With the increasing number of implantation of total ankle arthroplasty a higher rate of pitfalls and failures has to be expected. Intra- and postoperative complications in total ankle arthroplasty, their sources of failure and revision options are demonstrated. In the time of 7/97 until 1/06 269 S.T.A.R. total ankle prostheses have been implanted at our hospital. Intraoperative complications occurred in 7 cases (4 fractures of the malleolus medialis, 2 fractures of distal fibula, 1 fissure of talus). We observed early complications in form of delayed wound healing (n=31) and 4 deep infections. A higher incidence of secondary wound healing is shown in rheumatoid arthritis patients in comparison to patients with OA. Late complications included persisting intraarticular synovitis, especially in rheumatoid arthritis, an impingement (11 cases) and osteolysis (4 cases). Revision surgery was performed in 45 cases (16.7%) 1.5 years after primary implantation (14 operations with problems in secondary wound healing, 9 lengthenings of the Achilles tendon with a dorsal capsulotomy (2 rheumatoid arthritis patients), 11 revisions of the PE gliding core with resection of periarticular hypertrophic bone formation, 4 revisions of singular components, 2 complete revisions of the prosthesis, 4 ankle fusions, 1 amputation. Only in 18 cases (6.7%) these complications and the following surgical procedures influenced the satisfaction of the patients. Despite the demonstrated complications, total ankle arthroplasty is more than an alternative to open ankle arthrodesis in the progressive phases of arthritic joint destruction, also in RA at a LDE stage ≥ III.
The increase of ROM in all patients is 17.9 (RA: 18.7 /OA: 16.6). Significant pain relief is described by 92.4% of patients, here all the groups showed no significant differences. An increase in the clinical outcome measured by the Kofoeds Ankle Score is seen from <
70 pts. preoperatively (100% of patients) to >
75 pts. postoperatively (82.3% of patients). The most frequent complication especially in patients with RA is a delayed wound healing (19%), but the revision rate is higher in patients with traumatic and idiopathic osteoarthritis (17% OA /13% RA). A secondary arthrodesis has to be performed only in 2 OA cases.
In 1994 Kofoed and Stürup already confirmed that within a follow-up of 10 years total ankle arthroplasty demonstrated a significant clinical improvement for the patients. In recent studies a 12 – year survival rate even of 84% was described (Kofoed, 1995).
In a retrospective study we evaluated the short – and midterm results in 44 patients with unconstrained total ankle arthroplasty and cementless fixation. These ankle replacements were performed between 8/1997 and 12/2000. A critical assessment concerning the indications and contraindications of this arthroplasty was performed due to the fact, that this surgical technique is not yet mentioned as a routinely performed surgical procedure of the ankle. The advantages in comparison to the open or arthroscopically assisted arthrodesis of the ankle were described. As initial diagnosis rheumatoid arthritis (n:16), post-traumatic osteoarthritis (n:10) or idiopathic osteoarthritis of the ankle (n:18) was mentioned. The patients age varied from 24 to 78 years; the 24 years old patient suffered from a posttraumatic osteoarthritis, in the 78 years old patient contralateral total ankle arthroplasty was performed 13 years ago.
There was a delay in superficial wound healing in 11 cases, in 4 cases soft tissue revision and once plastic surgery had to be performed. One female patient with RA had a postoperative deep infection after preoperative radiosynoviorthesis of the ankle. Additionally osteosynthetical reconstruction of the fibula (n:2) and the talus (n:1) was necessary. One patient underwent revisional surgery due to progressive wear and fracture of the polyethylene inlay. Furthermore three patients suffered from continuing instability, that one had a secondary open arthrodesis and two a syndesmoplasty combined with revision of the PE inlay. The radiological examination offered migration and progredient radiolucency lines especially near to the tibial part of the prosthesis in three cases. Nevertheless more than 80% of the patients were satisfied or very satisfied with their ankle arthroplasty, only 4 patients now would have denied the surgical procedure. As main improvements reduction of pain and increased mobility (ROM: >
40°) were mentioned.
The success of total ankle arthroplasty may depend on exact technique, correct hindfoot alignment and sufficient capsuloligamentous stability of the ankle. So this surgical procedure may provide a high rate of functional improvement for the patients and may prevent the probably necessary arthrodesis.
The periprosthetic loss of bone mass may compromise the longevity of femoral stems in THA. The benefit of metaphyseal hydroxyapatite - coating remains controversial. Better Osseo integration is reported by Jaffe and Scott, whereas Dorr considered no clinical or radiographic value for the use of hydroxyapatite.
Evaluating the influence of this hydroxyapatite - coating of the femoral stems a double blind, randomized prospective study with two groups of uncemented total hip replacements using the Endoplus-SL-Plus-stem was conducted. Matched pairs with and without hydroxy-apatite-coating were compared clinically, radiographically and by QDR-bone-densitometry for 5 years with an average follow-up of 3, 7 years. 92 new hydroxylapatite-coated titanium stems and 90 non-coated stems were implanted. Main indications were an osteoarthritic (primary osteoarthritis / hip dysplasia / femur head necrosis: n = 134 (73, 6%) destruction or a postinflammatory arthritic destruction due to a rheumatoid arthritis (n = 48 ( 26, 4%))
The HA-coated stems showed a statistical significant increase in bone mineral density in Gruen zone 1 (789 g/cm2 vs. 711 g/cm2
The titanium/hydroxyapatite-coating enables a better early osteointegration of the