A randomised prospective study of 4 bearing surfaces in hip replacements is being conducted. The primary objective is to identify the best long term bearing surface clinically and radiographically, and metal ion levels have been measured in all cases. Patieents have been randomised to the 4 bearing surfaces viz. Ceramic on XLinked Poly, Ceramic on Ceramic, Metal on Metal and Ceramic on Metal. Pre operative blood samples and follow up blood samples for metal ion analysis using the ICPMS method have been taken in all patients. As at February 2008 187 patients have been recruited, and metal ion levels at 1 year are available in 52 patients. Metal ion levels are not increased with Ceramic on XLinked Poly or Ceramic on Ceramic bearings. At 1 year follow up the metal ion levels in Ceramic on Metal bearings is half that of Metal on Metal bearings using the mean levels, and one third using the madian levels. Of note is that the chromium levels in Ceramic on Metal bearings is the least elevated. Due to laboratory evidence that Ceramic on Metal bearings have the best surface wear characteristics with no head stripe wear, and laboratory and clinical evidence of lower metal ion blood levels, Ceramic on Metal hip replacements could be a bearing surface of the future

Introduction. Ceramic femoral heads have superior scratch resistant with better wettability and improved wear characteristics compared to metal heads in the laboratory setting. The objective of this study was to compare long-term in vivo wear rates of ceramic and metal femoral heads against conventional polyethylene articulation with cementless stems in young, active patients. Materials and Methods. Thirty-one matched pair of alumina and metal (Cr-Co) femoral heads against conventional polyethylene in young patients (between 45 and 65 years old) were analyzed for wear and failures for mechanical reasons. The match was based on gender and age at the time of surgery. All procedures were performed between June 1989 and May 1992 by a single surgeon via posterolateral approach, using cementless RB (Ranawat-Bernstein) stems, HG II (Harris-Galante) cups, 4150 conventional polyethylene and 28 mm femoral heads. Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) hip score was used for clinical analysis. Wear measurements were performed between the initial anteroposterior standing pelvis radiographs, at a minimum of one year after the index procedure to eliminate the effect of bedding-in period, and the latest follow-up. Two independent observers analyzed polyethylene wear rates using the computer-assisted Roman 1.70 software. In revision cases, the wear rates were calculated from radiographs prior to revision surgery. A pair student t test was performed to analyze the statistical difference. Two-tailed ρ values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant. Results. The mean age was 54.5 ± 8.5 at the time of surgery (range 23.3–65). Average clinical and radiographic follow-up were 17 ± 2.1 (range 12.8–20) and 14.1±2.6 years (range 10–19.1) respectively. The mean HSS score in ceramic and metal groups were 30.4 ± 8 (range 24–56) and 36.6 ± 4.7 (range 20–40) respectively. The mean wear rate for the ceramic group and the metal group were 0.086 ± 0.046 mm/year and 0.137 ± 0.052 mm/year, respectively which was statistically significant (p < 0.001). There were no revisions in the ceramic group for osteolysis or loosening, however one patient required a strut graft for femoral osteolysis that was distal to the tip of the implant due to non-circumferential porous coating of the stem. There were 3 cup revisions in the metal group, all for acetabular osteolysis, and no stem lysis or loosening. Discussion and Conclusion. The low mean wear rate of ceramic compared to metal in this study is consistent with previously published laboratory reports. There was no revision for loosening or osteolysis in the ceramic group, which demonstrates superior durability compared to metal femoral heads. The strength of this study is that this is the first long-term report comparing ceramic and metal femoral heads against conventional polyethylene with cementless stems using a matched pair analysis in young patients

