Ankle fusion (AF), a durable intervention for ankle arthritis, has been the management of choice but restricts mobility. Recently, total ankle replacement (TAR) has been offered to patients looking to maintain mobility. The aim was to compare the biomechanics of AF and TAR while walking on inverted and everted slopes which create a greater demand for complex foot mobility than level walking. A ten-camera motion detection setup captured trials as patients walked in both directions over a 5⁰ lateral slope with embedded force plates. Moments (Nm/Kg) across the knee and ankle were exported from Visual 3D in the sagittal and frontal plane, and data were reported as means with 95% confidence intervals. 15 patients were recruited (6 TAR, 9 AF). The median age, follow-up and BMI was 67 years, 4 years and 35.8 kg/m² in AF, and 73 years, 7 years and 28.1 kg/m² in TAR, respectively. During inverted slope walking (4 TAR, 7 AF), abduction moments across (i) the knee: TAR 0.38 (0.37–0.39) vs AF 0.37 (0.27–0.52) and (ii) the ankle: TAR 0.20 (0.13–0.27) vs AF 0.25 (0.18–0.32), and extension moments across (i) the knee: TAR 0.68 (0.38–0.97) vs AF 0.85 (0.69–1.01) and (ii) the ankle: TAR 1.46 (1.30–1.62) vs AF 1.30 (1.08–1.52). During everted walking (5 TAR, 7 AF), abduction moments across (i) the knee: TAR 0.41 (0.30–0.52) vs AF 0.46 (0.27–0.66) and (ii) the ankle: TAR 0.24 (0.11–0.38) vs AF 0.26 (0.18–0.33), and extension moments across (i) the knee: TAR 0.76 (0.54–0.99) vs AF 0.93 (0.72–1.14) and (ii) the ankle: TAR 1.39 (1.19–1.59) vs AF 1.26 (1.04–1.48). There were no differences in abduction moments during inverted or everted slope walking. However, patients with AF had increased extension moments across the knee, particularly on inverted slopes, suggesting that AF creates a greater demand for knee compensation than TAR.
Perthes’ disease is an idiopathic avascular necrosis of the developing femoral head, often causing deformity that impairs physical function. Current treatments aim to optimize the joint reaction force across the hip by enhancing congruency between the acetabulum and femoral head. Despite a century of research, there is no consensus regarding the optimal treatment. The aim of this study was to describe the experiences of children, their families, and clinicians when considering the treatment of Perthes’ disease. A qualitative study gathered information from children and their families affected by Perthes’ disease, along with treating clinicians. Interviews followed a coding framework, with the interview schedule informed by behavioural theory and patient and public involvement. Transcripts were analyzed using the framework method.Aims
Methods
This study aims to assess the changes in mechanical behaviour over time in ‘haemarthritic’ articular cartilage compared to ‘healthy’ articular cartilage. Pin-on-plate and indentation tests were used to determine the coefficient of friction (COF) and deformation of ‘healthy’ and ‘haemarthritic articular cartilage. Osteochondral pins (8 mm) were extracted from porcine tali and immersed in exposure fluid for two hours prior to test. Pins were articulated against a larger bovine femoral plate for 3600 seconds under a load of 50 N. Osteochondral pins (8 mm) were loaded during indentation testing for 3600 seconds under a load of 0.25 N. To mimic the effect of a joint bleed in vitro; serum, whole blood and 50% v/v were used as exposure and lubricant fluids. COF and deformation were expressed as mean (n=3) and statistically analysed using a one-way ANOVA and post-hoc Tukey test (p>0.05). The serum condition yielded a COF of 0.0428 ± 0.02 with 0.08mm ± 0.04 deformation. The 50% v/v condition produced a higher COF of 0.0485 ± 0.02 and 0.21mm ± 0.04 deformation. The lowest COF and deformation were produced by the whole blood condition (0.0292 ± 0.02 and 0.06mm ± 0.006 respectively). Statistical analysis indicated no significant difference across the friction test conditions but a significant difference across all indentation test conditions (ANOVA, p>0.05). Combination of creep deformation and wear was observed on the articular surface up to 24 hours post-test in 50% v/v and whole blood conditions. The average haemophilia patient can experience multiple joint bleeds per year of which this study demonstrates the effect of just one joint bleed. This study has provided evidence of potential reversible and irreversible mechanical changes to articular cartilage surface during a joint bleed.
