First-time revision acetabular components have a 36% re-revision rate at 10 years in Australia, with subsequent revisions known to have even worse results. Acetabular component migration >1mm at two years following revision THA is a surrogate for long term loosening. This study aimed to measure the migration of porous tantalum components used at revision surgery and investigate the effect of achieving press-fit and/or three-point fixation within acetabular bone.

Between May 2011 and March 2018, 55 patients (56 hips; 30 female, 25 male) underwent acetabular revision THR with a porous tantalum component, with a post-operative CT scan to assess implant to host bone contact achieved and Radiostereometric Analysis (RSA) examinations on day 2, 3 months, 1 and 2 years. A porous tantalum component was used because the defects treated (Paprosky IIa:IIb:IIc:IIIa:IIIb; 2:6:8:22:18; 13 with pelvic discontinuity) were either deemed too large or in a position preventing screw fixation of an implant with low coefficient of friction. Press-fit and three-point fixation of the implant was assessed intra-operatively and on postoperative imaging.

Three-point acetabular fixation was achieved in 51 hips (92%), 34 (62%) of which were press-fit. The mean implant to host bone contact achieved was 36% (range 9-71%). The majority (52/56, 93%) of components demonstrated acceptable early stability. Four components migrated >1mm proximally at two years (1.1, 3.2, 3.6 and 16.4mm). Three of these were in hips with Paprosky IIIB defects, including 2 with pelvic discontinuity. Neither press-fit nor three-point fixation was achieved for these three components and the cup to host bone contact achieved was low (30, 32 and 59%).

The majority of porous tantalum components had acceptable stability at two years following revision surgery despite treating large acetabular defects and poor bone quality. Components without press-fit or three-point fixation were associated with unacceptable amounts of early migration.

First-time revision acetabular components have a 36% re-revision rate at 10 years in Australia, with subsequent revisions known to have even worse results. Acetabular component migration >1mm at two years following revision THA is a surrogate for long term loosening. This study aimed to measure the migration of porous tantalum components used at revision surgery and investigate the effect of achieving press-fit and/or three-point fixation within acetabular bone.

Between May 2011 and March 2018, 55 patients (56 hips; 30 female, 25 male) underwent acetabular revision THR with a porous tantalum component, with a post-operative CT scan to assess implant to host bone contact achieved and Radiostereometric Analysis (RSA) examinations on day 2, 3 months, 1 and 2 years. A porous tantalum component was used because the defects treated (Paprosky IIa:IIb:IIc:IIIa:IIIb; 2:6:8:22:18; 13 with pelvic discontinuity) were either deemed too large or in a position preventing screw fixation of an implant with low coefficient of friction. Press-fit and three-point fixation of the implant was assessed intra-operatively and on postoperative imaging.

Three-point acetabular fixation was achieved in 51 hips (92%), 34 (62%) of which were press-fit. The mean implant to host bone contact achieved was 36% (range 9–71%). The majority (52/56, 93%) of components demonstrated acceptable early stability. Four components migrated >1mm proximally at two years (1.1, 3.2, 3.6 and 16.4mm). Three of these were in hips with Paprosky IIIB defects, including 2 with pelvic discontinuity. Neither press-fit nor three-point fixation was achieved for these three components and the cup to host bone contact achieved was low (30, 32 and 59%).

The majority of porous tantalum components had acceptable stability at two years following revision surgery despite treating large acetabular defects and poor bone quality. Components without press-fit or three-point fixation were associated with unacceptable amounts of early migration.

Introduction

Severely comminuted, displaced acetabular fractures with articular impaction in the elderly population present significant treatment challenges. To allow early post-operative rehabilitation and limit the sequelae of immobility, treatment with acute total hip replacement (THA) has been advocated in selected patients. Achieving primary stability of the acetabular cup without early migration is challenging and there is no current consensus on the optimum method of acetabular reconstruction. We present clinical results and radiostereometric analysis of trabecular metal (TM) cup cage construct reconstruction in immediate THA without acetabular fracture fixation.

Acetabular components used to treat large defects are at greater risk of loosening. Porous tantalum acetabular components have reported the most promising early to midterm revision rates. Early stability of acetabular components used at revision THR was shown to be a good predictor of later loosening. The primary aim was to assess the migration of porous acetabular component used to reconstruct severe acetabular defects. Secondarily, we investigated the effect of acetabular defect severity and type of component fixation on migration.

Radiosterometric analysis was used to measure migration at a mean follow-up of four years, (range 2–10) in 59 reconstructions of severe acetabular defects with porous tantalum components. Acetabular component fixation was classified as superior if augmented with screws through cup, augments or cage in the ilium only. Fixation was classified as combined, superior and inferior, if flanges and/or screws were also placed in the ischium and or pubis. Acceptable limits of proximal migration were defined as ≤1mm within 2 years and ≤2.5mm at any time point.

Eight hips had reconstruction of Paprosky II defects with superior fixation only. The mean proximal migration of the eight acetabular components was 0.25mm (0.08–0.40) at 2 years and 0.29mm (0.10–0.81) at last follow-up.

Fifty-one hips had reconstruction of Paprosky III defects. Seven of these reconstructions exceeded the migration thresholds. Five reconstructions (four with superior fixation and one cup cage construct with no inferior screw fixation) of hips with pelvic discontinuity developed pain and were re-revised for loosening. Two reconstructions are asymptomatic and migrated 2.68mm (cup-cage construct with superior screws) and 2.86mm (no pelvic discontinuity, superior fixation) at final follow-up. The mean proximal migration of the 51 Paprosky III reconstructions was 0.99mm (0.03 to 16.4) at 2 years and 1.92mm (0.01 to 29.4) at last follow-up. The mean proximal translation at 2 years of the 11 reconstructions with inferior screw fixation was 0.2mm (−0.6 to 0.7mm), compared with 0.9mm (−0.6 to 16.4mm) for the reconstructions without inferior screw fixation.

In conclusion, when used to reconstruct Paprosky II defects, porous tantalum acetabular components provide component stability similar to a good performing primary THR. These implants achieve adequate stability when used to treat Paprosky III defects, including those with pelvic discontinuity. For the most severe defects, combined fixation with inferior screws is recommended, particularly when reconstructing hips with pelvic discontinuity.