Background. Impaction bone grafting with milled human allograft is the gold standard for replacing lost bone stock during revision hip surgery. Problems surrounding the use of allograft include cost, availability, disease transmission and stem subsidence (usually due to shear failure of the surrounding allograft). Aims. To investigate various polymers for use as substitute allograft. The ideal graft would be a composite with similar mechanical characteristics as allograft, and with the ability to form de novo bone. Methods. High and low molecular weight (MW) forms of three different polymers (polylactic acid (PLA), poly (lactic-co-glycolic) acid (PLGA) and polycaprolactone (PCL)) were milled, impacted into discs, and then tested in a custom built shear testing rig, and compared to allograft. A second stage of the experiment involved the addition of skeletal stem cells (SSC) to each of the milled polymers, impaction, 8 days incubation, and then tests for cell viability and number, via fluorostaining and biochemical (WST-1, DNA) assays. Results. The shear strengths of both high/ low MW PLA, and high/low MW PLGA were significantly higher than those of milled allograft but high and low MW PCL was poor to impact, and had significantly lower shear strengths. Fluorostaining showed good cell survival on high MW PLA, high MW PCL and both high and low MW PLGA. These findings were confirmed on both DNA and WST-1 assays. Conclusions. High MW PLA as well as high and low MW PLGA performed well both in mechanical testing and cell compatibility studies. These three polymers are good contenders to produce a living composite for use as substitute human allograft in impaction bone grafting

Background. Skeletal stem cells (SSCs) have been used for the treatment of osteonecrosis of the femoral head to prevent subsequent collapse. In isolation SSCs do not provide structural support but an innovative case series in Southampton, UK, has used SSCs in combination with impaction bone grafting (IBG) to improve both the biological and mechanical environment and to regenerate new bone at the necrotic site. Aims. Analysis of retrieved tissue-engineered bone as part of ongoing follow-up of this translational case series. Methods. With Proof-of-Concept established in vitro and in vivo, the use of a living bone composite of SSCs and allograft has been translated to four patients (five hips) for treatment of osteonecrosis of their femoral heads. Parallel in vitro culture of the implanted cell-graft construct was performed. Patient follow-up was by serial clinical and radiological examination. In one patient collapse occurred in both hips due to more advanced disease than was originally appreciated. This necessitated bilateral hip arthroplasty, but allowed retrieval of the femoral heads. These were analyzed for Type 1 Collagen production, bone morphology, bone density and mechanical strength by micro computed tomography (CT), histology (A/S stain, Collagen Type 1 immunostain, biorefringence) and mechanical testing. Representative sections of cortical, trabecular and tissue engineered bone were excised from the femoral heads using a diamond-tipped saw-blade and tested to failure by axial compression. Results. Parallel in vitro analysis demonstrated sustained cell growth and viability on the allograft. Three patients currently remain asymptomatic at up to three year follow-up. Histological analysis of the two retrieved femoral heads demonstrated, critically, Type 1 collagen production in the regenerated tissue as well as mature trabecular architecture, indicative of de novo tissue engineered bone. The trabecular morphology of regenerated bone was evident on CT, and this had a bone density of 1400 Grey scale units, (compared to 1200 for natural trabecular bone and 1800 for cortical bone). On axial compressive testing the regenerated bone on the left showed a 24.8% increase in compressive strength compared to ipsilateral normal trabecular bone, and a 22.9% increase on the left. Conclusions. Retrieval analysis data has demonstrated the translational potential of a living bone composite, while ongoing clinical follow-up shows this to be an effective new treatment for osteonecrosis of the femoral head. Regeneration of the necrotic bone may prevent subsequent collapse, thereby delaying, or possibly avoiding, the need for hip arthroplasty in early stage osteonecrosis. Evaluation of this tissue engineering construct has confirmed the potential for clinical treatment of bone defects using SSC based strategies