This study reports the clinical and sonographic
outcome of arthroscopic rotator cuff repair in patients aged ≥ 70 years
and aimed to determine factors associated with re-tear. A total
of 69 consecutive repairs were performed in 68 patients with a mean
age of 77 years (70 to 86). Constant-Murley scores were collected
pre-operatively and at one year post-operatively. The integrity
of the repair was assessed using ultrasound. Re-tear was detected
in 20 of 62 patients (32%) assessed with ultrasound. Age at operation We conclude that arthroscopic rotator cuff repair in patients
aged ≥ 70 years is a successful procedure. The gender and age of
the patient are important factors to consider when planning management. Cite this article:
A prospective study was carried out to determine if recognised histological features seen at surgery could help predict those rotator cuff tendon repairs which re-ruptured. 40 rotator cuff tendon edge specimens from 40 patients’ shoulders were analysed histologically following routine mini-open rotator cuff repair. 32/40 underwent Ultrasonography, at a mean time of 35 months post-operatively, to determine repair integrity. The histological features seen at surgery were then compared to the repair integrity of the tendon from which it had been taken.
Economic evaluation of surgical procedures is necessary in view of emerging, often more expensive newer techniques and the budget constraints in an increasingly cost conscious NHS. The purpose of the study was to compare the cost effectiveness of open cuff repair with arthroscopic repair for moderate size tears. This was a prospective study involving 20 patients. Ten had an arthroscopic repair and 10 had an open procedure. Effectiveness was measured by pre and post-operative Oxford scores. The patients also had Constant scores done. Costs were estimated from the departmental and hospital financial data.
Eighteen Arthroscopic and nine mini-open
Arthroscopic
The purpose of this study is to report the 1 to 5 year results of arthroscopic
Obesity is associated with poor outcomes and increased risk of failure after rotator cuff (RC) repair surgery. The effect of diet-induced obesity (DIO) on enthesis healing has not been well characterised and whether its effects can be reversed with dietary intervention is unknown. We hypothesised that DIO would result in inferior enthesis healing in a rat model of RC repair and that dietary intervention in the peri-operative period would improve enthesis healing. A total of 78 male Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into three weight-matched groups from weaning and fed either: control diet (CD), high-fat diet (HFD), or HFD until surgery, then CD thereafter (HF-CD). After 12 weeks the left supraspinatus tendon was detached, followed by immediate surgical repair. At 2 and 12 weeks post-surgery, animals were cullers and RCs harvested for biomechanical and histological evaluation. Body composition and metabolic markers were assessed via DEXA and plasma analyses, respectively. DIO was established in the HFD and HF-CD groups prior to surgery, and subsequently reversed in the HF-CD group after surgery. At 12 weeks post-surgery, plasma leptin concentrations were higher in the HFD group compared to the CD group (5.28 vs. 2.91ng/ml, P=0.003). Histologically, the appearance of the repaired entheses was poorer in both the HFD and HF-CD compared to the CD group at 12 weeks (overall histological score 6.20 (P=0.008), 4.98 (P=0.001) and 8.68 out of 15, respectively). The repaired entheses in the HF-CD group had significantly lower (26.4 N, P=0.028) load-at-failure 12 weeks post-surgery compared to the CD group (34.4 N); while the HFD group was low, but not significantly different (28.1 N, P=0.096). Body mass at the time of surgery, plasma leptin and body fat percentage were negatively correlated with histological scores and plasma leptin with load-at-failure 12 weeks post-surgery. DIO impaired enthesis healing in this rat RC repair model, with inferior biomechanical and histological outcomes. Restoring normal weight with dietary change after surgery did not improve healing outcomes. Exploring interventions that improve the metabolic state of obese patients and counselling patients appropriately about their modest expectations after repair should be considered.