Introduction. Ceramic femoral heads have proven to be more scratch resistant with better wettability and improved wear characteristics compared to metal heads in the laboratory setting. The objective of this study was to compare long-term survivorship and in vivo wear rates of ceramic and metal femoral heads against conventional polyethylene articulation in young patients. Materials and Methods. Thirty-one matched pair of alumina and metal femoral heads against conventional polyethylene in young patients (≤ 65 years) were analyzed for wear and failures for mechanical reasons. The match was based on gender and age at the time of surgery. All procedures were performed between June 1989 and May 1992 by a single surgeon via posterolateral approach, using non-cemented RB (Ranawat-Bernstein) stems, HG II (Harris-Galante) cups, 4150 conventional polyethylene and 28mm femoral heads. Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) hip score was used for clinical analysis. Wear measurements were performed between the initial anteroposterior standing pelvis radiographs, at a minimum of one year after the index procedure to eliminate the effect of bedding-in period, and the latest follow-up. Two independent observers analyzed polyethylene wear rates using the computer-assisted Roman 1.70 software. In revision cases, the wear rates were calculated from radiographs prior to revision surgery. A pair student t test was performed to analyze the statistical difference. Two-tailed ρ values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant. Results. The mean age was 54.5 ± 8.5 at the time of surgery (range 23.3–65). Average clinical and radiographic follow-up were 17 ± 2.1 (range 12.8–20) and 14.1 ± 2.6 years (range 10–19.1) respectively. The mean HSS score in ceramic and metal groups were 30.4 ± 8 (range 24–56) and 36.6 ± 4.7 (range 20–40) respectively. The mean wear rate for the ceramic group and the metal group were 0.086 ± 0.046 mm/year and 0.137 ± 0.052 mm/year, respectively which was statistically significant (p < 0.001). There were no revisions in the ceramic group for osteolysis or loosening, however one patient required a strut graft for femoral osteolysis that was distal to the tip of the implant due to non-circumferential porous coating of the stem. There were 3 cup revisions in the metal group, all for acetabular osteolysis, and no stem lysis or loosening. The Kaplan-Meier survivorship for revision for mechanical failure in the ceramic and metal group was 100% and 90.3% respectively. Discussion. The low mean wear rate of ceramic compared to metal in this study is consistent with previously published laboratory reports. There was no revision for loosening or osteolysis in the ceramic group, with 100% survivorship for revision due to mechanical failures, which demonstrates superior durability of this material compared to metal femoral heads. The strength of this study is that this the first long-term report comparing ceramic and metal femoral heads against conventional polyethylene using a matched pair analysis in young patients

Traditional hip prostheses, which involve metal on poly-ethylene articulations, have shown good survivorship at ten years, but in the long term, wear debris induced osteolysis has been found to cause loosening and failure. Specifically, micron and submicron size polyethylene wear particles generated at the articulating surfaces enter the periprosthetic tissues, activate the macrophages causing adverse cellular reactions and bone resorption. Recent laboratory, retrieval and clinical studies have shown that oxidation of the traditional polyethylene irradiated in air, causes wear to increase by a factor of three following either storage on the shelf for five years or following implantation in vivo for 15 years. Furthermore, damage or scratching of metallic femoral heads has been shown to increase wear by a factor of two. In vitro cell culture studies with real polyethylene wear particles, have shown that the intensity of the adverse cellular reactions is critically dependent on the size of the polyethylene wear particle with the smallest particles 0.1 to 1 mm being the most active. A novel model has been developed to predict functional biological activity and osteolytic potential, by integrating wear rates, particle analysis and cell culture studies. Stabilised and crosslinked polyethylenes have been investigated and been found to reduce wear rates by a factor of three compared to oxidised and aged materials. A moderate level of crosslinking reduced wear from 50 to 35 mm3 per million cycles compared to non crosslinked materials. However, against scratched femoral heads, the wear rate of both stabilised and cross-linked polyethylene was elevated to levels where the functional biological activity remains a concern in the long term. Alternative bearing surfaces, metal on metal, and alumina ceramic on ceramic provide potential to substantially reduce wear. Metal on metal bearings have shown mean wear rates of 1.5 mm3/year in the hip joint simulator, with very small, 30 nm size particles. Alumina ceramic ceramic have also shown very low wear rates of approximately 1 mm3/year, even in the presence of microseparation and rim contact, with small 10 nm size wear particles and larger particles up to 1 mm in size caused by grain boundary fracture. The functional biological activity and osteolytic potential of the alumina ceramic couple is predicted to be at least ten times lower than crosslinked polyethylene. New ceramic materials (zirconia toughened alumina) have been shown to further reduce ceramic ceramic wear. Furthermore, novel differential hardness ceramic on metal bearings have shown even lower wear rates. The currently available hard on hard bearings and the recent further improvements of these bearing couples, indicate that osteolysis free lifetimes well beyond 20 years are now possible

