Open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with trans-articular screws or dorsal plating is the standard surgical technique for displaced Lisfranc injuries. This aim of this study is to compare the clinical outcomes of percutaneous reduction and internal fixation (PRIF) of low energy Lisfranc injuries with a matched, control group of patients treated with ORIF. Over a seven-year period (2012–2019), 16 consecutive patients with a low energy Myerson B2-type injury were treated with PRIF. Patient demographics were recorded within a prospectively maintained database at the institution. This study sample was matched for age, sex and mechanism of injury to a control group of 16 patients with similar Myerson B2-type injuries treated with ORIF. Clinical outcome was compared using the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) midfoot score and Manchester Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOXFQ). At a mean follow up of 43.0 months (95% CI 35.6 – 50.4), both the AOFAS and MOXFQ scores were significantly higher in the PRIF group compared to the control ORIF group (AOFAS 89.1vs 76.4, p=0.03; MOXFQ 10.0 vs 27.6, p=0.03). There were no immediate postoperative complications in either group. At final follow up, there was no radiological evidence of midfoot osteoarthritis in any patient in the PRIF group. Three patients in the ORIF group developed midfoot osteoarthritis, one of whom required midfoot fusion. PRIF is a technically simple, less invasive method of operative stabilisation of low energy Lisfranc injures which also appears to be associated with better mid-term clinical outcomes compared to ORIF

Aims

The aim of this study was to compare the functional and radiological outcomes and the complication rate after nail and plate fixation of unstable fractures of the ankle in elderly patients.

Background. Acquired flatfoot deformity goes ahead with a partial or complete rupture and thus insufficiency of the tibialis posterior tendon. We present the results of flexor digitorum longus transfer and medial displacement calcaneal osteotomy to reconstruct the acquired deformity. Material & Methods. Twenty two patients (24 feet) with an average age of 58 (36–75) years were operated on for acquired flexible flatfoot deformity. Two patients had a bilateral procedure. Patients were seen pre-and postoperatively in order to evaluate following parameters: AOFAS hindfoot score, visual analogue scale for pain (0–10), the tarsometatarsal angle on lateral and ap standing x-rays, the cuneiform heights and talocalcaneal angle on lateral standing x-rays and subjective postoperative satisfaction score (1-worst to 5-best). Average time of follow-up was 24.7 months (12–48). Results. The AOFAS hindfoot score could be increased from 46.4 to 89.5 points, the visual analogue scale for pain decreased from 6.6 to 1.1. The average satisfaction score was 4.5 points with one patient scoring 2 and another one scoring 3. All the other patients scored either 4 or 5. All radiological parameters could be improved. Following complications were seen: one recurrence, two patients with irritation of the sural nerve, one patient with hypesthesia of the big toe. The calcaneal screws had to be removed in 3 patients. Conclusion. Flexor digitorum longus transfer together with medial displacement calcaneal osteotomy gave satisfactory results for the treatment of acquired flatfoot deformity. All radiologic parameters were improved

Triple arthrodesis is the most effective treatment resource for restoring shape and stability to the hind-foot. It is used in order to achieve a plantigrade foot, aligned, stable and painless, in the treatment of various pathologies. However, it has the effect of changing the dynamic mobility of the foot and diminishes the adapting ability to uneven ground, influencing the outcome. Opinions differ on the necessity of internal fixation to maintain the proper alignment of the hind-foot and improve consolidation, influencing the results. The authors reviewed the patients who underwent triple arthrodesis between 01/01/1998 and 31/12/2008. Of a total of 46 patients 28 were reviewed, corresponding to 29 feet that underwent 36 interventions (7 recurrences). Patients were divided into two groups according to whether or not the placement of internal fixation. They were evaluated according to the AOFAS ankle and hindfoot score and correlated with the radiologic result. The most frequent indications for surgery were osteoarthrosis of the tarsus and sequelae of fractures of the calcaneus. In the group without fixation 68% had radiological signs of consolidation. 24% required revision for non consolidation. In the group with internal fixation there was 72.7% consolidation and 9.1% required revision surgery. Bone graft was more often used in internal fixation group (72.7% vs 40%). Group without fixation vs group with internal fixation:. AOFAS mean score: 74.5% vs 61.6%, patients without pain: 50% vs 20%; plantigrade foot with good alignment: 66.7% vs 40% without pain: 50% vs 20%; tibiotarsal arthritis: 48% vs 63.6%; Lisfranc arthrosis: 44% vs 63.6%. There is a higher rate of consolidation in the group setting. However, the functional outcome seems to be better in the group without fixation. Fixation seems to be associated with better consolidation. The functional outcome is related to a plantigrade and well aligned foot

