Deterioration in knee joint proprioception has been postulated to occur following injury, resulting in further instability due to disruption of receptors and feedback mechanisms. Surgical reconstruction techniques may also influence post-operative proprioceptive ability (PA). We hypothesised that anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction techniques which disrupt the knee capsule would result in a decrease in PA.

Following ethical approval, a total of 48 subjects (mean age: 28.1 ± 10.5, 34 male, 14 female) undergoing ACL reconstruction surgery were included in the study. Fifteen subjects underwent “open” capsule ACL surgery and patellar tendon graft, whereas 33 subjects had “closed” capsule surgery with a hamstring tendon graft. Knee proprioception was measured on a custom-designed test apparatus incorporating electromagnetic position sensors (Polhemus Fastrack) located on femoral and tibial landmarks to accurately track knee angle during flexion-extension (no load). Leg flexion-extension under partial weight-bearing (5kg) was also evaluated. Pre-operative PA was assessed bilaterally, and then again on operated joints at three, six and twelve months post-op. Proprioceptive ability was measured as the cumulative absolute error in knee angle (°) between five repeat measurements and a target angle.

We observed no significant difference in PA between injured and contralateral knees prior to ACL reconstruction. Post-operatively, no significant difference in PA was observed between “open” versus “closed” ACL techniques, irrespective of loading conditions. While trends indicated that PA during knee extension (no load) and leg flexion (partial weight-bearing) improved over the 12 months compared to pre-operative values in closed ACL surgery, these were not significantly different to open ACL results.

The proportion of subjects whose PA improved in at least two out of the three post-op evaluations was also similar (approx 50%) across all groups, irrespective of joint loading. The only difference was PA during leg flexion under partial weight bearing, where 27% of open ACL surgery patients showed improvement in two or more follow-up tests, as opposed to 58% of closed ACL surgery patients.

We present a method to determine pre- and postoperative PA during knee flexion/extension under no load as well as under partial weight-bearing. We saw no significant difference in PA of the knee under no-load versus load. We also saw no significant difference in postoperative PA following open capsule, patellar tendon graft versus closed capsule, hamstring tendon graft ACL reconstruction technique after 1 year follow-up.

Recent studies have assessed operative skill in surgical trainees “objectively” based on patient outcomes by attempting to statistically separate many contributory variables. Compression hip screw fixation (CHS) for neck of femur fracture (#NOF) is a standard operation commonly performed by orthopaedic trainees of varying experience. Our aim was to determine if trainees could be assessed objectively on their efficiency and aptitude in performance of this operation. A secondary aim was to evaluate the predictors of fixation failure for CHS described in the literature.

Records and radiographs for all CHS performed by trainees of all levels for acute adult #NOF were examined retrospectively for 2 calendar years. Preoperative patient and fracture variables were scored. Outcome measures included operative time, scores of accuracy of fracture reduction and fixation, blood loss and complications. Failure of fixation was compared to the scores given to radiographs. Multivariate analysis was used to apportion variance between multiple contributing factors.

Three hundred and eight two eligible operations were performed by 26 trainees. Operative time was effected by fracture complexity, trainee level and trainee operator (all p< 0.05). “Tip apex distance”, a measure of depth and centrality of screw placement in the femoral head, known to predict screw cut out was associated with trainee operator. Other outcome scores of fixation on radiographs were not correlated with fracture, patient or operator variables. Blood loss and complications were not associated with operator. The rate of failure of fixation was low and associated with scores of reduction quality only (p< 0.05).

Trainees of variable experience perform CHS with a low overall complication rate and the most noticeable performance difference seems to be in speed of surgery.