Purpose of Study:. To look at the difference in metal ion levels using Ceramic on Metal (COM) and Metal on Metal (MOM) bearings in Total Hip Replacements, comparing the results between well placed and poorly placed cups. Methods:. Metal ion levels using the ICP-MS method of assay have been studied as part of a prospective randomised trial between 4 different bearing combinations. The ion levels have been raised in the COM and MOM bearings. Metal ions are not raised in the Ceramic on Ceramic (COC) and Ceramic on X linked Poly(COP) bearings, showing that no other material in the study prosthesis aside from the bearing surfaces contribute to raised ion levels. Cup inclination and cup anteversion has been measured in all patients. Results:. At 3 year follow-up the Cobalt and Chrome levels are significantly lower with the COM bearing than the MOM bearing when both well and poorly placed cups are included, and seem to be returning to normal pre-operative levels. Taking cups put in in Lewinnik's safe zones, then the Chrome levels are similar between the two bearings, but the Cobalt levels remain raised in the MOM bearing. Conclusion:. Cobalt and Chrome levels are significantly lower in COM bearings than MOM bearings when cups are not placed in the ideal position. This represents an added advantage in the use of COM bearings as compared to MOM bearings

To compare complications, survivorship and results in 2 groups of Furlong-HAP Active, one with ceramic-ceramic and the other with metal-XLPE friction pair

Prospective, non-randomized, comparison of 2 series of JRI uncemented prosthesis, implanted with identical protocol by 1 surgeon in 1 hospital from 2006 to 2014. Friction pair was ceramic (Biolox Forte or Delta) in 35 patients of 53.7+/−10.6 years (25–69) (21 males, 60%), and CrCo-XLPE in 65 cases of 69.0+/−8.9 years (42–81) (36 males, 55%); there were significant differences in age (p<0.00001) but not in sex (p=0.6565).

Head diameter: Ce-Ce with 19 of 28mm, 9 of 32 and 7 of 36mm; Me-PE with 63 of 28mm, 1 of 32 and 1 of 36. Follow-up averaged 10.5+/−3.1 years (1–15) in ceramic and 9.8+/−3.8 years (2–15) in XLPE group. Pearson, Fisher, Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Student, Mann-Whitney, calculated with the informatic tools Microsoft Excel 2007 and https://www.socscistatistics.com/tests/.

Complications in ceramic joints: 2 late infections (Fisher exact test=0.6101) (1 DAIR, 1 one-stage exchange); 1 dislocation (Fisher exact test=0.2549) (closed reduction); 1 Vancouver C fracture (ORIF) (Fisher exact test=0.6548). Complications in Me-XLPE joints: 2 late infections (Fisher=0.6101) (1 DAIR, 1 two-stage exchange); 7 dislocations (Fisher=0.2549) (2 early, open reduction) (5 late: 3 closed reduction, 1 cup revision, 1 constrained cup); 4 Vancouver B fractures (Fisher=0.6548) (2 intraoperative, cerclages; 2 late, exchange).

Final follow-up: Harris Hip Score averaged 93.2+/−13.7 (23–100) in ceramic and 94.3+/−8.7 (65–100) in XLPE joints (p=0.64552).

Wear: 0.06+/−0.38mm (0–1.5) in ceramic and 0.16+/−0.5mm (0–2) in Me-PE THAs (p=0.30302).

Osteolysis in Charnley-De Lee zones: 8 zones (6 patients) (17%) in ceramic cups, 25 zones (15 patients) (23%) in XLPE cups (p=0.980127).

Survivorship without any surgery or closed reduction after 15 years: 91.0% in ceramic joints, 83.8% in Me-XLPE joints.

Survivorship without component exchange after 15 years: 93.9% in ceramic joints, 93.6% in Me-XLPE joints.

At least after 10 years follow-up of Furlong-HAP Active, metal-XLPE and ceramic-ceramic joints present no significant differences in complications, clinical score, wear, acetabular osteolysis, or survivorship without component exchange. On the contrary, survivorship without any surgery or closed reduction is different because of the high rate of dislocation in 28mm metal-poly joints.