To compare the cost-utility of removable brace compared with cast in the management of adult patients with ankle fracture. A within-trial economic evaluation conducted from the UK NHS and personnel social services (PSS) perspective. Health resources and quality-of-life data were collected as part of the Ankle Injury Rehabilitation (AIR) multicentre, randomized controlled trial over a 12-month period using trial case report forms and patient-completed questionnaires. Cost-utility analysis was estimated in terms of the incremental cost per quality adjusted life year (QALY) gained. Estimate uncertainty was explored by bootstrapping, visualized on the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio plane. Net monetary benefit and probability of cost-effectiveness were evaluated at a range of willingness-to-pay thresholds and visualized graphically.Aims
Methods
Flattening of the talar dome is observed clinically in haemarthropathy as structural and functional changes advance but has not been quantified yet. In order to confirm clinical observation, and assess the degree of change, morphological measurements were derived from MR images. Four measurements were taken, using ImageJ (1.52v), from sagittal MRI projections at three locations – medial, lateral and central: Trochlear Tali Arc Length (TaAL), Talar Height (TaH), Trochlear Tali Length (TaL), and Trochlear Tali Radius (TaR). These measurements were used to generate three ratios of interest: TaR:TaAL, TaAL:TaL, and TaL:TaH. With the hypothesis of a flattening of the talar dome with haemarthropathy, it was expected that TaR:TaAL and TaL:TaH should be greater for haemophilic ankles, and TaAL:TaL should be smaller. A total of 126 MR images (ethics: MEEC 18–022) were included to assess the difference in those ratios between non-diseased ankles (33 images from 11 volunteers) and haemophilic ankles (93 images from 8 patients’ ankles). Non-diseased control measurements were compared to literature to assess the capacity of doing measurements on MRI instead of radiographs or CT.Abstract
OBJECTIVE
METHODS
The importance of cup position on the performance of total hip replacements (THR) has been demonstrated in Pelvic movement data for walking for 39 unilateral THR patients was acquired (Leeds Biomedical Research Centre). Patient's elected walking speed was used to group patients into high- and low-functioning (mean speed, 1.36(SD 0.09)ms−1 and 0.85(SD 0.08)ms−1 respectively). A computational algorithm (Python3.7) was developed to calculate cup version during gait cycle. Inputs were pelvic angles and initial cup orientation (assumed to be 45° inclination and 7° version, anterior pelvic plane was parallel to radiological frontal plane). Outputs were cup version angles during a gait cycle (101 measurements/cycle). Minimum, maximum and average cup version during gait cycle were measured for each patient. Two-sample t-test (p=0.05) was used to compare groups.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Implant loosening remains a common cause of total ankle replacement (TAR) revision, and has been associated with wear-mediated osteolysis. Limited pre-clinical studies for TARs have been reported and the variety of experiment settings make it difficult to compare wear rates. Factors such as simulator control mechanism; whether pneumatic or electromechanical, may influence the integrity of the simulator outputs with respect to input profiles. This study compares the wear of a TAR, tested in electromechanical and pneumatic experimental simulators under identical input conditions. Twelve medium BOX® (MatOrtho Ltd) TARs (n=6 for each simulator) were tested in an electromechanical and pneumatic knee simulator (Simulation Solutions, UK) for 3 million cycles (Mc). Standard ‘Leeds’ displacement-controlled inputs were used. Kinematic performance was investigated by comparing the output profiles against the maximum demanded input values. The lubricant used was 25% new-born calf serum and wear was determined gravimetrically.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) is an alternative to ankle arthrodesis, replacing the degenerated joint with a mechanical motion-preserving alternative. Implant loosening remains a primary cause of TAA revision, and has been associated with wear-mediated osteolysis. Differing implant designs have a major influence on the wear performance of joint replacements. Providing a range of implant sizes allows surgeons a greater intra-operative choice for varying patient anatomy and potential to minimise wear. Minimal pre-clinical testing exists in the literature that investigates the effect of implant size on the wear behaviour. The aim of this study therefore was to investigate the effect of two different implant sizes on the wear performance of a TAA. Six ‘medium’ and six ‘extra small’ BOX® (MatOrtho Ltd, UK) TAA implants, of the same conceptual design and polyethylene insert thickness, were tested in a modified 6 station pneumatic knee simulator. 