Traditionally, unstable anterior pelvic ring injuries have been stabilised with an external fixator or by internal fixation. Recently, a new percutaneous technique of placement of bilateral supraacetabular polyaxial screws and subcutaneous connecting bar to assemble an “internal fixator” has been described. We present the surgical technique and early clinical results of using this technique in twenty-five consecutive patients with a rotationally unstable pelvic ring injury and no diastasis of the symphysis pubis treated between April 2010 and December 2013. Additional posterior pelvic stabilisation with percutaneous iliosacral screws was used in 23 of these patients. The anterior device was routinely removed after three months. Radiological evidence of union of the anterior pelvic ring was seen in 24 of 25 patients at a minimum 6 month follow-up. Thirteen patients developed sensory deficits in the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve (five bilateral) and only one fully recovered. The anterior pelvic internal fixator is a reliable, safe and easy percutaneous technique for the treatment of anterior pelvic ring injuries, facilitating the reduction and stabilisation of rotational displacement. However, lateral femoral cutaneous nerve dysfunction is common. The technique is recommended in cases with bilateral or unilateral pubic rami fractures and no diastasis of the symphysis pubis.
We sought to evaluate the impact of a dedicated weekly ortho-plastics operating list on our ability to provide definitive soft tissue cover of open lower limb fractures within 72 hours. We reviewed all open lower limb fractures at our centre before and after the introduction of an ortho-plastics list to determine whether definitive soft tissue coverage was achieved within 72 hours. There were 23 open lower limb fractures at our centre in 2012 before the introduction of the ortho-plastics operating list of which only 7 (30%) had definitive soft tissue coverage within 72 hours. We hypothesised that the main reason for this was not patient or injury related factors but rather the logistical difficulties of coordinating theatre time on a routine trauma list with senior orthopaedic and plastic surgeon availability. To test this hypothesis we re-audited our time to soft tissue cover six months after the introduction of the ortho-plastics list and 70% of cases achieved coverage within 72 hours. Achieving definitive soft tissue coverage of open lower limb fractures within 72 hours of injury is a challenge. A dedicated weekly ortho-plastics operating list significantly improves our ability to deliver this service.
Fractures of the proximal femur are one of the
greatest challenges facing the medical community, constituting a
heavy socioeconomic burden worldwide. Controversy exists regarding
the optimal treatment for independent patients with displaced intracapsular fractures
of the proximal femur. The recognised alternatives are hemiarthroplasty
and total hip replacement. At present there is no established standard
of care, with both types of arthroplasty being used in many centres.
The principal advantages of total hip replacement are a functional
benefit over hemiarthroplasty and a reduced risk of revision surgery.
The principal criticism is the increased risk of dislocation. We
believe that an alternative acetabular component may reduce the
risk of dislocation but still provide the functional benefit of
total hip replacement in these patients. We therefore propose to
investigate the dislocation risk of a dual-mobility acetabular component
compared with standard polyethylene component in total hip replacement
for independent patients with displaced intracapsular fractures
of the proximal femur within the framework of the larger WHiTE (Warwick
Hip Trauma Evaluation) Comprehensive Cohort Study. Cite this article:
Fractures of the proximal femur are one of the
greatest challenges facing the medical community, constituting a
heavy socioeconomic burden worldwide. Controversy exists regarding
the optimal treatment for patients with unstable trochanteric proximal
femoral fractures. The recognised treatment alternatives are extramedullary
fixation usually with a sliding hip screw and intramedullary fixation
with a cephalomedullary nail. Current evidence suggests that best
results and lowest complication rates occur using a sliding hip screw.
Complications in these difficult fractures are relatively common
regardless of type of treatment. We believe that a novel device,
the X-Bolt dynamic plating system, may offer superior fixation over
a sliding hip screw with lower reoperation risk and better function.