This study presents an unusual recurrent case of pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS) around a ceramic-on-metal (COM) hip retrieved at 9-years. PVNS literature relates to metal-polyethylene and ceramic-ceramic bearings. Amstutz reported 2 cases with MOM resurfacing and Xiaomei reported PVNS recurring at 14 years with metal-on-polyethylene THA. Friedman reported on PVNS recurrence in a ceramic THA. Ours may be the first reported case of recurrent PVNS of a ceramic-on-metal articulation.

This young female patient (now 38-years of age) had a total hip replacement in 2006 for PVNS in her left hip. In her initial work-up, this case was presumed to be a pseudotumor problem, typical of those related to CoCr debris with high metal-ion concentrations. She had an CoCr stem (AML), 36mm Biolox-delta head (Ceramtec), and a Pinnacle acetabular cup with CoCr liner (Ultramet, Depuy J&J). This patient had no concerns regarding subluxation, dislocation or squeaking. Three years ago she complained of mild to moderate groin and thigh pain in her left hip. This worsened in the past year. She noticed increased swelling now with an asymmetry to her right hip. She went to the emergency room in Dec-2014 and was referred to a plastic surgeon. In our consult we reviewed MARS-MRI and CT-scans that demonstrated multiple mass lesions surrounding the hip. Laboratory results presented Co=0.7, Cr=0.3 ESR=38 and Crp=0.3.

At revision surgery, the joint fluid was hemorrhagic/bloody with hemosiderin staining the soft tissues. Multiple large 4–5×5cm nodules were present in anterior aspect of the hip as well as multiple nodules surrounding posterior capsule and sciatic nerve. Pathology demonstrated a very cellular matrix with hemosiderin-stained tissue and multiple giant cells, which was judged consistent with PVNS. The trunnion showed no fretting, no contamination and no discoloration. The superior neck showed impingement due to low-inclination cup. There was minimal evidence of metal-debris staining the tissues. There was a large metallic-like stripe across the ceramic head.

This is a particularly interesting case and may be the first reported recurrent PVNS around a ceramic-on-metal bearing (COM). Data is scant regarding clinical results of COM bearings and here we have a nine-year result in a young and active female patient. She was believed to have a metalosis-related pseudotumor yet her metal-ion levels were not alarmingly high and there was no particular evidence of implant damage or gross wear products. In addition, the CoCr trunnion appeared pristine. Our work-up continues with analyses of wear and histopath-evidence. This case may demonstrate the need for a broadening of the differential diagnosis when dealing with hip failures.

The purpose of this study was to compare the effect of femoral head material (delta ceramic versus metal) on polyethylene wear in a consecutive prospective randomized series of low friction total hip arthroplasty. A total of 110 patients with a mean age of 60.6 ± 9.3 (34–75) years were randomized (power of 90%, alpha of 5%) to receive either a metal (55 hips) or a delta ceramic (55 hips) femoral head. The polyethylene socket was moderately cross-linked (3 Mrads of gamma radiation in nitrogen) and annealed at 130°C in all hips. All other parameters were identical in both groups. The primary criterion for evaluation was linear head penetration measurement using the Martell system, performed by an investigator blinded to the material of the femoral head. Creep and steady state wear values were calculated. At the minimum of 3-year follow-up, complete data were available for analysis in 38 hips at a median follow-up of 4.4 years (3.0 to 5.7), and in 42 hips at a median follow-up of 4.0 years (3.0 to 5.4) in the metal and delta ceramic groups, respectively. The mean creep, measured as the linear head penetration at one year follow-up, was 0.42 ± 1.0 mm in the metal group versus 0.30 ± 0.81 mm in the delta ceramic group (Mann and Whitney test, p = 0.56). The mean steady state penetration rate from one year onwards measured 0.17 ± 0.44 mm/year (median 0.072) in the metal group versus 0.074 ± 0.44 mm/year (median 0.072) in the delta ceramic group (Mann and Whitney test, p = 0.48). No case of delta ceramic femoral head fracture was recorded, and no hip had signs of periprosthetic osteolysis. This study demonstrated that up to 5-year follow-up, delta ceramic femoral head did not significantly influence creep neither wear of a contemporary annealed polyethylene. Longer follow-up is necessary to further evaluate the potential clinical benefits of delta ceramic

Aims

In 2015, we published the results of our ceramic-on-metal (CoM) total hip arthroplasties (THAs) performed between October 2007 and July 2009 with a mean follow-up of 34 months (23 to 45) and a revision rate of 3.1%. The aim of this paper is to present the longer-term outcomes.

