a mean improvement of 20 with respect to the function scores and 65 with respect to knee scores. 50% of re-operations were for aseptic loosening with a further 25% each for infection and instability. In conclusion, re-operation for total knee replacement is shown to have had a satisfactory outcome in most cases. The results for revision surgery using a two stage procedure, in the treatment of infected total knee replacements, showed this to be very effective.
Between 1989 and 1993 we implanted a matrix support prosthesis made of carbon fibre for the treatment of chronic painful articular defects of the patella in 27 patients. The mean period of follow-up was 33 months (11 to 54) with clinical and arthroscopic evaluation of the implant. Overall, there were four excellent, three good, seven fair and 13 poor results. Nine patients subsequently had a patellectomy for persistent pain at a mean of 27 months after surgery (14 to 47). The mean visual analogue pain scores in those who retained their patella were 7.6 before operation and 5.5 at the time of the latest follow-up. Patient satisfaction for the entire group was 41%. There appeared to be good incorporation of the prosthesis and a satisfactory ingrowth of fibrocartilage, but the poor results in 48% and low patient satisfaction discourage us from recommending the procedure for lesions of the articular cartilage of the patella. The consistent seeding of the joint with carbon-fibre debris and a histiocytic giant-cell reaction in the synovium are also a cause for concern.
We report the theoretical basis of a method to measure axial migration of femoral components of total hip replacements (THR). The use of the top of the greater trochanter and a lateral point on the collar of the stem, allowing for variations of up to 10 degrees rotation of the femur in any direction between successive radiographs, gave a maximum error of 0.37 mm. At a more realistic 5 degrees rotational variation, the error was only 0.13 mm. These data were confirmed in an experimental study using digitisation of points and special software. We also showed that the centre of the femoral head, the stem tip, and the lesser trochanter provided less accurate landmarks. In a second study we digitised a series of radiographs of 51 Charnley and 57 Stanmore THRs; the mean migration rates were found to be identical. We then studied 46 successful stems with a minimum follow-up of eight years and 46 stems which had failed by aseptic loosening at different times. At two years, the successful stems had migrated by a mean of 1.45 +/- 0.68 mm, but the failed cases had a mean migration of 4.32 +/- 2.58 mm (p <
0.0001). Of the successful cases 76% had migrated less than 2 mm, while in the failed group 84% had migrated more than 2 mm. For any particular case migration of more than 2.6 mm at two years had only a 5% chance of continuing success and would therefore merit special follow-up. Only 24% of the eventually successful stems showed migration at the stem-cement interface, but this had happened in every failed stem. We conclude that it would be possible to evaluate a new cemented design of femoral stem over a two-year period by the use of our method and to compare its performance against the reported known standard of the Charnley and Stanmore designs.
We report a high rate of failure of the Ring polyethylene cementless cup caused largely by granulomatous osteolysis. We have reviewed 126 prostheses inserted from 1986 to 1992 at from 11 to 90 months after surgery. There was radiological evidence of osteolytic granulomas adjacent to the external surface of the cup in 32%, appearing on average at three years from operation. In a subgroup of 59 prostheses followed for at least four years the incidence of such changes was 54%. A total of 27 cups (22%) have required revision, 21 for granulomatous loosening at an average follow-up of five years. In the retrieved prostheses there was obvious polyethylene abrasion and histological examination confirmed the presence of polyethylene wear debris. We found no significant correlation of osteolysis with cup size, although smaller cups were predominant among those having revision.
We report a case in which the popliteal artery was divided during upper tibial osteotomy performed with the knee in 90 degrees of flexion. This position is believed to allow it to fall safely back from the tibia, but we could find no published confirmation. We used duplex ultrasonography in ten healthy volunteers to measure the distance from the popliteal artery to the posterior surface of the tibia at various degrees of flexion of the knee. Our results showed that in 12 of 20 knees the popliteal artery was closer to the tibia in 90 degrees of knee flexion than in full extension. Surgeons performing upper tibial osteotomy should be aware that flexing the knee does not protect the popliteal artery from injury.
We describe 83 knees (69 patients) which had had patellectomy for anterior knee pain (52), patellofemoral osteoarthritis (25) or comminuted fractures (6) between 1942 and 1978. The patients were questioned about their symptoms and the function of the operated knee 14 to 50 years after operation. In the group with anterior knee pain, 76% achieved good results and were satisfied with the operation. Only 54% of the osteoarthritis group had satisfactory relief of pain and most had progressive deterioration of function. Sixteen patients who had had unilateral patellectomy were assessed by dynamometry, ultrasound and radiography. The average quadriceps muscle power was 60% of that on the normal side although two patients had stronger muscles in their operated than in their unoperated legs.
We measured joint position sense in the knee by a new method which tests the proprioceptive contribution of the joint capsule and ligaments. The leg was supported on a splint, and held in several positions of flexion. The subjects' perception of the position was recorded on a visual analogue model and compared with the actual angle of flexion. Eighty-one normal and 45 osteoarthritic knees were examined, as were 10 knees with semi-constrained and 11 with hinged joint replacements. All were assessed with and without an elastic bandage around the knee. There was a steady decline in joint position sense with age in subjects with normal knees. Those with osteoarthritic knees had impaired joint position sense at all ages (p less than 0.001). Knee replacement improved the joint position sense slightly (p less than 0.02); semi-constrained replacement had a greater effect than hinged replacement. The effect of an elastic bandage in subjects with poor position sense was dramatic, improving accuracy by 40% (p less than 0.001). It is proposed that reduced proprioception in elderly and osteoarthritic subjects may be responsible for initiation or advancement of degeneration of the knee.