Controversy remains as to whether the contralateral hip should be fixed in patients presenting with unilateral slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE). This study compares the outcomes of those patients who had prophylactic fixation with those who did not. We identified 90 consecutive patients with a mean age of 12.3 years presenting to the study centre with SCFE from a prospective operative database. The patient's notes and radiographs were retrospectively analysed for post-operative complications, re-presentation with a contralateral slip, and the presence of a cam lesion. The mean length of follow-up was 8 years (range 3 to 13). Fifty patients (56%) underwent unilateral fixation and 40 patients underwent bilateral fixation, of which 4 (4%) patients had simultaneous bilateral SCFE and 36 (40%) had prophylactic fixation of the contralateral hip. Twenty-three patients (46%) that underwent unilateral fixation, went onto have contralateral fixation for a further SCFE. Two patients from this group had symptomatic femoracetabular impingement from cam lesions and one patient required a Southwick osteotomy for a severe slip. Five patients (10%) that had unilateral fixation only demonstrated cam lesions on radiographic analysis, being suggestive of an asymptomatic slip. No post-operative complications were observed for the contralateral hip in patients that had prophylactic screw fixation and no cam lesions were identified on radiographic assessment. This study suggests that the contralateral hip in patients presenting with unilateral SCFE should be routinely offered prophylactic fixation to avoid a further slip, which may be severe, and the morbidity associated with a secondary cam lesion

Prophylactic fixation of the contralateral hip in cases of unilateral slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) remains contentious. Our senior author reported a 10 year series in 2006 that identified a rate of subsequent contralateral slip of 25percnt; when prophylactic fixation was not performed. This led to a change in local practice and employment of prophylactic fixation as standard. We report the 10 year outcomes following this change in practice. A prospective study of all patients who presented with diagnosis of SCFE between 2004 and 2014 in our region. Intra-operative complication and post-operative complication were the primary outcomes. 31 patients presented during the study period: 16 male patients and 15 female patients. The mean age was 12.16 (8–16, SD 2.07). 25 patients had stable SCFE and 5 had unstable SCFE. Stability was uncertain in 1 patient. 25 patients had unilateral SCFE and 6 had bilateral SCFE. 24 patients who had unilateral SUFE had contralateral pinning performed. 1 unilateral SCFE did not have contralateral pinning performed as there was partial fusion of physis on contralateral side. In the hips fixed prophylactically there was 1 cases of transient intraoperative screw penetration into the joint and 1 case of minor wound dehiscence. There were no cases or chondrolysis or AVN. There were no further contralateral slips. This change in practice has been adopted with minimal complication. The fixation of the contralateral side is not without risk but by adopting this model the risk of subsequent slip has been reduced from 25percnt; to 0percnt;

Twenty-three patients with thirty hips of slipped capital femoral epiphysis were treated in our department, KK Women's and Children's Hospital, Singapore between 1997 and 2005. Except one patient lost of follow-up, twenty-four SCFEs with more than 2 years (25 to 73 months, average 38.5 months) follow-up were reviewed. This study is to evaluate the effectiveness and outcome of our protocol: Russell traction followed by gentle manipulative reduction with a single screw fixation & spica cast immobilization (for acute-on-chronic cases with unstable and reducible SCFE). In this series, there were 13 boys & 5 girls, mean age 12 year old ranging from 10 to 14 years. Among them 7 were Chinese, 6 Malays & 5 Indians. There were 12 unilateral cases (8 on the left & 4 right, 67%) & 6 bilateral cases (33%), including 2 patients found contralateral SCFE subsequently 1 year postoperatively. Acute-on-chronic SCFE were 16 & chronic SCFE 8. 16 were Grate I & 8 Grate II. Russell traction was on preoperatively with an average of 6 days. Gentle manipulative reduction under general anesthesia was performed in 20 SCFEs (12 GI & 8 GII) and 17 of them were successful. Fixation with a single screw was used for all cases except one hip with 2 screws. Average follow-up was 38.5 months. Good results achieved. All patient were symptom free with good function. No complications of AVN, chondrolysis, screw loosening and reslipping of the affective hips. Our protocol of management for SCFE has been largely successful in term of manipulative reduction and fixation

Slipped capital femoral epiphysiolysis (SCFE) is a rare condition with a unknown aetiopathogenesis. An early diagnosis and treatment is essential to minimize premature degeneration of the joint. The authors reviewed the cases treated between 1980 and 2005 in our institution. This study was aimed at evaluating patients with hip epiphysiolysis surgically treated by canullated screws or pinning and previously controlled by short-term follow-up, in order to evaluate radiographic medium/ long term evolution, looking for evidence of degenerative arthritis or femoroacetabular impingement. We performed a retrospective review of the clinical notes and radiographs of all patients with slipped upper femoral epiphysis who were surgically treated at our institution between January 1980 and December 2005. These patients performed radiographs to detect evidence of osteonecrosis, chondrolysis, degenerative arthritis or femoroacetabular impingment. To grade the radiological osteoarthritic changes the grading system of Kellgren and Lawrence was used. These changes were correlated with the existence of femoroacetabular impingement. The radiological results were correlated with the Loder'sclassification of stability and the morphological classification. 43 patients were reviewed, corresponding to 47 treated hips. AP and Lowenstein x-ray views were taken in all patients. The alfa angle and the head-shaft angle were measured in the Lowenstein view (frog-leg). Of 16 patients with impingement only 1 patient didn't present pistol grip deformity. 4 contralateral hips also presented the deformity. The mean alfa angle was 99,4. 43% of the patients with unstable hips have impingment. In stable hips this percentage is of 35%. The Patrick test was positive in 30% of the hips with SCFE and only 17% of the unafected hips. The Kellgren and Lawrence scale was very diferent between trhe SCFE and control groups, with 43% grade 2, 17% grade 3 and 6% grade 4, versus 30% grade 2, 6% grade 3 and 0% grade 4. Some patients show bilateral pistol grip deformity and clinical signs of impingment, despite only having one hip with SCFE