In vivo and in vitro studies of ceramic on ceramic (COC) bearings have demonstrated that swing phase microseparation followed by the impact of the femoral head on the superior acetabular insert rim leads to accelerated wear. However, resultant wear remained low. The wear of ceramic on polyethylene (COP) and metal on metal (MOM) couples under swing phase microseparation is unknown, this study aimed to compare the wear of these total hip replacements under standard and microseparation conditions.

A physiological hip simulator was used, loads and motions were applied to approximate in vivo conditions. Microseparation was achieved by displacing the femoral head inferiorly during swing phase, the head contacted the inferior cup rim and was laterally displaced. On heel strike the head contacted the superior cup rim prior to relocation. Components (as shown in table 1) were tested for 5 million cycles, at a frequency of 1 hertz in 25% (v/v) new born calf serum. Under standard conditions, wear of COC and MOM bearings was significantly lower than wear of COP couples. Under microseparation conditions the COC and MOM wear increased by 4 and 25 times respectively. Microseparation conditions reduced wear of COP couples by a factor of 4. Creep deformation and damage to the UHMWPE cup rim was observed, however, wear remained low. It is postulated that this reduction in polyethylene wear is due to the separation of the components in swing phase improving the entrapment of lubricant, hence wear is reduced via a squeeze film lubrication mechanism.

Introduction

Hip replacements are falling short of matching the life expectancy of coxarthritis patients, due to implanting THR in younger patients and due to increasingly active patients. The most frequently implanted hip prostheses use cross linked (XL) polyethylene (PE) on metal bearings in the USA and most of the Western world. Concerns remain in the long term around the potential of wear debris-induced aseptic loosening. Thus exploring lower-wearing alternative bearings remains a major research goal.

PEEK (poly-ether-ether-ketone) is a thermoplastic polymer with enhanced mechanical properties. This study compared the wear of PEEK to the wear of cross linked polyethylene, when sliding against cobalt chrome (CoCr) metallic counterfaces, and compared the wear of carbon-fibre reinforced (CFR)-PEEK to cross linked polyethylene when sliding against metallic and ceramic counterfaces under different contact stresses within the hip joint.

Introduction

The process of wear and corrosion at the head-neck junction of a total hip replacement is initiated when the femoral head and stem are joined together during surgery. To date, the effects of the surface topography of the femoral head and metal stem on the contact mechanics during assembly and thus on tribology and fretting corrosion during service life of the implant are not well understood. Therefore, the objective of this study was to investigate the influence of the surface topography of the metal stem taper on contact mechanics and wear during assembly of the head-neck junction using Finite Element models.

Background

The main reasons for hip prosthesis failure are aseptic loosening and periprosthetic joint infection (PJI). The real frequency of PJI is probably largely underestimated because of non-standardized definition criteria, diagnostic procedure, treatment algorithm and other confounders. Therefore, data from joint registries are not reflecting the frequency of PJI and can be misleading; particularly low-grade PJI can be frequently misdiagnosed as aseptic failure. Therefore, prospective clinical studies with standardized protocol, comprehensive diagnostic procedure and sufficient follow-up should be performed. Sonication of explanted prosthesis is highly sensitive for detection of biofilms on prosthetic surface and allows quantitative analysis of biofilm formation. We hypothesize that by using sonication, ceramic components (BIOLOX®delta, BIOLOX®forte) will show higher resistance against biofilm adhesion compared to polyethylene (PE) and metal (CoCrMo).

