Background. The gold standard of care of clubfoot is the Ponseti method of serial manipulation and casting, followed by percutaneous tendo-achilles tenotomy. In our setting, registrars work in district hospitals where they run Ponseti clubfoot clinics with little or no specialist supervision. They use the Pirani score to serially assess improvement of the deformity during casting and to determine whether the foot is ready for tenotomy. Purpose of Study. To test the inter-observer reliability of the Pirani score, and whether it can be used by non-specialist doctors running Ponseti clubfoot clinics. Methods. Ethics permission was obtained from our institution. This is a prospective study where patients under the age of one year with idiopathic clubfoot were recruited from clubfoot clinics at our institution, over a period of four months. Following a training session using the original description of the score, each foot was independently assessed using the Pirani score by two paediatric orthopaedic surgeons, two orthopaedic registrars and two medical officers. The inter-observer reliability was assessed using the Fixed-marginal Kappa statistic and Percentage agreement. The first 15 feet were used as a learning curve, and hence excluded from final analysis. Results. 73 feet in 37 patients with idiopathic clubfoot (25 boys, 12 girls) under the age of 1 year were included in the study. The Kappa statistic and percentage agreement for the six variables of the Pirani score were determined. Whilst the overall agreement was determined by the Kappa statistic to be slight to fair, the two consultants were found to have a higher inter-observer reliability than the registrars and medical officers. Conclusion. Our results conflict with previously published studies in that the inter-observer reliability of the Pirani score was poor. In addition, we feel that this score cannot be reliably used by non-specialist doctors running Ponseti clubfoot clinics. NO DISCLOSURES

The Pirani scoring system, together with the Ponseti method of club foot management, was assessed for its predictive value. The data on 70 idiopathic club feet successfully treated by the Ponseti method and scored by Pirani’s system between February 2002 and May 2004 were analysed. There was a significant positive correlation between the initial Pirani score and number of casts required to correct the deformity. A foot scoring 4 or more is likely to require at least four casts, and one scoring less than 4 will require three or fewer. A foot with a hindfoot score of 2.5 or 3 has a 72% chance of requiring a tenotomy. The Pirani scoring system is reliable, quick, and easy to use, and provides a good forecast about the likely treatment for an individual foot but a low score does not exclude the possibility that a tenotomy may be required

Aim: To determine the value of the Pirani clubfoot-scoring system at initial presentation in predicting subsequent relapse. Method: All clubfoot patients treated by one surgeon from 2002 to 2006 were included. Treatment followed the standard protocol, involving weekly stretching and casting until the foot was corrected, followed by Achilles tenotomy and plasters for 3 weeks. Thereafter, the child was placed in a foot abduction splint. Relapses within 6 months of instigating the foot abduction splint were classed as early and subsequent relapses as late. The severity of clubfoot was assessed using the Pirani scoring system which comprises two sub-scores – Midfoot Contracture Score (MFCS) and Hindfoot Contracture Score (HFCS). MFCS and HFCS can each be 0.0–3.0, giving rise to a Total Pirani Score (TPS) of 0.0–6.0. Results: Sixty-one clubfoot patients were treated, with five lost to the follow-up. A total of 89 clubfeet were treated. There were 3 early and 19 late relapses. The average interval between initiating the foot abduction splint and late relapse was 23 months. TPS median was 4.5 in the no relapse group, 4.0 in the early relapse group, and 5.0 in the late relapse group. MFCS median was 2.0 in the no relapse group, 2.0 in the early relapse group, and 2.0 in late relapse group. HFCS median was 2.5 in the no relapse group, 2.5 in the early relapse group, and 3.0 in the late relapse group. Higher HFCS was statistically significant when comparing the late and no relapse groups (p< 0.05, 95% CI −0.5–0.0). Conclusions: Higher Pirani scores were associated with late relapses, but HFCS is a stronger predictor of potential late relapse. Close follow-up is advised for patients at risk