Objective. Ankle fractures are frequent and seem to be easy to handle in most cases. Of course, also these easy fractures can cause infections that must be carefully managed. What risk factors do we find? What options do we have in treating these complications? What are the consequences and what will the result for the patient be like, compared to non-infected cases?. In a retrospective study we included 82 patients treated with an osteosynthesis in ankle fractures (AO 44 B or C fractures). Average age was 52.4 years (range 20–84 years, median 51.0). Results. In 9 (10.9%) patients there were septic complications. Concerning risk factors, we found 4 (44.4%) patients with nicotine abuse, 2 (22.2%) with additional alcohol abuse. Average stay in hospital was 39.6 days (range 9–95 days). In 4 (44.4%) cases local infection was treated with antibiotics and rest alone. 5 (55.5%) of the patients had additional operations due to infection, in average 5.4 per patient (range 1–10). Early implant removal was done in 3 (33.3%) cases, in average after 3 months. We found 2 (22.2%) infections due to Staphylococcus aureus, 1 (11.1%) due to MRSA and one infection with MRSA and Proteus mirabilis. In one case vacuum dressing had been applied for 44 days. In another case infection could only be healed with an intramedullary vancomycin augmented spacer and finally a screw arthodesis of the ankle, this was a patient with proven arteriosclerosis of the lower extremities. All other fractures finally showed bony healing in xrays. No plastic surgery (e.g. flaps) was needed to close a wound definitely. In follow up (in average after 33 months, range 17–42), the average AOFAS of these patients was 76.5 (range 35–100, median 81.5), compared to an average AOFAS of 89.4 (range 35–100, median 98.0) of all patients. No patient developed a septic syndrom, no ICU stay occurred because of the infection. Conclusions. In spite of most cases of ankle fractures having good outcomes without complications, once infected an ankle osteosynthesis can be a serious problem for both surgeon and patient. Consequent surgical therapy at the right time including early hardware removal, spacers or vacuum dressing if necessary as well as an antibiotic regime addressing problematic pathogens like MRSA are needed to control infections. Problems remaining are functional outcome and wound closure in this sensitive area. Plastic surgery might be needed

Introduction. Currently, a validate scale of ankle osteoarthritis (OA) is not available and different classifications have been used, making comparisons between studies difficult. In other joints as the hip and knee, the Kellgren-Lawrence (K&L) scale, chosen as reference by the World Health Organizations is widely used to characterize OA. It consists of a physician based assessment of 3 radiological features: osteophyte formation, joint space narrowing and bone end sclerosis described as follows: grade 0: normal joint; grade 1: minute osteophytes of doubtfull significance; grade 2: definite osteophytes; grade 3: moderate diminution of joint space; grade 4: joint space greatly impaired, subchondral sclerosis. Until now, the K&L scale has never been validated in the ankle. Our objective was to assess the usefulness of the K&L scale for the ankle joint, by determining its reliability and by comparing it to functional scores and to computerized minimal joint space width (minJSW) and sclerosis measurements. Additionally we propose an atlas of standardized radiographs for each of the K&L grades in the ankle. Methods. 73 patients 10 to 20 years post ankle ORIF were examined. Bilateral ankle radiographs were taken. Four physicians independently assessed the K&L grades and evaluated tibial and talar sclerosis on anteroposterior radiographs. Functional outcome was assessed with the AOFAS Hindfoot score. Bone density and minJSW were measured using a previously validated Ankle Image Digital Analysis software (AIDA). Results. The interobserver reliability, for the K&L stages was 0.60 (intraclass correlation coefficient) indicating moderate to good agreement. The mean AOFAS hindfoot score decreased substantially (p = 009) and linearly from 99.3 in K&L grade 0 to 79.5 points in K&L grade 4. The minJSW assessed by AIDA was similar among grades 0 to 2 (between 2 and 2.5mm), but significantly lower in grade 3 (1.8mm) and in grade 4 (1.1mm). A decreased minJSW less than 2mm, commonly used as a threshold for the assessment of hip and knee OA, was found in 77% of K&L grades 3–4 compared to 33% of grades 0–2, sensitivity 77.4% and specificity 66.7%. Physician based assessment revealed that subchondral sclerosis was present in 16% of K&L grade 1 patients, 52% of grade 2, 70% of grade 3 and 100% of grade 4 patients. No correlation could be found between physician based assessment and digital image analysis of subchondral sclerosis. Conclusions. Interobserver reliability in assessment of ankle OA using the K&L scale was similar to other previously described joints. OA progression correlated with functional diminution. Joint space narrowing assessed AIDA as well as the cut-off of 2mm correlated well with the K&L scale. Overall, we recommend the use of the K&L scale for the radiographic assessment of ankle OA

