OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY: Metatarsal osteotomies are common procedures for correction of hallux valgus. The aim of this study is to compare linear distal metatarsal osteotomy (LDMO) with SCARF osteotomy a clinical prospective randomised study.

METHODS: Forty patients affected by bilateral hallux valgus similar in both sides regarding clinical and radiographic assessment were included. X-rays, AOFAS, Maryland Foot Score (MFS) were considered before surgery up to 4 years follow-up. All patients were operated bilaterally, and received SCARF osteotomy in one side, and in the other LDMO performed through a 1 cm skin incision under the direct view control. Duration of surgery was recorded. Postoperative care was similar in both groups and consisted of gauze bondage and weight bearing with talus shoes for 4 weeks.

RESULTS: No statistical differences were observed in preoperative HVA, IMA, PASA in both groups. Average surgical time was 17 minutes in SCARF and 3 minutes in LDMO (p< 0.0005). No complications were observed in the series, with no wound dehiscence. All osteotomies healed. At 4 year follow up, no statistical differences were observed in HVA, IMA, PASA comparing SCARF with LDMO. Average AOFAS score was 87±12 in SCARF and 89±10 in LDMO (p=0.07), and MFS was 86±7 in SCARF and 90±3 in SERI (p=0.08).

CONCLUSION: Both SCARF and LDMO techniques resulted effective in the correction of hallux valgus, however SERI, a minimally invasive technique, performed with a shorter skin incision, more rapid surgical time, fixed with a less expensive device (one kirshner wire), resulted in a better clinical outcome.

INTRODUCTION: Distal metatarsal osteotomies have been described for surgical treatment of hallux valgus with good results. The aim of this study is to review the results of our first 1000 consecutive hallux valgus cases treated by minimally invasive distal metatarsal osteotomy, SERI (Simple Effective Rapid Inexpensive).

MATERIAL AND METHODS: 1000 feet in 641 patients (359 bilateral), aged between 20 and 65 years (mean 49) affected by hallux valgus without arthritis were studied. Inclusion criteria were deformity less than 40° and intermetatarsal angle up to 18°. A 1-cm medial incision at the metatarsal neck, and a complete osteotomy were performed using an oscillating saw. With the naked eye all characteristics of the deformity were corrected by displacement of the metatarsal head (HVA, IMA, PASA, dorsal or plantar displacement). The osteotomy was stabilized by a 2-mm Kirschner wire. Immediate weight bearing was allowed with gauze bandage and talus shoes for 4 weeks. All patients were checked at an average follow-up of 37 months.

RESULTS: All osteotomies healed, delayed consolidation was observed in 25 feet. Slight stiffness was observed in 31 feet. Mean AOFAS score was 48+15 pre-op and 89+13 at follow up. The pre-op HVA was 32+8, while at follow-up it was 18+8 (p< 0.005), pre-op IMA was 14+3, while at follow-up it was 6+4 (p< 0.005), the pre-op PASA was 21+9, while at follow-up was 9+8(p< 0.005).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: SERI osteotomy was simple, effective, rapid and inexpensive in correcting hallux valgus deformity. Clinical and radiographical findings showed an adequate correction of the deformity.

INTRODUCTION: Displaced comminuted intra-articular calcaneal fractures (DCCF) need anatomic reduction to avoid painful subtalar joint, deformities, tendon or nerve impingment. Open reduction and internal fixation has been extensively reported, but all series reported considerable rate of skin complications, infections and need of additional plastic procedure. The aim of this study is to review a series of DCCF operated by minimally invasive technique.

MATERIAL AND METHODS: 66 DCCF type Sanders II-III were selected in 63 patients aged 18–57 years. X-ray and CT scan were performed. Surgery consisted of percutaneous traction-reduction of the calcaneal body by bone forceps and fixation by K-wires under image intensifier. Then, a lateral 3 cm skin incision was performed to reduce subtalar joint and to fix it by 1 or 2 screws. In case of involvement of the calcano-cuboid joint, the incision was distally extended and a 4-hole plate was applied. K-wires were removed 5 weeks after surgery and weight bearing was permitted 12–16 weeks after surgery. Patients were evaluated clinically by AOFAS score and radiographically at 4 years follow-up (3–7).

RESULTS: No skin complications or infections were encountered in the series. All fractures healed. Mean postoperative Bohler angle was 29±5°. AOFAS score was 89±11. 31 cases were excellent, 22 good, 9 fair and 4 poor. 25 cases presented radiographic signs of subtalar joint arthritis, painful only in 4.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Minimally invasive surgical treatment resulted adequate for treating DCCF, in fact if soft tissues are preserved by surgical trauma, dangerous complications like infections and skin problems can be avoided.