Aims. There is a lack of high-quality research investigating outcomes of Ponseti-treated idiopathic clubfeet and correlation with relapse. This study assessed clinical and quality of life (QoL) outcomes using a standardized core outcome set (COS), comparing children with and without relapse. Methods. A total of 11 international centres participated in this institutional review board-approved observational study. Data including demographics, information regarding presentation, treatment, and details of subsequent relapse and management were collected between 1 June 2022 and 30 June 2023 from consecutive clinic patients who had a minimum five-year follow-up. The clubfoot COS incorporating 31 parameters was used. A regression model assessed relationships between baseline variables and outcomes (clinical/QoL). Results. Overall, 293 patients (432 feet) with a median age of 89 months (interquartile range 72 to 113) were included. The relapse rate was 37%, with repeated relapse in 14%. Treatment considered a standard part of the Ponseti journey (recasting, repeat tenotomy, and tibialis anterior tendon transfer) was performed in 35% of cases, with soft-tissue release and osteotomies in 5% and 2% of cases, respectively. Predictors of relapse included duration of follow-up, higher initial Pirani score, and poor Evertor muscle activity. Relapse was associated with poorer outcomes. Conclusion. This is the first multicentre study using a standardized COS following clubfoot treatment. It distinguishes patients with and without relapse in terms of clinical outcomes and QoL, with poorer outcomes in the relapse group. This tool allows comparison of treatment methods and outcomes, facilitates information sharing, and sets family expectations. Predictors of relapse encourage us to create appropriate treatment pathways to reduce relapse and improve outcome. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2024;106-B(7):735–743

Aims. The gold standard for percutaneous Achilles tendon tenotomy during the Ponseti treatment for idiopathic clubfoot is a tenotomy with a No. 15 blade. This trial aims to establish the technique where the tenotomy is performed with a large-bore needle as noninferior to the gold standard. Methods. We randomized feet from children aged below 36 months with idiopathic clubfoot on a 1:1 basis in either the blade or needle group. Follow-up was conducted at three weeks and three months postoperatively, where dorsiflexion range, Pirani scores, and complications were recorded. The noninferiority margin was set at 4° difference in dorsiflexion range at three months postoperatively. Results. The blade group had more dorsiflexion at both follow-up consultations: 18.36° versus 18.03° (p = 0.115) at three weeks and 18.96° versus 18.26° (p = 0.001) at three months. The difference of the mean at three months 0.7° is well below the noninferiority margin of 4°. There was no significant difference in Pirani scores. The blade group had more extensive scar marks at three months than the needle group (8 vs 2). No major complications were recorded. Conclusion. The needle tenotomy is noninferior to the blade tenotomy for usage in Ponseti treatment for idiopathic clubfoot in children aged below 36 months. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2024;106-B(8):871–878

To our knowledge, we are the only centre in the UK where Achilles tenotomies (TA) for CTEV Ponseti correction are performed in outpatient clinic under local anaesthetic by an Advanced Physiotherapy Practitioner (APP) in orthopaedics. This study aims to present the outcomes and safety of this practice. Retrospective analysis of cases of idiopathic CTEV undergoing Ponseti correction January 2020 to October 2022. Demographic data: Pirani score and number of casts before boots and bar. Patients were divided into five groups: Group 1: TA performed by an Orthopaedic consultant under general anaesthetic (GA) in theatre. Group 2: TA performed by an Orthopaedic consultant under local anaesthetic (LA) in theatre. Group 3: TA performed by APP under GA in theatre. Group 4: TA performed by APP under LA in theatre. Group 5: TA performed by an APP under LA in outpatient clinic. Complications recorded: revision TA, infection, neurovascular injury or need for re-casting. Mean follow up 18 months. 45 feet included. Mean Pirani score 5.5, age started casting 33 days and total number of casts 6. No significant difference in demographic details between groups. 6, 4, 20, 5 and 10 tenotomies were performed in groups 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 respectively. Complications were 1 revision tenotomy from group 2, one from group 4 and 1 renewal of cast from 3. This study demonstrates that TAs performed in outpatient clinic under LA by an APP is safe and feasible. No increase in complications were observed compared to TAs performed by orthopaedic consultants