INTRODUCTION. Percutaneous surgery is an increasingly accepted technic for the treatment of Hallux valgus but it has some limitations when the intermetatarsal angle ismoderate to severe, having high risk of recurrence. The mini tight-rope used as a complement for precutaneous surgery avoids complications of open surgery osteotomies (delays consolidation, pain, screws protusion, infection) and it allows us continue with the recurrent trend towards minimal invasive surgery. MATERIAL AND METHOD. Between 2007 and 2009, 60 patients with severe Hallux valgus were treated in our Hospital using the percutaneous mini tight-rope. The mean age of patients was 62, 5 patients were man and 55 were woman. The mean follow-up was 18 months. RESULTS. Patients had clinical assessment using AOFAS score, radiological assessment and a subjective satisfaction degree assessment at 2,6 weeks and 4-6-12 months postoperative. As complications we found four technical failures due to learning curve, one infection and one second metatarsal fracture. CONCLUSION. mini tight-rope is a good option as a supplement in the treatment of severe hallux valgus by percutaneous technique because it avoids complications of open surgery, obtaining satisfactory results in 76% of cases according to the AOFAS scale

The avulsion fracture of the V-th metatarsal and Jones fractures often show delayed and non-union. The tension belt osteosynthesis shows often soft tissue problems due to the thin soft tisshe covering. A new minimal invasive method with the 3,5mm XXS nail and the clinical results are presented. Percutaneously the fracture is reduced with a K-wire as a joy stick. This or if the direction needed is different a second K-wire as guide is introduced and with a canulated 3,5 mm drill the place for the nail is prepared. Proximal and distal to the fracture one threaded wire locking and fracture compression through the nail (proximal longitudinal holes) are performed. 77 patients with a XXS nail fixation of MT V fractures were treated from July 1999 to Jan.2006. Clinical and radiological re-examination at 1 to 6 years were performed. The AOFAS was 22 pre- and 96 postoperatively. No pseudarthrosis but in 53 patients implant removal was done in part due to local discomfort. This was strictly correlated to the length of the threaded wires to the bone surface. 95% reached pretrauma activity levels. Satisfaction was 9 from 10 points. The XXS nails allow a percutaneous stable fixation of the avulsion and Jones fractures of the V-th metatarsus. The complication rate is low

Background. Distal tibial metaphyseal fractures pose many complexities. This study assessed the outcomes of distal tibial fractures treated with percutaneously inserted medial locking plates. Methods. Eighteen patients were selected based on the fracture pattern and classified using the AO classification and stabilised with an AO medial tibial locking plate. Time to fracture union, complications and outcomes were assessed with the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle score at 12 months. Results. Sixteen of the 18 patients achieved fracture union, with 1 patient lost to follow up. Twelve fractures united within 24 weeks, with an average union time of 23.1 weeks. Three delayed unions, two at 28 weeks and one at 56 weeks. The average time to union was 32 weeks in the smokers and 15.3 weeks in the non-smokers. Five of the 18 patients (27%) developed complications. One superficial wound infection and one chronic wound infection, resulting in non-union at 56 weeks, requiring revision. Two patients required plate removal, one after sustaining an open fracture at the proximal end of the plate 6 months after surgery (post fracture union) and the other for painful hardware. One patient had implant failure of three proximal diaphyseal locking screws at the screw head/neck junction, but successful fracture union. The average AOFAS ankle score was 88.8 overall, and 92.1 in fractures that united within 24 weeks. Conclusions. Distal tibial locking plates have high fracture union rates, minimum soft tissue complications, and good functional outcomes. The literature shows similar fracture union and complication rates in locking and non-locking plates