We therefore propose to investigate the clinical effectiveness of
the X-bolt dynamic plating system compared with standard sliding
hip screw fixation within the framework of a the larger WHiTE (Warwick
Hip Trauma Evaluation) Comprehensive Cohort Study. Cite this article:
In August 2007 NICE issued its guidance for the treatment of patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA) with arthroscopic lavage. The recommendations stated that referral for arthroscopic lavage and debridement should not be offered as part of treatment for osteoarthritis, unless the person has osteoarthritis with a clear history of ‘mechanical locking’ (not gelling, giving way, or x-ray evidence of loose bodies). The aim of this study was to assess both the application of these guidelines over a four month period and whether this procedure had improved symptoms at first follow-up. This was a retrospective review from August-December 2011. The total number of arthroscopies performed during this period was obtained from theatre records. Further data was obtained through the hospital's electronic database. The diagnosis of OA was made through the analysis of referral and clinic letters, plain radiographs, MRI reports and operation notes. Only those patients with persisting OA symptoms were included, those with OA and recent history of injury or trauma were excluded. During this time period, 222 knee arthroscopies were performed in total, 99 were identified with persistent OA symptoms. Having identified these patients, referral letters were further analysed to identify the initial presenting symptom. Of the 99, 50 presented with pain, 28 presented with pain plus another symptom other than locking e.g. stiffness/swelling/giving-way, 21 presented with pain plus mechanical locking. According to current guidelines only these 21 patients should have been offered arthroscopic lavage as a form of treatment. In addition to these findings we identified what procedures had been carried out during arthroscopy for each symptom. Of those presenting with pain, 82% had a washout and debridement, 8% had washout, 4% had partial medial meniscectomy, 4% had lateral patellar release and 2% had partial lateral meniscectomy. Those with pain plus other symptoms not including locking, 82% had washout and debridement, 11% had partial medial meniscectomy, and 7% had a washout. Of those presenting with pain plus mechanical locking, 81% had washout and debridement and 19% had partial medial meniscectomy. Following the procedure, we analysed the outcome of symptoms at first-follow up. The mean follow-up time was 8 weeks. Of those presenting with just pain, 44% showed improvement, 52% had no change/on-going symptoms, 2% were unknown. Of those with pain plus other symptoms other than locking, 57% showed improvement, 35% had no change/on-going symptoms, 8% unknown. Of those with pain plus mechanical locking, 80% showed improvement, 10% had no change/on-going symptoms, 10% unknown. The results of this study support the current evidence that unless there are clear mechanical symptoms of locking, the use of arthroscopy in arthritic knee joints should be judicious and the reasons should be clearly documented.
Autologous bone graft has been used in the treatment of complex bone defects for more than a century. Morbidity associated with the harvest of this bone graft has led orthopaedic surgeons to seek alternative therapies in the treatment of long bone non-unions. The aim of this study was to determine whether the use of demineralised bone matrix as a bone healing adjunct improves clinical outcomes in adult patients with long bone non-union. A systematic search was carried out of the peer-reviewed English language literature to identify all relevant studies. The search strategy returned a total of 47 studies. Five of these studies were relevant to the research question. The studies were critically assessed and where appropriate combined in a meta-analysis. 4 non-comparative studies and one comparative study were reviewed. An overall estimate of the rate of union for the five studies was 86% (95%CI: 71–94%). The one comparative study demonstrated the relative risk (RR) of healing was not significantly better than in patients treated with autologous bone graft; RR=1.03 (95%CI 0.96–1.12). There are limited data to support the use of demineralised bone matrix in the treatment of long bone non-union. Demineralised bone matrix is likely to be similarly effective to other treatments in the management of non-union. This study confirms the clinical and ethical requirements to proceed with a randomised controlled trial to test the effectiveness of this intervention.
The orientation of the acetabular component in metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty affects wear rate and hence failure. Correct assessment of acetabular orientation is key in assessing the painful hip resurfacing. This study aimed to establish if interpretation of pelvic radiographs with TraumaCad software can provide a reliable alternative to computed tomography (CT) in measuring the acetabular inclination and version. TraumaCad was used to measure the acetabular orientation on AP pelvis radiographs of 14 painful hip resurfacings. Four orthopaedic surgeons performed each measurement twice. These were compared with measurements taken from CT reformats performed by an experienced musculoskeletal radiologist. The correlation between TraumaCad and CT was calculated, as was the intra- and inter-observer reliability of TraumaCad. There is strong correlation between the two techniques for the measurement of inclination and version (p<0.001). Intra- and inter-observer reliability of TraumaCad measurements are good (p<0.001). Mean absolute error for measurement of inclination was 2.1°. TraumaCad underestimated version compared to CT in 93% of cases, by 12.6 degrees on average. When assessing acetabular orientation in hip resurfacing, the orthopaedic surgeon may use TraumaCad in the knowledge that it correlates well with CT and has good intra- and inter-observer reliability but underestimates version by 12° on average. This underestimation may be contributed to by the natural divergence of the X-ray beam, the short arc of the ellipse left exposed by the large diameter head, and the non-hemispherical resurfacing cup.
