Introduction. Total hip prostheses which use a ceramic head within a metal liner are a relatively recent introduction. As such, survivorship rates from independent centres alongside explant analysis are rare. The early experience with this novel ceramic-on-metal (CoM) bearing couple is reported. Methods and Materials. All CoM hips implanted between 2008 and 2009 at a single hospital by a single surgeon were reviewed. Radiographs were analysed using EBRA software to determine acetabular cup inclination and anteversion angles. Blood metal ion concentrations were measured using inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy (ICPMS). Explants were measured for bearing surface and taper wear using a high precision co-ordinate measuring machine. The roughness of the articulating surfaces was measured with a non-contact profilometer. Results. In 54 patients 56 CoM hips were implanted. Mean (range) age was 64 years (34-87). There were 41 females and 15 males. Patients were followed-up for a mean of 1.5 years. Three hips were revised at mean of 1.2 years (2 female, 1 male) with a further 3 listed for revision under 1.5 years giving an overall failure rate of 10.7%. All these patients reported with pain. X-rays of failed devices showed a characteristic pattern of femoral stem loosening. Serum cobalt and chromium were less than 2 micrograms/L. Explant analysis of the three revised hips showed wear at the liner rim in each case. In two of these cases the wear extended completely around the circumference. The wear volumes were 4.1, 2.0 and 2.3mm3 respectively. The ceramic heads were unworn but some transfer of metal could be seen visually. There was no significant wear or deformation at the taper junctions. Typical ceramic head roughness values were 3nm Ra and so most of the surface area of the heads remained in a pristine condition. Discussion. The very high early failure rate using COM is concerning. Explant analysis suggests equatorial contacts with propagation of high frictional forces distally. These forces may have caused early loosening of the femoral stems. Orthopaedic surgeons need to be aware of this new mechanism of failure which is associated with low metal ions

Background. The worldwide withdrawal of the DePuy Articular Surface Replacement (ASR) device in both its resurfacing and total hip replacement (THR) form on 26 August 2010, after 93,000 were implanted worldwide, has had major implications. The 2010 National Joint Registry for England and Wales quoted figures of 12-13% failure at five years; however these figures may be an underestimate. Patients and methods. In 2004 a single surgeon prospective study of the ASR bearing surface was undertaken. Presented are the Adverse Reaction to Metal Debris (ARMD) failure rates of the ASR resurfacing and ASR THR systems. The diagnosis of ARMD was made by the senior author and was based on clinical history, examination, ultrasound findings, metal ion analysis of blood and joint fluid, operative findings and histopathological analysis of tissues retrieved at revision. Acetabular cup position in vivo was determined using EBRA software. Mean follow up was 52 months (24-81) and 70 patients were beyond 6 years of the procedure at the time of writing. Kaplan Meier survival analysis was carried out firstly with joints designated ‘failure’ if the patient had undergone revision surgery or if the patient had been listed for revision. A second survival analysis was carried out with a failure defined as a serum cobalt concentration > 7microgrammes/L (MHRA guideline from MDA-2010-069). Full explant analysis was carried out for retrieved prostheses. Results. There were 505 ASR hips in total (418 resurfacings and 87 THRs). 657 metal ion samples were available at the time of writing including 152 repeats. Survival analysis using revision/listed for revision as end point (at 6 years): ASR resurfacing: 26.1% failure; ASR THR: 55.5% failure. Survival using ion analysis (at 5 years): ASR resurfacing: 50.1% failure; ASR THR: 66.5% failure. The median (range) volumetric wear rate of failed prostheses was 8.23mm3/year (0.51-95.5). Failure and high ion concentrations are linked to acetabular cup size, anteversion and inclination. Increased failure rates in THRs were due to wear at the taper junction of head and stem. Conclusion. Design flaws in the ASR have led to excessive wear and consequently catastrophic failure rates secondary to ARMD