This study aims to investigate the mechanical properties of a rotator cuff tear repaired with a polypropylene interposition graft in an ovine infraspinatus ex-vivo model. Twenty fresh shoulders from skeletally mature sheep were used in this study. A tear size of 20 mm from the tendon joint was created in the infraspinatus tendon to simulate a large tear in fifteen specimens. This was repaired with a polypropylene mesh used as an interposition graft between the ends of the tendon. Eight specimens were secured with mattress stitches while seven were secured to the remnant tendon on the greater tuberosity side by continuous stitching. Remaining five specimens with an intact tendon served as a control group. All specimens underwent cyclic loading with a universal testing machine to determine the ultimate failure load and gap distance. Gap distance increased with progressive cyclic loading through 3000 cycles for all repaired specimens. Mean gap distance after 3000 cycles for both continuous and mattress groups are 1.7 mm and 4.2 mm respectively (P = .001). Significantly higher mean ultimate failure load was also observed with 549.2 N in the continuous group, 426.6 N in the mattress group and 370 N in the intact group. The use of a polypropylene mesh as an interposition graft for large irreparable rotator cuff tears is biomechanically suitable and results in a robust repair that is comparable to an intact rotator cuff tendon. When paired with a continuous suturing technique, it demonstrates significantly resultant superior biomechanical properties that may potentially reduce re-tear rates after repairing large or massive rotator cuff tears.
We hypothesised that diet-induced obesity (DIO) would result in inferior enthesis healing in a rat model of rotator cuff (RC) repair and that dietary intervention in the peri-operative period would improve enthesis healing. A total of 78 male Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into three weight-matched groups from weaning and fed either: control diet (CD), high-fat diet (HFD), or HFD until surgery, then CD thereafter (HF-CD). After 12 weeks, the left supraspinatus tendon was detached, followed by immediate surgical repair. At 2 and 12 weeks post-surgery, animals were culled, and RCs harvested for biomechanical and histological evaluation. Body composition and metabolic markers were assessed via DEXA and plasma analyses, respectively. DIO was established in the HFD and HF-CD groups before surgery and subsequently reversed in the HF-CD group after surgery. Histologically, the appearance of the repaired entheses was poorer in both the HFD and HF-CD groups compared with the CD group at 12 weeks after surgery, with semiquantitative scores of 6.2 (P<0.01), 4.98 (P<0.01), and 8.7 of 15, respectively. The repaired entheses in the HF-CD group had a significantly lower load to failure (P=0.03) at 12 weeks after surgery compared with the CD group, while the load to failure in the HFD group was low but not significantly different (P=0.10). Plasma leptin were negatively correlated with histology scores and load to failure at 12 weeks after surgery. DIO impaired enthesis healing in this rat RC repair model, with inferior biomechanical and histological outcomes. Restoring normal weight with dietary change after surgery did not improve healing outcomes. Circulating levels of leptin significantly correlated with poor healing outcomes. This pre-clinical rodent model demonstrates that obesity is a potentially modifiable factor that impairs RC healing and increases the risk of failure after RC surgery.
The purpose of this study was to assess the clinical outcomes of three different rotator cuff repair techniques and to correlate these results with the integrity of the cuff as determined by ultrasonographic evaluation. Three cohorts of patients had repair of a symptomatic rotator cuff tear using:. an open technique with Mitek RC Quickanchor double row, one mattress suture per anchor (n = 49);. arthroscopic knotted Mitek RC Fastin single row, two simple sutures per anchor (n = 53);. arthroscopic knotless with Opus Magnum single row, one inverted mattress suture per anchor (n = 57) by one surgeon. Standardised patient and examiner determined outcomes were obtained prospectively pre-operatively and at 6 weeks, 3 months and 6 months post-operatively. Ultrasound studies were performed with a validated protocol at 6 months post surgery. Arthroscopic knotless repair was, on average,14 minutes faster than both open cuff repair (p<
0.001) and arthroscopic knotted repair (p<
0.01).Clinical outcomes were similar with the exception that the arthroscopic groups had, on average, 20% better ASES scores than the open group at 6 months (p<
0.001). The only complication was re-tear, which correlated with tear size (r=0.5, p<
0.001) and operation time (r=0.3, p<
0.001) and occurred more frequently following open repair (39%) compared with arthroscopic knotted (25%) and arthroscopic knotless (16%) repair (p<
0.01). The retear rates of tears >
8cm2 were significantly greater (p<
0.01) when using an open (88%) or arthroscopic knotted (67%) technique compared to the arthroscopic knotless (25%) cohort.