We have modified the Ponseti casting technique by using a below-knee Softcast instead of an above-knee plaster of Paris cast. Treatment was initiated as soon as possible after birth and the Pirani score was recorded at each visit. Following the manipulation techniques of Ponseti, a below-knee Softcast was applied directly over a stockinette for a snug fit and particular attention was paid to creating a deep groove above the heel to prevent slippage. If necessary, a percutaneous Achilles tenotomy was performed and casting continued until the child was fitted with Denis Browne abduction boots. Between April 2003 and May 2007 we treated 51 consecutive babies with 80 idiopathic club feet with a mean age at presentation of 4.5 weeks (4 days to 62 weeks). The initial mean Pirani score was 5.5 (3 to 6). It took a mean of 8.5 weeks (4 to 53) of weekly manipulation and casting to reach the stage of percutaneous Achilles tenotomy. A total of 20 feet (25%) did not require a tenotomy and for the 60 that did, the mean Pirani score at time of operation was 2.5 (0.5 to 3). Denis Browne boots were applied at a mean of 10 weeks (4 to 56) after presentation. The mean time from tenotomy to boots was 3.3 weeks (2 to 10). We experienced one case of cast-slippage during a period of non-attendance, which prolonged the casting process. One case of prolonged casting required repeated tenotomy, and three feet required repeated tenotomy and casting after relapsing while in Denis Browne boots. We believe the use of a below-knee Softcast in conjunction with Ponseti manipulation techniques shows promising initial results which are comparable to those using above-knee plaster of Paris casts

We conducted a prospective randomised controlled trial to compare the standard Ponseti plaster method with an accelerated method for the treatment of idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus. The standard weekly plaster-change method was accelerated to three times per week. We hypothesised that both methods would be equally effective in achieving correction. A total of 40 consecutive patients (61 feet) were entered into the trial. The initial median Pirani score was 5.5 (95% confidence interval 4.5 to 6.0) in the accelerated group and 5.0 (95% confidence interval 4.0 to 5.0) in the standard control group. The scores decreased by an average 4.5 in the accelerated group and 4.0 in the control group. There was no significant difference in the final Pirani score between the two groups (chi-squared test, p = 0.308). The median number of treatment days in plaster was 16 in the accelerated group and 42 in the control group (p < 0.001). Of the 19 patients in the accelerated group, three required plaster treatment for more than 21 days and were then assigned to the standard control method. Of the 40 patients, 36 were followed for a minimum of six months. These results suggest that comparable outcomes can be achieved with an accelerated Ponseti method. The ability to complete all necessary manipulations within a three-week period facilitates treatment where patients have to travel long distances

We studied 24 children (40 feet) to demonstrate that a physiotherapist-delivered Ponseti service is as successful as a medically-led programme in obtaining correction of an idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus deformity. The median Pirani score at the start of treatment was 5.5 (mean 4.75; 2 to 6). A Pirani score of ≥5 predicted the need for tenotomy (p < 0.01). Of the 40 feet studied, 39 (97.5%) achieved correction of deformity. The remaining foot required surgical correction. A total of 25 (62.5%) of the feet underwent an Achilles tenotomy, which was performed by a surgeon in the physiotherapy clinic. There was full compliance with the foot abduction orthoses in 36 (90%) feet. Continuity of care was assured, as one practitioner was responsible for all patient contact. This was rated highly by the patient satisfaction survey. We believe that the Ponseti technique is suitable for use by non-medical personnel, but a holistic approach and good continuity of care are essential to the success of the programme