Aims. The survival of humeral hemiarthroplasties in patients with relatively intact glenoid cartilage could theoretically be extended by minimizing the associated postoperative glenoid erosion. Ceramic has gained attention as an alternative to metal as a material for hemiarthroplasties because of its superior tribological properties. The aim of this study was to assess the in vitro wear performance of ceramic and metal humeral hemiarthroplasties on natural glenoids. Methods. Intact right cadaveric shoulders from donors aged between 50 and 65 years were assigned to a ceramic group (n = 8, four male cadavers) and a metal group (n = 9, four male cadavers). A dedicated shoulder wear simulator was used to simulate daily activity by replicating the relevant joint motion and loading profiles. During testing, the joint was kept lubricated with diluted calf serum at room temperature. Each test of wear was performed for 500,000 cycles at 1.2 Hz. At intervals of 125,000 cycles, micro-CT scans of each glenoid were taken to characterize and quantify glenoid wear by calculating the change in the thickness of its articular cartilage. Results. At the completion of the wear test, the total thickness of the cartilage had significantly decreased in both the ceramic and metal groups, by 27% (p = 0.019) and 29% (p = 0.008), respectively. However, the differences between the two were not significant (p = 0.606) and the patterns of wear in the specimens were unpredictable. No significant correlation was found between cartilage wear and various factors, including age, sex, the size of the humeral head, joint mismatch, the thickness of the native cartilage, and the surface roughness (all p > 0.05). Conclusion. Although ceramic has better tribological properties than metal, we did not find evidence that its use in hemiarthroplasty of the shoulder in patients with healthy cartilage is a better alternative than conventional metal humeral heads. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2024;106-B(11):1273–1283

Our experience with metal/metal desings in France date from 1994. The goal of this study is to communicate our primary and comparative clinical results of 90 implants followed a minimum of 6 years

Material and method: We have reviewed the first 94 patients from our first year using metal/metal.90 case files were complete and we compare thes patients (group 1) to a control group of 90 patients receiving ceramic/poly couple, operated in the same time period (group two) with the same hybrid TH system. Average follow up: Five years and eight months.

Results and discussion: 4 of the 94 were unavailable for follow up at six years. None of these patients experienced clinical problems relared to the metal/metal. The clinical results (Merle and Harris score) are all good or excellent and there is no difference between the 2 groups. The x-ray results: For acetabular cup the two groups are identical and for femoral component (Barrack evaluation) all two groups have the same quality of cementation and maintain the cement mantle integrity achieved post-op. We decided therefore to examine specially the RLL changes in zone seven (comparison 3 month x-ray/latest follow-up x-ray); significant differences between the two groups were found in this study: The lower incidence of zone seven radiolucent changes in group one indicates a better clinical tolerance in the metal/metal configuration (p=0.0256). Considering the results reported here and the advanced studies, we can confirm that metal/metal systems are not the unique answer to PE-wear and THA longevity, but it is one solution that is available today and seems trustable.