Several studies showed the efficacy of arthroscopic repair for Type II SLAP lesions without other associated lesions, but the only data reported on the association of arthroscopic repair of Type II SLAP lesion and rotator cuff tears involve young and active patient. To our knowledge, no studies have focused on patients over 50. We evaluated the results of a randomized controlled trial of arthroscopic repair in patients over 50 with rotator cuff tears and Type II SLAP lesion in whom the repair was effected repairing the two lesions, or repairing the rotator cuff tears and performing a tenotomy of the long head of the biceps. We recruited 63 patients. In 31 patients, we repaired the rotator cuff and the Type II SLAP lesion (Group 1). In the other 32 patients, we repaired the rotator cuff and tenotomized the long head of the biceps (Group 2). 7 patients (2 in the group 1 and 5 in the group 2) were lost to final follow up. A modified UCLA shoulder rating scale was used to evaluate pre-operative and post-operative shoulder pain, function, active forward flexion, strength and patient satisfaction. Of 63 patients randomized to one of the two treatments, 5.2 year results were available for 56. 7 patients (2 in the group 1 and 5 in the group 2) did not return at the final follow up. Statistically significant differences were seen with respect to the UCLA score and ROM values at final follow-up In Group 1 (SLAP repair and rotator cuff repair), the UCLA showed a statistically significant improvement from a pre-operative average rating of 10.4 (range 6 to 14) to an average of 27.9 (24–35) postoperatively (P<
0.001). In Group 2 (biceps tenotomy and rotator cuff repair), the UCLA showed a statistically significant improvement from a pre-operative average rating of 10.1 (range 5 to 14) to an average of 32.1 (range 30 to 35) post-operatively (P<
0.001) There was statistically significant difference in total post-operative UCLA scores and ROM when comparing the two groups post-operatively (P<
0.05). Arthroscopic management has been recommended for some SLAP lesions, but no studies have focused on patients over 50 with rotator cuff tear and Type II SLAP lesion. We compared the clinical outcome of patients over 50 affected with rotator cuff tears and Type II SLAP lesion in whom both the defects were repaired, or the rotator cuff tear was repaired and the long head of the biceps tendon was tenotomized. In our hands, the association of rotator cuff repair and biceps tenotomy provides better clinical outcome compared with repair of Type II SLAP lesion and of the rotator cuff. The repair of the two defects, in fact, can lead to worst clinical results compared with association
It is undetermined which factors predict return to work following arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. We aimed to identify which factors predicted return to work at any level, and return to pre-injury levels of work 6 months post-arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. Multiple logistic regression analysis of prospectively collected demographic, pre-injury, preoperative, and intraoperative data from 1502 consecutive primary arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs, performed by a single surgeon, was performed to identify independent predictors of return to work, and return to pre-injury levels of work respectively, 6 months post-surgery. Six months post-rotator cuff repair, 76% of patients returned to work (RTW), and 40% returned to pre-injury levels of work (Full-RTW). RTW at 6 months was likely if patients were still working after their injuries, but prior to surgery (Wald statistic [W]=55, p<0.0001), were stronger in internal rotation preoperatively (W=8, p=0.004), had full-thickness tears (W=9, p=0.002), and were female (W=5, p=0.030). Patients who achieved Full-RTW were likely to have worked less strenuously pre-injury (W=173, p<0.0001), worked more strenuously post-injury but pre-surgery (W=22, p<0.0001), had greater behind-the-back lift-off strength preoperatively (W=8, p=0.004), and had less passive external rotation range of motion preoperatively (W=5, p=0.034). Patients who were still working post-injury, but pre-surgery were 1.6-times more likely to RTW than patients who were not (p<0.0001). Patients who nominated their pre-injury level of work as “light” were 11-times more likely to achieve Full-RTW than those who nominated “strenuous” (p<0.0001). Six months post-rotator cuff repair, a higher patient-rated post-injury, but pre-surgery level of work was the strongest predictor of RTW. A lower patient-rated pre-injury level of work was the strongest predictor of Full-RTW. Greater preoperative subscapularis strength independently predicted both RTW, and Full-RTW.
