Aluminia ceramic on ceramic (COC) bearing surfaces have been used for 35 years in total hip arthroplasty (THA). Studies report 85% survival at a minimum follow-up of 18.5 years. Nonetheless, an audible noise is a finding associated with COC bearings with incidence rates of 2–10%. This study aims to determine the prevalence of noise and evaluate its effect on patients. All patients who had a COC THA from August 2003 to December 2010 were contacted and asked to complete a standardised questionnaire. This asked about the presence and characteristics of a noise and if associated with activities, pain and whether this phenomenon should be mentioned preoperatively. Four consultant surgeons performed 282 consecutive primary COC THAs in 258 patients. (Male=122, Female=136 mean age 68.5; age range 28–88). In all cases, the same brand of ceramic acetabular component and stems were implanted. 11.0% had a noise, of which 5.5% had a squeak. Pain was experienced in 38.7% of patients in hips that made a noise. There was no trauma and one dislocation in this group. In this study, 85% of noises occur during weight-bearing although no patients have reduced daily activities as a result of the noises. Of all the patients, 55.0% stated they would have preferred to have known about a noisy hip possibility before consenting but none would have refused consent. Squeaking has not been a problem here despite the prevalence being higher than most in the literature. The authors recommend that squeaking should be discussed preoperatively. A checklist for Orthopaedic Trainees is being drafted to enable trainees to counsel patients appropriately, allowing patients a better opportunity to give informed consent

Ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) total hip arthroplasty (THA) can produce articular noise during the normal activities, generating discomfort to the patient. THA noise has to be investigated also as a potential predictor and a clinical sign of prosthetic failure. An observational study has been carried out to characterize the noise in CoC cementless THA, and to analyze the related factors. A total of 46 patients with noisy hip have been enrolled in 38 months, within the follow-up protocol normally applied for the early diagnosis of ceramic liner fracture [1]. Noise recording was based on a high-quality audible recorder (mod. LS 3, Olympus, Japan) and a portable ultrasonic transducer (mod USB AE 1ch, PAC, USA). The sensors for noise recording were applied to the hip of the patient during a sequence of repeatable motorial activities (forward and backward walking, squat, sit in a chair, flexion and extension of the leg). Sessions were also video-recorded to associate the noise emission to the specific movements. Each noise event was initially identified by the operator and therefore classified by comparison to the spectral characteristics (duration, intensity and frequency) of the main noise types. Number and spectral characteristics of noise events were obtained and correlated to the factors describing the clinical status of the patient, the surgical approach, the prosthetic device implanted. The study investigated also the noise as a sign of implant failure, by comparison with the total number of implants failed in the cohort during the study. We observed three types of noise with the main spectral characteristics in agreement to the literature: clicking, squeaking and popping. Among the identified types of noise, squeaking showed the longest duration and the highest amplitude. The 63% of hip presented the emission of just one type of noise, while the remaining a mix of types. The movement with the highest presence of noise was walking, followed by squat. Correlation was found between the noise type and the dimension of the ceramic head (p<0.001), with the sizes of 32 mm more affected by squeaking that the smaller one. Squeaking appeared before during the follow-up than the other types of noise. The 35% (16/46) of the noisy hips were revised during the study. Among the revised hips, the 81% (13/16) were affected by impingement and/or severe damage of the prosthetic components. The antiversion of the cup (p=0.008), the presence of debris in the synovial fluid (p=0.021) and the average frequency of squeaking (p=0.006) were significant predictors for the revision, but it has to be mentioned that the squeaking data was obtained on a small subset of revised patients. Ultrasonic analysis did not show significant correlations. The study presented and validated an experimental procedure to analyze noisy hips in clinical trials. Noise is confirmed to be a significant parameter in the follow-up evaluation of ceramic THA

Objectives

Our study aimed to examine not only the incidence but also the impact of noise from two types of total hip replacement articulations: ceramic-on-ceramic and ceramic-on-polyethylene.