Introduction. Significant reduction in the wear of current orthopaedic bearing materials has made it challenging to isolate wear debris from simulator lubricants. Ceramics such as silicon nitride (SiN), as well as ceramic-like surface coatings on metal substrates have been explored as potential alternatives to conventional implant materials. Current isolation methods were designed for isolating conventional metal, UHMWPE and ceramic wear debris. The objective of this study was to develop methodology for isolation and characterisation of modern ceramic or ceramic-like coating particles and metal wear particles from serum lubricants under ultra-low wearing conditions. Sodium polytungstate (SPT) was used as a novel density gradient medium due to its properties, such as high water solubility, the fact that it is non-toxic and acts as a protein denaturant, coupled with a large density range of 1.1–3.0 g/cm3 in water. Methods. SiN nanoparticles (<50nm nanopowder, Sigma-Aldrich) and clinically relevant cobalt-chromium wear debris were added to 25% (v/v) bovine serum lubricant at concentrations of 0.03 and 0.3 mm3/ million cycles. The particles were isolated by a newly developed method using SPT gradients. The sample volume was reduced by centrifuging the lubricant at 160,000 g for 3 h at 20°C. Then, re-suspended pellet was digested twice with 0.5 mg/ml proteinse K for 18 hours at 50°C in the presence of 0.5% (w/v) SDS. Particles were then isolated from partially hydrolysed proteins by density gradient ultracentrifugation at 270,000 g for 4 h using SPT gradients [Figure 1]. At the end of centrifugation, particles were pelleted at the bottom of the centrifuge tube, leaving protein fragments and other impurities suspended higher up the tube. Isolated particles were then washed with pyrogen free water, dispersed by sonication and filtered through 15 nm polycarbonate membrane filters for SEM and EDX analysis. Results and Discussion. The morphology and size distribution of the SiN and cobalt-chromium particles was not altered after isolation [Figure 2] [Figure 3]. The mode size of the SiN particles was 30–40 nm, while the mode size of cobalt-chromium particles was 10–20 nm [Figure 3]. Unlike current isolation methods, the present study developed a highly sensitive method which uses cost effective commercially available reagents and components. Furthermore, the particles are recovered in solution and can be readily analysed using commercial size analysers, prior to use in cell studies. This study also confirmed the aggregation characteristics of silicon nitride particles in aqueous medium as observed in previous studies. The above method may also be used to isolate wear debris of materials that have density higher than 1.6 g/cm3. This includes the majority of ceramics, metals and ceramic-like coatings used in TJR components such as alumina, zirconia toughened alumina, titanium, chromium nitride coating, titanium nitride coating and chromium carbon nitride coating. Conclusions. The new isolation method successfully isolated silicon nitride nanoparticles and cobalt-chromium wear debris from serum lubricant at ultra-low concentrations of 0.03 mm3/million cycles. Acknowledgements. The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under grant agreement no. GA-310477 LifeLongJoints

Aims. Metal and ceramic humeral head bearing surfaces are available choices in anatomical shoulder arthroplasties. Wear studies have shown superior performance of ceramic heads, however comparison of clinical outcomes according to bearing surface in total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) and hemiarthroplasty (HA) is limited. This study aimed to compare the rates of revision and reoperation following metal and ceramic humeral head TSA and HA using data from the National Joint Registry (NJR), which collects data from England, Wales, Northern Ireland, Isle of Man and the States of Guernsey. Methods. NJR shoulder arthroplasty records were linked to Hospital Episode Statistics and the National Mortality Register. TSA and HA performed for osteoarthritis (OA) in patients with an intact rotator cuff were included. Metal and ceramic humeral head prostheses were matched within separate TSA and HA groups using propensity scores based on 12 and 11 characteristics, respectively. The primary outcome was time to first revision and the secondary outcome was non-revision reoperation. Results. A total of 4,799 TSAs (3,578 metal, 1,221 ceramic) and 1,363 HAs (1,020 metal, 343 ceramic) were included. The rate of revision was higher for metal compared with ceramic TSA, hazard ratio (HR) 3.31 (95% confidence interval (CI) 1.67 to 6.58). At eight years, prosthesis survival for ceramic TSA was 98.7% (95% CI 97.3 to 99.4) compared with 96.4% (95% CI 95.2 to 97.3) for metal TSA. The majority of revision TSAs were for cuff insufficiency or instability/dislocation. There was no significant difference in the revision rate for ceramic compared with metal head HA (HR 1.33 (95% CI 0.76 to 2.34)). For ceramic HA, eight-year prosthetic survival was 92.8% (95% CI 86.9 to 96.1), compared with 91.6% (95% CI 89.3 to 93.5) for metal HA. The majority of revision HAs were for cuff failure. Conclusion. The rate of all-cause revision was higher following metal compared with ceramic humeral head TSA in patients with OA and an intact rotator cuff. There was no difference in the revision rate for HA according to bearing surface. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2024;106-B(5):482–491