Surgical reattachment of torn rotator cuff tendons can lead to satisfactory clinical outcome but failures remain common. Ortho-R product is a freeze-dried formulation of chitosan (CS) that is solubilized in platelet-rich plasma (PRP) to form injectable implants. The purpose of the current pilot study was to determine Ortho-R implant acute residency, test safety of different implant doses, and assess efficacy over standard of care in a sheep model. The infraspinatus tendon (ISP) was detached and immediately repaired in 22 skeletally mature ewes. Repair was done with four suture anchors in a suture bridge configuration (n = 6 controls). Freeze-dried formulations containing 1% w/v chitosan (number average molar mass 35 kDa and degree of deacetylation 83%) with 1% w/v trehalose (as lyoprotectant) and 42.2 mM calcium chloride (as clot activator) were solubilized with autologous leukocyte-rich PRP and injected at the tendon-bone interface and on top of the repaired site (n = 6 with a 1 mL dose and n = 6 with a 2 mL dose). Acute implant residency was assessed histologically at 1 day (n = 2 with a 1 mL dose and n = 2 with a 2 mL dose). Outcome measures included MRI assessment at baseline, 6 weeks and 12 weeks, histopathology at 12 weeks and clinical pathology. MRI images and histological slides were scored by 2 blinded readers (veterinarian and human radiologist, and veterinarian pathologist) and averaged. The Generalized Linear Model task (SAS Enterprise Guide 7.1 and SAS 9.4) was used to compare the different groups with post-hoc analysis to test for pairwise differences. Ortho-R implants were detected near the enthesis, near the top of the anchors holes and at the surface of ISP tendon and muscle at 1 day. Numerous polymorphonuclear cells were recruited to the implant in the case of ISP tendon and muscle. On MRI, all repair sites were hyperintense compared to normal tendon at 6 weeks and only 1 out 18 repair sites was isointense at 12 weeks. The tendon repair site gap seen on MRI, which is the length of the hyperintense region between the greater tuberosity and tendon with normal signal intensity, was decreased by treatment with the 2 mL dose when compared to control at 12 weeks (p = 0.01). Histologically, none of the repair sites were structurally normal. A trend of improved structural organization of the tendon (p = 0.06) and improved structural appearance of the enthesis (p = 0.1) with 2 mL dose treatment compared to control was seen at 12 weeks. There was no treatment-specific effect on all standard safety outcome measures, which suggests high safety. Ortho-R implants (2 mL dose) modulated the rotator cuff healing processes in this large animal model. The promising MRI and histological findings may translate into improved mechanical performance, which will be assessed in a future study with a larger number of animals. This study provides preliminary evidence on the safety and efficacy of Ortho-R implants in a large animal model that could potentially be translated to a clinical setting.