5 million cycles (Mc) of wear simulation were completed for each implant size, under kinematics aiming to replicate an ankle gait cycle (Figure 1) [1]. The simulator used had six degrees of freedom, of which four were controlled. The maximum axial load was 3150N, equivalent to 4.5 times body weight of a 70kg individual. The flexion profile ranged from −15° plantarflexion to 15° dorsiflexion. Rotation about the tibial component ranged from −2.3° of internal rotation to 8° external rotation, and anterior/posterior (AP) displacement ranged from 3.1 mm anterior to −0.9 mm posterior displacement. The lubricant used was 25% bovine serum supplemented with 0.04% sodium azide to prevent bacterial degradation. The wear of the TAA polyethylene inserts were determined gravimetrically after each Mc, with unloaded soak controls used to compensate for the uptake of moisture by the polyethylene.Background
Materials & Methods
Post-operative periprosthetic femoral fractures (PFF) are a devastating complication associated with high mortality and are costly. Few risk factors are modifiable apart from implant choice. The design features governing risk of PFF are unknown. We estimated the 90-day risk of revision for PFF associated with design features of cementless femoral stems and to investigate the effect of a collar on early PFF risk using a biomechanical in-vitro model. 337 647 primary THAs from the National Joint Registry (UK) were included in a multivariable survival and regression analysis to identify the adjusted hazard of PFF revision following primary THA using cementless stems. The effect of a collar in cementless THA on early PFF was evaluated in an in-vitro model using paired fresh frozen cadaveric femora.Background
Patients, materials and methods
Intraoperative periprosthetic femoral fractures (IOPFF) lead to reduced implant survival. A deeper understanding of predictors enables surgeons to modify techniques and patient selection to reduce the risk of IOPFF. The aim of this study was to estimate predictors of IOPFF and each anatomical subtype (calcar crack, trochanteric fracture, femoral shaft fracture) during primary THA. This retrospective cohort study included 793823 primary THAs between 2004 and 2016. Relative risks for patient, surgical and implant factors are estimated for any IOPFF fracture and for all anatomical subtypes of IOPFF.Introduction
Methods
Preclinical testing of implants considers THR patients a homogenous group; in reality, patients are heterogeneous and previous large cohort studies have explored stratification and identified that THR patients function differently [1]. The wide- spread failure of the ASR hip highlighted the potential importance of patient characteristics [2], and a more robust pre- clinical testing procedure may have improved prediction of outcome. Therefore this study aimed to identify differences in hip contact force (HCF) in THR patients stratified by their functional ability. 133 THR patients, >12 months post-surgery, underwent 3D kinematic (Vicon, UK) and kinetic (AMTI, USA) analysis whilst walking at self-selected speed. HCF's, normalized by body weight, were computed through multibody modeling (AnyBody Technology, Denmark) during gait and a mean for each patient was calculated from three to five walking trials. Patients were stratified into three functionality groups by distribution around the mean gait speed for the full cohort of 1.1m/s. The low functioning group (LF) comprised cases with a gait speed ≤0.93 m/s (i.e. 1.1m/s ≤1SD), the mid functioning group (MF) comprised cases with a gait speed between 0.94 m/s and 1.25 m/s (cohort mean ± 1SD), while the high functioning group (HF) included cases walking ≥1.26 m/s. Differences between groups were analyzed using one- dimensional statistical parametric mapping [3]. Linear regression was used to test for significant differences across groups. The test statistic SPM{t} was evaluated at each point in the normalized time series, and a critical threshold corresponding to an error rate of α= 0.05 was calculated based on random field theory. Supra-threshold clusters with their associated p-values were then identified.Introduction
Methods