Aims. The Ponseti method is the benchmark treatment for the correction of clubfoot. The primary rate of correction is very high, but outcome further down the treatment pathway is less predictable. Several methods of assessing severity at presentation have been reported. Classification later in the course of treatment is more challenging. This systematic review considers the outcome of the Ponseti method in terms of relapse and determines how clubfoot is assessed at presentation, correction, and relapse. Patients and Methods. A prospectively registered systematic review was carried out according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Studies that reported idiopathic clubfoot treated by the Ponseti method between 1 January 2012 and 31 May 2017 were included. The data extracted included demographics, Ponseti methodology, assessment methods, and rates of relapse and surgery. Results. A total of 84 studies were included (7335 patients, 10 535 clubfeet). The relapse rate varied between 1.9% and 45%. The rates of relapse and major surgery (1.4% to 53.3%) and minor surgery (0.6% to 48.8%) both increased with follow-up time. There was high variability in the assessment methods used across timepoints; only 57% of the studies defined relapse. Pirani scoring was the method most often used. Conclusion. Recurrence and further surgical intervention in idiopathic clubfoot increases with the duration of follow-up. The corrected and the relapsed foot are poorly defined, which contributes to variability in outcome. The results suggest that a consensus for a definition of relapse is needed. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B:639–645

Outcome studies of the Ponseti method from various centres have reported success rates ranging from 85–95%. The vast majority of patients can expect a supple, functional and pain free foot. The small percentage of feet that are resistant to Ponseti treatment often require open surgical correction, leading to scarring and stiffness. We present a method of correcting resistant equinus by a tenotomy and calcaneal pulldown technique. This method is complimentary to the Ponseti technique. Method. Prospective study of 40 feet in 28 patients who underwent an Achilles tenotomy and calcaneal pulldown technique. The indications for this method were resistant equinus and problems with casting. Feet scored with the Pirani method. Under a general anaesthetic, a standard Achilles tenotomy was performed. The equinus deformity corrected by traction of the calcaneum with a “catspaw” retractor and dorsiflexion of the forefoot. Further treatment was performed according to the Ponseti method. The Ponseti clubfoot brace was used to maintain correction. Results. 28 patients 40 feet. Mean preoperative Pirani score:3.0 (left 3.0, right 3.1 range 1.5–6). Mean preoperative Hindfoot Pirani score:2.5 (left 2.55, right 2.5 Range 1.5–3). Mean post operative Pirani score:2.0(left 2.0, right 2.0 Range 0.5–6). Mean postoperative Hindfoot pirani score:1.45. Three patients had severe arthrogryphosis, of whom 2 did not correct requiring open surgery. All idiopathic CTEV feet corrected with a range of 5–20 degrees of dorsiflexion at last follow up. The mean follow up was 43.64 months (range 7–96 months). Conclusions. The calcaneal pulldown technique is a useful complmentary adjunct to the Ponseti method. It enables the correction of equinus without the need for open surgery. Since the introduction of the technique to our unit it has negated the need for open surgery. The results are encouraging, it is a simple effective technique that can help in difficult CTEV cases