In hallux valgus (HV), toe pronation is frequently seen, although there may be some with no pronation. Aims. to evaluate big toe pronation in patients with HV with a clinical and radiographic method. Material and methods. prospective study of 40 patients with HV on the waiting list for surgical treatment. Patients were standing barefoot on a rigid platform. Digital photographs were taken in a frontal plane to obtain the nail-floor angle formed by the secant line of toenail border and a line formed by the platform edge. All patients were evaluated using the AOFAS for HV and lesser toes, if they were affected. Personal and social data were obtained from clinical interviews. Charge radiographs were used to obtain HV, intermetatarsal and PASA angles, first metatarsal rotation as well as sesamoid bones displacement. Exclusion criteria: rheumatoid arthritis and previous intervention on foot or toes. Statistical analysis were performed with a multiple lineal regression. Results. the mean age was 57 years old, they were 31 female and 9 men, with an average AOFAS score of 49, they had a mean of 37° HV angle, 27° nail-floor angle, 20° first metatarsal rotation in about half of patients. We have found a statistical significant relation between HV and nail-floor angles (p<0,001), between sesamoid bones displacement and nail-floor angles (p<0,007), between first metatarsal rotation and HV angle (p<0,001. We found no statistically significant but strong relation between first metatarsal rotation and sesamoid bones displacement. Conclusion. nail-floor angle is strongly related to degree of HV, displacement of sesamoid bones and rotation of the first metatarsal

Aims

No randomized comparative study has compared the extensile lateral approach (ELA) and sinus tarsi approach (STA) for Sanders type 2 calcaneal fractures. This randomized comparative study was conducted to confirm whether the STA was prone to fewer wound complications than the ELA.

Objectives. Osteochondral ankle defects (OCDs) mainly occur in a young, active population. In 63% of cases the defect is located on the medial talar dome. Arthroscopic debridement and microfracture is considered the primary treatment for defects up to 15 mm. To treat patients with a secondary OCD of the medial talar dome, a 15-mm diameter metal implant (HemiCAP ®) was developed. The set of 15 offset sizes was designed to correspond with the anatomy of various talar dome curvatures. Recently, two independent biomechanical cadaver studies were published, providing rationale for clinical use. The present study was undertaken to evaluate the clinical effectiveness and safety of the metal implantation technique for osteochondral lesions of the medial talar dome in a prospective study. Material and methods. Since October 2007, twenty patients have been treated with the implant. Four patients who did not meet the inclusion criteria and four patients who had less than one-year follow-up at the time of writing were left out of this analysis. Twelve patients are reported with one year (n=8) or two years (n=4) follow-up. All patients had had one or two earlier operations without success. On preoperative CT-scanning, the mean lesion size was 16 × 11 (range, 9–26 × 8–14) mm. Outcome measures were: Numeric Rating Scale pain (NRS) at rest and when walking, Foot Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) Ankle-Hindfoot score, and clinical and radiographic complications. Data are presented as median and range. The Wilcoxon signed ranks test was used to calculate p-values. Results. All patients recovered well from surgery. The NRS at rest improved from 3 (0–7) preoperatively, to 0.5 (0–4) after 1 year and 1 (0–1) after 2 years follow-up (p < 0.05). The NRS when walking was 6.5 (4–8) preoperatively, improving to 1.5 (0–5) at 1 year and 1 (0–2) at 2 years follow-up (p < 0.05). The five subscales of the FAOS improved from 14–64 preoperatively, to 53–91 after 1 year and 63–100 after 2 years (p < 0.05). The AOFAS improved from 70 (42–75) before surgery to 86 (58–100) at 1 year, and 89 (82–90) at 2 years follow-up (p < 0.05). There were no clinical or radiographic complications. Conclusion. The metallic implantation technique appears to be a promising treatment for secondary OCDs of the talus, but more patients and longer follow-up are necessary to draw firm conclusions