Total hip replacement (THR) patients are often considered a homogenous group whereas in reality, patients are heterogeneous. Variation in revision rates between patient groups suggest that implants are exposed to different environmental conditions in different patients [1]. Previous reports suggest that for every unit increase of BMI, there is a 2% increased risk of revision of a THR [2]. The aim of this study was to better understand the effect of patient-specific characteristics such as BMI on hip motions and to explore the possible impact on wear. 137 THR patients, at least 12 months post-surgery, underwent 3D kinematic (Vicon, Oxford, UK) and kinetic (AMTI, USA) analysis whilst walking at self-selected walking speed. 3D kinematic data were then mapped onto a modelled femoral cup at 20 pre-determined points to create pathways for femoral head contact, which were then quantified by deriving the aspect ratio (AR). Patients were stratified into three groups determined by BMI scores; healthy weight (BMI ≤25 kg/m2) (n=34); overweight (BMI >25kg/m2 to ≤ 30 kg/m2) (n=66) and obese patients (BMI > 30 kg/m2) (n=37). Comparisons were made using 95% confidence intervals (CI) and one way ANOVAs.Introduction
Methods
One of the known mechanisms which could contribute to the failure of total hip replacements (THR) is edge contact. Failures associated with edge contact include rim damage and lysis due to altered loading and torques. Recent study on four THR patients showed that the inclusion of pelvic motions in a contact model increased the risk of edge contact in some patients. The aim of current study was to determine whether pelvic motions have the same effect on contact location for a larger patient cohort and determine the contribution of each of the pelvic rotations to this effect. Gait data was acquired from five male and five female unilateral THR patients using a ten camera Vicon system (Oxford Metrics, UK) interfaced with twin force plates (AMTI) and using a CAST marker set. All patients had good surgical outcomes, confirmed by patient-reported outcomes and were considered well-functioning, based on elective walking speed. Joint contact forces and pelvic motions were obtained from the AnyBody modelling system (AnyBody Technologies, DK). Only gait cycle regions with available force plate data were considered. A finite element model of a 32mm head on a featureless hemispherical polyethylene cup, 0.5mm radial clearance, was used to obtain the contact area from the contact force. A bespoke computational tool was used to analyse patients' gait profiles with and without pelvic motions. The risk of edge contact was measured as a “centre proximity angle” between the cup pole and centre of the contact area, and “edge proximity angle” between the cup pole and the furthest contact area point away from the pole. Pelvic tilt, drop and internal-external rotation were considered one at a time and in combinations.Introduction
Methods
Total ankle replacement (TAR) is a substitute to ankle fusion, replacing the degenerated joint with a mechanical motion-conserving alternative. Compared with hip and knee replacements, TARs remain to be implanted in much smaller numbers, due to the surgical complexity and low mid-to-long term survival rates. TAR manufacturers have recently explored the use of varying implant sizes to improve TAR performance. This would allow surgeons a wider scope for implanting devices for varying patient demographics. Minimal pre-clinical testing has been demonstrated to date, while existing wear simulation standards lack definition. Clinical failure of TARs and limited research into wear testing defined a need for further investigation into the wear performance of TARs to understand the effects of the kinematics on varying implant sizes. Six medium and six extra small BOX® (MatOrtho) TARs will be tested in a modified knee simulator for 5 million cycles (Mc). The combinations of simulator inputs that mimic natural gait conditions were extracted from ankle kinematic profiles defined in previous literature. The peak axial load will be 3.15 kN, which is equivalent to 4.5 times body weight of a 70kg individual. The flexion profile ranges from 15° plantarflexion to 15° dorsiflexion. Rotation about the tibial component will range from −2.3° of internal rotation to 8° external rotation, while the anterior/posterior displacement will be 7mm anterior to −2mm posterior throughout the gait cycle. The components will be rotated through the simulation stations every Mc to account for inter-station variability. Gravimetric measurements of polyethylene wear will be taken at every Mc stage. A contact profilometer will also be used to measure average surface roughness of each articulating surface pre-and-post simulation. The development of such methods will be crucial in the ongoing improvement of TARs, and in enhancing clinical functionality, through understanding the envelope of TAR performance.