The search for the ideal bearing surfaces to be used in Total Hip Replacement continues. The current “best” materials are felt to be various combinations of metal, ceramics and cross linked polyethylene. This study aims to identify the best combination with the lowest side effect profile. In February 2004 a prospective randomised trial on different bearing surfaces was started. The combinations selected were ceramic on cross linked polyethylene, ceramic on ceramic, metal on metal and ceramic on metal. Institutional ethics clearance was obtained. In all patients uncemented femoral stems are used, and an uncemented porocoated acetabular shell. 28mm Head size was selected. Blood samples have been taken to measure the metal ion concentrations in all patients. These are measured pre operatively, and repeated at intended follow up visits at 3 months, 1, 3, 5 and 10 years post operative using a graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometer. Between February 2004 and 2006 seventy hips have undergone total hip replacement. There are 85 patients (11 bilateral). 40% are males and 60% female. The average age at operation is 52 years (17 to 72). 46% Hips are left and 54% right. Follow up includes blood samples and the Harris Hip Score. Complications to date have been surgeon related, with three femoral components needing early revision for technical reasons. This has not affected the bearing surfaces. Ten patients have hetero-topic ossification. Cup inclination averages at 48 degrees (32 degrees to 69 degrees). Post operative blood metal ion levels are compared to the patient’s pre-operative level. To date there is no increase in the metal ion levels for the ceramic/cross linked poly ethylene and ceramic/ceramic articulations. The ceramic metal group is providing intermediate raised metal ion levels, and the highest metal ion levels are in the metal on metal articulation group. In the laboratory the ceramic on metal articulation demonstrates the least wear of all the groups studied, with metal on metal second. The high level of metal ions in the latter groups has always been of concern. This study demonstrates a lower blood level of metal ions in the ceramic on metal group. If the in vivo wear rate in this group is as good as the laboratory wear, it becomes a very attractive bearing surface in younger active patients

Osteolysis is one of a major cause of failure that affect long term survival rate in THA. Hard-on-hard bearing surface were developed to reduce wear and osteolysis, such as ceramic-on-ceramic which is the lowest wear rate was introduced but it still has squeaking and ceramic fracture. Metal-on-metal bearing surface significantly reduce wear rate but it still release metal ion which affect local tissue reaction. Then ceramic-on-metal is another choice of bearing with combine the advantage of reduce wear rate, metal ion release, no stripe wear, no squeaking and no ceramic fracture. However after clinical use ALTRs may occur and disturb the longevity of THA. During January 2009 to December 2009 we performed 98 THR with the same femoral stem and acetabular cup with difference bearing which were 87 cases of metal on cross-linked PE, 8 cases of ceramic on metal and 5 cases of metal on metal. Routinely postoperative care were done with clinical evaluation, plain x-rays and Harris hip score. After 5 years follow up there are clinical problems in ceramic on metal THA with decrease clinical score and progressive osteolysis in radiographic finding in 2 cases then we investigated to find the cause of this problem and revise the components. We preformed magnetic resonance imaging and collect blood sample for ESR, CRP and Cobalt and Chromium level. We revised 2 cases of ceramic on metal THA, during surgery we collected tissue for bacterial and AFB and histopathology. All retrieval components were studied for wear pattern. First patient have thigh pain and progressive osteolysis after year 4. th. of follow up. She had normal ESR and CRP with high level of cobalt and chromium level. We revised both components and tissue histopathology showed metallosis with chronic inflammation. Another patient had failure due to ALTRs with mixed solid-cystic mass at trochanteric bursa but component is stable then only bearing surface were change. Wear pattern at femoral head was in weight bearing area with corresponding to apical center wear of metal liner. Our study showed that only in group of ceramic-on-metal THA that have 5 years follow up have early reoperation due to osteolysis and tissue reaction. We routinely stop to use this bearing since 2010. But we have small number of cases in our study to conclude that is bearing are not suitable for clinical usage

In 1998, lysis / wear were the biggest concerns in THR. 3 distinct tacks emerged: Alternatives to polyethylene: Ceramic / Ceramic; Metal / Metal; Make a better polyethylene. MOM story is well known: bad ending!!. Large adoption of Ceramic / Ceramic: positives: low wear, benign MR findings, even low dislocation rates !! negatives: fractures still occurred, noise generation, liner malseating, metal transfer (edge effects). Crosslinked Polyethylene: Update: 13–15 year follow-up of 1st generation XLPE with remelted product: Annual wear rates of 0.004 (metal heads) 0.002 (ceramic heads)!. No lysis!! Wear rates for “standard” heads and large heads both low approaching the lower limits of detection!!. CONCLUSION: Crosslinked Polyethylene with Ceramic Heads: The Winner and Still Champion!