Untreated clubfoot results in serious disability, but mild to moderate residual deformities can still cause functional limitations and pain. Measuring the impact of clubfoot deformities on children's wellbeing is challenging. There is little literature discussing the variability in outcomes and implications of clubfoot based on where geographically the child resides. Although the use of patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) is steadily growing in pediatric orthopaedics, few studies on clubfoot have incorporated them. The most widely used PROM for pediatric foot and ankle pathology is the Oxford Foot and Ankle Questionnaire for Children (OXFAQ-C) that include a physical, school and play, emotional and shoe wear domains. The aim of this study is to evaluate the validity and regional differences in scores of the OXFAQ-C questionnaire to identify functional disability in children with clubfoot in India and Canada. This is a retrospective cohort study of children in Indian and Canadian clubfoot registries aged 5-16 years who completed >1 parent or child OXFAQ-C. The OXFAQ-C was administered once in 01/2020 to all patients in the Indian registry, and prospectively between 06/2019 and 03/2021 at initial visit, 3, 6, 12 months post-intervention, then annually for the Canadian patients. Demographic, clubfoot, and treatment data were compared to OXFAQ-C domain scores. Descriptive statistics and regression analysis were performed. Parent-child concordance was evaluated with Pearson's Coefficient of Correlation (PCC). The cohort had 361 patients (253 from India, 108 from Canada). Non-idiopathic clubfoot occurred in 15% of children in India and 5% in Canada, and bilateral in 53% in India and 50% in Canada. Tenotomy rate was 75% in India and 62% in Canada. Median age at presentation was 3 months in India and 1 month in Canada. Mean Pirani score at presentation and number of Ponseti casts were 4.9 and 6.1 in India and 5.3 and 5.7 in Canada, respectively. Parents reported lower scores in all domains the older the child was at presentation (p Canadians scored significantly lower for all domains (p < 0 .001), with the difference being larger for child-reported scores. The greatest difference was for physical domain. Canadian parents on average scored their child 6.21 points lower than Indian parents, and Canadian children scored a mean of 7.57 lower than Indian children. OXFAQ-C scores differed significantly between Indian and Canadian children despite similar demographic and clubfoot characteristics. Younger age at presentation and tenotomy may improve OXFAQ-C scores in childhood. Parent-child concordance was strong in this population. The OXFAQ-C is an adequate tool to assess functional outcomes of children with clubfeet. Cultural validation of patient reported outcome tools is critical

This study is a mid-term follow up of an original series of 51 babies treated with a modified Ponseti technique for idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus using below-knee Softcast (easier to remove and hygienic). 1. to determine whether this method is as effective as traditional above-knee plastering. Methods. 51 consecutive babies were treated (April 2003-May 2007) and serial Pirani scores were recorded. Dennis Browne Boots (DBB) were applied when correction was achieved and an Achilles tenotomy was performed if necessary to complete the correction. DBB were worn fulltime for 3 months and at night for 3.5 years. Results. Of the original 51, 3 were lost to follow up and 3 were diagnosed with a neuromuscular condition and excluded. 45 patients, 34 boys and 11 girls were followed up for a mean of 55.3 months (range 36–85 months). Mean age at presentation was 16 days with a median Pirani score of 6.0 (5.5, 60). 75.7% required an Achilles tenotomy before DBB. Median Pirani score at tenotomy was 2.5 (2.0, 2.5). Time to boots (weeks) was mean 5.0 (4.2, 6.0) in the non-tenotomy group and 10.7 (9.8, 11.8) in the tenotomy group. 2 patients had residual deformity after plastering requiring surgery and there were 6 recurrences requiring surgery (4 tibialis anterior tendon transfers and 2 open releases). There appears to be a greater risk of operative intervention for girls and non-compliance with DBB. The estimate of 5-year (60 month) survival without surgery was 85% (96% CI; 70,99%). Conclusion. Below knee Softcast allows correction of CTEV with comparable results to traditional above knee techniques. Consistent with current literature, our series found that compliance with DBB is one of the strongest predictors of success. Brewster MB, Gupta M, Pattison GT, Dunn-van der Ploeg ID. Ponseti casting: a new soft option. JBJS(Br) 2008 Nov; 90(11): 1512–1515

This is the first study in the Ponseti-era to compare severity and outcomes in cases of idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) diagnosed antenatally versus those diagnosed at birth. Small pre-Ponseti studies showed antenatal diagnosis to be a predictor of severity and poor prognosis. Prospective data collection was used to compare indicators of severity and outcomes for idiopathic CTEV between these two groups. These include Pirani score, number of casts, follow-up Roye score and need for surgery. 68 children with 106 affected feet were included. Antenatal diagnosis (AD) was made in 45 children (71 feet), with birth diagnosis (BD) in 23 children (35 feet). Mean follow-up age was 4.8 years (AD = 4.9, BD = 4.7), male:female ratio 2:1 (AD=BD) with bilateral CTEV in 55% (AD = 58%, BD=52%). Mean initial Pirani scores were 5.25 in the AD group vs 4.86 in the BD group (p=0.06). Mean Roye score at follow-up was 1.39/4 in the AD group vs 1.26/4 in the BD group (p=0.33) with 33% vs 30% complaining of pain respectively (p=0.80). Surgery was needed in 11/71 (15.5%) in the AD group vs 1/35 (2.9%) in the BD group (p=0.06)). There is no significant difference in severity between antenatal and birth diagnoses of idiopathic CTEV and no difference in outcomes between these groups when treated with the Ponseti regime. Although small, our sample size is greater than the largest published comparable study