In the UK, the posterior approach (PA) and direct lateral approach (DLA) are the most common total hip arthroplasty (THA) procedures. Few studies however, have compared the subsequent functional outcomes. This exploratory study aimed to examine the effect of PA and DLA approaches on post-operative hip kinematics, strength and hip muscle cross-sectional area (CSA), compared to healthy controls. Participants comprised of 15 cases in the DLA group, > 12 month post-operatively, (ten male, age 68.9+/-5.5 years, BMI 26.9+/-3.0), 13 cases in the PA group (six male; age 72.9+/-6.9 years, BMI 27.1+/-3.6) and 11 age/BMI-matched healthy control participants. All participants underwent 3D kinematic (Vicon, Oxford, UK) and kinetic (AMTI, USA) analysis whist performing self-selected and fast walking as well as sit-to-stand and stand-to-sit. Isometric dynamometry was performed (Biodex Medical systems, USA) for all major muscle groups around the operated hip, and a subset of five participants (three DLA v two PA) underwent “slice encoding for metal artefact correction” (SEMAC) MRI imaging to measure muscle CSA. Patient-reported outcome measures were collected. Both post-operative surgical groups exhibited altered gait, particularly in limited hip extension, compared to the control participants. The DLA group demonstrated forced hip extension matching controls only under fast walking conditions while the PA group did not achieve hip extension. Both surgical approaches achieved high PROMs scores. The PA group were weaker for all strength activities tested, whereas the DLA cases demonstrated similar hip strength to controls. SEMAC imaging revealed reduced CSA for those muscles dissected during surgery, compared to the contralateral side. This exploratory study demonstrated small but measurable differences between surgical approaches for muscle CSA, hip strength of major hip muscle groups and a number of gait variables, although both approaches produce satisfactory functional outcomes for patients after surgery.
Total ankle replacement (TAR) is less successful than other joint replacements with a 77% survivorship at 10 years. Predominant indications for revision include: Insert dislocation, soft tissue impingement and pain/stiffness. Insert edge-loading may be both a product and cause of these indications and was reported to affect 22% of patients with the, now withdrawn from market, Ankle Evolutive System (AES) TAR (Transysteme, Nimes, France). Compressive forces up to seven times body weight over a relatively small contact area (∼6.0 to 9.2 cm2), in combination with multi-directional motion potentially causes significant polyethylene wear and deformation in mobile-bearing TAR designs. Direct methods of measuring component volume (e.g. pycnometer) use Archimedes' principle but cannot identify spatial changes in volume or form indicative of wear/deformation. Quantitative methods for surface analysis bridge this limitation and may advance methods for analysing the edge loading phenomena in TAR. Determine the frequency of edge loading in a cohort of explanted total ankle replacements and compare the quantitative surface characteristics using a novel explant analysis method.Introduction
Aim
Total ankle replacement (TAR) has a mean survivorship of 77% at 10 years which is poor compared to other types of joint arthroplasty. Osteolysis and aseptic loosening are commonly cited TAR failure modes, the mechanisms of which are unknown. Retrieval analyses of TAR devices may reveal mechanisms of failure similar or dissimilar to other joint replacements. This study investigated whether TAR explants exhibit similar damage modes to those recognised in other total joint replacements. 22 Ankle Evolution System TARs (Transystème, Nimes, France) were implanted and retrieved by the same surgeon. Mean implantation time was 7.8 yrs (5.3 to 12.1 range). Pain and/or loosening were the indications for revision. Macro photography, an Alicona Infinite microscope and the Hood/Wasielewski scale were used to classify damage modes on the polyethylene insert. Scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy was used to determine the composition of third body debris and to image the fixation surface of the tibial components. Mean damage score was 185.4 (± 40.0 SD). Damage modes common to total knee replacements were identified on both the superior and inferior insert surfaces, these included: burnishing, scratching, pitting and abrasion. Titanium particles, hydroxyapatite fragments and bone debris were embedded in the insert surfaces. Fixation surface delamination was identified by the ongrowth of tissue between the cobalt chromium substrate and titanium alloy coating. Damage modes indicative of high levels of wear and deformation were evident. Pitting caused by third body debris was abundant and suggested fixation surface wear and failure.