A rotator cuff tear is one of the most common traumatic and degenerative tendon injuries resulting in over 4.5 million physician visits in the US alone. Functional restoration of rotator cuff defects usually requires surgical repair, estimated at 300,000 cased in the US annually. However, postoperative retear of repaired tendons ranges from 20% in small to medium tears to over 90% in large and massive tears. Recently, augmentation with grafting materials to strengthen a reparable tear or to bridge an unrepairable defect has become a common and attractive strategy to reduce the retear rate, especially for large or massive tears. Current graft materials, however, have encountered great challenges in achieving these goals. To meet these challenges, we have developed an engineered tendon with layered tendon-fibrocartilage-bone composite (TFBC) from patellar-tibia unit revitalized by seeding bone marrow derived stem cells (BMDSCs) within the slices, and then reassembled to an engineered tendon. Both
The aim of this prospective study was to report the mid-term results of arthroscopic repair of full thickness rotator cuff tears. One hundred and four shoulders in 102 consecutive patients were operated within a two-year period. There were 52 female and 50 male patients with a mean age of 64 years (range 41 to 79). Standard arthroscopic techniques of cuff repair were used, under regional inter-scalene block and balanced anaesthesia. The mean size of the cuff tear was 3 cm (range 1 to 6 cm). Patients were discharged within 24 hours and followed a specific rehabilitation protocol. An assessment was performed pre-operatively and at a mean follow-up of 7 months (range 3 to 24 months). Outcome measures included pain, activities of daily living, shoulder power and function and level of patient satisfaction. Satisfactory pain relief was achieved in 98 patients (94%) with significant pain relief in 87 patients (83.6 %) and good in 12 patients (11.5 %). Ninety -six patients (92.3%) reported a satisfactory improvement in activities of daily living, with significant improvement in 89 (85.6%) and good in 7 (6.7%). Shoulder power was markedly improved in 95 patients (93%). High levels of patient satisfaction were noted in 93 patients. Seven patients were moderately satisfied and two patients were not satisfied. The mean shoulder score improved from 29 pre-op to 82 post-op, and the shoulder function score from 32 pre-op to 84 post–op. Similar results were found when the subgroup of 65 patients over the age of sixty was compared to the group of 37 patients under the age of sixty. No difference in outcome was also noted in relation to the size of the tear, length of follow –up or sex of the patient. We believe that this study has shown that the arthroscopic repair of the rotator cuff can consistently achieve a satisfactory outcome. It may therefore be considered as an alternative to the traditional open techniques.
This study was designed to evaluate the results of arthroscopic rotator cuff repair at a minimum follow-up of 2 years. Only isolated full-thickness rotator cuff tears were included in the study. Of 63 cases that met the criteria, 51 were followed up. Results were measured with pre-operative and postoperative UCLA shoulder scores, Western Ontario Rotator Cuff (WORC)© scores, range of motion, strength and radiographs. The time to recovery and return to work, complications and patient satisfaction were also recorded. Data from various tear sizes were analysed to determine significant differences. At the most recent follow-up, all patients had less pain and better function. Patients rated 48 shoulders (94%) satisfactory. Mean forward flexion was 170.4° and mean manual strength was 4.8/5. Significant strength differences in flexion and external rotation were found between various sizes of tear (p <
0.01). Mean UCLA scores for all tear sizes significantly improved from a preoperative 10.3 (±2.4) to a postoperative 32.1 (±4.3). The mean for small tears was 35, for medium tears 33.3 and for large tears 30. This difference was statistically significant (p <
0.05). Excellent postoperative UCLA scores were achieved in 26 shoulders (51%) and good results in 17 (33%), with seven shoulders (14%) fair and one (2%) poor. The mean overall WORC© score was 86.8% (±17.1) of normal. The mean time to recovery was 5.1 months. Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair has good results and can be done on an outpatient basis with few complications. The results appear to depend on the tear size.
Surgical repair of rotator cuff tears have high failure rates (20–70%), often due to a lack of biological healing. Augmenting repairs with extracellular matrix-based scaffolds is a common option for surgeons, although to date, no commercially available product has proven to be effective. In this study, a novel collagen scaffold was assessed for its efficacy in augmenting rotator cuff repair. The collagen scaffold was assessed