The use of megaprostheses is accompanied with periprosthetic infection in up to 15% of cases. Among metals with antimicrobial activity, silver has raised the interest of investigators because of its good antimicrobial activity. The aim of this study was to determine the infection rate of silver-coated megaprostheses in comparision to uncoated titanium prostheses. We prospectively identified 40 patients who were treated with a silver-coated proximal femur (n=17) or proximal tibia (n=23) replacement (Mutars®, Implantcast, Germany). Patients with a silver-coated tumor endoprosthesis were compared with 74 (proximal femur replacement n=33, proximal tibia n=41) retrospectively assessed patients with a titanium endoprosthesis regarding the number of infections. In the titanium group a proximal femur replacement was associated with the highest infection rate (18.2%; time of infection in mean 15 months postoperatively). In the silver-group infection could be reduced to 5.9% (time of infection 12 months postoperatively). In patients with a proximal tibia replacement the infection rate could be reduced from 17.1% (time of infection in mean 28 months postoperatively) to 4.3% (time of infection 4 months postoperatively) in the silver group. Regarding the final, successful treatment of infection it can be stated that in the silver group the patients could be treated either by intravenous antibiotics only or by a one-stage exchange of the prosthetic body. In the titanium group seven patients (53%) were treated by a two-stage reimplantation of the prosthesis, in 4 patients (31%) an amputation and in one patient rotationplasty was performed. We conclude that silver-coated megaendoprostheses can reduce the risk of infection on a short-term followup. Importantly, minor revisions in the case of infection in patients with a silver-coated prostheses were more often successful. Further studies with more patients and a longer followup are necessary in order to evaluate the possible benefit of silver exactly.
Megaendoprotheses are widely used in the reconstruction of large bone defects in orthopaedic tumour surgery. The major complications (up to 36%) are periprosthetic infections. Persisting periprosthetic infections lead to secondary amputation up to 37% of the cases. One underestimated reason for persisting infections are subpopulations of S. aureus called “small colony variants” (SCVs). Aim of this study was to evaluate that silver ions might prevent or cure a periprosthetic infection caused by SCVs. For testing the antimicrobial activity of silver-coated titanium we used a technique introduced by Bechert et al. Therefore an adhesion and proliferation assay was performed with clinical isolates of S. aureus SCV (A22616/3). We tested the adhesion and proliferation properties of S aureus SCV on stainless steel (steel), Cobalt-Chrome-Molybdenum-alloy (CoCrMo), Titan-Aluminium-Vanadium-alloy (TiAlVa) and silver-coated Titan-Aluminium-Vanadium-alloy (scTiAlVa). Adhesion of S. aureus SCV is significantly reduced on scTiAlVa vs. steel (p>
0001). We could also demonstrate that the proliferation rate of scTiAlVa vs. all tested materials is significant (p>
0001) lower. We concluded that silver-coating has an effective antimicrobial activity against S. aureus SCVs. Thus silver-coated megaendoprostheses are a good prophylaxis against persisting infections caused by S. aureus SCVs.
