Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 2 of 2
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 97-B, Issue SUPP_6 | Pages 1 - 1
1 May 2015
Franklin M Carley S Callaghan M
Full Access

Of those foot and ankle injuries requiring radiographs based on the Ottawa Foot and Ankle Rules only approximately 22% will have a fracture.

This diagnostic cohort study examined if ultrasound could detect acute non-bony foot and ankle injuries. Ottawa Rules positive patients over 16 years were eligible. An ED member performed scans for injury of tendons and ligaments blind to radiograph findings. Patients without fracture were re-scanned at 2 weeks. The Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), a validated, patient-reported outcome measure, was completed at baseline (based on pre-injury status), 2 and 6 weeks.

110 subjects participated. 99 did not have significant radiological fractures. FAOS scores were significantly different at 2 weeks compared with baseline across all subscales (p< 0.000). At 6 weeks a significant difference persisted between scores for the ‘Pain’, ‘Sport’ and ‘QOL’ subscales (p<0.043, p<0.000, p<0.000 respectively) compared with baseline. Initial post-injury USS Anterior Talofibular Ligament (ATFL) findings were significantly predictive of FAOS Subscale results for ‘Symptoms’, ‘Sport’ and ‘QOL’ - respective p values being p<0.004 95% CI (−20.184, −4.402), p<0.029 95% CI (−31.857, −1.896) and p<0.008 95% CI (−32.118, −5.561).

ATFL ultrasound status at the time of injury predicts patient perceived sporting function at 6 weeks.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 480 - 480
1 Nov 2011
Canagasabey M Callaghan M Carley S
Full Access

Introduction: Foot and ankle injuries are common in the Emergency Department (ED)1. Of those which require radiographs, in accordance with the Ottawa Foot and Ankle Rules, approximately 22% have a fracture.2 In the last decade ultrasound has been developing as a tool for emergency musculoskeletal assessment – it is inexpensive, rapid and visualises soft tissue and bony structures.

Methods: This diagnostic cohort study was designed to determine whether ultrasound could detect acute bony and non-bony foot and ankle injuries. Ottawa Rules positive patients over 16 year of age without obvious dislocation/compound fracture were eligible. An ultrasound scan (USS) for bony injury was performed by a member of the ED, blinded to radiographic findings. Patient management was determined according to the radiographs. Significant fractures were defined as a breadth greater than 3 mm (as per the Ottawa Foot & Ankle Rules study group)3. All radiographic reporting was conducted blind to the results of the USS. All USS operators received a specific 2-day training in musculoskeletal ultrasound prior to the trial.

Results: One hundred and ten subjects were recruited. eleven had significant radiological fractures, ten of which were seen on ultrasound. The single missed fracture arose due to the operator not scanning proximally enough on the fibula. On re-scanning following radiographic review the fracture was clearly seen on ultrasound. To date the sensitivity of USS is 90.9%, with 95% CI (65.7, 98.3). The specificity is 90.9% with 95% CI (88.1, 91.7). The positive predictive value is 0.526, with a 95% CI (0.380, 0.569). The negative predictive value is 0.989, with a 95% CI (0.959, 0.998). The positive likelihood ratio is 10.00, with a 95% CI (5.526, 11.901) and the negative likelihood ratio is 0.100, with a 95% CI (0.018, 0.389).

Conclusion: Our pilot study demonstrates that ultrasound shows great promise for the sensitive detection of foot and ankle fractures.