Informed consent is vital for good patient-surgeon communication. It allows the patient to be given an unbiased and accurate view of the procedure as well giving an opportunity for patients to gain trust in their surgical team. The consent form is written evidence of this discussion and a poor consent form implies a sub-standard consenting process. The General Medical Council (GMC) have issued guidelines for consent in surgical procedures. These state that all common risks and rare but serious risks should be disclosed as well as all information being given in clear simple and consistent language. Currently, the consent form for a hip fracture operation is hand written. Our hypothesis was that the quality of consenting is variable and that many important complications may not be identified. The British Orthopaedic Association (BOA) blue book, ‘The care of patients with fragility fractures,’ has given guidance of common and serious complications associated with operative management of hip fractures. In addition to these procedure specific complications, we have identified general complications from standardised joint arthroplasty consent forms in our trust, such as deep vein thrombosis. Our standards based on GMC guidance are that the consent form should be legible, free from jargon, without abbreviations and should include the specific and general complications. We retrospectively identified and analysed 30 consecutive consent forms of patients that underwent operative management for hip fractures between March and April 2011. Of all consent forms, 59% were completely or partly illegible, 77% had used abbreviations and medical jargon. Inclusion of general complications on the consent form varied; infection 100%, bleeding 100%, deep vein thrombosis 82%, MI 18%, pneumonia 12%, death 12% and haematoma 0%. Specific operative complications were poorly included, with no patients undergoing hemiarthroplasty being advised of the risk of prosthetic loosening, acetabular wear or periprosthetic fractures. For consent of patients undergoing fracture fixation, 67% had been informed of re-operation and 40% had been told of non-union. This data shows that consent forms are generally poorly written and subject to great variation in complications for the same surgical procedure. This data is likely to apply to some extent to all hospitals that use blank consent forms. This has implications for patient care and safety, as well as medicolegal implications for medical professionals. In our hospital, consent forms have been standardised for joint arthroplasty, with all complication pre-printed with plain English explanations below. Our proposal is that all common operations should have pre-printed consent forms. This would standardise consenting and provide a much improved documentary evidence of the consenting process. This data has a number of lessons that can be applied to other hospitals. Firstly, we suggest that other hospitals consider standardised consent forms. Secondly, individual trainees should be clear that consent forms remain the documentary evidence of the consenting process, long after you forget the verbal details and you should ensure that you include all complications, write clearly and without jargon or abbreviations.
The femur is a common site for skeletal metastases. The Gamma2 nail has proved effective in relieving pain and restoring function. Little data exists on the use of the Gamma3 Long Nail (GLN) in this condition. Improved instrumentation is suggested to reduce operative time and facilitate minimally invasive surgery. This study reports a series of patients treated in a District General Hospital. A retrospective casenote review was performed of all patients treated with the GLN for femoral metastatic disease over a five year period. Patients were followed-up for a minimum of one year. Functional level was assessed using the Parker Mobility Score (PMS). 12 patients underwent 15 nailings. Mean age was 75.4 years (median 75.7, range 61-92). In bilateral cases, the operations were performed during the same hospital admission. There were seven prophylactic nailings for impending fracture from proximal femoral lesions, seven procedures for actual fractures distal to the intertrochanteric line, and one basicervical fracture associated with multiple femoral metastases. Primaries were four prostate, two breast, two lung, one bowel, one bladder, one renal, and one myeloma. Average anaesthetic time for all procedures was 134 mins (median 125, range 90-210). Average peri-operative drop in serum haemoglobin was 2.3g/dL (median 2.1, range 0.6-4.8). Five patients with actual fracture and one patient with impending fracture required blood transfusion, receiving 2.2 units on average. In-hospital mortality rate was 0.83%, with only one patient not surviving to discharge. One year mortality was 83.3%. Only two patients were alive one year post-operation. Of the remaining patients, average survival was 3.2 months (median 3, range 1-6). Patients spent an average of 17 days on an acute orthopaedic unit (median 14, range 4-80). Two patients required further convalescence in a rehabilitation unit. There were three surgical complications. Two impending fractures became complete, One intra-operatively and one post-operatively. In the case of basi-cervical fracture, the proximal screw cut out of the femoral head, requiring revision to a long-stem bipolar hemiarthroplasty. This was the only re-operation required in this series. Average pre-operative PMS was 5.2 (median 4, range 2-9). Average peri-operative drop in PMS was two points (median 1.5, range 0-6). Of the 11 patients who survived to discharge, 10 were independently mobile and returned to their pre-operation residence. Nine required a change in walking aids. Only one patient reported post-operative pain. This small patient series suggests that the Gamma3 Long Nail is a suitable treatment option for impending and actual metastatic femoral fractures in the District General setting. Length of stay, in-hospital mortality and re-operation rates compare favourably with published data on the Gamma2. There was a significant drop in Parker Mobility Score but all patients bar one were independently mobile and returned to their home. Anaesthetic time was not lower than with the Gamma2, suggesting little tangible benefit of the new instrumentation.
A two sample t-test demonstrated cobalt and chromium ion levels were significantly higher in patients with abnormalities on USS (p=0.038, p=0.05 respectively), patients with normal USS were more likely to have a retroverted femoral component (p=0.01).