Introduction. Debate remains which surgical technique should be used for ankle arthrodesis. Several open approaches have been described, as well as the arthroscopic method, using a variety of fixation devices. Both arthroscopic and open procedures have good results with union rates of 93–95%, 3% malunion rate and patient satisfaction of 70–90%, although some report complication rates as high as 40%. Aims. To identify union, complication and patient satisfaction rates with open ankle fusions (using the plane between EHL and tibialis anterior). Method. A retrospective review of all isolated primary fusions performed between 2005 and 2009. Patient records were reviewed and patients were recalled for clinical evaluation and AOFAS scoring. Follow up range was 7 months–8.3 years (mean 4 years). Results. 82 ankles were identified in 73 patients. Medical notes were reviewed for all patients. Fifty five patients were clinically reviewed (75% response rate), a further 3 contacted by telephone (79% response rate). Fifeteen were not contactable. Male 47: 35 female, age range at surgery 18–75 years (mean 56.1), left 37: 45 right, 8 were smokers. Causes leading to fusion were: Trauma 52 (63%), OA 17, Rh.A 7, CMT 3, CTEV 2, Talar AVN 1. All fusions were performed with 2 (78) or 3 (4) medial tibiotalar screws. Length of stay range: 1–12 days (mean 3.1). All patients were placed in plaster post operatively for a minimum 12 weeks. Time to union ranged from 8 to 39 weeks (mean 13.3) with a union rate of 100%. Major complications were 14.6%: 7 (8.5%) malalignment, 3 (3.7%) wound problems, 2 (2.4%) complex regional pain syndrome. There were no non unions, DVT, PE, stress fractures or deep infections. There were 2 (2.4%) delayed unions (> 6 months, both smokers), 6 (7%) asymptomatic superficial peroneal nerve injuries and one saphenous nerve injury. Four (4.8%) required screw removal. Subsequent fusions were performed in 7.3%, 4 subtalar, 1 triple and 1 chopart. The AOFAS range was 8–89 (mean 66). 79% were either ‘very satisfied’ or ‘satisfied’ and 8% were ‘very disatisfied’ or ‘disatisfied’. Patients played a variety of sports including golf, squash, badmington and sky diving. Conclusion. These results show excellent union rates (100%) in part related to the strong no smoking policy and meticulous surgical technique. Two delayed unions (union at 39 and 31 weeks) were smokers. There were high satisfaction rates, however varus malalignment and persistent pain (particularly CRPS) resulted in dissatisfaction. Many patients remained highly active. These results exceed the current reported union rates and compare favourable with complications and patient satisfaction and we therefore advocate this technique

Our aim was to compare the one-year post-operative outcomes following retention or removal of syndesmotic screws in adult patients with a fracture of the ankle that was treated surgically. A total of 51 patients (35 males, 16 females), with a mean age of 33.5 years (16 to 62), undergoing fibular osteosynthesis and syndesmotic screw fixation, were randomly allocated to retention of the syndesmotic screw or removal at three months post-operatively. The two groups were comparable at baseline.

One year post-operatively, there was no significant difference in the mean Olerud–Molander ankle score (82.4 retention vs 86.7 removal, p = 0.367), the mean American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle-hindfoot score (88.6 vs 90.1, p = 0.688), the mean American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons foot and ankle score (96.3 vs 94.0, p = 0.250), the mean visual analogue pain score (1.0 vs 0.7, p = 0.237), the mean active dorsiflexion (10.2° vs 13.0°, p = 0.194) and plantar flexion (33.6° vs 31.3°, p = 0.503) of the ankle, or the mean radiological tibiofibular clear space (5.0 mm vs 5.3 mm, p = 0.276) between the two groups. A total of 19 patients (76%) in the retention group had a loose and/or broken screw one year post-operatively.

We conclude that removal of a syndesmotic screw produces no significant functional, clinical or radiological benefit in adult patients who are treated surgically for a fracture of the ankle.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2014;96-B:1699–1705.

Aims

Although infrequent, a fracture of the cuboid can lead to significant disruption of the integrity of the midfoot and its function. The purpose of this study was to classify the pattern of fractures of the cuboid, relate them to the mechanism of injury and suggest methods of managing them.

The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical and radiological outcome of patients with intact, broken and removed syndesmosis screws after Weber B or C ankle fracture with an associated injury to the syndesmosis. We hypothesised that there would be no difference. Of a possible 142 patients who fulfilled our inclusion criteria, 52 returned for clinical and radiological assessment at least one year after surgery. Of these, 27 had intact syndesmosis screws, ten had broken screws, and 15 had undergone elective removal of the screw. The mean American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle/hindfoot score was 83.07 (sd 13.59) in the intact screw group, 92.40 (sd 12.69) in the broken screw group, and 85.80 (sd 11.33) in the removed screw group (p = 0.0466).