Congenital Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV) occurs in approximately 1 in 1000 live births. Most cases occur as an isolated birth defect and are considered idiopathic. The widespread adoption of the Ponseti technique of serial casting followed by Achilles tenotomy and long term bracing has revolutionised the outcomes in CTEV. In most cases, plantigrade, flexible, pain-free feet may be produced without the need for extensive surgery. It is estimated that about 10% of cases of CTEV are not idiopathic. These feet are stiffer and more challenging to treat. In particular, there is little evidence in the literature concerning the efficacy of the Ponseti method in these cases. In our institution, a dedicated weekly Ponseti clinic has operated since 2005. To date 140 patients have been treated. We prospectively enter all details regarding their management onto an independent international database. The aim of this study was to audit the non-idiopathic cases of CTEV and to assess the effectiveness of the Ponseti technique in these challenging cases. Outcome measures included the Pirani score and eventual need for surgical intervention. We identified 29 cases (46 feet) with non-idiopathic CTEV. This comprises 21% of our workload. Seventeen were bilateral. The commonest diagnoses were neuromuscular conditions such as spina bifida (5 cases) and cerebral palsy (3 cases). There were 4 cases of Trisomy 21. Other causes included Nail Patella syndrome, Moebius syndrome, Larsen syndrome and Ito syndrome. In approximately 12% of cases, the underlying disorder remained undiagnosed despite thorough medical and genetic testing. In cases of non-idiopathic CTEV, the mean starting Pirani score was 5.5 (out of 6). After serial casting and Achilles tenotomy, the average score was 2.0. Twenty-one of 46 feet (46%) ultimately required further surgical intervention (mostly posteromedial release). We found that certain conditions were more likely to be successfully treated with the Ponseti method – these included conditions characterised by ligamentous laxity such as Trisomy 21 and Ehlers Danlos syndrome. All patients showed some improvement in Pirani score after serial casting. We believe that it is essential to attempt the Ponseti method of serial casting in all cases of CTEV. More than half of all non-idiopathic cases will not require further surgical intervention – and those that do are not as stiff thanks to the effects of serial casting. Thus, the surgery required is not as complex as it might otherwise have been. This is the largest series of its kind in the current medical literature

Congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) is a complex three-dimensional deformity with an incidence of 1–3 per 1000 live births. The Ponseti method is widely accepted and practiced, giving reliably good long-term results. There are a number of studies showing the benefits of a physiotherapy led Ponseti service with outcomes similar to a consultant led service. We present the first prospective randomised series comparing a physiotherapy led Ponseti service with a standard orthopaedic surgeon led series. 16 infants with bilateral CTEV were randomised into two groups. Each infant had one foot treated by a physiotherapist and the other foot treated by an orthopaedic surgeon using the Ponseti technique. Both groups had a premanipulation Pirani score of 5.5. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 12 months and the results demonstrated no significant difference in the post-treatment Pirani scores (p=0.77) and no significant difference in the success rate the Ponseti technique (p=1.00). This study is the first of its kind and demonstrates the value of a physiotherapy led Ponseti service in the management of CTEV. Although overall supervision by a paediatric orthopaedic surgeon is still necessary, this service will allow the surgeon to spend more time dealing with more complex problems

