Abstract

Introduction

Bisphosphonates (BP) are the first-line therapy for preventing osteoporotic fragility fractures. However, concern regarding their efficacy is growing because bisphosphonate use is associated with over-suppression of remodeling. Animal studies have reported that BP therapy is associated with accumulation of micro-cracks (Fig. 1) and a reduction in bone mechanical properties, but the effect on humans has not been investigated. Therefore, our aim was to quantify the mechanical strength of bone treated with BP, and correlate this with the microarchitecture and density of micro-damage in comparison with untreated osteoporotic hip-fractured and non-fractured elderly controls.

Clavicular hook plates have been used over the last decade in the treatment of lateral clavicular fractures with good rates of union reported throughout the literature. Fewer studies have reported the functional outcome of these patients and some have reported potential soft tissue damage post plate removal. We aimed to review the functional outcomes alongside union rates in patients treated with hook plates for lateral clavicular fractures.

In this retrospective case series, 21 patients with traumatic lateral third clavicular fractures were included. 15 had Neer type II fractures, 4 Neer type III fractures, 1 patient had a Neer type I fracture and 1 radiograph was not able to be classified. All patients were treated with clavicular hook plates at the same district general hospital by five experienced surgeons between March 2010 and February 2015 adhering to the same surgical protocol. All patients had standard physiotherapy and post operative follow up. Plates were removed when radiological union was achieved in all but one patient who had the plate removed before union was achieved due to prolonged non-union. Patients were followed up post plate removal and evaluated clinically using the Oxford Shoulder Score. Their post plate radiographs were assessed by an independent radiologist and bony union documented.

21 patients were included. Mean age was 40 (range 14–63) with a male:female ratio of 17:4. Mean follow up was 5 months post injury (1–26 months). The hook plate remained in situ for a mean time of 4.3 months (2–16 months). One patient developed a post-operative wound infection treated with antibiotics, 2 patients developed adhesive capsulitis, one patient had not achieved bony union prior to hook plate removal at 16 months, however did achieve union 2 months post plate removal, two patients required revision plating. All patients achieved bony union eventually with good alignment and no displacement of the acromioclavicular joint seen on the most recent post operative radiographs. Post plate removal Oxford Shoulder Scores indicated good shoulder function with a mean score of 41.5 (maximum score possible 48 and the range of scores for our cohort was 30–47).

Our data would support the use of hook plates in the treatment of lateral clavicular fractures. All patients achieved union eventually with good alignment and this was reflected in the good functional outcome scores. This study is limited in its small cohort and short-term follow up. More research is required to examine the long term consequences of hook plate surgery in a larger patient population.

Osteoporosis is a global health issue with 200 million people suffering worldwide and it is a common condition in the elderly. Bisphosphonates including alendronate and risendronate are considered as the first line treatment for osteoporosis. However, there is increasing evidence that bisphosphonate (BP) therapy is associated with atypical fractures. Animal studies have reported a dose-dependent association between the duration of BP therapy and the accumulation of micro-damage. We tested the hypothesis that hip fracture patients treated with BP exhibited greater micro-damage density than untreated fracture and ‘healthy’ aging non-fracture controls.

Trabecular bone cores from patients treated with BP were compared with patients who had not received any treatment for bone metabolic disease (ethics reference: R13004). Non-fractured cadaveric femora from individuals with no history of bone metabolic disease were used as controls. Cores were imaged in high spatial resolution (∼1.3µm) using Synchrotron X-ray tomography (Diamond Light Source Ltd.) A novel classification system was devised to characterise features of micro-damage in the Synchrotron images: micro-cracks, diffuse damage and perforations. Synchrotron micro-CT stacks were visualised and analysed using ImageJ, Avizo and VGStudio MAX.

Our findings show that the BP group had the highest micro-damage density across all groups. The BP group (7.7/mm³) also exhibited greater micro-crack density than the fracture (4.3/mm³) and non-fracture (4.1/mm³) controls. Furthermore, the BP group (1.9/mm³) demonstrated increased diffuse damage when compared to the fracture (0.3/mm³) and non-fracture (0.8/mm³) controls. In contrast, the BP group (1.9mm³) had fewer perforations than fracture (3.0/mm³) and non-fracture controls (3.9/mm³).

BP inhibits bone remodelling, thereby reducing the number of perforated trabeculae, but over-suppression leads to micro-damage accumulation. Accumulated damage could weaken the trabecular bone in the femoral head and neck, increasing the risk of a fracture during a trip or fall.

Millions of people suffer from bone and joint inflammatory problems and usually result in extreme cases with total joint replacement. Most commonly affected joints are the hip and the knee. Over the past 20 years there has been a revival in interest of metal-on-metal hip replacements. Various alloys have been used in joint replacement, the most successful in the Cobalt-based alloys. As compared to others the cobalt based alloys have higher wear resistance and therefore less risk of failure. The most common Co-based alloy used in clinical application is the ASTM F75 alloy, which is extensively used in femoral and acetabular components. Conventional methods to fabricate the alloy are via cast or wrought techniques. Wrought alloys are better than their cast materials due to their superior mechanical properties as the forging process promotes plastic deformation. An alternative method of fabrication is via powder processing and has shown significant improvements to produce finer grained materials, which relate to enhancement in properties, such as strength, toughness, ductility.

One of the key stages of powder processing is sintering of the powder to fuse the particles together. A superior but simple sintering processing is spark plasma sintering (SPS), which produces highly dense materials with minimum grain growth. This is achieved by a pulsed electrical current heating the material while applying a pressure to compact the powdered material. This process has the ability to densify nanopowders, in order to produce microstructures with finer grains and superior mechanical properties.

Using SPS and nanopowders for the first time, we have been able to prepare the ASTM F75 cobalt–chromium–molybdenum (Co–Cr–Mo) orthopaedic alloy composition. In this work we have investigated, the effect of processing variables on the structural features of the alloy (phases present, grain size and microstructure). We have been able to produce specimens of >99% of the theoretical density. The structures were free of carbides, which a vital breakthrough. Detrimental carbide phases in the microstructure as found in the more conventional methods of fabrication have shown to cause problems in wear. The compacts are of higher hardness than cast or wrought products despite the absence of carbides in the microstructure. The gain in hardness is because of the presence of oxides in the microstructure and we hope to quantify the oxide content in the future. The mechanisms of oxide formation are explained by considering chemical thermodynamics and kinetics. The next step is to evaluate the tribological performance (wear, friction, lubrication regimes) of this SPS-processed material and compare its performance with conventional MoM products (cast and wrought). The SPS route offers significant advantages over the conventional cast and wrought routes used to prepare this alloy for orthopaedic applications.