Understanding the cause of failure of total knee arthroplasties (TKA) is essential in guiding clinical decision making and adjusting treatment concepts for revision surgery. The purpose of the study was to determine current mechanisms of failure of TKA and to describe changes and trends in revision surgery over the last 10 years. A retrospective review was done on all patients who had revision total knee arthroplasty during a 10-year period (2000–2009) at one institution. The preoperative evaluation in conjunction with the intraoperative findings was used to determine causes of failure. All procedures were categorizes as Sharkey et al. described previously. The data was analyzed regarding the cause of failure and displaying the incidence and trends over the last 10 years. 1225 surgeries were done in the time period with a steady increase of procedures per year (34 procedures in 2000 to 196 in 2009). The most common cause of revision TKA was aseptic failure in 65% and septic failure in 31% of the reviewed cases. However, we could observe a steady proportional increase of the septic classified revisions over the time. Both categories could be subdivided to specific causes of failure including aseptic loosening (24%), anterior knee pain (20%), instability (6,4%), arthrofibrosis (4,9%), PE wear (3,6%), malpositioning/malrotation (2,7%) periprosthetic fracture (2,0%) and other (4,6%), or in early (12,9%), late (15,4%) or low-grade infection (3,3%), respectively. Complementary to the classification Sharkey et al. described in 2002 we identified new subcategories of failure: malrotation (since 2003), Low-Grade-Infection (since 2006), allergic failure/loosening (since 2006), Mid-Flexion-Instability (since 2007), soft tissue impingement (since 2009). The incidence of the classic aseptic loosening due to PE wear shows a clear decrease in the last 10 years whereas we could observe an increase of the new diagnosis of instability, malrotation or low-grade-infection as determined cause of failure. The detailed analysis of the failure mechanism in total knee arthroplasty is important to understand the clinical problem and to adjust treatment strategies. We were able to complement present classifications and give a first overview on the incidence for specific causes of failure. Our data shows changes in the indication for surgery over the time and compared to the collective of Sharkey et al. from 1997–2000. This might be due to new diagnostic methods and better implant materials as well as to a generally increased awareness of the specific mechanism of TKA failure