There was no difference in clinical outcome of patients with intact or removed syndesmotic screws. Paradoxically, patients with a broken syndesmosis screw had the best clinical outcome. Our data do not support the removal of intact or broken syndesmosis screws, and we caution against attributing post-operative ankle pain to breakage of the syndesmosis screw.

We have compared the results at a mean follow-up of 13 years (11 to 14) of two groups of supination-external rotation type-4 fractures of the ankle, in one of which there was a fracture of the medial malleolus and in the other the medial deltoid ligament had been partially or completely ruptured.

Of 66 patients treated operatively between 1993 and 1997, 36 were available for follow-up. Arthroscopy had been performed in all patients pre-operatively to assess the extent of the intra-articular lesions. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hind-foot score was used for clinical evaluation and showed a significant difference in both the total and the functional scores (p < 0.05), but not in those for pain or alignment, in favour of the group with a damaged deltoid ligament (p < 0.05). The only significant difference between the groups on the short-form 36 quality-of-life score was for bodily pain, again in favour of the group with a damaged deltoid ligament. There was no significant difference between the groups in the subjective visual analogue scores or in the modified Kannus radiological score.

Arthroscopically, there was a significant difference with an increased risk of loose bodies in the group with an intact deltoid ligament (p < 0.005), although there was no significant increased risk of deep cartilage lesions in the two groups.

At a mean follow-up of 13 years after operative treatment of a supination-external rotation type-4 ankle fracture patients with partial or complete rupture of the medial deltoid ligament tended to have a better result than those with a medial malleolar fracture.

A high rate of complications is associated with open reduction and internal fixation of Sanders type 4 fractures of the calcaneum. We assessed the long-term outcome of 83 Sanders type 4 comminuted intra-articular fractures of the calcaneum in 64 patients who underwent non-operative treatment between 1999 and 2005. Each fracture was treated by closed reduction and immobilisation in a long leg cast. Patients were reviewed every three months in the first year, and every six months thereafter. At each visit, the involved ankles were assessed by the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) criteria. The degree of fracture healing and the presence of osteoarthritis were assessed.

At a mean follow-up of 51 months (24 to 70) the mean AOFAS score was 72 (52 to 92). Osteoarthritis was scored radiologically using Graves’ classification and was evident in the subtalar joints of 75 ankles (90%) on x-ray and in all ankles on CT scans, of which 20 were grade 0 or 1, 39 grade 2, and 24 grade 3.

A non-operative approach to treating these fractures may be simpler, less expensive, easier to administer with fewer complications, and may be better tolerated than surgery, by many patients.

The extended lateral L-shaped approach for the treatment of displaced intra-articular fractures of the calcaneum may be complicated by wound infection, haematoma, dehiscence and injury to the sural nerve. In an effort to reduce the risk of problems with wound healing a technique was developed that combined open reduction and fixation of the joint fragments and of the anterior process with percutaneous reduction and screw fixation of the tuberosity. A group of 24 patients with unilateral isolated closed Sanders type II and III fractures was treated using this technique and compared to a similar group of 26 patients managed by the extended approach and lateral plating. The operation was significantly shorter (p < 0.001) in the first group, but more minor secondary procedures and removal of heel screws were necessary. There were no wound complications in this group, whereas four minor complications occurred in the second group. The accuracy and maintenance of reduction, and ultimate function were equivalent.

Fracture-dislocations of the tarsometatarsal (Lisfranc) joints are frequently overlooked or misdiagnosed at initial presentation. This is a comparative cohort study over a period of five years comparing primary open reduction and internal fixation in 22 patients (23 feet) with secondary corrective arthrodesis in 22 patients (22 feet) who presented with painful malunion at a mean of 22 months (1.5 to 45) after injury. In the first group primary treatment by open reduction and internal fixation for eight weeks with Kirschner-wires or screws was undertaken, in the second group treatment was by secondary corrective arthrodesis. There was one deep infection in the first group. In the delayed group there was one complete and one partial nonunion.

In each group 20 patients were available for follow-up at a mean of 36 months (24 to 89) after operation. The mean American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society midfoot score was 81.4 (62 to 100) after primary treatment and 71.8 (35 to 88) after corrective arthrodesis (t-test; p = 0.031).

We conclude that primary treatment by open reduction and internal fixation of tarsometatarsal fracture-dislocations leads to improved functional results, earlier return to work and greater patient satisfaction than secondary corrective arthrodesis, which remains a useful salvage procedure providing significant relief of pain and improvement in function.