Introduction: The management of idiopathic talipes equino varus remains controversial. Excellent long term results have been reported with non operative management using the Ponseti technique. Aim: To assess prospectively the early radiologic and clinical results in idiopathic club feet treated in New Zealand by the Ponseti technique. Method: We have reviewed prospectively 29 feet in 19 consecutive patients presenting with idiopathic club feet. The initial assessment consisted of a clinical examination, assessment of the Pirani score and clinical photographs. At follow-up the Pirani score, ankle range of motion, foot length and calf circumference were measured and radiographs were taken. Follow-up was at an average age of 7.3 months. Results: The Pirani score improved from an average of 4.9 to 0.5. The range of motion averaged 32 degrees dorsiflexion and 42 degrees plantar flexion. Radiographs showed good correction of the hindfoot with a mean talocalcaneal index of 55 degrees, and a dorsiflexion tibiocalcaneal angle of 62 degrees. A normal mean AP talo-first metatarsal, AP calcaneo-fifth metatarsal angle, and lateral talo-first metatarsal angle showed good correction of midfoot adductus and cavus. Forced dorsiflexion radiographs showed that ⅗ ths of dorsiflexion motion occurred in the hindfoot and ⅖ ths in the midfoot. Complications were all minor. One non-compliant patient required bilateral posteromedial releases. Conclusions: This is the largest reported series outside of Iowa City using this technique and the first to show the early radiographic findings. Excellent early clinical and radiographic results have been shown

The August 2012 Children’s orthopaedics Roundup. 360. looks at: whether 3D-CT gives a better idea of coverage than plain radiographs; forearm fractures after trampolining accidents; forearm fractures and the Rush pin; the fractured distal radius; elastic stable intramedullary nailing for long-bone fractures; aponeurotic recession for the equinus foot; the torn medial patellofemoral ligament and the adductor tubercle; slipped capital femoral epiphysis; paediatric wrist arthroscopy; and Pirani scores and clubfoot

Introduction. It has been postulated that a mild clubfoot does better than a severe clubfoot no matter what treatment course is taken. There have been previous efforts to classify clubfoot. For units worldwide that use the Ponseti Method of clubfoot management, the Pirani scoring system is widely used. This scoring system has previously been shown to predict the number of plasters required to gain correction. Our study aimed to investigate whether the Pirani score gave an indication of longer-term outcome using tibialis anterior tendon transfer as an endpoint. Methods. A prospectively collated database was used to identify all patients treated in the Ponseti clinic at the Royal Manchester Children's Hospital between 2002 and 2005 with idiopathic clubfoot who had not received any treatment prior to their referral. Rate of tibialis tendon transfer as well as the patient's presenting Pirani score were noted. Feet were grouped for analytical purposes into a mild clubfoot (Pirani score <4) and a severe clubfoot (Pirani score 4) category depending on initial examination. Clinic records were reviewed retrospectively to identify patients who were poorly compliant at wearing boots and bars and were categorised into having “good” or “bad” compliance with orthosis use. Results. 132 feet in 94 children were included in the study. 30 (23%) tibialis tendon transfers were performed at a mean of 4.2 years (range 2.3–5.5 years). Children with severe clubfoot had a significantly higher rate of tendon transfer compared with those with mild clubfoot (28% vs. 6%; p=0.0001). 81% of patients were classified as being “good” boot wearers. Tibialis tendon transfer rates in those who were poorly compliant with boot usage were significantly higher compared with those with good compliance (52% vs. 16%; p=0.0003). There was a significantly higher tendon transfer rate in those with severe disease and poor compliance compared with good compliance (69% vs. 20%; p=0.0002). There was no association between boot compliance and tendon transfer rates in those with mild disease. Conclusion. This study shows that late recurrences, requiring tibialis anterior tendon transfer, are associated with severity of disease at presentation and compliance with use of orthoses. Tendon transfer rates are higher for those with severe disease. We have confirmed previous reports that compliance with orthotic use is associated with recurrence. However, the novel findings regarding recurrence rates in mild clubfeet may have implications regarding usage of orthoses in the management of mild idiopathic clubfeet after initial manipulation using the Ponseti method